The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   TMNT killing Shredder (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=10995)

Coola Yagami 09-20-2004 08:09 PM

TMNT killing Shredder
 
I'm surprised the TMNT don't give much of a damn that they supposedly killed the Shredder twice. I mean, sure in the real world who would give a damn, but in cartoons, expecially for kids, the heroes always gotta care and go the extra mile to save the bad guy regardless if it's the same guy that killed and raped their family or something.

But in the TMNT show Splinter had Shredder fall off a building and a water tower collapse on him. They basically turned and went home, not even acting surprised that their sensei just killed a man. Then in RTNY, Leo slices Shredder's head off, and the gang is celebrating and stuff. It's not like they know the guy is is gonna pick up his head and walk off. As far as they're concerned, Leo just beheaded a man, and he doesn't even react to the fact he just did so.

I'm not saying this is bad, I'm just saying I'm surprised the series got away with this, especially since the tmnt were meant to be like.. idols for kids, wether the show was made for kids or not. Well meant to be is not the right term, more like protrayed as or looked upon as. The only thing I seen so far as terms of 'being overly good' was diving into the ocean trying to rescue Garbage Man.

Kazari 09-20-2004 08:15 PM

Well after dealing with all they have dealt with the Shredder..I am sure they were very GLAD that he was dead.

the Dark Knight 09-20-2004 10:35 PM

Don't take this the wrong way, but what do you expect them to do? After Splinter "kills" Shredder, do you expect the Turtles to walk over to their sensei and say "dude, master, killing is wrong" like some kinda after-school special? Maybe the Turtles and Splinter figure "you know, Shredder's probably still alive, but we defeated him, maybe he'll leave us alone."

Coola Yagami 09-20-2004 11:19 PM

Well no, but they coulda acted somewhat surprised their master did that. Or Splinter himself could have acted surprised the water tower smashed him up, wanting to defeat him but not go overkill on his ass. The only consolation being that they know Shredder would never hurt anyone else again.


lol btw on a related subject, I find it ironic that splinter never told them about how shredder killed yoshi so that their training would never be tainted by revenge and hatred, when in the comics, splinter basically trained them to someday to be good enough to kill shredder.

Ryona 09-20-2004 11:59 PM

You have to understand that the TMNT and Splinter are WARRIORS not life-guards. Ninjutsu is a warrior martial art, unlike your typical corner Karate school which is for self-defence basicly. Splinter has educated the TMNT in the arts of killing and subduing. The TMNT where raised to be as tough as nails in the face of death. I for one am GLAD that there's no lame over the top heroics like your typical super-heroes. It's REALISTIC. They ARE ninja.

Coola Yagami 09-21-2004 12:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryo
You have to understand that the TMNT and Splinter are WARRIORS not life-guards. Ninjutsu is a warrior martial art, unlike your typical corner Karate school which is for self-defence basicly. Splinter has educated the TMNT in the arts of killing and subduing. The TMNT where raised to be as tough as nails in the face of death. I for one am GLAD that there's no lame over the top heroics like your typical super-heroes. It's REALISTIC. They ARE ninja.

I know dude, I'm just saying I'm surprised they pulled off this attitude on saturday morning tv without taking too much flak for it. The show is taking bolder risks than many action shows before it which is cool.

Shark 09-21-2004 12:44 AM

Thats because the censors don't watch them, because they believe it's going to be all kiddy. Hence the TV Y7 rateing instead of the TV PG rateing it deserves.

ZariusTwo 09-21-2004 07:22 AM

[quote="Coola Yagami"]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryo
I know dude, I'm just saying I'm surprised they pulled off this attitude on saturday morning tv without taking too much flak for it. The show is taking bolder risks than many action shows before it which is cool.

Beast Wars and Reboot took the same risks (even going even farther) and got away with it, Transformers: The Movie genually killed off chracters and got away with it, G.I Joe: The Movie saw Duke IMPALED by a Snake dagger and they got away with it.

Anarchistguy 09-21-2004 09:18 AM

Heh. Duke was actually supposed to DIE from that snake dagger, but because kids cried like hell when Optimus Prime died, they let him live.

Shreddette 09-21-2004 02:17 PM

I gotta say, I been getting ingo the new TMNT now and really like it.
I like the recent episode a lot, I can't wait to see what happens to Leo!

I also think it's awesomely creative, I love the battledome thing they got going! Splinter has shown to be much more mysterious, which is cool.

I hope that the censors don't start noticing this and let the cartoon continue on being dark as it is. I'm sick of fuzzy toons.

Jet-ski_Ninja 09-21-2004 02:19 PM

The turtles didn't kill anybody in the old show. I wonder why? Maybe because it was more for kids than grown-ups?

Anarchistguy 09-21-2004 02:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jet-ski_Ninja
The turtles didn't kill anybody in the old show. I wonder why? Maybe because it was more for kids than grown-ups?

Yeah. Once a mutated Vernon was about to eat Baxter Stockman, But Mikey grabbed Stockman with his grappling hook and Vernon said: "Hey! That's MY entrée!" to which Raph replied: "Sorry, Vernon. That is NOT how we get rid of villains on this show."

InsaneZane 09-21-2004 03:22 PM

actually there were moments of silence for each...
Earlier in that first ep your talking about, Splinter says he planned on avenging Hamato Yoshi.....
there was an awkward silence there....for a second

and also after Leo and Shredder faced off....
There was also an awkward silence there...

Both cases they are trying to defeat a villain...
Its not like they can deal with cops and bring shredder to justice....
or web him up between 2 buildings and wait for the police to show up...

so they have to eliminate him...
kids understand this type of stuff sometimes
and should be viewed as entertainment
not as a bad influence

Savanti Romero 09-21-2004 03:34 PM

I am also glad TMNT can have that attitude. I agree they are ninja and that's what they do. They're not heros. I can remember those fake toys called Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles or something. Nevermind that's off topic. But I am a little surprised they got away with it now that I think about it. But I'm glad they did.

Jet-ski_Ninja 09-22-2004 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by anarchistguy
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jet-ski_Ninja
The turtles didn't kill anybody in the old show. I wonder why? Maybe because it was more for kids than grown-ups?

Yeah. Once a mutated Vernon was about to eat Baxter Stockman, But Mikey grabbed Stockman with his grappling hook and Vernon said: "Hey! That's MY entrée!" to which Raph replied: "Sorry, Vernon. That is NOT how we get rid of villains on this show."

Oh yeah! I remember that ep. and that moment! It was funny! :lol:! Baxter wanted to transform every humans into insects. He wanted revenge! :evilgrin:

jeff the cheff 09-22-2004 01:37 PM

Quote:

Don't take this the wrong way, but what do you expect them to do? After Splinter "kills" Shredder, do you expect the Turtles to walk over to their sensei and say "dude, master, killing is wrong" like some kinda after-school special?

HAHAHA! That was just funny. You have a good point, though. What were they supposed to do?

Ryona 09-22-2004 02:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeff the cheff

HAHAHA! That was just funny. You have a good point, though. What were they supposed to do?

The TMNT would do nothing to get in Splinter's way because they have the same mind set. Killing comes with being a warrior, and the TMNT know this and understand it very well, and they accept it.

Anyway, it's great to see Leo and Raph make contact with their weapons on living beings in this show.
Like, when you see Leo slashing at a Foot Soldier. Just as the blade is about to make contact, you see the screen go black and a bright slash mark appears on the screen, then you see the Foot drop to the floor.
Now that's VERY sugestive!

Anarchistguy 09-23-2004 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryo
Like, when you see Leo slashing at a Foot Soldier. Just as the blade is about to make contact, you see the screen go black and a bright slash mark appears on the screen, then you see the Foot drop to the floor.
Now that's VERY sugestive!

Not that anyone cares, but believe it or not, that actually hapened in the old cartoon too. Only once in the whole series, though. And it wasn't on a foot soldier, but a psychotic robot

Kazari 09-23-2004 04:25 PM

True but robots are one thing but slashing REAL humans is a lot worse! LOL

Anarchistguy 09-23-2004 04:29 PM

You don't understand. I was pointing at the fact that they actually used that kind of action sequence in the old toon.

Kazari 09-23-2004 05:06 PM

Oh ok!

[email protected] 09-24-2004 07:30 AM

Re: TMNT killing Shredder
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami
I'm surprised the TMNT don't give much of a damn that they supposedly killed the Shredder twice. I mean, sure in the real world who would give a damn, but in cartoons, expecially for kids, the heroes always gotta care and go the extra mile to save the bad guy regardless if it's the same guy that killed and raped their family or something.

But in the TMNT show Splinter had Shredder fall off a building and a water tower collapse on him. They basically turned and went home, not even acting surprised that their sensei just killed a man. Then in RTNY, Leo slices Shredder's head off, and the gang is celebrating and stuff. It's not like they know the guy is is gonna pick up his head and walk off. As far as they're concerned, Leo just beheaded a man, and he doesn't even react to the fact he just did so.

Of course they wouldn't remember what leo said in return to new york part 2, have you forgotten how he destroyed april's apartment, drove us away from our home and nearly killed this all, well I haven't and I want to see this thing through to the bitter end. And Splinter wanted to avenge yoshi. Shredder had no good in him and was just 1000% pure evil so of course the turtles wouldn't care because of all the suffering he has caused the Turtles. The turtles did not even expect him to pick up his head and walk off. Leo actually said master splinter when he made the watertower fall off shredder, but the turtles were not mad at him seemingly, but they just missed shredder's hand pop out of the watertower. Splinter said he had always wanted to avenge yoshi.

I'm not saying this is bad, I'm just saying I'm surprised the series got away with this, especially since the tmnt were meant to be like.. idols for kids, wether the show was made for kids or not. Well meant to be is not the right term, more like protrayed as or looked upon as. The only thing I seen so far as terms of 'being overly good' was diving into the ocean trying to rescue Garbage Man.


ChibiJaime 09-24-2004 07:47 AM

The boys gotta do what they have to do. They understood perfectly what Splinter was trying to do... he wanted to avenge his master, who - as we all saw and heard - was quite dead (I'm of the sound mind that the Shredder beheaded him).

To avenge a death is a life for a life... an eye for an eye, so to speak. The boys know and understand that their lives revolve around combat... there is always that chance that one of them could be hurt or killed... and always a chance they could lose their master.

In that same respect, the chance is ALWAYS there for a villain to be killed... even by accidental means. They may try to prevent it (they're teenagers... this is summing up a group, but teenagers tend to question their morals far more often than adults... hence the jumping into the river to save the Garbageman).

Personally, I am very much enjoying this new and darker TMNT. You posed a good question, though... I can see where you came from with it.

In the end, it all boils down to their training. In their minds, they very well may have been questioning Splinter's motives... most teenagers do that.

But would they have confronted him about it? I sincerely doubt it. He follows his code of honor, one they were taught, and even if they don't understand it, they will follow it. It's just the way they are.

Serp 09-24-2004 11:48 AM

With Shredder it was a kill or be killed situation. Splinter did go in over kill with the whole water tower thing I was quite amazed. Though I would be shocked if I just killed a man.

ChibiJaime 09-24-2004 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zanhilton-Jac
Splinter did go in over kill with the whole water tower thing I was quite amazed.

If I was Splinter, I would've gone overkill too. After a man walks out of a burning building without a scratch, one would suspect it'd take a little more to kill him.

Even if it didn't work. ^^;

shadowflame611 09-24-2004 07:21 PM

Re: TMNT killing Shredder
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami
Then in RTNY, Leo slices Shredder's head off, and the gang is celebrating and stuff. It's not like they know the guy is is gonna pick up his head and walk off. As far as they're concerned, Leo just beheaded a man, and he doesn't even react to the fact he just did so.

I'm not saying this is bad, I'm just saying I'm surprised the series got away with this, especially since the tmnt were meant to be like.. idols for kids, wether the show was made for kids or not. Well meant to be is not the right term, more like protrayed as or looked upon as. The only thing I seen so far as terms of 'being overly good' was diving into the ocean trying to rescue Garbage Man.

Yeah...but in RTNY, i think that Leo was juss a little worried bout Splinter. He was kinda cryin b4 he left him. And mebby he was juss numb from the fact that he juss killed shredder. Mebby he was juss glad it was over... you are right, though. He dident show much of a reaction.

Urbanski 09-24-2004 07:45 PM

I don't think Leo would show much emotion in that situation. He is always focused, so he knew what had to be done in the showdown in "Return to New York". When his mission was accomplished, it was over (he thought), and as mentioned he now had to attend to Splinter.

Doppleganger 09-24-2004 08:20 PM

I think the turtles would try another way. But since Shreddar is such a relentless enemy well they had no choice but to do what they did. "Kill or be killed." As they say. It's harsh but true.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:32 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.