![]() |
They should have never died
I watched SAINW again...
I'm looking at the cuts Raph and Leo took...I dont care how sharp Karai's katana was, unless it posessed some kind of un-earthly elements, those cuts wouldn't have killed them. Leo's shell, being mutant, would be at least 2x thicker than the average turtle, at least that much. He'd have taken injury but not death THAT easy. and Raph, his injury would have been more seriously but not death, crippling yes. Death, not that quick. Mikey..I dunno, cause we never see, I assumed he was hacked. yea yea i know, its just for story..blablablah... just what i think. dont get me wrong i love the ep... |
Yeah, I never understood why they made them die, I've spent hours pondering that....I mean it doesn't make sense to me, but hey it's their show, they can do whatever...
|
True. Those cuts wouldn't have really killed them. But it's a kids show, and they really can't have plunging katanas and oozing blood shown to children 8-years-old-and-under at 10 A.M.
|
Those weren't the real Ninja Turtles. In a sense they were products of an alternate timeline in which Donatello no longer existed due to his disapearance from the present. Therefore, the deaths of Splinter, Casey, Karai and even Shredder never were real either.
|
Maybe Leo's shell got weaker in middle age??? Yeah, that one bugged me more than the others, especially since one of the earlier episodes showed him deflecting weapons with his shell. But it's plot device I guess... the significance of Karai stabbing him in the back an' all. Even if his back technically shouldn't be stabbable. :tanime:
|
You're absolutly right, Buslady. It was ridiculous the way they died.
I remember you saying that it would have been more believable if Karai had sliced the back of Leo's neck instead. As for Raph, stabbing him through his belly is not possible because of his plastron. Now, if the sword was plunged through his side, between his ribs, that would work since there doesn't seem to be protection on the sides. I really don't care if this is a Saturday morning cartoon; the writers need to keep these things logical and realistic. |
Quote:
As for not showing Katana's plunging into bodies...what about the ep where Leo did just that in a dream sequence to Splinter??? |
Did you stop to think that maybe the cuts arent what killed them? Leo had to fight Karai once again, someone he has in a sense cared for, and she delivered a finishing blow on him. He relaized Mikey was dead and Splinter too. He could have just lost his will to live. Raph as well, he just didnt care about life anymore and let himself die. The wound may not have been fatal but their both old. A heart attack, stressed enduced? They would be around the age for such a thing to happen when they died. Imagine living your entire life feeling loss. And then to be stuck down and watch your family die right in front of you. That's what killed them. An acheing heart, the sword slashes were there to symbolize their loss of life. Well that's how I look at it anyways
|
Although I understand what you mean, Spitfire... I still don't think that would work well...
Both Leo's and Raph's blows were non-fatal. You can't just die simply out of not wanting to live anymore. The body doesn't automaticly shut down like that. Plus, I'm pretty sure they all wanted to live through it. When Raph was struck down, he desperately crawl towards Leo and tried be with him for as long as he could. No matter how depressed a person is, they can't die unless they activly kill them selves or allow them selves to be killed. And I don't think the TMNT allowed themselves to be killed. Also, the TMNT are not old. Turtles can live for several decades. The fact that Splinter out lives the common rat by several times means that the TMNT will out live the common turtle by several times too. I don't even think at 100 the TMNT would be middle aged. Also, being middle aged doesn't mean your going to drop dead from excessive stress... especially if you're a healthy, perfectly fit martial artist. |
Well no one knows how the mutation really is now do we? For Splinter it could do one thing but for the turtles maybe another. The mutation could have caused them to age like humans, or make them weaker in their later years. If Leo had wrinkles I can assume he ages like a human. And once you hit around the age of 40 you could die of a heart attack at any moment*Im baseing this off what I learned in Anatomy class*. That's just my theory. It's also very possible that they didnt put much thought into it and left it up to the viewer to interpet
|
Quote:
Anyway, I understand what you mean. They could age like humans. It is possible, though I like to think they'll live to be at least over two hundred. Plus, to me, they still looked as youthful as they were when they were teens. It seems only the humans aged in that episode. I know that middle aged people can get heart attacks and such... but I doubt that would happen to the TMNT. Splinter shows us that he can do incredible feats and push himself to the limits and still be alright after wards. That's pretty amazing for his age... though there are reasons to why he can do all that without consequences. Martial arts is very good for the mind, body, and soul. |
Quote:
|
True, but I think it's also the case of cramming alot of stuff in one episode. Things were just simply rushed.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I wonder… I wonder if Karai didn’t have a traditional katana after all, but something enhanced with technology. With the technical knowledge of Baxter, and the Utroms, it seems possible. Maybe some sort of sonic weapon, that would send waves into the object at impact, doing far more damage than a physical slice.
The Sword of Tengu looked like a relatively normal sword, and look at the power it had. True, it was very flashy, as Shredder was going for not only sheer power, but I imagine he’d want to make a good impression on his enemies as well. If Karai commissioned something similar, she’d obviously want something less showy. I know, the writers were just trying to get past censors, but if we’re going to dissect this anyway… |
You have to realize that this IS a kids' show so they can't add a lot of stuff...the writers wanted them to die in this episode but they can't get too violent with for young viewers...even though death is strong enough -_-
|
Quote:
The guys (or ladies, however the case may be) who make the storyboards aren't perfect. They'll make mistakes. There was that whole turtles are amphibious, they're not, they are, they're not... bladdy blah blah thing when the show first kicked off. Anywho, yeah, they shouldn't have died. But they did. :ohwell: Interesting indeed. |
Quote:
Quote:
Because of mutation, we dunno what middle age would be for a TMNT. Typical pond turtles can live around 30 -40 but that's been beaten by a 85 year old red ear slider I just heard about. So their life could be doubled by that or cut in half. Who knows. If they kept up their physique, and it looked like they did, they should be in pretty good fighting condition. |
I always assumed that because they were already very human, that they'd age like us too. They can't hold their breath for a long time in this series, they can hold it about as long as us. "What a Croc" proves that with Mikey nearly drowning.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I beg to differ... it IS possible for a body to die if the person has lost hte will to live mentally... HOWEVER... it is a gradual process... it doesn't happen immediately.... often.. the person dies from starvation or malnurition or whatnot... basically, the person is dead mentally, is just wasting away, waiting for the body to finally shut down... Think Episode III: Spoiler:
Think of the novel "Where the Red Fern Grows" Spoiler:
So.. I just wanted to say that Depression can kill people, that losing the will to live can cause one's death. HOWEVER... it doesnt apply in this situation... because in each case, the death was gradual... it didn't happen suddenly... So in this situation... you COULD argue that Leo and Ralph lost the will to live, but... they would still be alive, physically... |
That theory doesn't hold much weight since they were all fighting for their lives.
|
Quote:
I understand what you mean, IceFlash78... But I was obviously speaking in the sense of dropping dead all of a sudden because you have just given up the will to live. And like Krow said, they were all fighting for their lives and for each other. They obviously wanted to get out of the fight alive. They especially developed a new hope and a high enthusiasm to live when they discovered that Donnie was alive and well. |
There are also several visual cues that the "future" Turtles are somewhere around middle age. The most obvious is Raph's face right as he collapses at Leo's side. It suddenly droops into these wrinkles... kinda creepy, actually; he looks like an old man. Turtle, that is.
But I don't worry too much about whether it should have happened or not. I tend to concentrate on why it happened (as well as any significance about how it happened), and how the characters (Don in this case) react to it. |
Quote:
Now this is just my theory and it's something to go by. Since the creators will never offer us a reason why. It is just a TV show and a kids one at that. By basic TV show standards those are killing blows Raph and Leo took. For all we know the creators didnt have any of this in mind. Im just trying to come up with reasons for them. |
That's a nice theory, but it doesn't really mean that they lost their will to live. I read it as you saying that they decided to sacrifice their lives instead for the greater good.
Bit of a difference, there. |
Well, I have a theory.
Maybe Karai's sword was dipped in poison that kills instantly. Just a thought. :) |
Maybe...it's a good idea Ben, but the sword wouldn't even have made a cut on Leo's shell when he was swiped and the posion would've been very fast acting because he fell to the floor straight away. To get past his shell and Raph's plaston, the sword would've had to be made of a super-strong metal. I did an assignment for History last term on Medieval Weapons and Armor. The best metal to use to make swords were (and most likely still are) Magnesium and Titanium. These metals are strong like iron, yet light weight. If Karai's sword wasn't made of any metal like the Sword of Tengu, it would've deffinatly had one, or maybe even both of the metals in her sword. With the right force, the Medieval swords could cut clean through the weilder's enemies, stright through the bone. Considering that a turtle's shell and plaston is basically bone, it's most likely how Karai could kill Leo and Raph
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:03 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.