View Full Version : donny Just flipped a car...Im treating this movie as a cartoon from now on.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 01:46 PM
I think if you're going to be all "Speed Racer" and just be completely ridiculous, then that's great, and there's a time and a place where it works.
I don't think TMNT really IS like that, though. I've always seen the franchise as interesting because it straddles the line between reality and fantasy, that the characters themselves are fantastic but the premise being that the world they inhabit is "real". I find that they become exponentially LESS interesting when they're placed in a universe full of batsh*t-crazy characters and over-the-top situations. They themselves should always be the craziest thing in the room.
It's like how Superman writers always try and resist putting him in the Justice League. "Why exactly is he special when there's six or seven other characters right next to him that can do the exact same stuff he does?" A lot of your premise is based on an element of fantasy in an otherwise-mundane world. You start getting into, "It's all fake, throw all real-world logic out the window," you come dangerously close to breaking the fiction you're trying to create.
I can see how some people really do think TMNT works best as cheesy, stupid "fun," all "Cowabunga" and pizza jokes, but I disagree. First movie proved you can have the best of that AND keep it grounded, and there's no need to try and paint it JUST as "kids stuff." I mean, don't we have enough TMNT stuff right now that's aimed just at kids, or people with the maturity/attention span of kids? What about the fans who are a little more sophisticated? It's not that we've outgrown the material, because many times over the years they've given us material that speaks to a slightly more sophisticated audience, and one of the things I was afraid of when Nick bought it was that all that was going to go away, and it would be *just* a "Goofy kids Franchise" forevermore. Looks like I was right. We'll never get a TMNT movie that's good objectively, as in, "You can not even know about TMNT at all and still think this is a good movie." It's, "you have to already be a fan to enjoy it, or else it just looks like swill." And that makes me really, really sad.
And I don't see how "Batman Begins" wasn't "fun". It was just the right amount of everything. The absolute last thing we need for *that* universe is campy sh*t like the Schumacher films. Bruce Wayne's a sick human being who's only heroic because he turns his violence on people more disturbed than he is who would actually hurt innocent people. I don't entirely see room for a ton of humor in that particular universe just because the guy dresses like a bat. That's zero excuse for magic ice skates and a Bat-Credit Card. The second and third Nolan films were way too into themselves, I'll grant you, but for my money "Begins" was as close to Perfect as a comic book movie can be. SO many people - parents, mostly - walked out of the theater talking about how "I know it's just Batman... but that was actually a really great movie!" It was the exact same thing with the first TMNT movie, and that's always the kind of reaction I hope for when one of "My" franchises gets a movie.
plastroncafe
07-17-2014, 02:16 PM
The trick is to get the ridiculous to seem plausible in the confines of the movie-world. To get people to suspend their disbelief long enough to be fully engaged in a movie. That's just good film-making/story-telling.
For me, realism means consistency. I want the world to have rules, and for characters living in that world to have to obey those rules.
Those rules need not be the ones that I, living in this world, must obey.
MrTMNT2012
07-17-2014, 02:17 PM
I think if you're going to be all "Speed Racer" and just be completely ridiculous, then that's great, and there's a time and a place where it works.
I don't think TMNT really IS like that, though. I've always seen the franchise as interesting because it straddles the line between reality and fantasy, that the characters themselves are fantastic but the premise being that the world they inhabit is "real". I find that they become exponentially LESS interesting when they're placed in a universe full of batsh*t-crazy characters and over-the-top situations. They themselves should always be the craziest thing in the room.
It's like how Superman writers always try and resist putting him in the Justice League. "Why exactly is he special when there's six or seven other characters right next to him that can do the exact same stuff he does?" A lot of your premise is based on an element of fantasy in an otherwise-mundane world. You start getting into, "It's all fake, throw all real-world logic out the window," you come dangerously close to breaking the fiction you're trying to create.
I can see how some people really do think TMNT works best as cheesy, stupid "fun," all "Cowabunga" and pizza jokes, but I disagree. First movie proved you can have the best of that AND keep it grounded, and there's no need to try and paint it JUST as "kids stuff." I mean, don't we have enough TMNT stuff right now that's aimed just at kids, or people with the maturity/attention span of kids? What about the fans who are a little more sophisticated? It's not that we've outgrown the material, because many times over the years they've given us material that speaks to a slightly more sophisticated audience, and one of the things I was afraid of when Nick bought it was that all that was going to go away, and it would be *just* a "Goofy kids Franchise" forevermore. Looks like I was right. We'll never get a TMNT movie that's good objectively, as in, "You can not even know about TMNT at all and still think this is a good movie." It's, "you have to already be a fan to enjoy it, or else it just looks like swill." And that makes me really, really sad.
And I don't see how "Batman Begins" wasn't "fun". It was just the right amount of everything. The absolute last thing we need for *that* universe is campy sh*t like the Schumacher films. Bruce Wayne's a sick human being who's only heroic because he turns his violence on people more disturbed than he is who would actually hurt innocent people. I don't entirely see room for a ton of humor in that particular universe just because the guy dresses like a bat. That's zero excuse for magic ice skates and a Bat-Credit Card. The second and third Nolan films were way too into themselves, I'll grant you, but for my money "Begins" was as close to Perfect as a comic book movie can be. SO many people - parents, mostly - walked out of the theater talking about how "I know it's just Batman... but that was actually a really great movie!" It was the exact same thing with the first TMNT movie, and that's always the kind of reaction I hope for when one of "My" franchises gets a movie.
The Dark Knight was more balanced and tonally nuanced in my opinion but whatever, it comes down to personal prefference. You're the first person I understand why you have a legitimate reason to not like this movie besides all the Bay hate.
I never take TMNT seriously and it benefits me when it comes down to movies like this. Unfortunately I don't think we'll ever see a 'Dark Knight' version of TMNT. Not in this lifetime anyway. A guy dressed as a bat can still be taken more seriously than Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles!
MrTMNT2012
07-17-2014, 02:23 PM
The trick is to get the ridiculous to seem plausible in the confines of the movie-world. To get people to suspend their disbelief long enough to be fully engaged in a movie. That's just good film-making/story-telling.
For me, realism means consistency. I want the world to have rules, and for characters living in that world to have to obey those rules.
Those rules need not be the ones that I, living in this world, must obey.
Exactly, and if you can believe there really are 4 giant mutated teenage ninja turtles then you should have no problem knowing they can flip cars and what not...
plastroncafe
07-17-2014, 02:33 PM
Exactly, and if you can believe there really are 4 giant mutated teenage ninja turtles then you should have no problem knowing they can flip cars and what not...
That's up to the film-makers though, and whether or not they're giving the subject material the gravitas it needs to accurately suspend the audience's disbelief.
It's all in the execution.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 02:36 PM
I kinda prefer Begins because it still fits completely into the comics universe without any mental "tweaking" on the part of the viewer. DK and DKR were very clearly their own universe, and the farther they got from the comics, the more each film suffered, because some of the choices made by the studio and the director were kind of hit-or-miss. I'unno, I like BB and DK both just fine, but I give Begins the nod for authenticity.
And frankly, my issue with the "Hulk TMNT" is less that it's implausible, more that it goes dangerously close to lore-breaking. Why would they even be ninja? They're unstoppable tanks! It's like how I love Superman but generally hate most of the comics before 1986, back when he was dangerously over-powered. I can get into flying, heat vision, bulletproof, all that... if a guy can literally blow out a star like a candle, or push a planet out of orbit, as Superman was apt to do in the 50s through the 70s, how exactly is there going to be any tension or drama in the stories? It's not enough for me to say, "Well, he's an alien, that explains all of it." For one, no it doesn't, and for two, you simply can't use that to explain away what is, basically, just poor writing. I love nothing more than I love Superman, and I can objectively say that Superman more or less sucked until John Byrne fixed him.
I don't particularly care about characters who are always conveniently stronger or well-equipped enough to tackle absolutely every situation. I can buy that Batman knows every martial art on Earth; once you pull out the can of Shark-Repellant Bat-Spray, I'm out. Make sense?
MrTMNT2012
07-17-2014, 02:37 PM
That's up to the film-makers though, and whether or not they're giving the subject material the gravitas it needs to accurately suspend the audience's disbelief.
It's all in the execution.
Yeah, it comes down to the writing really. If the characters are well-developed and believable enough, it's easier for the audience to suspend their disbelief on the obsurd situations around those characters.
Sighphi
07-17-2014, 04:35 PM
Exactly, and if you can believe there really are 4 giant mutated teenage ninja turtles then you should have no problem knowing they can flip cars and what not...
A chemical that changes animal to humanoids has nothing to do with the technology that the turtles have access to. Now, like i said before, if this is some alien tech then it's ok. If it's not then we have some problems.
BTW, in the new trailer Raph seems to ..... expel bullets that are on his shell while screaming.
So..... their shell can be controlled and react in certain ways?
These guys are really the Fantastic Four at this point.
MrTMNT2012
07-17-2014, 04:42 PM
BTW, in the new trailer Raph seems to ..... expel bullets that are on his shell while screaming.
So..... their shell can be control and react in certain ways?
These guys are really the Fantastic Four at this point.
It's literally plot armour. :lol:
Sumac
07-17-2014, 04:44 PM
says who? you?
Me.
And I am not worse than you, dear, in any regard.
I believe, when creator breaks the inner logic of the setting the whole work goes to hell, unless creator intentionally wants to create ridiculous parody. This simple idea should be understandable by anyone, who can get the rules of writing and creating. Well, maybe not the ones who want to watch movies with their brains being turned off or just go to see EXPLOSIONS!! and CGI EFFECTS!! For those people, sadly, quality and logic doesn't matter. Doesn't mean that people who can make good stories should not try to educate them.
And no matter which way you look at it, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles will always be ridiculous. Sorry to break that for you people expecting Citizen Kane...
I, for one, do not expect, nor I want Citizen Kane out of TMNT.
I want simply a good movie. Without pathetic excessiveness resulting from hidden fetishes or complexes of a producer, with no stereotyping, without changes for the sake of changes. Just a damn good movie.
I know that for some people it's hard to get this concept, but not everything should be done in OVER THE TOP manner to be good, when it comes to fantastical and even ridiculous premises. In the end, guy in the bat suit or humanoid alien in blue tights are ridiculous concepts, but it didn't stop authors from telling good stories about them, that were serious and entertaining at the same time.
TMNT 2k3 and the first TMNT movie (and for some extent TMNT'07) are examples of how it can be done and when people say "TMNT is ridiculous, it couldn't be serious at all, embrace the stupidity" I want to tell them two things: they need to learn more about TMNT and all their problems with the concept of serious TMNT exist only in their heads, not in objective reality.
It seems, it's becoming a good tradition as I completely agree with Leo656.
slingtheory
07-17-2014, 05:06 PM
And no matter which way you look at it, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles will always be ridiculous. Sorry to break that for you people expecting Citizen Kane... no more ridiculous than most other comic book creations. It doesn't matter how wacky the premise seems what matters is what you do with the stories. And just like anything else there can be thought provoking tales that explore serious issues written on the back of this concept so the idea that its inherently silly is no excuse for anything
terrorblade
07-17-2014, 05:21 PM
Me.
And I am not worse than you, dear, in any regard.
I believe, when creator breaks the inner logic of the setting the whole work goes to hell, unless creator intentionally wants to create ridiculous parody. This simple idea should be understandable by anyone, who can get the rules of writing and creating. Well, maybe not the ones who want to watch movies with their brains being turned off or just go to see EXPLOSIONS!! and CGI EFFECTS!! For those people, sadly, quality and logic doesn't matter. Doesn't mean that people who can make good stories should not try to educate them.
I, for one, do not expect, nor I want Citizen Kane out of TMNT.
I want simply a good movie. Without pathetic excessiveness resulting from hidden fetishes or complexes of a producer, with no stereotyping, without changes for the sake of changes. Just a damn good movie.
I know that for some people it's hard to get this concept, but not everything should be done in OVER THE TOP manner to be good, when it comes to fantastical and even ridiculous premises. In the end, guy in the bat suit or humanoid alien in blue tights are ridiculous concepts, but it didn't stop authors from telling good stories about them, that were serious and entertaining at the same time.
TMNT 2k3 and the first TMNT movie (and for some extent TMNT'07) are examples of how it can be done and when people say "TMNT is ridiculous, it couldn't be serious at all, embrace the stupidity" I want to tell them two things: they need to learn more about TMNT and all their problems with the concept of serious TMNT exist only in their heads, not in objective reality.
It seems, it's becoming a good tradition as I completely agree with Leo656.
Donnie build these things in the almighty 2k3 series, in my opinion all of them are more ridiculous than his spring powered staff in this movie
http://i.imgur.com/d8uC8Jq.png
http://i.imgur.com/Ye0iQSB.png
http://i.imgur.com/fc9YiGB.png
All of that are made with little to no explanation. The only explanation behind that is that he's Donatello, and he does machines.
And here's a turtle deflecting bullets by spinning his weapon.
http://i.imgur.com/ZHx0ygM.png
zodiac brave
07-17-2014, 05:57 PM
when people say "TMNT is ridiculous, it couldn't be serious at all, embrace the stupidity" I want to tell them two things: they need to learn more about TMNT and all their problems with the concept of serious TMNT exist only in their heads, not in objective reality.
except its NOT objective.
its actually quite subjective (being an opinion and all...)
Leo656
07-17-2014, 08:24 PM
Terrorblade: I get what you're saying, and all's I can say to that is what I've said elsewhere, that some things work Just Fine in cartoons and comics, but simply don't play well in live action.
Like, if they had Luthor zooming around in his clunky green battle armor shooting Kryptonite lasers at Superman in the next movie, they really couldn't pull it off without it looking a little bit silly. It's terrific in the comics and cartoons. It works in that area. As far as things I'd actually want to see in a Superman film, Luthor's battle armor is pretty low on the list. I mean, it'd be kinda cool, but they'd have to be pretty careful how they did it. Or Mxyzptlk. How exactly would THAT work in a movie? Some stuff just works much better on paper or in cartoons than in real life or live action. Some of the people who make comic book movies seem kind of oblivious to that.
Sumac: Thanks, buddy. Most people do, eventually. 8)
Galactus
07-17-2014, 08:33 PM
Donnie build these things in the almighty 2k3 series, in my opinion all of them are more ridiculous than his spring powered staff in this movie
All of that are made with little to no explanation. The only explanation behind that is that he's Donatello, and he does machines.
And here's a turtle deflecting bullets by spinning his weapon.
Does it really need to be said (again) that some things are more acceptable in cartoon setting than they are in live action movie.
Something else to consider that acceptable in moderation were just brush it off as a conceit of the genre. If this movie is filled with all manner of outrageous things in almost every scene then it just becomes stupid.
I'll also point out that one thing about Don's tech specifically that I've liked is that in most (not all) versions he's started with what seems to be an acceptable level of technical expertise that increased over time. Even the highly outlandish Fred Wolf show he didn't do anything that truly with implied idea that it's exposure to alien tech that gives the knowledge to build the truly advanced stuff.
terrorblade
07-17-2014, 09:17 PM
I only use the 4kids series as an example because he used it as his example of TMNT done right. I'm wondering what you guys opinion about their origin in this film, because them being scientific experiments is more realistic than them mutating because they fall into an alien ooze. When they change things it is wrong (turtles appearance, origin etc) but when they retain things common to other incarnations (Donnie's advance inventions, humor) it is still wrong. We like this franchise for different reasons so don't say that there's only one way for a TMNT movie to be done. This movie just reminds me why I like TMNT so much.
Sumac
07-17-2014, 09:25 PM
except its NOT objective.
its actually quite subjective (being an opinion and all...)
You want to tell me that TMNT can't have serious stories?
Gee...I guess TMNT comic books, 2k3 series and first movie have never existed in your objective reality. Well, not everyone can be lucky, I guess. :lol:
Donnie build these things in the almighty 2k3 series, in my opinion all of them are more ridiculous than his spring powered staff in this movie
In context of the cartoon, which had alien invasion, space and time travel, they have looked quite plausible.
Leo656
07-17-2014, 09:39 PM
I only use the 4kids series as an example because he used it as his example of TMNT done right. I'm wondering what you guys opinion about their origin in this film, because them being scientific experiments is more realistic than them mutating because they fall into an alien ooze. When they change things it is wrong (turtles appearance, origin etc) but when they retain things common to other incarnations (Donnie's advance inventions, humor) it is still wrong. We like this franchise for different reasons so don't say that there's only one way for a TMNT movie to be done. This movie just reminds me why I like TMNT so much.
I get what you mean. I, myself, love 2K3, but there's a lot of stuff I only like in *that* universe and don't care to see crossed-over. Further, that entire series seemed pretty heavy into sci-fi, so some of Donnie's tech just seemed more of a natural evolution of the character and the situations he found himself in. And that's part of where ideas in TV can be gradually implemented, and to better success, than when it's crammed into a two-hour film. Seeing the character in live action for the first time in 20 years, wearing the entire 2014 Ghostbusters Fall Collection, is extremely jarring without any build-up.
As far as the mutation goes, I once had an idea for a story, where basically the Ooze itself was a science experiment designed to create living weapons, while the Turtles themselves being exposed to it was still an accident. I really get annoyed when everything in movies happens for a specific reason, everyone knows everyone else intimately, and everything happens via Grand Design. Life isn't like that. I think Shredder having a hand in creating the Ooze as a way to create mutant warriors, and the Turtles themselves only being exposed accidentally, is fine. Having the Turtles themselves be specifically genetically engineered from birth to be those weapons, I think, is a little too far into "Superboy made Luthor's hair fall out, and that's why they hate each other" territory.
It's a subtle distinction between what plays well and what doesn't, but I feel it's an important one.
zodiac brave
07-17-2014, 10:21 PM
You want to tell me that TMNT can't have serious stories?
Gee...I guess TMNT comic books, 2k3 series and first movie have never existed in your objective reality. Well, not everyone can be lucky, I guess.
*sigh*
i never said that. how you even came to that conclusion is kind of a mystery to me considering i never even referenced what you were saying about whatever it was you were talking about.
you, however, did say;
I want to tell them two things: they need to learn more about TMNT and all their problems with the concept of serious TMNT exist only in their heads, not in objective reality.
the idea that someone's (or in this case, a group of someones) problems with a given idea exist only in their heads is just arrogant. and not true. especially in terms of whats being argued here, it is indeed a HIGHLY SUBJECTIVE topic.
reality being "objective" doesn't mean it fits what you want it to fit, and honestly, i dont even think you used that word in any context that could be considered grammatically correct or significantly relevant.
:ohwell:
seriously, can you explain what you mean by "objective reality"?
graphic_content
07-17-2014, 11:15 PM
azmrG8AtP3U
oddly enough, for however powerful his staff seams, it wasnt the retractable portion that 'pushed' the truck, seeing the whole scene in context...it really was the integrity of the staff, and leverage from the rock. check the vid above.
Raptor86
07-18-2014, 12:57 AM
Mikey broke a car roof with a punch?!
Leo656
07-18-2014, 01:03 AM
Mikey broke a car roof with a punch?!
I cracked up at that, too. That was just shortly after the one effects guy said, "We're trying hard to keep everything super-realistic"... and then Mikey hops on his rocket skateboard. :lol:
Ahhhhh well.
Wildcat
07-18-2014, 01:16 AM
Flipping a car like this is not ridiculous. Its just meant to look like a plausible way do something cool.
I don't think its actually possible because there was an episode of Mythbusters where they try to do the same thing with a broken drive shaft and it doesn't send the car flipping into the air but many, serious, Hollywood movies do things that aren't actually possible. Mythbusters has tested many of them.
So don't fault this movie for doing something over the top.
Warhorse
07-18-2014, 01:38 AM
I cracked up at that, too. That was just shortly after the one effects guy said, "We're trying hard to keep everything super-realistic"... and then Mikey hops on his rocket skateboard. :lol:
Ahhhhh well.
:lol::lol::lol::lol: I was thinking the same damn thing when I saw that. They just need to stop with the realistic quotes, all they are doing is backing themselves into a corner with that crap.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 01:47 AM
:lol: As I've said, you can be "grounded and serious" OR "balls-out crazy"... but trying to do BOTH at the exact same time is... puzzling.
I mean, it's a puff piece, so obviously it's been clipped for brevity. I'm sure the full quote actually made sense. "The textures and so forth as far as the CGI effects, those are super-realistic. Everything else you see in the movie may as well be Alice In Wonderland." Something like that. :lol:
Wildcat
07-18-2014, 02:22 AM
:lol: As I've said, you can be "grounded and serious" OR "balls-out crazy"... but trying to do BOTH at the exact same time is... puzzling.Then you should be against even the most serious movies with action scenes because they've most likely done something "balls out crazy".
Whats you're favorite action movie thats grounding in reality? Not sc-fi, horror or superhero movie. A legitimate serious movie with action scenes?
It probably did something exaggerated to look cool but isn't actually possible in real life.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 02:33 AM
It's all in the execution, my dude. All in the execution. But I'm not the least bit surprised, at this point, that things like "nuance" and "subtlety" and "steady-handed execution" aren't familiar concepts with this crowd.
I get it, guy, you're one of the "It's All Fake Anyway So There's Zero Rules" crowd. As someone who spent most of high school studying writing, how to create characters, and how to maintain an illusion of reality (aka "verisimilitude") inside a fictional setting, I'd vehemently disagree with your logic.
But it's whatever, man. Go bug Andrew about it. He'll argue the so-called "Crisler's Law" with you until you're ready to shoot him in the face. :P
And that's a really tough question you're asking if we discount super-hero or science fiction movies from the "Action" genre. I guess I'd say... Rocky IV, when Rocky beat Communism to death with nothing but his own two hands and a steely glare? I guess that was a little far-fetched.
Wildcat
07-18-2014, 03:05 AM
It's all in the execution, my dude. All in the execution. But I'm not the least bit surprised, at this point, that things like "nuance" and "subtlety" and "steady-handed execution" aren't familiar concepts with this crowd.
I get it, guy, you're one of the "It's All Fake Anyway So There's Zero Rules" crowd. As someone who spent most of high school studying writing, how to create characters, and how to maintain an illusion of reality (aka "verisimilitude") inside a fictional setting, I'd vehemently disagree with your logic.
But it's whatever, man. Go bug Andrew about it. He'll argue the so-called "Crisler's Law" with you until you're ready to shoot him in the face. :P
And that's a really tough question you're asking if we discount super-hero or science fiction movies from the "Action" genre. I guess I'd say... Rocky IV, when Rocky beat Communism to death with nothing but his own two hands and a steely glare? I guess that was a little far-fetched.Was that at me or the people who made the movie?
Is Rocky action? Its more like drama imo. Anyway you say its all in execution but even the most serious movies have exaggerated action with cars flying around or some big event happening that would not in real life given the same circumstances. Yet people wanna fault this for having an exaggerated car flip.
I understand the complaints are mostly feuled by hating so I know we're not having a legitimate discussion about these things, just thought Id mention other scenarios.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 03:12 AM
I understand the complaints are mostly feuled by hating so I know we're not having a legitimate discussion about these things, just thought Id mention other scenarios.
You're ridiculous in general.
Some. People. Don't. Like. Camp. That's not "Hating".
The reason no "Legitimate discussion" happens around here is because whenever anyone explains their taste, it gets rebuffed with "Nah, you're just a hater, don't take things so seriously." How about No, buddy?
Candy Kappa
07-18-2014, 03:13 AM
Can't say I am fueled by hate, more annoyance.
Jester
07-18-2014, 03:14 AM
With all the uses of "real(ity)" I can't help but think:
http://ofmusingsandwonderings.files.wordpress.com/2013/03/you-keep-using-that-word1.jpg
Leo656
07-18-2014, 03:21 AM
For the movie, it's annoyance. For TMNT fans in general, it's creeping towards full-blown hatred every day.
"You don't like what I like, and your reasons don't satisfy me. You think too much and are therefore a 'Hater', because you have a higher-functioning brain and an attention span greater than that of a child. Clearly, you're Ninja Turtling incorrectly."
What. The f*ck. Ever. You people with your intolerance of other people's valid opinions. Disgusting.
Wildcat
07-18-2014, 03:50 AM
Some. People. Don't. Like. Camp. That's not "HatingOh that is a much better way to describe it. I can understanding not liking campiness.
Still alot of people here don't make that clear if thats the case. Alot of people are actually hating. Its not just one big misunderstanding of camp.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 04:04 AM
I get that, man, but... that's their prerogative. I just... I can't find one single example of anyone saying, "Don't like this movie," or, "If you like it, there's something wrong with you." Maybe some people imply it, but nobody is saying it.
I get heated because, someone will say, "There's no *real* criticism, no discussion, just Hating," and when someone just plainly says, "Okay, here's my beef, and here's what I'd prefer," it's the same old circular logic. "Nah, that's not good enough, just more hate." It's no one person, but it's making it really hard to even want to have a discussion. A pep rally isn't a discussion, either. And nobody's popping anybody's balloons when they say, "Well, I disagree on some of that."
It's not just this forum or anything, either. Since the stupid internet became a thing and nobody has to talk face to face anymore, nobody even knows what a conversation, discussion, or debate even IS. "I like this." "I LOVE this!" "Me too!" "Me Three!" "I don't." "Well, you're f*cking retarded, then." That's entirely what passes for "discussion" nowadays. Here, there, and everywhere. Sad.
Sorry if it seems I'm snapping at specific people. I'm not.
Candy Kappa
07-18-2014, 04:06 AM
Can't say I've seen a lot post that are just "grr hate grr". Most seem to articulate what causes their dislike.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 04:14 AM
You know what? I have seen it, but not around here. I see it on stupid Yahoo and YouTube comments. You know, where you see what the real face of humanity looks like in all its "glory". The cross-section of what the majority of people generally think, apparently. Either that, or only the stupidest people legally allowed to use a keyboard ever bother to comment on Yahoo and YouTube.
I do see some blind hate for the TMNT movie in those spots, so I'll grant you that. But I definitely don't see that here. And to be fair, the people who take time out to comment on Yahoo and YouTube are, basically, the worst people on Earth anyway, judging solely by their comments.
graphic_content
07-18-2014, 06:47 AM
Mikey broke a car roof with a punch?!
I was shocked to see that, punching through a window, sure, but the roof of a car...smh. I'm not so upset that it's completely turning me off, but 1) I don't expect that kind of strength or aggressiveness from Mikey 2) it doesn't help the whole this is supposed to be more realistic argument
Mikey broke a car roof with a punch?!
...haha, what!?
But nah, these Turtles aren't Hulks at all. Nope. :tlol:
I get that, man, but... that's their prerogative. I just... I can't find one single example of anyone saying, "Don't like this movie," or, "If you like it, there's something wrong with you." Maybe some people imply it, but nobody is saying it.
I get heated because, someone will say, "There's no *real* criticism, no discussion, just Hating," and when someone just plainly says, "Okay, here's my beef, and here's what I'd prefer," it's the same old circular logic. "Nah, that's not good enough, just more hate." It's no one person, but it's making it really hard to even want to have a discussion. A pep rally isn't a discussion, either. And nobody's popping anybody's balloons when they say, "Well, I disagree on some of that."
It's not just this forum or anything, either. Since the stupid internet became a thing and nobody has to talk face to face anymore, nobody even knows what a conversation, discussion, or debate even IS. "I like this." "I LOVE this!" "Me too!" "Me Three!" "I don't." "Well, you're f*cking retarded, then." That's entirely what passes for "discussion" nowadays. Here, there, and everywhere. Sad.
Sorry if it seems I'm snapping at specific people. I'm not.
Can't say I've seen a lot post that are just "grr hate grr". Most seem to articulate what causes their dislike.
Exactly, exactly, exactly.
I don't expect anyone to agree with me. I'm used to being a bit outside the Zeitgeist with this stuff, but I think I make some valid points and I try to be really clear and fair when I do. And I feel like that's the same with you, and with other posters who've criticized what they've seen from this movie. And I really haven't seen much, if any, unexplained/unsubstantiated "hating". But I have seen a lot of good, fair points made and questions asked that have been ignored or dismissed as "hating".
Basically... disagree if you want to. Anyone. About anything. But at least respect the person you're disagreeing with and try to match the level of conversation you're wading into. To the folks throwing terms like "haters" and "whiners" around: if I clearly lay out my thoughts and opinions and back them up, and all you've got in response is insults, then maybe you don't have much of an argument yourself.
MrTMNT2012
07-18-2014, 09:04 AM
...haha, what!?
But nah, these Turtles aren't Hulks at all. Nope. :tlol:
No, they're not. Other than their colour and mutated origins, they have almost nothing in common with Hulk. I don't see the Turtles throwing Tanks 100M away or doing anything they haven't done in previous incarnations. So from now on, any character with somewhat super strength should be considered 'Hulks' by your logic?
I don't expect anyone to agree with me. I'm used to being a bit outside the Zeitgeist with this stuff, but I think I make some valid point
You try to, but you really don't. Other than Leo656, I haven't seen one constructive criticism towards the movie besides the usual Bay & Megan Fox hate!
You try to, but you really don't. Other than Leo656, I haven't seen one constructive criticism towards the movie besides the usual Bay & Megan Fox hate!
Bullspit. I've backed up my criticisms constantly. If you can't see that, either you need better reading comprehension skills or you're lying.
There's no point replying to you anymore. Done.
Glados
07-18-2014, 09:10 AM
I was shocked to see that, punching through a window, sure, but the roof of a car...smh. I'm not so upset that it's completely turning me off, but 1) I don't expect that kind of strength or aggressiveness from Mikey 2) it doesn't help the whole this is supposed to be more realistic argument
Wasn't there a little sun-roof (or what ever it's called in English) that he punched through?
Anyway, wow... you people (I'm addressing both camps) need to stop these arguments of who's "better" of the "haters and lovers", it's getting UTTERLY ridiculous! It's like two kindergarten kids just poking each other more and more aggressively, trying to get in the last poke... It doesn't matter, no one wins anything!
Sumac
07-18-2014, 09:40 AM
i never said that. how you even came to that conclusion is kind of a mystery to me considering i never even referenced what you were saying about whatever it was you were talking about.
So existence of serious TMNT works is subjective?
What? They either exist or don't.
Now for the second part:
the idea that someone's (or in this case, a group of someones) problems with a given idea exist only in their heads is just arrogant. and not true. especially in terms of whats being argued here, it is indeed a HIGHLY SUBJECTIVE topic.
Oh my. This is ridiculuous...:lol:
Let me break it just for you:
There is reality: serious TMNT works do exist.
There is an opinion: TMNT can't have serious works.
Opinion doesn't influence reality in this case, since no matter what you believe serious TMNT works do exist and will not dissappear because of your and other people opinions.
And by the way, opinion is something that exists only in your head, it's not part of objective reality. Just part of your mind.
reality being "objective" doesn't mean it fits what you want it to fit, and honestly, i dont even think you used that word in any context that could be considered grammatically correct or significantly relevant.
Sure, pal. When reality doesn't bend to your view it instantly becomes something "not correct or relevant". Ha-ha. Sure, sure.
Warhorse
07-18-2014, 04:34 PM
I was shocked to see that, punching through a window, sure, but the roof of a car...smh. I'm not so upset that it's completely turning me off, but 1) I don't expect that kind of strength or aggressiveness from Mikey 2) it doesn't help the whole this is supposed to be more realistic argument
Yeah. This is something that we would see with Raph (he somewhat did something similar in 2k3, using the handle of his sai the break into the windshield) but, to be honest, when pushed hard enough, Mikey can and does bite back. Who knows, there were rumors a while back that Mikey was going to be tortured, and maybe it's the guy who was torturing him that Mikey goes after.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 07:43 PM
No, they're not. Other than their colour and mutated origins, they have almost nothing in common with Hulk. I don't see the Turtles throwing Tanks 100M away or doing anything they haven't done in previous incarnations. So from now on, any character with somewhat super strength should be considered 'Hulks' by your logic?
You try to, but you really don't. Other than Leo656, I haven't seen one constructive criticism towards the movie besides the usual Bay & Megan Fox hate!
Cept the tmnt don't have super strength... Just intense ninja training. Might as well have batman do the same thing.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 08:01 PM
It's fairly obvious that all the decisions were made working backwards from the kind of scenes the studio execs wanted to see. The size, girth, and strength of the Turtles, and the villains, is clearly in keeping with the kind of action the people making the movie wanted to execute, regardless of whether it fit the characters as we know them. "We want to see Turtles big enough and strong enough to flip over humvees and punch through steel. They're not that? Well, then make 'em that way."
I generally don't like that. The story is supposed to serve the characters, not the other way around.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:05 PM
It's fairly obvious that all the decisions were made working backwards from the kind of scenes the studio execs wanted to see. The size, girth, and strength of the Turtles, and the villains, is clearly in keeping with the kind of action the people making the movie wanted to execute, regardless of whether it fit the characters as we know them. "We want to see Turtles big enough and strong enough to flip over humvees and punch through steel. They're not that? Well, then make 'em that way."
I generally don't like that. The story is supposed to serve the characters, not the other way around.
I wouldn't be surprised. The fact so many people just overlook this or hand wave this so easily makes me wonder if they ever saw the cartoons or comics. It's like to say I'm a fan of daredevil but if I see him kick a van across the street in a movie I'm gonna start calling bs.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 08:05 PM
Cept the tmnt don't have super strength... Just intense ninja training. Might as well have batman do the same thing.
Well, in the first Spider-man trilogy they gave him real webs instead of web shooter. Not sure how people reacted then but i think giving him organic web shooters works on those films. Maybe making the turtles stronger than normal humans will work in this film too.
Xiewin
07-18-2014, 08:09 PM
Well, in the first Spider-man trilogy they gave him real webs instead of web shooter. Not sure how people reacted then but i think giving him organic web shooters works on those films. Maybe making the turtles stronger than normal humans will work in this film too.
I really like the idea that the turtles are more stronger than humans in this film.
I loved tmnt for years but I never liked the fact that they were so much smaller than humans, im glad it was a reverse in the movie.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:12 PM
Well, in the first Spider-man trilogy they gave him real webs instead of web shooter. Not sure how people reacted then but i think giving him organic web shooters works on those films. Maybe making the turtles stronger than normal humans will work in this film too.
People bitched about that crap too. Then we got new movies that fixed it.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 08:12 PM
I really like the idea that the turtles are more stronger than humans in this film.
I loved tmnt for years but I never liked the fact that they were so much smaller than humans, im glad it was a reverse in the movie.
but thats what made them unique they were "normal" they didn't need super strength or super powers or hulking sizes
they have to prove to themselves that they can fend for themselves...as someone mentioned aside from the 80s series they really aren't even superheroes, as they only save the world by accident in most incarnations
you know who else is like that?...batman, the turtles are pretty much a super poor batman
Leo656
07-18-2014, 08:13 PM
See, I get that, and even support it, because the organic web shooters actually, logically works better that way! It never made sense to me that a 16-year-old kid could invent anything that complicated, and further, someone with too much free time recently did a study that proved that Parker would need thousands of gallons of web fluid packed into those things, and they'd be so heavy he couldn't move his arms. Organic web shooters was a rare example of changing something that didn't make ANY sense from a logical standpoint, and fixing it.
The Turtles being super-strong and extra-large, however, serves to "improve" nothing, unless you ever really, really wanted to see Mikey kick someone SO hard they fly 30 feet. "It looks bad-ass" is NOT valid reason for changing something like that. They never needed to be super-strong, just good fighters. Now, they don't even need to be good fighters, because they're super-strong. They actually come closer to breaking the lore than fixing it.
Basically, if the change is an improvement, then fine. Fix it. "It looks cool"? Newp.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:15 PM
Exactly. That's where the ninja training and weapons come in. If these tmnt can punch steel and flip over humvees they don't need weapons or to be ninjas at all. It's like having a character know every known martial arts ever... But then making him as strong as the juggernaut anyway. Why bother.
Xiewin
07-18-2014, 08:22 PM
but thats what made them unique they were "normal" they didn't need super strength or super powers or hulking sizes
you know who else is like that?...batman, they turtles are pretty much a super poor batman
Maybe the super strength is a little bit too overwhelming, but I personally just never liked the fact that they were 4 or 5 feet tall.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 08:23 PM
Exactly. That's where the ninja training and weapons come in. If these tmnt can punch steel and flip over humvees they don't need weapons or to be ninjas at all. It's like having a character know every known martial arts ever... But then making him as strong as the juggernaut anyway. Why bother.
There's also a Spider-Man story where he is trained in kung fu, their reasoning behind that is even if you have super strength it doesn't necessarily make you a great fighter. So I disagree that giving them superhuman strength will make their Ninja trainings useless. I also don't think that these turtles strength is on Spider-Man level let alone the Hulk.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:25 PM
There's also a Spider-Man story where he is trained in kung fu, their reasoning behind that is even if you have super strength it doesn't necessarily make you a great fighter. So I disagree that giving them superhuman strength will make their Ninja trainings useless. I also don't think that these turtles strength is on Spider-Man level let alone the Hulk.
Punching through steel and flipping a van over with a stick is at Spider-man or slightly above Spider-Man level....
Leo656
07-18-2014, 08:29 PM
Maybe the super strength is a little bit too overwhelming, but I personally just never liked the fact that they were 4 or 5 feet tall.
When I used to write fics I personally prefer them taller, too, usually writing them about the same height as the movie, actually - maybe 6 and a half feet tall. But way less bulky.
I think they could be bigger but still not be grossly over-powered. It does make a difference. Superman knows how to box; Wildcat, apparently the greatest hand-to-hand fighter besides Batman in the DCU, taught him how. Does he ever use those skills? Nope, because while he may have those skills, a guy who can punch through a mountain and zap lasers from his eyes has no need to ever do anything else.
Martial arts is all about finesse. These Turtles have zero need for finesse. If they can punch through steel, one punch would take a human's head clean off his neck. It's just badly thought out.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 08:35 PM
Punching through steel and flipping a van over with a stick is at Spider-man or slightly above Spider-Man level....
Maybe you're right but we've seen Spider-Man do more impressive feats than that. But my point still stands, giving them superhuman strength doesn't make the ninja part useless. I'm sure a ninja Hulk is more dangerous than a normal Hulk.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 08:37 PM
Maybe you're right but we've seen Spider-Man do more impressive feats than that. But my point still stands, giving them superhuman strength doesn't make the ninja part useless. I'm sure a ninja Hulk is more dangerous than a normal Hulk.
Spiderman was created with Super Human strength though...like Superman its more him learning a skill after gaining Super Powers
if the turtles were always Super powered and then learned martial arts it would be the same thing
size i will give you maybe 4ft is to small i to usually make my turtles a average human height, with mike always being shirtest
but 6-7th is way to big especially when you roid them out so much
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 08:40 PM
Spiderman was created with Super Human strength though...like Superman its more him learning a skill after gaining Super Powers
if the turtles were always Super powered and then learned martial arts it would be the same thing
My initial point is in the movies they gave him organic webs instead of web shooters, and it works well in those films. So I will repeat again, making the turtles stronger than normal humans may work in this movie.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 08:49 PM
But see, while I get the point you're attempting, I think the logic doesn't work. Organic web shooters is, objectively, better. It took something that didn't make sense, outside of Comic Book Logic, and made it work. Having the Turtles be super-strong creates MORE gaps in logic, not fewer. "I can punch through a wall. Must I learn how to spin-kick?"
Mike Tyson. Was he a "finesse" fighter? Or did he just plain beat guys' faces into mulch because he could? If you can physically overpower someone, you do that.
There's no reason for it other than the studio decided they wanted to make a super-hero movie, and re-created the Turtles to fit that mold. Simple as that. It's not "better" that way. I'd argue they can have the same amount of action in the movie without that new wrinkle.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 08:52 PM
look at it this way in the bts we see Mikey punch through the car roof with ease
in trailers we see Michelangelo punch a guy in the face same force
where is the consistency? that guys face should be on the wall.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 08:53 PM
But see, while I get the point you're attempting, I think the logic doesn't work. Organic web shooters is, objectively, better. It took something that didn't make sense, outside of Comic Book Logic, and made it work. Having the Turtles be super-strong creates MORE gaps in logic, not fewer. "I can punch through a wall. Must I learn how to spin-kick?"
Mike Tyson. Was he a "finesse" fighter? Or did he just plain beat guys' faces into mulch because he could? If you can physically overpower someone, you do that.
There's no reason for it other than the studio decided they wanted to make a super-hero movie, and re-created the Turtles to fit that mold. Simple as that. It's not "better" that way. I'd argue they can have the same amount of action in the movie without that new wrinkle.
Plus at that size back flipping, cartwheeling and spin kicking is gonna obviously look fake and make then look cartoonish. They're obviously heavy as hell. Making then seem weightless is gonna look as bad as that first hulk movie.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 09:02 PM
look at it this way in the bts we see Mikey punch through the car roof with ease
in trailers we see Michelangelo punch a guy in the face same force
where is the consistency? that guys face should be on the wall.
So we are all in agreement that these turtles are on Spider-man level strength,right?but did we ever see Spider-Man punch someone's head off? I really hate to say this but sometimes we just don't want change. Even the organic webs is objectively better when it was announced that the new Spider-Man film will have the web shooter back the fans reaction is very positive because it's comic accurate. Heck, there are even people that wants a new Batman movie with blue and grey costume.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 09:05 PM
So we are all in agreement that these turtles are on Spider-man level strength,right?but did we ever see Spider-Man punch someone's head off? I really hate to say this but sometimes we just don't want change. Even the organic webs is objectively better when it was announced that the new Spider-Man film will have the web shooter back the fans reaction is very positive because it's comic accurate. Heck, there are even people that wants a new Batman movie with blue and grey costume.
Change is one thing. These guys are more like 'your turtles sucks. Let's show you how ninja turtles are REALLY done. Our version will knock your version out of the park'.
Honestly... It does kinda look like these guys can mop the floor with the mirage 80s 2k3 and nick tmnt all at once.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 09:05 PM
Usually Spider-Man only hits guys that can take it, and the rest of the time, he does something else.
Some things just don't make sense, and the "people just don't want change" argument is weak. Change is fine if it's fixing things, not when it creates new problems OR was only done "because it looks cool." Nothing should ever, ever be done just because "It looks cool." That's pandering.
Change is one thing. These guys are more like 'your turtles sucks. Let's show you how ninja turtles are REALLY done. Our version will knock your version out of the park'.
Yeah, the attitude of the people making the movie isn't helping. "Everyone before us was wrong. We know better." It's pretty arrogant, regardless how the movie turns out.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 09:14 PM
Usually Spider-Man only hits guys that can take it, and the rest of the time, he does something else.
Some things just don't make sense, and the "people just don't want change" argument is weak. Change is fine if it's fixing things, not when it creates new problems OR was only done "because it looks cool." Nothing should ever, ever be done just because "It looks cool." That's pandering.
Yeah, the attitude of the people making the movie isn't helping. "Everyone before us was wrong. We know better." It's pretty arrogant, regardless how the movie turns out.
The main thing is most of the people blindly supporting this are proving them right.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 09:18 PM
The main thing is most of the people blindly supporting this are proving them right.
I give up. There's really no point in arguing with you people.
Xiewin
07-18-2014, 09:20 PM
The main thing is most of the people blindly supporting this are proving them right.
please stop with the insults...
Leo656
07-18-2014, 09:26 PM
terrorblade/Xelwin: There's a distinction in what Coola said. "Blindly supporting." There are various "camps" even among people who support the movie. Some, are willing to give it a chance and are being optimistic about it. Others - the ones *I* have a problem with as well - are the ones who swear it has to be good based on the TMNT brand name alone, and that the brand name alone is worthy of our dollars, regardless of quality.
I didn't read that as, "Everyone who is supporting the movie is a blind loyalist, and proving the studio right," I read it as, "The ones who say they will love the movie even if it's terrible are proving the studio right that nothing matters but the brand name."
Again, there's a distinction. A subtle, yet important one.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 09:30 PM
terrorblade/Xelwin: There's a distinction in what Coola said. "Blindly supporting." There are various "camps" even among people who support the movie. Some, are willing to give it a chance and are being optimistic about it. Others - the ones *I* have a problem with as well - are the ones who swear it has to be good based on the TMNT brand name alone, and that the brand name alone is worthy of our dollars, regardless of quality.
I didn't read that as, "Everyone who is supporting the movie is a blind loyalist, and proving the studio right," I read it as, "The ones who say they will love the movie even if it's terrible are proving the studio right that nothing matters but the brand name."
Again, there's a distinction. A subtle, yet important one.
But there's also people who blindly hates this movie but is it really necessary to brought them up?
Ok, i'm back to arguing again.:lol:
Leo656
07-18-2014, 09:36 PM
Some, yeah, but it's not fair to paint everyone on either side with the same brush. People change their minds every day about stuff like this! I was on board with the movie way early on until I saw the visual style and got a whiff of the story. I don't like it, so I probably won't pay theater price for it, but I'm not "blindly hating" it, myself. And to be fair, I don't think anyone on "Your Side" thinks I am. I've explained my position. But so have others, and I still see them called "haters", and it ain't right, or even accurate.
Some people are blindly hating and some are blindly loving, yeah. But not everyone is one or the other, not even close.
And for Chtulu's sake, who's arguing? About any of it? I swear, nobody should ever be allowed to post on a forum until they can pass a written exam on the differences between "Arguing" and "Debating". One implies people are mad at each other, the other just implies they don't agree but really, really like talking about how they don't agree.
I ain't mad at anyone for liking this thing. I don't get it, but that's all your prerogative. But what's wrong with ***talking*** about how we disagree? Maybe I'm crazy, but I think that's healthy.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 09:43 PM
Some, yeah, but it's not fair to paint everyone on either side with the same brush. People change their minds every day about stuff like this! I was on board with the movie way early on until I saw the visual style and got a whiff of the story. I don't like it, so I probably won't pay theater price for it, but I'm not "blindly hating" it, myself. And to be fair, I don't think anyone on "Your Side" thinks I am. I've explained my position. But so have others, and I still see them called "haters", and it ain't right, or even accurate.
Some people are blindly hating and some are blindly loving, yeah. But not everyone is one or the other, not even close.
And for Chtulu's sake, who's arguing? About any of it? I swear, nobody should ever be allowed to post on a forum until they can pass a written exam on the differences between "Arguing" and "Debating". One implies people are mad at each other, the other just implies they don't agree but really, really like talking about how they don't agree.
I ain't mad at anyone for liking this thing. I don't get it, but that's all your prerogative. But what's wrong with ***talking*** about how we disagree? Maybe I'm crazy, but I think that's healthy.
I know it's really low to do this but I have to defend myself lol.
ar·gue
ˈärgyo͞o/
verb
gerund or present participle: arguing
give reasons or cite evidence in support of an idea, action, or theory, typically with the aim of persuading others to share one's view.
In logic and philosophy, an argument is an attempt to persuade someone of something, by giving reasons for accepting a particular conclusion as evident.The general form of an argument in a natural language is that of premises (typically in the form of propositions, statements or sentences) in support of a claim: the conclusion. The structure of some arguments can also be set out in a formal language, and formally defined "arguments" can be made independently of natural language arguments, as in math, logic and computer science.
Sighphi
07-18-2014, 09:45 PM
Chill out, dudes, this thread is about how cartoony this movie is. This is not about hating each other but learning to love this live action cartoon. I mean, seriously, they have stepped up the cartoon stuff to the max now. The flipping of the truck is the least cartoony thing at this point.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 09:52 PM
I know it's really low to do this but I have to defend myself lol.
Uhh, there wasn't an "attack" so there was nothing to "defend", boss. You do seem to have a problem, at times, knowing the difference between someone arguing and someone debating, but that could just as well be because text doesn't carry tone. I didn't say you, specifically, had no clue.
I generally speak to "The Room", no need to take it personally.
terrorblade
07-18-2014, 09:56 PM
Sorry then I use the word arguing in my last two posts so I thought you were referring to me. It doesn't change the fact we are still arguing though.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 10:05 PM
I ain't arguing, buddy. :) I mean, you saying you were arguing with someone was what prompted my reply, but I wasn't exactly swiping at you either.
Every thread gets like that, I hate it. Half the time it doesn't even look like anyone's arguing, then people get all "Stop arguing", and it's like, "Well, I don't agree with this guy, but I'm not arguing with him, and I prefer to not simply not talk," so what's a guy to do?
I'unno. Maybe you're arguing, but you and I aren't arguing. I just think some of your logic is a little flimsy and pointing out where the holes are. Ain't mad at ya.
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 10:36 PM
terrorblade/Xelwin: There's a distinction in what Coola said. "Blindly supporting." There are various "camps" even among people who support the movie. Some, are willing to give it a chance and are being optimistic about it. Others - the ones *I* have a problem with as well - are the ones who swear it has to be good based on the TMNT brand name alone, and that the brand name alone is worthy of our dollars, regardless of quality.
I didn't read that as, "Everyone who is supporting the movie is a blind loyalist, and proving the studio right," I read it as, "The ones who say they will love the movie even if it's terrible are proving the studio right that nothing matters but the brand name."
Again, there's a distinction. A subtle, yet important one.
Leo gets me. Some people actually wanna see the movie out of curiosity. But some see all these needless changes and screw ups slap them in the face and continues to insist it'll be the best thing ever. Every step of the way we heard bad thing after bad thing and the only defense was 'wait and see'. We waited and now we saw. Still crap. He'll most of it was the same crap we were worried about except now we have the visual evidence to prove we were right. People still don't care and still insist it will be best thing ever. I bet after the movie is out and we hate it there will still be people saying we hated it 'because we didn't understand it'.
It boggles the mind how you can be a fan of something and then support something that is ruining and screwing up the thing you're supposed to be a fan of.
It's like Leo said. Leave the dramatic changes and experimentation stuff for the cartoons and such. That's why there's stuff like Fast Forward and reincarnated IDW tmnt. A franchise movie that's supposed to introduce the general audience to the tmnt should share more with the actual material so people know what they're all about after the movie is over.
That's why we don't have a batman movie be like Beware The Batman for example. You don't make a movie with katana as a sidekick and a gun toting Alfred.
Raven
07-18-2014, 10:43 PM
Leo gets me. Some people actually wanna see the movie out of curiosity. But some see all these needless changes and screw ups slap them in the face and continues to insist it'll be the best thing ever. Every step of the way we heard bad thing after bad thing and the only defense was 'wait and see'. We waited and now we saw. Still crap. He'll most of it was the same crap we were worried about except now we have the visual evidence to prove we were right. People still don't care and still insist it will be best thing ever. I bet after the movie is out and we hate it there will still be people saying we hated it 'because we didn't understand it'.
It boggles the mind how you can be a fan of something and then support something that is ruining and screwing up the thing you're supposed to be a fan of.
It's like Leo said. Leave the dramatic changes and experimentation stuff for the cartoons and such. That's why there's stuff like Fast Forward and reincarnated IDW tmnt. A franchise movie that's supposed to introduce the general audience to the tmnt should share more with the actual material so people know what they're all about after the movie is over.
That's why we don't have a batman movie be like Beware The Batman for example. You don't make a movie with katana as a sidekick and a gun toting Alfred.
I think thats really the hardest part of the TMNT franchise, is so little of it remains consistent with a past iteration of itself. I agree this movie has a lot of bad things going for it and much of it looks terrible (although the fight scenes look to be quite fun).
But the film makers only seem to be familiar with the OT, so it makes sense that they would approach it in this weird manner. (I think I'm grasping for straws now, lol).
Theres two problems that any franchise faces when its getting turned into a movie. One it sticks so close to the source material that its boring, dull and overly predicable. I personally don't want to see that (Although 300 and watchmen did a fantastic job with this approach.)
Then theres the other issue, straying so far from the source that its almost unrecognizable. I think this movie is leaning closer in this area, I wish they would of found a nice middle ground. Keep it fresh but stay true to the heart of the concept...and not bring in four hulk looking turtles.
Leo656
07-18-2014, 10:54 PM
I liked "Watchmen". I get the criticism that it was "too reverent", but what the hell are you supposed to do with that? That's the story the guy wrote! That's the way it looked! I mean, I respect Alan Moore. A lot. I don't like everything he wrote, but he's one of the best. Take what he wrote... and mess with it? Do "My Version" of it? I'd never be so presumptuous as to even subliminally suggest that my ideas were somehow better than his. I mean, they did make some changes, but even Moore always said he hated the comic's ending, and he wrote the thing.
I've heard people say "Just don't make the movie at all," but that wasn't realistic. DC/WB was always going to do it eventually just because it's one of their biggest moneymakers of all time in print. I'd rather see a super-"stiff" version of it than one that was the same in name only. All the important parts were intact. The only thing I didn't like was when they'd play the "Bad Guy Music" every time Ozymandias was on screen. I mean, if you read it, you know, but that was some pretty over-done "foreshadowing".
I've seen bits of some of the earlier scripts that took some bigger departures from the source, and they were awful. "Dr. Manhattan undoes his own creation and everyone else zaps into a parallel universe where they only ever existed as comic book characters" was awwwwwwful. Thank god they got away from thinking crap like that would play.
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-18-2014, 11:00 PM
Then theres the other issue, straying so far from the source that its almost unrecognizable. I think this movie is leaning closer in this area, I wish they would of found a nice middle ground. Keep it fresh but stay true to the heart of the concept...and not bring in four hulk looking turtles.
as i said before i think the problem with saying you are sticking close to the source of tmnt, comes from the many many, iterations, adaptations and Multiverses
as you,i and Leo have said the OT seems to be their main source
with a few sprinkles here and there from other versions...but how deep they went into them is unknown
its the same problem they will have in a power rangers movie if they say they are going to stick to its source..hence why they are making sure its lablbed a Mighty Morphin film...there so many "Origins" and chapters that they in a way could all be source
Gimme_Three
07-18-2014, 11:00 PM
Exactly. That's where the ninja training and weapons come in. If these tmnt can punch steel and flip over humvees they don't need weapons or to be ninjas at all. It's like having a character know every known martial arts ever... But then making him as strong as the juggernaut anyway. Why bother.
They are trained as kids, How's splinter to know how big they'd grow. I like the fact that of splinter training them to be ninjas to stay hidden and protect themselves. The trailers suggest splinter is training them to be heroes (not a fan of) I'm not a fan of their strength but at the same time I know that it will deliver some wow factors during action/fight scenes which is exciting.
Raven
07-18-2014, 11:10 PM
as i said before i think the problem with saying you are sticking close to the source of tmnt, comes from the many many, iterations, adaptations and Multiverses
Thats really the hardest part of the TMNT, sure its mutagen that created them but that can be done so many different ways. Such as is Yoshi Splinter or a human, or does Yoshi exist at all?
Its not as straight forward as Superman or Batman, where it was one event that set them forward on their journey. The Turtles really don't have that one specific thing (Esp. if you take Yoshi out of the picture).
But I'm talking on not a lot of sleep and have no clue if I'm making any sense anymore, lol.
Also, when ever some one talks about the source material many of us right away assume the 1st issue, the mirage run and such. But I'm sure many people outside of us would jump to the OT (the film makers).
Coola Yagami
07-18-2014, 11:18 PM
Well... The one specific thing is they were regular turtles covered in ooze.... And they almost ruined that by wanting to make them aliens.
Xiewin
07-19-2014, 12:14 AM
It boggles the mind how you can be a fan of something and then support something that is ruining and screwing up the thing you're supposed to be a fan of.
Maybe because I like the changes? How does this not make me a fan of tmnt??
Shark_Blade
07-19-2014, 05:58 AM
Maybe because I like the changes? How does this not make me a fan of tmnt??
Agree. Some changes are for the better in certain cases.
It's just some purists got so level headed they think some people are not "true fans" when it's not how they want it to be.
Leo656
07-19-2014, 08:18 AM
It's less a matter of being a "true fan", more about what some people on either side of the debate consider to be questionable tastes in general.
I mean, believe it or not, some people like The Grateful Dead. Now, those people, frankly, should never be allowed to vote or otherwise have an influence in anything, because admitting, out loud and in public, that you enjoy The Grateful Dead is quite literally the musical equivalent of admitting you can't tell the difference between goat piss and lemonade. But... they're absolutely entitled to their opinion. :)
Point being, some people simply can't understand why some people find certain things appealing. It has little to nothing to do with being a "true fan" of anything. Some people like coconut, and some people think those people are crazy. F*ck the first group, by the way. :P
TheJ-manTurtleMan
07-19-2014, 09:59 AM
...I like the Grateful Dead and coconuts...
Leo656
07-19-2014, 10:08 AM
Please tell me you also enjoy sardines and the films of Tyler Perry. Even if it's not true, just lie to me. :lol:
Coola Yagami
07-19-2014, 10:19 AM
It's less a matter of being a "true fan", more about what some people on either side of the debate consider to be questionable tastes in general.
I mean, believe it or not, some people like The Grateful Dead. Now, those people, frankly, should never be allowed to vote or otherwise have an influence in anything, because admitting, out loud and in public, that you enjoy The Grateful Dead is quite literally the musical equivalent of admitting you can't tell the difference between goat piss and lemonade. But... they're absolutely entitled to their opinion. :)
Point being, some people simply can't understand why some people find certain things appealing. It has little to nothing to do with being a "true fan" of anything. Some people like coconut, and some people think those people are crazy. F*ck the first group, by the way. :P
I see it more like... You like batman due to his tragic backstory his mastery of fighting styles the fact he can do so much while still being just a regular human, master detective, awesome villains, blah blah blah.
Then they make a movie with Bruce's parents being alive and him becoming a hero for the hell of it, him unable to fight worth jack but he has a super bat suit that basically does all the fighting for him, and him being a dumbass incompetent while Robin is doing all the detective work and problem solving. As the movies villian is crazy quilt and egghead.
And yet you still go see it and treat it like the best movie ever and it inspires sequels. Instead of you know... Having the character you like and series you like be completely ruined and spit on.
That's my viewpoint. That's just my opinion and how I see it. This movie is the Db evolution and Mario bros movie version of the ninja turtles. Ruining and changing everything that would make you a tmnt fan in the first place. And yet for whatever reason so many people are loving it. And I don't mean like Leo says that 'it's so terrible but I'll still support it cause it's tmnt' no I mean actually like it. When a movie screws up and spits on the series and characters you like and yet you like it anyway, it makes me wonder if you really liked the series all that much to begin with.
I didn't like db evolution cause I'm a DBZ fan. I didn't like mk Armageddon cause im a mk fan. I didn't like legend of chun li cause I'm a street fighter fan. I'm not gonna enjoy tmnt 2014 cause I'm a tmnt fan. All I can really say is 'at least the fights will be awesome and hey we see Megan O'Neil bend way over while Vernon cracks a joke' But everything else, no. Just no.
Leo656
07-19-2014, 10:22 AM
Breaking it down like that, it's pretty understandable. "Why call it 'X' when it's really not 'X', it's 'Y'?" I get that.
And the world, sadly, just ain't ready for Crazy Quilt. :lol: (Kudos for Obscure Reference, by the way)
Heh... "Legend of Chun-Li"... well, if absolutely nothing else, we know TMNT cannot possibly be any worse than that. They'd have to literally be trying to see if it was possible to make a movie so bad it somehow gave human beings feline AIDS.
That movie... was not good.
slingtheory
07-19-2014, 11:07 AM
yeah I'd never take it upon myself to say somebody isn't a true fan no matter how much I disagree with them. I get that there are people who are genuinely excited about the changes but to me its just not tmnt. I agree with coola in that to me it does look like the super Mario bros. movie or dbe take on the turtles where the characters are there, they have the right names, hell in some cases the right personality but its still a far cry from what the source material intended it to be. what its always been. and that puts me off of it as a fan of the original material. and I really don't understand the thought process behind making a movie this way were you risk alienating a lot of the established fan base by putting your own spin on things. that says to me that you don't think the content is strong enough to succeed as is in movie form without you attempting to improve it and that's a pretty crappy way to go about an adaptation in my opinion. it makes you wonder what do you even get if you succeed. if people latch onto the revised version are they really likely to stick around and get into the other stuff that's so different than what you've done. wouldn't it make more sense if the movie was a little more cohesive to the rest of the franchise in an effort to show general audiences whats so great about it and grow the fanbase. that's my take on it anyway I don't know. my question to everybody who likes what they've done with the characters is this what you guys want to see going forward in everything turtles related or are you considering it just a one off.
pennydreadful
07-19-2014, 05:58 PM
Hey now here's a question - we all know I like "bad" movies... if I end up not liking this movie, does that mean it's good? Or if I end up liking it, does it mean it's bad? :P I just blew your minds...
Jester
07-19-2014, 06:02 PM
Hey now here's a question - we all know I like "bad" movies... if I end up not liking this movie, does that mean it's good? Or if I end up liking it, does it mean it's bad? :P I just blew your minds...
I know the feeling. One of my favorite movies is the Jesse Ventura classic Abraxas....it's soooooo bad.
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 06:34 PM
Hey now here's a question - we all know I like "bad" movies... if I end up not liking this movie, does that mean it's good? Or if I end up liking it, does it mean it's bad? :P I just blew your minds...
Stop stop stop... you're gonna tear a hole in the universe proposing these ideas, and then the Turtles have to save it and these 2014 guys are too new, they aren't ready for that yet!
pennydreadful
07-19-2014, 06:47 PM
http://rymimg.com/lk/l/w/693cf87e775624a7f263f1b3432052af/5259590.gif
But if I tear open an interdimensional rift, your chances of capturing Leo increase exponentially... *innocent eyes*
Shark_Blade
07-19-2014, 06:50 PM
No one knows it's entirely good or bad yet, we've only seen glimpses (and I'm liking it a lot so far).
It's not long now..:D
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 07:08 PM
http://rymimg.com/lk/l/w/693cf87e775624a7f263f1b3432052af/5259590.gif
But if I tear open an interdimensional rift, your chances of capturing Leo increase exponentially... *innocent eyes*
But I think that might require a spacesuit and I have none.:cry:
pennydreadful
07-19-2014, 07:12 PM
Nah, just tempt him over to our side by waving pizza and a copy of The Ultimate History of Katana at him. :P
IndigoErth
07-19-2014, 07:25 PM
:lol::lol::lol: Sounds like a plan!
The Boston Ninja Turtle
07-19-2014, 09:16 PM
I know the feeling. One of my favorite movies is the Jesse Ventura classic Abraxas....it's soooooo bad.
Suburban Commando is one of my all time favorite Movies
samxsteal
07-19-2014, 10:45 PM
I know the feeling. One of my favorite movies is the Jesse Ventura classic Abraxas....it's soooooo bad.
Surf ninjas, three ninjas(except that high noon mountain one that one was stupid)
Leo656
07-20-2014, 12:54 AM
Suburban Commando is one of the greatest movies ever made.
Fixed.
three ninjas(except that high noon mountain one that one was stupid)
http://cineplex.media.baselineresearch.com/images/275612/275612_full.jpg
Dave f*cking Dragon is not f*cking amused.
Jester
07-20-2014, 12:57 AM
This is another one of my al time favorite bad flicks:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/91/Santa_With_Muscles.jpg
Ed Begley Jr, Mila Kunis, Garrett Morris and the Hulkster makes for a fun time, brother.
samxsteal
07-20-2014, 01:06 AM
Fixed.
http://cineplex.media.baselineresearch.com/images/275612/275612_full.jpg
Dave f*cking Dragon is not f*cking amused.
Really it wasn't his fault more like the writer and pretty but every other actor involved
Leo656
07-20-2014, 01:21 AM
Jester: He totally saved the f*ck out of that orphanage. I wish magic crystals were growing under MY house. :ohwell:
sam: Whenever people say Hogan never "did business", I direct them to that movie, where he repeatedly did the job for Loni f*cking Anderson. :lol: That dude put over eeeeeeveryone.
Also: BEST toupee ever.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.