The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   NO-bad review from hollywood reporter (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=18893)

tambour 03-17-2007 02:49 PM

NO-bad review from hollywood reporter
 
Even CGI doesn't pump much life into these kung fu critters. The new film's calculations show the most in the mix of tame violence to maintain a PG rating and youthful humor and a skateboarding sequence to keep the appeal broad. Ultimately, the movie seems driven more by the need to keep a toy line and franchise alive than any creative inspiration.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/....jsp?&rid=8927

VaughnMichael 03-17-2007 02:55 PM

even worse the basterds website made my computer crash! *shakes fist*:lol:
ok now I'm reading this guys review...what a tard will people get it through there damn heads once and for all kids today are not as stupid as grownups things geez and we wonder why we have crap on tv like barny.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-17-2007 03:00 PM

What kind of review was that? Most of it was a synopsis of the movie. They didn't give any good reasons why the movie was "bad". There was as much thought put into that, as there is in an average Fox sitcom.

johnnyblaze 03-17-2007 03:06 PM

oh well, can't win em' all even though they never gave a reason as to why they disliked it in their review.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-17-2007 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 478066)
oh well, can't win em' all even though they never gave a reason as to why they disliked it in their review.

Exactly, it's completley bogus.

1. The review obviously has never seen/read any of the interviews with Kevin that show how passionate he is about the franchise.

2. they only remember the Turtles from the old show, and thats clouding they're judgement some.

Cure 03-17-2007 05:38 PM

He gives plenty of reasons as to why he didn't like it. The plastic-y animation, the contrived family values, the afterthought villainy, the recycled sci-fi.........................

.............or are you guys automatically bashing his review because it's something you don't wanna hear? :roll:

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-17-2007 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cure4AIDS (Post 478135)
He gives plenty of reasons as to why he didn't like it. The plastic-y animation, the contrived family values, the afterthought villainy, the recycled sci-fi.........................

.............or are you guys automatically bashing his review because it's something you don't wanna hear? :roll:

It would have been helpfull if he gave better examples. Like I said, most of the review was just a synopsis of the movie.

Kendamu 03-17-2007 06:46 PM

I'm not worried about it. For every single douchebag reviewer who can't remember anything beyond Bebop or Vanilla Ice there's probably a buttload of kids who have the exact opposite opinion. So Hollywood Reporter can go rot in Hell for not taking about 20 minutes to find an interview with Kevin or look at a short synopsis of the previous TMNT movies to get an idea of where this is going.

Raph'N'Roll 03-17-2007 10:15 PM

Well that guy's an idiot for thinking the animation was "plastic-y" I was blown away by it, and believe me I'd be first to criticize it.

Spitfire 03-17-2007 11:38 PM

Wow I stopped reading here "Bottom Line: This one feels and acts so '90s"

Good because newer movies suck ass anyways. I'll gladly invite the 90's to return.

Rooish 03-17-2007 11:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cure4AIDS (Post 478135)
He gives plenty of reasons as to why he didn't like it. The plastic-y animation, the contrived family values, the afterthought villainy, the recycled sci-fi.........................

.............or are you guys automatically bashing his review because it's something you don't wanna hear? :roll:

Heh, good point. I think I may feel the same way about the latter three complaints when I see the movie (especially the contrived family values, if that is indeed what happens). Although the animation looks good.

SavantiRomero 03-18-2007 02:05 AM

Family Values was a big part of the whole movie, without it, the story wouldn't have worked. Contrived? It was overspoken in certain scenes, otherwise it was well done. Can't please everyone all the time. I think this movie did awsome in trying to level the pleasing all round.

As to plasticy animation, it was not the absolute best CGI animation I've seen, but alot of that was contributed to the fact that the models were kept in a semi-cartoon state so in all honesty, the animation at times, did look a bit (but not too much) unrealistic.

I personally believe that a few weapons hit the ground a little to flat (no bounce at all) but those were little things. You can however tell that even the CGI artists/animators were spending ALOT of time/care on the main focus of the movie :D.

I read the article. While I don't personally agree with everything they say, I can see their point/view.

Buslady 03-18-2007 09:25 AM

NEVER listen to those "professional" critics, they see nothing but bad in movies like these.
WHen people were coming out, we'd ask them if they liked it...ALL of the folks we asked said it was good. So...the general public views it as a good movie.

Warhorse 03-18-2007 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 478543)
NEVER listen to those "professional" critics, they see nothing but bad in movies like these.
WHen people were coming out, we'd ask them if they liked it...ALL of the folks we asked said it was good. So...the general public views it as a good movie.

You know, you are right about some of them critics, if not 90% of them. All they really do, is to concentrate on what they did not like about the movie, and to actually look for something to be wrong. I thought critics should be people who like to watch movies, not the opposite. And it's beyond me why people worry about what the (pros) think. They are not of the majority, at least not in my neck of the woods. I'd say. listen to what the regular joe says. Word of mouth, the animation is kick ass, the personalities and voices are as perfect as one can get. The only thing that people seem to not like is the sub plot of the monsters. But I think they wanted to save the foot rebuild stories for a sequel (if there is one) where they can produce a PG-13 flick as opposed to a PG one.

Raph's Girl 03-18-2007 12:07 PM

I read that so called review several days ago. The reviewer also states that this is the first foray for the TMNT into CGI.

See..these reporters (like that other idiot reviewer who states that Next Mutation was a cartoon) need to do what is called RESEARCH. Otherwise, he would have known that this was indeed not the first try out at CGI due to the proposed CGI tv series that you can go see the pilot of at the official TMNT site. :roll:

johnnyblaze 03-18-2007 12:15 PM

its not a big deal--besides how many positive reviews have we seen compared to the negative ones

Rooish 03-18-2007 12:31 PM

The positive reviews are all from TMNT fans, though.

johnnyblaze 03-18-2007 12:38 PM

so? isn't that what matters the most--that the fans like it

kerfootw 03-18-2007 01:31 PM

I read that a couple of months ago. He didn't say too much about the movie and talked about history. The $hithead!

BigApple3AM 03-18-2007 02:35 PM

Careful guys. You're sounding way too defensive. If someone didn't like it that's fine. I saw it and would only give it like a C. I still love the turtles, and it was great seeing them on the big screen, but if you thought this was going to be a hit with the critics you were deluding yourselves. It was really cheesey, but the name sort of implies that, or at least it used to. I don't think they ever say Teenage or Mutant in the movie. I thought the name was a great part of the turtles, i only abbreviate because I'm lazy, but for the movie I think they should have kept it spelled out. I think the CG made it pretty obvious that it wasn't going to be the same as the first film and that this would be a new thing mostly for little kids. Anyway enough of that tangent.

I disagree with a lot of the review but agree with others. The animation models themselves didn't give much to work with, I really REALLY hate that April. I remember the cover from the beginning of the original comics, with April and the guys standing around, then think of the movie April and really wonder where it went wrong. A lot the characters seemed more like charicatures of their old selves. Even though Pete was involved, if you're expecting anything like the mirage comics... DON'T. Go in expecting Turtles meets Power Rangers and your expectations won't be lowered like mine were.

Rooish 03-18-2007 02:44 PM

Yeah ... I still don't like that everyone's design is freakish, and not just the Turtles'.

sgtfbomb 03-18-2007 03:00 PM

[QUOTE=Goongasnootch;478158]I'm not worried about it. For every single douchebag reviewer who can't remember anything beyond Bebop or Vanilla Ice there's probably a buttload of kids who have the exact opposite opinion. So Hollywood Reporter can go rot in Hell for not taking about 20 minutes to find an interview with Kevin or look at a short synopsis of the previous TMNT movies to get an idea of where this is going.[/QUOTE]

Now thats not right..it's only the critics job to watch the movie and review, he doesnt have to research it or it's creators. TMNT isn't for everyone, nor is any film. Continuing to bash critics for hating something you like gets to be pretty hypocritical when you know that if this guy gave a good review, you'd be praising it, whether he did his research or not, which is not his job.

kerfootw 03-18-2007 03:09 PM

An imdb member who lives in Manchester said that it was terrible. So then one of the members made fun of her name, I commented laughing at how good the retort was.

johnnyblaze 03-18-2007 03:13 PM

its not going to win everyone over. even films like Spider-Man 2 and Batman Begins have people that say it sucked so its best not to get so bent out of shape over it. at the end of the day its what you get from the film that matters.

Whitewolf89 03-18-2007 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 478543)
NEVER listen to those "professional" critics, they see nothing but bad in movies like these.
WHen people were coming out, we'd ask them if they liked it...ALL of the folks we asked said it was good. So...the general public views it as a good movie.

Good point, sys. I never pay much attention to what reviewers OR critics say about a movie myself.

For instance, the critics all raved about how good the first Dukes of Hazzard movie was (and most of them denigrated the wonderfully funny TV series that inspired it), but to me (after reluctantly agreeing to watch the DVD release with my niece), it confirmed my opinion that it was nothing but a idiotic, decidedly UN-funny and ridiculous parody of the original series itself. jessica Simpson as Daisy and Willy Nelson as Uncle Jesse were just....wrong, that's the long and the short of it.)

And besides, IF you look at the track record of MOST reviewers and critic, 9 times out of 10, the movie that they pan or put down will be the most popular with the fans. The difference between them and us is that WE go to a movie because we love the characters and/or story. THEY watch them 9and most of the time DIS them) because they're PAID to (supposedly) be objective, but IF the don't like a flick, there's no way in shell that they're gonna say anything good about it.

And that's MY $0.02 cents on the matter!

Oooops! Times up, peeps! See yas all tonight sometime!

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-18-2007 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ectocooler (Post 478690)
Careful guys. You're sounding way too defensive. If someone didn't like it that's fine. I saw it and would only give it like a C. I still love the turtles, and it was great seeing them on the big screen, but if you thought this was going to be a hit with the critics you were deluding yourselves. It was really cheesey, but the name sort of implies that, or at least it used to. I don't think they ever say Teenage or Mutant in the movie. I thought the name was a great part of the turtles, i only abbreviate because I'm lazy, but for the movie I think they should have kept it spelled out. I think the CG made it pretty obvious that it wasn't going to be the same as the first film and that this would be a new thing mostly for little kids. Anyway enough of that tangent.

I disagree with a lot of the review but agree with others. The animation models themselves didn't give much to work with, I really REALLY hate that April. I remember the cover from the beginning of the original comics, with April and the guys standing around, then think of the movie April and really wonder where it went wrong. A lot the characters seemed more like charicatures of their old selves. Even though Pete was involved, if you're expecting anything like the mirage comics... DON'T. Go in expecting Turtles meets Power Rangers and your expectations won't be lowered like mine were.

How about I go in expecting it to be excellent. That okay with you?

BigApple3AM 03-18-2007 04:24 PM

Sure - if you have low standards :lol:

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-18-2007 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ectocooler (Post 478761)
Sure - if you have low standards :lol:

If I wasn't so in-check, I'd flame you for that one.

Rooish 03-18-2007 05:23 PM

There's another crappy review on Rottentomatoes.com now. It can be found at http://www.slantmagazine.com/film/fi...ew.asp?ID=2861

johnnyblaze 03-18-2007 05:28 PM

Quote:

If the monsters, which the powerful Max Winters (Patrick Stewart) has been trying to find with the help of the Foot Clan and the story's resuscitated stone soldiers, have been wreaking havoc on the earth for three millennia, why is this the first time anyone has heard anything about them?More importantly, why are they all chillin' in the Big Apple?
I thought the monsters were supposed to be creatures from urban legends : bigfoot, jersey devil, vampire monster etc.

plus there was a line in the novel where Winters explains why the monsters are suddenly showing up in NYC. He explained it as their animal instinct leading them there because of the stars lineing up, about to open the gateway to where they originally came from--did it get cut from the film?

tambour 03-18-2007 05:36 PM

Variety don't like it either

http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117...ryid=1263&cs=1

Conceived for fans but dumbed down for tots, "TMNT" takes one of the most curious comicbook phenoms of the '80s and translates it to yet another platform: a PG-rated all-CG toon. Animation quality is leagues beyond the hand-drawn style that launched the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to popularity, and the storyline is no shallower than "300" (even if ripped turtle shells have nothing on Spartan abs), but pic lacks the personality that made these animated action figures so appealing 20 years ago. Kids will devour this like anchovy-free pizza, while nostalgia-driven kidult attendance should spell sequels for this "cash cowabunga."

Warhorse 03-18-2007 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 478797)
There's another crappy review on Rottentomatoes.com now. It can be found at http://www.slantmagazine.com/film/fi...ew.asp?ID=2861

Don't worry about the critics. If the movie is any good, (judging by the clips, it looks like to be quite the TMNT crowd pleaser) than it will be fine. Just go and watch it so you can form your own opinion.

I'm going because I like to see the Turtles on the big screen. The characters look to be down pat, and the cgi is awesome. And you have that big climatic Leo vs Raph fight. How cool is that?

Rooish 03-18-2007 05:36 PM

I'm not sure, johnnyblaze; I'm not seeing it until Friday. Looks like the whole board will have seen it before me. I actually think it's pretty cool that they're all monsters from urban legends.

Does anyone know how many "urban legend" monsters are in the movie, and which ones they are?

BigApple3AM 03-18-2007 05:38 PM

I assumed that clarified that at the very beginning. I missed like the first 2-3 minutes because my dumbass brother HAD to have a $5 icee.

If it wasn't in those 3 minutes, then they don't say anything about it in the film. They don't give any of the monsters names, and the "jersey devil" had about as much screen time as slimer did in the original ghostbusters movie.

The first reviewer was fine in my opinion, but the second link posted was harsh and not really proffessional. Who uses the word "lame" when writing movie reviews for a living? He brings up good points but doesn't execute his writing well.

I kind of agree with Variety too. I think maybe they should have let TMNT die down a bit and then boosted it with a movie, then again maybe they wouldn't be able to get the greenlite then. It was good and the Raph vs Leo fight was AWESOME.
Spoiler:
Leo's my fav but the outcome of that fight was perfect!

johnnyblaze 03-18-2007 05:41 PM

hmmm weird that the answers to some of the questions seem to show up in the novel but not the film. damn editing

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-18-2007 05:48 PM

I'd be more respectfull of the reviews if the ignorance in them weren't so obvious.

Quote:

I kind of agree with Variety too. I think maybe they should have let TMNT die down a bit and then boosted it with a movie, then again maybe they wouldn't be able to get the greenlite then. It was good and the Raph vs Leo fight was AWESOME.
Haven't they died down enough. I mean, alot of people didn't even know the new show exsisted.

Rooish 03-18-2007 05:57 PM

But isn't it best when people can go into a movie ignorant on a subject, and then the movie is clear enough and well-constructed enough to enlighten them?

Peanut 03-18-2007 06:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 478816)
But isn't it best when people can go into a movie ignorant on a subject, and then the movie is clear enough and well-constructed enough to enlighten them?

You got it, brotha. People who use the, "They just don't know about the subject!" excuse are in heavy denial.

Everyone needs to just stop slamming on critics at this point. As long as you like the movie, who cares? And just because it's the turtles doesn't mean we all need to ignore all the things that may be negative about the movie. I really think people need to stop trying to convince themselves they'll enjoy the movie, and just see it and find out for themselves.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-18-2007 06:04 PM

Quote:

but pic lacks the personality that made these animated action figures so appealing 20 years ago
What exactly do they mean by that. The fact that it's not all slapstick anymore. This is exactly what I feared. The old show stigma strikes again.

BigApple3AM 03-18-2007 06:25 PM

Hmm, since it's a movie critic I'd guess they're talking about the first few films. The first movie was as slapstick as this movie was imo. Mikey was in my opinion much worse in the new movie than he was in the original cartoon.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:02 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.