![]() |
How much does 2k3 follow the comic?
Sorry if this has been posted somewhere before..
I was just wondering how much of the 2k3 series follows the original storyline of the Mirage comic? I've only read a few of the issues online, and a few of the 2k3 episodes.. It bothers me that Splinter is gray instead of brown. :ohwell: I was watching a couple episodes from TLS yesterday on Youtube, and was reeeaally surprised to see the turtles turn into dragons..!! Did that really happen in the original comic?! |
Quote:
To answer your main question, though, the first two seasons were based very heavily on the original comics, but it added some extra stuff (for example, I don't think Garbageman was in the comics, but again, I could be wrong). After the second season, I think the cartoon began to pull away from the comics. I haven't been following the 2k3 cartoon very closely, though, so maybe someone else can clear things up some more. |
yeah there is a lot of compare and contrast discussions mostly because yeah it does flow with the comics to a point. This is one of those things where I would love to pull out all my comics and all my DVDs and go on a huge tangent...
Actually the closer to comic episodes were the earlier seasons like The turtles all have a comic book that went into the series... for example Tales of Leo (comic) and Shredder strikes back (2K3) The episode with Donny and Kirby...Raph meeting Casey Jones, Mikey and the Christmas episode (finding Klunk) Some other storylines like.... Baxter Stockman and mousers, The fugitoid and Tricerations... City at war... If you have access to it just read the first comic from 84 and watch the first 2003 episode "Things change" Some of the lines are exactly the same Now these are just a few and they aren't mirror perfect from comic to series but if you read and watch you really make see all the connections Talk about opening the flood gate...I guess a simple yes would have been sufficient...lol |
The 2k3 takes storylines from the comics but also changes them to fit their universe better.
If you expect 2k3 to be a faithful adaption of the comics...it is to an extent, but its also basically old stuff with new stuff. After 6 seasons its officially its own animal now. There's a LOT of differences between the arcs in the show and the arcs in the comics. |
A lot of stuff from "Return Of Savanti" is apparently the same. Although they actually eat the fish before returning home. http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/sho...73&postcount=8
|
Or some elements are taken from the comics, like Rogue in the House had the TMNT use a brain-damaged Triceraton to fight on their side against the Foot, similar to how they did in the comic's version of Return of New York and such.
Characters like Renet, Nobody, Leatherhead, Rat King and such are from the comics and have similar episodes. |
I think it's best to leave it at "It's loosely based on the mirage comics". Otherwise, it gets to confusing :lol:
|
Yeah its safe to say its loosely based because alot of the arcs are changed a bit to fit the "kid friendly" standards, for example City At War. Go read the comic and watch the show sort of the same premise but completely different when you factor in Casey isn't with another woman and April isn't in California with her sister.
|
So I take it the Bishop character isn't in the comics.
Next to Shredder, I am starting to like Bishop more and more. |
I've read the first few issues of the first series, and the first season of 2k3 about sums them up...
|
I just read the first 12 or so comics. The triceratons / fugitoid story is great, I couldn't stop reading. I haven't seen the new toons, so I hope they did a good job with it.
|
Quote:
|
Season 1:
Things Change, A Better Mousetrap, Attack of the Mousers - Vol. 1 #2-3 Meet Casey Jones - Raphael The Shredder Strikes - Vol. 1 #1 (the rooftop fight part) The King - Donatello The Shredder Strikes Back, Part 1 - Leonardo The Shredder Strikes Back, Part 2 - Vol. 1 #10 Return to New York - Vol. 1 #19-21 Season 2: The Search for Splinter - Vol. 1 #4 Turtles in Space - Vol. 1 #5-6 Secret Origins - Vol. 1 #7 (except the virtual reality/Shredder part) What a Croc - Vol. 1 #45 City at War - Vol. 1 #50-62 (kinda) The Golden Puck - Vol. 1 #14 (kinda) Return of the Justice Force - Vol. 1 #15 Season 3: Hunted - Tales #6 Nobody's Fool - Tales #2 The Christmas Aliens - Michaelangelo Time Travails - Vol. 1 #8 (minus Cerebus) Season 4: Cousin Sid - Tales #1 The People's Choice - Vol. 1 #13 Sons of the Silent Age - Vol. 1 #28 I, Monster - Tales #4 Still Nobody - back-up story in Tales TPB All Hallows Thieves - Tales #3 Return of Savanti - Tales #7 (might've missed one here or there) In short, the comics that haven't been adapted and are in Mirage continuity: #9 - The Passing (although there has been other flashback stories focusing on the early years) #11 - True Stories (although Tales of Leo was sorta similar) #12 - Survivalists #24-26 - The River (it's still in-continuity to me, dammit! :P ) #27 & Tales #5 (Radical & Complete Carnage! Where are they in the cartoon?) #46-47 - Masks #48-49 - Shades of Gray And various short stories a la Still Nobody. |
Same as it Never Was is loosely based on the Image comics, which aren't considered canon and kind of an alternate reality anyway, from what I've heard.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
:lol: |
There are some parallels that kinda remind you of some bits of the Image comics (Raph missing an eye, Don using an exosuit) but like Putrescent said, not an adaptation. One of my favorites, though. :)
|
Quote:
Besides, I said it was based loosely on Volume 3. I didn't say it followed it word for word. All of the cartoons where the turtles are sent by the Ultimate Draco are based on a comic in the mirage universe. Raphael was sent to the planet racers(Across the Universe), Michelangelo met up with the Super Turtles (Reality Check), and Leonardo got sent to Usagi's world (The Real World Pt 1). Donatello was sent to an alternate future loosely based on the Volume 3 image comics (Same as it Never Was). No, they aren't complete adaptations, but it is obvious that they are inspired by what happened in those comics. |
Quote:
Let's see Raphs' worn an eye patch in Mirage, Archie, & Image. Both Mirage And Archie had it happen in the future. Image had it happen in the current storyline Raph had the eye patch on for what 1 maybe 2 issues then he dawned Casey's hockey mask until he found shredders old outfits and became the new shredder. Quote:
Quote:
1.) Raphael nor any other character from anything in the Mirage or Turtle related universes have ever been a part of Planet Racers besides on the show Jim Lawsons Planet Racers is a comic book all in it's self because he and Peter are so close this got to be part of the new show. 2.) The Michaelangelo story also never happened in the comic book we see a Panel in Vol. 4 of the Mirage comics as well and we never see the characters again. 3.) Leonoardo and the turtles have met Usagi in both his own comics and the mirage comics but the episode for the 2k3 show is not based on any one comic book. Much like Planet Racers Usagi appears in allot of the Turtles incarnations because Peter Laird is very close to the creator of Usagi Yojimbo Stan Saki. 4.) The Future world in which the Utrom Shredder has control over is absolutely nothing like the Image comics series Name one thing that was even close to being like it? The closest thing we've ever seen in this series that even remotely scraped the surface of the Image TMNT series was when in the episode "The Darkness Within" Raph sees his worst nightmare himself as the shredder. I'm not trying to be an @sshole I just don't want anyone to be misslead. |
Quote:
If Putrescent says it's wrong it's wrong. This man knows more about the comics then alot of the people on here. |
Quote:
|
Yeah, Ok, throw stuff at the Newb and tell me that I don't know what I'm talking about then.
Whatever man, you don't have to get on my case about it. As far as I know, I've seen all of the shows and I'm not saying that the Battle Nexus is based on any of the comics, I never said that, but from what I saw and what I've read, I'd say it was inspired by it. Maybe I haven't read EVERY SINGLE FREAKIN comic book out there, or for that matter, seen every single episode, but I have read a few including the Image comics. And from my humble and obviously ill informed opinion, I would say that there is some basis for inspiration for those episodes. I'm not saying Raphael visited the Planet Racers in the comics, or that Michelangelo visited the Super Turtles either, and last I checked, Shredder was never an Utrom in Comic World for that matter. But then again, does it really matter? Really, on the grand scheme of things, does this make any difference what so ever? So what if they are based on comics or not, is this knowledge going to stop the world from spinning? I think not. I'll get back to my life where I could care less if a cartoon episode is based on a comic book or not, because I just realized I DON'T CARE! But since you seem to care so much, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and admit that you might be right. |
Quote:
I like answering questions for people who don't know this crap. And you obviously do care because you responded to my informative post for you or anyone else in a harsh critical way. Oh and you may be a newb but don't do things yourself bro and not expect for someone to toss the truth at you. There's no case to get on it's an open and shut one really like I said before you thought you knew you didn't I wanted to help and inform you of what really was going down. And as you say you have a real life my telling you what's the actual story's of everything tmnt is the least of your worries I'm more than sure. But sorry you got so hurt over it. Well that's fine and dandy man but I wouldn't be tossing around Wiki links and stuff then if you haven't Cause if I don't know something I sure research it before I try to come back at someone but never trying to be harsh. I didn't say you said any of those things I'm making sure people know these so they won't be quoted as the truth. And yes your correct he never was a Utrom in the comics and thank gods for that! No actually if you want to get technical like that nothing really matters and we might as well pack our bags and just leave now. but yes in fact it does matter I'd particularly not appreciate a bunch of ill-informed fans running around spreading wrong information because it comes back later as being exact truth then much time is wasted trying to prove things to people that you've already known for a long time that's pretty much easily accessable over at www.ninjaturtles.com Might be right? I am most of the things I'm telling you have been said by Peter Laird himself who hates the Image comics series. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
So I don't know much, and maybe I don't know what the hell I'm talking about (but I do check Ninjaturtles.com frequently for info on upcoming DVDs and what not). And I will admit that I'm no expert on the comics, so I will concede that point. I just remember being a huge turtle fan back in third grade with the cool (and now I realize very campy and corny but loveable) original cartoon. That was, oh, fifteen years ago? Hell. I just rediscovered Turtles a little over two years ago with the awe inspiring power of DVD. All hail DVD. But now I have a correction to point out. I'm not a bro, I'm a girl. Hey, and don't knock Wiki! That site comes in real handy now and then for us ill informed! |
Quote:
Oh and my bad haha easy mistake I saw your user pic with the hat on and just sort of though sorry hehe:| Wiki is pretty bad though atleast when it comes to allot of things simply because it's just so easy to edit. It really needs to have much more strict rules. |
Eh, no harm done.
Yes, I am a little irritated, and I didn't really mean to make it apparent on my post, but I wasn't irritated at you (ok, maybe a little), more so of RL situations that are completely out of my control. I understand, you mod the forum for people like me :P We get so rowdy sometimes! |
Ok so a question after all of this...debating...
What is the Image series compared to the others? Im confused. |
Quote:
I guess they liked the idea at the time but Peter Laird has made it pretty clear he dislikes it allot. |
So it is Volume 2 and up by different authors? I guess my question is, what is it's difference to the original series?
I am under the impression that the Tales of the TMNT and the Movie Prequel comics are all done by independent comic writers / artists and are not of the same group that made, lets say, for example, Volume 1 TMNT or the TMNT Archie series? |
Quote:
Mirage Comics Volume 1, 2, & 4 Also Tales Volume 1 & 2 Image Comics TMNT vol. 3 (but isn't being used) Archie Comics is a world all in it's self and is loosley based on the 80's cartoon. The new movie comics are based on the world of the movies. But reguardless of differnt artists drawing the comics At some point or another Peter Laird or Kevin Eastman had to over look everything before it went to print. They all may have come from differnt publications and artists but when everythings said and done the money made went back to Mirage who own the TMNT as a whole. |
Thats exactly what I wanted to know. Thanks. I just got into the comics after obtaining the first 4 graphic novels.
So what happened with Volume 3 exactly? |
Quote:
Well Vol 3 like I said went to Image comics who are known for their bloody, all out big battles, and mutilations in their comics. Well it didn't go over well with many fans and the series only lasted 23 issues. I like it myself but I like when the norm isn't done to characters all the time. It started out with the turtles having a birthday Shredders Daughter Pamiko(who is only used in this series) comes to town With some cyborgs they blast up the place. To make a long story short Raphael pokes one of the cyborgs with his Sai it shoots out sparks disfiguring his face. He wears an eye patch for awhile, then dawns Casey Jones old Hocky mask, and towards the end of the series he comes along Shredders old outfits and Raphael becomes the new leader of the foot Clan until some one called Lady Shredder comes along we never find out she is though the series ends before that. Many thought it was Karai but we were told in the comic that she was presumed dead. The Cyborgs and Pamiko Capture a Donatello whos all bloody and full of bullet holes he awaks frightend and scared trys to make an escape doesn't realize he's in a helicopter and plumits to his death along with one of the cyborgs who jumps out after him. Donatello hits the earth along with the Cyborg the cyborgs body now merges with Donatellos making him go crazy for awhile. It takes some time but he gets back to his normal self once the Cyborgs mind has left Donatellos with the help of Splinter who Meets Donatellos Spirit on the Astral Plane. Michaelangelo becomes a writter which I think was the best part of the series. Leonardo Gets his one hand bitten off by a Kamodo Dragon from one of the new Villains King Komodo who Comes about when he Captures Splinter and takes some of his mutant blood out of him. Splinter after this escapes I'm pretty sure (it's been awhile since I've read these) and gets bitten by a bat and he mutates again becoming a vampire type creature running amuck in the city killing people and turning them into mutant vampires. The Savage Dragon makes allot of cameos in the comic it being written by his creator Erik Larson and all. April, Casey, & a very young Shadow are in the comic as well. Shadow plays a huge part in a storyline about the mafia (her mother was related to the mob boss) and they capture Shadow the foot clan are involved as well which leads mike into saving Shadow because he feels bad because he was baby sitting for April & Casey who Flipp out on him. Leather head is in the series as well with a little Utrom Buddy. The Triceratons come back because they get a distress call that is set off by Donatello fixing Zog (the triceraton who helped the turtles fight the foot clan in return to new york in mirage vol. 1). Michaelangelo Also get a girl friend Sara who is part of erik larson Super Freaks comic. Allot of Erik Larson other characters make cameos as well in the series and they even go as far to poke fun of Venus De Milo from the next mutation which was around at the same time. I may have left some things out but if you have any more questions just ask. |
Great Synopsis.
Who is Shadow? That is unclear to me. Also, Raph becomes the head of the foot? Fromw hat I have read, Shredder dies in...the first comic? I am unsure if he actually comes back or not, but when Raph takes over the foot clan he does so as a good guy or as a bad guy? |
Quote:
2K3 series was a mix of the original comics line and new material wonderfully blended into a well done series...until Farty Forward. Bleah! |
Quote:
Quote:
In the Leonardo Microseries, however, Shredder returns, kicks Leo's shell, and the story continues into Mirage V1 #10, where the turtles flee to Northampton for a year. In V1 #19-21, the turtles "Return to New York" and face the Shredder for a final time. This second Shredder is revealed to be a clone, and the explanation is kind of wacky (it deals with worms, and is not technically a clone, or Oroku Saki returned from the grave). After that, the Mirage comics kind of jumped around, with lots of guest writers, and no real continuity to speak of. When they pick up again, another year or so has passed, and the Foot Clan is at war (this is also part of the "City At War" story arc), without the Shredder to keep them reigned in. During the story, the Shredder reappears, again, but this time, it's a woman named Karai, who forges a truce with the turtles to help her stop the war. At the end of "City at War", the Foot Clan and the Turtles part ways in peace. The Image series (Volume 3) starts up not long after this (Mirage Vol. 2 takes place over avery sort period of time), and the turtles are still in a truce with the Foot. When Shadow is kidnapped by the Foot, Raph mentions he has been hanging with the Foot (who help him save Shadow after some coersion). Later, Raph is visiting the Foot again when the guy who hired them to kidnap Shadow (her biological grandfather, who only appears in the Image series) sends his goons to wipe out the Foot. Raph finds a hidden room, where the original Shredder kept his spare armor suits, and all his personal weapons. Raph suits up as the Shredder, and saves the remnants of the Foot clan. Quote:
Pimiko and Raph are both ousted, and Lady Shredder's identity is never revealed. |
Great recap, I really am understanding now. So Image is a different company than Mirage...and therefore is this whole "universe" is unofficial?
|
Quote:
There is also the Dreamwave comics that appear to be based on the 2k3 series (it was pretty) but it had a short life of seven comics. Pity, I was liking where it was going myself *sighs* I personally like the Image comics as well (not really liking Vol4 so far myself, but I'm sort of reading them out of order). The only problem I'm having is the fact that they just seem to stop without finishing their story due to lack of interest. *sighs* After watching the cartoons for so long, its nice to see that the Turtles will actually kill people. They are, after all, Ninjas. |
Why is Volume 4 called Volume 4? Since Vol 3 is unofficial...?
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:26 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.