PDA

View Full Version : What was wrong with the 4th movie?


Pages : [1] 2

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 10:41 AM
I'm noticing a lot of recent disdain for it, and I want to know, why? Yes, it didn't break new ground and it was essentially a movie for kids and fans of the franchise, but I don't see what was wrong with it.

The movie was barely about the 13 monsters, it was mostly about the Turtles splitting away as a family and getting back together toward the end. This is why most of the monster stuff aside from two (Bigfoot, and Jersey Devil), all happened quickly and off-screen.

In the review threads for this movie, it was heavily praised. (You can check the poll on it at the top of this forum, just to see those old posts about peoples reaction to the movie).

Thoughts?

Cure
04-25-2009, 10:46 AM
It was boring and uninteresting, simple as that.

Ron
04-25-2009, 10:48 AM
It was boring and uninteresting, simple as that.

X2.

Ron

sdp
04-25-2009, 11:26 AM
I was going to make this topic but you beat me to it....Its really divided into two things:

What went wrong with the movie for me?

Kevin Monroe: He hyped the movie way too much in the forums. I loved that he posted here but he made me get huge unrealistic expectations based on
his posts.

The teaser: The teaser was amazing, it confirmed everything Kevin Monroe was saying was true which the movie wasn't.

Too much plot: Why set up the whole 13 monsters thing when they were pretty much not used, such a waste of time on something that wasn't fully used and anything with them felt like it was thrown to make us not forget about it. The foot was awesome but it added to the cluster of things the movie was already doing.


I liked the movie and I think its a good but it failed to be an amazing movie and one of the greatest TMNT stories like I(we were) was led to believe. And it failed to get me all excited about the TMNT after I saw it.

Doc_ock_4mugen
04-25-2009, 11:28 AM
Most of the monster hunt part was boring, the only pat that I think that was awesome was the Leo/Raph fight... also No Shredder... Most people hate the Shredder-less films... And the artistic look of the non-turtle characters is kinda bothersome to some people... at least to me... I hate when people look like the offspring of Stick figures and Tetris blocks.

sdp
04-25-2009, 11:36 AM
What went wrong with the movie for the general audience?


-CG, people wanted live action as CGI movies are still viewed as something for kids.

-No Shredder, It doesn't matter what people on this forum think to most of the TMNT fans, TMNT is the turtles and shredder.

-Too different from the OT, this movie is more like the new show than the old and people didn't like that.

-The movie is far from a great movie, its a decent film and a good TMNT story but it wasn't what people wanted. In fact everything in the movie was what people didn't associate the turtles with.

-TV spots and trailers were definitely geared for kids.


The movie had a lot of hype among the general audience and it started to decline more and more.

Aztec General
04-25-2009, 01:55 PM
The main storyline (immortal Conqusitadors, 13 monsters, rock soldeirs, etc.) was nonsensical, stupid, uninteresting, underused, and just plain awful. I have no idea why Peter Laird approved this trash. Perhaps an unknown like Kevin Munroe was all he could afford to hire?

Cipher
04-25-2009, 02:12 PM
Wasted opportunity (any mainstream Turtles fiction that doesn't up the ante hurts the franchise). Inconsistant tone. Unnecessary self-cencorship. Nonsensical, incoherrent plot.

Pick your poison. It did look pretty, though.

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 03:06 PM
The main storyline (immortal Conqusitadors, 13 monsters, rock soldeirs, etc.) was nonsensical, stupid, uninteresting, underused, and just plain awful. I have no idea why Peter Laird approved this trash. Perhaps an unknown like Kevin Munroe was all he could afford to hire?

That kind of plot is very similar to stuff we see in the Mirage comics all the time.

Maybe it wasn't best to use that plot for a theatrical movie, but that plot isn't any different than all the sci-fi or monster stuff in the Mirage comic universe.

Cipher
04-25-2009, 03:39 PM
Maybe it wasn't best to use that plot for a theatrical movie, but that plot isn't any different than all the sci-fi or monster stuff in the Mirage comic universe.It's not that it wasn't realistic, it's that it was sloppy. You can't plug thirteen monsters, an evil corporation, and ninja rivalries into an hour and twenty minutes. The fact that we didn't even see all the monsters shows how asinine that plotline was.

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 03:46 PM
The fact that we didn't even see all the monsters shows how asinine that plotline was.

I thought that was the point, the monsters were not the main focus on the movie, the focus was on the four brothers drifting apart (although mostly Leo and Raph), and the monsters were just to move the story along.

Did you really want to see them track down all 13 monsters in the film? I thought the way they did it was perfect, because if you stop to think about it, the movie wasn't "let's catch all the monsters ala Pokemon" like some people make it out to be.

I have some problems with the movies pacing itself, but the actual plot was no more ridiculous than what goes on in the Mirage universe half the time.

sdp
04-25-2009, 04:07 PM
The plot isn't necessarily out there for the TMNT however people were not expecting that. Even if the OT dealt a lot with sci-fi, magic etc. People don't expect that when they think of the turtles, they think of shredder and mutations.


Yeah the movie tried to do too much and its all clustered up in the movie.


It doesn't deserve the hate it gets definitely though. It was still a disappointment.

NiNi
04-25-2009, 04:08 PM
I like the 4th movie, but it did have some issues in my opinion.

Mainly it was the storyline. I mean they had to collect 13 monsters and such - you'd think that'd be more like something for a cartoon season if anything else. It was just a plot-line that didn't seem to work as a full length feature film.

Plus there was also the fact that Mikey and Don hardly had any screentime - that was a factor.

And that there seemed to be a wee bit more talking than action. Don't get me wrong, I love the dialogue in the movie when it was something meaningful - like when Splinter talks to Raph about the concept of favorite son/student.

Visually the movie was gorgeous, the voices were great, but it just seemed...like a rush job with the plotline.

Rooish
04-25-2009, 04:46 PM
I think the problem was that it was sort of an inexplicably inconsistent movie. It didn't work as a kids' movie (too dark at times), it didn't work as an adults' movie (too short, the jokes were too lame, the dramatic parts seemed rushed and corny), and it tried to cram in too much in too short a time. If they'd just stuck with Munroe's original script, which was better fleshed out and longer, it would have been much better. It seems that nearly every joke from Munroe's original script was shortened or tamed just slightly, making them fall flat, almost without exception. It wasn't funny! The theatre was full when I went, and no one laughed. It was silent! The only time I laughed was the Gilmore Girls gag, and Mike bringing his Cowabunga Carl head out at the end. I cringed a lot more than I laughed, or cried for that matter.

It was hyperactive; there were too many plot-lines to follow, so none of them got fully developed. Max Winters and the monsters had nothing, absolutely nothing, to do with the Turtles. Any sort of deep meaning that could be derived from it--such as Winters' attempts to achieve immortality--could not be tied in with the Turtles. I'm not saying that the movie needed a deep plot, but since it tried to be deep, it could have been consistent about it.

Both Winters and the Foot/Karai seemed like two completely unrelated extra plots. Didn't give enough time for the Turtles plot

The Turtles plot was okay, but I suspect that people who weren't really familiar with the conflicts between the Turtles (because all they knew were the old toon Turtles) must have been really confused by how unhappy the family seemed. Mike and Don were barely in the movie, and Leo and Raph acted like little bitches. Raph took over the movie for no clear reason, since he acted like a jerk the whole time and didn't improve (and Leo was no better).

I just watched it and felt that it wasn't a very good movie because it was too short and inconsistent. All it really worked as was an action/adventure, but in all other respects--drama, humour, character development, universal appeal, or consistency--it didn't work. I found it frustrating to watch because it could have been a lot more. Nice animation though!

Cipher
04-25-2009, 04:50 PM
Did you really want to see them track down all 13 monsters in the film? I thought the way they did it was perfect, because if you stop to think about it, the movie wasn't "let's catch all the monsters ala Pokemon" like some people make it out to be.That's all fine, but if you're not going to invest time into the thirteen monsters, don't put the thirteen monsters into the film. It's writing 101.

Aztec General
04-25-2009, 05:18 PM
That's all fine, but if you're not going to invest time into the thirteen monsters, don't put the thirteen monsters into the film. It's writing 101.

LOL. Exactly. What was the point if they weren't going to do anything with it? Can anyone tell me why those monsters needed to be in the film to begin with? Aside from possible cute looking toys?

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 05:21 PM
LOL. Exactly. What was the point if they weren't going to do anything with it? Can anyone tell me why those monsters needed to be in the film to begin with? Aside from possible cute looking toys?

So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?

Candy Kappa
04-25-2009, 05:36 PM
loved the visuals, the cgi was amazing, but its seems like everyone is trying to do the same style, pixar, dreamworks and imagi
but the story was weak and bad written, the movie was way too short (and they edited away scenes)

Aztec General
04-25-2009, 05:37 PM
So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?

What does any of that have to do with the TMNT? Who cares? 13 Monsters breaks the curse of immortality? What an incredibly stupid plot device! Why even bother having the TMNT in a movie about this?

You are free to your own opinion of course...but my lord the storyline was GOD AWFUL! Peter Laird must have been smoking some funky stuff when he approved this garbage.

Candy Kappa
04-25-2009, 05:44 PM
i find most of the stuff in his review true, I disagree on the splinter part thought

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-critic/6246-tmnt

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 06:47 PM
What does any of that have to do with the TMNT? Who cares? 13 Monsters breaks the curse of immortality? What an incredibly stupid plot device! Why even bother having the TMNT in a movie about this?

So wait, in other words in order for something "having to do with TMNT," it has to constantly be about Shredder and the Foot, or the big-name villains like Baxter, Rat King, etc...?

Again, how is this different than the random one-shot monsters or aliens they face in the Mirage universe? And whether you like it or not, those characters are now canon TMNT characters.

Peter Laird must have been smoking some funky stuff when he approved this garbage.

If Peter Laird thought the movie script was bad, he wouldn't have bothered to spend all that time on it.

Cure
04-25-2009, 07:37 PM
So wait, in other words in order for something "having to do with TMNT," it has to constantly be about Shredder and the Foot, or the big-name villains like Baxter, Rat King, etc...?

Again, how is this different than the random one-shot monsters or aliens they face in the Mirage universe? And whether you like it or not, those characters are now canon TMNT characters.



If Peter Laird thought the movie script was bad, he wouldn't have bothered to spend all that time on it.

OK, you asked and got your answer. What's the point of disputing it with everyone when you got what you wanted?

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 07:39 PM
OK, you asked and your got answer. What's the point of disputing it with everyone when you got what you wanted?

Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.

Despite the fact it had the Turtles, Splinter, Casey, April, Karai and the Foot.

I bet if this movie had come out directly to DVD, and wasn't a theatrical release, people would just accept it for what it was.

ToTheNines
04-25-2009, 07:55 PM
Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.

Because a theatrical release is a big ****in deal. No one except fans read the comic, so when aliens show up in issue 32 of tales, no one gives a ****. But when it's a movie, everyone sees it... it's a hell of a lot longer... and it takes bunches a money to make. So you don't want to **** it up, you make it as good as possible.

CyberCubed
04-25-2009, 09:27 PM
The movie has some problems, but its not a disaster. As said, if this wasn't a theatrical release, I bet half the people complaining about it just wouldn't care.

Dragon Turtle
04-26-2009, 04:34 AM
Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.


Just like CGI vs live-action, or whether or not the movie reflected any particular version of TMNT, some people will not like sci-sf and fantansy elements, but those elements are as much as part of TMNT then anything else. It's all subjective.

As to what I feel were the shortcomings of the 4th movie:

1) Lack of action: There just wasn't enough action in the movie to appeal to casual non-turtle fans, who are not going to a movie theater to watch a movie that wasn't going to wow them. Even the fight between Leo and Raph, while technically beautiful, was short and vanilla. With the CGI medium you could have crafted set pieces that live-action could never hope to achieve.


2) Underdeveloped plot: Immortals? 13 monsters? Honestly, the premise was no more stupid then most TMNT plots, including the first movie, the difference being is how much those plots are developed. Max Winters, the stone warriors, and the monsters are barely seen throughout the film. I would compare the way they were handled in the same way Ghostbusters handled the Gozer plot, but unlike TMNT, there is more to the story then just Gozer.
The other major plot point (Leo and Raph) also feels short and somewhat contrived.

TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Personally, I was not a huge fan of the human character designs, Matsuda's designs might work better for 2d animation, but his simple cartoonish designs didn't work for me here.


Still TMNT was a good movie, pretty much on par with the first one.

Kendamu
04-26-2009, 05:12 AM
I didn't hate it by any means. In fact, I had fun! However, I read the novel before I watched the movie, so I had slightly different expectations based on what I imagined. Not a huge problem, though.

My only really big gripe is that the TMNT vs. Foot Ninja scene outside of Winters' tower was waaaaaay to short! If that scene had been even only twice as long (about two minutes) I would've been happy and it would've been my favorite part!

Overall, I think the fourth movie is probably my second-favorite of the four. I don't like the third movie and I can only take so much Vanilla Ice before I have to stay away from the second movie for awhile due to it's climax.

Really, if there's anything I can say that can improve future TMNT movies, is that there needs to be more Ninja battles and less magic warriors fighting monsters. Considering where the new movie is supposed to be going, I think I'll get my wish in a couple years.

Candy Kappa
04-26-2009, 05:35 AM
I also didn't like the scene shooting, like in the foot fight, it did hardly contain any editing, it was like watching a game not a movie.
like in advent children, they had camera angles and views that can't be done in live movies and it look amazing.

while tmnt it looked like they just made the camera view follow around in the 3d program, render it and they just went "that was quick, lets keep that"

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-26-2009, 08:00 AM
The plot. I hated those stone generals and Raphael being so violent. The best TMNT story with one leaving the other is the 1987 cartoon's "Take Me to Your Leader".

Cipher
04-26-2009, 01:22 PM
So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?I'm going to try to explain this very slowly. Again.

The monsters may have been integrated (somewhat) into the plot. But the fact is that all of those plot points could be tied together with something less cumbersome than thirteen (unseen) monsters. Hell, just put one or two monsters in the movie for the Generals to hunt down, if you really, really have to have them in there at all.

I don't have a problem with supernatural elements (although the Turtles do need to have a more serious tale on the big-screen). It was just sloppy, awful writing.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-26-2009, 03:02 PM
Just like CGI vs live-action, or whether or not the movie reflected any particular version of TMNT, some people will not like sci-sf and fantansy elements, but those elements are as much as part of TMNT then anything else. It's all subjective.

As to what I feel were the shortcomings of the 4th movie:

1) Lack of action: There just wasn't enough action in the movie to appeal to casual non-turtle fans, who are not going to a movie theater to watch a movie that wasn't going to wow them. Even the fight between Leo and Raph, while technically beautiful, was short and vanilla. With the CGI medium you could have crafted set pieces that live-action could never hope to achieve.


2) Underdeveloped plot: Immortals? 13 monsters? Honestly, the premise was no more stupid then most TMNT plots, including the first movie, the difference being is how much those plots are developed. Max Winters, the stone warriors, and the monsters are barely seen throughout the film. I would compare the way they were handled in the same way Ghostbusters handled the Gozer plot, but unlike TMNT, there is more to the story then just Gozer.
The other major plot point (Leo and Raph) also feels short and somewhat contrived.

TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Personally, I was not a huge fan of the human character designs, Matsuda's designs might work better for 2d animation, but his simple cartoonish designs didn't work for me here.


Still TMNT was a good movie, pretty much on par with the first one.

I like some science fiction, the entire concept of four turtles mutating is already still science fiction, but not fantasy. Fantasy belongs to fantasy movies/stories (like the Lord of the Rings, Mio, My Mio, the Brothers Lionheart, Willow, and even He-Man has some fantasy in it).

Buslady
04-26-2009, 05:31 PM
The good: CGI, family element, mako, raph was hot

the bad: story was bland.

basically that's it. the main story line was weak, it was so run of the mill bland...yay monsters. How zzzzzzzzz.........

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-27-2009, 05:08 PM
The good: CGI, family element, mako, raph was hot

the bad: story was bland.

basically that's it. the main story line was weak, it was so run of the mill bland...yay monsters. How zzzzzzzzz.........

I agree on CGI. Maybe they should test it more. But classic animation is what I like best.

gobo
04-27-2009, 05:24 PM
What was wrong with the 4th movie?
No resonance. It wasn't bad by any means, but it wasn't very memorable.

Ralphmacchio
04-27-2009, 06:04 PM
I'd rather watch the third one then this film.

Yes, I'd rather watch a paper thin story about the Turtles time traveling back to feudal japan then watch this. The story had no pacing, no character development, very uninteresting plot points. The back story of the bad guy was really dumb. Just a really uneven and easily forgotten movie. The Ralp-Leo fight was good but that's about it. If we are going to be fans, then we should be able to criticize.

BoggleKng
04-27-2009, 08:00 PM
I didn't hate it by any means. In fact, I had fun! However, I read the novel before I watched the movie, so I had slightly different expectations based on what I imagined. Not a huge problem, though.


The movie comic was a bit better and more involved.. The movie didn't totally stick as much as the 3rd one.... I found myself chuckling art Raph's one liners but that was about it.. kinda hard for people to pick up TMNT from it if they haven't been previously introduced..

Spitfire
04-27-2009, 10:53 PM
It fell apart in the second act and only a few scenes really grabbed me.

Andrew NDB
04-28-2009, 02:08 AM
TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Nonsense. Unless there is a ton of establishing shots that didn't make the final cut, 98% of the movie we got is the movie that was in Munroe's script.

And to ask what was wrong with the movie? I'm being very honest, but I think an easier question to pose would be what wasn't wrong with it... to answer that question, maybe... eh... I guess the Turtles' CGI was pretty decent? Except for Mikey? A couple of the family/unity moments worked well, too, even if they seemed like they belonged in a better Turtles movie.

Dragon Turtle
04-28-2009, 02:25 AM
Nonsense. Unless there is a ton of establishing shots that didn't make the final cut, 98% of the movie we got is the movie that was in Munroe's script.


Just going by what Monroe said on the dvd and other places, the movie was around two hours long before cutdowns, and only a third of what was deleted made it to the dvd.

Andrew NDB
04-28-2009, 02:36 AM
Just going by what Monroe said on the dvd and other places, the movie was around two hours long before cutdowns, and only a third of what was deleted made it to the dvd.

That simply isn't true. At best, grossly exaggerated.

Dragon Turtle
04-28-2009, 03:17 AM
That simply isn't true. At best, grossly exaggerated.

Kevin Monroe:


As for DVD extras – yeeaahhh – how much does the locked commentary suck? I can’t imagine why anyone would think that no one is interested in the ACTUAL AUDIO. It was just dumb. And those were still around a third of the actual alt scenes that didn’t make it in the movie, so I have no idea when those will surface, if ever. But it was nice to have some of those clips see the light of day. And especially nice to show a hint that we actually DID feature Mikey and Donnie more before they were taken out.


From the DVD:

"after we got everything up on reels, and the entire running time was like two hours long we realized that it was enough for it's own movie (the April/Casey subplot).

Spitfire
04-28-2009, 03:50 AM
Odd that there are alt scenes and cut stuff since he went off about how you don't animate what you don't intend to use because it cost extra money and all that. That's quite a bit to cut.

thebrownranger
04-28-2009, 09:41 AM
What was wrong with the 2007 movie?

EVERYTHING.

I really can't seem to understand why everyone thinks this movie is so amazing or at least decent. The story by far, takes the cake for crappiest element of the movie. Seriously, the legend of Yaotl?? Max Winters wasn't even close to a villain. Oh yeah, let's not forget that cheesy opening intro which put me to sleep. The 4 stone generals idea made it even less interesting. Where the f*** where all the 13 monsters?! This makes a better cartoon story arc than for a major film. IMO it appeals to only the very young generation of 5-10 year old TMNT fans. Donny and Mikey hardly had any screen-time, and Splinter looked like deformed dog for crying out loud. The CG humans looked terrible. Chris Evans and SMG were horrible picks for Casey/April (let's not forget how bad they looked). God, I hope they're not candidates for the new 2011 film. The fight scenes were a joke and it came out to be a comedy instead. As for music, the entire album sucked. Klaus Badelt's scores were so-so b/c it didn't have that dark ninjitsu type sound to it like the first movie had. The turtles looked alright, but they could have done way better. For some reason the sci-fi crap does NOT go well at all with a ninja turtles movie. That's another reason I'm not all that crazy about having Stockman/the mousers/ the utroms in the upcoming 2011 film, and I guess thats why the original first movie kicked TMNT (2007)'s ass. I think just the Shredder/the Foot clan will do just fine for the new movie. The original movie was straight up to the point with an awesome plot and fight scenes. I don't know why the hell Laird let this 2007 movie pass. TMNT(2007) was not even a tmnt movie or a movie in general to say the least. It was dissapointing, stupid, uninteresting, boring, childish, too short, and cliche.

'NUFF SAID.

Dragon Turtle
04-28-2009, 02:20 PM
Odd that there are alt scenes and cut stuff since he went off about how you don't animate what you don't intend to use because it cost extra money and all that. That's quite a bit to cut.

It was probably one of the reasons why he wasn't really considered for the CGI sequel, I doubt any of the higher ups were happy about all that money left on the cutting room floor, and maybe a reason he ran into problems on Gatchaman.

cqb101
04-28-2009, 02:27 PM
I still have yet to be able to sit through the movie without falling asleep.

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
04-28-2009, 04:30 PM
Better than the II & III for sure but doesn't come close to the first movie. I basically didn't like the story. The whole monsters thing was a ploy by 4kids and Playmates to sell toys. Period. They should of done a story with the Turtles against Karai and the Foot, leading up to Shredder's return in the sequel. (The sequel that we now are not getting.) The best part of the movie was the Leo/Raph rooftop fight. Superb animation but other than that, I can file the film under the "Okay" category.

Extreme_Enigma
04-28-2009, 04:57 PM
Sorry if anyone else had the same reasons and posted it on here.(I didn't read the whole thread)
1. Why have the monster story when it's about the turtles getting back together?
2. Michelangelo never said a word to Raphael the whole movie.
3. I had some others but I lost them. :ohwell:

Candy Kappa
04-28-2009, 05:02 PM
having 13 monster was a bit overboard when we hardly see half of them.

Lil G
04-30-2009, 08:21 AM
Sorry if anyone else had the same reasons and posted it on here.(I didn't read the whole thread)
1. Why have the monster story when it's about the turtles getting back together?
2. Michelangelo never said a word to Raphael the whole movie.
3. I had some others but I lost them. :ohwell:

Oh god you don't know how hard I was just laughing because of that last line.:lol::lol::lol:

Lil G
04-30-2009, 08:24 AM
What was wrong with the 2007 movie?

EVERYTHING.

I really can't seem to understand why everyone thinks this movie is so amazing or at least decent. The story by far, takes the cake for crappiest element of the movie. Seriously, the legend of Yaotl?? Max Winters wasn't even close to a villain. Oh yeah, let's not forget that cheesy opening intro which put me to sleep. The 4 stone generals idea made it even less interesting. Where the f*** where all the 13 monsters?! This makes a better cartoon story arc than for a major film. IMO it appeals to only the very young generation of 5-10 year old TMNT fans. Donny and Mikey hardly had any screen-time, and Splinter looked like deformed dog for crying out loud. The CG humans looked terrible. Chris Evans and SMG were horrible picks for Casey/April (let's not forget how bad they looked). God, I hope they're not candidates for the new 2011 film. The fight scenes were a joke and it came out to be a comedy instead. As for music, the entire album sucked. Klaus Badelt's scores were so-so b/c it didn't have that dark ninjitsu type sound to it like the first movie had. The turtles looked alright, but they could have done way better. For some reason the sci-fi crap does NOT go well at all with a ninja turtles movie. That's another reason I'm not all that crazy about having Stockman/the mousers/ the utroms in the upcoming 2011 film, and I guess thats why the original first movie kicked TMNT (2007)'s ass. I think just the Shredder/the Foot clan will do just fine for the new movie. The original movie was straight up to the point with an awesome plot and fight scenes. I don't know why the hell Laird let this 2007 movie pass. TMNT(2007) was not even a tmnt movie or a movie in general to say the least. It was dissapointing, stupid, uninteresting, boring, childish, too short, and cliche.

'NUFF SAID.

Lighten up dude. It wasn't that bad. I would give it a good 6.5/10. You're just one of those dudes that are missing the old TMNT movies, so when a new movie comes out you automatically put it down if it isn't drop dead good.

thebrownranger
04-30-2009, 02:17 PM
Lighten up dude. It wasn't that bad. I would give it a good 6.5/10. You're just one of those dudes that are missing the old TMNT movies, so when a new movie comes out you automatically put it down if it isn't drop dead good.

Umm, and you know exactly the type of person I am right? Listen, I've watched it enough for myself to know where things go well and where things fall off. Do I miss the first film? Absolutely, but don't think I was expecting this to be a disaster from the beginning just b/c it was all CG with a different story and nobody from the original cast was there. People have their differences with tmnt depending on what they liked or grew up with the most. The first time I was ever exposed to the turtles was when the first movie came out. Then came the comics and cartoon for me. That's how I became a fan. So next time dude, please don't make any assumptions about a person you barely know. Just to let you know.

Andrew NDB
05-01-2009, 09:34 PM
Kevin Monroe:


As for DVD extras – yeeaahhh – how much does the locked commentary suck? I can’t imagine why anyone would think that no one is interested in the ACTUAL AUDIO. It was just dumb. And those were still around a third of the actual alt scenes that didn’t make it in the movie, so I have no idea when those will surface, if ever. But it was nice to have some of those clips see the light of day. And especially nice to show a hint that we actually DID feature Mikey and Donnie more before they were taken out.


From the DVD:

"after we got everything up on reels, and the entire running time was like two hours long we realized that it was enough for it's own movie (the April/Casey subplot).

I'm aware of what he's said. I'm telling you flat out there simply isn't enough material in the original script to support the amount of running time he's trumpeting about. It doesn't exist.

Dragon Turtle
05-02-2009, 02:20 AM
I'm aware of what he's said. I'm telling you flat out there simply isn't enough material in the original script to support the amount of running time he's trumpeting about. It doesn't exist.

So is Monroe lying about this extra footage, for what reason, and where did you see the original script?

Sage Ninja
05-02-2009, 07:06 PM
I think the problem was that it was sort of an inexplicably inconsistent movie. It didn't work as a kids' movie (too dark at times), it didn't work as an adults' movie (too short, the jokes were too lame, the dramatic parts seemed rushed and corny), and it tried to cram in too much in too short a time. If they'd just stuck with Munroe's original script, which was better fleshed out and longer, it would have been much better. It seems that nearly every joke from Munroe's original script was shortened or tamed just slightly, making them fall flat, almost without exception. It wasn't funny! The theatre was full when I went, and no one laughed. It was silent! The only time I laughed was the Gilmore Girls gag, and Mike bringing his Cowabunga Carl head out at the end. I cringed a lot more than I laughed, or cried for that matter.

It was hyperactive; there were too many plot-lines to follow, so none of them got fully developed. Max Winters and the monsters had nothing, absolutely nothing, to do with the Turtles. Any sort of deep meaning that could be derived from it--such as Winters' attempts to achieve immortality--could not be tied in with the Turtles. I'm not saying that the movie needed a deep plot, but since it tried to be deep, it could have been consistent about it.

Both Winters and the Foot/Karai seemed like two completely unrelated extra plots. Didn't give enough time for the Turtles plot

The Turtles plot was okay, but I suspect that people who weren't really familiar with the conflicts between the Turtles (because all they knew were the old toon Turtles) must have been really confused by how unhappy the family seemed. Mike and Don were barely in the movie, and Leo and Raph acted like little bitches. Raph took over the movie for no clear reason, since he acted like a jerk the whole time and didn't improve (and Leo was no better).
I just watched it and felt that it wasn't a very good movie because it was too short and inconsistent. All it really worked as was an action/adventure, but in all other respects--drama, humour, character development, universal appeal, or consistency--it didn't work. I found it frustrating to watch because it could have been a lot more. Nice animation though!

spoken for truth. Took the words right outta my mouth especially the part I bolded.

Rooish
05-04-2009, 07:27 PM
Nice to know we're still on the same page, Sagey. :D

Sage Ninja
05-04-2009, 10:12 PM
**hugs Rooish**Me too! how've you been girl! :)

to elaberate more on on Rooish's comment on Raph and Leo here:

Leo and Raph acted like little bitches. Raph took over the movie for no clear reason, since he acted like a jerk the whole time and didn't improve (and Leo was no better).

this might get me alot of hate coming my way but, I think one of the reasons the 4th movie needed was not have Leo and Raph dominate the whole thing like they did. Actually, I think what future TMNT movies need to realize is that Don and Mikey are main characters too, not just Raph and Leo and their rivalry. ANd they seriously need to be more than just supporting characters or back drop props. The turtles are about the four of them, not just the two. Don and Mikey really need to come into their own as main characters with their nuiances and not just their religated sterotypes, of the brainy one and the baby brother/comic relief. Mikey and Don have their own stories to tell. Their own thoughts and emotions that need to be explored.

lukekeith
05-05-2009, 02:05 AM
I think one of the biggest things I really disliked about the TMNT film was the poorly constructed "power struggle" as I've come to call it. You see, I'm an avid anime fan, and one thing that anime does VERY well is develop a character over time and provide logical reasons why they get stronger over the course of a story.

For example.....

In the TMNT film....

first part of movie:
- All four turtles fight one of the monsters and get their butts kicked, it wasn't even close.

- Stone people show up and take out the monster in a single blow.

(by this logic we can assume that if turtles are weaker than monster, and stone people are stronger than monster, then turtles are MUCH weaker than stone people... right?)

end of movie:
- Turtles fight stone people ONE VS. ONE AND WIN!!! (under the guise of "teamwork" when... oh wait... THEY FOUGHT ONE VS. ONE!!! How is that teamwork exactly? And how did they become 50 times stronger in a matter of days? Did anybody else find that amusing? Or am I just overdosing on crazy pills?

My other large frustration is they are constantly downplaying Splinter's wisdom. He is supposed to be their mentor, however... everytime he tells them not to do something (usually Raph) and they do it anyway, it always works out for the better!

By that logic if Splinter says to Raphael "don't go out", and Raph goes out anyway... but his impulsive actions put him in a situation where he learns critical information that leads to their victory in the end... does that make Splinter an idiot or Raphael wiser than Splinter?

The movie is FILLED with stuff like that... even within an absurd universe where turtles are mutated into humanoid creatures who can use ninja you can still use common sense!

Rooish
05-05-2009, 07:26 PM
this might get me alot of hate coming my way but, I think one of the reasons the 4th movie needed was not have Leo and Raph dominate the whole thing like they did. Actually, I think what future TMNT movies need to realize is that Don and Mikey are main characters too, not just Raph and Leo and their rivalry. ANd they seriously need to be more than just supporting characters or back drop props. The turtles are about the four of them, not just the two. Don and Mikey really need to come into their own as main characters with their nuiances and not just their religated sterotypes, of the brainy one and the baby brother/comic relief. Mikey and Don have their own stories to tell. Their own thoughts and emotions that need to be explored.

Hugs to you, too! Also, agreed. I find the Leo/Raph conflict almost boring without it being tempered by Mike and Don ... I remember in another thread, other people arguing that Mike or Don could not carry a movie very well. That's the whole point, though, neither can Leo or Raph. A movie needs all four of them, more or less equally. People who don't think Don and Mike are interesting aren't bothering to learn about them. I'm sure Munroe would have expanded on them given more time, but he didn't, which was disappointing.

I think one of the biggest things I really disliked about the TMNT film was the poorly constructed "power struggle" as I've come to call it. You see, I'm an avid anime fan, and one thing that anime does VERY well is develop a character over time and provide logical reasons why they get stronger over the course of a story.

Yeah, I love that about anime! It took me a while to realize that anime's ridiculously slow-moving plots led to intense character development. I love it now that I see it.

DougieTMNT
05-06-2009, 03:11 AM
I have quite a few problems with the movie. The biggest one for me is the animation style, I think it works fine for the Turtles, but I hate the design of pretty much all the other characters. They look ridiculous.

jalexbrown
05-07-2009, 10:49 AM
I can't be the only one here who kind of liked the 4th movie. I mean, setting aside the terrible story and the fact that the humans looked liked semi-deformed stick figures, it was the Turtles for heaven's sake. When I see the Turtles on screen, I get excited regardless. And after so many years without seeing them on the big screen, the 4th movie was that much more exciting. As a whole, though, I think that the 4th movie left fans thirsty with their mouths dry. It wasn't quite what anybody was hoping for, so no matter what you were in for you came out kind of disappointed. All-in-all, though, I didn't think it was a great movie, but I can definitely look past its shortcomings because the Turtles are in it.

Ginny
05-07-2009, 01:07 PM
I liked the 4th movie. I'm a huge animation fan, so I thought the CGI was pretty cool. The story was interesting, although there were some rather gaping plot holes. I can't say I loved it, or hated it, but I know what scene annoyed me the most and what scene I loved the most. The end with Mikey's sneezing fit annoyed me beyond belief. I mean, was that really necessary? My favorite scene (of course) had to be the Raph/Leo fight. I thought it was very well done.

I wouldn't be at all upset if many aspects of the new film were done in CGI, although I think I'm in the minority on that one.

jalexbrown
05-07-2009, 01:26 PM
Aside from the story, the CGI used in the 4th movie didn't bother me at all. And besides, I do think that in the process of bashing the 4th movie we often times forget that 4th movie > 3rd movie. As long as the 5th movie manages to surpass the 3rd, I'll be remotely satisfied with it, even though I'd definitely prefer seeing it done to its fullest potential.

Jelly Bean
05-12-2009, 07:26 PM
I don't know what every one is so pissed about in the CGI movie. It was turtles. It was fighting. Does it really matter that it had stone warriors in it? How was the plot any more out there than something from the 4kids cartoon?

I think people are just mad that Casey and April didn't have an explicit sweaty hump and grind scene.

Coola Yagami
05-12-2009, 08:36 PM
I don't know what every one is so pissed about in the CGI movie. It was turtles. It was fighting. Does it really matter that it had stone warriors in it? How was the plot any more out there than something from the 4kids cartoon?

I think people are just mad that Casey and April didn't have an explicit sweaty hump and grind scene.


It was Turtles... no it was Leo and Raph... and those other 2 guys...
It was fighting... no.. it was Leo and Raph fighting.. and those other 2 guys... kinda/sorta fighting/blink and you miss it....
Stone Warriors? Not a prob as long as ALL FOUR Turtles get to equally fight them, instead of mostly Raph and Leo, and then all 4 of them jumpkicking them into the portal....
The plots from the 4Kids cartoon usually have all 4 turtles in it fighting...

Yes we needed an explicit April/Casey sweaty bump and grind scene... or at least an April shower scene...

plastroncafe
05-12-2009, 09:04 PM
I'm late to this party, but I really liked the 2007 movie. It was far from perfect, but it was the best non-comic treatment the characters have gotten to date.

The Bad:

- Plot holes.
Why did the generals move? What was up with the red glowing crystals?
- The Unnecessary voice overs.
Isn't the first rule of film: show, don't tell.
- "Brothers"
Drink every time you hear this word and you'll be well on your way to alcohol poisoning. Lay off the plot hammer boys, someone's going to get hurt.
- Celebrity voice actors
I love Sarah Michelle Gellar, I do. But...she wasn't April. She was Sarah Michelle Gellar.
- Not enough Mikey and Don
I really truly wish that they added in the deleted scenes, or at least put them on the dvd without commentary.

The Good:

- The Voice Actors
All four turtles were amazing. I hope with all my fanboy heart that they tap these guys to do the voices in the next movie.
- MAKO!
Such a shame to have lost him.
- The kitchen table scene
I would watch an entire movie of nothing but The Turtles at Home.
- The Roof fight
Waited my entire fannish life for that scene alone. And it was everything I wanted it to be.
- The humor
Smoke pellets, prat falls, Casey and Raph's heart to heart...er snooze.

Rooish
05-12-2009, 09:29 PM
It was Turtles... no it was Leo and Raph... and those other 2 guys...
It was fighting... no.. it was Leo and Raph fighting.. and those other 2 guys... kinda/sorta fighting/blink and you miss it....
Stone Warriors? Not a prob as long as ALL FOUR Turtles get to equally fight them, instead of mostly Raph and Leo, and then all 4 of them jumpkicking them into the portal....
The plots from the 4Kids cartoon usually have all 4 turtles in it fighting...

Yes we needed an explicit April/Casey sweaty bump and grind scene... or at least an April shower scene...

I thought that with the group fight scenes, they coula at least focused more on Mike and Don them. They could have been like, "Oh yeah, this is what we've been missing out on for 2 years!"

Coola Yagami
05-12-2009, 09:32 PM
IMO They should have added those finished deleted scenes into the movie already... instead of having to pay for some Director's Cut later on down...

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-12-2009, 10:11 PM
I personally like the 4th movie, it just doesn't withstand the test of time very well. I enjoyed it the first time I saw it, but for some reason, it seems to drag on longer and longer every time I rewatch it. :ohwell:

Still, I do like that it's considerably more serious than any of the previous three movies. But I'd still have to rank it below the first movie and, yes, even the second movie. The third movie is still an abomination, though.

plastroncafe
05-12-2009, 10:14 PM
The third movie is still an abomination, though.

That's how I feel about the second one.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-12-2009, 10:28 PM
That's how I feel about the second one.

Ya, I'll admit that the second movie was a considerable step down from the fantastic first movie. There's way too much stupidity in it, but I think the third movie is even worse. The second movie at least has its moments, and I really liked Donatello's wanting to discover a sense of purpose. The third movie, however, was just one horrible, face-palming one-liner after another, with the Turtles all being goofy idiots that share the same personality and no depth, whatsoever... and even Splinter was a bit of a goofy idiot. And that's just wrong.

Ginny
05-13-2009, 12:17 PM
IMO They should have added those finished deleted scenes into the movie already... instead of having to pay for some Director's Cut later on down...

OMG you are so right! I loved every single deleted scene, they all should have been in there.

shuriken
05-14-2009, 01:31 AM
I think there was a lot wrong with it actually. Starting with two plots that really didn't need to be there and an unnatural love for Leo and Raph on Screen.
Ok I Guess I'll do a list of the Good and the Bad.
Good
1-Animation was very well done, the turtles looked awesome, it took a while for me to get used to their designs though.
2-Voice work for the most part was done very well, Chris Evans did a surprisingly good job with Casey and Karai sounded super smexy.
3-New York never looked this cool and cgi-ish.
4-The Leo and Raph fight was amazing.

Bad
1-Max Winters plot was all over the place. Since this has nothing to do with the turtles they decided to tie it to the story by making April work for the guy.
2-If the monsters were released thousands of years ago in CENTRAL AMERICA WTF are they ALL doing in New York? Shouldn't the portal be in CENTRAL AMERICA/ Somewhere in Mexico or Guatemala?
3-Why the hell does Raph wear the Nightwatcher suit and not use his sais as a crimefighter? He did fine before the suit, why use it now?
4-The Foot Clan was pretty useless and added next to nill to the plot. I like Karai but they couldn't even catch one f*cking monster and did a really crappy job defending Winters's fortress thing ( I mean come on the 1st movie foot soldiers were 10x more intimidating than those ant looking bastards). Onece the Stone generals got going they all captured the monsters with relative ease.
5-Leo made no sense reprimanding Raph for being the Night-watcher because he was doing what they should have been doing from the get go, fighting crime.
6-Splinter was also useless. Sending Leo to train made things worse, and he seemed completely oblivious to the fact that there was tension within his family, while in the first movie he could communicate with them through meditation. WTF
7-13 monsters with stars aligning and an immortal doesn't really scream out TMNT for me. I think it would have made more sense if Winters hired the foot to find the four stone warriors to break the curse instead of 13 monsters. But then again why have that element in the movie ata all?
8-Humans looked like sh*t.Jokes all sucked, although Cowabunga carl is an awesome idea.
9-Simple math
TMNT>Bigfoot>Stone Generals>TMNT?( with relative ease I might add)
10-all of the above.
Overall I give the movie a 5 out of 10. It did some things right, while failing at others like a sensical plot and character development. It wasn't very memorable and I left the theatres feeling dissapointed and embarrassed. I tired to like it and defended before it came out but it just wasn't for me.

Andrew NDB
05-14-2009, 06:00 PM
5-Leo made no sense reprimanding Raph for being the Night-watcher because he was doing what they should have been doing from the get go, fighting crime.

That's really the antithesis of the TMNT: they're not crimefighters. And why would they be? Why should they be? Why should they patrol the streets of a world they can never be a part of?

It makes sense in the context of the movie (even though the movie itself is mostly sh**) that Raphael would adopt a crimefighting persona as a way to blow off steam... however it does not make sense as a regular profession or mission of any of the TMNT. These aren't superheroes or vigilantes... they're ninja who have enemies and occasionally become involved in some crazy situations.

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 06:44 PM
That's really the antithesis of the TMNT: they're not crimefighters. And why would they be? Why should they be? Why should they patrol the streets of a world they can never be a part of?

It makes sense in the context of the movie (even though the movie itself is mostly sh**) that Raphael would adopt a crimefighting persona as a way to blow off steam... however it does not make sense as a regular profession or mission of any of the TMNT. These aren't superheroes or vigilantes... they're ninja who have enemies and occasionally become involved in some crazy situations.

Don't Raph and Leo have this very argument during City at War?

Andrew NDB
05-14-2009, 09:14 PM
Don't Raph and Leo have this very argument during City at War?

Yes they do.

"We're not the saviors of mankind. We never were."

Rooish
05-14-2009, 09:41 PM
I thought Don said that. In RtNY. ;)

But whatever. Oddly, in the comics, it's Leo who often wants to avoid the situation (I seem to recall him not wanting to return in RtNY, and not wanting to get involved in CaW, while Raph did). But in the 2003 show, Raph doesn't want to get involved and Leo does.

I thought Raph was kinda out-of-character in those episodes, and indeed for most of the 2003 show. But that's really off-topic, I suppose.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-14-2009, 11:07 PM
Well, but then again, the way the movie is presented, they make it seem like the Turtles are superheroes, which is why Leo's lecture on the rooftop doesn't seem to make sense to most people (especially those unfamiliar with the comics). I remember the Nostalgia Critic had the same complaint as Shuriken.

I think that's a big problem with all the TMNT universes that aren't the original Mirage comics, is that the TMNT are presented as superheroes who fight crime and patrol the city, rather than how they should be portrayed: unfortunate abnormalities who try to mind their own business most of the time, but end up attracting trouble due to their uniqueness. I'm really hoping that the upcoming movie finds a way to drive home the point that the TMNT are NOT superheroes. I really hate it when the media calls them superheroes, and further perpetuates this fallacy. :ohwell:

Coola Yagami
05-15-2009, 12:38 AM
The movie had them patrol the rooftops.... Leo have a problem vigilantees... while not having a problem with Casey.... and then they all go back to being vigilantees anyways...

Andrew NDB
05-15-2009, 12:48 AM
Well, but then again, the way the movie is presented, they make it seem like the Turtles are superheroes,

The movie had them patrol the rooftops....

The movies don't have much to do with the Mirage source material/core TMNT universe.

I think that's a big problem with all the TMNT universes that aren't the original Mirage comics

You recognize the problem, then. Here's to the reboot getting it right... maybe.

plastroncafe
05-15-2009, 10:15 AM
I was on my way into work this morning rehashing in my head a debate going on else forum, when something hit me. One of the main reasons why I enjoyed the 2007 movie as much as I did.

Leo made sense to me.

I started out with turtles as a staunch Raph girl, but then as time moved on I've become more and more of a fan of Mike. Don I've always felt like I've understood, though he's never a character I've been able to "identify" with, for lack of a better term.

Leo? Has always been boring to me. He's Superman. He's Cyclops. He's...the boyscout. And it wasn't until this new movie, where his emotions and neurosis were laid out on the table very bluntly that I really understood where he's coming from.

For me, the 2007 movie was more of a character study than an actual story, and I think that's why it's been so easy for me to just up and overlook the parts of the story that just didn't work. The breakfast scene alone was worth the price of admission. It reminded me that my favorite X-men issues aren't the ones where they're saving the world, or having OMG Maximum DRAMAZ, but when they're playing touch football with a "no powers" rule.

That's what the 2007 movie gave me, albeit in tinier than I'd like amounts. And that's why I think I'll always like it, in spite of its flaws. It gave me a Leo to care about.

whitemonkey
06-18-2009, 10:13 PM
When I left the theater I was kinda pissed I didnt realize it was gonna be so childish.
This is the first and hopefully last tmnt thing I will dislike.

Dark 5cythe
06-18-2009, 10:45 PM
What was wrong with it? Nothing. it was fun and cheesy just like the cartoons were. Oh thats right you can NEVER please fanboys. They NEED to gripe about something.

But it still would have been better if it had been live action :D

Dark 5cythe
06-18-2009, 10:46 PM
When I left the theater I was kinda pissed I didnt realize it was gonna be so childish.
This is the first and hopefully last tmnt thing I will dislike.

huh........you must never have seen the cartoons then.

whitemonkey
06-19-2009, 01:35 PM
I love the cartoons ,but its not the same. No shredder? new voices? I dont even like the look of the turtles.

Are you a fan of the movie?

Newton Gimmick
06-20-2009, 07:36 AM
I really rather enjoyed it and would probably rank it as #2 or #3 in terms of the franchise. The problems were the story was just too convoluted. Were the monsters the bad guys or the generals? Too much focus on that. Should have just have one set of creatures be it monsters or generals.

Needed more focus on the Foot portion of the story. It came off a bit half hearted and they provided some of the more interesting elements of the film.

Still I think it was a lot better than people give it credit for and I typically hate CG only films.

Spike Spiegel
06-20-2009, 11:37 AM
I really rather enjoyed it and would probably rank it as #2 or #3 in terms of the franchise. The problems were the story was just too convoluted.

Needed more focus on the Foot portion of the story. It came off a bit half hearted and they provided some of the more interesting elements of the film.



The characterization, etc. was okay, but after a while, I didn't really care about the story because it was so predictable. And there were way, way too many monsters...

TMNTD
07-19-2009, 05:34 PM
This movie was what I clean out from my turtles aquarium, pure TURTLE SH*T ! That's why there's going to be a reboot because even Laird was unhappy with the end result. This movie made TMNT 3 look like Citizen Kane.

What made this movie terrible ;

- CGI Animation instead of live action

- Character Designs.

- Voice Acting

-Sarah Michelle Gellar & Chris Evans

-Stupid Ass Plot

- Catered to 5-10 year olds.

This movie ranks right up there with Dragonball :Evolution and Streetfighter : Legend of Chun Li

Andrew NDB
07-19-2009, 06:15 PM
What was wrong with it? Nothing. it was fun and cheesy just like the cartoons were. Oh thats right you can NEVER please fanboys. They NEED to gripe about something.

But it still would have been better if it had been live action :D

huh........you must never have seen the cartoons then.

We've all seen the cartoons. Let me ask you a question now: Have you read the comics? Because that's where the Turtles began -- that's the source material, not the children's cartoons.

And the TMNT in that are quite a bit different. In an age where the successful comic book movies are looking more and more to the source material, it's confusing and more than a little bit backwards that the TMNT in the mass media is doing the opposite by examining the source material's children spinoffs that've all run their course.

I really rather enjoyed it and would probably rank it as #2 or #3 in terms of the franchise.

That's not saying much. There's the original TMNT movie in 1990... and then a whole lot of freefalling suck.

This movie was what I clean out from my turtles aquarium, pure TURTLE SH*T !

I love this quote.

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
07-19-2009, 06:25 PM
Wasn't perfect but still was better than Turtles 3. Easily better. The one thing I will always remember about TMNT is the Leo vs. Raph rooftop fight. I really enjoyed that. :) Other than that, yeah I agree. Stupid plot, less forcus on Karai and the Foot was DUMB, and whenever I heard April talk I thought it was Buffy.

Jester
07-19-2009, 06:31 PM
I don't understand why TMNT 3 gets so much bile. It's story and action aren't bad, it's the non-Henson costuming that gets me, and I can kinda look past that.

Dragon Turtle
07-19-2009, 08:00 PM
That's why there's going to be a reboot because even Laird was unhappy with the end result.

Just for the record, Laird AND Eastman were both happy with the movie.

The only thing wrong with the plot was that it was not developed enough to really interest anyone, other then that, it is just your standard TMNT plot.



And the TMNT in that are quite a bit different. In an age where the successful comic book movies are looking more and more to the source material, it's confusing and more than a little bit backwards that the TMNT in the mass media is doing the opposite by examining the source material's children spinoffs that've all run their course.


The billions of dollars the children spinoffs have produced compared to the original comics, which to be honest ran its course an even longer time ago, is the biggest factor propelling the turtle franchise.

CyberCubed
07-19-2009, 08:23 PM
That's why there's going to be a reboot because even Laird was unhappy with the end result.

That's entirely untrue. Peter appears to have been very happy with the movie, he's said on his blog its his second favorite TMNT movie after the original.

The reason they're going with a re-boot has nothing to do with 4th movie storywise, its simply because they're going with a different director with a different view of the franchise.

Andrew NDB
07-19-2009, 08:50 PM
That's entirely untrue. Peter appears to have been very happy with the movie, he's said on his blog its his second favorite TMNT movie after the original.

Kevin's been rather diplomatic about the 4th movie the few times I've seen him mention it. Peter, I think, has been quoted as saying he was... "90% happy with it," or something such.

The reason they're going with a re-boot has nothing to do with 4th movie storywise, its simply because they're going with a different director with a different view of the franchise.

Well we know that's not true. They don't even have a director locked yet but have already been saying, from the first moment Mirage approved this development deal, that it would be a Batman Begins-esque reboot.

sdp
07-20-2009, 01:52 AM
I just watched the movie for a third time and this movie so far has gotten better with each viewing.

Theater: I was dissapointed.

DVD a year ago: Enjoyed it more.

DVD a few days ago: Loved it.

My only complaints this time is the intro going from a quick recap of the turtles to the Yaotl story is odd. It seems that it could have worked better if it had been incorporated elsewhere, like having April getting the story told by a local. Though I'm not sure if without it having a lonely Leo in the Jungle would have worked as well since doing that made you forget totally that you were watching a turtles movie :lol:

The 13 monsters, they should have made them 3 monsters or 4. It was too many for the little purpose they had.


I think its because at first I had huge expectations, and now I just expected a regular TMNT story and was given a great one instead.

TMNTD
07-20-2009, 01:46 PM
My bad, it wasn't Peter Laird who was unhappy with the movie, it was Pete Stireeta ( I think that's how u spell his last name) , the writer at Slashfilm.com who was unhappy with the movie.

Either way, TMNT still reinforced the stereotype that the turtles are kiddie fodder. And I HATE IT !!!

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 02:49 PM
Either way, TMNT still reinforced the stereotype that the turtles are kiddie fodder.

Quite right. And I thought that, after well over a decade of development hell, the fourth movie represented TMNT's last chance in the mass media to do the opposite... and it just squandered the opportunity en masse. Spectacularly.

I'm truly surprised that TMNT is getting another shot with this latest movie and... what can I say? It sounds like the right people are saying the right things but it's tough -- nay, extremely difficult to get anything in the way of confidence up that it won't just be slightly less of an offensively toddler film.

Dragon Turtle
07-20-2009, 06:15 PM
My only complaints this time is the intro going from a quick recap of the turtles to the Yaotl story is odd. It seems that it could have worked better if it had been incorporated elsewhere, like having April getting the story told by a local. Though I'm not sure if without it having a lonely Leo in the Jungle would have worked as well since doing that made you forget totally that you were watching a turtles movie :lol:


I have no idea why they shoehorned Yaotl the story into the intro, the original opening was much better, probably just to give Laurence Fishburne something to do.



The 13 monsters, they should have made them 3 monsters or 4. It was too many for the little purpose they had.


Either that or just increase their number a thousand-fold, effectively reducing their role to background noise, and focusing more on the actual villains.


Either way, TMNT still reinforced the stereotype that the turtles are kiddie fodder. And I HATE IT !!!

As long as TMNT brings in money as a kids property, that's something you'll just have to get used to.


Quite right. And I thought that, after well over a decade of development hell, the fourth movie represented TMNT's last chance in the mass media to do the opposite... and it just squandered the opportunity en masse. Spectacularly.


Considering how the general public views the Ninja turtles, I believe the last movie was a good step in the right direction, at least in terms of moving the tone of the franchise away from the OT and last couple of movies, but to believe that a PG movie green lighted due to the success of the new kids cartoon would be anything more then it was, is a bit unrealistic.

TMNTD
07-20-2009, 07:30 PM
I have no idea why they shoehorned Yaotl the story into the intro, the original opening was much better, probably just to give Laurence Fishburne something to do.




Either that or just increase their number a thousand-fold, effectively reducing their role to background noise, and focusing more on the actual villains.



As long as TMNT brings in money as a kids property, that's something you'll just have to get used to.





Considering how the general public views the Ninja turtles, I believe the last movie was a good step in the right direction, at least in terms of moving the tone of the franchise away from the OT and last couple of movies, but to believe that a PG movie green lighted due to the success of the new kids cartoon would be anything more then it was, is a bit unrealistic.

So basically Dragon Turtle, you're saying that no matter what, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise will be cursed forever as being for kids by the general public ?

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 08:39 PM
Considering how the general public views the Ninja turtles, I believe the last movie was a good step in the right direction, at least in terms of moving the tone of the franchise away from the OT and last couple of movies, but to believe that a PG movie green lighted due to the success of the new kids cartoon would be anything more then it was, is a bit unrealistic.

You and I are just going to have to agree to disagree on that... that last movie embraced wholeheartedly all the stereotypes and cliches surrounding the original children's cartoon. Even the 4Kids cartoon took the TMNT more seriously than seen in this film... and that's still worlds below what it ought to be to approach the Mirage TMNT.

Coola Yagami
07-20-2009, 08:57 PM
Well... except Raph and Leo beating the crap out of each other in the movie.... when has such a fight between brothers been seen in the old or new cartoons? In the 2K3, mostly Raph and Leo bickered alot.

Dragon Turtle
07-20-2009, 09:43 PM
So basically Dragon Turtle, you're saying that no matter what, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise will be cursed forever as being for kids by the general public ?

Basically yes, the truth of the matter is that the turtles as kids franchise has made a lot money over the years, and there doesn't seem to be any reason why Mirage would turn their backs to this source of revenue.

But being viewed as a kid property by the general public doesn't necessarily mean you can't produce material for an older audience, and that material can't be successful. If they decide to go PG-13 and aime the next movie toward older audiences, and it's successful, then we can get another movie in the same mold. And if Mirage licenses out the Mirage comics, and they do well, they can continue to deliver mature TMNT stories for Mirage fans.



You and I are just going to have to agree to disagree on that... that last movie embraced wholeheartedly all the stereotypes and cliches surrounding the original children's cartoon. Even the 4Kids cartoon took the TMNT more seriously than seen in this film... and that's still worlds below what it ought to be to approach the Mirage TMNT.


I personally just don't see it, I will agree with you that the tone of the movie was actually a notch below the 2k3 toon, in the fact that the 2k3 toon has actually displayed some graphic violence (for a Saturday mourning cartoon), but the OT was mostly a comedy a with a few bits of action thrown in, 2k7 movie, even with its out-there plot, for the most part played it straight, much of the "humor" is regulated to Mikey, who most agree was barely in the movie.

Many OT fans and reviewers who never cared anything about the turtles would be more then happy to tell you their disdain for the "humorless" TMNT movie "that took itself too seriously" and "was missing the goofy charm of the original movies".

TMNT was certainly not as serious as the Mirage comics (as it never set out to be), but it certainly wasn't as goofy as the OT either.

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 11:15 PM
Basically yes, the truth of the matter is that the turtles as kids franchise has made a lot money over the years, and there doesn't seem to be any reason why Mirage would turn their backs to this source of revenue.

Other than it being a very cyclical example of a limited nature... they come out with a new incarnation every generation or so, and folks outgrow it within a few years... reboot, rinse, and repeat.

With just about all of the honest-to-goodness comic book movies that take the source material seriously doing gangbusters... it might give TPTB pause to, finally, make an attempt at something more endearing than what they've done in the past.

Why not come up with a new take on TMNT in the mass media that isn't quite as arbitrarily outgrowable? It seems in everyone's best interests... fiscal and otherwise.

But being viewed as a kid property by the general public doesn't necessarily mean you can't produce material for an older audience, and that material can't be successful. If they decide to go PG-13 and aime the next movie toward older audiences, and it's successful, then we can get another movie in the same mold. And if Mirage licenses out the Mirage comics, and they do well, they can continue to deliver mature TMNT stories for Mirage fans.

There's no reason fully "mature" TMNT stories can't be told in PG-13 fashion. And if you believe that a successful movie must be "for" any fandom -- yes, even the Mirage fandom -- then you're not seeing the bigger picture.

The gangbuster TMNT movie we all know in our hearts there can be needs to reach well out beyond any existing fandom. Any fandom showing up for opening weekend would only be the icing on the cake, not the cake itself. In fact, if you were populate the seats with all the still-active fans of the Mirage, original cartoon, and newer cartoon... you still wouldn't arrive at box office numbers that would even be satisfactory, let alone a box office smash.

Many OT fans and reviewers who never cared anything about the turtles would be more then happy to tell you their disdain for the "humorless" TMNT movie "that took itself too seriously" and "was missing the goofy charm of the original movies".

Which isn't relevant on the basis that none of these folks would even be within the target demographic of a PG-13 action movie... and on what I elaborated a bit on above.

TMNT was certainly not as serious as the Mirage comics (as it never set out to be), but it certainly wasn't as goofy as the OT either.

I won't argue with any of this. But it doesn't mean I or anyone else have to bite down and accept it as, "Well, at least it was as best as we can expect, given the old cartoons and all that."

I don't know about anyone else, but I'm damned tired of having to make excuses to ourselves and others for that. We all know TMNT has the ability to make a truly kick-ass movie. It does. With other successful comic book movies -- done faithfully, with a helping of directors injecting them with their own vision -- kicking the door open... there's no reason we shouldn't hold this new movie up to the same expectations.

Dragon Turtle
07-21-2009, 01:47 AM
Other than it being a very cyclical example of a limited nature... they come out with a new incarnation every generation or so, and folks outgrow it within a few years... reboot, rinse, and repeat.


If it works, no real reason to stop.



Why not come up with a new take on TMNT in the mass media that isn't quite as arbitrarily outgrowable? It seems in everyone's best interests... fiscal and otherwise.


A forward thinking company would be able to do both.



There's no reason fully "mature" TMNT stories can't be told in PG-13 fashion. And if you believe that a successful movie must be "for" any fandom -- yes, even the Mirage fandom -- then you're not seeing the bigger picture.

The gangbuster TMNT movie we all know in our hearts there can be needs to reach well out beyond any existing fandom. Any fandom showing up for opening weekend would only be the icing on the cake, not the cake itself. In fact, if you were populate the seats with all the still-active fans of the Mirage, original cartoon, and newer cartoon... you still wouldn't arrive at box office numbers that would even be satisfactory, let alone a box office smash.


Yes, I agree.


Which isn't relevant on the basis that none of these folks would even be within the target demographic of a PG-13 action movie... and on what I elaborated a bit on above.


It's relevant to idea that 2k7 movie embraces the stereotypes and cliches of the old cartoon. And who is the target demographic for a PG-13 action movie, the 20-30 somethings who grew up with the old toon and the people who don't have any real ties to the fandom but will still possibly go see a movie featuring the TMNT, seem to be a couple of the target audiences that you may want to go after.


I won't argue with any of this. But it doesn't mean I or anyone else have to bite down and accept it as, "Well, at least it was as best as we can expect, given the old cartoons and all that."


No, there is no reason that you or anyone has to accept something that is not to their liking, if people don't like the movie because it's not enough like the Mirage comics or enough like the OT, that's perfectly fine. But for a movie designed specifically as a kids movie, the 2k7 movie along with the 2k3 cartoon, makes the idea of doing a really serious TMNT movie not be viewed as a complete joke to the masses.

TMNTD
07-22-2009, 11:56 AM
It just frustrates the hell outta me with these movies. You have a property like Batman, who started off very Dark, then went campy with the 60's show and Super Friends, and was totally redeemed by Frank Miller in " Dark Knight Returns " and Burton and Knolan's " Batman " and " Batman Begins", and still be able to appease both kids and adults. But when u mention Ninja Turtles, everybody automatically assumes it's just for kids. Sure the OT was cheesy, but it was no way near as campy and corny as the Batman tv series.

I mentioned having the Triceratons and Utroms on the Ninja Turtles thread on the SHH forum, and they acted like it was " too out there ". With movies like " X-men, Hellboy, Transformers, etc. " popular, how can a movie about 4 mutant turtles fighting alien dinosaurs be " too ot there ? "

Samurai Usagi
07-22-2009, 12:16 PM
Lets say you are aiming at ten year olds. It will be three years before a movie comes out. They will then be thirteen. Then you make another one of the same mold as the first one. It will be another three years, The kids will then be sisteen and even though the movie is like it was as the first, the sixteen year olds will hate, just because they are "older" and have "grown" past it.

It like the cartoons of your kid era were great, you watch them twenty years later and you catch all the stuff or "cheesyness" you didn't notice when you were young.

TMNTD
07-22-2009, 01:03 PM
But that's just it. Slapstick aside, the OT was really a great cartoon. Fun stories and great characters ( Let's face it, Mirage was very limited in creatig interesting new characters). If it wasn't for the OT, I would've never learned about the Mirage turtles. But as much as the fans grow up, the mature aspect of the turtles are never presented because those in control of the property always use the " OT Formula." Not all of the toons of my childhood were cheesy. Some of the original episodes of " Transformers" and " Real Ghostbusters " had some pretty good writing, and some of the episodes were quite dark. For every step forward that the turtles make like with " 2003 Toon ", they always end up taken two steps back with stuff like " TMNT " and " FAST FORWARD ".

Dejablue
12-20-2009, 02:22 AM
Wow I am so late to respond but This is basically my rating of the movies

1. The first movie

2. The fourth movie

3. The third movie :o

4. The second movie.

Yeah that's kinda baffling aint it? how can I like the evil third movie over the more tolerable second? Well that's sort of an interesting story I guess. But not worth telling. I liked the fourth movie. I can't really explain why. If I could go back in time I'd probably try and tell the director all the things he did wrong. But there must be something about it I really liked to have watched it three times in a row.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
12-20-2009, 05:19 AM
The plot. I would like to se Shredder, maybe with Krang and the Technodrome from the 1987 TMNT cartoon.

Koi
12-20-2009, 11:15 AM
The CGI was beautiful and amazing. It was my main focus, but since I had friends with me they told me their opinions.

One bud (a new comers to the ninja turtles) was oh so much confused with this movie, they threw characters at them that would appear underdeveloped because they have never heard or seen them before. (ex. Karai)

One of my friends bashed the movie because they thought that in some scenes it could have been more then brotherly love... O_0 ew.

My last friend was wondering why it was so short and rushed.

Hopefully the next movie will make up for this one so me and ALL my friends can enjoy it. I personally liked the movie because it was so pretty, gorgeous CGI. I also liked the fight scenes, they were entertaining to watch ^_^.

norinrad2
12-20-2009, 11:52 AM
The movie wasn't horrible & I love that they kept that whole family falling apart theme running through it. My only pet peeve was, don't they ever get tired of having their masks on all the time? Some scenes where they're not wearing all their gear like in the comics would've been kinda cool. :tidea:

heretic888
12-20-2009, 12:12 PM
What was wrong with the 4th movie? Well, in a nutshell....

1) The plot. Oh gods, the plot. The story was something I would maybe expect from one of the guest writers in Volume 1 or one of the stand-alone issues of Tales of the TMNT. It was NOT the story that should have been the TMNT's first appearance on the silver screen after 14 years (or ever, really). Not by a long shot.

2) Leonardo & Raphael The Movie. Every other character in this movie, including the two other Ninja Turtles, were undeveloped background characters.

3) The writing. Michelangelo, when he actually had lines, was portrayed as an attention-seeking idiot. And the lines Raphael had near the end, where he actually spoke of "good" as some kind of absolute was horridly out of character and oversimplified. Actually, I disliked the portrayal of the TMNT as some sort of superhero team dedicated to ridding the city of evil as a whole.

4) The humans. This is a minor aesthetic quibble, but I felt the design and animations for the human characters was overtly cartoony and goofy looking. By contrast, the TMNT and Splinter looked great.

The only redeeming qualities of this movie, in my opinion, were the CGI animation of the TMNT themselves and the fight between Raph and Leo. The rest was almost total disappointment.

TMNTD
12-22-2009, 12:50 AM
what was wrong with the 4th movie? Well, in a nutshell....

1) the plot. Oh gods, the plot. The story was something i would maybe expect from one of the guest writers in volume 1 or one of the stand-alone issues of tales of the tmnt. It was not the story that should have been the tmnt's first appearance on the silver screen after 14 years (or ever, really). Not by a long shot.

2) leonardo & raphael the movie. Every other character in this movie, including the two other ninja turtles, were undeveloped background characters.

3) the writing. Michelangelo, when he actually had lines, was portrayed as an attention-seeking idiot. And the lines raphael had near the end, where he actually spoke of "good" as some kind of absolute was horridly out of character and oversimplified. Actually, i disliked the portrayal of the tmnt as some sort of superhero team dedicated to ridding the city of evil as a whole.

4) the humans. This is a minor aesthetic quibble, but i felt the design and animations for the human characters was overtly cartoony and goofy looking. By contrast, the tmnt and splinter looked great.

The only redeeming qualities of this movie, in my opinion, were the cgi animation of the tmnt themselves and the fight between raph and leo. The rest was almost total disappointment.


i totally agree !!!!

ryukenden
12-23-2009, 03:52 PM
I find it very odd that Leo would go to Central America for training. Why not Japan? That would make more sense.

The 13 Monsters was very cliche'. The human characters definitely looked really goofy.

Vivi
12-23-2009, 11:39 PM
The story was not great...in fact, it was pretty bloody awful. That said, there were some fairly decent bits, the animation (aside from the humans) and va's were good.

Daniel Orduna
12-24-2009, 11:52 PM
2 much raph and leo, mike 2 goofy, 4 kids,no blood,

Guitar_Raph
12-25-2009, 04:41 AM
Only one motorcycle ride for Night Watcher.

ooglafina
01-01-2010, 06:38 PM
Something that baffles me about the fourth movie. The director says in the commentary several times that the "sequal" (that he'll never do) should involve Karai or that any new movies will most likely involve Karai. So why didn't he just go with her in the first place and scrap the 13 monsters? It felt like he was taking a main character, and a much more interesting character, and shoving her into a little nutshell to make room for the more glossy looking monsters and Winters.

Andrew NDB
01-01-2010, 06:42 PM
Something that baffles me about the fourth movie. The director says in the commentary several times that the "sequal" (that he'll never do) should involve Karai or that any new movies will most likely involve Karai.

And showing her get her ass beat by April O'Neil is a fine way of building her up for such an imaginary sequel...

ooglafina
01-01-2010, 06:51 PM
I know. I didn't think much about her and then in the commentary, he says that she's going to be key to the renewal of the franchise. I didn't realize what a cool character with an interesting background she was until I did later research. I just thought she was some schmuck who was in charge of the Foot clan.

CyberCubed
01-01-2010, 07:23 PM
You honestly didn't know who Karai was when watching this movie the first time? The character has existed since 1992.

Dejablue
01-01-2010, 07:30 PM
You honestly didn't know who Karai was when watching this movie the first time? The character has existed since 1992.

Some people get into the franchise late. Yeesh.

ooglafina
01-01-2010, 07:33 PM
Well, I've been busy since 1992. Being in high school and being in college. I've just had down time now. I plan on catching up on the series, since I've obviously had other interests since I was 10 years old, mostly Sims 2 and Buffy, but I'm done with those so I'm having fun catching up on something else. And right now I'm enjoying seeing other fans opinions and perceptions of the characters. I'll keep my ignorance to myself.

Dragon Turtle
01-01-2010, 11:49 PM
Something that baffles me about the fourth movie. The director says in the commentary several times that the "sequal" (that he'll never do) should involve Karai or that any new movies will most likely involve Karai. So why didn't he just go with her in the first place and scrap the 13 monsters? It felt like he was taking a main character, and a much more interesting character, and shoving her into a little nutshell to make room for the more glossy looking monsters and Winters.


Karai's was mostly there just to introduce her before any bigger role she may have had in a sequel, if anything she gets as much development as Winters or monster plot, which really doesn't say much about the development of Winters or the monster plot.

Oculus Orbus
01-02-2010, 05:50 AM
It was awful. Really, it could have been a lot better very easily. If you think about it, the plot didn't make any sense. On one side, it seemed like it was made for TMNT fans, not introducing any characters or showing the relationships between them, and just telling this ridiculous story of the 13 monsters. But then, when you actually see it, being a fan, it's just too silly.

The Leo and Raph parts were kind of entertaining, and sure the only thing in the film that had some kind of development, but thinking about the film as a whole, it was way too cliché. I found it really sad that after so long, this is all they managed to come out with.

It was really disappointing.

Daniel Orduna
01-02-2010, 06:31 AM
karai is hot jajaj:lol:

The Stryker
01-02-2010, 12:01 PM
Something that baffles me about the fourth movie. The director says in the commentary several times that the "sequal" (that he'll never do) should involve Karai or that any new movies will most likely involve Karai.

Phew. Dodged a bullet there.

SwordofTengu
01-03-2010, 07:21 PM
I got the 4 movie collection on DVD. I had never seen the 3rd or 4th movies. For me, TMNT was decent at best. It had some good scenes and I loved the fight between Raph and Leo (the only better than decent part of the movie). The part that turned me off was when Casey said "Gee Raph, you sure know how to sure a lady a good time." My cousin and I burst out laughing and we talked about the next day. For me, the turtle films get worse as they go.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles- Great film! It makes me laugh and has some good action. It's no masterpiece, but it is a great experience.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: Secret of the Ooze- This one's good, but the lack of action is dissapointing. It's still enjoyable and has a couple fantastic scenes.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III- Everybody will kill me for this but I thought this one wasn't half-bad, it made me laugh and while the animatronics were poor, this one was still good.

TMNT- It felt too different, it threw loops to the past 3 films and overall, it was decent, but it did not at all need to be made like it did.

ooglafina
01-03-2010, 07:56 PM
I got the 4 movie collection on DVD. I had never seen the 3rd or 4th movies. For me, TMNT was decent at best. It had some good scenes and I loved the fight between Raph and Leo (the only better than decent part of the movie). The part that turned me off was when Casey said "Gee Raph, you sure know how to sure a lady a good time." My cousin and I burst out laughing and we talked about the next day. For me, the turtle films get worse as they go.

So, fellow Michigander. How many days have you gone without seeing the sun?

I agree that the Raph kicks Leo's ass scene was the best and I attribute that to the vocal performances. The director says that they recorded them together in a real time dialogue and not over seperate days like usual. The line about showing a lady a good time didn't bother me, but it's funny you mention it because I was annoyed at the "And I thought girl's scouts were pushy." It was a rip off of Mike's "And I thought insurance salesmen were pushy." I call it a ripoff because if it were an homage, he should have quoted it word for word. That dialogue felt a little too whimsical for the situation to me.

And no bad words for liking the third one. I know several intelligent people who enjoyed it. I think the funny sound effects were off putting to me.

XERO
01-03-2010, 07:59 PM
And no bad words for liking the third one. I know several intelligent people who enjoyed it.

Do you know any dumb people who hated it?

ooglafina
01-03-2010, 08:03 PM
I don't know. I don't really like it. Maybe I'm dumb.

XERO
01-03-2010, 08:08 PM
... Maybe. :P

Koi
01-03-2010, 09:58 PM
I agree that the Raph kicks Leo's ass scene was the best and I attribute that to the vocal performances.


I liked the seen better when they finally just shut up to tell you the truth... There was way to much dialogue for my likings in the movie already so the scene kinda drug it even more out for me.

Andrew NDB
01-04-2010, 01:17 PM
I liked the seen better when they finally just shut up to tell you the truth... There was way to much dialogue for my likings in the movie already so the scene kinda drug it even more out for me.

Speak for yourself, the voice actors made the movie for me! FAP! FAP! FAP!

Seriously, I don't get it.

Shredder_Fan
01-29-2010, 03:28 PM
Iv'e seen this movie and.....it whas boring.
I mean, I grow up with the Cartoon Turtles:

Krang and Shredder time,
Shredder is the 1 and only to fight with the Turtles.
He is so cool and full of hate to them

I really really really hope that in the new comming movie
that Shredder is back but now with Krang and Technodrome Bebop and Rocksteady. Give the other Turtles fans there wish come true.

I grow up with Shredder, Krang, The Technodrome and stuff

Cowabunga Kiefer
01-29-2010, 10:38 PM
Some people get into the franchise late. Yeesh.
Ha ha, I saw the movie the first time not knowing anybody's name. The only prior knowledge were the 2 NT episodes I watched the day before. So, Dejablue isn't the only one!!!

Cowabunga Kiefer
02-05-2010, 07:51 PM
I swear, these critics have no heart or hope for the future of TMNT. Read this...

http://movies.tvguide.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/review/286990

I especially like the part where he labels the Foot Clan as "The Foot Patrol" You can;t make these harsh criticisms if you don't fully understand what you're talking about!

Coola Yagami
02-05-2010, 11:28 PM
LOL Foot Patrol. The review was too short. It tried to explain too much about the plot which didn't leave much space for the guy to give his actual thoughts on it. And April's curves were amplified??? She was a ****in toothpick!!!

Warhorse
02-06-2010, 11:10 AM
LOL that he thinks the director was aiming to be cool by shortening the Turtles names to Leo, Don, Raph and Mikey. I guess he didn't watch the first live action film.:roll:

jaymq
02-06-2010, 12:26 PM
LOL that he thinks the director was aiming to be cool by shortening the Turtles names to Leo, Don, Raph and Mikey. I guess he didn't watch the first live action film.:roll:

Yea, dude clearly thinks OT was the "original canon".

shuriken
02-06-2010, 12:33 PM
LOL that he thinks the director was aiming to be cool by shortening the Turtles names to Leo, Don, Raph and Mikey. I guess he didn't watch the first live action film.:roll:

or have any idea about people having nicknames for extrememely long names.

Dragon Turtle
02-06-2010, 11:26 PM
I swear, these critics have no heart or hope for the future of TMNT. Read this...

http://movies.tvguide.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/review/286990

I especially like the part where he labels the Foot Clan as "The Foot Patrol" You can;t make these harsh criticisms if you don't fully understand what you're talking about!

Still a better review then Michael Phillips review

http://events.the-dispatch.com/reviews/show/7675-review-tmnt

Koi
02-07-2010, 10:52 AM
Still a better review then Michael Phillips review

http://events.the-dispatch.com/reviews/show/7675-review-tmnt

The movie was bad, their shouldn't be any surprise in any reviewers tearing it up for it.

Dragon Turtle
02-07-2010, 01:41 PM
The movie was bad, their shouldn't be any surprise in any reviewers tearing it up for it.

People are entitled to their opinions, including you, but if you're going to criticise the movie, try actually discussing the actual movie, and not made up nonsense about it being too violent.

Koi
02-07-2010, 02:56 PM
People are entitled to their opinions, including you, but if you're going to criticise the movie, try actually discussing the actual movie, and not made up nonsense about it being too violent.

May I ask when did I said this?

Galactus
02-07-2010, 04:09 PM
May I ask when did I said this?

I think he's referring to the actual Michael Phillips review which trashed the cgi movie off the bat for being too violent.

I don't think any negative review of the movie I've read actualy hit the nails on why the film wasn't that good. That's to be expected as with the franchise people have radicaly different expectations.

Both those reviews didn't really say what was wrong with the film but rather criticise it in the case of the first review for it's darkness and moving away from the fun surfer lingo or shortening the names (because they've never referred to each other as Leo, Don, Mike and Raph) or in the case of the second it's supposed violence. I wonder what those two critics would think if they saw a real TMNT film.

Cure
02-07-2010, 05:58 PM
I wonder what those two critics would think if they saw a real TMNT film.

Yeah, because the last 4 were totally imaginary, right?

Dragon Turtle
02-07-2010, 06:19 PM
I think he's referring to the actual Michael Phillips review which trashed the cgi movie off the bat for being too violent.


Yes.


I don't think any negative review of the movie I've read actualy hit the nails on why the film wasn't that good. That's to be expected as with the franchise people have radicaly different expectations.


If you can get past the general swipes at TMNT in general, or biased opinions of what the turtles should be (usually based on foggy memories of the cartoons or comics), you can find legitimate, well thought out criticisms about the movie.

Yeah, because the last 4 were totally imaginary, right?

I assuming he means one based solely on the Mirage comics.

Koi
02-07-2010, 06:40 PM
Here are some more decent reviews
http://newsblaze.com/story/20070804140741tsop.nb/topstory.html
http://www.avclub.com/articles/tmnt,3539/

Dragon Turtle
02-07-2010, 11:20 PM
Here are some more decent reviews
http://newsblaze.com/story/20070804140741tsop.nb/topstory.html
http://www.avclub.com/articles/tmnt,3539/

I honestly can't tell much from the first review but I can agree with several points the reviewer in the second review made, especially how the prologue cuts the tension right out of the movie and the lack of development on the subplots.

CyberCubed
02-09-2010, 09:09 PM
From the review:

Did the world need another Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles spin-off?

I really hate it how every time TMNT comes back with a new series/movie, the critics always say, "Did they really need to bring this ancient dinosaur from the 80's back?" or something along those lines.

Do these morons realize there is no difference to TMNT returning then the constant Batman/Superman/Spiderman movie re-boots?

Koi
02-09-2010, 09:29 PM
I really hate it how every time TMNT comes back with a new series/movie, the critics always say, "Did they really need to bring this ancient dinosaur from the 80's back?" or something along those lines.

Do these morons realize there is no difference to TMNT returning then the constant Batman/Superman/Spiderman movie re-boots?

Critics will be critics.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 01:39 AM
Wow I am so late to respond but This is basically my rating of the movies

1. The first movie

2. The fourth movie

3. The third movie :o

4. The second movie.

Yeah that's kinda baffling aint it? how can I like the evil third movie over the more tolerable second? Well that's sort of an interesting story I guess. But not worth telling. I liked the fourth movie. I can't really explain why. If I could go back in time I'd probably try and tell the director all the things he did wrong. But there must be something about it I really liked to have watched it three times in a row.

I'd guess it'd be the whole Vanilla Ice thing right?

As for TMNT I kinda liked it. Though I do admit the whole Winters story was boring, Karai basically came out of nowhere in the sense that you'd have to watch 2k3 to even know who she is, and well it just seems like they fast forwarded too much over the whole shredder thing. Like they didn't really try to explain it all that much. "Turtles fought shredder, they kicked his ass, now lets go on with the movie"

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 08:18 PM
What bothered me most about the fourth movie was a combination of a couple things.

- It was the most ridiculous, generic version of Mikey I've ever seen

- I've grown a bit tired of the cliche Leo/Raph feud, especially when it leads to one of them getting beaten up or kidnapped.

- A lot of my distaste for it is a product of too much hype.

- It felt like they started the movie with one concept, but then decided that it wasn't important enough to flesh out. If you're not going to flesh out a concept, you shouldn't use it at all.

- No Shredder. Remember when TMNT3 came out, and there was no Shredder? Apparently Monroe didn't get the memo that it wasn't acceptable.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 08:20 PM
- No Shredder. Remember when TMNT3 came out, and there was no Shredder? Apparently Monroe didn't get the memo that it wasn't acceptable.

That was the one thing he did right. He just forgot to include a captivating threat in his stead.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 08:22 PM
That was the one thing he did right. He just forgot to include a captivating threat in his stead.

I'm not sure I'm getting you. You found it okay that he excluded Shredder from the movie? I'm not calling out your opinion or degrading it, but would you care to explain why?

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 08:39 PM
I'm not sure I'm getting you. You found it okay that he excluded Shredder from the movie? I'm not calling out your opinion or degrading it, but would you care to explain why?

For one, because it was a continuance of the existing film universe and in the existing film universe the Shredder had been done to death. Literally. And he had been made into a sham in the last movie (TMNT II).

Which isn't to say Shredder couldn't return in Movie 5. In fact, I'm pretty sure that was the plan... even thinking back to Movie 4 in my head my eyes are rolling thinking about that very, very non-subtle "Someone from your past will return!!! And his name rhymes with Cheddar!" tucked near the end of the movie.

But anyway, I've always said: if the TMNT can't survive -- on the big screen or otherwise -- without the constant presence of the Shredder, then they really don't deserve to in my opinion.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 10:33 PM
For one, because it was a continuance of the existing film universe and in the existing film universe the Shredder had been done to death. Literally. And he had been made into a sham in the last movie (TMNT II).

Which isn't to say Shredder couldn't return in Movie 5. In fact, I'm pretty sure that was the plan... even thinking back to Movie 4 in my head my eyes are rolling thinking about that very, very non-subtle "Someone from your past will return!!! And his name rhymes with Cheddar!" tucked near the end of the movie.

But anyway, I've always said: if the TMNT can't survive -- on the big screen or otherwise -- without the constant presence of the Shredder, then they really don't deserve to in my opinion.

I always had a problem thinking of TMNT 4 as a continuation of the movies from TMNT3. The time lapse between films was so great that it was quite frankly a bit presumptuous to assume that most of the people seeing it would have preexisting knowledge of the story; in both of the showings I went to in theaters, there was maybe ten people combined old enough to have seen the first trilogy. I think that TMNT 4 - or, as I'd prefer to refer to it: TMNT 2007 - should have been a reboot, but then that would pretty much eliminate any necessity for a reboot in 2012. To be totally honest, I don't think TMNT 2007 contributed much whatsoever to the franchise, and I think that it could have done without it at all. But make a movie over ten years later with a PG demographic audience and assume that the audience would have any preexisting knowledge of the source material is asinine.

As for rather or not TMNT as a film or as a franchise could stand without the Shredder: I absolutely think it could, and I see no problem with the concept that it might try to do so; what I do despise is when Shredder gets replaced with a generic feudal Japanese warlord and a Clint Eastwood wannabe, or some uninteresting character trying to collect thirteen statues. Certainly TMNT can stand as both a film and a franchise without The Shredder, but if that's the best they can do to make a film without him, I'd much rather they use him over the alternative.

sdp
03-08-2010, 10:49 PM
TMNT 2007 WAS a reboot, it was not in continuity with the past films.j

While Mirage fans may find it good that Shredder wasn't in it its one of the main reasons it didn't do as good as it could (the others being it was CG and marketed for kids). Shredder has been a huge part of both animated series pretty much.

I didn't mind that there was no Shredder but I would have loved to see Shredder from that continuity, and the ending (rhymes with Cheddar? :lol: ) made me want the sequel which would have Shredder. Same way Batman Begins made me want the Joker for the second movie with the ending hinting at him.

The new reboot NEEDS shredder, he doesn't have to be in every movie though just like Joker doesn't need to be in every movie. And while BBegins proves you didn't need a main villain for the first movie, TMNT is not Batman and I doubt it'd be able to pull it off. The best thing about Shredder not being in the 2007 movie is that he'd need to be in the reboot and then we'd get something similar to Superman Returns. It was made as a loose sequel to the first four movies which had the silly Luthor and you know for the Superman Luthor the awesome Businessman Luthor would be great for it but Luthor has been overdone in the movies and its not something anyone really wants to see even if this would be a superior version.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 10:51 PM
TMNT 2007 WAS a reboot, it was not in continuity with the past films.j

While Mirage fans may find it good that Shredder wasn't in it its one of the main reasons it didn't do as good as it could (the others being it was CG and marketed for kids). Shredder has been a huge part of both animated series pretty much.

I didn't mind that there was no Shredder but I would have loved to see Shredder from that continuity, and the ending (rhymes with Cheddar? :lol: ) made me want the sequel which would have Shredder. Same way Batman Begins made me want the Joker for the second movie with the ending hinting at him.

The new reboot NEEDS shredder, he doesn't have to be in every movie though just like Joker doesn't need to be in every movie. And while BBegins proves you didn't need a main villain for the first movie, TMNT is not Batman and I doubt it'd be able to pull it off. The best thing about Shredder not being in the 2007 movie is that he'd need to be in the reboot and then we'd get something similar to Superman Returns. It was made as a loose sequel to the first four movies which had the silly Luthor and you know for the Superman Luthor the awesome Businessman Luthor would be great for it but Luthor has been overdone in the movies and its not something anyone really wants to see even if this would be a superior version.

I agree that the new reboot really does need Shredder in it. If they want to stand any sort of chance of attracting the mainstream, they'll keep the first movie down-to-Earth with the Turtles and Shredder, and they'll save any of the more sci-fi/out-there concepts for potential future films.

EDIT: Just to add another thought: TMNT 2007 suffered from a severe identity crisis, where it didn't really know what it was; it wasn't exactly a reboot, but it certainly wasn't a continuation of the 90s trilogy, and it certainly wasn't a tie-in to any television series, and it wasn't a tie-in to the comics, but it also wasn't a cash-in designed to lure the mainstream in with false promises; I'm not really sure what TMNT 2007 was trying to be.

Dragon Turtle
03-08-2010, 11:32 PM
While Mirage fans may find it good that Shredder wasn't in it its one of the main reasons it didn't do as good as it could (the others being it was CG and marketed for kids). Shredder has been a huge part of both animated series pretty much.


I will say that after 15 years, it would have been a good idea to show the Shredder in some form (and I mean more then just a static picture of him), since I knew there would be the "hey where's Shredder!" complaint. Maybe in a final battle flask back scene.




I didn't mind that there was no Shredder but I would have loved to see Shredder from that continuity, and the ending (rhymes with Cheddar? :lol: ) made me want the sequel which would have Shredder. Same way Batman Begins made me want the Joker for the second movie with the ending hinting at him.

The new reboot NEEDS shredder, he doesn't have to be in every movie though just like Joker doesn't need to be in every movie. And while BBegins proves you didn't need a main villain for the first movie, TMNT is not Batman and I doubt it'd be able to pull it off.


Would a true ninja turtle fan refuse to see a TMNT movie featuring a well though out and credible villain that isn't Shredder? They don't sound like much of a fan to me.


Just to add another thought: TMNT 2007 suffered from a severe identity crisis, where it didn't really know what it was; it wasn't exactly a reboot, but it certainly wasn't a continuation of the 90s trilogy, and it certainly wasn't a tie-in to any television series, and it wasn't a tie-in to the comics, but it also wasn't a cash-in designed to lure the mainstream in with false promises; I'm not really sure what TMNT 2007 was trying to be.

It's own movie.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 11:36 PM
TMNT 2007 WAS a reboot, it was not in continuity with the past films.

The WGA card-carrying member who wrote and directed the movie begs to differ. But you can do whatever you want, really... "Create Your Own Adventure"... or continuity/fanon, in this case.

sdp
03-08-2010, 11:40 PM
The WGA card-carrying member who wrote and directed the movie begs to differ. But you can do whatever you want, really... "Create Your Own Adventure"... or continuity/fanon, in this case.

Kevin Munroe said it was at best a loose sequel.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 11:46 PM
Kevin Munroe said it was at best a loose sequel.

It must fall into some sort of continuity, because it assumes preexisting knowledge. I just can't quite figure out where to pen it. I mean, I fail to see it tying into the 90s trilogy; they went from the subway home to some new, random sewer joint for no apparent reason; April's all of a sudden a treasure hunter; Leonardo went off to the jungles of South America to train for a reason isn't made the least bit apparent by the 90s trilogy; Kairi shows up, even though the 90s trilogy doesn't ever so much as consider acknowledging her existence. I wish I could figure out exactly what it's supposed to tie into, and where at in the continuity.

Dragon Turtle
03-08-2010, 11:53 PM
It must fall into some sort of continuity, because it assumes preexisting knowledge. I just can't quite figure out where to pen it. I mean, I fail to see it tying into the 90s trilogy; they went from the subway home to some new, random sewer joint for no apparent reason; April's all of a sudden a treasure hunter; Leonardo went off to the jungles of South America to train for a reason isn't made the least bit apparent by the 90s trilogy; Kairi shows up, even though the 90s trilogy doesn't ever so much as consider acknowledging her existence. I wish I could figure out exactly what it's supposed to tie into, and where at in the continuity.

TMNT 4 was not tied into any continuity, Monroe at first considered to tie it to the first three live action movies, but in the end decided against it, TMNT 4 is better thought of as its own separate continuity.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 11:53 PM
but in the end decided against it

Where did he say this?

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 12:14 AM
TMNT 4 was not tied into any continuity, Monroe at first considered to tie it to the first three live action movies, but in the end decided against it, TMNT 4 is better thought of as its own separate continuity.

Well, if Monroe indeed DOESN'T consider TMNT 2007 to be a part of any preexisting continuity, than I'm even more inclined to credit his competence as a filmmaker, because the plot is horrible and doesn't stand very well at all on its own. The whole movie just reeks as though SOMETHING happened before the movie began.

Dragon Turtle
03-09-2010, 12:22 AM
Where did he say this?

From one interview I remember from Animated Views:

AV: How does your film fit into the Turtles universe? For instance, is it more of a continuation to the first three films or the latest TV series?

KM: You know, it’s funny. There’s so much you can do. There’s so much in the Turtles’ past, as far as adventures and stuff. So when we first started, we were trying to find what we were going to say – what was going to be lore and what wasn’t, for the movie. At the end of the day, we just realized, ‘Let’s just make the whole thing lore.’

Basically, they’ve lived all these adventures, and they’ve defeated all these villains. Now, they find themselves without direction, because they don’t have a common enemy to fight anymore. The movie became more about a rebirth of the heroes, instead of an origin story.


In essence, the 2007 continuity is a just generalized imaging of the turtle universe, in the beginning it was probably tied closer to the original movies, simply so they didn't have to tell an origin movie.

Well, if Monroe indeed DOESN'T consider TMNT 2007 to be a part of any preexisting continuity, than I'm even more inclined to credit his competence as a filmmaker, because the plot is horrible and doesn't stand very well at all on its own. The whole movie just reeks as though SOMETHING happened before the movie began.

A movie doesn't need to be based on any preexisting continuity, few comic book based movies are. I will agree the underdeveloped plot doesn't really hold up on its own, but that has nothing to do with continuity.

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 12:26 AM
From one interview I remember from Animated Views:

AV: How does your film fit into the Turtles universe? For instance, is it more of a continuation to the first three films or the latest TV series?

KM: You know, it’s funny. There’s so much you can do. There’s so much in the Turtles’ past, as far as adventures and stuff. So when we first started, we were trying to find what we were going to say – what was going to be lore and what wasn’t, for the movie. At the end of the day, we just realized, ‘Let’s just make the whole thing lore.’

Basically, they’ve lived all these adventures, and they’ve defeated all these villains. Now, they find themselves without direction, because they don’t have a common enemy to fight anymore. The movie became more about a rebirth of the heroes, instead of an origin story.


In essence, the 2007 continuity is a just generalized imaging of the turtle universe, in the beginning it was probably tied closer to the original movies, simply so they didn't have to tell an origin movie.

I still feel that the movie as a whole lacked any sort of vision or direction. It felt like Monroe and the execs couldn't agree on a solid concept, so they just said "Screw it" and decided to do something totally different instead.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 01:22 AM
In essence, the 2007 continuity is a just generalized imaging of the turtle universe, in the beginning it was probably tied closer to the original movies, simply so they didn't have to tell an origin movie.

Good quote. I capitulate to you, then. It seems it is a composite movie.

A movie doesn't need to be based on any preexisting continuity, few comic book based movies are. I will agree the underdeveloped plot doesn't really hold up on its own, but that has nothing to do with continuity.

From what Munroe has said that I'd read previously it seemed to me that the 2007 movie was intended to be set apart from the first three movies, but still using them as a loose history... but not necessarily being beholden to them. They were the same Turtles as the Turtles in those movies, but they're in a different place mentally and time-wise and such, yadda yadda.

I still feel that the movie as a whole lacked any sort of vision or direction. It felt like Monroe and the execs couldn't agree on a solid concept, so they just said "Screw it" and decided to do something totally different instead.

And here's where I absolutely will defend Munroe. You just know the guy had a great vision, a big image of The Badass TMNT Movie... the one that rinses our collective mouths of the taste of the previous couple. However he had the odds stacked against him from the start... being a new director, not a lot in the way of pull and what-have-you... in the end, I kind of imagine the guy more or less became like a filter for WB and their studio execs and the kind of movie they wanted to make.

There are moments -- fleeting ones -- in the 2007 movie where you see a glimmer of something brilliant... but then it passes. I absolutely don't blame Munroe.

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 01:49 AM
Good quote. I capitulate to you, then. It seems it is a composite movie.



From what Munroe has said that I'd read previously it seemed to me that the 2007 movie was intended to be set apart from the first three movies, but still using them as a loose history... but not necessarily being beholden to them. They were the same Turtles as the Turtles in those movies, but they're in a different place mentally and time-wise and such, yadda yadda.



And here's where I absolutely will defend Munroe. You just know the guy had a great vision, a big image of The Badass TMNT Movie... the one that rinses our collective mouths of the taste of the previous couple. However he had the odds stacked against him from the start... being a new director, not a lot in the way of pull and what-have-you... in the end, I kind of imagine the guy more or less became like a filter for WB and their studio execs and the kind of movie they wanted to make.

There are moments -- fleeting ones -- in the 2007 movie where you see a glimmer of something brilliant... but then it passes. I absolutely don't blame Munroe.

I absolutely believe Monroe might have had a unique vision for the movie, but most if not all of whatever vision he had got robbed at some point in the film making process. There are points in the movie where, for just a very slim moment, you see something and think it's awesome and see Monroe's potential shine through; it's just unfortunate that, for whatever vision and ambition Monroe might have had at one point, it was pretty much nullified in the final product, because he didn't have the reputation to get the execs on board with his ideas.

Dragon Turtle
03-09-2010, 02:14 AM
And here's where I absolutely will defend Munroe. You just know the guy had a great vision, a big image of The Badass TMNT Movie... the one that rinses our collective mouths of the taste of the previous couple. However he had the odds stacked against him from the start... being a new director, not a lot in the way of pull and what-have-you... in the end, I kind of imagine the guy more or less became like a filter for WB and their studio execs and the kind of movie they wanted to make.

There are moments -- fleeting ones -- in the 2007 movie where you see a glimmer of something brilliant... but then it passes. I absolutely don't blame Munroe.


The areas where I would find fault with the movie that were directly caused by WB would be the PG rating, which handcuffed much of what they could do in terms of action and the insistence that movie be under 90 minutes, which I felt hindered the development of the story. But, he and Laird had a lot more creative control over the movie then most parties that hand over the rights to their properties to movie studios.

Spitfire
03-09-2010, 07:45 AM
The trophy wall, them being older, and the fact it's in the movie series boxset leads me to believe it takes place in the same continuity. I don't care what he intended to do I think it's pretty obvious when the time sceptor, Shredder's helmet, and the TGRI canister is sitting there. There's no other way you can read that but "movie universe". Also any of the stuff they mentioned happening before hand were pretty much covered in the movie prequel comics.

ToTheNines
03-09-2010, 09:42 AM
There's no other way you can read that but "movie universe".

Um, it was just a nod to the fans... there was also stuff from the comics. And Turtles never took Shredders helmet in the movies, so that doesn't mean anything.

There's just way too many contradictions and the really don't fit well together.

sdp
03-09-2010, 09:46 AM
Munroe always knew the movie would be PG, that is not what hindered the movie. And before we blame WB, look at all the stuff that happened to Imagi after the movie came out, I'm sure all those problems were there from the start so if anything I believe Imagi had more to do with messing with his vision. As far as his vision the movie tried to do way too many things at once, the monsters subplot was almost irrelevant, the foot were just kinda there and whatnot, it needed more time for all the plot he put into it instead everything is kinda rushed.


The trophy wall, them being older, and the fact it's in the movie series boxset leads me to believe it takes place in the same continuity. I don't care what he intended to do I think it's pretty obvious when the time sceptor, Shredder's helmet, and the TGRI canister is sitting there. There's no other way you can read that but "movie universe". Also any of the stuff they mentioned happening before hand were pretty much covered in the movie prequel comics.

Movie box sets don't mean anything, they just package things that go together. The two Hulk and Punisher movies are not in continuity and they're packaged together thats just marketing. The trophy room was put as a nod to fans not to piece it together in continuity. Shredder has been in every TMNT incarnation, the canister does not read TGRI, and the time scepter doesn't mean anything since TMNT universes share stuff, Tokka and Rahzar appeared later on in the OT but its not in continuity with the movie, Hun eventually appeared in Mirage but its not in continuity with the show. No reason why these turtles couldn't also have had that adventure. The turtles universe depicted in the movie is MUCH different from the ones in the movies, this one like most TMNT universes is more sci-fi heavy while the three live action movies are more grounded in reality. The turtles personalities are really nothing like they are in the movies as well. Not to mention you see triceraton blasters in the trophy room, that never happened in the live action movies and its not something I see those turtles ever fighting against. Also Silver Sentry shows up in one of the prequel books and I don't see Silver Sentry being canon with the original trilogy. Before the movie came out I wanted the movie to be in continuity with the past four so the "legacy" could continue but after watching it, it was clear that this was a different universe. The Next Mutation has more connections and fits much better with the movie continuity than this movie does.

All that you need to know for this movie is that the turtles are older and have defeated Shredder. That is pretty generic that has happened in every TMNT universe.

Anyways and on these forums Munroe mentioned how that is all you needed to know. When people kept asking he mentioned "well all you need to know is the Shredder has been defeated and years have passed so it could take place after the first movie". Later when people kept asking (including me :lol: ) he mentioned it could be seen as a "loose sequel to the first movie, maybe the second". But most of the time when asked or mentioning he said this was basically a new continuity having no ties to the first three movies.

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 10:22 AM
The Next Mutation has more connections and fits much better with the movie continuity than this movie does.

I always had a nagging suspicion that The Next Mutation was supposed to be in the movie continuity, but I figured I was alone in thinking so.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 11:00 AM
Munroe always knew the movie would be PG, that is not what hindered the movie.

It's a major contributing factor. How can it not be? They were going into development of the film knowing it contractually had to be PG... how would that not affect the film on every level and sensibility?

I always had a nagging suspicion that The Next Mutation was supposed to be in the movie continuity, but I figured I was alone in thinking so.

You're not alone. Kevin Eastman said from the beginning it was intended to be in the movie universe.

Plus Splinter's ear, the same subway lair, etc., it's not rocket science.

Coola Yagami
03-09-2010, 11:29 AM
Not to mention Mike's line about taking down crime syndicates with guns and whatnot. They never fought any mobsters or guys with guns in the original trilogy. And assuming they fought Triceratons sometime between III and this one is just assuming too much.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 11:43 AM
Not to mention Mike's line about taking down crime syndicates with guns and whatnot. They never fought any mobsters or guys with guns in the original trilogy. And assuming they fought Triceratons sometime between III and this one is just assuming too much.

Though not impossible.

odupianist
03-09-2010, 12:03 PM
And assuming they fought Triceratons sometime between III and this one is just assuming too much.

I don't see how it is assuming "too much". It's definitely feasible. Just as in the 2k3 cartoon, while they may have been gone months over on D'Hoonib, it could have been just minutes here. Still very plausible.

EDIT: And actually, I just remembered something, in Raph's prequel comic, they DO fight Triceratons.

sdp
03-09-2010, 12:31 PM
It's a major contributing factor. How can it not be? They were going into development of the film knowing it contractually had to be PG... how would that not affect the film on every level and sensibility?

They knew from the start it was PG so its not like it was denied later on and they had to change stuff. The TMNT can work well as PG its not like they were being limited, only in the sense that it couldn't be extra dark and gritty like the comics and even if it was PG-13 it wouldn't have connected with audiences anyway since it was CG.

You can't have a CG PG-13 movie and people take it seriously, they don't they still see it as a kids movie which is why Sky Captain, Beowulf, Final Fantasy all failed. Sure the movies had problems (except for Sky Captain) but people still didn't take them seriously as if they had been live action. Its still a long way before the stigma of animation is for kids to go away.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 12:43 PM
They knew from the start it was PG so its not like it was denied later on and they had to change stuff.

Right. But my point is that it wasn't like a real movie where it's that the director shoots the movie more or less the way he wants to suit his vision and the MPAA gives it whatever rating they want... no, Munroe was told, "You gotta keep it PG!"

The TMNT can work well as PG

Not in the slightest.

its not like they were being limited

OK, where's my LOLcopter? Am I being Punk'd?

only in the sense that it couldn't be extra dark and gritty like the comics and even if it was PG-13

So "ninjas" but no actual ninja action on-screen, gottit. Who would want to see that, anyway? And I think Michelangelo's trademark weapon is overrated... we shouldn't see it being used on-screen.

it wouldn't have connected with audiences anyway since it was CG.

That's a matter of taste, I suppose.

I don't have any strong feelings on this either way... apart from the retardedly Inspector Gadget-looking humans in the 2007 movie really pissing me off and yanking me out of the movie.

You can't have a CG PG-13 movie and people take it seriously,

The jury is still out on that.

they don't they still see it as a kids movie which is why Sky Captain, Beowulf, Final Fantasy all failed.

Those failed because of a combination of people not knowing what to make of them, shi**y previews, and sh*t marketing campaigns. Oh yeah... and then there's also the fact that all three of those were pretty terrible movies.

Sure the movies had problems (except for Sky Captain) but people still didn't take them seriously as if they had been live action. Its still a long way before the stigma of animation is for kids to go away.

You might have a point... but it's a little moot with the current movie being live-action.

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 01:02 PM
It's a major contributing factor. How can it not be? They were going into development of the film knowing it contractually had to be PG... how would that not affect the film on every level and sensibility?



You're not alone. Kevin Eastman said from the beginning it was intended to be in the movie universe.

Plus Splinter's ear, the same subway lair, etc., it's not rocket science.

I can't tell if there's any hostility in that part about it not being rocket science, but I'm going to assume not.

Anyways, the fact that Munroe was stuck working with a PG rating from the get-go undeniably had an impact on how the film turned out. Munroe had ideas, but he had to either tone them down to get the PG rating or - as the mafia would say - fuhgettaboutit. It's my understanding that the studio absolutely wasn't willing to work with anyone on the rating, that it was PG or no go. The verdict is still out on rather or not Viacom will enforce a similar policy or not, but I'm still glad to at least think they *could* loosen up, which we know WB wouldn't have done if it were up to them.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 01:38 PM
Anyways, the fact that Munroe was stuck working with a PG rating from the get-go undeniably had an impact on how the film turned out. Munroe had ideas, but he had to either tone them down to get the PG rating or - as the mafia would say - fuhgettaboutit. It's my understanding that the studio absolutely wasn't willing to work with anyone on the rating, that it was PG or no go.

Yeah.

The verdict is still out on rather or not Viacom will enforce a similar policy or not, but I'm still glad to at least think they *could* loosen up, which we know WB wouldn't have done if it were up to them.

Right. I'll say it again, but it was a little bit concerning thing to me -- and it might be nothing -- when the producer seemed to be defending/advocating a PG rating at the San Diego ComiCon TMNT panel. "Look at what the latest Harry Potter movie got away with, and that was PG!" ... which is a nonsense thing to say.

jalexbrown
03-09-2010, 01:52 PM
Yeah.



Right. I'll say it again, but it was a little bit concerning thing to me -- and it might be nothing -- when the producer seemed to be defending/advocating a PG rating at the San Diego ComiCon TMNT panel. "Look at what the latest Harry Potter movie got away with, and that was PG!" ... which is a nonsense thing to say.

Well, yeah...I admit that the odds of Viacom taking a risk are slim to none. usually I, as a fan, would jump ship the minute they started trying to defend the PG rating. I'm not really sure what makes this instance different, to be honest, but I guess I just so much want the reboot to *not* be utter bull**** that I'm trying my hardest to keep myself in good spirits until I know for certain otherwise.

Dragon Turtle
03-09-2010, 03:38 PM
Munroe always knew the movie would be PG, that is not what hindered the movie. And before we blame WB, look at all the stuff that happened to Imagi after the movie came out, I'm sure all those problems were there from the start so if anything I believe Imagi had more to do with messing with his vision. As far as his vision the movie tried to do way too many things at once, the monsters subplot was almost irrelevant, the foot were just kinda there and whatnot, it needed more time for all the plot he put into it instead everything is kinda rushed.



Because of the PG rating, Monroe and company had to walk on eggshells when it came to what they were allowed to depict in terms of action, as they had to constantly get approval from the MPAA for what was acceptable for PG and what was not.

As for Imagi, Peter Laird had said he and Monroe had quite a bit of creative freedom, here's a quote from Project Fanboy.

MG: Did you have more creative control over the recent film than the previous features?

PL: Yes, much more -- I give a lot of credit to Imagi for that... they were great to work with. Unlike my experience with the previous movies' producers, the people at Imagi really listened to what I had to say. I was closely involved with the writer/director Kevin Munroe from the initial conception of the plot right through to the final script.


However, I do believe that Imagi wanted more control over the sequel, and in my opinion, that was one of the main reasons TMNT 2 didn't get made.


About the monster plot being underdeveloped, while it's true there isn't much to it, I never got the impression it was to be the main focus of the movie, it was more like the Gozer plot from Ghostbusters, a movie referenced many times by Monroe as inspiration for TMNT 4, which played more in the background to the Ghostbuster's origin story. It was the "family" plot that was truly underdeveloped.


If there is something to blame Imagi for, it would be their approach to film making, TMNT was to be the prototype for their business model of producing theatrical quality CG movies at a lower cost then other studios. TMNT was produced in less then 2 years, about half the time of a typical Pixar movie, that puts a greater strain on the editing and writing of a movie, Monroe had mentioned how they had developed the Casey/April subplot, only to dump it in the end, you can only wonder how much time was wasted.



They knew from the start it was PG so its not like it was denied later on and they had to change stuff. The TMNT can work well as PG its not like they were being limited, only in the sense that it couldn't be extra dark and gritty like the comics and even if it was PG-13 it wouldn't have connected with audiences anyway since it was CG.


When the question of should a movie be PG or PG-13 comes up, it's strictly not about making a movie "dark and gritty", since PG-13 has such a wide range. Most superhero movies are PG-13, and most are hardly what I would call "dark and gritty", and many these movies don't seem to have a problem connecting with audiences. If you want an example how a PG rating can effect a movie, look no further then Mikey's use of his nunchucks, Monroe was told that Mikey was not allowed to use them, even to just swing them around, or the movie would have ended up with a PG-13 rating.

Andrew NDB
03-09-2010, 04:08 PM
If you want an example how a PG rating can effect a movie, look no further then Mikey's use of his nunchucks, Monroe was told that Mikey was not allowed to use them, even to just swing them around, or the movie would have ended up with a PG-13 rating.

Yep. I mean, it really can't be any simpler than that: if one of the titular characters can't use their trademark weapon -- at all -- because of the PG rating, there's a big f***ing problem.

odupianist
03-10-2010, 07:57 AM
And I think Michelangelo's trademark weapon is overrated... we shouldn't see it being used on-screen.


Just out of curiousity, why shouldn't we be seeing it on screen? I don't see how it's any more overrated than swords that just get swung around without any actual contact. I might be in the minority, but I actually enjoy when Mike uses his trademark weapon.

Yep. I mean, it really can't be any simpler than that: if one of the titular characters can't use their trademark weapon -- at all -- because of the PG rating, there's a big f***ing problem.

Totally agree with you there.

Candy Kappa
03-10-2010, 08:55 AM
Just out of curiousity, why shouldn't we be seeing it on screen? I don't see how it's any more overrated than swords that just get swung around without any actual contact. I might be in the minority, but I actually enjoy when Mike uses his trademark weapon.

unlike swords, nunchuck are illegal in some countries.... and that apparently justify the idiocy of not letting mikey use his weapons

ToTheNines
03-10-2010, 09:25 AM
The WGA card-carrying member who wrote and directed the movie begs to differ. But you can do whatever you want, really... "Create Your Own Adventure"... or continuity/fanon, in this case.

Really, it takes more half-assed fanfiction-ish explainations to connect the CGI movie to the live actions ones than it does to separate them.

Yep. I mean, it really can't be any simpler than that: if one of the titular characters can't use their trademark weapon -- at all -- because of the PG rating, there's a big f***ing problem.

It's just plain asinine, especially considering TMNT was an animated movie... and we've seen what is allowed of nunchucks in an animated tv show.

The next movie should be PG-13 for a number of debatable reasons, but there's no arguing with the nun-chucks. PG-13 or bust, case closed.

Andrew NDB
03-10-2010, 12:17 PM
Well let's try this again.

Just out of curiousity, why shouldn't we be seeing it on screen? I don't see how it's any more overrated than swords that just get swung around without any actual contact. I might be in the minority, but I actually enjoy when Mike uses his trademark weapon.

Pfft. Nonsense. Why should any of the Turtles be able to use their weapons on-screen? Highly overrated (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/sarcasm).

Really, it takes more half-assed fanfiction-ish explainations to connect the CGI movie to the live actions ones

Hardly. "Some time passed. They had other adventures." How hard is that?

Vivi
03-10-2010, 03:14 PM
What did Munroe want to do with the story before it was effectively cut back by execs? I mean, is the final result a skeleton of the original of the idea, or a different idea. I think it is possible to have had a better plot even with PG restrictions. But of course, a higher rating would mean more of the fun stuff for a (questionably) mature audience.

jalexbrown
03-10-2010, 06:40 PM
What did Munroe want to do with the story before it was effectively cut back by execs? I mean, is the final result a skeleton of the original of the idea, or a different idea. I think it is possible to have had a better plot even with PG restrictions. But of course, a higher rating would mean more of the fun stuff for a (questionably) mature audience.

I don't really know what he wanted from the get-go, but I believe - and someone can correct me on this if I'm wrong - that he knew from the start that he didn't want Shredder in the movie.

Andrew NDB
03-10-2010, 07:54 PM
What did Munroe want to do with the story before it was effectively cut back by execs? I mean, is the final result a skeleton of the original of the idea, or a different idea. I think it is possible to have had a better plot even with PG restrictions. But of course, a higher rating would mean more of the fun stuff for a (questionably) mature audience.

That's not really a fair question. I mean, there'd be TMNT stories he'd want to do... but he knew he couldn't do them if they were contractually PG-bound and all the other considerations ("Gotta move some toys!"). It wasn't like he wrote some badass TMNT story to end all stories and then it was cut back... he knew he couldn't write that to begin with.

So it's more a question of, what would Kevin Munroe's ultimate TMNT movie script be without any studio interference, not "What was the original story?" The original story is pretty much exactly the movie we got on screen.

Galactus
03-10-2010, 08:29 PM
What did Munroe want to do with the story before it was effectively cut back by execs? I mean, is the final result a skeleton of the original of the idea, or a different idea. I think it is possible to have had a better plot even with PG restrictions. But of course, a higher rating would mean more of the fun stuff for a (questionably) mature audience.

Well we have a good idea it was always going to revolve around Winters and his stone generals considering a working title was TMNT: Immortal. Although wonder if it was his concept or one he inherited.

I think in DVD commentary (though with my fuzzy memory it could elswhere) he says that originaly it was just the stone generals and the medallion things Winters used to reanimate them was to play a big part in the movie. At some point Raph was supposed to die but the medallion would bring him back to life.

I imagine that 13 monsters were tacked on at the behest of others. Beyond that we'd have probably gotten a similar-ish story but probably different in tone. Well that's just my opinion based on what we know.

jalexbrown
03-10-2010, 10:44 PM
Well we have a good idea it was always going to revolve around Winters and his stone generals considering a working title was TMNT: Immortal. Although wonder if it was his concept or one he inherited.

I think in DVD commentary (though with my fuzzy memory it could elswhere) he says that originaly it was just the stone generals and the medallion things Winters used to reanimate them was to play a big part in the movie. At some point Raph was supposed to die but the medallion would bring him back to life.

I imagine that 13 monsters were tacked on at the behest of others. Beyond that we'd have probably gotten a similar-ish story but probably different in tone. Well that's just my opinion based on what we know.

The thirteen monsters seemed like an attempt to make more characters they could get as action figures and fast-food tie-ins. Of course they didn't end up in any Happy Meal bags, but they did end up as action figures, so...

Cipher
03-10-2010, 11:11 PM
I'm of the opinion that this film could've been improved significantly just by removing the thirteen monsters. That felt so tacked on I was practically waiting for a price tag to show up on the screen.

CyberCubed
03-10-2010, 11:12 PM
The thirteen monsters seemed like an attempt to make more characters they could get as action figures and fast-food tie-ins. Of course they didn't end up in any Happy Meal bags, but they did end up as action figures, so...

Only about 5 of the monsters wound up as action figures. The rest never became toys.

So if that was the intent, that never happened.

Dragon Turtle
03-11-2010, 12:05 AM
I imagine that 13 monsters were tacked on at the behest of others. Beyond that we'd have probably gotten a similar-ish story but probably different in tone. Well that's just my opinion based on what we know.

The 13 monsters were thought up by Monroe and Laird.



I'm of the opinion that this film could've been improved significantly just by removing the thirteen monsters. That felt so tacked on I was practically waiting for a price tag to show up on the screen.


I think better use of the monsters or developing the Generals would have significantly improved the movie, as is, the monsters were so insignificant they could have easily been replaced with any other generic MacGuffin.

Cipher
03-11-2010, 12:12 AM
You can have the monsters or you can have the (more interesting, I think) generals. Shoehorning both into a 90-minute film was an appallingly bad idea from every concievable standpoint.

Dragon Turtle
03-11-2010, 01:05 AM
You can have the monsters or you can have the (more interesting, I think) generals. Shoehorning both into a 90-minute film was an appallingly bad idea from every concievable standpoint.

They monsters could have never have been the main antagonists in the movie, since they lack any real personality, they are essentially an extension of the havoc associated with the real villains, the generals. The monsters could have been used to enhance the setting of the story, through action scenes involving the turtles or just general mayhem in New York. They really don't, or shouldn't, take away from the development of the generals, who are simply underdeveloped due to the writing.

If there are any superfluous elements that needed to be removed, I would have to say they would be the Nightwatcher and April/Casey subplots.

jalexbrown
03-12-2010, 03:06 PM
They monsters could have never have been the main antagonists in the movie, since they lack any real personality, they are essentially an extension of the havoc associated with the real villains, the generals. The monsters could have been used to enhance the setting of the story, through action scenes involving the turtles or just general mayhem in New York. They really don't, or shouldn't, take away from the development of the generals, who are simply underdeveloped due to the writing.

If there are any superfluous elements that needed to be removed, I would have to say they would be the Nightwatcher and April/Casey subplots.

I definitely could have done without the Nightwater stuff, but then it would have made Raph much less developed and fleshed out in the movie.

Dragon Turtle
03-14-2010, 10:25 PM
I definitely could have done without the Nightwater stuff, but then it would have made Raph much less developed and fleshed out in the movie.

There were other ways to develop Raph's character without the Nightwatcher subplot, the tension between Raph and Leo could have been better explored, and since that tension had existed long before Leo knew about Raph being the Nightwatcher, the subplot feels like useless clutter.

Shredder_Fan
03-29-2010, 05:33 PM
the 4th movie whas boring
100% sucks.....

just like the TMNT for ever cartoon/movie
in that cartoon the new Technodrome whas ****t-up (so not cool)

and just like the 4th movie
it whas not cool

only the end that Karai told the Turtles someone is back
and please god i hope its Shredder

and that he meet Krang and stuff with the Technodrome as HQ
hope that will be in the new one

Andrew NDB
03-29-2010, 06:03 PM
only the end that Karai told the Turtles someone is back

Who else could she have possibly been talking about?

That line of dialogue was so on-the-nose it was palpable.

and that he meet Krang and stuff with the Technodrome as HQ
hope that will be in the new one

Don't count on it. But they seem a pretty safe bet for the new CGI cartoon.

Scandia
03-29-2010, 08:56 PM
The historical inaccuracies. The Spanish language did NOT even exist 3000 years ago- in fact, its mother tongue, Latin, was just emerging. The language spoken in Iberia 3000 years ago is closest to modern day Basque- a mysterious language isolate. The languages spoken 3000 years ago in Mexico were in the Amerind family- the Aztec and Maya languages, for example. So why would the characters have names in a language that did not even exist back then, nor come into contact with that part of the world for a loooong time? BIG historical goof on their part. If Yaotl had a name in the Aztec language, why did his siblings have names in Spanish- more incongruencies.


"is Spanish"

Coola Yagami
03-29-2010, 09:25 PM
And why was Yaotl human and his siblings... like monsterous?

Samhain
03-29-2010, 09:30 PM
The historical inaccuracies. The Spanish language did NOT even exist 3000 years ago- in fact, its mother tongue, Latin, was just emerging. The language spoken in Iberia 3000 years ago is closest to modern day Basque- a mysterious language isolate. The languages spoken 3000 years ago in Mexico were in the Amerind family- the Aztec and Maya languages, for example. So why would the characters have names in a language that did not even exist back then, nor come into contact with that part of the world for a loooong time? BIG historical goof on their part. If Yaotl had a name in the Aztec language, why did his siblings have names in Spanish- more incongruencies.


"is Spanish"

Uh, this irks me aswell.:roll:

Davetello
04-06-2010, 10:51 AM
It was a decent watch the first two or three times, but it grows boring. The storyline was fairly weak and the CGI wasn't that impressive.

Best part was the Leo v Raph fight, but besides that it just wasn't a movie which held my attention well, despite being the turtles.

Davetello
04-06-2010, 10:52 AM
The historical inaccuracies. The Spanish language did NOT even exist 3000 years ago- in fact, its mother tongue, Latin, was just emerging. The language spoken in Iberia 3000 years ago is closest to modern day Basque- a mysterious language isolate. The languages spoken 3000 years ago in Mexico were in the Amerind family- the Aztec and Maya languages, for example. So why would the characters have names in a language that did not even exist back then, nor come into contact with that part of the world for a loooong time? BIG historical goof on their part. If Yaotl had a name in the Aztec language, why did his siblings have names in Spanish- more incongruencies.


"is Spanish"

This is a good point too, and something which had not occurred to me.

JWarner
04-06-2010, 01:14 PM
This is one of my favorite topics... and kind of encompasses turtle fandom at its core. Because there are so many versions of the turtle property, ranging from kid-friendly to not-so-kid-friendly, it's clearly impossible to accommodate everyone's tastes in a single production. IMHO, I believe that this movie was a valiant effort. I found it entertaining and enjoyable. I tend to lean towards the original book in terms of theme, but can appreciate making the franchise accessible to as many people as possible. That being said, I understand that some people may feel that the storyline was not up to snuff and I think that point can be justifiably argued...

However... I think that questioning the production quality of this film isn't right. The animation of this film was fantastic! The lighting and color palette was great, from the dusty earthy tones in the South American village to the foliage in the jungle, to the night time rooftops... the red hue of the neon sign in Raph and Leo's fight scene, not to mention the rain on said rooftop. The overall animated movements of four turtles that walk on two legs... and btw they had very distinct body language. The backgrounds were well thought out and insanely rendered. And of course the fight choreography was great.

I guess what I'm saying is that the story is what it is and everybody has their own opinion... and that's cool. But I think that as a CGI production, this was a good looking piece of film, and I think it deserves to be recognized as such.

...heh, heh... now I guess I'll take my lumps...

BlueLightning
04-08-2010, 03:48 PM
I was watching this morning the ending of the movie, and reminded me of this topic. I like this film, whe I first saw this on theaters I was expecting something different, but I wasn't dissapointed. I was amazed by the CGI designs, I liked the details. But I think the reason that people did not like this film that much was their expectations and visions of what this film should be. Kind of like what happened with Superman Returns. It was a quasi-sequel of the first movies, and payed homage to them. Even some lines of dialogue connect this film with the older ones, from the obvious ones to the more obscure ones (like the dialogue of Raph and Leo after he is rescued). The thing is that the story wasn't right for a theatrical film. It tried to be epic, but it didn't make it.

It was a missed oportunity, they could have made a great film, a more traditional Turtle movie, so to speak.That's the reason I think this film is disliked, because it was a wasted opportunity.

The beauty of the Ninja Turtles is that you can put them in every random situation, and when it is handled right, you get always a great story. This film was good, I liked it, but it could have been much better.

Warhorse
04-11-2010, 10:51 AM
What I liked and disliked about the movie.

First: I loved the over all look and atmosphere that was created by the CGI crew. It was stellar.

I loved the characterizations of Raph, Leo and Donny, and their relationship with each other. The dialogue between those three were pretty crisp as well.

I loved the voice overs for Raph, Leo and Don as well.

What I didn't like:
The overall plot. I agree with most, it should have somehow revolve around the City At War arc. It's in canon, and thanks to the 2k3 toon, kids and adults should be familiar with Karai.

Not enough Don. Yeah, I'm a Raph fan, but the movie showed so much promise with Don's first appearance, and I was looking forward to more of the foursome, but then he fell back to just a supporting character, barely. April and Casey seemed to have more screen time than Don. Mikey got the shaft too, but considering his poor character development in this film, I hardly noticed.

Mikey's characterization and vocal work. In the older movies, Mikey had charm and wit, and didn't sound like a pot head. In this movie, he like devolved by 10 degrees.
I didn't like Splinter either. I didn't like his voice or his characterization, and some of his dialogue. Instead of a noble master and caring father, he came across as an asshole to me.

I didn't care for Casey or April characterizations either. It's not like I liked them or not, but they didn't particularly stand out for me either.

oldmanwinters
04-11-2010, 10:27 PM
I add my voice to the list of those who disdain the April O'Neil: Super Ninja portrayal. Nevertheless, it looks like the original script had staged the April/Karai fight scene a bit differently:

From Munroe's TMNT script (SECOND REVISED First Draft Polish
August 5, 2005, p.81:

93 EXT. WINTERS PARK 93
We finally get to see how much of an ass-kicker Master
Splinter is. Same with April, who squares off against Karai.
They fight hard. April ends up cornered, about to be skewered
by her blade when...
-CLUNK! She wobbles and then passes out. When Karai falls out
of frame, she reveals CASEY JONES a hundred yards behind her
holding his HOCKEY STICK! April frowns.
APRIL
I had the situation under control.
CASEY
(smirks)
You’re welcome.
Mikey fights the most like Jackie Chan - comical maneuvers
backed by solid-hitting blows. Don uses his bo-staff in 1001
different ways, both offensively and defensively.
Casey is enjoying the hell out of it. High flying, adrenaline
rush. He even catches April checking him out, and vice versa.
April suddenly spots an opening to the front doors!
APRIL
Guys! Front door is open. Now!
They all charge the front door!

Source:http://www.script-o-rama.com/table4.shtml


I think that take would have worked much better for the final cut and made the fight more believable. What do you guys think?

Candy Kappa
04-12-2010, 03:09 AM
think that would had worked better, taking Karai out with a blow from behind.

dontplaydead27
04-21-2010, 08:38 AM
I didn't read all 11 pages of this, but I skimmed quite a bit. There are some very good points on here as to why this movie didn't "live up" to most.

My dislikes are as follows;

Don and Mike's virtual no screen time/interaction with the other turtles. I thought they got shafted with the Leo/Raph plot overshadowing them. As someone said, April and Casey got more screentime than Don or Mike, especially Don. Being a Donny fan, I was mostly pissed about this.

The nightwatcher subplot. I see what the point of it was or could be interpreted as, but I think this movie wasn't the place for it. Making one turtle out to be a batman-esque vigilante automatically puts him in the spotlight and overshadows everyone else. Huge efforts would have to be made to make it seem not so un-balanced- these steps were not taken. It seems it was just used to lead up to a Raph and Leo fight. I loved the fight, however if you are a halfway intelligent person and a fight is your FAVORITE part of a movie, then that speaks volumes about the plot.

The absence of Shredder. I know, I hear many of you say that Shredder isn't the only villain in the turtles gallery, but to most of us he's the icon of it all. He has a rich history with the turtles and Splinter, and the fans. I don't think you can "overuse" him just as you can't overuse the turtles. You can be creative and think of other ways to implement him. For me, the old 3rd movie (aside from blowing hot nuts anyway) sucked far more because Shredder was dead and not used- nor was any bad guy that we gave a **** about. I'm not saying you can't create a new enemy (see my thoughts on Karai after this), but make sure it's an enemy we want to CARE ABOUT- meaning someone you generally want to fear, that you recognize as the antagonist. Not this Darth Vader/Anakin show me why you're evil stuff. I don't mean someone we sympathize with, just someone who would scare us if we were in their presence or crossed them. Think Shredder from the original movie. We were treated to little backstory, nothing that explained his devious ways but instead showed us that overall he was just a guy who wanted to steal and do bad things. There was no sympathy. I can't stand moviemakers who can't grasp the concept that villain and sympathy DO NOT go together. You take away the mystery of the evil and give it a reason, then you take away the evil. George Lucas can go to hell for basically taking a dump on HIS OWN character. He created the posterboy for evil, and destroyed it for apparently no other reason than a buck. Enough of that, we need Shredder, ESPECIALLY when you are reviving life into a movie franchise that's been dead for years.------{ a note, I realize i'm wrong by saying we NEED Shredder. You don't NEED Shredder for a reboot of an old franchise, you just need a good plot, this has been proven in comic movies by Chris Nolan. Yeah, I said it. On a Turtles board. Fact of the matter is, the plot wasn't that great}

Mikes portrayal. Horribly stupid and stoner skater-kid that you want to punch in the face. What screen time he did get was ruined by this, so thank god he wasn't in the movie any more.

More Karai and Foot clan. I will say, if Karai and the Foot were the main baddies in this movie, it would have been SO MUCH better. Having a villain that's at least connected to Shredder, and maybe could possibly be trying to locate him would be an acceptable way to do a movie. She had mystique enough to be a decent enemy. I did not like how it was shown that the clan was still around, but they weren't utilized at all and almost worthless to mention- because it just showed you how much more they could have done with the movie.

That's my main complaints.

Loco
04-24-2010, 05:39 PM
What was wrong in the 2007 movie ? actually that's a quick answer even Analphabet Utroms will understand it, The Movie. I'm a roots admirator , Baron has ruled this gamE & nobody can't reach his level. Imagi movie was bad , ugly turtles , I will never buy any toys or collectible from that one. I just liked the Raph & Leo's "Matrix" Scene , was a beautiful animation and water looked stunning.but.. that's all folks.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-25-2010, 07:23 AM
the 4th movie whas boring
100% sucks.....

just like the TMNT for ever cartoon/movie
in that cartoon the new Technodrome whas ****t-up (so not cool)

and just like the 4th movie
it whas not cool

only the end that Karai told the Turtles someone is back
and please god i hope its Shredder

and that he meet Krang and stuff with the Technodrome as HQ
hope that will be in the new one

I agree. Many people have wanted to see the Technodrome on the cinema screen since the early 1990's.

Koi
04-25-2010, 08:59 PM
The fact it was a fourth movie and it resembled nothing of the past three is what is wrong with it.

RiseAbove873
05-06-2010, 09:33 AM
I haven't watched it in a while but the things that I remember that I don't like are:

1. The plot. Monsters? People who live forever? No Shredder? Come on. Why?

2. Raph getting the upper hand over Leonardo. No way would Raph "beat" Leonardo.

3. April as a ninja.

4. Rap music doesn't belong in TMNT. In fact, it doesn't belong anywhere.

5. The under development of certain characters.

Teddy
05-07-2010, 10:03 PM
I love the 4th movie (so sue me), but the one thing that REALLY bugs me about it was how they made April look like a 12-year-old girl. Then when she gets all "pouty" on the phone with Casey? I hate that, it's so stupid. And yeah, the fact that she's suddenly a master ninja too doesn't sit well, either. >.<

So basically, I HATED April in that movie.

The Stryker
05-07-2010, 11:41 PM
4. Rap music doesn't belong in TMNT. In fact, it doesn't belong anywhere.

VFsTr0kGAqU

Powder
05-08-2010, 12:01 AM
4. Rap music doesn't belong in TMNT. In fact, it doesn't belong anywhere.


Where have you been?

Did you miss all three original movie soundtracks? ...Or the fact that Vanilla Ice was in the second film?

Did you miss mikey playing something awfully reminiscent of hip hop from his ghettoblaster in various episodes of the OT?

Have you never seen the "hip hop michelangelo" action figure from the original playmates line?

As Tokka once put it, "Hip hop music has always been an integral part of the TMNT mythos". Thats a quote that bears truth.

I don't care for the Gym Class Heroes, so I can agree that their song being in the movie was kinda... well, wack. But had it been a rap song something more fitting to the TMNT culture rather then what confused suits thought kids would like, it would've been the norm.

A fact, such as many characters didn't get much backstory or screen time, serves to be a valid point to make. However, discrediting a genre (that you don't like) often placed in the realm of teen turtles is... dare I say- "Ludacris". :tlol: It belongs somewhere. Where? In TMNT media, peoples headphones, & right alongside rock, country, techno & so forth. 8)

Loco
05-08-2010, 12:29 PM
4. Rap music doesn't belong in TMNT. In fact, it doesn't belong anywhere.

WTF ?
Imo Vanilla Ice wasn't really a Rapper :lol: ( or 4 f*ckin' worse awards)
http://www.monsterup.com/upload/1273340326973.gif (http://www.monsterup.com)
you're all right for the rest Powder

4 Rise above873 I show you somes powder examples

http://www.monsterup.com/upload/1273339499966.jpg (http://www.monsterup.com)

http://www.monsterup.com/upload/1273340326710.gif (http://www.monsterup.com)

http://www.monsterup.com/upload/1273339499333.jpg (http://www.monsterup.com)

http://www.monsterup.com/upload/1273339500664.gif (http://www.monsterup.com)

Hip Hop doesn't belong to TMNT nah Nah ^^ ;)

Koi
05-08-2010, 12:54 PM
Vanilla Ice was rapper...

Galactus
05-08-2010, 03:10 PM
The plot. Monsters? People who live forever? No Shredder? Come on. Why?

They have more villains than Shredder y'know. The character is dead and if TMNT movie can't succeed without him then there's no hope for a movie series beyond one movie.

Monsters and fantasy elements are a part of TMNT lore. Nothing was really wrong with the plot other than it wasn't presented in a good way. Then again I wonder if OT fans would've liked the movie better had it Shredder gathering the 13 monsters for nefarious reason...for most it would have made the movie even worse.

Raph getting the upper hand over Leonardo. No way would Raph "beat" Leonardo.

You can break the news to Eastman & Laird then that they don't know their own creation as Raph defintively beat Leo in TMNT Vol #19 Return To New York Book 1.

If I remember correctly Raph also beat Leo in the Archie series too. I can't remember the exact issue but it was when they fought each other in Stump Arena. Of course Don later beat Raph. Controversial I know but I believe with varying factors such as prep time, environment, motivation any of the turtles could beat each other...and have.

3. April as a ninja.

April has trained in ninjitsu in the original comics, the Archie series really ran with the idea of her being a trained ninja and the 2003 cartoon also had her a training in ninjitsu.

If she's part of a family of ninjas that is at war with another ninja clan as well as getting involved in other dangerous activities it's ridiculous for her not to want to learn to defend herself.

4. Rap music doesn't belong in TMNT. In fact, it doesn't belong anywhere.

Your bias against that genre aside I think others have pointed out how wrong you are.

5. The under development of certain characters.

Well I'd agree but generaly a movie with large cast tend to focus on a few to the detriment of the others. Other than making Mikey a bit too comical I'm reasonably happy with with the characterisation in the short time we got..in the sense that "it'll do"

Loco
05-08-2010, 04:02 PM
Vanilla Ice was rapper...
I was jokin' ;)
I dislike vanilla.I Prefer chocolate Arella lol ;)

RiseAbove873
05-09-2010, 10:51 AM
Of course I've seen the original TMNT movies. I felt the same way back then as I do now. I stand by my opinion that rap doesn't belong in the TMNT universe. In fact, I don't feel that it belongs anywhere.

Powder
05-09-2010, 12:44 PM
Of course I've seen the original TMNT movies. I felt the same way back then as I do now. I stand by my opinion that rap doesn't belong in the TMNT universe. In fact, I don't feel that it belongs anywhere.

I can force unecessary opinions too. Maybe you don't belong on the drome. In fact maybe you don't belong anywhere.

:tlol:

Loco
05-09-2010, 06:20 PM
Maybe you don't belong on the drome. In fact maybe you don't belong anywhere.

:tlol:

:lol: this was necessary
:tlol:
Seriously Riseabove dude , don't you have read the last page man. we get you don't like hip hop but don't stay stuck on your ideas like that you'll not make good pals here like that way me thinks. (& trust I'm not the good example, but I'm not Lost 4ever)

RiseAbove873
05-09-2010, 09:04 PM
I can force unecessary opinions too. Maybe you don't belong on the drome. In fact maybe you don't belong anywhere.

:tlol:




The OP asked for our OPINIONS on what we thought was wrong with the movie and I gave my OPINIONS. Not once did I try to "force" my opinions on anyone. There was no reason to be rude.

Koi
05-09-2010, 09:49 PM
Don't worry RiseAbove873, opinions belong anywhere there is a question. It was just the way I think people read it that made it seem like it came off as more of a fact then opinion on your part.

The Stryker
05-10-2010, 12:26 AM
Of course I've seen the original TMNT movies. I felt the same way back then as I do now. I stand by my opinion that rap doesn't belong in the TMNT universe. In fact, I don't feel that it belongs anywhere.

But you won't explain this stance at all for some strange reason.

Powder
05-10-2010, 12:43 AM
But you won't explain this stance at all for some strange reason.



He probably one of those 'its just noise' types.

:trolleye:

RiseAbove873
05-10-2010, 04:19 AM
But you won't explain this stance at all for some strange reason.

I assumed common sense would have been enough. Apparently not.

The Stryker
05-10-2010, 04:24 AM
Wha.

It's common sense to know why you hate rap music? Is this one of those ruining america things?

RiseAbove873
05-10-2010, 08:56 AM
Wha.

It's common sense to know why you hate rap music? Is this one of those ruining america things?


Yes it is common sense to assume somebody doesn't like something when he/she puts it as an answer to a "What was wrong with the 4th movie?" thread. Shouldn't have to be explained. Also, when I think of ninja, martial arts, and/or epic battles, the last thing that comes to mind is rap music. Sorry for giving some of you more credit than deserved.

Again, not once did I try to "force" anything on anybody and that accusation has no merit.

Cure
05-10-2010, 11:44 AM
Also, when I think of ninja, martial arts, and/or epic battles, the last thing that comes to mind is rap music.

You seem to be forgetting 1/4 of their identity: teenage.

Also, when you say "IN FACT, it doesn't belong anywhere" you're stating it as fact. The word's right there.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-10-2010, 11:50 AM
We've had out differences Cure, but I couldn't agree with you more strongly. I can't believe how long this thread has lasted (but then, TMNT fans are always looking for the bad/things to b!tch about).

RiseAbove873
05-10-2010, 12:15 PM
You seem to be forgetting 1/4 of their identity: teenage.

Also, when you say "IN FACT, it doesn't belong anywhere" you're stating it as fact. The word's right there.

I might have worded it wrong but you know damn well it was an opinion. Anyway, this is ridiculous. I don't want to argue. I replied with my opinion and that's that. I shouldn't have to defend it.

If you want to continue to mock and belittle me for not sharing your opinions, well, go ahead. I came to this forum because of my love for Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, not to get in to arguments.

Loco
05-10-2010, 03:59 PM
I think It's okay now dudes.Ok he's new give him a new start. Riseabove, You had say you don't like Hip Hop ok , now we can move on and talk about all the others things you might like in the TMNT world, but pal you started a bit wrong, your opinion is okay for us, the fact we don't accept is when you say "hip hop doesn't belong anywhere" I think this is the biggest problem , you can keep that for you I mean , I hate tokyo hotel and tectonik but I'm not going to put down the fans of that kind of music. get it or not , I'm out of that thread.I gived my point on that "fake" turtle movie (cartoon 3d)

voltron80
05-10-2010, 06:07 PM
I enjoyed the movie overall but the main issues I had with the movie is one the story the movie could probably done better if it just focused on the turtles drifting apart and then coming together as brothers then a team because the 13 monsters/Winters angle felt tack on and it felt out of place. Another was Don and Mike seemed like they were secondary characters outside some comic relief scenes they didn't had much of a role.

Another issue I wonder did time restriction force Kevin Monroe to cut his story? Scenes went by fast and other than the Leo and Nightwatch man/Raph fight I don't remember too many long scenes.

Time restriction could also explain why they didn't explain what events happen between Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3 and TMNT like April going from news reporter to antique dealer and how Karai is the new leader of the foot when Tatsu was second in command in the first two movies and they never mention her.

Sidian
06-20-2010, 10:21 PM
I don't understand why TMNT 3 gets so much bile. It's story and action aren't bad, it's the non-Henson costuming that gets me, and I can kinda look past that.

THANK GOD SOMEONE ELSE AGREES!!!!

honestly the costumes were the only thing that bugged me about that movie and its a minor gripe...to me theres nothing bad about it. heck it didnt even have other mutants which most people seem to love the idea of around here...

would have liked to have seen casey jones in action a bit though...would have been cool. other than that though i still love it...can still remember seeing it in theaters...ahh memories!

Andrew NDB
06-20-2010, 11:16 PM
Yeah, TMNT 3 wasn't as terrible as 2 or 4, actually. Just the costumes were a problem and wayyy too much slapstick/camp for good measure... but within it, it had quite a heart. The Yoshi-Raphael angle was actually pretty endearing.

ooglafina
06-20-2010, 11:57 PM
One of the things that bothered me was that there seemed to an all around cheapness about the whole production. It's sort of hard to describe. I always thought that maybe they invested all their money in the newfangled suits and the Japanese palace set or something. And it was nice to hear Corey Feldman again.

TheCanadiandrome
06-21-2010, 12:15 AM
i dunno, to me all the movies have some redeemable qualities.

ooglafina
06-22-2010, 07:35 PM
I'm watching the third one right now and they just heard Mitsu say that Raph is, "Just like the other one," and then they all celebrate. I wonder why they assume he's alive. Seems like they would go, "NOO!" since her gang had just jumped them all. Made me laugh anyway. Never bothered me when I was younger.

Spitfire
06-22-2010, 08:40 PM
THANK GOD SOMEONE ELSE AGREES!!!!

honestly the costumes were the only thing that bugged me about that movie and its a minor gripe...to me theres nothing bad about it. heck it didnt even have other mutants which most people seem to love the idea of around here...

So the horrible dialogue didn't bother you? The half ass voice acting? The fact that 90% of the lines aren't even lip synced properly? None of that bothered you?

TMNT 3 isn't just **** because the costumes are ass it's **** because everything is ass. Take away the idea that maybe the story wasn't that bad and the movie has zero redeeming qualities. The production quality is laughable. I've seen porn with higher standards. It's actually embarrassing to watch. If anyone saw that film, most kids today likely included, they'd think turtles was ****ing retarded and I wouldn't be inclined to argue with them.

Candy Kappa
06-22-2010, 08:45 PM
So the horrible dialogue didn't bother you? The half ass voice acting? The fact that 90% of the lines aren't even lip synced properly? None of that bothered you?

TMNT 3 isn't just **** because the costumes are ass it's **** because everything is ass. Take away the idea that maybe the story wasn't that bad and the movie has zero redeeming qualities. The production quality is laughable. I've seem porn with higher standards. It's actually embarrassing to watch. If anyone saw that film, most kids today likely included, they'd think turtles was ****ing retarded and I wouldn't be inclined to argue with them.


This is the reasons the movie is horrible, the costumes are only one of many issues TMNT 3: "Turtles in Time" had.

TuЯco
06-22-2010, 09:35 PM
i bet if in the begining they didnt let people know raph was nightwatcher it would been a little better.

Cure
06-22-2010, 09:42 PM
i bet if in the begining they didnt let people know raph was nightwatcher it would been a little better.

For sure. That was totally one of the major complaints the entire fandom had.