Sonic vs Mario

[InsaneZane]

Well, obviously the one you like most is gonna be the one in your opinion capable of beating the other.

Well, Mario is just a d@mn plumber...
Sonic is really fast and has sharp, blades-like... whatever on his back.

I think Sonic would whup his @$$, and only rednecks would think otherwise.

[That Matt Guy]

Mario could just shoot those fireballs at Sonic and roast him.

[redsai4lex]

:x :x That is rediculous!!!!!!!!!

SONIC WOULD DODGE THOSE FIREBALLS!!!

Sonic would slice him to pieces of FAT FILLED ITALIAN PLUMBER MAGGOT FOOD and then stomp on his remains when he is done!!!!!!! :evilgrin:

NOTHING MARIO CAN DO COULD EVER HIT SONIC!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Kid Icarus]

NOTHING MARIO CAN DO COULD EVER HIT SONIC!!!!!!!!!!!!

besides selling more copies of his games ;)?

Just kidding, I dun wanna unlease a flame war or console war here... those get really bad.

I like mario games more than sonic games, but i have a high respect for sonic (my first system, that was mine alone, was a genesis with sonic 1).

I'm gonna say Mario. Hopefully SEGA lets Nintendo put Sonic in SSB:M2 or what ever the new SSB game is gonna be.

[That Matt Guy]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast.

[Reznorite420]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast....and collects rings, and gains the Chaos Emeralds to become Super Sonic/Hyper Sonic, can collect shields to boost his powers (fire, lightning, and bubble), and can smash ENTIRE walls (as opposed to Mario who can only crumble small sections of brick with his head), none of which Mario can do. So it goes without saying that Sonic owns Mario any day.

I take it you've never played anything past Sonic 1, maybe Sonic 2 at most, Matt :roll:

[Knuckles]

Ah, the good ol' days of Nintendo vs. Sega, (before the sacrilege of putting Sonic in Nintendo games). I was always for Nintendo during the glorious 16-bit wars, and I'm the type who generally picks a side in those type of things and stays there--viciously against the opposing side to boot. So I always hated Sega, and the only time nowadays I pick up a Sega controller is to play the Japanese version of X-Men vs. Street Fighter on Sega Saturn, (cuz it's more like the arcade, unlike the PS version). I don't play Nintendo really anymore though, having lost respect for it, and generally playing video games far less than I used to. To pick a side, I'd have to pick Mario, seeing as I'm way more inclined toward Nintendo than Sega despite my current feelings on Nintendo. I know the argument isn't Nintendo vs. Sega, but hey, these type of things always come down to who you like more anyway.

[Karpo_007]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast....and collects rings, and gains the Chaos Emeralds to become Super Sonic/Hyper Sonic, can collect shields to boost his powers (fire, lightning, and bubble), and can smash ENTIRE walls (as opposed to Mario who can only crumble small sections of brick with his head), none of which Mario can do. So it goes without saying that Sonic owns Mario any day.

I take it you've never played anything past Sonic 1, maybe Sonic 2 at most, Matt :roll:

I take it you haven't played anything past Super Mario Bros. And even in that game mario can do much more than smash bricks. The whole thread is stupid.... It's a matter of opinion, and I think Mario games are much better. But im not that closed minded as some people here, I do like Sonic games to.

[Deepflame]

Kinda worthless question. It's the developers that decide how powerful their heroes are gonna be. Most heroes armed with a lasergun (as an example) would beat Sonic.
Take it like this; woudn't Megaman or Samus Aran beat Sonic into a muddy pile on the ground?

Still Mario is way cooler than Sonic, besides having better games :)

[Karpo_007]

I agree, but matter of opinion really. But fact is they have sold much more Mario games. All the "real" mario games are great, not counting Mario Carts or Tennis' or the like. Haven't played sunshine yet tough, but I've heard it's ok game to.

[Reznorite420]

I take it you haven't played anything past Super Mario Bros.You're sadly mistaken.

The following argument will be based only on the first 3 Mario games and first 3 Sonic games (S&K is basically just a continuation of Sonic 3, so there's no need to include it)

SMB 1: Mario can smash bricks, collect coins, become invincible, stomp on enemies, and throw fireballs. Ya-friggin'-hoo :sleep: :sleep: :sleep:

SMB 2: All 4 Characters can run, pick up enemies and throw them, pick up items from the grass, collect Starmen when a certain number of cherries are collected. At least no 2 characters have the exact same abilities, so that's a plus. Still, in general, :sleep: :sleep:

SMB 3: OK, so Mario/Luigi has a more diverse selection of gaining powers: leaves, fireflowers, frog suits, hammer suits, tanooki (whatever the hell that means) suits, and all that jazz. Pretty impressive, but sill :| at best.

In general: Mario collects coins instead of rings, and he gets the points the moment he grabs one. While that's an immediate advantage over the Sonic games, sadly the only random factor about the coin grabbing is the choice of whether or not the player controlling Mario actually grabs the coins or not. Other than that, the coin-grabbing is pretty stote. The beauty of Sonic is that not only can the player choose when to grab the rings, but:

- Sonic's chances of survival depend on the rings :thumbsup: ; Mario always has the same chance of surviving regardless of the number of coins he has, they're just there for extra points :thumbsdo:

- Sonic can lose rings, thus creating another random and fun factor in the gameplay, and he can recover as many as he can before they all go away :thumbsup: ; Mario doesn't lose coins, so there's less fun in trying to survive in the level, they're only there to collect to gain points and lives, whoopee-frickin'-doo :thumbsdo:

I do have a life outside of this forum, so I'll stop there for now to allow the rest of you to have your say on what I've said (that's a tonguetie if I ever heard it :lol: )

BTW, I am taking Sonic's side NOT simply because I like Sega over Nintendo (each is good in its own way), but because I'm looking at the actual abilities of each character.

Oh, and Knuckles, I find it very ironic that you'd be pro-Mario since your username is the same of character that's in the Sonic the Hedgehog series :roll:

[Peanut]

Yeah but atleast the Mario Kart, Tennis, Golf, Party whatever are GOOD games. I'd go as far as calling both Mario Kart and Tennis GREAT games. Sonic has had some really really bad side games. Although I love Sonic's 1-3 and Knuckles. I also think it's safe to say that ALL of Mario's 3d "main" titles have been alot better than Sonic's 3d games. Super Mario 64 blows Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 out of the water 10 times over. As far as the fight goes...do I hear super star? Mario is invunerable and BAM Sonic is down. It takes Sonic too long to get the Chaos Emeralds. Oh man Rez. That has got to be the worst argument ever. Anyone who calls Super Mario Bros. a snooze fest has something wrong! My list would go as follows
Super Mario Bros.
:D
Super Mario Bros. 2
:|
Super Mario Bros. 3
:D
Sonic The Hedgehog
:)
Sonic The Hedgehog 2
:D
Sonic The Hedgehog 3
:)

[Reznorite420]

Mario's winning? That situation's on the same level as a Kindergartener beating the snot out of Arnold Schwartzenegger...IT AIN'T SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN!!!!

[Reznorite420]

As far as the fight goes...do I hear super star? Mario is invunerable and BAM Sonic is down. It takes Sonic too long to get the Chaos Emeralds.Ah, but Sonic doesn't HAVE to have the emeralds to be invincible; there ARE the boxes with the swirling stars that have the same effect as the Starman in Mario (yeah, I'm guessing you don't know EITHER game series very well considering you didn't even call it a Starman).

[Peanut]

I was actually trying to remember the name of the item but I couldn't. I know tons about both series. I just haven't played Sonic in a LONG time. I completely forgot about the Sonic power up. I do remember it now though. The stars spin around him and it plays the theme music. Yes I remember now. Thanks for reminding me.

[That Matt Guy]

Doesn't Sonic battle some fat ass Russian guy?

[Peanut]

Yeah Robotnic(sp?) or Dr.Eggman is a pretty bad enemy. He's ok but I prefer King "Bowser" Koopa and maybe even...Wart? The stupid guy who gets killed by eating turnips!

[Loolaa]

I love both Mario and Sonic, it was kind of hard chosing but I opted for Mario in the end because Mario 64 is one of my all time favourites.

...plus I've got a thing for his brother... :lol: :lol: :lol:

[Nturtle]

Yeah its Wart, there is a reason why Mario 2 is so diffrent from the others though...

There was a diffrent Mario 2 released in Japan that had more levels, after you beat 8-4 it went to level "A-1" and then all the way up to D-4, this game was much tougher than any other Mario game and the Japanese thought it would be too tough for Americans (no kidding), so they took another game called "Doki Doki Panic" and changed the characters of that game into Mario characters. They made Luigi the tall skinny character, which is wwhy Luigi looks diffrent than Mario in other games.

Japanese Mario 2 was eventually released in America in the SNES game collection "Mario All Stars" but it was instead called "The lost levels".

And, Mario is just better than Sonic, he is so much cooler, he would destroy him!

[Karpo_007]

Super mario is what started the whole genre basicly, Sure sonic did introduce some new ideas, like the high framerate, and generally the fast pace of the game. Still, it owns much to Super Mario Bros. As do all of the platformers. Sonic 2, 3& and knuckles do not have any big new ideas between them, But every Mario Game introduced something new.

And I do think that Mario tennis and Kart games are good, but they can be hardly be compared to Sonic games. And I agree, 3d Mario games are better than 3d sonic games, But they aren't bad games either.

It seems Mario is winning, not a suprise really, thats how it has always been. Sega has never been very succesfull with it's consoles or games, thats unfortunate really.

[Raven]

hell I think they would end up fighting each other than end up becoming lovers...................................but I would go for mario

[Karpo_007]

Well right now they are on the same side, both Inhabit the Gamecube.

[GK Punk]

You wanna know who would win???


SAMUS ARAN BAYBEE!! She can speed dash, and Blow sonic away with a missile. Then Mario would be her play toy for awhile. :evilgrin:

[Karpo_007]

Nah, as this video proves Mario has only one girl in his heart:

http://www.videogamedc.com/Pixeled_Parodies/Mack_Daddy_Mario_2/mack_daddy_mario_2.html

[Nothing offensive, very funny music video]

[Peanut]

Master Cheif would blow Samus away! Or they may become cyborg suit lovers!

[The 7th Turtle]

and what about Cpatain Falcon? or Fox Mccloud? and the one and only Link :D

[That Matt Guy]

Naw, the knight from Ghosts N' Goblins could take em all on.

[Peanut]

:lol: Was I the only one who couldn't beat that game? Maybe it's because I was so little but I always had trouble with that game.

[That Matt Guy]

:lol: I still can't beat it.

[The 7th Turtle]

never played this game... I don't know what is it really... :-?

[That Matt Guy]

It's about a knight that fights a bunch of zombies and ghosts. It's impossible because you get hit twice and then die.

[The 7th Turtle]

then it's pritty dumb... am i right?

[That Matt Guy]

No, it's a classic but it's hard as hell.

[Kid Icarus]

You wanna know who would win???


SAMUS ARAN BAYBEE!! She can speed dash, and Blow sonic away with a missile. Then Mario would be her play toy for awhile. :evilgrin:

Hell yes! I'd like to see Sonic or Mario take on Meta Ridley and live through it!

[Peanut]

I probably couldn't beat it either. It was mega tough. I played it some about a year ago and had trouble getting past the first level. Probably one of the hardest games I've ever played.

[GK Punk]

Man.. Gouls n Ghosts.. A long time ago on the MDb we declared that the most difficult game in HISTORY.. My quote about it:

"Damn that game, it kicks my ass everytime"

and Gwgtrunks: hehe Meta Ridley would kill them all. And if he didn't.. the Metroid Prime Sure as hell would :o

[That Matt Guy]

I have gotten to the end before, but it STARTS ALL OVER FROM LEVEL 1 before you get to the "real ending" :dead:

[Peanut]

Whatever happened to games like that? Games used to be mega hard. Now most games are pretty easy. Sometimes I wish they'd just get back to some basics on games instead of giving us crap like FFX where the most difficult part of the game is having to sit through the cut scenes.

[Stone Ill]

I've noticed that a lot of people are misunderstanding the question. It's bascially saying who would win in a fighter: Sonic or Mario, but a lot of you guys are just voting for what games you think are better.

Mario: An overweight plumber who can jump really high. :lol:

Sonic: A blue hedgehog who can run really fast. :)

[GK Punk]

I've noticed that a lot of people are misunderstanding the question. It's bascially saying who would win in a fighter: Sonic or Mario, but a lot of you guys are just voting for what games you think are better.

Mario: An overweight plumber who can jump really high. :lol:

Sonic: A blue hedgehog who can run really fast. :)

No, I understood, they'd begin to fight and Samus would bust out her freeze ray and speed boots and kill them all :o

[Dane E5R]

I got to this thread TOO LATE. Reznorite, I've got your back bud.. Although I thought this thread would be about which character would win in a fight. But anyway, if the two were to get into a fight, there's not a THING Mario could do to scratch Sonic. Sonic's speed is just a fraction of what he can do, and that alone is enough to stop Mario. Also, whoever said that Dr. Robotnik was a lame villain....Dude, the man is a freakin' GENIOUS! Bowser is a big lizard with castles that gets his jollies off kidnapping mushrooms.. Robotnik is a terrorist that has the ability to enslave living creatures and turn them into machines, as well as building them from scratch. Plus he has more important things to do then capture the same damn girl time after time (and why on earth is she so easy to capture? She's the best character in Mario 2!) Someone also brought up Super Sonic. 'Nuff said. All and all, no one in Mario's Universe could put a scratch on anyone in Sonic's. Not even Amy or Tails. Say what you guys like, and I'm sure I'll have something to say back.

[InsaneZane]

Put it this way..
Sonic Adventure or Mario Sunshine?

All Mario's got is fireballs and a watergun.
Theres no way he'd even catch Sonic the Hedgehog.
Sonic would do Marios job for him and clean the toilet with 'em.
f'n plumber, A PLUMBER! :dead:

[Mars-Chan]

SONIC SONIC SONIC!!! *plays her old Sonic game for Sega*

[Dane E5R]

Kinda worthless question. It's the developers that decide how powerful their heroes are gonna be. Most heroes armed with a lasergun (as an example) would beat Sonic.
Take it like this; woudn't Megaman or Samus Aran beat Sonic into a muddy pile on the ground?


Um..Are you guys aware that Sonic spends ALL HIS TIME fighting robots??

[The Stryker]

Samus isn't a robot

[Dane E5R]

Samus isn't a robot

Megaman is. Besides, I didn't mean to direct it toward Samus specifically, more toward people who think Sonic would be so easily defeated by people with lasers.

[Leo656]

Ash from Evil Dead: Fistful of Boomstick would impale Mario on his chainsaw, stick dynamite in his mouth and watch him blow up, then quip: "Aw, come ON! You're getting blood EVERYWHERE!" Then he'd just switch the chainsaw attachment with the Gaitlin Gun attachment and blow Sonic into little blue chunks of goo, while smugly musing "Now where'd I put that ammo? Ah, there it is... in your skull!"

Ash: Undisputed Champion of Video Games. Hail to the King, baby! :evilgrin:

[XERO]

As much as I love Mario, I'm gonna have to face facts...Sonic would win in a fight. He's is simply too fast, too sneaky and too witty. Plus, he's got skin tougher than leather. If he did a Homing Attack, he would probably split Mario in half!!

But Mario wouldn't go down without a fight. He would get his hands on Sonic at LEAST once since Sonic is obviously cocky, and when he does, he would just do one of his SSBM moves on him. That would stun Sonic for just a moment, and Mario would shoot him with a fireball and then whack him with his DK Hammer.

But of course, Sonic would be packin' Rings, and that would save his bacon. He would then literally run circles around Mario and would do a Spin Dash aimed at Mario's big stomach. That would DEFINATELY knock the wind out of the Plumpy Plumber.

Down but not out, Mario pulls out his trump card... a Starman. He would rush at full speed towards Sonic but would do his Triple Jump, catching Sonic off guard, and fall full force to the ground, bashing Sonic with his Butt Stomp. Thinking he'd won, he would do his Victory Pose, which gives Sonic just enough time to charge up energy for his Ancient Light Speed Attack.

"Reeeeadyyy..."

Before Mario can say "Momma Mia..."

Sonic would flash at light speed towards Mario, hitting him in the back of his head, knocking him out cold.

Sonic wins the battle, but not the war...

[Leo656]

:lol: You can't say c0cky? That's some bullsh|t right there! :lol:

[XERO]

Tell me about it, Leo! :x

That sucks...Uh bad choice of words! :P

[redsai4lex]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast.

What does Mario do????????? hes just FAT!!!!!!!!!
Sonic would slice him

[redsai4lex]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast....and collects rings, and gains the Chaos Emeralds to become Super Sonic/Hyper Sonic, can collect shields to boost his powers (fire, lightning, and bubble), and can smash ENTIRE walls (as opposed to Mario who can only crumble small sections of brick with his head), none of which Mario can do. So it goes without saying that Sonic owns Mario any day.

I take it you've never played anything past Sonic 1, maybe Sonic 2 at most, Matt :roll:

THIS IS A"""""FACT"""""

[redsai4lex]

Ah, the good ol' days of Nintendo vs. Sega, (before the sacrilege of putting Sonic in Nintendo games). I was always for Nintendo during the glorious 16-bit wars, and I'm the type who generally picks a side in those type of things and stays there--viciously against the opposing side to boot. So I always hated Sega, and the only time nowadays I pick up a Sega controller is to play the Japanese version of X-Men vs. Street Fighter on Sega Saturn, (cuz it's more like the arcade, unlike the PS version). I don't play Nintendo really anymore though, having lost respect for it, and generally playing video games far less than I used to. To pick a side, I'd have to pick Mario, seeing as I'm way more inclined toward Nintendo than Sega despite my current feelings on Nintendo. I know the argument isn't Nintendo vs. Sega, but hey, these type of things always come down to who you like more anyway.

How could you like Mario more when your name is "Knuckles"???????????

[redsai4lex]

As much as I love Mario, I'm gonna have to face facts...Sonic would win in a fight. He's is simply too fast, too sneaky and too witty. Plus, he's got skin tougher than leather. If he did a Homing Attack, he would probably split Mario in half!!

But Mario wouldn't go down without a fight. He would get his hands on Sonic at LEAST once since Sonic is obviously c**ky, and when he does, he would just do one of his SSBM moves on him. That would stun Sonic for just a moment, and Mario would shoot him with a fireball and then whack him with his DK Hammer.

But of course, Sonic would be packin' Rings, and that would save his bacon. He would then literally run circles around Mario and would do a Spin Dash aimed at Mario's big stomach. That would DEFINATELY knock the wind out of the Plumpy Plumber.

Down but not out, Mario pulls out his trump card... a Starman. He would rush at full speed towards Sonic but would do his Triple Jump, catching Sonic off guard, and fall full force to the ground, bashing Sonic with his Butt Stomp. Thinking he'd won, he would do his Victory Pose, which gives Sonic just enough time to charge up energy for his Ancient Light Speed Attack.

"Reeeeadyyy..."

Before Mario can say "Momma Mia..."

Sonic would flash at light speed towards Mario, hitting him in the back of his head, knocking him out cold.

Sonic wins the battle, but not the war...

Mario would NOT ever hit Sonic (not even once) he would go down without a fight!!!!!!!
Sonic wins FLAWLESS VICTORY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Remember................

That is rediculous!!!!!!!!!

SONIC WOULD DODGE THOSE FIREBALLS!!!

Sonic would slice him to pieces of FAT FILLED ITALIAN PLUMBER MAGGOT FOOD and then stomp on his remains when he is done!!!!!!!

NOTHING MARIO CAN DO COULD EVER HIT SONIC!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Karpo_007]

Sigh...

[The 7th Turtle]

What does Mario do????????? hes just FAT!!!!!!!!!

:lol: :lol:

i don't think any of them will win... because Wario will come and kill them both with his Bonzai! NAHA! :evilgrin:

[XERO]

As much as I love Mario, I'm gonna have to face facts...Sonic would win in a fight. He's is simply too fast, too sneaky and too witty. Plus, he's got skin tougher than leather. If he did a Homing Attack, he would probably split Mario in half!!

But Mario wouldn't go down without a fight. He would get his hands on Sonic at LEAST once since Sonic is obviously c**ky, and when he does, he would just do one of his SSBM moves on him. That would stun Sonic for just a moment, and Mario would shoot him with a fireball and then whack him with his DK Hammer.

But of course, Sonic would be packin' Rings, and that would save his bacon. He would then literally run circles around Mario and would do a Spin Dash aimed at Mario's big stomach. That would DEFINATELY knock the wind out of the Plumpy Plumber.

Down but not out, Mario pulls out his trump card... a Starman. He would rush at full speed towards Sonic but would do his Triple Jump, catching Sonic off guard, and fall full force to the ground, bashing Sonic with his Butt Stomp. Thinking he'd won, he would do his Victory Pose, which gives Sonic just enough time to charge up energy for his Ancient Light Speed Attack.

"Reeeeadyyy..."

Before Mario can say "Momma Mia..."

Sonic would flash at light speed towards Mario, hitting him in the back of his head, knocking him out cold.

Sonic wins the battle, but not the war...

Mario would NOT ever hit Sonic (not even once) he would go down without a fight!!!!!!!
Sonic wins FLAWLESS VICTORY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Remember................

That is rediculous!!!!!!!!!

SONIC WOULD DODGE THOSE FIREBALLS!!!

Sonic would slice him to pieces of FAT FILLED ITALIAN PLUMBER MAGGOT FOOD and then stomp on his remains when he is done!!!!!!!

NOTHING MARIO CAN DO COULD EVER HIT SONIC!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yeah, but like I said, Sonic is too c0cky. He would let his overconfidence get the best of him (at least for a couple of seconds) before he actually gets serious. That's when Mario would make his move.

It's like the classic story The Tortoise and the Hare, where the Hare(Sonic) thought he had the race won by long shot, so he decides to take a nap. But the hard-working, never-give-up attitude of the Tortoise(Mario) keeps racing. And, of course he wins because the Hare(Sonic) was sleeping, not realizing the Tortoise(Mario) was dedicated to finishing the race.

SILLY RABBIT!!!!!!!!!!

But, this is Sonic we're talking about, and Sonic does have a sense of dedication, and Mario is a dedicated guy. He is just too slow, but he is also smart and he uses the environment to his short advantage. But Sonic would still win. He has killer moves that Mario wishes he could do.

CASE CLOSED! 8)

[Karpo_007]

And Now, who would win, Mario or X-wing? X-wing of course It has energy shield and 2 lasers. Not to mention Proton missiles. Case closed.

[Stone Ill]

What does Sonic do? He just runs fast.

What does Mario do????????? hes just FAT!!!!!!!!!


:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

That's just classic..










But the funny thing is, if so many people think Sonic would win, why is Mario still winning in the polls!?

[Karpo_007]

Because it seems people are voting for better game, not who would win the fight.

[Raven]

mario would win....................I think

[Deepflame]

Heh, actually I think Mario has a good chance at beating Sonic if he uses sum tactics :). I can start by bringin up the fact that Mario can carry at least 21 items with him (Super Mario 3.) He could have 21 stars, or something like that.
To real point. Mario has the Tanooki outfit, which gives him the ability to transform into a statue which protects him from harm.
Sonic charges up one of his cheap shot spins and rushes towards Mario. The plumber then all of a sudden becomes a statue. Sonic is smacked flat against Mario, who immideatly change into Fire Mario and fries Sonic to a crisp. Or he can get real messy and arm himself with the hammerbrothers Hammer and shell. The idea of Mario smacking one of those hammers into Sonic's forehead is rather disturbing, though.

[Dane E5R]

Heh, actually I think Mario has a good chance at beating Sonic if he uses sum tactics :). I can start by bringin up the fact that Mario can carry at least 21 items with him (Super Mario 3.) He could have 21 stars, or something like that.
To real point. Mario has the Tanooki outfit, which gives him the ability to transform into a statue which protects him from harm.
Sonic charges up one of his cheap shot spins and rushes towards Mario. The plumber then all of a sudden becomes a statue. Sonic is smacked flat against Mario, who immideatly change into Fire Mario and fries Sonic to a crisp. Or he can get real messy and arm himself with the hammerbrothers Hammer and shell. The idea of Mario smacking one of those hammers into Sonic's forehead is rather disturbing, though.

I'm sorry, but no. The tanooki suit does not protect him from harm, it just makes the baddies think that he's a statue, so they ignore him. Not once have I seen them attack him while he's a statue and get knocked flat on their backs, then just walk past. If he turned to stone, Sonic would simply spin dash through him. He can hold whatever he wants with him, but nothing he has is going to surpass with the chaos emeralds do for Sonic. And those hammers would be ineffective, super or no.

[Karpo_007]

Ok, My turn now, Yes X.wing would beat Mario, But it would beat sonic to, As fas as sonic is, X-wing is faster, it can fly high, and use lasers, If Sonic is to fast to dodge them, X-wing could use proton torpedoes, wich do have option for heat seeking to. No matter how fast Sonic is, He is not faster than proton torpedoes and there for X-wing would win.

[JameO]

Ok, My turn now, Yes X.wing would beat Mario, But it would beat sonic to, As fas as sonic is, X-wing is faster, it can fly high, and use lasers, If Sonic is to fast to dodge them, X-wing could use proton torpedoes, wich do have option for heat seeking to. No matter how fast Sonic is, He is not faster than proton torpedoes and there for X-wing would win.

:lol: Go Karpo! Go Karpo! GO! :lol:

[Karpo_007]

If someone comes up with good enough theory how sonic would beat X-wing, I have a certain ball looking space craft in mind.

[Raven]

sonic could only beat the x-wing if I were the pilot!!!!!!!!!!!!

I MEAN COME ITS THE ONLY WAY!!!!!!!

[Karpo_007]

Yes, but lets say Wedge Antilles is piloting.

[Raven]

sonic would run so fast he would create a tornedo and the x-wing would get caught in than the tornedo would turn into george lucas and rewrite the hole plot of sonic vs x-wing til its complete crap!

[Karpo_007]

:lol: That could actually work!

[Raven]

now thinking of a way of how mario will be the x-wing thats a challenge


runs off to think of how mario will beat the x-wing

[Karpo_007]

There's always the possibility that the Ghos of Jar Jar bink would come to Wedges head saying "Whaat Are yoossa doing", and Wedge would just crash the ship in the state of shock.

[Raven]

:lol: hell if jar jar did that to me I do the same thing!

[Deepflame]

I'm sorry, but no. The tanooki suit does not protect him from harm, it just makes the baddies think that he's a statue, so they ignore him. Not once have I seen them attack him while he's a statue and get knocked flat on their backs, then just walk past. If he turned to stone, Sonic would simply spin dash through him. He can hold whatever he wants with him, but nothing he has is going to surpass with the chaos emeralds do for Sonic. And those hammers would be ineffective, super or no.

The Tanooki suit actually does protect him from harm (kinda :) ). I don't have my Allstars manual in english, but translated it says sumthin' like: "Mario cannot be harmed while he is in statue form" (though I realize this may vary.) The baddies ignores Mario since they understand attacking him would do nuthin :p
Yeh yeh, I'm stretching it a bit. But on the other hand you can stand right in front of a cannon ball (The big ones. The gun is mounted on an immovable tower, so it doesn't matter if they belive him to be a statue or not) without any effect. Powerful as he is, I do not belive Sonic could compete with one of those (opinion.)

[Deepflame]

Actually, I'm scrapping the Tanooki idea. Instead I say that since Mario is not a slow character, he should be able to avoid Sonic's attacks. Using the hammers (why would they not be effective? They finish of Bowser in 6 hits, and he is a very big, scaly and strong enemy) Mario would be a strong opponent for Sonic, possibly too strong.

Any further discussion about this scenario is pointless, as it bases upon my opinions such as: "Bowser can take a lot more damage than Sonic."
So no, I'm not right. But I'm not wrong either :)

Heh, on page one I say that it's a pointless discussion. Realized that the second time now :)

Don't remember who said it, but Megaman is not to be compared to some lousy robots made by allmighty coward Dr.Robotnik.

[Dane E5R]

Chaos Emeralds. Nothing Mario has has even a fraction of the power these things give Sonic. Tanooki, hammer, whatever. And the reason I say the hammers would be ineffective is the fact that they would not be able to hit Sonic. Why? Because Mario himself can dodge them. And anything Mario can dodge, Sonic can dodge 99x quicker. He can break the sound barrier, he can dodge a few hammers. That also goes for your "Mario would be able to dodge Sonic's attacks." If Mario can dodge sound, perhaps. I disagree that this a pointless discussion based on opinion, because everything I've said is based on facts.

[Raven]

man you guys know way to much about mario............

[majesty329]

I like Mario better but that's just my opinion.

[Stone Ill]

How can Mario turning into a statue protect himself from Sonic? SONIC CAN BREAK THROUGH WALLS AND BASICALLY ANY SOLID THING if you have notice. :P

[robot717]

Sonic would annihilate Mario.

First of all,Mario would never lay a finger on Sonic.He's way too fast.Sonic regularly dodges lasers and missles.Mario's fireballs wouldn't be an issue.His Raccoon suit may let him fly away,but that isn't going to help him in a fight.Kuribu's Shoe is powerful but way too slow.FLUDD,Mario's waterpack would be useless.The most it could do is piss Sonic off.

Sonic fights machines.Not only does he fight them but he rips them to shreds with his spines.If Sonic can do that to hunks of steel what's he going to do to a flesh and blood human like Mario? This is going to make GTA: Vice City look like Rainbow Brite.

Sonic also wins in the backup department.Every one of Sonic's companions is just as powerful as he.Some even moreso.What does Mario have? A princess who is too stupid to keep herself from being captured repeatedly.Toad a half human half mushroom guy who spends most of his time cowering in the corner while Mario does all the work.He might be useful if the gang wants to get stoned but as a warrior he's worthless.And of course Luigi.The guy got one game and he spent most of it screaming like a little girl.Sonic might choke when the smell of Luigi's freshly crapped pants reaches his nose,but that's about the extent of Luigi's talents.

[Wingnut]

Ok,ok as u can see by my sig and avy im a Sonic fan,but i'll give Mario the benefit of the doubt.....

In a strait fight no,albilties

Sonic would MURDER Mario

In a fight with abilities

Mario would come out on top by a hair (only because he has more suits and the fireball thing)