PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Vol. 3 #25 & #24 reprint


Pages : 1 [2]

Andrew NDB
02-27-2012, 09:25 PM
Here's my review at TMNT Entity! (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/02/tmnt-vol-3-25.html)

If you haven't gotten your copy yet, I'd avoid it. SPOILERS and all that.

Great review, thank you!

About the one F bomb (I knew this was going to come up, by the way), I was personally against it but... *ahem*... I hope someone jumps in this thread and fields that one. :) That person did make a pretty compelling point for it, though.

DrSpengler
02-27-2012, 09:26 PM
Here's my review at TMNT Entity! (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/02/tmnt-vol-3-25.html)

If you haven't gotten your copy yet, beware: SPOILERS.

As mentioned, though, it was a GREAT ride and everybody involved should give themselves a pat on the back. This was a true labor of love and the amount of cooperation between the fans involved and the creators involved is truly inspiring.

DrSpengler
02-27-2012, 09:29 PM
Heh, yeah, I think we've talked about that stuff before in e-mail.

I'd certainly like to hear their argument for it, though; I'm always up for a compelling alternate perspective.

Andrew NDB
02-27-2012, 09:41 PM
Heh, yeah, I think we've talked about that stuff before in e-mail.

Not this specifically, as the one place the F bomb appears is not in the script.

I'd certainly like to hear their argument for it, though; I'm always up for a compelling alternate perspective.

My first inkling was always to keep it in line with what the Image series would or wouldn't have done... hence the !@?# kind of fare. To me, though, it was a compelling point and... at the end of the day, I'm not a guy that's going to ever advocate TMNT censorship so I couldn't really fight it in good conscience. And then there's the matter of it making me laugh.

Adam
02-28-2012, 12:03 AM
Here's my review at TMNT Entity! (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/02/tmnt-vol-3-25.html)


Thanks for another swell review, dude!


I'd certainly like to hear their argument for it, though; I'm always up for a compelling alternate perspective.

Yep -- that one was my doing. For folks who aren't sure what we're talking about, please wait to read the issue before you read the spoilered sections of this conversation. I really don't want that bit ruined for you ahead of time.

Andrew had a number of "@#%$" symbol-style swears throughout the script (including that line of Leo's). But there were also uncensored occurrences of "sh*t" and other choice language. The reasoning behind uncensoring Leo's line was precisely because it would be so unexpected. It's at the end of a two-issue, 80-page-long story where we'd previously given you no indication that we'd be using that word -- and since Leo's such a straight-arrow kinda guy, it makes what he's saying that much more potent. The reaction I was going for was, "Oh, man, if Leo is saying this, then he really means business."

Andrew had already made the Turtles' dialogue a bit saltier than I've seen it (probably ever, except Bodycount) -- and I wanted to cap the scene with a moment that just took that a little further in a funny and unexpected kinda way.

Adam
02-28-2012, 12:14 AM
How many pages is it? More than issue 24?
If I recall, it's about the exact same page count as #24. Difference being, there's a lot more "main" story and a lot less backup material in #25 vs. #24.

Precisely! And this bears repeating:

TMNT 25 is 52 FREAKIN' PAGES!

If you combine the main story pages from 24 and 25, you have the equivalent of four Image issues in terms of page count. Add all the backups and pin-ups on top of that... and these are some fat books. And more fun trivia: When printing traditional staple-bound comics, most printers won't go beyond 52 pages, actually. Look at books around this size from major publishers (and anything bigger); those'll usually be paperback-bound.

Basically what I'm saying is Andrew has packed these things to their limits with as much material as possible.

Venom
02-28-2012, 12:21 AM
While the dialogue, as before, feels forced and unnatural, I thoroughly enjoyed how everything was tied back together into Mirage continuity; you could almost feel the proverbial needle pulling the thread tight with each page turn!

Thanks to all involved, it was definitely a worthwhile wait. :tsmile:

oldmanwinters
02-28-2012, 12:24 AM
If you combine the main story pages from 24 and 25, you have the equivalent of four Image issues in terms of page count. Add all the backups and pin-ups on top of that... and these are some fat books. And more fun trivia: When printing traditional staple-bound comics, most printers won't go beyond 52 pages, actually. Look at books around this size from major publishers (and anything bigger); those'll usually be paperback-bound.

Basically what I'm saying is Andrew has packed these things to their limits with as much material as possible.

Indeed, these books strike me as very high quality print jobs!

It really felt like some of the old Mirage issues, free of advertisements and packed with creative content from cover to cover!

However, my books did have a bit of an odd smell about them when I pulled them out of their sturdy packaging. I've never received a comic that didn't sit on a store shelf for a while, so I'm wondering if I'm just not accustomed to the "new comic smell." :-)

I threw them in a paper bag together with a light sprinkling of baking soda for a few hours. That seemed to neutralize the odd odor.

Demon-Alukard
02-28-2012, 07:48 AM
Thank you for the good words, guys! I did my best for this story.

If someone interested in the original artwork from TMNT Vol.3 #24-25, please PM me for the details.

DrSpengler
02-28-2012, 11:34 AM
Ah, here's another quick print run question.

The original print run of #24 was 100 copies. How many copies did the 2nd print run of #24 consist of?

Andrew NDB
02-28-2012, 12:06 PM
Only 35 copies.

DrSpengler
02-28-2012, 12:16 PM
Thanks! Added to #24's Turtle Tips.

CyberCubed
02-28-2012, 12:56 PM
I believe I sent in my money around October, is that the batch that went out first?

Andrew NDB
02-28-2012, 01:28 PM
I believe I sent in my money around October, is that the batch that went out first?

I have pre-orders beginning on 10/9 and onward.

CyberCubed
02-28-2012, 02:00 PM
Ah, ok. I checked my records and I sent in the money on October 13th. Hopefully that was in the first batch.

junkboy
02-28-2012, 02:23 PM
I checked as well and have 2 payments made.
On October 10 and October 13.

One for issue 25 + shipping and the other is for issue 24 ( 2nd printing ) i guess. To be shipped together.

Dunno if i am in the first batch. My 24 & 25 should have been sent if i am in the first or second batch , i guess. Will be waiting for some time cause of international shipping tho.

Andrew NDB
02-28-2012, 02:37 PM
I checked as well and have 2 payments made.
On October 10 and October 13.

One for issue 25 + shipping and the other is for issue 24 ( 2nd printing ) i guess. To be shipped together.

Dunno if i am in the first batch. My 24 & 25 should have been sent if i am in the first or second batch , i guess. Will be waiting for some time cause of international shipping tho.

You made the first batch.

Ah, ok. I checked my records and I sent in the money on October 13th. Hopefully that was in the first batch.

You did not make the first batch. But you're either in the one I sent on Saturday or the one I'm sending today.

junkboy
02-28-2012, 02:41 PM
Cool
thanks for the info.

ToTheNines
02-28-2012, 02:46 PM
Not to encourage a flood of people asking this... but I sent my payment on the Oct. 12th, did that make the first wave?

oldmanwinters
02-28-2012, 05:37 PM
I gotta say...

Andrew did more with the Baxter angle in a few panels than Jim Lawson did in that whole 4-issue mini-series. Masterful job!

Powder
02-28-2012, 09:21 PM
I got my copy today. Much better in book form than as a script alone. Noticed a few changes, all for the better. You are one hell of a turtle writer, Andrew. I'd be happy as all hell to let you take the reigns of any future Mirage stuff. You get the turtles real well. I'm still not the biggest fan of DA's art but I can't not credit his efforts. Everything had a nice flow, plenty of dynamic poses, he has a very good grasp on perspective and architecture too, though the anatomy could use some work. Also no pupils would've gave the turtles a much larger appeal to me but y'all have already told me everyone aboard was in favor of them. Farleys work was great to see. Everything ties in beautifully, I'm glad to see this conclusion finally concluded. Plus I love that new book smell.

oldmanwinters
02-28-2012, 09:54 PM
I got my copy today. Much better in book form than as a script alone. Noticed a few changes, all for the better.
Hey, I'd be interested to read some early script concepts for comparison!

I'm still not the biggest fan of DA's art but I can't not credit his efforts. Everything had a nice flow, plenty of dynamic poses, he has a very good grasp on perspective and architecture too, though the anatomy could use some work. Also no pupils would've gave the turtles a much larger appeal to me but y'all have already told me everyone aboard was in favor of them. Farleys work was great to see. Everything ties in beautifully, I'm glad to see this conclusion finally concluded.

Arseniy's work on these books reminds me of an interesting, if slightly unprofessional, amalgamation of Fosco's proportions with early Mirage inking. (At least, those were the two things that came to my mind!)

In my opinion, the only point where this really felt like fan-art was page 6 of issue #25 (the full page spread with the four heroes posing heroically before making their last stand). It just felt like DA fudged the proportions and, thus, shattered the illusion of depth. Leo (especially his head) looks askew and it gives the whole scene a 2-dimensional look. Not that I could do any better, of course, but still...

Out of over 100 epic pages of art, that's a small critique on an otherwise jaw-dropping artistic accomplishment. The luscious inking (and tones!) just adds sooo much to the overall effect.

Plus I love that new book smell.

Hehe, I take it you read my post on the subject? This is a book that truly requires you to use ALL your senses to appreciate. (Granted that "taste" is strictly a matter of opinion. :-))

DrSpengler
02-28-2012, 10:02 PM
In my opinion, the only point where this really felt like fan-art was page 6 of issue #25 (the full page spread with the four heroes posing heroically before making their last stand). It just felt like DA fudged the proportions and, thus, shattered the illusion of depth. Leo (especially his head) looks askew and it gives the whole scene a 2-dimensional look. Not that I could do any better, of course, but still...

(that was Fosco)

oldmanwinters
02-28-2012, 10:05 PM
(that was Fosco)

Seriously?

*checks credits on inner cover*

:ohwell:

lol, so ironic!

EDIT: Frank, just so you know, I think pages 26 & 46 look really nice!

Venom
02-28-2012, 10:36 PM
While the dialogue, as before, feels forced and unnatural, I thoroughly enjoyed how everything was tied back together into Mirage continuity; you could almost feel the proverbial needle pulling the thread tight with each page turn!

Thanks to all involved, it was definitely a worthwhile wait. :tsmile:

In addition, was the Halls spread meant to depict the end of Mirage by the Turtles' being displayed, a vague hint to Odyssey (along with Dr. X's last statement),or an ambiguous way to say there are many untold stories left to tell?

Andrew NDB
02-29-2012, 01:02 AM
In addition, was the Halls spread meant to depict the end of Mirage by the Turtles' being displayed, a vague hint to Odyssey (along with Dr. X's last statement),or an ambiguous way to say there are many untold stories left to tell?

All roads lead to "Odyssey." ;)

But no, no attempt on my part to link anything to that. That will stand alone. Very alone.

thingy
02-29-2012, 08:57 AM
@#!%IN' A

My copy arrived this morning and it's very impressive stuff. Good to see things tying together, but aside from filling in the gaps I enjoyed it because its a very entertaining read. I Loved the action and there's some great looking pages throughout.

Well done (and thanks) to everyone involved in bringing us this conclusion.

RE: the spoiler being discussed on the previous page
I didn't have a problem with the f-bomb, but it did seem a bit strange when swears had been censored elsewhere. Reading Adam's explanation, I understand the reasoning behind it now, but I think I would have gone either/or on the censoring rather than a mix of both.

Ninjinister
03-01-2012, 01:56 AM
Mine arrived here in Tacoma today. I enjoyed it. It did feel like too many things were happening at once, but then again, life can do that too. Thumbs up.

ToTheNines
03-01-2012, 10:01 AM
Never the end!

Just got mine, and even though it got the sh*t beat out of it in the mail, it totally rocked.

A lot to wrap my head around after just one read, but here's some thoughts:

DA's art is even better this time around, and I loved all the brutal kills.

The way so many Mirage and Image plot points were referenced or concluded was great, there was a few of them I didn't expect.

The Halls of Lost Legends bit was great. Considering Volume 3 was almost the turtles last ride back in the 90's, it was perfect having Merlin say it was not yet the turtles time.

It feels good to finally have this all wrapped up, can't wait to see what else you have in store.

About the one thing you guys were talking about earlier:

Definitely should have just gone with no censorship all around. And I didn't think Leo's line was out of place, perhaps I'm just reading it with a different tone than some of you.

The Berger back up was great (I'm a sucker Christmas stuff), but how does it take place after 19? That issue ends with Don and Horridus on the air car with a Triceraton breathing down their necks. I guess you just wanted to place it somewhere that could have Raph as Shredder, and Leo without his hand. Would have worked just fine if you gave Leo his hand and put it after #16.

A big thanks to everyone involved with this project, your hard work really shows!

Venom
03-01-2012, 11:12 AM
For folks who aren't sure what we're talking about, please wait to read the issue before you read the spoilered sections of this conversation. I really don't want that bit ruined for you ahead of time.

The reasoning behind uncensoring Leo's line was precisely because it would be so unexpected. It's at the end of a two-issue, 80-page-long story where we'd previously given you no indication that we'd be using that word -- and since Leo's such a straight-arrow kinda guy, it makes what he's saying that much more potent. The reaction I was going for was, "Oh, man, if Leo is saying this, then he really means business."

The word felt contrived in the context it was used; it felt out of character for him to say, epecially when talking about a non-issue.

I'm sorry for continually sounding so critical of a fan-produced labor of love that I didn't have to buy but did out of my love for the Turtles, much like everyone else.

Adam
03-01-2012, 07:49 PM
RE: the spoiler being discussed on the previous page
I didn't have a problem with the f-bomb, but it did seem a bit strange when swears had been censored elsewhere. Reading Adam's explanation, I understand the reasoning behind it now, but I think I would have gone either/or on the censoring rather than a mix of both.


About the one thing you guys were talking about earlier:

Definitely should have just gone with no censorship all around. And I didn't think Leo's line was out of place, perhaps I'm just reading it with a different tone than some of you.


Normally I would agree, but...

The problem with "no censorship all around" is that it would have ruined the surprise of that moment. And the surprise was the entire point-- that it would be somewhat shocking. Shocking and maybe kinda funny.

I laughed, anyway. :D


The word felt contrived in the context it was used; it felt out of character for him to say, epecially when talking about a non-issue.

Some thoughts:

I don't think it was a non-issue for Leo; obviously it was enough of an issue for him to use such strong speech. Even in the censored version, Leo was swearing to add potency to his point-- to show just how important it was to him.

To illustrate what I'm talking about with a for-instance: My wife never swears. I, by contrast, use various obscenities pretty casually. So while none of my friends bat an eye when I say something profane, people stand up and take notice when my wife does it. Because when she swears, she means business.

On the topic of using "@#%$"-style swearing-- there are definitely occasions in comicdom where the symbols are in place to indicate general profanity. There are other times where it's REALLY clear which word is intended, and I think #24 and #25 fit into this category. So-- censored or uncensored--the technical meaning of Leo's line is exactly the same either way (the only difference being that uncensoring the word gives the readers a surprise).

Leaving it censored would be the equivalent of a BEEP in an R-Rated movie being broadcast on television; it might sound less profane, but it actually isn't. The word is being spoken, and you know it is being spoken.


As for it being out of character for Leo-- I'm kinda of two minds about that:

1) On the one hand, I don't think it's out of character for Leo in this specific story. The comic is already filled with profanity, and Leo's sort of extending an olive branch to Raph (at a time when Raph is vulnerably admitting his attraction to Pimiko) by revealing a secret to him and doing it with words that are closer to Raph's vocabulary than Leo's own. Sort of like Leo's saying "I'm here for you, brother" and he's doing it on Raph's terms-- terms which will make Raph immediately recognize and appreciate Leo's earnestness.

2) On the other hand-- if this were my own story, I probably wouldn't have the turtles swear as much. I don't find it offensive or anything-- it's just not what I would do with them. I'd tone it down a bit. But this was Andrew's story to tell, and those words (censored or not) were a part of that. And again-- given the events of 24/25 and everything-- I do think it was appropriate in the context of this story.

I'm sorry for continually sounding so critical of a fan-produced labor of love that I didn't have to buy but did out of my love for the Turtles, much like everyone else.
No worries at all! I'm sure I speak for everyone when I say we all welcome and value your input. Thanks also to you and everyone for supporting our efforts here (and for indulging in my verbose ramblings on swearing). :)

ToTheNines
03-01-2012, 07:59 PM
The problem with "no censorship all around" is that it would have ruined the surprise of that moment. And the surprise was the entire point-- that it would be somewhat shocking. Shocking and maybe kinda funny.

I laughed, anyway. :D

Wasn't the only other censored word after Leo's F bomb though? If you would have just let Puzzorelli say "mother fu(ker" it wouldn't have been a problem for me.

Andrew NDB
03-01-2012, 08:14 PM
Wasn't the only other censored word after Leo's F bomb though? If you would have just let Puzzorelli say "mother fu(ker" it wouldn't have been a problem for me.

Myself, I don't consider "c0cksucker" much of a swear word. I mean, I guess it is, but it's about equivalent to "sh!t" in my book. And "sh!t" is never censored in #24 or #25 because "sh!t" used to appear quite a bit in the old Mirage books, so I don't feel that should be a word shied away from 25 years later.

Adam
03-01-2012, 08:25 PM
Wasn't the only other censored word after Leo's F bomb though? If you would have just let Puzzorelli say "mother fu(ker" it wouldn't have been a problem for me.

Nope-- "F**king* is rendered using symbols on page 6 in #25 and at least once in #24.

ToTheNines
03-01-2012, 09:43 PM
Nope-- "F**king* is rendered using symbols on page 6 in #25 and at least once in #24.

Oops, you're right. Oh well I love this comic either way.

A few other things.

Favorite turtle award goes to Mike. I felt like he had the best moments in this one. Him calling the little Shredder Clone a "little sh*t" and then popping his head off was awesome. I've always headed that wee guy lol.

Brilliant idea having the big showdown take place in the sewers, that doesn't happen enough. Too often we see the battles against the Foot take place on a rooftop or in some warehouse, etc.

I'm guessing you did it on purpose, but good call on leaving the Oroku family out of this issue. Leaves things open-ended so as to not affect "Cold, Cold Ice".

My very last gripe, I swear. What was with Leo saying "Bushido" as he lobbed off King Komodo's head? I think that page would have been twice as awesome without any dialogue bubble.

Matches Malone
03-01-2012, 10:56 PM
Myself, I don't consider "c0cksucker" much of a swear word. I mean, I guess it is, but it's about equivalent to "sh!t" in my book. And "sh!t" is never censored in #24 or #25 because "sh!t" used to appear quite a bit in the old Mirage books, so I don't feel that should be a word shied away from 25 years later.

Sorry if this is a bit off-topic... I remember there were swears in the old Mirage books, but I don't remember sh*t shown uncensored. Do you remember which issues? This is just purely out of curiosity. I remember "Holy Hippo Spit!" Or maybe that was Archie... heh.

Demon-Alukard
03-01-2012, 11:35 PM
I remember "Holy Hippo Spit!" Or maybe that was Archie... heh.
Yep, it was in Mirage comics, at least twice-- TMNT v1 #3 and TMNT v4 #1.

Andrew NDB
03-02-2012, 12:33 AM
Sorry if this is a bit off-topic... I remember there were swears in the old Mirage books, but I don't remember sh*t shown uncensored. Do you remember which issues? This is just purely out of curiosity. I remember "Holy Hippo Spit!" Or maybe that was Archie... heh.

Top of my head I can't say, but I know for a fact in TMNT Vol. 1, #21.

CyberCubed
03-02-2012, 12:42 AM
I read my copy which came today, I definitely really liked it. It basically did everything I hoped it would and there were definitely some things I didn't see coming:

The fact that Cheng leeching off Splinter's energy would cause his death in Volume 4. I never even thought of this, but it actually makes perfect sense.

Dr. X also telling the other Utroms to make first contact was also a nice touch and wrapped up his and Leatherhead's character arcs well.

I was kind of wondering if Pimiko would die in this given she never appears again, and I am glad to see it happened in a fitting way, with the whole Oroku Saki feud ending once and for all.

Lastly the Turtles returning to form seemed a little rushed, (especially Leo and Raph's), but it was understandable given the timeframe you guys had. The huge fight in the sewers was awesome in every way.

I have to say Komodo's return seemed to come out of nowhere though, but him lurking in the sewers would still make sense.

Basically loved the aspect of Karai taking control of the Foot again and slaughtering Shadow's biological father.


All in all a great story and it really is a shame that this won't reach a bigger audience by being officially published. Maybe something can be worked out once IDW gets up to the Image trades....especially given Kevin's involvement.

ToTheNines
03-02-2012, 06:26 AM
All in all a great story and it really is a shame that this won't reach a bigger audience by being officially published. Maybe something can be worked out once IDW gets up to the Image trades....especially given Kevin's involvement.

I would be thrilled to see these guys get paid for this.

CyberCubed
03-02-2012, 10:38 AM
I would be thrilled to see these guys get paid for this.

That's the only thing I am not sure about, IDW would have to compensate everyone involved for putting this together if they publish it. And for back-up stuff like Dan Berger's story, or the pin-ups, or even Frank Fosco.

Ninjinister
03-02-2012, 11:08 AM
Dr. X also telling the other Utroms to make first contact was also a nice touch and wrapped up his and Leatherhead's character arcs well.


Basically loved the aspect of Karai taking control of the Foot again and slaughtering Shadow's biological father.



1. Dr. X is a female. They made a point to make this apparent right there in the issue.

2. That's her grandfather. Her daddy's already dead.

DrSpengler
03-02-2012, 01:24 PM
Even though the story's been available for a year and a half, I wanted to wait until #25 was published before I reviewed it.

my review of "Christmas Past" at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/03/christmas-past.html)

It's a great little 2-page story and a nice (brief) follow-up to "Dark Shadows". The chronology is kind of... out of whack, though. I know the editor's note says after #19, but the only place I can see to put it is between #21 and #22.

Though that hinges on Raph leaving Foot HQ after Pimiko challenges him, going to the mausoleum to celebrate Christmas, then returning to Foot HQ for his showdown.

There isn't much else that can be done about that. But whether it fits or not, it's still a good story and that's what's really important.


EDIT: Also, added it to the "Mirage Future TMNT Chronology" (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2010/07/mysterious-future-era-of-mirage.html)!

twopinacoladas
03-02-2012, 01:44 PM
I got #25 in yesterday and I had been saving #24 to read them both in one sitting. Honestly it was so long since I had read the Image books now I was forgetting stuff I had to quickly read a couple previous issues to make sure I was up to speed.

I was seriously impressed with both issues maybe even more with #25 but they kind of blended together so nicley in one read its hard to say.

I think these are the best TMNT comic's I have read in a long time. The art was awesome, the tones, the story and writing were also really well done. I am highly impressed with both books front to back Andrew great work getting this together over the past couple years and everyone that was involved fantastic job :).

I just want to add that these books looked so polished the detail's the toning not to mention all tying up all the story lines and linking it to the Mirage vol 4 so seamlessly a lot of passion was put into this project my hat is off.

Andrew NDB
03-03-2012, 12:32 AM
All in all a great story and it really is a shame that this won't reach a bigger audience by being officially published. Maybe something can be worked out once IDW gets up to the Image trades....especially given Kevin's involvement.

I would be thrilled to see these guys get paid for this.

Far be it for me to turn away money and I can't imagine I'd ever say "No" to these seeing official publication, but several things...

#1: The basic understanding has always been that if there was an official outlet for an Image finisher and the deal and money was right, Gary and Frank would just come in and do it themselves.

#2: Official channels were already explored, thoroughly. It's fairly well chronicled on the original TMNT 24/25 thread.

#3: This was never about money. Never. If you've read the letters I wrote in as a kid to Volume 3 you may have some idea where I'm coming from... this was a total passion project, for myself, and everyone doing the "heavy lifting." From Arseniy sweating his ass off rendering these amazing pages from the pencilling and inking phase, to Dave's amazing tones that made all of us kind of collectively do a double-take, to Adam doing a whole hell of a lot more (in not just the lettering but overall production and fine-tuning) in all of these two issues than I think he'll ever get proper credit for, to Courtland's fantastic cover colors to Ross stepping in and happily weeding out a ton of crap from my scripts and not only that, but adding a great deal of objective creativity all his own.

Another thing I want to comment, and it's kind of brought up in Spengler's review of #25, is target audience. This was written and devised as, "OK, this is pretty much for the hardcore TMNT Mirage/Image fans. It's going to have a minuscule print run to suit." To write it as such was a decision that I came to when the official channels seemed to sufficiently be closed. If the opportunity was, "[insert company name publishing TMNT comics] is willing to publish your Image conclusion story as a standalone mini-series"... the story I would write would be quite different, and not be so rife with nods and sideways references. I've always known there are ways to do a kick-ass Image conclusion story that would be relatively self-contained and stand alone... but this isn't it -- it didn't need to be, it's not trying to grab "new readers," nor is that even really an option for something like this. What you read in #24 and #25 now is very aware that the people reading it are... well, people like you and I. It's not trying to be overly accessible or "if this is your first TMNT comic..."... it's trying to, in order of prominence: 1. Adequately conclude Vol. 3 with as much respect to where Gary was taking things, 2. Retroactively segue things back into where we know the Mirage TMNT ended up after Vol. 3 was truncated, not just in Vol. 4 (though that was always a priority) but also the Tales Volume 2 stories that popped up as well. 3. Throw longtime readers of Mirage/Image TMNT comics a lot of bones as suits the material.

I will say the biggest personal thrill for me so far, and I don't think I've ever shared this with Frank (or anyone, really), is when I stayed at his place while doing last year's Chicago Con... is, you know, he keeps all of his Image TMNT comics on his bookshelf, right? All of them, the whole run. And at the end, right after #23... was the #24 we did. That meant a lot to me and really validated a ton of the effort put into things.

marcelangelo
03-03-2012, 06:55 AM
wow that is fantastic indeed that he included this book into his run!!congrats to all the happy faces you made on us small group of turtles brothers and sisters around the globe!!
this is a truly great project!!
can't wait to read it finally!(hasn't arrived yet)

The Fifth Turtle
03-03-2012, 10:08 AM
I will say the biggest personal thrill for me so far, and I don't think I've ever shared this with Frank (or anyone, really), is when I stayed at his place while doing last year's Chicago Con... is, you know, he keeps all of his Image TMNT comics on his bookshelf, right? All of them, the whole run. And at the end, right after #23... was the #24 we did. That meant a lot to me and really validated a ton of the effort put into things.

Wow! thats icing on the cake for sure.......or perhaps the whole cake?

BTW I received both 24 and 25 yesterday in perfect shape. These books look amazing and I can't wait to read them!

Master Splinter
03-03-2012, 07:34 PM
I thoroughly enjoyed #25. Took me more than 90 minutes to take it all in.

-ms

bloodmetaldonor
03-04-2012, 01:18 AM
got my issues in the mail yesterday!! thanks again andrew!! my only complaint is that i can't read them yet, cause i'm still missing some issue from the image series, and i'm holding off on reading it until i have the entire run. these issues look awesome though!! naturally i took the time to look through them and peruse the art. loving both those jim lawson sketches!! cheers on a top notch job!!

Andrew NDB
03-04-2012, 02:40 AM
Even though the story's been available for a year and a half, I wanted to wait until #25 was published before I reviewed it.

my review of "Christmas Past" at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/03/christmas-past.html)


Ah, was wondering when/if you'd review that two-pager. Nice!

It's a great little 2-page story and a nice (brief) follow-up to "Dark Shadows". The chronology is kind of... out of whack, though. I know the editor's note says after #19, but the only place I can see to put it is between #21 and #22.

"After #19" can still be "between #21 and #22." :)

Jester
03-04-2012, 02:55 AM
"After #19" can still be "between #21 and #22." :)
Then that's a vague editor's note then... :D

CyberCubed
03-04-2012, 09:32 AM
I have to comment that I liked how April's design really looked like she did in the Image series. That was good continuity right there, since her hair was longer and straighter in that series than her bizarre Mirage curly hair-do.

DrSpengler
03-04-2012, 10:14 AM
"After #19" can still be "between #21 and #22." :)

You win this round!

Rooish
03-04-2012, 09:10 PM
Top of my head I can't say, but I know for a fact in TMNT Vol. 1, #21.

Yeah, I don't recall s**t in the Mirage books at all! It's not in 21! Confusion.

Will 25 be available for download soon? I loved #24!

Andrew NDB
03-05-2012, 03:11 AM
Yeah, I don't recall s**t in the Mirage books at all! It's not in 21! Confusion.

Not in #21? Damn, could have sworn. But definitely in "Return to New York" at large. You guys are really going to make me go back over the old books and come up with a list...

Will 25 be available for download soon?

Not too soon, no. But yeah, on the horizon.

Also, wanted to say... one big, final sendout of books going out. Not tomorrow, but day after. Then everyone should have their stuff.

Also, new review popped up from Michele Ivey on the Cowabunga Corner:
http://www.cowabungacorner.com/reviews/review-image-tmnt-25

Jester
03-05-2012, 03:15 AM
Not too soon, no. But yeah, on the horizon.
Well phooey. :P

Andrew NDB
03-05-2012, 03:18 AM
"After #19" can still be "between #21 and #22." :)

Then that's a vague editor's note then... :D

You win this round!

This is going to sound like a copout, or at least Monday morning quarterbacking on my part, but now I do remember my way of thinking on the matter... poring over the Image stuff, it did occur to me that it would be difficult/impossible to place the events there right right after #19... but that's really where it ought to go, thematically. But I realized the events of the issue wouldn't quite allow it. So basically, "After #19" was literally me going... "at the soonest opportunity after the events of #19."

junkboy
03-05-2012, 03:50 AM
My copies arrived today to Turkey. I feel great that they came in great condition. I was waiting at least some corner bends and some spine bends but i guess i was lucky ( one thing which rarely happens to me in the shipping )
The books look stunning. Have not read yet.
Thanks a lot Andrew and all the crew.

CyberCubed
03-05-2012, 11:59 PM
I love the fact that now most of the loose ends in the Mirage universe have finally been put to rest. Other than the stuff going on in Volume 4, I think the only old storyline left unresolved is Tristan's Gang War story, and that's about it.

Well if worse comes to worse, I suppose we know who we can turn to for a Volume 4 conclusion if PL truly throws in the towel for good.

Andrew NDB
03-06-2012, 10:12 AM
Other than the stuff going on in Volume 4, I think the only old storyline left unresolved is Tristan's Gang War story, and that's about it.

If things had stayed on course, that's what you would have gotten in a #0, intermixed with Warlord Komodo, Pimiko and cyborg mercenary intrigue. Ah well.

CyberCubed
03-06-2012, 12:06 PM
If things had stayed on course, that's what you would have gotten in a #0, intermixed with Warlord Komodo, Pimiko and cyborg mercenary intrigue. Ah well.

IDW has said in their Gi-Joe and Transformer series they revived old plotlines from different continuities.

Since Tristan works for IDW, I think there is a chance they could publish stand-alone specials set in the Mirage continuity. Of course I wouldn't expect anything like this till the IDW series is established with a healthy run of good sales....but maybe in a few years.

I don't see IDW wanting to keep the Mirage continuity alive much otherwise though, so I am guessing if Volume 4 finally ends, we'll be saying our grand farewell to the "original" Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

Andrew NDB
03-06-2012, 12:30 PM
If given the opportunity, I think he'd rather do it under the umbrella of the IDW-verse, from the ground up again.

Which still leaves the Mirage universe version of it unfulfilled.

marcelangelo
03-06-2012, 02:47 PM
why do you think so, andrew?have you talked to him about it already?

Andrew NDB
03-06-2012, 03:55 PM
why do you think so, andrew?have you talked to him about it already?

About a year ago.

marcelangelo
03-06-2012, 04:49 PM
oh...well, then I hope he'll get to it one day...although it does sound strange to my ears to get to see that story once more from the start in this new universe;)..but, the more tristan turtles the better I say...

CyberCubed
03-06-2012, 05:42 PM
If given the opportunity, I think he'd rather do it under the umbrella of the IDW-verse, from the ground up again.

Which still leaves the Mirage universe version of it unfulfilled.

Well can't he make it ambiguous so it could take place with both continuities? Other than the bandana colors I mean.

Andrew NDB
03-12-2012, 09:42 PM
I notice a few people calling the guy in the Hall of Lost Legends "Locke." That's not Locke.

It's Merlin.

ToTheNines
03-12-2012, 10:16 PM
I notice a few people calling the guy in the Hall of Lost Legends "Locke." That's not Locke.

It's Merlin.

Whoops, guilty...

I'd just read Spengler's review before that. He Incepted me.

DrSpengler
03-12-2012, 10:59 PM
*fixed*

My bad.

Bjarni
03-13-2012, 07:41 AM
I'm still waiting for my copy of #25, when do you think I should be expecting it?

Andrew NDB
03-13-2012, 10:49 AM
I'm still waiting for my copy of #25, when do you think I should be expecting it?

Any day, I would imagine.

Mayhem
03-13-2012, 01:54 PM
No sign of my issues yet, hopefully soon :)

staypuftweepel
03-13-2012, 06:49 PM
I got my book I think last week or the week before that, I can't remember, because I've had a lot of deliveries lately. It was a great surprise to get issue 25. I'm really looking forward to reading it, but I'm gonna reread 1-24 again. I already looked through it and think it looks really great. Congratulations on putting together two great looking Turtle comics. Thanks.
-Gary

Lordmylar06
03-13-2012, 07:54 PM
I now have a copy of each on the way! Thanks to the creative team that put all this together! :D

bjaxx87
03-14-2012, 04:59 AM
I'm still waiting as well, but I guess it will still take a while ^^.

- I live in Germany
- They're going to Russia first (for DA's signatures)
- They won't be dispatched before the reprint of Tales #71 is ready

I wonder if the Tales #71 reprints are already in production? They should have been finished around the same time as #24 and #25 (at least that's what DA told me in a PM some time ago).

However, I'm looking forward to receive them but I'm patient :tsmile:.

marcelangelo
03-14-2012, 05:23 AM
hey bjaxx87!wher in germany do you live?ich komme aus münchen...;)
waiting for mine but don't sweat it because I know it is worth the wait...

bjaxx87
03-14-2012, 06:02 AM
NRW, Hilden bei Düsseldorf um genau zu sein ;).

German turtle fans are rare these days... Most of the people here don't even know there was a comic book before the Hero Turtles show ^^. And that's why they don't like the 4kids show... :roll:

ToTheNines
03-14-2012, 11:18 AM
Anyone else having a hell of time finding Savage Dragon #71? I know it's not important to read, but I want it just for completions sake.

DrSpengler
03-14-2012, 11:58 AM
Anyone else having a hell of time finding Savage Dragon #71? I know it's not important to read, but I want it just for completions sake.

I believe it was published at a time when Image was reeling from their bubble bursting and all their titles from that period were published with comaratively thinner print runs.

Issues of Spawn from around that time were not only a pain in the ass to track down when Iw as filling gaps in my collection, but also double or more the price of issues before and after because of their scarcity.

CyberCubed
03-14-2012, 12:05 PM
I'm surprised Image is still a healthy, stable company releasing comics for over a decade in today's market.

Master Splinter
03-14-2012, 02:19 PM
I'm surprised Image is still a healthy, stable company releasing comics for over a decade in today's market.

I am sure that titles like Savage Dragon and The Walking Dead and many others have really helped the company...

-ms

marcelangelo
03-14-2012, 02:30 PM
NRW, Hilden bei Düsseldorf um genau zu sein ;).

German turtle fans are rare these days... Most of the people here don't even know there was a comic book before the Hero Turtles show ^^. And that's why they don't like the 4kids show... :roll:

nur zu wahr leider..;)willkommen im forum, amigo!hudemxs hier is auch aus dem deutschsprachigen raum...(sorry wenn der name net scheid stimmt grad;)..)der macht auch auf youtube öfters nette reviews zu allem turtles mäßigen...hey, haste früher auch immer das hero turtles super comic magazin gehabt?;)

hey, image comics is not just in the business over a decade, but they are celebrating their 20th anniversary right now!....;)

the walking dead is really good, I am really happy checked that out for myself a while ago...another GREAT series that just started out there is called 'fatale' if you're looking for something to read give that book a chance.you won't be dissappointed....

Powder
03-14-2012, 05:27 PM
Anyone else having a hell of time finding Savage Dragon #71? I know it's not important to read, but I want it just for completions sake.

What is the significance of it in relation to this? I either never knew or forgot. :P

ToTheNines
03-14-2012, 05:49 PM
What is the significance of it in relation to this? I either never knew or forgot. :P

There's an editor's note that cites Savage Dragon #71 as the issue that explains why Horridus walked out on Mike.

I found one on ebay for 2.50, but the dumbass is charging 6.50 for shipping. I sell comics online all the time, they don't even cost 3 dollars to ship.

Adam
03-14-2012, 07:42 PM
What is the significance of it in relation to this? I either never knew or forgot. :P
There's an editor's note that cites Savage Dragon #71 as the issue that explains why Horridus walked out on Mike.

I found one on ebay for 2.50, but the dumbass is charging 6.50 for shipping. I sell comics online all the time, they don't even cost 3 dollars to ship.

Far be it for me to tell someone to not buy an issue of SD, but buying it just because of that editor's note seems a bit overboard. The scene in question is a VERY brief gag with Horridus, and it's not about her relationship with Mike at all.

Andrew had to tie up the Mikey/Horridus relationship completely in a very small amount of space. The Dragon reference helps a bit, but it really doesn't add anything beyond what Horridus says: "I think he LIKES me! Hee hee!"

Basically, all you need to know is that Horridus/Sara is still very much a child mentally, and she didn't fully understand or reciprocate Mike's true feelings toward her*-- and that's all made pretty clear in the TMNT comics themselves.

*Much like she doesn't really understand adult relationships in general, or that Dragon didn't in fact feel "that way" about her.

ToTheNines
03-14-2012, 08:46 PM
Yeah. Like I said, I really only want it for completions sake.

John Pannozzi
03-14-2012, 10:10 PM
Here's a summary of the Savage Dragon issue in question for those who are curious. (http://savagedragonwiki.wikispaces.com/Savage+Dragon+71)

azrael
03-15-2012, 03:25 PM
really enjoyed it finally having time to read it made it worth while... Bravo Bravo!!! the only thing that seemed a bit off was the "F-word", but didnt detach from the story since it was towards the end.

All in all story, art, and print was very nicely done.

Cowabunga Carl
03-16-2012, 10:54 AM
Is there a PDF of issue 25? Or are there any left overs of 24 and 25 that are still for sale?

Andrew NDB
03-16-2012, 11:07 AM
Is there a PDF of issue 25? Or are there any left overs of 24 and 25 that are still for sale?

No PDF will be released for 25 for a long time. #24 is pretty much kaput with extra copies, though there's still some #25 left.

nickn
03-16-2012, 05:34 PM
man so no way to get them both? I missed the boat on them : (

Princess Anri
03-17-2012, 12:19 AM
Hey, Andrew, do you know if mine shipped?

I ordered 24 and 25 and paid via PayPal on January 1st (tmnt.ebay@gmail).

I have not received anything yet.

Please let me know. Thank you.

Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 02:43 AM
I stumbled upon the Facebook page for this and it says there is an Image #0 written by Tristan Jones... sorry if this has already been covered, but what's the deal with this? Was this another issue that was printed?

thingy
03-20-2012, 04:32 AM
It was intended to be a conclusion to the Gang Wars storyline, but it didn't happen in the end so you haven't missed anything.

A little *too* Raph
03-20-2012, 08:08 PM
Just wanted to say I got my #25 in the mail a week or so ago and had totally forgotten that I ordered it. It was a nice surprise!

Ch'rell
03-25-2012, 03:35 AM
Just wanted to chime in and say I haven't gotten my #25 yet either. I paypalled for both #24 and #25 on I believe 09-08-2011.

Mayhem
03-25-2012, 11:28 AM
I was fairly late to the party but my 24/25 haven't arrived yet either. If they haven't been sent out yet, fair enough heh.

marcelangelo
03-25-2012, 12:19 PM
I think no worries allowed as I am also waiting for my reading pleasure of issue 25...guess this week sometime...

Princess Anri
03-26-2012, 05:48 PM
Got my copies of 24 and 25 in the mail today (thanks for taking care of that so fast, Andrew)!

Everything was in great condition.

Strangely enough, I also got my Tales of TMNT 71 today as well (thanks Demon).

Pretty big coincidence but a welcome one.

Can't wait to read them!

Andrew NDB
03-27-2012, 01:23 AM
Strangely enough, I also got my Tales of TMNT 71 today as well (thanks Demon).

Pretty big coincidence but a welcome one.

I can't claim to have anything to do with that. That is funny, though.

bjaxx87
03-27-2012, 07:18 AM
Strangely enough, I also got my Tales of TMNT 71 today as well (thanks Demon).

That's great to know. I was worried if the Tales #71 reprint has been finished already. So I should receive all 3 issues soon as well :tsmile:.

rich
03-28-2012, 10:13 AM
Kudos to to everyone involved...a really great set of stories and some superb artwork.

Sadly, however, someone (http://www.ebay.com/itm/160771345874?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1363) received their issue of #25 and decided to try and profit from it. :(

Demon-Alukard
03-28-2012, 11:02 AM
Sadly, however, someone (http://www.ebay.com/itm/160771345874?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1363) received their issue of #25 and decided to try and profit from it. :(
Yeah, I just saw it today... Well, it's hard cheese for him.

That's great to know. I was worried if the Tales #71 reprint has been finished already. So I should receive all 3 issues soon as well :tsmile:.

Yes, I didn't post it here, but Tales #71 second print was printed a while back, and I sent it everyone who preordered the book (except of you, bjaxx, since I didn't received TMNT v3 #24-25 from Andrew yet). I've added the new pin-up (my own artwork) in a second print, it's the only difference from the original issue.

Powder
03-28-2012, 09:58 PM
What a scumbag.

ToTheNines
03-28-2012, 10:07 PM
Lol, I know. It's not like he's just getting rid of it and recollecting what he paid in shipping (which would still be iffy)... but 55 freakin bucks? Unscrupulous.

Hope no one bids.

Chris
03-29-2012, 01:35 AM
Got my copy last week. It was a fantastic read just like #24. Thanks again to all involved and congratulations on doing such a fantastic finale to the Image series and still managing to tie in a load of other loose ends!

bjaxx87
03-29-2012, 07:57 AM
Yes, I didn't post it here, but Tales #71 second print was printed a while back, and I sent it everyone who preordered the book (except of you, bjaxx, since I didn't received TMNT v3 #24-25 from Andrew yet). I've added the new pin-up (my own artwork) in a second print, it's the only difference from the original issue.

Ah, okay, that's good to know! :tsmile: It's no problem for me to wait some more weeks, I'm just happy that all 3 issues are existent and I'm looking forward to receive them - no rush! :twink:

Bjarni
03-29-2012, 10:48 PM
I saw a couple of people still haven't received their copies so I guess I shouldn't be worried that my copy hasn't arrived in Iceland yet.

azrael
03-30-2012, 08:53 AM
so who lives in ohio?

If that really goes for $55 imagine what the misprints will go for, maybe even 1 billion dollars

Mayhem
04-01-2012, 06:04 PM
My copies have arrived, many thanks. Now need some time to read them...

PizzaPower
04-02-2012, 07:26 AM
got mine in the mail cant wait to read it when iget back to USA from this damn Afghanistan.

DK2
04-04-2012, 10:26 PM
Got my #25 in the mail earlier in the week. I'm just waiting for my Tales of #71.

Lampy
04-06-2012, 03:29 AM
hello all! i'm still new here... but i've been a long time turtles fan. is it too late to get a copy of both issues Andrew?

marcelangelo
04-21-2012, 09:00 AM
I got my copy in the mail today and read it right after training session.WOW!!!congrats and big thank yous for pulling this through!I hope you know in your heart that all this work and passion is appreciated and cared for a great deal!I feel proud of possessing these two issues in my comic rack!!

Lampy
05-14-2012, 04:12 AM
Andrew!!! i got my copy in the mail today. it looks amazing... and i love the story. thanks man!
now if i can only get my hands on #24 hard copy...

Flitcraft
05-14-2012, 02:45 PM
I got my copy today, too. The cover is a true work of art and really has a vintage TMNT feel to it. Everyone involved with this book did a great job and should be very proud. Thank you!

HotJuicyBurgers
05-25-2012, 12:26 PM
I seem to have shown up late to the party :(

Like... a couple of years late...

No chance I could get these 2 issues huh?

SS_Turtle
05-25-2012, 03:58 PM
Can't wait to get my copy of 25 in the mail.
Wish I had seen this thread last year so I could have gotten a printed version of #24. If anyone wants to sell me there copy I'll happily buy it from you :D

Powder
05-26-2012, 12:23 AM
I seem to have shown up late to the party :(

Like... a couple of years late...

No chance I could get these 2 issues huh?

I think there are still some copies of #24 left, just email Andrew to find out.

turkishproverb
05-26-2012, 01:10 AM
Hey. I have #24, and was wondering if copies were still available?

Andrew NDB
05-26-2012, 02:07 AM
Hey. I have #24, and was wondering if copies were still available?

Of #25, yes. #24, not at all.

Lampy
05-26-2012, 02:28 AM
Will there be another reprint of #24 in the near future? I too was a bit late.

turkishproverb
05-26-2012, 03:40 AM
Of #25, yes. #24, not at all.

Cool. :tcool:

SS_Turtle
05-28-2012, 08:46 PM
Will there be another reprint of #24 in the near future? I too was a bit late.

If your looking for issue #24 there's one listed on ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/RARE-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-TMNT-Volume-3-Issue-24-/300716362306?pt=US_Comic_Books&hash=item4604178a42

Lampy
05-28-2012, 09:20 PM
If your looking for issue #24 there's one listed on ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/RARE-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-TMNT-Volume-3-Issue-24-/300716362306?pt=US_Comic_Books&hash=item4604178a42

Thanks SS_Turtle. But i purchased one from DemonAlukard a few days ago. Thanks again DA!

bjaxx87
05-30-2012, 03:40 AM
Yay! This took quite a while, but now I finally received my copies too :tsmile:. Didn't read them yet, but they look AWESOME! It definitely was worth the waiting! Thank you guys so much!

Unfortunately they didn't reach me in perfect condition (some edges and the spines got damaged) but that's okay. I'm no collector :twink:.

Demon-Alukard
05-30-2012, 03:53 AM
Unfortunately they didn't reach me in perfect condition (some edges and the spines got damaged) but that's okay. I'm no collector :twink:.
This is how they reached to me -- I've packed them as careful as I can.
Good to hear you've got them!

bjaxx87
05-30-2012, 05:29 AM
I didn't want to blame anyone, your packaging was perfect! Guess those comics have spent a lot of time in different custom offices :twink:.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2012, 10:14 PM
This is how they reached to me -- I've packed them as careful as I can.
Good to hear you've got them!

And as you can attest to, they were shipped to you in super bubble-wrapped packaging.

A new review of #25 is up:
http://comicsonline.com/2012/05/comic-review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-volume-3-issues-24-25/

CyberCubed
05-30-2012, 10:18 PM
Interesting review, even though I never understood why people still question Image's canon status at this point. It was written to take place for Mirage continuity from the beginning, nothing will ever change that.

And the time gap between its conclusion and when Vol. 4 started allowed these "untold events" to take place.

Demon-Alukard
05-31-2012, 04:30 AM
And as you can attest to, they were shipped to you in super bubble-wrapped packaging.
Yes, they was packaged well, it's just the long way to Russia--
Very good preview, thanks for the link!

HotJuicyBurgers
05-31-2012, 09:25 AM
And as you can attest to, they were shipped to you in super bubble-wrapped packaging.

A new review of #25 is up:
http://comicsonline.com/2012/05/comic-review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-volume-3-issues-24-25/

Hey Andrew, I sent you the money for the issue a couple of days ago, and I just want to make sure you got it?

SS_Turtle
05-31-2012, 11:03 AM
Of #25, yes. #24, not at all.

Hey Andrew, I also sent you the money for the issue over a week ago (5-19), and I just want to make sure you got it?

Andrew NDB
06-01-2012, 02:53 AM
Yes, one more big order needs to go out the door.

SS_Turtle
06-07-2012, 08:29 PM
Yes, one more big order needs to go out the door.

Thanks for the update, I also go your email earlier this week.

SS_Turtle
06-16-2012, 10:54 AM
Yes, they was packaged well, it's just the long way to Russia--
Very good preview, thanks for the link!

DA just got my package earlier this week, thanks again it took less that 2 weeks to get so not to bad. Package arrived in great shape, just some stress to the spines as can be expected considering the misc customs it went through.

Demon-Alukard
06-16-2012, 12:19 PM
DA just got my package earlier this week, thanks again it took less that 2 weeks to get so not to bad. Package arrived in great shape, just some stress to the spines as can be expected considering the misc customs it went through.

Good to hear! =)

HotJuicyBurgers
06-18-2012, 01:42 PM
Yes, one more big order needs to go out the door.

Hey man, was just wondering if we could get an update on the status of these? Super excited to get to read it!

PizzaPower
06-22-2012, 09:35 AM
have to say finally back from Afghanistan and 25 even better then 24! Great job!

Andrew NDB
06-25-2012, 12:47 AM
Would anyone be interested in the digital release of #25... tonight?

Jephael
06-25-2012, 10:26 PM
I'm really glad you finally decided to release your comic in digital form, and for free to boot!

liugeaux
09-03-2012, 07:05 PM
Am I too late to get in on this, If the quality's good on the print I would love to order both 24 and 25. I'm assuming $20 for the pair.

nelodiavolo
09-03-2012, 11:09 PM
Going through this tread, I'm pretty sure #24 is sold out....but I would be interested in #25 if any are available. Should probably email Andrew. His Odyssey project has spiked some interest in these reissue releases. Also curious if a digital of 25 was released yet.

Lampy
09-04-2012, 12:51 AM
Going through this tread, I'm pretty sure #24 is sold out....but I would be interested in #25 if any are available. Should probably email Andrew. His Odyssey project has spiked some interest in these reissue releases. Also curious if a digital of 25 was released yet.

Andrew released the digital copies a while back. Here's the link to the thread:
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37987

Andrew NDB
09-04-2012, 01:22 AM
Still a few #25s left.

#24... I dunno, I've gotten a lot of requests lately, maybe I should make like a "wish list" of people interested in a third printing to see if it'd be a worthwhile venture.

nelodiavolo
09-04-2012, 02:36 AM
Andrew released the digital copies a while back. Here's the link to the thread:
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37987

Still a few #25s left.

#24... I dunno, I've gotten a lot of requests lately, maybe I should make like a "wish list" of people interested in a third printing to see if it'd be a worthwhile venture.

Awesome, thanks Lampy. The digital prints are great, but holding them in my hand would be even better. :tgrin:

Andrew, I am definitely interested in both issues and would gladly purchase 25. Sorry, I'm still pretty new to the forum, so I am thinking an email would be best to conduct a transaction? Also, I don't want to jump the gun on liugeaux, since he asked before I did.

But yea, I'd be willing to be added to the wishlist for 24 if one is ever printed.

Lampy
09-04-2012, 03:40 AM
Awesome, thanks Lampy. The digital prints are great, but holding them in my hand would be even better. :tgrin:

Andrew, I am definitely interested in both issues and would gladly purchase 25. Sorry, I'm still pretty new to the forum, so I am thinking an email would be best to conduct a transaction? Also, I don't want to jump the gun on liugeaux, since he asked before I did.

But yea, I'd be willing to be added to the wishlist for 24 if one is ever printed.


no problem... i totally agree. all the hard work that was put into this is definitely something to behold physically. i just got my copy of #25 from Andrew and #24 from DemonAlukard a few months ago. They truly are awesome additions to the volume.

Yep It's A Trap
09-04-2012, 04:07 AM
How do I order a #25?

rich
09-04-2012, 09:19 AM
Still a few #25s left.

#24... I dunno, I've gotten a lot of requests lately, maybe I should make like a "wish list" of people interested in a third printing to see if it'd be a worthwhile venture.

Although I have both printings of #24 (and they are truly awesome), if there's a 3rd printing you can count me in.

FoxZerro
09-04-2012, 09:50 AM
Still a few #25s left.

#24... I dunno, I've gotten a lot of requests lately, maybe I should make like a "wish list" of people interested in a third printing to see if it'd be a worthwhile venture.

Putting my name on the wish list for a third print of 24.

and if there are 25's still available I would be all about one of those as well.

dragonside
10-22-2012, 12:09 AM
putting myself on a wishlist.

I'm wanting to purchase issues #24 and #25, hopefully odyssey has sparked enough interest in another print run :)

Tuxedo Moroboshi
03-17-2014, 04:45 AM
Sorry for necroposting, but I totally missed out on this the first time. I think I'd be interested in a third printing, so you could put me down on that "wishlist".

mrmaczaps
03-20-2014, 07:09 PM
Sorry for necroposting, but I totally missed out on this the first time. I think I'd be interested in a third printing, so you could put me down on that "wishlist".

Well, since you started it... I'd be interested in a new printing as well... :D

ianke_2002
03-21-2014, 02:00 PM
Ditto to the two above me.

miru
03-23-2014, 12:41 AM
I wonder if anybody'll try to continue the Fleetway and Dreamwave TMNT comics, and if the Archie Forever War will ever resurface?

Tuxedo Moroboshi
03-23-2014, 05:44 AM
I do remember that the Forever War was going to finally happen some years ago, but I think it was either cancelled or put on hiatus (which, considering how much time has passed now, is essentially the same as being cancelled). It could be interesting to see that coming through and also doubling as a finale for the Archie TMNT-verse.

Mobius37
03-30-2014, 05:25 PM
I would definitely be interested in both #24 and #25.

Mr Null
04-06-2014, 11:31 PM
I stopped reading volume 3 at issue #11 or #13. Cant remember off the top of my head. Which I am totally upset about now, because it is so hard to find the rest of the issues, and when I do, the prices are just out of control.

Demon-Alukard
07-29-2025, 07:53 PM
THE NEW PREORDER from Turtles Club!

https://sun9-56.userapi.com/s/v1/ig2/5XP2zugs1fgM3cy_kEW_YdzLEEZc5APKaWSnCrpLUoxOEu4Do1 rIES1YKf5gMxFQYQ1XQ4L0SLsvt0Ag7P6z0zNs.jpg?quality =95&as=32x47,48x71,72x106,108x159,160x235,240x353,360x 529,480x706,540x794,640x941,720x1058,800x1176&from=bu&cs=800x0 https://sun9-57.userapi.com/s/v1/ig2/b-gUltsK0ys9hOqBT3sum-pm2cWvn5thbiwR4ir_ovwPa0PPJyfc6SOmDd1AM1MQd2ouCubX 6-uj1d5vwG8NLLV4.jpg?quality=95&as=32x47,48x71,72x106,108x159,160x235,240x353,360x 529,480x706,540x794,640x941,720x1058,800x1176&from=bu&cs=800x0 https://sun9-68.userapi.com/s/v1/ig2/8tMd0UVikYOYMlcKkx9MvZ9RRq0sbMr89Wsayeln7uHhtCrl_f 3rw31VtgVaVVydnD1C1Oe1-BbzBDG6f3_66KLA.jpg?quality=95&as=32x47,48x71,72x106,108x159,160x235,240x353,360x 529,480x706,540x794,640x941,720x1058,800x1176&from=bu&cs=800x0

A new player appears in the city, throwing everything into disarray and preventing Raphael and Pimiko from leading the Foot Clan. Who is hiding behind the mask? As we know, the TMNT Volume 3 series, now called ‘Urban Legends’, was officially completed by original authors Gary Carlson and Frank Fosco, with the participation of Andrew Modeen, in 2020!

And now, the events of the original conclusion of the TMNT Volume 3 series from 2011-2012, written by Andrew Modeen using Gary Carlson's notes and illustrated by Arseniy Dubakov with contributions from Frank Fosco, and also including illustrations by Jim Lawson, Dan Berger, and even Kevin Eastman, are returning to the Mirageverse timeline!

With a brand new prologue and epilogue, the story begins a large, interconnected storyline spanning several books that will lead to a grand, logical conclusion for the Hamato family!

What's about ULTIMATE edition?

IDW "The Ultimate Collection" design aesthetic and deluxe size!
New ULTIMATE-like collage cover by Arseniy Dubakov and Dmitry Bobrovnik (colors), inspired by IDW's TMNT The Ultimate Collection series;
12 new pages from Jim Lawson + 14 new pages by Arseniy Dubakov;
Whole batch of original back-up stories (including ‘TMNT Vs Spawn’, published in fullcolor for the first time);
Gallery with all covers & additional material
Hardcover book, high quality gloss paper, 148 pages, 12,1x8,4 inches


***

This is a non-profit crowdfunded book, from fans to fans, with a very small print run.
We using raised funds to pay artists for their work and/or to recover, search for, prepare and print new forgotten TMNT books from 1984-2009.
Contacts:
E-mail: [email protected]

Mr. Entertainment
07-29-2025, 08:02 PM
So, is it an overlap of the ending Gary & Frank did 5 years ago?

Demon-Alukard
07-29-2025, 09:29 PM
So, is it an overlap of the ending Gary & Frank did 5 years ago?
Now both endings will be included in the Mirageverse timeline.

ToTheNines
07-30-2025, 12:43 AM
I love this story. Very glad to see a re-release and also happy we now have a name to call it by, especially since the official 24-26 made the numbering overlap.

I’m also psyched that The Shredder is being rewritten to fit with this version, since I don’t really care for the Urban Legends finale.

The new stuff from Jim definitely looks like Splinter in the Battle Nexus. The new Arseniy pages are incredible. Poster worthy stuff.

bjaxx87
07-30-2025, 08:07 AM
Now both endings will be included in the Mirageverse timeline.
Color me interested. So I guess we can expect multiverse shenanigans since it doesn't sound like there will be cuts/rewrites to the main story of the 2011/2012 conclusion (apart from prologue and epilogue)?

ToTheNines
07-30-2025, 08:43 PM
I just noticed that very interesting Easter egg in the bottom left corner of the back cover. Can’t wait!

Zog The Magnificent
07-30-2025, 09:00 PM
So now it's all going to fit together? I'm sold on that. I always liked the original Vol. 3 ending better, and if The Shredder will change to accommodate it, then I could really get behind that. I can't wait!

ToTheNines
08-03-2025, 02:23 PM
Yeah that was perhaps my least favorite aspect of The Shredder. That it retconned the original conclusion in favor of Urban Legends. I do understand the importance of Amaya and Pimiko being alive for the “present day” stuff, but I still prefer combining Amaya with Head Hunter and The Mistress and having them both die at the end of the Image run.

Andrew NDB
08-04-2025, 01:15 AM
I think we did some pretty neat stuff in this Ultimate edition. And it's all going to pay off in other stuff. And maybe some stuff yet to come.

Yeah that was perhaps my least favorite aspect of The Shredder. That it retconned the original conclusion in favor of Urban Legends.

I mean, to be precise... Urban Legends retconned it and The Shredder just rolled with it. What are we going to do, you know, ignore Urban Legends? It wasn't my call and of course I campaigned for certain modifications and notes in what the last three Urban Legends issues did. In fact, I don't think Gary said "no" to any of them. But obviously there wouldn't be any stuff like, "Well hey, how about go a COMPLETELY different direction with Lady Shredder" and such.

ToTheNines
08-04-2025, 01:32 AM
I don’t think it would have been the worst thing to ignore Urban Legends, personally. If Unfinished Business was your story with notes from Gary and Urban Legends was Gary’s story with notes from you, I don’t think it would have been disrespectful to ignore his work in favor of your own. Especially considering Urban Legends was IDW and your stories are published under Turtles Club.

That being said, Amaya and Pimiko are important pieces of The Shredder, so I’m not saying it was the wrong call. I’m just such a huge fan of Unfinished Business, so I have conflicting feelings on the whole thing.

I understand you have the utmost respect for Gary, I’m sure that was a huge factor. I do as well, and I’m glad this reprint is acknowledging both stories.

Zog The Magnificent
08-06-2025, 04:31 PM
I don’t think it would have been the worst thing to ignore Urban Legends, personally. If Unfinished Business was your story with notes from Gary and Urban Legends was Gary’s story with notes from you, I don’t think it would have been disrespectful to ignore his work in favor of your own. Especially considering Urban Legends was IDW and your stories are published under Turtles Club.

That being said, Amaya and Pimiko are important pieces of The Shredder, so I’m not saying it was the wrong call. I’m just such a huge fan of Unfinished Business, so I have conflicting feelings on the whole thing.

I understand you have the utmost respect for Gary, I’m sure that was a huge factor. I do as well, and I’m glad this reprint is acknowledging both stories.

I agree with this, on the basis that Urban Legends ends up being more of it's own thing in IDW, while your stories have all built into this sort of Mirage sub-universe, of which Unfinished Business is sort of a lichpin. Personally, I would have ignored it as well, and just let them be two different takes.

However, putting them both back together, and making a way for both to exist? Completely in favor of it, and can't wait to see how it all works out.

CyberCubed
08-06-2025, 05:23 PM
I'm really surprised you guys can still get away with printing these, I know Russian law doesn't care about this stuff, but I'm pretty sure Nick has to be aware of these fan books by now. It's a bit different when just commissioning fanart from artists for like 1 page, these are full-on continuous books.

Especially now that the Archie Adventures books are continuing with IDW, but now there's new Archie issues after the Forever War ended too. I guess printing these in Russia compared to the U.S. is really a godsend here?

Have you guys ever gotten a "cease and desist" letter from Nick at all after all this time?

Zog The Magnificent
08-06-2025, 07:55 PM
I'm really surprised you guys can still get away with printing these, I know Russian law doesn't care about this stuff, but I'm pretty sure Nick has to be aware of these fan books by now. It's a bit different when just commissioning fanart from artists for like 1 page, these are full-on continuous books.

Especially now that the Archie Adventures books are continuing with IDW, but now there's new Archie issues after the Forever War ended too. I guess printing these in Russia compared to the U.S. is really a godsend here?

Have you guys ever gotten a "cease and desist" letter from Nick at all after all this time?

SHH! Don't jinx it! Everyone knows it doesn't exist until it's spoken of!

Demon-Alukard
08-06-2025, 10:35 PM
Especially now that the Archie Adventures books are continuing with IDW, but now there's new Archie issues after the Forever War ended too.
Continuing by IDW? Do you mean another reprints of ugly scans?

IDW has not published anything new about Archiverse and Mirageverse and has not engaged any Mirage artists for anything beyond some covers (except for those Anniversary specials, when they are remembered once every ten years)!

The only achievement IDW did in all these years is Urban Legends. Everything else is just reissues and reissues and reissues. It's unclear how the TMNT Vol. 4 series will end now. Will they just republish 31 issues in three years? Or will they not even last that long, with a monthly release of existing and untouched material?

I guess printing these in Russia compared to the U.S. is really a godsend here
All of our projects are essentially free creative works. We do not pursue any financial gain or profit; this is work done by fans for fans, and the proceeds from the books go toward creating more books.

The books are not sold anywhere in open access, and starting with the current reissue of The Shredder and Unfinished Business and follow-up stories, Andrew has also abandoned the idea of crowdfunding platforms (which could be blocked at any time). Therefore, I see no reason to prosecute us in any way.

As for Russia, we have exactly the same laws, and intellectual property rights are protected in the same way in court. I am more sympathetic to the Japanese approach, where doujinshi are welcomed and sold freely in book stores.

ToTheNines
08-07-2025, 03:41 AM
and has not engaged any Mirage artists for anything beyond some covers (except for those Anniversary specials, when they are remembered once every ten years)!

Yeah this is pretty infuriating. I know they were trying to establish their own version first, and that’s fine. But most of the old Mirage bullpen is sitting there with all that talent and creativity for all these years, but never being tapped for anything significant.


All of our projects are essentially free creative works. We do not pursue any financial gain or profit; this is work done by fans for fans, and the proceeds from the books go toward creating more books.

The books are not sold anywhere in open access, and starting with the current reissue of The Shredder and Unfinished Business and follow-up stories, Andrew has also abandoned the idea of crowdfunding platforms (which could be blocked at any time). Therefore, I see no reason to prosecute us in any way.

As for Russia, we have exactly the same laws, and intellectual property rights are protected in the same way in court. I am more sympathetic to the Japanese approach, where doujinshi are welcomed and sold freely in book stores.

The pages you get from the artists are essentially no different than getting a character commission from the same people. They’re just sequential art rather than a portrait. And the product isn’t mass produced.

I know for a fact that people at IDW are aware of Turtles Club. I just don’t think they have much of a case if they would try to say you’re taking any business from them, because you’re not. If anything, you’re helping the property stay relevant amongst a certain demographic.

Let’s just all pretend you’re using Peter’s “18 Mirage issues per year” clause while he’s just sitting on it. ;)

ToTheNines
10-25-2025, 03:50 PM
https://i.imgur.com/WZdeKIy.jpeg

Zog The Magnificent
10-25-2025, 04:20 PM
Is that post-TMNT Vol. 4 I spy?

ToTheNines
10-28-2025, 06:18 PM
Is that post-TMNT Vol. 4 I spy?

Yeah he’s definitely in the Battle Nexus.

Question for Andrew or Arseniy: did Mr. Carlson have any input for the new prologue or epilogue?

Demon-Alukard
10-28-2025, 10:44 PM
Yeah he’s definitely in the Battle Nexus.

Question for Andrew or Arseniy: did Mr. Carlson have any input for the new prologue or epilogue?

Nope. The plot of the additional pages is mine, the script is by Andrew.

One more teaser:
https://sun9-6.userapi.com/s/v1/if2/SR5SsP1SoM8KTyozrZ79GLV39x2hm7lAX15p49gCYV7E2eoaB-hWLJfaCJT9Vk4uC4CVfr_yVTLE637NcRT3VWzt.jpg?quality =95&as=32x24,48x36,72x54,108x81,160x120,240x180,360x27 0,480x359,540x404,640x479,720x539,1080x809,1099x82 3&from=bu&cs=1099x0

ToTheNines
01-27-2026, 06:35 PM
Getting ahead of myself, I’m sure these are still a few months out, but I had a question.

With all the new material coming, which should be read first? Unfinished Business or Shredder?

Andrew NDB
01-27-2026, 06:48 PM
With all the new material coming, which should be read first? Unfinished Business or Shredder?

The new stuff in Unfinished Business would be a good deal of time before the present day stuff in Shredder. However... there is stuff threaded throughout that sort of "begins" in Ultimate Shredder. There could be a case for either, but I'd say Ultimate Shredder.

Zog The Magnificent
01-27-2026, 10:41 PM
Nope. The plot of the additional pages is mine, the script is by Andrew.

One more teaser:
https://sun9-6.userapi.com/s/v1/if2/SR5SsP1SoM8KTyozrZ79GLV39x2hm7lAX15p49gCYV7E2eoaB-hWLJfaCJT9Vk4uC4CVfr_yVTLE637NcRT3VWzt.jpg?quality =95&as=32x24,48x36,72x54,108x81,160x120,240x180,360x27 0,480x359,540x404,640x479,720x539,1080x809,1099x82 3&from=bu&cs=1099x0

Okay, these teasers are definitely giving me... thoughts. But I suppose I'll save them for later.

ToTheNines
01-28-2026, 07:31 PM
The new stuff in Unfinished Business would be a good deal of time before the present day stuff in Shredder. However... there is stuff threaded throughout that sort of "begins" in Ultimate Shredder. There could be a case for either, but I'd say Ultimate Shredder.

Cool, thanks! Can’t wait.

Did you guys realize this is lining up with the 15 year anniversary of #24? Pretty cool.

Demon-Alukard
01-29-2026, 07:47 PM
Getting ahead of myself, I’m sure these are still a few months out, but I had a question.

With all the new material coming, which should be read first? Unfinished Business or Shredder?

I think it's worth starting with Unfinished Business so that the intrigue unfolds gradually.

ToTheNines
01-30-2026, 11:30 AM
The new stuff in Unfinished Business would be a good deal of time before the present day stuff in Shredder. However... there is stuff threaded throughout that sort of "begins" in Ultimate Shredder. There could be a case for either, but I'd say Ultimate Shredder.

I think it's worth starting with Unfinished Business so that the intrigue unfolds gradually.

Damn, now I'm torn!

Demon-Alukard
03-30-2026, 10:02 AM
The artwork for Unfinished Business is fully done now as well!
All that's left is a little work on additional toning/duoshading, proofreading, and preparing for printing.

https://i.imgur.com/vxtSTyb.png

ToTheNines
03-31-2026, 01:58 PM
Awesome, thanks for sharing.

Very cool. I think I kind of see where the story for the prologue/epilogue is going. Can’t wait!

ToTheNines
07-02-2026, 04:08 PM
With the dubiously numbered TMNT #300 upon us, I just want to point out that this version of TMNT #25 will always be TMNT #100 to me, even if it came after most of volume 4.

Volume 1 = 62
Volume 2= 13 (75)
Volume 3 = 23 + 2 (100)

neatoman
07-02-2026, 04:44 PM
With the dubiously numbered TMNT #300 upon us, I just want to point out that this version of TMNT #25 will always be TMNT #100 to me, even if it came after most of volume 4.

Volume 1 = 62
Volume 2= 13 (75)
Volume 3 = 23 + 2 (100)

You're not cool with V4 issue 2 being #100?

Which reminds me, do you think DC or whoever gets the license next will honor IDW's legacy numbering when it comes around for like #500 or whatever?

ToTheNines
07-03-2026, 05:47 AM
You're not cool with V4 issue 2 being #100?

Well if you were keeping it purely Mirage, or asked Laird, you’d probably have to say Vol. 4 #25 was TMNT #100. Between #2 and #25, neither one is particularly monumental or climactic.

Image #25 feels more worthy. It was not only a nice cap on Vol. 3, but brought many things full circle from Vol. 1 and Tales. It really felt like the end of their teenage days, before entering the “lost years” era that led to Vol. 4.

Which reminds me, do you think DC or whoever gets the license next will honor IDW's legacy numbering when it comes around for like #500 or whatever?

Probably. Anything for a gimmick book with 300 variant covers.

Demon-Alukard
10-06-2026, 02:06 PM
Long-awaited news, friends! The Shredder and Unfinished Business are finally going to the printer!
We worked on the books right up until the last minute (including making changes to The Shredder just today to account for upcoming issues of Tales), and I’m very pleased with the final result of the both books!
If anyone wants to make it onto the Thanks page at the very last minute, now's the time to join! Feel free to send me direct message for details (or email).

https://sun9-68.vkuserphoto.ru/s/v1/ig2/sNmu76lvblrWioBEWNtXl8qI_JOiFxLaC2ZLsKeQVotlva053R eOSMA8lo8zz_iIIxbIXjrfiiWEPOMQ3Ys0osw2.jpg?quality =95&as=32x47,48x71,72x106,108x159,160x235,240x353,360x 529,480x706,540x794,640x941,700x1029&from=bu&cs=700x0 https://sun9-7.vkuserphoto.ru/s/v1/ig2/egolZnQrx48z68knhZBf7pyh_276JOwA2hNqCi8cK8mW88rsmS tmxogoqY0HJk0e5l34EX16HvSR-OLyNyH127-W.jpg?quality=95&as=32x47,48x71,72x106,108x159,160x235,240x353,360x 529,480x706,540x794,640x941,700x1029&from=bu&u=SRGFisYrDEWfmcE4K_tzTHIvHNvvOIrBrdyyuxtxujE&cs=700x0

ToTheNines
10-06-2026, 03:57 PM
I’m thrilled to hear this!

Mostly just my own OCD/autism, but I was going to be bummed if this wasn’t out in time for the 15th anniversary of #24, but I guess next year would work too in honor of #25 lol.