PDA

View Full Version : Seein Red


(DC)
03-07-2010, 02:18 PM
For the new 2012 movie, should the all red headbands come back? Not only is it historicly accurate but since they are basing more on the old comics it would make sense. It's hard enough to find enough fabric to make headband for four turtles in the sewer, let alone four multicolored ones.

Oculus Orbus
03-07-2010, 02:20 PM
It would be so nice to have them all wearing red bandanas.

The Stryker
03-07-2010, 02:36 PM
Who said it would be based more on the old comics?

odupianist
03-08-2010, 08:09 AM
As much as I'd like to see that, I highly doubt it will happen. Movie execs see the viewing audience dumb enough that they feel we need to see a color differential rather than just look at the weapons or hear their voices. Personally, I'd love to see the red bandanas, I just find it highly improbable. I think the first movie is the closest we'll get to the old comics, but I could be wrong.

Doc_ock_4mugen
03-08-2010, 08:27 AM
I'd like the red ones to be in at least one flashback scene (seeing that they're most likely to use multi-colored)

sdp
03-08-2010, 10:57 AM
That will never happen in any media besides the Mirage universe which is good since I think all red bandannas is kinda stupid and makes as much sense as colored bandannas. I can see it happening in the beginning though in a flashback or Splinter giving them colors to distinguish them, people wouldn't care about that and it'd be a nice nod for all the Mirage fans.

Cipher
03-08-2010, 11:20 AM
I don't expect it to happen at all, but I'd love it if it did.

The colored masks are ridiculous. And there are so many other ways to identify them on film. Weapons, skin color, voice, even body-type if they go that route (which I'm not a fan of).

That will never happen in any media besides the Mirage universe which is good since I think all red bandannas is kinda stupid and makes as much sense as colored bandannas.Look, turtles in masks is inherently stupid to begin with. But four individually styled masks is few steps stupider than a ninja team sharing one color for solidarity and enemy confusion. And as some one else pointed out, it's not like Splinter was running to fabric stores or anything.

The Stryker
03-08-2010, 01:09 PM
The colored masks are ridiculous. And there are so many other ways to identify them on film. Weapons, skin color, voice, even body-type if they go that route (which I'm not a fan of).


Weapons you would have to really pay attention to, Voice wouldn't matter in fight scenes and Skin Color would require them to be really well lit all the time.

Cipher
03-08-2010, 02:31 PM
Weapons you would have to really pay attention to, Voice wouldn't matter in fight scenes and Skin Color would require them to be really well lit all the time.So then everyone watching Turtles Forever was constantly baffled by which Mirage Turtle they were watching at the time, ammirite? People loved 'em.

And voice doesn't matter in fight scenes? Problem solved because those are the only times when they're guarunteed to be brandishing their weapons.

Still not saying it's plausible. But it's a lot more workable than people give it credit for.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 02:32 PM
For the new 2012 movie, should the all red headbands come back?

Yes. And it would send a firm message that this is a new beginning/reboot, not a continuance of the other horrible movies.

Kendamu
03-08-2010, 02:35 PM
If it happens, cool. If not, whatever. I don't know what to expect right now.

Candy Kappa
03-08-2010, 04:23 PM
I'd love to see the red bandannas, I think they are awesome.

The Stryker
03-08-2010, 04:25 PM
So then everyone watching Turtles Forever was constantly baffled by which Mirage Turtle they were watching at the time, ammirite? People loved 'em.

I was confused a few times but it didn't really matter since it was like 7 minutes.

Kendamu
03-08-2010, 04:27 PM
It never really confused me. Their voices were distinct enough and they were almost always with weapons in-view or in some sort of variation of a classic pose.

jaymq
03-08-2010, 05:49 PM
I think it'd be awesome, but my hopes aren't high on the bandannas.

As for Turtles Forever Mirage turtles... they were also in black and white, not just 'red bandannas'. Their bodies were all drawn the same along with every other Mirage issue 1 thing they could fit in. So, if there was confusion, it was because they were being accurate to mirage issue 1. if the movie is in color, they could just as easily give them different skin tones or something else if they wanna differentiate from 2k3.

Just some thoughts, I think it'd be cool, but it wouldn't really bother me as long as they have good personalities, animation and plot.

Oh and I hardly think Splinter of all people would be 'confused' who was who after raising them. Not unless there's something wrong with his senses. I'm not keen on people who can't tell the difference between twins (or more if that's the case) if they've been around them for more than a few weeks. Just seems silly to me. Even twins have differences.

Leo656
03-08-2010, 06:01 PM
Never been a fan of all-red. I suspect a lot of people who prefer it only do so because it was the original and thus, "the way it was meant to be". But I disagree with that logic; Superman's "S" logo went through dozens of redesigns over decades before coming to the version we all know. I doubt anyone wants to see it revert to a plain yellow triangle with an S scrawled in it, just because that's how it looked in Action Comics #1.

It's just easier to follow the characters in motion when they're all wearing different colors, as well as helping people who don't follow the characters learn who is who much easier. It serves a purpose and isn't as ridiculous as some make it sound, given the fact the turtles were able to not only find masks to wear, but kneepads, elbow pads, belts, a variety of weapons, etc.

All red looks cool enough as well, but I feel the multi-colored masks work best across a wide range of media.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 06:11 PM
Never been a fan of all-red. I suspect a lot of people who prefer it only do so because it was the original and thus, "the way it was meant to be".

No. Not only because. Find me a ninja clan that runs around playing dress-up with different mood-ring colors. One that would would seem pretty metrosexual and weird to me. I'd imagine most folks in ninja clans would all wear the same color bandanna.

But yes, to answer seriously: multi-colored bandannas make the TMNT seem like less of a legitimate ninja clan. Which is kind of a big deal given they're literally called "Ninja Turtles."

It's just easier to follow the characters in motion when they're all wearing different colors, as well as helping people who don't follow the characters learn who is who much easier. It serves a purpose and isn't as ridiculous as some make it sound, given the fact the turtles were able to not only find masks to wear, but kneepads, elbow pads, belts, a variety of weapons, etc.

I'd agree that the multi-colored bandannas is a lesser evil than the lettered belts... but that doesn't make multi-colored bandannas any less unnecessary or demeaning to audiences.

It never really confused me. Their voices were distinct enough and they were almost always with weapons in-view or in some sort of variation of a classic pose.

There's that, and then there's the simple fact that their bodies, skin speckles, faces, builds all look very different. I mean, show me the suits from the films or even the CGI Turtles from the last awful movie... remove the bandannas and all color from them, I can still tell you exactly which one is which without hesitation. You're telling me you can't? You're a liar.

I've said it before, but arguing "They all look alike without different colored bandannas to tell them apart!" is dangerously close to, "All black people look alike, can't some of them wear different hats so I can tell them apart?"

sdp
03-08-2010, 06:11 PM
I originally wrote a big post on why people would hate it and it wouldn't work but decided to delete it since I'm kind of tired of discussing this from my other topic.

Fact is no matter what anyone thinks we will never see red bandannas from the turtles outside of the Mirage comics.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 06:18 PM
Fact is no matter what anyone thinks we will never see red bandannas from the turtles outside of the Mirage comics.

Probably not, you're right. But that doesn't mean we need to bend over and pretend it's a good idea that there not be.

Leo656
03-08-2010, 06:29 PM
I'd imagine most folks in ninja clans would all wear the same color bandanna.

Of course they would, but it's pretty pointless to argue the "realistic-ness" of anything relating to Ninja Turtles if you wanna break it down. I know that argument's been used ad nauseum over the years, but it's true.

I mean, what about the Green Lantern Corps, if you really wanna split hairs? They've been likened to the Marine Corps. I don't think the Marines let people individualize their uniforms the way GLs do. But I'm oh-so-glad that Guy and Kyle and others get to have unique uniforms, because it suits them individually. In the end it doesn't matter, because GLs aren't real Marines and the TMNT aren't a real ninja clan.

Fact is, all-red vs. multi-colored is just an individual's preference, nothing more. One is no more "realistic" nor "demeaning" than the other, unless one chooses to see it that way. I choose to see it as a separation of universes, nothing more. I honestly never knew anyone even felt so strongly about it until I found the internet.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 06:37 PM
Of course they would, but it's pretty pointless to argue the "realistic-ness" of anything relating to Ninja Turtles if you wanna break it down. I know that argument's been used ad nauseum over the years, but it's true.

We're not talking about "realistic-ness." Whether you gravitate more toward the comedy in TMNT or more toward the ninja action... no matter how silly or "out-there" the material may get, a big component that must be sold to the reader is that yes, these four are part of a ninja clan. If their ninja clan is made into some kind of caricature of one or made into a sham (which is what the multi colors do to a large extent)... then the material suffers for it.

I mean, what about the Green Lantern Corps, if you really wanna split hairs? They've been likened to the Marine Corps. I don't think the Marines let people individualize their uniforms the way GLs do.

There's no real-world 6 billion year-old Guardians of the Universe to judge against and say, "No, no, the Green Lantern Corps has it all wrong, this is what the Guardians would actually do," so that comparison is a little silly. There is, however, real ninja clans... more than enough that we can say without doubt, "No multi-colored bandannas in ninja clans."

And the fact is that the Guardians didn't let Green Lanterns individualize their costumes. It wasn't until the Guardians left after the first Crisis during "Millennium" that Green Lanterns decided that, basically with the bosses gone, it was OK to customize their suits.

But I'm oh-so-glad that Guy and Kyle and others get to have unique uniforms, because it suits them individually.

Yeah. It's a good thing they're not Marines, isn't it?

Leo656
03-08-2010, 06:51 PM
Given Guy's outspoken political views, if he WERE a Marine I don't think there'd be much left of the Middle East... :lol:

I confess, I never got into the whole "ninja-ness" of TMNT as much as some others, meaning I never really went as deep into it, studied it, took it as seriously as some people do. Not that they're wrong and I'm right, it's just that the fact that they're ninjas wasn't what appealed to me about the characters initially. So I admit, whether reading or writing or watching them, "ninja accuracy" isn't the thing I'm most interested in or looking for. Probably why I'm a bit detached on the importance of bandana color.

For me, the pizza obsession from the old 'toon was the worst bit of "dumbing down", way worse than the belts or bandanas, but that's just me.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 07:43 PM
I personally don't mind the multi-colored bandannas too much - there are much bigger issues to pick at, in my opinion - but, going that route again, I'd at least like a better explanation as to WHY they have multi-colored bandannas, and WHY they're going against the grain on that aspect. For the record, I'm not talking about the director or producer's reasoning; I mean, I want the movie to explain it as a plot point.

Krutch
03-21-2010, 11:21 PM
If you want to split hairs, I remember reading that Ninja Clans did not have matching "ninja suits" at all, as most of the time they were disguised as villagers and the like. People have the idea that they were disguised in black from artwork from the time, depicting them in black, but that was only a way to show they were "invisible". Tenugui(Tengui? I forget) were the closest thing to a "ninja clan bandana" that I can think of that existed. But that was more of a towel that you can use in different ways.

At the end of the day, they're mutant turtles. I think they can make they're own rules.

Turo602
03-22-2010, 12:23 AM
All I got to say is that the red headbands suck big time. The multicolored headbands just add independence and personality to the Turtles. They look cooler with the multicolored headbands. Just because the movie might be based off the comics doesn't mean that they should all have the red headbands, It could be based off the comics story wise, just like the first TMNT film.

Andrew NDB
03-22-2010, 12:57 AM
Just because the movie might be based off the comics doesn't mean that they should all have the red headbands

Read the rest of the thread, please.

Vivi
03-22-2010, 02:11 AM
I don't mind the multi-coloured headbands, even though the TMNT belong to a clan, I doubt they'd have difficulty telling who was in theirs. To see a movie done where they all wear red would be interesting, there would probably be a few double takes to make sure who is who.
Do ninjas even wear headbands across their eyes? It seems cumbersome.

Revan
03-22-2010, 09:51 AM
Never been a fan of all-red. I suspect a lot of people who prefer it only do so because it was the original and thus, "the way it was meant to be". But I disagree with that logic; Superman's "S" logo went through dozens of redesigns over decades before coming to the version we all know. I doubt anyone wants to see it revert to a plain yellow triangle with an S scrawled in it, just because that's how it looked in Action Comics #1.
Apples and Oranges. Superman as been around since the 30s and thus has had fans from far more generations than the TMNT. Who are you to say that someone who read action comics 1 doesn't prefer the original Superman S logo? You obviously prefer it but someone who grew up with the early superman stories might not share your opinion. TMNT has only been around 25 years. Superman and ninja turtles are so completely different. Comparing the turtles to Superman is flattering for the turtles but truthfully the two don't belong in the same category. Even turtle fans would have to agree that Superman's popularity far overshadows that of our little green friends.
It's just easier to follow the characters in motion when they're all wearing different colors, as well as helping people who don't follow the characters learn who is who much easier.
That's the problem with movies... Whatever is easy. What is the problem with thinking at a movie?
Fact is, all-red vs. multi-colored is just an individual's preference, nothing more. One is no more "realistic" nor "demeaning" than the other.
Be careful when starting an argument with the "fact is." You must follow that with actual facts, not an opinion. It is your opinion that one is no more demeaning or realistic than the other.
All red looks cool enough as well, but I feel the multi-colored masks work best across a wide range of media.
We aren't talking about a wide range of media. This thread is a discussion about the new 2012 movie. MOVIE. Singular type of media.

Audiences were disappointed with the most recent TMNT movie. They wanted Shredder Krang and the technodrome and got Max friggin Winters and some goofy monsters. It wasn't funny enough for people who wanted the OT yet wasn't dramatic enough for fans of the comics. It was a weak attempt to cater to both crowds and it just didn't work.

I agree with Andrew. If the new movie is going to be a serious attempt at action, they are going to have to do something significant to change expectations. Reverting back to red bandanas would be a step in that direction. What better way to tell audiences "These aren't your goofy ninja-pizza-eating turtles."
However, if they decide to make a slap-stick comedic movie, belches and all, perhaps they should keep everything the same to try to suck nostalgic OT fans back into the theatre.
I really all depends on who the movie is geared toward.

Silly and funny - Keep it simple. Keep things the same. Make Mike a bumbling incompetent idiot. Throw food but don't use weapons.

Serious adventure - They should try to break the stereotype with something major. They have to change something to develop a new identity.

Sage Ninja
03-22-2010, 02:00 PM
maybe this might be a stupid cop out but what if they have it where the turtles wear all red bandannas when they are going about their buisness (battle, dojo, training, ect) doing the whole ninja clan unity thing. Then when they are just hanging out around the lair like watching tv or whatever, they can personalize their bandannas with the multi colors to express their indivduality, or what ever...but I guess it begs the question why they would bother wearing bandannas at all when they are just palling around...but maybe that can be a comprimise (though stupid) to appease both sides.

ToTheNines
03-22-2010, 02:54 PM
maybe this might be a stupid cop out but what if they have it where the turtles wear all red bandannas when they are going about their buisness (battle, dojo, training, ect) doing the whole ninja clan unity thing. Then when they are just hanging out around the lair like watching tv or whatever, they can personalize their bandannas with the multi colors to express their indivduality, or what ever...but I guess it begs the question why they would bother wearing bandannas at all when they are just palling around...but maybe that can be a comprimise (though stupid) to appease both sides.

The best way to go about that would be having them in all red, and then after they meet April she bitches about not being able to tell them apart, so they go rainbow.

Not my idea by the way, I wanna say Tristan thought it up but I don't remember.

Cipher
03-22-2010, 03:01 PM
Not my idea by the way, I wanna say Tristan thought it up but I don't remember.That was Tristan.

Anyway, why don't they just do something totally unexpected and have two Turtles wear yellow and two wear magenta? That would solve things.

Cure
03-22-2010, 05:12 PM
I think the all red bandannas is kinda dumb. I'd prefer to tell them apart at a quick glance rather than thinking "Who is this? Look for their weapon...OK, it's Mikey". Dumb.

Koi
03-22-2010, 05:51 PM
I think the all red bandannas is kinda dumb. I'd prefer to tell them apart at a quick glance rather than thinking "Who is this? Look for their weapon...OK, it's Mikey". Dumb.

But they could have actual characteristics that define them apart, skin color, size, and physical differences.

Cure
03-22-2010, 05:56 PM
But they could have actual characteristics that define them apart, skin color, size, and physical differences.

Right, but there'll still be work involved in memorizing who is who. Colored bandannas is the quickest way of telling them apart.

saul
03-22-2010, 06:44 PM
I always likened the masks to karate belts. Do karate belts look gay? Rather than debate hypothetical 'what-ifs', here is, very simply, what they would look like.

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4040/4455876128_ff1ecec8dc_o.png

To me, the all red just seems like lazy design.

NOTE: I do NOT like _brightly_ colored masks like in the 3rd movie. This is a point to consider. Not all hue's & shades are equal. The colors in the 1st film were right on, whereas the 2nd got Leo's blue too light...

saul
03-22-2010, 06:46 PM
FYI: for a million $$ I will personally re-color every frame in the original movie for you to make them all red...

Powder
03-22-2010, 07:07 PM
That is sooooooooooo coool

Revan
03-22-2010, 07:24 PM
http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4040/4455876128_ff1ecec8dc_o.png
It's still easy to tell who is who. Each costume is so different.

Oculus Orbus
03-22-2010, 08:20 PM
I absolutely love that pic. I would buy the idea of them going multi colored after meeting April, but they should all wear red at some point.

ToTheNines
03-22-2010, 11:14 PM
FYI: for a million $$ I will personally re-color every frame in the original movie for you to make them all red...

What's your paypal e-mail?

Luzmagica
03-23-2010, 12:09 PM
What's your paypal e-mail?


:lol::lol::lol: A special price for re-colour the 3 live-action movies????:D:lol::lol::lol:

Samhain
03-23-2010, 12:55 PM
I would LOVE to see the Tmnt wearing there red masks. It is the original and like alot of other people have said, it makes more sense because they are ninjas so they should have one universal color.

However, it wont happen. And im ok with that. No surprise. People are dumb if they cant tell the difference. If your a true turtle fan, you wont be confused as to who you are looking at. After a lil bit, you will just know.

Cipher
03-23-2010, 01:23 PM
I would LOVE to see the Tmnt wearing there red masks. It is the original and like alot of other people have said, it makes more sense because they are ninjas so they should have one universal color.

However, it wont happen. And im ok with that. No surprise. People are dumb if they cant tell the difference. If your a true turtle fan, you wont be confused as to who you are looking at. After a lil bit, you will just know.I can see how it might be confusing in shots like the one posted above. But all they need is one other cosmetic difference. And even if not, no biggie. They can dissolve into one group when they're not speaking, and I don't see a problem.

But seriously, for an example of how non-essential colored masks are for telling them apart, go watch the first episode of Fast Foward. Unless you're brain dead, you should have no trouble telling who's who, despite the fact that they're all weaponless and maskless. Why? They have different skin tones and different voices. That's literally all you need.

Luzmagica
03-23-2010, 02:10 PM
I can see how it might be confusing in shots like the one posted above. But all they need is one other cosmetic difference. And even if not, no biggie. They can dissolve into one group when they're not speaking, and I don't see a problem.

But seriously, for an example of how non-essential colored masks are for telling them apart, go watch the first episode of Fast Foward. Unless you're brain dead, you should have no trouble telling who's who, despite the fact that they're all weaponless and maskless. Why? They have different skin tones and different voices. That's literally all you need.

Touché!!! :twink:

Leo656
03-23-2010, 02:46 PM
Be careful when starting an argument with the "fact is." You must follow that with actual facts, not an opinion. It is your opinion that one is no more demeaning or realistic than the other.


Um, not exactly. The entire debate is about opinions. There are no "facts" to reinforce one person's preference over another. Some people prefer the TMNT in all red, some prefer multi-colored, and I seriously don't see one single "fact" that reinforces that one version is "better" than another.

After seeing this debate pop up countless times for years and years, I think it can also be stated as "fact" that a lot of people care way too much about this.

Candy Kappa
03-23-2010, 03:47 PM
But seriously, for an example of how non-essential colored masks are for telling them apart, go watch the first episode of Fast Foward. Unless you're brain dead, you should have no trouble telling who's who, despite the fact that they're all weaponless and maskless. Why? They have different skin tones and different voices. That's literally all you need.

this is a very good example, since it looks very strange when the turtles wears their masks all the time even when their home. they would take them of often in the comics.

I think that would be a interesting thing to see in the upcoming movie/new show, seeing the turtles relax after a tough day not wearing their obvious sweaty gear

Spitfire
03-23-2010, 04:54 PM
It's a kids movie, kids like colors. "I like the orange one he's funny." When I was in school kids never called the turtles by their names. A few of my friends and myself were the only ones who ever referred to the turtles by their names. Everyone else just called them "the purple one" or whatever. It works and there's a reason they did it. A lot of kids favorite turtle was also their favorite color too.

Having all red bandannas would be nice, a flashback really being the best place to use them as someone mentioned before. This medium is probably the only one where having all red bandannas would be the least confusing. But kids, people who grew up with turtles, and the general public knows them to have colors. You switch that up and people won't be too happy about it.

They're out to make money not to please a small group of hardcore fans. Everyone working on turtles has made it abundantly clear that what we think doesn't matter. Besides movie studios don't listen to hardcore fans anyway no matter how big the base is.

syk_skillz
03-23-2010, 05:30 PM
Beginning of movie all red
Meet April and become friends
April confused
Birth of Multicolored headbands

Both sides get what they want, reason for hem being multi.

Turo602
03-23-2010, 06:12 PM
It's a kids movie, kids like colors. "I like the orange one he's funny." When I was in school kids never called the turtles by their names. A few of my friends and myself were the only ones who ever referred to the turtles by their names. Everyone else just called them "the purple one" or whatever. It works and there's a reason they did it. A lot of kids favorite turtle was also their favorite color too.

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! That is so true! Even now my friends still call them the red or blue one, or the guy with the swords. That's only because they aren't really all into TMNT.

Candy Kappa
03-23-2010, 09:21 PM
I've noticed most people I've talked to knows the turtles by their name, getting their colors all wrong. One of my roomies likes Donatello since he's the nerd, she have a thing for nerds they're cute with a aloud awe following. she mentioned all the other color til she got to purple, I slightly nodded and she was very proud remembering the right color. :D

Samhain
03-23-2010, 09:42 PM
Beginning of movie all red
Meet April and become friends
April confused
Birth of Multicolored headbands

Both sides get what they want, reason for hem being multi.

I like this idea.

Andrew NDB
03-23-2010, 09:55 PM
Beginning of movie all red
Meet April and become friends
April confused
Turtles tell April to f*** off.

Much better now.

Vivi
03-23-2010, 11:53 PM
^
that actually sits better with me, too.

Turo602
03-24-2010, 12:15 AM
Beginning of movie all red
Meet April and become friends
April confused
Birth of Multicolored headbands

Both sides get what they want, reason for hem being multi.

Naw, that seems to much of an annoying way to put it in. The colors aren't really important. It would seem to much of a time waster. Multicolored for ever!

Gyt Kaliba
03-24-2010, 12:47 AM
I know it won't change the minds of anyone dead-set on all-red headbands anyway, but that's not what I'm trying to do. I just had another idea for how they could have both maybe.

They could go the entire film in their all red bandanas maybe, and have April complain about not being able to tell them apart, and they just groan. During the final battle with Shredder (presuming it'd be him again), their masks get torn, ruined. So when they get back and mention that, April just smirks and holds something out to them, unseen to us. They blink, '...You're kidding, right?'. Scene change, some robbery is going down, and the Turtles stop them now in their multi-color bandanas. Credits roll.

I think it'd be a nice way to have both anyway, because then the next film would be just the multi-color ones obviously, and we would have essentially had all-red for one film.

Turo602
03-24-2010, 01:09 AM
Good Idea but that would mean that the whole film except the ending would be all red bandannas. And just like Spitfire said, It's a kids movie and people want to tell them apart faster. And anyway they look way cooler and independent with their own color. When I think of Leo I think of him with a blue bandanna and etc, that's like having the Power Rangers in all the same color.

ToTheNines
03-24-2010, 09:42 AM
They could go the entire film in their all red bandanas maybe, and have April complain about not being able to tell them apart, and they just groan. During the final battle with Shredder (presuming it'd be him again), their masks get torn, ruined. So when they get back and mention that, April just smirks and holds something out to them, unseen to us. They blink, '...You're kidding, right?'. Scene change, some robbery is going down, and the Turtles stop them now in their multi-color bandanas. Credits roll.

I think that scenario would work better backwards.

Like have them in the multicolored bandanas, but before the final battle they (or Splinter) decide that wearing one singular color would be a symbol of their unity.

It's corny, but whatever. I also think there's a tactical advantage to all red bandanas... if they move in and out quickly on their enemies it might give them the illusion that they're fighting one extremely fast mofo instead of 4 relatively quick mofos.

Gyt Kaliba
03-24-2010, 09:52 AM
@Turo - I agree, I prefer them multi-colored too, and actually prefer the idea of them switching earlier on over my idea of it taking the whole film. The idea just came to me though, and figured I should throw it out there.

@ToTheNines - That's actually a really cool idea I think. Either way, I now want at least part of it to be all-red so they can do that illusion you're talking about.

Doc_ock_4mugen
03-24-2010, 10:39 AM
as long as we don't get the huge buckles with the L, D, R, M on them...

Luzmagica
03-24-2010, 11:35 AM
as long as we don't get the huge buckles with the L, D, R, M on them...

Complete agree, dude!!! :D:lol::D

kool75uk1
03-24-2010, 12:00 PM
It would also be good in the new film if the TMNT never say "PIZZA" or "COWABUNGA"!!!

Andrew NDB
03-24-2010, 01:33 PM
You're kidding, right?'. Scene change, some robbery is going down, and the Turtles stop them now in their multi-color bandanas. Credits roll.

I'd feel bait and switched and dirty. I'd say I'd walk out of the movie... but if it's at the end credits, I'm kind of supposed to, aren't I?

Spitfire
03-24-2010, 01:59 PM
You really have to ask yourself though, does it matter? Does them having or not having add anything to the story what so ever? Unless the bandanna color is written into the story, and at that point they must really be out of ideas, it's not important. They could have red bandannas and still be burping and yelling "Cowabunga". The tone of the film isn't going to change just because their masks do. This film is being used to promo the new cartoon series so if that's indication we can see where it's going.

I little toss back would be fun but if it's not there I'm not going to care. I love the Mirage comics, I love the cartoon series.

saul
03-24-2010, 02:18 PM
If you have all that $$$, why not do us a favor and buy the movie rights so Steve Barren can finally be allowed to share his directors cut

Andrew NDB
03-24-2010, 03:07 PM
You really have to ask yourself though, does it matter? Does them having or not having add anything to the story what so ever?

Yes. It helps sell them to audiences as a legitimate ninja clan, something they claim to be.

Multi-colored bandannas make that aspect of the TMNT a bit of a sham. And I don't know about you guys, but I don't like the TMNT I read/watch/[insert word] to be a sham.

kool75uk1
03-24-2010, 03:34 PM
If you have all that $$$, why not do us a favor and buy the movie rights so Steve Barren can finally be allowed to share his directors cut

Cant you save up your pocket money each week and do us all a favor.

Yes. It helps sell them to audiences as a legitimate ninja clan, something they claim to be.

Multi-colored bandannas make that aspect of the TMNT a bit of a sham. And I don't know about you guys, but I don't like the TMNT I read/watch/[insert word] to be a sham.

I totally agree.

Brandatello
03-24-2010, 04:03 PM
I highly doubt it will happen. Movie execs see the viewing audience dumb enough that they feel we need to see a color differential rather than just look at the weapons or hear their voices.

that is exactly what i thought too...i would love to see original headbands...but the kids that would see this would get confused way too easily

Turo602
03-24-2010, 04:04 PM
Yes. It helps sell them to audiences as a legitimate ninja clan, something they claim to be.

Multi-colored bandannas make that aspect of the TMNT a bit of a sham. And I don't know about you guys, but I don't like the TMNT I read/watch/[insert word] to be a sham.

Multicolored is what the majority of people know the TMNT as. And The TMNT aren't a clan, their brothers and a team. The Foot are a clan and they look the same not the TMNT. No one making the movie is going to say,"WAIT, what about those super hardcore TMNT fans, F*ck the rest of the audience".

Andrew NDB
03-24-2010, 04:51 PM
Multicolored is what the majority of people know the TMNT as.

We've been over this. A TMNT movie isn't going to be made or broken by any existing fans anyway... so why should it overly concern itself with them at all?

And The TMNT aren't a clan, their brothers and a team.

They're ninja. They're a clan. They were raised from birth to assassinate Oroku Saki (I believe it's even flat out said that they're the "Hamato Clan" in the comics). Splinter is their leader. This is well established in the source material. You are free to plug your ears, cover your eyes and go "LALALALALA!!!" but that doesn't change the facts.

Turo602
03-24-2010, 05:00 PM
Aww, you got me there, but I'm not a pussy who denies facts. But yeah, Multicolored is still waaaaay better and will happen.

Krutch
03-24-2010, 06:12 PM
I'd prefer the multicolored bandannas. I think I said it in another thread like this, I find the colors very symbolic of the TMNT. Not as in "Red = Anger, etc), but when I see red, orange, blue, and purple in a combination, I automatically think TMNT. If theres four pieces of a board game that are that color, I'll think TMNT, for example. Kind of like when I see red, yellow, pink, blue, and black, i think Power Rangers. The colors have been long associated with each other.

As long as the movie itself is good, I could care less if they all had black bandannas.

Gyt Kaliba
03-24-2010, 06:34 PM
As long as the movie itself is good, I could care less if they all had black bandannas.

Quoted for truth. I mean, it'd be a minor gripe, 'Aw man. They never wore black, what the heck' from me, but just a nitpicky one, and I acknowledge that. It's nothing that would make-or-break the film. As long as the film itself turns out good, the mask colors is just an aesthetic choice.

Andrew NDB
03-24-2010, 08:46 PM
Aww, you got me there, but I'm not a pussy who denies facts.

That's good. That seperates you from a lotta folks around the fandom.

Krang
03-25-2010, 02:21 AM
After seeing this debate pop up countless times for years and years, I think it can also be stated as "fact" that a lot of people care way too much about this.
Exactly what I was thinking...

Yes. It helps sell them to audiences as a legitimate ninja clan, something they claim to be.
How so? Outside of the TMNT, I've never heard of ninja uniforms of any kind including bandannas, much less red ones. They don't, for example, help conceal their identities or hold parts of the uniform together, so what purpose are they supposed to serve? Besides, one of the primary goals of a ninja is to blend in to avoid being seen, so red seems like a rather impractical choice of color.

Personally, I don't think either red or multicolor bandannas were meant to be realistic, especially considering the fact that the entire concept of the TMNT started off as a joke (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/origin/origin.htm).

The Stryker
03-25-2010, 02:39 AM
Personally, I don't think either red or multicolor bandannas were meant to be realistic, especially considering the fact that the entire concept of the TMNT started off as a joke (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/origin/origin.htm).

THANK YOU.

People need to calm down with the "Realism" talk. Who cares?

Krutch
03-25-2010, 03:17 AM
I've never heard of ninja uniforms of any kind including bandannas, much less red ones. They don't, for example, help conceal their identities or hold parts of the uniform together, so what purpose are they supposed to serve? Besides, one of the primary goals of a ninja is to blend in to avoid being seen.

Exactly my point. Ninjas were dressed as villagers, merchants, monks... anything to avoid suspicion. Giving them all matching color headbands don't do anything to give them legitimacy as a ninja clan.

If you want to get crazy, Raphael's trench coat and hat is the most ninja-faithful disguise we've seen :P

Candy Kappa
03-25-2010, 04:09 AM
still the foot use a initial uniform, and most ninja clans in comics and movies uses same uniform. not realistic but that's what pop culture have colored the Ninja through the years.

for me the red masks would be a positive thing having in the movies, but I'll cope seeing color masks. but I'd love to see moments where they don't use masks. they could use the masks as they face off the foot.

Think I read this somewhere, but I can't remember where I got it from , but the masks was in honor of their master, could be my head just fooling me, is there any origin about the masks?

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 10:37 AM
How so? Outside of the TMNT, I've never heard of ninja uniforms of any kind including bandannas, much less red ones.

No one's talking about uniforms, just uniformity. You won't find any ninja clans with members whining about, "I need to express myself and my individuality! I want a purple bandanna, not a red one! Wahh!"

Such ninja would probably get assassinated by their own clan. And they'd probably deserve it.

They don't, for example, help conceal their identities or hold parts of the uniform together, so what purpose are they supposed to serve? Besides, one of the primary goals of a ninja is to blend in to avoid being seen, so red seems like a rather impractical choice of color.

Perhaps. But it's the color of Clan Hamato, for better or worse.

The same way a gang (Yakuza, for example) or a Marine squad might all go and get a common tattoo, I'm sure it's intended to create a sort of visual bond between the members of Clan Hamato.

Personally, I don't think either red or multicolor bandannas were meant to be realistic, especially considering the fact that the entire concept of the TMNT started off as a joke (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/origin/origin.htm).

To a hugely overstated extent by the fandom, mostly to justify the bizarre "additions" of the children's spinoff universes.

According to Eastman and Laird, while there were admittedly a couple of parodic elements in the first issue, it wasn't a parody -- now I guess you can do whatever you want, but I'm not going to argue with both creators of the TMNT.

Luzmagica
03-25-2010, 11:43 AM
Uff!!! ....this thread is burning!!!! :teek::D:twink:

AquaParade
03-25-2010, 11:58 AM
No one's talking about uniforms, just uniformity. You won't find any ninja clans with members whining about, "I need to express myself and my individuality! I want a purple bandanna, not a red one! Wahh!"



Keep in mind though, that the Turtles aren't your average ninja clan ;)


Don't get me wrong though. I would love to see the turtles all wearing red. It really does give them a more unified and team-like feel. Due to general audiences though, I don't see us finding a way out of the multi-colored masks. Like some have mentioned, I think the best route to go is to have them switch masks at some threshold in the film. ( The toy companies may like the idea of being able to package tons of " Leonardo w/ red mask"'s as well as "Leonardo w/ blue mask") Also, when it comes to marketing, they could easily just show of the multicolored mask parts of the film in trailers and promotional images.

So how would the switch occur in a way that makes sense and feels good? That's a little tougher...Honestly, I think the April idea could work...but they'd have to come up with an integral and prominent reason. " Psh, guys I can never tell you apart! ...Take these multicolored masks!" Kinda cheesy, huh?

Spitfire
03-25-2010, 02:27 PM
They're teenagers so the flaw in that logic is they crave individuality and despise uniformity. It actually makes plenty of sense for them to not only have colored bandannas but want them. They're not a real ninja clan anyways. Splinter isn't the revenge hungry man with questionable morals in anything but the comics.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 03:32 PM
They're teenagers so the flaw in that logic is they crave individuality and despise uniformity.

Regular tykes like you or I used to be with puberty and hormones and all that stuff, maybe. These are mutant turtles growing up in a drainage sewer with some weird rat as their ninjitsu teacher/quasi-father figure. These weren't kids going to school slipping notes to Suzie in 3rd period or fed up with, to paraphrase Will Smith, "parents who don't understand."

And if you're imagining some kind of story where the Turtles as young teenagers sock it to Splinter and say, "No, Master Splinter! We're not wearing your stupid red bandannas, we're getting our own colors!" and sort of rebel against the color red... then you're just talking about fanfiction.

It actually makes plenty of sense for them to not only have colored bandannas but want them. They're not a real ninja clan anyways.

Of course they are. Raised and trained to assassinate a man.

Maybe they're missing the Ultra-Covert-Handshake-Secret-Kick-in-the-Ass approval of The Official Ninja Authentication Committeeâ„¢ but they're certainly a ninja clan in every way that matters.

Plus they say they are. Similarly, the Foot have recognized them as such in the past.

Splinter isn't the revenge hungry man with questionable morals in anything but the actual source material itself.

Fixed that for you.

And is that not enough? It ought to be.

Turo602
03-25-2010, 04:11 PM
Then that means the TMNT aren't real Ninjas. Since when were Turtles ninjas and since when did ninjas live in the sewers and eat pizza and pull money oughta there ass to pay for pizza and even able to speak or communicate with a rat and a lady named April and a guy wearing a hockey mask. Oh right in comics, movies, and in cartoons. People complaining on Turtles needing to be a clan and wearing matching uniforms. It doesn't matter and the point is that the TMNT look cooler and look more independent with multicolored headbands. Thats what killed the X-Men movies, matching uniforms. There not multicolored for them, but for our sakes.

ToTheNines
03-25-2010, 04:19 PM
Thats what killed the X-Men movies, matching uniforms.

That's mega bullsh*t.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 05:27 PM
Then that means the TMNT aren't real Ninjas. Since when were Turtles ninjas and since when did ninjas live in the sewers and eat pizza and pull money oughta there ass to pay for pizza

How many times do you see the Turtles ordering pizza in the sewers in the comics? I can't think of any.

And though I can't think of any times I saw them eating pizza in the core comics, I'm pretty sure if there were times it would've been at April's place or such. And I'm pretty sure April has money.

and even able to speak or communicate with a rat and a lady named April and a guy wearing a hockey mask. Oh right in comics, movies, and in cartoons. People complaining on Turtles needing to be a clan and wearing matching uniforms.

These are non-arguments. You might as well say about Batman, "Why shouldn't Batman start wearing low-cut speedos, sunglasses and a bright belt buckle that has a 'B' on it? It's already a story about a guy dressing up like a bat to fight crime, so why not make it even sillier?"

The answer is simple: because that'd be stupid.

It doesn't matter and the point is that the TMNT look cooler and look more independent with multicolored headbands.

In your opinion... which is pretty clearly biased by a nostalgia for the cartoons. Not that there's anything wrong with the cartoons or even that there's anything wrong with you for having an affinity for them... but let's call a spade a spade.

Thats what killed the X-Men movies, matching uniforms. There not multicolored for them, but for our sakes.

Nonsense.

Powder
03-25-2010, 05:31 PM
Red is better. I would prefer red. They want to make it like the comic? Red. Real ninjas have a clan symbol/color & in the case of the hamato CLAN, that is red. Look at the foot CLAN in the first movie... they at least knew enough to let THEM match. If they insist on multi-color I would at least hope for an explanation... they could start red and change for April or individuality or whatever the hell else...

RED RED RED.

And for those of you trying to rationalize the absurdity of ninjas living in the sewer and interacting with hockey mask wearing vigilantes, give it up. Walking talking turtles wouldnt even happen anyway BUt if they did, & they were raised only to know one thing, ninjitsu, such should be presented in the most realistic way possible. At the least they could give them slightly different shades of red because its not like they could walk in to a department store and buy 4 of them... they would've just come across them in their travels or something.

Not mention, me & Andrew have had this talk before, whats up with all the 'code of bushido' crap leo spews out? COB is for SAMURAI not ninja. Ninjas are assassins with little to no sense of honor. Red bandanas, ruthlessness, these would be qualities to bring in huge box office numbers; a whole 'new' side to the turtles.

Turo602
03-25-2010, 05:36 PM
Red bandanas, ruthlessness, these would be qualities to bring in huge box office numbers; a whole 'new' side to the turtles.

That will screw over the rest of the audience except the HARDCORE original TMNT comics fans.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 05:42 PM
Not mention, me & Andrew have had this talk before, whats up with all the 'code of bushido' crap leo spews out? COB is for SAMURAI not ninja. Ninjas are assassins with little to no sense of honor. Red bandanas, ruthlessness, these would be qualities to bring in huge box office numbers; a whole 'new' side to the turtles.

Bushido translates as "the way of the warrior," which speaks of the way a warrior -- be it a samurai or otherwise -- conducts themself in battle.

While "an honorable ninja" is virtually a contradiction in terms, it's not impossible. There's just no real historical precedent for it.

I kind of like that dichotomy about the Turtles in the comics. They're torn between the ninja they were trained to be from near birth (this sort of, "beneath the surface, they're all killers" thing) and kind of "doing the right thing." Which never ascends to a level where they're like actively fighting crime or anything (which would be pretty apocryphal to what the Turtles are all about, in my book), but you know... if someone is getting beaten or robbed right in front of them, if they just happen to be there at that time maybe they'd step in. You know?

Vivi
03-25-2010, 05:59 PM
As the new movie will most likely have multi-colored headbands, I would prefer no reasoning behind it.

But if necessary, my favorite 'explanation' of the different colors so far has been when the Ancient One unceremoniously handed out different bandannas to the turtles when they were young, with no thought behind who got what. As popular as the Ancient One seems to be around here.

Spitfire
03-25-2010, 06:00 PM
Red bandanas, ruthlessness, these would be qualities to bring in huge box office numbers; a whole 'new' side to the turtles.

No it wouldn't movies typically make 60% of their money over seas. Over seas they know the turtles as having colors. Most of the comics never really made it China or most of Asia. They have no idea the turtles ever wore red. In fact when NECA released their turtles line over seas they complained it sold poorly because the market thought they were discolored.

Also I don't know how ruthless you're going for but it's very rare rated R films make lots of money. Turtles being a kids property in the public eye for the past 20 years would make it suicide to try something like that. Oh yeah we would love the movie, no doubts there, but it's not the best for the property.

I agree with you guys, I'd like to see the turtles represented just as they were in the comics on the big screen. However I know how Hollywood works and I don't see it happening, not with this movie anyways. This movie is made to promote a Nicktoons cartoon series. I'd be floored if it was anything higher then PG. The new toon will feature colored bandannas as they want to rework the format of the old series and reapply it for today's audience.

If turtles fell off the map for awhile and came back with an in your face PG-13 or R rated movie I could see this working. They're not in that place right now through. They're still fresh and front running the "retro 80's" fad right now. Lots of people would skip the movie over them changing something they see to be solid fact. We may know the turtles as killers with no remorse but the average person knows them as pizza eating teenagers who like to skate board and make corny jokes. That's what people want to see. Take the innocence away from those characters for people and you'll piss them off. You can say you don't care about those people or what they think but it's because of those people turtles are even still around. As a fan base we don't generate enough revenue to the property to overcome that.

Turo602
03-25-2010, 06:07 PM
Yeah, that's why I loved the 2k3 show so much. Because it represented the comics and also kept there own creativity. And also had different color headbands.

Cipher
03-25-2010, 06:12 PM
But if necessary, my favorite 'explanation' of the different colors so far has been when the Ancient One unceremoniously handed out different bandannas to the turtles when they were young, with no thought behind who got what. As popular as the Ancient One seems to be around here.I could honestly care less about the bandana colors. I mean, I vastly prefer red, but I won't be crushed if they show up multi-colored.

But keep the Ancient One the hell away from this movie at all costs. And all future iterations of the franchise, for that matter.

CyberCubed
03-25-2010, 06:38 PM
The bitterness in this thread is astounding.

I prefer them red in the comics but colored in multimedia like the cartoons and movies.

Even Peter Laird himself said he didn't mind the multi-colored bandanas, as long as it was just the head bandana and not the arm/leg bands or the initial belts.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 06:41 PM
No it wouldn't movies typically make 60% of their money over seas. Over seas they know the turtles as having colors. Most of the comics never really made it China or most of Asia. They have no idea the turtles ever wore red.

Once again, a new movie isn't going to be made or broken by any existing TMNT fandom... so overly concerning themselves with them would be pointless and an exercise in futility.

Also I don't know how ruthless you're going for but it's very rare rated R films make lots of money.

It's interesting that any time someone suggests the TMNT actually white-knuckle it a bit, the cartoon advocates immediately jump to, "An R-rated movie won't work!"

Nobody's talking about an R-rated movie. PG-13 is a perfectly equitable middle ground for all parties.

I agree with you guys, I'd like to see the turtles represented just as they were in the comics on the big screen. However I know how Hollywood works and I don't see it happening, not with this movie anyways. This movie is made to promote a Nicktoons cartoon series.

The timing is coincidental, but what's good for the goose is good for the gander in this case. It was not intentional and one is not linked to the other, I can tell you.

If turtles fell off the map for awhile and came back with an in your face PG-13 or R rated movie I could see this working.

That might be the ideal scenario, but do realize that there's a huge chasm between an "in your face PG-13" Turtles movie and an "in your face R-rated" Turtles movie.

They're not in that place right now through. They're still fresh and front running the "retro 80's" fad right now. Lots of people would skip the movie over them changing something they see to be solid fact.

I agree the media focus of late has been... counter-productive to what a edgier PG-13 TMNT movie might be, but not necessarily. It's not like a PG-13 TMNT movie is going to be "Ninja Assassin" -- it just means the combat will actually have a little bit of teeth, and maybe the language not so Sesame Streety.

We may know the turtles as killers with no remorse but the average person knows them as pizza eating teenagers who like to skate board and make corny jokes. That's what people want to see.

We're back to the existing fandom... once again, already aged out of the target demographic and a non-issue. It's already been 3 years since the last movie which was allllll about skateboarding and corny jokes and that movie failed to perform.

My point: before you make excuses for it (it was CGI! no Shredder! etc.), if that's what audiences and this big, expansive, active TMNT fandom ready to buy movie tickets as you would have us believe there is want to see, why didn't they bother to show up to see the last movie?

More importantly, why should a movie studio/financiers bank on trying the same tactic as the last movie (kiddified, toyified) for the next movie? That seems dangerously close to the definition of insanity: trying the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.

It's time for change in our mass media Turtles, people! Change!

http://dimpost.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/barack_obama.jpg

Can I get a witness? Can I get a hallelujah?

Take the innocence away from those characters for people and you'll piss them off.

In other words, when they fight keep it toothless, and make sure Mikey doesn't use his nunchuks?

Who are these people? Tell me, so I can go to their door and backhand them.

You can say you don't care about those people or what they think

I don't have to say that -- it's a movie studio fact of life.

Yeah, that's why I loved the 2k3 show so much. Because it represented the comics

Not hardly. Except the Kirby episode and maybe most of I, Monster -- those were pretty close.

Even Peter Laird himself said he didn't mind the multi-colored bandanas, as long as it was just the head bandana and not the arm/leg bands or the initial belts.

In a gotta-pick-your-battles sort of way, yes, Laird has said he will take the colored bandannas over the letters on their belts -- if it's gotta be one or the other.

Spitfire
03-25-2010, 07:00 PM
If you can make that case to Nick and whatever studio they work with please do. I'm no cartoon advocate. I snobbishly reject most of 2K3 because they butchered a lot of the comic storylines by toning them down or changing things that didn't need to be changed. The idea of a turtles movie that's more then just a kids film is something I've wanted for a long time. I just know all the things working against it. It's interesting to see people's reasoning for why it would work.

I agree with almost everything you said. While I didn't like TMNT in the least it performed quite well. It made back 3 times what it cost to make. It cost 34 and made back almost 96. Not the hugest of numbers but the movie was pretty cheap. WB was happy with the return.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 07:13 PM
If you can make that case to Nick and whatever studio they work with please do.

The Paramount movie's wheels were already in motion before the Nick deal, and the Paramount movie sounds like it's quite a different beast.

Which isn't to say that Nick doesn't have the power to come in at the 11th hour and veto things and change stuff up... but it doesn't sound like they're doing that.

I agree with almost everything you said. While I didn't like TMNT in the least it performed quite well. It made back 3 times what it cost to make. It cost 34

That's just the production budget. Marketing budget on a film like that would have been at least 15 to 20 million... which still leaves a bit of profit but profit alone does not make a major studio release like that a "success."

In fact, they flat out told us it was expected to do 100 million domestically and it didn't even come close to doing half of that.

ToTheNines
03-25-2010, 07:25 PM
Marketing budget on a film like that would have been at least 15 to 20 million

Are you sure about that? They hardly advertised the sh*t at all.

I remember it was #1 in the country in its first week, I was quite pissed that they didn't have a commercial boasting that fact like every other movie does.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 08:11 PM
Are you sure about that? They hardly advertised the sh*t at all.

That's a modest estimate. It's actually probably closer to 25 million.

http://www.the-numbers.com/movies/2007/TMNT.php

ToTheNines
03-25-2010, 08:53 PM
That's a modest estimate. It's actually probably closer to 25 million.

http://www.the-numbers.com/movies/2007/TMNT.php

Well, I am not a pussy who ignores facts.

Turo602
03-25-2010, 09:03 PM
Well, I am not a pussy who ignores facts.

Were you copying me. If you were then :lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

ToTheNines
03-25-2010, 09:19 PM
Were you copying me. If you were then :lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

I was lol, it's a good phrase.

Powder
03-25-2010, 09:20 PM
Everything Andrew said in regards to spitfire referancing my post is simply a greater representation of the points I've been trying to make... The same pattern keeps getting repeated to little success. The turtles are one of many franchises to get 're-done' but they are one of the only ones that just copycats its former self. That = fail. Red bandanas aren't necessary to reinvent them but I just prefer it & also think it would draw more attention to it. People would be like 'whaaaat? they're all red? why ar- WHOA YOU SAW THAT?1 THIZ TRAILER IS BADAZZ'! What I do stand by however is the need for PG-13, serious, and somewhat remorseless turtles. They don't have to love blood or be trigger happy so to speak but rather take joy in beating the snot out of those with ill intentions. Protect & serve damnit. If they were to do this radical change (no pun intended ;) ) the red masks would be the icing on the cake I guess you could say... or rather the hint to people that these turtles don't appeal strictly to kids. Someone in their 20's who may have grown out of the turtles would maybe turn down a cartoon based venture but if he saw something more mature with passable violence that was both acceptable to 'kids' and adults, they'd be all over it I think. Transformers, as mentioned before many times, is a good example.

Spitfire
03-25-2010, 09:34 PM
I bet the ratio of people who would jump to see a movie with Krang, the Technodrome, Bebop and Rocksteady in it is probably greater then those who would jump to see what you're talking about. When the new toon came out and even Smash Up that's all you heard. "Where are they?" People think they're the best characters aside from the turtles for some reason. While I don't personally agree it's what people want to see.

To be honest I'd like to see a re-invention that completely casts off everything. They can keep looks but I'm seriously tired of the origin story and they either need to write a new one or avoid telling it again. I'm sick of Shredder as well. I want a new villain who isn't totally stock or for them to use a lesser known one that hasn't had screen time yet. Mirage is full of them. Karai wasn't much of anything in "TMNT" so maybe done properly she could carry the film as a villain but she had maybe one crowning moment for me in 2K3 so I doubt it.

The film obviously has the Foot but it's getting stale. I'm honestly afraid by the time they get around to making the perfect turtles movies for us fans I won't care anymore. I'm not sure this film will do anything for me. Unless they can really turn it around and I don't see them having many options to work with. They want to do some hybrid of everything which in theory could be great but it could suck too.

Andrew NDB
03-25-2010, 09:49 PM
I bet the ratio of people who would jump to see a movie with Krang, the Technodrome, Bebop and Rocksteady in it is probably greater then those who would jump to see what you're talking about.

I think you remain in denial that OS movie ticket buyers are no longer in the target demographic and won't fill enough seats to put a substantial dent in the box office. Because they're not.

Cure
03-25-2010, 09:52 PM
Do people here REALLY think the general public knows/cares enough about ninjas to be upset about the lack of uniformity? Because that's dumb.

ToTheNines
03-25-2010, 11:16 PM
Another possibility to bring in the red bandanas mid-movie: Maybe Splinter gets captured (or killed, or assumed to be killed), and the turtles make bandanas out of one his red kimonos in honor of him.

Just a reminder, I'm not a writer lol

Powder
03-25-2010, 11:52 PM
Yeah I wish at the least they'd give it a nod or something like that.

Krutch
03-26-2010, 12:22 AM
My point: before you make excuses for it (it was CGI! no Shredder! etc.), if that's what audiences and this big, expansive, active TMNT fandom ready to buy movie tickets as you would have us believe there is want to see, why didn't they bother to show up to see the last movie?

That's unfair.

It's not an "excuse" that leaving out any recognizable villains hurt the movie's gross, it's a pretty valid point.

Superman 1 and 2 both had recognizable villains, higher gross than 3 and 4 which didn't.
The Dark Knight had recognizable villains, higher gross than Batman Begins which didn't.
Turtles 1 and 2 had recognizable villains, higher gross than III and TMNT which didn't.

And, at the end of the day, TMNT just wasn't a good movie. There wasn't enough substance in the movie to generate any word of mouth. The action wasn't good, the humor was outdated, the story was a mess... The 80s toon fans wanted to see Shredder, Krang, Beebop, Rocksteady, The Technodrome, Live Action, and the Turtles. 1/7 isn't good enough.

Why didn't they bother to show up to see the last movie? Because it sucked. And it really didn't cater to them as much as you think it did.

(Yeah, believe it or not, "Ra's al Ghul" and "The Scarecrow" aren't household names to the mass market audience)

Samhain
03-26-2010, 06:37 PM
Have I said I love this thread yet? Cause I do.

Look people. It is the way the were meant to be. The colors were added for children! Eastman and Laird would not have done that on their own. But im not dumb. I know we will never get a movie of the all red bandana Tmnt. But in my eyes, thats the TRUE Ninja Turtles. I think a little nod to the comics would be enough for me to be happy. Some ideas in this thread are not bad! Especially,

Another possibility to bring in the red bandanas mid-movie: Maybe Splinter gets captured (or killed, or assumed to be killed), and the turtles make bandanas out of one his red kimonos in honor of him.

Just a reminder, I'm not a writer lol

I could see them now! Standing on the roof, wearing all red, and pissed! That scene, to me, is EPIC. The way the Tmnt should be.:twink:

bridgegrn
03-26-2010, 06:41 PM
I don't see why its so illogical for them to wear different colored masks. I mean yeah, we know the real reason as to why they are different but its not like it makes or breaks the fact that they are ninjas. I mean, lets say they adapt the first issue- every panel, every word but Donatello happens to be wearing purple when he takes his bo to Shredder's face. Is he really any less of a ninja? Story wise It's not hard to believe that maybe, they just have preferences. Hell, it could be like 2K3 where their masks were gifts because of something brave that they did as kids and that they just still wear them. In that case they didnt choose colors, they were given colors. I just feel like it makes no sense to say that different color masks make no sense.

Samhain
03-26-2010, 06:47 PM
lets say they adapt the first issue- every panel, every word but Donatello happens to be wearing purple when he takes his bo to Shredder's face. Is he really any less of a ninja?

Less of a ninja? Naw, I dont think so. But that would be horrid if they did do that. Just wouldnt work. Thinking of that reminds me of how I cringe when I see Custom Neca figures with toon colors. Just no.

Krutch
03-26-2010, 06:47 PM
^bridgegrn^ I agree. I have a feeling if they always had multicolor headbands this wouldn't even be a discussion.

Samhain
03-26-2010, 06:51 PM
^bridgegrn^ I agree. I have a feeling if they always had multicolor headbands this wouldn't even be a discussion.

He didnt say ''If they always had them''. If that was the case, then no, they would originally wore diff colored bandanas. I wouldnt have an issue. He said ''adapt''.

Andrew NDB
03-26-2010, 06:54 PM
And, at the end of the day, TMNT just wasn't a good movie.

There wasn't enough substance in the movie to generate any word of mouth. The action wasn't good, the humor was outdated, the story was a mess...

All of this is true. And those are exactly the reasons it underperformed.

Not because of a lack of Technodromes or cowabunga or other nonsense like that... though of course the nostalgic OS folks love to use the lack of that as the reasons for said underperformance.

"You see?!! They didn't give us Bebops and cowabunga, and look what happened!!! Proof positive!"

Horsesh**.

The 80s toon fans wanted to see Shredder, Krang, Beebop, Rocksteady, The Technodrome, Live Action, and the Turtles. 1/7 isn't good enough.

If you say so. These multi-millions of 80s toon fans that you would have us believe still exist that are allegedly active ticket-buying fans -- despite every statistical law that Hollywood and financiers have quantified and proven and hold to as far as demographics and how much pie which age group is going to yield -- that will refuse to see a TMNT movie that is virtually identical tonally to the 80s toon... these aren't very good 80s toon fans at all, I think.

Why didn't they bother to show up to see the last movie? Because it sucked.

They'd have to see it to gauge that, I would think. And if they were such fans of the OS, surely they'd take a gamble going into it.

My point is... the OS fans are out there. There's hundreds of active ones, thousands and perhaps tens of thousands... maybe even a million across the continental US alone. We're talking about active TMNT OS fans or retired OS fans that would be willing to re-indulge their childhood and see a movie that's exactly in the same vein as the OS. Even if every single one of these million fans showed up to an OS movie -- and that's crazy, we're talking about guys and girls in their 30s and 40s now -- that wouldn't even so much as put a dent in the box office.

(Yeah, believe it or not, "Ra's al Ghul" and "The Scarecrow" aren't household names to the mass market audience)

Which really only works against your case -- they are... now. After Batman Begins.

I don't think it's unreasonable to put stock in a TMNT Begins type approach.

Brodie
03-26-2010, 10:02 PM
I'd go so far as to say that Ras al Ghul and Scarecrow still aren't household names.

People never really picked up on the fact that Liam Neeson was actually Ras, and always referred to Cillian Murphy as "that guy from 28 Days Later."

Koi
03-26-2010, 10:15 PM
The turtles should have hot pink bandannas.

Andrew NDB
03-26-2010, 10:23 PM
The turtles should have hot pink bandannas.

As long as they all have hot pink bandannas. :)

Koi
03-26-2010, 10:31 PM
As long as they all have hot pink bandannas. :)

Of course.
http://img707.imageshack.us/img707/1475/hotpinkk.jpg

AquaParade
03-26-2010, 10:43 PM
As long as they all have hot pink bandannas. :)

This brings up an interesting thought...I was just imagining the big wigs in their offices discussing the bandanna issue...

"Hmm...all the same color? Well alright, but were not going with red. Red is too ________!

Imagine if they decided to keep them all in the same color, but instead went with Leonardo's blue or something. How many of you red bandanna lovers would be ok with this? Personally I think i'd be kinda irked. All red or multicolored for me.

Vivi
03-26-2010, 10:45 PM
Black would look OK.
But it would not seem right, I guess.

Krutch
03-26-2010, 10:51 PM
He didnt say ''If they always had them''. If that was the case, then no, they would originally wore diff colored bandanas. I wouldnt have an issue. He said ''adapt''.
Yeah, lol, sorry. That was meant to be two separate thoughts entirely.
Not because of a lack of Technodromes or cowabunga or other nonsense like that... though of course the nostalgic OS folks love to use the lack of that as the reasons for said underperformance.
No. One glance at a commercial or trailer is enough to put people off. The trailer had freakin "your mom" jokes and a loud, out of place burp. You could just tell the movie was gonna suck. Not to mention, when I was hyped about it(prior to the second trailer), I had several conversations with people that went like this:

"Hey, theres a new Turtles movie coming out!"
"Awesome! I loved the ninja turtles!"
"Yeah, it's CGI-"
"What, no suits?"
"No, CGI."
"Ah, that sucks. The suits were awesome. Is Krang finally gonna be in it?"
"Umm... no. Neither is Shredder. Or Beebop. Or Rocksteady."
"What? **** that movie man, thats not a Turtles movie to me."

I loved Power Rangers growing up and if they did a reboot I'd be all for it. But if I found out it was CGI, no Lord Zedd, Goldar, Rita Repulsa... no thanks. And that's only 1/5 :P
These multi-millions of 80s toon fans that you would have us believe still exist that are allegedly active ticket-buying fans -- despite every statistical law that Hollywood and financiers have quantified and proven and hold to as far as demographics and how much pie which age group is going to yield -- that will refuse to see a TMNT movie that is virtually identical tonally to the 80s toon... these aren't very good 80s toon fans at all, I think.
You really think TMNT was identical tonally to the OT? Really? And again, it really, really wasn't marketed to the 80s toon fans like you think it was. I'm not even sure what the target audience was come to think of it. There wasnt enough of any universe to please any of those crowds. So, I think they were gearing it for new kids all together, with extremely small nods to fans, like the trophy room.
and that's crazy, we're talking about guys and girls in their 30s and 40s now
Uh, I'm 24. I grew up on the old toon. There are plenty of others out there. Also, people in their 30s or 40s would love the chance to bring their kids with them to see it. So in alot of cases you'd be seeing an extra ticket being bought.
Which really only works against your case -- they are... now. After Batman Begins.
No, I definitely still wouldn't say that. Without bringing up Batman, go up to a random person in a movie theater and ask who Ra's al Ghul is and I'm sure the majority wouldn't have a clue.
I don't think it's unreasonable to put stock in a TMNT Begins type approach.
I agree. I'd love a realistic Turtles movie. Hell, I'd so much prefer a Begins approach over an 80s toon adaption. But it would need a big name director or, at the very least, a strong trailer to work. And this discussion is in the wrong thread :P

Koi
03-26-2010, 11:10 PM
Any one that I know, that knows about TMNT are just random emo/goth teens that get TMNT gear from Hot Topic. They couldn't tell you the turtles names worth crud, even with their multi colored bandannas.

You still need to learn which is which with their colored/red bandannas if where a new fan, so I could really go either way with this subject. If the creators of the movie give enough individual traits without the colored bandannas it should be just as easy to figure out who is whom if they want red. If not, less for them to deal with on other characteristics, I guess.

Hmm, could the creators use the colored bandannas so they could get away with bad writing/creating of the individual turtles? How clever.

The Stryker
03-26-2010, 11:51 PM
Hmm, could the creators use the colored bandannas so they could get away with bad writing/creating of the individual turtles? How clever.

What? Are you dumb? This makes no sense.

Koi
03-26-2010, 11:57 PM
What? Are you dumb? This makes no sense.

I was remarking how using colored head bands to give recognition to each character, you could (what if situation) easily just take out character traits that set them apart, and only have basic traits to back them up, because people would identify them by their masks.

The Stryker
03-27-2010, 12:06 AM
Oy. Because they've done that in the past right?

Personally I find the mirage turtles to be devoid of character. I've already went into that all over this crazy place.

Koi
03-27-2010, 12:14 AM
Oy. Because they've done that in the past right?

Personally I find the mirage turtles to be devoid of character. I've already went into that all over this crazy place.

It was just something random that popped in my head, not because it was done before or anything like that.

But what you said does kind of disprove my random thought. I did actually find the comic turtle really bland and easily mixed. Most likely the reason to this day I don't fancy the turtles that much in comparison to the minor characters and enemies in the shows/comics/movies.

Powder
03-27-2010, 01:40 AM
But what you said does kind of disprove my random thought. I did actually find the comic turtle really bland and easily mixed. Most likely the reason to this day I don't fancy the turtles that much in comparison to the minor characters and enemies in the shows/comics/movies.


There were many times in the old mirage stuff where that was true. In vol.3 I think Gary did a great job better distinguishing the turtles. Then in vol.4 it got a little boring again but with tales there were alot of new talented folks working on it who were able to breathe fresh life into the characters. For instance, Tristan.

Spitfire
03-27-2010, 02:50 AM
The turtles personality traits started to really surface around the time the TV series premiered. Before 1987 the turtles all seemed to act the same. They were pretty one dimensional. The one shots were a precursor to what the ended up being in the end which came out a year before the cartoon but they only grazed the surface. The turtles didn't full develop into these personalities until much later. I assume what happened was that Eastman and Laird didn't plan on it being so successful and thus didn't feel the need to characterize the turtles. Once they saw how popular the turtles were they decided to add personality to them.

Colored bandannas isn't a way to excuse bad writing. The color purple doesn't mean you're smart.

Krang
03-27-2010, 04:56 AM
Wow, lots of posts in here since I last checked. But to address what was said a few pages back...

No one's talking about uniforms, just uniformity.
Actually, it does have a lot to do with uniforms. Since bandannas wouldn't realistically be part of a ninja uniform to begin with, there's not much of a point left in arguing for the realism of red ones. Now if you want to push for red bandannas because that's how it was in the original comics, go right ahead, but I just think it's nonsense to claim that they would be in any way realistic.

Perhaps. But it's the color of Clan Hamato, for better or worse.

The same way a gang (Yakuza, for example) or a Marine squad might all go and get a common tattoo, I'm sure it's intended to create a sort of visual bond between the members of Clan Hamato.
What's the point of a visual bond if their goal is to avoid being seen? I highly doubt a real ninja clan would endanger themselves just to show the world that they are part of the same clan.

According to Eastman and Laird, while there were admittedly a couple of parodic elements in the first issue, it wasn't a parody -- now I guess you can do whatever you want, but I'm not going to argue with both creators of the TMNT.
You might want to read what you quoted again, because that's not what I said at all. I said that the concept started off as a joke, not anything about the first issue. Eastman and Laird saying that they "got real punchy" and "started drawing cartoons to amuse themselves" doesn't exactly imply that they got out all of their ninja books and thoroughly researched what a legitimate ninja clan would wear when coming up with the character designs.

Real ninjas have a clan symbol/color & in the case of the hamato CLAN, that is red.
Symbols, maybe, but colors?

Walking talking turtles wouldnt even happen anyway BUt if they did, & they were raised only to know one thing, ninjitsu, such should be presented in the most realistic way possible.
The most realistic way would be for them to dress in all black, or at least get rid of the bandannas entirely.

Even if every single one of these million fans showed up to an OS movie -- and that's crazy, we're talking about guys and girls in their 30s and 40s now -- that wouldn't even so much as put a dent in the box office.
Not to say anything about the idea itself, but just wanted to point out that your math is off. People in their 40s would have been adults when the OT debuted. The age range you're looking for is early 20s to mid 30s (the OT did run until 1996, after all).

Andrew NDB
03-27-2010, 02:40 PM
Actually, it does have a lot to do with uniforms. Since bandannas wouldn't realistically be part of a ninja uniform to begin with,

There's nothing to say a particular ninja clan couldn't don bandannas. There may have even been.

there's not much of a point left in arguing for the realism of red ones. Now if you want to push for red bandannas because that's how it was in the original comics, go right ahead,

No disrespect, but it really sounds like you arrived in the thread late. No, even though that's as good a reason as any for their inclusion, it's not because of that.

but I just think it's nonsense to claim that they would be in any way realistic.

Vs. the alternative? Different brightly colored bandannas?

What's the point of a visual bond if their goal is to avoid being seen?

Just shooting from the hip here, but misdirection and confusion? You see a shadowy figure moving in the shadows and catch just a glimpse of red against the darkness... you turn, then you see another glimpse of red bandanna, then from the other side of the room.

Suddenly you think, "I'm completely surrounded, there must be like 10 of them, I'm completely surrounded and f***ed!"

Sounds pretty ninja-like to me.

I highly doubt a real ninja clan would endanger themselves just to show the world that they are part of the same clan.

The same idealology in which Yakuza and Chinese Triads brand themselves with very particular tattoos.

Symbols, maybe, but colors?

Color, singular. Not plural.

The most realistic way would be for them to dress in all black, or at least get rid of the bandannas entirely.

I don't entirely disagree with this notion... which is why I liked what Tristan Jones did in a couple of his issues with the TMNT doing just that (dressing in all black, etc.).

Nevertheless, all red bandannas are a trope of Clan Hamato.

Not to say anything about the idea itself, but just wanted to point out that your math is off. People in their 40s would have been adults when the OT debuted.

17ish + 23 (2010 - 1987) = 40. Though maybe it is a big crazy to think 17 year olds would start watching the OS.

And by the time the new movie hits in 2012, someone who was 15 in 1987 would be celebrating their 40th birthday.

The age range you're looking for is early 20s to mid 30s (the OT did run until 1996, after all).

Late twenties to mid-to-late 30s. OT was hardly drawing in new audiences (in any significant number, anyway) by the time 1996 rolled around.

sdp
03-27-2010, 04:09 PM
I remember why I bailed out on this thread.

I can understand you are a fan of the comics and want the movie to be like it, but you seem to be pushing that your version is better.

Red bandannas are nowhere near more realistic than colored ones. Yeah a bit more goofy maybe but so is the original red ones if you want to over analyze. Not to mention they are iconic and what people want. All red would not give any message that this is an mature version.

The age range for the turtles 40s? what? I'd say early 30s are the ones who were already pretty old when they got into a kids franchise. If transformers did well with the nostalgia crowd and its a much older fanbase then the turtles will do fine with that audience since they are younger. Not to mention they also have a few of the older people who watched 2k3 as kids. Obviously those people can't hold a movie by themselves it also needs to appeal to a new generation of kids.

There is no way they can make this into a "this isn't the turtles you know from the cartoons", at least not in the way you are suggesting. Especially since the movie is Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. You can make it more serious but Batman this is not.

Cipher
03-27-2010, 04:51 PM
I wouldn't mind all black masks in the least. It could make sense for a new universe too.

Powder
03-27-2010, 05:19 PM
I wouldn't mind all black masks in the least. It could make sense for a new universe too.

I've been thinking that alot lately actually.

Krutch
03-27-2010, 05:19 PM
Making your opponent think he's outnumbered is a clever tactic... And entirely un-ninja like. The opponent shouldn't even know he's in danger until he hits the floor. Ninjas aren't Batman. They don't use scare tactics. They sneak around the defense and hit their mark before anyone knows they're there.

And for arguments sake let's use the scare tactic scenerio with colored headbands. Assuming it's at night, which I assume it would be, if I'm only just seeing glimpses of the turtles I wouldn't make out the color of their bandana anyways. It'd be the exact safe effect as all red. And I think I'd already think I'm outnumbered by the time I catch a glimpse of the third or forth turtle. I'd have no clue how big their numbers are.

You're also forgetting the sole fact that they are MUTANTS WITH WEAPONS. That alone is enough to intimidate. I doubt their target is gonna care what colors they're wearing.

Koi
03-27-2010, 08:43 PM
Making your opponent think he's outnumbered is a clever tactic... And entirely un-ninja like. The opponent shouldn't even know he's in danger until he hits the floor. Ninjas aren't Batman. They don't use scare tactics. They sneak around the defense and hit their mark before anyone knows they're there.

I can understand where you are going, ninjas are ninjas and do not do super BA long fights, but instead have instant kills... But I myself would rather watch a long dramatic fight scene then a quick easy kill.


You're also forgetting the sole fact that they are MUTANTS WITH WEAPONS. That alone is enough to intimidate. I doubt their target is gonna care what colors they're wearing.

oh really? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=30354)

Just kidding.

Revan
03-27-2010, 11:26 PM
I remember why I bailed out on this thread.

I can understand you are a fan of the comics and want the movie to be like it, but you seem to be pushing that your version is better.
Welcome to the internet
All red would not give any message that this is an mature version.
But it would be an obvious indicator that this isn't the silly OT version of the turtles we are all familiar with.
The age range for the turtles 40s? what? I'd say early 30s are the ones who were already pretty old when they got into a kids franchise. If transformers did well with the nostalgia crowd and its a much older fanbase then the turtles will do fine with that audience since they are younger.
The nostalgic factor you refer to is based from a cartoon series that was action based. The OT turtles was geared more toward comedy with some action sprinkled in.
And the new Transformers movie had WAY WAY more action in it that all 4 turtles movies combined (which is probably the reason it was more successfull, not because of nostalgia)
There is no way they can make this into a "this isn't the turtles you know from the cartoons"
I don't understand why that is impossible. They just need to find a way to send the message clearly.

Krutch
03-28-2010, 02:08 AM
I can understand where you are going, ninjas are ninjas and do not do super BA long fights, but instead have instant kills... But I myself would rather watch a long dramatic fight scene then a quick easy kill.

lol I completely agree. But he was defending what he felt is ninja-like, so I had to state my opinion:P

Krang
03-28-2010, 03:59 AM
There's nothing to say a particular ninja clan couldn't don bandannas. There may have even been.
That goes back to the question I asked before: What would be the purpose of bandannas? I very much doubt they would be part of a uniform unless there was a reason for them to be.

No, even though that's as good a reason as any for their inclusion, it's not because of that.
It's not because of the comics? Then why should there be bandannas at all rather than more traditional ninja uniforms?

Vs. the alternative? Different brightly colored bandannas?
Huh? I'm just saying that ninja clans with red bandannas are not realistic. I didn't even mention colored bandannas... :-?

Just shooting from the hip here, but misdirection and confusion? You see a shadowy figure moving in the shadows and catch just a glimpse of red against the darkness... you turn, then you see another glimpse of red bandanna, then from the other side of the room.

Suddenly you think, "I'm completely surrounded, there must be like 10 of them, I'm completely surrounded and f***ed!"

Sounds pretty ninja-like to me.
Not to me. Like Krutch said, if you're a ninja, you aren't supposed to be seen at all until it's too late for your enemies. If they're spotted before they attack, it would be all over for them against skilled enemies, who aren't going to just stand there and be scared. Any martial artist can tell you that it's incredibly important not to allow your opponent to predict your attacks.

The same idealology in which Yakuza and Chinese Triads brand themselves with very particular tattoos.
The difference here is that tattoos don't give the enemy a tactical advantage.

Color, singular. Not plural.
My comment was in response to the concept that different ninja clans wear different colors.

17ish + 23 (2010 - 1987) = 40. Though maybe it is a big crazy to think 17 year olds would start watching the OS.

And by the time the new movie hits in 2012, someone who was 15 in 1987 would be celebrating their 40th birthday.
...Yes. That doesn't change either of the two things I said.

Late twenties to mid-to-late 30s. OT was hardly drawing in new audiences (in any significant number, anyway) by the time 1996 rolled around.
The OT was most popular in the early 90s, and as I recall, that popularity lasted at least through 1992 or 93. You're saying that there weren't enough young kids who began watching during that time (and would now be in their early-mid 20s) to be worth counting? Yet you're saying that there were more people in their mid-late teens watching during that time (who would now be in their late 30s)? Wow, so much for target demographics... :P

But it would be an obvious indicator that this isn't the silly OT version of the turtles we are all familiar with.

[...]

I don't understand why that is impossible. They just need to find a way to send the message clearly.
But if this is supposed to be bringing in an entirely new audience, they wouldn't need to send such a message.

Revan
03-28-2010, 09:38 AM
But if this is supposed to be bringing in an entirely new audience, they wouldn't need to send such a message.
I understant that but I'm curious HOW they plan to bring said new audience.

If they have a better idea, it's all good IMO but wouldn't you agree that all red bandanas would be a clear attention grabber?

Candy Kappa
03-28-2010, 01:55 PM
[QUOTE=Krang;763636]My comment was in response to the concept that different ninja clans wear different colors.
[QUOTE]

all know that the white ninja is a good guy, the black ninja is a bad guy and the gray ninja changes sides:P

Redeemer
03-28-2010, 02:07 PM
I say keep colored head bands. That it.

The Stryker
03-28-2010, 03:14 PM
If they have a better idea, it's all good IMO but wouldn't you agree that all red bandanas would be a clear attention grabber?

I wouldn't agree with that. All it would say to most people "not in the know" is that the Ninja Turtles are now completely generic and uniformed.

Revan
03-28-2010, 08:24 PM
I wouldn't agree with that. All it would say to most people "not in the know" is that the Ninja Turtles are now completely generic and uniformed.

Really?

By "not in the know," do you mean those people who are unfamiliar with the comic?

I suppose I just figured that a drastic change (such as a bandana color swap) would be a good way to get the attention of OT fans. They would definately notice if their childhood heroes suddenly had a serious makeover.

Redeemer
03-28-2010, 09:04 PM
That is a good point go with the different colored bandannas.

Krang
03-29-2010, 02:13 AM
I understant that but I'm curious HOW they plan to bring said new audience.
Good question. But I personally don't entirely agree with the new audience concept, so that's one for those who do agree with it to answer.

If they have a better idea, it's all good IMO but wouldn't you agree that all red bandanas would be a clear attention grabber?
You're right, it would. I'm not sure that it would be a good idea to focus on that for advertising, though, since ads like that don't always work (http://www.slate.com/id/1006675/).

all know that the white ninja is a good guy, the black ninja is a bad guy and the gray ninja changes sides:P
:lol:

Buffy
03-29-2010, 06:41 AM
all know that the white ninja is a good guy, the black ninja is a bad guy and the gray ninja changes sides:P

Gi Joe made a big mistake then:

http://i374.photobucket.com/albums/oo184/DrawingMelee/finale-gi-joe-poster.jpg

Andrew NDB
03-29-2010, 11:42 AM
I can understand you are a fan of the comics and want the movie to be like it,

It's not about what I want -- I'm saying that's pretty much the only option left that they haven't already exhausted.

And it's an option that seems to be working out great for other comic-to-movie franchises.

but you seem to be pushing that your version is better.

Oh, you mean Kevin Eastman & Peter Laird's version? Yes, I do believe that version is better and I don't believe I should have to apologize if that offends anyone.

Red bandannas are nowhere near more realistic than colored ones.

Feel free to quantify that.

Yeah a bit more goofy maybe but so is the original red ones if you want to over analyze.

OK, well yes... in all fairness, the answer to the question "Why do the TMNT wear bandannas?" is, literally, because when Eastman and Laird were doing their first Turtle sketches they determined that a bandanna around the eyes made them seem more "ninja-like."

Nevertheless, they're a trope of the Turtles and a given. As such, I think it's prudent to go with the most sensible "take" on them out there... and, yeah, I think that would be the one without all the rainbow colors.

All red would not give any message that this is an mature version.

It would help.

The age range for the turtles 40s? what? I'd say early 30s are the ones who were already pretty old when they got into a kids franchise. If transformers did well with the nostalgia crowd and its a much older fanbase then the turtles will do fine with that audience since they are younger. Not to mention they also have a few of the older people who watched 2k3 as kids. Obviously those people can't hold a movie by themselves it also needs to appeal to a new generation of kids.

They have to be the driving focus. The existing fans and nostalgic adults would only be of peripheral concern... as they should be.

There is no way they can make this into a "this isn't the turtles you know from the cartoons"

Sure they can.

Especially since the movie is Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

Their age is irrelevant. The movie "Kick-Ass" has a 10 year old girl in it chopping off body parts and talking about c*cks.

Not that I'm trying to say it should or could be a hard-R movie such as that.

You can make it more serious but Batman this is not.

In many respects the TMNT source material is more serious than Batman. But it's a funny thing... at it's lightest it is much lighter than Batman at his lightest, but at its darkest it seems to be a bit darker than Batman at his darkest.

I mean, you don't see Batman going around chopping off heads or limbs, do you?

I wouldn't mind all black masks in the least. It could make sense for a new universe too.

I would jump aboard that boat, sure.

Making your opponent think he's outnumbered is a clever tactic... And entirely un-ninja like.

Of course, but they can't employ straight ninja/stealth assassination tactics against a room full of Foot. And it would be pretty stupid (limiting?) if the Turtles were unable to adapt to a given scenario.

The opponent shouldn't even know he's in danger until he hits the floor. Ninjas aren't Batman. They don't use scare tactics. They sneak around the defense and hit their mark before anyone knows they're there.

Ideally. But that's not always possible.

And for arguments sake let's use the scare tactic scenerio with colored headbands. Assuming it's at night, which I assume it would be, if I'm only just seeing glimpses of the turtles I wouldn't make out the color of their bandana anyways.

Maye it's time for a new prescription.

You're also forgetting the sole fact that they are MUTANTS WITH WEAPONS. That alone is enough to intimidate. I doubt their target is gonna care what colors they're wearing.

Between the Foot, Triceratons, Complete Carnage, Savanti, etc., the Turtles don't seem to run into a lot of enemies that crap their pants about the mutant factor. I don't think they would be counting on that, really.

That goes back to the question I asked before: What would be the purpose of bandannas? I very much doubt they would be part of a uniform unless there was a reason for them to be.

As I wrote above, yes, the bandannas are there because -- for better or worse -- Kev and Pete decided that adding bandannas made their Turtles look more ninja-like. I'd be surprised if it was any more complex than that, and I doubt much more thought was afforded it than that.

It's not because of the comics?

The comics create the precedent for them, not the direct necessity. The necessity is twofold, primarily: 1) Send out ye olde message, "Maybe you've heard of the TMNT... y'know how goofy and such they seemed? Well, this isn't that," and, 2) They're more sensible than the alternative: the rainbow bandannas.

Then why should there be bandannas at all rather than more traditional ninja uniforms?

Because there's no real precedent for that in any media, Tristan's couple of Tales comics notwithstanding.

Not that I'd be necessarily against the idea.

Huh? I'm just saying that ninja clans with red bandannas are not realistic. I didn't even mention colored bandannas... :-?

You didn't need to. :)

Not to me. Like Krutch said, if you're a ninja, you aren't supposed to be seen at all until it's too late for your enemies. If they're spotted before they attack, it would be all over for them against skilled enemies, who aren't going to just stand there and be scared. Any martial artist can tell you that it's incredibly important not to allow your opponent to predict your attacks.

As I said, every battle and scenario is going to be different.

The OT was most popular in the early 90s, and as I recall, that popularity lasted at least through 1992 or 93.

But by 96? That's an eternity in kid years/taste. I know that by the time TMNT 3 dropped (and I do mean dropped... ker-plunk right into the bowl, that is) no one seemed to care. Folks had already outgrown TMNT and moved on.

I would've moved right on with them had I not discovered the comics.

You're saying that there weren't enough young kids who began watching during that time (and would now be in their early-mid 20s) to be worth counting?

You mean the few who started watching from 93-96? No, to movie studios and financiers this number would not be worth counting. Sorry for that.

Yet you're saying that there were more people in their mid-late teens watching during that time (who would now be in their late 30s)? Wow, so much for target demographics... :P

Where did I say that? I was playing devil's advocate on what you're saying and implying... that there's alllll these aged-out-of-target-demographic fans (fans that somehow didn't bother to support the last movie) that are going to flock to see a OS TMNT movie and make it a big hit in spite of that flying in the face of every bit of quantifiable data we know about (actioner) demographics.

I agree, it's bulls***.

But if this is supposed to be bringing in an entirely new audience, they wouldn't need to send such a message.

Not untrue. But why not, while they're at it, you know?

Candy Kappa
03-29-2010, 12:14 PM
[QUOTE=Buffy;763872]Gi Joe made a big mistake then:QUOTE]

no rule without exceptions :D

plastroncafe
03-29-2010, 02:40 PM
I like the red masks. Makes me as the viewer/reader have to pay just that much more attention to what's going on in the scene. Is it confusing at first? Well yeah, but...you get used to it.

First time through the HBO mini-series "Band of Brothers" I had no idea who anyone was. Bunch of white guys in military uniforms. But as time wore on it became second nature to know who was who by the million little things that make everyone different.

I don't think this would be any different.

But precedent has been set, and yeah, it's more than likely that the turtles will have multicolored masks like in the cartoons and live action movies. Which...to me just says that people think that kids are too stupid to tell one character from another. But...what're you gonna do?

What I'd really love to see in this next live action movie is maskless turtles.

Don't get me wrong, I love the masks. They're great in terms of cartoon style. Masks being a classic element in the super hero genre.
They make sense in the world. The turtles sweat, but don't have eyebrows. Masks make sense.

And in terms of color coding? Yeah, I've always fallen to the idea that they did it for April's sake...even when the canons themselves don't lean towards that conclusion.

But maskless turtles, even for a scene or two, would be awesome. And with the SFX tech that we've got now? I think it's more than possible that it could happen.

Andrew NDB
03-29-2010, 03:02 PM
Don't get me wrong, I love the masks. They're great in terms of cartoon style. Masks being a classic element in the super hero genre. They make sense in the world. The turtles sweat, but don't have eyebrows. Masks make sense.

Actually, that's a very good point -- the bandannas could act as a sort of sweat band, yeah?

Krutch
03-29-2010, 05:15 PM
Oh, you mean Kevin Eastman & Peter Laird's version? Yes, I do believe that version is better and I don't believe I should have to apologize if that offends anyone.

No ones asking for an apology. But... do you really think that someone can't build something better out of someone elses idea? Do you really think wrestling fans are missing the days of no storylines or unique characters of when McMahon's dad was running the place?

They has to be the driving focus. The existing fans and nostalgic adults would only be of peripheral concern... as they should be.

I dont see the logic in making a movie to purposely avoid existing fans of the franchise, whatever the incarnation may be. If you're trying to gather new fans altogether, why even take an existing property?

Of course, but they can't employ straight ninja/stealth assassination tactics against a room full of Foot. And it would be pretty stupid (limiting?) if the Turtles were unable to adapt to a given scenario.

Uh, yes, yes they could avoid a room of foot ninja. Because the turtles are superior ninja. And its not like the Foot would be actively looking for them. They'd be training, etc... And yes, the turtles should be able to adapt to any scenerio. But they wouldn't allow themselves to be caught in any other scenerio other than the one they planned out themselves, if they were real ninja.

Just shooting from the hip here, but misdirection and confusion? You see a shadowy figure moving in the shadows and catch just a glimpse of red against the darkness...
Maye it's time for a new prescription.

Uh, no. If its as dark as that example, red and orange would look pretty much the same. Purple and Blue would look the same. And they would all look brown/black in the darkness. And, again, this scenerio shouldn't even happen.

Between the Foot, Triceratons, Complete Carnage, Savanti, etc., the Turtles don't seem to run into a lot of enemies that crap their pants about the mutant factor. I don't think they would be counting on that, really.

And the Foot would be intimidated by numbers? They're always in enourmous numbers themselves. And Complete Carnage, Triceratons, and Savanti to some extent are all monsters themselves. That kind of avoids the fact. And again, if we are to get true ninja here, Turtles would only use sneak attacks.

You need to understand, ninjas are not noble in the least. They'd get paid to assassinate people. Sometimes they'd even hire their own cheaper work to get the job done and keep the cut themselves. The Ninja Turtles are far from real ninjas. People cant keep falling back on what a real ninja would be to defend the turtles image.

The comics create the precedent for them, not the direct necessity. The necessity is twofold, primarily: 1) Send out ye olde message, "Maybe you've heard of the TMNT... y'know how goofy and such they seemed? Well, this isn't that," and, 2) They're more sensible than the alternative: the rainbow bandannas.

I'll use Power Rangers again for a point. If you saw a poster of 5 red rangers together, would you think "Oh this is gonna be a mature take on the series" or would you just go "Huh? Why are they all wearing red?" and not give it another thought.

As I said, every battle and scenario is going to be different.

No.... pretty much ninjas just plan a stealth kill and vanish, or they wouldnt go through with it in the first place.

Not untrue. But why not, while they're at it, you know?

"Why not?" is the worst reason I've heard to defend a point :P Why not give Raph a gun? Why not make Mikey a heroin addict? You know, while they're at it. Appealing to new audiences and all. :P

plastroncafe
03-29-2010, 05:33 PM
I dont see the logic in making a movie to purposely avoid existing fans of the franchise, whatever the incarnation may be. If you're trying to gather new fans altogether, why even take an existing property?


Because that's how Hollywood works?

Andrew NDB
03-29-2010, 05:55 PM
No ones asking for an apology. But... do you really think that someone can't build something better out of someone elses idea?

I think you can do whatever you want.

Do you really think wrestling fans are missing the days of no storylines or unique characters of when McMahon's dad was running the place?

I think nowadays wrestling fans are missing a lot of things from years ago.

I dont see the logic in making a movie to purposely avoid existing fans of the franchise, whatever the incarnation may be. If you're trying to gather new fans altogether, why even take an existing property?

It's a proven money-maker with untapped potential. And gritty comic books are pretty valuable real estate right now in films.

Uh, yes, yes they could avoid a room of foot ninja.

Who's talking about avoiding it? I'm talking about them taking out a room full of Foot ninja.

And the Foot would be intimidated by numbers? They're always in enourmous numbers themselves. And Complete Carnage, Triceratons, and Savanti to some extent are all monsters themselves. That kind of avoids the fact. And again, if we are to get true ninja here, Turtles would only use sneak attacks.

You need to understand, ninjas are not noble in the least. They'd get paid to assassinate people. Sometimes they'd even hire their own cheaper work to get the job done and keep the cut themselves. The Ninja Turtles are far from real ninjas. People cant keep falling back on what a real ninja would be to defend the turtles image.

While you raise valid points, it's well documented that while they are a legitimate ninja clan of a sort, they do operate with a great sense of an almost samurai-like honor.

A bit of a contradiction in terms... but that's our Turtles. I like the dichotomy of it myself.

I'll use Power Rangers again

Please don't.

for a point. If you saw a poster of 5 red rangers together, would you think "Oh this is gonna be a mature take on the series" or would you just go "Huh? Why are they all wearing red?" and not give it another thought.

It would get me curious enough to do some digging to see what it's about, I suppose.

No one's suggesting the red bandannas is going to be some kind of end-all, be-all, "WOW! Look at those red bandannas -- this must be an all new take on the TMNT! I'm pre-ordering tickets now!!" Just that it'd help.

A little.

No.... pretty much ninjas just plan a stealth kill and vanish, or they wouldnt go through with it in the first place.

Not untrue. But it's not quite apples to apples when we're talking about ninjas fighting other ninjas. It would become like some kind of ridiculous shell game -- that's why most of the Foot vs. TMNT battles quickly descend into sort of these open, melee-type affairs.

"Why not?" is the worst reason I've heard to defend a point :P Why not give Raph a gun?

You mean again? He's used guns and blown away people on multiple occasions. Several Turtles have.

Why not make Mikey a heroin addict?

You're obviously joking but something in that vein (no pun intended) might lead to a pretty compelling story.

Krang
03-30-2010, 03:26 AM
As I wrote above, yes, the bandannas are there because -- for better or worse -- Kev and Pete decided that adding bandannas made their Turtles look more ninja-like. I'd be surprised if it was any more complex than that, and I doubt much more thought was afforded it than that.
My point exactly.

The comics create the precedent for them, not the direct necessity. The necessity is twofold, primarily: 1) Send out ye olde message, "Maybe you've heard of the TMNT... y'know how goofy and such they seemed? Well, this isn't that," and, 2) They're more sensible than the alternative: the rainbow bandannas.
Now "sensible" I can agree with. I don't care all that much about mask colors in general, but on the off chance that this movie will be a serious take on the TMNT based closely on the comics, I can see that red bandannas would make more sense than colored ones. But the reason I agree with that is because that's how it is in the comics, not because of any nonsense about them being realistic.

You didn't need to. :)
Considering the fact that the conversation wasn't about colored bandannas up to that point, neither did you. :P

As I said, every battle and scenario is going to be different.
Krutch already covered this topic well, but I'll also add this: I can't imagine any scenario where it would be a good idea for a ninja clan to give their enemies a tactical advantage by making themselves easier to see.

But by 96? That's an eternity in kid years/taste. I know that by the time TMNT 3 dropped (and I do mean dropped... ker-plunk right into the bowl, that is) no one seemed to care. Folks had already outgrown TMNT and moved on.
Yeah, I know. That's not what I was talking about, though.

You mean the few who started watching from 93-96?
No, I mean the ones who started watching during the period of popularity from 90 to 92 or 93, which is what I said in the sentence you just quoted above. The younger ones among them would now be in their early-mid 20s.

Where did I say that?
In two places, actually. In your first estimate when you said that OT fans are "in their 30s and 40s," and in your next post when you adjusted your estimate to say, "Late twenties to mid-to-late 30s." Both estimates include fans in their late 30s but refuse to acknowledge fans in their early-mid 20s, meaning that you're saying there are more of the former than the latter.

I was playing devil's advocate on what you're saying and implying... that there's alllll these aged-out-of-target-demographic fans (fans that somehow didn't bother to support the last movie) that are going to flock to see a OS TMNT movie and make it a big hit in spite of that flying in the face of every bit of quantifiable data we know about (actioner) demographics.
Wait, what? Either you're very confused, or that's a blatant straw man argument, because I never said or implied any of that... :blanksta:

Not untrue. But why not, while they're at it, you know?
Because, according to you, there aren't a significant number of OT fans who would see a new TMNT movie. Why should the creators waste their time and advertising money on them if they won't bring in the ticket sales? Besides, negative advertising tactics like that are prone to backfire.

Krutch
03-30-2010, 03:55 AM
I think nowadays wrestling fans are missing a lot of things from years ago.

Todays wrestling sucks because they went too far and had to dial back. Now it just seems like a shell of the "attitude" era. But its still 100000 times better than pre-vince.

Who's talking about avoiding it? I'm talking about them taking out a room full of Foot ninja.

But why is my question. If they're target is the Shredder, they're not going to waste time taking out a room full of Foot. Thats not being ninja like at all. They would be practically invisible until they reach Shredder. And they wouldn't confront him to have a showdown, they'd stealth kill or poison him.

A bit of a contradiction in terms... but that's our Turtles. I like the dichotomy of it myself.
But you can't have it both ways. You're saying that its more ninja like to have red bandannas but its alright for them to pretty much be everything but ninja? And you're saying that this dichotomy cant involve different colored bandannas? If they are allowed to use different attack methods, different stealth methods, different honor-code, different way-of-life, then who's to say that they cant wear different colored headbands? Where do you draw the line?

No one's suggesting the red bandannas is going to be some kind of end-all, be-all, "WOW! Look at those red bandannas -- this must be an all new take on the TMNT!
Um...
Yes. And it would send a firm message that this is a new beginning/reboot, not a continuance of the other horrible movies.
Send out ye olde message, "Maybe you've heard of the TMNT... y'know how goofy and such they seemed? Well, this isn't that,"

:roll:

But it's not quite apples to apples when we're talking about ninjas fighting other ninjas. It would become like some kind of ridiculous shell game -- that's why most of the Foot vs. TMNT battles quickly descend into sort of these open, melee-type affairs.

Look, this again goes back to the whole "what defines a ninja in the tmnt universe?" question. According to our history, neither of them are. So the reason that they break out into open melee fights are strictly for action-story telling purposes. Not that thats a bad thing. It's obviously a more compelling story when your heroes are in jeopardy, but its still not ninja.

You mean again? He's used guns and blown away people on multiple occasions. Several Turtles have.

Lol, yeah, I regretted typing that the second I posted that. I instantly thought of the cover of Bodycount and was like "well... let's hope my sarcasm was layed thick enough" :P

You're obviously joking but something in that vein (no pun intended) might lead to a pretty compelling story.

lol it would be kinda interesting, wouldnt it? I always saw Mikey as the addict :P

Powder
03-30-2010, 04:50 AM
I just wanna say I feel like a proud father. You're all being so civil and making intelligent points that are backed by facts. Thank god for that. I'm sure you can all imagine the shlt storm this COULD be.

Krutch
03-30-2010, 05:08 AM
I just wanna say I feel like a proud father. You're all being so civil and making intelligent points that are backed by facts. Thank god for that. I'm sure you can all imagine the shlt storm this COULD be.

lmao, totally. You should have been on the Vanilla Ice message board about 6 years back. Sh*t was like Hiroshima.

Scandia
03-30-2010, 07:04 AM
I do not want all red bandannas in a TMNT movie. I prefer the multicolored ones. Whoever decided on that for the OT had a wonderful idea.

discordiatookie
03-30-2010, 03:16 PM
I just wanna say I feel like a proud father. You're all being so civil and making intelligent points that are backed by facts. Thank god for that. I'm sure you can all imagine the shlt storm this COULD be.

Heh, I was reading through this earlier and thinking something similar. Great to see so many opinions, well thought out and not just pointless arguing.

As for me, I don't really mind either way. I'd love to see red bandanas, however if it goes the colour route, i'm still up for it...

Samhain
03-30-2010, 03:31 PM
Heh, I was reading through this earlier and thinking something similar. Great to see so many opinions, well thought out and not just pointless arguing.

As for me, I don't really mind either way. I'd love to see red bandanas, however if it goes the colour route, i'm still up for it...

I agree. Just show there actually ARE mature people on this board. We are all on the same side anyways.:tthumbsu:

Gyt Kaliba
03-30-2010, 05:39 PM
I hadn't really noticed till Powder pointed it out, but things have been amazingly civil, even in the disagreements. There's nothing wrong with disagreements so long as basic respect is kept between both parties, so I think it has gone well.

Now if only I didn't see so many pointless flaming threads on the anime forums I frequent...

Sage Ninja
03-30-2010, 11:54 PM
I'm waiting for someone to make a thread asking on whether or not the turtles should have tails in the up coming movie since they had them in the mirage comics. :lol:

The Stryker
03-31-2010, 02:12 AM
I'm waiting for someone to make a thread asking on whether or not the turtles should have tails in the up coming movie since they had them in the mirage comics. :lol:

That, I would argue.

I'm showing my maturity here but from certain angles it looks like poop that's stuck.

Krang
03-31-2010, 03:44 AM
I just wanna say I feel like a proud father. You're all being so civil and making intelligent points that are backed by facts. Thank god for that. I'm sure you can all imagine the shlt storm this COULD be.
Agreed. I'm glad to see that this topic is being discussed maturely without anyone resorting to personal attacks.

I do not want all red bandannas in a TMNT movie. I prefer the multicolored ones. Whoever decided on that for the OT had a wonderful idea.
Not sure who came up with the specific colors, but the one who came up with the idea of multicolored bandannas was actually Peter Laird.

NameGoesHere1066
03-31-2010, 01:10 PM
I'm waiting for someone to make a thread asking on whether or not the turtles should have tails in the up coming movie since they had them in the mirage comics.

That, I would argue.

I'm showing my maturity here but from certain angles it looks like poop that's stuck.

that will never happen in any medium outside the comics because you would have too many angry parents bitching about how the turtles are "exposed" :trolleye:

but to answer the thread topic, all red would be awsome but I don't care if we get multi-colored at this point.

The Stryker
03-31-2010, 04:37 PM
The tails also look like dicks. That's another problem.

Edit: Surprised that isn't censored. Oh well.

Krutch
03-31-2010, 04:44 PM
I like the tails, but I dont care too much if we lose'em.

Candy Kappa
03-31-2010, 06:39 PM
I prefer the turtles with tails and red masks, but this is really just a part of the design, I'd be more concerned if they look too cartoony like the chipmunks, or too realistic, a hyper realistic look on the turtles could alienate them with the audience, and too cartoony the movie can't be taken on a serious tone.

multi masks or red masks, I'd love to see idividuality in the design for each turtle, making them easy to see the difference without any gear or clothes on.

Sage Ninja
04-01-2010, 02:26 PM
I'm showing my maturity here but from certain angles it looks like poop that's stuck.

....

http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i289/Zarana-X/Artsy/1995-Leonardo.jpg


:o

TMNachoT
04-01-2010, 10:30 PM
That, I would argue.
it looks like poop that's stuck.

Ha! ha! Ha!:D

Leo656
04-03-2010, 01:01 AM
I can't help but think how rich all'a y'all would be if you went to law school and applied this same debating tenacity. :lol:

ryukenden
04-03-2010, 10:09 AM
Even if this movie with all red bandana turtles is to be more grittier than the first movie and is successful, a lot of people would be complaining about why the masks aren't colored.

I'm fine with it either way.

Davetello
04-03-2010, 10:13 AM
Won't happen unfortunately, but would love it to.

Samhain
04-03-2010, 01:39 PM
Even if this movie with all red bandana turtles is to be more grittier than the first movie and is successful, a lot of people would be complaining about why the masks aren't colored.

I'm fine with it either way.

Doesnt matter which way it goes. someone will ALWAYS be complaining. O well.

Spitfire
04-03-2010, 05:10 PM
Actually, that's a very good point -- the bandannas could act as a sort of sweat band, yeah?

Not a bad reason to have them but the major flaw in that is reptiles don't sweat. The turtles have been shown sweating before though which always bothered me. If we're going for full blown realism here then having sweating reptiles would be bad.

Samhain
04-03-2010, 05:46 PM
Not a bad reason to have them but the major flaw in that is reptiles don't sweat. The turtles have been shown sweating before though which always bothered me. If we're going for full blown realism here then having sweating reptiles would be bad.

But they are humanoid so that might make it make more sense.

Spitfire
04-03-2010, 06:20 PM
But they are humanoid so that might make it make more sense.

That's a great point. If you go by the old toon origin story that would make sense but going by the comic origin it doesn't work. The OT mutation happened because of a cross of DNA. IE the last thing you touch your DNA combines with and you get a mash up of two species.

In the comic the turtles and Splinter are just exposed to the mutagen and it causes a mutation of their psychical form. This wouldn't change their inner biology. All the mutagen did to them in the comic was cause their brains to develop beyond their species normal capacity and cause their limbs to develop further as well. Reptiles did at one point stand on two legs and had three fingers so it's quite believable. This is of course assuming a turtle is a less evolved version of some dinosaur and if you do that you can completely take the human element out of their mutation.

Hey this is fun, attempting to apply logic to the turtles.

Samhain
04-03-2010, 07:01 PM
Good point as well.



Hey this is fun, attempting to apply logic to the turtles.

Yes, almost seems stupid considering what we are talking about. Almost.:lol:

But one thing I noticed is that in the episode where they meet Leatherhead mikey needs a mask to go under water. Now I know turtles hold their breath, so whats up with that. Or maybe thats a mistake? They also seem to be scared a few times throughout the series of water. Like when they had flashbacks and I think one of them fell into rapid running sewer water. Maybe the mutation took some of that ''turtle'' instinct such as being able to swim away.lol. But maybe the mutagen could do something to them possibly making them warm blooded? Or atleast change them in that way. It wouldnt be a far reach considering we are talking about mutated turtles who are also ninja. Haha.

Spitfire
04-03-2010, 07:21 PM
Good point as well.

Yes, almost seems stupid considering what we are talking about. Almost.:lol:
Haha very true. We're just that devoted to the turtles, we much understand them.

But one thing I noticed is that in the episode where they meet Leatherhead mikey needs a mask to go under water. Now I know turtles hold their breath, so whats up with that. Or maybe thats a mistake? They also seem to be scared a few times throughout the series of water. Like when they had flashbacks and I think one of them fell into rapid running sewer water. Maybe the mutation took some of that ''turtle'' instinct such as being able to swim away.lol. But maybe the mutagen could do something to them possibly making them warm blooded? Or atleast change them in that way. It wouldnt be a far reach considering we are talking about mutated turtles who are also ninja. Haha.
Well many dinosaurs couldn't swim so I guess you could say they can't handle water like a turtle because their method of breathing evolved and they have no flippers. The fear of water could be a psychological thing too as they have developed brains which cab lead to irrational fear. That always bothered me too. It was obviously just a cheap way of tossing suspense into a scene.

I don't know how cold a sewer is but some of the locations the turtles have been to are cold. They never seem to bundle up so it would make sense they still have their reptile blood, which means they adapt to their environment. Guess they just never wanted to show Raph sunning himself on a rock.

plastroncafe
04-03-2010, 10:10 PM
My girlfriend is a paleontologist, and we've had a conversation or two about the biological nature of the Turtles. She...wanted me to make a list of all the instances where the Turtles sweat in order to figure out whether or not they were ecto or endothermic. Or, possibly poly-thermic....who knows.

But their sweating isn't the only thing that makes no sense from a reptile standpoint. They also have teeth, opposable thumbs, and the wrong number of digits on their hands and feet.

Also, only because I've seen someone else mention it, turtles do not have a shared ancestor with dinosaurs. They two lines co-existed. I wish I could find the link, but there's actually a prehistoric turtle that they found in Australia that was given the Genus species name "ninja turtle". Alas.

I don't think sewers get that cold, otherwise the pipes in them would freeze, and that'd be bad. They're well below the frost line, so they might be protected. That being said, I don't think the turtles are cold-blooded because...well, reptiles tend to go into a type of torpor if their core body temperature is allowed to go down too far.

...which is totally all on topic. I swear...

Spitfire
04-03-2010, 10:51 PM
My girlfriend is a paleontologist, and we've had a conversation or two about the biological nature of the Turtles. She...wanted me to make a list of all the instances where the Turtles sweat in order to figure out whether or not they were ecto or endothermic. Or, possibly poly-thermic....who knows.

But their sweating isn't the only thing that makes no sense from a reptile standpoint. They also have teeth, opposable thumbs, and the wrong number of digits on their hands and feet.

Also, only because I've seen someone else mention it, turtles do not have a shared ancestor with dinosaurs. They two lines co-existed. I wish I could find the link, but there's actually a prehistoric turtle that they found in Australia that was given the Genus species name "ninja turtle". Alas.

I don't think sewers get that cold, otherwise the pipes in them would freeze, and that'd be bad. They're well below the frost line, so they might be protected. That being said, I don't think the turtles are cold-blooded because...well, reptiles tend to go into a type of torpor if their core body temperature is allowed to go down too far.

...which is totally all on topic. I swear...
This post is awesome. I didn't know turtles at one point co-existed with dinosaurs, though it makes perfect sense.

I guess you can't add cold hard scientific fact to the turtles, it just doesn't work.

Samhain
04-04-2010, 09:53 AM
My girlfriend is a paleontologist, and we've had a conversation or two about the biological nature of the Turtles. She...wanted me to make a list of all the instances where the Turtles sweat in order to figure out whether or not they were ecto or endothermic. Or, possibly poly-thermic....who knows.

But their sweating isn't the only thing that makes no sense from a reptile standpoint. They also have teeth, opposable thumbs, and the wrong number of digits on their hands and feet.

Also, only because I've seen someone else mention it, turtles do not have a shared ancestor with dinosaurs. They two lines co-existed. I wish I could find the link, but there's actually a prehistoric turtle that they found in Australia that was given the Genus species name "ninja turtle". Alas.

I don't think sewers get that cold, otherwise the pipes in them would freeze, and that'd be bad. They're well below the frost line, so they might be protected. That being said, I don't think the turtles are cold-blooded because...well, reptiles tend to go into a type of torpor if their core body temperature is allowed to go down too far.

...which is totally all on topic. I swear...

Reading this post made me realize I seriously need a life. Lmao. :lol:

plastroncafe
04-04-2010, 09:59 AM
Reading this post made me realize I seriously need a life. Lmao. :lol:

Trust me when I say few people do pillow talk quite the same way as me and my girl.

Katie
04-04-2010, 04:02 PM
GLAD they just never wanted to show Raph sunning himself on a rock.



Had to fix something for you really quick.....I had a vision of millions of fangirls squirming over thoughts of Raph sunbathing. gross.


Anywho..... Why do they HAVE to have all red bandanas to achive a "gritty feel"? For that matter why do they have to be gritty at all? Once we got into dinosaurs from space in the comics, to me at least, the realism (gritty or not) went bye bye. (ok, ok, at the point that there were talking turtles and a rat it went bye bye...but you know)

Also, on the endo, ecto, polythermic discussion....I don't see how they would change from normal turtles unles we were doing the DNA mash up.

.....but since that's old toon, I'm pretty sure the "gritty realism" crowd wouldn't want that, ergo, bandanas are again pointless to the uniform discussion.

I'm thinking, if I was a ninja, i sure as hell wouldn't want ANYTHING flapping around that an enemy could get ahold of during a fight....or could get caught on something while I was sneaking around.

But then again we are talking about characters created by two stoned guys who had no clue about real turtles or ninjas. they just thought their character looked cool. why not have fun colors and fun stories?








Kinda feels like a new civil war. I'm with colored bandanas!!

Samhain
04-04-2010, 04:49 PM
But then again we are talking about characters created by two stoned guys who had no clue about real turtles or ninjas.

Were they ? If they were all this would make a hell of alot more sense. :lol:

Candy Kappa
04-04-2010, 08:07 PM
just a quick question off topic, it's not a huge deal to make a own thread bout it, but reading plastroncafe, and the mentioning of the wrong digits on their hands and feet.

In how to draw tmnt vol1 nr. 1 by Solson pub. it stands in the legs and feet section that shows and tells that the turtles heels act as the third 'thumb-like' toe with grabbing power.
Similar to Nightcrawler in X-men

Is this still canon, or is it forgotten

JWarner
04-04-2010, 11:19 PM
Okay... I've only read most of this thread, THEN skipped to the end but I'll chime in anyways, forgive me.

Red is the original color; and the only people that know it are the people who read the book or pay attention to such things... not many.
The turtles are universally recognized by their separate colors.
The new movie will in no way appeal to the fans of the comic series only.

To address the statement that you'll tell the difference via voice and other such things? Remember the trailer for the first movie when Mike says "I love being a turtle!" It was Raph's voice. Folks say Hollywood thinks the audience is stupid. I disagree. Hollywood is stupid, the director, actors, and crew would not be able to tell the difference without the different colors...

Being a purest, I would agree with the argument for red bandanas. But I can live with the multi-colors... Just do the film in Black and White.

Krutch
04-05-2010, 12:28 PM
Just do the film in Black and White.

Now there's a neat idea. That'd be fun to watch. Maybe even with dashes of color like Sin City.

JWarner
04-05-2010, 12:42 PM
Now there's a neat idea. That'd be fun to watch. Maybe even with dashes of color like Sin City.

You got it.

Koi
04-05-2010, 05:39 PM
I just found the Sin City/The Spirit style... a tad cheesy. I would not want to see another movie in that style, especially TMNT. I don't think I could handle all the colors gone in the movie. As a female I like my pretty colors and would be ten times more upset if they where gone then some bandanna color change.

Revan
04-05-2010, 07:31 PM
To address the statement that you'll tell the difference via voice and other such things? Remember the trailer for the first movie when Mike says "I love being a turtle!" It was Raph's voice.
Folks say Hollywood thinks the audience is stupid. I disagree. Hollywood is stupid, the director, actors, and crew would not be able to tell the difference without the different colors...
It actually wasn't Josh's voice. But it was totally random and you are so right about hollywood dumbing things down. I don't see the problem with watching an intelligent movie that makes you think about what is going on.

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/white.jpg

The Stryker
04-05-2010, 08:21 PM
There's a difference between a movie making you think and not knowing which character is which at a glance.

Leo656
04-06-2010, 04:24 PM
Were they ? If they were all this would make a hell of alot more sense. :lol:

I wasn't there, but given the era/timeframe, the relative goofiness inherent in the idea itself, and the fact that most "artistic" people (whether it be writers, visual artists, musicians, etc.) tend to "heighten" their creativity with chemicals and other substances, I would bet money that Kev and Pete were doing massive bong rips when they created the TMNT. I'm pretty sure "staying up late watching bad tv" or whatever they say inspired the turtles' creation is code for the unspoken "plus we were really baked."

Not saying definitely but... it's a little naive to think otherwise, in my opinion.

Samhain
04-06-2010, 05:17 PM
I wasn't there, but given the era/timeframe, the relative goofiness inherent in the idea itself, and the fact that most "artistic" people (whether it be writers, visual artists, musicians, etc.) tend to "heighten" their creativity with chemicals and other substances, I would bet money that Kev and Pete were doing massive bong rips when they created the TMNT. I'm pretty sure "staying up late watching bad tv" or whatever they say inspired the turtles' creation is code for the unspoken "plus we were really baked."

Not saying definitely but... it's a little naive to think otherwise, in my opinion.

Lmao yeah I agree.

Powder
04-07-2010, 01:22 AM
Like you said- that was code for being stoned. I've had to word things differently to tell stoner stories in the past & thats one of the top excuses. Bad tv, hyped on 'junk food & sugar', so tired we were delirious, & so on...

I mean look at pictures of them from back in the day... c'mon.

plastroncafe
04-07-2010, 10:29 AM
You've got to give them credit though, it's not every day that a stoner idea is so successful. Usually they just end up looking like jibberish the morning after.

Samhain
04-07-2010, 01:44 PM
You've got to give them credit though, it's not every day that a stoner idea is so successful. Usually they just end up looking like jibberish the morning after.

I believe the Tmnt was just so ridiculously close to being one of those ''crazy ideas''. But it wasnt. LOL.

Leo656
04-12-2010, 12:24 AM
Thank god for that, I say. They could've just gone to White Castle and forgotten the whole thing like the rest of us do when we're up til 3am watching Speed Racer cartoons.

Cipher
04-12-2010, 04:31 PM
I'm pretty sure "staying up late watching bad tv" or whatever they say inspired the turtles' creation is code for the unspoken "plus we were really baked."Hahaha. I've thought this for years, and I'm glad someone else finally pointed it out.

There's no reason to work "staying up late watching bad tv" into the story everytime otherwise. I'd be willing to place a fair bet on the fact that they were chemically altered in some way.

I wasn't there, but given the era/timeframe, the relative goofiness inherent in the idea itself, and the fact that most "artistic" people (whether it be writers, visual artists, musicians, etc.) tend to "heighten" their creativityThis is categorically false though. For every artist who uses drugs in their creative process, there are more who don't. Not that they don't use them otherwise, but they're not always inducive to creative output.

I know, personally, I can't write for sh*t when I'm under the influence. And believe me, I've tried.

plastroncafe
04-12-2010, 04:43 PM
This is categorically false though. For every artist who uses drugs in their creative process, there are more who don't. Not that they don't use them otherwise, but they're not always inducive to creative output.

I know, personally, I can't write for sh*t when I'm under the influence. And believe me, I've tried.

While I don't doubt your experiences, I do your assumption that there are more artists who don't, than who do. Mostly because no one has any real way of knowing what most artists do to inspire their creative process. There's no data to cite, and therefore no "false" statements.

Me personally? It's the company I'm with, rather than what I'm doing at the time, that inspires me the most. Usually though? That company involves the use of if not alcohol, than a significant amount of sugar and/or caffeine.

So you're guess is as good as mine as to what's actually going on there.

And I know one professional writer who is stone cold straight edge, but gets her inspiration from the routine of sitting down to write early in the morning with a yerba matte.

Cipher
04-12-2010, 05:12 PM
While I don't doubt your experiences, I do your assumption that there are more artists who don't, than who do. Mostly because no one has any real way of knowing what most artists do to inspire their creative process. There's no data to cite, and therefore no "false" statements.

Me personally? It's the company I'm with, rather than what I'm doing at the time, that inspires me the most. Usually though? That company involves the use of if not alcohol, than a significant amount of sugar and/or caffeine.I guess most of my experience is with other writers, since I'm going through an English program. I don't know anyone that gets f*cked up before writing. Mostly because, well, you're f*cked up and it's hard to be poetic or terse in that state.

It's probably (I'm just guessing) more prevalent among visual artists and musicians. Although I have a friend at a very experimental music school, and not only does he staunchly avoid all forms of drugs, lots of other students there do too.

Krutch
04-28-2010, 01:23 AM
Yeah, when I write I cant be the least bit intoxicated. I get too distracted.

Alot of my artist friends say they get baked before they draw, but when I'm with them I always see them get baked and never get any work done. They're just too lazy.

Mutated Turtle
05-25-2010, 02:35 AM
turtles should have red masks in the new movie

Andrew NDB
05-25-2010, 01:28 PM
I guess most of my experience is with other writers, since I'm going through an English program. I don't know anyone that gets f*cked up before writing.

Yeah, when I write I cant be the least bit intoxicated. I get too distracted.

I know a lot of guys in the industry and you two -- at least as far as comics go, I can't speak for novelists and the like -- are far closer to being the exceptions than the rule.

For myself, sipping on a martini is quite conducive to getting the creative juices flowing.

Venom
05-25-2010, 02:46 PM
That's how all the awesome crazy ass **** happens in comics!

"Duuude, what if Norman Osborn ****ing ruled the Marvel Universe?!"

Spitfire
05-25-2010, 02:52 PM
We refer to that as an "art crutch" at my school. The students that do work intoxicated obviously did so. They're work is usually the worst of the lot and funny enough they always take pride in the fact they have to be drunk/high to be creative. Writing something when you're stoned might sound like a good idea because your mind is "free" and "open", as people would put it, but you'll probably look back on it and go "Wtf". It's entirely possible to write bizarre and fun things when you're not stoned or intoxicated.

People do what they will but I'd find it hard to believe that some of the greatest writers sit around smoking joints while coming up with their best works. Drinking I can see more so but only to loosen up, being completely smashed isn't going to accomplish anything either.

Andrew NDB
05-25-2010, 03:01 PM
Writing something when you're stoned might sound like a good idea

A horrible idea, as far as I'm concerned. The few times I've ever smoked weed, all I did was feel stupid and want to sleep. Writing would be about the last thing on Earth I'd want to do at that point, though I do "get" that weed seems to affect different people radically differently.

People do what they will but I'd find it hard to believe that some of the greatest writers sit around smoking joints while coming up with their best works.

It helps them focus, I would imagine. Though not so much with weed (a downer) as I would imagine with coke or meth or the like.

Drinking I can see more so but only to loosen up, being completely smashed isn't going to accomplish anything either.

You do realize there's different sorts of intoxication, though? I mean, if I drink a few beers I feel boistrous and happy and all that, but it's a rather "stupid drunk." Sipping on some wine, or martinis, or the like is the polar opposite... can actually heighten the creative process and make it darn fun. Of course, like with anything, there eventually comes a plateau at which Gandalf is waiting for you with his wand yelling "YOU SHALL NOT PASS!" If you decide to ignore Gandalf and keep on drinking past this point, it's probably best to turn off the computer and come back to whatever you're working on the next day.

Then there's drinks like tequila or mezcal. Perhaps something about agave, but I drink these and I become extremely irritable and argumentative.

So yeah. There's not just "drunk" and "high." There's all sorts of different levels and conditions therein.

Spitfire
05-25-2010, 03:13 PM
Oh yeah and I agree. Like I said being buzzed I understand I just don't get people who like to be completely plastered or stoned out of their minds when writing. I've seen the kind of work it yields and I'm not very impressed.

Andrew NDB
05-25-2010, 03:22 PM
Like I said being buzzed I understand I just don't get people who like to be completely plastered or stoned out of their minds when writing.

Completely plastered or doped up, yeah, that's a little bit weird. Though then there's guys like Alan Moore who drink by the truckload nightly (and god knows what else), and yet still manage to turn in some of the most brilliant work you could ever hope to read.

Spitfire
05-25-2010, 04:16 PM
Very true. Alan Moore is English though, they drink alcohol like it's water over there. :lol:

Sidian
06-09-2010, 12:27 AM
i know im gonna get flamed by the comic purists but i hate the idea of all red bandannas. hate it. granted i think they probably could have used another color other than PURPLE but im way past the point of caring about that.

dont get me wrong..im smart enough to tell the difference. i just prefer to see the different colored masks...it just seems to separate them further as characters to me. especially when i see who each color is assigned to...it seems to fit for the most part...i could explain why but its kinda weird so ill just leave it at that lol.

bridgegrn
08-05-2010, 09:43 PM
random thought: the turtles are generally assumed to be red eared sliders right? maybe have a scene with the turtles without their masks, and all four of them could have the red, mask like markings on their faces. that way all 4 of them would look like they have red masks without losing the colored masks.

Charlotte_Sometimes
08-09-2010, 08:17 PM
I really don't see the point of all red masks. I mean, sure, it's more accurate to the Mirage comics, but honestly, the multi-colored masks was an improvement in a number of ways.

I suppose I'm not "fangirly" enough, and I'm sure I'll be called out as blasphemous for suggesting that color coded masks was a better idea than Eastman & Laird's idea of a monotone color... but oh well.

ooglafina
08-09-2010, 08:25 PM
I really don't see the point of all red masks. I mean, sure, it's more accurate to the Mirage comics, but honestly, the multi-colored masks was an improvement in a number of ways.

I suppose I'm not "fangirly" enough, and I'm sure I'll be called out as blasphemous for suggesting that color coded masks was a better idea than Eastman & Laird's idea of a monotone color... but oh well.

Oh yeah and I agree. Like I said being buzzed I understand I just don't get people who like to be completely plastered or stoned out of their minds when writing. I've seen the kind of work it yields and I'm not very impressed.

Okay, I don't really care about the idea of the red bandannas either. I don't think it will ever happen again either because the color coded bandannas are too ingrained in the minds of the public.

Now I want to resurrect the dead discussion from May, since I wasn't around then. I'm a creative writing major and I can honestly say that I've never ever been remotely high or drunk in any capacity. I know there's a history of alcoholism in my family and so I want to stay away from the whole thing.

Plus, I feel like it would really damage they way I process abstract and subconscious thought. The idea that you can only be drunk to be creative makes me think that they can't reach that abstract Zen part of the brain that you need to tap into. I want to know that I can reach into that part of myself whenever I need to and that I don't need a substance to help.

That's just the way I work though. I know that there are lots of writers and musicians and whatever that have done great things under the influence and maybe that works for them.

ToTheNines
08-09-2010, 08:31 PM
I suppose I'm not "fangirly" enough, and I'm sure I'll be called out as blasphemous for suggesting that color coded masks was a better idea than Eastman & Laird's idea of a monotone color... but oh well.

Certainly not blasphemous, just depends on your favorite Turtles interpretation is.

I don't have a particular favorite, but I like the idea of them looking like they're from the same clan.

Charlotte_Sometimes
08-09-2010, 08:39 PM
Certainly not blasphemous, just depends on your favorite Turtles interpretation is.

I don't have a particular favorite, but I like the idea of them looking like they're from the same clan.

I don't think there's any confusion of them not being from the same clan. Their attire is pretty identical.

No one has really questioned Ryu and Ken (from Street Fighter) being from seperate clans, even though one wears a white gi, and the other wears a red gi.

ToTheNines
08-09-2010, 08:45 PM
I don't think there's any confusion of them not being from the same clan. Their attire is pretty identical.

Ha, yeah... plus the whole "mutant turtle" thing lol.

I dunno, it just depends on the medium for me really. What I want most out of this movie is something new (to TMNT films), so I guess that's actually my main reasoning.

Andrew NDB
08-10-2010, 06:16 PM
No one has really questioned Ryu and Ken (from Street Fighter) being from seperate clans, even though one wears a white gi, and the other wears a red gi.

Huh? I wasn't aware there was anyone out there that actually believes that Ryu and Ken are ninja, let alone from any ninja clans.

Andrew NDB
08-10-2010, 06:17 PM
honestly, the multi-colored masks was an improvement in a number of ways.

Absolutely not. In no ways.

Koi
08-10-2010, 06:46 PM
Absolutely not. In no ways.

It kind of was, especially in the direction they were taking the show. Helps kids recognized the turtles, it was bright and colorful gave life to them, brought more personality to the characters.

plastroncafe
08-10-2010, 07:05 PM
It kind of was, especially in the direction they were taking the show. Helps kids recognized the turtles, it was bright and colorful gave life to them, brought more personality to the characters.

Forgive me if I fail to see the multiple color bandanna thing as having any other real purpose than the selling of more toys.

Kids aren't so simple that they can't tell one voice from another.

Charlotte_Sometimes
08-10-2010, 07:06 PM
Arella is right on the ball. Seperate colors gave individual uniqueness to the appearance of four who otherwise looked like complete clones.
I mean, it's a little sad when we have to see the TMNT with weapons in their hands at all times just to tell them appart.
And taking it a bit further with slightly different shades of green I found was a rather clever move too.

I'm not at all dumping on Eastman & Laird's original design, but I don't think it's logical to discard clever inovations on the TMNT just because it didn't come from the creators themselves.

Like, didn't E&L back in the Mirage days in the 80s pretty much hand over TMNT to various artists and writers and say "Go nuts"? So I don't think they're opose to creativeness.

Andrew NDB
08-10-2010, 07:38 PM
It kind of was, especially in the direction they were taking the show. Helps kids recognized the turtles,

Ah, so it helped children be lazy by providing an additional visual aid.

it was bright and colorful gave life to them, brought more personality to the characters.

If I put on a bright purple T-shirt, that somehow imbues me with more personality or life than I otherwise had with a plain white T-shirt? That's... cra -- ... eh, a very interesting stance.

Oniri
08-10-2010, 08:09 PM
I think we already have enough individually in the turtles. If you think about each turtle has a different:

1)voice
2)weapon
3)personality
4)skin tone
5) (depending on how they handle it) heights/size/body type

We don't really need the different color headbands to add "color" to the turtles because they already written and designed well individually. If anything, the type of "personality" you associate with the headband colors comes from the turtles, not the other way around. I'm not saying the color headbands are the worst thing that could happen. I just believe that throwing them in there just for the heck of it doesn't make sense, specially if there are going to be a lot of dark scenes in the movie in which the audience may not be able to view the headbands clearly anyway.

I did like idea of putting a little red around their eyes or near their eyes on their actual skin. Technically, they are red ear sliders and it would be nice to see a little nod to their humble beginnings. :)