PDA

View Full Version : (Possible Spoilers) The IDW TMNT New Issue Discussion Thread


Pages : [1] 2

Jester
08-24-2011, 11:44 AM
I went to my local shop and picked up cover A (The Raph cover) of IDW's new ongoing TMNT title. I've just finished reading it and I thought I'd create a thread where we can talk about each issue as it hits. So on to TMNT 1:
We are introduced to April, Casey, Baxter, and the shadowy figure of "General Krang" a military "man" who is bankrolling Stockman's genetic experiments, which the Turtles and Splinter are a part of. He's also working on a super soldier mutagen for Krang. Is Krang an amalgam of the ole Utrom Shredder and Agent Bishop?
The events occur in the present day, 18 months ago, and 15 months ago. Seems that the Turtles will mutate to a teenage state. I still hope Splinter is a father and not just a pal. The Turtles and Splinter are all part of an experiment. So far no Yoshi, but we do get an attempt at an explanation as to why a rat could learn ninjitsu: the genetic experiments are attempting to "splinter" the rat's "human" abilities from that of the rat. The Turtles are part of a human body armor experiment.
April is the one who names the Turtles after the Renaissance greats. She seems to have a larger part in the Turtles origin this time around.
I'm, not sure what I think of the changes so far. I mean we're only one issue in so I don't know what might come in the months to come, though each arc is only 4 issues long, so the blanks had better be filled in quickly. So far I'm concerned by the modified "genetic experiments" origin and the lack of Hamato Yoshi.

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 11:47 AM
I figured you'd be a Raph cover guy! Did the shop have each turtle option available? I'm probably going to pick up my issue later today.

Jester
08-24-2011, 11:50 AM
All 4 Turtles were there. They may have had the fold out cover...but I didn't check them thoroughly. I was just excited to see Turtles on the IDW rack.

Jester
08-24-2011, 11:55 AM
Oh and one more thing:
A dumpster diving Raph finds a "COWABUNGA!" t-shirt and exclaims, "Oh, now that's just wrong." before discarding it. Kinda funny, but seems every Not-Fred Wolf interpretation of the Turtles has used that gag.

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:06 PM
So far I haven't heard anything that makes me flinch.

But the day is young.

pl212
08-24-2011, 12:17 PM
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is, they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/
I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

Jester
08-24-2011, 12:17 PM
So far I haven't heard anything that makes me flinch.

But the day is young.

Really, I'd have sworn the only 18 month span between baby turtles/unmutated rat to fighting Hob and his goons would do something flinch-esque. I mean, what does that mean for the family dynamic, and the ninja training that the Turtles and Splinter have been mutants for A LITTLE OVER A YEAR!

Oh and pl212, you might spoiler tag....just in case.

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 12:20 PM
Jester's new avatar is spooky!

Jester
08-24-2011, 12:22 PM
Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".
Casey is introduced getting pummeled by his blitzed pops. Raphael breaks down their door to aid in the domestic dispute. Thoughts Andrew?

pl212
08-24-2011, 12:24 PM
Oh and pl212, you might spoiler tag....just in case.
Ok I spoiler tagged it :D
but why would I need it when the title of the thread says it anyways :/

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:27 PM
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is, they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/
I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

Oh, is that what you meant? I was confused by the "they will mutate to a teenage state" part.

But yeah... I'm not sure about 18 month-old Turtles that are supposed to be ninja. Sounds pretty dodgy at best to me, on paper. Is it possible you're/we're missing something?

Jester
08-24-2011, 12:29 PM
Ok I spoiler tagged it :D
but why would I need it when the title of the thread says it anyways :/
Because I'm sure even thought the title says it, some one will gripe that we didn't tag stuff...despite the title saying there will be spoilers.
Edit and yes Andrew less than 2 years takes place between pre-mutated animals and "ninja butt-kicking."

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:40 PM
Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".
Casey is introduced getting pummeled by his blitzed pops. Raphael breaks down their door to aid in the domestic dispute. Thoughts Andrew?

I think -- as the beginning of what I am assuming will be a blossoming Casey-Raphael friendship and introduction of Casey -- it is thematically more powerful than them just running into each other in the park by chance.

What's Casey look like?

Raph's Girl
08-24-2011, 12:43 PM
I dunno. I find the issue to be.... WEIRD.

Ok so we have Chet who in the Mirage comics was the kid who purchased the turtles and then lost them in the sewers. Now he's working for Baxter (who works for General Krang) to make this super soldier serum thing. April starts out as the college intern and ends up naming the turtles because she's taking a class in Renaissance art.

Yes it's nice that April is now more part of their origin and Chet has a bigger role. But the origin is just....off somehow. The way they name Splinter is kinda stupid as well (and is it just me or did Lindsey look like Irma?) But they become fighters in only a couple months?? Plus Casey is obviously YOUNGER than April. He's just a kid being abused by his alcaholic father.

And the whole thing with General Krang. I hope he ends up being human and not some alien.

Oh and the turtles... They're obviously Sea Turtles...but the poor things should have more water than that!

pl212
08-24-2011, 12:44 PM
Oh, is that what you meant? I was confused by the "they will mutate to a teenage state" part.

But yeah... I'm not sure about 18 month-old Turtles that are supposed to be ninja. Sounds pretty dodgy at best to me, on paper. Is it possible you're/we're missing something?

Sorry for the confusion I was assuming anyone who posts here have already read the issue and knew what I was talking about.
So 18 months before they were "ninja turtles" they were in a lab as actual turtles. A few months later they became what we all know now.
I found it weird.

TomWaltz
08-24-2011, 12:44 PM
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is, they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/
I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

All will be revealed in time, my friends...

For now, thanks so much for your kind and loyal support! I'm excited to watch the debate over the new series on Technodrome -- you folks are the best fans in the world!

We're gonna have fun!

Talk soon...

Tom

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:47 PM
Sorry for the confusion I was assuming anyone who posts here have already read the issue and knew what I was talking about.
So 18 months before they were "ninja turtles" they were in a lab as actual turtles. A few months later they became what we all know now.
I found it weird.

I haven't read the issue yet so I'm only going off of your guys' cryptic blurbs, but does it seem that we might be headed toward the Turtles formerly being humans, merging with humans, or something along those lines?

pl212
08-24-2011, 12:52 PM
I haven't read the issue yet so I'm only going off of your guys' cryptic blurbs, but does it seem that we might be headed toward the Turtles formerly being humans, merging with humans, or something along those lines?

I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:56 PM
I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.

Well, I'm not against such a thing as long as it's not something rubbish like the Fred Wolf "touch this and touch that" mutagen.

Jester
08-24-2011, 12:58 PM
I dunna about that. Part of me thinks that...The genetically modified Turtles and Rat will come into contact with some of Baxter's/Krang's super soldier mutagen and grow to their humanoid size. Maybe the good people at Stock-Gen train them in ninjitsu...you know through Weapon X style virtual reality immersion technology.

pl212
08-24-2011, 12:58 PM
Well, I'm not against such a thing as long as it's not something rubbish like the Fred Wolf "touch this and touch that" mutagen.

lol exactly.
I think this was a good start, it showed a bit of everything and left me wanting more :D

Jester
08-24-2011, 01:02 PM
That's for sure. September seems all too far away.

LeoNerdo
08-24-2011, 01:04 PM
I just read it -- some things that stuck out to me or ideas I had:

The 4 turtles are sea turtles. I dig that since the Mirage gang used to put ads in some books and links on their website for Save the Sea turtle foundation websites. Another thought on this is that sea turtles only have flippers and no toes/claws like the red-eared sliders do they? To me that means there may be some kind of human involvement in the mutation process for it to make sense for them to form hands, fingers, feet and toes.

General Krang is some type of "warlord". That's pretty cool. He's also paying for the super soldier mutagen Baxter is creating. Maybe down the line somewhere he tests it on himself (presuming he's human) and mutates in to an ugly brain guy. :tlol:

pl212
08-24-2011, 01:07 PM
I just read it -- some things that stuck out to me or ideas I had:

The 4 turtles are sea turtles. I dig that since the Mirage gang used to put ads in some books and links on their website for Save the Sea turtle foundation websites. Another thought on this is that sea turtles only have flippers and no toes/claws like the red-eared sliders do they? To me that means there may be some kind of human involvement in the mutation process for it to make sense for them to form hands, fingers, feet and toes.

General Krang is some type of "warlord". That's pretty cool. He's also paying for the super soldier mutagen Baxter is creating. Maybe down the line somewhere he tests it on himself (presuming he's human) and mutates in to an ugly brain guy. :tlol:


General Krang seemed like a cyborg/android to me, I don't know if I was over analyzing but it seemed like you can see his metal arm underneath his sleeve.
Check it out , what do you think ?

Jester
08-24-2011, 01:11 PM
General Krang seemed like a cyborg/android to me, I don't know if I was over analyzing but it seemed like you can see his metal arm underneath his sleeve.
Check it out , what do you think ?
I think you may be right. Looks like a gloved hand and a metal arm underneath. We may have a rogue Utrom.

LeoNerdo
08-24-2011, 01:16 PM
Ah, I hadn't paid very close attention to that panel. Good point. I dunno if that's a metal arm or a sleeve, though it's certainly possible. The gloved hand is rather conspicuous unless he's had some type of accident in the past. Could be an android or Utrom-like character though.

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 01:23 PM
Straight up, I dislike the new origin. Some parts of it are clever, some are just off. But I won't let it bother me once the story gets rolling. And I appreciate the fact that they're not just regurgitating what we've seen before.

Anyways, there were no incentive covers at my closest store (which ain't close) but I got Leo and Raph.

Jester
08-24-2011, 01:32 PM
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

The Fifth Turtle
08-24-2011, 01:37 PM
I got all four basic covers today from my local shop. I was able to hand pick a copy of each from the shipping box. I am very lucky I did too because they only had a few Donnys, and Leos. There were only two Raphs and only one Mikey. Had I gotten there late I would have walked with only 3 out of the 4 brothers. Is anyone else noticing a cover to be more rare than the others? (not counting the variants of course)

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 01:42 PM
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

I think it's cool. His interior art trumps his covers (which is odd). I'm definitely eager to see more.

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 01:50 PM
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

OK, brutally honest: I really dig his style but not so much his plastrons (they look kinda "soft" and angular) or his Turtle expressions (a little... too much?). I'm concerned that his artwork isn't really going to bring the "Oh wow!" factor that a new TMNT comic kind of needs on the shelf right now -- TMNT has a... let's call it a "certain reputation." At this point, when some random person discovers this comic in their shop and flips through it it needs to POP or the book won't be given a second look or chance. Coupled with the so-so coloring, I'm a little worried in that department.


Ah, I hadn't paid very close attention to that panel. Good point. I dunno if that's a metal arm or a sleeve, though it's certainly possible. The gloved hand is rather conspicuous unless he's had some type of accident in the past. Could be an android or Utrom-like character though.

I don't think it's too profound to pretty much assume that if IDW went to all the trouble of importing Krang from the Fred Wolf cartoon they wouldn't make him something other than either the disembodied brain-like warlord or a rogue Utrom warlord. I'm sure "General Krang" has a secret we'll be let in on soon enough.

TheCanadiandrome
08-24-2011, 01:54 PM
wow, after reading some of the posts, i'm kinda excited to get my hands on this

Revan
08-24-2011, 01:55 PM
Just read it and I really enjoyed this one.

I got a kick out of the nods to other versions of the turtles like the cowabunga t-shirt. As far as art goes, I think the turtles are the weakest. The humans look good (except for a few panels of April, who looks awkward in some and cute in others).

I am a bit unsure how I feel about the turtles being normal turtles only 18 months before squaring off with Old Hob's goons. So far, I like the old origin better where they grow up as a family rather than mutating into an older state. But I'm sure we will get a clearer picture what is going on in the months to come.

General Krang intrigues me. Especially that gloved hand with what appears to be a metal arm under the sleeve. Burnow island reminds me of "the island" from the x-men origins: Wolverine movie.

Either Chet is a dork with a stutter or he is very nervous working on this project. Probably just a nerd with a speech impediment but perhaps he knows he doing some illegal work. Might indicate Krang up to no good. :tgrin:

Raph is the "feisty" one. :tlol:
And April seems VERY attached to them. Like, Buslady attached. :ohwell:

Raph eats out of the trash? :teek: Yuck. But they are animals after all.

Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.

I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.
I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 02:01 PM
Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.

Not totally true. April's a college intern which means she's 19-22, and just because Casey's getting beat up by his dad doesn't mean he's that young. I'm 20 and I'm living at home for the time being.

LeoNerdo
08-24-2011, 02:06 PM
Just read it and I really enjoyed this one.

I got a kick out of the nods to other versions of the turtles like the cowabunga t-shirt. As far as art goes, I think the turtles are the weakest. The humans look good (except for a few panels of April, who looks awkward in some and cute in others).

I am a bit unsure how I feel about the turtles being normal turtles only 18 months before squaring off with Old Hob's goons. So far, I like the old origin better where they grow up as a family rather than mutating into an older state. But I'm sure we will get a clearer picture what is going on in the months to come.

General Krang intrigues me. Especially that gloved hand with what appears to be a metal arm under the sleeve. Burnow island reminds me of "the island" from the x-men origins: Wolverine movie.

Either Chet is a dork with a stutter or he is very nervous working on this project. Probably just a nerd with a speech impediment but perhaps he knows he doing some illegal work. Might indicate Krang up to no good. :tgrin:

Raph is the "feisty" one. :tlol:
And April seems VERY attached to them. Like, Buslady attached. :ohwell:

Raph eats out of the trash? :teek: Yuck. But they are animals after all.

Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.


I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

I thought just the opposite about the art direction. I think the Turtles and Splinter look fine, but the humans or rather Chet in particular looks pretty awkward in almost every panel he appears. I'm not real crazy about the design on Old Hob either, but I guess I'm curious to see how he got a gang of humans to take orders from him.

Samhain
08-24-2011, 02:15 PM
I haven't read the issue yet but you guys are getting me excited. I actually like what Im hearing about the origin story. Different is welcome, atleat IMO.

As far as Dan Duncan's art.... yeah, I would have loved a ''Star'' artist attached to this book to give it a little attention. Maybe Ethan Van Sciver or Finch. But so far I love everything about the way he draws the turtles. From the Over-exaggerated facial Expressions to the weird plastron designs. LOVE IT ALL. It's different but maybe that's what this franchise needs. Change.

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 02:32 PM
I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

Wait, but they're sea turtles now, right? Sea turtles in a terrarium... isn't that like an oxymoron?

As far as Dan Duncan's art.... yeah, I would have loved a ''Star'' artist attached to this book to give it a little attention. Maybe Ethan Van Sciver or Finch.

Both of those guys are DC exclusive but yes, someone certainly in that vein, if only just for the first story arc.

Buffy
08-24-2011, 02:34 PM
Just read it and liked it a lot. I like the fact that they decided to entirely change the origin story and do something else. IDW can go any way they want to now.

I also think it's a bit weird that the turtles have learned martial arts in only a year time. Maybe they used the technique Neo used in the matrix. :)

PAAATE
08-24-2011, 02:39 PM
tl;dr-version: Too much story with too quick of a pace, not enough moments to explore characters.

Long version: It seems a little bland and cliché at this point, but the thing I care the most about are well-written, complex characters, and that's rarely something you achieve in the first issue, so yeah, I'll wait a few issues before I pass any real judgment on this one.

They possibly tried to cram a little too much story into it and not enough true character-moments, but then again, I don't know what the different pay-offs will be, and maybe they need to begin this many stories at once for whatever-they-have-planned to work.

Like I said, I'll wait and see where this is going, but if I had to give the first issue a rating, it would be 3/10

The 3 points comes from Raph's story which is the most interesting so far :P

Abnormal Freak
08-24-2011, 02:55 PM
I like it. :) The new stuff brought to the table is a welcome change; it's absurd to think that this book should be like the other origins, and I'm intrigued to see where things go.

And I like Duncan's Turtles and Splinter, and Old Hob looks pretty cool, but I'm not terribly fond of his humans. Then again...I was never terribly fond of Eastman and Laird's humans either. :p

I'm not entirely sure yet what to think of the coloring. On one hand, it seems a little drab; but on the other, it's not the boring, shiny, blatantly obvious computer coloring of most books I flip through, so it gets a lot of appreciation from me for looking pretty unique and creative.

I wish the Eastman covers weren't special variants and were as easily obtainable as the Duncan covers. So bummed I couldn't get hold of Eastman's cover for #1, which I specified I wanted several months in advance. :\ (I'm thinking an employee at the shop snagged it, possibly to sell online. The shop certainly had more than ten copies available so they should have gotten that particular incentive variant.) Duncan's covers are awesome so I'm pleased with my Leonardo cover, but I'd have far preferred to have Eastman's art in my hands.

Revan
08-24-2011, 03:06 PM
Wait, but they're sea turtles now, right? Sea turtles in a terrarium... isn't that like an oxymoron?

Perhaps. If we are going by the art, it sure looks more like a terrarium than an aquarium. There is hardly any water in it at all.

But I didn't catch where it was stated they were sea turtles. Stockman refers to them as terrapins, which seems to contradict their classification as sea turtles since terrapin is the term used for fresh water turtles, not sea turtles.

I also think it's a bit weird that the turtles have learned martial arts in only a year time. Maybe they used the technique Neo used in the matrix. :)

It might be possible that the four turtles in the terrarium are not the teenage mutant ninja turtles. 18 months just seems so fast. Perhaps April already knows the teenage mutant ninja turtles and that is why she names the normal turtles the way she does. After all, she seemed to name the turtles after the characteristics of the tmnt. She named the one pigging out Mike. Raph was trying to escape. Don was studying...

Of course that doesn't explain why the rat's name is Splinter since April didn't name him...

IamtheKnight
08-24-2011, 03:27 PM
I got covers A,B,C,D, and the Kevin Eastman(which they only had two copies of). Here are my thoughts on the issue The origin is well different. I don't like the idea of April and the other scientist naming the turtles and Splinter. Does this mean that there is no Hamato Yoshi? Baxter seems to have a bigger role now. I also like that he is working for Krang. The art will take some getting used to, I don't like the mutants designs but I don't mind the humans. Can't wait for the next issue!

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 03:44 PM
I hadn't planned on it but apparently I have five TMNT #1s waiting for me at home -- the individual Turtle covers and the Eastman cover.

At least, I hope it's the Eastman cover... if it's the Sam Keith cover, I'll be out for blood. ;)

I got covers A,B,C,D, and the Kevin Eastman(which they only had two copies of). Here are my thoughts on the issue The origin is well different. I don't like the idea of April and the other scientist naming the turtles and Splinter. Does this mean that there is no Hamato Yoshi? Baxter seems to have a bigger role now. I also like that he is working for Krang. The art will take some getting used to, I don't like the mutants designs but I don't mind the humans. Can't wait for the next issue!

On its own the lack of Hamato Yoshi does not bother me... but it does make me worry about the eventual introduction of Oroku Saki/The Shredder. Of all the things a little dodgy or could be tweaked this way or that in the Mirage TMNT, the dynamic between the families of Yoshi (meaning, including the TMNT) and Saki wouldn't be something I'd think anyone would want to see mucked around with too much.

Raph's Girl
08-24-2011, 03:45 PM
But I didn't catch where it was stated they were sea turtles.

Of course that doesn't explain why the rat's name is Splinter since April didn't name him...

Splinter already had his name. April asked why they called him that and Lindsey explained it.

As for their species. They clearly look like Sea Turtles but yes they're in a terrarium, the poor dears.

IamtheNorm
08-24-2011, 03:46 PM
I read it earlier today and must say that I wasn't ready for the book to end when it did.

I will say that the story lines I am currently most interested in are April, Casey, Baxter and Krang, and Raph. I know that covers most of the first issue, but I am very excited to find how what happens. It's going to be hard waiting between issues.

Slap-Happy
08-24-2011, 03:54 PM
I just got back from two Hastings stores, where both shipments of the Hastings variants where bent to sh*t out of the Diamond box. So I just have the Leo cover for now, the Eastman and Gatefold come later.

Only thing that has me worried about the origin is that Baxter mentions "Terrapin/Human Exo Armor" or something like that. I really hope the turtles aren't mutated humans.

Buffy
08-24-2011, 03:59 PM
It might be possible that the four turtles in the terrarium are not the teenage mutant ninja turtles. 18 months just seems so fast. Perhaps April already knows the teenage mutant ninja turtles and that is why she names the normal turtles the way she does. After all, she seemed to name the turtles after the characteristics of the tmnt. She named the one pigging out Mike. Raph was trying to escape. Don was studying...


That would seem more logical, never thought of it that way.

Master Splinter
08-24-2011, 04:00 PM
It might be possible that the four turtles in the terrarium are not the teenage mutant ninja turtles. 18 months just seems so fast. Perhaps April already knows the teenage mutant ninja turtles and that is why she names the normal turtles the way she does. After all, she seemed to name the turtles after the characteristics of the tmnt. She named the one pigging out Mike. Raph was trying to escape. Don was studying...

Of course that doesn't explain why the rat's name is Splinter since April didn't name him...

April says she is taking an art class and that is why she named them that way. She didn't even know what they were talking about when Lindsay mentioned the psychotropic drug testing they are doing with Splinter. She thinks she is interning for bio-engineering for food. I think she is pretty clueless right now. I would imagine she has a big heart for the creatures in the tank and probably tries to save them at some point from the testing they are doing.

Chet appears to be minding his words. I don't think it's a stutter more of a careful way of making sure he doesn't say anything wrong, because as you can see, they are being watched.

-ms

azrael
08-24-2011, 04:04 PM
Can we pause this till I get my copy tomorrow.... Only joking of course

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 04:04 PM
It might be possible that the four turtles in the terrarium are not the teenage mutant ninja turtles. 18 months just seems so fast.

Could be. The four sea turtles could just be a clever bit of sleight of hand.

Heh. The origin of the Turtles at IDW is beginning to sound like a (pun only somewhat intended) shell game. I do like how it has provoked all this discussion back and forth.

kev trashcan
08-24-2011, 04:11 PM
just got back from riding my bike down to the comic shop to pick this up, im about to read it, i was surprised to see it in color, but it looks awesome either way.

Revan
08-24-2011, 04:22 PM
April says she is taking an art class and that is why she named them that way.

-ms

Of course she said that. What else would she say? "Oh I know 4 anthropomorphic talking turtles who practice ninjitsu so I named them after those guys."

I'm just saying it's possible

Besides, why would she take a Renaissance art class?

Jester
08-24-2011, 04:24 PM
I don't know...seems like a lot of work to make us think they are the turtles, if they aren't. And what of Splinter?

I was gonna say, "But then again how do they remember the names?" but in Mirage continuity Splinter remembered his name.

Oh and here's a picture of the turtles flippers and all:
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/scan0004.jpg

The tank seems to change from page to page...in the "18 months ago" pages it almost looks like a tank full of water, with the coloring and the odd black "bubbles". But in the picture where April names them, it looks like it's not...and there's only a very little bit of water.

Revan
08-24-2011, 04:26 PM
I don't know...seems like a lot of work to make us think they are the turtles, if they aren't.

I believe that is the point of misdirection. I suppose I will just drop it. It is very unlikely and I don't even believe that is what is going on. Just making an observation.

twopinacoladas
08-24-2011, 04:27 PM
It was hit or miss for me, I liked the beginning fight scene, not sure about Old Hob, as for the new origin, I'll wait and see. I am looking forward to see how the end plays out in the next issue.

TomWaltz
08-24-2011, 04:30 PM
Of course she said that. What else would she say? "Oh I know 4 anthropomorphic talking turtles who practice ninjitsu so I named them after those guys."

I'm just saying it's possible

Besides, why would she take a Renaissance art class?

Even science students need to take elective classes...

:tgrin:

Slap-Happy
08-24-2011, 04:39 PM
Hey Tom, how many issues do we get before we get the full origin?

Master Splinter
08-24-2011, 04:39 PM
Of course she said that. What else would she say? "Oh I know 4 anthropomorphic talking turtles who practice ninjitsu so I named them after those guys."

I'm just saying it's possible

Besides, why would she take a Renaissance art class?

Yes but the rat was already named Splinter. If she already knew TMNT and was hiding it, how would Lindsay and crew already know to call the rat Splinter...

And I agree with Tom, ya got to take electives... I took a film class as an elective when my degree is with information technology...

-ms

Revan
08-24-2011, 04:41 PM
I think it would be funny to see a certain cat chasing the normal Splinter rat around StokGen in the next issue. :tgrin:

Master Splinter
08-24-2011, 04:41 PM
Hey Tom, how many issues do we get before we get the full origin?

I am pretty sure the origin will be done within the first arc, but I can see more back story coming down the road in future arcs.

-ms

AquaParade
08-24-2011, 04:46 PM
I just finished reading. It's hard for me to say much at this point, but I'll give my first impressions...

- I really dig the art and the coloring. Perhaps I am in the minority, but both the pencils and coloring look great to me.

- Old Hob seems like a pretty cool character to far. Starting the first issue off with a Mutant cat, as opposed to The Foot was a gutsy move, but it truly feels like a breath of fresh air. I am definitely into the idea of the turtles/Splinter being rare and unique as mutants, but I'm interested in Old Hob, nonetheless.

- Mikey saying something sly/funny and having to be hushed by Splinter, was nice. I guess it's the little character moments like that, that stick out to me. Mikey really felt like a "Teenage Ninja".

- Please don't let the turtles be former humans. A sped up mutation and advanced learning of Ninjitsu, I can tumble with, but knowing that the turtles used be " Dick, Harry, Michael, and Steven" will seriously sketch me out.

Excited to see what comes next :)

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 04:47 PM
I don't know...seems like a lot of work to make us think they are the turtles, if they aren't. And what of Splinter?

I was gonna say, "But then again how do they remember the names?" but in Mirage continuity Splinter remembered his name.

Oh and here's a picture of the turtles flippers and all:
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/scan0004.jpg

The tank seems to change from page to page...in the "18 months ago" pages it almost looks like a tank full of water, with the coloring and the odd black "bubbles". But in the picture where April names them, it looks like it's not...and there's only a very little bit of water.

Those are definitely sea turtles. Whether it's a case of "Dan, draw four turtles in the tank" and sea turtles are what he came up with on the fly or it's a case of Tom intending them that way from the get-go, who knows.

I guess to create any kind of true sea turtle habitat you would need to do recreate both land and water.

DrSpengler
08-24-2011, 04:47 PM
Late to the party, but I have a dayjob.

Here's my review at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/08/tmnt-idw-1.html)

I liked it. Yeah, not a lotta story for $4 bucks, but that's comics these days. I'm intrigued by the plot thread let loose and wanna see how they play out.

The first issue hooked me and that's exactly what a good first issue is supposed to do.

discordiatookie
08-24-2011, 04:48 PM
C'mon, the one next to the palm tree is obviously Slash! And, y'know, April has infiltrated the bad guy's HQ, where Stockman is trying to replicate the mutations of the TMNT. These are totally the Evil Turtles. Or something. :P

This is all sounding pretty good so far, I love how everything is getting mixed up and changed and we aren't just getting the same old story rehashed again. I haven't got the issue yet personally, unfortunately when I went to my LCS and Forbidden Planet, deliveries hadn't arrived yet. Typical. Can't wait until tomorrow!

Jester
08-24-2011, 04:52 PM
Something else just dawned on me....how can Old Hob be a "long-time foe," to quote Doc, if Splinter has known him at most a year....that's not a very long time.

Powder
08-24-2011, 04:54 PM
Now I understand why people say our fandom will complain regardless of anything.

Sheesh.

As for me...

I FREAKIN' LOVE IT.

I'm not using spoilers, if you're reading this thread you should know better, God damn it.

The art was dope, they punched my in the face with a fist of nostalgia, all of those references/characters coming from different series' & all... Krang! Stockman! Casey! CHET! April in a yellow shirt! (Hahaha!) Fantastic. The humor had me laughin' out loud, the action is gritty, Eastmans colored variant is a gem to stare at, the pacing for me was great 'cause they made a path for all necessary origins to start on, the OT nods/disses were a neato addition, & I just can't wait for September. Hell yes.

Revan
08-24-2011, 04:55 PM
Something else just dawned on me....how can Old Hob be a "long-time foe," to quote Doc, if Splinter has known him at most a year....that's not a very long time.

do we know how long they have known each other?

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 04:57 PM
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/scan0004.jpg


I wonder which of the two Turtles are the two that are mating there...

Jester
08-24-2011, 05:05 PM
NO TURTLE-CEST ANDY!!!

Come on, man!
Now I understand why people say our fandom will complain regardless of anything.

Sheesh.

As for me...

I FREAKIN' LOVE IT.

I'm not using spoilers, if you're reading this thread you should know better, God damn it.

The art was dope, they punched my in the face with a fist of nostalgia, all of those references/characters coming from different series' & all... Krang! Stockman! Casey! CHET! April in a yellow shirt! (Hahaha!) Fantastic. The humor had me laughin' out loud, the action is gritty, Eastmans colored variant is a gem to stare at, the pacing for me was great 'cause they made a path for all necessary origins to start on, the OT nods/disses were a neato addition, & I just can't wait for September. Hell yes.
Oh, come on Dennis. You know that I tend to be fair in my criticism. I'm on board for next month, but I wasn't blown away by this first entry. ;)

discordiatookie
08-24-2011, 05:13 PM
I LIKE HOW SPLINTER GOT HIS NAME LOL

http://i201.photobucket.com/albums/aa15/discordiatookie/shitgotreal.jpg

i really don't know where it comes from.


Also, I can't wait until tomorrow to get my hands on it. Oh, i've said that before. Thanks for the review Spengs! And, I haven't even read it yet, but I really do dig the colours and art style.

Mating turtles? Blatantly Tokka and Venus. (Evil Turtle Clan.)

Jester
08-24-2011, 05:15 PM
I LIKE HOW SPLINTER GOT HIS NAME LOL

http://i201.photobucket.com/albums/aa15/discordiatookie/shitgotreal.jpg

i really don't know where it comes from.
Well played, Scotsman!

discordiatookie
08-24-2011, 05:18 PM
Well played, Scotsman!

Aw shucks. Thanks :toops:

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 05:48 PM
One thing that's cheesy is that Krang's shrouded in shadows. If he's a rouge Utrom posing as an Army General, his exo-suit probably just looks like some old white dude. Why hide that?

Something else just dawned on me....how can Old Hob be a "long-time foe," to quote Doc, if Splinter has known him at most a year....that's not a very long time.

Splinter says that he has "the bittersweet experience of centuries" during his in-battle voiceover.

I'm quite confused... I wish comics were weekly.

TomWaltz
08-24-2011, 05:51 PM
Hey Tom, how many issues do we get before we get the full origin?

Well... I'll say this much: MUCH of the origin story will be revealed in the first four issues, but we've got surprises up our sleeves, my friends, some of which we won't start revealing until a special (and, I hope, shocking in a good way) issue #5.

And, yes, we do have a plan... and, yes, all will be revealed...

Eventually.

:tgrin:

kev trashcan
08-24-2011, 06:00 PM
Well... I'll say this much: MUCH of the origin story will be revealed in the first four issues, but we've got surprises up our sleeves, my friends, some of which we won't start revealing until a special (and, I hope, shocking in a good way) issue #5.

And, yes, we do have a plan... and, yes, all will be revealed...

Eventually.

:tgrin:

sounds good to me.

i loved the first issue. its already a breath of fresh air. the whole raph being on his own thing is interesting to me and is already making me relate to this character again, in a new way. really looking forward to seeing what happens next in issue 2

TomWaltz
08-24-2011, 06:01 PM
Late to the party, but I have a dayjob.

Here's my review at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/08/tmnt-idw-1.html)

I liked it. Yeah, not a lotta story for $4 bucks, but that's comics these days. I'm intrigued by the plot thread let loose and wanna see how they play out.

The first issue hooked me and that's exactly what a good first issue is supposed to do.

Cool review DrSpengler -- really enjoyed reading it!

Thanks!

Tom W.

DrSpengler
08-24-2011, 06:07 PM
Cool review DrSpengler -- really enjoyed reading it!

Thanks!

Tom W.

And I enjoyed reading the comic!

SO NOW WE'RE EVEN.

IamtheNorm
08-24-2011, 06:14 PM
Something else just dawned on me....how can Old Hob be a "long-time foe," to quote Doc, if Splinter has known him at most a year....that's not a very long time.

I was thinking Old Hob was an alley cat that had tried to eat splinter before the mutation. And the cat was/started to chase splinter during the mutation and got caught up in it.

1984TMNT
08-24-2011, 06:28 PM
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

I both enjoy the new artwork, but also think it should "pop" a bit more. I dig it, but something about it just doesn't come across as "finished"....?

1984TMNT
08-24-2011, 06:49 PM
I can't help but think (as others have hinted at) that the turtles we see are NOT the actual TMNT. It would make sense that Krang, somewhere in the past, has seen or run into the guys and is now trying to replicate their transformation. However, that still doesn't make any sense of Splinter being there and being named by the scientists.

I really enjoyed the first issue, but will definitely say I have some concern over some of the following possibilities:


the turtles being sea turtles
the fact that the TMNT will be former humans
Possible no Yoshi in this universe


I'm definitely up for a few new spins on the Origin story, but would prefer that it's not drastically different than what we know (the guys were turtles and grew up / trained together over the years. While part of me thinks it's neat that April has given the turtles names, if it turns out that Splinter is NOT the one who actually gives the guys their names, I'd be kind of bummed. That was always a great starting point for his being their Father figure, which I'd hate to see stripped away.

joe-eyeball
08-24-2011, 07:12 PM
Yeah, I'm in the group who is not really sure how to feel about this first issue. I guess I would have to say I did not really enjoy it, but the art is pretty good.

My thoughts on the turtles is that maybe the "sea turtles" are and splinter are the second round of experiments at Stockgen and the TMNT and Splinter we know were experiments gone wrong or they escaped. And April has been sent into Stockgen for recon purposes by the TMNT which she already knows.

Of course my theory is sort of shot down by the fact that April is scared of a normal sized rat which would seem sort of out of place if she already knew a mutated one, and that she does not appear to be all that nosey with the Stockgen employees.

Or maybe the "sea turtles" and Splinter we see are the actual TMNT and the experiments along with a super soldier serum or mutagen is what will accelerate their abilities and age. I DON'T FREAKIN' KNOW!!!

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 07:16 PM
http://comics.ign.com/articles/118/1189683p1.html

Samhain
08-24-2011, 07:27 PM
Well, Baxter is back and BLACK. Yes, that makes me happy.:)

Powder
08-24-2011, 07:28 PM
http://comics.ign.com/articles/118/1189683p1.html


This new series showcases the Turtles as they were in the beginning – violent, edgy, and more prone to battling ninjas on rooftops than space aliens and talking dinosaurs.


Oh that's right, they didn't fight Dinosaurs in outer space right from the beginning and again many many times.

No, wait, they did.

Ninjinister
08-24-2011, 07:32 PM
I hear Clancy Brown's voice in my head when I read Old Hob's speech balloons.

Jester
08-24-2011, 07:41 PM
the fact that the TMNT will be former humans

That's not a fact...we don't know a whole lot of anything at the moment...which may be the leading part of my frustration.

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 07:41 PM
I hear Clancy Brown's voice in my head when I read Old Hob's speech balloons.

I hear a more raspy voice, like Boss Zucco from Fast Forward but without the mobster accent.

Anyone else have trouble reading General Krang's dialogue without plugging in Pat Fraley's voice? lol

Samhain
08-24-2011, 07:47 PM
Anyone else have trouble reading General Krang's dialogue without plugging in Pat Fraley's voice? lol

LMAO! Yeah, I tend to read my comics outloud when Im alone. So it was a little difficult not to burst into Krang for that portion of the book.:D

Jester
08-24-2011, 07:52 PM
I tried (and failed) to make Fraley's Krang voice more menacing. :P
I totally read Baxter as Scott Williams though.

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 08:12 PM
Well, when I went down to my LCS around 5pm today, they had sold out of everything but two Mikey covers and the Dealer-Incentive B cover (with the fold-out-wrap-around cover). By the time I checked out with the variant cover, another guy had bought one of the Mikeys. Good to see the Turtles made good on their first issue among fans and collectors (in Louisville, at least).

I haven't read the issue yet so I'm only going off of your guys' cryptic blurbs, but does it seem that we might be headed toward the Turtles formerly being humans, merging with humans, or something along those lines?

I figure this will inevitably happen in some future incarnation of the turtles. But... I just don't think its this one.

I dunna about that. Part of me thinks that...The genetically modified Turtles and Rat will come into contact with some of Baxter's/Krang's super soldier mutagen and grow to their humanoid size. Maybe the good people at Stock-Gen train them in ninjitsu...you know through Weapon X style virtual reality immersion technology.

I thought the same thing as Jester. I couldn't help but consider this the "Marvel-esque" interpretation of the TMNT origin story.

tl;dr-version: Too much story with too quick of a pace, not enough moments to explore characters.

Long version: It seems a little bland and cliché at this point, but the thing I care the most about are well-written, complex characters, and that's rarely something you achieve in the first issue, so yeah, I'll wait a few issues before I pass any real judgment on this one.

They possibly tried to cram a little too much story into it and not enough true character-moments, but then again, I don't know what the different pay-offs will be

Late to the party, but I have a dayjob.

Here's my review at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/08/tmnt-idw-1.html)

I liked it. Yeah, not a lotta story for $4 bucks, but that's comics these days. I'm intrigued by the plot thread let loose and wanna see how they play out.

The first issue hooked me and that's exactly what a good first issue is supposed to do.

I sympathize with both of these critiques. Once I got to the end, I got really disappointed that the next issue with be almost 30 days away! It almost made me wish I had waited to read the first four issues all at once. (Yeah, right, like that would ever happen, lol)



As for me...

I FREAKIN' LOVE IT.


I like Powder's enthusiasm! It's nice to see drastically creative takes on the tired old TMNT origin story. I don't know if I'll like the final result, but it does interest me enough to keep reading. Mission accomplished, IDW.

I wonder which of the two Turtles are the two that are mating there...

Sadly, I thought the same thing when I saw that picture. It's... awkward.

TMNT_Master
08-24-2011, 08:16 PM
C'mon, the one next to the palm tree is obviously Slash!

Hahaha! True, true.. :tgrin:

Utromshredderhater
08-24-2011, 08:52 PM
Now they have already made the first mistake of changing the origin to make it make more "sense" and deviating away greatly from what has worked for years,
Like 4kids with that stupid Utrom and Demon Shredders. I say let's stay the course

Abnormal Freak
08-24-2011, 08:54 PM
I say, stick to the old issues if that's what you want. :p What's the use of a rehash?

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 08:54 PM
I totally read Baxter as Scott Williams though.

Haha, Williams nailed that character for eternity as far as I'm concerned.

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 08:58 PM
Now they have already made the first mistake of changing the origin to make it make more "sense" and deviating away greatly from what has worked for years,
Like 4kids with that stupid Utrom and Demon Shredders. I say let's stay the course

Will we be seeing a name change to from "Utromshredderhater" to "Terrapin/humanexo-armorsynthesishater"? :twink:

Utromshredderhater
08-24-2011, 09:04 PM
Will we be seeing a name change to from "Utromshredderhater" to "Terrapin/humanexo-armorsynthesishater"? :twink:


Ha Ha (sarcatic)

Venom
08-24-2011, 09:06 PM
Will we be seeing a name change to from "Utromshredderhater" to "Terrapin/humanexo-armorsynthesishater"? :twink:

Ha Ha (sincere)

Abnormal Freak
08-24-2011, 09:12 PM
Ha Ha (amused) :)

ToTheNines
08-24-2011, 09:14 PM
Not bitching, but I think a mod should change the thread title to "IDW's TMNT #1".

Maybe.

Utromshredderhater
08-24-2011, 09:22 PM
You all just get a kick out off making fun off me don't you. just admit it

gbhq
08-24-2011, 09:24 PM
Just read the issue and actually enjoyed it, the art is actually not too bad.
We obviously need to read more so we can piece together the story and the fact that Eastman is co-writing it makes it all that much better.

I was really grateful to my lcs owner, he had put his only Eastman, gatefold and Keith variant covers aside for me - so i managed to pick up seven covers in one shot.

Ninjinister
08-24-2011, 09:33 PM
Now they have already made the first mistake of changing the origin to make it make more "sense" and deviating away greatly from what has worked for years,
Like 4kids with that stupid Utrom and Demon Shredders. I say let's stay the course

This is utterly ridiculous. Who wants to read the same s**t with different pictures?

willtupper
08-24-2011, 09:36 PM
I don't have much to add. Other than you can put me down in the "freakin' loved it!" camp.

That's not an exaggeration. I wanted to take this comic to prom. I wanted to dance with it during every song, then I wanted the chauffeur to drive us home before I gave the comic a passionate - but respectful! - kiss goodnight.

I'm going to respect this comic in the morning.

But, no. It's not perfect. Not many comics are. How could it have been better? As I read it over, I can only come up with two big issues that I had with what we got:

1. The comic is 22-pages long. In that short space, we are introduced to:

Old Hob
Splinter
Leonardo
Michelangelo
Donatello
Raphael
Chet Allen
April O'Neil
Baxter Stockman
General Krang
Lindsey (a minor character? But still - a character)
Casey Jones
Casey Jones' Dad (presumably another minor character)

That is 13 characters, in 22 pages. That's a new character approximately every 1.7 pages. Which is a LOT! But, I've got a feeling that will iron itself out with the next few issues. I guess it's good to get all the players out "on stage" right away, but still. It did feel a little overwhelming.

2. The adverbs:

The skies rumble threateningly. [pg1]

Coldly analytical and deliberate. [pg5]

Militantly disciplined and precise. [pg5]

Absurdly unorthodox and carefree. [pg5]

These four captions all contain unnecessary words. The adverbs add nothing. Sure, take them away and the captions are both shorter and simpler:

The skies rumble. Analytical and deliberate. Disciplined and precise. Unorthodox and carefree.

Only now, they're also far stronger. Adverbs are our enemy. The red pen of editorial justice must strike hard, and then fade away...

Into the night (but not "swiftly" into the night, or "stealthily" into the night. Just fade way. Into the night).

I'm counting down the days until issue 2 hits stands happily (ha! ;)).

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 09:47 PM
Okay, I got inspired by that last page and just had to make this up:

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/idwTMNTchildservices.jpg

Venom
08-24-2011, 09:52 PM
Okay, I got inspired by that last page and just had to make this up

:D I gotta snag that and post it on my girlfriend's fb page (she works in that industry!) :D:D

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 10:06 PM
You all just get a kick out off making fun off me don't you. just admit it

VR9NbvTOfaU

No harm meant, USH. I respect the fact that turtle fans have diverse tastes. "Each to his own, boys; there's plenty for all." (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-zI9ztvzn4#t=4m01s)

I don't have much to add. Other than you can put me down in the "freakin' loved it!" camp.

That's not an exaggeration. I wanted to take this comic to prom. I wanted to dance with it during every song, then I wanted the chauffeur to drive us home before I gave the comic a passionate - but respectful! - kiss goodnight.

I'm going to respect this comic in the morning.

Uh-huh... You might wanna get some help, Will. J/K

2. The adverbs:


These four captions all contain unnecessary words. The adverbs add nothing. Sure, take them away and the captions are both shorter and simpler:

...

Only now, they're also far stronger. Adverbs are our enemy. The red pen of editorial justice must strike hard, and then fade away...

Into the night (but not "swiftly" into the night, or "stealthily" into the night. Just fade way. Into the night).


As a general principle... I so totally agree!

However, the one exception I appreciated in this issue was Leonardo's "militantly disciplined" description. It struck me as very odd when I read it. I thought, "now how did Leonardo get military training?" But as I read through the issue and started catching the ramifications of their (potential) origin, that particular adverb really takes on a whole new significance.

:D I gotta snag that and post it on my girlfriend's fb page (she works in that industry!) :D:D

I've always wanted to create "the next great internet meme.":tcool:

Nelson
08-24-2011, 10:09 PM
Got it and read it in ten minutes, maybe less. Not too much to it. Wasn't clever, funny of exciting. Art was amateurish and felt rushed; the Eastman-penciled samples at the end looked better than the actual comic.

Of course it suffers from current-comic-storytelling-itis in that it's all introduction. Of course to know the whole story you'll have to buy and read three more issues (I'm guessing here.) And not even by then we'll have a complete story, but just an introduction to the second arc. Bah.

I won't buy more issues. Maybe if the reviews are amazing I'll get the trade, but I doubt it.

Abnormal Freak
08-24-2011, 10:11 PM
And the new book brings out Nelson. :p Hi, dude.

Eastman posted a few of his layouts on Facebook:

http://www.facebook.com/home.php?ref=hpskip#!/media/set/?set=a.2126312328884.116700.1578189979

It's interesting how his art makes more sense. That panel where Splinter thwacks Old Hob with his stick looks really goofy and difficult to read in the final art; here in Eastman's layout, you can actually read the action. He's always been really good with motion (line of action or whatever).

1984TMNT
08-24-2011, 10:15 PM
That's not a fact...we don't know a whole lot of anything at the moment...which may be the leading part of my frustration.

Never said it was. I said it's a possibility.

Nelson
08-24-2011, 10:21 PM
Hi, Freak! Just saw the link and yes, his layouts are more understandable...

I'm concerned that his artwork isn't really going to bring the "Oh wow!" factor that a new TMNT comic kind of needs on the shelf right now -- TMNT has a... let's call it a "certain reputation." At this point, when some random person discovers this comic in their shop and flips through it it needs to POP or the book won't be given a second look or chance. Coupled with the so-so coloring, I'm a little worried in that department.

I don't think this comic will help TMNT gain new fans.

Bah...

oldmanwinters
08-24-2011, 10:44 PM
Casey's dad's true identity is:


http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/40/401079-35939-sandman_large.JPG (http://www.comicvine.com/35939-sandman/105-401079/)
http://www.comicvine.com/sandman/29-3544/all-images/108-218750/35939-sandman/105-401079/

It was so obvious to me. Surely somebody else thought that too?

soccerstud652
08-24-2011, 10:45 PM
Anyone else keep thinking:

Splinters back from the dead!!! Not Battle Nexus Splinter!!!! oh wait. This isn't Vol. 4.

In all seriousness, it's just nice to see the turtles back on the comic shelves, with some new life and maybe some new adventures to come...

Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 11:01 PM
My mini-review of TMNT #1:

Story & writing: I'm pleasantly surprised on all fronts. Before this I didn't know him from Adam, but right away it seems that Tom Waltz is a writer that really understands narrative and the oft-maligned (these days in some of the most "critically acclaimed" books at DC) craft of proper storytelling. I get right away that this isn't just a fluke, that he really does know how to spin a yarn casting us right into things without providing all the answers (yet leaving us still begging them, but this is how it should be). We're not beaten over the head with splash pages or any of the nonsense that passes for so-called "widescreen comics" these days or really anything that ever feels like "filler"... pretty much every page, every panel is treated like the true creative real estate it should be in a comic. It's no mystery I have huge trepidation about making a new comic book TMNT universe that is to be some kind of hodgepodge of the children's spinoff material... many interviews have popped up indicating this kind of general, "We're going to try to please all TMNT fans" -- now, I've been a TMNT fan for a very long time and I consider myself pretty familiar with just about every facet of it, from the Fred Wolf hardcorers to the slash-fictioners to the ones living in fictional universes where they're in a band with a Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation band... to name just some. My point is, generally speaking -- and I can pretty much guarantee you with the TMNT fandom -- if you go into things trying to please everyone, you're going to end up pleasing no one. This cautionary mentality on my part, however, mostly seems to have been for nothing it turns out. Tom and company didn't just draw this up on the fly or on a whim or coming from any kind of blind nostalgia-for-nostalgia's-sake. There seems to have been serious world-making thought into the hows and the whys and the whos and I really get the sense it's all going to be made very organic to one another when we're enough issues in that we can go, "Ohhh, OK, now I get it."

Art: I have no axe to grind about Dan Duncan, and if this was 1992 there would be absolutely nothing wrong with him on a TMNT comic. He has style, he understands proportion and perspective (believe it or not, right there that already puts him head and shoulders over a huge number of his peers). His take on TMNT is unique and as valid as any other. Unfortunately, though, this is not 1992... it's 2011, and the Turtles as a comic have a very large uphill battle to fight as far as the general comic-going public (such as it is) is concerned. You see, even if every active user on this message board -- or hell, every "active" TMNT fan out there -- went out there and picked up a copy of TMNT #1... that's not even remotely close to enough to keep a book like this afloat -- it needs to capture the regular comic book readers, the same people getting done with DC's "Blackest Night" or Marvel's "Fear Itself" or what-have-you. I tell you, if I wasn't already a TMNT fan and I picked this up on the shelf on a whim... I don't know that I'd be captivated by it, given the art. Several panels in Stockman's lab and elsewhere are just downright sketchy, and there seems to be a general reluctance to do a lot in the way of backgrounds by Dan, more panels than not going by with none whatsoever (the colorist left to kind of try and compensate). But these are just commercial worries on the art, not gripes on my behalf, per se. I want this book to succeed and so should you.

Coloring: You know, I'm a bit mixed. My first thoughts from the ashcan and all that was that the coloring is "so-so" and maybe that hasn't changed all that much since (this book, or at least this opening story needs a Moose or Nei Ruffino-caliber coloring job to really make this thing pop off the shelves)... but I will say that after carefully reading and looking over #1 that I have a great deal more sympathy for Ronda Pattison. Dan's art is such that he's leaving panel after panel as these wide, blank canvases that she's more or less left to make heads or tails of and kind of "save." She does a good job with what she's given, and I do love her attention to lighting as seen when Raphael is looking in on the Jones family, and her "blood splotch" effect during the Old Hob scuffle. I'd like to see what she could do with a stronger artist as the synergy between artist and colorist can often be a thing that varies wildly from combination to combination.

But yes, IDW's TMNT definitely has my support and #1 has certainly locked my interest. What a cool book.

Raph's Girl
08-24-2011, 11:39 PM
Casey's dad's true identity is:


http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/40/401079-35939-sandman_large.JPG (http://www.comicvine.com/35939-sandman/105-401079/)
http://www.comicvine.com/sandman/29-3544/all-images/108-218750/35939-sandman/105-401079/

It was so obvious to me. Surely somebody else thought that too?

I was thinking the same thing when I saw him. I was like "Sandman had another kid?" :lol:

Abnormal Freak
08-24-2011, 11:44 PM
A gripe I have with the book, which others have mentioned, is definitely it being so short. Issue one was a breeze to get through (I usually take a pretty long time reading a single issue, "studying" the art and that), and $4 for 22 pages is kind of bogus, to be honest. I hope future issues will be longer.

NYShell
08-24-2011, 11:46 PM
(First of all I haven't been on this forum in so long. Too much to do and not enough time for this. Its good to see fans still doing Turtle stuff.) This is the first time I picked up a Turtles issue on the release date, and a number one issue at that! First of all, the cover artwork isn't all that bad. It looks kinda edgy and gritty. I didn't realize Eastmen was involved and doing the story. I was kind of worried when I first heard IDW was picking up the TMNT comics. Reading the through the comic, I thought some parts were a little weird. Like the character Old Hob. They didn't explain his background so I'm curious to learn about his origin. Raph hardly had any prescense in this issue, and it was a number one! I was expecting all four brothers to be together in the first issue! But it was interesting to see him by his lonesome self, again. I thought it was kind of cool to see April having a connection with the turtles before they mutated, working in Stockman's company. I hope they don't turn him into a fly, again. Splinter is already interacting with the turtles and April too. Splinter's job of naming the turtles is covered by April. And I'm assuming she's a college student after her talking about her history class. I'm really anxious to see if General Krang is an actual army general or an Utrom posing as a human. And wait a minute... no Shredder!? That's like taking away Megatron from Transformers. And its cool to see Casey as an adolescent. There were a lot of things that made me doubt this direction IDW is taking, but its to early to make any conclusions. All in all, I'm really excited to see what IDW is going to do next! :tgrin:

jase
08-24-2011, 11:54 PM
I assume when Splinter narrates "and with the bittersweet experience of centuries" he is referencing the age old war between cats and rats. I don't think it is anything more than that...

RskimB
08-24-2011, 11:55 PM
so far i'm whelmed. but its still early in the series so i'll give it time. Still trying to adjust but Duncan's art seems a bit too sketch like. As other have mentioned things that seem a bit off: floppy plastrons, no pupils, DEM TEETH. story was alright went by quickly, looking for the gaps to be filled but it set the next issue decently enough.

Topsu
08-25-2011, 12:14 AM
I FREAKIN' LOVE IT.
This.

I really liked the art and story so far, I can't wait for the next issue. My only complain is that I think 4 first issues should probably be read on same sitting to get more out of the origin story.

willtupper
08-25-2011, 01:01 AM
I get what you're saying, my friend. But it still doesn't work for me.

Being disciplined and precise is to behave "militantly." Those qualities are inherent to being militant.

You'll never, ever see someone say:

Militantly undisciplined and imprecise.

I'm sorry. But that's just not going to happen.

So, I still feel that "militantly" (like pretty much every other adverb, ever) is overkill.

ALSO:

I left a character out of my earlier list. There is also "Margaret," a voice that appears to belong to a some sort of secretary for Baxter Stockman.

That bumps the total number of characters introduced in issue one up to fourteen. Which, in a 22 page story, averages out to 1 character every 1.57 pages.

Has anyone heard word on the release date of issue 2? If it's 4 weeks from yesterday (Wednesday, August 24th), that would put it out on Wednesday, September 21st.

As a general principle... I so totally agree!

However, the one exception I appreciated in this issue was Leonardo's "militantly disciplined" description. It struck me as very odd when I read it. I thought, "now how did Leonardo get military training?" But as I read through the issue and started catching the ramifications of their (potential) origin, that particular adverb really takes on a whole new significance.

Zog the Equalizer
08-25-2011, 01:03 AM
Picked up my copy from my pull box at my local comic shop. They charged me $10 for the Eastmen for it instead of normal price so I had to hold off buying any of the other variants for now. At least until I find a way to pay for text books. So far I really like the changed origin. Then again I'm just happy to see TMNT comics back on the shelves in general.

Eiko
08-25-2011, 01:17 AM
I have not received this book in the mail yet but what i have read about it on here sounds promising. I hope doesn't turn out like the the Mirage series where most of the story's where quite boring. Only time will tell i guess.

adz
08-25-2011, 05:34 AM
Well what a turtley Thursday it has been for me! I get home to two parcels at my door, the 4 cyber samurai TMNT Figurines, issue #49 of TMNT Vol #1 (last i needed to finish off Vol #1 YEEEEHEEEE!!! AND Issue #1 of IDW at my LCS! Best day ever haha. Now to the serious stuff, IDW's TMNT....LOVED IT!! It's great to have a fresh take on our green pals origins. Besides we will ALWAYS have there original origins, that will never go away. The story awesome, art awesome all just simply awesome. Can't wait till #2!!

Cheesebrush
08-25-2011, 06:06 AM
At least most of you have got copies - I've had this on order (plus all possible cover variants they can get their hands on) with a major comic shop here in London since it was first announced. I just called them and it hasn't even arrived even though all this week's other IDW titles are in!

I'm not exactly happy. They said they will get them next week but I am somewhat suspicious that they won't turn up at all or I'll only get one cover variant. Trouble is I now have to wait a week to see what does (or doesn't) turn up - I can't just go elsewhere to get them. Grrrrrr.......

ToTheNines
08-25-2011, 06:45 AM
I really wish I hadn't read the ashcan... those first eight pages are the only look we get at Splinter and the guys (aside from the regular animals and Raph's solo outing).

Donnie
08-25-2011, 08:32 AM
I'm late to the party, but I was at the feast...

I went to my local shop an hour after it opened and purchased 4 Donny covers, 1 Mikey, the Eastman variant, and the Kieth variant (snagged it for $10!)

The opening sequence introducing the Turtles was spot on, even if Raphael wasn't present. It just worked. Michelangelo stood out to me - his "Train THIS!" was very Raphael-esque but worked for him as well.

The mystery of the origin story is really the top priority here. At first, I was thinking those turtles in the tank couldn't be the TMNT - I know the original story was hard to digest for newcomers, but at least the ooze was created by an unexplainable alien technology, and not by human minds. I can deal with that, but as a student of science I really hope IDW fleshes out a decent scientific explanation (as fit for science fiction at least) for the rapid mutation of the Turtles in only 18 months time, including how their martial arts abilities were learned, etc.

I honestly wouldn't mind some sort of blending of human/Turtle in the origin - it would make sense to go into more depth and explain why the Turtles are humanoid, after all. I like Jester's meanderings concerning the Marvel-esque origin, perhaps they were trained to be super soldiers but somehow broke free (I'm sure April would have a hand in setting them free). That doesn't account for the insane ninja skills acquired, but I have faith in Tom, Kevin & co. that we will get well rounded explanations for everything!

All in all, this was an amazing first issue for me. Seeing the Turtles in comic form again made me extremely happy, and IDW isn't just regurgitating the same old - they are totally re-vamping the series while keeping in the original Mirage vein. It's a bold but necessary move, in my opinion. I'm so excited for the next issue!

EDIT: It is entirely possible that "General Krang" is an utrom and is supplying Stockman with the alien technology to mutate the Turtles. This hadn't immediately occured to me.

The Big Bad
08-25-2011, 11:36 AM
I read it, and I put a review up at my other, non-TMNT blog (http://doknowbutchie.wordpress.com/2011/08/25/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-vol-6-1/). Because that's how I roll. In general, I feel its a good starting issue if you already liked the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, but has little to recommend it if you're not. Choice segment:

Now, it’s hard to say whether these changes will work or not—so far, we’ve only been given a tiny bit of backstory, and to be entirely fair, none of the changes so far have been badly implemented, so far—in fact, they’re the most intriguing and interesting part of the book (this isn’t entirely a positive thing [...]). However, the pessimistic part of me feels that unless there’s some kind of upcoming drastic swerve, the changes so far change the characters in ways that make them not the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, but a similar concept with the TMNT name attached. For example, there has been no mention so far of any of turtles’ Japanese backstory: how, then, do the characters become ninja, as opposed to boxers, traceurs , or capoeira masters? Why is Splinter their master, for that matter?

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 11:52 AM
My mini-review of TMNT #1:

Story & writing: I'm pleasantly surprised on all fronts. Before this I didn't know him from Adam, but right away it seems that Tom Waltz is a writer that really understands narrative and the oft-maligned (these days in some of the most "critically acclaimed" books at DC) craft of proper storytelling. I get right away that this isn't just a fluke, that he really does know how to spin a yarn casting us right into things without providing all the answers (yet leaving us still begging them, but this is how it should be). We're not beaten over the head with splash pages or any of the nonsense that passes for so-called "widescreen comics" these days or really anything that ever feels like "filler"... pretty much every page, every panel is treated like the true creative real estate it should be in a comic. It's no mystery I have huge trepidation about making a new comic book TMNT universe that is to be some kind of hodgepodge of the children's spinoff material... many interviews have popped up indicating this kind of general, "We're going to try to please all TMNT fans" -- now, I've been a TMNT fan for a very long time and I consider myself pretty familiar with just about every facet of it, from the Fred Wolf hardcorers to the slash-fictioners to the ones living in fictional universes where they're in a band with a Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation band... to name just some. My point is, generally speaking -- and I can pretty much guarantee you with the TMNT fandom -- if you go into things trying to please everyone, you're going to end up pleasing no one. This cautionary mentality on my part, however, mostly seems to have been for nothing it turns out. Tom and company didn't just draw this up on the fly or on a whim or coming from any kind of blind nostalgia-for-nostalgia's-sake. There seems to have been serious world-making thought into the hows and the whys and the whos and I really get the sense it's all going to be made very organic to one another when we're enough issues in that we can go, "Ohhh, OK, now I get it."

Art: I have no axe to grind about Dan Duncan, and if this was 1992 there would be absolutely nothing wrong with him on a TMNT comic. He has style, he understands proportion and perspective (believe it or not, right there that already puts him head and shoulders over a huge number of his peers). His take on TMNT is unique and as valid as any other. Unfortunately, though, this is not 1992... it's 2011, and the Turtles as a comic have a very large uphill battle to fight as far as the general comic-going public (such as it is) is concerned. You see, even if every active user on this message board -- or hell, every "active" TMNT fan out there -- went out there and picked up a copy of TMNT #1... that's not even remotely close to enough to keep a book like this afloat -- it needs to capture the regular comic book readers, the same people getting done with DC's "Blackest Night" or Marvel's "Fear Itself" or what-have-you. I tell you, if I wasn't already a TMNT fan and I picked this up on the shelf on a whim... I don't know that I'd be captivated by it, given the art. Several panels in Stockman's lab and elsewhere are just downright sketchy, and there seems to be a general reluctance to do a lot in the way of backgrounds by Dan, more panels than not going by with none whatsoever (the colorist left to kind of try and compensate). But these are just commercial worries on the art, not gripes on my behalf, per se. I want this book to succeed and so should you.

Coloring: You know, I'm a bit mixed. My first thoughts from the ashcan and all that was that the coloring is "so-so" and maybe that hasn't changed all that much since (this book, or at least this opening story needs a Moose or Nei Ruffino-caliber coloring job to really make this thing pop off the shelves)... but I will say that after carefully reading and looking over #1 that I have a great deal more sympathy for Ronda Pattison. Dan's art is such that he's leaving panel after panel as these wide, blank canvases that she's more or less left to make heads or tails of and kind of "save." She does a good job with what she's given, and I do love her attention to lighting as seen when Raphael is looking in on the Jones family, and her "blood splotch" effect during the Old Hob scuffle. I'd like to see what she could do with a stronger artist as the synergy between artist and colorist can often be a thing that varies wildly from combination to combination.

But yes, IDW's TMNT definitely has my support and #1 has certainly locked my interest. What a cool book.

Great write-up, Andrew -- thanks much, man!

Tom

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 12:06 PM
I get what you're saying, my friend. But it still doesn't work for me.

Being disciplined and precise is to behave "militantly." Those qualities are inherent to being militant.

You'll never, ever see someone say:

Militantly undisciplined and imprecise.

I'm sorry. But that's just not going to happen.

So, I still feel that "militantly" (like pretty much every other adverb, ever) is overkill.

ALSO:

I left a character out of my earlier list. There is also "Margaret," a voice that appears to belong to a some sort of secretary for Baxter Stockman.

That bumps the total number of characters introduced in issue one up to fourteen. Which, in a 22 page story, averages out to 1 character every 1.57 pages.

Has anyone heard word on the release date of issue 2? If it's 4 weeks from yesterday (Wednesday, August 24th), that would put it out on Wednesday, September 21st.

I LOVE the adverb debate! Actually, I totally, truly, lovingly, whole-heartedly, excitedly, happily LOVE the adverb debate! :)

To be (completely) honest, willtupper, the adverbs were a deliberate choice -- our Splinter tends to wax a bit purple, so to speak, and those redundant adverbs are a part of his speech pattern, both as a component of his inner-monologue as well as his inter-personal conversations. I tried to get him to stop using all those (insanely) crazy adverbs, but he shook his cane at me (angrily, of course), so I (simply) backed down and (quickly) typed his words the way he (adamantly) wanted me to.

:tgrin:

Thanks for your support of our story -- really dug your character list!

Tom W.

Jester
08-25-2011, 12:23 PM
14fXm4FOMPM

1984TMNT
08-25-2011, 12:27 PM
The mystery of the origin story is really the top priority here. At first, I was thinking those turtles in the tank couldn't be the TMNT - I know the original story was hard to digest for newcomers, but at least the ooze was created by an unexplainable alien technology, and not by human minds. I can deal with that, but as a student of science I really hope IDW fleshes out a decent scientific explanation (as fit for science fiction at least) for the rapid mutation of the Turtles in only 18 months time, including how their martial arts abilities were learned, etc.

I honestly wouldn't mind some sort of blending of human/Turtle in the origin - it would make sense to go into more depth and explain why the Turtles are humanoid, after all. I like Jester's meanderings concerning the Marvel-esque origin, perhaps they were trained to be super soldiers but somehow broke free (I'm sure April would have a hand in setting them free). That doesn't account for the insane ninja skills acquired, but I have faith in Tom, Kevin & co. that we will get well rounded explanations for everything!


If their origin does in fact end up going down this road (or something similar), is anyone else concerned that this really alters the "family" aspect of the guys? For me, this would fundamentally change the dynamic between the guys themselves, and Splinter as well. I'm sure it's debatable, but I really think that the guys being a family and growing together over the years is something that has allowed the TMNT to be relate-able to most fans, including casual folks.

Having the Turtles creation be attributed to a "Super Soldier" program just doesn't sit well with me (It seems like there have been plenty of characters that have been created in a lab this way....whether accidental or on purpose - see, Captain America, Spider Man, The Hulk, etc). Isn't that essentially how Bebop and Rocksteady were created? Taking humans and trying to mutate them into a super humans who are genetically altered to have animal like features/strength/qualities? I think having the Turtles accidentally mutated to human form is more intriguing, followed by experiments where others try to replicate that feat, with mixed results. Of course, this doesn't mean that the accident has to be a child carrying four turtles and dropping them down a sewer drain into a pile of ooze. I just think there is a lot of potential to really put a spin on the original origin without completely changing every aspect of it.

Obviously, everything is speculation right now, but I just don't see how the guys can truly bond as a family unit, train, etc. in 18 months and have that be something that is "believable" (relative term when speaking of TMNT) or nearly as relate-able.

At the end of the day, I can't wait to see what happens and how this all unfolds. I'm keeping my hopes up that I'm able to "buy in" to the story provided and stay interested. So far, I'm hooked and counting down the days for the next issue. This is going to be a loooooooong 5 months. ;)

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 12:50 PM
14fXm4FOMPM

Heh!

:lol:

Jester
08-25-2011, 12:54 PM
Gotta live up to the name...and I like adverbs. :D

Donnie
08-25-2011, 12:56 PM
If their origin does in fact end up going down this road (or something similar), is anyone else concerned that this really alters the "family" aspect of the guys? For me, this would fundamentally change the dynamic between the guys themselves, and Splinter as well. I'm sure it's debatable, but I really think that the guys being a family and growing together over the years is something that has allowed the TMNT to be relate-able to most fans, including casual folks.

Obviously, everything is speculation right now, but I just don't see how the guys can truly bond as a family unit, train, etc. in 18 months and have that be something that is "believable" (relative term when speaking of TMNT) or nearly as relate-able.


I share your concerns. Splinter did say "my sons" during the battle, though, which gives me hope.

Jester
08-25-2011, 12:58 PM
Indeed, that did give me some hope as well, since the whole year and a half scenario kinda has me on edge...but only time will tell if my fears are well founded. This is the first issue after all there will be a lot of mystery, so you come back salivating in 30 days.

TheCanadiandrome
08-25-2011, 01:21 PM
Well what a turtley Thursday it has been for me! I get home to two parcels at my door, the 4 cyber samurai TMNT Figurines, issue #49 of TMNT Vol #1 (last i needed to finish off Vol #1 YEEEEHEEEE!!! AND Issue #1 of IDW at my LCS! Best day ever haha. Now to the serious stuff, IDW's TMNT....LOVED IT!! It's great to have a fresh take on our green pals origins. Besides we will ALWAYS have there original origins, that will never go away. The story awesome, art awesome all just simply awesome. Can't wait till #2!!

hey congrats on that

Rat A Tat
08-25-2011, 01:23 PM
The loss of the family feeling between the turtles, along with the confusion of how they've learned to fight, were immediately my two biggest concerns/questions when I put #1 down. My thoughts are still largely up in the air about them learning to fight, mainly waiting for #2 to help enlighten me, but after a day of reflection I'm not as concerned about the family aspect.

I think the TMNT staff can easily still work in the family sentiments without having 15 years of history between the turtles and Splinter, and I'm sure that they fully intend to. It even creates potential for new angles of watching that family form, in ways we've not quite delved into in the past. In remaining open-minded to this complete reboot, I'm actually now looking forward to how they build the family relationships.

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 01:34 PM
The loss of the family feeling between the turtles, along with the confusion of how they've learned to fight, were immediately my two biggest concerns/questions when I put #1 down. My thoughts are still largely up in the air about them learning to fight, mainly waiting for #2 to help enlighten me, but after a day of reflection I'm not as concerned about the family aspect.

I think the TMNT staff can easily still work in the family sentiments without having 15 years of history between the turtles and Splinter, and I'm sure that they fully intend to. It even creates potential for new angles of watching that family form, in ways we've not quite delved into in the past. In remaining open-minded to this complete reboot, I'm actually now looking forward to how they build the family relationships.

As I mentioned in the SDCC ashcan interview, the part about TMNT lore that has always meant the most to me is the familial bonds that the turtles share with not only Master Splinter, but also with Casey Jones and April O'Neil, to name a few. Rest assured -- and without giving too much away -- I will say that it will continue to be a huge part of this new IDW continuity.

We've many surprises yet...

Master Splinter
08-25-2011, 01:34 PM
I think the TMNT staff can easily still work in the family sentiments without having 15 years of history between the turtles and Splinter, and I'm sure that they fully intend to. It even creates potential for new angles of watching that family form, in ways we've not quite delved into in the past. In remaining open-minded to this complete reboot, I'm actually now looking forward to how they build the family relationships.

I feel like the family is already there. If you notice non-mutated Splinter is sitting atop of the turtle cage. Thus (in my eyes) showing he is protecting them. Standing over them as a father figure per say. Maybe he already had some testing done on him and he feels as though he must protect other animals within the building. The psycho treatment thing was to seperate human like thought from animal instinct, well what if it improved the human like thought, and the animals are already mutating and becoming a family through this bond.... As far as the ninja training stuff, I think it is perfectly feasible that they could get dowsed with the "super-solider mutagen" and gain incredible strength and probably advanced fighting knowledge... Who knows? Also, who is to say that Splinter before being taken to the bio-engineering facility wasn't Hamato Yoshi's pet, or lived in Japan, etc...

I just can't wait to see what happens... Damn you Tom Waltz and your 30 day waiting period! LOL!

-ms

1984TMNT
08-25-2011, 01:46 PM
As I mentioned in the SDCC ashcan interview, the part about TMNT lore that has always meant the most to me is the familial bonds that the turtles share with not only Master Splinter, but also with Casey Jones and April O'Neil, to name a few. Rest assured -- and without giving too much away -- I will say that it will continue to be a huge part of this new IDW continuity.

We've many surprises yet...

That's great to know. Very re-assuring. Now hopefully, we'll see/learn they developed into ninjas with intense training and not just from some syrum :trazz:

You're such a tease, Tom.

Seriously though, it's awesome that you are taking the time to gauge fan reaction and chime in with your thoughts. On behalf of the TMNT fandom, thank you!!

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 01:52 PM
I feel like the family is already there. If you notice non-mutated Splinter is sitting atop of the turtle cage. Thus (in my eyes) showing he is protecting them. Standing over them as a father figure per say. Maybe he already had some testing done on him and he feels as though he must protect other animals within the building. The psycho treatment thing was to seperate human like thought from animal instinct, well what if it improved the human like thought, and the animals are already mutating and becoming a family through this bond.... As far as the ninja training stuff, I think it is perfectly feasible that they could get dowsed with the "super-solider mutagen" and gain incredible strength and probably advanced fighting knowledge... Who knows? Also, who is to say that Splinter before being taken to the bio-engineering facility wasn't Hamato Yoshi's pet, or lived in Japan, etc...

I just can't wait to see what happens... Damn you Tom Waltz and your 30 day waiting period! LOL!

-ms

I'm cruel that way.

But... because I love you folks so much, here's a sneak peek at a page from issue #2 showing the gang in their "family room." Shhh... don't tell anyone... this preview is our little secret, right?

:)

oldmanwinters
08-25-2011, 01:54 PM
Shhh... don't tell anyone... this preview is our little secret, right?

:)

Of course I'll keep it secret!

*Blabs to the world*

And page 18 no less! It's almost a preview of the cliff-hanger ending!

Jester
08-25-2011, 01:57 PM
I'm cruel that way.

But... because I love you folks so much, here's a sneak peek at a page from issue #2 showing the gang in their "family room." Shhh... don't tell anyone... this preview is our little secret, right?

:)
To the facebooks and such....


Kidding...kidding.

Donnie
08-25-2011, 02:13 PM
I absolutely love the lair! Thanks so much, Tom!

LeoNerdo
08-25-2011, 02:21 PM
I just gotta say how cool it is to be here at the beginning of an ongoing Turtles book, and to have the man at the helm of this ship here sharing it with us. Pure awesome-ness! Thank you Tom!

Rat A Tat
08-25-2011, 02:32 PM
I feel like the family is already there. If you notice non-mutated Splinter is sitting atop of the turtle cage. Thus (in my eyes) showing he is protecting them. Standing over them as a father figure per say. Maybe he already had some testing done on him and he feels as though he must protect other animals within the building.

-ms

Well said. Hm, there's also that shot of one of the turtles standing on the others back, leaning up against the glass almost as if maybe trying to get out, or get a better view of something. Has a teamwork/family vibe to it almost. Which two might they be, eh? Donny and Mikey? Haha.


Thanks for the sneak peak Tom! Gleaning info from this page...hm...there's only pepperoni on that pizza Mikey's eating, no jelly beans or marshmallows! DISCUSS!! :P

Master Splinter
08-25-2011, 02:33 PM
I'm cruel that way.

But... because I love you folks so much, here's a sneak peek at a page from issue #2 showing the gang in their "family room." Shhh... don't tell anyone... this preview is our little secret, right?

:)

Looks great!

-ms

azrael
08-25-2011, 03:22 PM
Sorry I am to the party a little late but .....

I effing loved this book better than what I was expecting, love the origin thus far, I love what they are keeping from mirage but throwing down like Rocky Balboa.

Cant wait for issue 2.

Interesting they choose sea turtles to represent the turtles.

Powder
08-25-2011, 03:43 PM
The expressions on that preview page... priceless, haha. I love seein' Don don the goggles, too.

Andrew NDB
08-25-2011, 03:47 PM
Interesting they choose sea turtles to represent the turtles.

That's about all I can say about that, too. I don't really have any feelings one way or the other on it... I mean, the Turtles aren't common pet shop turtles in this iteration of TMNT, so it's not like "OMG, why aren't they red-earred sliders?!"

You know what would be cool? Is if they were Mata Mata Turtles. :)

uStu1ccjqLM

Jester
08-25-2011, 04:01 PM
My brother-in-law has(had...I'm not sure anymore) one of those....ugly suckers.

ToTheNines
08-25-2011, 04:13 PM
http://comics.ign.com/articles/119/1190389p1.html

It got an 8 outta 10.

Aaaand, looks like #2 won't be out till the 28th of September.

Abnormal Freak
08-25-2011, 04:20 PM
I gotta laugh every time someone uses the words and phrase "dark and gritty" to describe the original comics. Have they ever even read the comics...?

ToTheNines
08-25-2011, 04:24 PM
Um, the subject matter could get pretty dark at times, and I'd call the art "gritty" for sure.

AquaParade
08-25-2011, 04:34 PM
Thanks for the preview, Tom!

Let me guess...If Raph was featured on that page, he would be over in the corner by himself with an angry look on his face. :P
I know, I know...Leonardo leads, Donatello does machines....But it's never fun when the guys get boxed into those little generic roles. Not that we have any clue as to if this is the case in the new series, but it's something to think about.

Really though, the more I read issue #1, the bigger the grin on my face. One issue in and it feels like you guys have really nailed the tone so far - The family vibe is there, the group comes off as a serious ninja clan, and even "Old Hob" seems to perfectly walk the line between whacky and badass!

Congrats to the whole IDW TMNT team, on super cool first issue!

EDIT: Out of curiosity Tom, do you have any idea how long you plan to stay on the book? Any guess as to how long Duncan will stay on? I guess I'm interested in how far ahead you have planned for your take on the tmnt...Unless it is Kevin who has long term story plans.

Andrew NDB
08-25-2011, 04:45 PM
I gotta laugh every time someone uses the words and phrase "dark and gritty" to describe the original comics. Have they ever even read the comics...?

#1, Leonardo special, #10, "Return to New York," "City at War"... yes, quite gritty. And compared to pretty much any iteration of the TMNT besides the comics? Yeah, pretty much f***in blackness.

TheCollector
08-25-2011, 06:02 PM
I gotta say, one thing I love is the new April, she just looks great to me.

Ok, now that that's said, I have two theory's on the whole 18 month thing.

One has already been stated, that that's not them, and April's like undercover there or something. Which is unlikely due to the name of the rat. But then again, with the whole naming thing, when Chet looks at her and she comments on the Art class, the way she says it, with the 'uh' there makes it seem like she was making it up. Or maybe I'm reading to much into it.

The other, which I don't think has been talked about on here yet is this, what if the experiments, which you know are being run on the turtles as well, due to how nervous Chet get's when talking about them as well, what if it's making them smarter? I mean you saw the two on top of eachother trying to escape. That seems like intelligence. Unless turtles are known to do that, I don't know. Or maybe just like how the original mutagen gave them intelligence, maybe this does as well, though at a faster rate.

That's my two theory's anyway.

Andrew NDB
08-25-2011, 06:23 PM
For all we know the Turtles go on a time-travelling trip for 15 years.

Venom
08-25-2011, 06:30 PM
Interesting they choose sea turtles to represent the turtles.

Think of it this way though - the flippers mutating into three fingers and two toes would be easier to comprehend than the Turtles being red-eared sliders and losing their stripes, two carpal phalanges, and three tarsal phalanges, and claws. :tgrin:

Donnie
08-25-2011, 06:31 PM
Tom, any chance you can fill a Donny fan in on what he's working on there? :)

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 06:48 PM
Tom, any chance you can fill a Donny fan in on what he's working on there? :)

He's converting that old boom box into an ipod, of course!

Roseangelo
08-25-2011, 06:52 PM
Tom: Page 10, then/than. Just sayin'. ;)

azrael
08-25-2011, 06:53 PM
Think of it this way though - the flippers mutating into three fingers and two toes would be easier to comprehend than the Turtles being red-eared sliders and losing their stripes, two carpal phalanges, and three tarsal phalanges, and claws. :tgrin:

I am not complaining, they could be genetic crossbreads and will remain unspecific. Sea Turtles will remain in the sea through most of its life while these turtles have very little water in the cage at all (other than drinking water.)

I always preferred them to be unspecific turtles anyway.

1984TMNT
08-25-2011, 06:53 PM
He's converting that old boom box into an ipod, of course!

Sounds like the pilot episode that was shown (storyboards).....?

Galactus
08-25-2011, 07:25 PM
Sounds like the pilot episode that was shown (storyboards).....?

Haven't read the book yet but from what everyone else has said it jumps out at me that this is a mature take on a lot of the elements of the upcoming Nickleodeon cartoon.

We have the turtles with wraps, younger versions of April and Casey, Krang and a corporation making animal mutants for nefarious reasons.

TomWaltz
08-25-2011, 07:26 PM
Tom: Page 10, then/than. Just sayin'. ;)

Good eye, Roseangelo! I looked at these pages a million times before they went to the printer and missed that little boo-boo every time. Then I'm looking at a copy yesterday and it jumps out at me!

Gah!

We'll get that fixed for the trade, though, no worries. April's much smarter than that, after all...

:)

azrael
08-25-2011, 08:32 PM
TomWaltz,

I got to say I loved it, I hope it never ends and can keep the momentum up. This book was a bomb going off on most of the stuff I knew as the turtles and took me by surprise, in a good way. I know most if not all of us feel this way, but Thank You to You and the TMNT team.

keep em' coming

Donnie
08-25-2011, 09:17 PM
He's converting that old boom box into an ipod, of course!

Many thanks!

Andrew NDB
08-25-2011, 10:39 PM
I will say that the more I read this, the more Dan's art grows on me. This doesn't change my original point, though.

Donnie
08-25-2011, 10:45 PM
I will say that the more I read this, the more Dan's art grows on me. This doesn't change my original point, though.

I keep re-reading, it gets better and better!

Jester
08-25-2011, 10:54 PM
Part of me wonders my feelings of dissatisfaction comes from reading the ashcan, as it's about 1/3 of the issue.

Donnie
08-25-2011, 11:08 PM
Part of me wonders my feelings of dissatisfaction comes from reading the ashcan, as it's about 1/3 of the issue.

You know, I was a little let down that we only saw Donny, Leo, and Mike in that first scene. But the rest of the book/the general feel of the Turtles being re-vamped and in the right hands made me get over it already! Which isn't easy for me to do...

LeoNerdo
08-25-2011, 11:10 PM
Part of me wonders my feelings of dissatisfaction comes from reading the ashcan, as it's about 1/3 of the issue.

This. I spoiled myself a little w/ the ashcan. But I think I'll look back at the first issue more fondly especially in the context of the whole arc.

azrael
08-26-2011, 02:50 PM
I have read this issue about 6 times now.... anyone else?

Abnormal Freak
08-26-2011, 03:14 PM
I've read it all of one time. :p Flipped through it a couple more times to look at the art and things, though. Can't understand wanting to wear oneself off on a single issue of a really short comic. Just don't totally hate the thing once the trade comes out. ;)

Logan
08-26-2011, 03:47 PM
Just got my copy today and finished reading a few moments ago. It left me wanting more... in a good way.

I'm liking how characters are being tied together early on. It feels very organic. My only complaint is that the issue was too short. But there's always next month. :tgrin:

Andrew NDB
08-26-2011, 03:47 PM
This. I spoiled myself a little w/ the ashcan.

For some reason I assumed that the ashcan was actually going to serve as like a TMNT #0, as it said "Continued in TMNT #1" (what it meant was, "To be re-released with more pages in TMNT #1"), so I guess I felt a little misled in that way. But it was my own fault.

Bauer536
08-26-2011, 09:57 PM
So I recently bought the first issue of the IDW TMNT comic. I wish I could've gotten it with Leo on the cover, but they only had Don at my comic book store. Maybe if I do find one, I'll give the one I have to my brother, or someone else.

Anyway, I read the issue. It was fun, but yet unusual. I don't know where Eastman is going with this. It kind of baffles yet confuses me. Stockman is planning to make these turtles barbaric warriors to fight in a war with General Krang? This is just a guess. I have a feeling all of Krang's past mutants were so dumb that they had killer strength. But it may be a surprise to Krang and Stockman when they find out these turtles and rat ain't dumb.:tlol: I'm hoping that happens. But this has occured eighteen months ago. How do they learn ninjutsu so fast? Besides, I'm hoping this war that Krang is in involves him working with the Shredder. Then it will be like a 24 episode, with many surprises after each commercial. I don't know. I kind of like it so far, but I'm not sure what my reaction is going to be later.

Still, I'm pumped to get the first 7 issues of the original '84 comics in hardcover! That is what I'm really going to love!:tgrin:

oldmanwinters
08-26-2011, 10:01 PM
Then it will be like a 24 episode, with many surprises after each commercial.

Then the story arc would end with April being interrogated as a traitor... only to learn it was Master Splinter masterminding the whole evil plot from the beginning! Muhahah!

Bauer536
08-26-2011, 10:09 PM
Hahahaha! That is so funny! Then they'll find out that April is really Nina Meyers! And then Splinter will be Charles Logan! :tlol:

The reason why I mentioned 24:

1. I'm obsessed with it.

2. I liked it.

3. Just like the show, the suspense kills me reading this comic.

4. I can't wait for a month for the next issue to come out. It's worse than waiting for a week to see the next 24 episode.

Anyway, the joke was hilarious. I'm just hoping I find out what mutates the turtles, how they become ninjas, see some more character development, and actually see the Shredder soon. I'd love to know when the Shredder arrives.:tsmile:

Scanderson
08-26-2011, 10:26 PM
I enjoyed the first issue. Every time I think I have settled on a theory regarding the origin, I see something else that seems inconsistent with that theory. I am excited to see what direction this will go.

Originally, I thought that the the rat and the sea turtles are not the TMNT and Splinter, but that Krang was funding experiments to try to duplicate in the lab what happened to the TMNT and Splinter years ago. I thought that April was covertly interning in the lab to learn the status/progress of the experiments. Obviously, if Krang/Baxter could recreate the TMNT origin, they could create a whole army of warriors like the TMNT.

April seems to be extremely interested in what is going on there. However, she would clearly be showing her hand by naming the turtles with the same names as the TMNT, so that likely is not the case.

What does seem clear is...

- Old Hob has a beef directly with Splinter, not necessarily with the TMNT, but will take them all out to get to Splinter. They have a history. perhaps Old Hob was in the lab with them, and there was a battle where Splinter damaged Old Hob's eye and defeated him. Looking forward to seeing this rivalry develop over time. Old Hob is responsible for the separation of Raphael from the group.

Great to have this to look forward to each month. Thanks!

oldmanwinters
08-26-2011, 10:46 PM
What does seem clear is...

- Old Hob has a beef directly with Splinter, not necessarily with the TMNT, but will take them all out to get to Splinter. They have a history. perhaps Old Hob was in the lab with them, and there was a battle where Splinter damaged Old Hob's eye and defeated him. Looking forward to seeing this rivalry develop over time. Old Hob is responsible for the separation of Raphael from the group.


Interesting theory... that would almost imply that Old Hob played the role usually occupied by Oroku Saki.

azrael
08-26-2011, 11:00 PM
I've read it all of one time. :p Flipped through it a couple more times to look at the art and things, though. Can't understand wanting to wear oneself off on a single issue of a really short comic. Just don't totally hate the thing once the trade comes out. ;)

I wont be buying the trade, so no worries. I feel like each time I read it I notice something else.

TheCollector
08-26-2011, 11:44 PM
Y'know, I just realized something that's got me very excited. This is a new universe, this is a whole new continuity, everything that happened in the mirage u is gone. That means only one thing. SHREDDERS ALIVE!!!!
If there is a Shredder, which I hope there will be. And hopefully he'll be quite menacing when he does show up. And hopefully he'll last more then one issue. Ever since I started reading the comics I've felt they wasted the character by offing him so early. Especially after seeing the movies and 2k3 cartoon.

Powder
08-27-2011, 12:13 AM
Nothing that happened in Mirage is "Gone", compadre. It remains in Mirage's universe.

Donnie
08-27-2011, 12:41 AM
Nothing that happened in Mirage is "Gone", compadre. It remains in Mirage's universe.

Seriously. Do not forget the roots, people!

willtupper
08-27-2011, 01:06 AM
Much obliged for your reply, Herr Waltz.

While I'm not quite sure I'm ready to buy into the whole idea that Splinter speaks like an insecure college sophomore trying to compensate for his latest poorly-penned paper by pumping it up with a plethora of purple prose, I DO believe that YOU believe it. And that is MORE than enough for me. Especially this early in the story.

Although... have you ever tried to talk (not write, but talk) like that? It's darn near impossible.

One of the perks, I guess, of being a giant mutant rat :tgrin:.

I LOVE the adverb debate! Actually, I totally, truly, lovingly, whole-heartedly, excitedly, happily LOVE the adverb debate! :)

To be (completely) honest, willtupper, the adverbs were a deliberate choice -- our Splinter tends to wax a bit purple, so to speak, and those redundant adverbs are a part of his speech pattern, both as a component of his inner-monologue as well as his inter-personal conversations. I tried to get him to stop using all those (insanely) crazy adverbs, but he shook his cane at me (angrily, of course), so I (simply) backed down and (quickly) typed his words the way he (adamantly) wanted me to.

:tgrin:

Thanks for your support of our story -- really dug your character list!

Tom W.

Venom
08-27-2011, 10:20 AM
One of the perks, I guess, of being a giant mutant rat :tgrin:.

Therein lies the key component of Splinter's speech. He's a RAT! Rat's can't talk unless mutated, and while he may use different patterns of speech he is still the wise rat sensei we've always loved. (I would have inserted "old" in there as well but this Splinter seems younger than his counterparts in the multiverse.)

His overuse of certiain redundant words do not detract from his intellect, but rather shows to us, the readers, that his mind processes things a bit differently due to his (presumably) animal origins being granted the ability to vocalize and conjugate sentences.

As an illustration, have you ever read the transcripts of apes who communicate through sign language? Their words are choppy, the grammar simplistic. Knowing Tom's intentions with Splinter's speech, I see it as his rodent mind's way of processing these new thoughts he was never meant to have.

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 11:04 AM
Nothing that happened in Mirage is "Gone", compadre. It remains in Mirage's universe.

I didn't mean gone as in doesn't exist, guess I should of worded it better. I meant gone as in, never happened in this new IDW universe. Sorry for the confusion.

Venom
08-27-2011, 11:11 AM
I didn't mean gone as in doesn't exist, guess I should of worded it better. I meant gone as in, never happened in this new IDW universe. Sorry for the confusion.

It did happen/ is happening though, just in another parallel universe.

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 03:27 PM
It did happen/ is happening though, just in another parallel universe.

What are you talking about? Everything that happened in the mirage verse isn't gonna happen exactly the same here. Already the origin seems to be completely different and Old Hob never existed before. Either did Krang. Well, this version of Krang. As far as I know he wasn't in the Mirage verse.

Venom
08-27-2011, 05:03 PM
What are you talking about? Everything that happened in the mirage verse isn't gonna happen exactly the same here. Already the origin seems to be completely different and Old Hob never existed before. Either did Krang. Well, this version of Krang. As far as I know he wasn't in the Mirage verse.

I reread your post and saw what you were saying. I took it as Powder did initially. :)

Jester
08-27-2011, 05:12 PM
What are you talking about? Everything that happened in the mirage verse isn't gonna happen exactly the same here. Already the origin seems to be completely different and Old Hob never existed before. Either did Krang. Well, this version of Krang. As far as I know he wasn't in the Mirage verse.
Yes, the stories in the Mirage universe won't happen (or at least not the same way) in the IDW universe beause this is a fresh start, but the Mirage universe is still a part of the TMNT Multiverse.

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 05:21 PM
Yes, the stories in the Mirage universe won't happen (or at least not the same way) in the IDW universe beause this is a fresh start, but the Mirage universe is still a part of the TMNT Multiverse.

I knoooow. But I'm not talking about the whole Multiverse. Just This Universe. It didn't happen in This Universe.

Jester
08-27-2011, 05:27 PM
I knoooow. But I'm not talking about the whole Multiverse. Just This Universe. It didn't happen in This Universe.
Just explaining what Venom was saying.

Powder
08-27-2011, 05:42 PM
*insert TMNT facepalm meme*

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 06:18 PM
Ok! This has got to stop! Lets just ignore I said anything cause if we don't we'll just keep explaining what we mean over and over till that's all that'll be in this thread.

Jester
08-27-2011, 06:22 PM
Agreed.

So what are your hopes for issue 2?

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 06:34 PM
Agreed.

So what are your hopes for issue 2?

More April for one thing. She's always been one of my fav characters, and I love the design she's got here. And I'll love to see what more of a part she plays in their origin. Maybe she helps them escape the facility.

I also love Donatello so hopefully he gets some good screen/panel time.

Otherwhy's I dunno what else I want for the second issue. Though I know in the long run I want both Shredder and Karai to show up one day. They're my other two fav characters.

Jester
08-27-2011, 06:40 PM
More April for one thing. She's always been one of my fav characters, and I love the design she's got here. And I'll love to see what more of a part she plays in their origin. Maybe she helps them escape the facility.
You know I'd never thought of that. April seems to question the work of Stockgen, and if she feels that that it'd be in their best interest, I could see her springing the Turtles (and reluctantly Splinter.)

As for more screen time for her, not that I did like her, but of a 20 page comic she got more page time last issue than most of the Turtles.

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 07:11 PM
You know I'd never thought of that. April seems to question the work of Stockgen, and if she feels that that it'd be in their best interest, I could see her springing the Turtles (and reluctantly Splinter.)

As for more screen time for her, not that I did like her, but of a 20 page comic she got more page time last issue than most of Turtles.
Yeah, yeah good point. I guess I mean I hope her screen time doesn't dwindle to nothing. I've read to many comics where a character I love who started out strong dwindled to only appearing once a year.

oldmanwinters
08-27-2011, 07:27 PM
Yeah, yeah good point. I guess I mean I hope her screen time doesn't dwindle to nothing. I've read to many comics where a character I love who started out strong dwindled to only appearing once a year.

And unfortunately, April is especially prone to doing just that in other TMNT media.

Jester
08-27-2011, 07:30 PM
And unfortunately, April is especially prone to doing just that in other TMNT media.
True, but part of me thinks Tom made her such a large part of things so early on in an attempt to prevent just that. But then again only time will tell.

Donnie
08-27-2011, 08:02 PM
I like Jester's meanderings concerning the Marvel-esque origin, perhaps they were trained to be super soldiers but somehow broke free (I'm sure April would have a hand in setting them free).

It's like I didn't even say anything...:roll:

TheCollector
08-27-2011, 08:07 PM
And unfortunately, April is especially prone to doing just that in other TMNT media.

Too true. There was that whole Turtles Fast Forward series where she didn't appear once. Then there was the third live action movie and Turtles Forever where she appeared like two minutes out of the whole thing in both.

Jester
08-27-2011, 08:14 PM
It's like I didn't even say anything...:roll:
Yeah...sorry 'bout that. I skimmed it.

Venom
08-27-2011, 10:19 PM
It's like I didn't even say anything...:roll:

Get used to it, it happens a lot. :P No one means ill will though. :)

Donnie
08-28-2011, 12:48 AM
Yeah...sorry 'bout that. I skimmed it.

Get used to it, it happens a lot. :P No one means ill will though. :)

I'm guilty of it, too. I was just messing around! :D

Shreddhead
08-28-2011, 02:45 PM
Just managed to get my hands on the first issue today, and im liking what i see. Theres lots of questions im wondering about that will keep me coming back to get the new issues. One of which is Old Hob( is it just me or did anyone else think of Calvin and Hobbes when they saw the preview of that section?).

Like some of you i am somewhat skeptical of the short time period between baby turtles and ninja teenagers but im sure the next issues will help to resolve those questions.

Abnormal Freak
08-28-2011, 04:54 PM
We'll get that fixed for the trade, though, no worries.

Speaking of the trade: Will all of the variant covers be collected?

Fugitoid Jones
08-29-2011, 05:48 AM
Yeah, yeah good point. I guess I mean I hope her screen time doesn't dwindle to nothing. I've read to many comics where a character I love who started out strong dwindled to only appearing once a year.

Or she started out strong and relatable, and then was revealed to be a drawing. Yeah, as long as that doesn't happen, I'll be fine.

Thorneyeagle
08-29-2011, 08:05 AM
I have been thinking a lot about the concept of eightteen months. The time frame is very short to explain a true mastery of skill or proficiency we expect from our ninja turtles. We can all kind of agree we have our hesitations about this.

Is it possible, that prior to being a lab rat, splinter may have resided in homato yoshi's house. Wathing him from afar. Not as a pet but as a rat would normally infest a house. While he does not seem as old in this continuity he does feel older than the turtles.

My thought is that, this fight could be used to show the affects of the mutagen on the turtles. Aside from martial arts skill. It opens an avenue to allow for development through training, not a training montage over the series, but a feeling of learning with the turtles.

Teenagers are not always masters and shortening the time frame gives a larger spectrum of room for growth in skills over the series. Gives the writers a little more room to play with.

Anyway apologies if already mentioned its eleven pages. I have not had a chance to read everything.

Jester
08-29-2011, 11:09 AM
Ok...I decided to track down the easiest variant cover of them all. I now have the Hastings variant. They had 4 when I bought mine, leaving 3 left. The store where I bought my Raph copy had 3 copies still as well, 2 Leos and a Donnie.

Abnormal Freak
08-29-2011, 11:11 AM
Or she started out strong and relatable, and then was revealed to be a drawing. Yeah, as long as that doesn't happen, I'll be fine.

But it explains so well why she was so quick to accept the Turtles!

:roll:

Yeah, the more I think about that story, the more I absolutely loathe it. I don't even consider it canon, to be frank. :\ If I start reading the earlier issues while considering that storyline, I'll get really pissed and possibly have all that good stuff ruined.

Xav
08-29-2011, 11:17 AM
Too true. There was that whole Turtles Fast Forward series where she didn't appear once. She did appear in the episode The Journal.

Donnie
08-29-2011, 11:23 AM
Ok...I decided to track down the easiest variant cover of them all. I now have the Hastings variant. They had 4 when I bought mine, leaving 3 left. The store where I bought my Raph copy had 3 copies still as well, 2 Leos and a Donnie.

Thanks for the update! That answers my question I asked you on Facebook. :D

I'm curious to know how many copies everyone's local shop has left.

Jester
08-29-2011, 11:26 AM
I wasn't sure if you were kidding...I thought you were making a funny. "Hey Jester! Where'd you get the Hastings exclusive cover?" "Um...Hastings."

Donnie
08-29-2011, 11:29 AM
I wasn't sure if you were kidding...I thought you were making a funny. "Hey Jester! Where'd you get the Hastings exclusive cover?" "Um...Hastings."

Haha! I never looked into the Hastings variant really, so I was kind of out of the loop that it was actually a variant from a shop called Hastings. Doh! :roll:

Jester
08-29-2011, 11:34 AM
I guess I didn't take into account not everyone has a Hastings.

TheCollector
08-29-2011, 01:09 PM
Or she started out strong and relatable, and then was revealed to be a drawing. Yeah, as long as that doesn't happen, I'll be fine.

Oh god, I hated that! Hopefully they don't pull that here.

Koi
08-29-2011, 01:25 PM
Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".

How is that Raph? I thought it was Mike...

Donnie
08-29-2011, 01:57 PM
How is that Raph? I thought it was Mike...

...did you read the issue?

Andrew NDB
08-29-2011, 02:08 PM
I have been thinking a lot about the concept of eightteen months. The time frame is very short to explain a true mastery of skill or proficiency we expect from our ninja turtles.

I have more than a sneaking suspicion we're missing some big puzzle pieces in this.

My biggest thing: no matter what else may or may not change, they're still the "Teenage" Mutant Ninja Turtles... not the "18 month Old" Mutant Ninja Turtles.

Venom
08-29-2011, 02:23 PM
Ok...I decided to track down the easiest variant cover of them all. I now have the Hastings variant. They had 4 when I bought mine, leaving 3 left. The store where I bought my Raph copy had 3 copies still as well, 2 Leos and a Donnie.

Aw man, you mean Hastings is that close to AL?! Shoot man...

plastroncafe
08-29-2011, 02:31 PM
I haven't read the whole thread, but...do we know for sure that the turtles in the tank are the turtles fighting Old Hob?

I mean, April comes up with those names pretty quick, is it possible that this is another company trying to recreate the turtles and Splinter? And that maybe April was sent there to infiltrate them?

This...is all mere speculation on my part.
If the timeline is as linear as it's originally painted, then at very least we'll have something closer to the first Mirage idea that: The turtles were their "teen" sizes a year after getting slimed.

Venom
08-29-2011, 02:45 PM
I mean, April comes up with those names pretty quick, is it possible that this is another company trying to recreate the turtles and Splinter? And that maybe April was sent there to infiltrate them?

Unlikely, April shares with Chet that she is taking an art course during the summer after telling him their names.

Thorneyeagle
08-29-2011, 03:03 PM
I have more than a sneaking suspicion we're missing some big puzzle pieces in this.

My biggest thing: no matter what else may or may not change, they're still the "Teenage" Mutant Ninja Turtles... not the "18 month Old" Mutant Ninja Turtles.

My thought has less to do with actual age than skill learned. They are teenagers, tis how we refer to them.

Your right that something is missing. I believe that in issue #2 we are going to havesome more flashbacks and a giant explination wrench slowy making an entrance. I would laugh if Renet (girl with time travel, incase I screwed up the name) appeared, warped them to ancient japan and were all trained by homato then :p.

Okay on a serious note, I think the four year old in me is chanting "more more more"

TheCollector
08-29-2011, 03:18 PM
Unlikely, April shares with Chet that she is taking an art course during the summer after telling him their names.

I dunno, the thing with that is, when she's telling him she starts off with 'Uh..'

That seems to indicate maybe she's trying to make something up on the spot. Y'know having slipped up by giving them such names like that.

That's just my theory though.

Andrew NDB
08-29-2011, 03:20 PM
I dunno, the thing with that is, when she's telling him she starts off with 'Uh..'

That seems to indicate maybe she's trying to make something up on the spot. Y'know having slipped up by giving them such names like that.

I think you guys are officially looking too deep into things now. But it's OK.

TheCollector
08-29-2011, 03:22 PM
Okay on a serious note, I think the four year old in me is chanting "more more more"

The four year old in me won't stop kicking. I never should of swallowed her whole.


Oh, man, couldn't resist.

Ninjinister
08-29-2011, 03:23 PM
I guess I didn't take into account not everyone has a Hastings.

I'd never even heard of it before this IDW variant.

azrael
08-29-2011, 03:25 PM
I have more than a sneaking suspicion we're missing some big puzzle pieces in this.

My biggest thing: no matter what else may or may not change, they're still the "Teenage" Mutant Ninja Turtles... not the "18 month Old" Mutant Ninja Turtles.

It says 18 months ago so 18 months ago could make them any age between 13-19.

i think its going to be a combat program called the "Foot" that along with the super soldier mutagen to make them ninja masters. (shot in the dark but what the hell?)

Thorneyeagle
08-29-2011, 03:33 PM
The four year old in me won't stop kicking. I never should of swallowed her whole.


Oh, man, couldn't resist.

Lol, but can not blame you.

azrael
08-29-2011, 03:34 PM
for anyone interested my LCS has 4 copies left 2 leo and 2 mike....

plastroncafe
08-29-2011, 03:56 PM
I think you guys are officially looking too deep into things now. But it's OK.

A comic fan? Officially looking too deeply into something?
TO HELL YOU SAY!

Toby Barrett
08-29-2011, 08:48 PM
Please tell me that the Hastings variant isn't the only cover Hastings is going to be carrying.. It's pretty much the only place in my area that sells comics, and I would be extremely disappointed if I had to settle for that lame cover..

Jester
08-29-2011, 08:54 PM
Please tell me that the Hastings variant isn't the only cover Hastings is going to be carrying.. It's pretty much the only place in my area that sells comics, and I would be extremely disappointed if I had to settle for that lame cover..
Sadly, looks that way. Though I really like it.
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/Hastingsmodified.jpg
Ok...so this is a modified cover. :D

Abnormal Freak
08-30-2011, 12:17 AM
That altered Hastings cover looks pretty slick.

Though I gotta wonder: Why, when the majority of TMNT comics have been in black and white, and for this color series the Turtles' bandannas are all red, why hasn't anyone ever thought to draw each Turtle with a distinctive face so you can easily tell them apart at first glance without seeing what weapons they're carrying? They did it in the first two movies, so why not anywhere else? And Vol. 3 and 4's methods were cheap ways of doing this.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
08-30-2011, 05:42 AM
A very serious question that i am surprised no one has asked , is how the sales of the issue are doing so far? Does it sell well? Has the sales exceed your expectations?

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
08-30-2011, 05:46 AM
He's converting that old boom box into an ipod, of course!

Tom can you please tell us when the Shredder will appear? I was shocked to see that Shredder was not there. He appeared at the first issue of the original comics he also appeared at the first episode of both the 1987 and 2003 series but not here! please tell us about him. He is my hero! i want to know! tell us please!! wil be a human or utrom? say something? will he appear in the second issue?

Jester
08-30-2011, 05:48 AM
A very serious question that i am surprised no one has asked , is how the sales of the issue are doing so far? Does it sell well? Has the sales exceed your expectations?
Tom Waltz posted a thread thanking fans because the issue is "sold out" at the distributor and is going into a second printing. That said, the places where I bought my copies still have 6 copies (3 at one, and 3 at the other), and I don't know about the other LCS and Hastings in the area. But it does seem to be doing OK.
Tom can you please tell us when the Shredder will appear? I was shocked to see that Shredder was not there. He appeared at the first issue of the original comics he also appeared at the first episode of both the 1987 and 2003 series but not here! please tell us about him. He is my hero! i want to know! tell us please!! wil be a human or utrom? say something? will he appear in the second issue?
Shredder may not even appear in this arc. This arc seems to be laying the ground work of establishing the new origin. And as for Shredder appearing in the 1st episode of the 2k3 series....kinda. Saki shows up several episodes before he's revealed as the Shredder. It takes 11 episodes for us to finally see the Shredder, and it works. If this series takes its time as well, I'm all for it. Besides, in the original comics, Shredder is introduced AND KILLED in the first issue. He's not as big a player in the Mirage canon as he is in the TV series. It's his legacy and the whole "revenge" thing that drives the plot in the Mirage comics.

Toby Barrett
08-30-2011, 06:09 AM
Sadly, looks that way. Though I really like it.
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/Hastingsmodified.jpg
Ok...so this is a modified cover. :D

That's the Hastings cover? The one I remember seeing had the turtles photoshopped in front of a Hastings store. This one is pretty awesome!
I guess that was just a place holder then, I feel a bit silly now. Suppose I jumped that gun a bit, heh.. Thanks for bringing that to my attention Jester.

Jester
08-30-2011, 06:16 AM
The one I remember seeing had the turtles photoshopped in front of a Hastings store.Yeah, I was gonna ask if that was the one you were thinking about. I wish I could find that picture of it again just to see how ugly it was.

Rat A Tat
08-30-2011, 07:07 AM
Yeah, I was gonna ask if that was the one you were thinking about. I wish I could find that picture of it again just to see how ugly it was.

Didn't someone post it in another thread? I know I've seen it somewhere recently.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
08-30-2011, 11:20 AM
Tom Waltz posted a thread thanking fans because the issue is "sold out" at the distributor and is going into a second printing. That said, the places where I bought my copies still have 6 copies (3 at one, and 3 at the other), and I don't know about the other LCS and Hastings in the area. But it does seem to be doing OK.

Shredder may not even appear in this arc. This arc seems to be laying the ground work of establishing the new origin. And as for Shredder appearing in the 1st episode of the 2k3 series....kinda. Saki shows up several episodes before he's revealed as the Shredder. It takes 11 episodes for us to finally see the Shredder, and it works. If this series takes its time as well, I'm all for it. Besides, in the original comics, Shredder is introduced AND KILLED in the first issue. He's not as big a player in the Mirage canon as he is in the TV series. It's his legacy and the whole "revenge" thing that drives the plot in the Mirage comics.


that great to hear that it sold well! but we must wait for official sales numbers to know for sure how much it sold. it must sell more than 1 million to become a succes and to be profitable for the company. Anyway bought it yesterday digital from IDW website!

Andrew NDB
08-30-2011, 01:33 PM
it must sell more than 1 million to become a succes and to be profitable for the company.

Pretending to know more than you know about comic book sales doesn't make you cool.

http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2011/2011-07.html

There's July's comic book sales charts. Only a single book cracks 100k and even that's pretty rare to see.

For comparison, IDW's G.I. Joe #2 sold 11,000 copies -- this is considered pretty good these days.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
08-30-2011, 01:50 PM
Pretending to know more than you know about comic book sales doesn't make you cool.

http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2011/2011-07.html

There's July's comic book sales charts. Only a single book cracks 100k and even that's pretty rare to see.

For comparison, IDW's G.I. Joe #2 sold 11,000 copies -- this is considered pretty good these days.


i was thinking about video games sales.... a video game is considered a succes when it sells more than 1 even 2 millions so i thought same goes for comics. Anyway tmnt is not in this list as you can see:(:( so if it sold so good like Tom said then why is not on topseller list?

Abnormal Freak
08-30-2011, 01:50 PM
There's July's comic book sales charts.

That should answer your question.

Andrew NDB
08-30-2011, 01:56 PM
i was thinking about video games sales.... a video game is considered a succes when it sells more than 1 even 2 millions so i thought same goes for comics.

Why would you do a silly thing like that? You might as well compare the cost of comics to movies. With video games today you're talking about massive teams of developers, renderers, animation, sound, spending whole years worth of man hours developing suitable game engines, and millions of developmental dollars. With comics you're just paying the team involved (and in TMNT's case, I'm assuming some kind of modest licensing fee) and the cost of printing and you're done.

Do you really think Grand Theft Auto 4 costs the same to create, develop, and distribute as IDW's TMNT #1?

sdp
08-30-2011, 02:10 PM
For someone who hasn't kept up with this I have a few questions for someone to answer:

1-For someone who hasn't read Mirage outside of two or three issues, since this is a new continuity and a reboot right so I don't need to know anything about Mirage besides the basic origin and I can pick this up without worrying about the past?

2-is that different bandannas cover a variant or fan made?

3- The comic is in color right? How is the comic so far?