PDA

View Full Version : Rogue One: A Star Wars Story


Pages : 1 [2]

Andrew NDB
10-13-2016, 01:04 PM
The Geonosians had the plans to built the Death Star, But they didn't built it themselves,

They designed the Death Star but didn't build it? But that was kind of their thing... hordes of disposable workers that could quickly build things. Now we're to believe it was just some random human dude, and probably some 3rd party workers?

Didn't the Geonosians design and build these too?

http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/7/76/Coreship.png

Clearly intended to callback (or forward in this case) to the Death Star.

CyberCubed
10-13-2016, 03:16 PM
The trailer looked really good. I'm interested. Action scenes look to be top notch.

sdp
10-13-2016, 11:04 PM
Trailer is ok, original one is still my favorite. It looks like a high budget SW movie of something I didn't care to see but hey, it's a high budget SW movie so I'm hyped. I still wish they had done 1000 different things but what can I do about it?


Wow, must have been hard work. And I thought Episode II revealed the Geonosians built the Death Star?

poor writing.

Mayhem
10-14-2016, 04:02 AM
It may be revealed in Rogue One, but I believe the Genosians designed the Death Star, but because of the Clone War, it didn't start being built until "the Empire" came into being. Jyn's father is instrumental in getting the project completed, maybe even coming up with solutions to problems found in the design, or the overall performance of the superlaser. There has to be reason, from the trailer, why the Imperials are deliberately looking for him.

Mayhem
10-14-2016, 04:04 AM
Didn't the Geonosians design and build these too?

http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/7/76/Coreship.png
I thought those was Neimoidian vessels? (the Trade Federation guys)

TheSkeletonMan939
10-14-2016, 08:05 AM
Yeah I think those are the center orbs of the trade federation ships. Maybe it's shape was deliberately made to look like the Death Star though, it's an interesting observation.

Powder
10-14-2016, 08:07 AM
Never been a SW fan but this looks pretty dope to me. Might watch sometime. Some great actors in there, & I love the robot dude's design.

THGhost
10-16-2016, 11:39 AM
I'm actually more excited for this than I was for The Force Awakens. T'will be nice to have a different formula/tone/focus for a change.

ProactiveMan
10-18-2016, 12:22 AM
This one really feels like Star Wars to me, more so than Ep.7. It's probably just the OG Storm Troopers, but it looks great.

Wow, must have been hard work. And I thought Episode II revealed the Geonosians built the Death Star?

Yeah, it will be interesting to see if they disavow the space cockroaches. I don’t think there is anything in the prequels that definitively state that the roaches actually built the Death Star, but Uncle George says it outright in one of the making of features on the DVD. ‘Stuff George said’ isn’t cannon anymore I guess, so it doesn’t stop them from contradicting him… but it will be interesting to see what happens.

ZariusTwo
11-10-2016, 02:50 PM
CTl_Tt3dhPw

Won't be too long now before I've seen the whole movie on Youtube

CyberCubed
11-10-2016, 02:58 PM
Fitting to have this movie come out the same year as Brexit and a Trump presidency. Amazing how movies mirror real life sometimes.

DestronMirage22
11-10-2016, 03:36 PM
Fitting to have this movie come out the same year as Brexit and a Trump presidency. Amazing how movies mirror real life sometimes.

Are you still going on about that? :trolleye:

snake
11-10-2016, 03:42 PM
Fitting to have this movie come out the same year as Brexit and a Trump presidency. Amazing how movies mirror real life sometimes.

A group of minorities and aliens decide to f*ck stuff up for the glorious empire?

Yeah pretty much lol

TurtleTitan97
11-10-2016, 03:58 PM
A group of minorities and aliens decide to f*ck stuff up for the glorious empire?

Yeah pretty much lol

:lol::lol::lol:

Shark_Blade
11-10-2016, 04:44 PM
I'm ready for more strong women protagonists. Seems we have plenty lately which is awesome.

- Katniss Everdeen
- Wonder Woman
- Rey
- Hermione Granger
- Amanda Waller (Suicide Squad)

All of them are powerful and formidable. Yes Hermione is better than Harry Potter himself. Fact.

TheSkeletonMan939
11-10-2016, 05:03 PM
Since when are Hermione and Waller protagonists? They're supporting characters.
Gotta agree with you though, Hermione>>>Harry.

CyberCubed
11-10-2016, 05:10 PM
Amanda Waller is a protagonist?

ToTheNines
11-10-2016, 05:18 PM
I like Jessica Jones.

Shark_Blade
11-10-2016, 05:57 PM
Okay maybe not all necessarily protagonists, but they still kick ass. :D

snake
11-11-2016, 08:51 PM
https://www.buzzfeed.com/marcusjones/star-wars-rogue-one-writers-join-rebellion-against-trump?utm_term=.xmgAArmNK0#.kskQQ8ZRLD


How did it even come to this? I'm just shocked by how stupid people are.

Shark_Blade
11-11-2016, 09:21 PM
I doubt they even gonna mention Trump in the movie. As to how Empire relates to Trump in real life, hey as long they're happy. Even Mark Hamill (Luke Skywalker) hinself retweeted in support.

CyberCubed
11-11-2016, 09:40 PM
Star Wars was originally created to express people overthrowing an oppressive government and freedom and justice for all. George Lucas said the Empire was based on Nazi Germany and other similar governments throughout history.

snake
11-11-2016, 09:45 PM
Star Wars was originally created to express people overthrowing an oppressive government and freedom and justice for all. George Lucas said the Empire was based on Nazi Germany and other similar governments throughout history.

Uh, no. Star Wars was created as a result of George's interest in mythology, culture, and storytelling as a whole.

CyberCubed
11-11-2016, 10:07 PM
http://www.history.com/news/the-real-history-that-inspired-star-wars

Nazi Germany
There’s nothing subtle about this historical allusion in “Star Wars.” After all, the elite assault forces fanatically devoted to the Galactic Empire share a common name with the paramilitary fighters who defended the Nazi Party—stormtroopers. The Imperial officers’ uniforms and even Darth Vader’s helmet resemble those worn by German Army members in World War II, and the gradual rise of Palpatine from chancellor to emperor mirrored Adolf Hitler’s similar political ascent from chancellor to dictator. The Empire wasn’t the only side in “Star Wars” that cribbed Nazi imagery, however. The final scene of the original 1977 “Star Wars” in which Princess Leia awards medals to Rebel heroes Luke Skywalker and Han Solo while soldiers stood at attention echoed the massive Nazi rallies in Nuremberg captured in Leni Riefenstahl’s 1935 propaganda film “Triumph of the Will.”

Vietnam War
The guerilla war waged by the Rebel Alliance against the Galactic Empire mirrored the battle between an insurgent force and a global superpower that was playing out in Vietnam as Lucas wrote “Star Wars”. The filmmaker, who was originally set to direct to the Vietnam War film “Apocalypse Now” in the early 1970s before moving on to “Star Wars,” said in an audio commentary on the 2004 re-release of “Return of the Jedi” that the Viet Cong served as his inspiration for the furry forest-dwelling Ewoks, who were able to defeat a vastly superior opponent in spite of their primitive weapons. As William J. Astore writes in “Star Wars and History,” both the Viet Cong and Ewoks were well-served by their “superior knowledge of the local terrain and an ability to blend into that terrain.”


Ancient Rome
The political institutions of “Star Wars”—such as the Senate, Republic and Empire—and the pseudo-Latin names of characters such as chancellors Valorum and Palpatine echo those of ancient Rome. As Tony Keen notes in “Star Wars and History,” the architecture on the planet Naboo resembles that of imperial Rome, and the pod race in “The Phantom Menace” rivals that of the Roman chariot race seen on screen in “Ben-Hur.” The transition from the democratic Galactic Republic to the dictatorial Galactic Empire over the course of the franchise also mirrors that of ancient Rome. “It is plain that the basic structure of Lucas’s history derives from the fall of the Roman Republic and the subsequent establishment of a monarchy,” Keen writes.

Cold War
The tense relationship between the United States and the Soviet Union, with the threat of nuclear annihilation lurking in the background, was hardly history when “Star Wars” first premiered in 1977. The threat to the planet posed by nuclear weapons was encapsulated on screen in the ultimate weapon of mass destruction—the Death Star—which destroyed Princess Leia’s home planet of Alderaan, a blue orb that closely resembled Earth. “Star Wars” itself entered the realm of Cold War history after it was adopted by the media in the 1980s as a nickname for President Ronald Reagan’s proposed Strategic Defense Initiative, which would have used lasers to defend the United States against incoming nuclear missiles.

C'mon, snake, I found this in a 5 second google search.

There's dozens of other articles like this that say the same thing.

Shark_Blade
11-12-2016, 02:22 AM
So Vader is basically Hitler. What about Kylo Ren?

TheSkeletonMan939
11-12-2016, 08:31 AM
I doubt they even gonna mention Trump in the movie.

Wow, are you sure? You're sure they won't mention the President-elect in a galaxy far far away, in a film that's already been shot?

snake
11-12-2016, 09:13 AM
http://www.history.com/news/the-real-history-that-inspired-star-wars



C'mon, snake, I found this in a 5 second google search.

There's dozens of other articles like this that say the same thing.

I never said that those weren't influences on Star Wars, but making an analogy to the Nazis was not the sole purpose Lucas made SW, like your previous post suggests.

Allio
11-12-2016, 11:57 AM
I'm not surprised about the "nazi" thing, considering how much star wars took influence from hakaider, supposedly, and "nazis" had always been a influence in bad guys in the 70's, like with shows like kamen rider

TheSkeletonMan939
11-12-2016, 12:25 PM
Yeah, everyone wanted to emulate the Nazis in their films. They were so perfectly evil that they served as great models for how to portray similar enemies in movies.

CyberCubed
11-12-2016, 12:47 PM
Star Wars came out in the 70's, the Cold War was essentially recent on everyone's minds (and technically continued throughout the 80s to 1991).

In general though its obvious the Emperor, Darth Vader, the empire, and everything else is based on any oppressive government in history where the people (the rebels) try to overthrow it.

ZariusTwo
11-12-2016, 01:16 PM
South Park wasn't kidding when it suggested the reason America went backwards was to get more people interested in Star Wars

TigerClaw
12-11-2016, 11:12 AM
The movie had its premiere yesterday and so far, The reactions have been positive.
https://www.comicbookmovie.com/scifi_movies/star_wars/the-first-reactions-to-rogue-one-a-star-wars-story-are-a147454

Vegita-San
12-11-2016, 06:16 PM
https://www.buzzfeed.com/marcusjones/star-wars-rogue-one-writers-join-rebellion-against-trump?utm_term=.xmgAArmNK0#.kskQQ8ZRLD


How did it even come to this? I'm just shocked by how stupid people are.

how well did it work out for feigbusters?

i've gotta say my excitement for this has dumped down a bit knowing femenism is now getting into star wars too...

some of the stuff kathleen kennedy says makes her no better than amy pascal.

gXOpicp4HF0

CyberCubed
12-11-2016, 06:28 PM
i've gotta say my excitement for this has dumped down a bit knowing femenism is now getting into star wars too...]

Star Wars has always had feminism.

snake
12-11-2016, 07:42 PM
I'm just ignoring that cuck sh*t. RO is gonna be awesome and I'm not gonna let SJWs ruin it.

plastroncafe
12-11-2016, 07:56 PM
Challenge Accepted.

TheSkeletonMan939
12-11-2016, 08:23 PM
I'm just ignoring that cuck sh*t. RO is gonna be awesome and I'm not gonna let SJWs ruin it.

The SJWs are too late... Star Wars in my eyes was ruined in 1983.

snake
12-11-2016, 08:56 PM
Challenge Accepted.

I'll personally send you money if you can ruin RO for me. It's not happening.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-12-2016, 09:39 AM
I'll personally send you money if you can ruin RO for me. It's not happening.

Now that money is involved, I, too, accept your challenge.

We talking Jacksons, Grants, or Franklins?

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 11:28 AM
Money?
Nah, the schadenfreude alone will be payment enough.

Besides, you should save that paper route money for something far more important.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-12-2016, 11:34 AM
Money?
Nah, the schadenfreude alone will be payment enough.

Besides, you should save that paper route money for something far more important.

:tlol:

He has a paper route? What is this, the 1980s!? I better dig out my old cassette tapes and Walkman!

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 11:44 AM
It was between that or mowing lawns, and I decided the mental image of a paper route was funnier.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-12-2016, 11:54 AM
It was between that or mowing lawns, and I decided the mental image of a paper route was funnier.

You absolutely made the right choice.

If it was mowing lawns, we'd have to start discussing illegal immigrants, minimum wage, and Donald Trump.

CyberCubed
12-12-2016, 12:22 PM
Star Wars was always about females. Everything that ever happened in a story was because of a female.

Darth Vader went evil because of Padme.

Luke and Han's entire story started over the rescue over Princess Leia.

The new main character is Rey. Now we have this female in Rogue one. It is always the females.

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 12:32 PM
Anakin didn't turn to the darkside because of Padme, but because he had no self control.
He got seduced by the shortcuts that came from the darkside. From the illusion of safety the darkside provided.

snake
12-12-2016, 02:43 PM
Money?
Nah, the schadenfreude alone will be payment enough.

Besides, you should save that paper route money for something far more important.

But I already bought a hooker last month!

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 03:08 PM
So many good followup quips...but which to choose?

snake
12-12-2016, 03:19 PM
So many good followup quips...but which to choose?

More quips than a Joss Whedon script.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-12-2016, 03:38 PM
More quips than a Joss Whedon script.

Now I'm having nightmarish flashbacks to Avengers 1 and 2. Thanks a lot, Snake.

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 03:42 PM
My work here is (nearly) done.

CyberCubed
12-12-2016, 04:29 PM
I actually prefer movies with female leads because if I'm to watch something for nearly 2 hours I'd rather be looking at a cute girl than some grisly man being all badass.

That only worked for 80's and early 90's era action movies, not in the modern years where they're all pretty boys.

Cure
12-12-2016, 04:31 PM
That only worked for 80's and early 90's era action movies, not in the modern years where they're all pretty boys.

Why not? Do the pretty boys give you feelings that confuse you?

CyberCubed
12-12-2016, 04:36 PM
Why not? Do the pretty boys give you feelings that confuse you?

http://i.imgur.com/LRlknxa.gif

ToTheNines
12-12-2016, 06:36 PM
If cybercubed came out, would Plastron like him more?

snake
12-12-2016, 06:38 PM
My work here is (nearly) done.

And you'll STILL be getting wage gaped after all you did!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-12-2016, 06:59 PM
And you'll STILL be getting wage gaped after all you did!

We're gaping at Plastron's wages now? What in the what?

I knew your love/hate relationship had to be an Oedipus complex, but this is a little more blatant than I was expecting. :tlol:

plastroncafe
12-12-2016, 09:29 PM
If cybercubed came out, would Plastron like him more?

Only one way to find out!

We're gaping at Plastron's wages now? What in the what?

I knew your love/hate relationship had to be an Oedipus complex, but this is a little more blatant than I was expecting. :tlol:

It's hard to believe he kisses his sexworker with that mouth, isn't it?

ZariusTwo
12-13-2016, 12:38 PM
Here's a review from Digital Spy

What results is a poignant, powerful paean to the Star Wars Universe, set in a world where the best thing you can hope for is hope itself. It's a perfect and complete standalone, but it changes everything.

Watching A New Hope will never feel the same again.

http://www.digitalspy.com/movies/star-wars/review/a816789/rogue-one-review/

CyberCubed
12-13-2016, 01:07 PM
Its so ironic this movie came out the same year Donald Trump was elected president and Brexit happened. Sometimes movies really do imitate real life.

snake
12-13-2016, 01:54 PM
Its so ironic this movie came out the same year Donald Trump was elected president and Brexit happened. Sometimes movies really do imitate real life.
I swear you made this post already.

CyberCubed
12-13-2016, 02:17 PM
I swear you made this post already.

I repeat myself all the time.

Dust
12-13-2016, 02:22 PM
I repeat myself all the time.

That's not a good thing.

Andrew NDB
12-14-2016, 01:33 PM
Some pretty light spoilers...

* Vader has a big scene where he slaughters "everybody" with his lightsaber. I'm not sure if these are the good guys or Imperials he's killing. Didn't ask.
* Tarkin is indeed in it, has a whole scene with him giving a big speech about fear. I'm told he's entirely CGI.
* A CGI Leia appears in two scenes!
* The last 30 minutes are confirmed to be "epic."

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
12-14-2016, 01:36 PM
I'm not gonna get Snake's lunch money, am I? :tlol:

plastroncafe
12-14-2016, 01:51 PM
Alternative Rogue One Titles:
https://twitter.com/i/web/status/809034290474455041
Brought to you by The Daily Mail and Youtube Comments

They had me at hello...
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CzpEZJCXEAAyzMw.jpg

AT-Man
12-14-2016, 02:02 PM
After seeing the movie, anyone who thinks it's feminist or any other-nist, is an idiot.

TheSkeletonMan939
12-14-2016, 06:08 PM
* Tarkin is indeed in it, has a whole scene with him giving a big speech about fear. I'm told he's entirely CGI.

If this is true, I find it a bit tasteless.

Andrew NDB
12-14-2016, 11:49 PM
If this is true, I find it a bit tasteless.

It's true.

CyberCubed
12-15-2016, 12:23 AM
I really wish they'd stop releasing Star Wars movies close to Christmas. I didn't see Episode 7 until the middle of January and it'll probably be the same with this one. No way am I going to attend a busy theater packed with screaming kids and adults to see Star Wars before the holidays.

Mayhem
12-15-2016, 04:51 AM
Couple of people I know who've seen it, said the first 2/3 are a bit meh (and they can see where the rewrites and edits have probably gone on), and last 1/3 (I guess the "epic" bit) is proper, full on Star Wars and worth paying the money for. Guess I'll see for myself on Sunday!

ZariusTwo
12-15-2016, 10:00 AM
Couple of people I know who've seen it, said the first 2/3 are a bit meh (and they can see where the rewrites and edits have probably gone on), and last 1/3 (I guess the "epic" bit) is proper, full on Star Wars and worth paying the money for. Guess I'll see for myself on Sunday!

I can back that up. Second act is horrendous. Nearly killed the movie for me, but the third act made it the best SW prequel we've had.

It's also better than The Force Awakens, it told an original story that was tightly interwoven with the prominent beats of the mythology. This is how you repurpose New Hope for the next generation and get away with it Abrams.

Oh, and Expect a lot of CGI Peter Cushing. More than what I thought I'd be getting...they use the same methods on Carrie Fisher at the end

And yes, Vader's scenes are WELL worth the price of admission. You will not believe how close he is to succeeding. It's sheer luck that gives us hope in the end

ToTheNines
12-15-2016, 09:24 PM
I really wish they'd stop releasing Star Wars movies close to Christmas. I didn't see Episode 7 until the middle of January and it'll probably be the same with this one. No way am I going to attend a busy theater packed with screaming kids and adults to see Star Wars before the holidays.

Once again, literally no one gives a f*ck when you see a movie.

TigerClaw
12-15-2016, 09:52 PM
I think it's smart to release Star Wars movies in December, Cause there aren't any big tentpole movies competing against it, It would guarantee huge box office, since it would go against smaller movies which are normally reserved for Oscar buzz.

If they released Star Wars during the summer, it would be overcrowded with a bunch of blockbuster summer movies also competing for the #1 spot, and Studios would **** themselves if there movie was competing against Star Wars, something that's guarantee to be the #1 movie.

NinjaPug
12-15-2016, 10:03 PM
That was the Star Wars movie I've been wanting. So much better than TFA.

Perfect use of Vader.

TigerClaw
12-15-2016, 10:11 PM
It's certified fresh on Rotten Tomatoes at 85%
https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/rogue_one_a_star_wars_story

I'm gonna see it on Saturday.

Krutch
12-15-2016, 10:47 PM
I can back that up. Second act is horrendous. Nearly killed the movie for me, but the third act made it the best SW prequel we've had.

I'll second this. First half was all over the place and because of it, I felt the cast of characters as a whole fell kind of flat.

I still liked the movie. But needed to spend less time with people going "We need to go here to get this that does this then we do this there and then we head back..." and more character moments.

ZariusTwo
12-16-2016, 02:35 AM
I'll second this. First half was all over the place and because of it, I felt the cast of characters as a whole fell kind of flat.

I still liked the movie. But needed to spend less time with people going "We need to go here to get this that does this then we do this there and then we head back..." and more character moments.

I concur...on one hand, some characters not getting personal stuff did'nt drag the movie down, but relationships are still hinted at that could have dealt with more backstory...and better reaction to everything that happens to them. Seemed every potential dramatic beat went by in a string of endlessly mundane conversations

Mayhem
12-16-2016, 04:09 AM
So for those who've seen it, given it's still two days away for me...

Are the "appearances" by the old school Red and Gold Leader re-purposed lines from ANH, or newly recorded dialogue? Angus MacInnes is certainly still alive, and Drewe Henley only died in February, so there could have been enough time to get him to record new material. I saw them credited on IMDB and was curious! Also, do we get a Red 5, whom we know must die for Luke to take his place heh?!

Krutch
12-16-2016, 07:31 AM
Seemed every potential dramatic beat went by in a string of endlessly mundane conversationsThat's exactly how it felt to me as well. Considering how much time we spend with Gyn, Cassian, Bodhi... they never really left much of an impression on me. Krennick had some nice moments with characters we already know from other movies, but still, I don't think anyone will be blown away by him, either. It all felt kind of flat when action wasn't taking place.

I also noticed a few scenes and dialogue from the trailers didn't make it into the final cut, so I wonder how much impact post production had on it.

I don't know.. I've had my reservations about Star Wars movies that aren't part of the main episodes and this movie didn't do much (or any) to sway me. Again, I liked it, but it too many movies like this will quickly wash away the novelty sooner than later, in my opinion.

Re: Mayhem's questions...
So for those who've seen it, given it's still two days away for me...

Are the "appearances" by the old school Red and Gold Leader re-purposed lines from ANH, or newly recorded dialogue? Honestly, I can't remember. I think it was new, though.

Also, do we get a Red 5, whom we know must die for Luke to take his place heh?!We do :)

NinjaPug
12-16-2016, 09:12 AM
I would also recommend reading Catalyst prior to seeing Rogue One. It really fills in a lot of the backstory with the Ersos, Saw, Tarkin and Krennic

Zak The Neutrino
12-16-2016, 10:06 AM
I thought the movie was awesome. I'm putting it as my second favorite in the franchise. Although maybe a bit sku'd that I just saw it. Could settle down further in time.

I get those complaining about character development but it's not really what this movie was about. It was more aimed to be a dark war movie so I didn't really feel we needed it or needed every little detail explained.

There are places in TFA where it gets sort of boring because they went too far on character development in my opinion. This was definitely the polar opposite but I think it worked well.

TigerClaw
12-16-2016, 04:05 PM
The movie made 29 million on Thursday.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/weekend-box-office-rogue-one-star-wars-story-29-million-previews-tally-thursday-956347

myconius
12-16-2016, 04:19 PM
i knew i was going to at least enjoy the movie, but ended up absolutely LOVING it!!

snake
12-16-2016, 04:27 PM
Loved it! This is the star wars I want!

Andrew NDB
12-16-2016, 04:34 PM
I also noticed a few scenes and dialogue from the trailers didn't make it into the final cut, so I wonder how much impact post production had on it.

It's pretty widely known that about half the movie was reshot, and Tony Gilroy reportedly walked away with 5 million dollars to do the rewrites and basically (secretly) re-direct the movie, away from Gareth. We may never know if the original was even darker, or lighter in tone.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/rogue-one-writer-tony-gilroy-make-millions-reshoots-951119

I'm preeeeetty sure I'm going to enjoy the film, but regardless, barring things like a Yoda movie or a Obi-Wan movies, Episode 8 and onward better stop being "Original Trilogy Greatest Hits" and start doing new and original stories. If not, SW is pretty much dead.

I actually saw a headline about Rogue One that said, "EVERYTHING A FAN WOULD WANT!" and I had horrible deja vu about that ghastly "Out of the Sewers" commercial that promised the same ("BEBOP! PIZZA! KRANG! AND F*** YOU!").

Raph's Girl
12-16-2016, 06:23 PM
This is definatly one of my top fave SW films now. Wow... awesome!! :D I squeed when R2, 3PO, and Leia popped up.

Shark_Blade
12-16-2016, 11:58 PM
Isn't it weird that it doesn't include the Star Wars theme crawl credit at the beginning?

Andrew NDB
12-17-2016, 02:41 AM
Isn't it weird that it doesn't include the Star Wars theme crawl credit at the beginning?

No, that's fine to be reserved for the numeric ones.

Watched it. Enjoyed it. Definitely you can see that Krennic was the biggest victims of the reshoots... they definitely came back and said, "The test audiences don't care about Krennic... they want more Tarkin and Vader!" and gutted his stuff to do so.

Personally I loved what they were able to do with CGI Tarkin. Leia wasn't bad, either.

ToTheNines
12-17-2016, 11:47 AM
https://media.giphy.com/media/3oz8xyRLsYwiV32Yve/source.gif

blindturtle02
12-17-2016, 01:43 PM
This is definatly one of my top fave SW films now. Wow... awesome!! :D I squeed when R2, 3PO, and Leia popped up.

God yes. I have to see this thing at least two more times. I was expecting it to be a decent film, but they knocked that mother out of the park.

TigerClaw
12-17-2016, 02:43 PM
Just saw it, This is the best Star Wars movie since episode 4.

TigerClaw
12-17-2016, 04:40 PM
This is the 1st Star Wars movie
in which all the heroes died at the end.
and it made sense for this movie.

Dust
12-17-2016, 05:46 PM
Just saw it, This is the best Star Wars movie since episode 4.

Empire is better than the original, just saying ;)

Shark_Blade
12-17-2016, 06:01 PM
I too prefer A New Hope than Empire tbh.

http://i.imgur.com/UJD1WQ9.jpg
Lol yeah all their members died instead of just one guy tbh. :tlol:

TigerClaw
12-17-2016, 06:04 PM
The space battle in this was 10x better then the one in Return Of The Jedi.

TigerClaw
12-17-2016, 06:25 PM
The movie has made $71 million at the box office as of Friday.
http://variety.com/2016/film/box-office/box-office-rogue-one-friday-1201944768/

CyberCubed
12-17-2016, 06:52 PM
Do you think this movie will get a sequel? Might be hard given the placement, but maybe they can make it take place between Episodes 4 and 5.

Shark_Blade
12-17-2016, 06:58 PM
A New Hope is the sequel...

snake
12-17-2016, 07:03 PM
Do you think this movie will get a sequel? Might be hard given the placement, but maybe they can make it take place between Episodes 4 and 5.

The sequel is a book called Twilight Company. Go read that.

Shark_Blade
12-17-2016, 08:08 PM
Aren't the books non-canon now? Like about Chewie's death and all.

NinjaPug
12-17-2016, 08:28 PM
The books released since Fall 2014 are canon.

CyberCubed
12-17-2016, 10:40 PM
A lot of people don't read the books/comics, or even the cartoons. For some people if it isn't a movie, it doesn't exist.

Cure
12-18-2016, 01:06 AM
I wish you didn't exist.

Andrew NDB
12-18-2016, 01:47 AM
Are we still sure Jyn isn't Rey's mother? :)

ZariusTwo
12-18-2016, 09:06 AM
I wish you didn't exist.

I can see his point. I don't particularly give two monkeys about Clone Wars or Rebels myself.

I've only ever read a handful of EU books and comics. Mostly the Zhan books, Dark Empire, Truce at Bakura, Splinter of the Mind's Eye, Shadows of the Empire etc. Stopped caring when they killed off Chewie and Mara.

Mayhem
12-18-2016, 09:33 AM
So back from the cinema now, I picked a decent time, the cinema was barely a quarter full and practically no kids screaming or making noise. My brother's fiancee was ready to strangle some guy near us who kept rustling his bag of sweets throughout heh.

Thoughts... probably will take another viewing mind you.

+ Darker than Empire because none of the heroes get out alive. I thought Bodhi might make it given he was the pilot and in the ship, but sadly not. You could hear a collective sigh of sadness in the audience when K2SO died.

+ On that note, Alan Tudyk gave a terrific performance as the robot.

- Thought Forrest Whittaker as Saw was a good cast, based on the character from Clone Wars. Why the negative? I was hoping he was going to go with them in the assault on the data storage facility. He didn't get enough to do, although he was on screen more than I expected.

+ Somewhere canon on film now finally explains to people that the Death Star is indeed like a giant lightsaber.

- The starting 1/3 of the film could have been linked together better, it jumps around a bit too much. And they don't explain how they know where Jyn is in order to rescue her.

- CGI Leia just didn't do it for me.

+ On the other hand, CGI Tarkin did work for me. Maybe it's easier to make old guys look realistic with computers?

- However, I suspect there was more Tarkin (and Vader) because Krennic's character arc and development got sacrificed a bit as a result in the reshoots. You don't really get to find out much about what makes him tick during the film.

- Missing bits from the trailer, especially Jyn vs TIE Fighter, I wanted that still in!

+ Blue Squadron finally on film, pity Blue Leader bought it, but there was a bit of a homage to ANH there re Red Leader as he hit the ground.

+ Vader at the end. Nuff said.

Re: Mayhem's questions...
Having now seen the film, I'd say they've cribbed sound clips from ANH, and possibly gotten new dialogue from the actors. More likely very good soundalikes. I did internally squee a bit actually seeing computer enhanced grabs of both Gold and Red Leader in new cockpit sequences though! I've had the pleasure of meeting both Drewe and Angus in the past, and both were really nice people, it's a pity Mr Henley didn't live to see himself back up on screen again.

TigerClaw
12-18-2016, 01:59 PM
The movie has made 155 million dollars at the box office, and is closing in on making 300 million worldwide.
https://www.comicbookmovie.com/scifi_movies/star_wars/box-office-rogue-one-a-star-wars-story-is-already-closing-a147582

Zak The Neutrino
12-18-2016, 02:11 PM
If anyone else is wondering why Saw Gerrera name sounds familiar go back and watch Clone Wars season 5 episode 2. It was an ah ha moment for me.

TigerClaw
12-18-2016, 04:21 PM
If anyone else is wondering why Saw Gerrera name sounds familiar go back and watch Clone Wars season 5 episode 2. It was an ah ha moment for me.
Saw Gerrera is gonna be appearing on an episode of Star Wars Rebels pretty soon.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cz5gSuDWQAEm18-.jpg:small

ProactiveMan
12-20-2016, 12:02 AM
I liked it. I agree with a lot of people that it was kind’a saggy in the middle.

The tone was a bit odd, and some of the performances were a little uneven – good at times and not so good otherwise. I caught a couple of actors trying to squeeze out tears without quite making it happen – and what the hell was Forest Whitaker going for? What accent was that, and why was he huffing gas like Denis Hopper in Blue Velvet? I think that may grow on me though, so I’m not going to say he was bad.

The last act was great – really exciting and well-staged. I thought the effects were awesome; I don’t know if the Star Destroyers were CGI or not, but they made them look like chunks of styrene just like the original trilogy, and that’s the best. I like the references to EU, I like that they didn’t throw out the prequels, and I want to see it again.

Something that has been bothering me: In the scene at Vader’s castle where he is in the Bacta tank, and he is suspended there with just his head and stumpy, naked torso, implies that his arms and legs are 100% removable. That’s a little weird isn’t it? I always thought they were more or less grafted onto him, but they treat them like a pair of pants in this movie. “Ben Mendelsohn’s here to see me, better put on my good pair of arms”.

Shark_Blade
12-20-2016, 09:25 AM
I liked it. I agree with a lot of people that it was kind’a saggy in the middle.

Agree. I saw it twice and I fell asleep in the middle part both times! Guess it's really that dull. :lol: I still love the film a lot though, the ending scenes make up for it.

TigerClaw
12-20-2016, 03:51 PM
Apparently the movie originally had a different ending, It explains all the reshoots.
https://www.comicbookmovie.com/sci-fi/star_wars/spoilers-gareth-edwards-reveals-rogue-one-a-star-wars-storys-a147615

Andrew NDB
12-20-2016, 03:54 PM
Apparently the movie originally had a different ending, It explains all the reshoots.
https://www.comicbookmovie.com/sci-fi/star_wars/spoilers-gareth-edwards-reveals-rogue-one-a-star-wars-storys-a147615

No, that doesn't explain anything about the reshoots. He's saying in the first script they didn't die... but long before shooting the full version he shot (that they would later hire the other guy to come in and reshoot half of), everyone still died.

Vegita-San
12-21-2016, 08:30 AM
meh. skip the first two thirds.. stay for the end.

even vader couldn't save this half bore fest.

TheSkeletonMan939
12-21-2016, 08:45 AM
I haven't seen the film but apparently, even in the more recent trailers, you can see all sorts of scenes cut that you would think would be part of huge action sequences.

Now again, haven't seen the film so I may be completely wrong here, but I have to wonder if Disney wanted a less consistently intimidating war film (because SW is for little kids, amirite?) and more focus on character moments. This might explain why some people think the film has an unusually slow pace until the end - action sequences were replaced with exposition stuff. That's what I would guess the reshoots entailed.

Allio
12-21-2016, 02:57 PM
so as there has always been a debate on "how to watch star wars" one of the most popular ones is called "flashback" where you go 4 > 5 > 1 > 2 > 3 > 6 > 7

So my question is, how would you incorporate Rogue one? I would put it at the beginning, here is why.

1. Title Scroll. All the other films has this, not this one. The title scroll gives an almost "Last Time on Star Wars" kind of feel, while this one is obviously stand alone and leads into episode 4, so putting it "last" or outside the "watch" doesn't really work if you want a real good narrative.

2. Luke is the New Hope - As others have said, the brings more emphasis on episode 4 and what it meant to get the plans and destroy the death star; but it also brings out the fact that the movie makes mention that "The Jedi are no more" a couple of times in the film, so when Luke learns he is a jedi, he is literally the galaxy's new hope.

3. Darth Vader - so in the orignal film, Darth only had about 12 minutes of screen time, and only a little bit of a shadow on everyone (it wasn't really until 5 where he came off as the threat) here, not only is Vader introduced as someone that is "known and not seen" we are also given only a bit of what he can do as well as well as we have seen what he can do to just mere soldiers, meaning once we see him again in episode 4, we know he is a threat cause we have seen what he can do.

So from one's perspective.

The Empire > "There is no Hope" > an extremely dangerous person appears > Suddenly a new hope > Someone that can stand against vader > holy ****, vader is luke's father > the origin of Vader and the Jedis > How the villains won > Episode 6

Andrew NDB
12-21-2016, 03:01 PM
There's a lot of talk that the reshoots were because Gareth's original movie was too talky, too much character (development) stuff and interactions... and that historically doesn't translate well to the coveted Chinese market. So Disney stepped in and retooled things to have less character moments and more missions, more action, more spectacle, more iconic stuff... stuff that translates just fine there.

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-08/19/xin_5520806200030953191372.jpg

Zak The Neutrino
12-21-2016, 03:05 PM
There's a lot of talk that the reshoots were because Gareth's original movie was too talky, too much character (development) stuff and interactions... and that historically doesn't translate well to the coveted Chinese market. So Disney stepped in and retooled things to have less character moments and more missions, more action, more spectacle, more iconic stuff... stuff that translates just fine there.

That's interesting because the biggest complaint I hear from people about the movie is there is no character development.

Andrew NDB
12-21-2016, 03:07 PM
That's interesting because the biggest complaint I hear from people about the movie is there is no character development.

That's... what I'm saying. Thanks to the Chinese (or rather, a preemptive measure to appease them and get their money). But there was, in the original version.

NinjaPug
12-21-2016, 03:16 PM
Doubt Lucasfilm cared much about the Chinese market. China only accounted for ~ 5% of TFA's total box office. They don't need that market to be successful unlike other movies. I'm sure they'd like to grow their fan base in that market but they're not going to deliberately put out an inferior product to do so. This isn't Paramount.

Andrew NDB
12-21-2016, 03:19 PM
Doubt Lucasfilm cared much about the Chinese market.

Lucasfilm might not... but Disney surely does.

Zak The Neutrino
12-21-2016, 03:25 PM
Doubt Lucasfilm cared much about the Chinese market. China only accounted for ~ 5% of TFA's total box office. They don't need that market to be successful unlike other movies. I'm sure they'd like to grow their fan base in that market but they're not going to deliberately put out an inferior product to do so. This isn't Paramount.

Lucasfilm might not... but Disney surely does.

Andrew is right. Remember Marvel changed the race of the ancient one in Dr Strange because of the Chinese market.

NinjaPug
12-21-2016, 03:41 PM
Marvel isn't Lucasfilm. Spare me the Disney argument.

I think it's preposterous to think they would intentionally make a weaker movie to appease a market that hasn't been a big money generator for the franchise.

Andrew NDB
12-21-2016, 03:45 PM
Marvel isn't Lucasfilm. Spare me the Disney argument.

"Lucasfilm" is even more of a puppet studio than Marvel for Disney. Do you really think Kathleen Kennedy is able to go to bat for things with Disney more than Kevin Feige is able to, when even Kevin Feige himself has been losing battles with them on the Chinese front?

And it's probably coincidence that two of China's biggest stars are in the movie (http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/rogue-one-5-things-know-882936?facebook_20161217).

Vegita-San
12-21-2016, 03:49 PM
Marvel isn't Lucasfilm. Spare me the Disney argument.

I think it's preposterous to think they would intentionally make a weaker movie to appease a market that hasn't been a big money generator for the franchise.


Disney and star wars had an entire book made just to introduce gay and lesbian main characters into the universe. Not just one, but FOUR. and that was the LEAST of THAT books problems. but considering it had an agenda just for that didn't help it any.
although to be fair, i'm still not sure if that was disney who wanted that or the author. but disney still had to approve it and let it pass even with all it's other issues. It felt like someone said 'i know the story is non existent, but look, diverse characters... maybe people would give it a pass just for that, OK it!'

(put down your pitch forks internet, i know i'm not the only one questioning the reason behind that decision)...

i wouldn't put it past hollywood to ruin a movie for dollar signs, intentionally or otherwise.

lets face it. boring flashy movies are the new norm now that china is in the picture. and that's only because hollywood thinks so little of the chinese citizens, that they think they have to dumb it down for them.

I await the first reply tearing this to shreds in a viscous fashion :).

Zak The Neutrino
12-21-2016, 05:16 PM
Also I thought I read some place that Rogue One is being distributed by Disney and not Lucas Film. I'm trying to find the source but I'm pretty sure I read that some place. The article made a big deal that this one was the first.

NinjaPug
12-21-2016, 05:31 PM
"Lucasfilm" is even more of a puppet studio than Marvel for Disney. Do you really think Kathleen Kennedy is able to go to bat for things with Disney more than Kevin Feige is able to, when even Kevin Feige himself has been losing battles with them on the Chinese front?

And it's probably coincidence that two of China's biggest stars are in the movie (http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/rogue-one-5-things-know-882936?facebook_20161217).

I actually think it's the opposite. Marvel relies heavily on foreign markets for their box office. Star Wars doesn't. It's a lot easier to fight back on something when the numbers support it.

Adding Chinese actors to a movie is a different argument. That's not intentionally changing the structure of a movie to appease the Chinese like your earlier post mentioned. KK has also made a point of adding diversity to SW since she took over. I've seen a number of interviews with her being asked specifically about Asian characters.

Also I thought I read some place that Rogue One is being distributed by Disney and not Lucas Film. I'm trying to find the source but I'm pretty sure I read that some place. The article made a big deal that this one was the first.

Disney distributes all Star Wars movies. That started with TFA last year.

Andrew NDB
12-21-2016, 05:41 PM
Also I thought I read some place that Rogue One is being distributed by Disney and not Lucas Film.

Lucasfilm never distributed any Star Wars movies.

Zak The Neutrino
12-21-2016, 06:24 PM
Lucasfilm never distributed any Star Wars movies.

Yeah but I thought I read there was something different about Rogue One as far as Disney's involvement vs TFA. TFA was Disney so I was wrong it's not that. This is what happens when you read a ton of articles about the movie before it comes out. :ohwell:

TurtleTitan97
12-21-2016, 08:38 PM
Just got back from seeing it. It was awesome! I'm so happy I managed to avoid spoilers before seeing it unlike Force Awakens. Vader attacking the Rebels at the end was so sweet! And the CGI for Tarkin and Leia was awesome. 10/10

Utrommaniac
12-21-2016, 09:02 PM
I just got back from seeing it too...and was wondering if it was CG.

As sad is it made me, it seemed appropriate for the characters to die for the story to go on. I even wanted to go home with my friend (who I've decided to start dating, but I don't want to call him my boyfriend because it sounds juvenile), and watch a New Hope but got tired halfway through.

But the detail in melding the two movies together worked perfectly.

We did have trouble hearing a lot of the audio, and so didn't fully pick up on what all the names were. For me, it ended up being "Girl" "Not Han Solo" "Chill Force Toph" "Grumpy" "Robot" and "Pilot" because I barely heard them.

THGhost
12-24-2016, 08:01 AM
Boy was this good. Loved the war movie feel, didn't even feel like a Star Wars movie at times which was a refreshing change.

The CG Tarkin was brilliant, the CG Leia not so much though. Talk about the uncanny valley. :lol:

DestronMirage22
12-26-2016, 07:21 PM
Saw it. Agree that the first half or so was boring. Really boring. The end though, it was fantastic, it actually felt like a Star Wars movie (unlike the Force Awakens).

I didn't get invested in the new characters themselves, and can't even remember what any of them were called, but I did like that they all kicked the bucket in the end..

CGI Tarkin and Leia were surprisingly good looking. Vader was great.

ToTheNines
12-26-2016, 07:25 PM
Anyone who thinks Tarkin looks good should see an optometrist. Not even being a dick.

My buddy who saw it with me said he looked fine, but was quick to admit he left the house without his contacts.

DestronMirage22
12-26-2016, 07:33 PM
I was sitting at the very back of the theater so he looked ok to me. :lol:
I did think he looked like a video game CGI cutscene character though, but he kinda passed as a really old and sickly looking dude.

TheSkeletonMan939
12-26-2016, 07:38 PM
His eyes were lifeless. I don't know what it is about eyes, but you can read a lot of emotion in them - and Tarkin's look pasted on.

Instead of forcing a subplot with him down our throats, if they had to use him at all, they should have hired a living, breathing lookalike and used lighting/camera tricks or something.

Leia looked better though.

ToTheNines
12-26-2016, 08:03 PM
Or facial prosthetics. Or keep his appearances hologram only.

Leia looked great, I thought. But that was like 5 seconds of screen time and she barely moved.

NinjaPug
12-26-2016, 08:49 PM
Tarkin's first appearance was so jarring to me that I completely tuned out everything else going on in the scene. His other scenes were fine once I accepted that the CGI looked like crap.

Cure
12-26-2016, 08:52 PM
they should have hired a living, breathing lookalike and used lighting/camera tricks or something.

Leia looked better though.

I feel like that's even more true for Leia. Everyone would have known who she was if her back was to the camera and shown like, her hair or something.

plastroncafe
12-26-2016, 10:59 PM
Anyone who thinks Tarkin looks good should see an optometrist. Not even being a dick.

I have, and you are.

snake
12-27-2016, 12:58 AM
Anyone that thinks Tarkin looked bad is a f*cking retard. Just look at this comparison!

http://img.lum.dolimg.com/v1/images/image_a9a2ed53.jpeg?region=207%2C0%2C1213%2C910&width=320http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/c/c1/Tarkininfobox.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/500?cb=20100620213033

AT-Man
12-27-2016, 05:40 AM
Neither Tarkin or Leia looked like real people. Ant-Man showed that Disney has access to some phenomenal "youngening" technique, too bad they didn't use it.

ToTheNines
12-27-2016, 05:43 AM
Anyone that thinks Tarkin looked bad is a f*cking retard. Just look at this comparison!

http://img.lum.dolimg.com/v1/images/image_a9a2ed53.jpeg?region=207%2C0%2C1213%2C910&width=320http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/c/c1/Tarkininfobox.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/500?cb=20100620213033


Lol

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/4b/d6/7c/4bd67c0dfbb87c29a2051afa54171635.jpg

TheSkeletonMan939
12-27-2016, 08:17 AM
Neither Tarkin or Leia looked like real people. Ant-Man showed that Disney has access to some phenomenal "youngening" technique, too bad they didn't use it.

Well for Ant-Man, they had the original actors to work off from. For Cushing, they probably had to parse an unholy amount of archive footage. I'd enjoy seeing a bonus feature on the DVD about how they went about creating Tarkin, because as gaudy as it is I'm really interested about the whole process.

Dust
12-27-2016, 08:26 AM
While Tarkin and Leia didn't look terrible, they looked siginificantly better than Young Jeff Bridges in Tron Legacy, they didn't look fully human and definitely looked off. Perhaps they could polish them for the DVD/Blu-Ray release, make them look better, but for what they did, I didn't think it was half bad.
Marvel Studios did it better though.

ranger_scout
12-27-2016, 10:23 AM
I've seen it twice and it's pretty darn good. The first time I saw it I thought that the beginning kind of dragged on a little bit and that part of the film didn't have my full attention as much as Episode VII: The Force Awakens did. However, once it got to the middle that was when my interest really kicked in. Once the end was drawing near I could understand why this wasn't going to have a sequel. It was very sad to see these new characters die, but their huge sacrifices for the good of the Rebellion. It was really nice to see Tikal, Guatemala once again being used as the setting for Yavin 4. I of course loved hearing James Earl Jones as Vader again along with the cameos from R2-D2 and C-3PO.

WebLurker
12-27-2016, 10:24 AM
I liked that they gave Tarkin and Leia scenes and that they were on-camera. While the effects may or may not be up to scratch, I liked what they were trying to do (tie the movies closer together), and the material the actors standing in were given was really good.

I guess since I realized that they have to do CGI to bring these characters back (and knew about Tarkin beforehand), I was more accepting. At any rate, I was only expecting a small cameo on a viewscreen for something, so my surprise was that he actually had substantial scenes and to be a major player and I really liked that.

snake
12-27-2016, 10:44 AM
I'm probably in the minority but Leia looked perfect IMO. Tarkin was a little rough but I could handle it. I wish they used the same guy from ROTS and aged him up a bit, because he looked EXACTLY like Cushing.

Andrew NDB
12-27-2016, 11:09 AM
Rogue One actually reminds me a lot of Terminator 3... the first 2/3s are sort of lame and retread... but then things kick up at the end, and it goes out super ballsy.

Andrew NDB
12-27-2016, 11:13 AM
I wish they used the same guy from ROTS and aged him up a bit, because he looked EXACTLY like Cushing.

Not really. They just put a crapload of makeup and prosthetics on him.

http://image.tmdb.org/t/p/w342/mBy1Zs6PBwuVWoiHxc8ChhC0YD1.jpg

Into...

http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/5/5b/Young_Tarkin.jpg

http://moa.omnimulti.com/images/thumb/6/63/Young_tarkin.jpg/189px-Young_tarkin.jpg

snake
12-27-2016, 11:28 AM
Not really. They just put a crapload of makeup and prosthetics on him.

http://image.tmdb.org/t/p/w342/mBy1Zs6PBwuVWoiHxc8ChhC0YD1.jpg

Into...

http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/5/5b/Young_Tarkin.jpg

http://moa.omnimulti.com/images/thumb/6/63/Young_tarkin.jpg/189px-Young_tarkin.jpg
Oh wow, I've never seen him without all the makeup. Yeah. Still I'm sure they could have aged him up using more makeup or found another look alike.

plastroncafe
12-27-2016, 11:53 AM
I was finally able to catch this movie on Christmas Day.
Overall I liked it, but I wouldn't go recommending it to someone who isn't already a HUGE fan of the franchise. It's far too insular a flick to be considered a good standalone movie, IMHO.

I really liked getting back to that world.
I thought the acting was good overall, loved what Tudyk brought to the table...as per usual. The CG stuff was distracting, but not entirely in a negative way. I just found myself watching the animation more than say, paying attention to what the characters were doing/saying during those scenes.

Kind of like the water effects in Moana, but less so.

It really makes me want to mainline all the cartoons.

ToTheNines
12-27-2016, 02:13 PM
Oh wow, I've never seen him without all the makeup. Yeah. Still I'm sure they could have aged him up using more makeup or found another look alike.

Yeah, they brought back the lady who played Mothma in unused ROTS scenes, why not do the same with Tarkin? Still could have dubbed him with Stephen Stanton.

Andrew NDB
12-27-2016, 02:18 PM
Yeah, they brought back the lady who played Mothma in unused ROTS scenes, why not do the same with Tarkin?

Because Wayne Pygram was never supposed to pass for Tarkin beyond a single faraway shot. And, outside of heavy makeup and prosthetic, looks nothing like Tarkin.

TheSkeletonMan939
12-27-2016, 02:18 PM
Part of the decision may have been based on a desire to show off new computer technology... if that's the case, then I think it backfired on them.

snake
12-27-2016, 02:21 PM
Part of the decision may have been based on a desire to show off new computer technology... if that's the case, then I think it backfired on them.

The only time I've seen complaints about Tarkin is when I'm browsing the internet. Everyone I know in real life thought he looked amazing.

plastroncafe
12-27-2016, 02:35 PM
People complaining loudly about something that didn't work for them, on my internet?

It's more likely than you think.

WebLurker
12-27-2016, 07:27 PM
I'm probably in the minority but Leia looked perfect IMO. Tarkin was a little rough but I could handle it. I wish they used the same guy from ROTS and aged him up a bit, because he looked EXACTLY like Cushing.

Yeah, I had no problems with the effects either.

sdp
12-30-2016, 10:49 PM
I finally saw the movie and I've got mixed feelings, I enjoyed a lot of things about it but there are too many "Why?"s for me to actually say I liked it. As vocal as I've been about The Force Awakens I think it's a better movie even if this movie has far less things that annoy me if that makes any sense. I had accidentally read a few spoilers but of stuff I already knew or suspected was going to happen so it didn't affect me a lot.

I have a problem (miscrave.com/articles/annual-star-wars-spin-offs)with the spin-offs and it being annual from the get go as I've mentioned in the Rogue One and Han-Solo threads. And I understand for this reason Disney want to make sure we understand this is a spin-off and not one of the "ones that count" but I think it was handled the wrong way. The movie begins with "A long time a go in a galaxy far far away..." but then there's no opening crawl..I know this had been debated and I felt either way was fine, we've had previous spin-off films like the Ewoks' without one and spin-offs that do have them like Clone Wars. But I really felt I needed it, especially after the a long time ago message. I felt like I was given blue balls after not getting my reward after being teased. The next point is the music which is kind of Star Warsy but some scenes just needed the Star Wars music and I think it was only used in the Vader scene which oddly enough didn't need it as much. Ok so this isn't a "main" Star Wars movie but that doesn't mean it can't have the music, it's part of what makes the franchise stand out. Sure you can have a majority of new music but some classic themes have to be there especially when your movie is basically a direct prequel to one of the main films so it shares a lot of visual content. And yet the end credits can have the classic Star Wars ending? Why break the rules there? And if they want to separate the spin-offs from the main series ones why did they not market The Force Awakens as Episode VII instead of just leaving it in the opening crawl? Think of all the Star Wars video games and would they really be the same without the music? It adds to the experience, even the opening crawl that you see in the games, it's something Star Wars should continue to use even if it's a spin-off.

To be a little positive I liked Director Krennic a lot, I think I read some scenes of him were cut and that would be a shame since he was one of the best characters. Jyn was an alright character and probably better motivated than Rey. The X-Wing fight was awesome and really enjoyed it. I think I've read a few people not like the CG? Overall I thought it was really good, sure you can tell Tarkin/Leia are CG since they look a bit like wax figures but they still look more realistic than the random aliens they create for the movies so that's my counter-argument the bug lady from The Force Awakens looks 100 times more fake than Tarkin or Leia.

I read a lot of things about how it made the original trilogy better or how much more complex the situation had become thanks to this movie but I don't really see any of that, on the contrary it was not something we needed to see. The movie was a little long and boring for me, we have a lot of parts that just go on that should've been cut and made it a shorter but tighter movie. We have way too many characters..so many that I only remember Jyn's and Krennic's names the other guys I'm looking up them up to be able to mention them here. Cassian was a good supporting character even if we never really find out much about him and thought the whole end of almost kissing and then holding hands like out of the blue but I don't care either way. Donnie Yen is awesome but his character here was lame, he did nothing besides knock out stormtroopers with a stick that felt more out of place than when ewoks did it; His friend Baze Malbus was alright. The Bodhi Rook was interesting, I wish we had gotten more on him instead of the others who also didn't get much development. The droid K-2SO was good for the most part and Saw Guerrera who apparently appeared in the Clone Wars cartoon which I think is awesome didn't have much reason to be in the movie and could've easily been cut but I really liked him and was sad to see him go out so early making his appearance pointless instead of really adding complexity to the plot.

I was afraid of how Vader was going to be handled and out of his three scenes only the last one was appropriate and awesome. The other two didn't need to be there and while it was cool to hear Vader (who sounded off in a few lines) he just didn't need to be there and does take a bit form his character more than any "nooooooo" ever could. Tarkin was also used too much while I was a fan of the CG as I mentioned he took time from Krennic. I also realized that if Tarkin is such an awesome villain that we should get more movies with him so regardless of what I think the CG went they should've recasted so they had an actor who can play him in other movies. While the final fight was pretty cool it also felt too big for what it was, it was basically busier than the Death Star battle and yet this was supposed to be a smaller conflict.

Some parts maybe because of lack of music or different mood made it seem like a fan film. And yeah it's a spin-off and it should do different things from Star Wars movies but it lacked a bit of the Star Wars magic and I don't think it was because it was too dark but because the story itself is so connected to the original trilogy that it doesn't fit well with them. The Force Awakens has that "Star Wars magic" even if I was not a big fan of that film on the other hand at least Rogue One is more original than Episode VII. So I'm unsure how I feel about it, it's not a bad movie but it's not great either and almost everything about the movie felt unnecessary as I've mentioned through out. I'm glad I watched it on theaters though but I feel after this one like other spin-off films can definitely be skipped like the young Han Solo film and be selective to what I watch on theaters or what can wait for me to watch at home.

I'll be reading the thread now and probably replying to some of you guys here.

sdp
12-30-2016, 11:22 PM
I forgot how boring the opening scene was until reading the comments, and from what I see a lot of you agree with me.

One thing i just noticed this movie retcons Episode II where we see it's the geonosian's who created the Death Star, now before someone here "explains to me" about how in "comic/book" it was explained that blahblahblah doesn't matter it's never shown on screen anywhere if you just watch the movies and these are the type of retcons the EU was known for so it's all the same mess now.


Well, you're not wrong but I can kind of see the frustration of looking forward to finally getting to see Darth Vader, but only actually getting like a minute and a half of it at the end of Episode III.

"A Star Wars Story: PURGE" could be pretty great.
That's what I want, sure you can have these movies with Vader for a minute doing his thing but no more. If you want to show Vader more give him his movie on how he eliminates all the remaining Jedi or a mission the Emperor gave him. We don't need a backstory we just want to see Vader being a badass like at the end of the movie. And this movie needs to be done now while James Earl Jones is still alive, I don't think his Vader is perfect anymore based on the pilot of Rebels and here but he still nails it most of the time.


Marvel isn't Lucasfilm. Spare me the Disney argument.

I think it's preposterous to think they would intentionally make a weaker movie to appease a market that hasn't been a big money generator for the franchise.

China has become a major player though since it's the only place where you can see growth, of course they are interested especially since it's not a big generator yet, but they hope it'll eventually be, hence the changes made here from The Force Awakens.

And the Disney isn't Pixar/Marvel/Lucasfilm is a popular but weak argument that people keep repeating. Sure they have a certain degree of autonomy but you are kidding yourself if you think Disney really does let them do what they want, they just have some more creative freedom since Disney has seen that it works but they're still behind their shoulders supervising, so enjoy your Cars 3 that Pixar totally made that decision by themselves.


Anyone that thinks Tarkin looked bad is a f*cking retard. Just look at this comparison!

http://img.lum.dolimg.com/v1/images/image_a9a2ed53.jpeg?region=207%2C0%2C1213%2C910&width=320http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/c/c1/Tarkininfobox.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/500?cb=20100620213033
I liked Tarkin but what are you trying to prove with this comparison? That's the tarkin used in a kids tv show that has a cartoony art-style vs real life.

While Tarkin and Leia didn't look terrible, they looked siginificantly better than Young Jeff Bridges in Tron Legacy, they didn't look fully human and definitely looked off. Perhaps they could polish them for the DVD/Blu-Ray release, make them look better, but for what they did, I didn't think it was half bad.
They won't polish anyone for the BR release they're moving on with their yearly Star Wars. But I do remember reading online how Young Jeff Bridges was perfect when that Tron Legacy came out and now people complain and these are indeed superior. The technology will continue to get better, I'm sure we'll get many spin-off films of the time between Episode VI and VII with Luke/Leia/Solo all looking younger and entirely made of CG say in 20 years or so.


I'm probably in the minority but Leia looked perfect IMO. Tarkin was a little rough but I could handle it. I wish they used the same guy from ROTS and aged him up a bit, because he looked EXACTLY like Cushing.

Not really. They just put a crapload of makeup and prosthetics on him.

http://image.tmdb.org/t/p/w342/mBy1Zs6PBwuVWoiHxc8ChhC0YD1.jpg

Into...

http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/5/5b/Young_Tarkin.jpg

http://moa.omnimulti.com/images/thumb/6/63/Young_tarkin.jpg/189px-Young_tarkin.jpg

Because Wayne Pygram was never supposed to pass for Tarkin beyond a single faraway shot. And, outside of heavy makeup and prosthetic, looks nothing like Tarkin.

Interesting, like I mentioned I thought Tarkin looked great for those short scenes but he's such an awesome villain we should see him in more movies so they should've cast someone who does look like him and have him appear in a few more movies.


edit: I think this movie's opinion will change radically in a few years, if you notice most people mention the final act as pretty much redeeming the rest but they justify the first parts of it so I think in a few years they'll see it as a bad movie with only a good finish.

The Deadman
01-01-2017, 05:11 PM
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Becomes Second Highest Grossing Movie of 2016 (http://411mania.com/movies/rogue-one-a-star-wars-story-becomes-second-highest-grossing-movie-of-2016/)

It's funny, people tried to get that boycott on Twitter going and it fell flat on it's face.

WebLurker
01-01-2017, 10:44 PM
I forgot how boring the opening scene was until reading the comments, and from what I see a lot of you agree with me.

I liked it, but to each their own.

One thing i just noticed this movie retcons Episode II where we see it's the geonosian's who created the Death Star, now before someone here "explains to me" about how in "comic/book" it was explained that blahblahblah doesn't matter it's never shown on screen anywhere if you just watch the movies and these are the type of retcons the EU was known for so it's all the same mess now.

We saw the Empire building the Death Star in Episode III. There's no retcon, esp. since the Sith were playing both sides (even Episode II shows Dooku bringing the plans to Sidious).

(FIY: The books and comics do matter. Star Wars canon is more than just the movies. The current run of tie-ins are (by official declaration) of equal canonical weight to the movies, so saying that what's onscreen is only what counts is not only wrong, it's not a decision we get to make. But whatever.)


That's what I want, sure you can have these movies with Vader for a minute doing his thing but no more. If you want to show Vader more give him his movie on how he eliminates all the remaining Jedi or a mission the Emperor gave him. We don't need a backstory we just want to see Vader being a badass like at the end of the movie. And this movie needs to be done now while James Earl Jones is still alive, I don't think his Vader is perfect anymore based on the pilot of Rebels and here but he still nails it most of the time.

I've liked the current use of Vader on TV and in the movies. Just enough, but not too much.

China has become a major player though since it's the only place where you can see growth, of course they are interested especially since it's not a big generator yet, but they hope it'll eventually be, hence the changes made here from The Force Awakens.

We'll see.

And the Disney isn't Pixar/Marvel/Lucasfilm is a popular but weak argument that people keep repeating. Sure they have a certain degree of autonomy but you are kidding yourself if you think Disney really does let them do what they want, they just have some more creative freedom since Disney has seen that it works but they're still behind their shoulders supervising, so enjoy your Cars 3 that Pixar totally made that decision by themselves.

By all accounts, LucasFilm is the one making 99% of the creative decisions, so I think it's safe to say that Disney isn't micromanaging. After all, Rogue One was an in-house idea pitched by a staff member.

They won't polish anyone for the BR release they're moving on with their yearly Star Wars. But I do remember reading online how Young Jeff Bridges was perfect when that Tron Legacy came out and now people complain and these are indeed superior. The technology will continue to get better, I'm sure we'll get many spin-off films of the time between Episode VI and VII with Luke/Leia/Solo all looking younger and entirely made of CG say in 20 years or so.

I thought the effects were fine, personally.

Interesting, like I mentioned I thought Tarkin looked great for those short scenes but he's such an awesome villain we should see him in more movies so they should've cast someone who does look like him and have him appear in a few more movies.

I'm not sure we need to see him in more movies. Other canon sources have done a lot with him (Tarkin, Rebels. Across the board, he's been used a lot.

Recasting is pretty hard, anyways. Some manage to pull it off (Ewan McGregor for Sir Alec Guinness as Ben Kenobi in Star Wars, Genevieve O'Reilly for Caroline Blaskiston as Mon Mothma, also from Star Wars, and Martin Freeman for Sir Ian McKellan as Bilbo Baggins in the Lord of the Rings/Hobbit movies, to name a few), but it's really hard to do and can make suspension of disbelief hard.

edit: I think this movie's opinion will change radically in a few years, if you notice most people mention the final act as pretty much redeeming the rest but they justify the first parts of it so I think in a few years they'll see it as a bad movie with only a good finish.

I don't know. While not a perfect movie, I think a case can be made that it's a good movie through and through. It's certainly up to par with the standard set by the series itself.

MikeandRaph87
01-02-2017, 12:47 PM
Here is a lego remake of the final scene of Rogue One.
http://www.flickeringmyth.com/2016/12/lego-remake-of-darth-vaders-final-scene-from-rogue-one/

Autbot_Benz
01-02-2017, 12:56 PM
Recasting is pretty hard, anyways. Some manage to pull it off (Ewan McGregor for Sir Alec Guinness as Ben Kenobi in Star Wars, Genevieve O'Reilly for Caroline Blaskiston as Mon Mothma, also from Star Wars, and Martin Freeman for Sir Ian McKellan as Bilbo Baggins in the Lord of the Rings/Hobbit movies, to name a few), but it's really hard to do and can make suspension of disbelief hard.

.

Martin Freeman was cast to replace Ian Holm who played Bilbo. Sir Ian Mckellan played Gandalf in all the middle earth movies

WebLurker
01-02-2017, 06:29 PM
Martin Freeman was cast to replace Ian Holm who played Bilbo. Sir Ian Mckellan played Gandalf in all the middle earth movies

How embarrassing! :D

TigerClaw
01-02-2017, 06:56 PM
Martin Freeman was cast to replace Ian Holm who played Bilbo. Sir Ian Mckellan played Gandalf in all the middle earth movies
Cause they needed a younger Bilbo.

TurtleTitan97
01-02-2017, 07:03 PM
Cause they needed a younger Bilbo.

Boy, nothing gets by you, does it? :roll:

snake
01-02-2017, 07:12 PM
Boy, nothing gets by you, does it? :roll:

There's still no proof that he ISN'T a robot.

Autbot_Benz
01-02-2017, 07:35 PM
Cause they needed a younger Bilbo.


http://i.imgur.com/m0nmNiq.jpg

ProactiveMan
01-06-2017, 12:28 AM
The only time I've seen complaints about Tarkin is when I'm browsing the internet. Everyone I know in real life thought he looked amazing.

I've heard a few verifiable real-life humans complain about it. Their opinions ranged from 'it was a bit creepy' to 'it was disrespectful'. I thought it looked alright, if not a little distracting. They couldn't stop messing with his eyelids - making him do a weird, subtle squint that looked too 'animated' for lack of a better word.

snake
01-06-2017, 05:47 AM
I've heard a few verifiable real-life humans complain about it. Their opinions ranged from 'it was a bit creepy' to 'it was disrespectful'. I thought it looked alright, if not a little distracting. They couldn't stop messing with his eyelids - making him do a weird, subtle squint that looked too 'animated' for lack of a better word.

He was animated a little odd. If they toned down his movements I could see it working much better for some people.

I don't understand where the "disrespectful" party is coming from. It was a recreation of the character Tarkin, not literally ressurecting Peter Cushing. By that logic the clone wars/rebels CGI models of Tarkin are a disrespect as well.

ToTheNines
01-06-2017, 06:01 AM
He was animated a little odd. If they toned down his movements I could see it working much better for some people.

I don't understand where the "disrespectful" party is coming from. It was a recreation of the character Tarkin, not literally ressurecting Peter Cushing. By that logic the clone wars/rebels CGI models of Tarkin are a disrespect as well.

Tarkin would have looked great in the Jim Carrey A Christmas Carol.

https://static01.nyt.com/images/2009/11/06/arts/06disney_span/articleLarge.jpg

CyberCubed
01-08-2017, 05:10 PM
So it's January which means I finally saw the movie, just today in fact. I always wait to January to see Star Wars movies, although suprisingly my theater was still fairly filled, at least 75% of the seats from what I could tell were taken. I guess people do similar to me.

I liked the movie overall, although I agree somewhere at the end of the first act and the middle it seemed to drag quite a bit. Mostly the whole prison scenes and then scenes on the planet with the rain up until her father appeared. I'm also surprised I somehow managed to avoid spoilers of all the characters fates in the movie after all this time. I certainly didn't expect the outcome we got.

This was a dark movie. It's the first Star Wars film I feel isn't for kids. All the other Star Wars films are uplifting, comedic, and have fun and iconic characters made for action figures and comic books. This was a gritty war movie with characters purposely toned down and "bland" but it worked well. I liked the female lead too.

I think the space battles were the best of any of the movies. Rather exciting.

snake
01-08-2017, 07:22 PM
Tarkin would have looked great in the Jim Carrey A Christmas Carol.

https://static01.nyt.com/images/2009/11/06/arts/06disney_span/articleLarge.jpg

I knew i recognized that odd skin tone from somewhere. :teek:

I wonder how bad that movie will look in 10-15 years.

Andrew NDB
01-08-2017, 07:25 PM
He was animated a little odd. If they toned down his movements I could see it working much better for some people.

I don't understand where the "disrespectful" party is coming from. It was a recreation of the character Tarkin, not literally ressurecting Peter Cushing. By that logic the clone wars/rebels CGI models of Tarkin are a disrespect as well.

Pretty sure if you're a dead screen actor, 9 times out of 10, if there's an afterlife and you're just kind of perpetually sitting there viewing the living, and someone asks you one day, "hey, dead actor guy, I know you've been dead for 40 years, but how do you feel about returning to the screen in some CGI version so people will be seeing you/talking about you again?" the answer is probably going to be yes. Versus the alternative.

People are getting upset about getting upset these days. All you can do is tune it out and silently, mentally give them a jerking off imogi.

Vegita-San
01-09-2017, 05:51 AM
People are getting upset about getting upset these days. All you can do is tune it out and silently, mentally give them a jerking off imogi.

don't dare bring up the fact that people are saying this movie is ONLY the best star wars movie ever ONLY because the cast is so diverse.
Or bring up the fact that the only reason chinese actors are getting attention is because thy are pandering to a communist government.

people loose their crap and go all SJW on you just to look good.

imagine that.

TheSkeletonMan939
01-09-2017, 11:09 AM
Pretty sure if you're a dead screen actor, 9 times out of 10, if there's an afterlife and you're just kind of perpetually sitting there viewing the living, and someone asks you one day, "hey, dead actor guy, I know you've been dead for 40 years, but how do you feel about returning to the screen in some CGI version so people will be seeing you/talking about you again?" the answer is probably going to be yes.

It's not you returning to the screen though. It's a CGI Frankenstein's monster. Your likeness is all there is; your mannerisms may be copied, but the acting isn't your own.

There's a difference between bringing the character back and bringing the actor, the human being, back.

ProactiveMan
01-10-2017, 11:00 PM
I don't understand where the "disrespectful" party is coming from. It was a recreation of the character Tarkin, not literally ressurecting Peter Cushing. By that logic the clone wars/rebels CGI models of Tarkin are a disrespect as well.

Yeah I dunno, I don’t feel the same way. If they had him dancing in an ad for vacuum cleaners or something, that would be different, but I thought it was as tastefully done as it could be. No worse than cutting in old footage anyway, so I think it’s the context and intent more than the technology. For a contrast sake, take Bruce Lee – the CGI face replacement they did for that whisky commercial was over the line in my opinion, because if he were alive, I don’t think he’d do it. But it’s no worse than what they did in Game of Death in the 70s, with more rudimentary technology.

CyberCubed
01-11-2017, 02:39 PM
Its a shame none of the side characters, besides the robot, were memorable. It would have been a better movie if we were made to care more when people died.

snake
01-11-2017, 02:46 PM
Its a shame none of the side characters, besides the robot, were memorable. It would have been a better movie if we were made to care more when people died.

Chirrut was pretty memorable.

sdp
01-11-2017, 04:05 PM
Chirrut was pretty memorable.

If I have to google him to know who he is then no he wasn't memorable. Having a gimmick doesn't make something memorable in fact I found him rather annoying.

plastroncafe
01-11-2017, 04:13 PM
I liked the two husbands. They were great.
Also the pilot. Oh and Forrest Whitaker's character.

And I'm always in the mood to see Hannibal act.

ToTheNines
01-11-2017, 04:24 PM
Chirrut was pretty memorable.

Agreed.

I thought Jyn's arc was brilliant. Even though it was pretty cliche to kill off Galen, the fact that her father restored her faith and inspired her after so many years apart was deep.

I also thought Captain Andor was badass.

And they tied in a freaking (formerly) one-off TCW character. That's awesome.

If I have to google him to know who he is then no he wasn't memorable. Having a gimmick doesn't make something memorable in fact I found him rather annoying.

Yes, because one little man had a short attention span means he wasn't memorable.

Autbot_Benz
01-11-2017, 04:25 PM
I agree with everyone the character development SUCKED in Rouge one didn't really care about anone once they died. I barley knew any of the names of the other characters besides Jyn Sau gurerra and the robot

I did enjoy the blind asian dude and the asian samoan guy with the big gun but shame they never mentioned there names in the movie

TurtleTitan97
01-11-2017, 04:55 PM
I did enjoy the blind asian dude and the asian samoan guy with the big gun but shame they never mentioned there names in the movie

If you were actually paying attention, they did say their names. The blind guy was Chirrut and his friend was Baze.

Andrew NDB
01-11-2017, 04:55 PM
I did enjoy the blind asian dude and the asian samoan guy with the big gun but shame they never mentioned there names in the movie

Yeah, if they mentioned their names in the movie, I never caught them.

CyberCubed
01-11-2017, 05:11 PM
I don't really remember any of their names either. I just known them as, "blind Asian guy," "other Asian guy with long hair," "scruffy looking guy with irish accent," "other guy with black hair who was with Jyn most of the movie," "the robot," and "the black guy who used a breathing thing and sounded like Darth Vader."

I don't even know what the name of the main villain general in the white suit was either.

ToTheNines
01-11-2017, 05:15 PM
"scruffy looking guy with irish accent"

Who the hell had an Irish accent?

CyberCubed
01-11-2017, 05:27 PM
Who the hell had an Irish accent?

Maybe it was Scottish? I don't know, all those accents sound the same to me, I can't tell the difference.

TheSkeletonMan939
01-11-2017, 05:41 PM
I think he's talking about the Imperial pilot dude.
Anyway, I also didn't know anyone's names, outside of Jyn's. I guess you're supposed to buy the toys and learn them that way. The names are intentionally weird-sounding, and so unless you know them ahead of time, anytime someone says his name it just sounds like mumbo-jumbo.

sdp
01-11-2017, 05:47 PM
Lots of little men in this thread, the internet and the population in general.

ToTheNines
01-11-2017, 05:56 PM
Jesus Christ dude, I'm not trying to measure dicks. I just meant "little" as in "insignificant". You had to get all uppity and matter-of-factly, acting like your lone opinion was empirical evidence.

plastroncafe
01-11-2017, 08:57 PM
I think he's talking about the Imperial pilot dude.
Anyway, I also didn't know anyone's names, outside of Jyn's. I guess you're supposed to buy the toys and learn them that way. The names are intentionally weird-sounding, and so unless you know them ahead of time, anytime someone says his name it just sounds like mumbo-jumbo.

Which makes it a whole lot like the original Trilogy.

sdp
01-11-2017, 09:09 PM
Defensive much?

WebLurker
01-11-2017, 11:56 PM
Its a shame none of the side characters, besides the robot, were memorable. It would have been a better movie if we were made to care more when people died.

I found most of them memorable and cared vey much when they died, although I will concede that it had more to do with the actor's performances than the writing.

I liked the two husbands. They were great.

Huh? There weren't any characters in the movie that fit that description.[/QUOTE]

TheSkeletonMan939
01-12-2017, 09:07 AM
Which makes it a whole lot like the original Trilogy.

Not necessarily. The OT had easy-to-name characters like Luke, Ben, Solo, and Chewie.
Here we have, uh, Saw? Chirrut Îmwe?

plastroncafe
01-12-2017, 12:35 PM
Not necessarily. The OT had easy-to-name characters like Luke, Ben, Solo, and Chewie.
Here we have, uh, Saw? Chirrut Îmwe?

I was referring to the fact that many fans only knew the more obscure characters names after they got the action figures.
And since the whole point of the movie is that it's populated by obscure characters, I think it makes sense.

Andrew NDB
01-12-2017, 12:38 PM
Not necessarily. The OT had easy-to-name characters like Luke, Ben, Solo, and Chewie.
Here we have, uh, Saw? Chirrut Îmwe?

VGfYX7NmYnU

TigerClaw
03-02-2017, 10:51 PM
How Rogue One Should Have Ended

RjR71XpAu0I

CyberCubed
03-02-2017, 11:02 PM
I'm not watching a 7 minute youtube video, but Rogue One ended fine. I hope he doesn't say the main characters should have lived.

WebLurker
03-03-2017, 09:35 AM
I'm not watching a 7 minute youtube video, but Rogue One ended fine. I hope he doesn't say the main characters should have lived.

I've heard of that series. It's just a tongue in cheek parody. (Frankly, I wish some of the characters had lived.)

The Deadman
04-11-2017, 12:23 PM
t9-pTStLGGo

Dust
04-11-2017, 01:01 PM
Maybe it was Scottish? I don't know, all those accents sound the same to me, I can't tell the difference.

Bodhi (who I assume you mean from process of elimination) is played by an English actor, who uses his natural accent in the film, therefore it's English, and doesn't sound at all Irish or Scottish.

Shark_Blade
04-11-2017, 01:49 PM
How Rogue One Should Have Ended

RjR71XpAu0I

Totally how it should've been. :tlol:

sdp
04-05-2018, 10:53 PM
I'm interested in watching the original cut / ending of Rogue One

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/star-wars-rogue-one-writer-tony-gilroy-opens-up-reshoots-1100060?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

In June 2016, Lucasfilm hired the Oscar-nominated writer to rework Rogue One: A Star Wars Story after the studio was unsatisfied by the state of director Gareth Edwards' movie. By August, he was taking a leading role in postproduction and oversaw reshoots to fix a few issues, including the film's ending. Gilroy ultimately was paid millions for his work, and many consider him the film's ghost director.


I don't know, the original movie is ok, it had some cool ideas but overall it just felt so unnecessary and created more problems than doing anything positive for the franchise.

Maybe this bolder version would've been more interesting even if not better. I mean I have no real interest in ever watching this movie again, maybe the other version would've been more polarizing but more engaging?

Andrew NDB
04-06-2018, 12:27 AM
maybe the other version would've been more polarizing but more engaging?

That's probably the perfect way to sum up how I imagine the original cut was. But who knows. We'll never know. We'll probably never see a single deleted scene from the actual Gareth Edwards cut.

AT-Man
08-04-2018, 10:29 AM
Nice to hear something in the SW universe makes sense.

ZSI_ipDApU8