View Full Version : WHY?! Explanations of why you defend or are repulsed by the designs
BubblyShell22
02-24-2014, 04:34 PM
I don't like the designs because they're horrendous. The lips look like they've had excessive plastic surgery, and I'm really not into the whole clothes thing either. If they have to have disguises, why not just use trench coats or something?
samxsteal
02-24-2014, 10:20 PM
I don't like the designs because they're horrendous. The lips look like they've had excessive plastic surgery, and I'm really not into the whole clothes thing either. If they have to have disguises, why not just use trench coats or something?
The lips and facial features are because there using Mocap and facial recognition to use for there characters. so they to there respective faces and morphed them into a mutated turtle face.
https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-frc1/t1/1966797_10152320275008013_405026875_n.jpghttps://scontent-a-iad.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash3/t1/q71/s720x720/1939658_10152320274888013_1208394168_n.jpghttps://scontent-b-iad.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/t1/1656364_10152320274788013_2110499588_n.jpghttps://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-frc1/t1/1920478_10152320274758013_1537512240_n.jpg
FoxBoxKid
02-24-2014, 10:33 PM
https://fbcdn-sphotos-c-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-frc1/t1/1966797_10152320275008013_405026875_n.jpghttps://scontent-a-iad.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash3/t1/q71/s720x720/1939658_10152320274888013_1208394168_n.jpghttps://scontent-b-iad.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn2/t1/1656364_10152320274788013_2110499588_n.jpghttps://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-frc1/t1/1920478_10152320274758013_1537512240_n.jpg
Uncanny. :lol:
samxsteal
02-24-2014, 10:57 PM
Uncanny. :lol:
its not perfect and i think it will look alot better and expressive during the film whihc i think is a good thing. One thing i really like about the Cartoons and the new one for sure is their expressions its pretty cool.
FoxBoxKid
02-24-2014, 11:40 PM
its not perfect and i think it will look alot better and expressive during the film whihc i think is a good thing. One thing i really like about the Cartoons and the new one for sure is their expressions its pretty cool.
I meant the resemblance is uncanny. :ohwell:
samxsteal
02-25-2014, 12:11 AM
I meant the resemblance is uncanny. :ohwell:
Yeah i was just saying it will be fantastic to see them talking and moving. Should be pretty cool
Candy Kappa
02-25-2014, 01:27 AM
oh, those faces. They look so laughable terrible.
TrickOrTreater
02-25-2014, 01:47 AM
oh, those faces. They look so laughable terrible.
Donnie's the only one that looks decent.
But then, of course, nerd glasses.
Candy Kappa
02-25-2014, 01:56 AM
Donnie got the best beak/snout of them all, at least from that angle we see his picture off. The philtrum isn't as deep compared to the others and his lips are a loot more subdued.
Leo is a not-so-close second, his lips are way too big, the philtrum is like a canyon and his eyes just looks too small and beady. The snout itself is fine, like a poor mans version of the OotS snout design.
Commenter 42
02-25-2014, 03:54 AM
oh, those faces. They look so laughable terrible.
Nightmare fuel.
BubblyShell22
02-25-2014, 08:27 AM
Sam, I know it's about mo-cap, but it still looks terrible. Ugh.
samxsteal
02-25-2014, 08:34 AM
Sam, I know it's about mo-cap, but it still looks terrible. Ugh.
That's fine you think so, i just disagree :ohwell:
I think once they're on screen moving and talking it will have a different effect then a still image, and it cool we're getting such expressive turtles in movie forum it one reason i like the cartoon's, and comics so much the turtles are all very expressive
Warhorse
02-25-2014, 11:57 PM
The lips and facial features are because there using Mocap and facial recognition to use for there characters. so they to there respective faces and morphed them into a mutated turtle face.
Eh, I don't know about that. I just thought they stuck lips on the Turtles because I have this feeling that one of them is going to be kissing a human, and if one Turtle has lips, then they all have to have lips.
samxsteal
02-26-2014, 12:03 AM
Eh, I don't know about that. I just thought they stuck lips on the Turtles because I have this feeling that one of them is going to be kissing a human, and if one Turtle has lips, then they all have to have lips.
I doubt this is the case. Facts are i remember then talking about ti in the past and mentioned that these turtles will be the most expressive turtles that we have ever gotten. and its pretty much confirmed that they're using faces as part of the MoCap of the movie.
http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/tD1kEjnPCoc/maxresdefault.jpg
The cameras near they faces are used to scan there faces to use in the creation of the turtles in CGI and to capture there expressions
Warhorse
02-26-2014, 12:07 AM
Hey, don't get mad at me. I'm just going with my gut instinct. If April or Karai end up kissing one of them, I won't be surprised.
samxsteal
02-26-2014, 12:15 AM
Hey, don't get mad at me. I'm just going with my gut instinct. If April or Karai end up kissing one of them, I won't be surprised.
Oh im not mad. ^_^ im an easy going guy dont really get mad frustrated yes(which you haven't don either) But not mad lol. Its possible i think April will kiss a turtle But maybe Karai if the stick with the Leo Karai Arc, but it may be to early, seeing as no one has ever officially made them a couple, and nick is taking it slow. Though im on of those fans who ship couples,
https://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lznq37Yf791qliiryo2_250.gif(deal with it)been trying a reason to use this lol
and even one of the parings KArai and leo, or April and Don would send fans and shippers through the roof. But i doubt they will in this movie, but i could be wrong wouldn't bother me either way lol
Warhorse
02-26-2014, 01:03 AM
Oh im not mad. ^_^ im an easy going guy dont really get mad frustrated yes(which you haven't don either) But not mad lol. Its possible i think April will kiss a turtle But maybe Karai if the stick with the Leo Karai Arc, but it may be to early, seeing as no one has ever officially made them a couple, and nick is taking it slow. Though im on of those fans who ship couples,
https://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lznq37Yf791qliiryo2_250.gif(deal with it)been trying a reason to use this lol
and even one of the parings KArai and leo, or April and Don would send fans and shippers through the roof. But i doubt they will in this movie, but i could be wrong wouldn't bother me either way lol
Heh, I wonder if Urma is going to be in this. Back in the 80's, people shipped her and Don quite a bit.
samxsteal
02-26-2014, 02:27 PM
Heh, I wonder if Urma is going to be in this. Back in the 80's, people shipped her and Don quite a bit.
well there are rumor out there, But they're just rumors at this point.
http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMzA5NjEyOTMwOF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNjEzMjYzNA@@._ V1_SY44_CR0,0,32,44_.jpgAbby Elliott ... Irma Langinstein (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2212031/?ref_=tt_cl_t7)
Warhorse
02-26-2014, 08:39 PM
well there are rumor out there, But they're just rumors at this point.
http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMzA5NjEyOTMwOF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNjEzMjYzNA@@._ V1_SY44_CR0,0,32,44_.jpgAbby Elliott ... Irma Langinstein (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2212031/?ref_=tt_cl_t7)
Eh, they already picked one. I was hoping they'd go with Kat Dennings, I think she'd make a great Irma.
samxsteal
02-26-2014, 10:19 PM
Eh, they already picked one. I was hoping they'd go with Kat Dennings, I think she'd make a great Irma.
she would be great but Abby is really funny as well
SwiftNinjaFox
02-28-2014, 09:19 AM
One thing I've not seen mentioned that's got me curious...
I'm assuming Splinter is going to be 4 feet tall, yet the turtles are going to be apparently 6 feet tall or more (they look ENORMOUS from the suits, particularly based off the Raph in(not so)cognito trenchcoat next to Megan Fox.
Definitely going to be different seeing that size difference after getting used to a taller Splinter here recently.
And will Splinter be doing some ninja fighting? Are we going to have a Yoda-esque Splinter scene? :D
turtlefanforever
02-28-2014, 01:15 PM
Eh, they already picked one. I was hoping they'd go with Kat Dennings, I think she'd make a great Irma.
But she would take the hot spotlight away from Megan so they would never do it. I think she's way hotter than Megan and more relevant too. She's been acting since way back in the day with "the scream team" I believe, it's a Disney channel movie. She's a good actor and two broke girls is popular.
liugeaux
02-28-2014, 02:01 PM
I love Kat Dennings, but after Thor 2, I'm kinda done with her acting. That movie needed 33% less Kat.
As for the topic at hand, I think i would be more ok with these new designs if the turtles weren't wearing clothes. If you want to make the turtles "badass" which they are clearly trying to do, don't put them in silly costumes. As it stands though, that movie is going to have to be phenomenal to make up for the god-awful character designs.
I want so badly to be excited about this movie, My life is so full of TMNT stuff seeing how misguided this movie has been makes me worried about the future of the franchise.
The 2008 TMNT wasn't the greatest movie ever, but at least it looked amazing and the Turtle designs were on point and wasn't embarrassing. This has the potential to be as bad or worse than disasters like Batman and Robin or Prince of Persia.
Lou 500
02-28-2014, 03:08 PM
I don't mind them wearing clothes; it gives slightly more real feel to them. Considering they're partly human wearing clothes like humans would only feel natural to them, even if they don't have anything hanging out.
samxsteal
02-28-2014, 03:09 PM
One thing I've not seen mentioned that's got me curious...
I'm assuming Splinter is going to be 4 feet tall, yet the turtles are going to be apparently 6 feet tall or more (they look ENORMOUS from the suits, particularly based off the Raph in(not so)cognito trenchcoat next to Megan Fox.
Definitely going to be different seeing that size difference after getting used to a taller Splinter here recently.
And will Splinter be doing some ninja fighting? Are we going to have a Yoda-esque Splinter scene? :Dsplinter Is the shorter version. As for Raph, they could always adjust height in post. As for fight i believe splinter have a stunt double there's a lot of great martial artists working on this movie. and it would definitely rock seeing some yoda style ass kicking.
But she would take the hot spotlight away from Megan so they would never do it. I think she's way hotter than Megan and more relevant too. She's been acting since way back in the day with "the scream team" I believe, it's a Disney channel movie. She's a good actor and two broke girls is popular.
I dont think thats the issue have you seen Abby she no ugly duckling.
I love Kat Dennings, but after Thor 2, I'm kinda done with her acting. That movie needed 33% less Kat.
As for the topic at hand, I think i would be more ok with these new designs if the turtles weren't wearing clothes. If you want to make the turtles "badass" which they are clearly trying to do, don't put them in silly costumes. As it stands though, that movie is going to have to be phenomenal to make up for the god-awful character designs.
I want so badly to be excited about this movie, My life is so full of TMNT stuff seeing how misguided this movie has been makes me worried about the future of the franchise.
The 2008 TMNT wasn't the greatest movie ever, but at least it looked amazing and the Turtle designs were on point and wasn't embarrassing. This has the potential to be as bad or worse than disasters like Batman and Robin or Prince of Persia.
Awe come on she wasn't even in it that much and it was funny with her intern lol.
AS for the designs i think they will seem so much more subtle to the eyes yes figure seem more O_O in your face as to the Toy marketing photos but they are for just about every toy line and they dont always accurately show how the character will look. I think seeing them on screen will show what to except as apposed to still photos wich will give a glimpse is not always the best way to judge. I for one like the designs and i understand why those who dont, dont. And i hope your opinions wil change once the trailer comes out.
Though it think that Before the trailer comes out we can expects a magazine exclusive as well as maybe a presents at the Teen choice seeing as tmnt is in the running for multiple awards. It be kind of Ironic to have a trailer telling use to catch the teaser during Winter soldier lol
samxsteal
02-28-2014, 03:35 PM
I don't mind them wearing clothes; it gives slightly more real feel to them. Considering they're partly human wearing clothes like humans would only feel natural to them, even if they don't have anything hanging out.
Have you ever seen a turtle Poo ITS pretty freaky i thought my friend turtle was dieing. But any way I totally agree with this and its not like we haven't sen turtles in clothing as For the ever Raging people and them going on about Subtlety at which level does it then become ok. Some people Loath this new look but are ok with something that's just as out there if not more so. It makes no since. We get You want the classic Belts, bands, head band, and weapons, but this really isn't a huge stretch.
This is my personal Opinion i understand some people don't agree then fine don't try convincing me other wise or explain why you hate it we've all heard it Umtingth times
turtlefanforever
02-28-2014, 05:45 PM
I love Kat Dennings, but after Thor 2, I'm kinda done with her acting. That movie needed 33% less Kat.
As for the topic at hand, I think i would be more ok with these new designs if the turtles weren't wearing clothes. If you want to make the turtles "badass" which they are clearly trying to do, don't put them in silly costumes. As it stands though, that movie is going to have to be phenomenal to make up for the god-awful character designs.
I want so badly to be excited about this movie, My life is so full of TMNT stuff seeing how misguided this movie has been makes me worried about the future of the franchise.
The 2008 TMNT wasn't the greatest movie ever, but at least it looked amazing and the Turtle designs were on point and wasn't embarrassing. This has the potential to be as bad or worse than disasters like Batman and Robin or Prince of Persia.
Everyone has their bad movies. But all in all she's a good actor as very attractive. And that movie as a whole wasn't terrible. Also I agree with everything else but have not seen prince of Persia reviews made it not with my time and I actually liked batman and robin believe it or not. Hated the dark night rises though.
I dont think thats the issue have you seen Abby she no ugly duckling.
Yeah but she's no Kat dennings
Donatello19
02-28-2014, 07:17 PM
Here are my thoughts:
Across all the turtles, I hat the lips and nostrils. They look stupid and stick out like a sore thumb.
Leonardo: I like his chest/torso armor, but that's about it...other than that he's just O.K..
Donatello: I hate all the cyber gear. I hate the nerd glasses and goggles. I hate how they attempted to mix together Japanese clothing with tech armor...it looks ridiculous. And he looks like he has a computer glued to his shell...like, what? Is he going to be walking around like that the whole time?
Michelangelo: To be honest, he's my favorite of the bunch. I like the necklace and sunglasses, it fits his character. The pants don't bother me, plus they add some more color..what I really hate is his sneakers....like, really?
Raphael: I can't decide if I hate him or Don more...Raph just looks stupid, again. The sunglasses...why? When are they ever out in sunlight? They don't have ears to hold them up..? The bandanna thing annoys me the most, I always hated that NM's style of it going all the way over the head, it just looks weird to me. The loin cloth is the only part of it that doesn't really annoy me.
Splinter: From what we've seen, he looks like Chuck E. Cheese. I don't like him short or gray, but that's just a personal preference.
Shredder's costume looks pretty good from that blurry picture though, I've gotta say. The cape looks epic.
I can get past the designs if the movie itself is good..
samxsteal
02-28-2014, 10:12 PM
Here are my thoughts:First i want to say i gree with alot of what you have said ^_^ , but wanted to throw in my thoughts as well
Across all the turtles, I hat the lips and nostrils. They look stupid and stick out like a sore thumb.
I'm not so upset about noses an lips, I think of it as a turtle transforming into a human and humans have noses and lips. And while it doesn't really matter, Lips are important in order to sound out words and form Syllable. That being said i know other versions didn't have lips But there using motion capture to well capture their faces. While back some one said that these turtles will be "the most expressive" they have ever been that's just me. As for the nostrils meh turtles tend to have prominent nostrils.
Leonardo: I like his chest/torso armor, but that's about it...other than that he's just O.K..
I love this Samurai, Japanese theme i just do, It may not be "ninja" but its not like Leonardo hasn't ever spouted Samurai esque thing in the past.
Donatello: I hate all the cyber gear. I hate the nerd glasses and goggles. I hate how they attempted to mix together Japanese clothing with tech armor...it looks ridiculous. And he looks like he has a computer glued to his shell...like, what? Is he going to be walking around like that the whole time?Again this is preference but from This photo http://i.imgur.com/dODYMj5.jpgI think its just a rig he has harnessed to his back. And again i think it cool he kept some Japanese aspects, and tech is just Don. As for the goggle nothing I haven't seen done to don before in the past. as for the glasses this was as posted and artwork for toy which are not always accurate, and i think it might just be use in portions of the movie and not wear them fully.
Michelangelo: To be honest, he's my favorite of the bunch. I like the necklace and sunglasses, it fits his character. The pants don't bother me, plus they add some more color..what I really hate is his sneakers....like, really?
I love Mikeys get up to me it screams MIkey. the show i see as mikey just goofing off. and all of them have foot wear so why not give him tennies lol.
Raphael: I can't decide if I hate him or Don more...Raph just looks stupid, again. The sunglasses...why? When are they ever out in sunlight? They don't have ears to hold them up..? The bandanna thing annoys me the most, I always hated that NM's style of it going all the way over the head, it just looks weird to me. The loin cloth is the only part of it that doesn't really annoy me.Again the glasses i think are an aspect of the art for the toy line, and not an aspect of the movie itself. Now am i saying he wont have sun glasses some time in the movie no it totally possible
Splinter: From what we've seen, he looks like Chuck E. Cheese. I don't like him short or gray, but that's just a personal preference. I think that it going to look similar to 2007 BTS or th 2k3 style splinter. The only look we have is a lego figure that not really to scale and i think it will look much better on screen.
Shredder's costume looks pretty good from that blurry picture though, I've gotta say. The cape looks epic.I love this i think it look intimidating and just awesome i don't get the hate it look like a supe'd up version of the Nick shredder
I can get past the designs if the movie itself is good..
Agreed and how good a movie is subjective and i understand there are those who will just not like the movie. But im still excited and expect to be fully entertained. and again these are just my opinions and there are those who will disagree. But you have some good points ^_^
turtlefanforever
03-01-2014, 12:31 AM
That giraffe neck Leo is just too much!! :tlol::tlol:
Lou 500
03-06-2014, 02:08 PM
They have little black voids where eyes should be.
TrickOrTreater
03-06-2014, 02:09 PM
They have little black voids where eyes should be.
Michael Bay sucked their souls out.
BubblyShell22
03-06-2014, 03:59 PM
Ugh, I hate those cake toppers, too. Give me the Nick Turtles any day for my b-day cake. They look like apes to me and not turtles in the face. Yuck.
TurtleTitan97
03-06-2014, 04:20 PM
I am really displeased over how these designs turned out, what with the excessive clothing they're wearing (Seriously, what's wrong with the traditional look? It's worked for 30 years.) , and those ugly turtle lips, these just aren't doing it for me.
And I feel like Mikey came out the worst out of the four. Seriously, he just looks so ugly, I can barely look at him. Leo looks the best, but that's not saying much.
Michelangelo
03-06-2014, 06:38 PM
It's been a little while now since the photos were leaked.
I'm liking the designs even more now. The images of the toys has also helped in getting an idea of what to expect in the way of the design in the movie. They just look interesting atm. Until the preview and of course the film I can only imagine them walking and talking etc. But for now my idea of the turtles based on these new looks is for awesomeness. Cowabunga!!!
TrickOrTreater
03-06-2014, 07:02 PM
I am really displeased over how these designs turned out, what with the excessive clothing they're wearing (Seriously, what's wrong with the traditional look? It's worked for 30 years.) , and those ugly turtle lips, these just aren't doing it for me.
And I feel like Mikey came out the worst out of the four. Seriously, he just looks so ugly, I can barely look at him. Leo looks the best, but that's not saying much.
His and Raph's faces are appalling.
Just hideous.
And personally, I think Donnie's face looks the "best." With Leo a close second(stupid lips). But then they go and give Donnie those idiotic stereotypical nerd glasses and ruin it.
samxsteal
03-07-2014, 03:42 PM
It's been a little while now since the photos were leaked.
I'm liking the designs even more now. The images of the toys has also helped in getting an idea of what to expect in the way of the design in the movie. They just look interesting atm. Until the preview and of course the film I can only imagine them walking and talking etc. But for now my idea of the turtles based on these new looks is for awesomeness. Cowabunga!!!
I agree. I can't wait to see them in action i think it will be great.
BubblyShell22
03-07-2014, 05:29 PM
I just showed my mom those cake toppers, and even she thinks the designs suck. She agreed with me that they look like apes, are too bulky, and that the clothes are unnecessary.
Candy Kappa
03-07-2014, 05:31 PM
I just noticed Don have the "nerd" glasses on that topper figure.
Ugh...
Technogeek29
03-07-2014, 10:53 PM
Showed my friend and his girl friend, they didn't hate the designs but weren't fans of it personally. What killed me is that his daughter was watching a re-run of 2k12 walked over to see and asked who were the green Donkey Kongs. Lol I laughed so hard at that.
turtlefanforever
03-08-2014, 09:46 AM
Showed my friend and his girl friend, they didn't hate the designs but weren't fans of it personally. What killed me is that his daughter was watching a re-run of 2k12 walked over to see and asked who were the green Donkey Kongs. Lol I laughed so hard at that.
Should have said they're the monsters coming to take all that's good in the world.
Commenter 42
03-08-2014, 06:32 PM
Should have said they're the monsters coming to take all that's good in the world.
I still can't understand the thinking that went into these "things".
It's like logic went out the window. Reminds me of the time Homer designed his own car.
http://www.themagazine.ca/cms/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/homerfront1.jpg
billbot85
03-09-2014, 09:30 PM
I guess I'm not a fan of the turtle designs because they seem to be too bulky/caveman like to me, and I don't like the hunched style either. The whole design just kinda makes them look primitive.
Leo656
03-10-2014, 07:51 AM
I still can't understand the thinking that went into these "things".
It's like logic went out the window. Reminds me of the time Homer designed his own car.
http://www.themagazine.ca/cms/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/homerfront1.jpg
:lol: Good form, old sport. Spot-on observation.
I'm alright with the physiques and even the faces. Not a fan of "shell abs" but I think it won't look as bad in motion. Those clothes, though... UGH...
People can't just keep using "Why Not?" to justify it. I'll see you your "Why Not?" and double down with "Why Bother?" "Why bother?" needs no justification, as 30 years of the franchise proves people will gladly accept the Same Old Thang as far as how the Turtles look. Meanwhile, the fact the audience is even 50/50 on these outfits and designs means they messed it up.
Don't... divide... your audience. Period. "Why NOT change it?" I say, "Why Risk It?"
Raptor86
03-11-2014, 04:15 AM
I hope the movie has a solid background to explain their "clothing" style.
Their faces don't bother me too much, they have some human facial feature (for people familiar with the TMNT RPG they have something between no and partial human look). It's okay, as they are half human-half turtles (following the old cartoon idea that ooze mutates you in the last living being you have touched).
I think the problem is theit bulkyness. How are they suppose to do ninja tricks, to be stealth? They look 1.90 mt tall and 100kg heavy!!!
Maybe the Don glasses will be on his nose just when he has to repair or build his "toys" to help him see the tiny details...
BubblyShell22
03-11-2014, 07:48 AM
I agree with Leo here. Why change something that's worked for 30 years? The Turtles in history have never needed clothes, and if they went out in disguise, they used trench coats. It seems to me that they changed it just because they figured it would look cool and probably just to be different. There's nothing wrong with just having the Turtles as they are with no other gimmicks.
samxsteal
03-11-2014, 01:13 PM
I hope the movie has a solid background to explain their "clothing" style.
Their faces don't bother me too much, they have some human facial feature (for people familiar with the TMNT RPG they have something between no and partial human look). It's okay, as they are half human-half turtles (following the old cartoon idea that ooze mutates you in the last living being you have touched).
I think the problem is theit bulkyness. How are they suppose to do ninja tricks, to be stealth? They look 1.90 mt tall and 100kg heavy!!!
Maybe the Don glasses will be on his nose just when he has to repair or build his "toys" to help him see the tiny details...I agree I dont get people got so hung up on there looks like i think it looks great as for who they will movie i dont think there size is going to really matter much because of the MoCap. and im pretty sure Dons not going to wear the glasses the whole time.
I agree with Leo here. Why change something that's worked for 30 years? The Turtles in history have never needed clothes, and if they went out in disguise, they used trench coats. It seems to me that they changed it just because they figured it would look cool and probably just to be different. There's nothing wrong with just having the Turtles as they are with no other gimmicks.
What about batman??? He had basically the same look for longer then 30 years and Just recently changed to an armored look.
http://cdn.screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/batman-infographic.jpg
Leo656
03-11-2014, 01:33 PM
Not really. Similarities have remained, but Batman's outfit has changed a lot over the years, even in the beginning. Within the very first year, the ears got shorter, the eyes bigger, the colors brighter, the gloves longer, and that was just the start. The changes have been more or less subtle as time has passed, but the costume always changed. Him having a variety of outfits has always fit his character because it's exactly the kind of thing he would do.
And one transition to the next with Batman was never, ever as big a jump as going from "regular" TMNT to the look from the new movie. It's not like he had the same exact look for 30 years and then suddenly it was a ton different. The ONE time they did that, with Azrael, the entire point was to show how stupid that kind of overly-complicated design really is!
And Batman was first referenced to have armor in his suit almost 30 years ago. First just behind the Bat symbol, then kevlar inside the cape, and it simply grew out from there. Three decades isn't at all recent, it's almost half the character's existence at this point. Sowwy.
Not every "rule" applies to all situations, guy. Batman can have a closet full of different outfits and nobody complains because he's always done that. Some people hate the Turtles designs strictly because it's really far from the norm and there really is no VALID reason for it.
And I know I'm not the first one to mention this, but the only thing the constant, never-ending straw-grasping in defense of the movie designs is doing, is keeping these debates and disagreements of taste going in circles forever. You've made your point. As best I can tell, you like absolutely everything, except if it's already been done. If it's new and fresh, you're down with it, if it's traditional and "boring", you're out. Fine. You've spoken on it. It should be obvious by now that a good chunk of folks are perfectly happy not sharing your "Everything is Awesome" POV, and believe it or not, we're not all miserable dicks.
Some of the ones you've labeled as such, in fact, are really pretty mellow and upbeat people and I know that for a fact because I've known them a lot longer than you have. BUT - get ready - we/they reserve the right to say something looks like sh*t if we think it looks like sh*t, and we don't need to be "Enlightened", especially not when so many of your arguments/defenses are as flimsy as a cotton candy tampon.
You love everything and are sad that others don't. Well, that's life, man, sorry. These circles are making me goddamn dizzy.
samxsteal
03-11-2014, 02:45 PM
Not really. Similarities have remained, but Batman's outfit has changed a lot over the years, even in the beginning. Within the very first year, the ears got shorter, the eyes bigger, the colors brighter, the gloves longer, and that was just the start. The changes have been more or less subtle as time has passed, but the costume always changed. Him having a variety of outfits has always fit his character because it's exactly the kind of thing he would do.But yet there hasn't been a fully armored Bat SUIT that he wears most of the time Up until recently. Changing of Symbols size and shape doesn't count. That's not what i'm saying.
And one transition to the next with Batman was never, ever as big a jump as going from "regular" TMNT to the look from the new movie. It's not like he had the same exact look for 30 years and then suddenly it was a ton different. The ONE time they did that, with Azrael, the entire point was to show how stupid that kind of overly-complicated design really is!
There really not that extreme Leo has Total of 4 added things replacing a total of three thing taken way He has chest and shoulder armor added, gauntlets, thigh and skirt armor (meant for protecting his thighs and vital body parts not just his groin) and Sandals four things thats it thats not extreme. There a literally tons of different redesign similar to the ones used and they are Deemed Awesome and Cool and Faithful While not being too extreme.
http://www.tencentticker.com/projectrooftop/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Leonardo.jpg
Now this is extreme Still freaking awesome but extreme
http://www.tencentticker.com/projectrooftop/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Donatello.jpg
And Batman was first referenced to have armor in his suit almost 30 years ago. First just behind the Bat symbol, then kevlar inside the cape, and it simply grew out from there. Three decades isn't at all recent, it's almost half the character's existence at this point. Sowwy.but his fully Armored look was not until recently
And please stop talking to my like that, IM not a freaking child:trolleye:
And I know I'm not the first one to mention this, but the only thing the constant, never-ending straw-grasping in defense of the movie designs is doing, is keeping these debates and disagreements of taste going in circles forever. You've made your point. As best I can tell, you like absolutely everything, except if it's already been done. If it's new and fresh, you're down with it, if it's traditional and "boring", you're out. Fine. You've spoken on it. It should be obvious by now that a good chunk of folks are perfectly happy not sharing your "Everything is Awesome" POV, and believe it or not, we're not all miserable dicks.I dont think everything is awesome just feel being optimistic and not being cynical is better for health and having a better outlook on life. Yeah the world sucks it does doesn't mean i have to constantly focus on all the negative of life and th world we live in does it. No i dont and i wont. DO i hate the previous versions? No. If they had more simpler designs would i be upset? No. Would other people be upset? yes, Cuz people Love to complain to complain.
And Could have definitely fool me on a bunch of the users on these boards. Thank god there a many the out weight those people that i can talk freely with, with out being Ganged up on.
Some of the ones you've labeled as such, in fact, are really pretty mellow and upbeat people and I know that for a fact because I've known them a lot longer than you have. BUT - get ready - we/they reserve the right to say something looks like sh*t if we think it looks like sh*t, and we don't need to be "Enlightened", especially not when so many of your arguments/defenses are as flimsy as a cotton candy tampon.Sorry Im glade you can get to know and hang out with some people that as far as i have seen have been nothing but grating, rude, hostile, "stereotypical Cyber bullies". They can Hold those right but when they start making fun of me and my reason for liking things then it becomes a problem. I'm not saying you cant dislike things, I just try to support why people should give them a chance.
ANd if you guys really feel so strongly against the movie Then Why are you even waisting time on these Board talking about them?? Move on let those who do enjoy what there seeing do just that with out the flagrant attacks on why they shouldn't enjoy what they've seen.
Sumac
03-11-2014, 03:10 PM
Change for the sake of change could work, when it's good. Sometimes it allows to flex creative muscle and break old boundaries. Sometimes it's even necessary thing to do.
But in case of new movie...it was not a good change.
Leo656
03-11-2014, 03:20 PM
sam:
Well, again, it's not really Us. No offense, but it's really more You. You're a good guy, and anyone can see you mean well, but literally every time anyone doesn't think something's great, you give hundreds of counter-points to try and Convert them, and a bunch of those points aren't great, at all. Yes, being positive is great. But not everything IS great, I'm sorry. Some things really suck. Sometimes, lots of people agree they suck, and they don't like, need, or want to be preached at.
You're not the only one doing it, for sure. But the "Negatives" are simply stating a case for their POV, not trying to convert people. You guys are more or less saying, there's something wrong with Us for not liking what you like. I'm sorry, that IS what you're doing, even if you're not trying to. Labeling people "bullies" or "close-minded" because they present arguments why they don't like something isn't "being positive", it's kind of its own form of bullying.
I don't have the privilege to know or hang with anyone here in "real life" - a few on FB - but I've been around here long enough to know how most of them are. And frankly, I'm surprised to see some of them getting so heated towards you. They generally are not like that to people. In speaking with them, and I'm not going to name names, it's apparently a combination of, you unrelentingly assault people with your overwhelming positivity long after it's been confirmed that you disagree and should just let bygones be bygones, and secondly, that you spend a lot of time putting together arguments or defenses that are just weak, and in turn, it keeps pointless arguing going on and on and on.
I will not defend the way people here have talked to you. I think people overreact a lot to things. But I have NEVER seen certain people here get so bent before, and a lot of it is that you just don't know when to Let It Go or Agree To Disagree. Me and Trick, for example, keep repeating the same stupid argument points too, because we keep being put in positions where we have to for some reason defend our honest opinions. That isn't fair, man.
We're glad you think/hope the movie and the Turtle designs are great. Nobody begrudges you that. But see how it didn't feel nice at all when I basically generalized you as some kind of simpleton who loves everything? It bothered you, right? Because you're NOT that, right? Well, me and a bunch of folks aren't simply "old-fashioned" or "close-minded" or a bunch of grouches just because we don't share the enthusiasm. We just aren't happy with our customer service so far. The soup is cold and the entree is taking f*cking forever to get here, and the decor on the walls is tacky. We have every right to complain.
When I affirm, or re-affirm an opinion, it's either simply to state it, or explain it. I don't think, for one second, I'm going to convince one person of f*cking anything at all. You seem to think you might, but you won't. People aren't wired that way. You ARE trying to convince people to share your POV, and instead, they're getting cranky. Work a little bit on NOT jumping in with "This is awesome" whenever anyone says something isn't their cup of tea, and I think people will mellow. I get that you're trying to play devil's advocate, it's that you are OVER-doing it, and again, no offense, your arguments often contain some pretty big logical gaps.
I ain't mad at ya, guy, I'll rap with you all day long about any f*ckin' thang. I'm a person who can entirely disagree with someone but not take it personal. And see, I think you're missing that some people LIKE to disagree with each other, and that it's NOT a hostile thing, necessarily, and that in turn is EXACTLY why we're here debating about the movie and stuff. Not because we hate each other and think other POVs are stupid, it's that it's just fun to vent to each other and even give each other sh*t.
One thing that bothers me a little, however... I'll never flat-out say someone is wrong unless I know it. When I do that and people try to counter it... I get cranky. I don't try to tear people down. If I say, like, "No, that's not why that happened, this is why that happened, and here's how I know that for a fact," please trust I kind of know what I'm talking about. THAT bothers me. That whole, "The sky is blue," "Well ACTUALLY at different times of day it turns reddish/orange..." thing. That's just being contrary. I won't say something as dickish as "you're wrong" to anyone unless it's proven fact. So if I AM saying it, please trust me, even if it hurts. K?
Sorry about the sowwy thing, that was snarkier than I meant it to be. Was just to add color, not as a shot.
--------------------------------------------------
Anyway... Bruce as Batman went to black body armor in 1994 to mimic the movie suits. Twenty years long enough for you yet? :P (Joke question, please let's NOT keep doing the Bat-usi, here, mkay? :lol:)
samxsteal
03-11-2014, 03:39 PM
Leo-
I get what you’re saying and that's fine
And i for one have definitely been personally attack and continue to be not by you. And really i don’t care all that much is suck because some of these people have been here a long time so people trust their judgment and when they start to belittle be people just assuming im some stupid Idiot who doesn't know what I’m talking about.
I don’t want to fight about this movie But when i see likeminded people like me Come in and say something like
"i love the new look of the turtle it’s something I’ve been wanting to see for some time."
And the get a response like
"These designs are terrible. They look the Apes I don’t get how people can like these Ewe Gross."
Cuz frankly i could say the exact thing in opposite and be picked on by all those people and be told how dare you not lets us dislike these freaks.
And that's the pentacle of hypocrisy.
Some like them some don't
That goes for every fandom out there for anything some like what they see some don’t
I really do like you Leo and while i don’t always agree and sometimes i get aggravated as I’m sure i do to you as well.
And I’m sure we could talk about thing we both agree on and have a lovely conversation.
And thought your long winded post have my ADHD doing flips i admire them.
Leo656
03-11-2014, 03:46 PM
Your typos blur my eyeballs so I guess we're even. :lol: (I knowwwww, probably typing from a phone, just razzin'.)
samxsteal
03-11-2014, 03:52 PM
Your typos blur my eyeballs so I guess we're even. :lol: (I knowwwww, probably typing from a phone, just razzin'.)
lol Tried to fix them lol
Raptor86
03-11-2014, 05:03 PM
Well, I can think about the new Sherlock Holmes movies (and series). His figure has been about the same for almost 100 years, but is was completely re-imagined in the Guy Ritchie movies... And those movies are actually good, guys...
Candy Kappa
03-11-2014, 05:09 PM
Well, I can think about the new Sherlock Holmes movies (and series). His figure has been about the same for almost 100 years, but is was completely re-imagined in the Guy Ritchie movies... And those movies are actually good, guys...
http://whatculture.com/film/how-faithful-is-guy-ritchies-sherlock-holmes-to-arthur-conan-doyle.php
Raptor86
03-11-2014, 05:45 PM
http://whatculture.com/film/how-faithful-is-guy-ritchies-sherlock-holmes-to-arthur-conan-doyle.php
Appearance: C Minus
Behavior: A
Personality: B Plus
So, of the new turtles we don't know anything about "Behavior" and "Personality" yet... will see, guys, we will see...
http://blogs.artinfo.com/secrethistoryofart/files/2014/01/sherlock-holmes.jpg
samxsteal
03-11-2014, 09:33 PM
Appearance: C Minus
Behavior: A
Personality: B Plus
So, of the new turtles we don't know anything about "Behavior" and "Personality" yet... will see, guys, we will see...
http://blogs.artinfo.com/secrethistoryofart/files/2014/01/sherlock-holmes.jpg
Personally i love Roberts Sherlock My favorite is the original Above all else, then BBC Sherlock just love it, then Roberts version, Haven't seen the NBC version, and it been a while since I've seen many of the others
But anyone remember the Disney movie the great mouse detective hahaha great Sherlock movie lol, also wishbone lol
But this is my point as well there is only so much we do know and I am patiently awaiting to see the final outcome.
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 02:38 AM
Appearance: C Minus
Behavior: A
Personality: B Plus
So, of the new turtles we don't know anything about "Behavior" and "Personality" yet... will see, guys, we will see...
http://blogs.artinfo.com/secrethistoryofart/files/2014/01/sherlock-holmes.jpg
At least he doesn't wear the hat, which isn't a apart of the book canon.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 03:01 AM
At least he doesn't wear the hat, which isn't a apart of the book canon.
I know! And that was a change that now is a part of the imagine of SH.
Changing is not always a bad thing.
Smaug has always been thougt as a 6 limbed dragon (and even Tolkien used to draw it that way)... But then it changed in the Hobbit movie, and BANG! Best dragon ever.
Moreover in the TMNT universe there are different sources... Different comics, cartoons etc.
If this new Turtle Movie has a good background that explains why they wear "clothes", shows the different personalities of the four, has ninja action, and it doesn't forget the main themes of the original sources, well we are going to have a good TMNT movie.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 03:08 AM
If this new Turtle Movie has a good background that explains why they wear "clothes", shows the different personalities of the four, has ninja action, and it doesn't forget the main themes of the original sources, well we are going to have a good TMNT movie.
I love the qualifier "if" in this post.
As if we should give the filmmakers brownie points IF some of the basic, must-have attributes of the TMNT are in this movie.
And it's pretty sad that we don't know for sure.
However, on the flipside. TMNT 3 had all those things too. Not a very good TMNT movie. Or movie in general.
Changing is not always a bad thing.
Name some changes(that have changed more than just updated) from this movie that we've seen so far that aren't bad things.
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 03:15 AM
I know! And that was a change that now is a part of the imagine of SH.
Changing is not always a bad thing.
Smaug has always been thougt as a 6 limbed dragon (and even Tolkien used to draw it that way)... But then it changed in the Hobbit movie, and BANG! Best dragon ever.
Moreover in the TMNT universe there are different sources... Different comics, cartoons etc.
If this new Turtle Movie has a good background that explains why they wear "clothes", shows the different personalities of the four, has ninja action, and it doesn't forget the main themes of the original sources, well we are going to have a good TMNT movie.
Eh, I wasn't a fan of making Smaug look like a Wyvern, but to the movies defense it is more "natural" looking compared to a four legged creature with a pair of wings. But, then again, it is a high-fantasy movie, so things can be weird and strange.
But besides turning a Dragon into a Wyvern, it is the better Smaug of the movie versions. Then again, that isn't saying much when you look at the other Movie Smaug.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 03:45 AM
Eh, I wasn't a fan of making Smaug look like a Wyvern, but to the movies defense it is more "natural" looking compared to a four legged creature with a pair of wings. But, then again, it is a high-fantasy movie, so things can be weird and strange.
But besides turning a Dragon into a Wyvern, it is the better Smaug of the movie versions. Then again, that isn't saying much when you look at the other Movie Smaug.
Movie Smaug is not a Wyvern. There's a huge article about that, but unfortunately it's in Italian (maybe you can google translate it)
http://meditazionitolkieniane.wordpress.com/2013/11/16/nessun-drago-e-una-viverna/
Name some changes(that have changed more than just updated) from this movie that we've seen so far that aren't bad things.
But what do we really now about this movie?! C'mon let's wait at least the trailer (that should be out in 2-3 weeks)!
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 03:49 AM
But what do we really now about this movie?! C'mon let's wait at least the trailer (that should be out in 2-3 weeks)!
A lot, but just for fun:
Shredder who is now a white man named Eric Sachs instead of a Japanese man named Oroku Saki.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 03:55 AM
Is it true that he is going to be the adopted son of Oroku saki?
If it is, for me, it will be fine.
Otherwise it's just a meh (FOR ME), not really a terrible thing. I am more interested in the turtles, if they have the same spirit of past embodiments that we love.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 03:57 AM
Is it true that he is going to be the adopted son of Oroku saki?
No we have no idea. As far as we know, Oroku Saki does not exist. Shredder is only Eric Sachs.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 03:59 AM
No we have no idea.
See? Let's wait, if they can find a good background for this choice I'll be fine :twink:
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 04:02 AM
Movie Smaug is not a Wyvern. There's a huge article about that, but unfortunately it's in Italian (maybe you can google translate it)
http://meditazionitolkieniane.wordpress.com/2013/11/16/nessun-drago-e-una-viverna/
Dungeons & Dragons terminology.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 04:04 AM
See? Let's wait, if they can find a good background for this choice I'll be fine :twink:
Okay. Let's say, just for fun, he IS the adopted son of Oroku Saki.
If that's the case, why bother with the Eric Sachs crap in the first place? Why not just use Oroku Saki as Shredder?
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 04:09 AM
Dungeons & Dragons terminology.
If you could read the article, you would learn that the wyvern does not exist in any litereature.
But we can talk of that in private, i guess it's enough OT :twink:
Okay. Let's say, just for fun, he IS the adopted son of Oroku Saki.
If that's the case, why bother with the Eric Sachs crap in the first place? Why not just use Oroku Saki as Shredder?
I am not a Hollywood screenwriter, let's see what they can give to us.
For example: we don't know if these turtles have faced Shredder before. Maybe Oruku saki is dead and his son is seeking revenge.
Maybe Eric Sachs was sent by his father in the US to fight the turtles? Who knows?
But I guess this is also OT, as this topic was to talk about the movie design choices not the story itself.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 04:22 AM
For example: we don't know if these turtles have faced Shredder before. Maybe Oruku saki is dead and his son is seeking revenge.
That doesn't make sense, because Saki isn't real and they could have just written him into the story as Shredder instead of bothering at all with this Eric Sachs nonsense.
Also, I don't want to see Shredder's son Eric wearing a ridiculous bladed battle suit.
I want to see Oroku Saki as Shredder fighting mocap Turtles with his skill and the very few fixed blades on his body.
Maybe Eric Sachs was sent by his father in the US to fight the turtles? Who knows?
Well considering Fichtner is pushing 60 I doubt we'll get anything to do with Sachs' "father" in this movie, of any fashion.
And if Oroku Saki IS included in this movie in some fashion, I'll be pissed off more so than if he's not not.
See? This is fun. We're having fun.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 05:01 AM
See? This is fun. We're having fun.
Of course it is! We are talking 'bout our beloved franchise!
This is an other theory by the way
http://i.imgur.com/W46vufr.jpg
I guess it is too farfetched...
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 05:13 AM
Of course it is! We are talking 'bout our beloved franchise!
This is an other theory by the way
http://i.imgur.com/W46vufr.jpg
I guess it is too farfetched...
Which, again, why bother with all the Eric Sachs crap? Why NOT keep him Oroku Saki even if he is Krang or Ch'rell or a random Utrom?
See? Sometimes change for the sake of change IS ******.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 06:01 AM
http://www.thefilmchair.com/wordpress/index.php/2013/07/03/does-the-shredder-have-a-new-origin-in-liebesmans-ninja-turtles/
I have to say I agree with this guy:
All things being equal, a new Shredder origin is nothing compared to what Burton did to The Joker’s “origin” in the 1989 Batman film. So despite being a life long Turtles fan, I’m rather interested to see this new take on a villain who is getting to be about as tired as Lex Luthor. As long as the Turtles are still mutants (and not aliens), then bring it on.
I mean I am more interested to what they're doing to the turtles rather than to the Shredder... We have a different point of view about that.
Technogeek29
03-12-2014, 06:05 AM
http://www.thefilmchair.com/wordpress/index.php/2013/07/03/does-the-shredder-have-a-new-origin-in-liebesmans-ninja-turtles/
I have to say I agree with this guy:
Bored with Shredder's orgin? Read Secret History of the Foot Clan.
Powder
03-12-2014, 06:13 AM
Bored with Shredder's orgin? Read Secret History of the Foot Clan.
Word to that. 4kids too, really.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 06:35 AM
http://www.thefilmchair.com/wordpress/index.php/2013/07/03/does-the-shredder-have-a-new-origin-in-liebesmans-ninja-turtles/
I have to say I agree with this guy:
I mean I am more interested to what they're doing to the turtles rather than to the Shredder... We have a different point of view about that.
So...because one change was worse at one point, any other change isn't AS bad or is fine?
There's no logic in that.
I wish people would stop making excuses for bad decisions simply because.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 07:26 AM
Bored with Shredder's orgin? Read Secret History of the Foot Clan.
I would like to (the cover of it looks really cool!), I have never read a TMNT comics, because in Italy they are really impossible to find. Here in the Netherlands I dunno.
So...because one change was worse at one point, any other change isn't AS bad or is fine?
There's no logic in that.
I don't understand what you are referring to :ohwell:. Anyway I just don't mind what they do to the Shredder. In the '87 cartoon (that i guess it is the main reference of this forum) he was depicted as an incompetent and stupid villain, so I didn't grow fond of the character. :shredder:
Maybe if I had read the comics I would had a different opinion.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 08:09 AM
I don't understand what you are referring to :ohwell:.
Joker's origin change in the Tim Burton movie.
That guy on the website you linked is saying that because there have been semi-worse changes to characters in past films, that makes what they've done to Shredder in this new movie okay.
Which is just wrong.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 08:15 AM
Uhm, I guess he meant that the Joker's origin were changed in the Tim Burton's movie, but then it turned to be very cool and iconic anyway.
We already saw a big change in the Splinter's origin in the '87 cartoon, didn't we?
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 08:27 AM
Uhm, I guess he meant that the Joker's origin were changed in the Tim Burton's movie, but then it turned to be very cool and iconic anyway.
Iconic in that a lot of people didn't like the fact that he became the killer of Bruce's parents.
And considering how well Nolan nailed Joker and Joker's complete LACK of origin, and that is very much largely praised...
We already saw a big change in the Splinter's origin in the '87 cartoon, didn't we?
Yeah? And? So? What?
Whether Splinter is the mutated pet rat of Hamato Yoshi or Splinter is Hamato Yoshi himself, it doesn't change his character very much, if at all.
I, personally, prefer the mutated pet rat angle myself, which was done very well in the original movies. But I also like the mutated Hamato Yoshi done well in the original and current cartoon. But either way, Splinter is still Splinter.
Making Shredder a white man named Eric Sachs fundamentally changes everything his core character is.
MajorViolence
03-12-2014, 09:09 AM
I always find it weird when I see people try to paint Splinter's changed origin in the cartoon as some giant deviation. It's still an extremely similar origin story, it just simplifies things by combining Yoshi and Splinter into one character. It made the origin story a hell of a lot simpler and easier for a child to understand, but it didn't lose any of the important plot elements. If you want to make a working comparison, I'd compare it to Utrom Shredder. It added elements and complicated origins instead of simplifying them. The fan reaction to that was divisive, just as this film's changes appear to be.
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 09:15 AM
I always find it weird when I see people try to paint Splinter's changed origin in the cartoon as some giant deviation. It's still an extremely similar origin story, it just simplifies things by combining Yoshi and Splinter into one character. It made the origin story a hell of a lot simpler and easier for a child to understand, but it didn't lose any of the important plot elements. If you want to make a working comparison, I'd compare it to Utrom Shredder. It added elements and complicated origins instead of simplifying them. The fan reaction to that was divisive, just as this film's changes appear to be.
I loved 2003 Shredder so very much, until the Utrom reveal.
Just absolutely hated it.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 09:37 AM
If you want to make a working comparison, I'd compare it to Utrom Shredder. It added elements and complicated origins instead of simplifying them. The fan reaction to that was divisive, just as this film's changes appear to be.
Yeah, you are right. I did not follow the 2003 TMNT back in those days. I have to do it, then, and get my own idea. :tcool:
Leo656
03-12-2014, 01:04 PM
King Ghidorah is the best dragon ever. He murdered Mars.
Anyone who can't see and accept that loses credibility with me. :P
According to DC editorial, we'll never know the "real" Joker origin anyway, so having the movies change it a little bit isn't a huge deal. I think having him kill Bruce's parents is a little too "full-circle", but I got what they were going for, and it worked for that movie. Wouldn't like it as the "real" version. I kind of like to pretend that Bruce in the movie "mis-remembered" it, and that he only *thought* Napier did it. In the 90s comic books, they even briefly retconned it so that Batman never found out who killed his parents, thus essentially he was "avenging" them every night. I enjoyed that take, because truthfully, once his parents' killer was punished, there was no good reason to keep being Batman other than self-fulfillment. It also made the entire story "darker", since Bruce never got even a little bit of closure for his parent's deaths, which more fits his character, I find.
Anyways, back on topic, there really is no GOOD reason for the changes made to Shredder's character for the movie, and I kind of wish people would stop insisting there is. There ARE reasons, yes, that people keep repeating. They are NOT, though, good reasons. Especially if it's yet another take on the origin story, which it is, then they shouldn't stray so far from the familiar. Everyone knows Shredder's basic deal. This is just another example of Hollywood insisting they need to do it "Their Way". Which is always bullsh*t.
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 01:32 PM
If you could read the article, you would learn that the wyvern does not exist in any litereature.
But we can talk of that in private, i guess it's enough OT :twink:
Not quite, Wyverns have appeared in medieval bestiaries.
But, personally I think Smaug was made into a Wyvern-esque form, is in the same vein as what Bethesda did to their dragons in the game Elder Scrolls V Skyrim. A four limbed dragon is a lot easier to animate and you have real world references on how such a creature would walk and fly, unlike the six limbed variant of a dragon, as such bone structure don't exist, similar to a Pegasus or a romanticized angel, such a body structure can easily be seen as unnatural and fall into the uncanny valley.
And, dragon is a very loose term, roaming from four legged snake with tiny wings on their back to no winged dragons with a long snake body and a camel shaped head, or a two legged, two winged dragon, as the "Wyvern" esthetics have been used for dragons.
Different culture will have a different definition on what a "dragon" is. ( but a Wyvern is pretty much static in what it looks like)
As for D&D.
In D&D Dragons and Wyverns are separate species, while Dragons are six limbed creature with intellect ranging from normal for humans to vastly intellectual, and have a uniqe breath weapon depending in what type of dragon they are. Example, Smaug is the archetypical dragon, and in D&D red dragons are basically what Smaug are, res scaled dragons with fire breath weapons. And most dragons are treasure hoarders.
Wyverns, although resemble true dragons, are smaller and of course lacks the front legs. They are known to be dumb, but are still cunning sly creatures, often evil and have poisonous stingers on their tails. They lack a breath weapon.
Hence why Smaugs looks can on a esthetic level here freed as a Wyvern, as he deviates from the iconic six limbed look of what a western dragon usually are depicted as, while a Wyvern for the most part have had their design stay uniformly as one.
Which can be intertwined with the turtles designs, so that I'm not completely off topic :P
The turtles designs are very much less of an turtle and looks more like a tortoise. The shells are bigger and more dome shaped, not very aerodynamic like the shell of a turtle, or even more specific a slider.
I'm really curious if the bullet proof shells will survive from the old script, personally I'm a bit weary if the idea. Certainly a turtle isn't bullet proof, the shell can withstand a lot of pressure, slider can survive the pressure from a crocs bite, and sea turtles can withstand more pressure then the bite of a great white shark. I'd like to see that aspect explored in one way or the other, but bullet proof? Sounds mor like an excuse to have the turtles in a gun fight...
I'm also curious how their plastron works, since it looks more shaped like a humans chest and belly, muscle toning within the scutes, which is a personal pet peeve of mine, I hate seeing muscles through the plastron, it makes no sense. But I do wonder of the plastron will be soft for better motion, which it probably will be since the turtles are all MoCap and a rigid plastron and carapace would ale it impossible for a humanoid turtle to even just walk properly, or making a summersault.
Raptor86
03-12-2014, 02:18 PM
Not quite, Wyverns have appeared in medieval bestiaries.ù
From wiki: The usual spelling wyvern is not attested before the 17th century as "winged two-footed dragon". (Hoad, T. F. (1993). English Etymology.)
The turtles designs are very much less of an turtle and looks more like a tortoise. The shells are bigger and more dome shaped, not very aerodynamic like the shell of a turtle, or even more specific a slider.
I guess you meant hydrodynamic, right? O_o
I'm really curious if the bullet proof shells will survive from the old script, personally I'm a bit weary if the idea. Certainly a turtle isn't bullet proof, the shell can withstand a lot of pressure, slider can survive the pressure from a crocs bite, and sea turtles can withstand more pressure then the bite of a great white shark. I'd like to see that aspect explored in one way or the other, but bullet proof? Sounds mor like an excuse to have the turtles in a gun fight...
I'm also curious how their plastron works, since it looks more shaped like a humans chest and belly, muscle toning within the scutes, which is a personal pet peeve of mine, I hate seeing muscles through the plastron, it makes no sense. But I do wonder of the plastron will be soft for better motion, which it probably will be since the turtles are all MoCap and a rigid plastron and carapace would ale it impossible for a humanoid turtle to even just walk properly, or making a summersault.
I agree with you, a bullet proof shells would be too much
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 02:32 PM
I guess you meant hydrodynamic, right? O_o
Yeah, forgot the proper name for liquid use, but the shape is more or less the same.
samxsteal
03-12-2014, 02:58 PM
ù
From wiki: The usual spelling wyvern is not attested before the 17th century as "winged two-footed dragon". (Hoad, T. F. (1993). English Etymology.)
I guess you meant hydrodynamic, right? O_o
I agree with you, a bullet proof shells would be too much
Though i guess on the back of the packaging of the original figure it say they have bullet proof shells if im remembering correctly
Candy Kappa
03-12-2014, 03:06 PM
The card bios also have a lot of other wacky factoids and tidbits that makes little to no sense. Like the turtles all comes from different pet stores in different places, like New Hapshell, Slowklahowa or pennshellvania.
Also, only Leo's shell is stated as bullet proof (and shock resistant) while Donnie's shell is hard as a tank, but poor Raph's shell is just hard as old gum... Someone didn't catch a lot of sun rays.
Leo656
03-12-2014, 03:27 PM
^^:lol: I remember that sh*t. Good times.
But yeah I wouldn't ever base anything of TMNT canon on what the card backs said. Just a balls-out goofy parody of the G.I. Joe cards and nothing more.
I mean, we ALL know Ace Duck didn't just fly the Blimp, as his card said. He was the Finest Feathered Fowl Of Planet Perdufus, and the Stump Intergalactic Wrestling Champion! How'd they leave that out?! :lol:
But yeah, not interested in bullet-proof shells. Why not just make their skin "thick and tough as leather" then, too, to become resistant to knives and other weapons, so they can't be damaged at all. Let's just have a team of invincible, indestructible Iron Mans, but they're Turtles.
plastroncafe
03-12-2014, 03:29 PM
Leo's shell deflects a bullet in the Mirage books, if memory serves.
For what that's worth.
Leo656
03-12-2014, 03:40 PM
I could see a ricochet but not a straight shot. I mean, it's actually forgivable to do A bullet bouncing off their shell, just for the sake of a cool visual and to reinforce the idea, "Yes, they're turtles, and their shells offer protection," but they should definitely be surprised they're still alive and NOT taking a chance on getting hit by a second one.
That's how I see it. "Everybody Gets ONE" is fine, but not full-on bullet-proof. I was actually glad that in the Dark Knight movies, they made it a point to mention his armor really didn't offer as much protection as it looked. When I saw the designs, I was concerned he'd just be a walking tank. If you're not Superman or Iron Man, bullets and knives should give you pause, even if you're a trained ninja warrior. Or especially then; if they were able to stop bullets, why learn martial arts? Just take the bullet, walk up to the guy, and smack him in the head, right? :lol:
I'm gonna give 'em the benefit of the doubt, though, for some reason, I don't think they'll be bulletproof in the new movie... despite the bad guys having guns EVERY where (that does kind of concern me, but... eh we'll see). Maybe as I said, ONE shot of a bullet grazing one of their shells, just for added "danger". I don't think (hope) we'll be seeing any full-on, Superman "It Tickles" action. I HOPE not.
plastroncafe
03-12-2014, 03:53 PM
Superman might be impervious to bullets, but even he ducks when someone throws a gun at him.
;)
Leo656
03-12-2014, 03:56 PM
http://img.pandawhale.com/post-9587-This-shark-surfaced-just-to-gi-cRIy.jpeg
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 07:56 PM
I'm gonna give 'em the benefit of the doubt, though, for some reason, I don't think they'll be bulletproof in the new movie... despite the bad guys having guns EVERY where (that does kind of concern me, but... eh we'll see). Maybe as I said, ONE shot of a bullet grazing one of their shells, just for added "danger". I don't think (hope) we'll be seeing any full-on, Superman "It Tickles" action. I HOPE not.
That's why it's better that the Foot be a traditional ninja clan with traditional ninja weapons.
It stretches credulity that the Turtles are running around fighting guys with big **** off rifles and sidearms when the Turtles are not at all impervious to bullets, because, you know, they're earth Turtles, not aliens(as far as we know).
They can be as stealthy as they want, sooner or later there'll be a big enough gather of Black Ops Military Bros with guns and they'll get a bead on you and open up.
But a huge group of Ninja with swords and nunchucks etc, and the Turtles stand a far better chance.
Leo656
03-12-2014, 10:53 PM
Yeah, I think that, in fiction, while you NEED to challenge, test, and threaten the hero, and we like to see the hero overcome seemingly-insurmountable odds... at the end of the day, we ALL know the hero has to win. It's predetermined. So, to that end, even though we know that they'll win, the idea is that for the story to fully satisfy, the threat they overcome should at least be a BELIEVABLE victory.
I always, always hate when I see one of those, "Well, that definitely would have f*cking killed him, but it's a movie" moments. I know the Turtles are good, maybe even "THA BEST, JABRONI! Sheik class, 1000%!"... but as you said, too many guys with too many guns just isn't plausible for a couple guys with swords, salad forks and broom handles, no matter how high they can kick.
Yeah, obviously, give the good guy a challenge, but like Lisa Simspon said, "A challenge I can DO!" And do somewhat believably. Not spin-kick an entire platoon of armed soldiers into chop suey. Don't ask anyone but Batman to do that, and even for Batman, he only gets away with it because he is, indeed, Batman, and nobody's got the balls to tell him it doesn't make sense, even though he's a fictional character.
His own creators are too afraid to be like, "Batman, maybe you can't dodge bullets. Maybe one of them hits you." "Nope. Batman." "Yeah, but there's like, a dozen guys with machine guns, and we just think it's not... "Ahem. Batman."
TrickOrTreater
03-12-2014, 11:08 PM
Yeah, I think that, in fiction, while you NEED to challenge, test, and threaten the hero, and we like to see the hero overcome seemingly-insurmountable odds... at the end of the day, we ALL know the hero has to win. It's predetermined. So, to that end, even though we know that they'll win, the idea is that for the story to fully satisfy, the threat they overcome should at least be a BELIEVABLE victory.
I always, always hate when I see one of those, "Well, that definitely would have f*cking killed him, but it's a movie" moments. I know the Turtles are good, maybe even "THA BEST, JABRONI! Sheik class, 1000%!"... but as you said, too many guys with too many guns just isn't plausible for a couple guys with swords, salad forks and broom handles, no matter how high they can kick.
Yeah, obviously, give the good guy a challenge, but like Lisa Simspon said, "A challenge I can DO!" And do somewhat believably. Not spin-kick an entire platoon of armed soldiers into chop suey. Don't ask anyone but Batman to do that, and even for Batman, he only gets away with it because he is, indeed, Batman, and nobody's got the balls to tell him it doesn't make sense, even though he's a fictional character.
His own creators are too afraid to be like, "Batman, maybe you can't dodge bullets. Maybe one of them hits you." "Nope. Batman." "Yeah, but there's like, a dozen guys with machine guns, and we just think it's not... "Ahem. Batman."
Yep, long and the short of it.
Turtles going up against ninja robots with lasers in a cartoon? Sign me up.
Turtles going up against Black Ops Military Bros with actual guns? Yeah...no.
Leo656
03-12-2014, 11:16 PM
I'm sure they'd take a few down first, but eventually, one of 'em gonna take an arrow to the knee.... :lol:
samxsteal
03-13-2014, 09:44 AM
I'm sure they'd take a few down first, but eventually, one of 'em gonna take an arrow to the knee.... :lol:
http://stream1.gifsoup.com/view7/2499088/ace-ventura-spear-legs-o.gif
BubblyShell22
03-13-2014, 09:46 AM
Totally agree with you there, Leo. Yes the Turtles are ninjas, but even they can't dodge bullets all of the time. One hitting the shell once? Okay, but that doesn't mean the next one's not going in the shoulder or even the head next time. I'm very leery of the whole Foot being military thing. Make them ninjas because that's what they've always been.
And back on topic of the designs, I hate them because of the clothing choice as others have said. Just makes no sense to have them dress that way, but I've said that enough. That's my two cents. And I don't care if people like it or are for it. If you are, more power to you. I'm not trying to force anyone to like anything, but it seems to me that if you have a negative opinion about anything, you're just stupid or something. And that's just not right.
Technogeek29
03-14-2014, 10:38 PM
A military like Foot could work if in the right hands. They operate like the Yakuza anyhow. But it should be more in the context of the OT or SAINW which had the foot carry guns. But We all know this is just Bay's obsession with military anything.
Warhorse
03-14-2014, 11:26 PM
A military like Foot could work if in the right hands. They operate like the Yakuza anyhow. But it should be more in the context of the OT or SAINW which had the foot carry guns. But We all know this is just Bay's obsession with military anything.
Well, in the cartoons, it is kind of unrealistic in a sense that there is an alien threat going down in one of the biggest cities in the world, and there isn't a military presence or martial law being initiated.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.