PDA

View Full Version : (Possible Spoilers) The IDW TMNT New Issue Discussion Thread


Pages : 1 [2]

Abnormal Freak
08-30-2011, 02:14 PM
1. This new comic's completely different and apparently alters the origin, so you don't need to know anything about previous comics.

2. The multi-colored bandanna Hastings cover is indeed altered—real thing has all red, but otherwise that's a real cover.

3. It's in color, and it kicks ass.

Andrew NDB
08-30-2011, 02:16 PM
1-For someone who hasn't read Mirage outside of two or three issues, since this is a new continuity and a reboot right so I don't need to know anything about Mirage besides the basic origin

You don't even need to know that. The basic origin is different now.

and I can pick this up without worrying about the past?

Correct.

2-is that different bandannas cover a variant or fan made?

Fan made. Though I think that Sam Keith variant cover somehow made it out the door with the different colored bandannas... I guess if the rainbow brigade had to be on one of them it couldn't have been on a better cover -- that thing is ugly, man.

3- The comic is in color right?

Yeah.

How is the comic so far?

Pretty neat. Check it out.

sdp
08-30-2011, 02:55 PM
I think I will, I always wanted to read Mirage first but counting that no easy way to access yet this will have to do until that day. Thanks for the feedback, it definitely looks interesting and I wasn't looking forward to it after what I've seen IDW do to other franchises I like.

Oniri
08-30-2011, 02:58 PM
I haven't pick up a single issue for anything in a while. I usually wait till collected volumes for everything, but I couldn't hold out. I was not disappointed.

I understand what folks mean by the art style having a really sketchy look, but it doesn't bother me. It just seems like the artist's style.The whole book is pretty much equally "sketchy" and there isn't really any more defined drawings in the piece that sorely stands out. Plus, with any series, the artist's style tends to change/improve as his run continues.

Also, I think we need to chill on the 18 month thing. I'm sure they'll explain that and, if they don't, I don't think this is the worst thing possible plot/time-wise.

Last but not least, baby turtles were too adorable. I turned the page and it was instant ovary explosion.

1984TMNT
08-30-2011, 03:11 PM
I'll preface this by saying that I think there is a LOT that we can't see at the moment, so really, just about any scenario any of us come up with could be plausible. I am going to refrain from making any assumptions until we have more facts on what the new origin really is.

With that said.....I do have concerns so far on the origin and hope those concerns are put to bed - quickly. I do have faith in Tom and the rest of the crew and don't believe they are taking this title lightly. I DO believe they have a plan and have really thought through the stories they want to tell and the universe they want to paint for us. However, as I have stated before, I really hope that they don't veer so far away from the original origin that we lose the family aspect (including the years of growing up together, hidden, while learning to become ninja).

I'm definitely up for a few new spins on the Origin story, but would prefer that it's not drastically different than what we know. In the end, I think this has the potential to be a great "re-boot" of the franchise, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they have to completely re-invent the wheel on the origin. The origin works, so why change it drastically? They can take this franchise in so many different and new directions with stories that take place post origin and it will feel natural. The TMNT still retain their classic origin tale (which connects all fans with a foundation of exactly what the TMNT are and represent) while providing completely new tales, characters, etc for everyone to discover (while sprinkling in some familiar ones as well).

I guess that would be my ideal version of this new universe.

Donnie
08-30-2011, 08:23 PM
Last but not least, baby turtles were too adorable. I turned the page and it was instant ovary explosion.

:lol:

You made a funny!

yagyu
08-31-2011, 04:05 AM
I liked the story, it was awesome to see the new take on General Krang. Honestly the art style didnt impress me. I was really hoping for a more stylized look, but im sure it will grow on me. Not saying i hate it or anything, just that it wasnt what I was hoping for lol.

Xav
08-31-2011, 01:46 PM
I liked the story, it was awesome to see the new take on General Krang. Though I don't think Krang has every been called General before.

Raven
08-31-2011, 07:29 PM
Im intrigued.

My first read through had me at the edge of my seat, I was expecting the same ole same ole with the origin story. But after reading some of what you guys have said here about the first issue I was a bit put off, not sure if I was going to like what was going to happen.

After reading it, I was impressed with a simple new perspective and look at the turtles history. A super Solider mutagen at first sounds kind of unimpressive, but the more that I thought about the question "Why would there be mutagen in the first place" really got me thinking. Old Hob was fun, while a short glimpse of what we are in store for only a day after reading Im hooked and want more.

I was really happy to see no mention of the foot or shredder, those guys are great but the Turtles have so much more they can offer. Im excited to see what awaits us, and how all these plots will intertwine.


I gave it a 9/10

TheCanadiandrome
09-01-2011, 03:03 AM
Once I get my copy I'm goingbto read it then see about possibly subbin so I can get the future issues with no problems

Rooish
09-01-2011, 10:43 AM
Okay I haven't posted in like three years, but there are so many new awesome things going on that I'm re-obsessed with the Turtles! I feel like I've come home.

I really like the new comic and am so far okay with the tweaked origin. I liked the art too but I haven't really been reading other comics these days, so I don't know if the art is less "professional" than normal. It's cool to have a colour comic though, and I think I like the all-red headbands? I know it's how they're supposed to be and the multi-colours are hokey, but I've always liked them anyway, thinking the colours really fit the Turtles' personalities and helped to define them. And I think all-black headbands would work better than all-red. But that's neither here nor there--you can tell who the Turtles are by their weapons and a good illustrator and writer makes them identifyable by their personalities, too. Like even if there weren't different skin colours, that is so obviously Mike and not Don that Splinter is holding back when Old Hob taunts them about Raphael. Anyway, I like the art and the gritty feel.

It's odd, though, that Eastman does such detailed awesome layouts (as shown in the back of the comic) and then someone with an entirely different style draws the comic. Too bad Eastman doesn't just pencil the thing!

Raphael without a mask or pupils did indeed look a bit creepy, as someone else said. I know it is weird that their pupils disappear when they put on the masks... so whatever, but I actually wouldn't mind if the Turtles just had pupils in general. More realistic and expressive.

Old Hob: What the heck, another mutant? Who is leading those gangsters, no questions asked? I do like when the Turtles and Splinter are kind of unique, when there aren't mutants all over the place. But it seems we will never get a comic like that.

Awesome that the Turtles and Splinter were part of military experiments. I bet there's going to be a huge chase to find them at some point in this comic, which I always wanted to see.

As for the mutated Turtles being like a bit over a year old... really weird. I think that the Turtles and Splinter could have still formed close bonds in that amount of time if they are all they ever knew, but I don't think they could have mastered the English language or learned martial arts.

Anyway! I'm looking forward to devouring these comics as they come out!

CyberCubed
09-01-2011, 03:19 PM
The origin story has me confused because well...it makes it seem like Hamato Yoshi and Shredder have absolutely nothing to do with Splinter or the Turtles at all.

These Turtles/Splinter are lab animals, they have nothing to do with the Foot Clan, Hamato Yoshi isn't Splinter's owner...etc.

I liked the way they handled April (she's more or less the same), Baxter (again, pretty much as we know him), Casey (nice origin), and even Krang, but otherwise its confusing.

The Turtles origins have always been linked with the Foot Clan and Hamato Yoshi/Shredder in every incarnation, so to see it left out altogether is...weird to say the least.

Andrew NDB
09-01-2011, 03:28 PM
I don't even want to speculate too much this early into things but right now, yes, the origin of these Turtles does seem much more rooted in the sci-fi than any kind of ninja intrigue. But that may quickly change.

CyberCubed
09-01-2011, 03:34 PM
I don't even want to speculate too much this early into things but right now, yes, the origin of these Turtles does seem much more rooted in the sci-fi than any kind of ninja intrigue. But that may quickly change.

Which makes you wonder why are they trained to be ninja's? If Splinter doesn't have any Japanese backstory or link with Hamato Yoshi or the Foot Clan whatsoever, how does it all make sense?

The whole origin seems like its done in a way to totally ignore anything to do with Yoshi/Shredder/Foot Clan altogether.

Also, did anyone else not like the idea of April naming the Turtles? I know its probably minor, but it just seems wrong not to see Splinter name them.

Toby Barrett
09-01-2011, 03:37 PM
We only know a very small fraction about the new turtles' origins. I'm more than certain they'll surprise us in how it all works out.

CyberCubed
09-01-2011, 03:43 PM
We only know a very small fraction about the new turtles' origins. I'm more than certain they'll surprise us in how it all works out.

That is true, but it would be kinda hard to link everything with Hamato Yoshi, Shredder, Foot Clan if these animals were always lab animals.

I guess I'll wait and see, but I don't really like this new origin. And keep in mind I love different takes on characters and have enjoyed every TMNT universe.

A little *too* Raph
09-01-2011, 06:07 PM
Ok, I'm a slacker and just read the first issue (eastman color variant!). I read the first few pages of the thread but not the whole thing so I'm sure I will be repeating what has been said, but I enjoyed it. I have never actually read a TMNT series from the beginning so I'm looking forward to this experience.

I also like all of the theories about the origin, it will be exciting to see where they take it.

The art actually doesn't bother me as much as I thought it would. Can't wait for the next issue.

Powder
09-01-2011, 08:44 PM
I have never actually read a TMNT series from the beginning so I'm looking forward to this experience.


I'll take this opportunity to echo the same statement. Been a fan since I was like, 18 months old, but I never did get it right.
It's quite exciting. ;)

Jester
09-01-2011, 09:10 PM
Ditto. The only TMNT comic I followed previously was the Archie series, but I didn't have the first issues...so this is my first "start at 1" for the Green Machine.

LeoNerdo
09-01-2011, 09:16 PM
Same goes for me. I'm incredibly stoked to be able to follow this incarnation from the beginning.

Donnie
09-01-2011, 09:21 PM
Same here, but that's because we were all too young to actually follow a comic series when we couldn't even operate a vehicle/work for money. Not to mention, I didn't really understand how comics worked back then. I used to just see a cover I thought was cool and get it. Hence why I ended up having one of those atrocious V.1 issues with Raph and that space alien. Number 38. Ugh. Gives me nightmares.

ToTheNines
09-01-2011, 09:25 PM
Same here, but that's because we were all too young to actually follow a comic series when we couldn't even operate a vehicle/work for money. Not to mention, I didn't really understand how comics worked back then. I used to just see a cover I thought was cool and get it. Hence why I ended up having one of those atrocious V.1 issues with Raph and that space alien. Number 38. Ugh. Gives me nightmares.

Think of the poor kids who read "Raphael: Bad Moon Rising" after seeing Ross Campbell's awesome cover art lol.

Coola Yagami
09-01-2011, 09:36 PM
Hmm my thoughts on the comic... pretty awesome. The fighting was cool, I just wish they didn't zoom-in too much on the hands and feet though. I'm surprised how human-like Old Hob looked though. Compared to the Turtles and Splinter, Hob looked more like a furry guy with a cat face than a weird humanoid cat. Still wondering how he got that gang to work for him, but we have to see.

The new origin is interesting, I'm also glad April was kept as a young adult. Mikey is cool so far, let's hope he doesn't annoy his brothers to no end like he did in the 2K3 version.

I guess while part of me wants to start with a clean slate when reading this, part of me still feels this kinda sounds like bad fanfiction except for the fact that it's actually in print and on sale in a shop. The new lab-type origin, a new mutant bad guy, inclusion of Krang (since alot of fans like to add OT elements to their fanfics) and a slightly 2K3-sh April and Baxter... and Raph mysteriously missing (don't the fics always have someone missing or dead, at least Raph is still alive).

I'm anxious to see issue 2. I'd love to finally have an on-going TMNT comic series again. Was too young for Mirage's first run, and the DW comics died after 5 or 6 issues... and Tales is basically random tales going from past, present to future and in-between. Not since the Archies have I had a good on-going TMNT series with an on-going storyline. So this will be my new hobby.

Jephael
09-01-2011, 09:38 PM
I for one like where they're going with this comic. So what if the characters' origins are changed? Atleast they still start out as ordinary turtles and Splinter starts out an ordinary rat. The only thing that kinda bothers me is Casey being abused by his father, though that's only because in the 4Kids series Casey's dad was a loving and caring person.

Donnie
09-01-2011, 09:39 PM
Think of the poor kids who read "Raphael: Bad Moon Rising" after seeing Ross Campbell's awesome cover art lol.

I've never read "Bad Moon Rising"...it's that bad?!

CyberCubed
09-01-2011, 09:41 PM
I've never read "Bad Moon Rising"...it's that bad?!

Its pretty bad as far as Mirage comics go.

Coola Yagami
09-01-2011, 10:13 PM
I for one like where they're going with this comic. So what if the characters' origins are changed? Atleast they still start out as ordinary turtles and Splinter starts out an ordinary rat. The only thing that kinda bothers me is Casey being abused by his father, though that's only because in the 4Kids series Casey's dad was a loving and caring person.

He wasn't in the DW version of the series though....

Bauer536
09-01-2011, 10:35 PM
I for one like where they're going with this comic. So what if the characters' origins are changed? Atleast they still start out as ordinary turtles and Splinter starts out an ordinary rat. The only thing that kinda bothers me is Casey being abused by his father, though that's only because in the 4Kids series Casey's dad was a loving and caring person.

Casey's dad may be a loving and caring person . . . except when he is drunk. We'll just have to see.:tsmile:

CyberCubed
09-02-2011, 12:47 AM
BTW did Chet's dialouge bother anyone else in this issue? The way he would constantly say, "Um," and "Heh" as if he was talking so slowly. It took forever to read through his speech bubbles.

Powder
09-02-2011, 12:50 AM
It didn't bother me, it just had me curious. Is he nervous? Is he hiding something? Is he slow? Does he like April?
I'm sure there's more to it...

CyberCubed
09-02-2011, 01:03 AM
Its odd how only April and Baxter seem much more in line with their Mirage counterparts than any other character. Yeah, Baxter is working for Krang and April names the Turtles, but other than that they're pretty similar.

The Turtles personalities seem mostly the same, but if their whole origin is different it fundamentally changes how one would look at the characters. Splinter is probably the biggest change, with no mention if he's Hamato Yoshi's pet or anything to do with the Foot. I also think Splinter is watching over the Turtles in a way, given he seems to constantly jump up to where they are. I don't know why though.

Funny, I thought the addition of a mutant cat like Old Hob would be the biggest change in this continuity...but he actually turned out to be the least of my worries in this issue. Its the whole changing of the Turtles/Splinter's origin that's the big question mark here.

azrael
09-02-2011, 04:07 PM
BTW did Chet's dialouge bother anyone else in this issue? The way he would constantly say, "Um," and "Heh" as if he was talking so slowly. It took forever to read through his speech bubbles.

I think he is a Utrom.

azrael
09-02-2011, 04:08 PM
Its odd how only April and Baxter seem much more in line with their Mirage counterparts than any other character. Yeah, Baxter is working for Krang and April names the Turtles, but other than that they're pretty similar.

The Turtles personalities seem mostly the same, but if their whole origin is different it fundamentally changes how one would look at the characters. Splinter is probably the biggest change, with no mention if he's Hamato Yoshi's pet or anything to do with the Foot. I also think Splinter is watching over the Turtles in a way, given he seems to constantly jump up to where they are. I don't know why though.

Funny, I thought the addition of a mutant cat like Old Hob would be the biggest change in this continuity...but he actually turned out to be the least of my worries in this issue. Its the whole changing of the Turtles/Splinter's origin that's the big question mark here.

I wouldnt worry about it or have the ?marks until its done if you dont like by then maybe ignore that part and enjoy some turtles of the teenage mutant variety

CyberCubed
09-02-2011, 11:50 PM
The more I think about it, the more I dislike the super soldier plot brewing. Its just so overdone. I also can't help but wonder what war General Krang is talking about. If its not a human war, how would Baxter know what it was?

I've got a bad feeling about the Turtles origins, and why its only been 12 months in flashbacks...they're probably going to be injected with "ninja fighting abilities" into their DNA from the super soldier program, so they quickly learn how to fight, rather than being trained for 15 years.

It really does feel like stuff is being changed just for the sake of stuff being changed. I hope I am wrong.

azrael
09-03-2011, 07:22 AM
What if they are still studing, the mutagen would prove to give them possible, enhanced learning capabilities meaning their study time would be a lot shorter than say ours. I do hope its not ninja fighting techniques injections.

Bauer536
09-03-2011, 03:14 PM
The more I think about it, the more I dislike the super soldier plot brewing. Its just so overdone. I also can't help but wonder what war General Krang is talking about. If its not a human war, how would Baxter know what it was?

I've got a bad feeling about the Turtles origins, and why its only been 12 months in flashbacks...they're probably going to be injected with "ninja fighting abilities" into their DNA from the super soldier program, so they quickly learn how to fight, rather than being trained for 15 years.

It really does feel like stuff is being changed just for the sake of stuff being changed. I hope I am wrong.

I don't know. I remember Leo saying, "Guys! Remember what Master Splinter taught us!" That should mean that the rat is still the sensei, and that the turtles are not going to get injected with ninja abilities.

Donnie
09-03-2011, 04:37 PM
I don't know. I remember Leo saying, "Guys! Remember what Master Splinter taught us!" That should mean that the rat is still the sensei, and that the turtles are not going to get injected with ninja abilities.

Good point Bauer!

Spitfire
09-05-2011, 02:48 AM
Didn't like it. References/homages to past material fell completely flat. Didn't find the new origin twists clever. I don't mind mixing things up and change is good but only when it's done well. Really don't like the art that much. The perspective on some of those shots is way out of whack. The groin kick comes to mind.

Glad it sold out and something turtles is doing well but the second issue better raise the bar cause right now it's sitting on the floor waiting to trip someone.

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 09:16 AM
Didn't like it. References/homages to past material fell completely flat. Didn't find the new origin twists clever. I don't mind mixing things up and change is good but only when it's done well. Really don't like the art that much. The perspective on some of those shots is way out of whack. The groin kick comes to mind.

Glad it sold out and something turtles is doing well but the second issue better raise the bar cause right now it's sitting on the floor waiting to trip someone.

I kinda agree, but again, its only the first issue.

I hope this origin makes more sense in the next few issues.

Spitfire
09-05-2011, 12:25 PM
It's not even about it making sense to me. It's stuff like April naming them, which ruins part of the bond between them and Splinter in my opinion. I get that April was always like their surrogate Mother in the comics but did they really have to go so far with that idea?

I also really can't stressed how strained and obvious the references. It's not clever or funny at all that Raph finds a Cowabunga t-shirt after dumpster diving for pizza.

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 03:52 PM
It does almost feel like fanfiction at times, where someone is trying to blend TMNT universes together.

Also did anyone not like how many times Baxter paused to say General Krang? It was as if they purposely name dropped it several times in case we somehow missed it the first time.

I can just imagine Krang in the body of a robot Russian General with a white beard.

Toby Barrett
09-05-2011, 04:20 PM
It's not even about it making sense to me. It's stuff like April naming them, which ruins part of the bond between them and Splinter in my opinion. I get that April was always like their surrogate Mother in the comics but did they really have to go so far with that idea?

I also really can't stressed how strained and obvious the references. It's not clever or funny at all that Raph finds a Cowabunga t-shirt after dumpster diving for pizza.

Personally, after seeing the same origin over and over again through different forms of media, I find the new origin to be fresh and interesting so far! It certainly has me excited and wondering about all the possibilities of what could happen over the next few months, and to me, that's what a good comic SHOULD do!

LeoNerdo
09-05-2011, 04:49 PM
I thought the first issue was most enjoyable when I put the Mirage continuity out of mind, much like I do when I read the Archie Adventures issues. It doesn't try to be and doesn't have to be the same. Let this thing be it's own animal.

TheCanadiandrome
09-05-2011, 05:21 PM
damn i wish CP would hurry up and deliver this to me! grrrr... i hate waiting!

Venom
09-05-2011, 05:54 PM
damn i wish CP would hurry up and deliver this to me! grrrr... i hate waiting!

.........e_e

Revan
09-05-2011, 06:06 PM
I thought the first issue was most enjoyable when I put the Mirage continuity out of mind, much like I do when I read the Archie Adventures issues. It doesn't try to be and doesn't have to be the same. Let this thing be it's own animal.

That makes sense.

Though I think there is something cool about delivering the entire origin story in a single issue the way mirage did it. We got the history, it worked, and then they dove right into adventures. IDW wouldn't do that since they knew they would be publishing several books which is a luxury PL and KE didn't have when they first produced TMNT #1

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 07:27 PM
People don't like the new origin because:

1. The turtles and splinter being lab animals instead of just being ordinary animals in pet stores makes things needlessly more generic.

2. April names the turtles instead of Splinter, thus ruining the family bond.

3. The 12 month flashbacks makes it seem like they've only been mutated 1 year instead of being teenagers.

4. No mention of Japan, Yoshi or Saki. If splinter has no connection with them, then why the hell are the turtles trained? This also completely ruins the rivalry with Shredder and the Foot. It now has no connection.

5. The super soldier program means that the turtles are being bred for combat.
5.

Toby Barrett
09-05-2011, 07:34 PM
I like it, and I'm a people.

Powder
09-05-2011, 07:47 PM
People don't like the new origin because:

1. The turtles and splinter being lab animals instead of just being ordinary animals in pet stores makes things needlessly more generic.

2. April names the turtles instead of Splinter, thus ruining the family bond.

3. The 12 month flashbacks makes it seem like they've only been mutated 1 year instead of being teenagers.

4. No mention of Japan, Yoshi or Saki. If splinter has no connection with them, then why the hell are the turtles trained? This also completely ruins the rivalry with Shredder and the Foot. It now has no connection.

5. The super soldier program means that the turtles are being bred for combat.


1. Doesn't bother me.

2. I thought it was kinda cute.

3. It's suspect, but I'm open-minded and eager to see how that works out.

4. In due time, surely.

5. We don't know that at all, don't treat it as a fact. & if that's the case, again, I'll go with the flow & see how it goes. Could be neat.

Master Splinter
09-05-2011, 08:06 PM
People don't like the new origin because:

1. The turtles and splinter being lab animals instead of just being ordinary animals in pet stores makes things needlessly more generic.

2. April names the turtles instead of Splinter, thus ruining the family bond.

3. The 12 month flashbacks makes it seem like they've only been mutated 1 year instead of being teenagers.

4. No mention of Japan, Yoshi or Saki. If splinter has no connection with them, then why the hell are the turtles trained? This also completely ruins the rivalry with Shredder and the Foot. It now has no connection.

5. The super soldier program means that the turtles are being bred for combat.
5.

First off I love the new origin so far. I think it is going to be an interesting story.

1)How is that generic? Have you ever read a story that involved a rat, four turtles that are being held in a mad scientists lab where mutating chemicals will more than likely mutate these animals into ninja fighting creatures?

2)How is April naming the turtles ruining the family bond? April was an important part of the turtles lives. Basically family herself. This is just a different way of telling a story.

3)Anything is possible in the comic world.

4)We have only read 1 issue so far. Let's see where it goes, there may be more history then what has been told. Don't get ahead of yourself.

5)More than likely. Sounds cool.

-ms

Spitfire
09-05-2011, 09:45 PM
I thought the first issue was most enjoyable when I put the Mirage continuity out of mind, much like I do when I read the Archie Adventures issues. It doesn't try to be and doesn't have to be the same. Let this thing be it's own animal.
Except I didn't have to do that to enjoy Archie and we were distinctly told Mirage was a huge part of the influence. All I see is red bandannas and some character names. Nothing else Mirage is intact. That's not even what bothers me though. Again I could careless it's different it's just not different in a way I think is very good. Anyone can do a spin on a origin story and with a franchise like turtles it should be clever and offer something to the built in fanbase. I guess because most TMNT fans will love and accept virtually anything, at first glance anyways, they didn't feel much work was needed. I had zero excitement that something new turtles was coming out. With that gone all I got was a mediocre comic with barely passable art and okay writing.

Donnie
09-05-2011, 09:48 PM
CyberCubed, just settle down. It's only the first issue - Tom Waltz has stated that the Turtles/Splinter's family bond is one of his favorite facets of the entire title - they aren't just going to write it off as insignificant. Jeesh.

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 10:26 PM
CyberCubed, just settle down. It's only the first issue - Tom Waltz has stated that the Turtles/Splinter's family bond is one of his favorite facets of the entire title - they aren't just going to write it off as insignificant. Jeesh.

They'll become a family after they're mutated, as we'll see in flashbacks, but it still doesn't account for pre-mutation. Remember, Splinter as a normal rat cared for the Turtles just as the mutagen was beginning to take effect.

I also really don't like April naming the Turtles. She is their big sister and first human friend, but her naming them makes her seem like the mother.

Lastly, how would you guys feel if Splinter was always a normal lab rat, and had no connection to Hamato Yoshi or the Foot? That would mean Splinter/Turtles would have no reason to consider Shredder their mortal enemy.

Powder
09-05-2011, 10:47 PM
That would mean Splinter/Turtles would have no reason to consider Shredder their mortal enemy.

Who the hell said that? No one? Right, nobody. THERE HAS BEEN ONE ISSUE, JUST RELAX.

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 10:54 PM
Who the hell said that? No one? Right, nobody. THERE HAS BEEN ONE ISSUE, JUST RELAX.

I am fine with waiting, but I hope Splinter isn't from America and we find out Yoshi was killed along the way and THEN Splinter got captured and put into this lab.

As long as Splinter has some memory of Hamato Yoshi I guess it would be fine.

Powder
09-05-2011, 10:56 PM
Yoshi was killed along the way and THEN Splinter got captured and put into this lab.

That would be fine with me... What's wrong with that? They both came from Japan.

CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 10:58 PM
That would be fine with me... What's wrong with that? They both came from Japan.

I kind of figure that's why we get a close up of Splinter's normal rat face looking a bit sad in the lab, but I dunno.

Maybe he is also looking after the Turtles because they were Yoshi's pet turtles too? He did seem to constantly jump up to their container.

Bauer536
09-06-2011, 05:49 AM
I don't really hate the idea . . . so far. It does kind of bother me a little bit. I'm not too crazy for this Old Hob, but I like this Stockman and General Krang relationship. Plus, I don't get that "Cowabunga!" t-shirt as much. Why was it rude to Raph. It's just a saying. Plus, the humans don't know who they are. That I felt was kind of thrown in.:tconfuse:

Besides, when does Issue#2 come out?:tconfuse: I've gotta pick this one up at my comic book store.

Powder
09-06-2011, 10:04 AM
I don't really hate the idea . . . so far. It does kind of bother me a little bit. I'm not too crazy for this Old Hob, but I like this Stockman and General Krang relationship. Plus, I don't get that "Cowabunga!" t-shirt as much. Why was it rude to Raph. It's just a saying. Plus, the humans don't know who they are. That I felt was kind of thrown in.:tconfuse:

Besides, when does Issue#2 come out?:tconfuse: I've gotta pick this one up at my comic book store.

Raph didn't think it was rude, just stupid. & every issue comes out one month after the last, always on a Wednesday.

Venom
09-06-2011, 12:37 PM
Raph didn't think it was rude, just stupid. & every issue comes out one month after the last, always on a Wednesday.

I have always liked "Cowabunga".

That's the one exlamation I think the comics shouldn't bash and forget; it sounds better than "Great googly-moogly!" or "Goongala goongala!".

It's a great phrase! Simply use it in appropriate places and don't overuse it and it would work fine.

LeoNerdo
09-06-2011, 01:59 PM
I have always liked "Cowabunga".

That's the one exlamation I think the comics shouldn't bash and forget; it sounds better than "Great googly-moogly!" or "Goongala goongala!".

It's a great phrase! Simply use it in appropriate places and don't overuse it and it would work fine.

THIS. I agree 100%. I have to say though, I also still enjoy all Mikey's 'radical, totally tubu-loso, mondo notions' from the OT....

Jester
09-06-2011, 02:09 PM
COWABUNGA!!

That good?

Rise1184
09-06-2011, 06:57 PM
After reading the new issue and some of the comments, I felt a variety of feelings. Part of me was "cool, something different", then the other part was, "things seem a bit rushed". I don't know, I honestly just got into the Mirage comics a year or so ago, along with already having the common knowledge of the OG toons and movies. I just felt something was missing, or just too much information was thrown too quickly. But this is a "reboot", so I am willing to be open minded about the differences. Perhaps there will be a bigger plan for the climax of this series, I can't wait to find out.

Other than that, I have a good feeling about the series, and I'm enjoying it so far.

CyberCubed
09-06-2011, 11:20 PM
I hope we see Old Hob as a normal cat in the lab in the next few issues. It would explain the rivalry with Splinter, if they had battles as normal animals before mutated.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-08-2011, 04:40 PM
Raph didn't think it was rude, just stupid. & every issue comes out one month after the last, always on a Wednesday.

So is the next one due out on the 21st, or the 28th?

Sheesh, I haven't even gotten my copies of #1 yet, and it's almost time to order #2. The pre-order options that were up on ebay for it are gone now.

DrSpengler
09-08-2011, 05:34 PM
it sounds better than "Great googly-moogly!"

Good lord, THIS.

Reading through the Archie comics, I absolutely loathe that catchphrase Murphy coined.

oldmanwinters
09-08-2011, 05:50 PM
I have always liked "Cowabunga".

That's the one exlamation I think the comics shouldn't bash and forget; it sounds better than "Great googly-moogly!" or "Goongala goongala!".

It's a great phrase! Simply use it in appropriate places and don't overuse it and it would work fine.

It's kinda funny in an ironic way. It seems that each new incarnation of TMNT tries so hard not to embrace its most popular era. It doesn't need to clone the old cartoon or live action movies, but it would be nice to see them given a bit more respect. *sigh*

Bauer536
09-08-2011, 09:58 PM
Hey guys. I've been looking at a few of the threads on the comic, and I'm a little worried. Where is this going? It doesn't really sound like the comics are doing (or going to do) that well. What's going on?

Coola Yagami
09-08-2011, 10:07 PM
I think it's cause they try so hard to make it seem like 'this isn't the 80's TMNT anymore'. Like, they used to say Cowabunga alot, but this new take is so fresh and so new, they actually *gasp!!!!* hate the phrase.

ToTheNines
09-08-2011, 10:10 PM
Hating "cowabunga" has become more cliche than saying it.

However, the way I looked at it after reading several times, is that Raph is probably trying to not think about his family since he ran away, and pulling out a shirt that says "cowabunga" on it made him think of Mike. That explains the "now that's just wrong" line. For me, at least.

CyberCubed
09-08-2011, 11:26 PM
Its just what is well known to casual fans. Pizza, Cowabunga...etc....that's why you always see these random shout-outs.

Didn't the Image series do something like this too? I can't remember exactly though.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-08-2011, 11:59 PM
Its just what is well known to casual fans. Pizza, Cowabunga...etc....that's why you always see these random shout-outs.

Didn't the Image series do something like this too? I can't remember exactly though.

They did, but half of the time it was more of an attempt to be sarcastic and present a harsh critique of the "mainstream" TMNT-- the Venus parody was a great example.

TheCanadiandrome
09-09-2011, 12:31 AM
finally got my copy of number one and i love it! i want more!

***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-10-2011, 07:36 PM
I finally read this book today and LOVED it.

Was I the only one who read this and was immediately struck by similarities in the art and writing style to the DreamWave book?

We probably won't get to see General Krang's face until later in the series, the same as was the case with Mr. Null-- and I'm thinking he is going to turn out to be some sort of renegade Utrom posing as a human (like Ch'rell). This may be the case in the Nick cartoon as well.

Powder
09-10-2011, 07:56 PM
We probably won't get to see General Krang's face until later in the series, the same as was the case with Mr. Null-- and I'm thinking he is going to turn out to be some sort of renegade Utrom posing as a human (like Ch'rell).

That's the same impression I got about it.

CyberCubed
09-10-2011, 08:00 PM
I hope Krang isn't an Utrom. Homages are pointless when they completely change the character.

Powder
09-10-2011, 08:14 PM
I hope Krang isn't an Utrom. Homages are pointless when they completely change the character.

Krang might as well be an Utrom though, really.

Jester
09-10-2011, 08:15 PM
Krang might as well be an Utrom though, really.
Depending on how you view the old daily TMNT comic strips, he actually IS an Utrom.

CyberCubed
09-10-2011, 08:19 PM
Depending on how you view the old daily TMNT comic strips, he actually IS an Utrom.

Krang and the Utroms may share a common ancestor but they are
different.

I also imagine Krang's war is with the Utroms, like Shredder in the 4kids series.

hobcjm
09-13-2011, 08:25 AM
I for one am totally on board with this new series. Granted, it could just be the fanboy in me excited to be able to start collecting from issue 1 onwards, but I enjoyed Dan Duncan's artwork and what we got of the story so far.

The story point that's burning me up inside has nothing to do with April naming the turtles, or their fifteen month accelerated growth. It's with what the hell happened between Old Hob and Raphael? What did he do that shamed/upset Raphael into leaving his brothers? And why do they believe him to be dead?

Also, that final page has me hanging for more. I can't wait to pick up #2 to see Raph lay some smack down on Casey's dad!

CyberCubed
09-14-2011, 07:38 PM
It's with what the hell happened between Old Hob and Raphael? What did he do that shamed/upset Raphael into leaving his brothers?

Oddly enough out of all the things going on, this is one of the least things that I care about finding the answer.

Donnie
09-14-2011, 08:05 PM
The story point that's burning me up inside has nothing to do with April naming the turtles, or their fifteen month accelerated growth. It's with what the hell happened between Old Hob and Raphael? What did he do that shamed/upset Raphael into leaving his brothers? And why do they believe him to be dead?


I have been wondering about this too, and I think it's probably the most undiscussed question about the new series. Possibly because nobody has any idea what could have happened that would have been so drastic - there are absolutely no clues from anything we've been given. Maybe Raphael feels responsible for someone's death, someone that was close to Splinter? Who knows...

Oh, I got it! Raphael feels responsible for the death of...HAMATO YOSHI!

:P

ToTheNines
09-15-2011, 08:06 PM
Apparently the book sold over 34,000 copies. That's really really good. Better than any other non-DC /Marvel book.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=34381

TobTurn
09-16-2011, 07:28 PM
What if it's special martial arts-mutagen or something like that, or ninjutsu-mutagen? It gives the mutated people/creatures martial arts-skills. That could explain the incredibly short time in which they learned to fight.

Jester
09-16-2011, 08:00 PM
What if it's special martial arts-mutagen or something like that, or ninjutsu-mutagen? It gives the mutated people/creatures martial arts-skills. That could explain the incredibly short time in which they learned to fight.
it also kinda kills the rat master angle. Is Splinter just another mutant ninja fighter, or did he train the turtles? Heck, Leo even says "like Splinter taught us" in issue 1...it's gonna be interesting how they deal with this.

oldmanwinters
09-16-2011, 10:14 PM
it also kinda kills the rat master angle. Is Splinter just another mutant ninja fighter, or did he train the turtles? Heck, Leo even says "like Splinter taught us" in issue 1...it's gonna be interesting how they deal with this.

Implanted memories, ala, the Weapon X project!:tconfuse:

Jester
09-16-2011, 10:22 PM
Implanted memories, ala, the Weapon X project!:tconfuse:
I really hope not...

Jester
09-17-2011, 08:18 PM
Ok...who hasn't been able to track down a copy? I plan on going back to one of my LCS to pick up a copy for Hero (if you still need me too...PM me if you still need one.) and I can totally pick up multiple copies...if need be. Just shoot me a PM if you want me to go ahead and pick up a basic copy of TMNT 1.

Toby Barrett
09-19-2011, 05:47 PM
IDW released a preview for TMNT #2 today! (http://issuu.com/idwpublishing/docs/tmnt-ong-02-preview?viewMode=magazine)

oldmanwinters
09-19-2011, 05:53 PM
IDW released a preview for TMNT #2 today! (http://issuu.com/idwpublishing/docs/tmnt-ong-02-preview?viewMode=magazine)

Initial thoughts:
It looks like Raphael vs. the Sandman (Flint Marko)!

Jester
09-19-2011, 06:17 PM
Further thoughts:
Why aren't Casey and Mr. (Mr.) Jones the least bit freaked out by a giant Turtle?

Toby Barrett
09-19-2011, 06:21 PM
Just looks like a big toitle. In a trench coat.

No big deal. XD

Jester
09-19-2011, 06:24 PM
Well played, Mr. Barrett.

oldmanwinters
09-19-2011, 06:25 PM
Further thoughts:
Why aren't Casey and Mr. (Mr.) Jones the least bit freaked out by a giant Turtle?

Perhaps for the same reason that a New York street gang takes orders from a giant cat?

Donnie
09-19-2011, 07:28 PM
Perhaps for the same reason that a New York street gang takes orders from a giant cat?

Could be. I found the scene rather predictable. Also, I'm trying really hard to like Duncan's art but the more I see that plastron moving relative to the Turtle's direction like a bendable piece of rubber, it falls flat on its face.

adz
09-19-2011, 07:37 PM
I'm digging Duncan's take on Eastmans action scenes, his turtle art is really growing on me. Can't believe it's been a month already!

Toby Barrett
09-19-2011, 07:54 PM
Could be. I found the scene rather predictable. Also, I'm trying really hard to like Duncan's art but the more I see that plastron moving relative to the Turtle's direction like a bendable piece of rubber, it falls flat on its face.

Meh. I really like Duncan's art. The plastron thing doesn't really bother me, just reminds me of the suits in the movies.

LeoNerdo
09-19-2011, 09:05 PM
Duncan's supporting characters don't do that much for me, but I do really like the way he draws the turtles. Can't wait to read the rest of the story and backstory..and I kinda wished I could've waited 2 days. 2 days! I just eat up every little scrap of info we get on this series.

Powder
09-19-2011, 09:15 PM
Meh. I really like Duncan's art. The plastron thing doesn't really bother me, just reminds me of the suits in the movies.

Same here broski.

Bauer536
09-19-2011, 10:10 PM
I'd sure love to pick up each issue to know what happens. But if I end up not liking this comic series, I don't know what I'll do with them. This makes me a bit worried.:tsad:

Powder
09-19-2011, 10:36 PM
I'd sure love to pick up each issue to know what happens. But if I end up not liking this comic series, I don't know what I'll do with them. This makes me a bit worried.:tsad:

...It's like $3.25 a pop bro. Hardly a loss. Just sell 'em as a lot down the line.

Bauer536
09-19-2011, 10:40 PM
...It's like $3.25 a pop bro. Hardly a loss. Just sell 'em as a lot down the line.

Thanks. I think I'll do that, only if this doesn't turn out to be a good incarnation. I'm still having high hopes for everything else though. Go Nickelodeon!:tsmile:

Nelson
09-19-2011, 10:45 PM
Predictable. Boring. Easy pass.

Sewer Dweller
09-19-2011, 11:02 PM
I think it looks good. I would've liked if Duncan drew Raph with the beady eyes like Kev used to draw in the original series when maskless. I think the white pupils work well with the bandana but without it looks weird.

Maybe Casey wasn't as freaked out coz he thought Raph was some guy who worked at some store selling food/mascot dressed in a turtle costume or maybe some vigilante dressed as a turtle.

New York's supposed to be a strange place :) Civilians see weird stuff going on everyday.

Bauer536
09-20-2011, 08:29 AM
I think it looks good. I would've liked if Duncan drew Raph with the beady eyes like Kev used to draw in the original series when maskless. I think the white pupils work well with the bandana but without it looks weird.

Maybe Casey wasn't as freaked out coz he thought Raph was some guy who worked at some store selling food/mascot dressed in a turtle costume or maybe some vigilante dressed as a turtle.

New York's supposed to be a strange place :) Civilians see weird stuff going on everyday.

:tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:

OH MY GOD!!!! I thought I was the only one who thought of this idea.

Yes, I think it would be a cool idea to have the turtles walking on the surface, lying to the humans that they work at a pizza place wearing turtle costumes. I can't believe you thought of that, too. HILARIOUS!!!!

:tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:

John Pannozzi
09-20-2011, 10:40 AM
Here are some of Eastman's layouts from #2. (http://ryalltime.wordpress.com/2011/09/19/tmnt-2-preview/)

Jester
09-20-2011, 10:54 AM
I always like Eastman's layouts better than the final art....am I a horrible person?

Toby Barrett
09-20-2011, 11:02 AM
I can see a few things I prefer the way Eastman layed out the page, and I see some things that I feel Duncan improved upon.

Venom
09-20-2011, 12:36 PM
Here are some of Eastman's layouts from #2. (http://ryalltime.wordpress.com/2011/09/19/tmnt-2-preview/)

Way cool!

I'm really enjoying the positive buzz folks have for the title again; just about everything you read has someone commenting on how awesome Kevin's layouts are and how great it is to see the Turtles on stands again...

Man, the power of effective marketing. :teek:

Well that bundled with compelling writing and decent art. :D

Donnie
09-20-2011, 01:17 PM
I always like Eastman's layouts better than the final art....am I a horrible person?

You're not alone! It's a no brainer for me, Eastman's art is just more my style of Turtles.

Jester
09-20-2011, 02:43 PM
You're not alone! It's a no brainer for me, Eastman's art is just more my style of Turtles.
Maybe it's experience. Maybe Duncan will get better with time...maybe.

Sabacooza
09-20-2011, 03:39 PM
Originally Posted by Jester
I always like Eastman's layouts better than the final art....am I a horrible person?
I guess I'm one of those horrible people to because I feel the same way. The story isn't bad but the art needs work.

Venom
09-20-2011, 03:57 PM
I guess I'm one of those horrible people to because I feel the same way. The story isn't bad but the art needs work.

Hey I've heard that before...oh, I remember: the last decade! :P jk :D

1984TMNT
09-20-2011, 04:32 PM
I have to admit that, for whatever reason, the art looked better to me in this preview than I initially thought it did in the 1st issue. It's growing on me.

It's killing me to see how long this might take to get the new take on the origin. I'm hoping the issues get a little longer as time goes on. :twink:

Gyt Kaliba
12-22-2011, 09:20 PM
I nabbed a copy of issue #1 of the IDW comic on a whim from Hastings today, and I'm not even kidding when I say it's like...the first US comic I've bought in my entire memory (though I've had a few things in the past, I just don't recall being the one that actually bought them). Unsure of what cover it is technically since it seems like there were multiple ones, but it's got all four Turtles on it if that helps any.

I'm definitely intrigued to see where this is all heading, the General Krang, the much earlier involvement of Casey and April, and everything else seems to be going in a radically different origin direction than any other incarnation thus far. Which is refreshing, but also a bit offputting, since a majority of the origin has always been the same or similar in every scenario.

My only complaint would be a non-issue really - the low page count. I'm spoiled by manga's much thicker page count though.:lol:

I probably won't be able to keep buying them, and would prefer an eventual omnibus of some sort anyway, but how many issues are out so far?

ToTheNines
12-22-2011, 09:23 PM
I probably won't be able to keep buying them, and would prefer an eventual omnibus of some sort anyway, but how many issues are out so far?

5 regular issues, plus a Raphael one-shot with Michelangelo's one-shot coming out the Wednesday before New Year's.

If you want to wait, a trade with the first 4 issues is coming out in Feb.

Grimlock
12-22-2011, 09:24 PM
but also a bit offputting, since a majority of the origin has always been the same or similar in every scenario.

but how many issues are out so far?

You ain't seen nothing yet. :DIssue 5 came out yesterday and the Raph Micro a few weeks back. Mike micro comes out the 28th. You have some cathing up to do.

Powder
12-22-2011, 09:25 PM
The cover you got, Gyt, happens to be a cover that is exclusive to Hastings. What's it called? The Hastings Variant. :trazz:

Gyt Kaliba
12-22-2011, 09:33 PM
Wow, quick replies, now I remember another reason I love this place.:D

5 regular issues, plus a Raphael one-shot with Michelangelo's one-shot coming out the Wednesday before New Year's.

If you want to wait, a trade with the first 4 issues is coming out in Feb.

Oh cool, I had no idea they were going to do individual Turtle one-shots just like Mirage did way back when, that's awesome.

I'll definitely look into that trade, has there been any word on the pricing yet? I'm definitely eying the first 'Ultimate Collection' volume for the old stuff, maybe nabbing it with Christmas money. The price is a bit steep though. At least, I think so - is $40-$50 about right for omnibuses like this?

You ain't seen nothing yet. :DIssue 5 came out yesterday and the Raph Micro a few weeks back. Mike micro comes out the 28th. You have some cathing up to do.

Definitely do, I'm about to start browsing the back-pages of this thread to thoroughly spoil plot points for myself, since I'm the weird sort that doesn't mind that at all.:lol:

The cover you got, Gyt, happens to be a cover that is exclusive to Hastings. What's it called? The Hastings Variant. :trazz:

Ha! That's kind of cool that they did a cover specifically for selling at Hastings. Personally, based on the few other covers I've seen, I quite like it too - I'd prefer a first issue cover have all four of them on it rather than a specific character.

ToTheNines
12-22-2011, 09:37 PM
Oh cool, I had no idea they were going to do individual Turtle one-shots just like Mirage did way back when, that's awesome.

I'll definitely look into that trade, has there been any word on the pricing yet?

Yeah, it was a great issue too. I'm sure Mike's will rock as well.

Here's the amazon page for the trade.

http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Constant/dp/1613771398/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1324611349&sr=8-2

Gyt Kaliba
12-22-2011, 09:45 PM
Thanks, now that's definitely more my style - slightly bigger collection with a decent price, woot.

Oh yeah, and on issue #1 again - I couldn't help but notice that Raph's eyes were still all white and glowing-like, even when he didn't have the mask on. I'm assuming this has been constant and with all the Turtles thus far, if we've seen them mask-less yet. Am I the only one not really feeling that style? The white eyes are bizarre enough WITH the masks (though I like it, and I know it harkens back to like...most every masked 'superhero' ever), but seeing their eyes like that without the mask is even weirder.

Not a huge deal, but just something I noticed that kinda seemed off to me.

Samhain
12-22-2011, 10:26 PM
Thanks, now that's definitely more my style - slightly bigger collection with a decent price, woot.

Oh yeah, and on issue #1 again - I couldn't help but notice that Raph's eyes were still all white and glowing-like, even when he didn't have the mask on. I'm assuming this has been constant and with all the Turtles thus far, if we've seen them mask-less yet. Am I the only one not really feeling that style? The white eyes are bizarre enough WITH the masks (though I like it, and I know it harkens back to like...most every masked 'superhero' ever), but seeing their eyes like that without the mask is even weirder.

Not a huge deal, but just something I noticed that kinda seemed off to me.

Nope. I like 'em with those kinda eyes. I dunno why, I don't want to see pupils. Though, in real life that would look pretty darn creepy.

RaphaelsIsolation
03-22-2013, 01:52 PM
Ah ha, I found it. Who would know this would be under this thread title.

I'll post my thoughts later after I re-read this baby in deluxe form

snake
03-22-2013, 03:16 PM
^ necroposter!!!!

RaphaelsIsolation
03-22-2013, 03:42 PM
yeah who really cares...? I could of made another thread. people get all screwed up on old posts being brought back... who cares

I'm going to read through the series again, and post comments. I think we all should rediscover these older issues now anyways

snake
03-22-2013, 03:47 PM
yeah who really cares...? I could of made another thread. people get all screwed up on old posts being brought back... who cares

I'm going to read through the series again, and post comments. I think we all should rediscover these older issues now anyways

Why post when no one cares about this thread anymore? It's two years old!

RaphaelsIsolation
03-22-2013, 03:56 PM
its a thread on the first issue, who cares dude? get over the whole OMG he posted a old thread...

i'm going to be re-enjoying all these. it's important to remember the older issues

RaphaelsIsolation
03-23-2013, 02:30 PM
I just reread this issue, wow.

It's a really good issue, I'll talk mainly on this #1 issue, as in it set aside from others.

I'm concerned about the 15 month turnaround, but we all know the reasons behind that now.

Krang seemed really cool. I thought it was really good. Nice lead it wanting you to buy more issues in the future.

corvus
03-27-2013, 06:44 PM
I was actually disappointed when I got this in the mail. I read an article saying "the original ninja turtles return to comics". I thought "cool they're continuing mirage". So I preordered and forgot about it til it came in the mail. Learned to love the series though.