PDA

View Full Version : What was wrong with the 4th movie?


Pages : 1 [2]

ooglafina
06-22-2010, 09:48 PM
I was actually thinking about that problem earlier today.

If they hadn't given away the whole idea of Winters being the pseudo badguy it would have been better too. It felt like an insult to my considerable :D intelligence to have to listen to a speech about how the generals turned to stone while I was watching them turn to stone at that moment. You have let the audience feel like they are a team player and that they are figuring things out on their own. You don't need to get, "everybody on the same page up front," unless they're really stupid. It completely undermined April's, "maybe, just maybe," speech later on because we obviously knew that Winters was immortal and blahbitty blah. Same exact thing as when Leo kicks off Raph's helmet. There's the issue that we realize that Leo's probably going to try to kick Raph's ass in a minute, but we're not surprised or anything unless we just started watching.

Don't sabotage your own scenes.

Just a writer's gripe about another writer.

Candy Kappa
06-22-2010, 09:58 PM
they could have kept the scenes that got deleted, and might kept the scene where Casey don't know Raph is Nightwatcher


heck they could have picked a better script
don't think we even saw all 13 monsters in the movie. And the turtles didn't even defeat any of them

ooglafina
06-23-2010, 07:52 AM
The thirteen monsters were just an excuse to have a movie because they needed a bad guy. The whole script just reeked of lazy choices. It's easier to give all the information up front instead of introducing it in the course of dramatic progress and it's easier to come up with some silly villain that nobody really fights than to use Karai in some way other than a sidekick.

P.S. - I just thought of another bit of laziness. The thirteen monsters were supposed to be the source of most mythological and fairy tale monsters. But we're never told that. We see Don reading a book about fairy tales, but I never put it together until I watched the commentary. They just figured that you could put it together, or not and just not know about it. The monsters didn't look anything like the things they were supposed to have inspired to me. Don't waste a concept that is integral to appreciating the bad guy by being too lazy to even tell us about it.

saul
07-07-2010, 12:15 AM
Where it went wrong was the director aimed for Ghostbusters, but ended up with Ghostbusters 2.

It was terrible how every character was so pathetic! They were all either bored or hated one another.

The turtles are brothers, and any disagreement should only be superficial. The idea of Raph wanting to kill Leo was too much and pointless drama.

When the characters hate their lives and each other it's hard for the audience to sympathize with them.

-Splinter watching soap operas?
-Terrible dialog. Especially when the turtles demean each other, such as Don treating Mike like a child. WTF? In the 1st movie Don had fun miming Mike: "pork rind?" "pork rind."
-Raph donning a _metal_ costume? (his black costume from the comics would have been WAY better-- the turtles don't need metal armor protection)
-Mike and Don's jobs. Seriously? That's the best Munroe could think of? Whatever happened to the edgy turtles that wouldn't even pay full price for late pizza? They could have stolen money from crooks.
-Casey's a little bitch
-The plot isn't enough about the turtles
-etc, etc

Andrew NDB
07-07-2010, 12:18 AM
Whatever happened to the edgy turtles that wouldn't even pay full price for late pizza?

If that equates to edgy Turtles I'd sure hate to see the non-edgy variety.

saul
07-07-2010, 12:59 AM
If that equates to edgy Turtles I'd sure hate to see the non-edgy variety.

But you see, it's the subtlety there that makes it so great. They aren't perfect boy scouts willing to sacrifice themselves at bad 9-5 tech or kid's party jobs. They are teenagers who will spare a few bucks at another's expense. Yet, at heart, they aren't bad.

The 1st movie set several bad examples for stealing: -Danny stealing April's 20, April stealing Raph's sai
Sure, it's not edgy like crack-cocaine edgy, or murdering a prostitute, but it's not something most people want kids to imitate. I love that the movie had this.

saul
07-07-2010, 01:02 AM
Also, if the turtles were able to live in the sewers for 15 years without stupid jobs, why would they need them suddenly in TMNT?

If they need electronic gear Don can fix it up for them salvaged from the trash. If they need money all they need to do is pocket some change off a bad guy. Hell, they could even collect all that garbage in the sewers and streets and recycle it for some descent dough.

gobo
07-07-2010, 01:16 AM
What was wrong with the 4th movie?
I probably answered this already, but I'll do it anyway since I'm bored/killing time. The answer is: USER ERROR. It was a bit generic and boring, but it's still a decent family film. Anyone who says it's bad because it wasn't all they hoped for has their standards set unreasonably high.

Dragon Turtle
07-07-2010, 01:41 AM
The turtles are brothers, and any disagreement should only be superficial. The idea of Raph wanting to kill Leo was too much and pointless drama.


Unfortunately, not all disagreements between brothers are superficial.

Also, if the turtles were able to live in the sewers for 15 years without stupid jobs, why would they need them suddenly in TMNT?



I see no problem in the turtles having a job to earn money, just because it's one of many underdeveloped or ignored aspects of the turtles franchise, doesn't make it a bad idea to explore.

ooglafina
07-07-2010, 07:43 AM
-Splinter watching soap operas?

That was actually the only thing in that movie that really made me laugh because it's exactly what my own grandma says. "Watching her stories." I didn't think any the less of him. I've watched soaps my whole life. So I guess it tapped into my fuzzy childhood grandparents feeling. But I don't know if that was really a good gag overall for the story.

Koi
07-07-2010, 02:02 PM
i bet if in the begining they didnt let people know raph was nightwatcher it would been a little better.

But it would have been so obvious anyhow if they didn't tell us it would have been completely irrelevant.

They could have just took out Nightwatcher all together if you ask me.

Powder
07-07-2010, 02:29 PM
They could have just took out Nightwatcher all together if you ask me.

Yeah. That whole thing was wack.

shuriken
07-07-2010, 03:59 PM
Yeah. That whole thing was wack.

word. He could have just been a ninja and whooped criminals asses to the same effect.

ooglafina
07-07-2010, 04:18 PM
I didn't understand why Leo had such a problem with it. Apparently, a costume is the difference between a ninja and a vigilante. It made him look really petty.

Shred87
07-07-2010, 08:31 PM
I think the movie was ok for what it was... it certainly didn't add anything to the series but what did everyone expect from a cgi movie with a 30 million dollar budget? Toy Story 3 was around 200 million for comparison... the turtles have a full stable of unused villians and it annoys me that the last two films created unremarkable and forgettable villians to use instead. Thats my biggest gripe.

Samhain
07-07-2010, 09:09 PM
IToy Story 3 was around 200 million for comparison...

Honestly, Toy story 3 could have been acted out by poop on sticks and it still would have been amazing. Thats the writing. It was fantastic. TMNT was horrible because of the writers.

Koi
07-07-2010, 09:22 PM
I just rewatched this movie with my little sister, and older brother, and my little sister's comment that she made about the turtles. Made me die a little inside. It is no lie I don't care for the turtles as much as I do for all the other characters of the show, but my little sister, she asked me if Raph and Leo were in fact a couple. I said flat out no, my brother teased and milked it for all it's worth the rest of the movie. I just sat there thinking that all the movies brotherly tensions and overly dramatic brother scenes should have been cut out. There were some serious scenes were you could hear a distant turtlecest fangirl out there squeal.

This movie always has something new I hate about it.

I can't wait for a remake, this CGI film sucks, and continues to go downhill the more I watch it. I need a more dark atmosphere, I loved the campy 80's but after rewatching the CGI film again, I NEED a darker edgier TMNT, I am tired of its flat out in between bull honky 4kids has been pulling out. I want a full out dark reincarnation of the comic. I want Mikey to not be a stupid twit, no Donny being a full out 2ndary character loner shy boy in the corner, no Leo being a full out prick bastard, or Raph being a freakin prissy pmsing teenage girl and main character of the darn movie.

Ugh. They better have a good reboot, or it is back to rewatching the OT and reading comics for me. For waiting for a dark TMNT movie after that point, ha! It will never happen I swear if the next movie isn't dark.

What is so wrong with wanting teenage MUTANT NINJA TURTLES In a TMNT movie? Or even just Mutant ninja turtles! No teens at all!

Dragon Turtle
07-07-2010, 10:08 PM
Yeah. That whole thing was wack.

While you can definitely argue that the Nightwatcher subplot was unnecessary, the underlying tension between Raph and Leo had little to do with the Nightwatcher, the concept is actually quite interesting, would have been a nice little story to explore in the comic or cartoon.

I didn't understand why Leo had such a problem with it. Apparently, a costume is the difference between a ninja and a vigilante. It made him look really petty.

Ninjas are not vigilantes, the Nightwatcher's high profile activities was bringing unwanted attention.

but what did everyone expect from a cgi movie with a 30 million dollar budget? Toy Story 3 was around 200 million for comparison...


What a 200 million dollar budget and the Pixar name would get you is the freedom to tell the story they want to tell, without studio execs butting in.

Shred87
07-07-2010, 10:39 PM
Honestly, Toy story 3 could have been acted out by poop on sticks and it still would have been amazing. Thats the writing. It was fantastic. TMNT was horrible because of the writers.

I have a feeling that budget and quality of writing/writers is directly related.

I'll say it again though what did every expect from a CGI movie? When you deal with this genre your success is going to be limited. It's basically a cartoon. And not only is it a cartoon but it really isn't meant for little kids. It's not Toy Story or Wall E. I hate to keep bringing up other movies but take a look at Star Wars... What other franchise has more die hard followers than start wars??? TMNT generated more money than the Clone Wars CGI movie. CGI simply doesn't work. You can't really make it too dark because it isn't going to attract the older crowd. You aren't going to get the young kids running to go see it. It's a no win situation

Dragon Turtle
07-07-2010, 11:29 PM
I have a feeling that budget and quality of writing/writers is directly related.


A lot of low budget movies tend to have good writers, while many big budget movies seem to have horrible writing.



I'll say it again though what did every expect from a CGI movie? When you deal with this genre your success is going to be limited. It's basically a cartoon. And not only is it a cartoon but it really isn't meant for little kids.


TMNT seems to have done quite well as a kids franchise over the years.


I hate to keep bringing up other movies but take a look at Star Wars... What other franchise has more die hard followers than start wars??? TMNT generated more money than the Clone Wars CGI movie. CGI simply doesn't work.

Clone Wars made it no secret it was little more then a made for tv animated series tossed into movie theaters to make a quick buck, and the fans treated it accordingly.

Shred87
07-07-2010, 11:44 PM
A lot of low budget movies tend to have good writers, while many big budget movies seem to have horrible writing.

Well that was clearly not the case here so I don't see the point


TMNT seems to have done quite well as a kids franchise over the years.

Oh really? Not when it comes to the movies. As the movies became lighter in tone so did the money they made. We're not talking tv shows here we're talkin motion pictures

Clone Wars made it no secret it was little more then a made for tv animated series tossed into movie theaters to make a quick buck, and the fans treated it accordingly

Says you. I don't buy that at all. And what was TMNT advertised as? This is Star Wars we're talking about. These ppl camped outside to wait for the live action movies to come out. Give me one CGI movie that wasn't aimed at tots that made money and I'll happily agree with you....

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 12:20 AM
Oh really? Not when it comes to the movies. As the movies became lighter in tone so did the money they made.

Not a bad point, actually. You know... in the four TMNT movies you can just about quantify the grit = money verses camp/light tone = not so much money ratio, film by film.

Dragon Turtle
07-08-2010, 12:42 AM
Oh really? Not when it comes to the movies. As the movies became lighter in tone so did the money they made. We're not talking tv shows here we're talkin motion pictures



The movies made less money as TMNT's popularity waned throughout the 90s.


And what was TMNT advertised as?


For what little advertising it got, a kids movie.



This is Star Wars we're talking about. These ppl camped outside to wait for the live action movies to come out.


Star Wars fans would camp out for the actual movies, not a glorified ad for a kids tv series.




Give me one CGI movie that wasn't aimed at tots that made money and I'll happily agree with you....

Not that there's a huge selection to chose from ...but there was Beowulf, about 200 million worldwide.. and this was a movie about Beowulf of all things.

Not a bad point, actually. You know... in the four TMNT movies you can just about quantify the grit = money verses camp/light tone = not so much money ratio, film by film.

If this was true, TMNT 4 would have made about as much money as the first movie.

Shred87
07-08-2010, 01:12 AM
The movies made less money as TMNT's popularity waned throughout the 90s.

Sry dude but Turtles II was made a year after the first. The 3 movies came out within 4 years of each other. They were not spaced out throughout the 90's and the first movie really kicked turtlemania into gear.


For what little advertising it got, a kids movie.

I guess we'll agree to disagree... yea it's a kids movie obviously but the trailors were much darker looking than a true kids movie. It's more like a pre-teen early teen age range I'd say. There's certainly a difference between TMNT and Finding Nemo so I dont agree when u say a "kids movie" in that sense.


Not that there's a huge selection to chose from ...but there was Beowulf, about 200 million worldwide.. and this was a movie about Beowulf of all things.

Technically I guess your right but although Beowulf is a form CGI you know damn well it wasn't made the same way as TMNT... Beowulf had somewhat of a 300 look to it. It wasn't animated characters. And oh yea fyi TMNT actually was more profitable when production cost is considered TMNT aprox 61million ...Beowulf aprox 46 million..... But touche`decent effort

If this was true, TMNT 4 would have made about as much money as the first movie.

I dont know what your watching if you think TMNT was as dark as the original movie. I completely disagree. You just said above it was advertised for little kids. I don't even think theres much of a debate with that.

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 01:13 AM
TMNT Part 4 wasn't even a real movie. It was like... a string of bad Playstation 1 game FMV sequences cut together. For little kids.

Dragon Turtle
07-08-2010, 02:37 AM
Sry dude but Turtles II was made a year after the first. The 3 movies came out within 4 years of each other. They were not spaced out throughout the 90's and the first movie really kicked turtlemania into gear.


Turtlemania peaked around the time the first movie came out, a big reason it did well at the boxoffice, TMNT was clearly going downhill by the time the third movie hit.



I guess we'll agree to disagree... yea it's a kids movie obviously but the trailors were much darker looking than a true kids movie. It's more like a pre-teen early teen age range I'd say.

With all those TV spots with the announcer proclaiming TMNT as the "first great family film of the year", TMNT was strictly marketed as kids film.



Technically I guess your right but although Beowulf is a form CGI you know damn well it wasn't made the same way as TMNT... Beowulf had somewhat of a 300 look to it. It wasn't animated characters.


Beowulf was CGI just like TMNT, featuring animated characters, unless you're referring to the character designs of the humans. If that the case do you believe TMNT would have done better with less cartoonish designs?



And oh yea fyi TMNT actually was more profitable when production cost is considered TMNT aprox 61million ...Beowulf aprox 46 million..... But touche`decent effort


Box office is box office, people who paid to go see the movie, nothing to really do with profit margins.


I dont know what your watching if you think TMNT was as dark as the original movie. I completely disagree. You just said above it was advertised for little kids. I don't even think theres much of a debate with that.


I just don't put the first TMNT movie on that high of pedestal when it comes to seriousness/grit/darkness, not that I necessarily believe TMNT 4 itself is a dark film. The silly moments in the first movie were far more sillier then the last one. As far as tone goes, the first movie was all over the map, from 80s toon campyness to Mirage comic seriousness, and looking at one of the main criticisms tossed at the fourth movie from critics, was that it took itself too seriously.

And believe or not the first movie was aimed at little kids too, at least as far as what Mirage thought was appropriate for kids.

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 03:15 AM
Turtlemania peaked around the time the first movie came out, a big reason it did well at the boxoffice, TMNT was clearly going downhill by the time the third movie hit.

While true, even impartially looking at TMNT 3 there's no discounting the very apparent decline in quality and increase in camp factor. I'm pretty sure that was the first movie to actually dub in Loony Tunes-like sound effects for slapstick effect, too. Was insulting to me, even as a 12 year old, and I know I wasn't alone.

With all those TV spots with the announcer proclaiming TMNT as the "first great family film of the year", TMNT was strictly marketed as kids film.

Agreed. And the CGI factor didn't help things. Plus the Inspector Gadget-like exaggerated humans certainly did it no favors, either.

Beowulf was CGI just like TMNT, featuring animated characters, unless you're referring to the character designs of the humans. If that the case do you believe TMNT would have done better with less cartoonish designs?

A little. But that script was a pretty damning anchor, no matter how you cut it visually.

I just don't put the first TMNT movie on that high of pedestal when it comes to seriousness/grit/darkness, not that I necessarily believe TMNT 4 itself is a dark film.

Smart man.

The silly moments in the first movie were far more sillier then the last one.

Nah. A whole scene/beat dedicated to Mikey burping is pretty much a trump card to whatever you could lay out from TMNT 1. To name just one example.

As far as tone goes, the first movie was all over the map, from 80s toon campyness to Mirage comic seriousness, and looking at one of the main criticisms tossed at the fourth movie from critics, was that it took itself too seriously.

Given what it was, I agree that'd be a valid criticism. There's no way that movie should have taken itself seriously, such as it was.

And believe or not the first movie was aimed at little kids too

It was painstakingly aimed at little kids. Yes.

at least as far as what Mirage thought was appropriate for kids.

I'm not sure how Mirage fits into the equation there. Peter approved a script... and I'm not sh*tting you, that was about script #25 they went through for TMNT Part 4. People forget the history of that movie.

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 02:09 PM
Technically I guess your right but although Beowulf is a form CGI you know damn well it wasn't made the same way as TMNT...

CGI is CGI, just like the 3d models on TMNT, the 3d models was made in a 3D modeling program.
the poly count will differ, longer render time. but it's still CGI and you asked for a CGI movie not aimed for kids/tots.

other CGI movies:resident evil degeneration, Final Fantasy Spirits Within. Appleseed (it got PG-13) 9 also got PG-13

and then there's all the CGI short films, I'm sure RYAN is not aimed for children.

Shred87
07-08-2010, 02:42 PM
but it's still CGI and you asked for a CGI movie not aimed for kids/tots.

I didn't ask for that actually but thank you for that well researched list..very impressive... I asked how many CGI films not aimed at kids were huge box office successes....

And I gave him his due for coming up with Beowulf did I not?

Shred87
07-08-2010, 02:57 PM
CGI is CGI, just like the 3d models on TMNT, the 3d models was made in a 3D modeling program.
the poly count will differ, longer render time. but it's still CGI and you asked for a CGI movie not aimed for kids/tots.

other CGI movies:resident evil degeneration, Final Fantasy Spirits Within. Appleseed (it got PG-13) 9 also got PG-13

and then there's all the CGI short films, I'm sure RYAN is not aimed for children.

Haha actually after re reading your post I have no idea what your point is...Not one of those movies actually was successful... My point was that you couldn't expect much from a low budget CGI film from the box office if it wasn't aimed at kids and lets see what your brought to the table shall we?

Resident Evil Degeneration - Recieved a limited release no box office info available

Final Fantasy Spririts Within - This movie LOST 52 million dollars

Nine - not too bad itself that movie only lost about 27 million dollars

Ryan - this is a short as you said not a motion picture... why don't we discuss the Donkey Kong CGI show that was out a few yrs ago

Appleseed - 10 million dollar budge...grossed a whopping 1.4 (only lost about 8.6 million..not too bad)

I thought you were getting a little snippy with me but I can clearly see that you were just trying to help me make my point... Once again CGI movies with a serious tone or not aimed at little tots= limited box office success. TMNT was nothing great but should be considered a success when all things are considered.

Dragon Turtle
07-08-2010, 03:14 PM
While true, even impartially looking at TMNT 3 there's no discounting the very apparent decline in quality and increase in camp factor. I'm pretty sure that was the first movie to actually dub in Loony Tunes-like sound effects for slapstick effect, too. Was insulting to me, even as a 12 year old, and I know I wasn't alone.



I'll agree with the decline of quality, but I don't see the increase in camp as having that much of an impact on box office, especially considering the source material, as perceived by kids, was the light-hearted campy 80s toon. And the first movie also had Loony Tunes sound effects.




Nah. A whole scene/beat dedicated to Mikey burping is pretty much a trump card to whatever you could lay out from TMNT 1. To name just one example.


By today's standards, a scene dedicated to Mikey burping is pretty restrained. Turtles dancing, pizza slices falling on Splinters head, a mock funeral for a moldy pizza. Nope, the first TMNT movie was sillier by far, as it was intended to be.


Given what it was, I agree that'd be a valid criticism. There's no way that movie should have taken itself seriously, such as it was.


Why shouldn't it have taken itself seriously if Laird and Monroe were writing the movie to be more in tone with the comics?



I'm not sure how Mirage fits into the equation there. Peter approved a script... and I'm not sh*tting you, that was about script #25 they went through for TMNT Part 4. People forget the history of that movie.

Are you referring to the the live-action part 4 that was never made or are you referring the first movie?

Shred87
07-08-2010, 03:20 PM
Are you referring to the the live-action part 4 that was never made or are you referring the first movie?

WHoa... I'm a little ignorant to this do you have any other info as far as what the movie would have been about...? :D

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 03:23 PM
I'll agree with the decline of quality, but I don't see the increase in camp as having that much of an impact on box office

I'm not saying it did, I'm just saying it seems to be a somewhat amusing coincidence.

And the first movie also had Loony Tunes sound effects.

Did it? I don't recall.

By today's standards, a scene dedicated to Mikey burping is pretty restrained. Turtles dancing, pizza slices falling on Splinters head, a mock funeral for a moldy pizza. Nope, the first TMNT movie was sillier by far, as it was intended to be.

The examples you point out -- while silly -- at least are genuinely amusing and serve as the "punchline" of one thing or another. Mike just randomly burping for laughs for like 16 minutes straight is just arbitrary and retarded.

Why shouldn't it have taken itself seriously if Laird and Monroe were writing the movie to be more in tone with the comics?

Laird didn't write anything. He gave Monroe notes. Munroe had the unenviable task of then "writing" his movie by committee.

And like hell that's in tone with any comics I've read. Maybe some Mark Martin or Hedden/McWeeney stuff, though even that had some tact to it.

Are you referring to the the live-action part 4 that was never made

The fourth movie took very different forms at something like 3 or 4 different studios until the Imagi/WB deal.

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 05:47 PM
Ryan - this is a short as you said not a motion picture... why don't we discuss the Donkey Kong CGI show that was out a few yrs ago
You have no idea what RYAN is about do you?:roll:

Full CGI movies aimed for a older audience is still very young and suffers from not yet have shaken off the idiotic belief that It's a "kids thing"

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 06:10 PM
WHoa... I'm a little ignorant to this do you have any other info as far as what the movie would have been about...? :D

At first, a semi-adaption of the Donatello special with Kirby... only Kirby wouldn't be a Jack Kirby clone, but rather a fifth Turtle from the dimension of created things. It was going to be a madcap multi-dimensional romper with biomechanical designs for Turtle armor drawn by Michael Dooney and Julie Strain as an evil Empress from the wacky dimension.

Later it was going to be retooled to be an NT:TNM movie with Venus in the mix.

Honestly, as much as I loathe it, the fourth movie we got probably has the best story of any of the potential fourth movies we almost got.

CyberCubed
07-08-2010, 07:49 PM
TMNT Part 4 wasn't even a real movie. It was like... a string of bad Playstation 1 game FMV sequences cut together. For little kids.

Do you actually remember what Playstation 1 FMV movies looked like?

If there's one thing you can't fault the movie for, its that the animation was pretty good.

Samhain
07-08-2010, 07:54 PM
I have no problem with CG. I believe the writers and plot for this movie absolutly killed it.

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 08:36 PM
Do you actually remember what Playstation 1 FMV movies looked like?

If there's one thing you can't fault the movie for, its that the animation was pretty good.

the animation is great, but the camera director failed miserably. Horrible shots especially during fight scenes. which made them look like old or mediocre cut scenes from a game

ooglafina
07-08-2010, 08:49 PM
It drives me nuts watching the 4th one because they should have started when they pan down to South America. I always think, "Well, the movie's starting now." Seeing them in NY in the first scene takes away any of the wonder when we first see Leo. They don't need to tell us that they defeated Shredder, that they're turtles, that they're brothers, that there is an ancient bad evil guy...

I always worry when a movie starts out with an omnipotent narrator. It usually means that they're too lazy to do it in scene or dialog like they should. The only movie that is so complicated that it needs an omnipotent narrator in the opening sequence if The Lord of the Rings, where they cover thousands of years of history in a few minutes.

Frame ups = laziness and they had two.

Rant over.

Dragon Turtle
07-08-2010, 09:18 PM
Did it? I don't recall.



Yes, one instance I recall was when mikey popped up out of the sewer after April mentions pizza.



The examples you point out -- while silly -- at least are genuinely amusing and serve as the "punchline" of one thing or another. Mike just randomly burping for laughs for like 16 minutes straight is just arbitrary and retarded.


I could go on about the music, dialog, slapstick fighting, and so on. The first movie was indeed design to be a more silly light-hearted movie, and there's nothing wrong with that as far as I'm concerned.


Laird didn't write anything. He gave Monroe notes. Munroe had the unenviable task of then "writing" his movie by committee.



Laird and Monroe worked for months on the treatment, and much of the writing was done by Monroe and his co-director Tom Tanaka. It wasn't til after they showed the movie to one distributors did they decided to butt in.



And like hell that's in tone with any comics I've read. Maybe some Mark Martin or Hedden/McWeeney stuff, though even that had some tact to it.


I don't see where you get TMNT 4 as being some super goofy kids movie, when you have many OT fans and critics who say it was too humorless
and took itself too seriously. I don't see it in the Leo/Raph or immortals subplots. Most of the humor/jokes seem to localized to mikey, who most people will agree he had very little screen time.



At first, a semi-adaption of the Donatello special with Kirby... only Kirby wouldn't be a Jack Kirby clone, but rather a fifth Turtle from the dimension of created things. It was going to be a madcap multi-dimensional romper with biomechanical designs for Turtle armor drawn by Michael Dooney and Julie Strain as an evil Empress from the wacky dimension.



There was also the idea of giving the turtles superpowers:


http://www.planetracers.com/blast/prblast0036.html
the animation is great, but the camera director failed miserably. Horrible shots especially during fight scenes. which made them look like old or mediocre cut scenes from a game

The scene that I believe failed in terms of camera work was the final battle, some scenes were pushed either too close or too far away.

It drives me nuts watching the 4th one because they should have started when they pan down to South America. I always think, "Well, the movie's starting now." Seeing them in NY in the first scene takes away any of the wonder when we first see Leo. They don't need to tell us that they defeated Shredder, that they're turtles, that they're brothers, that there is an ancient bad evil guy...



Beware the hand of meddling studio execs.

Eiko
07-08-2010, 09:43 PM
What i hated about the 4TH movie the monsters to much Leo Raph fighting i see that enough in the cartoons. No Mike or Don They needed a bigger part in the film. The Film could have been so much better.

Andrew NDB
07-30-2010, 12:15 PM
No Mike or Don They needed a bigger part in the film.

Be careful what you wish for. If that Mike had been in the film any more than he was I honestly don't think I could have stomached the movie.

Shark_Blade
07-31-2010, 08:48 AM
I'm sure he meant more Mike and Donnie action. For goodness sake Mike's nunchakus barely make any screen time. It's mainly all about Raph and Leo which sucks, big time. It's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, not Teenage Mutant Ninja Leonardo and Raphael.

Shred87
07-31-2010, 08:56 AM
I was thinking about this the other day... Doing a CGI movie seemed like the perfect opprtunity to do a Fugitoid/Federation/Triceraton arc.. They still could have incorporated the Leo/Raph feud and him being away. I mean that might have been the only shot we got of getting a good adaption of the story. I think CGI would have taken well to all the time traveling and mutant aliens being involved.

Rise1184
08-04-2010, 09:39 PM
I don't know, some of it was cool, but nothing is like the recent one, "Turtles Forever". I really enjoyed that one

ooglafina
08-05-2010, 09:15 PM
I was just thinking, when Leo flies into that display case full of swords and then we get the shot of him all tricked out with weaponry, do we ever get to see him use them? I can't remember that he does. I should go check because if he doesn't, then they wasted an opportunity for a really cool sequence. Probably would have cost too much and exceeded their rating.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
08-10-2010, 07:51 PM
Yeah I can admit I was disappointed in the fourth film.

I agree that the film felt too childish at times (the burping and such), the plot was fairly forgettable...it just seemed like a forgettable film. Not an awful movie...just a movie that after over a decade of waiting for a new flick...and it didn't feel anything like an event. Except the Leo & Raph rooftop fight.

But even that...well this is just my own personal preference:

A. I would have liked for Raph to...I don't know...even have one simple talk or conversation with Mikey. It's weird that two brothers never really talk to one another (I know, they didn't that much, in the other movies...at least they had that one 'turtle wax' moment in part 1, and quite a few moments with each other in part 2). Mainly because they bring in this whole 'Mikey a fan of Nightwatcher'...and then do nothing with it. It would have been interesting to see/hear more...but nothing. Even Shrek, Wall-E, and these other movies have much better character development.

B. I wouldn't have put April & Casey into the flick. Why did they HAVE to be in the movie? Now in a sequel? Fine. But you could have taken the time used for them and develop the brothers more. Just more 'character' moments that just didn't drive the crappy plot along (or the childish stuff like the 'burp' and etc.)

C. I never truly understood why Leo became a vigilante in the jungle, and that was fine...but Raph does the same thing in New York, but that's just TERRIBLE. Hey Leo...two faced much? But if there was some more reason to it...then it could have been interesting to see and such. But to me, the Leonardo is this movie was just too much of an arrogant, two-faced ass (the "I'm better the you", and againg the whole 'I can be a vigilante in the jungle, but YOU can't because..." uhm, why?)

D. For some reason the film felt short...maybe that's just me.

E. The plot was lackluster...and trying to cast voice actors like Chris Evans and Sarah Michelle Gellar...but like I said, I wouldn't have had April & Casey in the movie in the first place.

F. I heard in the commentary that there would have been a moment near the end where Raphael would have been hurt/killed, and I believe Patrick Stewart or someone else used something to bring him back. I remember hearing something like that but the director was told by Laird he couldn't do that. Now that would have been interesting...you could have had that Raph felt bad for what he almost did to Leo, he pushes Leo out of the way for retribution, you could have had a solid moment between those two (it need more than just the 'handing the swords' thing) with perhaps Raphael saying sorry or 'you were right'...maybe Leo saying that he wasn't right, they they need him and such. Bottom line...a lot more heart and something for the people who have grown up with this for over two decades.

G. Maybe it could have been neat if Raph used his Nightwatcher ways for good (I mean they were already for good), but use his armor/bike/stuff to help his brothers and get Leo out at the end. Could even throw a quick moment of Mikey seeing the guy he was a big fan of in action.

I'm sure I could think of more but I'd just be boring people. The movie is what it is...although unfortunately, while I do not hate the film...I found it disappointing and lacking. Despite what people think...TMNT isn't JUST for kids by this point. Even films like Wall-E and such have more to it.

ooglafina
08-10-2010, 08:24 PM
A. I would have liked for Raph to...I don't know...even have one simple talk or conversation with Mikey. It's weird that two brothers never really talk to one another

D. For some reason the film felt short...maybe that's just me.

I think the biggest problem, or one of them anyway, was that they wasted way too much time on crap nobody cared about. Like the burping scene and all that. It was like they didn't understand how to layer things. You can have more than one thing going on at a time. I think they're always so worried that they're going to confuse the audience that they accidentally insult our intelligence. The plot was explained far too much. That was the big issue with the plot. We didn't need to be spoon-fed every bit about it up front. It took all the mystery out of it. You have to let the audience feel like they're figuring things out too as they go along.

So they spent too much time telling us who the bad guys were and on "funny" kid Mikey humor to include important stuff like showing Raph and Mike talking at all to each other.

Andrew NDB
08-10-2010, 11:56 PM
Yeah I can admit I was disappointed in the fourth film.

It's not 2007 anymore. Apparently it's OK for people to admit that publically now.

And not get mobbed.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
08-11-2010, 12:13 AM
It's not 2007 anymore. Apparently it's OK for people to admit that publically now.

And not get mobbed.

lol that is true...but with the internet...ya never know. But thank you anyway sir.

Dragon Turtle
08-11-2010, 03:52 AM
I was just thinking, when Leo flies into that display case full of swords and then we get the shot of him all tricked out with weaponry, do we ever get to see him use them? I can't remember that he does. I should go check because if he doesn't, then they wasted an opportunity for a really cool sequence. Probably would have cost too much and exceeded their rating.

He doesn't, even though the script actually describes the fight, I suspect time and money constraints probably played a big role in their absence.




B. I wouldn't have put April & Casey into the flick. Why did they HAVE to be in the movie? Now in a sequel? Fine. But you could have taken the time used for them and develop the brothers more.


I actually have no problem with April & Casey, since I like to consider them as a part of the turtles family, any character development you can give them would be welcomed.


C. I never truly understood why Leo became a vigilante in the jungle, and that was fine...but Raph does the same thing in New York, but that's just TERRIBLE. Hey Leo...two faced much? But if there was some more reason to it...then it could have been interesting to see and such. But to me, the Leonardo is this movie was just too much of an arrogant, two-faced ass (the "I'm better the you", and againg the whole 'I can be a vigilante in the jungle, but YOU can't because..." uhm, why?)


There is a bit of a difference in between what Leo did in the jungle and what Raph does as the Nightwatcher (or what Leo perceives). Leo came across a situation where people needed help and probably couldn't depend on the local authorities, he didn't actively go out seeking wrongs to right. The Nightwatcher was actively a crimefighter, whose flashy antics were indirectly drawing attention to the turtles. Leo saw the Nightwatcher as somewhat of a grandstanding self-promoter.


D. For some reason the film felt short...maybe that's just me.


No, it's not just you, the directors cut was about two hours long.

ooglafina
08-11-2010, 08:28 AM
He doesn't, even though the script actually describes the fight, I suspect time and money constraints probably played a big role in their absence.


No, it's not just you, the directors cut was about two hours long.

I wish they would have just cut the whole gag then. It was like telling a joke without a punchline.

Is there a release of the director's cut anywhere? I would be really interested in seeing it.

Dragon Turtle
08-11-2010, 02:20 PM
Is there a release of the director's cut anywhere? I would be really interested in seeing it.

No release, and given Warner Home Video's track record with TMNT DC/SE video releases, I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it.

ooglafina
08-11-2010, 03:07 PM
That's what I thought.

Andrew NDB
08-11-2010, 03:32 PM
No, it's not just you, the directors cut was about two hours long.

Not even close.

It's virtually the same movie without the fat they cut. Would have been preferable to leave the Casey proposal in there and a tiny bit more of the Winters exposition... but neither one of those tiny bits salvages much of anything despite what a lot of you folks seem to hope/wish.

Dragon Turtle
08-11-2010, 10:14 PM
Not even close.


Unless you can produce the directors cut on youtube, I'll stick with Kevin Monroe saying a 2 hour directors cut does indeed exist.



It's virtually the same movie without the fat they cut. Would have been preferable to leave the Casey proposal in there and a tiny bit more of the Winters exposition... but neither one of those tiny bits salvages much of anything despite what a lot of you folks seem to hope/wish.

Not much salvaging needed, if they had stuck closer to the Mirage approved script it would easily had been the best TMNT movie around.

sdp
08-11-2010, 11:54 PM
I was about to post my thoughts again when I realized my thoughts are still the same as before and they are on the first page of the thread so no reason to state them again.

I just want to say I really do like the movie though, it has its faults but everything in it



Clone Wars made it no secret it was little more then a made for tv animated series tossed into movie theaters to make a quick buck, and the fans treated it accordingly
Says you. I don't buy that at all. And what was TMNT advertised as? This is Star Wars we're talking about. These ppl camped outside to wait for the live action movies to come out. Give me one CGI movie that wasn't aimed at tots that made money and I'll happily agree with you....

Clone Wars was a last minute decision for it to come out as a movie in theaters, even Lucas described the film as "almost an afterthought". The movie was announced just months before it actually came out in theaters.

TMNT was advertised as an actual movie, heck we got a teaser poster 2 years before it came out. It may have been SWs but it was announced months before it came out and it was cartoony CG and marketed as the film that leads in to the new CG show premiering two months after the movie. And it got terrible reviews about how it felt like three episodes sewed together, of course it didn't do good, not necessarily because it was CG, this wasn't a movie that took 3 years to make like the other SWs movies. As for one movie not aimed at kids that made money, how about Avatar? Its techically mostly CG so it should count.

But with that said I definitely agree with you, no straight up CG movie can attract an older audience for the same reason an animated movie can't either. When they see it they think its a cartoon for kids and don't take it seriously, this is why there are very few animated movies (cg/traditional animation) aimed at an older crowd, its a sad fact. And yes this definitely hurt TMNT 2007 since a lot of people saw it as a kids movie because of it (also the fact that these weren't based on the 87 cartoon).



TMNT Part 4 wasn't even a real movie. It was like... a string of bad Playstation 1 game FMV sequences cut together. For little kids.

What? The CG in the movie was impressive at the time it came out I thought it was second only to Pixar in terms of CG, if you don't like the character designs thats another thing.

ooglafina
08-12-2010, 08:30 AM
What? The CG in the movie was impressive at the time it came out I thought it was second only to Pixar in terms of CG, if you don't like the character designs thats another thing.

I liked the character designs for the turtles. They were all a little different and they weren't the big hulking things like in the 2k3. Bigorexia turtles are super annoying to me. I didn't like the humans though. They had the typical sort of wacked cartoon proportions.

And no matter how many people say, "I didn't like it because I don't like CG," the CG was pretty good, at least for the time. That's really getting on my nerves. You categorically hate CG? That's a pretty broad generalization and sort of a cop out.

P.S. - I'm sort of in a bad mood right now because there are a bunch of fans on my wet carpet and it sounds and feels like a wind tunnel.

Candy Kappa
08-12-2010, 07:43 PM
What? The CG in the movie was impressive at the time it came out I thought it was second only to Pixar in terms of CG, if you don't like the character designs thats another thing.

don't think it'sso much about the quality of the CGI, but more on the horrible Camera directing.

The Camera Director for TMNT needs a kick some place painful