The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Why didn't TMNT resonate with the "general " audience? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19416)

jignat 04-01-2007 07:51 PM

Why didn't TMNT resonate with the "general " audience?
 
Most of us fans or casual fans seeme dto appreciate the move with varying levels from above average to excellent.
But there doesnt seem to be much buzz "in the real world" off th einternet.
In my local area. Everyone is still raving about 300 apparently.
I guess the fans supported the movie in addition to curious people/kids for the 1st weekend. But now only the slim faithful are seeing it at the cinemas.

So what reasons do you think most played a part in the film not doing superb as opposed to just good?

Was it b/c it was s till a PG flick, b/c it wasnt a live action or live action/cg hybrid? Because it had no Shredder? B/c of critics unmerciful reviews?
B/c it was too serious? B/c of lack of promotion of the film? Or was it just the bad luck of being sandwiched b/tween 300 and blades/robinsons?

I guess i could be seen as being overly negative. but it burns me that a movie withn great animation , voice acting, and is respectful to Eastman/Lairds vision isnt getting enough props.
Not to digress much, but Im still scared about the Transformer movie.
While it may do extremely well, im hesitant that any link to the comic/cartoon will be eroded and it will end up as big robots fghting w/little characterization and toilet humor.

Discuss.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-01-2007 07:57 PM

Becuase they didn't make any changes to the orgin, or base it off the old cartoon, to please the mainstream.

I mean, look at all the negative reviews, alot of people were pissed because it wasn't goofy and self aware like the old cartoon.

You really had to be familiar with the characters to appreciate this flick, which is why Roper hated it.

Warhorse 04-01-2007 07:58 PM

I think the film was not as action packed as it could have been. I am willing to bet if this film was a PG-13, and more raw, it would have the audience flocking to it.


I also wonder if all the Turtles were to venture out of New York for some quest to find a lost treasure or to find a kidnapped individual, it could also create new stories and appeal.

Mr. Snackpants 04-01-2007 08:06 PM

A LOT of people my age were pissed about the CGI. Then when they found out Shredder wasn't in the movie, that was the "last straw" so to speak. They were basically too close-minded and couldn't accept any changes to what they loved so much as a child. The people who did go and see liked it for the most part...well it's probably 50/50. The people who didnt like hated the monsters and the story.

Spitfire 04-01-2007 08:12 PM

People who think Shredder should be the only TMNT villain belong in a mental hospital for being retarded. I actually punched one of my friends for saying some thing like that.

"If Shredder isn't in it it won't be good because he's the core turtles villain and you can't have a story without him" So I dead armed him for being an idiot. Then everyone laughed at him.

jignat 04-01-2007 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Snackpants (Post 488887)
A LOT of people my age were pissed about the CGI. Then when they found out Shredder wasn't in the movie, that was the "last straw" so to speak. They were basically too close-minded and couldn't accept any changes to what they loved so much as a child. The people who did go and see liked it for the most part...well it's probably 50/50. The people who didnt like hated the monsters and the story.

I could possibly see the CGI, and shredder stuff, but I liked the story.
It may have been rushed and a bit underdeveloped, but certainly MILEs above any of the alien/monster stories of the 87 toon. Even though i used to get tired of shredder/krang/bebop/rocksteady, whenver there was a mad scientist/alien story most of the time it was incrediblyh generic imo.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-01-2007 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx (Post 488890)
People who think Shredder should be the only TMNT villain belong in a mental hospital for being retarded. I actually punched one of my friends for saying some thing like that.

"If Shredder isn't in it it won't be good because he's the core turtles villain and you can't have a story without him" So I dead armed him for being an idiot. Then everyone laughed at him.

It's just sad people can be so closed minded. Especially with the CGI thing. I mean, I've asked these people, do they really wanna see guys in bulky suits again? It's like their blind to all the positve attributes.

Also, all the people who claimed this movie rapped their childhood, should probably be wearing a helemt when they go outside.

Shark_Blade 04-01-2007 08:26 PM

Has anyone watched that movie Garfield? It was horrible and boring yet it has a sequeal. So maybe we will get one nonetheless.

And to the critical reviewers, screw them. As long as a movie is enjoyable, nothing can take it away from us. They can just get a life than beating movies to death with their poor reviewing skills.

johnnyblaze 04-01-2007 08:27 PM

the biggest complain I keep hearing is that Shredder isn't in it and that it is CGI. I get the impression that is why people aren't interested. IMO though, they are seriously missing out

Spitfire 04-01-2007 08:30 PM

Funny thing about that is I read these reviews and I can't see any GOOD reasons for them disliking it. They all whine about crap that just comes off as childish or really stupid. None of them have valid points they just make stupid jokes and dance around why they really dislike the movie.

It's treated like a video game movie, they hated it before they even watched it.

johnnyblaze 04-01-2007 08:32 PM

yeah let's face it, TMNT is an easy target for animosity because of its past. damned if they cater to it, damned if they don't, and damned if they try and find a middle ground lol

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-01-2007 08:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx (Post 488901)
Funny thing about that is I read these reviews and I can't see any GOOD reasons for them disliking it. They all whine about crap that just comes off as childish or really stupid. None of them have valid points they just make stupid jokes and dance around why they really dislike the movie.

It's treated like a video game movie, they hated it before they even watched it.

The only reasonable bad review I've seen is from Capone over at Aint it Cool News. Other than that, they've all been crap.

Fledermaus 04-01-2007 08:38 PM

1. Promotion for TMNT sucked "eggs"...;)

2. Plot was not tied in enough to the story -- we were not reminded enough of its imminence or importance... PLUS.... come on guys. 13 monsters? Immortal warlords?? Stone generals??? Every 3000 years????? etc....
To be fair though, it helps if you've seen Ghostbusters, I think. I enjoyed this movie because it felt a lot like a good hybrid of TMNT and ghostbusters...:D

To me, this movie really felt like it was lifted out of some theoretical classic TMNT comic -- from the characters's story, to the outrageously 'out there' plot... the comics were parodying things, but it was hard to tell because it took itself 'seriously' as a parody. I think this movie did that as well -- I saw all these references to previous major movies -- Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LOTR, Shrek/Beauty and the Beast... Unlike an actual pure comedy, however, TMNT does not spell out to the audience what it's parodying. To me, I was just all the more amused by the seriousness of it all. For many people, though -- I think they like to have their genres spelled out.
TMNT 2007 (even the first film) reminds me a lot of movies like Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LXG, Hellboy -- movies that are sort of dark, and are meant to be fun, though not pure goofball comedies. They can even have an appropriate amount of weight to them, which I felt the new TMNT movie had. I'm surprised there's no legitimate name for these kinds of films. It's definitely an unnamed genre. They aren't just action films. They are "things-that-go-bump-in-the-night" films. Slightly dark and sinister, crazy for sure, serious if it chooses to be, but always tons of fun.

3. They really need to re-edit this movie without pandering to the censors or concern for time. What matters most is that the movie be tightly strung together -- the slightly loose feel of the movie probably turned off some people with little patience for the outlandishness of the genre -- like snooty film critics or those who didn't grow up really embracing the TMNT.

4. We needed some more, very genuine, very strong humor. We had great action. It would have been better to have great humor to balance it -- the humor would have to be smart and well timed. Some stupid humor is a given, but not the majority of it, and certainly not the highlight scenes featured in trailers (Mikey's burp was disgusting, and while it did show us how immature he is, it wasn't inherently funny.) Jersey devil is a pretty good example of action humor, and I think that scene was actually more popular than people here realize. We needed to move a little more into the direction of "injured turtles at breakfast" because the humor there was grounded in their character interactions.

johnnyblaze 04-01-2007 08:50 PM

oh yeah, injured turtles at breakfast ruled

cormano 04-01-2007 08:52 PM

What are you talking about? The movie was number one opening weekend! Just because your circle of friends weren't excited about it doesn't mean it isn't a mainstream hit.

Fledermaus 04-01-2007 09:02 PM

#1 opening weekend. But even now, I think it's too early to say how the movie will perform overall. There are still lots and lots of people who have not seen TMNT and are still thinking of seeing it.

My friends (not really TMNT like me) who saw the film really enjoyed the movie. I think the threadstarter's point is that not everyone loved it so much to come see it a SECOND time -- only half of my friends saw, or will see TMNT at least a second time.

I think that, unfortunately, promotion really does have a lot to do with it. You know what they say -- out of sight, out of mind.

However, as far as I know... about 2/3 of the people who know I've seen TMNT, and who have not seen TMNT and were thinking about it asked me what I thought of the film. They are interested, but the main thing is that I think that a lot of people aren't sure about the film.

The film is technically, as I've said before, only as good as the first film. Only now the problem is most of that generation has jobs and school -- TMNT isn't quite the pandemic phenomenon it was seventeen years ago. And this film was very good, but it was only awesome if you already know the TMNT.

Buslady 04-01-2007 09:31 PM

Probably because they were expecting old toon garbage but got the REAL TMNT instead. Fooey on them.

iris 04-01-2007 09:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cormano (Post 488914)
What are you talking about? The movie was number one opening weekend! Just because your circle of friends weren't excited about it doesn't mean it isn't a mainstream hit.

S'what I was going to say.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 488905)
2. Plot was not tied in enough to the story -- we were not reminded enough of its imminence or importance... PLUS.... come on guys. 13 monsters? Immortal warlords?? Stone generals??? Every 3000 years????? etc....
To be fair though, it helps if you've seen Ghostbusters, I think. I enjoyed this movie because it felt a lot like a good hybrid of TMNT and ghostbusters...:D

To me, this movie really felt like it was lifted out of some theoretical classic TMNT comic -- from the characters's story, to the outrageously 'out there' plot... the comics were parodying things, but it was hard to tell because it took itself 'seriously' as a parody. I think this movie did that as well -- I saw all these references to previous major movies -- Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LOTR, Shrek/Beauty and the Beast... Unlike an actual pure comedy, however, TMNT does not spell out to the audience what it's parodying. To me, I was just all the more amused by the seriousness of it all. For many people, though -- I think they like to have their genres spelled out.
TMNT 2007 (even the first film) reminds me a lot of movies like Ghostbusters, Gremlins, LXG, Hellboy -- movies that are sort of dark, and are meant to be fun, though not pure goofball comedies. They can even have an appropriate amount of weight to them, which I felt the new TMNT movie had. I'm surprised there's no legitimate name for these kinds of films. It's definitely an unnamed genre. They aren't just action films. They are "things-that-go-bump-in-the-night" films. Slightly dark and sinister, crazy for sure, serious if it chooses to be, but always tons of fun.

It would be some genre within Fantasy. Like urban mythology.

Tinuvielsdreams 04-01-2007 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 488937)
Probably because they were expecting old toon garbage but got the REAL TMNT instead. Fooey on them.

Well put! If I read one more review that says too serious with not enough pizza...grrrrrr I don't know what I will do but it will be something not nice...lol

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-01-2007 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinuvielsdreams (Post 488950)
Well put! If I read one more review that says too serious with not enough pizza...grrrrrr I don't know what I will do but it will be something not nice...lol

Then you better not read Film Threat's review.

The guy trashed it simply because it wasn't goofy.

Mr. Snackpants 04-01-2007 10:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cormano (Post 488914)
What are you talking about? The movie was number one opening weekend! Just because your circle of friends weren't excited about it doesn't mean it isn't a mainstream hit.

Yeah it was #1 opening weekend against no competition. This weekend 2-3 big movies were released, so we'll see how well it held up.

EDIT: It ended up at #4 and about 9 million for the weekend. Not bad, where it was figured to end up.

TheAnimatedSeries 04-01-2007 10:10 PM

Probably because like some people have said, this movie caters especially to fans who know about and are interested in the characters at a deeper level than casual fans. Tender moments onscreen between Raph and Leo mean alot to us, but most mainstream fans care more about ninja kick butt action and having a shell of a time. They went to TMNT expecting the old movies, they didnt get that, but I am certain everyone who went to 300 did see three hundred Spartans throw down against the persian empire.

I dont blame the casual fan who doesnt embrace this movie the way we have. If I hadnt had months to get over the lousy plastic human designs and the all ready mentioned to death unacceptable time monsters plot, that may have thrown my opinion off alot. I cant explain though why they wouldnt be able to see passed that and realize the characterization, one liners and heart of the franchise is intact, theres no reason to be truly disappointed in the movie. It is the Turtles, it is a solid representation of the characters.

Juniorx 04-01-2007 10:47 PM

it didnt get that much attention cause it wasnt live like the 1st one did to alot fans and the non fans.just mosty of the fans where expected that.cause the live one was believeble and magical.only if they made it with cg and live for example spider-man.my point of veiw i didnt see guys in suits i saw turtles right.sorry im not tryin start any trouble.i still like this new tmnt.hope there will be a sequal even pg13 then maybe it will get that attetion it needs.some of you might not agree.

Revan 04-01-2007 10:58 PM

Perhaps the public's prejudice played a role. We have seen on these boards the opinions of certain individuals and their disgust with cgi and how it destroys their whole ability to enjoy the film. Or maybe because III was so bad that TMNT 4 was written off early.

Also, I feel that to enjoy TMNT you need to be a fan already or at least be familiar with the tmnt.

Seiza 04-02-2007 05:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neutrino (Post 488997)
Also, I feel that to enjoy TMNT you need to be a fan already or at least be familiar with the tmnt.

Same here.

Mr. Munroe and his team wanted to make this movie for the fans, I believe--and they succeeded too well. The Raph/Leo fight, as awesome as it is, would resonate more with fans who've already had some emotional and historical investment in the turtles. Otherwise it's just another fight, with the slight hint that it's more than a simple "rebel vs. leader", but without the proper amount screentime to explore it. And it was short to boot.

The same goes for all the little things that made TMNT 4 so awesome for me--Mikey's baby brother role, Don's brief argument with Raph, Leo's lingering self-doubt, Raph's masked hurt. I wonder how much a casual viewer would appreciate the Don/Raph scene compared to a long-time fan?

And the overall monster "main plot" simply wasn't detailed enough to draw the general audience in, especially without Shredder. The comics may have moved past him, but the general audience hasn't.

Still, though. Even my friend who still liked the 80s toon over the 2k3 toon enjoyed the movie. It really has a lot to do with being open to the new medium and story.

Warhorse 04-02-2007 05:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 489162)
And the overall monster "main plot" simply wasn't detailed enough to draw the general audience in, especially without Shredder. The comics may have moved past him, but the general audience hasn't.

This is actually a good speculation as to another reason why the audience is dismissing it. It seems to be formulac that the main villian never truly does die, and in most cases, when you are dealing with a comic book icon on a regular basis, I guess it needs a regular arch enemy.

I personaly, could care less if Shredder was in this movie or not. As long as the characters of the Turtles are done to my liking, movie is fine by me. Like all things, there is room for improvement. I was prepared for the monster because of reading this forum and the novel, but the casual movie goer very well could be lost and be like WTF?

Leo's Man 04-02-2007 07:42 AM

I think the new movie does not resonate well with many audiences because it is for one a movie made by fans for the fans, so it assumes naturally from that notion that they can dive straight into the story and not truly worry about trying to get others up to speed on the brothers, splinter, shredder and so on and so on. While lifelong fans of TMNT have no problem with this 'filler' being exluded from the film, new fans and casual viewers may feel like they are being left out to dry, and somewhat treated like babies in a way.

Tinuvielsdreams 04-02-2007 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael (Post 488956)
Then you better not read Film Threat's review.

The guy trashed it simply because it wasn't goofy.

oh man, thanks for the warning... I am just gonna to avoid magazines and newspapers for awhile...*Twitch* Twitch*
LOL

Jo Dawn 04-02-2007 10:48 AM

I'm not sure I understand the 'Shredder not being in it' reasoning for people to not see it.

Someone who has no knowledge of the franchise really wouldn't know Shredder, except for 2K3, and he's gone. And if they've already seen the older movies, then they know he was destroyed...

Maybe I'm not 'getting' that arguement... That, or it just doesn't make sense to me, heh.


And as for the 'goofy' reviewer... They would loathe the day I ever read that and get a chance to comment.

The Shelf 04-02-2007 11:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn (Post 489221)
I'm not sure I understand the 'Shredder not being in it' reasoning for people to not see it.

Someone who has no knowledge of the franchise really wouldn't know Shredder, except for 2K3, and he's gone. And if they've already seen the older movies, then they know he was destroyed...

Maybe I'm not 'getting' that arguement... That, or it just doesn't make sense to me, heh.

I think that complaint comes mostly from the more casual fans who didn't know that this movie takes place after the other 3. I think most people thought this was starting over with the turtles. If it was, then I could accept their complaints, but that's not how things worked out.

Youal 04-02-2007 11:38 AM

The mojarity of the critics are from the stone ages. Their mentality is that animation is suppose to be cute and wacky. They can't accept TMNT since it contain violence and abit of dark elements. Also, they dismiss the movie just because its asscoicated with toy merchandising which is true but if you look at the other animations, its no different.

Seiza 04-02-2007 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn (Post 489221)
I'm not sure I understand the 'Shredder not being in it' reasoning for people to not see it.

It's like Batman without Joker, or... okay, can't think of any other pop culture references. XD; Harry Potter without Voldemort? Kingdom Hearts without Sora?

So these are the people with general knowledge, who might've seen a couple of 80s toon episodes on VHS, owned a TMNT lunch box and never thought about the franchise again. So when they think of the turtles, Shredder automatically comes to mind: Continuity be damned, where there's the turtles there has to be Shredder.

Those kind of people. I've seen gamers refuse to buy Kingdom Hearts 3 if it didn't include Sora, so... it's pretty normal for me.

Jo Dawn 04-02-2007 01:02 PM

Not to be argumentative, but I've never seen it that way. I think of TMNT, I think of... well... TMNT. Batman has existed without the Joker (in movies) the same as Harry Potter will withouth Voldemort. Besides, both of those characters are still alive and hanging around.

Oh well... Some people just can't be helped then, I suppose. ;)

Revan 04-02-2007 01:54 PM

Many fans, for one reason or another, simply cannot let go of the shredder. He has been engrained in children's experiences and many people love him as the villian.

I don't care who the villian is in tmnt movies, as long as the turtles are portrayed correctly.

Cassidy 04-02-2007 08:35 PM

I wanted to take some friends to see it, but they said something that discouraged me from doing so.

"Does it have Krang in it?"

Further discussion revealed that they hadn't even seen the previous movies because they hadn't wanted to mess up their 80's cartoon memories.

Basically, they were TMNT illiterate. Since they still thought of TMNT in terms of the 80's cartoon, I figured they wouldn't get much out of this movie. I'm very familiar with the Raph/Leo conflict... they wouldn't be. The fight and whatnot would not resonate with them.

They'd probably also bemoan the fact that Shredder wasn't in it. Whereas, I was excited to see Karai (though she was under utilized).

They'd expect pizza.

They'd expect 80's cartoonish goofiness.

And they'd be disappointed.

So I'm going to agree with what some other folks have said. This was a movie made by fans for fans. The casual viewer just wouldn't "get it" I don't think, since they aren't emotionally invested and familiar with the characters like the fans are.

RskimB 04-02-2007 09:08 PM

bad timing? it was released during spring break in a lot of places, week after its initial release competitors w/ similar target demos. MtR and Blades of Glory muscle in on TMNT spot. Not too mention the lack of glowing reviews and comparatively weak ad campaign.

gobo 04-02-2007 11:28 PM

If by "general audience", you mean the casual fans (aka the fickle jerks who were only interested in this movie because they loved the Turtles in the early '90s though they haven't had anything at all to do with them before or since the first cartoon), then I guess that was a rhetorical question. If that's not the question, then my answer is because it was too heavy for their strict diet of fluffy Disney BS.

Seiza 04-03-2007 01:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn (Post 489279)
Not to be argumentative, but I've never seen it that way. I think of TMNT, I think of... well... TMNT. Batman has existed without the Joker (in movies) the same as Harry Potter will withouth Voldemort. Besides, both of those characters are still alive and hanging around.

I've never seen it that way either. I guess some fans have this eternal image of the Hero fighting the Archvillain in a never-ending conflict...

And I think it also comes from Shredder being the recurring villain in the 80s toon. He kept coming back, and casual fans got used to his constant presence. :lol:


[EDIT] Just to add to the number of reasons, one of my friends told me he didn't enjoy the movie as much because it didn't "feel" like the previous three movies... not a sentiment I can quite grasp. His second reason made more sense to me: he felt the writers should've made this an origin story again. I guess he saw it as a Batman Begins type of movie, not so much a continuation of the movie canon. He compared it to how Spiderman introduced the characters.

On one hand, watching the origin play out again would've been a great way to introduce TMNT to new audiences (seeing it yourself is always better than listening to a narration). But I wonder how much old fans would appreciate having to sit through that again? I'd place the blame on advertising for not making it crystal clear it's a continuation-- a loose one, but still a continuation.

Roseangelo 04-03-2007 01:28 AM

After seeing the movie six times now, the biggest fault I can come up with is that there aren't enough Turtles in this movie titled TMNT. The story is too big for the running time, so a lot of that time is spent on exposition that is or isn't interesting. And most of that exposition doesn't involve Turtles. I think it would have helped with the "general audience" if the boys had more screen time.

Zechs 04-03-2007 01:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 489717)
I've never seen it that way either. I guess some fans have this eternal image of the Hero fighting the Archvillain in a never-ending conflict...

And I think it also comes from Shredder being the recurring villain in the 80s toon. He kept coming back, and casual fans got used to his constant presence. :lol:

Not to mention the sequel to the live action had the Shredder returning as well.

Still being a big Shredder fan I was greatly pleased with the movie. I went in the mindset like I did with Batman Begins. With this movie returing the franchise and zero Shredder so he doesn't overshadow the actual characters and if he does return then you can be gitty at the fact (hence why I loved the ending to BB the most).

I only wish we could have gotten a better understanding of Karai and the Foot currently since they just appear and we never get an understanding as why they're acting like mercenaries. And that could have been greatly expanded on during the small fight Leo had with Karai. But oh well still was fun.

Also Roeper is an idiot.

When I watched his review, and he didn't understand a thing about what he movie was for. It was for the fans. Those who enjoyed the first two live action movies are going to love this. When have we ever gotten an action CGI animated movie ever in America?


Then this past week I was laughing at how he enjoyed Meet the Robinsons even though as he said, "was easily predictable though I'll give it a thumbs up." I just wish someone whose a fan of this board would suddenly lurch out from the shadows and just beat Roeper and start yelling, "DUDE! You knock down a movie that was trying to be something original and yet you give thumbs up to something that isn't."


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.