we wish you a turtle christmas vs christmas aliens

[mikey22]

which one do you prefer?

ugh this we wish you a turtles christmas was so pitiful "and a pizza with pepperoni" and these guys are teenage mutant jamican turtles

christmas aliens was sharp because mikey was the main chracater


i hope the nick toon will have a tmnt christmas episode :)

[mikey22]

the guy who did splinter in wish u a tmnt christmas??? was that the same guy who did the next mutation splinter? sounds like him.

[Jester]

1000x Christmas Aliens.

[BubblyShell22]

Christmas Aliens only because I don't remember the other one. Sounds cheesy though, so it's probably a good thing I don't remember it.

[LeotheLateBloomer]

Christmas Aliens! The only time I ever enjoyed We Wish You a Turtles Christmas was when I was a dumb 7 year old kid (It came out in 94, right?).

[krangsaneurysm]

yes Turtles Christmas was out in 94.. I'll have to go with Christmas Aliens also haha
Christmas Aliens! The only time I ever enjoyed We Wish You a Turtles Christmas was when I was a dumb 7 year old kid (It came out in 94, right?).

[The Fifth Turtle]

We wish you a t..u.rt......I can't even type it.

Christmas aliens.

[ABrown]

The Christmas Aliens was a decent episode. Not a great episode, but it was good.

[victory_angel]

The Christmas Aliens was a decent episode. Not a great episode, but it was good.

I haven't seen "we wish you a turtle christmas" and from what I've read about it, I'm glad I haven't.


So I'm going with "Christmas Alien's" by default

[NYShell]

Were those two things the only TMNT Christmas videos?

[DonatelloNinja82]

Christmas Aliens a million times over...

[Whatswiththeheadbands?]

Christmas aliens. Never seen we wish you a turtle Christmas

[Cipher]

"We Wish You a Turtles Christmas" by a country mile.

Witness the brilliance:

_Tke4_bn-TY

It hits all the right notes for a perfect Turtles story. The Turtles getting Splinter a framed pizza as a gift, musical numbers, partying with kids in the street -- all that essential Eastman and Laird stuff that came to define the sharpest elements of the series toward the end of Volume 1. In fact, if you asked me for my single most definitive version of the characters, "We Wish You a Turtles Christmas" might actually be it.

[MsMarvelDuckie]

Dear gawd Cipher I hope you're joking....

[The Fifth Turtle]

Dear gawd Cipher I hope you're joking....

Have you seen we wish you a turtles xmas? ....... of course he's serious.

[Powder]

Dear gawd Cipher I hope you're joking....

...Still having problems with that? :lol:

[pannoni1]

Are you kidding me? Turtle Christmas was once a choice on the Worst Ninja Turtles Creation poll and came in second only to the Out of their Shells concert (should have been the Out to Your Town sequel to that IMO). I never even knew it existed until two years ago.

Christmas Aliens is a classic being the basis of the Michelangelo Micro, and then adapted into the 4kids series. Plus it was written by Eastman & Laird so you can't go wrong there. Very heartwarming story that should be read and/or seen every year. Now if this poll involved Christmas aliens: Mirage vs. 4kids, I'd prefer 4kids since it has Usagi, Casey, the Purple Dragons, and Silver Sentry, though the Mirage has more direct discipline with the police and a more sneaky escape. Too bad the Fred Wolf show could have at least made Michelangelo Toys Around take place at Christmas, except that its one of the worst episodes of that series!

[ryukenden]

Didn't see Christmas Aliens but it sure sounds a million times better than that horrid special.

[Cipher]

Dear gawd Cipher I hope you're joking....
I don't joke.

[bigk4062]

Are you kidding me? Turtle Christmas was once a choice on the Worst Ninja Turtles Creation poll and came in second only to the Out of their Shells concert (should have been the Out to Your Town sequel to that IMO). I never even knew it existed until two years ago.


I can't believe i watched either... I still remember the rhinestones on their bandanas for the out of their shells concert... makes me sick:tsweatdr:

[The Turtle Terminator]

Are you kidding me? Turtle Christmas was once a choice on the Worst Ninja Turtles Creation poll and came in second only to the Out of their Shells concert (should have been the Out to Your Town sequel to that IMO). I never even knew it existed until two years ago.

Christmas Aliens is a classic being the basis of the Michelangelo Micro, and then adapted into the 4kids series. Plus it was written by Eastman & Laird so you can't go wrong there. Very heartwarming story that should be read and/or seen every year. Now if this poll involved Christmas aliens: Mirage vs. 4kids, I'd prefer 4kids since it has Usagi, Casey, the Purple Dragons, and Silver Sentry, though the Mirage has more direct discipline with the police and a more sneaky escape. Too bad the Fred Wolf show could have at least made Michelangelo Toys Around take place at Christmas, except that its one of the worst episodes of that series!

Agreed. Problems with a turtle Christmas:

Costumes- Do you EVERstop smiling?:tsad:

Place- The TMNT are out with kids in broad daylight with no disguises

Christmas Aliens for win!!!!

[MsMarvelDuckie]

I don't joke.

In that case, your life must be very dull and sad. Everyone needs to laugh and joke once in a while. :tsad::tcry: But seriously, that Christmas special is probably tops on my list of worst TMNT experiences ever. The only thing possibly as bad might be Next Mutation (and Coming Out of Their Shells- although I DO like some of the songs. Just not the costumes and most of the rest of it....)