PDA

View Full Version : Casey and April #4 preview/discussion


ToTheNines
09-19-2015, 09:55 AM
http://www.comicbookresources.com/comic-previews/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-casey-april-4-idw-2015

ChosenOne
09-19-2015, 10:19 AM
Finally! I spent all of yesterday and this morning (in Europe) searching for this preview but you got the drop on me, Nines. I guess they took their sweet time posting it figuring not many people would care about the delay. :evilgrin:

Aaand... Welcome to what the previous three issues should've been like!

ToTheNines
09-19-2015, 12:30 PM
I guess Rat King was (or posed as) Spiro Agnew. Kinda funny.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-19-2015, 12:45 PM
Richard Nixon done got taken in by Rat King? :tlol:

And where the FVCK was all this goodness the first three useless issues?

oldmanwinters
09-19-2015, 01:42 PM
Richard Nixon done got taken in by Rat King? :tlol:



Poor Tricky Dick just can't catch a break when it comes to his portrayal in comic books, I guess. Maybe it's not quite as bad as what Marvel did to him in Captain America #175.

ctt4lfecw
09-19-2015, 03:11 PM
Ah yes the book where nothing really ever happens. Thank god this is over this week. Batman/tmnt here we come!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-19-2015, 05:50 PM
Poor Tricky Dick just can't catch a break when it comes to his portrayal in comic books, I guess. Maybe its' not quite as bad as what Marvel did to him in Captain America #175.

Care to give me a spoiler on Nixon in Captain America? You intrigue me greatly, old man! :tsmile:

ChosenOne
09-19-2015, 06:43 PM
I'll just leave this here...

http://i.imgur.com/frOCuS4.jpg

oldmanwinters
09-19-2015, 06:53 PM
Care to give me a spoiler on Nixon in Captain America? You intrigue me greatly, old man! :tsmile:

Sadly, I've never actually read that infamously historic issue myself, but it was one of the most pivotal events in Captain America's character development way back in the 1970s in the wake of Vietnam and the Watergate scandal. It really shook up Cap as to whether he was really fighting on the side of the good guys anymore. As I understand, it was the conclusion of the "Secret Empire" storyline (now available in a TPB if interested), where Cap discovered the mysterious leader of the Secret Empire was non other than . . . eh... some high ranking government official whose face remained shielded from the reader via silhouette... who promptly committed suicide! Marvel editors tried to distance themselves from committing to the true identity of "Number One," but the authorial intention was pretty obvious.
http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Number_One_%28Secret_Empire_2%29_%28Earth-616%29

ToTheNines
09-19-2015, 07:25 PM
I'll just leave this here...

http://i.imgur.com/frOCuS4.jpg

I laughed a little too hard at that.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-19-2015, 08:41 PM
Sadly, I've never actually read that infamously historic issue myself, but it was one of the most pivotal events in Captain America's character development way back in the 1970s in the wake of Vietnam and the Watergate scandal. It really shook up Cap as to whether he was really fighting on the side of the good guys anymore. As I understand, it was the conclusion of the "Secret Empire" storyline (now available in a TPB if interested), where Cap discovered the mysterious leader of the Secret Empire was non other than . . . eh... some high ranking government official whose face remained shielded from the reader via silhouette... who promptly committed suicide! Marvel editors tried to distance themselves from committing to the true identity of "Number One," but the authorial intention was pretty obvious.
http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Number_One_%28Secret_Empire_2%29_%28Earth-616%29

Interesting indeed! I think my favorite portrayal of Richard Nixon is from Doctor Who's "Day of the Moon" two-part story. I love those episodes...

I'll just leave this here...

http://i.imgur.com/frOCuS4.jpg

Oh Rat King... :tlol: Face it, RK, you haven't done much else yet this story. Unless you redeem yourself with some sheer badassery this issue, you've been reduced to the TMNT's version of Stubb's.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_B._%22Stubb%22_Stubblefield

shredder orokusaki
09-21-2015, 02:33 AM
Will it release tomorow?

old_hob88
09-21-2015, 06:37 AM
Will it release tomorow?

It comes out this Wednesday.

old_hob88
09-21-2015, 06:39 AM
So far the preview for #4 looks better. I'm hoping we get some big payoff this issue to make up for the slow pacing of the first three.

ChosenOne
09-23-2015, 08:20 AM
Well, it was a decent end to the mini, at least... Though it felt a bit rushed, especially after three issues where nothing happened and suddenly we were moving so fast that the final pages came out of nowhere.

Not the best effort by the IDW TMNT crew in terms of a mini, but this issue was at least intriguing.

old_hob88
09-23-2015, 09:41 AM
Well, it was a decent end to the mini, at least... Though it felt a bit rushed, especially after three issues where nothing happened and suddenly we were moving so fast that the final pages came out of nowhere.

Not the best effort by the IDW TMNT crew in terms of a mini, but this issue was at least intriguing.

I agree with this, but I feel the payoff at the end still wasn't worth the first 3 issues. Honestly, we don't really know too much more about the pantheon other than

There is a snake immortal (kinda looks like Scaletail, but that's unlikely) and April is going to play a big part in the coming war. Also "Red"'s real name is Aka.

I was just hoping for something more in terms of what is coming up with the pantheon, or perhaps another character reveal.

I dunno, I just found this whole mini to be a disappointment.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 09:48 AM
I agree with this, but I feel the payoff at the end still wasn't worth the first 3 issues. Honestly, we don't really know too much more about the pantheon other than

There is a snake immortal (kinda looks like Scaletail, but that's unlikely) and April is going to play a big part in the coming war. Also "Red"'s real name is Aka.

I was just hoping for something more in terms of what is coming up with the pantheon, or perhaps another character reveal.

I dunno, I just found this whole mini to be a disappointment.

Haven't had a chance to read it yet. So, to sum EVERYTHING we've learned from this mini-series:


Rat King likes Barbeque,
Rat King has a sister he calls Red but is named Aka and is a crane,
Rat King has a snake sibling,
and last and most importantly...
Mariko Tamaki should NEVER write for TMNT again

old_hob88
09-23-2015, 10:17 AM
Haven't had a chance to read it yet. So, to sum EVERYTHING we've learned from this mini-series:


Rat King likes Barbeque,
Rat King has a sister he calls Red but is named Aka and is a crane,
Rat King has a snake sibling,
and last and most importantly...
Mariko Tamaki should NEVER write for TMNT again


^Pretty much this.

Metalhead 2.0
09-23-2015, 11:53 AM
All I want to know is where did Aka get that pizza?
There wasn't a store for miles and even if there was it's not like she can just walk in there and buy it...

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 12:02 PM
All I want to know is where did Aka get that pizza?
There wasn't a store for miles and even if there was it's not like she can just walk in there and buy it...

Well, this IS a TMNT comic. What better way to disguise a terrible useless story than by including...

Pizza?

Metalhead 2.0
09-23-2015, 12:17 PM
Well, this IS a TMNT comic. What better way to disguise a terrible useless story than by including...

Pizza?

Musta been anchovies, because it stunk.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 12:53 PM
Musta been anchovies, because it stunk.

Hey-o, THAT was great! Nearly fell out of my chair laughing. :tlol:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 01:20 PM
Just finished reading it.

Rat King got one good line of dialogue... "Tell me, how are your fellow warriors? One is... a shell of his former self?" Oh no he didn't! :teek: :tlol:

But seriously, this entire mini-series has been a colossal waste of time and money. There's a WAR coming? Who would've guessed? Really glad we spent $17.27 and four months only to find out that:

Rat King has a crane sister named Aka (or "Red") and The Pantheon is going to war against humanity
That's IT. NOTHING else of any substance. Man, this entire affair has been BS.

old_hob88
09-23-2015, 01:27 PM
Just finished reading it.

Rat King got one good line of dialogue... "Tell me, how are your fellow warriors? One is... a shell of his former self?" Oh no he didn't! :teek: :tlol:

But seriously, this entire mini-series has been a colossal waste of time and money. There's a WAR coming? Who would've guessed? Really glad we spent $17.27 and four months only to find out that:

Rat King has a crane sister named Aka (or "Red") and The Pantheon is going to war against humanity
That's IT. NOTHING else of any substance. Man, this entire affair has been BS.

Made even better by the fact that issue #36 and TMNT/Ghostbusters, and just about everything else since then has basically told us the pantheon is going to war against humanity.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 01:34 PM
Made even better by the fact that issue #36 and TMNT/Ghostbusters, and just about everything else since then has basically told us the pantheon is going to war against humanity.

Exactly.
And seeing how APRIL is the one to find the scroll, and the one to take the initiative to go to California, and the one to work with Professor Miller... NOBODY could predict that SHE would be somehow important in the coming Pantheon war!!! :teek:
Seriously, this is the worst TMNT story by IDW ever. At least Eastman's appalling annual issues have actual action in them.

Metalhead 2.0
09-23-2015, 01:46 PM
At least Eastman's appalling annual issues have actual action in them.

Even if it looks like he was having a seizure while drawing it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 01:51 PM
Even if it looks like he was having a seizure while drawing it.

:tlol: And does them in black and white, so that we can't tell the Turtles apart. Man, even the first issue in the City Fall story arc is pretty lousy... only reason I ever reread it is because Shredder and Miller find Kitsune in the last few pages.

Still, looks like T.S. Eliot next to this Tamaka lady.

Tazi
09-23-2015, 01:52 PM
Sorry, but this was very dissapointing. :(
This story went nowhere, there's simply no real conclusion or development at the end. There nothing new about the pantheon, the Rat King, and we don't even get to know this 'Aka' character. We already know since a long time about the human/pantheon was is coming, it wasn't a new info. What they could give us is a backstory to Kitsune and Rat King and such, or more info about their motivation.
IDW should give Paul Allor all the miniseries. He is one of the best writers TMNT had so far.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 02:26 PM
Hopefully, at least, IDW will learn from this that Tamaka's style of story-non-telling does not belong in TMNT and will not bring them revenue.

It's a difficult decision for me, because I'm a "completist", but I will NOT be buying this mini-series' Trade Paperback edition.

Next time we see the Pantheon in the ongoing TMNT series, I fully expect to see all of this recapped. All it takes is two freaking sentences... that's what this whole damn mini-series boiled down to.

Actually, ONE sentence.

Rat King has a crane sister named Aka who is nice, and the Pantheon is going to war with humanity. No character insight, no world building, nothing. The end. Next time, just give us the fvcking sentence and save us all some money and time, please.

CyberCubed
09-23-2015, 02:48 PM
This was a pretty good issue but this entire mini-series should have been a 2-parter at best. One issue of set-up and then this one and it would have been perfect. I'm glad we finally learned about the Gods and what's to come.

Unfortunately seems like Casey will probably die in the future, but oh well.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 02:55 PM
This was a pretty good issue but this entire mini-series should have been a 2-parter at best. One issue of set-up and then this one and it would have been perfect. I'm glad we finally learned about the Gods and what's to come.

Unfortunately seems like Casey will probably die in the future, but oh well.

Humans have an average lifespan of 70-80 years, so yes, Casey will probably die in the future.

Tazi
09-23-2015, 02:56 PM
Humans have an average lifespan of 70-80 years, so yes, Casey will probably die in the future.

ahhh, good one! :lol:

CyberCubed
09-23-2015, 03:25 PM
Humans have an average lifespan of 70-80 years, so yes, Casey will probably die in the future.

Casey's fate was sealed by the Gods, he will likely die in the upcoming story arc.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 03:49 PM
Casey's fate was sealed by the Gods, he will likely die in the upcoming story arc.

I doubt it. There are any number of ways that fate could be "unsealed", if you will.

For one, what if someday, Hun offers to give his life instead? If Hun's still around, it seems likely the writers have some sort of endgame (possibly even catharsis) in mind beyond just working with the Mutanimals.

boywonder26
09-23-2015, 04:56 PM
I rather enjoyed this story arc, yeah the pace was different and I fell like there could have been a little more to it but over all I liked it..the art was decent as well.

ToTheNines
09-23-2015, 07:16 PM
Hmm, so I really enjoyed 1 and 2, thought 3 was starting to get tedious and I was left a little confused by this one.

However, I think you guys are being really hard on Tamaki. I can imagine that writers of these minis are limited in what they are allowed to reveal, so you can't really blame her for the scope of this story not being as big as you might have hoped.

One thing we can take from this is that Leo survived Vengeance unscathed, since this has to take place after that.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 07:23 PM
Hmm, so I really enjoyed 1 and 2, thought 3 was starting to get tedious and I was left a little confused by this one.

However, I think you guys are being really hard on Tamaki. I can imagine that writers of these minis are limited in what they are allowed to reveal, so you can't really blame her for the scope of this story not being as big as you might have hoped.

One thing we can take from this is that Leo survived Vengeance unscathed, since this has to take place after that.

As you can see in some of our discussion, we've bandied about different ways to tell the same story WITHOUT boring the pants off everyone and WITH developing Casey and April as characters. If I do say so myself, I wrote up a pretty awesome little outline for how the first three issues could have gone, without tripping up anything revealed in the fourth issue.

The same result could have been reached, plot-wise, without being such a tedious journey. THAT is Tamaka's crime, and NO, we are not being too hard on her.

But I'm honestly glad a couple of you were able to enjoy it more than most of us... I salute you.

ToTheNines
09-23-2015, 07:29 PM
I feel you, I thought the overall plot was interesting and different. Perhaps some of the relationship drama was forced, but I still liked it.

I just expected more info in this one. And then the RK/Casey foreshadowing just came outta no where. And then it was over lol.

Also, why is she Tamaka now?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-23-2015, 08:05 PM
I feel you, I thought the overall plot was interesting and different. Perhaps some of the relationship drama was forced, but I still liked it.

I just expected more info in this one. And then the RK/Casey foreshadowing just came outta no where. And then it was over lol.

Also, why is she Tamaka now?

Oops. Because I screwed up. :toops: Tamaki, my bad.

oldmanwinters
09-23-2015, 09:01 PM
Well, it's over!

I enjoyed issue #4, and thought it was well done. However, this series probably could have worked much better as a three-part story. Issues 2 and 3 really run together in my mind to the point where I can't remember what happened in each issue. Issue 1 had so much needless filler scenes with April and Casey meeting the different people that I really wish the whole arc could have been compressed to form a more focused story.

Also, did anybody else think the Rat King's grin looked a whole lot like the Joker from the last season of Batman: The Animated Series?
kepgBBpT7M4

Ninjinister
09-24-2015, 03:28 AM
Aka(i) is Japanese for red (aka being the noun version) so it's less really a nickname and more of a... transliteration, I guess?

FunkyDoesIt
09-24-2015, 05:07 PM
The only ending that would have made this whole micro worth it, would have been a 20$ bill stapled on the last page.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-24-2015, 05:16 PM
The only ending that would have made this whole micro worth it, would have been a 20$ bill stapled on the last page.

I like the way you think, mate, and wholeheartedly concur. :tlol:

oldmanwinters
09-24-2015, 05:57 PM
The only ending that would have made this whole micro worth it, would have been a 20$ bill stapled on the last page.

Man, that would be such a collector's item that I almost wouldn't want to pull it out and ruin the book's near mint value!

ctt4lfecw
09-24-2015, 08:41 PM
Haha haha!!

Metalhead 2.0
09-25-2015, 09:31 AM
Also, did anybody else think the Rat King's grin looked a whole lot like the Joker from the last season of Batman: The Animated Series?

I actually thought his whole gangling, lanky look with the big exaggerated grin was clearly channeling Joker. Even small things like the way he sat in the chair.

swing_kinker
09-25-2015, 11:23 PM
Thought the mini started off well but what a disappointing last two issues. Went out like a wet fart..

The Big Bad
09-26-2015, 03:57 AM
I have no idea if Mariko Tamaki ever read the Archie TMNT comics, or if she set down to try and replicate them with this mini, but either way, that's what I feel we got: this is Archie as hell, and I love it for it. It may be the most successful anyone in the past decade has ever been when it comes to recreating a past TMNT era. And the thing is that it does it without ever trying to replicate that era's set ups or superficial elements, which, if intentional, is really smart. It's probably not intentional though, which makes it all the more fantastic.

And it's so warm! I'll complain until the end of time about how IDW's take on the turtles feels too mechanical, so seeing this, which is the complete opposite of mechanical, feels wonderful. It gives me hope for greater variation in the line's future. Probably not, given the reaction here (and elsewhere?), but heck, I'm going to be optimistic for once.

More of this, please.

Kingoji
09-26-2015, 04:50 AM
^ I kinda see what you mean about the Archie comparisons, but I think that would only really be true if it were applied in the vein I originally came in here to post: That this should not have been a mini. This is the sort of material that should have been going on as an 'aside' in the main books; a couple of pages a month just to keep us up to date that was thrown in between scene changes of the main event.
Granted, the timing would have been tricky given that the last few main issues and at least up to #50 seem to be happening in a couple of hours tops... but actually, thinking about it, I guess so was this mini.

ToTheNines
09-26-2015, 06:30 AM
I have no idea if Mariko Tamaki ever read the Archie TMNT comics, or if she set down to try and replicate them with this mini, but either way, that's what I feel we got: this is Archie as hell, and I love it for it. It may be the most successful anyone in the past decade has ever been when it comes to recreating a past TMNT era. And the thing is that it does it without ever trying to replicate that era's set ups or superficial elements, which, if intentional, is really smart. It's probably not intentional though, which makes it all the more fantastic.

Not sure if I see it. How so, exactly?

oldmanwinters
09-26-2015, 08:57 AM
I have no idea if Mariko Tamaki ever read the Archie TMNT comics, or if she set down to try and replicate them with this mini, but either way, that's what I feel we got: this is Archie as hell, and I love it for it. It may be the most successful anyone in the past decade has ever been when it comes to recreating a past TMNT era.

I agree that the plot definitely feels like something out of the Archie-era akin to TMNT Adventures #40 ("The Other"), but the structural difference is the biggest problem for me. An Archie story would have covered this kind of tale in a single issue, a series of backup strips, or as a feature in one of their 48-page specials. The IDW model stretches these stories out into multiple issues making attempts at cliffhanger endings that amount to overrated teasers.

And I liked the story overall.

ToTheNines
09-27-2015, 09:15 AM
So I just read Vengeance this morning and realized the whole reason they even went to the desert was to retrieve some book that Miller was convinced was out there. Did they even mention in once in this mini?

PangolinFeets
09-27-2015, 09:43 AM
I guess I'm one of the few who liked it. Maybe because I like Tamaki's other work so I knew what we were getting into: A quiet story about a couple trying to figure out their problems and help their friends. I think this did more for Casey than April though, which was a bit disappointing for me. We got to see more of him torn up inside and I loved the scene with him and the drum circle. And Koh NAILS the Rat King. She draws him looking so sly and devious.
Thumbs up from me, IDW.

Shark_Blade
09-27-2015, 09:52 AM
I like it too. Capril are just too cute together. :tlove:

Sophie Campbell
09-27-2015, 10:33 AM
i loved it too! this is probably my favorite IDW TMNT story since Turtles in Time. it really feels like TMNT to me: kinda quiet, weird, pensive at times, symbolism, the feeling of warmth like Big Bad said. i love Rat King and Aka and all of the interlocking IDW mythology but sometimes i wish there could be stories like this but that don't tie into the main overarching interlocking plot or whatever, like April and Casey could go out west for a vacation and run into some random unrelated monsters or spirits or mutants. but whatever, i still loved the mini and it's nice seeing April and Casey more involved with everything and doing stuff without the Turtles. i love how stark yet warm everything is, i like the hazy almost leisurely tone to it. it's light on plot, yeah, but plot isn't everything, storytelling isn't always about driving plot and relaying new plot information, it's way more about tone and the FEEL of the story. it's HOW things happen, i really appreciate this mini for that. and i like that it makes the Rat King seem like less like an outright villain, it's way more nuanced than him being simply an evil entity.

Blossombrooks
09-27-2015, 11:20 AM
I just got around to reading #4 today (the subscription cover looks absolutely amazing by the way Sophie!! :D) It was good in my opinion, I enjoyed learning more about the Rat King, I can't wait to see where he'll pop up again, I'm not sure I believe Aka when she says he isn't ruled by malice.

The Big Bad
09-27-2015, 07:14 PM
I agree that the plot definitely feels like something out of the Archie-era akin to TMNT Adventures #40 ("The Other"), but the structural difference is the biggest problem for me. An Archie story would have covered this kind of tale in a single issue, a series of backup strips, or as a feature in one of their 48-page specials. The IDW model stretches these stories out into multiple issues making attempts at cliffhanger endings that amount to overrated teasers.

And I liked the story overall.

Actually, I feel the structure is a huge part of what that makes this mini feel so Archie-like (or perhaps, more accurately, Steven Murphy-like). Think of something like "The Future Shark Trilogy", which spends its first two issues on exposition, completely forgets to explain just what the baddies are planning to do with the time machine they've been trying to build for the last ten issues, brings in the Rat King to an already overcrowded battle just because, and has a significant part of that final battle to take place further in the future for reasons that are not entirely apparent. Or think of "Dreamland", which just goes from scene to scene without much of an attempt to thematically connect them all. Granted, the Archie books would include considerably more action than this mini did, but it's very much the same approach to storytelling, focused more on (loosely connected) set pieces aimed at creating impressions, rather than on creating a tightly plotted story.

ctt4lfecw
09-27-2015, 08:31 PM
I don't know. I walked in thinking we were gonna get True Detective, this Washtenaw I was expecting. It's better when read all together. But it's definitely been the worst to wait in between months for. Such a let down. I like Aka and Rat King had some good dialogue in the last issue, but it's not enough to make up for the last 4 months.

Joey Kamikaze
09-28-2015, 01:51 AM
One of the first rules of storytelling is "Don't waste my time." This mini-series broke that rule from beginning to end. It reminds me of a lot of late 90's/early 00's anime, the parade of post-Evangelion stuff where there was this focus on having characters give half-statements or deal with existential quandaries that are supposed to be all deep and meaningful, keeping plot elements hidden as if that somehow improved them... and that sort of storytelling is utterly boring in the hands of 99% of writers. These four issues were all style, no substance, and they didn't contribute anything to the overall narrative.

Here's to hoping this weaboo girl never gets her wannabe manga style near TMNT again.

ToTheNines
09-28-2015, 04:37 AM
Well she's Japanese, so you can't really call her a weeaboo...

The Big Bad
09-28-2015, 05:52 AM
Here's to hoping this weaboo girl never gets her wannabe manga style near TMNT again.

We're done with trying to make creators feel welcome here, I see.

ToTheNines
09-28-2015, 06:04 AM
Yeah, that ship has sailed. I still cringe every time though.

Sophie Campbell
09-28-2015, 11:27 AM
We're done with trying to make creators feel welcome here, I see.

seriously. this thread just took a bit of a dark turn. why do i keep coming back here? XD

Ninjinister
09-28-2015, 11:46 AM
If you aren't fond of someone's work and feel the need to express yourself, use constructive criticism. Being an utter dickcheese instead will help a total of zero people.

super curry max
09-28-2015, 01:27 PM
So I just read Vengeance this morning and realized the whole reason they even went to the desert was to retrieve some book that Miller was convinced was out there. Did they even mention in once in this mini?

nope. not a once.

this mini was entirely unnecessary and if it truly had to be done could have been done in a single issue or less.

Never have I been so disappointed in a comic story. IDW has never NEVER let me down. until now. I hope this doesn't start a trend,

Tazi
09-28-2015, 03:18 PM
seriously. this thread just took a bit of a dark turn. why do i keep coming back here? XD

maybe you enjoy horror :D

SDCC
09-29-2015, 11:31 AM
Well, it's over.

My review. (http://www.superdstuff.com/2015/09/tmnt-casey-april-4.html)

That was a waste of time. If you enjoyed it I'm happy for you; I'm glad it gave you something different. But for me it's the first black mark against IDW TMNT.

Onwards and upwards to #50!

Technogeek29
09-30-2015, 10:48 PM
Who at the end feels issue 1 the and issue 4 were the only one's worth reading?
the first one to set the place and time and 4 to explain everything we know. I wouldn't mind a April Mini series or a Casey Mini series just the character by themselves. We got a bit of that with Casey in the back ground. and the April Micro showed how much the Turtles interfere with her normal lifestyle. I would like to see her pull a Mirage April and try to distance herself a bit from them.

Klunk1234
10-01-2015, 08:16 AM
i loved it too! this is probably my favorite IDW TMNT story since Turtles in Time. it really feels like TMNT to me: kinda quiet, weird, pensive at times, symbolism, the feeling of warmth like Big Bad said. i love Rat King and Aka and all of the interlocking IDW mythology but sometimes i wish there could be stories like this but that don't tie into the main overarching interlocking plot or whatever, like April and Casey could go out west for a vacation and run into some random unrelated monsters or spirits or mutants. but whatever, i still loved the mini and it's nice seeing April and Casey more involved with everything and doing stuff without the Turtles. i love how stark yet warm everything is, i like the hazy almost leisurely tone to it. it's light on plot, yeah, but plot isn't everything, storytelling isn't always about driving plot and relaying new plot information, it's way more about tone and the FEEL of the story. it's HOW things happen, i really appreciate this mini for that. and i like that it makes the Rat King seem like less like an outright villain, it's way more nuanced than him being simply an evil entity.

I'm also one of the few people who like this mini, instead of destroying it with horrible criticism using quotes like this: " The only thing we have learn about this issue is..." Or "This is so boring". Unfortunately, April and Casey was not the only issue that doesn't sell well; the Mutanimals series have had the same fate. Acording to the guy of the comic shop that I go ( It's not the same guy from the other comic shop that I used to go) say that customers don't like to buy comics where the Turtles are not there.

SDCC
10-01-2015, 09:34 AM
I'm also one of the few people who like this mini, instead of destroying it with horrible criticism using quotes like this: " The only thing we have learn about this issue is..." Or "This is so boring". Unfortunately, April and Casey was not the only issue that doesn't sell well; the Mutanimals series have had the same fate. Acording to the guy of the comic shop that I go ( It's not the same guy from the other comic shop that I used to go) say that customers don't like to buy comics where the Turtles are not there.

Mutanimals didn't do well? Damn, that was a very good mini series. Shame.

I didn't like this series at all, but I don't want IDW to stop trying things. This one just wasn't for me.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-01-2015, 09:37 AM
I'm also one of the few people who like this mini, instead of destroying it with horrible criticism using quotes like this: " The only thing we have learn about this issue is..." Or "This is so boring". Unfortunately, April and Casey was not the only issue that doesn't sell well; the Mutanimals series have had the same fate. Acording to the guy of the comic shop that I go ( It's not the same guy from the other comic shop that I used to go) say that customers don't like to buy comics where the Turtles are not there.

Constructive criticism is horrible? Geez, how many trophies did you get free as a kid?

As fans who want to make sure feedback is provided to creators and IDW, and who want the best possible TMNT stories to keep being produced, we not only have the right BUT THE RESPONSIBILITY to not support comics or movies that we feel are lacking and inferior. We do that two ways: #1 with our wallets #2 with criticism.

Editor's Note Comics
10-01-2015, 01:54 PM
I liked that this arc had slower pacing and a different kind of story. With how intense the main series has been for a while now, I thought this was a welcome change of pace.

ctt4lfecw
10-01-2015, 02:30 PM
If I were in charge, I'd fire anyone associated with this comic. I'd tell them to Hit the bricks. They're not invited back. They won't be writing for us anymore.

ToTheNines
10-01-2015, 02:32 PM
You would fire Bobby Curnow?

Ninjinister
10-01-2015, 04:45 PM
Constructive criticism is horrible? Geez, how many trophies did you get free as a kid?

As fans who want to make sure feedback is provided to creators and IDW, and who want the best possible TMNT stories to keep being produced, we not only have the right BUT THE RESPONSIBILITY to not support comics or movies that we feel are lacking and inferior. We do that two ways: #1 with our wallets #2 with criticism.

Because what Klunk mentioned (the constant regurgitating of those two phrases) IS horrible criticism. It doesn't give context. Say WHY you feel that way.

http://www.quickmeme.com/img/83/83204891de479f30af2fcec5af1e0ca5cd27edf9d1bd2c5eca 1c931a71e3f983.jpg

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-01-2015, 06:31 PM
Because what Klunk mentioned (the constant regurgitating of those two phrases) IS horrible criticism. It doesn't give context. Say WHY you feel that way.

http://www.quickmeme.com/img/83/83204891de479f30af2fcec5af1e0ca5cd27edf9d1bd2c5eca 1c931a71e3f983.jpg

Go back and read, mate; we have, multiple times. I even outlined at length a way to convey the same information, but in a way that doesn't cure insomnia.

I get that some of you liked this, and appreciated it for it was; I get that Bobby wanted to try a new style to bring in more readers (and based on some of you, it might have worked). But that doesn't change that I feel cheated out of four months and about $20.

ctt4lfecw
10-01-2015, 08:39 PM
Go back and read, mate; we have, multiple times. I even outlined at length a way to convey the same information, but in a way that doesn't cure insomnia.

I get that some of you liked this, and appreciated it for it was; I get that Bobby wanted to try a new style to bring in more readers (and based on some of you, it might have worked). But that doesn't change that I feel cheated out of four months and about $20.

This to the max.

DrSpengler
10-03-2015, 03:36 PM
Here's my full summary and review of TMNT Casey & April #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/10/tmnt-casey-april-4.html)

Just didn't feel this miniseries at all. In the end, I don't think it told us anything we hadn't already learned in the ongoing series, about the Pantheon or Casey/April. If anything, it came off like it was just there to kill time until #50.

ChosenOne
10-03-2015, 04:45 PM
Here's my full summary and review of TMNT Casey & April #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2015/10/tmnt-casey-april-4.html)

Just didn't feel this miniseries at all. In the end, I don't think it told us anything we hadn't already learned in the ongoing series, about the Pantheon or Casey/April. If anything, it came off like it was just there to kill time until #50.

That it most certainly did! Four months of our lives, gone.

MsMarvelDuckie
10-03-2015, 05:29 PM
I've been debating whether to get this series when it comes out in TPB, but now I'm wondering if I should just skip it. I still want to complete the entire IDW run, so I'll definitely be getting the Mutanimals mini-series, but not sure about this one, after what I've heard of it. Any insight?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-03-2015, 05:32 PM
I've been debating whether to get this series when it comes out in TPB, but now I'm wondering if I should just skip it. I still want to complete the entire IDW run, so I'll definitely be getting the Mutanimals mini-series, but not sure about this one, after what I've heard of it. Any insight?

Mutanimals is AMAZING. Get it definitely.

I'm not buying the Casey & April TPB immediately, if ever. I'm basically waiting to see how much of the Aka interaction is recapped in the ongoing TMNT series, and how badly I'm forced to acquire the mini-series trade for my collection. I really don't want to financially reward a project that was a vast personal disappointment.

Toby Barrett
10-03-2015, 10:23 PM
Oh boy, was this story ****.

Shark_Blade
10-03-2015, 11:01 PM
I kinda get why people are peeved because the story is not heavily related to the main story arc plot, but the story is about April and Casey and that's what I'm getting. Maybe that's why I'm enjoying it more?

And if I want heavy action, there's always the Mutanimals to go to at anytime. Maybe April & Casey's story will be action packed in the future if there is anymore opportunity like this? Who knows.

And also the artwork is nice. As an artist myself, I appreciate the style and the color pallete this series brought to the table. Very luscious and vivid colors. It's a special little mini series to me and very precious imo.

I downloaded all my tmnt comics into my ipad. Ah, ebook, very convenient technology. :tlove:

The Big Bad
10-05-2015, 05:49 AM
I've been debating whether to get this series when it comes out in TPB, but now I'm wondering if I should just skip it. I still want to complete the entire IDW run, so I'll definitely be getting the Mutanimals mini-series, but not sure about this one, after what I've heard of it. Any insight?

If you have Comixology, the first three issues can be obtained for $1.99 each there. Try the first one: it should be more than enough for you to learn if the mini is your cup of tea.

ChosenOne
10-05-2015, 10:19 AM
I kinda get why people are peeved because the story is not heavily related to the main story arc plot, but the story is about April and Casey and that's what I'm getting. Maybe that's why I'm enjoying it more?

I think it's because we were expecting the story to be "Casey and April do something useful", not just "Casey and April".

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-05-2015, 10:31 AM
I think it's because we were expecting the story to be "Casey and April do something useful", not just "Casey and April".

:tlol: I like the way you put that...

Danetello
10-07-2015, 01:45 PM
I finally got around to reading #4 today, and while nothing really happened in it, I do think that they are setting us up for the next big story arc after TMNT #50. The whole "we're Gods, a war is coming, and you (April) will be part of it" was a huge sign, I think.
Just my thoughts :)

Powder
10-07-2015, 08:07 PM
Well, I did not enjoy that.

I'm very interested in the Pantheon stuff to come of this, though.

Metropoliskid41
10-08-2015, 05:01 PM
Yeah definitely the product of some serious decompressed storytelling. Probably could have been condensed into a 2 issue mini or maybe even a single issue.

Definitely served more of a role as setup for future stuff instead of adding anything big and new itself. The whole mini read together really invokes that single issue of a Micro-Series tie-in feel, which I would be all for Micro-Series vol. 3 at this point.