PDA

View Full Version : The Rock Confirmed To Play Black Adam In DC's "SHAZAM" Movie


Pages : 1 [2]

Andrew NDB
10-18-2022, 06:40 PM
Yeah, that reviewer does seem to have it out for the movie, to be fair.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 06:45 PM
I'll be honest, I'm going for The Cameo and that's it. Movie looks "just fine" but if it legit moves me or surprises me, I'll be shocked. That said, I don't see anything to suggest it's Actually Bad. I don't even like The Rock, but I've been saying for years that playing this character is like the only reason he was even born so I'm supportive of it.

Like it's probably VERY over-stuffed, I would guess. But that's probably as bad as it gets.

Now, if people overwhelmingly love THIS DC movie with a half-dozen brand-new characters who never got a solo movie crammed into it, and it's the same people who hated on BvS and Justice League for that reason... someone is gonna have to explain to me once and for all how Anti-Snyder Bias isn't real. We'll see what happens with that.

Andrew NDB
10-18-2022, 06:53 PM
The Rock: "I don't want Black Adam's origin and rise to be lost in a movie he has to share with Shazam."

Also the Rock: "OK, let's put the entire Justice Society of America into the Black Adam movie."

Autbot_Benz
10-18-2022, 06:56 PM
‘Black Adam’ Review: Dwayne Johnson’s Superhero Debut Is Another Catastrophe for DC’s Film Universe (https://www.indiewire.com/2022/10/black-adam-movie-review-1234773729/)

Hm......

LMAO The writer calls the JSA the "DCEU's Farm Team" and that they get into "minor league scraps". geeze

Who pissed in that dumbasses's cereal

Taking a page out of the Brie Larson/Women director's handbook

she dispatches the Justice Society of America to get him under control, because there’s nothing DCEU movies love more than assembling a team of people that general audiences have never heard of and couldn’t possibly care about.

This movie isn't made for you you being the general audience :roll:

Leo656
10-18-2022, 06:58 PM
Andrew: :lol: Right? But that screams "WB Decision" to me. Obviously they're not gonna give the guy EVERY concession he asked for every time.

Plus if we really break it down, most of Black Adam's important stories have more to do with the JSA than Captain Marvel, anyhow. Like yes clearly he was created to be Captain Marvel's main villain but for the last two decades he's much more a JSA villain. So it's not a decision without logic to it. By this point you "can't" have Black Adam without including the JSA somehow, they're too entangled.

Plus they REALLY gotta pump up "Shazam" before he takes a swing at Black Adam. In the movies the guy's a f*cking clown, they can't put him against Black Adam until they course-correct and turn Shazam into a more serious character who can hold his own. Going by the sequel trailer, they're doing the opposite. So who knows what will happen but as of Right Now putting Cap and Adam together would be a very bad idea.

Autbot_Benz
10-18-2022, 07:00 PM
Also to that angry reviewer read a ****ing comic book or look up the JSA on the DC Wiki. its simple:lol:

Leo656
10-18-2022, 07:04 PM
Biggest gripe with me:

MoS established that Superman was The First. The world lost their minds because he was an Unknown Unknown.

Now there's a JSA and apparently has been for a while. I'm dying to hear the explanation and I'm hoping it's at least plausible.

Coola Yagami
10-18-2022, 07:21 PM
So okay, two things I feel obligated to mention out of hand:

1. Legitimately, this is the first outright negative review I've read. Most are saying it's no worse than "decent if predictable", and more are saying it's actually Pretty Good.

2. More importantly, the author of this review makes no attempt whatsoever to hide their disdain for super-hero movies. He makes repeated mention of how same-y, boring, predictable, and irritating they are (to him).

So basically, "I don't like super-hero movies, and therefore I hate this one too, because it does what all of them do." I'm paraphrasing, but that's essentially the review.

It's his opinion, but to me it's why people who don't like punk rock shouldn't review punk albums; you can have an opinion, but your opinion needs an asterisk besides it because you're entirely not the audience for the material. Or it'd be like me reviewing a Grateful Dead album. "This is one of the worst albums I ever heard... just like ALL of the other ones by this band." Would you take my review seriously? Probably not.

We'll see what comes of it, I'm hoping to go this weekend. Just saying, it took me all of 15 seconds to realize that this guy has an axe to grind with the entire genre. Movie might be lackluster but I certainly wouldn't take his word for it.

So far, the thing that gives me some concern is that between the "homage" shots to Snyder's movies, and the fact that they shot the movie as a Hard R and then edited it down to PG-13... it kinda seems like they're trying to mimic Snyder as hard as they can in a very superficial way, and that can turn out Good or Bad and we won't know until it's all out there in front of us.

Stuff like this is why they call Sushi-X to review fighting games and not the guy that hates them and only like RPGs.

Autbot_Benz
10-18-2022, 07:28 PM
They did some JSA tie in comics for the movie so that might explain how they came to be in the movie verse

Leo656
10-18-2022, 07:28 PM
Stuff like this is why they call Sushi-X to review fighting games and not the guy that hates them and only like RPGs.

Well, I mean the great thing about EGM was once in a while they WOULD let the RPG guy review a fighting game... and if RPG Guy liked said fighting game, as much as Sushi-X did, then you KNEW it had to be at least decent if the guy who wasn't even a fan of the genre had a blast with it. That's what got me into Soul Calibur; I didn't play fighting games, wasn't any good at them, but EVERYBODY loved that one so I knew it was worth my time to check out, and lo and behold it was. If only the hardcore fighting game fans liked it, it wouldn't have moved me at all, I only cared when the "casuals" also said it was a 10. So it's not like it's a bad idea to get a cross-section of opinions.

I'm not against casting a wide net and collecting a wide range of opinions, I mean that's what it's about. But I always say to really listen when someone tells you who they are... so if a guy gives a comic book movie a bad review AND makes repeated mention of the fact he also hates comic book movies in general... well, I'm going to weigh ALL of the data, including the fact that the guy probably went in expecting to have a bad time and then, shockingly, had a bad time.

Like I know there will be other bad reviews, there always are, but if a guy repeatedly can't help but say "I hate these movies" I'm just plain not going to listen to that, I think that's bad/lazy criticism. Like, even if I end up hating the movie I would still think the review itself was bad because it came from an intellectually dishonest place.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 07:41 PM
They did some JSA tie in comics for the movie so that might explain how they came to be in the movie verse

I didn't see those.

To be blunt, the entire DCEU timeline/canon is a mess anyway so it's not like it really matters at this point. But one of the biggest and most fundamental points of Snyder's plan was that Superman was the beacon who drew the others out, Wonder Woman was around but was a cipher nobody knew existed and Batman was in the shadows as a myth, everyone else came after that, inspired by Superman revealing himself to the world.

So now, it's kinda "bad" enough that there's 80 million superheroes suddenly tripping over each other in the movies since they decided not to actually do the legwork and instead just drop them on everyone as if they'd always been there, but I mean, the toothpaste is out of the tube on that. But I mean, the JSA isn't the Suicide Squad, they're rather a big deal and this universe barely has a Justice LEAGUE, so 1. Where did these people come from? and 2. How long have they been around?

I know I pretty much have to just accept ANY explanation and shrug, at this point, I just hope it doesn't stretch credibility TOO much, is all. Like, "They TOO have been operating secretly in the shadows since 50+ years ago... just like This One and That One and..." Like that would just be the worst since they've run that well dry by now between Wonder Woman and the Squad and everything else. Plus it just ruins the entire point of MoS and everything it was designed to set up. "Superman was the Very First Super-Hero and his appearance changed the whole world! ...Except not, because there were actually like 100 other guys first, AND the government knew about them and just decided to act all shocked when Superman showed up." Like, it just creates a lot of really bad wrinkles in the storytelling.

Even "This JSA showed up 5 minutes ago" would be a bit of a stretch from a different direction, but I mean, it would be better, kind of, a little.

Coola Yagami
10-18-2022, 07:53 PM
Like in the movies, the Justice League pretty much don't exist. They've only been united in one movie and I forgot if the world at large knew about them. I'm not sure how popular the Avengers were to the world in their first movie, but they've been around long enough that several movies in the world at large now knows of them. But yeah, the JL barely exists and now they want to say the JSA is a big deal that's either always been around or is known by all?

They really dropped the ball.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 08:00 PM
I mean, most/all of the movies we're getting Now weren't supposed to come out until AFTER Justice League 3. Therein lies the problem. JL3 would have ended with Superman uniting literally the entire world behind him to stop Darkseid - the JLA, the Marines, the Amazons, the Atlanteans, everybody - and after that would be the foretold "New Age Of Heroes". But see, people thought the Blues in Snyder's color palette weren't Blue Enough, pitched a giant hissy fit, and so all that went in the garbage.

It's even worse because most people really liked Snyder's Justice League once they finally saw it. There was a lot of, "Ohhhhhh I see where this was all going, now" and they were happy with it, they wanted to see where it was gonna go. So as I was saying at the time, if people had just f*cking WAITED and let the story play out as intended, everyone would have been happy and we wouldn't be in the mess we're in Now.

So now we have all this confusion and even the movies like Flash that were designed to "fix it all" just become more convoluted as a result of all the retcons and release dates getting pushed back and all the other stuff.

Literally, if people had just shut up and let things be, everything would be Fine. But noooooooooooo. :roll: A'ight. Don't cry about how messy sh*t is now, then, you forfeited your right to do that back in 2017.

I mean, *I* will still cry about how messy it all is Now, but that's because I was Right about everything Back Then and history has vindicated me in that. :lol: So I'll just sit here with my giant box of "Told Ya So's" and heckle from the cheap seats. :trazz:

Leo656
10-18-2022, 08:18 PM
So I am seeing more and more mixed-to-negative revews but they're a bit more even-handed.

Common criticisms seem to be:

- Rock is too stoic and bland. To be expected, it's a stoic character and frankly, Dwayne is not a good actor. He's great at playing Himself, a goofy, cheerful, smiling dipsh*t but he can't really convey emotions or depth well. So I completely believe this is dead-on, but also, that it's kind of to be expected.

- Should have been a JSA movie with Black Adam as the villain, and it would have worked MUCH better than it being "A Black Adam movie with the JSA crammed in". Lots of praise for the JSA, especially Dr. Fate, but Adam himself comes off one-note.

This was obviously WB bending over for the biggest star in Hollywood and his massive ego, but yeah, it makes sense and it's something I feared from the jump.

- Lots and lots of second-rate "homages" to Snyder's visual style - blatantly stolen shots from Snyder's DC movies, the "slow-mo/speed-up" effect being used often, etc. - and they just don't land well because... Zack Snyder didn't direct it.

- Big chunks of the movie seem to be missing, and it affects everything from plot to pacing. We know this for a fact because again, they shot it for a hard R rating and then chopped it down to PG-13. Worked GREAT for BvS, right?! :roll:

There's other stuff too, like the plot being over-stuffed and it making no sense why the JSA would even work with a scumbag like Waller in the first place. It definitely sounds like a mixed bag of a movie for sure.

But see, the people saying this stuff are easier to believe when they don't pause every five minutes to say "Oh, by the way, I hate these movies as a rule."

Sounds like I'll think it's about a 7 out of 10 in the end, but we'll see.

I'm just gonna be the most unpopular guy in the room as usual and say that WB should have just made nice with Zack and given him this project to do. It's entirely in his wheelhouse, and if they're gonna do sh*t like "Shoot the movie One Way and then butcher it in post-production" and rip off a bunch of his shots - badly - then why not just let HIM do it since he's already done this before? Snyder doing Black Adam would be an easy 10 out of 10, especially if they let it be R Rated. Someone else pretending to be Zack Snyder... eh. 6 or 7 out of 10, sounds like.

Goes to show how much they hate the guy. Ah well.

IMJ
10-18-2022, 08:28 PM
The Rock: "I don't want Black Adam's origin and rise to be lost in a movie he has to share with Shazam."

Also the Rock: "OK, let's put the entire Justice Society of America into the Black Adam movie."

This was obviously WB bending over for the biggest star in Hollywood and his massive ego

Totally self-serving, IMHO. Black Adam is, generally speaking, a nothing burger DC villain who has been used well maybe.... twice. As if Black Adam's "origin and rise" are held in the highest levels of comic book esteem or something.

I actually don't mind this whole thing. I generally like the Rock. But the point to me is that, as usual, I just don't like phony or woefully incompetent bull$#!( from anybody. It's like "dude, Rock. You strong armed a full movie for a D-List villain from DC and probably leveraged their need for a hit to do it. Good job and all - that's awesome for you, but don't talk to me about the "importance" of f'n Black Adam".

Who pissed in that dumbasses's cereal

Taking a page out of the Brie Larson/Women director's handbook

This movie isn't made for you you being the general audience :roll:

I agree with your point here for the most part, but who was this movie made for? Were there "die-hard DC fans' clamoring for a Black Adam movie? Because I'm fairly dug-into the hobby spanning collecting to sales and I've literally never heard anyone say "man once they make that Black Adam movie, I can die happy!"

- Rock is too stoic and bland.

Yeah, it's like "the Rock plays the Rock, dude. He's a one trick pony in 'serious roles' and really can only branch out into the occasional dry-comedy. You never see a movie where the Rock adapts to a character. He just goes out and does "the rock".

Autbot_Benz
10-18-2022, 08:36 PM
I agree with your point here for the most part, but who was this movie made for? Were there "die-hard DC fans' clamoring for a Black Adam movie? Because I'm fairly dug-into the hobby spanning collecting to sales and I've literally never heard anyone say "man once they make that Black Adam movie, I can die happy!"

I agree only Dwayne/rock fans and maybe the small percent of fans of the character are seeing it for Black Adam. I am seeing it for my boy Dr Fate and Hawkman for a lesser extent

IMJ
10-18-2022, 08:42 PM
I agree only Dwayne/rock fans and maybe the small percent of fans of the character are seeing it for Black Adam. I am seeing it for my boy Dr Fate and Hawkman for a lesser extent

Yeah I think Dr. Fate is the character I'm most interested in seeing in this one too...

Leo656
10-18-2022, 08:45 PM
Everyone seems to be raving about Fate, even in the bad reviews. So that's cool, I love Dr. Fate and even if the movie underwhelms then at least I know I'll enjoy That.

TigerClaw
10-18-2022, 08:51 PM
Despite these reviews, I still plan on seeing it, Maybe with the new management, They can do a JSA movie.

Autbot_Benz
10-18-2022, 08:54 PM
Agreed Dr Fate is awesome one of my favorite characters and one of my favorite figures I have.

https://i.imgur.com/46EQhl1.jpg



Still can't get over Pierce Brosnan is playing him.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 09:01 PM
Yeah Brosnan is pretty cool, he has the voice... like he maybe wouldn't have been my very first pick but I mean, there have been multiple people under the helmet anyway so you have some wiggle room as to Who it is and What they look like. If you asked "Who else?" or "Who better?", I couldn't really tell you.

Maybe with the new management, They can do a JSA movie.

Apparently, they did, and just called it "Black Adam" by mistake.

Coola Yagami
10-18-2022, 09:04 PM
Yeah Brosnan is pretty cool, he has the voice... like he maybe wouldn't have been my very first pick but I mean, there have been multiple people under the helmet anyway so you have some wiggle room as to Who it is and What they look like. If you asked "Who else?" or "Who better?", I couldn't really tell you.



Apparently, they did, and just called it "Black Adam" by mistake.

Birds of Prey- first time?

Leo656
10-18-2022, 09:17 PM
Heh I was thinking that.

I still haven't actually seen that piece of sh*t. :lol: I doubt I ever will, there's just no f*cking reason for me, personally, to see it.

Coola Yagami
10-18-2022, 09:44 PM
Heh I was thinking that.

I still haven't actually seen that piece of sh*t. :lol: I doubt I ever will, there's just no f*cking reason for me, personally, to see it.

Same. Like yourself, I tend to not watch stuff I feel would be a waste of time.

That's the one thing that always bothers me about the 'big time' Youtubers. Despite making tons of videos about how terrible something sounds, they still actually go watch the thing because they have to make that one 'OMG IT WAS EVEN WORSE THAN I THOUGHT' to get them views. Hate-watching is such a waste of time.

Andrew NDB
10-18-2022, 09:49 PM
Now what does it mean for the DCEU if Black Adam really, really tanks?

TigerClaw
10-18-2022, 09:52 PM
Now what does it mean for the DCEU if Black Adam really, really tanks?
We still have the new Shazam coming out, and the Flash.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 09:57 PM
I mean, it would have to be Baywatch-level bad to "tank", and it probably isn't. I think it will do alright thanks to his built-in fanbase. It may under-perform vs. expectations but I doubt it would "tank".

So I think a better question would be "What if it 'only' makes $800 million?"

In which case... well, it's WB, so most likely... cancel everything except that stupid Lady Gaga Joker movie and the RPatz sequel nobody really wants but will accept over getting nothing at all. "New Managemant" or not, it's all WB even knows HOW to do; overreact, scorched earth, try again with more women and race-swaps.

Movie might not be great but it tanking would be pretty bad for the business so I hope it does well anyway.

We still have the new Shazam coming out, and the Flash.

Both of which look... really bad.

Shazam 2 looks REALLY f*cking bad.

Andrew NDB
10-18-2022, 10:01 PM
There was a moderate energy in the fandom when Shazam 1 came out. But waiting 4 years between movies killed that, surely.

Coola Yagami
10-18-2022, 10:04 PM
Now what does it mean for the DCEU if Black Adam really, really tanks?

It would be business as usual of course.

Leo656
10-18-2022, 10:20 PM
There was a moderate energy in the fandom when Shazam 1 came out. But waiting 4 years between movies killed that, surely.

I mean, the entire hook is, "He's a super-hero... but he's ALSO a little kid!" and now he's not even a little kid anymore because WB is so f*cking ass at getting movies made in a timely fashion. :lol: And it's not like you can just plug in any random kid to play Billy Batson every time the actor ages out, that's just stupid.

Sequel makes it even worse because the first movie made the entire Marvel Family a big huge deal but THEY too are gonna age out of everything super fast. So while it was cool to see in the moment, it's also kinda like, "...That wasn't a great decision, they kinda boxed themselves into a corner here."

Captain Marvel would probably work better as a TV series than a series of films, quite frankly, and that's a big reason why. Nothing centered on a cast of children lends itself to a series of films made every 3-5 years.

I liked the first movie, the trailers made it look incredibly stupid and goofy but the movie itself was actually pretty good! The sequel looks SO bad, though, with even more bad "comedy" and Cap being a neurotic, impotent joke. THAT GUY is gonna fight Black Adam one'a these days? Seriously? He's on a therapist's couch whining about what a crummy super-hero he is! F*CKING JEEEEZIS!

Oh, also, just since I love reminding everyone about how often WB recycles its own old, often-bad ideas for super-hero movies... that bit with Cap on the shrink's couch was ripped from one of the 1998-era Superman scripts, specifically the one that was so bad they had Kevin Smith of all people try to fix it. :lol: I can't believe they're still pulling up sh*t from scripts they abandoned almost 30 years ago for being too awful to film, but again... WB. :lol:

CyberCubed
10-19-2022, 09:52 AM
Most people seeing this movie will know nothing about DC superheroes. They're seeing it for The Rock and that's it. I bet they never heard the name, "Black Adam" in the entire lives.

Andrew NDB
10-19-2022, 12:06 PM
Movie is at 47% on Rotten Tomatoes with 47 reviews counted:

https://www.darkhorizons.com/the-black-adam-reviews-are-in/

IMJ
10-19-2022, 02:17 PM
There was a moderate energy in the fandom when Shazam 1 came out. But waiting 4 years between movies killed that, surely.

Yeah. And the truth is that the first Shazam wasn't even really that great of a movie. It was just light-hearted and didn't bash anyone over the head with woke $#!(, so I think people were more likely to enjoy it at that time.

It's like Sonic. Both Sonic and Shazam had some woke $#!( in them, but it wasn't billed as such and the woke $#!( elements were slightly more normalized. So normal people didn't care and by comparison of the moment both Shazam and Sonic performed better arguably than they would have in a socio-political atmosphere that was more stable.

So far I have little interest in the Shazam sequel.

Coola Yagami
10-19-2022, 02:47 PM
Yeah. And the truth is that the first Shazam wasn't even really that great of a movie. It was just light-hearted and didn't bash anyone over the head with woke $#!(, so I think people were more likely to enjoy it at that time.

It's like Sonic. Both Sonic and Shazam had some woke $#!( in them, but it wasn't billed as such and the woke $#!( elements were slightly more normalized. So normal people didn't care and by comparison of the moment both Shazam and Sonic performed better arguably than they would have in a socio-political atmosphere that was more stable.

So far I have little interest in the Shazam sequel.

I don't remember anything 'woke' in Sonic? Only thing I could possibly think of is maybe the inter-racial couple but I mean.... that's pretty much old news for at least a decade. And I wouldn't even call that woke, it was just a thing that became popular. There wasn't any moral grandstanding or virtue signalling over dating someone from a different race as you.

I remember mostly the pandering towards Olive Garden than pandering towards the woke narrative.

IMJ
10-19-2022, 03:06 PM
I don't remember anything 'woke' in Sonic? Only thing I could possibly think of is maybe the inter-racial couple but I mean.... that's pretty much old news for at least a decade. And I wouldn't even call that woke, it was just a thing that became popular. There wasn't any moral grandstanding or virtue signalling over dating someone from a different race as you.

I remember mostly the pandering towards Olive Garden than pandering towards the woke narrative.

Yeah those things were what I was suggesting, and also were sort of my point - it was organic. It was a non-issue.

oldmanwinters
10-19-2022, 03:07 PM
Eh... I'll probably see it next week, with a ticket voucher discount.

Coola Yagami
10-19-2022, 03:13 PM
Yeah those things were what I was suggesting, and also were sort of my point - it was organic. It was a non-issue.

I mean... I guess? That would have been woke maybe back in the late 80's/early 90's to maaaaaybe push 'the narrative' that hey, 'dating someone outside your race is no big deal! Go for it!' since that was more taboo back then.

But it's such a common thing for so long, I don't really see it as 'woke' or going against the norm.

Now maybe if Sonic was living with a trans couple, that I can see.

Coola Yagami
10-19-2022, 03:14 PM
Eh... I'll probably see it next week, with a ticket voucher discount.

I'm actually gonna hard pass on this and go see Smile. Zero interest in Black Adam. At least morbidly curious about Smile.

CyberCubed
10-19-2022, 03:36 PM
I'll watch it for free when it comes out in HD on the streaming websites. Should only be in 2 months at most.

Leo656
10-19-2022, 04:00 PM
Sounds like a mess but people are loving Fate and that's a lot of what I wanted to see anyway. I'm trying to go this weekend for Fate and Cavill. Not expecting more than "It was okay."

My concern is that since WB leaked the cameo to drum up ticket sales, if the movie does poorly then all that hopeful talk about revitalizing Superman goes out the window. All I give a sh*t about from WB is more Cavill as Superman, at this point. But this very well could be the last time we see it, ever.

So yeah selfishly I hope it does well even if it's not great. I mean awful movies make big money all the time so hopefully it does okay. That sh*tty other thing Rock does with the car movies, that sh*t is for the f*cking birds but those movies make tons of money despite being pure garbage. I don't get why some "bad" things fail and other, worse things get to be world-beaters.

Andrew NDB
10-19-2022, 04:57 PM
My concern is that since WB leaked the cameo to drum up ticket sales, if the movie does poorly then all that hopeful talk about revitalizing Superman goes out the window. .

Yeah, I had that same thought. Like they may actually go, "Damn, maybe we really do need black Superman to salvage things."

Leo656
10-19-2022, 05:53 PM
But after THAT, aside from "Call everyone a racist" what does WB do when they find out the hard way that no-f*cking-body wants Black Superman?

Probably just retire the character permanently for "lack of relevance" is my guess.

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-21-2022, 11:27 AM
Eh, it was a fun movie, but nothing special. Dr Fate was cool, rest of the JSA was... ok, I guess. I was a decent superhero flick, like Shazam was. Nothing really stand-out, though. I do like how they handled Adam's native country, and his interactions with his people's modern descendants. I kind of hope this does well enough, that we get a Shazam vs Black Adam movie down the line.

Andrew NDB
10-21-2022, 11:32 AM
I worry they're going to go the Venom route, to where he's basically just a superhero and it'd be very difficult and inorganic to suddenly force him into a situation in which he'd be the villain in a different superhero movie.

Panda_Kahn_fan
10-21-2022, 11:41 AM
I worry they're going to go the Venom route, to where he's basically just a superhero and it'd be very difficult and inorganic to suddenly force him into a situation in which he'd be the villain in a different superhero movie.

Oh don't worry, they set him up as a possible antagonist to any DC hero. He's been warned the minute he sets foot outside of Khandaq, the other DC heroes will be on him. And the way Black Adam chafes under restrictions, a conflict is inevitable; either him leaving to interfere in another nation, or heroes coming in to interfere with his rule.

oldmanwinters
10-21-2022, 11:53 AM
Probably just retire the character permanently for "lack of relevance" is my guess.

January 1, 2034 can't come soon enough!

IMJ
10-21-2022, 01:07 PM
I worry they're going to go the Venom route, to where he's basically just a superhero and it'd be very difficult and inorganic to suddenly force him into a situation in which he'd be the villain in a different superhero movie.

Absolutely what they are going to do....

Autbot_Benz
10-21-2022, 01:42 PM
I Read spoilers for this movie and I won't be surprised to see Khalid Nanssour as Dr Fate in a feature movie. He is cool in the comics from what I read.

Andrew NDB
10-21-2022, 05:09 PM
It's looking pretty good around where I live. Just about all the showings tonight seem reasonably full when I check seat availability on Fandango.

Coola Yagami
10-21-2022, 05:20 PM
Absolutely what they are going to do....

It's kinda like what Andrew said way back then. How are they expected to cheer for Shazam whupping Black Adam's ass if they're supposed to think he's a bad-ass superhero in this one?

Even though it sounds more like he'll be fighting Superman instead.

Question though, did he still yell SHAZAM when powering up?

Andrew NDB
10-21-2022, 05:27 PM
It's kinda like what Andrew said way back then. How are they expected to cheer for Shazam whupping Black Adam's ass if they're supposed to think he's a bad-ass superhero in this one?

Even though it sounds more like he'll be fighting Superman instead.

Same difference, though, really. Unless they try and flip it around and make it like Superman is the dumbass for just blindly following orders but then... if they're trying to put the Cavill Superman back over, do they really want audiences to be rooting against him?

I do admit, the thought of Cavill and the Rock trading punches and throwing each other through mountains isn't a bad one. They're just not setting it up right and not really thinking things through logically.

joe-eyeball
10-21-2022, 05:33 PM
They're just not setting it up right and not really thinking things through logically.

This statement alone describes the entire DCEU perfectly!

Leo656
10-21-2022, 05:59 PM
EDIT: Apparently we're going tonight at 10. Whooo.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2022, 01:31 AM
Saw it. So... a few decent beats but, eh, this isn't a very good movie. It feels like something from the 90s actioners, as expected. Only about 3 of the one liners/gags really landed. Pretty much you could remove the JSA from the movie and it wouldn't make much of a difference, except then they'd have more time to make us care about Black Adam and his supporting cast... which aren't great. And that kid was a horrible actor.

I admit, they DID do an OK job milking the PG-13 rating. One thing in particular early on was surprising.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 02:31 AM
I don't agree, I think it's one of the better DC ones for sure, not as good as anything Snyder did but it's up there with stuff like Aquaman and Wonder Woman easily. The plot was a bit muddled, there's 500lbs of exposition and the third act plot twist of who The First Champion really was seemed a bit tacked-on, extraneous, and out of left field, and a few of the jokes totally don't land at all. BUT, the JSA stuff was pretty great, especially the visuals for Dr. Fate and Cyclone during the fight scenes, that stuff was fantastic.

There's really nothing "wrong" with the movie, the only thing working against it is, "It's a super-hero movie and we have 80 million of them now so Here's One More". So it doesn't really excel at anything on its own, but I don't ever feel fair taking points off for that, it's not the movie's fault the market is oversaturated, there's really no new ground the genre can break anymore. It does what it's supposed to do. I'd have polished a few things but there's not much of a better movie they possibly could have made out of the parts they chose to use.

Black Adam himself is pretty one-note but I mean, he plays the part well enough for what it is, it's a thin character. I think that's why they had to pad the movie with the JSA, they more than make up for the Black Adam character's lack of outward charisma. Which is technically a sin because it's his movie, but again, the character doesn't lend himself well to solo affairs and it's hard to make such a one-dimensional character dynamic. So the trick becomes to have the characters around him take up the remaining slack and I do feel that they accomplished that.

Wasn't expecting much but way better than I expected. Again, there just isn't... anything really WRONG with it. And the stuff it does well, like the JSA stuff, it does VERY well. The worst thing I can say is some of the CGI wasn't great (although some of it really was), and in the "Intergang storms the house" scene the "100 camera cuts per second" sh*t was aggravating, but thankfully the movie isn't always like that. Although that stuff IS a problem more than it should be, but I mean a lot of action movies do that now. I prefer Snyder's wide-angle "let the scenes breathe, don't hide the action with jump cuts" approach BUT YA KNOW.

I can't in good conscience go lower than 8, frankly. I'd go a hair higher if the plot was smoother and the editing wasn't so car-crashy. I admittedly tend to be pretty forgiving, but to be honest the only way I feel it could be objectively lower than a 7 is if a person watches it while comparing it to other movies and that's simply never fair, especially in a such a crowded market.

Notes:
- Theater wasn't full, but about 2/3s or 3/4s. This is pretty typical for most movies at this theater, actually, unless it's MCU or Star Wars almost nobody ever sits in the first three rows no matter what the movie is so it's rare I've ever seen a fully-packed house there even on opening night. I've been going there my whole life and it's the damnedest thing. Works out fine for us, we end up getting Row 3 center every time which is pretty much prime seating. For some reason at this place people like to crowd the back. But yeah, decent crowd.

- They played the Shazam 2 trailer right before the movie started. Yeah, wow, that looks awful. I am REALLY hoping that like the first movie, they just made the trailers look goofy on purpose and the movie itself is more even, because going off the trailer that movie looks SO DUMB. Yeah, that guy ain't ready to fight Black Adam anytime soon. No way, if they made the Cap vs. Black Adam movie and had it out next year it'd be f*cking dog sh*t. I feel like they need at least two or three whole movies to Level Up Captain Marvel before he could hang with Black Adam. I'm curious to see what they do eventually, but in 2022 the idea of those characters facing off in their present state is just a bad joke. Hopefully, they fix things so it becomes plausible.

- Well, I was dead wrong about a lot of expectations. Black Adam is sufficiently ruthless in this, way more than I expected. To be fair, most of my expectations were based on things Rock has said in interviews like "Never wanting his movies to be too dark or violent", he's a "family movie guy" and all that. I even said right here a few times, "You can bet he's not gonna be ripping anybody in half like in the comics", and... well, shut my mouth.

- I have NO doubt that the R-rated cut that they initially filmed was a LOT better, and probably more coherent story-wise. Pretty sure there'll be a Special Edition or Ultimate Edition or Director's Cut at some point, I sure hope so.

- For anyone wondering, no, the JSA get no background, no backstory, no explanation whatsoever, which is one of the few problems I do have with the movie. You're just basically meant to accept, "Well, this world is now full of super-heroes so here's four more of them." I REALLY hope we get a proper JSA movie out of this because especially after seeing how they fared in action the characters definitely deserve it, and they'd have room to breathe and get into their stories better. I want to know where they came from, how long they've been around, and what their connection is to Amanda Waller, other than "She's the DCEU Nick Fury now". Cyclone is the only one who gets even a hint of backstory about her powers, which is a bummer.

- Always fun to see Amanda Waller, even though - as stated - they don't even attempt to explain how she knows these guys. She just snaps her fingers and metahumans jump, apparently.

- Dr. Fate really does steal the goddamn show, and everything he did was terrific and looked amazing. He's not a solo movie type of character and we'll probably never see him again unless they do a JSA movie, but if this is the only movie we ever get with Dr. Fate than at least he was a joy to watch for every moment he was in it.

- I liked that the Cyclone/Atom Smasher stuff was kept to a dull roar, it was cute without being overbearing. I kept thinking GREAT, here's the love story subplot every movie has to have, but it never turned into that, and that's refreshing.

- "Hawkman" was pretty good, but I say it in quotes because really, that isn't Hawkman, and I don't mean because he's black. Hawkman would be the LAST one to go around spouting "Heroes Don't Kill" and telling people to tone down the violence, and he's also not JSA frontman either. I get it, these are decisions that get made because "We can't use Alan Scott, we need him for the Green Lantern TV series" (which will probably never even happen, let's be real), but the team needs a leader so he gets to be it. But it's whatever, so they basically stuck Alan Scott's personality onto Hawkman for contractual reasons, it's dumb but the character still works. The only thing I didn't like was his costume could have been better, it's too plain, especially the pants. But everything else was great with him. The movie kind of makes him a bit of a sap to contrast him with Adam, but I mean, y'know, Real Life Reasons and all that.

- What they did with the real villain wasn't bad but like the "First Champion" twist, it kind of doesn't feel entirely earned or built-to as well as it could've been. Once he was at full power, all that stuff was pretty good. I really liked the brief "underworld" stuff before he was revived in his full form, that was really cool.

- The score wasn't really remarkable, I'm trying to remember specific cues but I can't. So I guess it was "fine".

- I'm kinda over "needle drops" in these movies, the two big ones in this one just don't fit. And I actually really like both of the songs used - "Bullet With Butterfly Wings" and "Paint It Black" - but the latter is too on the nose and also does not fit well with the scene it's attached to. And I don't know WHAT "Bullet..." was doing in there, I swear to God people just stick that onto movie soundtracks because people love setting up a scene with "The world is a vampire...." I adore the song but I kinda think there ought'a be a moratorium on using it in movies and trailers for a while. It's beyond overdone.

- After seeing this movie, I can tell you one thing for a fact: WB actually really, really, REALLY LOVES Zack Snyder... they just wish his movies made more money. Because they rip him off SO F*CKING HARD in a lot of the action scenes that it almost becomes parody at times. I promise you, if his movies made the bank WB arbitrarily decided they "needed" to, he'd still be out there doing stuff like this, instead of WB hiring someone to be all "So get as close to Zack's style as you can... but add bad jokes for Mom and Little Timmy." Seriously, there's "homage" and then there's Memorex. It wasn't done BADLY it was just... very, very blatant.

- I popped for the scene of Adam on the throne, because it's a perfect recreation of a comic book panel and I'm a sucker for that sh*t. He even had his legs positioned right.

- There was applause for the Superman cameo but nothing as loud as in the leaked footage. I was admittedly pretty loud, though. :lol: I notice when I go to movies people are generally afraid to clap or cheer unless I do, then they get loose. Dunno why.

So anyway, yeah, much better than I thought and one of the better non-Snyder DC movies although I know that's not saying much. If it'd been R-rated and Snyder directed it, well, obviously it would be much better but this is frankly as good as we can expect unless WB and Zack ever kiss and make up. In the meantime, we'd best get used to people just copying his visuals and adding "humor" into the mix to keep it light. It's a way to go, I guess.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 02:33 AM
Like I said, 7 or 8 and I don't see how it gets lower unless you really want/need/expect it to be "something new", which... it can't be, realistically, there simply won't be another "groundbreaking" or "game-changing" comic book movie because the market won't allow for that. So that said, I think this is about as good as it gets for non-Snyder DC movies.

Pretty much you could remove the JSA from the movie and it wouldn't make much of a difference

This, I disagree with HARD, take out the JSA and there's hardly even a movie. You can't have Adam by himself against Some Rando, he's equally a Captain Marvel character and/or a JSA character but you simply couldn't do this movie without one or the other, and as I said Cap is nowhere NEAR ready for Black Adam the way things stand right now. I can see how a JSA movie with him as the villain would have been tighter but I think that movie would have a lot of the same problems that this one has, just from a different angle.

ZariusTwo
10-22-2022, 02:41 AM
I keep thinking Dwayne would have benefited more being the antagonist in a Justice Society movie than carrying this by himself. Re-edit the movie into the JSA would be preferable, but at the same time, they don't have existing bank with the mainstream, at best you'll get a couple of CW fans who'll remember the JSA from Smallville:P

Andrew NDB
10-22-2022, 03:09 AM
I don't agree, I think it's one of the better DC ones for sure, not as good as anything Snyder did but it's up there with stuff like Aquaman and Wonder Woman easily.

Aquaman, yes. It's about equivalent to the tone and feel and level of writing as that. WW, nah. There's nothing in Black Adam as good as those first two acts of WW.

Black Adam himself is pretty one-note but I mean, he plays the part well enough for what it is, it's a thin character. I think that's why they had to pad the movie with the JSA, they more than make up for the Black Adam character's lack of outward charisma. Which is technically a sin because it's his movie, but again, the character doesn't lend himself well to solo affairs and it's hard to make such a one-dimensional character dynamic. So the trick becomes to have the characters around him take up the remaining slack and I do feel that they accomplished that.

I guess.

Wasn't expecting much but way better than I expected. Again, there just isn't... anything really WRONG with it. And the stuff it does well, like the JSA stuff, it does VERY well. The worst thing I can say is some of the CGI wasn't great (although some of it really was), and in the "Intergang storms the house" scene the "100 camera cuts per second" sh*t was aggravating, but thankfully the movie isn't always like that. Although that stuff IS a problem more than it should be, but I mean a lot of action movies do that now. I prefer Snyder's wide-angle "let the scenes breathe, don't hide the action with jump cuts" approach BUT YA KNOW.

The quick cutting bugged you, what bugged me was the metric ton of ADR going on. Like, whenever the camera isn't on someone's mouth, suddenly they're spitting out one-liners or funny stuff they clearly thought of later on in post. It's the Marvel school of "let's fill in all the silence we can with laughs."

I can't in good conscience go lower than 8, frankly.

If we're saying, for example -- personally -- if Birds of Prey or WW84 is like a 2 or a 3 and Man of Steel is a 9 or a 10, I'd say charitably this is about a 6, 6.5 tops.

They played the Shazam 2 trailer right before the movie started. Yeah, wow, that looks awful. I am REALLY hoping that like the first movie, they just made the trailers look goofy on purpose and the movie itself is more even, because going off the trailer that movie looks SO DUMB. Yeah, that guy ain't ready to fight Black Adam anytime soon. No way, if they made the Cap vs. Black Adam movie and had it out next year it'd be f*cking dog sh*t. I feel like they need at least two or three whole movies to Level Up Captain Marvel before he could hang with Black Adam. I'm curious to see what they do eventually, but in 2022 the idea of those characters facing off in their present state is just a bad joke. Hopefully, they fix things so it becomes plausible.

Yeah, that trailer. It just looks so busy and trying too hard for goofy laughs, this time out. Coupled with Levy looking a lot older in the face and those kids not really looking like kids anymore. A couple of those "Shazam!" transformation group shots are a little embarrassing to look at. Like, wow, they grew like an inch.

Well, I was dead wrong about a lot of expectations. Black Adam is sufficiently ruthless in this, way more than I expected. To be fair, most of my expectations were based on things Rock has said in interviews like "Never wanting his movies to be too dark or violent", he's a "family movie guy" and all that. I even said right here a few times, "You can bet he's not gonna be ripping anybody in half like in the comics", and... well, shut my mouth.

I would've liked to have seen him punch through one head, but whatever.

I have NO doubt that the R-rated cut that they initially filmed was a LOT better, and probably more coherent story-wise. Pretty sure there'll be a Special Edition or Ultimate Edition or Director's Cut at some point, I sure hope so.

That could really help things, I think.

Always fun to see Amanda Waller, even though - as stated - they don't even attempt to explain how she knows these guys. She just snaps her fingers and metahumans jump, apparently.

Yeah, weird.

Dr. Fate really does steal the goddamn show, and everything he did was terrific and looked amazing. He's not a solo movie type of character and we'll probably never see him again unless they do a JSA movie, but if this is the only movie we ever get with Dr. Fate than at least he was a joy to watch for every moment he was in it.

I probably enjoyed his stuff more than anything in the whole Dr. Strange Multiverse of Madness movie.

- I'm kinda over "needle drops" in these movies, the two big ones in this one just don't fit. And I actually really like both of the songs used - "Bullet With Butterfly Wings" and "Paint It Black" - but the latter is too on the nose and also does not fit well with the scene it's attached to. And I don't know WHAT "Bullet..." was doing in there, I swear to God people just stick that onto movie soundtracks because people love setting up a scene with "The world is a vampire...." I adore the song but I kinda think there ought'a be a moratorium on using it in movies and trailers for a while.

Yeah, those songs make it feel like a 90s actioner. And reminds me of what the studio was trying to do with their cut of Suicide Squad.

There was applause for the Superman cameo but nothing as loud as in the leaked footage. I was admittedly pretty loud, though. :lol: I notice when I go to movies people are generally afraid to clap or cheer unless I do, then they get loose. Dunno why.

I was looking forward to seeing/hearing the reaction there. Sadly, 95% of the theater left before they could see it, so it was only like me, wife and kid, and a couple of old guys scattered about and it was silent.

If it'd been R-rated and Snyder directed it, well, obviously it would be much better but this is frankly as good as we can expect unless WB and Zack ever kiss and make up. In the meantime, we'd best get used to people just copying his visuals and adding "humor" into the mix to keep it light. It's a way to go, I guess.

I feel like if The Suicide Squad had performed this would have surely been A-OK with an R. As is, WB probably blamed a lot of performance on that R-rating.

Like I said, 7 or 8 and I don't see how it gets lower unless you really want/need/expect it to be "something new", which... it can't be, realistically, there simply won't be another "groundbreaking" or "game-changing" comic book movie because the market won't allow for that. So that said, I think this is about as good as it gets for non-Snyder DC movies.

I mean, it's better than what Sony is doing with Venom. Not a TON better, but it's the same kind of filmmaking model.

This, I disagree with HARD, take out the JSA and there's hardly even a movie. You can't have Adam by himself against Some Rando, he's equally a Captain Marvel character and/or a JSA character but you simply couldn't do this movie without one or the other, and as I said Cap is nowhere NEAR ready for Black Adam the way things stand right now. I can see how a JSA movie with him as the villain would have been tighter but I think that movie would have a lot of the same problems that this one has, just from a different angle.

Well, yeah, you remove the JSA and you'd have a 45 minute movie. But story beats-wise, the JSA weren't really organic to anything going on in the movie. And I'm not even sure Black Adam needed to have a big bad to fight in it. Until the first trailer, I kind of just assumed Black Adam would be the villain of his own movie, only "seeing the light" by the end of it.

Also, I'm not sure they really accomplished his "face turn" very well. It's a bit like the last Mummy movie where before we even get a chance to hate or be scared of the titular character, we're overloaded with sympathetic backstory so as to not only not hate or be scared of them, but to feel sorry for them... before they even do much at all.

I keep thinking Dwayne would have benefited more being the antagonist in a Justice Society movie than carrying this by himself. Re-edit the movie into the JSA would be preferable

I think you're right. Just spitballing, but yeah, had they built a JSA-centric movie about the JSA assembling right as Black Adam appears and rises as a threat, there might have been a solid movie in that. Black Adam used sparingly, Terminator-like, until we little by little get his backstory. Maybe in the third act the JSA manages to recruit Billy Batson as "the muscle," and we get the first meet in a group setting.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 03:11 AM
I keep thinking Dwayne would have benefited more being the antagonist in a Justice Society movie than carrying this by himself. Re-edit the movie into the JSA would be preferable, but at the same time, they don't have existing bank with the mainstream, at best you'll get a couple of CW fans who'll remember the JSA from Smallville:P

They would've needed to change the plot around entirely, but I can see how it could have been done. Although probably not as successful as setting up Black Adam as the character the DCEU and WB needs/wants him to be. And I don't think that movie would have been TOO much better than this one, especially without Scott or Garrick, who they "can't" use right now because they're tied up in a bunch of stuff WB will never actually make.

Like, Real World Why stuff. We don't have to like it, we DO have to accept it and set expectations accordingly. WB doesn't "need" the JSA. They need The Rock to bring his "box office Viagra" to the DC franchise. A JSA movie doesn't accomplish that, even if he's in it. Just like "Birds of Prey" didn't draw a crowd even with Harley Quinn in it, but "Harley Quinn and BoP" did... slightly better, after they switched the title around to make clear she was the star. Didn't help MUCH, but the uptick after they switched the title proved that they should've marketed it as her movie all along.

..I mean what they SHOULD have done was cancelled that piece of sh*t Birds of Prey movie before they ever made it, but you know what I mean. :trazz:

I do sincerely hope now that they got some of the heavy lifting out of the way, they can do a real JSA movie with the full roster. I went into this movie not knowing (in this universe; obviously I know the comics stuff) how long the JSA have existed, how they met, where the individuals came from and/or got their powers, why they're Waller's foot soldiers, and if these are the only four members. After watching the movie, I STILL don't know ANY of that stuff, and it's the only thing I really don't like. But I get it, it's NOT a JSA movie so they felt like it'd be wasted time to get into it, and I guess it would've been.

Still, it's a lot to just drop these guys into the mix and not even attempt to get into any of it. My head is still so set in Snyder's "There were only a few metahumans in existence, technology isn't super advanced, etc." establishment, especially since they're still building on his framework... so to go into a movie and suddenly there's 500 super-heroes with no explanation and mercenaries have Eternium-powered hoverbikes like something outta Star Wars... it just kinda breaks your brain a little. I know the toothpaste is out of the tube, but still. The idea was originally to build things to this kind of point s l o w l y, but then we all know WB and "patience", plus they started this whole deal a decade ago and have barely made any progress. So yeah, I get it, "who cares, just go full-on comic book, get crazy" but it doesn't feel earned.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2022, 03:23 AM
Like, Real World Why stuff. We don't have to like it, we DO have to accept it and set expectations accordingly. WB doesn't "need" the JSA. They need The Rock to bring his "box office Viagra" to the DC franchise. A JSA movie doesn't accomplish that

Correct. In fact, I'd strongly advise against a JSA movie. I am a fan of them, but the DCEU needs a JSA movie like the comics need a 29th reboot of the Legion of Super-Heroes comic. I just don't see it being successful. They absolutely would have to put out a new Justice League movie with all the A-listers and score big before even considering that kind of stuff with the C-listers, down the line. Especially after The Suicide Squad bombed. I'm pretty sure the general public's awareness of The Weasel isn't too different from their awareness of Atom Smasher.

Still, it's a lot to just drop these guys into the mix and not even attempt to get into any of it. My head is still so set in Snyder's "There were only a few metahumans in existence, technology isn't super advanced, etc." establishment, especially since they're still building on his framework... so to go into a movie and suddenly there's 500 super-heroes with no explanation and mercenaries have Eternium-powered hoverbikes like something outta Star Wars... it just kinda breaks your brain a little.

I was immediately reminded of the recent Godzilla movies. We got that first one that was grittily real-ish and contemporary with Bryan Cranston doing Breaking Bad-level acting in the background, then only like a movie later we've suddenly got little hover ships with neon lights flying around like Star Trek shuttlecraft and so on. I know, it's a movie, but immediately I'm checked out of taking it seriously.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 03:37 AM
Aquaman, yes. It's about equivalent to the tone and feel and level of writing as that. WW, nah. There's nothing in Black Adam as good as those first two acts of WW.

The quick cutting bugged you, what bugged me was the metric ton of ADR going on. Like, whenever the camera isn't on someone's mouth, suddenly they're spitting out one-liners or funny stuff they clearly thought of later on in post. It's the Marvel school of "let's fill in all the silence we can with laughs."

Yeah, that trailer. It just looks so busy and trying too hard for goofy laughs, this time out. Coupled with Levy looking a lot older in the face and those kids not really looking like kids anymore. A couple of those "Shazam!" transformation group shots are a little embarrassing to look at. Like, wow, they grew like an inch.

Yeah, those songs make it feel like a 90s actioner. And reminds me of what the studio was trying to do with their cut of Suicide Squad.


In order:

- I'unno, see, because they're entirely different kinds of super-hero movies. Like this one is by design a CGI Action Slugfest, and the CGI Action Slugfest parts of Wonder Woman were the only thing people cried about (they were "fine"). That was an action/drama period piece and this is a Big Loud Action Movie. I think they both succeed well enough at their individual mission statements.

Thus I personally can only compare them insofar as, "How likely would I be to watch either of them again?" And the honest answer is, about the same. Neither one is among my all-time favorites but they're both movies I'll still be checking out from time to time for many years. Maybe not all the time - I liked WW a ton but haven't actually watched it in years - but I'm not done with either of them for sure.

- Yeah, the jump cuts were trying to hide some of that but yeah. I'm never a huge fan of that either, but the pacing in those scenes was so frenetic I was more focused on what was going on than watching for that kind of stuff. I'd probably have caught more of it later on upon a second or third watch.

Like how I mentioned that the music didn't thrill me or stand out in any way (nor did it bother me; it was just There); I'm huge into music but for some reason, with films the visuals always stand out to me more than the audio does. Zimmer's score for MoS left little impression when I watched the movie the very first time but HOLY SH*T do I adore it now. For some reason the audio of a movie takes like two or three passes before it becomes one of my biggest priorities. But yeah, this would have annoyed me eventually, I'm sure. But since I'm more visually-oriented with movies the quick-cut sh*t bothered me more.

Like, in that "storm the house" scene they were jump-cutting and nothing was even happening! :lol: Three or more cuts within two seconds? Lay off the caffeine! A guy took two steps to the right, you don't need to show it from three different F*CKING angles! :lol:

- Holy sh*t yeah, what about Zachary Levi, huh? OOOOF the guy looks f*cking SIXTY now! What'd he do, spend all his money from the first movie on crack and cheap whiskey? He looks like SH*T and he wasn't a good visual choice for the role anyway. Like he was "serviceable", but that's all, and now he looks like his own Dad.

I popped huge for the Marvel Family in the first movie just because I didn't think they'd go there, but yeah I can't say I love them being the focal point of the sequel, I mean HE is barely even established and the sequel is all about how he's the weakest link of "his own" super-hero family? F*ck outta here. I liked it in the first movie as a fan but it was objectively too much too soon and now it's f*cking sh*t up.

Mary Marvel is f*cking hot as f*ck, though, so... there's that. Like I've always been a huge fan of the character, never expected to see her in a movie at all, now we actually do AND she's smokin'. That's nice, I appreciate that.

- For a half a second I did think, "Ah geez, they're doing it like Suicide Squad". :lol: And then they pulled it back.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 03:44 AM
Correct. In fact, I'd strongly advise against a JSA movie. I am a fan of them, but the DCEU needs a JSA movie like the comics need a 29th reboot of the Legion of Super-Heroes comic. I just don't see it being successful. They absolutely would have to put out a new Justice League movie with all the A-listers and score big before even considering that kind of stuff with the C-listers, down the line. Especially after The Suicide Squad bombed. I'm pretty sure the general public's awareness of The Weasel isn't too different from their awareness of Atom Smasher.



I was immediately reminded of the recent Godzilla movies. We got that first one that was grittily real-ish and contemporary with Bryan Cranston doing Breaking Bad-level acting in the background, then only like a movie later we've suddenly got little hover ships with neon lights flying around like Star Trek shuttlecraft and so on. I know, it's a movie, but immediately I'm checked out of taking it seriously.

- Yes, 100, another JLA movie should be their priority far beyond a JSA one. They won't, just like they won't do a Green Lantern movie because the JLA name is "toxic" just like the name "Green Lantern" is "toxic" for their movie branch after the first one, but that's dumb.

- I was sitting there and as soon as I saw the hoverbikes I literally said in my head that I was gonna come home and you were gonna say EVERY WORD that you just said in that paragraph. :lol: I literally said "I can't wait for Andrew to say how this reminded him of how they ruined the Godzilla movies." That's so awesome.

In my head I'm just saying that between-movies someone from S.T.A.R. Labs figured out Kryptonian tech from the ship and that's why there's all this Star Wars tech in the DCEU now when there wasn't before. Makes sense if you squint. :lol: It's as good as we're ever gonna get.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2022, 04:12 AM
Thus I personally can only compare them insofar as, "How likely would I be to watch either of them again?" And the honest answer is, about the same. Neither one is among my all-time favorites but they're both movies I'll still be checking out from time to time for many years. Maybe not all the time - I liked WW a ton but haven't actually watched it in years - but I'm not done with either of them for sure.

I guess that's fair. But while something like MoS or WW would be a no-brainer for me to put back on in any revisiting of the DCEU years later or to show someone else... Black Adam, I dunno. I wouldn't say that no, I wouldn't, but unless he as a character goes on to bigger and better things in the DCEU then I probably wouldn't. It's missing too many elements to independently elevate itself, and the music score is a major component of that to name just one.

I saw it 2 hours ago and I can't remember any of the score. Just those ham-fisted songs.

Zimmer's score for MoS left little impression when I watched the movie the very first time but HOLY SH*T do I adore it now.

Absolutely. That score fills you with wonder and excitement and "alien." It's wonderful. What Zimmer did there was magic.

Holy sh*t yeah, what about Zachary Levi, huh? OOOOF the guy looks f*cking SIXTY now! What'd he do, spend all his money from the first movie on crack and cheap whiskey? He looks like SH*T and he wasn't a good visual choice for the role anyway. Like he was "serviceable", but that's all, and now he looks like his own Dad.

It's weird! I know you're his greatest fan but they really should have just gotten a John Cena type for the role (also, probably BIG muscled people for all of the Super versions of the other kids to offset the inevitable aging). And over here on the Black Adam side, you have him filling out the costume earnestly, how ridiculous is Levi going to look when he's going toe to toe with him?

- Yes, 100, another JLA movie should be their priority far beyond a JSA one. They won't, just like they won't do a Green Lantern movie because the JLA name is "toxic" just like the name "Green Lantern" is "toxic" for their movie branch after the first one, but that's dumb.

I dunno. Getting the trinity right seems to be a priority for Zaslav. The obvious endgame there has to be a proper Justice League.

Green Lantern... what a mess on all sides, including that show. I still maintain that the first GL movie wasn't beyond saving in a sequel.

I was sitting there and as soon as I saw the hoverbikes I literally said in my head that I was gonna come home and you were gonna say EVERY WORD that you just said in that paragraph. :lol: I literally said "I can't wait for Andrew to say how this reminded him of how they ruined the Godzilla movies." That's so awesome.

It's just upsetting. Less so in Black Adam, because as you say, mankind has had unknown years now to study and reverse engineer Kryptonian tech (though this seemed to go beyond that? were these little ships phasing through matter in Black Adam or just jumping forward super fast?). In the Godzilla movies, what? They studied the MUTA DNA and it somehow taught them how to make Star Trek hovercraft? The one logical thing Independence Day: Resurgence got right was how humanity would absolutely jump to it with reverse engineering alien tech leftover for, you know, the next attack which could happen a year later, or a month. Even though they basically stole that from War of the Worlds: Goliath.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 04:38 AM
I saw it 2 hours ago and I can't remember any of the score. Just those ham-fisted songs.

It's weird! They really should have just gotten a John Cena type for the role. And over here on the Black Adam side, you have him filling out the costume earnestly, how ridiculous is Levi going to look when he's going toe to toe with him?

Green Lantern... what a mess on all sides, including that show. I still maintain that the first GL movie wasn't beyond saving in a sequel.


- Yeah, the more I think about it this movie may have the single most generic score I've ever heard. :lol: To me that's just garnish, like I appreciate a mind-blowing score but it's a visual medium, I don't always miss it if it's not there. But yeah, I do agree that there's just nothing moving about it, it just didn't really hurt the movie for me personally.

- My All-Time pick for Captain Marvel, like if they got to make it 20 years or so ago, was always Brendan Frasier. But then he got way too old, fat, and bald (and way earlier than he should have), but yeah when I was a teenager he would've been the guy.

Y'know who'd honestly be the best pick NOW, though, and I'm not even kidding? Brandon Routh. No, I'm dead f*cking serious. He still looks fairly youthful, he has a fanbase among a section of the DC audience, the CW Crisis stuff showed that he can still "go", he's very tall and adequately jacked (when the designers give him a suit that highlights his physique properly; he looked much better in the Crisis suit than the movie one), it would be a "Previous DC Movie Easter Egg" that people always bust nuts for, he has the "looks a lot (but not quite) like Superman" thing that Cap needs to have, AND as we've seen in a few things that Routh does great when he's allowed to display a kind of cheeky sense of humor, which also fits Cap.

Like seriously, I doubt he was ever up for it, doubt he got the call or auditioned at all but HE would have been the best possible Captain Marvel for so many reasons and I'm aggravated that I'm probably the first person who ever even thought of that. Should have been a no-brainer.

Would be totally worth it just for him to crack, "I feel like I'm more of a 'Superman' than you are!" when him and Cavill inevitably met. See, I'm the only one who f*cking knows anything, it's infuriating.

- Green Lantern 2: Hal vs. Sinestro would have been MUCH better than GL1, absolutely, and I liked GL1 more than most people. But I left thinking, "Well, heavy lifting is does, sequel will be better." Yellow Ring Sinestro is all anyone cared about seeing, anyway. It still pisses me off that WB - AS USUAL - decided that the best course of action to a minor fumble is, "Let's scorch and salt the earth so nothing ever grows here again." Like ALL they ever do is overreact as a rule, they are such a f*cking sh*t company and since they have always been I am not convinced that will change no matter how many regime changes and mergers there are. That company is f*cking cursed.

AquaParade
10-22-2022, 04:42 AM
Brenden Fraser may have been physically destroyed by his own anxiety from the sound of things.

Unless all that “Brendan Fraser is back! He was sexually harassed and blacklisted but he is back!” angle is just exaggerated puff-piece stuff to try and revive a dead career.

But if it it’s as bad as he implied, yeah, maybe it explains the quick aging.

Although, even if it is exaggerated, I guess going from hero-to-zero would be hard either way. The guy does seem sort of fragile.

I’d buy him as Hal. He was fun in the Mummy movies and had enough charisma, as an actor.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 04:51 AM
Y'know, I don't keep up with him much at all, I sincerely have no idea about any of that or what the deal is with that. All I know is I used to see him in stuff, "Bedazzled" was really good (Hurley was SO F*CKING HOT in that), and then shortly after he vanished into the Phantom Zone, then the next time anyone saw him he was fat and bald. And now apparently he did a movie and people remembered he existed and it's some kind of feel-good comeback thing.

Good for him, by the way, I just haven't paid any attention so I don't actually know what's going on or has been going on with him.

It's just that as a kid, I couldn't help but notice that a lot of his headshots for various movies looked a lot like the way Captain Marvel looked on the covers of the old Justice League International comics, and then at one point he was up for Superman back in the late-90s/very early-2000s but obviously nothing happened there, but at one point he was the official "If we can't get anybody else 'better' or more marketable to play Superman, it'll be him" pick, like not WB's first choice but none of their first choices actually wanted to do it, and he said he would if it came down to it. But then obviously no movie got made and it all just evaporated.

I never thought he would've been a great Superman - "good enough", maybe, which again was basically what WB had him on retainer for, "He's good enough if we can't get a Real Star" - and part of that was because he generally has a goofier, goonish kind of quality. BUT it's the same thing that made me think he would've been "eh" as Superman to make me think he would have, at that time, been a very good Captain Marvel.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2022, 04:57 AM
* Green Lantern 2, with Sinestro vs. Hal. Sure, that seemed the certain way to go. There is a lot of great storylines they could have done as long as they had a better vision. We could have seen Ryan Reynolds' Hal becoming not a Ryan Reynolds' Hal with what he would go through in such a thing. And we'd have a great character arc as a result.

* Brendan Fraser as Captain Marvel. Yes. Absolutely. 22 years ago, for sure.

* Brandon Routh as Captain Marvel. No, I can't agree. He was cast as Superman because he had the same "swimmer's body" as Christopher Reeve. Also, because Bryan Singer is into that. Captain Marvel should not have a "swimmer's body." He should forever have a hyper-exaggerated Charles Atlas-type body. But mannerisms and performance-wise, sure. He could do it. And hey, there's probably nothing that says Brandon Routh couldn't bulk up to tank-like levels if directed to do so. Or maybe there is, I don't know. We saw what happened when Tom Hardy was tasked with bulking up for Bane, the biggest muscled villain Batman has ever encountered.

* The perfect casting for Hal Jordan would always have been an in his prime Dennis Quaid. That's even exactly who Darryl Banks modeled Hal after in his run. And I agree.

Also, I admit. When there was rumors about Tom Cruise for Hal Jordan, I wasn't too bitter about it. Especially if it's like an Ant-Man where Hal Jordan is like the legacy character and the main character is a new GL, like Kyle. That could work. In fact, imagine how beautiful an "Emerald Twilight" story would be with Tom Cruise as Parallax Hal going nuts?

Leo656
10-22-2022, 05:11 AM
You're gonna tell me with a straight face that This Guy - while admittedly no Rock or Cena - isn't jacked enough to fill out a padded/sculpted muscle suit? Yer boshin' me. Look at those delts.

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_Ne5Lb2SiFHg/S41pgwWh4pI/AAAAAAAAs74/rCgpW9Ykryc/s400/routh01.jpg

He does have a bit of a lankier frame skeletal-wise but Routh gets wider/thicker or not as roles require. He was also way bigger, more jacked and cut up than Reeve EVER was, at the time he did the movie. The costume designers actually thought he was TOO big, because you're correct in a sense that they wanted him to be reminiscent of Reeve, as in a leaner type of musculature, and so when they designed the suit they did everything they could to make him look far leaner than he really was, specifically making the trunks way too low so his torso would look longer/slimmer. They did everything they could to hide how much taller/thicker Routh was than Reeve because ostensibly, you were supposed to believe they were The Same Guy within the movie's fiction. In reality he was much, much bigger than Reeve. Too big to wear the "proper" costume, unfortunately, in the opinion of the costumers.

Start with the above picture, get him on even the most basic Comic Book Movie Steroid Kit to get a little thicker and more defined, give him a suit that fits properly like the CW Crisis suit, and you've got your Captain Marvel. Done deal. Even in that one pic he's barely in shape and he's way thicker off the gas than Zachary Levi is on it. I know that's not saying much, but you're totally not giving the guy enough credit.

Plus, there's a certain very vocal and very whiny contingent of Superman fans who simply will not shut up about him getting a Superman project, and I kinda want those people to shut up already, and I feel like having him play Cap might be a good enough compromise to finally make those people quit their eternal bitching.

- For what it's worth, I've seen some pictures of the old Reeve suits and what they looked like inside... y e a h those things had a lot more padding than you'd think, and Reeve never even looked jacked as Superman. I know the "Darth Vader/David Prowse got him in shape" story is a fan favorite, but... Reeve hardly worked out for Superman, to be brutally honest. He just didn't care for it and the suit was pretty much half of his physique. Too bad.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 05:23 AM
* The perfect casting for Hal Jordan would always have been an in his prime Dennis Quaid. That's even exactly who Darryl Banks modeled Hal after in his run. And I agree.



Chris Pine would be my dream pick for Hal, but WB had to go and make him Steve Trevor just because they have to f*ck up every single layup anyone gives them.

But yeah ever since I saw him as Kirk in those Trek movies I was like, "If he took this exact same 'rebel within the organization, maverick-style good guy who flies by the seat of his pants but pulls it together in the end somehow, maybe with a little help from his friends' type of energy... he would be a PERFECT Hal Jordan."

But again... WB gonna WB. Literally any scrub could have been "Steve Trevor" (especially since they were just gonna kill him off anyway) but they had the best potential Hal Jordan they're gonna get within this particular era... and they punted because "LoL dawg we don't do Green Lantern movies."

AquaParade
10-22-2022, 06:02 AM
Brendan Fraser was sort of the “Chris Pratt” of his day.

Autbot_Benz
10-22-2022, 10:06 AM
I just hate that they killed Dr Fate in his first ever movie. The one character everyone is raving about in the movie and they do that.

Leo656
10-22-2022, 10:19 AM
Nabu always finds a new host anyway. Fate is Eternal.

AquaParade
10-22-2022, 10:20 AM
I kind of figured they would when they cast Pierce Brosnan.

As long as the new Dr has the awesome outfit, is relatively chill, and has badass magic, I’ll be happy. I love the character because he looks cool and has magic powers, what can I say.

Have you guys seen this? I’m probably gonna skip the theater but if it’s like… as good as Man of Steel, I’d head to to theater. I doubt that but it’s hard to tell because Man of Steel didn’t really please audiences anymore than this seems to.

Autbot_Benz
10-22-2022, 10:41 AM
I kind of figured they would when they cast Pierce Brosnan.

As long as the new Dr has the awesome outfit, is relatively chill, and has badass magic, I’ll be happy. I love the character because he looks cool and has magic powers, what can I say.


If they follow the comics his apprentice Khalid Nanssour will take up the mantle next.

https://i.imgur.com/Win3w6Q.jpg

Leo656
10-22-2022, 05:38 PM
Have you guys seen this? I’m probably gonna skip the theater but if it’s like… as good as Man of Steel, I’d head to to theater. I doubt that but it’s hard to tell because Man of Steel didn’t really please audiences anymore than this seems to.

It is nowhere near as good as Man of Steel but it also isn't playing the same sport. The story isn't as good, nor as well-told, in fact it's rather sloppily told to be perfectly honest. It all makes sense when you stop to think about it, but that's just it, you have to try and reconcile it all in your head because on the surface, certain things they do seem really "just because", except they're not, they only seem that way because the movie presents information in a very disjointed manner.

Also, as Andrew alluded to, they really don't do anything to put over Black Adam as someone who needs to be "redeemed" in the first place. They TELL you he had a hissy fit and killed a bunch of people a long time ago, and that he's trying to rise above and overcome being controlled by his rage... but you don't even really see "his rage", he seems rather stoic the entire time. So that's a bit iffy. Like yes, he violently kills a bunch of people, but he's not even making "angry face" or anything he just very calmly kills them, and the movie and its characters (except Hawkman) ALL keep saying how much they deserved it so everyone should just get out of Black Adam's way and let him kill people. Very mixed-messaging in the movie, for sure. Like the mom character basically spends the entire movie telling the JSA they're a bunch of useless pussies because they don't go around killing everyone.

But when you're watching it it becomes very apparent that it's not the kind of movie where you're supposed to care too much about anything except 1. Rock wrecking house and being a badass, and 2. The razzle-dazzle of the fight scenes.

I don't know if you'd like it, honestly. The comic book movies I've seen you get the most enjoyment out of in recent years were Joker and The Batman, and I'm not sure if this kind of blatant CGI-fest is up your alley but I don't know, something tells me you wouldn't enjoy this one as much as I did, although you'd probably be impressed at least with a lot of the fight scene visuals. Fate and Cyclone really were very well-done.

I stand by my "It's at worst a 7" opinion but I confess I'm also grading on a curve because I know standards are lower in a post-Snyder DCEU. They want to catch up to Marvel as soon as possible, which means less plot, more CGI and jokes. We'll never get anything Man of Steel quality again, those days are gone. At best we'll get stuff like this, "Copy some of the shots but do them less-well." It's good enough for what it needed to be. "Good enough" is gonna be the best case for everything in the DCEU going forward since they want to play it safe as a rule from now on.

AquaParade
10-23-2022, 01:03 AM
I ended up seeing Black Adam. I thought it was okay. Probably wouldn’t watch it again. Clunky storytelling, dialogue, and acting in parts. Overall, very cliche and nothing we haven’t seen before. No artistic touch or heartfelt moments.

On the other hand, it doesn’t sink as low as films like Suicide Squad or JL 2017 - not even close.
The film has it’s moments and there is some quality action to behold, though again, nothing that’s a cut above it’s competition.
Doctor Fate was indeed the highlight.

So, yeah, not a bad movie but not truly worthy of a recommendation, imo.

Andrew NDB
10-23-2022, 01:26 AM
Thinking on it more, do we really want to see Black Adam vs. Superman? It seems like it'd just be a less interesting Zod fight, except Black Adam has lightning instead of heat vision and there'd be no stakes or emotional hook to the fight.

I kind of wonder if Dr. Fate, Hawkman, and Atom Smasher are in the movie so as to announce, "See? We have our own Dr. Strange, Falcon, and Ant-Man! DC is back in the game!" I mean, I guess the movie did need them such as it was written.

Leo656
10-23-2022, 01:39 AM
From the way Flex talks, it's not gonna happen for a few movies (which would mean 3-5 years or so) anyway so I'm not even really contemplating the Ifs. I'll give a sh*t when it actually happens, same as anything else.

Plus it's WB, which means it's never gonna happen anyways. There'll be another regime change and reboot long before any Black Adam vs. Superman thing gets done. All just hopeful/wishful thinking, nothing more.

Like they'll coexist and interact in things, probably, but they've said out loud, the next time you see these guys onscreen together it's not gonna be jumping right into a big fight scene like a lot of people expect it to be.

The only reason to care or be excited about this is that in the interim we MAY finally get another Cavill solo movie before the next big regime change/reboot, and then they'll let him go for being too old.

Knowing the way WB operates - and do NOT give me any "New Regime" bullsh*t, please, none of that matters - standard operating procedure of any fan should be, "Don't even think about this sh*t until the movie comes out." Because 9.9 times out of 10... movie never even comes out.


I kind of wonder if Dr. Fate, Hawkman, and Atom Smasher are in the movie so as to announce, "See? We have our own Dr. Strange, Falcon, and Ant-Man! DC is back in the game!" I mean, I guess the movie did need them such as it was written.

I mean, those characters are way better than their insipid Diet Coke Marvel Versions any goddamn way.

Falcon. Snerk. ANT-MAN, for f*ck's sake. People swear that Marvel fans aren't easily amused when they'll accept a Z-lister like Falcon as Captain America, and Ant-Man has TWO solo movies. The only way that sh*t happens is if your audience will swallow literally anything with your sticker on it.

AquaParade
10-23-2022, 07:41 AM
Black Adam v Superman doesn’t necessarily excite me, no.

Even after seeing Black Adam, I don’t feel invested in his character at all.
Even if I were, I’m not sure I’d be excited at the idea of yet another superhero film structured roughly around “let’s fight and then we’re friends”.

Conceptually, that isn’t exciting. Same with most crossover comics (even though I’m looking forward to Batman vs Spawn).

I’m open to seeing more of The Rock’s Black Adam and I definitely want to see another Superman film, ideally with Cavill, but they don’t need to be one and the same by any means.

I just want a honest to goodness sequel to Man of Steel, assuming they get a great director on board.

TigerClaw
10-23-2022, 02:03 PM
I thought the movie was pretty good, a lot of the action in the movie was very Snyder like with the use of the slow motion scenes.

Leo656
10-23-2022, 05:47 PM
Apparently it had a good opening at $67 million domestic and about $140 million worldwide total, which was above expectations. Rock's biggest opening in a starring role and the biggest DC opening since Aquaman. It's expected to hold steady as there's no real competition for a few weeks yet and general audience word-of-mouth is that the critics were way too harsh. So it will probably do alright when all is said and done.

oldmanwinters
10-23-2022, 07:39 PM
Apparently it had a good opening at $67 million domestic and about $140 million worldwide total, which was above expectations. Rock's biggest opening in a starring role and the biggest DC opening since Aquaman. It's expected to hold steady as there's no real competition for a few weeks yet and general audience word-of-mouth is that the critics were way too harsh. So it will probably do alright when all is said and done.

Huh, for as big and prevalent Johnson (bazinga) is as a movie star, I am surprised he hadn’t yet headlined a box office debut that high.

Andrew NDB
10-23-2022, 08:10 PM
200 million dollar budget (did it NEED that high, for this?) plus I'd wager around 50 for marketing. That's still a steep hill to climb. Next weekend should reveal how it'll go.

AquaParade
10-23-2022, 10:25 PM
Pretty sure it’s not the biggest DC opening since Aquaman.

Leo656
10-24-2022, 01:47 AM
Might be right, the article I was looking at originally said "of any DC opening since Aquaman" but now it says "of any DCEU opening since Aquaman" which is a whole different conversation.

I'm guessing the person writing it didn't really get the difference between "DC movies" and "DCEU movies" and thus they changed it when a reader pointed out the error.

Andrew NDB
10-24-2022, 03:08 AM
I hate to say it, but as much as I hear "it took 15 years to make this"... I don't see it. Not at the script level. Possibly some of the casting choices and direction.

AquaParade
10-24-2022, 04:07 AM
Yeah, people keep making a distinction between DC films and DCEU, but unless we are speaking directly of story canon, we may as well group them all together imo.

Audiences aren’t trained to look at these films that distinctly yet. They are just “DC films” to people, if they’re even somewhat informed.

Leo656
10-24-2022, 05:47 AM
I hate to say it, but as much as I hear "it took 15 years to make this"... I don't see it. Not at the script level. Possibly some of the casting choices and direction.

OH, god no, they wrote that script on a napkin the day before they shot it, absolutely. :lol: "15 years in the making" absolutely refers to getting all the moving parts to align, nothing more.

To be fair, though, most comic book movies have bad scripts and many start shooting with NO script. Even Burton's Batman only had a partial script, they made up huge chunks of that movie while they were shooting, especially the third act. All of that cathedral stuff was booked on the fly when WB had concerns about Batman beating a senior citizen to death with his bare hands as the original script outline had ordained. Nobody knew how the movie was really going to end until they were deep in production. Nicholson had no idea why he was even climbing those stairs, and neither did Burton.

So I mean, yeah, weak script, but that is always the most extraneous part of these projects anyway. Comic book movies are only one step above horror movies in the "Nobody Watches These Movies For Plot" department.

AquaParade
10-24-2022, 07:36 AM
Yeah, I like how constant delays are played as a selling point. Thats funny.

“This late bill was in the making for 15 years. Get hyped.”

IMJ
10-24-2022, 09:06 AM
I just hate that they killed Dr Fate in his first ever movie. The one character everyone is raving about in the movie and they do that.

Well.... opened the thread from "New Posts" and the first thing I saw. LMAO
Guess that spoils that!

Ah well, no big deal. Just another comic book movie disappointment.

Leo656
10-24-2022, 09:28 AM
Do people seriously not understand how Dr. Fate works? Jesus Christ.

oldmanwinters
10-24-2022, 10:20 AM
Do people seriously not understand how Dr. Fate works?

Does Warner Bros?

CyberCubed
10-24-2022, 11:05 AM
I just started watching this and Hawkman is black now? I somehow missed the casting. Also is he human or is he a black man from Thanagar? There are black aliens now?

Why wasn't there an uproar that Hawkman is black?

drgon78
10-24-2022, 12:22 PM
Just got back from the theaters, I liked it, a lot better then i thought it was going to be. Though I have to say that kid is really annoying.

Andrew NDB
10-24-2022, 03:48 PM
Just got back from the theaters, I liked it, a lot better then i thought it was going to be. Though I have to say that kid is really annoying.

Terrible actor.

CyberCubed
10-24-2022, 06:39 PM
I checked the first page of this thread and this was made in 2014. We're in 2022. :ohwell:

What on earth took 8 years for this movie to come out? What the hell.

Andrew NDB
10-24-2022, 06:48 PM
Whoa, look what Cavill says on his IG. This WAS part of a larger deal.

https://i.postimg.cc/C5Pfn0zH/Screenshot-20221024-164643-Instagram.jpg

TigerClaw
10-24-2022, 06:59 PM
Whoa, look what Cavill says on his IG. This WAS part of a larger seal.

https://i.postimg.cc/C5Pfn0zH/Screenshot-20221024-164643-Instagram.jpg
The question now is, Will Superman be in Black Adam 2, Or will Black Adam be in Man of Steel 2?

The thing is, As much as we would love to see those two fight, I predict that they will set aside there differences and join together to fight a bigger threat.

Turo602
10-24-2022, 07:02 PM
I checked the first page of this thread and this was made in 2014. We're in 2022. :ohwell:

What on earth took 8 years for this movie to come out? What the hell.

As The Rock said, Black Adam couldn't exist without the larger DC universe first being established and we all know how that's been.

IMJ
10-24-2022, 07:33 PM
I would love to see Waverider on screen. Doing something central and cool to the story.

Seriously.

CyberCubed
10-24-2022, 08:36 PM
Is it time for Ryan Reynolds Green Lantern to return?

Leo656
10-24-2022, 08:50 PM
I wouldn't cry about it.

oldmanwinters
10-24-2022, 09:44 PM
Saw it tonite. It was fine… for a movie with the Rock. Movie was carried by Rock and Pierce Brosnan mugging the camera. Also, some explicit Fast & Furious references… very meta? Maybe it was my theatre but it was hard to hear a lot of dialogue due to the background score being so loud. I do like Amanda Waller being so ever present even if it is from the shadows.

CyberCubed
10-24-2022, 10:25 PM
Weirdly I thought The Rock was the weakest part of the movie. He had almost no charisma here at all which is weird because he's usually fun in most of his other movies. I think as said, him doing the serious role doesn't really work. He needs to be written like a goofball or fun badass type character, not a stoic one.

Usually there's always a moment in his movies where he does something so ridiculous you can't help but laugh, but there was nothing in that here.

Leo656
10-24-2022, 10:38 PM
It's kind of a Catch-22, there really isn't anyone else who physically embodies the role as well, but as stated, he almost always plays a goof which does not fit Black Adam at all.

I blame the director, frankly. I know nothing about him but the entire point of a director is to direct the actors' performance. I've read many people say that this director has never made a truly good movie and I can kind of believe that, and a director can make or break an actor's performance. For example, look at the Star Wars Prequels: A bunch of REALLY good actors (...and Hayden F*cking Christiansen, but let's ignore that for a moment), all giving THE worst performances of their entire respective careers. That only happens if you have a bad director, or one who doesn't care about capturing the human performance as much as the spectacle of things.

I'm pretty sure that was the case here. A director in way over his head, focusing so much on getting the CGI shots right that they didn't bother directing the cast well.

They honestly should have just had Snyder do this movie, I'm dead f*cking serious. It'd be an easy 10/10, with all the plot holes and other "WTF-ery" completely neutralized, much better visuals, and much better performances from the cast with actual emotion being displayed.

oldmanwinters
10-24-2022, 10:59 PM
I am not familiar with Shazam lore but for a movie like this, the backstory seems needlessly convoluted. Kinda reminds me of Keanu Reeves’ Constantine in that regard.

AquaParade
10-24-2022, 11:05 PM
It doesn’t matter what’chu think!

Andrew NDB
10-24-2022, 11:33 PM
It's kind of a Catch-22, there really isn't anyone else who physically embodies the role as well,

Well, Black Adam has never been like a HUGE Rock-like guy. He's usually portrayed a little bit like Namor with a swimmer's body. He DOES look a lot like the Rock did around 1999-2000 or so (hair included... and why didn't they bother to give the Rock some hair in this, exactly?). Toned but not monstrous.

Oh, and one thing I didn't mention. I definitely did hear the John Williams theme when Superman showed up! The rumor was true. It worked. I wouldn't mind seeing the full John Williams score utilized in places in a new Superman movie alongside the Zimmer-type stuff.

Leo656
10-25-2022, 12:29 AM
I am not familiar with Shazam lore but for a movie like this, the backstory seems needlessly convoluted. Kinda reminds me of Keanu Reeves’ Constantine in that regard.

It was, especially the third act plot twist that The First Champion was not Teth Adam but Teth Adam's son. That was all handled very badly and I don't think it was necessary at all.

I get WHY they did it; the movie opens with a young, idealistic kid talking about overthrowing oppression and being a hero... THEN we meet "Black Adam" and he's just a big angry rage monster, and the two seem to be completely irreconcilable, personality-wise. "This kid was talking about heroes a minute ago, now he's blowing people up with magic lightning bolts? That ain't right..."

So to explain, it, "Okay, the kid was Teth Adam's SON, and hence Black Adam is so angry and violent because he saw his family get killed. And it reconciles the two things somewhat but it definitely needed to be handled better, OR not even bother going there and just writing a better, cleaner origin story. Just say "He WAS all idealistic but then he immediately became corrupted by the power since the power was never meant for mortals to wield in the first place."

That's what I THOUGHT they were going to do, and what they should have done. The only reason I think they did not is because it's "predictable", but sometimes that's just plain better. Not everything needs to be a surprise or a twist. That whole reveal is easily, EASILY the worst thing in the entire movie, because it's so clunky, poorly done and very ill-timed; they give you this big exposition dump and then jump to a big action scene, and you can barely focus on the action scene because you're still going "Wait, so WHAT was that about with his kid, now?" Quit trying to outsmart the audience; Keep It Simple, Stupid.

There's so much disparate canon with all of the Marvels that I only know some of it well myself, but I think they were trying very hard to merge different canons into one for this, and it didn't really work. Like in the series 52 back in 2005 or so, there was a big plot about his present-day family being killed and THAT set him off on a rage - he actually murdered the entire country of Khandaq - but that was completely different from this one, I think they just wanted to keep the bones of "his family was killed" and go from there. But it's just clunky, doesn't work. Should have just said "the power corrupted him", would've been ten times better.

It also would have furthered the Adam/Superman parallels, because people being afraid of his power and how it may corrupt him has been Superman's entire arc since Man of Steel. Yeah, they just tried to do too much and f*cked it up.

Xav
10-25-2022, 04:49 AM
I just started watching this and Hawkman is black now? I somehow missed the casting. Also is he human or is he a black man from Thanagar? There are black aliens now?

Why wasn't there an uproar that Hawkman is black?Cyclone also wasn't black in the comics, but I guess becuase they aren't super well known charaters their casting isn't gonna make news.

Leo656
10-25-2022, 05:05 AM
Yeah I was gonna say I wish they hadn't flipped either her or Hawkman, but I ended up liking the actors enough to not care incredibly much, and Cyclone is such a deep cut character I was able to shrug that one off easier. They did an okay job, I liked how they did it. She was one of my favorite things in the movie, actually. Especially the way they played with color during her action scenes.

I liked the little "...And we're the rookies!" deal they had going on with her and Atom Smasher, it wasn't overbearing to me and they were both at the least competent. Atom Smasher was a bit of a clumsy noob but I've seen him kinda be like that in the comics, too.

I actually liked everyone pretty much, the kid annoyed me but more so in the beginning and I guess I got used to him after a while, but definitely the weakest part of the movie. But as far as the main cast and particularly Adam and the JSA, I thought they did good. Rock obviously sort of whiffed on it, but for some reason I don't blame him, I feel like it wasn't entirely his fault. Like I'm sure there are other takes of those scenes where he maybe played it darker or more menacing, like there are times you can see a much better performance juuuuust beneath the one you are seeing. I hope he grows into the role a little bit, I'm sure he will, it'll come more natural to him as he gets used to it. I actually got a kick out of the Clint Eastwood bit.

I wasn't a huge fan of Hawkman's retractable wings, but I almost get it, I'unno. I mean, you CAN do that, and it's realistic, it's just I'unno I wouldn't have bothered. He looked weird every time he would be standing there with just the helmet on and no wings, like the wings complete the whole thing, man. When he was at "full mast" and everything he looked cool, but I think his outfit is too plain. Needed to be at least a bit more comics accurate. But I liked him, I liked the mace and everything. They did pretty good, I wanted to see the Claw of Horus but I guess you can't have everything.

I liked the movie, it's fun but I think the more you see it some more of the rough stuff will stick out.

CyberCubed
10-25-2022, 06:28 AM
Honestly the whole jet and the mansion with the two young teen superheroes reminded me of the X-men more than anything else. I half expected Prof. Xavier to make a cameo.

oldmanwinters
10-25-2022, 08:31 AM
That whole reveal is easily, EASILY the worst thing in the entire movie, because it's so clunky, poorly done and very ill-timed; they give you this big exposition dump and then jump to a big action scene, and you can barely focus on the action scene because you're still going "Wait, so WHAT was that about with his kid, now?" Quit trying to outsmart the audience; Keep It Simple, Stupid. . . .

It also would have furthered the Adam/Superman parallels, because people being afraid of his power and how it may corrupt him has been Superman's entire arc since Man of Steel.

The way I see it, EITHER backstory could have worked for a single BA movie. The one they settled on reveals BA to be a brokenhearted dad, thus the emotional anchor of the plot has to do with him becoming a surrogate father of sorts to the new kid/kids. Doesn't make it a great film, but it WORKS for a one-off tale. Now the question is... how much is Warners committed to that portrayal going forward with a franchise (because this business is all about "What's Next?"). Does anybody really want to see Amon as a major factor in the DCEU going forward? And if the franchise soon shoves Amon and Professor Adrianna into obscurity, what's the point then? And then they can always kill 'em off to force BA into another traumatic, rage state, but I thought "Fridging" characters had long fallen out of favor.

Yes, I think going with the "Power Corrupted Superman/Shazam" angle makes a lot more sense long-term, and it could have worked perfectly well for a debut movie too. If Warners ever gets around to the Apocalyptic Injustice-style future foreshadowed since BvS, then having an established Black Adam gets even more interesting. Maybe BA ends up influencing Superman on the lure of revenge over lost love?

Cyclone also wasn't black in the comics, but I guess becuase they aren't super well known charaters their casting isn't gonna make news.

I hate to admit, but my first thought after seeing both was "where those characters [her and Hawkman] originally redheads in the comics?"

Sure enough, Cyclone was, but at least they tried to throw a bone with the actress having read highlights. As for Katar Hol/Carter Hall... eh, my lazy Google searches suggest he's been traditionally black or brown haired. Maybe Hawkgirl in the JLU cartoons being so prominently red-headed made me expect we'd have another instance of Hollywood race-changing a traditional red-headed character.

I think Hodge & Swindell did a perfectly fine job in the movie (I don't care to see a movie with them as leads), but that's just the cynical old man I am when it comes to these things.

Honestly the whole jet and the mansion with the two young teen superheroes reminded me of the X-men more than anything else. I half expected Prof. Xavier to make a cameo.

VERY X-Men-ish.

I did appreciate seeing the name Task Force X on screen, so now we have both a Suicide Squad, TFX, and Justice Society rolling around under Waller's supervision. PLUS, she's got Superman on speed dial? I think Cavill had ALMOST as much dialogue in this movie as he did in all of BvS (https://www.digitalspy.com/movies/a791456/henry-cavill-batman-v-superman-dawn-of-justice-lines/).

Andrew NDB
11-03-2022, 01:13 AM
So it's not looking good for Black Adam. Weekend #2 is over with now and it's just sitting at 115 domestic and 139 international. It seems set to end at Shazam! numbers (which are 140 domestic and 223 international), which would be fine except Shazam!'s budget was 85 million... and Black Adam's budget is 200 million. Honestly, the best hope Black Adam has at this point is somehow clawing its way to baaaarely break even over the next two weekends, then it's all over.

Leo656
11-03-2022, 03:08 AM
Supposedly it releases in China on November 11th and they're expecting it to do around $200 million over there.

Andrew NDB
11-03-2022, 03:50 AM
Supposedly it releases in China on November 11th and they're expecting it to do around $200 million over there.

That could move the meter a bit, sure.

So I'm not saying giving him hair or actual Black Adam ears would have helped or hurt, but why weren't they there?

Turo602
11-03-2022, 04:43 AM
So I'm not saying giving him hair or actual Black Adam ears would have helped or hurt, but why weren't they there?

I think they avoided the hair and pointy ears because The Rock is far more well known and recognizable than Black Adam, and the selling point of this whole project from day one was seeing The Rock as a Superman level being kicking ass and one day crossing paths with Superman. Black Adam himself was never the point and a casual audience who recognizes The Rock would likely be distracted by The Rock with a Black Adam cut and silly pointed ears. The internet would have just ended up mocking it like they do everything because casuals aren't actually invested enough in Black Adam to see a Black Adam film, they're there to see The Rock.

Leo656
11-03-2022, 05:01 AM
I agree with that. I think giving him a goofy-looking hairpiece would have been a distraction and just one more thing for the critics to rip apart, and they're already being way more brutal than usual for some reason.

Like, I'm generally all about fidelity, and I prefer the characters look as close to the comics as possible. But let's be honest, if you want someone to "disappear into a role" and fully embody their character... you don't call The Rock. You call The Rock when you want everyone to go see your new The Rock movie starring The Rock that has The Rock in it.

Would've been "nice" if he had the hairpiece, but people just would've made fun of it and it's such an innocuous thing. For me it's like Cavill's spitcurl as Superman, it's cute when they bother to do it but when they don't do it I don't actually care.

Stuff like that shouldn't be a big deal. Like, the spitcurl was such a priority for Superman Returns that they had a special clip-on spitcurl for Brandon Routh to wear, since his hair just plain refused to cooperate no matter how much gel they used. :lol: And it looks so dumb I wish they didn't even bother, and knowing the lengths they went to just to say, "SEE! He has a spitcurl!" just illustrates how off those peoples' priorities were. Did it help anything about the movie? Nah. Did it look dumb and kinda fake (since it WAS fake)? Yeah. Would it have made any difference at all if they just said "F*ck it" and let his hair do whatever it wanted? Newp.

Sometimes you can't get hung up on the minutiae. That's for meth-heads like Bryan Singer to do. :trazz:

Andrew NDB
11-05-2022, 04:49 AM
So... there's a lot of articles about it won't open in China because Pierce Brosnan wore a Taiwan thing somewhere in the press for the movie.

Though also... the ears. China? Is there a John Cena-like thing going on there? Ehhhh...

Leo656
11-05-2022, 10:11 AM
Well, that's a bummer.

Sets a terrible precedent, too, since now every DC movie is gonna be extra super-duper "safe" to avoid pissing off China, on account of how bad they need their money.

Coola Yagami
11-05-2022, 10:30 AM
The moment AMERICAN productions relied on the Chinese box office is when we started losing. I remember the first time I heard whatever movie had to change this or that 'cause of China', I was like 'wtf? why? who gives a flying **** what China thinks'. Then I was told about the importance of China and how badly we need their money and I'm still like 'wtf? why?'

Leo656
11-05-2022, 10:41 AM
Movies are too expensive nowadays, that's all there is to it.

If your movie can't be a success without bending over for an evil totalitarian regime that unleashed a global manmade Death Plague, you need to stop insisting that movies need $300 million budgets and billion-dollar grosses. Go back to props and stop-motion and matte painted backgrounds if you have to. Common sense needs to prevail at some point.

IMJ
11-05-2022, 02:07 PM
Movies are too expensive nowadays, that's all there is to it.

If your movie can't be a success without bending over for an evil totalitarian regime that unleashed a global manmade Death Plague, you need to stop insisting that movies need $300 million budgets and billion-dollar grosses. Go back to props and stop-motion and matte painted backgrounds if you have to. Common sense needs to prevail at some point.

This is why every horror movie does well. All you need is two cameras, 6 actors and a horror gimmick to fall within a 10 million dollar producer's budget and you'll most likely make at least 40 million in theaters on it.

Leo656
11-05-2022, 04:00 PM
Yep. Halloween Ends had one of the biggest second-week dropoffs in HISTORY and yet still turned a huge profit because it cost nothing to make. The horrible reviews and word of mouth did no damage at all because it made its budget back many times over in two days.

Granted, that's apples and oranges compared to super-hero movies, but the basic idea is the same. "Gotta spend money to make money" DOES NOT apply to the movie business, all you do is dig yourself a hole.

Andrew NDB
11-07-2022, 12:14 PM
HfrmzSX4J-M

LeotheLateBloomer
11-07-2022, 01:53 PM
Yep. Halloween Ends had one of the biggest second-week dropoffs in HISTORY and yet still turned a huge profit because it cost nothing to make. The horrible reviews and word of mouth did no damage at all because it made its budget back many times over in two days.

Granted, that's apples and oranges compared to super-hero movies, but the basic idea is the same. "Gotta spend money to make money" DOES NOT apply to the movie business, all you do is dig yourself a hole.

Audiences never learn, especially dumb teens who just want to see a rated R horror film, good or bad reviews aside.

Andrew NDB
11-08-2022, 01:20 AM
Audiences never learn, especially dumb teens who just want to see a rated R horror film, good or bad reviews aside.

I've watched Halloween Ends twice now. Once with the wife and once with the daughter. I really don't think we could've gotten much more than this. A root exploration of what causes "evil" at the same time as we get a Michael Meyers final run of it. Definitively. This wasn't a retread.

If anything, like the last one, I just wanted more of that funny black kid from the 2018 movie.

Andrew NDB
11-19-2022, 04:05 PM
Looks like that's it for Black Adam. 153 million domestic plus 201 international and no China release happening. It's going to close slightly under what Shazam! did, though again, Shazam! had less than half of the budget of Black Adam and that was considered a modest success. After on demand and such Black Adam will barely, barely break even and that's a big "if." Imagine if the Cavill appearance hadn't have even leaked?

So yeah, forget about Black Adam 2. Maybe he'll show up again in some team-up movie or Shazam! 3 (also a big if, since Shazam! 2's success is hardly a given) or something, but that'll be it. The Rock lied... the hierarchy of the DCEU didn't change. It didn't even cause a ripple.

Also, it's pretty sad to look at the slate of previous DCEU movies. They haven't had a single movie that's made money since Shazam! itself, and that wasn't even like a big blockbuster. Birds of Prey, Wonder Woman 1984, The Suicide Squad, all big losers.

The moment AMERICAN productions relied on the Chinese box office is when we started losing. I remember the first time I heard whatever movie had to change this or that 'cause of China', I was like 'wtf? why? who gives a flying **** what China thinks'. Then I was told about the importance of China and how badly we need their money and I'm still like 'wtf? why?'

I don't have a problem with studios reediting movies for other countries, removing this or changing that, or adding stuff (like giving that Chinese guy a somewhat bigger part in the Chinese version of Iron Man 2)... but when the actual movie that arrives in US theaters is tainted or shaped by that... that's bullsh**.

ZariusTwo
11-22-2022, 12:43 PM
Film's out on Digital VOD already. L taken.

Leo656
12-07-2022, 01:20 AM
Now that the dust is settled, it's official: WB is gonna lose between $100-200 million on "The Great Course-Correction Movie". The movie they went to great lengths to convince us would be "the saving grace of the DCEU" is perhaps its most high-profile failure. Consider that BoP and the Squad sequel did very badly, but nobody expected big returns on those movies. THIS was touted as the DC movie that was finally gonna win everyone over, establish brand confidence among critics and fans, and finally set a firm and stable course for the future, and... nope.

I've said it before and I'll say it a million times: As divisive as Snyder's movies were, at least they made Actual Profit. BvS may have a dismal RT score and may in fact be THE most "love it or hate it" movie in all of movies period, not just super-hero fare, but at least there's not $200 million of red ink stuck to it. It's actually one of the most financially-successful DC movies of all time, factoring in discs and such. So somebody liked it.

But lest we forget, the current state of the DCEU is ALL because WB demanded that BvS make about $1.1 billion and it "only" made a little under 900 mil. Still profitable, still plenty of toys sold, altogether a very successful piece of business for WB even if the reviews were scathing. BUT, "not good enough", they dumped both Baby and Bathwater and they've been floundering ever since. Wonder Woman and Aquaman did okay but that feels like forever ago, now, and more recently WB would KILL for one of their DCEU movies to "just" scrape under 900 mil. That "failure" that started all of their woes in the first place is a result they would do anything to replicate, now. When goddamn "Shazam!" with its honestly crummy box office take is considered a "success" as far as the DCEU, you really gotta wonder what the hell these people grade by. For the last 5 years it seems like they settle for, "Well, we barely made money (or lost a ton of it) BUT the reviews in Entertainment Weekly weren't so bad!"

I don't see Flash or Aquaman 2 doing huge business either, frankly. More and more, it's like "They REALLY should have just let Zack do his thing" seems like the best-case scenario. I mean even if it had failed, it'd all be over and done with by now and we'd be looking at the hard reboot and a clean slate. And if it had gotten over with people in the long run, then even better. As it is, pushing him out seems like a worse mistake every day because it's clear as a bell they really have no ultimate plan or vision for this sh*t. All WB knows how to do is react, and then OVER react.

All the hoopla about "James Gunn is gonna save the DCEU!", and so far we have a Blue Beetle poster and some more whispers about Spielberg doing Blackhawks. Yawn. It's still ultimately WB in charge, and it's still a giant f*cking mess of their own making over there.

CyberCubed
12-07-2022, 06:27 AM
Even if this was a great movie, the reason it bombed is because literally nobody cares or even knows who Black Adam is. And The Rock cast as him obviously doesn't hold as much star power as he used to.

Instead of DC making sure movies for their top heroes work, they keep making movies about characters nobody in the real world even knows. The Blue Beetle movie is going to bomb just as bad too, even if the movie itself turns out good.

IMJ
12-07-2022, 09:43 AM
Well to James Gunn's credit he did remove DC's "Gorilla Limit". So.... you know. :roll:

AquaParade
12-07-2022, 09:49 AM
All the hoopla about "James Gunn is gonna save the DCEU!", and so far we have a Blue Beetle poster and some more whispers about Spielberg doing Blackhawks. Yawn. It's still ultimately WB in charge, and it's still a giant f*cking mess of their own making over there.

James Gunn hasn't had a chance to do anything yet. He's simply helping past projects reach completion while he plans for the future.

As for it still being WB in charge - yes and no. David Zaslav is upending the entire operation they had going on, from the looks of things. It's a new approach.

Generally speaking, WB has been very reactionary, but that's in part due to the constant changes in leadership. But with Zaslav at the top now, he should be able to reign that in a little, especially with Gunn in the big chair - a guy who clearly has a plan and a vision (which, no, I don't think is going to be full on dick-jokes by any stretch).

Autbot_Benz
12-07-2022, 06:24 PM
Dwayne Johnson
@TheRock
Waited to confirm with financiers before I shared this excellent #BlackAdam news - our film will PROFIT between $52M-$72M.
Fact.
At almost $400M worldwide we are building our new franchise step by step (first Captain America did $370M) for the DC future.


https://twitter.com/TheRock/status/1600589666683846656

Leo656
12-07-2022, 11:38 PM
The reports are conflicting. I don't buy Rock's tweet, sounds like spin.

Reports are coming out that since Black Adam failed, WB is back in "hard reboot" mode. Aquaman 2 will be allegedly be used to close off the DCEU once and for all, after which the entire franchise will be given a total reboot. Every single actor will be recast and things will start over from Zero.

This directly clashes with the reports that Black Adam 2 is on the fast track and Hawkman as well... but what is MORE likely, in all honesty, considering the movie lost a fortune (no matter WHAT Dwayne says)?

Supposedly there will be a "major announcement" next week to let everyone know once and for all what the DC plan is, so there's no more confusion or mixed signals. Smart money says it's the "hard reboot" announcement.

Ah well.

AquaParade
12-08-2022, 07:28 AM
The reports are conflicting. I don't buy Rock's tweet, sounds like spin.

Reports are coming out that since Black Adam failed, WB is back in "hard reboot" mode. Aquaman 2 will be allegedly be used to close off the DCEU once and for all, after which the entire franchise will be given a total reboot. Every single actor will be recast and things will start over from Zero.

This directly clashes with the reports that Black Adam 2 is on the fast track and Hawkman as well... but what is MORE likely, in all honesty, considering the movie lost a fortune (no matter WHAT Dwayne says)?

Supposedly there will be a "major announcement" next week to let everyone know once and for all what the DC plan is, so there's no more confusion or mixed signals. Smart money says it's the "hard reboot" announcement.

Ah well.

Also, Variety removed the mention of BA2 and a Hawkman spin-off from their article. Must have been shut down by Gunn, possibly behind the scenes to help them save face. He’s been shutting down rumors hardcore since he took the job.
He put a few grifters in their place on Twitter and it was glorious to watch.

I think it’s pretty clear to see The Rock was trying to make a power play, and was leveraging the Snyder fandom and Cavill to make that happen. It didn’t really work.

I’m thinking Rock had to fight very hard for Cavill, and when it didn’t bring the film to even break even, the studio decided “eff it, let’s reboot.”

If that is the case, it would be very presumptuous of Cavill though. He’s out there saying “I’m back, I’m back.” I’ve gotta think he will play Superman again at least once, but who knows at this point. I’d think even with a reboot, you could do some multiverse shenanigans to give the guy his due. Will be extremely interesting and kinda sad if that cameo was his last appearance. Hard to imagine. Cavill is just hard to place a bead on. He tends to be vague when discussing Superman, he turns down a lot of cameos, he didn’t seem to love Zack’s vision, rumors (I stress the word) are that he’s difficult to work with. So who knows.

Coola Yagami
12-08-2022, 12:20 PM
Also, Variety removed the mention of BA2 and a Hawkman spin-off from their article. Must have been shut down by Gunn, possibly behind the scenes to help them save face. He’s been shutting down rumors hardcore since he took the job.
He put a few grifters in their place on Twitter and it was glorious to watch.

I think it’s pretty clear to see The Rock was trying to make a power play, and was leveraging the Snyder fandom and Cavill to make that happen. It didn’t really work.

I’m thinking Rock had to fight very hard for Cavill, and when it didn’t bring the film to even break even, the studio decided “eff it, let’s reboot.”

If that is the case, it would be very presumptuous of Cavill though. He’s out there saying “I’m back, I’m back.” I’ve gotta think he will play Superman again at least once, but who knows at this point. I’d think even with a reboot, you could do some multiverse shenanigans to give the guy his due. Will be extremely interesting and kinda sad if that cameo was his last appearance. Hard to imagine. Cavill is just hard to place a bead on. He tends to be vague when discussing Superman, he turns down a lot of cameos, he didn’t seem to love Zack’s vision, rumors (I stress the word) are that he’s difficult to work with. So who knows.

Shoulda just done Man of Steel 2 way back then before all the crossover business. Bad enough they had to put Batman in the sequel, where now all the press was more concerned about who will play the new Batman rather than anything related to Superman, then they cram in Doomsday and Wonder Woman AND hints of the other heroes existing too.

AquaParade
12-08-2022, 12:43 PM
Shoulda just done Man of Steel 2 way back then before all the crossover business. Bad enough they had to put Batman in the sequel, where now all the press was more concerned about who will play the new Batman rather than anything related to Superman, then they cram in Doomsday and Wonder Woman AND hints of the other heroes existing too.

Hard to imagine due to butterfly effect, but it sounds better than what they did, to me.

A hypothetical Man of Steel 2 sounds awesome, and it allows Ben Affleck some time to develop his vision, without having to prepare for the role so soon.

Autbot_Benz
12-08-2022, 12:49 PM
James Gunn
@JamesGunn
So. As for the story yesterday in the Hollywood Reporter, some of it is true, some of it is half-true, some of it is not true, & some of it we haven’t decided yet whether it’s true or not.
10:27 AM · Dec 8, 2022


Although this first month at DC has been fruitful, building the next ten years of story takes time & we’re still just beginning.

Peter & I chose to helm DC Studios knowing we were coming into a fractious environment, both in the stories being told & in the audience itself & there would be an unavoidable transitional period as we moved into telling a cohesive story across film, TV, animation, and gaming.



But, in the end, the drawbacks of that transitional period were dwarfed by the creative possibilities & the opportunity to build upon what has worked in DC so far & to help rectify what has not.


We know we are not going to make every single person happy every step of the way, but we can promise everything we do is done in the service of the STORY & in the service of the DC CHARACTERS we know you cherish and we have cherished our whole lives.



As for more answers about the future of the DCU, I will sadly have to ask you to wait. We are giving these characters & the stories the time & attention they deserve & we ourselves still have a lot more questions to ask & answer.

from Gunn's twitter

Andrew NDB
12-13-2022, 11:03 PM
The more Gunn talks about things the more I'm getting worried, honestly. I hope we get some actual good news soon. The "announcement" about Cavill is back and a new Superman movie is coming was like the only good, exciting news to come out about the DCEU in many years now. And now that might be pulled away? It'd be fine and enough for now if they just reassured people with a quick, "Yes, Cavill's our guy, yes he's going to be headlining a new Superman movie. No, we haven't figured out what exactly that's going to resemble."

I also don't like the way Gunn is handling fans, en masse. I'm already seeing a lot of "Oh, you're probably typing this from your mom's basement!" type stuff from him in response to posts that aren't even that bad or rude. The same exact stuff you'd hear from the whole cast of Ghostbusters 2016 and its defenders everyday when that came out and the reactions started coming in.

I admit, though, if it does turn out that there was absolutely no real deal with Cavill to do a new Superman movie or anything, and he solo announced something that wasn't actually happening while knowing that new heads hadn't even started yet and would of course have their own ideas about things... eh... that kind of paints Cavill in a certain light. And not a good one. Even if it was a calculated power play to try and force the hands of whoever took over afterward... not good.

Leo656
12-13-2022, 11:40 PM
I also don't like the way Gunn is handling fans, en masse. I'm already seeing a lot of "Oh, you're probably typing this from your mom's basement!" type stuff from him in response to posts that aren't even that bad or rude.

Statistically, he's probably not wrong.

ZariusTwo
12-14-2022, 03:28 AM
I don't see the ten year plan sticking at all. Warner wants instantanious results, fans want instantaneous results. They completely lack the patience of Marvel and it's fanbase.

ZariusTwo
12-17-2022, 08:03 AM
Dwayne has unfollowed Warner and DC on social media

https://twitter.com/homeofdcu/status/1603897686066925568?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5 Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1603897686066925568%7Ctwgr% 5Ef73019e7531142c1e35b4cf38a7b97bcd0134157%7Ctwcon %5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fofficialfan.proboards.com%2F thread%2F623658%2Fpurpose-news-thread-henry-again%3Fpage%3D16

Leo656
12-17-2022, 08:23 AM
So, what MCU character is he gonna play?

I bet he feels like a real dope. A week ago he was on Twitter bragging about "$50 million profit for Black Adam! Sequel and Hawkman spin-off are Go!" a f*cking hour before word came out that everything was cancelled. :lol: "Wanted to wait and get confirmation from the financiers"... Buddy, you don't need a meteorologist to tell you it's raining sh*t if it's already up to your neck. Take your hundreds of millions and go buy a clue. Also, bragging about "$50 million profit" in the first place - a lie, first of all; after marketing budgets, they lost a TON on that movie - was super pathetic, considering that's the Movie Money equivalent of about t'ree-fitty. Dude was bragging about finding some change under the sofa cushions, an hour before he got publicly fired.

I mean, it sucks, and it's too bad, but it's Dwayne, so whatever, f*ck him. I AM glad he tried with getting Cavill back, sincerely. But I am also glad I don't have to be grateful to him anymore, either. :trazz:

WB needed his clout much more than he needed them, though. At the rate they're going, forget a "10-year plan", at the rate they're alienating people in the industry in 5 years or less nobody in Hollywood will want to go near WB, especially not the DC Films division. Everyone comes away with just the worst stories and terrible experiences. No wonder they can't find any writer or director for Superman. "Come make DC movies for us! We treat you like sh*t, throw you under the bus, blame you for every shortfall while taking full credit for any and all success you may fall into! It's awesome!"

Like, okay, "money", sure, but... secret is out, now, it's a terrible place to work and other studios pay more, with better treatment. It's like when people ask me if I'd ever want to go to WWE and I answer sincerely "No, not ever," and they swear I'm lying, that I'd go for the money. And I tell them, a bunch of my friends worked there, they all have horror stories, I don't get on a plane anyways and frankly I don't need the money in exchange for ALL the bullsh*t it entails. Money isn't everything, and there's no point in working where people treat you like sh*t.

"Our 10-Year DC Plan! Year One... see if ANYONE in Hollywood won't hang up immediately when they hear the words 'DC Movie'."

F*ck 'em.

IMJ
12-17-2022, 10:40 AM
Obviously this is only the planning stage for Gunn, but so far all of this has yielded a dismal feeling towards the DCU - like any good will for them is just G-O-N-E-. I also think it's very opportunistic of Gunn to be placed in the position of orchestration that he has been put it, and then he "announces" that HE is working on the next Superman script. My feelings on that are that he is supposed to be organizing the course of action and he should've assigned someone to the next Superman script.

It just feels like a drunk-with-power so I'll get my name on as much as I can in the new-order situation. Just doesn't feel or look good.

Although as to the Black Adam part of this, it also feels that Dwayne Johnson went in like "savior primadonna" as well. He made a movie about a character that nobody was going to care about while throwing veiled shade at the I.P. that his character should've been in. It's like - "dude you are talking about changing the balance of power in a Universe that is failing Superman of all people and you are going on like you are playing the role of a character like Superman." It came off as all ego instead of earnest enthusiasm. I dunno.

AquaParade
12-17-2022, 10:43 AM
So you’re mad at WB for severing their relationship with the Rock after his movie lost them money?

That’s what you do when something fails. Especially if you’re the new head of the studio and had nothing to do with the project. Can’t blame Gunn for WB’s past.
I think Gunn will bring in a lot of talent. People want to work with him. Filmmakers feel they can trust another filmmaker way more than a “suit”.

Andrew NDB
12-17-2022, 01:42 PM
Makes me wonder. Maybe the Rock and his shared agent with Cavill really did think that WB would call off the search for a Feige if Black Adam did gangbusters. But why would WB simultaneously tell Cavill to announce his new Superman movie?

I hope we get some Tweets with the Rock calling Gunn a jabroni.

Sumac
12-17-2022, 02:20 PM
I agree with others who say that WB actively ruining their reputation with that shitshow. I understand, that they have money to offer, but why anyone would work with them long-term, if they change their plans on yearly basis and can change their decisions in the span of several months. Its not like you conduct business or create long-term contracts.

I think Gunn will bring in a lot of talent. People want to work with him. Filmmakers feel they can trust another filmmaker way more than a “suit”.
Like Snyder did? And what had happened with those talents?
You ARE a definition of "This is fine".

TigerClaw
12-17-2022, 02:34 PM
I think the DCU is in good hands, They need to start fresh with new faces playing these characters, And make these characters more relatable, Its part of what the MCU made so successful, They made its character very likable and memorable, This is something DCU needs.

It will be interesting what they will do with the Flash, Aquaman, and Shazam for the DCU.

IMJ
12-17-2022, 02:52 PM
So you’re mad at WB for severing their relationship with the Rock after his movie lost them money?

That’s what you do when something fails. Especially if you’re the new head of the studio and had nothing to do with the project. Can’t blame Gunn for WB’s past.
I think Gunn will bring in a lot of talent. People want to work with him. Filmmakers feel they can trust another filmmaker way more than a “suit”.

Who are you talking to with this post? You didn't quote anyone, and if it was a response to what I wrote, what are you talking about!?!?

AquaParade
12-17-2022, 03:23 PM
Like Snyder did? And what had happened with those talents?
You ARE a definition of "This is fine".

Are you comparing Snyder’s role in the DCEU to Gunn’s position as head of the studio? That would be odd.

And this is fine. Gunn has to be a better fit than the guys who rushed out JL2017 to get a bonus check and Hamada wasn’t looking great either. Not sure what you’re melting down about.

Sumac
12-17-2022, 03:55 PM
Are you comparing Snyder’s role in the DCEU to Gunn’s position as head of the studio? That would be odd.
Why? Snyder was supposed to lead DCCU in terms of both story and style. Gunn is supposed to do the same, with added responsibility of mapping future of CU.

And this is fine. Gunn has to be a better fit than the guys who rushed out JL2017 to get a bonus check and Hamada wasn’t looking great either. Not sure what you’re melting down about.
Except for would be willing to give WB a benefit of the doubt, after shitshow of the last few years?

AquaParade
12-17-2022, 03:58 PM
Why? Snyder was supposed to lead DCCU in terms of both story and style. Gunn is supposed to do the same, with added responsibility of mapping future of CU.


Except for would be willing to give WB a benefit of the doubt, after shitshow of the last few years?

1. Because they are completely different positions. Even when Snyder was taking the lead on the DCEU, he still answered to the studio heads. Gunn IS the studio head.

2. Anyone who was willing to give WB a chance a few months ago should be willing to now. There is actually someone in charge who has passion, a vision, and a clue, for the first time in… who knows how long.
I’m not saying WBD is in a great position but as of late they are finally shaping up. The people whose decisions you are upset with do not work there anymore.

It’s not like they just switched studio heads for the fifth time either. The actual owners of WBD changed. You can hate the previous leadership all you want, but they aren’t even there anymore, so why hold it against the current leadership?

It’s basically like hating your new neighbors simply because the old ones were a-holes. Same old address, completely new leadership.

Andrew NDB
12-17-2022, 04:11 PM
Is it in good hands? Gunn has only shown that he is into juvenile humor with ensemble casts of weird characters... and the last movie he did like that lost a ton of money. Peacemaker was OK, but just more of the same and hardly made a mark.

AquaParade
12-17-2022, 04:17 PM
Is it in good hands? Gunn has only shown that he is into juvenile humor with ensemble casts of weird characters... and the last movie he did like that lost a ton of money. Peacemaker was OK, but just more of the same and hardly made a mark.

Well, he has also produced stuff like Brightburn. I think we are assuming too much if we think that everything in the DCU is going to feel like a James Gunn film.

I’ll say that hearing that he is writing Superman doesn’t excite me. If he ends up directing that, I’ll be curious but not initially excited. I don’t love any of his projects that I’ve seen.

But as a head of the studio, let’s remember who we are comparing him to. Do you want a passionate filmmaker who understands and respects the material as the head of the studio or do you want people like the guys who rushed out 2017 for a bonus check?

We are still going to get different directors and different tones to these films, I’m sure. But now they are going to answer to someone who has a big picture vision and an understanding of filmmaking.

Maybe Gunn gets way too hands-on and turns everything into a big ****-sucking laugh, but I just don’t see it.

ZariusTwo
12-18-2022, 02:17 AM
Maybe Gunn gets way too hands-on and turns everything into a big ****-sucking laugh, but I just don’t see it.

Peacemaker exists.

Andrew NDB
12-18-2022, 02:46 AM
Which brings up an interesting sidenote. Peacemaker season 2 is happening. In season 1 we saw both Ezra Miller Flash and Momoa Aquaman there with a blurry Superman and WW. Foreshadowing? How is any of this going to make sense?

I still think somehow Aquaman Momoa might survive and the core WW movies might survive.

Also... why exactly did the Rock make it a crusade to become buffer than ever for the part? And how dumb does he feel for it not making any difference?

AquaParade
12-18-2022, 05:20 AM
Peacemaker exists.

I’m not sure you understand that he is not writing & directing all of these movies. He wrote all of Peacemaker and directed most of it.

Andrew NDB
12-19-2022, 02:04 AM
It's an interesting situation in that WB wanted to find their own Feige and landed on Gunn, who IS a filmmaker. Kevin Feige is not a filmmaker. He is a super talented and multitasking producer and showrunner on a huge scale. But it's not like Kevin Feige was writing the script for Iron Man.

Which is the interesting part. Imagine if he had. If Kevin Feige wrote the script for Iron Man 1, and then shopped it around to directors who he'd hope to attract as hired guns. To start out the MCU. Because that's what happening with Superman.

Chris
12-19-2022, 07:41 AM
Which brings up an interesting sidenote. Peacemaker season 2 is happening. In season 1 we saw both Ezra Miller Flash and Momoa Aquaman there with a blurry Superman and WW. Foreshadowing? How is any of this going to make sense?


My gut feeling is Gunn will get Peacemaker season 2 out in 2023/2024 with the first reboot films arriving in 2025.

Andrew NDB
12-20-2022, 08:19 PM
The Rock turned down a Black Adam cameo in Shazam 2.

https://screenrant.com/shazan-2-dwayne-johnson-refused-black-adam-cameo/

That's a great way to not get people excited about the one place we might ever see his Black Adam again, at this point.

Sumac
12-21-2022, 01:37 PM
Rock burns bridges with DC?

Andrew NDB
01-07-2023, 07:50 PM
So the Rock's takeaway from Black Adam is that he discovered that he's even more awesome than he thought.

https://www.darkhorizons.com/dwayne-johnson-accepts-black-adam-failure/

IMJ
01-07-2023, 08:20 PM
The rock is in a deepening spiral of overcompensation in his public announcements that I'm pretty sure began the minute he first said "the hierarchy of power, bla bla bla"

Coola Yagami
01-07-2023, 09:51 PM
Poor dude still thinks he's cutting promos in WWE and that they mean anything in real life.

oldmanwinters
01-24-2023, 03:09 PM
Sounds like Shazam 2 has a marketing (budget?) problem:
https://www.cbr.com/warner-bros-discovery-marketing-failure-shazam-2/

IMJ
01-24-2023, 05:12 PM
Sounds like Shazam 2 has a marketing (budget?) problem:
https://www.cbr.com/warner-bros-discovery-marketing-failure-shazam-2/

I wouldn't doubt it. They'll want to make their money back but they don't want to milk the box office so that there's no argument to be made for a 3rd movie. Either that or even more likely, it's probably a "cut your losses" move for a movie that has absolutely zero hype behind it.

sdp
08-21-2025, 01:10 PM
I just watched the Shazam trilogy:

Shazam:not as good as people made it out to be, I think the kid to adult wasn't used well enough as it could've, it's not bad just nothing special
Shazam 2:I liked some of the themes but overall like last movie it doesn't do enough, it feels like a more of the same sequel

Black Adam: such a mixed bag, I would've liked it more had it had more Shazam connections than the few ones we got. Why is he an antihero? Why is everyone so unwilling to kill to be s hero? The dceu was very murderous hell even Gunn's DCU has hawkgirl killing and here that's what makes Black Adam so bad? So silly. It has good things as well I enjoyed it but not enough for this to have rebooted the DCEU.

Andrew NDB
08-21-2025, 01:21 PM
Black Adam is really a bizarre thing. But then so is Shazam 2. A big part of it all is the Rock smelling his own farts... wanting to... what did he say... "change the hierarchy of power" at WB/the DCEU? First in refusing to appear in Shazam 2 in any capacity and then in making Black Adam the big, bloated and ultimately very stupid movie it was. All the while getting people's hopes up for a Cavill movie that would never happen, because the Rock thought he was "on top" of WB with their superheroes.

It makes you wonder, though. If Black Adam had made a billion dollars... what then? James Gunn still soldiers on, cancels the Cavill movie, stuffs Black Adam into the corner exactly how it went? I really doubt it. I think the Rock's power play would have worked, but it hinged on Black Adam doing big numbers (it didn't, it failed).

I also think Gunn is being repeatedly pretty dishonest in interviews, over and over again.

sdp
08-21-2025, 01:29 PM
It would've been an interesting messy timeline to be in, even if a worse one.Same for all those movies that came out during the transition, Flash, Aquaman, blue beetle, had any of those made a lot of money WB would've forced Gunn to incorporate them and only make it a soft reboot. All of them failing was likely the best scenario.

But man how hype would Captain Marv..err Shazam vs Black Adam have been. By refusing to fight his nemesis he faield at making a franchise.
Then again a big part of the appeal of Shazam is seeing a kid in an adult body, 2 kind of worked because it was a coming or age movie, but no one wants an adult Billy becoming Shazam.

IMJ
08-21-2025, 02:11 PM
While Zachary Levi played a fun "superhero", he was entirely unconvincing as "Shazam".

I couldn't even bring myself to sit through the second one even if the first was single-viewing-escapism.

The only redeeming aspects of Black Adam were Hawkman (who was great but should fail on the principle of "race swap" alone) and I never thought I'd see the day where I'd love a Dr. Fate movie.

Autbot_Benz
08-21-2025, 06:29 PM
While Zachary Levi played a fun "superhero", he was entirely unconvincing as "Shazam".

I couldn't even bring myself to sit through the second one even if the first was single-viewing-escapism.

The only redeeming aspects of Black Adam were Hawkman (who was great but should fail on the principle of "race swap" alone) and I never thought I'd see the day where I'd love a Dr. Fate movie.

Ya Dr Fate is the only good thing in this movie. I would love for Gunn to bring back Pierce Brosnan’s Dr Fate for his universe

Andrew NDB
08-21-2025, 06:52 PM
Ya Dr Fate is the only good thing in this movie.

And they killed him off.