View Full Version : TMNT: The Last Ronin #1 Preview and Discussion
Diorm
06-15-2020, 09:07 AM
I actually said that because there are still no end to Volume 4. Wich was a personnal project. If Last Ronin, a project that is being very much talked about, didnt wake anything in him to come back and end Volume 4, then what will? He just gave the pitch of Last Ronin and that's it. At this point I really can say that he will never comeback. At least he can give the pitch of what he intended to do with Volume 4 to Jim Lawson, but even he started to make a "what if" futur story to mirage that takes place after Volume 4, in "TMNT 2030". Even he knows that Peter wont come back to it. Hell, he even made mock up cover arts of the missing issues at the start of the year.
PizzaPower1985
06-15-2020, 09:55 AM
I actually said that because there are still no end to Volume 4. Wich was a personnal project. If Last Ronin, a project that is being very much talked about, didnt wake anything in him to come back and end Volume 4, then what will? He just gave the pitch of Last Ronin and that's it. At this point I really can say that he will never comeback. At least he can give the pitch of what he intended to do with Volume 4 to Jim Lawson, but even he started to make a "what if" futur story to mirage that takes place after Volume 4, in "TMNT 2030". Even he knows that Peter wont come back to it. Hell, he even made mock up cover arts of the missing issues at the start of the year.
Exactly my point. Laird seems to have given up. Never say never, but I think you're spot on. He's, in all honesty, probably forever done with TMNT.
hypered1
06-15-2020, 10:49 AM
I actually said that because there are still no end to Volume 4. Wich was a personnal project. If Last Ronin, a project that is being very much talked about, didnt wake anything in him to come back and end Volume 4, then what will? He just gave the pitch of Last Ronin and that's it. At this point I really can say that he will never comeback. At least he can give the pitch of what he intended to do with Volume 4 to Jim Lawson, but even he started to make a "what if" futur story to mirage that takes place after Volume 4, in "TMNT 2030". Even he knows that Peter wont come back to it. Hell, he even made mock up cover arts of the missing issues at the start of the year.
I don't suppose you have a link to those cover arts by any chance? Thanks in advance.
AquaParade
06-15-2020, 11:26 AM
Give Peter Laird a few more years. Let his mind bend as far as possible and we may get to see him go even more wild with the Mirage conclusion than he did with April's origin. Let's see him go so far that Kevin Eastman's new thing will be having to dodge questions on his thoughts about how bat-**** insane (or potentially offensive) his co-creator's conclusion to the franchise was. It will be a ball watching Nickelodeon and Viacom struggle to snuff it's existence into the land of forgotten memory. I'm thinking on the level of Neal Adam's "Odyssey" or Frank Miller's "Holy Terror". All the greats deserve one.
All in jest, but it does feel like this was the perfect opportunity for him to come back, if he were anywhere near ready. He was willing to collaborate on the anniversary cover with Eastman, and we don't even have one of those for the first issue of TLR, so you have to wonder what the variable is in this scenario, whether it's simply that Peter "didn't feel like doing it" or something more.
Who knows though, perhaps he will eventually invite Kevin to do something with him under Mirage studios. It seems possible that he is somewhat interested but would rather do something under the imprint they created together. I could have sworn we heard him recently hint at working with Kevin again one day (Netflix 'Toys' special?) He does seem partial to doing things on his own terms. Probably doesn't like the idea of running a TMNT story by Nickelodeon for approval...
Yes, I've convinced myself that must be it.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-15-2020, 11:40 AM
He hasn't even updated his TMNT blog in... 2 years? 3?
Laird's done. Laird TMNT is deader than Lincoln. And we should properly mourn its passing.
PizzaPower1985
06-15-2020, 12:26 PM
He hasn't even updated his TMNT blog in... 2 years? 3?
Laird's done. Laird TMNT is deader than Lincoln. And we should properly mourn its passing.
Wait! Lincoln's dead? Holy $hit!
Diorm
06-15-2020, 12:40 PM
I don't suppose you have a link to those cover arts by any chance? Thanks in advance.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?p=1800352
I swear it was there, but all those links are down now. Maybe on the facebook page?
And it was the start of last year. Sorry 2020 is so shi tty that I mixed both years.
bjaxx87
06-17-2020, 06:50 AM
I don't know..., I'm trying not to get too excited for this. While it's based on an age-old script I fear that this will become a very... IDW-influenced book. Remembering how much they hyped mediocre stories like City Fall or their take on City at War I doubt they will manage to achieve the look and feel of a real Mirage book. (I'd be happy to be proven otherwise, though.)
Sharman
06-17-2020, 12:49 PM
It has been reiterated in several interviews and whatnot from Eastman that Laird's role is simply as co-originator of the story. After that Eastman and Waltz developed and reworked it with the latter writing the actual script. Then the remaining creative team do their stuff ...
As for volume four - Laird wrote on his blog several times that he essentially just lost interest and that the volume will probably never be concluded. He did say, however, that he has an outline for the remainder of the volume and stated he might one day publish it. That was several year ago, however ...
AquaParade
06-17-2020, 12:58 PM
It has been reiterated in several interviews and whatnot from Eastman that Laird's role is simply as co-originator of the story. After that Eastman and Waltz developed and reworked it with the latter writing the actual script. Then the remaining creative team do their stuff ...
As for volume four - Laird wrote on his blog several times that he essentially just lost interest and that the volume will probably never be concluded. He did say, however, that he has an outline for the remainder of the volume and stated he might one day publish it. That was several year ago, however ...
I'd think the only reason for him to publish it at this point would be if he were 100% sure he had no interest in fleshing it out. There could be hope for those who want to see the volume wrapped up.
It's not particularly high on my wish list. I'm pretty much fine with the conclusion to Volume 4 being as ambiguous as any other "future tmnt" story we have seen glimpses of.
I much rather see Kevin and Peter reunite, even for a one-shot. It wouldn't need to be the final story at the end of the timeline, but something more of an "emotional close" to the Mirage series.
Andrew NDB
06-17-2020, 01:05 PM
I don't know..., I'm trying not to get too excited for this. While it's based on an age-old script I fear that this will become a very... IDW-influenced book. Remembering how much they hyped mediocre stories like City Fall or their take on City at War I doubt they will manage to achieve the look and feel of a real Mirage book. (I'd be happy to be proven otherwise, though.)
There is the big question as to killing. I'm pretty sure "The Turtle" of this was intended to kill his enemies in the 1987 outline... which Nickelodeon won't allow. Or will they treat this as an exception/something grandfathered in, I wonder?
Diorm
06-17-2020, 01:34 PM
I mean, in the IDW comic:
Shredder did Seppuku with the help of Splinter. And Don was smashed to death by Rocksteady
But yeah, The Mike Rooth variant cover tend to show Footbot instead of foot ninja. So no human killing? But that cover has Rocksteady and Bebop with leatherhead in the back too. We can take it like a real thing or not...
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Eaf9fNLXYAILXrK?format=jpg&name=large
AquaParade
06-17-2020, 01:54 PM
There is the big question as to killing. I'm pretty sure "The Turtle" of this was intended to kill his enemies in the 1987 outline... which Nickelodeon won't allow. Or will they treat this as an exception/something grandfathered in, I wonder?
Kevin said in an interview the other day that this was one of the darkest TMNT stories ever. I can't quote him at the moment but I'm pretttty sure that's what he said. Still not a guarantee by any means, but it should be up on Youtube or may even be one of the interviews I linked in the general discussion section, in case you're curious.
At the same time, Mike Rooth's variant cover has a bunch of stabbed Foot Ninja with wires and tech visible under the "skin", so that may be telling.
Diorm
06-17-2020, 02:17 PM
At the same time, Mike Rooth's variant cover has a bunch of stabbed Foot Ninja with wires and tech visible under the "skin", so that may be telling.
... yeah that's what I just said.
Andrew NDB
06-17-2020, 03:25 PM
I mean, in the IDW comic:
Shredder did Seppuku with the help of Splinter. And Don was smashed to death by Rocksteady
Those aren't examples of the Turtles killing anyone. Nick has no problem with anyone else killing, apparently... just a big "No" on the Turtles doing so. They have to remain friendly neighborhood ninjas, in their minds.
But yeah, The Mike Rooth variant cover tend to show Footbot instead of foot ninja.
Not a good sign at all. Not at all.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-17-2020, 04:22 PM
Those aren't examples of the Turtles killing anyone. Nick has no problem with anyone else killing, apparently... just a big "No" on the Turtles doing so. They have to remain friendly neighborhood ninjas, in their minds.
Not a good sign at all. Not at all.
Yep. Splinter can kill, Slash can kill, Shredder and Krang can kill... hell, April could probably kill. Just not the four Turtles.
And while I'd like to think the Footbots are artistic license, I'm a little worried myself.
Galactus
06-17-2020, 05:34 PM
Well...it is set in the future with advanced tech. Robot Foot wouldn't be out of place in this setting and would probably be part of the initial plans for the story without jumping to the conclusions about whether this is done deliberately to avoid the turtles killing people.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-17-2020, 05:46 PM
Well...it is set in the future with advanced tech. Robot Foot wouldn't be out of place in this setting and would probably be part of the initial plans for the story without jumping to the conclusions about whether this is done deliberately to avoid the turtles killing people.
If it's from the OG Eastman/Laird idea, back in '89 or whenever, there's no way it was always meant to be robots.
Now, there's a good chance it's artistic license. Bebop and Rocksteady are on the cover, too, after all.
But if it IS robots, we all know why.
AquaParade
06-17-2020, 07:47 PM
It won't be gratuitous but I'm sure we'll see some death and consequence. We've already seen that to a small degree in IDW books.
Andrew NDB
06-18-2020, 04:43 AM
But if not by "The Turtle" himself... then it seems diminished. If this is supposed to be some kind of basically adapted version of the Mirage's lost "Unforgiven" (not literally, that movie hadn't come out in 1987)... it'd be pretty weird if William Munny just shot everyone in the leg in that third act and yelled at Little Bill for the climax. Or if someone else just steps in for the last big kill or whatever.
PizzaPower1985
06-18-2020, 05:58 AM
The more I hear about this story, even though you're all just speculating, the more I kinda lose interest. The Last Ronin is still very much on my radar. My antennae are out and I'm ready for it. I will check it out when it arrives, but it may be a dud.
It's kinda reminding me of how I was when they announced Frank Miller's Superman: Year One... Ooh, intriguing and exciting... a potentially golden-age/Max Fleischer inspired Frank Miller Superman story... but then I saw it and it was a pile of cow dung that even had Superman showing support for the current POTUS of all things. JR Jr. should have never been allowed anywhere near DC Comics.
Given how IDW's Turtles has suffered since at least 2017 (there have been some good things tho) The Last Ronin may be all hype. I'm still holding my breath in anticipation though.
wpugh2424
06-18-2020, 10:03 AM
anyone have opinions on the jetpack exclusive packs for this comic release?
AquaParade
06-18-2020, 10:21 AM
But if not by "The Turtle" himself... then it seems diminished. If this is supposed to be some kind of basically adapted version of the Mirage's lost "Unforgiven" (not literally, that movie hadn't come out in 1987)... it'd be pretty weird if William Munny just shot everyone in the leg in that third act and yelled at Little Bill for the climax. Or if someone else just steps in for the last big kill or whatever.
Mm, good point. It's going to feel neutered if our turtle is doing the ol' "sword slap" on hordes of deadly ninja. I'm feeling optimistic based off Kevin's comments. I play a dangerous game that way.
Diorm
06-18-2020, 10:23 AM
Those aren't examples of the Turtles killing anyone. Nick has no problem with anyone else killing, apparently... just a big "No" on the Turtles doing so. They have to remain friendly neighborhood ninjas, in their minds.
Gotcha.
But I think Ninja bot are going to be a thing. And I think they will look like those, because the covers were done by two different artists:
https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT_TLR-01_Cover-RE-Sanctum-Sanctorum_rich.png
https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT_TLR-01_Cover-RE-Artgerm-Collectibles-A_rich.jpg
Or they dont know the design of the ninja bot and just did something really similar.
Or all those artists just think: futur = robot ninja.
a potentially golden-age/Max Fleischer inspired
Wow that's a name I didnt know I would see on this forum.
I'm feeling optimistic based off Kevin's comments.
The problem is; Kevin is really enthusiastic about a lot of Turtles projects that were bad in the end :ohwell:
AquaParade
06-18-2020, 11:11 AM
The problem is; Kevin is really enthusiastic about a lot of Turtles projects that were bad in the end :ohwell:
It's true. When discussing future TMNT projects, his goal is always to highlight the bright side. But to be fair, I'm going more off of his specific comments that this will be aimed towards more mature readers, and while he is often optimistic, I think he is pretty honest at the same time. He is involved with this and I have to assume they'd get clearance with Viacom/Nickelodeon before pushing forward with comments like that. Just my thinking as of now.
I'd still never expect a slaughterhouse of an issue by any means, but I would not be surprised to see more mature themes here than we've gotten in the IDW book. I wouldn't be surprised to see this turtle take a life, for example.
Galactus
06-18-2020, 11:38 AM
Kevin also said that the Platinum Dunes movies were dark and gritty among other things to hype them so yeah we shouldn't necessarily take everything he says at face value.
Still while the two variant covers use the same designs for the attacking ninjas only one shows machinery. It could be artistic license as has been suggested after all the same cover shows the handles of the turtles weapons with the toy/cartoon colours (the other does not) which if this is supposed to be based on Mirage is definitely not accurate. I suppose they could be cyborgs.
Even then I don't think the turtles fighting robot ninjas in a technologically advanced future is quite the red flag it is being taken as.
EDIT
I notice that the first variant cover also has the turtle with nostrils which we haven't seen in the previews. Also no one tell Cybercubed.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-18-2020, 11:53 AM
$hit, the Turtle fighting Footbots isn't just one cover?
It's three?
That's enough for me. Foot bots guaranteed, FFS. :tgrumble:
Leo656
06-18-2020, 12:15 PM
and while he is often optimistic, I think he is pretty honest at the same time.
Whaaaaaaat. :lol:
To borrow an old chestnut from Jim Cornette, "Kevin Eastman would rather climb a tree and lie, than stand on the ground and tell the truth."
Just going by precedent. :trazz:
AquaParade
06-18-2020, 12:19 PM
Kevin also said that the Platinum Dunes movies were dark and gritty among other things to hype them so yeah we shouldn't necessarily take everything he says at face value.
The PD film was designed to be dark and gritty at one point. You can still see some of those elements in the film, painted over with a brush, akin to Joss Whedon's Justice League. The actors and crew have all discussed the many different versions of that film floating around the editing room, as well as the major set-piece action scene that was removed (apparently the one that inspired the "Raid" comments from Kevin).
Not that the PD film was ever going to be great, but them taking the designs from Zulli's Soul's Winter is telling of the direction they were going early on. I mean, even the awkward boner joke, as "edgy"(/s) as it is, is intended to be "adult humor". I'm sure they talked Kevin Eastman up on how true this would be to his original vision, only "updated for modern audiences!", which he probably bought into the hype of himself and shared with fans. I don't think Kevin ever touted the second PD film as being "dark and gritty" however.
At least, with TLR, he is heavily involved from start to finish and has a much better grip and perspective on the tone of the project.
PizzaPower1985
06-18-2020, 12:20 PM
Eastman is a slave to his brand, folks. If he thinks a little white fib is gonna somehow line his pockets or make him look good, he'll do it. Lies are fundamental to businessmen and their capitalists ways. Don't ever underestimate the links some people will go to to earn a greasy buck.
AquaParade
06-18-2020, 12:32 PM
Eastman is a slave to his brand, folks. If he thinks a little white fib is gonna somehow line his pockets or make him look good, he'll do it. Lies are fundamental to businessmen and their capitalists ways. Don't ever underestimate the links some people will go to to earn a greasy buck.
I think this is a "black and white" sort of view. It's always good to be skeptical, especially when you are dealing with comments from someone selling you a product - definitely.
I don't think it means that we can't take anything Kevin says at face-value or trust anything he says about upcoming TMNT projects. I take most of his words with a grain of salt, but if he says this comic he is creating is aimed at a more adult audience, I believe him. But that's a personal decision, so to each their own.
Leo656
06-18-2020, 12:36 PM
It most likely is aimed at an older audience, but... with some unfortunate Nickelodeon creative handcuffs slapped on.
Imagine this same potential story/product, but published by Vertigo. Without some toy company telling you The Rules of it.
Sigh. We're in the darkest timeline. F*ck you, Barry Allen.
PizzaPower1985
06-18-2020, 12:44 PM
Sigh. We're in the darkest timeline. F*ck you, Barry Allen.
It's all the speed force's fault. LOL. I still wish we could go back to before Flashpoint and strap DiDio to a chair and slap him and say "STOP IT! You're gonna ruin everything."
MikeandRaph87
06-18-2020, 12:45 PM
I mean, in the IDW comic:
Shredder did Seppuku with the help of Splinter. And Don was smashed to death by Rocksteady
But yeah, The Mike Rooth variant cover tend to show Footbot instead of foot ninja. So no human killing? But that cover has Rocksteady and Bebop with leatherhead in the back too. We can take it like a real thing or not...
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Eaf9fNLXYAILXrK?format=jpg&name=large
Bebop, Rocksteady, and Leatherhead oppose the Turtle protagonist? This just got more interesting. It could be nothing more than cover art, but it piqued my interest in this.
Diorm
06-18-2020, 12:46 PM
But that deal with Nickelodeon is kinda weird. I mean, does it only apply to new comics? Because IDW has been republishing the "killing turtles" for the past couple of years, with no "beware kids, this is for adult readers" on the covers.
Leo656
06-18-2020, 12:49 PM
It's all the speed force's fault. LOL. I still wish we could go back to before Flashpoint and strap DiDio to a chair and slap him and say "STOP IT! You're gonna ruin everything."
I'm just saying, I'm JUST Saying... that before Barry had to go try and save his Mommy, the PD TMNT movies didn't exist, Kevin Smith wasn't writing He-Man, Rose McGowan was still hot, a "Speed Racer" movie sequel was still a theoretical possibility, we didn't have COVID-19, Randy Savage, Roddy Piper and Ultimate Warrior were still alive, AND you could still ride the trolley for a nickel.
...Not entirely sure about that last one, but I'm just saying. I'm JUST Saying.
AquaParade
06-18-2020, 12:56 PM
I think The Flash should spend less time running. Isn't the dude able to think at super speed??
Leo656
06-18-2020, 01:38 PM
Ha ha, that made me snicker, old chum.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-18-2020, 02:39 PM
I'm just saying, I'm JUST Saying... that before Barry had to go try and save his Mommy, the PD TMNT movies didn't exist, Kevin Smith wasn't writing He-Man, Rose McGowan was still hot, a "Speed Racer" movie sequel was still a theoretical possibility, we didn't have COVID-19, Randy Savage, Roddy Piper and Ultimate Warrior were still alive, AND you could still ride the trolley for a nickel.
...Not entirely sure about that last one, but I'm just saying. I'm JUST Saying.
.... :teek:
DAMMIT, BARRY!!!
Galactus
06-18-2020, 03:26 PM
.... :teek:
DAMMIT, BARRY!!!
I think you mean
DAMMIT, GEOFF JOHNS
Leo656
06-18-2020, 03:27 PM
Geoff Johns at least gave us epic runs on Teen Titans and JSA.
Barry Allen's given us nothing. NOTHING BUT MORE F*CKING PROBLEMS!
Andrew NDB
06-19-2020, 02:14 AM
I think you mean
DAMMIT, GEOFF JOHNS
Geoff Johns at least gave us epic runs on Teen Titans and JSA.
You guys are literally summoning me. But no. That was back in the days when editorial actually reined Geoff Johns in and weren't afraid of him. He got sticky notes back then. And did great stuff as a result.
Hell, there are probably a ton of hack writers throughout the decades whose courses were "righted" by really great editors. But they are the unsung heroes of comic history. Because they really get no credit in these things. Back at a time when the editor was supposed to delve into the history of a thing so maybe the writer wouldn't necessarily have to (but it'd be neat if they did, as a bonus)... and offer up "Hey, can't do this because of #223, or hey, this blurb of dialogue doesn't jive with #323" kind of stuff. Now that's all sort of shunned. "Just do whatever!" has been the last few years.
PizzaPower1985
06-19-2020, 06:51 AM
You guys are literally summoning me. But no. That was back in the days when editorial actually reined Geoff Johns in and weren't afraid of him. He got sticky notes back then. And did great stuff as a result.
Hell, there are probably a ton of hack writers throughout the decades whose courses were "righted" by really great editors. But they are the unsung heroes of comic history. Because they really get no credit in these things. Back at a time when the editor was supposed to delve into the history of a thing so maybe the writer wouldn't necessarily have to (but it'd be neat if they did, as a bonus)... and offer up "Hey, can't do this because of #223, or hey, this blurb of dialogue doesn't jive with #323" kind of stuff. Now that's all sort of shunned. "Just do whatever!" has been the last few years.
Mark Waid claims that HE is the only one that cares about DC History. But that's not true because John Byrne agonized over history when he wrote Superman, Etrigan, Wonder Woman and his brief New Gods run. A lot od people care about history and don't need editors to reign them in. Johns very often is a hack who just writes to sell books. His Flash run, early, was great but he wasn't writing The Flash because Barry is the real Flash (just ask any of DC's old guard). Johns is not ever going to be the kind of writer that say, Alan Moore is or even Denny O'neil, who professed to never care about continuity (that is until he became the Batman editor).
The problem with DC since 1993 has been that they suddenly became aware of the state of the idustry and have been trying to make up for their (and Marvel's) failings by throwing stunts and 60+ issue multi-part storylines at the wall and being like READ IT B*TCHES. Rarely has it worked. Batman hasn't been Batman since Bane broke his back. Superman suffered shortly after the wedding, Hal became Paralax (WTF?) and X-men went bad after Claremont left and JMS' Spider-man completely changed the character into something that has nothing to do with the Lee/Ditko/Romita version. The Big 2 have occasional brightspots but unless Jenette Kahn/Paul Levitz comes back or Jim Shooter/Archie Goodwin at Marvel, those companies WILL NEVER be like they were. DiDio is something so horrible, I dare not mention it here.
Diorm
06-19-2020, 07:15 AM
All those writers don't care about continuity. They just want to put their mark on the brand with no restrictions.
Something they dont think about is that it's a distraction to their story:
So, did Bane broke Batman's Back in this new timeline? Because Azrael as a totally new origin now and he never was Batman...
So, is Victor Fries married or just a creepy stalker in this? Retcon ok.
Oh it's Lady Shiva. Does Batman know her? Seems like it.
Yes there was a Flashpoint. But we still fuc*** dont know what is still canon or not. 19 years laters!
They need a real editor to put a stop to all those writers doing whatever they want. And I dont think Jim Lee is the guy. I like him, but he can't be the only editor of DC.
PizzaPower1985
06-19-2020, 08:03 AM
All those writers don't care about continuity. They just want to put their mark on the brand with no restrictions.
Something they dont think about is that it's a distraction to their story:
So, did Bane broke Batman's Back in this new timeline? Because Azrael as a totally new origin now and he never was Batman...
So, is Victor Fries married or just a creepy stalker in this? Retcon ok.
Oh it's Lady Shiva. Does Batman know her? Seems like it.
Yes there was a Flashpoint. But we still fuc*** dont know what is still canon or not. 19 years laters!
They need a real editor to put a stop to all those writers doing whatever they want. And I dont think Jim Lee is the guy. I like him, but he can't be the only editor of DC.
There are plenty of writers who care about continuity so I respectfully disagree. And yeah, that's the kind of thing that happens when you reboot your universe every few years... what sticks, if anything, doesn't really matter. Roger Stern used to say when he worked at Marvel in the 80's, that the "real" Marvel Universe ended when Stan Lee stopped writing all the books because continuity was light and since Lee was the mastermind everything seemed to fit together. Editor after editor "changes things" because they wanna leave their mark.
As for Jim Lee... Who was the brilliant, genius executive who said "Hey, let's appoint an artist who is NOT a writer as 2nd in command of our publishing line"? That person deserves the "dumb dumb of the year" award in my book.
Lee belongs at a drawing board, not anywhere else.
Diorm
06-19-2020, 09:24 AM
There are plenty of writers who care about continuity so I respectfully disagree.
You're right. Not all writers. But kinda a lot of them. Unless they do an elseworld story.
Grant Morrison use everything that happened before to use in his stories. Scott Snyder to a certain degree. But some just doesnt care or make the characters act "out of character" and thats just sad, is all.
But yeah Last Ronin... :lol:
Am I the only one that doesnt want the name of the turtle to be revealed anywere in the book? Just being vague about it and let the mystery be?
Blade Runner: Is he a Replicant?
Inception: Is he still sleeping?
Those are the endings that keep people talking to this day.
What Turtle was he in the end?
PizzaPower1985
06-19-2020, 09:27 AM
You're right. Not all writers. But kinda a lot of them. Unless they do an elseworld story.
Grant Morrison use everything that happened before to use in his stories. Scott Snyder to a certain degree. But some just doesnt care or make the characters act "out of character" and thats just sad, is all.
But yeah Last Ronin... :lol:
Am I the only one that doesnt want the name of the turtle to be revealed anywere in the book? Just being vague about it and let the mystery be?
Blade Runner: Is he a Replicant?
Inception: Is he still sleeping?
Those are the endings that keep people talking to this day.
What Turtle was he in the end?
I very much love the idea of the Last Ronin being unnameable. That way we can speculate for years to come... as long as the story is good, let's go with that idea.
Andrew NDB
06-20-2020, 01:05 AM
The PD film was designed to be dark and gritty at one point.
You mean the Fusco script, that was thrown out almost immediately because it was "too dark"?
AquaParade
06-20-2020, 01:10 AM
You mean the Fusco script, that was thrown out almost immediately because it was "too dark"?
No, not the Fusco script, which I would still love to read one day.
The PD film. It seems evident that they had no idea which type of tone to try and capture. The end result is this weird mishmash of fart and boner jokes. Aimed at who? No one knows.
PizzaPower1985
06-20-2020, 06:01 AM
Is the Fusco script available online?
I wanna read it.
AquaParade
06-20-2020, 09:32 AM
It?s not available.
It?s also another script that is “great according to Kevin Eastman”, so some may not have much faith in it.
PizzaPower1985
06-20-2020, 09:50 AM
I think the closest we come (movie wise) to a Mirage, 4Kids, IDW type of story the better off we are. In fact, with regard to film scripts, at this point the writer should probably just outright steal whole stories, plot lines and scenes from the 4Kids cartoon, at this point. Throw in a few creative flourishes to make it different. Just play it safe because no Hollywood writer seems to understand or be able to get the TMNT correct when it comes to films. That said, I really wanna read that script.
Now,
Please correct me if I'm wrong, BUT I've always thought that Eastman was the one most responsible for the street level, gritty NY style of TMNT because that's where his sensibilities lie. Is that true? It's what I love most about TMNT so I think that may be the reason why IDW has been so... great.
The primary reason why I'm interested in The Last Ronin is because of its influence from DKR and because I know Eastman can make it gritty, serious and introspective.
Andrew NDB
06-21-2020, 02:08 AM
It?s not available.
It?s also another script that is ?great according to Kevin Eastman?, so some may not have much faith in it.
I've heard Kevin speak to me personally with great passion over the phone about it (not to some news outlet, or anything, or something for public consumption) so I kind of believe him when he told me it was the best Turtles thing he's ever read.
AquaParade
06-22-2020, 09:34 AM
I've heard Kevin speak to me personally with great passion over the phone about it (not to some news outlet, or anything, or something for public consumption) so I kind of believe him when he told me it was the best Turtles thing he's ever read.
I guess we all apply our belief in Kevin's words where we pick and choose then.
Toxin45
06-23-2020, 02:01 PM
So when is the update on the last ronin?
PizzaPower1985
06-23-2020, 02:13 PM
So when?s is the update on the last ronin
No word yet that I'm aware of. Last I saw was this preview... Supposed to be dropping in July or August still right?
https://www.previewsworld.com/Article/242270-The-Last-Ronin-Imagines-a-Dark-Future-for-the-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles
AquaParade
07-10-2020, 09:51 AM
I finally pre-ordered a variant.
I had my eye on the Santolouco and the Mike Rooth at first, but I ended up deciding on the second of the Khoi Pham variants, which is probably my favorite of the whole batch of variants, so I'm pretty happy with it.
https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets/TMNT_TLR-01_Cover-RE-The-Comics-Vault-A_rich.jpg
Curious to see what y'all end up with.
IndigoErth
07-10-2020, 12:40 PM
It may be way too early to ask since the first issue isn't even out yet, but for those who are avid longtime comic readers/collectors and may have paid attention to the typical timetables of these things... any thought on how long it may be after all the issues are out that a collected hardback volume might happen?
Never really been a collector of individual comic issues, but I already know I want that hardback someday. :)
Sharman
07-12-2020, 08:43 AM
I finally pre-ordered a variant.
I had my eye on the Santolouco and the Mike Rooth at first, but I ended up deciding on the second of the Khoi Pham variants, which is probably my favorite of the whole batch of variants, so I'm pretty happy with it.
Curious to see what y'all end up with.
There are some great variant covers but the sheer number of them has short-circuited my collecting gene which has now left me feeling that I couldn't give two-hoots about collecting more than the basic covers.
PizzaPower1985
07-12-2020, 08:53 AM
It may be way too early to ask since the first issue isn't even out yet, but for those who are avid longtime comic readers/collectors and may have paid attention to the typical timetables of these things... any thought on how long it may be after all the issues are out that a collected hardback volume might happen?
Never really been a collector of individual comic issues, but I already know I want that hardback someday. :)
I only buy in trade/hardcover as well and am very excited at the prospect of Last Ronin sitting on my shelf too. It will probably take about 1 to 3 months for a trade to be released once the series has finished in single issues. That's the timetable for most trades/hardcovers these days.
AquaParade
07-12-2020, 09:55 AM
Does anyone know where to get protective sleeves that will fit this format? Preferably mylar .
PizzaPower1985
07-12-2020, 10:16 AM
Does anyone know where to get protective sleeves that will fit this format? Preferably mylar .
The days of different-sized mylar are kinda over, are they not? I think it's all just pretty standard sized bags that get sold these days. Not quite sure tho. Would Andrew or Leo know?
TMNTChris1980
07-12-2020, 10:27 AM
I've never bought them from here, but its worth a shot.
https://egerber.com/
IndigoErth
07-12-2020, 11:24 AM
I only buy in trade/hardcover as well and am very excited at the prospect of Last Ronin sitting on my shelf too. It will probably take about 1 to 3 months for a trade to be released once the series has finished in single issues. That's the timetable for most trades/hardcovers these days.
Thank you! :D
PizzaPower1985
07-12-2020, 11:47 AM
I've never bought them from here, but its worth a shot.
https://egerber.com/
I totally forgot that boards came in half sizes and I haven't seen the 1.42 ml bags in years. I've been out of collecting single issues for so long it's ridiculous.
Sharman
07-17-2020, 02:33 PM
Big Country Comics are reporting that TLR #1 will be delayed until September 9th
Sharman
07-23-2020, 06:14 PM
So, Eastman has let slip that Andy Kuhn has had to depart TLR.
From: SDCC Drinks and Q&A with the Eastmans!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wKFUEFT4Hs
neatoman
07-23-2020, 06:16 PM
So, Eastman has let slip that Andy Kuhn has had to depart TLR.
From: SDCC Drinks and Q&A with the Eastmans!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wKFUEFT4Hs
Who'll be his replacement?
MikeandRaph87
07-23-2020, 06:17 PM
So, Eastman has let slip that Andy Kuhn has had to depart TLR.
From: SDCC Drinks and Q&A with the Eastmans!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wKFUEFT4Hs
How far in the process of developing the five issues are they? I would assume at least two issues are completed awaiting print.
Sharman
07-23-2020, 06:19 PM
Apparently more details are to follow. Was meant to be discussed on another virtual panel this coming weekend
IndigoErth
07-23-2020, 07:18 PM
With all the awesome cover art... am I the only one now wanting a Last Ronin Turtle figure later?
PizzaPower1985
07-23-2020, 07:38 PM
With all the awesome cover art... am I the only one now wanting a Last Ronin Turtle figure later?
That would be cool!
AquaParade
07-24-2020, 08:52 AM
With all the awesome cover art... am I the only one now wanting a Last Ronin Turtle figure later?
I love a figure that can holster a lot of accessories, so this sounds awesome to me.
Very curious to see who replaces Andy Kuhn...
This seems like a book with a strong vision, so I feel a bit bad about the creative team having to shift artists two issues in.
PizzaPower1985
07-24-2020, 09:35 AM
I love a figure that can holster a lot of accessories, so this sounds awesome to me.
Very curious to see who replaces Andy Kuhn...
This seems like a book with a strong vision, so I feel a bit bad about the creative team having to shift artists two issues in.
That's a problem I have with so many TMNT figures. Donnie has no place for his staff on the back of his belt... Mikey's chucks can't be holstered in the front either. Often Leo's scabbards are the only place for weapons and Raph occasionally gets slots for his sai and jutte.
MikeandRaph87
07-24-2020, 01:05 PM
I had to do a Wal-Mart run and a student I had two years ago approached me with one thing on his mind, "So sir, Mike is the last ronin isn't he?". Nothing about how his first year of college was, or how everyone is doing, it was the above.:lol:
Mayhem
07-25-2020, 03:19 PM
So, Eastman has let slip that Andy Kuhn has had to depart TLR. From: SDCC Drinks and Q&A with the Eastmans!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wKFUEFT4Hs
I have a good idea why but not at liberty to say sadly, as I have been chatting with Andy on and off as he is working on a commission for me. Hopefully Kevin will be allowed to divulge more.
TigerClaw
07-25-2020, 03:35 PM
I have a good idea why but not at liberty to say sadly, as I have been chatting with Andy on and off as he is working on a commission for me. Hopefully Kevin will be allowed to divulge more.
I'm gonna have to assume its your classic creative differences thing.
Mayhem
07-26-2020, 05:13 AM
I'm gonna have to assume its your classic creative differences thing.
Definitely not (unless it’ something I don’t know), don’t have to worry about that sort of thing.
AquaParade
07-26-2020, 11:57 AM
Apparently more details are to follow. Was meant to be discussed on another virtual panel this coming weekend
Anyone know what panel this is?
Sharman
07-26-2020, 04:07 PM
Anyone know what panel this is?
That would be this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsrb_1dfET8&feature=youtu.be&fbclid=IwAR2xlpoA_ZOH6ewEsPNywrPZfA_yhC4f1-SE2NAqS-T1b6_0apOLQV4TUSg
funatic
07-26-2020, 07:13 PM
Who'll be his replacement?
Ben Bishop is taking the helm (at least for part of it? it was a little unclear) as announced in the Comic-Con panel today.
I have a good idea why but not at liberty to say sadly, as I have been chatting with Andy on and off as he is working on a commission for me. Hopefully Kevin will be allowed to divulge more.
Nothing more divulged than "personal reasons", hope everything is okay!
AquaParade
07-26-2020, 07:40 PM
That would be this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsrb_1dfET8&feature=youtu.be&fbclid=IwAR2xlpoA_ZOH6ewEsPNywrPZfA_yhC4f1-SE2NAqS-T1b6_0apOLQV4TUSg
Thanks.
Yeah, Ben Bishop is doing select scenes in issues #2-4, from the sound of it. They are still in discussions regarding other replacements.
Kevin once again reiterated that this would be the edgiest tmnt story in quite a while, with approval from Nickelodeon.
Sharman
07-27-2020, 03:44 PM
Thanks.
Yeah, Ben Bishop is doing select scenes in issues #2-4, from the sound of it. They are still in discussions regarding other replacements.
Kevin once again reiterated that this would be the edgiest tmnt story in quite a while, with approval from Nickelodeon.
Yeah, on this wee 'panel' it's made clear that Bishop will be working on the 'flashbacks'.
Ninjinister
07-27-2020, 07:44 PM
I'm struggling to figure out internally, why I just have no interest in this. Like I've wanted to, but I don't and I don't understand why.
Powder
07-27-2020, 08:17 PM
I'm struggling to figure out internally, why I just have no interest in this. Like I've wanted to, but I don't and I don't understand why.
Probably because of the deceptive marketing? It's been pushed like it's the first legitimate Eastman & Laird collaboration since City At War when in reality it's just Kevin repurposing an old idea from 1987's liner notes with various IDW interior guys doing their usual thing. Pete has made it very clear he wants nothing to do with the property, & we've already seen what Kevin can do with turtle comics in the last decade on his own so that's nothing new (though always welcomed, naturally). I'm not really terribly excited either.
We don't know what continuity it's gonna be in, that counts, too. If it's Mirage, it's gonna feel completely un-mirage 'cause Andy & Ben are the new guys (read: visually synonymous with IDW's universe), & it would likely be riddled with contradictions unless Kev has read all of Vol. 4, & Tales Vol. 2, & remembers all the odd short stories that deal with elder turtles.
The 10,000 variant covers thing is a bit, uh, cheapening, too.
80gmrp
07-28-2020, 06:15 AM
Probably because of the deceptive marketing? It's been pushed like it's the first legitimate Eastman & Laird collaboration since City At War when in reality it's just Kevin repurposing an old idea from 1987's liner notes with various IDW interior guys doing their usual thing. Pete has made it very clear he wants nothing to do with the property
Yeah, I had heard the same thing regarding Laird not wanting to be involved anymore, which is why I was a bit confused why he's supposedly involved with this. Good to know it may have just been the marketing game again.
Andrew NDB
07-28-2020, 06:19 AM
It really should have been. I wonder what the barriers there were.
AquaParade
07-28-2020, 07:29 AM
Initial marketing does seem a bit deceptive now, but I‘m still excited by the concept.
I don’t think Peter would want to work on anything that has to be approved by Nick. He can make his own TMNT comic on his own terms should he have the desire and may want to save his energy for that. Just a wild guess.
MikeandRaph87
07-28-2020, 11:11 AM
I think it will be mixed to positive in reception and its because it was advertised as a product of Mirage, but it was quickly reviewed Laird has no direct involvement and covers indicate that Bebop, Rocksteady, and Leatherhead are involved and the perception of a IDW style. So it would likely cater more towards my not too dark yet not goofy preference. While it spikes my interest it I was not interested because I don't care for The Dark Knight Returns or anything of the black and white comics after Return to New York. Yet those who prfer the grittier stories are let down. It is a hard product to please. At least the marketing gave us a better idea not long out of the gate. It could have mislead the overall audience the way TMNT Smash Up did all the way to release.
AquaParade
07-28-2020, 11:31 AM
TMNT Smash Up...now that was a weird product.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-28-2020, 11:33 AM
I think it will be mixed to positive in reception and its because it was advertised as a product of Mirage, but it was quickly reviewed Laird has no direct involvement and covers indicate that Bebop, Rocksteady, and Leatherhead are involved and the perception of a IDW style. So it would likely cater more towards my not too dark yet not goofy preference. While it spikes my interest it I was not interested because I don't care for The Dark Knight Returns or anything of the black and white comics after Return to New York. Yet those who prfer the grittier stories are let down. It is a hard product to please. At least the marketing gave us a better idea not long out of the gate. It could have mislead the overall audience the way TMNT Smash Up did all the way to release.
Dude.
You've been reading Batman comics for how long and you still take comic covers at face value? :tlol:
Bebop and Rocksteady aren't going to be in this. Odds of Leatherhead appearing are about as good as Obama and W inviting me to play cribbage with them Thursday night.
Leo656
07-28-2020, 11:42 AM
Well, they ARE kinda buddies in Real Life, so I can see them hanging out playing cribbage. But I don't think they'd invite YOUR broke ass. You don't even bring the GOOD beer! :lol::trazz:
80gmrp
07-28-2020, 12:11 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady aren't going to be in this. Odds of Leatherhead appearing are about as good as Obama and W inviting me to play cribbage with them Thursday night.
Yeah, I just did a search about The Last Ronin, and none of the results I found, visual or text-wise, make mention of this. If you found something I didn’t, MikeandRaph, I’d be willing to look, though.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-28-2020, 12:13 PM
Well, they ARE kinda buddies in Real Life, so I can see them hanging out playing cribbage. But I don't think they'd invite YOUR broke ass. You don't even bring the GOOD beer! :lol::trazz:
****, man, they're the ones with the money. THEY buy the good beer, I... I don't know, provide witty commentary and admit I didn't vote for either of them? :tlol:
Leo656
07-28-2020, 12:20 PM
You better at least be the one blasting "Beer For My Horses" on a constant loop or you're never getting invited to anything again, pal.
No f*cking social etiquette.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-28-2020, 12:35 PM
You better at least be the one blasting "Beer For My Horses" on a constant loop or you're never getting invited to anything again, pal.
No f*cking social etiquette.
Hell yeah, man.
80gmrp
07-28-2020, 12:59 PM
Yeah, I just did a search about The Last Ronin, and none of the results I found, visual or text-wise, make mention of this. If you found something I didn?t, MikeandRaph, I?d be willing to look, though.
I apologize for bumping my unanswered question, though in my defense, it will bring the thread back on topic. I just did more searching (including an extensive browsing of all of the variant covers I could find), and it seems to me the only character certain to be in this series, other than whichever turtle survives, is Shredder: no mention of anyone else that I've found, so I feel it best to ask again: MikeandRaph87, where did you get that information about who else is in the issues?
TomWaltz
07-28-2020, 03:29 PM
I apologize for bumping my unanswered question, though in my defense, it will bring the thread back on topic. I just did more searching (including an extensive browsing of all of the variant covers I could find), and it seems to me the only character certain to be in this series, other than whichever turtle survives, is Shredder: no mention of anyone else that I've found, so I feel it best to ask again: MikeandRaph87, where did you get that information about who else is in the issues?
I will not give any other spoilers other than this: Bebop and Rocksteady do NOT appear in The Last Ronin. No Leatherhead, either.
Fake news.
RE cover content is up to the retailers who commission them.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
80gmrp
07-28-2020, 04:54 PM
Thank you for clarifying as an official source. Rest assured, I was not asking for spoilers: only trying to find out what was revealed already and what wasn't.
TomWaltz
07-28-2020, 04:57 PM
Thank you for clarifying as an official source. Rest assured, I was not asking for spoilers: only trying to find out what was revealed already and what wasn't.
No worries! Hope you dig the book when it comes out. We're getting some unexpected changes handled behind the scenes, but I'm sincerely excited about what's happening. Look for announcements soon.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Sharman
07-28-2020, 06:37 PM
No worries! Hope you dig the book when it comes out. We're getting some unexpected changes handled behind the scenes, but I'm sincerely excited about what's happening. Look for announcements soon.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
I'm excited for it, regardless of any bts issues or delays.
AquaParade
07-28-2020, 07:17 PM
Same here. You guys dont need me to tell you this, but take your time. Can't wait.
Ninjinister
07-30-2020, 07:51 PM
Anybody see/have the ashcan yet? My shop had it today for $25 and I'm like o.o I know it's oversized but I think $8 is the most I've ever paid for an ashcan.
King Kahn
07-30-2020, 09:22 PM
I will not give any other spoilers other than this: Bebop and Rocksteady do NOT appear in The Last Ronin. No Leatherhead, either.
Fake news.
RE cover content is up to the retailers who commission them.
Talk soon...
Tom W.
interesting, do you give them any character material to work from? Character turn arounds of The Ronin for instance to make sure there is a little continuity in how they look?
hypered1
07-31-2020, 03:26 AM
Anybody see/have the ashcan yet? My shop had it today for $25 and I'm like o.o I know it's oversized but I think $8 is the most I've ever paid for an ashcan.
Sounds like you need to find a new comic shop, the current RRP for each issue is $8.99. At $25 you'd be paying the same for half of the series again and not getting a full issue out of it.
AquaParade
07-31-2020, 07:07 AM
Anybody see/have the ashcan yet? My shop had it today for $25 and I'm like o.o I know it's oversized but I think $8 is the most I've ever paid for an ashcan.
Lame attempt by the owner.
rs_jr
07-31-2020, 10:05 AM
i hope we get magazine size black and white with zip tone version of the this series
Ninjinister
07-31-2020, 07:37 PM
Sounds like you need to find a new comic shop, the current RRP for each issue is $8.99. At $25 you'd be paying the same for half of the series again and not getting a full issue out of it.
Lame attempt by the owner.
Yeah, I'm gonna change stores because of one comic :roll:
Looking at ebay though, there isn't any below $20.
EDIT: Same with every online comic shop I'm coming across, too.
AquaParade
07-31-2020, 09:44 PM
Hm. Maybe that?s my bad. I thought those were supposed to be free for customers.
Andrew NDB
08-01-2020, 12:40 AM
My $0.02. For me, only speaking personally, the excitement would have been in marketing embracing this as "The Mirage Final Story" (also, and I'm sure questions were asked and it was probably a "no" but maybe more nudging of Laird to participate anew). But I can understand and appreciate the want for the ambiguity of things, like for fans it can be "Is it the Final IDW Story? Is it the Final Mirage Story? Let's make it vague so it could be either!" But it in making it either, it also kind of makes it neither. It just kind of makes it this thing that's there.
Also, no slight on Ben Bishop or Kuhn when it was Kuhn at all, but also it would have been more of a "bombshell" if -- obviously barring Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird duoing the art, as in the past -- it'd been the Mirage "house" artists tackling it, for good measure. Since I think the idea should have been to tickle the nostalgia of fans (the "lost TMNT story" and all). Like, Lawson with Kevin's inks would have been amazing beyond measure. Or Dooney on his own.
Galactus
08-01-2020, 07:23 AM
I dunno...getting Mirage artists other than Eastman & Laird would be a bit of a gamble sales wise.
Like it would be Lawson doing the art, wouldn't it? I love his work but I'm not sure it would be a good fit for a mainstream book. Maybe if they could Dooney to do more than just covers and pin ups but that seems unlikely.
frank_one
08-01-2020, 11:52 AM
Laird's name shouldn't be on the cover, that's it. This is not an Eastman/Laird collaboration, it's fake news, fake marketing.
Laird's name shouldn't be on the cover, that's it. This is not an Eastman/Laird collaboration, it's fake news, fake marketing.
It is partly his concept, so by legal standards his name has to be somewhere attached to it. I don?t mind it being on the cover.
Andrew NDB
08-01-2020, 05:12 PM
I dunno...getting Mirage artists other than Eastman & Laird would be a bit of a gamble sales wise.
I'm not sure Kuhn or Bishop themselves are "draws" on the shelves.
Like it would be Lawson doing the art, wouldn't it?
With Kevin on inks, as I said. You can see how this looks back in Vol. 1, #21. Very unique.
AquaParade
08-01-2020, 08:04 PM
I liked Lawson's work best in City at War, but can't remember who did the inking there. Could have been Lawson himself for all I know.
It still had the signature cartoony Lawson style, but the figures seemed to have more weight, depth, and detail.
I liked Lawson's work best in City at War, but can't remember who did the inking there. Could have been Lawson himself for all I know.
It still had the signature cartoony Lawson style, but the figures seemed to have more weight, depth, and detail.
I believe it was Kieth Aiken or some name like that inking the whole CAW story. I disagree about Eastman inking Lawson today. It'd be a disaster. Lawson's work has changed so drastically even Kevin inking it would not change it or make it look like the art from RTNY. We're talking about the fact Kevin and Peter did the layouts for RTNY. Jim drew from what was shown somewhat. Jim's style then was awesome back then that it complimented those two's art. To me he was the next best Mirage artist after Kevin and Peter for Mirage TMNT. His style now would be totally unsuitable for something as epic as Last Ronin nor for mainstream comics from IDW. You wouldn't want that art as the selling point of Last Ronin, right? I don't want to put Jim's art down but its not the way to sell a comic if it was the only choice. He's done so much TMNT art it really is time for another artist. Mike Dooney and Steve Lavigne are the same in terms of a cartoony style more so. Eric Talbot I think could do it if he stuck to Kevin's style from the layouts. Eric's art now for the TMNT has a more creepy reptilian vibe. The best would be Craig Farley. He'd be awesome. Its a shame he doesn't get more comic work from other publishers. Hell, Frank Fosco to me would be OK as well for Last Ronin. He to me would be the imaginary Mirage artist. His style is almost up to Mirage like material and standard.
My question is Ben Bishop up for the challenge of completing this mini series? Said he's gonna do it. Unless this is mistaken, I initially heard Ben was doing only flashbacks scenes. Is he the full artist on Last Ronin now?
I'm only basing this from the summarised article from bleedingcool of the TMNT comic con video of Tom, Kevin and Ben, i didn't watch it.
I liked Lawson's work best in City at War, but can't remember who did the inking there. Could have been Lawson himself for all I know.
It still had the signature cartoony Lawson style, but the figures seemed to have more weight, depth, and detail.
Lawson's art after CaW doesn't work for more "serious" storylines, the only issue he did that I really enjoyed in the Tales/Vol 4 era was the last issue of Gang Wars due its comedic nature.
AquaParade
08-02-2020, 12:27 AM
I think Frank Fosco is a great suggestion. I’d love to see him follow Kevin’s layouts if the two were up for it.
Andrew NDB
08-02-2020, 04:51 AM
I don't agree. Kevin is a guy that takes a lot of liberties as an inker (and not in a bad way)... you throw his inks over Lawson's pencils. Wow.
Sharman
08-02-2020, 08:43 AM
I don't agree. Kevin is a guy that takes a lot of liberties as an inker (and not in a bad way)... you throw his inks over Lawson's pencils. Wow.
I think the idea of bringing some semblance of a Mirage 'team' would, indeed, be interesting and I certainly miss some of the distinct art from that original period. Whilst I find the modern art to be more on the 'realistic' side, I loved the flair that some of the original TMNT art had. That said, I do enjoy the work of some of the 'current' TMNT artists and Bishop is one.
I don't agree. Kevin is a guy that takes a lot of liberties as an inker (and not in a bad way)... you throw his inks over Lawson's pencils. Wow.
Your basing this on art from 31 years ago. Kevin's style now can also be funky looking at times. His covers for the Ultimate Collection HC's and TPB versions vary in his best effort or not. Look at Ryan Brown and Jim Lawson together again from Tales TMNT Vol. 1, to Tales of TMNT Vol. 2 #25 in 2006? Brown couldn't make it look better. We've never seen Kevin ink over Jim's art of today. Sure Kevin may give the inking and black depth onto the art but he won't be able to improve the art. We've seen Peter inking over Jim during a chunk of TMNT Vol. 4. It only looked decent because Peter was using the duotone shades again. Peter still inked it awhile after he stopped the duotone shades but he at least tried to make the characters look more rounded. Jim's style is every figure is all blocky and square shaped corners from fingers to toes, faces, etc. Nothing like the style Last Ronin's art that's been previewed so far.
NinjaPug
08-12-2020, 10:09 PM
A lost piece of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles history was being recreated as Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Last Ronin by Kevin Eastman, Tom Waltz, and Andy Kuhn, from an original outline written by Turtles co-creators Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird back in 1987 and set in 2017. Eastman revisited the future Turtles story from the past, established in 2040, and scheduled as a five-issue series.
The first issue was initially solicited to be published next week, the 19th of August 2020. Naturally, it was late, and the schedule slipped to the 16th of September, and it recently went to Final Order Cut-Off with, I am told, very large order numbers, and it made it high onto the Advance Reorders chart.
But now there's a big change. Esau Escorza and Isaac Escorza, best known for their work on Tarna for Heavy Metal, are now joining the art team with Kevin Eastman, but Andy Kuhn is no longer listed on the creative team. Apparently, this stems from poor retailer reaction to The Last Ronin preview, and a new sampler is in the works.
Also, the book's launch has been pushed back until late October, with the first FOC date now rescheduled to the 5th of October ahead of publication on the 28th of October, while the second issue has slipped all the way into December. Here are the solicited books and current schedules for all five issues.
TMNT THE LAST RONIN #1 (OF 5)
IDW PUBLISHING
JUN200557
(W) Kevin Eastman, Peter Laird, Tom Waltz (A/CA) Kevin Eastman, Esau Escorza, Issac Escorza
It's the TMNT event of 2020! Springing from the minds of TMNT co-creators Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird comes an epic like you've never seen before! In a future NYC far different than the one we know today, a lone surviving Turtle goes on a seemingly hopeless mission to obtain justice for his fallen family and friends. Kinetic layouts from Eastman, moody inks from Andy Kuhn and a thrilling script full of surprises from longtime TMNT scribe Tom Waltz all combine to make this one of the most memorable TMNT stories you will ever read! Oversized in both format and page count, this is a perennial TMNT tale that can't be missed!SRP: $8.99 NEW FOC: 10/5/20 On Sale Date: 10/28/20
TMNT THE LAST RONIN #2 (OF 5)
IDW PUBLISHING
AUG200574
Secrets are revealed as we begin to discover what happened in the past to lead to this nightmarish future. The Ronin meets an unexpected new ally, but the Foot Clan begins an exhaustive sweep of the Bottom to find the vengeful mutant. And what role does Baxter Stockman play? SRP: $8.99. On Sale Date: 12/16/20
TMNT THE LAST RONIN #3 (OF 5)
IDW PUBLISHING
On Sale Date: 2/17/21
TMNT THE LAST RONIN #4 (OF 5)
IDW PUBLISHING
On Sale Date: 4/14/21
TMNT THE LAST RONIN #5 (OF 5)
IDW PUBLISHING
On Sale Date: 5/19/21
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/kevin-eastman-and-peter-lairds-tmnt-last-ronin-delayed-with-changes/
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/kevin-eastman-and-peter-lairds-tmnt-last-ronin-delayed-with-changes/
So if the first issue is being completely redrawn, how collectible does that make the ashcan with Andy?s artwork?
Sharman
08-13-2020, 06:10 AM
So if the first issue is being completely redrawn, how collectible does that make the ashcan with Andy?s artwork?
Is that what's happening? Do we know for sure?
I'm so confused.
Diorm
08-13-2020, 07:08 AM
Esau Escorza? That's a totaly different look. Did he ever draw any turtles so I can see what the ronin will look like?
Andy Kuhn leaving was addressed here https://www.comicsbeat.com/sdcc-20-kevin-eastman-panel-last-ronin/
PizzaPower1985
08-13-2020, 08:09 AM
Just saw the news myself... TMNT LAST RONIN #1 has been delayed till October with issue 2 now moving to December, also it has been confirmed it will have a new creative team.
So, does that make the series less desirable at all. Does this news damage its hype?
AquaParade
08-13-2020, 08:39 AM
I'm glad it is being delayed. I was beginning to worry about them getting desperate and grabbing whoever they could to rush the artwork. This is good to hear.
That said, I'm skeptical of Bleeding Cool's reasoning, but it's interesting if true. I think Kuhn's art is quite good, if maybe not spectacular for a book as big as this, but why would retailers make a fuss about this book?
Now to check out the new artists...
Edit: okay it's hard to get a good idea of exactly how this will look, as both artists have their own pencils/inks to find, so who knows what their approach will be.
That said, it's damn good art either way. Can't wait to see them follow Kevin's layouts.
This will be best for the book and please people here as well, I'm thinking.
Really curious what will happen with the first issue, regarding Kuhn's art, solicitations, etc.
It will depend how far along he is, but his set of pages would be a really cool "extra" in the collection, if they end up doing the first issue over, which hopefully they can justify for consistency.
Best wishes to any of the team who are reading.
TomWaltz
08-13-2020, 11:56 AM
More details here, my friends:
https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1293791377445154816
Talk soon...
Tom W.
AquaParade
08-13-2020, 12:08 PM
Thanks, Tom! Now we just need you to slip us some preview art.
And for anyone who can't click the link, Tom clarified that the official statement is that this comes down to scheduling and personal issues, not retailer reception. Also, they are re-doing the first issue and have a new colorist on board as well.
King Kahn
08-13-2020, 09:42 PM
8.99 an issue, those better be big issues lol
Thanks, Tom! Now we just need you to slip us some preview art.
And for anyone who can't click the link, Tom clarified that the official statement is that this comes down to scheduling and personal issues, not retailer reception. Also, they are re-doing the first issue and have a new colorist on board as well.
makes sense to make the entire series as a whole more consistent in look and feel.
Sharman
08-14-2020, 06:42 AM
8.99 an issue, those better be big issues lol
makes sense to make the entire series as a whole more consistent in look and feel.
I have to agree. It's always been easier (for me, at least) when the creative team are consistent. That said, when the artist changes on such a long running series as TMNT I see it as a breath of fresh air (even if style, detail - even costumes - have changed).
But, for a limited series, consistency is probably better.
I do hope we get a teaser soon ...
Redeemer
08-14-2020, 07:25 PM
8.99 an issue, those better be big issues lol
makes sense to make the entire series as a whole more consistent in look and feel.
Well the series is bi-monthly so it makes sense
Turnstone
08-14-2020, 08:11 PM
According to Twitter, they?re starting completely over with the art? Guess that means my ashcan will be heading straight up in value.
CyberCubed
08-14-2020, 10:22 PM
The entire handling of this project and the communication behind it has been so bizarre, because it's so unlike anything IDW has put out TMNT wise in the past. Dropping Andy the original artist attached to this who already drew an issue and re-doing all the art from scratch with a new team, instead of say having the new art team start with issue #2 or something like that?
Not to mention the weird vague hinting this could be either in the Mirage or IDW universe, rather than saying directly. And then of course the original news that it was an old Peter Laird story when it's really not that either for the most part.
Like I know COVID and all and probably some behind the scenes issues happened, but ever since this mini-series was announced its been a roller coaster of mixed signals. Even now I don't know what to make of it.
MikeandRaph87
08-15-2020, 10:14 AM
"But now there's a big change. Esau Escorza and Isaac Escorza, best known for their work on Tarna for Heavy Metal, are now joining the art team with Kevin Eastman, but Andy Kuhn is no longer listed on the creative team. Apparently, this stems from poor retailer reaction to The Last Ronin preview, and a new sampler is in the works."
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/kevin-eastman-and-peter-lairds-tmnt-last-ronin-delayed-with-changes/
What is all this about?
Turnstone
08-15-2020, 11:06 AM
The sad part is that do you know how big this would sell if they had managed to get Eastman and Laird to do the original art for it? It would never happen but man, that would be something.
AquaParade
08-15-2020, 11:09 AM
I think were that ever to happen, it would be in a book published through Mirage. That's wild speculation, but it's based on getting a general feel for Peter's sensibilities over the years. And it would be that much cooler, wouldn't it?
King Kahn
08-15-2020, 07:04 PM
"But now there's a big change. Esau Escorza and Isaac Escorza, best known for their work on Tarna for Heavy Metal, are now joining the art team with Kevin Eastman, but Andy Kuhn is no longer listed on the creative team. Apparently, this stems from poor retailer reaction to The Last Ronin preview, and a new sampler is in the works."
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/kevin-eastman-and-peter-lairds-tmnt-last-ronin-delayed-with-changes/
What is all this about?
it was only about scheduling conflicts, the bleeding cool story was debunked.
This is crazy its getting so delayed. I too am little confused why not go with what you have thats done and let the new artists go on from there? Seems some of this could've avoided anymore of a delay. But I guess like others have said they wanna maintain a consistency in the art. So is the other artist from Drawing Blood still involved? Is that gonna change again? If they wanna maintain consistency now they have three artists on this book? Just seems ironic its on Last Ronin that has had all the hoopla I doubt IDW has ever seen in their time with the TMNT licence.
member_removed
08-16-2020, 12:01 AM
The sad part is that do you know how big this would sell if they had managed to get Eastman and Laird to do the original art for it? It would never happen but man, that would be something.
I imagine IDW has Eastman signed up to some uber tight contract to stop him from producing TMNT comics elsewhere?
Andrew NDB
08-16-2020, 12:44 AM
"But now there's a big change. Esau Escorza and Isaac Escorza, best known for their work on Tarna for Heavy Metal, are now joining the art team with Kevin Eastman, but Andy Kuhn is no longer listed on the creative team. Apparently, this stems from poor retailer reaction to The Last Ronin preview, and a new sampler is in the works."
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/kevin-eastman-and-peter-lairds-tmnt-last-ronin-delayed-with-changes/
*edit: Oh.
Galactus
08-16-2020, 08:06 AM
If this was an ongoing monthly series they'd probably have kept Kuhn's work but being a graphic novel they probably want a consistent look and visual tone from beginning to end. Makes total sense to me.
Also while it maybe somewhat deceptive to promote this as a reunion of Eastman and Laird's it does use what look like detailed story ideas from him and the series does have his blessing.
hypered1
08-16-2020, 08:09 AM
it was only about scheduling conflicts, the bleeding cool story was debunked.
No surprises there then.
frank_one
08-16-2020, 01:46 PM
I think were that ever to happen, it would be in a book published through Mirage. That's wild speculation, but it's based on getting a general feel for Peter's sensibilities over the years. And it would be that much cooler, wouldn't it?True. If Laird and Eastman were to do a new TMNT story togheter they wouldn't need IDW to publish it, but Eastman seems to be on good terms with IDW, so I don't know.
rs_jr
08-16-2020, 03:44 PM
I really wish they would just come out and be clear if this is a mirage storyline which would be nice knowing ultimately how the mirage final story goes or jut say its IDW so no mirage hopes are bashed.
Did they ever mention if the increased price is for page count alone or is the book bigger like the first 4 mirage books.
If it is a mirage story I'm still hoping we get a B/W zip atone edition of the series
MikeandRaph87
08-16-2020, 03:55 PM
I really wish they would just come out and be clear if this is a mirage storyline which would be nice knowing ultimately how the mirage final story goes or jut say its IDW so no mirage hopes are bashed.
Did they ever mention if the increased price is for page count alone or is the book bigger like the first 4 mirage books.
If it is a mirage story I'm still hoping we get a B/W zip atone edition of the series
It's not. Kevin stated in the virtual panel of SDCC that it is its own thing, not set in any specific universe.
Its the format the book is in that makes it costly. If the initial preview ashcan is the actual dimension size of the issues, then thats why. Its 50 page books in the prestige, graphic novel format. Kevin initially stated that "Last Ronin" to him was more in the Mirage universe since it was conceived during that time between he and Peter. A "what if/elseworlds" story. Then he's been saying it can fit into any TMNT incarnation. Little iffy how that could be with any incarnation due to how their presented buts thats me. Kinda looked up the art of Esau Escorza and Isaac Escorza and it looks to be decent, characterised, north american, manga style to me. Pretty much the style IDW seems to have taken with their TMNT books generally. I don't think their a bad choice but how they make a turtle look is the question. Strange this is an IDW book but I assume Kevin nabs 2 guys from his Heavy Metal connections out of the blue.
AquaParade
08-16-2020, 08:22 PM
Interesting to get your perspective on the art of Esau Escorza. I feel that his art is quite different than what we generally see in the ongoing series. Looks more expensive, frankly.
I'm not sure how I'll feel about the new colorist. Their style has a strong digital look to it, which I'm not typically a fan of.
Edit: I just realized that the main cover for issue #2 is done by the new artists.
rs_jr
08-17-2020, 02:46 AM
why not just get Jim Lawson to do it especially if he can channel his old style in mirage volume 1?
Andrew NDB
08-17-2020, 03:19 AM
True. If Laird and Eastman were to do a new TMNT story togheter they wouldn't need IDW to publish it, but Eastman seems to be on good terms with IDW, so I don't know.
They'd probably want to go the IDW route if so. Peter still has his 18 comics a year clause but it's not like he has a deal with any distributor. Though if going the IDW route means hamstringing violence or Turtle killing (which would have absolutely been there in the 1987 idea)... probably a non-starter.
Diorm
08-17-2020, 07:14 AM
Is "heavily injuring" a thing that can work? I mean, Batman is not a killer in DKR, but he was breaking bones left and right.
AquaParade
08-17-2020, 08:36 AM
Is "heavily injuring" a thing that can work? I mean, Batman is not a killer in DKR, but he was breaking bones left and right.
Probably not in this context, but it depends. You have to work overtime to sell the idea that someone vows to never kill while constantly putting their life at risk, as well as their loved ones. With loved ones coming into play, you have to be wary of the character coming across as selfish or ineffectual.
With Batman, there are ways to do it. I can get into the idea that Batman's true enemy, in his mind anyway, is death itself, if you want to play it that way. It's thematically rich while also playing into the idea that Bruce's mind is slightly off-kilter, and I like that. Doesn't have to be that way of course.
There actually could be room to play there with the TMNT, seeing as the franchise is rooted in the consequences of killing and revenge, but if you're swinging swords around, you're fighting an uphill battle.
For instance, I just recently re-read the IDW Leonardo micro-issue, and it just doesn't work. It's played as an intense, dire face-off between Leo and a literal army of foot ninja, in which he battles for his life by slapping hordes of deadly ninja with his swords. When Foot backup arrives and their numbers double, Leonardo laments that he's got "a lot of ninja to interrogate." You can not tell if it is supposed to be a joke.
Diorm
08-17-2020, 08:40 AM
Well it's like in the Archie comic. Leo always saying: "I hate guns!". Says the guy with the katana blades...:lol:
Andrew NDB
08-17-2020, 07:39 PM
Is "heavily injuring" a thing that can work? I mean, Batman is not a killer in DKR, but he was breaking bones left and right.
Well the Mirage Turtles are killers, so Batman is irrelevant.
Well it's like in the Archie comic. Leo always saying: "I hate guns!". Says the guy with the katana blades...:lol:
Knowing Steve Murphy I'm pretty sure he'd repeal the 2nd amendment tomorrow if he could (also, push through the entire contents of the Green New Deal) so that's probably a little bleedthrough, but even as a kid I always read that as Leo not necessarily hating guns, but rather hating the sportmanship (or a lack thereof) of it. i.e., "You'd rather just shoot me with a gun? That's a cheat! How about you fight me like a man, mano e mano?"
Leo656
08-18-2020, 12:46 AM
It's stupid that a guy who carries swords would ever 1. Have a problem with and throw shade at another's chosen lethal weapons, and 2. Mostly just use his swords to slap people.
But yeah I kinda read the thing in Archie the same way, more of like "That's no fair" rather than "Hey! Foul! Those things can kill people!" Leo's my favorite, but frankly if he's not gonna slice anyone up with those things than he might as well be carrying a yo-yo. That stuff always gets on my nerves.
why not just get Jim Lawson to do it especially if he can channel his old style in mirage volume 1?
If you were an editor or higher up at a comic book publisher would you seriously want Jim Lawon's current art as a selling point of a comic book? As you alluded to, if it was his past style of art then more of a possibility. Not his work today. Jim hasn't drawn his past style in years. You could see his style has slowly changed starting from TMNT #28 to the Shades of Grey/City at War issues, then TMNT Vol. 2, to now. It really changed alot in that span. I don't mean to bash Jim's art but he has drawn to much TMNT and its time to see others draw them, especially the Mirage versions. I think he's great on other stuff with his art. He was really good on the Paleo comics of his. Definitely has the knack for dinos and nature. Good enough for the random covers here and there IDW got him to make for the various TMNT Mirage trades IDW did. Good for the nostalgia and the content it represents. I'm really surprised they never even looked at Craig Farley or Frank Fosco as choices. Kevin just went with these Heavy Metal guys. Truly kinda shows he's not in touch with the Mirage guys anymore I think. I remember him saying that in an interview years ago too.
I was so use to Kuhn's work we've seen so far now its no longer the case. It set the tone to me for Last Ronin's look.
rs_jr
08-19-2020, 01:00 AM
the reason i bring up old Jim Lawson style because i think am remembering correctly but he did a commission a couple years ago in his old art style because he whoever asked for the commission wanted it in that art style so its shows he has the ability to go the to his older less blocky style.
AC Farley would be amazing but is he still doing full interior art?
Rick Vetich would be good too but not sure of how he does futuristic stuff.
The Heavy metal guys art don't look it would fit but i really hope they prove me wrong.
Hoping something inspires Peter and he makes use of the 18 issues per year
Andrew NDB
08-19-2020, 01:40 AM
If you were an editor or higher up at a comic book publisher would you seriously want Jim Lawon's current art as a selling point of a comic book? As you alluded to, if it was his past style of art then more of a possibility. Not his work today. Jim hasn't drawn his past style in years. You could see his style has slowly changed starting from TMNT #28 to the Shades of Grey/City at War issues, then TMNT Vol. 2, to now. It really changed alot in that span. I don't mean to bash Jim's art but he has drawn to much TMNT and its time to see others draw them, especially the Mirage versions. I think he's great on other stuff with his art. He was really good on the Paleo comics of his. Definitely has the knack for dinos and nature. Good enough for the random covers here and there IDW got him to make for the various TMNT Mirage trades IDW did. Good for the nostalgia and the content it represents.
I'd just give Jim a decent inker with a modern sensibility. For maximum marketability.
I'm really surprised they never even looked at Craig Farley or Frank Fosco as choices. Kevin just went with these Heavy Metal guys. Truly kinda shows he's not in touch with the Mirage guys anymore I think. I remember him saying that in an interview years ago too.
He talks to Frank. Not so much Lawson or anybody. He talks to Farley from time to time. Kevin was going to look into getting going on prints of all of Farley's TMNT paintings.
AC Farley would be amazing but is he still doing full interior art?
Sort of. He has been slowly working on a new version of "Bioneers" (now called "Recombatants"), but I don't think very actively. He's pretty busy on other stuff. I've asked him, "What would you do if IDW offered you a gig, like tomorrow?" and he's said that while he's done at heart with TMNT, he'd definitely consider it.
Veitch, I don't know if he'd work for IDW. He'd want to retain all rights to his art and even if IDW was OK with that, Nickelodeon wouldn't be (as we know, that's why they can't reprint his TMNT issues).
Egon1982
08-19-2020, 06:54 AM
Well it's like in the Archie comic. Leo always saying: "I hate guns!". Says the guy with the katana blades...:lol:
He just likes to use old fashion pre-gun style weapons than guns as he doesn't believe in guns you know.
AquaParade
08-19-2020, 08:49 AM
Farley would have been an insanely cool choice for this book, if he were available and disciplined enough. It sure would be interesting to see him follow Kevin's layouts. Sort of wonder if those styles would clash. If nothing else, they should commission a variant from him.
Fosco would have felt perfectly natural as well, like a slightly cleaned up version of what Kuhn was doing, I think his style would blend effortlessly with Kevin's. I'm pretty happy with the new artists as of now. I think it's cool to mix the flavor of Heavy Metal with TMNT. Just need a preview to get a better idea.
AquaParade
08-19-2020, 12:07 PM
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/web-of-venom-wraith-thor-and-tmnt-last-ronin-tops-advance-reorders/
This book is hanging out near the top of the reorder charts. Hoping this is big. The war is long, but this could be a small, positive step towards tmnt material for adults.
It's also worth nothing that the book is $8.99 and ranking among cheaper books. It's going to be a big deal for IDW and I fully expect a sequel after seeing this.
TonySiegel
08-19-2020, 12:16 PM
Even my casual comic book fan friends are looking forward to this. I suppose you add dark and dystopian to anything and it becomes more interesting, the Dark Knight effect if you will.
AquaParade
08-19-2020, 12:23 PM
Yeah, I think most people are actually quite receptive to the idea of grittier TMNT stories, as well. Spruce it up, put it in their face, and they will eat it up. It just doesn't happen enough.
TonySiegel
08-19-2020, 12:33 PM
The Turtles as an IP is in a great place right now so happy Laird and Eastman are working together again.
I have a sneaking suspicion that Laird would've shown up at NYCC if not for Covid burying the year 2020.
Sharman
08-19-2020, 03:25 PM
Yeah, I think most people are actually quite receptive to the idea of grittier TMNT stories, as well. Spruce it up, put it in their face, and they will eat it up. It just doesn't happen enough.
From your mouth to God's (nickelodeon's) ears. There are many who have been craving the grittier Turtles for years, now. One can only hope that TLR will deliver something closer to the original Mirage Mutants rather than the softer take we've gotten these last few years.
frank_one
08-19-2020, 05:40 PM
I'd just give Jim a decent inker with a modern sensibility. For maximum marketability.
I don't know. You want Lawson to do the art but then you want an other artist to "hide" his peculiar style. This is... weird, a bit unrespectfull maybe, if you think about it. Don't get me wrong, I understand your point.
The way I see it, Lawson has his own style and we need to deal with it, that's it. We old Mirage fans love Jim and what he did with the Turtles (and what he's still doing with his new projects) but he's not the kind of artist IDW is looking for.
Maximum marketability? I'm not sure. I mean, I guess the majority of the ones who are buying IDW's TMNT doesn't even know who Jim Lawson is. They probably have never read a Mirage issue. We old Mirage dudes are a niche, the IDW series is aimed to the old toon fans for the most part, they are the ones who keep the franchise profitable and the ones who are still buying this series.
Weapons@theready
08-19-2020, 06:30 PM
Even my casual comic book fan friends are looking forward to this. I suppose you add dark and dystopian to anything and it becomes more interesting, the Dark Knight effect if you will.
I?ve had so many people who aren?t even comic book fans randomly start conversations with me about it because they know I?m a fan. So it?s operating on a different level right now, hopefully it lives up to the hype
Andrew NDB
08-19-2020, 07:53 PM
Farley would have been an insanely cool choice for this book, if he were available and disciplined enough. It sure would be interesting to see him follow Kevin's layouts.
Definitely a surefire way to not get Farley involved would be to ask him to follow someone else's layouts.
AquaParade
08-19-2020, 09:48 PM
https://comic-watch.com/news/interviews/a-joyous-shell-ebration-36-years-of-timeless-turtle-fun-an-interview-with-kevin-eastman/amp?__twitter_impression=true
Kevin calling this book "hyper violent" and aimed at original Mirage fans.
Andrew NDB
08-19-2020, 11:58 PM
"Tom and I approached this story and it's going to be set into the future like 20 years or so. It?s going to be dark, edgy, and is specifically and solely directed towards the original turtles audience, the older audience that lean more towards the Mirage Universe, the IDW Universe but it is going to be an independent universe within itself and it?s going to be hyper-violent, epic, it?s going to be something that touches on things that a lot of fans can relate to but it is a wholly and solely a story that is dedicated to the heart and soul of all things turtles. I?m not sure if this is Tom and I?s swan song but it is something Tom and I have been thinking about for about 2 years so this story is going to be everything that every fan has ever wanted to see with the turtles."
I don't know... I'm skeptical. Hyper-violent PG-13, maybe. Why make all the Foot Soldiers into robots if it was going to be balls to the walls? Seems like a workaround since the Turtle wouldn't be allowed to kill any people.
Sharman
08-20-2020, 06:49 AM
Yeah, I'm with Andrew on this one. Hper-violent could mean any number of things in this particular set-up.
Still. Looking. Forward. To. It. Though.
AquaParade
08-20-2020, 07:01 AM
Nah, he's not going to call it hyper violent because a bunch of robots getting blown up. There will be some blood. Really doesn't need to read much harder than pg-13 to capture the tone of those old Mirage books, if it is done tastefully. Those comics have a lot of violence and blood but it never felt taboo to read as a kid or anything, imo.
Andrew NDB
08-20-2020, 07:41 AM
I suspect the bad guys will do terrible things... bloody things. Because that's fine. The Turtle... killing a lot of robots in badass poses, closeups on cutting off robot arms and legs. Maybe monsters. That might be the go to. I hope I'm wrong.
NinjaPug
08-20-2020, 10:46 AM
"Tom and I approached this story and it's going to be set into the future like 20 years or so. It?s going to be dark, edgy, and is specifically and solely directed towards the original turtles audience, the older audience that lean more towards the Mirage Universe, the IDW Universe but it is going to be an independent universe within itself and it?s going to be hyper-violent, epic, it?s going to be something that touches on things that a lot of fans can relate to but it is a wholly and solely a story that is dedicated to the heart and soul of all things turtles. I?m not sure if this is Tom and I?s swan song but it is something Tom and I have been thinking about for about 2 years so this story is going to be everything that every fan has ever wanted to see with the turtles."
I don't know... I'm skeptical. Hyper-violent PG-13, maybe. Why make all the Foot Soldiers into robots if it was going to be balls to the walls? Seems like a workaround since the Turtle wouldn't be allowed to kill any people.
Do we know they?re all robots or are you basing that off the variant cover that also had Leatherhead and Rocksteady?
Think the skepticism is warranted though.
AquaParade
08-20-2020, 10:56 AM
I agree that the worry is warranted, because this is Nickelodeon we are dealing with, but I'm also thinking Kevin wouldn't blow so much smoke up our ass and keep bringing up old Mirage fans when it is something he is directly working on and has some level of authorized control over.
If Viacom have in fact let loose the reigns a bit, and let Kevin please old school fans with this comic, it'd be a pretty interesting step for the franchise under their ownership, and even more so when you consider Batman v TMNT was able to step up the maturity in the children's animation arena as well just last year.
But you also have to consider that Nickelodeon has had no issue reprinting Mirage or Image TMNT material. In the second issue of City at War, the turtles visit a blown up sex shop and a few issues later we see Foot Ninja heads literally being "popped" by robots while foot ninja spray bullets every which way. The turtles make blowjob jokes in the Image comic. All this printed in books with Nickelodeon logos inside. This is the same market the comicbooks like The Last Ronin are going to. Is there really much difference between printing violence and sex in the old stuff vs printing violence in the new stuff? Maybe Viacom realized the answer is "no."
stormbringer
08-23-2020, 12:58 AM
Based on the previews and interviews, it seems like it'll be pretty good. Fingers crossed.
AquaParade
08-23-2020, 08:55 AM
You'd think we'd see a new preview by now. Sounds like they replaced Kuhn a while ago.
Andrew NDB
08-23-2020, 02:54 PM
Do we know they?re all robots or are you basing that off the variant cover that also had Leatherhead and Rocksteady?
Think the skepticism is warranted though.
There are two covers with Foot robots. Seems a sure thing.
Enscripture
08-23-2020, 03:18 PM
Watch this turtle be Jennika lol
NinjaPug
08-23-2020, 05:01 PM
There are two covers with Foot robots. Seems a sure thing.
Seems likely but just making sure I didn?t miss something that was revealed about the project or if assumptions were being made based on variant covers.
neatoman
08-23-2020, 05:29 PM
Watch this turtle be Jennika lol
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/proxy/Z6ygW0Kf_Tv-bsIN4SMvGlCTCCGAIr8MWz86APRmZm-2uQwY0wZhAPBeSbCAj0izoZvqXI59EZlV3blvzViNojhqaoCAj CSjuyPwNWmD6chTM6a3bScjNU-lLA
rs_jr
08-23-2020, 08:53 PM
in the Mirage comics if I'm remembering this correctly we saw old one eyed Raph, old blind Donni and he meets old Leo and gives him a sword, so all three were shown old in the Mirage comics.
Has the Mirage comics ever shown older mikey?
Is the last ting we know about Mikey is him going into space and we don't know what happened afterwards ?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-23-2020, 08:56 PM
in the Mirage comics if I'm remembering this correctly we saw old one eyed Raph, old blind Donni and he meets old Leo and gives him a sword, so all three were shown old in the Mirage comics.
Has the Mirage comics ever shown older mikey?
Is the last ting we know about Mikey is him going into space and we don't know what happened afterwards ?
That is correct.
AquaParade
08-23-2020, 08:56 PM
Idk but I hope Mirage never gets a proper canon ending. I love how strange and mysterious it is.
rs_jr
08-23-2020, 10:55 PM
well i hope it continues to everyone that enjoys it.
Hopefully for people like me that tried to get into multiple times and couldn't get a other series from IDW like how they continued GIJOE RAH or once they collect volume 4 and hopeful add issues to finish it ( i think PL mentioned 4 more issues to go) they end up giving us the 18 issues of Mirage per year
CyberCubed
08-24-2020, 10:36 AM
Idk but I hope Mirage never gets a proper canon ending. I love how strange and mysterious it is.
Technically the last issue with all the "old Turtles" we've seen through Tales over the years are the end of the Mirage universe anyway. People should just read whatever last issue we saw old Raph, Don, Leo, etc. in.
Rooish
08-24-2020, 08:21 PM
in the Mirage comics if I'm remembering this correctly we saw old one eyed Raph, old blind Donni and he meets old Leo and gives him a sword, so all three were shown old in the Mirage comics.
Has the Mirage comics ever shown older mikey?
Is the last ting we know about Mikey is him going into space and we don't know what happened afterwards ?
Yeah that's it. There are a few issues of Tales of the TMNT vol 2 thar imply he made it back. Swan Song if I recall. And the side story of the reprint of Tales Vol 1 showed him pretty old and implied he outlived Raph, although not Leo or Don. It's all speculation though.
rs_jr
08-25-2020, 04:08 AM
Yeah that's it. There are a few issues of Tales of the TMNT vol 2 thar imply he made it back. Swan Song if I recall. And the side story of the reprint of Tales Vol 1 showed him pretty old and implied he outlived Raph, although not Leo or Don. It's all speculation though.
I though that side story from the reprint of tales with the older turtles was a computer simulation and not necessarily a old memory unless i am misremembering
Andrew NDB
08-25-2020, 04:09 AM
Watch this turtle be Jennika lol
Impossible. Doesn't exist in Mirage, never will, and this is supposed to be universe ambiguous.
Rooish
08-25-2020, 04:23 PM
I though that side story from the reprint of tales with the older turtles was a computer simulation and not necessarily a old memory unless i am misremembering
Yes true. The impression I got was that Don was seeing them in order they died based on their appearance. But who knows really
Turnstone
10-01-2020, 01:46 PM
Any news as of lately? Been so dry out there.
AquaParade
10-01-2020, 04:16 PM
Nope. I keep checking.
I believe it was Tom W who posted on twitter not too long ago that the first issue was being sent to the printer.
Sharman
10-02-2020, 12:41 PM
The cover art has also changed (as expected). Same Eastman layout, though.
AquaParade
10-02-2020, 01:25 PM
Can you link to the new cover? I'm seeing the same Eastman/Kuhn one everywhere.
TomWaltz
10-02-2020, 02:53 PM
https://twitter.com/TomWaltz/status/1310644200665300993
Talk soon...
Tom W.
AquaParade
10-02-2020, 04:06 PM
I love the new look! Can't wait to see more. Thanks, Tom.
NinjaPug
10-02-2020, 05:49 PM
I like the look of that panel
Sharman
10-07-2020, 06:34 AM
Courtesy of Eastman's facebook page:
https://scontent.fman1-2.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/120316661_1422321651300855_703260376279545030_o.jp g?_nc_cat=100&_nc_sid=730e14&_nc_ohc=nGmZ6PycHNUAX9WwhmZ&_nc_ht=scontent.fman1-2.fna&oh=6ecf20a40ca7d46da81d93b1b05d8075&oe=5FA479D0
Andrew NDB
10-07-2020, 07:00 AM
Very nice art.
oldmanwinters
10-07-2020, 09:20 AM
Hmm...
http://i.imgur.com/94vRxtAl.jpg (https://imgur.com/94vRxtA)
AquaParade
10-07-2020, 11:07 AM
Love it! Very interesting getting to see the different interpretations over Eastman's layout. Hope we get more opportunities to see the comparison. I'm more than happy with the new artists though.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-07-2020, 11:35 AM
Hmm...
http://i.imgur.com/94vRxtAl.jpg (https://imgur.com/94vRxtA)
That was my initial reaction, too. :tlol:
MikeandRaph87
10-07-2020, 12:44 PM
Hmm...
http://i.imgur.com/94vRxtAl.jpg (https://imgur.com/94vRxtA)
:lol: Great minds think alike.
Dick Grayson is the optimist and light in a dark environment and so is Michelangelo so the similarities to the Robin 'R' to that of the Last Ronin points in Mike's direction. Maybe I am overthinking...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-07-2020, 01:07 PM
:lol: Great minds think alike.
Dick Grayson is the optimist and light in a dark environment and so is Michelangelo so the similarities to the Robin 'R' to that of the Last Ronin points in Mike's direction. Maybe I am overthinking...
You're overthinking.
If anything, it's Raphael because the Turtles wore intial belts in that dumb cartoon we all used to love.
See, that's not it either, but it's at least a lot closer to what Eastman's logic COULD be. But it's just a cool stylized R for Ronin. :tsmile:
NinjaPug
10-07-2020, 05:30 PM
Interview with Kevin - nothing really new in here:
https://www.gamesradar.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-last-ronin-tmnt/
oldmanwinters
10-07-2020, 06:19 PM
That was my initial reaction, too. :tlol:
:lol: Great minds think alike.
Dick Grayson is the optimist and light in a dark environment and so is Michelangelo so the similarities to the Robin 'R' to that of the Last Ronin points in Mike's direction. Maybe I am overthinking...
A few months ago I derailed a whole social media thread when the original poster mistakenly asked "So, what do you think of the last robin?"
Andrew NDB
10-07-2020, 06:47 PM
Interview with Kevin - nothing really new in here:
https://www.gamesradar.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-last-ronin-tmnt/
"But, just as they were growing beyond the 'kids version,' they often discovered the Mirage books, the role-playing games, that edgier universe... and they were sucked back in big time, and for life. The majority of these fans that want to be entertained by their favorite characters at their age level - 30-somethings - they want to see the TMNT in that Daredevil TV series universe. Well-written and with R-Rated action."
That's a good quote. Though with Robo-Foot... not sure if we're getting the "R-rated action"? I suspect the R-rated action will be relegated to violence not caused by the Turtle.
Leo656
10-07-2020, 07:22 PM
But... but but.... but everyone around HERE says that little kids are the bread and butter... and that the only way to keep things going is by aiming everything at 5-year olds... Didn't you hear? Didn't you hear that there's no point in aiming at 30-somethings???
People around here and on the FB page keep saying it... you mean to tell me it's not true....?
AquaParade
10-07-2020, 08:53 PM
I wouldn't be surprised it Nick loosens up on the restrictions with this book. Why not? They are perfectly fine with publishing City at War and Bodycount.
Leo656
10-07-2020, 09:06 PM
I think there's at least some "plausible deniability" on Nick's end with that older stuff. That probably helps.
Like, "It wasn't created on our watch, therefore we're not fully responsible for it BUT since people want it so bad we're alright putting it out there for them."
When it comes to NEW content being created under their supervision, I imagine there's a much tighter leash. If some soccer mommy sent them an angry letter after accidentally giving their first-grader "City At War", Nick could at least say "Hey, we didn't book that, it was like that before we got here!" But if they solicited something like "Bodycount" in the Here and Now and someone complained, they'd have to accept full blame and responsibility. And I can't imagine that they'd want the hassle.
There's always ONE Karen, after all.
AquaParade
10-07-2020, 10:22 PM
Fair point. Definitely interested to see what Kevin's idea of "adult" is then. I have faith this will be a cool book.
Kevin is saying all sorts of tantalizing things. You can tell he really wants this book to fix the perception of TMNT. It's a big ask, but I admire the effort and the project could very well lead to better things for TMNT if things work out.
Leo656
10-07-2020, 10:41 PM
Much as ol' "Cash-The-Check Kevin" has shown that he's pretty happy with just about anything that says "TMNT" so long as he gets paid... yeah, I do kinda feel like the constant toddlerization (or at LEAST bowdlerization) of the brand in recent years is something he's not entirely in favor of, and would do more to change it if he could.
Can't imagine that the "Heavy Metal" guy is in full agreement with the ever-growing (but still false) "Screw the 30-somethings, little kids are the brand's foundation" chorus. Too bad he isn't in a position of more authority. His stuff's never been exactly my taste (at least on his own) but I mean, if he had more say than I imagine at the very least there'd be more variety of TMNT products available for different age groups and audiences.
Hopefully this will be a nice bone. We'll see.
AquaParade
10-08-2020, 08:33 AM
It just takes a little social intelligence to decipher when Kevin is speaking his truth or not. He's been asked about "Rise..." a hundred times, and while he is nice, it's quite obviously not his thing. He doesn't gush over it the way he does the 2012 show, 1990 film, or TLR.
The only recent exception was the PD movies, which he did promote and then seemed to regret, as they were a complete soggy mess by the time they came out of the oven.
Idk, I'm going to keep defending Kevin' word, bc to me it's quite obvious when he is being sincere. Not everyone will pick up on that.
AquaParade
10-08-2020, 10:57 AM
https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/exclusive-ashcan-preview-the-last-ronin-is-a-dark-knight-returns-of-ninja-turtles-comics
Interview and preview. The new pages look so good.
NinjaPug
10-08-2020, 11:14 AM
https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/exclusive-ashcan-preview-the-last-ronin-is-a-dark-knight-returns-of-ninja-turtles-comics
Interview and preview. The new pages look so good.
Agreed.
Article says Issue 1 is now out 10/31 instead of 10/28 - seems like a mistake as I doubt they’ll release this on a Saturday.
NinjaPug
10-08-2020, 01:37 PM
Tom provided another look and refers to them as future Foot Soldiers
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Ej02_BVU0AUSvKk?format=jpg&name=medium
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2020, 01:52 PM
Tom provided another look and refers to them as future Foot Soldiers
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Ej02_BVU0AUSvKk?format=jpg&name=medium
Beautiful art.
But also, those sure look like fvcking robots to me...
AquaParade
10-08-2020, 02:10 PM
They're def robots. Nothing we haven't seen in IDW books, so it is safe to assume Kevin is referring to other aspects of the story when he references the maturity level.
I want a sense of danger and consequence that matches the action on the page as much as anyone else, but I'm not going to draw any hard conclusions based on a small preview.
You can see that Kevin hasn't lost a beat when it comes to kick-ass layouts and the new colorist is adding a cinematic flair. I can't wait to pop this book open.
Judging by the early reception and the way Kevin is talking about this, it sounds like the beginning of something new for the franchise. A small pocket universe that can hopefully influence the direction of future TMNT projects in the mainstream.
TomWaltz
10-08-2020, 02:17 PM
Future Foot soldier says, "Ouchie."
AquaParade
10-08-2020, 02:19 PM
That looks like a human(android?). We should make more false assumptions about the book and hope they lead to another preview.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-08-2020, 02:36 PM
That looks like a human(android?). We should make more false assumptions about the book and hope they lead to another preview.
The Last Ronin is obviously Venus de Milo. I can see shell boobs under that black cloth.
Andrew NDB
10-08-2020, 08:12 PM
They're def robots. Nothing we haven't seen in IDW books, so it is safe to assume Kevin is referring to other aspects of the story when he references the maturity level.
I'm guessing the bad guy(s) kill people and do bad, even bloody things... while the Turtle just chops up robots. If we're lucky, maybe the Turtle pushes the main bad guy off a building or something at the end, or there's an explosion and the bad guy is caught in it.
Sharman
10-13-2020, 06:35 AM
Future Foot soldier says, "Ouchie."
Hmmm. So vague. Love it.
Sumac
10-14-2020, 12:24 PM
Those Foot Soldiers look like sentai characters.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
10-14-2020, 12:25 PM
Those Foot Soldiers look like sentai characters.
Notice me, sentai!
AquaParade
10-14-2020, 12:26 PM
Looks like Tom has been sharing panels on Twitter the last few days.
Diorm
10-15-2020, 09:02 AM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Ej8jze1UYAEI4lS.jpg
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EkPSjn1UYAAT9NS.jpg
Andrew NDB
10-16-2020, 02:52 AM
How about a variant with B&W interiors with digital duotones?
neatoman
10-16-2020, 08:03 AM
How about a variant with B&W interiors with digital duotones?
Ask Bobby, he might be able to authorise such an edition if the demand is high enough.
Allio
10-16-2020, 11:14 AM
Those Foot Soldiers look like sentai characters.
or at least what western designers think sentai designs look like. Seriously, you would think that Boom would be able to match "It's just spandex" aesthetic, but NO~
Sharman
10-16-2020, 04:36 PM
Confirmation of the nature of the Foot Soldiers (potential spoilers)
https://www.gamesradar.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-the-last-ronin-1-tmnt-review/
Sharman
10-16-2020, 04:37 PM
How about a variant with B&W interiors with digital duotones?
That would be sublime!
AquaParade
10-16-2020, 06:24 PM
Damn. That review gave the book a back massage and a foot massage at the same time. I'm glad because it's going to entice even more people to check this book out. So cool.
CyberCubed
10-16-2020, 06:30 PM
Man, that review was way too spoiler-y. I had to stop after the first few paragraphs because they gave too much away.
Leo656
10-16-2020, 06:58 PM
Psssssssshhhhhh. There's barely anything Spoiler-y in there at all. C'mon. Ever read the back of a DVD case before watching a movie? That was exactly as "Spoiler-y" as that review is.
Frankly, I'm glad they revealed as much as they did because this actually sounds like something I'd be interested in reading, now. I went from not caring at all to "Might Buy". So, they did their job with their coverage.
I'm betting Andrew will be at the very least annoyed with the villain's lineage... :trazz:
Oroku Hiroto – the son of Kirai and grandson to Oroku Saki (the Shredder)
....Implies that this is yet another version that places Karai as Oroku Saki's daughter... which she almost certainly was NOT in the original Mirage canon the way I understand it.
I mean, I know this obviously isn't a Mirage work, but didn't they at one point say or imply that "It can fit into any TMNT universe if you squint a little bit"? Well, that right there kinda goes against that. At the very least it doesn't fit in with Mirage because of that detail, unless at some point the Mirage canon changed and I missed it. Which I guess is possible.
Nitpicky, I guess, but you know the more purist type of people around here are gonna say the same thing. :trazz:
NinjaPug
10-16-2020, 07:55 PM
Psssssssshhhhhh. There's barely anything Spoiler-y in there at all. C'mon. Ever read the back of a DVD case before watching a movie? That was exactly as "Spoiler-y" as that review is.
Frankly, I'm glad they revealed as much as they did because this actually sounds like something I'd be interested in reading, now. I went from not caring at all to "Might Buy". So, they did their job with their coverage.
I'm betting Andrew will be at the very least annoyed with the villain's lineage... :trazz:
....Implies that this is yet another version that places Karai as Oroku Saki's daughter... which she almost certainly was NOT in the original Mirage canon the way I understand it.
I mean, I know this obviously isn't a Mirage work, but didn't they at one point say or imply that "It can fit into any TMNT universe if you squint a little bit"? Well, that right there kinda goes against that. At the very least it doesn't fit in with Mirage because of that detail, unless at some point the Mirage canon changed and I missed it. Which I guess is possible.
Nitpicky, I guess, but you know the more purist type of people around here are gonna say the same thing. :trazz:
That was the main thing that stuck out to me.
Wasn't there an interview with Kevin from a few years ago where he incorrectly referred to Karai as Saki's daughter in the Mirage books? It wouldn't shock me if Kevin believes that to be the case even though that's not how it was in the book.
Leo656
10-16-2020, 08:08 PM
If Kevin smoked half as much herb over the years as I suspect, I can't blame him for not having the finer details straight. :trazz: But yeah, jokes aside, he dipped in and out of TMNT over the years and I assume he both forgot and wasn't paying attention to certain things in the interim.
It's probably just gotten to, "Screw it, she's his daughter in everything else so now, retroactively, she always was his daughter in everything, period" levels.
Frankly... never been a huge fan of it. I mean I get why it's a thing people do, I just don't think it was ever really necessary and I don't generally like retcons.
BUT, this is gonna be one of those "history and circumstance overrides you" kinda things. That's indisputable. If TMNT is still around in 30 years, and someone doing trivia asks, "Who Is Karai related to?", the official answer is simply gonna be "She's Shredder's daughter". They won't even asterisk it. They're not gonna bother saying "Despite not being created as such." It's just gonna be that way.
Kind of annoying, really, but eh, whattyagonnado?
AquaParade
10-16-2020, 08:43 PM
They've been promoting this book as being outside of any continuity. The allusions to Mirage are more about evoking the tone and feeling of those books.
hypered1
10-16-2020, 08:47 PM
If Kevin smoked half as much herb over the years as I suspect, I can't blame him for not having the finer details straight. :trazz: But yeah, jokes aside, he dipped in and out of TMNT over the years and I assume he both forgot and wasn't paying attention to certain things in the interim.
It's probably just gotten to, "Screw it, she's his daughter in everything else so now, retroactively, she always was his daughter in everything, period" levels.
Frankly... never been a huge fan of it. I mean I get why it's a thing people do, I just don't think it was ever really necessary and I don't generally like retcons.
BUT, this is gonna be one of those "history and circumstance overrides you" kinda things. That's indisputable. If TMNT is still around in 30 years, and someone doing trivia asks, "Who Is Karai related to?", the official answer is simply gonna be "She's Shredder's daughter". They won't even asterisk it. They're not gonna bother saying "Despite not being created as such." It's just gonna be that way.
Kind of annoying, really, but eh, whattyagonnado?
Ok, firstly in the IDW series Karai has always referred to Saki as Grandfather, secondly there's no need to be so uneccessarily rigid to a 'canon' where even half of Volume 1 doesn't even count for most people.
Andrew NDB
10-16-2020, 08:50 PM
Karai is Shredder's daughter in this? Yikes. That's hardly minutia... that's a pretty big deal. And yeah, forget about "it can fit in either Mirage or IDW" entirely.
AquaParade
10-16-2020, 08:59 PM
It never could have fit in both. Either they are reincarnated or not. It seems that the more work Tom and Kevin put in, the more of it's own thing it became. Dark Knight Returns being the obvious example.
As for Karai, I prefer her to not be related to Shredder, generally speaking, but if you have a good story hook for it, than sure. It's not something to get hung up on.
Leo656
10-16-2020, 09:15 PM
More than anything, it kinda seems like it's not "outside canon". I feel like it's simply going to be IDW canon with a more Mirage-like aesthetic. And that they said "It's outside canon" and/or "It could theoretically fit into any canon" so as to lure in casuals and Mirage fans alike.
Pretty sure it's "just" a "possible future" within the IDW canon, and not any of those other things. That was all spin.
Still sounds interesting. Just saying.
neatoman
10-16-2020, 09:48 PM
If we're being literal with the wording, it's obviously not an IDW continuity book either. Karai and Shredder may not be unrelated there like in Mirage, but they aren't actually father/daughter either.
Leo656
10-16-2020, 10:00 PM
You're right, whoops. Good point.
AquaParade
10-16-2020, 10:36 PM
Yeah, I wouldn't see any reason to think it's an undercover operation to get us to read an IDW continuity book. It simply is what it says it is. Some of y'all have trust issues.
I mean, they did come off a bit strong with the allusions to this being a pure Laird/Eastman book, but they've been pretty clear about what this is since.
At this point I'm 99% sure the turtles are gonna execute some people in this book, just because all the assumptions and predictions in this thread are getting destroyed. Hell, even I assumed I was looking at robot foot soldiers, so I'm guilty too.
Ninjinister
10-17-2020, 03:01 AM
"Kirai" lmao
She was older than Saki so yeah there's no way in hell.
Leo656
10-17-2020, 03:23 AM
I'm guessing that the depiction of Karai in Mirage is forevermore going to be dismissed as "Early-Installment Weirdness."
Also, yeah, WTF is up with nobody - absolutely nobody - proofreading for spelling errors anymore. :lol:
Andrew NDB
10-17-2020, 03:30 AM
"Kirai" lmao
She was older than Saki so yeah there's no way in hell.
Way older. And had like a 20 year old daughter.
Galactus
10-17-2020, 07:56 AM
Heck who knows since this is all sprang from an unused pitch Laird made in the 80s Kirai may be some proto-Karai. An entirely different yet similar character...it's possible.
More likely the original pitch had an evil daughter of Oroku Saki and that Karai has basically become that in most versions of the franchise after the Mirage book Kevin just merged the two.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.