The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Is it time for a restart? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=12112)

Aztec General 03-28-2005 08:50 PM

Is it time for a restart?
 
Do you think it's time for a TMNT comic restart?

IMHO that the answer is yes. Don't get me wrong I still want Volume 4 and Tales Vol. 2 to continue, but I'd like to see a new creative team take on the TMNT and start them from scratch. I guess you can think of it as "Ultimate TMNT". My only requests would be that they pay respect to the basic Mirage storyline and that they keep it mature like the Mirage series. Other than that I'd give the creative team free reign.

Your thoughts?

Kali 03-28-2005 10:59 PM

I'd love for that to happen. I'd love to be on the team. But unless it's a fan-based project, I don't think it's going to happen any time soon. Peter's still too possessive and protective over his TMNT. Although the new show is an "Ultimate TMNT" of sorts...

OA 03-29-2005 06:30 PM

an "Ultimate TMNT" would be fantastic but like Kali said, I doubt it'd ever come to light...

Spitfire 03-29-2005 06:34 PM

Dreamwave had an orgnial comic going from the start and look what happened :cry:
But if someone else does it that wont go out of buiness! I would love to see it. It would be nice to see all the older issues re-done with better art and with new ideas

Aztec General 03-29-2005 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx
Dreamwave had an orgnial comic going from the start and look what happened :cry:
But if someone else does it that wont go out of buiness! I would love to see it. It would be nice to see all the older issues re-done with better art and with new ideas

Dreamwave (minus Lesean's art) STUNK!! There was nothing original about it.

CyberCubed 03-29-2005 09:27 PM

No, the restart was the new cartoon series, I don't want to see old ground redone again in comic form.

How many times can April meet the Turtles for the first time? I mean c'mon.

DrSpengler 03-29-2005 09:38 PM

I'm afraid I have to go with the prvious poster. I'm getting pretty sick of rehashes of the TMNT's origin. How many times have we seen April freak-out at the turtles?

Original Mirage comic
Original TMNT cartoon
First TMNT movie
New TMNT cartoon
Dreamwave comic

And I never read the Archie stuff. They rehash their first encounter, too?

If they do an "Ultimate" TMNT, so to speak, then they should make it different. A different origin, a different first encounter with April, etc. Otherwise, it's just everything we've seen before. That's one reason why I don't mind Utrom-Shredder in the new toon. A little change never hurt.

Spitfire 03-29-2005 10:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
Dreamwave (minus Lesean's art) STUNK!! There was nothing original about it.

Dreamwave was great. Well okay I only liked the TMNT comics and the DMC comics. The other stuff just looked good. But I still miss them. I wanted more DMC comics :(

ZariusTwo 03-30-2005 08:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
Do you think it's time for a TMNT comic restart?

IMHO that the answer is yes. Don't get me wrong I still want Volume 4 and Tales Vol. 2 to continue, but I'd like to see a new creative team take on the TMNT and start them from scratch. I guess you can think of it as "Ultimate TMNT".

We have already have that. It's called the new animated series.

Aztec General 03-30-2005 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZariusTwo
We have already have that. It's called the new animated series.


I don't disagree, but I mean in comic book form. The new show is essentially an "Ultimate" version of the Mirage comics. But I'd just love to see it redone in comic book form as well, in a manner that was different from both the Mirage comics and the new toon.

I agree that if they were to restart the franchise in "Ultimate" fashion they should have a great deal of liberty in doing so.

When I say that they should "follow the general Mirage story" I mean the same characters and locations should be used. I'd have no problem with them taking the story in whatever direction they were to see fit. In fact I'd prefer it to be that way.

For example the storyline doesn't have to be:
Shredder Strikes
Shredder Strikes Back
Return to New York
City At War
etc.

They could retell the story of these characters and their relations however they deemed appopriate. All the while allowing for the lattitude to introduce new characters, plots, etc.

coryroo24 03-30-2005 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
Dreamwave (minus Lesean's art) STUNK!! There was nothing original about it.

I agree, they should have started at issue #5 instead of just having 4 comics about the first couple new tmnt eps.

rayfillet101 03-30-2005 07:03 PM

i think it is time for a comic based on the show, maybe dreamwave, maybe not. but i really think we need to bring chaplin, karai, quarry, angel, and all the new characters into a comic book!

Buslady 03-30-2005 10:21 PM

I liked Lawson's art from a long time ago but right now it's not that great, he used to draw people alot better ten years ago..i was looking in some old issues recently..

I wouldnt mind Dooney taking over for artwork. And no more maiming Raph..jeez...this gamera raph is lame o rama

Ra 03-30-2005 11:46 PM

i for one agree. April keeps on fainting because she keeps on meeting the turtles for the first time, all the origins have to be retold, and the intro for Shredder or another bad guy that we've already seen. i would like this 'Ultimite Turtle' idea. one condition though - it can be sold world wide in very town. i couldn't even find the Dreamwave comics down here when they were sold back in America! i just don't want that to happen to anyone else anymore

Spitfire 03-31-2005 01:10 AM

I liked Dreamwaves telling of April meeting the turtles. It wasnt the same as the show. It was in a sense but it was told with-in a dream she was having when she fainted from the mouser attacks. It was different, so the comics arent exactly like the show but I still see what you guys mean. The Archie comics were totally orgnial dispite the show so they could have done something different but oh well

Coola Yagami 03-31-2005 07:44 AM

Dreamwave would have continued better if they did better storyarcs. Their new stories were kinda ok, but you know, their series got cancelled with Leo training some street kid, instead of us seeing the Shredder and stuff.

The DW comics were still different from the show, sorta. Like the Mousers storyline, the first chapter was taken from April's point of view, showing parts of her childhood and questioning why she worked with Baxter to begin with. And part 2 dealt from Baxter's point of view, showing his college days and how he got into science. Hell, it even showed how Hun first met Baxter and got him to join the Foot.

As for the Archie comics, their first issues were based on the cartoon, so April met the TMNT the same way. But after issue 5 the series went for its own ride and never looked back.

Aztec General 03-31-2005 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx
The Archie comics were totally orgnial dispite the show so they could have done something different but oh well

True, and from what I can tell they became quite interesting at the end. Although my one gripe about the Archie series is that it didn't respect the general Mirage framework. No Casey Jones, Utroms, Triceratons, Foot ninja (forget about those robots), etc. It just took the characters of the TMNT, Splinter, April, Shredder, Leatherhead, and Rat King and made its own storyline. The personalities of these characters often didn't even match their Mirage counterparts. Which is admirable for its originality, but in another way it just didn't feel like the TMNT.

Coola Yagami 04-01-2005 12:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
True, and from what I can tell they became quite interesting at the end. Although my one gripe about the Archie series is that it didn't respect the general Mirage framework. No Casey Jones, Utroms, Triceratons, Foot ninja (forget about those robots), etc. It just took the characters of the TMNT, Splinter, April, Shredder, Leatherhead, and Rat King and made its own storyline. The personalities of these characters often didn't even match their Mirage counterparts. Which is admirable for its originality, but in another way it just didn't feel like the TMNT.

Obviously because they went the route of the cartoon and toyline of the time. Like the cartoon, Splinter was Hamato Yoshi, the TMNT talked like surfers and were pizza-crazed (but not as bad as the show) and you had characters from the toyline/show like Bebop, Rocksteady, Mondo Gecko and Slash.

raphael_is_cool 04-01-2005 11:21 AM

I'm happy with the new show for 'Ultimate' stuff

I'd only think a new comic would be a good idea if they got someone like Andy Kubert or Stuart Immonen pencilling with some cool colour work (Dreamwave was too drab). And that's never gonna happen. :P

The only new way for April, I'd imagine, would be to have her evil like Baxter Stockman or something and work from there. :ohwell:

Jephael 04-01-2005 11:45 AM

I loved how well the Archie series was made. If anything, they were a big improvement in comparision to the goofiness of the original cartoon at the time.

BartAllen 04-01-2005 03:19 PM

NO. the mirage series is going great. I do think at times the story is going slow. but it feels real. i dont know.

Lone Wolf 04-01-2005 04:33 PM

I don't see what the point would be. We have already seen so many different interpretations of the Turtles, where is the need for yet another?

Tigerfog 04-03-2005 11:43 PM

Hmm, let's see, here are the different 'universes' of TMNT I can remember:

1)TMNT Mirage storyline (includes Image)
2)TMNT Archie comics
3)TMNT old cartoon (includes TMNT UK comics)
4)TMNT Dreamwave
5)TMNT movies
6)TMNT next mutation
7)TMNT japanese anime ('Super Turtles')
8 )Numerous, numerous other TMNT mangas released in Japan - like one called 'Mutant Turtles GAIDEN' which can be seen at the official site of TMNT (no relation or whatsover with my project!)

I know for sure that no matter how good a new TMNT universe can be, the original Mirage comics will still be THE real TMNT and also the best. I really wonder how can anything else top those comics.
Rearranging the turtles' meeting with April would be a good idea, IMO, because all universes seem to make April encounter them the same way! But Casey... I wouldn't want his first contact with Raph be changed in any way. That's just too perfect.
What I'd really like is to see Eric Talbot draw from time to time. I have the 'Shell Shock' comic book and I think Talbot's art in it is quite good. With the return of Dan Berger in Tales of the TMNT VOL.2 and Chris Allan, I can only hope that Talbot will quit inking for a while and return to the pencil.

raphael_is_cool 04-04-2005 12:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tigerfog
I can only hope that Talbot will quit inking for a while

This may sound rude but I wouldn't mind if he quit inking full-stop. Lawson does a pretty good job inking his own stuff from what I've seen and Talbot doesn't seem to be at the top of his game like in Volume One (when his work was brilliant)

Lone Wolf 04-04-2005 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tigerfog
Hmm, let's see, here are the different 'universes' of TMNT I can remember:

1)TMNT Mirage storyline (includes Image)
2)TMNT Archie comics
3)TMNT old cartoon (includes TMNT UK comics)
4)TMNT Dreamwave
5)TMNT movies
6)TMNT next mutation
7)TMNT japanese anime ('Super Turtles')
8 )Numerous, numerous other TMNT mangas released in Japan - like one called 'Mutant Turtles GAIDEN' which can be seen at the official site of TMNT (no relation or whatsover with my project!)

I know for sure that no matter how good a new TMNT universe can be, the original Mirage comics will still be THE real TMNT and also the best. I really wonder how can anything else top those comics.
Rearranging the turtles' meeting with April would be a good idea, IMO, because all universes seem to make April encounter them the same way! But Casey... I wouldn't want his first contact with Raph be changed in any way. That's just too perfect.
What I'd really like is to see Eric Talbot draw from time to time. I have the 'Shell Shock' comic book and I think Talbot's art in it is quite good. With the return of Dan Berger in Tales of the TMNT VOL.2 and Chris Allan, I can only hope that Talbot will quit inking for a while and return to the pencil.

Uh, I think you forgot the new animated series. :)

DrSpengler 04-04-2005 01:34 PM

And isn't the Next Mutation a continuation of the movie timeline?

Aztec General 04-04-2005 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler
And isn't the Next Mutation a continuation of the movie timeline?

If by "continuation" you mean "raping" than yes it is. :lol:

DrSpengler 04-04-2005 07:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
If by "continuation" you mean "raping" than yes it is. :lol:

Hey, I never said it was good...

;)

ZariusTwo 04-09-2005 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler
And isn't the Next Mutation a continuation of the movie timeline?


It reuses movie sets and has some small hints, (and of course, Jarrah's unreliable Next Mutation guide continues to make it look as if it is in continunity) but the upcoming movie pretty much discards the third fillm, and most likly Next Mutation

PenguinCleese 04-11-2005 12:22 AM

Well I think a comic mini series would work this way. In an Ultimates style or even Kingdom Come. It was somewhat done recently with the show (with the alternate realities), but it would be cool to see a completely new retelling of the origin. I agree about April fainting and all is getting old, I hope the upcoming movie doesn't rehash it too much. I'm sure we all know now the origin (even kids) and if someone wants to learn it, there are plenty of ways to find it out. Having an Evil Casey and a hero Shredder would be cool. How about a Splinter that was paralyzed in a fight and has to train from a wheelchair. There are endless (and better than mine) ideas and possibilites.

AS for the Archie series it was a great comic. In the beginning it did follow the show storyline, but not too much later it started with it's own stories (I think around 8 or so) and continued to entertain me every month and brought plenty of the character we loved in. It was a cross between the original cartoon show and the new cartoon show. The quips and all were there, but so was the seriousness and the action. I was sad to se that book go, it did have some great storylines. And I can read through that whole series any day still and be completely entertained by it.

And pertaining to Peter's hold over the TMNT, I feel that it is for good reason. If you had created a gritty hard a** comic book (for the 80s at least) and it was turned into a cheesy cartoon show (at least from his point of view I'm sure), how would you feel? To him I bet it was like spitting on the comic TMNT. I know we all loved the show, but at the time we were kids, and it was the best out there. But I'm sure any of the 23 year olds who were reading the comic in 84 hated the cartoon. I think Peter feels the same way and now since he has control again it's like a father protecting his kids. I do prefer this over anything else though, since if anyone should have control it is him (and Eastman, but hey, what can you do?).

ZariusTwo 04-11-2005 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PenguinCleese
I think Peter feels the same way

Pete actually respects the original cartoon for it's accomplishments, but he knows that was'nt his creation, nothing more, nothing less, he despises the Next Mutation far more.

Spitfire 04-11-2005 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZariusTwo
the upcoming movie pretty much discards the third fillm, and most likly Next Mutation

Out witht he bad in with the new as they say....or atleast as I hope

Karpo_007 04-11-2005 10:12 PM

Might be a good idea. While I do enjoy the on going vol.4 I think it lacks something that made the first volume so good. Might be the total lack of Eastman's influence, or the simple fact people change while growing older, and the stories they tell change with them.

It's nice to see some new blood writing Tales, and as a whole I tend to like the Tales vol. 2 better than TMNT vol. 4. So if there would be a good writing team, who understands the basics of the Mirage TMNT and have fresh ideas, it might be a nice change.

FALLEN ELDOR 04-12-2005 08:48 PM

The problem have with the Mirage universe is that they aren't teenage nor are they fighting the foot...I'm not a fan of the Mirage universe, because I grew up on the old cartoon and the movies. It's hard to accept the TMNT without the foot, It's like Batman with out The Joker, Or superman without Lex Luthor. The Shredder is a very personal, very human foe and it's not about world domination or alien brain looking things, It's about human emotions of love and revenge, of lost love, betrayal and dishonor. The TMNT movie encompassed everything that makes the TMNT so damn cool, and I want to see that story unfold in a fresh and interesting new way where the shredder isn't killed off prematurely or turned into a ****ing alien!

An "ultimate" TMNT would allow for things that aren't apart of the new cartoon, reinvention of classic non Mirage TMNT. I think it would be cool to see otherwise lame characters reinvented in such a radical and different ways. Imagine Bebop and Rocksteady as ruthless and deadly bounty hunters hired by the Triceritons to kill the Turtles. Imagine the Turtles visiting an alternate word populated with humanoid turtles like Slash and Venus in interesting and non lame ways? Imagine Leatherhead and The Rat King returning to the TMNT deadly list of rouge's gallery? My biggest problem with the new cartoon is that Laird shot him self in the foot by stifling the creative ability on the new TMNT. I want to see a version of the TMNT that can be the best rounded version of the TMNT by taking all the best things out of each version of to really make an ULTIMATE version of THE TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TRUTLES!

Also I want to see the TMNT in color and in every book store and newsrack, I Think a partnering with Dark Horse comics would help to boost promotion of the book.

Aztec General 04-12-2005 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
Might be a good idea. While I do enjoy the on going vol.4 I think it lacks something that made the first volume so good. Might be the total lack of Eastman's influence, or the simple fact people change while growing older, and the stories they tell change with them.

It's nice to see some new blood writing Tales, and as a whole I tend to like the Tales vol. 2 better than TMNT vol. 4. So if there would be a good writing team, who understands the basics of the Mirage TMNT and have fresh ideas, it might be a nice change.

I agree. I'd hate to say (mostly because Laird is likely reading and will call me on it next issue) but Volume 4 appears to be going nowhere. It doesn't seem to have any direction. They really need to speed up the story SIGNIFICANTLY.

Karpo_007 04-12-2005 09:18 PM

Quote:

The problem have with the Mirage universe is that they aren't teenage nor are they fighting the foot...I'm not a fan of the Mirage universe, because I grew up on the old cartoon and the movies. It's hard to accept the TMNT without the foot, It's like Batman with out The Joker, Or superman without Lex Luthor. The Shredder is a very personal, very human foe and it's not about world domination or alien brain looking things, It's about human emotions of love and revenge, of lost love, betrayal and dishonor. The TMNT movie encompassed everything that makes the TMNT so damn cool, and I want to see that story unfold in a fresh and interesting new way where the shredder isn't killed off prematurely or turned into a ****ing alien!

Mirage has always been much more serious than any later version, especially the first cartoon and the sequels to the movie. When they fight the Foot Clan and the Shredder, people actually get hurt and die. It's an on going story, with changing themes and enemies. You can not really compare it to the first cartoon, wich, after the first season, followed the basic formula of every 80s cartoon. No on going story, the TMNT fight pretty much one main villain with few guest villains appearing every now and then. And of course the infamous story-reset button that is pressed after every episode.

In that format, keeping one villain constantly alive works, but not in the format the Mirage comics series uses. And I don't think it really works in the new cartoon either. Shredder has "died" enough, I hope they will move the story along finally with the next story. That being said, like I said before, if the writing team was good and had fresh new ideas, I too, would like to see the TMNT be teenagers again fighting the Foot Clan for the first time, most importantly without the limitations of a cartoon show.

Karpo_007 04-12-2005 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
I agree. I'd hate to say (mostly because Laird is likely reading and will call me on it next issue) but Volume 4 appears to be going nowhere. It doesn't seem to have any direction. They really need to speed up the story SIGNIFICANTLY.

Yeah, I think being bi-monthly really hurts the flow of the story, and I'm starting to get a feeling that there really isn't any bigger picture behind all the new sub-plots. It is stil interesting to read, but I'm almost starting to think I enjoyed vol. 2 more overall.

Aztec General 04-13-2005 10:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
Yeah, I think being bi-monthly really hurts the flow of the story, and I'm starting to get a feeling that there really isn't any bigger picture behind all the new sub-plots. It is stil interesting to read, but I'm almost starting to think I enjoyed vol. 2 more overall.

I felt the same way about the first 11 or so issues. I kept thinking what is the big secret behind all of this? This is gonna be huge! Alas, after 20 issues sadly nothing's happened.

I liked Vol. 2 a great deal. It's very underrated. The only beef I have with it is the way that it ended.

Jephael 04-13-2005 01:45 PM

As far as I can tell, there is no big secret being kept here. Basically, they're all going through one revelation after another concerning either the distant or recent past and how it affects their preception of the present is what keeps the story going.

ZariusTwo 04-13-2005 02:44 PM

Laird is writing the story as spontanious occurence, this is life TMNT style.

The Foiot are still a considerably large part of the current story (Karai's book) the conflicts between Leonardo and Karai over that are quite compelling, and could be the primary catilyst to the resolution to this arc, I love the pacing of this tale, confronting pasts, conflcited presents, it's a fairly good premise and it shows.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.