The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Despite it being called a "lose sequel".... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19179)

Mandi-chan 03-25-2007 07:46 PM

Despite it being called a "lose sequel"....
 
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

Revan 03-25-2007 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

I completely agree with you. It seems more like the new bond sequel. More recent but same ages. I just try not to think about it because the movie was so great. After so long, we get a great tmnt movie... life is good

SLASH!!! 03-25-2007 07:50 PM

So you don't see it as any kind of sequal because of the 17 year time and technology difference?

Mr. Snackpants 03-25-2007 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now?

Are you serious?

ZariusTwo 03-25-2007 07:52 PM

I'll go with the official source. Loose sequel. Besides, you're using "real time" for much of your criticisms. Deal with it.

Mandi-chan 03-25-2007 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Snackpants (Post 483900)
Are you serious?

Uh, yes.

Is there a problem with that? Did they look or act like they were in their 30's to you?

Revan 03-25-2007 07:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now?

No. There is a big gap in between movies but the events supposedly happen shortly after movie 3. :roll:

Warhorse 03-25-2007 07:54 PM

You know, the first movie may have been released in 1990, but I don't recall the movie being placed in 1990. I don't remember the new movie being placed in exact year either.:ohwell:

Starkiller 03-25-2007 07:55 PM

This is one of those things I'm just not going to put a lot of thought into, otherwise my head will hurt. You might have noticed some artifacts from previous movies during the scene where Splinter places Max Winter's helmet on a shelf next to Shredder's. You can see the sceptre from the third film along with a few other familiar objects.

It works as a sequel on the one hand because if we take into account the events of the previous movies, we know why/how the Shredder died and who the Foot Clan, April and Casey are, not to mention how the Turtles came to be. But then there are many facts which don't add up at all. So it is just like the Bond films or Superman Returns in that respect.

Revan 03-25-2007 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 483910)
You know, the first movie may have been released in 1990, but I don't recall the movie being placed in 1990. I don't remember the new movie being placed in exact year either.:ohwell:

Did they subtitle the year that Winters first opened the portal. Because if they did then we could do the math and determine the exact year.

ToTheNines 03-25-2007 07:58 PM

But what about how Morpheus says in the begining "they defeated many enemies before destroying the Shredder".... The turtles fought no one before the Shredder in the original movies

Mr. Snackpants 03-25-2007 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483908)
Uh, yes.

Is there a problem with that? Did they look or act like they were in their 30's to you?

No, because they aren't. Just because the previous movies were made around 15 years ago doesn't mean this movie is set 15 years prior.

Mandi-chan 03-25-2007 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Starkiller (Post 483913)
This is one of those things I'm just not going to put a lot of thought into, otherwise my head will hurt. You might have noticed some artifacts from previous movies during the scene where Splinter places Max Winter's helmet on a shelf next to Shredder's. You can see the sceptre from the third film along with a few other familiar objects.

It works as a sequel on the one hand because if we take into account the events of the previous movies, we know why/how the Shredder died and who the Foot Clan, April and Casey are, not to mention how the Turtles came to be. But then there are many facts which don't add up at all. So it is just like the Bond films or Superman Returns in that respect.

I DID notice the sceptre from the third movie there...but like some of the one liners in the movie, took it to be more of a homage to the original films.

I've already listed the things about this movie that didn't add up to me to make this a sequel...plus it didn't feel like a continuation to those films to me.

But that's just how I felt, I guess I'm alone huh?:D

Revan 03-25-2007 08:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 483917)
But what about how Morpheus says in the begining "they defeated many enemies before destroying the Shredder".... The turtles fought no one before the Shredder in the original movies

Sure they did. They beat up street thugs, foot soldiers, tokka rahzar, tatsu... so on so on so on

ToTheNines 03-25-2007 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neutrino (Post 483923)
Sure they did. They beat up street thugs, foot soldiers, tokka rahzar, tatsu... so on so on so on

Hmmm... ya got me

Starkiller 03-25-2007 08:11 PM

Quote:

I DID notice the sceptre from the third movie there...but like some of the one liners in the movie, took it to be more of a homage to the original films.

I've already listed the things about this movie that didn't add up to me to make this a sequel...plus it didn't feel like a continuation to those films to me.

But that's just how I felt, I guess I'm alone huh?
Well there are reasons for and against it being a sequel. I don't think you'll be alone in your opinion, I'm just choosing to cop out and not make one at all because I can't decide and see no reason to. I enjoy TMNT as it stands; a loose sequel. I like the idea of it being a sequel, but I agree that it does not feel like a continuation of the previous films.

TheAnimatedSeries 03-26-2007 01:24 AM

I think of it like this, you can too. The first films are what you see when you watch them. They're in the 90's, they are what they are.

This new movie says those events happend. The Turtles defeated the Shredder. The Turtles went back in time. The Turtles did that stuff, that is their history, but it is not necessarily as it was portrayed in those movies. Maybe it didnt happen in the early 90's, maybe they never met Vanilla Ice, but the major events still happend.

Thats how I see it anyway, and I can eat 28 slices of pizza in one sitting.

AquaParade 03-26-2007 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheAnimatedSeries (Post 484132)
Thats how I see it anyway, and I can eat 28 slices of pizza in one sitting.

hahaha, good way to prove your knowledge.

DrSpengler 03-26-2007 10:44 AM

Eh, I see it as a "personal canon" thing. As a "loose sequel" the audience if given the priviledge of deciding exactly what that means.

Personally, I like to think of it as a sequel to the first movie, ignoring Secret of the Ooze and TMNT III, becuase I thought the tones of those two films didn't fit in at all.

But that's my personal canon and it doesn't extend past anyone but myself.

Who knows, maybe the sequel will throw in lots of indisputable references to II and III and I'll have to readjust my opinion?

I take it as a matter of preference.

Straight-Edge 03-26-2007 10:50 AM

I kind of felt like the Movie was a sequel to the old movies, but *also* a natural progression from the new cartoon series (ignoring Fast Forward).

I think some work was put into the script so that while it didn't call back to anything from the 'toon, it also didn't contradict anything either. Cuz, if you think about it, all those kids in the theater are growing up on the new cartoon, and if they've been watching dilligently, nothing in the movie should come as a surprise to them.

Shredder's "gone"? Sure, that's what happened in the show.
April and Casey are together? Yup, a year later they would be a closer couple.
Karai, who's she? Shredder's replacement.
Turtles and the Foot? In an uneasy but trustless cease-fire.

Seriously looking at it, the movie assumes all these characters know each other, and everything that doesn't pertain to this specific plot is very vague backstory, so that if you saw the old movies, you're up to speed. If you know the new cartoon, your're up to speed. So it pretty much worked as the "next step" for either fanbase.

Draconic 03-26-2007 10:53 AM

I like to think of it like this:

It's just another legend of the TMNT to me, it's another story about them, and the movie is an interpretation of the legend. The movie is a representation of what happened, as though they were the imaginings of a storyteller.

Does it matter that she used a cell phone instead of a phone booth? Not really, all that matters is that in the story, she called.

gobo 03-26-2007 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

That's what's so loose about it. ^_^

Willis 03-26-2007 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

The homages really what define it as a sequel. More importantly it proves that this isn't starting all from scratch, the Turtles do have some history that can fall back on.

If they didn't have this, people DEFINITELY would be questioning why there is no Shredder or any characters like that.

And yes, April has a different job. I don't remember what she was doing in the second or third movies.. but I do remember she got fired in the first movie from being a news reporter. Maybe new jobs just didn't work out and she decided to start her own business?

jeff the cheff 03-26-2007 02:40 PM

These are some good points that claim TMNT is not really a sequel. But they aren't the same age in this film, they are supposed to be about 18 or so. They don't say it in the movie, but I think Kevin Munroe said it somewhere, and mike and don have jobs, which seems like they are older than 15-16.

Starkiller 03-26-2007 03:58 PM

Quote:

And yes, April has a different job. I don't remember what she was doing in the second or third movies.. but I do remember she got fired in the first movie from being a news reporter. Maybe new jobs just didn't work out and she decided to start her own business?
April was fired halfway through the first movie, but she got her job back by the end of it.

Kunoichi_Haruko 03-26-2007 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Starkiller (Post 484574)
April was fired halfway through the first movie, but she got her job back by the end of it.

And she was definitely a reporter all of the second movie. It's the third movie that's filled with uncertainty...I think...I may have to watch it again...

TheAnimatedSeries 03-26-2007 04:14 PM

I dont think it references anything about her job in the third movie. At the begining she is about to go on vacation, so its possible she could be taking a vacation from her reporting job given the sway she has (highest paid reporter, biggest window office).

Starkiller 03-26-2007 04:15 PM

Quote:

And she was definitely a reporter all of the second movie. It's the third movie that's filled with uncertainty...I think...I may have to watch it again...
Yeah, I don't think the third film states her job title at all. I guess it's not important as the first two films stated April's occupation and the bulk of Movie 3 takes place in ancient Japan, so it's really irrelevant to the plot.

TheAnimatedSeries 03-26-2007 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Draconic (Post 484302)
I like to think of it like this:

It's just another legend of the TMNT to me, it's another story about them, and the movie is an interpretation of the legend. The movie is a representation of what happened, as though they were the imaginings of a storyteller.

Does it matter that she used a cell phone instead of a phone booth? Not really, all that matters is that in the story, she called.

Thats just how I see it. Alot of people get hung up on those things that are irrelevant. Bond can use a cell phone because people use them now, but CR can take place in the same universe as the other films by just assiming those events will happen to him.

If you want to debate about things and say it cant be a sequel because they would be older, I would suggest this cant be a sequel to the original movies because it doesnt explain why their world is made by computers now.

Dragnskull 03-26-2007 06:23 PM

personally, im just going with it being yet another world of our TMNT

theres:
TMNT: The comics
TMNT: Volume 3
TMNT: Archie
TMNT: Oldschool Cartoon
TMNT: Newschool Cartoon
TMNT: movies 1 and 2

and now there is a new addition:

TMNT: New movie

and personaly, i dont mind, i loved it. but honostly, i fyou think about it, this movie had tie-ins that allowed it to match up with just about any of the tmnt timelines.

-April was doing artifact-ancient stuff: her antique shop in the comics, in TMNT1, and new cartoon i believe
-Shredder was gone: Comics, Movies, and new toon
-Karai was there: Comics and new toon
-Foot soldiers were gg ninjas: Comics, New toon
-Sci-fie/alienish things were happening: Comics, New Toon
-The collections on splinters shelf: Movie

and honoslty, if you watched the old toons alone, you could walk into that movie, and come out, although not knowing of what exactly happened, still being able to comprehend how it would tie in with the old 80's cartoon you knew and loved.

think about it, honostly i think he made it so that it can relate to any of the timelines you knew about most.

sdp 04-06-2007 11:10 PM

I was going to make a topic about this same thing.

I wanted this movie to be in continuity until recently, its a whole different universe adding the other movies does nothing to the film.

This is clearly a different continuity, these turtles would have handled TMNT1-3 totally different.

The old movie "trophy" room can be just a generic trophy room, many turtle universes have defeated the Shredder, and the time scepter? well why can't it exist in this continuity as well? many TMNT universes share stuff.

This movie has to be a different continuity.

Shark_Blade 04-07-2007 12:58 AM

The movie happens a while after movie 3. The technology is cool because we don't want to look lame now do we? So life is good, they are cool:)

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-07-2007 01:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan (Post 483893)
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

It's called retconing. DC comics does it all the time.

johnnyblaze 04-07-2007 09:04 AM

even if it is a loose sequel now I expect it to 100% become its own animal by the possible sequel


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.