The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   A plot hole that bugged me...SPOILERS!!! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19191)

longbowhunter 03-25-2007 11:03 PM

A plot hole that bugged me...SPOILERS!!!
 
When Casey first sees "The Nightwatcher" he knows right off the bat that its Raph because..."he looks like a giant metal turtle". But when Leo and The Nightwatcher fight,Leo doesnt know who it is...he even acts shocked when Raphs helmet comes off. You're telling me Leo couldnt even recognize his own brother? At the very least he should have recognized Raphs fighting style as someone who was trained by Master Splinter. Ok...I know I'm over-thinking this waayyyy too much,it just bugged me.

Jester 03-25-2007 11:07 PM

No...don't be sorry. I felt the same way, especially when i watched it the second time, just a few minutes ago.

bmxbandit 03-25-2007 11:09 PM

maybe after being gone for over a year he didn't recognize him as much as casey did as casey sees him more? all 4 turtles had a convo about the nightwatcher previous to the encounter and raph didn't let on that he was the nightwatcher. that is how i took it.

Jester 03-25-2007 11:11 PM

*shrugs* In his Scrapbook, Mikey puts it all together, does he know it's raphie?

Seiza 03-25-2007 11:16 PM

You'd think the three fingers on the Nightwatcher would've clued Leo in. XD

Perhaps Leo was so focused on finding Raph (I presume that's why he was hanging around above ground) that it never clicked that the Nightwatcher looked and fought like Raph. I can just imagine Leo going into auto-nagging mode...

Revan 03-25-2007 11:47 PM

Just try not to think of it is the best I can say. Yes it's strange but we have all had senior moments. Perhaps Leo just had a brain fart.

Shark 03-25-2007 11:54 PM

I noticed this in the first place. I assumed Leo KNEW he was Raph the whole time, same way Casey did. But when Raph lost the helmet, and Leo was shocked, I was more like, 'What the ****?' I even said it out loud, while I was sitting next to some young kids. This did annoy me, but I didn't care too much as I still enjoyed it. I would of prefered Casey not of guessed it actually.

bmxbandit 03-26-2007 12:17 AM

it was also raining when they fought so maybe the rain blurred his vision ;)

Revan 03-26-2007 12:32 AM

Leo was quite preoccupied during the confrontation. He was angry with the nightwatcher and had never seen him before. Casey has most likey seen many photos of the nightwatcher. Studying photos and comparing them to the turtles. Put 2 and 2 together.

iris 03-26-2007 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by longbowhunter (Post 484060)
When Casey first sees "The Nightwatcher" he knows right off the bat that its Raph because..."he looks like a giant metal turtle". But when Leo and The Nightwatcher fight,Leo doesnt know who it is...he even acts shocked when Raphs helmet comes off. You're telling me Leo couldnt even recognize his own brother? At the very least he should have recognized Raphs fighting style as someone who was trained by Master Splinter. Ok...I know I'm over-thinking this waayyyy too much,it just bugged me.

I thought that said a bunch about Leo's state of mind. Leo was supposed to be out looking for Raph-- at least I figured that's what Splinter wanted him to do. What does he do instead? He chases down this Nightwatcher character, whose very existence seems to annoy him, and picks a fight. Heaven forbid the Nightwatcher move in on Leo's crimefighting territory; I bet Leo might even think Nightwatcher is a copycat.

But Leo's distracting himself with the Nightwatcher confrontation, even though he knows that's not his top priority. Because Leo's angry at a bunch of things at this point-- at Raph, and the injustice of taking the blame as the older brother, possibly at himself. So in a nice little ironic twist, even as Leo is lecturing Nightwatcher about how raw anger can make you lose sight of your objective, Leo's cold fury narrows his vision. He doesn't see something that probably would have been patently obvious to him if he'd been calm and nonjudgemental, like Casey was. So Leo surprises Nightwatcher, and then Nightwatcher surprises the hell outta Leo... both for about the same reason.

(Or not. I think maybe I think too much.)

ETA: Or, what Neutrino said more efficiently. ;)

VaughnMichael 03-26-2007 02:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iris (Post 484119)
I thought that said a bunch about Leo's state of mind. Leo was supposed to be out looking for Raph-- at least I figured that's what Splinter wanted him to do. What does he do instead? He chases down this Nightwatcher character, whose very existence seems to annoy him, and picks a fight. Heaven forbid the Nightwatcher move in on Leo's crimefighting territory; I bet Leo might even think Nightwatcher is a copycat.

But Leo's distracting himself with the Nightwatcher confrontation, even though he knows that's not his top priority. Because Leo's angry at a bunch of things at this point-- at Raph, and the injustice of taking the blame as the older brother, possibly at himself. So in a nice little ironic twist, even as Leo is lecturing Nightwatcher about how raw anger can make you lose sight of your objective, Leo's cold fury narrows his vision. He doesn't see something that probably would have been patently obvious to him if he'd been calm and nonjudgemental, like Casey was. So Leo surprises Nightwatcher, and then Nightwatcher surprises the hell outta Leo... both for about the same reason.

(Or not. I think maybe I think too much.)

ETA: Or, what Neutrino said more efficiently. ;)

nah I think what you said pretty much sums it up!
When Leo saw Him I'd like to add he also goes hmm at one point I think..

johnnyblaze 03-26-2007 05:10 AM

I don't see how its a plot hole that Leo did'nt notice Raph was the Nightwatcher but Casey did. He probably just didnt notice the shape of his hands, and his back armor looked like a backpack and not a shell. and its obvious he didn't think it was something Raph would do (thus his shock when he found out what Raph was doing)

plus I don't think he was chasing down Nightwatcher when he was supposed to be lookign for Raph. The impression I got was that he was looking for Raph and came across the diner--where the man was screaming inside for the Nightwatcher not to hurt him and the Nightwatcher was holding the tray of money. He obviously observed /heard the yelling considering he sent the blade flying into the store and into the cash register to get Nightwatcher's attention. It seemed to me he was looking for Raph and found the Nightwatcher instead (and when he found him the situation it looked alot worse than it actually was and caused him to react) not that he was looking for the Nightwatcher and ignoring Raph.

Shark 03-26-2007 05:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 484200)
plus I don't think he was chasing down Nightwatcher when he was supposed to be lookign for Raph. The impression I got was that he was looking for Raph and came across the diner--where the man was screaming inside for the Nightwatcher not to hurt him and the Nightwatcher was holding the tray of money. He obviously observed /heard the yelling considering he sent the blade flying into the store and into the cash register to get Nightwatcher's attention. It seemed to me he was looking for Raph and found the Nightwatcher instead (and when he found him the situation it looked alot worse than it actually was and caused him to react) not that he was looking for the Nightwatcher and ignoring Raph.

I think we all noticed this already...

gobo 03-26-2007 05:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iris (Post 484119)
I thought that said a bunch about Leo's state of mind. Leo was supposed to be out looking for Raph-- at least I figured that's what Splinter wanted him to do. What does he do instead? He chases down this Nightwatcher character, whose very existence seems to annoy him, and picks a fight. Heaven forbid the Nightwatcher move in on Leo's crimefighting territory; I bet Leo might even think Nightwatcher is a copycat.

But Leo's distracting himself with the Nightwatcher confrontation, even though he knows that's not his top priority. Because Leo's angry at a bunch of things at this point-- at Raph, and the injustice of taking the blame as the older brother, possibly at himself. So in a nice little ironic twist, even as Leo is lecturing Nightwatcher about how raw anger can make you lose sight of your objective, Leo's cold fury narrows his vision. He doesn't see something that probably would have been patently obvious to him if he'd been calm and nonjudgemental, like Casey was. So Leo surprises Nightwatcher, and then Nightwatcher surprises the hell outta Leo... both for about the same reason.

(Or not. I think maybe I think too much.)

ETA: Or, what Neutrino said more efficiently. ;)

^^ Exactly why I thought this wasn't necessarily a plot-hole. The Nightwatcher's very existence ticked Leo off. Raph's insubordination ticked Leo off. When he was sent to find Raph, his frustration was growing. So, when he saw The Nightwatcher, he knew that was a chance to blow off some steam before he found Raph. His righteous indignation blinded him from the obvious. It's all likely occurences in psychological terms.

Shark 03-26-2007 06:06 AM

The more I think about it, the more I realise this CAN'T be a plothole. Many of us saw this and noticed it the first time. It's VERY hard to miss, so the creators HAD to of easily noticed this just like us. I doubt they'd slip it through just to fool stupid kids, knowing that the majority of people who will see the movie will be a little smarter than kids. So they must of had their own reasons to make this 'plothole', so I'm sure one(some) of you guys are right.

Buslady 03-26-2007 08:09 AM

Who really cares? Leo's reaction was well worth it all.

Jo Dawn 03-26-2007 08:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iris (Post 484119)
I thought that said a bunch about Leo's state of mind. Leo was supposed to be out looking for Raph-- at least I figured that's what Splinter wanted him to do. What does he do instead? He chases down this Nightwatcher character, whose very existence seems to annoy him, and picks a fight. Heaven forbid the Nightwatcher move in on Leo's crimefighting territory; I bet Leo might even think Nightwatcher is a copycat.

But Leo's distracting himself with the Nightwatcher confrontation, even though he knows that's not his top priority. Because Leo's angry at a bunch of things at this point-- at Raph, and the injustice of taking the blame as the older brother, possibly at himself. So in a nice little ironic twist, even as Leo is lecturing Nightwatcher about how raw anger can make you lose sight of your objective, Leo's cold fury narrows his vision. He doesn't see something that probably would have been patently obvious to him if he'd been calm and nonjudgemental, like Casey was. So Leo surprises Nightwatcher, and then Nightwatcher surprises the hell outta Leo... both for about the same reason.

Agreed.

Quote:

Exactly why I thought this wasn't necessarily a plot-hole. The Nightwatcher's very existence ticked Leo off. Raph's insubordination ticked Leo off. When he was sent to find Raph, his frustration was growing. So, when he saw The Nightwatcher, he knew that was a chance to blow off some steam before he found Raph. His righteous indignation blinded him from the obvious. It's all likely occurences in psychological terms.
Agreed.

Really... and as for the fighting style; the Foot also fight in a ninja style, why not this new guy?

It's not a plot hole. It's an AWESOME MOMENT IN THE MOVIE.

Which I want to see again. For the third time.

johnnyblaze 03-26-2007 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shark (Post 484203)
I think we all noticed this already...

yeah, so...?

Straight-Edge 03-26-2007 10:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 484070)
You'd think the three fingers on the Nightwatcher would've clued Leo in. XD

Check the first scenes of the Night Watcher, especially as he revs up his bike. It looked to me like the gloves had black stitching running down the middle of his index and pinky fingers (IE, the two that aren't his thumb). It's subtle, but it gives the impression of the Watcher having five fingers.

The same thing was done in X-Men evolution, where Nightcrawler used a holograph to make himself look normal at school, and the human form hands had index and middle fingers that were always tight tgether (same witht he ring finger and pinky). It gave the illusion of five fingers, but anyone looking closely would see they were clearly only three.

Like I said, it's subtle, but between that, the backpack, and the boots, I think the animators did a good job of masking the turtlier parts.

Willis 03-26-2007 12:57 PM

I think the fact Casey reconizing the NightWatcher as Raph was more then just the obvious shape and look.

Casey and Raphael were always tight. Both hot heads ready to kick someone around for no good reason other then the punk did something bad.

So he probably was reading about the NightWatcher one evening and thought "man I wonder what Raph would say about a guy like this".. and then he took another look and it clicked. DUH!

jenna 03-26-2007 01:50 PM

Some people only see what they want to see until the reality is right in front of their eyes. Leo had already made the Nightwatcher into an enemy, right from the moment he learned of his existence.

As for Casey, Casey can relate to Raphael because of thier shared issues - given how they met (in all incarnations) he was probably counting the days before Raph finally snapped and started a vigilante routine of his own.

Seiza 03-31-2007 07:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Straight-Edge (Post 484284)
Check the first scenes of the Night Watcher, especially as he revs up his bike. It looked to me like the gloves had black stitching running down the middle of his index and pinky fingers (IE, the two that aren't his thumb). It's subtle, but it gives the impression of the Watcher having five fingers.

Finally managed to do that, and yep, it definitely does give the impression of five fingers. Especially when you're a panicked robber running for your life. ^^;

Also, Casey's been continuing his vigilante gig, right? Could be that he managed to get some first-hand accounts from the Nightwatcher's victims (? okay, that sounds a bit... weird...) before the police reached them. Put their descriptions, Raph's sleeping habits and his own knowledge of his best buddy together--and it doesn't seem so far-fetched for him to figure it out. The closest the turtles would get to the Nightwatcher would be blurry news photos.

The Shelf 03-31-2007 10:20 AM

I can understand why Leo didn't know who Nightwatcher was. Donatello didn't even know, so why should we expect Leo to? The only person who figured it out was Casey, and that's only because he's closer to Raph than anyone else.

Sage Ninja 03-31-2007 12:49 PM

I think this goes to show how actually smart Casey is and not the hard headed idiot he is often portrayed as. I think Casey is alot more intelligent and perceptive than most people (including Raphael) give him credit for. I like the way Casey was handled in this version.

gobo 04-02-2007 01:44 AM

Also quite important to remember, this isn't your typical Leo we're talking about. He's more arrogant than we're used to. And, he's stolen Donnie's gentleman status, and tweaked it with extra smoothness (most noticeable when he catches April at the beginning). Also, if this is a plot-hole, what do you call the fact that no one recognized Superman as Clark Kent for so long? Anyway, I don't find it hard to believe, though I still do think he SHOULD have noticed.

Dorkfish 04-03-2007 03:23 PM

I always thought of it as kind of comedic irony. Casey, in this movie is posed as this clumsy goof, yet he is the only one observant enough to reconize Raph.

Though, it did kinda make me wonder why after Splinter told Leo "You know what you must do." and Leo gave that determined "Yes sensei." and he still didn't know. Hrrmm... Though I guess earlier stated theories of Leo just running in to him on his look for Raph makes good sense too. Just wish it was a little more clear. Maybe since the movie is missing an extra 30 minutes of footage, they cut something out pertaining to this...??? ^^; But I'm not going to complain too much. That whole scene of Leo chasing him down and the fight is my favorite part of the movie. <3

johnnyblaze 04-03-2007 03:34 PM

I thought the "You know what you must do" part meant he had to find and make peace with Raphael

Revan 04-03-2007 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 489965)
I thought the "You know what you must do" part meant he had to find and make peace with Raphael

I thought it meant he had to show Raph that Raph's methods are flawed and that Raph is not ready to lead himself because of his impatience and anger.

johnnyblaze 04-03-2007 03:41 PM

I guess its open to interpretation but to me it seemed like Splinter just wanted Leo to reach out to his brother

Zelda 04-03-2007 05:39 PM

What bothered me more about the Nightwatcher thing was that I didn't understand why Leo was so upset at his existance--it's not okay for one guy to go out and fight, but if it's a team of the four turtles then it's suddenly okay? Especiially with the bit at the end about standing for good :P just seems weirdly hypocritical. Maybe Leo was just jealous :P

I thought for a second during the fight that Leo did recognize Raph and that's why he was lecturing but..nope!

johnnyblaze 04-03-2007 10:17 PM

it was explained a bit better in the book--Mikey gives him a scrapbook of old newspapers to look at and they all talk about how Nightwatcher is overly vicious, doing more harm than good, ect ect

Seiza 04-03-2007 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 489965)
I thought the "You know what you must do" part meant he had to find and make peace with Raphael

Yeah, Splinter had already told him the minute he came back to talk to Raph, which Leo never did (or got the chance to do). I imagine Splinter was telling him to chase after his brother and patch things up, rather than leave him to wander the streets (which Leo indicated he wanted to do, with his "Why do we need Raph anyway?" line).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zelda
What bothered me more about the Nightwatcher thing was that I didn't understand why Leo was so upset at his existance--it's not okay for one guy to go out and fight, but if it's a team of the four turtles then it's suddenly okay?

To add on to johnnyblaze, I think it also had to do with the Nightwatcher's methods bringing more attention to vigilantes in general from the police and public--which could spell trouble for whenever the turtles finally get back to busting criminals.

RaphistheBest 04-09-2007 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 484228)
Who really cares? Leo's reaction was well worth it all.


Yes, Leo's reaction to the fact that Raph was the Nightwatcher was well worth it and it was definitely worth it when Raph owned Leo hardcore. The fact that Leo didn't notice that Raph was the Nightwatcher before the helmet came off? Well, Leo may have all the "great qualities of a leader" but I don't give him that much credit.

Splinter gave him the role as a leader while they were all teenagers and like any "normal" teen that can go to your head no matter how mature, or whatever, you are. In my opinion, Leo's "I'm the leader" was still in his head and he apparently thought that everything would be just as it was before he left even though he had been gone for so long. He hasn't seen how his brothers have changed and not once thought that Raph was out running around in a rad outfit and helmet making headlines. Leo just didn't think that Raph would actually do something like that.

Fighting the Nightwatcher was something Leo felt he had to do because of the whole "being-a-hero" thing and saw this as a way to kill two birds with one stone: stop the Nightwatcher and blow off some steam. Leo's shock was grand but that steam that he had wanted to blow off doubled pretty quickly.

The line that cements the idea (for me anyhow) that Leo still has that "I'm the leader" mindset is when he tells Raph "I'm better than you." Obviously those leader qualities were still being pushed around quite a bit due to what Splinter instilled into Leo.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.