The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   "2 Thumbs Down"...:( (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19259)

Jester 03-27-2007 06:15 PM

"2 Thumbs Down"...:(
 
Ebert and Roeper's review finally up.

http://bventertainment.go.com/tv/bue...bertandroeper/

Don't say I didn't warn ya...2 thumbs down.

So, a review by 2 guys who were not fans and think that only kids and the "brain-injured" could enjoy it. This is why TMNT will work for fans and even people who just wanna have a good time, and NOT movie reviewers who want a secret deeper meaning to a movie about teenage turtles who happen to be mutant ninjas.

Kunoichi_Haruko 03-27-2007 06:20 PM

"Junk food"?
"Brady Bunch"?
"...and it's all crap!"?

:grits teeth:

I'm just gonna grin and bear it...barely...

Warhorse 03-27-2007 06:22 PM

Well, if these critics give that Meet the Robinsons two thumbs up and alot of praise (because face it, that movie really looks to suck, I mean, wtf is the plot to begin with, considering that's all these critics complain about) you know they are being paid by certain movie studios to praise one movie while bash another.

LogicDonny 03-27-2007 06:23 PM

"If you were 8 in 1990 or if your 8 NOW!!, you might find some campy entertainment value in this cheery mess"

then the other guy is like "it's junk food basically, they taken the cartoon and they turn it into a video game and that seem fine"

then they wanted to quickly move on :lol:

they were squleming over the movie review.. hated it lol.

OA 03-27-2007 06:29 PM

Whatever...

What a terrible, terrible review...but those guys don't know what they're talking about...I mean, Roeper himself says that the tmnt concept "isn't particualrly a clever idea" or words to that effect...so of course his view on the movie will nasty...as for the other guy who ive never heard of - he's a loser...

Jester 03-27-2007 06:31 PM

I seriously think those 2 went in to the movie going, "I have to review Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, dear god help me."

In other words they psyched themselves down about as much as we psyched ourselves up for this film.

And what's wrong with a "junk food" movie. I know I don't always go into a movie wanting to think, I just wanna see Turtles kick monster butt.

Head Spinnin' Bebop 03-27-2007 06:31 PM

Oh well, as they said themselves, they were never into any old TMNT and obviously have no clue about the following something like the Turtles have and what they were. So, I dunno why they bother. Calling people brain injured was going a bit far though lol, but yeaaaa...

LogicDonny 03-27-2007 06:32 PM

look they have different tastes in movies, they don't like those kind of movies and we have to accept it. they are paid to review movies. you can't expect a perfect record..

What happened to Ebert? I thought he reviews movies with Roper.

Nightwatcher 03-27-2007 06:33 PM

That seemed rather unprofessional to me. It's fine that they don't like it, but to take cheap shots at people that would is rather lame.

Jester 03-27-2007 06:34 PM

Agreed Nightwatchman. ;)

Anarky 03-27-2007 06:34 PM

Let's kill the f***ers! Torches and pitchforks at the ready! They deserve to die for this blasphemy!

Seriously, reviews don't really matter in the end, so I wouldn't make a big fuzz about them. In the end, all that matters are ticket sales, and nobody can complain about that at the moment. So let the critics be critics and kill them all...

tekninja 03-27-2007 06:35 PM

yea, i saw the review sunday night and i wanted to punch them both in the face. it made me sad... and mad.:( :x

LogicDonny 03-27-2007 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 485439)
Agreed Nightwatchman. ;)

lol you took that from the movie :lol: when leo accidently said the wrong name.

Yes I can understand.. it just isn't fair.. Someone should write and say why!

Jester 03-27-2007 06:38 PM

I agree with Anarky. Most critically acclaimed films I absolutely hate (case and point: Lost ion Translation) and movies critics dog I love. TMNT will probably not be a critics darling, but that ,may actually be for the better.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 03-27-2007 07:41 PM

Okay, everyone who gives a **** about what Ebert and Roper say, please speak up now........











I did'nt think so.

TheAnimatedSeries 03-27-2007 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LogicDonny (Post 485436)
look they have different tastes in movies, they don't like those kind of movies and we have to accept it. they are paid to review movies. you can't expect a perfect record..

What happened to Ebert? I thought he reviews movies with Roper.

Yes, they are PAID to give movie specific reviews, too. Dont ever get pissed at critics, you might think their opinion has more weight than yours but it doesnt. Dont let them bother you. Honestly, I just check yahoo movies to see the letter grades they give something I think will be good, and if its mostly C's and a few F's then I know its probably all right. If its all A's then its probably Flushed Away, one of the worst movies to ever happen.

On occasions critics will like something cool like 300, but then again, that could just be them taking a payoff.

Also, keep in mind that they didnt even like the original movie, and that Ebert's former partner gave the Power Rangers movie a thumbs up because he "really like old Godzilla movies as a kid". Critics opinions are meaningless unless theres a specific critic whose opinion you respect.

Ratchet 03-27-2007 07:54 PM

Yeah, but Ebert is a guy who puts bugger all research into his reviews. I remember constantly reading the review for TMNT 1 on Cinemania (remember that?!) and being baffled as to why he seemed to think that the movie was based on a video game. Clearly had no idea about the cartoon that had been running several years prior OR the comic book from which it all stemmed!

iris 03-27-2007 07:55 PM

That wasn't too bad. They basically said they didn't care and the movie was light fare. True enough. But yeah, very unprofessional-- makes you wonder if they even watched the movie.

All in all, it was free advertising.

But hello, since when do animators yell "Cut!" while filming? That doesn't even make sense. Way to rip up what little credibility you might have had, mister.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anarky (Post 485441)
Let's kill the f***ers! Torches and pitchforks at the ready! They deserve to die for this blasphemy!

Please, dude, I don't like being tempted to use the rolly eyes emoticon. :p

Jester 03-27-2007 07:56 PM

And for the most part I do respect E&R's opinions and reviews, the main reason why this hits a little harder than most.

Kendamu 03-27-2007 08:02 PM

The Snootch is not pleased.

I give these reviewers two green thumbs down and a five-minute game misconduct for roughing.

Aignatius 03-27-2007 08:06 PM

They need to stop making dismissing comments about the young and brain damaged. There are both in the fandom, so what? Why be so insulting? They need to get off their high horse.
Not that everyone who is into the TMNT is either young or brain damaged...

I'd say there was as much meaningful drama and insight in this film as most of the others out there. I can list a lot of other movies geared for adults that had far less intellectual development.
Even the silly moments in TMNT made the characters all the more developed and believable.

E & R is just prejudiced against sentient rats and turtles. Bah. Humbug.

Jester 03-27-2007 08:23 PM

heck, what development happens in 300?

Wes 03-27-2007 08:42 PM

I dunno, I think it's a fair review -- but then again, I wasn't too keen on the movie myself. TMNT is a pretty lacking film that only really "works" for people who can go the extra mile and overlook all of its shortcomings simply because they like the Turtles (or geek out for awesome animation). It ultimately boils down to Leo vs Raph -- because nothing else really got the time and/or attention to really mean anything -- so of course people who could care less about those characters to begin with aren't going to give the film positive marks.

I also thought the video game thing was an apt comparison -- it was fairly lacking in the same way that video games are lacking, because games rely on players to fill in the motivational gaps. But unless one already brought it with him/her in the form of overwhelming nostalgia or fan devotion or CGI geekery, this movie didn't have that interactive quality to save it.

Jester 03-27-2007 09:17 PM

One wonders if that could be because Monroe has directed video games.

But I can agree, but the fan bashing near the end seemed a bit much. It's one thing to not like something, its another to vilify and look down your noes at those who do. "Brain injured." come on.

Buslady 03-27-2007 09:22 PM

Lemme wear Raph's Nightwatcher outfit, I'll chain 'em up by their ...parts....and show 'em what's crap...they are.
It was also pretty damn insulting with the 'brain damaged' comment, alot of special needs folks are FANS of TMNT, that was just RUDE.

iris 03-27-2007 09:24 PM

Speaking of the brain injured demographic, I just told a bunch of drunken college students to see TMNT. Figured that was close enough. :evilgrin:

Jester 03-27-2007 09:27 PM

Oooooo, cutting a little close there iris. I mean my name's jester and even I wouldn't go there.

audman 03-27-2007 09:29 PM

Yeah, That was ridiculously smug of them. It is like "look mom I am on tv. I can say all kinds of dismissive and retarded things because I think I am cool and my opinion matters more than all of you". Actually reminds me of a 12 year old who logs onto halo and says " I am going to Pwn all of you". Just dumb. I think a majority of the people do not really give these people much thought. I don't like how they go and review the 300 movie as an great retelling of a graphic novel when that really is not that much different conceptwise. TMNT is based on characters from a comic book. We were not going to expect an oscar performance from jack nicholson or something. I enjoyed it and am telling everyone who cared to listen that I really thought it was enjoyable for adults as well as kids. I don't think E&R have ever rated something I liked 2 thumbs up. Guess i am braindead and 8 years old. end rant. I just hate pompous a**es.

iris 03-27-2007 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 485690)
Oooooo, cutting a little close there iris. I mean my name's jester and even I wouldn't go there.

Does it help if I'm a drunken college student myself? :goof:

Willis 03-27-2007 09:35 PM

It's sad that such pathedic excuses for review's can be taken by the public as truths. (we TMNT fans know better, but there are those who listen religiously).

Seriously, with all the cheap-shots they take it's clear they walked into this movie with a negative outlook, so not even the holy grail of movies would give it a good review. Reviewers and critics of ANYTHING are supposed to walk into a situation unbiased and optimistic. They are far from that.

Whatever happened to their inner child's I wonder.. Obviously THEY didn't watch cartoons when they were young, they must have been hired to do taxes when they were 8 years old and their inner child drown in a well.

Spitfire 03-27-2007 09:36 PM

Reviews don't bother me. Usually I agree with them. In this case they address things I saw wrong with the movie just in a harsher way.

This is the stupidest line I read in a review
"Time stands still during the many feeble jokes; the Turtles comic book came out in 1984, the last year you could get a laugh just by ending a sentence with the word 'dude.'"

Cause the TMNT say dude all the time in the COMIC. Moron.

Fledermaus 03-27-2007 09:36 PM

Who gives a rip what Roeper and his little assistant have to say about TMNT?:roll: Anyone who's going to depend on their review for a movie like this probably would probably hate the film no matter what. I wouldn't worry about this deterring many moviegoers who had any interest in seeing the movie to begin with... at least, it won't deter the smart ones who already realize that most critics hate the TMNT. :thumbsdo: :thumbsdo:

JetsAndHeels 03-27-2007 09:42 PM

Obviously I am "brain-injured" because I have seen it twice and I love it.

If that is wrong of me then darnit I don't want to be right. Holla!!

Vegita-San 03-27-2007 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ratchet (Post 485560)
Yeah, but Ebert is a guy who puts bugger all research into his reviews. I remember constantly reading the review for TMNT 1 on Cinemania (remember that?!) and being baffled as to why he seemed to think that the movie was based on a video game. Clearly had no idea about the cartoon that had been running several years prior OR the comic book from which it all stemmed!

Maybe these dudes are secretly fans but have a vendetta against warner brothers for releasing a bad movie a week ago, or something? :)

Wes 03-27-2007 10:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 485674)
One wonders if that could be because Monroe has directed video games.

That's a very good point.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 485674)
But I can agree, but the fan bashing near the end seemed a bit much. It's one thing to not like something, its another to vilify and look down your noes at those who do. "Brain injured." come on.

And weeeeeeelll... that's what reviewers do! I mean, insofar as one is convinced that one is right about a particular movie and the severity of its flaws, one would have to conclude that those who either don't notice them at all or can overlook them for whatever reason are kind of lacking in certain faculties (whether they explicitly say so or not). I don't always agree with Roeper (mostly when it comes to undeniably awful movies that he inexplicably gives a thumb up), but I like that he's not afraid to go all out in his attacks on movies he thinks are bad.

Juniorx 03-27-2007 10:50 PM

is there any possible way send email to these jackass's.i never like them but they reveiws on other movies that suck...give them good reveiws.look i understand turtles arent anit for anyone but calling us brain dead from likin em and the new movie is going to far.at least the movie is in number 1 hope it stays there pretty long so that to the haters of tmnt how much it has huge fanbase that we take it serious.

Head Spinnin' Bebop 03-27-2007 11:05 PM

I agree with them sometimes, and I don't care about them giving it a bad review, I can see some not liking it, its just he way they went about it. Couldn’t stand that stand-in dude either.

But, lets face it, a lot of movies they give bad reviews to, have become hits. I remember Home Alone, they said it was terrible and one to miss, and just look how big that movie became. Same with POTC, mixed on that and boy, look at where the pirates are now!!!!

Bry 03-27-2007 11:35 PM

Honestly, who cares? They're movie critics. Do their opinions matter any more than next guy who's seen a movie and wants to voice their opinion about it? Not in the slightest. And honestly, from what I've seen online, the general reception to the movie was rather positive. That means more to me than anything a handful of "professional reviewers" have to say.

I enjoyed the movie, and the opinions of two guys who freely admit they don't "get it" isn't going to change that. They seemed to have bad attitudes going into it anyway, so I don't see why their opinions should count for much of anything.

PrivateRadio 03-28-2007 12:09 AM

You know what's great about this? They could have put out the most poorly written review ever published, and if they gave the movie two thumbs up this entire thread would be "Great review! I totally agree!".

But when they don't like the movie, of course they're awful men with an awful review.

Lone Wolf 03-28-2007 12:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wes (Post 485613)
I dunno, I think it's a fair review -- but then again, I wasn't too keen on the movie myself. TMNT is a pretty lacking film that only really "works" for people who can go the extra mile and overlook all of its shortcomings simply because they like the Turtles (or geek out for awesome animation). It ultimately boils down to Leo vs Raph -- because nothing else really got the time and/or attention to really mean anything -- so of course people who could care less about those characters to begin with aren't going to give the film positive marks.

I also thought the video game thing was an apt comparison -- it was fairly lacking in the same way that video games are lacking, because games rely on players to fill in the motivational gaps. But unless one already brought it with him/her in the form of overwhelming nostalgia or fan devotion or CGI geekery, this movie didn't have that interactive quality to save it.


Fair review? You mean the one where he provides hardly any reasons for his opinion besides the assertion that if you like this movie, "you are braindead"? If this guy gave that review in a fifth-grade English class, he would get an F, albeit with some special recognition for impressive vocabulary (for a fifth grader).

He bashed the very concept of TMNT as viable for a movie. Is that also one of his many fair criticsms in your estimation?

He said if you enjoyed the older movie you would enjoy this one. Said this in a negative tone. Also a fair assertion you agree with?

He said the older movies were also stupid and he did not enjoy them. You said some people will "geek out" over the great animation. He said the animation was "okay".

The video game comparison is totally whacked. They ALSO compared it to a video game back in 19-freaking-90 because they are snobs that are trying to make the whole concept seem juvenile and only appealing to the same imbeciles that like videogames (in their perception). Remember, "the whole thing is dumb. We should just move on."

Plenty of online critics and other people that have given it favorable marks are not turtle freaks, such as Ebert's own associate Misha Davenport. The issue here is not simply his unfavorable opinion, but that Ebert clearly was not prepared to give the movie a chance when he entered the theater. He essentially admits this throughout the interview: he has never enjoyed ANYTHING related to TMNT.

You might not like the new movie, but if you are actually a TMNT fan, I would be wary of taking the side of this fire-spewing hater.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:00 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.