View Full Version : Secret History of the Foot Clan #4 Discussion
TonySiegel
03-18-2013, 05:15 PM
The end of this miniseries is here fellow mutants... :tsad:
http://www.comicsalliance.com/2013/03/18/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-secret-history-of-the-foot-clan-4-preview/
whatcha think bout this joint?
CyberCubed
03-18-2013, 05:55 PM
Is it just me or does Mike and Don look really young in those middle panels, almost Nick-ish? Nice preview so far.
Redeemer
03-18-2013, 06:19 PM
I can't wait for wed.!!!!! it will be Turtle take over Wensday!!!!!
Slade
03-18-2013, 06:26 PM
I don't want to read the preview, but I'm so ready to get this!
corvus
03-19-2013, 11:08 AM
I love how they included Angels dads bar from the annual.
Gonna miss this series but with the villain micros right around the corner I'll get over it quickly.
Toby Barrett
03-19-2013, 11:31 AM
The "I can read more manga now" line irks me pretty bad, but otherwise, looking forward to the tpb coming out soon.
Erik Burnham
03-19-2013, 12:08 PM
The "I can read more manga now" line irks me pretty bad, but otherwise, looking forward to the tpb coming out soon.
It was suggested to me by someone else. I thought it was kind of funny. Sorry it irks. (:
CyberCubed
03-19-2013, 12:29 PM
Ah, the whole anime/manga craze in the U.S. died down back by 2006 at the latest. Seems odd to still have references to it now in 2013.
Toby Barrett
03-19-2013, 12:36 PM
It was suggested to me by someone else. I thought it was kind of funny. Sorry it irks. (:
Hehe, it's no big, and I'm sure I'm the only one it actually bugs, just imagining it being said makes me "ehhh..." :p
Erik Burnham
03-19-2013, 12:51 PM
Ah, the whole anime/manga craze in the U.S. died down back by 2006 at the latest. Seems odd to still have references to it now in 2013.
Well, a craze dying down doesn't mean that they go away - or where would TMNT (or Ghostbusters!) be? (: My career thanks people for not sticking solely with the tastes of wild mainstream popularity! :D
Back to manga. The stuff is still out there, in all bookstores (albeit in smaller sections.) Untranslated stuff is even easier to get.
In this case, all it means is Mikey likes reading comics and has a whole bunch more now available to him. (; I wouldn't have thought of it without the suggestion, but hey, it still struck me as funny.
corvus
03-19-2013, 01:10 PM
Michelangelo is my favorite turtle, I strongly dislike anime but still it makes sense to me that he'd like it and wanna use his new found ability to read Japanese for that purpose. But would it be the modern dialect that he speaks? I don't know much about the language but I know if you went to Britain in the middle ages and spoke modern English no one would know what you were saying. Did the Japanese have the same dialect then as they do now?
Erik Burnham
03-19-2013, 01:29 PM
Michelangelo is my favorite turtle, I strongly dislike anime but still it makes sense to me that he'd like it and wanna use his new found ability to read Japanese for that purpose. But would it be the modern dialect that he speaks? I don't know much about the language but I know if you went to Britain in the middle ages and spoke modern English no one would know what you were saying. Did the Japanese have the same dialect then as they do now?
IIRC, modern Japanese started around 1600-ish. Differences? More than likely, but I can't say that it's as drastic as the evolution of modern English.
In either case, Mateus' original idea was to have Donatello be able to read the language.
I suggested the switch for several reasons - I like that it gives Michelangelo something that the others don't have - but primarily, since what Mikey wants most is to connect with others, and language is one of the tools of connecting, it fit thematically to give this attribute to him.
The manga joke aside. (:
Vi11AiN6
03-19-2013, 01:51 PM
AWESOME!!!! Great series and it's cool the see the bar from the Annual.
IDW has done the best job of using such details to constantly keep this series interesting and cohesive..
thelouisguy
03-19-2013, 02:02 PM
I love how they included Angels dads bar from the annual.
Sweet! I hope they burn it down like they did April's Dad's shop.
oldmanwinters
03-19-2013, 05:07 PM
Looks like #4 is already getting some high praise!
http://www.flickeringmyth.com/2013/03/comic-book-review-teenage-mutant-ninja.html
Venom
03-19-2013, 05:27 PM
In either case, Mateus' original idea was to have Donatello be able to read the language.
I suggested the switch for several reasons - I like that it gives Michelangelo something that the others don't have - but primarily, since what Mikey wants most is to connect with others, and language is one of the tools of connecting, it fit thematically to give this attribute to him.
Erik, after that comment I must thank you, man. Far too often is Mike subjugated to the role of "the young, dumb, baby bro" of the group, completely sidetracking his own very creative, right-brained, intelligence. He's not stupid, but so many writers forget that aspect; personally, I would say he's on par with Donnie, but the two are on polarizing spectrums: Don expresses himself logically, analytically, and methodically, whereas Mike expresses himself through writing, art, and concepts.
Folks typically think he's dumb when Don says something "smart" and Mike repeats in in simplistic terms, missing the fact that he grasps what Don said just fine, just reiterating in a more common-sense approach.
Mike is a "slacker smart guy": yeah, he's bright, he's also the best naturally gifted Turtle, but he's more about enjoying the whole of life than focusing on one discipline, unless it's comics, games, and movies! :trazz:
So, again Erik, thank you for being so observant.
Redeemer
03-19-2013, 07:39 PM
So today I went to my comic book store to pick up my books and of course its tuesday!!!!not Wensday!!!!! lmao I thought I would share this to hopefully make some one day :lol:
TheCanadiandrome
03-19-2013, 07:41 PM
lookin good! can't wait to own this and then eventually the TPB
Ninjinister
03-19-2013, 08:02 PM
Ha ha, the prof makes a reference to Splinter's original origin and April dismisses it as ridiculous.
Plasticplayhouse
03-20-2013, 06:25 AM
The "I can read more manga now" line irks me pretty bad, but otherwise, looking forward to the tpb coming out soon.
may i ask why? i thought it was pretty funny.
this arch has been awesome. great writing and art on all fronts from IDW's TMNT. if it continues like this, this series can roll on easy for many more years to come :)
Slade
03-20-2013, 05:50 PM
I hate to see this arc end. It was really good.
I didn't mind the manga line and I'm also glad Mikey got a new talent.
Also, I'm thinking there won't be an alliance between Shredder and Krang. Especially sine Saki attacked the "iron demon".
DrSpengler
03-20-2013, 08:47 PM
Here's my review of Secret History #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/03/tmnt-secret-history-of-foot-clan-4.html)
Whew, it's been a busy day for reviewing.
I really think this may be my favorite storyline in the IDW-verse so far. Just such a great piece of work. For anyone looking to get into the IDW series, this is probably the best introductory arc as it works great by itself, but leaves plenty of questions open about the series to entice new readers to start from the beginning and get drawn in.
And I don't know if it was planned this way or what, but having both the Krang War and Secret History running simultaneously was an awesome way to open up the mythology of the IDW-verse from both the sci-fi and spiritual sides at the same time. The past four months have seen so much world building; I've been loving it.
And I like that Miller got to stick around as an abused intellectual lackey for the Foot. He makes a great parallel for Baxter, who is employed by Krang under similar circumstances.
I suppose my only question is... who was that Foot Soldier getting scarred over the eye in TMNT #2 if it wasn't Saki? Just a nobody?
Ninjinister
03-20-2013, 09:08 PM
The "I can read more manga now" line irks me pretty bad, but otherwise, looking forward to the tpb coming out soon.
Why would it? It's super in-character for Mike.
DrSpengler
03-20-2013, 09:15 PM
Just read the thread (I avoid these until I've read the whole issue for myself because I like to be a spoiler virgin).
The manga line was right up Mikey's alley. He's a comic book dork. I, personally, don't care for manga (even though I translate TMNT manga but that's different, dammit!), but I won't let my personal tastes affect how I view a character. Hell, even in the Mirage universe, Mikey was a fan of Ghibli movies and Japanese animation. His being a manga fan is perfectly fine.
And reading Erik's comment, I'm glad he changed the translation dealie from Don to Mike. not just because it gives Mikey something unique and it fits his persona of being open minded and wanting to connect with people, but because Don is still being shown having trouble accepting reincarnation as fact. I figure that until he can accept it, he'll probably have the most trouble of all his brothers when it comes to tapping into aspects of his previous life.
TheCanadiandrome
03-21-2013, 12:55 AM
Going to get this soon. Manga line eh? Cool! I'd love some new manga
ToTheNines
03-21-2013, 08:18 AM
I read this twice last night and can't help but feel a little disappointed.
Ever since seeing the shadowy outline of an android body in the preview cover for this issue way back in December, I always thought this would be the big Utrom connection issue. Imagine my surprise (and everyone elses, I'm sure) when the Iron Demon/Quanin showed up at the end of #1. Also, imagine my surprise when he was almost entirely absent in the following two issues. I didn't consider it a big deal with a whole issue left... but all we ended up getting was a flashforward to when Saki finally turned on him and "killed him" rather abruptly.
No clue as to why or how he ended up in this dimension, no real hint as to what exactly his final objective on Earth was. Furthermore, not too much happened in the present day setting either. Splinter and Shredder had a nice fight, but it was too short. There wasn't any hints toward Leo joining the Foot. Before we see the exact process of Saki's resurrection (which was pretty cool), Mike makes some offhand joke about it and kinda ruins it. The Ashi No Himitsu was unceremoniously destroyed. Alopex ended up having zero connection to Kitsune.
The art was great, of course. No one's going to argue that. My favorite panel was probably the flame arrows whizzing past Shredder.
corvus
03-21-2013, 11:44 AM
No way that was Quanin. It's an unnamed utrom as far as we know. They killed him and destroyed his portal. It was a big revelation that there's a connection between Saki and utroms. They kind of lead us to believe he was Krang or Quanin but I think that was kind of unavoidable, utroms are hard to distinguish from one another.
DrSpengler
03-21-2013, 11:48 AM
I took the scene as the Utrom getting kicked through the portal and THEN it exploding, not necessarily meaning the Utrom is dead.
And I suppose any unnamed Utrom could have taken on the grandiose identity of "Iron Demon", but I dunno. That seems wasted on a nobody. I'm still going with the presumption that it was Quanin at least until we're told otherwise.
EDIT: Also, I figured it was Quanin because he was shown with a tuning fork on the head of his robot body in the ongoing, a detail shared by the Iron Demon in Secret History.
Metropoliskid41
03-21-2013, 12:20 PM
An incredible issue, and a really incredible mini series, great story, perfect pacing, with some gorgeous art. I really hope we get to see a Secret History of the Utrom mini now follow it up, touch on Utrom exploration of our dimension, what Utrom the Iron Demon actually was, how he came to earth & essentially created Kitsune. We've known that Shredder & Krang have been "battling" or "rival" factions now since issue 1, that's how the turtles were mutated, this scratched the surface of that, but there is still more awesomness in their background & history to be explored & touched upon. When did Krang & the Utrom return to earth & so on. There is a lot of potential here, I hope Bobby taps Erik & Mateus to team-up & explore it in upcoming minis.
I really dug this mini, it added so much depth & new world building mythos to the Foot Clan. I can't wait to see what's next. Tip of the cap to all who were involved on this one over at IDW.
corvus
03-21-2013, 12:22 PM
I took the scene as the Utrom getting kicked through the portal and THEN it exploding, not necessarily meaning the Utrom is dead.
And I suppose any unnamed Utrom could have taken on the grandiose identity of "Iron Demon", but I dunno. That seems wasted on a nobody. I'm still going with the presumption that it was Quanin at least until we're told otherwise.
EDIT: Also, I figured it was Quanin because his robot body in both the ongoing and Secre History has the tuning fork on its head which is a detail so far only Quanine has been shown to have (Krang's robot body lacks the tuning fork).
Read it once, didn't catch that bit where he was kicked through the portal. The exosuit made me think an older one, utroms live a long time and they probably upgrade their suits. I'm starting to think it was Quanin and then Krang, saki said he served it in two incarnations. That would explain Krangs knowledge of earth and his desire to destroy it.
Metropoliskid41
03-21-2013, 12:28 PM
Read it once, didn't catch that bit where he was kicked through the portal. The exosuit made me think an older one, utroms live a long time and they probably upgrade their suits. I'm starting to think it was Quanin and then Krang, saki said he served it in two incarnations. That would explain Krangs knowledge of earth and his desire to destroy it.
I took Saki's comment of serving it in two incarnations as meaning he himself (as in Saki) served the SAME Demon/Utrom twice, as the corrupt Foot Clan leader who his father slayed (sorry the name escapes me at the moment) and then again after he is reborn as Oraku Saki & raised by his father who murdered him in his previous life.
ToTheNines
03-21-2013, 12:29 PM
Like Spengler said, look at the ongoing (#19) and it's pretty clear who Quanin is.
corvus
03-21-2013, 12:44 PM
I saw that. But the suit is also a lot different than Quanins and its too different to just beartist interpretation. Which means it could be another utrom still. But...imagine Quanin falling through a portal and dying in his sons presence do to wounds he received from the foot cause I could see that happening and it'd be pretty cool.
DrSpengler
03-21-2013, 01:13 PM
I took Saki's comment of serving it in two incarnations as meaning he himself (as in Saki) served the SAME Demon/Utrom twice, as the corrupt Foot Clan leader who his father slayed (sorry the name escapes me at the moment) and then again after he is reborn as Oraku Saki & raised by his father who murdered him in his previous life.
Yeah, that was how I read it, too. He served the Iron Demon once as Tatsuo Takeshi and then again as Oroku Saki.
Erik Burnham
03-21-2013, 01:17 PM
I read this twice last night and can't help but feel a little disappointed.
Ever since seeing the shadowy outline of an android body in the preview cover for this issue way back in December, I always thought this would be the big Utrom connection issue. Imagine my surprise (and everyone elses, I'm sure) when the Iron Demon/Quanin showed up at the end of #1. Also, imagine my surprise when he was almost entirely absent in the following two issues. I didn't consider it a big deal with a whole issue left... but all we ended up getting was a flashforward to when Saki finally turned on him and "killed him" rather abruptly.
No clue as to why or how he ended up in this dimension, no real hint as to what exactly his final objective on Earth was. Furthermore, not too much happened in the present day setting either. Splinter and Shredder had a nice fight, but it was too short. There wasn't any hints toward Leo joining the Foot. Before we see the exact process of Saki's resurrection (which was pretty cool), Mike makes some offhand joke about it and kinda ruins it. The Ashi No Himitsu was unceremoniously destroyed. Alopex ended up having zero connection to Kitsune.
The art was great, of course. No one's going to argue that. My favorite panel was probably the flame arrows whizzing past Shredder.
Well, some things feed back into the main series (or potentially other micros.) Some things (Dark Leo tie-ins for example) didn't get any real estate because there wasn't any space. (:
And there was a line -- one of Mateus' -- about the Foot's first mutant (Alopex) being a fox because Shredder specifically wanted it that way. He liked the symbolism. But, really, it didn't work in the scene as well as we'd hoped. Could've been my failings there.
Still, there are a lot of ideas that should be touched on. Luckily there's many more turtle comics upcoming.
As an example, someone at a con asked me about Masato in the Splinter Micro. Said I should really have explained more about what happened to him. He seemed like a decent guy, how come he wasn't speaking up when Saki was getting crazy (back in TMNT #5?) Why didn't I acknowledge that?
Well, we know what happened to him now, nine months later, in another series. (:
Lotsa shuffling, guys, and especially, lots of hindsight. Nature of the beast. (:
corvus
03-21-2013, 01:46 PM
Thank you for explaining that bit about Alopex. I've been saying for awhile there's no real connection between Alopex and Kitsune.
Martin
03-21-2013, 04:02 PM
Some things ( Dark Leo tie-ins for example) didn't get any real estate because there wasn't any space. (:
Whoa, I like what I'm reading there... :)
I'm still waiting for my copies down here in argentina. I really hope that digital comics will be available for people outside the us at some point in the future. It's really hard for me to stay away from other sources while I wait for my trades to get here. Patience is a virtue I guess :ohwell:
Erik Burnham
03-21-2013, 05:22 PM
Whoa, I like what I'm reading there... :)
I'm still waiting for my copies down here in argentina. I really hope that digital comics will be available for people outside the us at some point in the future. It's really hard for me to stay away from other sources while I wait for my trades to get here. Patience is a virtue I guess :ohwell:
I was just riffing on Nines' specific comment about Leo joining the Foot. (:
Panda_Kahn_fan
03-21-2013, 05:30 PM
One question I do have though; Does the Kitsune Witch have a name? (If it were me, I'd call her Pimiko, from the Mirage character. And her Daughter of the same name with Saki would be Karai's ancestor.)
Redeemer
03-21-2013, 05:34 PM
This mini-series was A-mazing!!!!! I love this mini series!!!!
Good job IDW :thumbsup:
This mini series is my favorite of the entire series so far!!!!!
DrSpengler
03-21-2013, 05:49 PM
One question I do have though; Does the Kitsune Witch have a name? (If it were me, I'd call her Pimiko, from the Mirage character. And her Daughter of the same name with Saki would be Karai's ancestor.)
I think maybe "Kitsune" IS her name, though I thought it was just a description of what she was at first. It's a bit of a generic name, though. "Fox".
Panda_Kahn_fan
03-21-2013, 05:58 PM
I think maybe "Kitsune" IS her name, though I thought it was just a description of what she was at first. It's a bit of a generic name, though. "Fox".
You sure about that? I didn't notice Saki address her with Kitsune as the name. If that is her name though, is cool.
DrSpengler
03-21-2013, 06:00 PM
You sure about that? I didn't notice Saki address her with Kitsune as the name. If that is her name though, is cool.
I'm not sure, which is why in my reviews I usually refer to her as "the Kitsune witch" 'cause I couldn't tell if Kitsune was intended as her proper name or a description of the magical creature she represented.
Redeemer
03-21-2013, 07:48 PM
The "I can read more manga now" line irks me pretty bad, but otherwise, looking forward to the tpb coming out soon.
seriously???? I loved that line!!!! so freaking funny!!!!!!!
This made it for me!!!!
Martin
03-21-2013, 07:52 PM
I was just riffing on Nines' specific comment about Leo joining the Foot. (:
You sure about that? Because 'dark leo' sounds pretty damn cool to me :trazz:
Erik Burnham
03-21-2013, 09:14 PM
You sure about that? Because 'dark leo' sounds pretty damn cool to me :trazz:
I glommed onto his example. We had a million things we couldn't include. Maybe a better example would've been more Utrom stuff.
Never. Post. Tired! (:
Martin
03-21-2013, 09:42 PM
I glommed onto his example. We had a million things we couldn't include. Maybe a better example would've been more Utrom stuff.
Never. Post. Tired! (:
Tell me about it! After 9 hours of work and 5 of uni I'm beat. So if anyone notices any incoherencies from my part, it's probably because of that. Apparently fatigue and writing in a foreign language don't go well together. Who knew?
Anyway, I got excited with the whole dark leo thingy since it kind of validated my hopes that Leo would switch teams due to some sort of brainwash or spell, rather than the usual 'goes undercover to gather intel'. But I probably was reading too much into it.
Ok, I'll stop harassing you now :trazz:
ToTheNines
03-21-2013, 10:13 PM
Well, some things feed back into the main series (or potentially other micros.) Some things (Dark Leo tie-ins for example) didn't get any real estate because there wasn't any space. (:
Understandable. It was only a 4 issue mini.
And there was a line -- one of Mateus' -- about the Foot's first mutant (Alopex) being a fox because Shredder specifically wanted it that way. He liked the symbolism. But, really, it didn't work in the scene as well as we'd hoped. Could've been my failings there.
That's pretty cool to know, regardless if it made it onto a panel or not.
Still, there are a lot of ideas that should be touched on. Luckily there's many more turtle comics upcoming.
As an example, someone at a con asked me about Masato in the Splinter Micro. Said I should really have explained more about what happened to him. He seemed like a decent guy, how come he wasn't speaking up when Saki was getting crazy (back in TMNT #5?) Why didn't I acknowledge that?
Well, we know what happened to him now, nine months later, in another series. (:
Lotsa shuffling, guys, and especially, lots of hindsight. Nature of the beast. (:
Right, right. I just put too much stock into #4 before reading it.
I love the creative team behind this TMNT universe but after almost 2 years, I kinda wish they'd wrap all this stuff up and put a cap on it, then come right back with a Volume 2.
Anyways, thanks for the input Burnham-san.
Panda_Kahn_fan
03-22-2013, 01:56 PM
No offense, but why do we need a vol.2? This isn't mirage, the series can go on indefinitely as long as sales are up.
ToTheNines
03-22-2013, 02:27 PM
We don't need one, I'm just starting to get tired of waiting a year (or longer) to have questions answered. I want them to tell a complete story, maybe take a short break, then come back with a sequel volume.
corvus
03-22-2013, 02:50 PM
I think the better solution is to give us a second monthly or even bi-monthly ongoing series. But that's expensive to do.
Panda_Kahn_fan
03-23-2013, 01:32 PM
Yeah, I'd love to see a second monthly!
Oy, I just read the previews, and I do actually think her name is Kitsune. As a former anime fan, the name seems kinda blah :ohwell: still think she's an awesome character though. Maybe her and shredder's daugher's name was Pimiko?
Venom
03-23-2013, 03:58 PM
I think the better solution is to give us a second monthly or even bi-monthly ongoing series. But that's expensive to do.
Not to mention the mental blowout it would give Tom to try and write it, on top of the other series and stories he writes for!
Powder
03-23-2013, 09:08 PM
Best part of the IDW series thus far. This would make an amazing film if you just tack on a brawl with Shredder at the end. I wish the whole series had this same tone and artist/writer duo (with all due respect to everyone else who have been amazing too).
Redeemer
03-23-2013, 09:57 PM
Best part of the IDW series thus far. This would make an amazing film if you just tack on a brawl with Shredder at the end. I wish the whole series had this same tone and artist/writer duo (with all due respect to everyone else who have been amazing too).
Agreed!!!! this has been my favorite arch of the IDW universe!!!!
***First of Two Latin Kings***
03-25-2013, 08:44 PM
I wonder if they can just point an anti-mutagen gun at Shredder and make him mortal again... :tlol:
seriously???? I loved that line!!!! so freaking funny!!!!!!!
This made it for me!!!!
I liked his analogy between playing Mario Brothers and reincarnation better, but I already said somewhere that he's had some of the best lines here of late. Does anyone else literally hear Greg Cipes' voice in their head when he speaks in the comic? I do.
I can see where people found the 2003 cartoon's Michelangelo annoying, I really can, but I think that the IDW series and the Nick cartoon have done a VERY good job with him, like the 2007 movie did.
MikeandRaph87
03-25-2013, 09:17 PM
I wonder if they can just point an anti-mutagen gun at Shredder and make him mortal again... :tlol:
I liked his analogy between playing Mario Brothers and reincarnation better, but I already said somewhere that he's had some of the best lines here of late. Does anyone else literally hear Greg Cipes' voice in their head when he speaks in the comic? I do.
I can see where people found the 2003 cartoon's Michelangelo annoying, I really can, but I think that the IDW series and the Nick cartoon have done a VERY good job with him, like the 2007 movie did.
No matter what I always hear the four turtles as voiced in the '87 cartoon. I guess its just how attached to them as a child I was and thier voices never went away to be replaced in my head since I still to this day hear those voices more than any. Still hearing two Raphs in the Nick cartoon. :trazz:
Anyway,as for the second title, the micros fill that nicely. A one and done yet connected issue with character focus. Maybe make it a bi-monthy after round three? It would be a nice showcase of IDW and overall independent writers and artist talent on top of the before mentioned. It would also progress the story a bit quicker and easier. I don't want a volume two for a long time. I know comic companies don't care about numbering anymore but I would like to see a TMNT comic reach 76 for once.
Redeemer
03-25-2013, 09:35 PM
.
I can see where people found the 2003 cartoon's Michelangelo annoying, I really can, but I think that the IDW series and the Nick cartoon have done a VERY good job with him,
I really dont understand all of the hate for 2k3 Mikey if 2k3 mikey is stupid then Nick Mikey must be a GRADE A RETARD. I dont like Nick Mikey at all worse incarnation of him ever.
Kendamu
03-26-2013, 12:04 AM
It was suggested to me by someone else. I thought it was kind of funny. Sorry it irks. (:
No, actually, it was pretty funny. It got a laugh out of me and everyone I showed it to. It's very Mikey-like. I'm glad you put it in there. :tgrin:
TheCanadiandrome
03-27-2013, 12:30 AM
Best part of the IDW series thus far. This would make an amazing film if you just tack on a brawl with Shredder at the end. I wish the whole series had this same tone and artist/writer duo (with all due respect to everyone else who have been amazing too).
agreed man totally
turtlefan27
03-28-2013, 05:33 PM
So,my comic shop won't have #4 till end of next month..fail..:tsad:
***First of Two Latin Kings***
03-28-2013, 07:33 PM
So,my comic shop won't have #4 till end of next month..fail..:tsad:
I can send you one if you pay the price of the book, + shipping.
Donnie
03-28-2013, 07:55 PM
No offense, but why do we need a vol.2? This isn't mirage, the series can go on indefinitely as long as sales are up.
Agreed...I don't see the need for a Vol.2 as long as sales are up, personally.
Best part of the IDW series thus far. This would make an amazing film if you just tack on a brawl with Shredder at the end. I wish the whole series had this same tone and artist/writer duo (with all due respect to everyone else who have been amazing too).
Also agreed. Erik is without a doubt one of my favorite TMNT writers, his work speaks for itself: there's depth, there's personality, there's plenty of character development.
I also applaud Mateus on this one, as it was a joint writing project. This team really worked well together, I'd love to see them join forces again! (And for that matter, I'd also like a Burnham/Campbell team up! :))
I can see where people found the 2003 cartoon's Michelangelo annoying, I really can, but I think that the IDW series and the Nick cartoon have done a VERY good job with him, like the 2007 movie did.
Totally disagree about the 2k7 movie doing anything good at all with Michelangelo, however I'm on board with your other statement - that Nick and definitely IDW are doing a fantastic job with Mikey. In my opinion, he's hands down the most fleshed out Turtle in the series (IDW). He's compassionate, heroic, brave, relentless, funny while not being annoying, etc. basically everything I'd want in Michelangelo.
As far as the magna line, it was totally in character for Mike. I don't get why that would be a complaint. The whole "bursting" effect was done so nicely, too. Added some good dynamics to the page.
The past four months have seen so much world building; I've been loving it.
And I like that Miller got to stick around as an abused intellectual lackey for the Foot. He makes a great parallel for Baxter, who is employed by Krang under similar circumstances.
Yeah! Miller was interesting - and I kind of understood his point as an historian - I'm not saying I would have gone with Shredder, but you can see why he'd want the book to be saved, or the chance to explore it further.
I suppose my only question is... who was that Foot Soldier getting scarred over the eye in TMNT #2 if it wasn't Saki? Just a nobody?
Ha! Totally forgot about that. Maybe that was an earlier idea for Shredder that evolved into what we eventually received. So now, yeah, he's a nobody, haha.
I read this twice last night and can't help but feel a little disappointed.
I feel like you're being a little overly harsh in your review - of course you're entitled to your opinions, so don't take that the wrong way. However I believe the writing had a great deal of character development, most notably for Shredder, in whom the series was clearly written for. It establishes a layer to Saki that was wholly absent from Mirage. The Iron-Demon angle was a very far side plot, and in only 4 issues how can you really flesh that out? It was touched upon, and it served its purpose showing how Saki eventually defied it. It's just not that important who the utrom was, or why he came, especially how he came. What's important is that Shredder defied him.
Andrew NDB
03-29-2013, 10:45 AM
I took the scene as the Utrom getting kicked through the portal and THEN it exploding, not necessarily meaning the Utrom is dead.
And I suppose any unnamed Utrom could have taken on the grandiose identity of "Iron Demon", but I dunno. That seems wasted on a nobody. I'm still going with the presumption that it was Quanin at least until we're told otherwise.
EDIT: Also, I figured it was Quanin because he was shown with a tuning fork on the head of his robot body in the ongoing, a detail shared by the Iron Demon in Secret History.
Could have been Ch'rell...
Venom
03-29-2013, 01:06 PM
Could have been Ch'rell...
Except Quanin had previous been shown in the 'toon-inspired suit prior to his appearance in SHotFC.
FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
04-12-2013, 02:19 AM
I loved this entire series and I LOVE the artwork.
Infact I was stoked to see Santolouco's name on the upcoming TMNT ongoing... I would love to see him pick up in replace of Kuhn.
My one complaint is that the book felt rushed. I think they could have given it another issue or two. Overall I love this series and I hope I can still track the variant covers, which were too hard for my store to get.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-12-2013, 08:23 AM
Overall I love this series and I hope I can still track the variant covers, which were too hard for my store to get.
I have them...
Powder
04-12-2013, 03:50 PM
I have them...
Do you have to try and sell stuff to people in practically every post you make? God.
FlogginMcMurryZombiePizza
04-14-2013, 08:10 PM
Is he selling or bragging?
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-16-2013, 09:52 PM
Do you have to try and sell stuff to people in practically every post you make? God.
Do you have to make judgments of other members/people in every other post you make?
First off, my sales volume is pretty high these days and I'm not desperate to sell stuff like I used to be, but I bought these variants at $10 a piece and then decided I didn't really *need* them. So I'll gladly take a loss on them to help another fan own what I agreed with you to be one of the best TMNT comic book story arcs ever, now that I have my A covers.
Raven
04-17-2013, 03:32 PM
This series was epic, it really dug more into the relationship of hamato and Saki. Although I was hoping for a bit more between the two, it was really fun to see how everything unfolded.
The regular series is good, but this was great!
Vi11AiN6
04-20-2013, 08:42 AM
This was hands down the best TMNT story and artwork EVER! So much in fact that I am going to send my friend I grew up with the paperback, He's been out of comics for years and turtles. We're both dad's now and I keep telling him to pick up the IDW series because it's the perfect blend of all things turtles.
This was the best story and the artwork is leaps and bounds beyond anything anyone else has ever done. The action sequences were some of the best I've ever seen in comics, little things like Don's Bo staff bending when he was hitting someone, or the panel where he knocks the lens off a Foot Soldier.
Also April looked Gorgeous!!!! I've never seen anyone draw April so cute.
I just got my copy yesterday and now I'm going to read all 4 in order...
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-28-2013, 07:30 PM
I'm re-reading this series again tonight, and I noticed that Oroku Saki doesn't seem to have any recollection of Kitsune from his past life, even though he identified all the objects that were his to be his as a child. I had forgotten the part where he is approached by Kitsune in his new life for the first time, and was thinking he was simply making passes at Tang Shen because he's an unfaithful lech.
ctt4lfecw
04-29-2013, 09:09 PM
SHotFC has been my favorite so far!
TheCanadiandrome
04-29-2013, 10:54 PM
bring on the TPB!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.