The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Splinter and Casey's potrayal in the film (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19494)

jignat 04-05-2007 12:00 AM

Splinter and Casey's potrayal in the film
 
What were you guys/gals thoughts on these 2 's characterization ?

I liked Casey, as it shows he has some problems adjusting to living with April, but
it seemed really weird that after Raph says he quit, that Casey of all people tells him to take a breather That seemed a bit out of character , maybe if april or don did.
Then again I did like his big kid like nature . Imo he was the funniest character with the best lines imo.

One of my friends thought Casey had been castrated almost. He says the change in his personality is too much to accept, even more than aprils change of professions. He says Casey should have been more "Crazy/unpredictable".

Splinter -- a lot of people on the net seemed to think splinter was too harsh , gruff overall. I confess with the voice and how he says "there are no excuses when you are the leader , my student" Also, it seems that as he is harping on the guys to put aside their differences and reunite, it seems ironic since he sends Leo to train. didnt he think they would slowly drift apart?
Especially with Raph 's rage etc..
Another thing I would have liked to have seen is a scene with splinter + the boys training in the lair or at least making them practice. also Im surprised Splinter is fine w/ mike the most immature going out to the surface during the day ,w/o fear of someone finding the lair or something after the events of TMNT 1. Though I'm glad he participates in the final battle and such.

Your thoughts?

Revan 04-05-2007 12:14 AM

It felt to me that Casey was going through a maturation. He tells raph he doesn't know if he is ready to settle down. He sounds like a young man becoming a man to me. We know him to be a crazy big kid but perhaps he's finally growing up.

Also, I felt that when he kisses April it shows that Casey is ready to move to the next step with April.

just my opinion

triplexxx 04-05-2007 12:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jignat (Post 490787)
Splinter -- a lot of people on the net seemed to think splinter was too harsh , gruff overall. I confess with the voice and how he says "there are no excuses when you are the leader , my student" Also, it seems that as he is harping on the guys to put aside their differences and reunite, it seems ironic since he sends Leo to train. didnt he think they would slowly drift apart?
Especially with Raph 's rage etc..
Another thing I would have liked to have seen is a scene with splinter + the boys training in the lair or at least making them practice. also Im surprised Splinter is fine w/ mike the most immature going out to the surface during the day ,w/o fear of someone finding the lair or something after the events of TMNT 1. Though I'm glad he participates in the final battle and such.

Your thoughts?

That's why I formulated my whole Splinter's-to-blame theory, because HE IS TO BLAME for the fact they drifted apart. What I didn't like was that he never thought about this & thought of blaming himself for the family break-up when his decision was what provoked their differences to get the better of them & broke them up in the first place. And despite their differences in levels of maturity, every turtle is well-trained and very self-sufficient and can take care of themselves up on the surface, day or night.

jignat 04-05-2007 12:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triplexxx (Post 490802)
. And despite their differences in levels of maturity, every turtle is well-trained and very self-sufficient and can take care of themselves up on the surface, day or night.

The turtles can take care of themselves, but all it takes is one lucky criminal to find their lair to make a mess of things.
in TMNT 1, even though Raph defeated aprils Attackers, he was still followed by foot ninjas who found the lair, then strategically waited for Splinter to be left alone, overpowered him, and you kknow the rest.

Willis 04-05-2007 01:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neutrino (Post 490799)
It felt to me that Casey was going through a maturation. He tells raph he doesn't know if he is ready to settle down. He sounds like a young man becoming a man to me. We know him to be a crazy big kid but perhaps he's finally growing up.

Also, I felt that when he kisses April it shows that Casey is ready to move to the next step with April.

just my opinion

Agreed, he knew April (pardon the pun) wanted a man in her life, but wasn't sure if he had what it took to meet those requirements. Actually I got the idea that he knew he could step up, or as you said settle down.. but was afraid it meant loosing everything else that defined who he was. Being sorta care-free and able to run around at night beating up thugs. (which meant sleeping all day :lol: )

Thats where the self doubt was coming from. But maybe I'm reading too much into it. (the casey-raph conversation is getting very foggy).


As far as Splinter goes.. I think he's very on top of things. Like a parent watching his kids grow up, he's letting them make their own decisions and make lives for themselves. I'm sure if he felt things were unsafe or any one of them were risking the security of home, he would have said something.

Regarding the hate-splinter thing..Two things come to mind:

1) If you live your life only being told and never figuring it out on your own - you'll never truthfully learn or mature. Some lessons are just better taught by watching from the sidelines and not coaching.

2) Some events are unable to be avoided. Do you have siblings? Have you grown up without ever fighting? I doubt it... The Turtles were bound to have issues among themselves as any family does, you cannot learn to coexist by having someone else constantly force you down into getting along - you need to work it out for yourselves.

triplexxx 04-05-2007 01:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jignat (Post 490816)
The turtles can take care of themselves, but all it takes is one lucky criminal to find their lair to make a mess of things.
in TMNT 1, even though Raph defeated aprils Attackers, he was still followed by foot ninjas who found the lair, then strategically waited for Splinter to be left alone, overpowered him, and you kknow the rest.

My guess on this situation: Splinter let his guard down in this movie. Since Shredder was dead, he probably figured the Foot were out of business and no other single criminal or criminal group had the capability to find their lair and pose a worthy threat to them. Though he was wrong about the Foot, nobody did find the lair in the movie, so no harm, no foul.

odupianist 04-05-2007 08:12 AM

Quote:

didnt he think they would slowly drift apart?
Maybe part of Leo's training was Leo leaving, family growing apart, and Leo coming back and having to pull the family together. That could have easily been the training. That's how I see it. I wouldn't hate Splinter for it. Splinter was obviously wise enough to see it.

Quote:

Another thing I would have liked to have seen is a scene with splinter + the boys training in the lair or at least making them practice.
Agreed.

Quote:

Splinter let his guard down in this movie. Since Shredder was dead, he probably figured the Foot were out of business and no other single criminal or criminal group had the capability to find their lair and pose a worthy threat to them.
Why would he have thought Shredder was dead in the first movie?


One thing I liked about Splinter though and I thought this was done quite nicely. When Raph comes back and Leo's been captured, Splinter is understanding and tryign to listen to Raph, here's what Raph has to say then goes from understanding to a quick second of compassion and hurt then to all out pissed but collected mode. Anyone else notice that? I thought that was hilarious. I started chuckling a bit even.

johnnyblaze 04-05-2007 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triplexxx (Post 490802)
That's why I formulated my whole Splinter's-to-blame theory, because HE IS TO BLAME for the fact they drifted apart. What I didn't like was that he never thought about this & thought of blaming himself for the family break-up when his decision was what provoked their differences to get the better of them & broke them up in the first place. And despite their differences in levels of maturity, every turtle is well-trained and very self-sufficient and can take care of themselves up on the surface, day or night.

still don't agree with you. All he did was try to protect his sons while Leo was away by telling them not to fight crime until they are a team again. Leo's training was specifically to aid all the turtles. He never told them not to train, he never told them not to seek out other interests, all he did was ask them not to fight crime. Raphael ofcourse took it the hardest (while Mikey and Don were not happy with it they didn't flip out like Raph) but whose to say Splinter didn't try and reach out to him the year Leo was gone. He knew what was bothering Raph (Leo) and when Leo came back he told him to reach to his brother.

And while yes each turtle is well trained in fighting there are differences in their skill level beyond teh physical aspects. With Leo's role in the team and his skill level he needed him to step it up a bit so he sent him to train. He thought Leo was ready for this so he sent him to gain the skills he needed to be better for his brothers. When the other turtles are ready i'm sure he's going to take the neccessary steps to push them forward in their training--but only when they are ready.

johnnyblaze 04-05-2007 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by odupianist (Post 490910)
Maybe part of Leo's training was Leo leaving, family growing apart, and Leo coming back and having to pull the family together. That could have easily been the training. That's how I see it. I wouldn't hate Splinter for it. Splinter was obviously wise enough to see it.



Agreed.



Why would he have thought Shredder was dead in the first movie?


One thing I liked about Splinter though and I thought this was done quite nicely. When Raph comes back and Leo's been captured, Splinter is understanding and tryign to listen to Raph, here's what Raph has to say then goes from understanding to a quick second of compassion and hurt then to all out pissed but collected mode. Anyone else notice that? I thought that was hilarious. I started chuckling a bit even.

I liked that while talking to Raphael he told him what qualities made him important to the team/family, why, when he was ready, he would be a good leader, and what exactly he needed to learn to be able to reach that point.

I think they hit a good balance between the ninja master who wants to students properly trained and a concerned father, who just wants the safety of his family

jenna 04-05-2007 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jignat (Post 490787)
it seemed really weird that after Raph says he quit, that Casey of all people tells him to take a breather That seemed a bit out of character , maybe if april or don did.

In the book at this point he says something along the lines of he spent his entire life being mad and running out of rooms and that he regrets it and wishes he had just taken a breather.

triplexxx 04-05-2007 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 490935)
still don't agree with you. All he did was try to protect his sons while Leo was away by telling them not to fight crime until they are a team again. Leo's training was specifically to aid all the turtles.

Yeah, but it ended up hurting them even more. They never would've had to regain their team dynamic if Splinter hadn't taken it from them in the first place.
Quote:

With Leo's role in the team and his skill level he needed him to step it up a bit so he sent him to train. He thought Leo was ready for this so he sent him to gain the skills he needed to be better for his brothers. When the other turtles are ready i'm sure he's going to take the neccessary steps to push them forward in their training--but only when they are ready.
And since when did Leonardo ever have to step it up? When has his leadership ever let the team down? When has Splinter's training ever not been enough for him? And how exactly did this year away make it any better? Not to mention, whenever did it cross Splinter's mind that sending his sons away on individual missions would be beneficial to the team and family dynamics?
True, in the end, they were a team and a family again, but it wasn't because of what they learned during their year apart, it's because of what they learned during the course of this movie, after they were reunited.
And what they learned is that they never needed jobs, special training assignments, or publicly known undercover identities (Nightwatcher) in order to function properly and be able to serve each of their purposes on the team. All they ever needed in order to do that was each other, and they had that all along, they were just deprived of it for a year, thanks to Splinter. They would've been just as strong a team as they were at the end of the movie even if Splinter hadn't broken them up in the first place, because all this succeeded in doing was getting two brothers fighting each other and getting one of them captured.

And about this whole Leonardo's training was a setup to break the family up so he could put them back together again: just because Leonardo's leader doesn't mean it's his sole responsibility to hold the team together, that takes all turtles' efforts and it's every turtles's responsibility, whatever their positions are on the team is irrelevant. Every turtle has an individual purpose on the team, every turtle's purpose is equally vital to the team, and if any one of them was gone, the others would fall apart.

Remember what Raphael said at the end->"We live together, we train together, we fight together, we stand for good together, We are ninjas. We strike hard, defend, protect, and fade into the night. And there aint no bad guy or monster ever going to change that, thats whats important, thats why we'll always be, brothers.....Oh, I love bein' a turtle". A lot of emphasis on the word "together". It is true that when they fight crime for NY they should indeed do so together, and their training should be no different. The mere fact that they train is good, but when they do so separately, it can cause problems as this movie proves; that's why they should always remain united both in the battle field, and in the practice dojo.

You don't have to agree with me, you can think what you want, but I still choose to believe Splinter's decision was a mistake, and I've good reason for it.
Quote:

Why would he have thought Shredder was dead in the first movie?
I was referring to this movie, not the first. Shredder is dead in this movie.

johnnyblaze 04-05-2007 11:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triplexxx (Post 491108)
Yeah, but it ended up hurting them even more. They never would've had to regain their team dynamic if Splinter hadn't taken it from them in the first place.

And since when did Leonardo ever have to step it up? When has his leadership ever let the team down? When has Splinter's training ever not been enough for him? And how exactly did this year away make it any better? Not to mention, whenever did it cross Splinter's mind that sending his sons away on individual missions would be beneficial to the team and family dynamics?
True, in the end, they were a team and a family again, but it wasn't because of what they learned during their year apart, it's because of what they learned during the course of this movie, after they were reunited.
And what they learned is that they never needed jobs, special training assignments, or publicly known undercover identities (Nightwatcher) in order to function properly and be able to serve each of their purposes on the team. All they ever needed in order to do that was each other, and they had that all along, they were just deprived of it for a year, thanks to Splinter. They would've been just as strong a team as they were at the end of the movie even if Splinter hadn't broken them up in the first place, because all this succeeded in doing was getting two brothers fighting each other and getting one of them captured.

And about this whole Leonardo's training was a setup to break the family up so he could put them back together again: just because Leonardo's leader doesn't mean it's his sole responsibility to hold the team together, that takes all turtles' efforts and it's every turtles's responsibility, whatever their positions are on the team is irrelevant. Every turtle has an individual purpose on the team, every turtle's purpose is equally vital to the team, and if any one of them was gone, the others would fall apart.

Remember what Raphael said at the end->"We live together, we train together, we fight together, we stand for good together, We are ninjas. We strike hard, defend, protect, and fade into the night. And there aint no bad guy or monster ever going to change that, thats whats important, thats why we'll always be, brothers.....Oh, I love bein' a turtle". A lot of emphasis on the word "together". It is true that when they fight crime for NY they should indeed do so together, and their training should be no different. The mere fact that they train is good, but when they do so separately, it can cause problems as this movie proves; that's why they should always remain united both in the battle field, and in the practice dojo.

You don't have to agree with me, you can think what you want, but I still choose to believe Splinter's decision was a mistake, and I've good reason for it.

I was referring to this movie, not the first. Shredder is dead in this movie.

Regardless of what happened after Splinter sent Leonardo away to train the team dynamic was compromised by the turtles inability to stick together as a family. Yes, Splinter sent Leonardo to train (and when I say stepping it up a notch I mean just that--taking his ability to lead and his skills and taking it up a notch for the benifit of the team) but there was already an established reason for this:Leonardo was ready--the others weren't. I mean yeah they are a team and a family but they are still very much individuals. They are individuals so its to expect that they may go in different directions at certain points in their lives because that is what happens when a family grows. Should Splinter had considered the possibility that things may not work out? Yeah and i'm sure he did but as their teacher he was to do whats best for their training. And that training has to play to their strengths and weaknesses. This was a mission designed for Leonardo and his strengths and weaknesses so he sent Leonardo.

And maybe part of what his training was supposed to show him was the importance of family. We already know that while Leo is well meaning he can be a bit arrogant (and as shown in his argument with Raph he deep down thinks that he is better than his brother). We know that Leo felt he was missing something that was preventing him from being a success in his mission. And we know that when he returned Splinter told him the time away should have made him stronger--and that his next mission was to bring order to the team/family which had only fallen apart because they were banned from doing the hero thing and they couldn't deal with that. Maybe the point was for him to realize and respect the strengths of his brothers (which is exactly what he learned through his battle with Raphael). Yes they look up to him , yes Splinter looks to him to help guide them when they need it, and yes they had a solid working dynamic before but it was far from perfect, especially on the Leo and Raph front (which Donatello pointed out was always the biggest issue with the team and their work.)It wasn't until the two actually got into a fight did things click and they found the respect for each other that was missing from their relationship.

Your acting like this rivalry is something new. These brothers were fighting way before Leo left. There has always been beef between certain members of the group (as I said before Donatello even mentioned it being a main issue with the group) even though yes they do love each other. But now that everything is out in the open and things have been vented its no longer brother vs brother like it used to be or falling in line again like little soldiers as Raphael described working with Leo. (and yeah Leo and Raph fought but the 2 of them taking swings at each other is not because of Splinter but because of Leo and Raph's inability to simply get along and respect each other. and thats something thats been brewing for years)The mission was supposed to make him realize and respect the strength of his team (and i'm willing to bet money that more specifically it was supposed to make him respect Raph more). When he said that he failed its because originally he missed the point of the mission--that the thing he could not figure out was missing and preventing him from completing his training was his family. He needs their support just as much as they need his (and don't get it twisted just because they need each others support does not mean the lose any kind of individuality that they have. you can still be your own person while knowing that your family has your back). Its not just a physical training mission but one thats supposed to make him emotionally better for each and every single one of his brothers. And yeah its not until the end that they are stronger and better than before because, well, there wouldn't be a movie if everything was spelled out in the beggining of the flick.

And yeah emphasis is put on togetherness because thats the lesson of the story, that if they are going to be out and about being the crime fighting heroes they know they can be they are going to need each other to be successful. And on a personal front for the boys it hammers home the idea that even if one of them is gone it doesn't mean they should fall apart. It doesn't make them any less of a family and it doesn't make it ok to stop supporting each other.

I just think your forgetting the most important thing: Heroics are only one aspect of who they are and what they do--and when it comes down to that yeah, Splinter would rather it be all 4 of them because all of their strengths will come into play and help save the day. But that is just when it comes to being crime fighters (which they were not supposed to be at the time).

Aside from that, they are individual parts of a family. Their falling out should have never came into play because just because one is gone doesn't mean the others should stop caring. Leo is still their brother. Splinter is still their father. Yes Leo is training for them, yes Splinter wants them to hold off on crimefighting but its ok. Why should they fall apart? Yes being together makes them stronger, but being apart should not make them weak. They don't have to freak out, or get angry or bitter or bored with life just because Leo went away or because they aren't allowed to run the streets beating up bad guys. If anything Splinter probably didn't realize that his boys relied so much on conflict to get by.

triplexxx 04-06-2007 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyblaze (Post 491303)
Regardless of what happened after Splinter sent Leonardo away to train the team dynamic was compromised by the turtles inability to stick together as a family. Yes, Splinter sent Leonardo to train (and when I say stepping it up a notch I mean just that--taking his ability to lead and his skills and taking it up a notch for the benifit of the team) but there was already an established reason for this:Leonardo was ready--the others weren't. I mean yeah they are a team and a family but they are still very much individuals. They are individuals so its to expect that they may go in different directions at certain points in their lives because that is what happens when a family grows. Should Splinter had considered the possibility that things may not work out? Yeah and i'm sure he did but as their teacher he was to do whats best for their training. And that training has to play to their strengths and weaknesses. This was a mission designed for Leonardo and his strengths and weaknesses so he sent Leonardo.

First off, it's not what happened after Splinter's decision to send him away that affected the team dynamic, it was the decision itself. Whether Leonardo is ready or not doesn't matter. Unfortunately for the turtles, they can't afford to live and go down their own paths like other "individuals". Their entire existence depends on their sticking together and to the shadows. If Splinter considered the consequences, then he should've forseen what would end up happening between Raphael and Leonardo and called it off, because all this did was make them more arrogant towards each other and almost caused them to kill each other. What's best for their training is that they "always train together" as Raphael so clearly stated at the end.
Quote:

And maybe part of what his training was supposed to show him was the importance of family. We already know that while Leo is well meaning he can be a bit arrogant (and as shown in his argument with Raph he deep down thinks that he is better than his brother). We know that Leo felt he was missing something that was preventing him from being a success in his mission. And we know that when he returned Splinter told him the time away should have made him stronger--and that his next mission was to bring order to the team/family which had only fallen apart because they were banned from doing the hero thing and they couldn't deal with that. Maybe the point was for him to realize and respect the strengths of his brothers (which is exactly what he learned through his battle with Raphael). Yes they look up to him , yes Splinter looks to him to help guide them when they need it, and yes they had a solid working dynamic before but it was far from perfect, especially on the Leo and Raph front (which Donatello pointed out was always the biggest issue with the team and their work.)It wasn't until the two actually got into a fight did things click and they found the respect for each other that was missing from their relationship.

Your acting like this rivalry is something new.
Newsflash: his time away didn't make him stronger, his coming home and being with his family is what did that. He never had to leave home to become stronger. That, I think was kind of a overreactive move on Splinter's part. Yes, their team dynamic isn't perfect, but nothing ever is, no matter how hard you try to make it. There may not be anything "perfect" in this world, but I do believe there are things that are "as good as they get". And no, I'm not acting like this rivalry is anything new, I know darn well there's always been heat between Leonardo and Raphael. However, their conflict has never been brought to this level of lethality before, where they could've accidently killed each other in a personal fight.
Quote:

These brothers were fighting way before Leo left. There has always been beef between certain members of the group (as I said before Donatello even mentioned it being a main issue with the group) even though yes they do love each other. But now that everything is out in the open and things have been vented its no longer brother vs brother like it used to be or falling in line again like little soldiers as Raphael described working with Leo. (and yeah Leo and Raph fought but the 2 of them taking swings at each other is not because of Splinter but because of Leo and Raph's inability to simply get along and respect each other. and thats something thats been brewing for years)
I think it's you that's acting like this "respect" is new. Like i already said, there's always been heat between certain brothers, but, nevertheless, they still have always had a healthy amount of respect for each other. Splinter could've fixed that without first making things worse between them by separating them for a year.

Quote:

And yeah emphasis is put on togetherness because thats the lesson of the story, that if they are going to be out and about being the crime fighting heroes they know they can be they are going to need each other to be successful. And on a personal front for the boys it hammers home the idea that even if one of them is gone it doesn't mean they should fall apart. It doesn't make them any less of a family and it doesn't make it ok to stop supporting each other.

I just think your forgetting the most important thing: Heroics are only one aspect of who they are and what they do--and when it comes down to that yeah, Splinter would rather it be all 4 of them because all of their strengths will come into play and help save the day. But that is just when it comes to being crime fighters (which they were not supposed to be at the time).

Aside from that, they are individual parts of a family. Their falling out should have never came into play because just because one is gone doesn't mean the others should stop caring. Leo is still their brother. Splinter is still their father. Yes Leo is training for them, yes Splinter wants them to hold off on crimefighting but its ok. Why should they fall apart? Yes being together makes them stronger, but being apart should not make them weak. They don't have to freak out, or get angry or bitter or bored with life just because Leo went away or because they aren't allowed to run the streets beating up bad guys. If anything Splinter probably didn't realize that his boys relied so much on conflict to get by.
Don't you remember SAINW? Remember what happened to the team/family when Donatello disappeared for many years. Beleive it or not, yes they are less of a family and cannot function properly if one of them is missing. Remember when Leonardo said in Grudge Match, "If one of us goes down, we all go down."? Being apart does make them weaker. That's why "remaining together" is so emphasized and is the main moral of this movie.

And who said anything about them not caring for each other anymore? That's not what the year of separation did to them. They still cared very much about each other. They only stopped working together and living their lives together, except for Donatello and Michaelangelo.

Freak out? Nobody freaked out, not even Raphael, he just found something constructive to do with his time. Something Splinter never really offered him or his brothers their entire life. The reason they depend on fighting crime is because it actually gives them a purpose in life. In case you don't remember the original comic storyline: the reason Splinter trained them in the first place was so they could use those skills to satisfy his personal vendetta. Their decision to be crime-fighters was entirely their choice, not his. I honestly doubt Splinter ever intended for his sons to ever use those skills he taught them for anything besides his vendetta, which would make him a somewhat negligent father.

Seiza 04-07-2007 05:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jignat (Post 490787)
it seemed really weird that after Raph says he quit, that Casey of all people tells him to take a breather That seemed a bit out of character , maybe if april or don did.

I thought Casey was the perfect person to stop Raph. Casey's closest in temperament to him AND his best friend, so you'd assume he'd be the first one to back Raph up. Yet, this hot-headed vigilante is the one telling Raph to calm down. It highlights how extreme Raph's actions were. If April or Don had done it, it wouldn't have felt the same because these two are seen as more "peaceful" characters.

Movie!Casey is love. My friend developed a bit of a crush on him. :D He's just a lovable big boy. And his lines were gold: "You do know I only have a wooden bat, don't you?" :lol:

Quote:

Splinter -- a lot of people on the net seemed to think splinter was too harsh , gruff overall. I confess with the voice and how he says "there are no excuses when you are the leader , my student" Also, it seems that as he is harping on the guys to put aside their differences and reunite, it seems ironic since he sends Leo to train. didnt he think they would slowly drift apart?
I don't think Splinter could have foreseen them drifting apart. For one, Leo was gone longer than he should've been. Secondly, and what I feel is the more important factor: Leo stopped writing back--Splinter definitely didn't tell him to do that, and cutting himself off emotionally must've hurt his brothers more than the physical distance. Personally, I think the latter was what made Raph really snap, not Splinter's decision to send Leo away.

Movie!Splinter strikes me as a normal sensei/father without superhuman sixth sense. Other versions always feel like the omni-wise-who-sees-all sensei. Movie!Splinter, though... when he was humming to himself in the breakfast scene, he struck me as almost oblivious (I think 2k3!Splinter would've known immediately something was up). So I wouldn't say he's on top of things. I can't imagine Splinter teaching them teamwork and family in this roundabout manner, when he couldn't even sense the tension at the breakfast table. I actually think he's a bit flawed here, and nicely so.

Movie!Splinter reminds me of parents who, without meaning to, depend overly on their eldest child. So I can see why he sent Leo out to train first, not predicting what would happen. Why not? Everything seems peaceful; travelling the world on his own would give him new experiences not found in a NY sewer. Leo's also the oldest, and, well... the oldest child is always the guinea pig for parental experiments. :P Perhaps after Leo returned, Splinter was planning to send Raph, Don and Mikey, one by one.

But when Leo unexpectedly cut off communication, I think he fumbled without his eldest around to be his second-in-command (when he was telling Donny to "be strong when your brothers are weak," I could just imagine him giving the same speech to Leo; and I think he was reminded of that too, from the sad look at the end).

So... Yeah. I like this Splinter. Well-meaning, but goofed up a bit in his methods. I'm not sure where he comes off as "harsh/gruff" (or moreso than his other incarnations)-- he reprimanded Leo because, as leader, it was Leo's fault that he couldn't control his "men". When a project goes awry, no matter who's involved, it's the head that rolls. Of course, it seemed unfair that he didn't take Raph to task too, but that's Splinter's weakness emerging: too much dependence on the oldest (and maybe even an overestimation of Leo's influence over his brothers), which hopefully diminished when his three sons pulled together on their own to rescue Leo.

johnnyblaze 04-07-2007 08:58 AM

Splinter just didn't expect his sons to forget so easily what it meant to be a family. Just because 1 is gone does not mean the others should have fallen apart or lose faith in each other. I can understand the super hero aspect of their relationship may be a bit rusty but had the other more personal end to their relationship never been compromised by them 'cracking' over the loss of Leo they would not have had an issue. Hell even Casey and April seemed a bit thrown off as to how the turtles reacted to Leo leaving. It seems to me Splinter thought his sons were stronger when it comes to that family aspect but apparently he was a bit wrong about that.

Seiza 04-07-2007 09:11 AM

^Agreed, especially when we find out just how much the turtles have been through together. Usually, you'd think life-threatening adventures (and the turtles had a lot of those, going by the Trophy Room) would bring people closer together. So I can't fault Splinter for not predicting that one son going away for a while would spell disaster.

Looking at it this way, it's fitting that the guys rescued Leo. That was the moment of reckoning: there was no alternative, Leo was not going to come back on his own. Either they got their act together or else.

jenna 04-08-2007 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 492116)
Of course, it seemed unfair that he didn't take Raph to task too, but that's Splinter's weakness emerging: too much dependence on the oldest (and maybe even an overestimation of Leo's influence over his brothers), which hopefully diminished when his three sons pulled together on their own to rescue Leo.

Also, I think in this film, Splinter seems to be very aware that Raphael is suffering and exhibits some fatherly protection over him. eg: Raphael is being aggressive with Donatello, yet Splinter chides Donatello for not recognising Raphael's positive qualities (I mean, all Don really did was make a comment: "Why couldn't you send him away for training?"); Splinter tells Leonardo that although he owes him no apology, he should talk about his prolonged absence with Raph who has struggled without him; when Leo tries to place the blame with Raph, Splinter jumps on him; and of course, later, he tells Leonardo that the team is incomplete without Raph. It is almost as though Splinter can recognise the role he has played in the rivalry between them by showing favouritism towards Leo and he is now trying to make amends to undo the damage done to Raphael.

One of the lines I really liked in the book which didn't make the film was when he said to Leo something along the lines: "A good leader knows when to show compassion and understanding. Your brother is in much need of both".

Bless Splinter... despite being a ninja master with a really wicked life story, he really is just a dad who loves his kids.

johnnyblaze 04-08-2007 06:47 PM

edit: nevermind

Seiza 04-08-2007 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenna (Post 493188)
It is almost as though Splinter can recognise the role he has played in the rivalry between them by showing favouritism towards Leo and he is now trying to make amends to undo the damage done to Raphael.

Though I'm not sure showing favouritism to another son is the best way to fix things. ;) (Can't help it, I keep scoffing at the scene where Raph storms outta Splinter's room. Students would never get away with that in our dojo. But then again, my sensei doesn't suffer from being a parent-cum-teacher. This was one case where I think Splinter couldn't separate his teacher/father role properly.)

Good point about Splinter's reaction to the Don/Raph argument (and about the fatherly protection, now that you mention it). I think he's most in tune with Raph's emotions out of anyone else in the family, so he almost takes it upon himself to explain Raph's actions to his brothers. That's what he seemed to be doing to Donny, and later practically spells out Raph's source of frustration to Leo.

Quote:

One of the lines I really liked in the book which didn't make the film was when he said to Leo something along the lines: "A good leader knows when to show compassion and understanding. Your brother is in much need of both".
That's so sweet! O_O

ARGH. Why did so much good stuff not make it to the movie?! :cry:

RaphistheBest 04-08-2007 11:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by odupianist (Post 490910)
Maybe part of Leo's training was Leo leaving, family growing apart, and Leo coming back and having to pull the family together. That could have easily been the training.

Leo leaving was part of his training, that's very straight forward. However, Leo didn't come back when he was supposed to. When April found Leo in the jungle she mentioned the fact that his training had ended and that he should have come home a long time ago. I think that Splinter figured that his best student would come back when he was supposed to and when he didn't he was probably pretty surprised. So I don't think that Splinter had it planned out that the family would drift apart and then Leo would show back up to pull them back together.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 12:03 AM

Quote:

Though I'm not sure showing favouritism to another son is the best way to fix things.
It's not. That's just something Splinter did which made things worse between them. It's just that Splinter probably realizes that this was "his" mistake and is trying to convince Raphael that it isn't the case, that he doesn't have a favorite.

Coola Yagami 04-09-2007 12:17 AM

The thing is.. since when were the TMNT supposed to actually be 'crimefighting heroes'? Weren't they just supposed to just try to live was a normal family, except weird stuff keeps happening to them all the time (mostly cause they killed Shredder and the Foot was always after them)?

Haven't seen the movie yet except for a short clip of Leo saying 'the Nightwatcher's days are done' and Raph saying the Nightwatcher was pickin up the slack since Leo left 'crime didn't take a break... you did'.

Since when does Leo get the idea that only they can stop crime in the city? What makes it THEIR city? And since when does Raph think THEY have to stop crime and the city will go to hell if at least one of them doesn't continue to fight crime?

As far as I can tell from the regular TMNT comics, their motives were-

first issue- Splinter trained them to kill Shredder
second/third issue- TMNT saw these new Mousers as a potencial threat to Splinter
triceratons/ultroms- all this was because Splinter was missing and they went through all that TCRI/Triceraton stuff to find him
shredder's return- the foot and shredder were the ones that beat Leo to an inch of his life
return to NY- payback time
city at war- the shredder elite were looking to kill Leo in revenge of their master. They only helped Karai so the Foot could leave them the hell alone already
volume 2- Baxter went after april, the tmnt retaliated

movie 1- TMNT happened to save April from the Foot, the rest was due to the Foot's retaliation, kidnapping splinter and beating Raph within an inch of his life
movie 2- all started when the Foot came back and started messing with april and shredder returning and stuff
movie 3- they were basically livin their own casual normal lives before april brought that damn artifact into their home


So basically the TMNT just try to live their lives. The constant Foot being after them all the time, or being at the wrong place at the wrong time keeps putting them into adventures. Unlike the older cartoon, they don't just go around trying to keep the city safe, jumping at a simple bank robbery or jewelry theft. In TMNT1 Raph went out to see a movie before he met Casey, he wasn't out lookin for trouble. In TMNT2 they only rescued Keno cause they happened to see him in trouble from across the street, not cause they were 'patrolling the streets looking for crimes to stop'. The clips I've seen from the movie makes it sound like they decided to become a crimefighting team.

Shark_Blade 04-09-2007 04:47 AM

In my opinion Splinter send Leo for training but not for a whole year. Leo was too caught up that's why the delay.

April said "Your training ended a year ago". So it's not the sensei's fault.I assume his training is like 2,3 months.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 11:12 AM

Splinter knew how much Leonardo's training meant to him and Splinter's training at home never failed him or any of the other turtles, and he also knew about Raphael's feelings towards Leonardo and he should've been certain that this whole deal would only end up worsening things between them, he doesn't need a "psychic sixth sense" to know that.

Also, what was always the turtles best asset in battle? Togetherness/Teamwork.
And when is their training most productive? When they do it together.

Splinter made this mistake, got the team separated, and then lay the blame on his sons. It wasn't until after Raphael and Leonardo brawled and Leonardo got captured that Splinter started act responsibly and being constructive towards his family.

johnnyblaze 04-09-2007 11:53 AM

he didn't blame anyone. Yeah he yelled at Leo--because he was the field leader when they ignored his request that they not fight. because of that he said he was dissapointed in Leo and when Leo tried to lay the blame on Raph Splinter stopped him.

Aside from that Splinter only asked that Leo talk to Raph seeing as though he was upset that Leo was gone for so long (a year longer than he was supposed to be gone )

aabxx 04-09-2007 03:17 PM

Leonardo sees himself as a warrior. There are times in a warrior's life, that the warrior is best left alone. In solitude the warrior can take a break from his responsibilities, hone his skills and learn new things about himself and the world.

It's not about Splinter splitting the team... it's more like Leonardo NEEDING to take that journey for himself and Splinter eager to comply. Btw, this happened with Leo in the 2003-cartoon too. And I seem to remember at least one of the other turtles taking a break from the group in the old or the new series as well. And I'm certain that Splinter has taken a break too, at least once... so taking a break is not so extraordinary as some of you make it sound.

I would think each of the turtles will want to take a break from the team sooner or later. It happens to every team... sooner or later, every member needs to experience solitude for various reasons. And the turtles would have many reasons to take a break from the team.

The interesting part is that whenever one member leaves, the team is on standby. So it sort of means everyone else takes a break as well. In Raphael's case, that frustrated him. And Michaelangelo became a "party dude"... I think it might've started off as something Mikey thought would be fun, but then it became routine and he learned some valuable lessons about life I think (ie. he matured). Don on the other hand, being the most mature of the bunch, failed to create harmony in the group... I'm not sure how much he tried though, Don being a loner and at the end of the day he'll always be more engulfed in his techno projects than keeping the family united (I know that feeling btw, and at the end of his days he might've thought a bit about this as well). I bet he learned a good few things about how hard it is to be a leader, family dynamics, Leo's role, about the others' personalities and his own. But maybe he failed to learn the most important lesson: Sometimes he needs a break from the machines... and I'd say he's the most likely turtle to find himself in central america or whereever next :D

Anyway, this blaming Splinter thing is silly.

jenna 04-09-2007 04:24 PM

Yeah, if Leo was every going to be a good leader, he needed to stop being the middleman between Splinter and the remaining turtles and learn the maturity and responsibility that could only be achieved by a period of self reflection and personal growth. We all saw Leo struggle as leader in Film 1 when Splinter was abducted. He wasn't able to take full control of the team until after some peaceful time at the farm. At first, he chose a path of what was effectively inactivity to find Splinter, allowed himself to be drawn into an argument with Raphael, and to resort to petty name calling in the process (which, if he weren't under the pressure of Splinter's absence, I'm sure he wouldn't have done - he would have simply delt with Raph with the quiet tolerance he previous employed). It was only after meditation etc that he made the decision to return to New York and be proactive. I think his time away in South America is an expansion of this.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenna (Post 494298)
Yeah, if Leo was every going to be a good leader, he needed to stop being the middleman between Splinter and the remaining turtles and learn the maturity and responsibility that could only be achieved by a period of self reflection and personal growth. We all saw Leo struggle as leader in Film 1 when Splinter was abducted. He wasn't able to take full control of the team until after some peaceful time at the farm. At first, he chose a path of what was effectively inactivity to find Splinter, allowed himself to be drawn into an argument with Raphael, and to resort to petty name calling in the process (which, if he weren't under the pressure of Splinter's absence, I'm sure he wouldn't have done - he would have simply delt with Raph with the quiet tolerance he previous employed).

You mean like the "quiet tolerance" he used on the rooftop before he and Raphael duked it out, saying things like "I'm better than you"? He also said the same thing about Raphael he did in the first movie, "Do we really need Raphael?", no family members were kidnapped, so no pressure.

Like aabxx said above, maybe it is true that solitude can help individual warriors on a team learn new things about themselves. But what did the turtles really learn about themselves during their year apart? All I saw was Donatello and Michaelangelo wrapped up in work (I don't see how Michaelangelo matured anymore), Raphael emotionally disconnecting from everyone and becoming too sure of his own independence, and Leonardo's middleman issue, as you put it, only worsening.

You ever heard anyone say that the turtles personalities are what they are because their family helps make them that way? That's most definitely truthful.
Raphael helped make Leonardo who he is and vice versa. It's probably the same with Donatello and Michaelangelo. Donatello has an aggressive side too, and Raphael tends to bring that out of him. Michaelangelo helps temper Leonardo's seriousness. The connections are endless.

Without being connected to one another, they don't learn and retain the lessons which are MOST important. Sometimes there are important things that can be learned in solitude, but is it worth learning these lessons if you have to forget those which you learned when you're with your family and not in solitude? Sometimes, learning certain knowledge can push other knowledge out of one's head. The turtles didn't learn the MOST important lessons during the year they were separated, they learned it during the course of this movie, after they had come back together and started interacting again.

After seeing what this resulted in, I doubt Splinter will ever again consider sending a son away like that. And this whole blaming Splinter thing is far from silly, it's very logical if one does the math.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 06:37 PM

Or dose not like Splinter.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 06:54 PM

....or just knows darn well what they're talking about and can back up their opinion. And I loved Splinter in the previous movies, but he was very different here.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 07:02 PM

Uh huh. So why is Splinter getting it all dumped on him when Leo chose to play "Ghost of the jungle" longer than he should have?

triplexxx 04-09-2007 07:04 PM

Because it was a mistake sending him to go become "ghost of the jungle" in the first place.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 07:07 PM

So's not coming back when you're supposed to.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 07:08 PM

Nevertheless, Splinter threw the first pitch.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 07:09 PM

And Leo took it too far.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 07:10 PM

And would never have done so if Splinter just kept him and everyone else home in the first place.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 07:11 PM

But was still responcible for staying there when he should have come back because of his own descison. Not Splinter's.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 07:14 PM

Splinter the one who decided to separate his family and because of it, the family got screwed up, he's the one who should get the anvil on his head.

Spawn Guy 04-09-2007 07:26 PM

Leo should at least get mildly concussed.

triplexxx 04-09-2007 07:32 PM

Well, they all deserve some blame, yes, I'll agree with that, still Splinter deserves the majority.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:03 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.