The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Thoughts on Michelangelo (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19678)

Courk 04-13-2007 07:33 PM

Thoughts on Michelangelo
 
Hi, I'm new here. I looked through the past topics and couldn't find anything on this. Hopefully I didn't miss anything. Anyway...

What did you think of Mikey in the new movie? I thought he was a bit too immature. I like him being energetic (I missed the leg shaking in the apartment :ohwell: ), but I just thought his immaturity was distracting. As one of the TMNT, he's supposed to be a highly trained ninja, but that just seemed too much at odds with how he acted at other times.

I mentioned this on the IMDB boards, and someone brought up the point that in the first movie, Mikey was a good ninja and knew it, hence the nunchuck scene. He was beyond competent in battle, whereas here he seemed to lack that level of skill.

Roseangelo 04-13-2007 07:40 PM

What leads you to believe Mike is lacking in skill in the new movie? He looked to be taking care of himself just fine, to me. Don't mistake the film makers' inability to show nunchuck strikes on screen as lack of skill on Mikey's part. ;)

I said this in another thread somewhere, but I really did like Mike in the new movie and honestly didn't find him to be "immature" as some claim. I would have liked to see more of him with a hint of more seriousness, but I still don't see immature.

Courk 04-13-2007 08:02 PM

I saw the movie almost 3 weeks ago, so specific examples are hard for me to remember. Mikey's not lacking in skill, he just doesn't seem as skilled as the 1990 version. I think it comes down to how he handles fighting. In the 1990 movie, a nunchucker comes out, and Mikey's reaction is to show off before continuing the fight. In this movie, his reaction at one point is to jump into Donnie's arms. One's confident, the other is scared.

Another point is in the trailer (I know it's not in the movie, but it's still associated with it). Everyone else lands and does their ninja stuff, while Mikey falls into a dumpster. That trailer was my introduction to the turtles for the first time in over a decade. It let me go into the theater having been shown that Raph, Leo, and Donnie are able to handle themselves, while Mikey can't.

What really stuck in my head about his behavior was his line to Leo when Leo first came back. "I have nightmares about birthday parties" is a cute line, but I didn't like the way it was said -- he sounded like a little kid. Combine that with the other points, and he comes across as immature.

ToTheNines 04-13-2007 08:09 PM

When you compare him to the original movie Mike, they're very different dudes.

bullet 04-13-2007 08:37 PM

i don't find him to be particularly immature.

he's pretty much in line with how he's always been...it isn't anything new. yeah, his nunchuck skills were more visible in the first movies but he also made kissy sounds to april over the phone and even donnie kissed a mop. they're turtles, they're teens...and they're ninjas. that's how they were meant to be :D

Quote:

Don't mistake the film makers' inability to show nunchuck strikes on screen as lack of skill on Mikey's part.
spot on.

Avatar Yuffie 04-13-2007 08:42 PM

I love his skateboard sequence. Wow. As in WOW.

As for immaturity... it never struck me at all.

Aignatius 04-13-2007 10:37 PM

Mike is just being himself. I really enjoyed the scene where he almost falls asleep in front of the TV, and then the news story about Nightwatcher comes on. Mike's face lights up, and he stands on the couch and does Mr. Universe poses. Cracks me up every time.

Warhorse 04-13-2007 11:56 PM

I agree with the post starter. Mikey has always been likable in the previous movies for me, but in this one, he was actually about as annoying to me as he is in the cartoons.

Especially in the first movie, he came off as quite witty, and an exceptional fighter. And even if the new movie was slightly hindered by the censorship to show nunchukus, he still could have been shown using his athletic prowess. But instead, I see him cowering behind Donny, crying out in pain or in when we do see him fighting, it's shoved off to the side and in the background, so we really cant see what he's doing.

Plus the whole "So it's like Haley's Comet" kind of bugged me. Mikey I always thought shot off hit or miss jokes, but he wasn;t down right stupid. And how come he was always spoooking and falling? There was one good scene with his skateboarding stint. But then when the Turtles were analyzing the dart that they abstracted out of Raph, Mikey falls down on his ramp.

It's not that Mikey is unlikable, but I found him as a character to be devolving compared to the other movies, while the other characters seemed to be dead on, or evolving at light speed.

bullet 04-14-2007 12:58 AM

well it may just be me, but i find skating through an actual pipe (save the halfpipe) underground while avoiding all sorts of potentially lethal obstacles to be pretty athletic and physically exhausting. at least he's getting in on the fight. i think he's echoing how he is in the 2k3 series. remember those underground monsters? though he did show bravery at the end, he only did it cuz he knew there was no one else he could depend on.

Cascadia 04-14-2007 01:03 AM

Mikey was just simply being himself. We have to remember that we did not get a chance to see the entire movie. There may be some parts that we do not know about in terms of Mikey.

triplexxx 04-14-2007 01:10 AM

Michaelangelo was more childish than in the previous movies, I'll admit that. But his fighting skills were top-notch in this movie; he did just as well as any of his brothers.

Bry 04-14-2007 01:24 AM

I actually really liked how they handled Michelangelo's character in the movie. He was a bit more childish, but at the same time not completely immature. He had more of an enthusiastic, wide-eyed innocence about him in this one, instead of just constantly making non-stop corny jokes. He was the lovable little brother.

(Much less irritating than in the 2K3 series, anyway!)

Warhorse 04-14-2007 01:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triplexxx (Post 499322)
But his fighting skills were top-notch in this movie; he did just as well as any of his brothers.


Really. In what scene do I actually see him fighting on par with his brothers (notably Leo and Raph, who seemed to be leagues ahead in the fight department compared to Mikey and Don)

I saw nothing in this movie that showed him fighting like he did in the first movie. I just saw the ending battle, the rest, he was no where to be found, cracking jokes when fighting was going on (in the first movie, he at least was fighting while cracking jokes) or toppling Donny.

I guess the original movies will continue to portray the best Mikey in my opinion. It's kind of depressing, he could be such a great character if he wasn;t used soley for slapstick. Like in the Cowabunga Carl, I would think because of his nature, he would actually have developed a rapport with the kids, not be succumbed to some punching bag.:ohwell:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bry (Post 499345)
I actually really liked how they handled Michelangelo's character in the movie. He was a bit more childish, but at the same time not completely immature. He had more of an enthusiastic, wide-eyed innocence about him in this one, instead of just constantly making non-stop corny jokes. He was the lovable little brother.

(Much less irritating than in the 2K3 series, anyway!)

I'll agree with you here, he is far more better portayed in this movie than 2k3! Minus the fighting scenes.

triplexxx 04-14-2007 01:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 499346)
Really. In what scene do I actually see him fighting on par with his brothers (notably Leo and Raph, who seemed to be leagues ahead in the fight department compared to Mikey and Don)

I saw nothing in this movie that showed him fighting like he did in the first movie. I just saw the ending battle

The ending battle....That was the proof. Every turtle fought equally well in that battle. I never saw any proof showing Leonardo and Raphael being leagues ahead of their brothers.
And in the battle between the monsters and the Foot, when the turtles joined in, I'd say they all did pretty decent, that is until the end when the building collapsed on to them.

Warhorse 04-14-2007 01:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triplexxx (Post 499351)
The ending battle....That was the proof. Every turtle fought equally well in that battle. I never saw any proof showing Leonardo and Raphael being leagues ahead of their brothers.
And in the battle between the monsters and the Foot, when the turtles joined in, I'd say they all did pretty decent, that is until the end when the building collapsed on to them.

I dissagree. Here's the fight I'm talking about! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dlvs9BW9wEs

Raph and April take down more foot than Mikey and Donny combines. Leo wasn't in the fight to compare. Maybe it's because we don't see enough of Mikey fighting, but compared to how Mikey fought in the first movie, he seemed to fall flat in that area.

But when they were fending off the stone generals, Raph actually flipped one right over his shoulder and over the balcony. How come Mikey wasn't shown using his speed and athletism to fight off a stone general?

And again, they still could have showed his athletic prowess in a fight like they showed in his skateboarding.

triplexxx 04-14-2007 02:39 AM

Well still, in the final battle against the generals, he was doing just as well as his brothers (I checked this out on youtube in a place where the entire movie is posted, so I can't put up the URL). And just because the camera wasn't on Michaelangelo and Donatello much in the courtyard, you can't say that means they weren't doing well, didn't their running on top of enemies' heads mean anything? Only the turtles and Splinter did that, didn't see April doing that. Michaelangelo's fighting was nowhere close to flat and he kicked just as much a** as his brothers did.

Shark_Blade 04-14-2007 03:18 AM

I don't see him as immature. Mikey is just being Mikey, that's all. And I agree with triplexxx, Mikey can handle the badguys just fine along with his brothers;) 8)

Warhorse 04-14-2007 03:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shark_Blade (Post 499417)
I don't see him as immature. Mikey is just being Mikey, that's all. And I agree with triplexxx, Mikey can handle the badguys just fine along with his brothers;) 8)

Again, his fighting wasn't as fun and thrilling in this movie as it was in the older movie, and the 2k3 toon.

The original poster was getting at that Mikey was often portayed as a clutz and a clown. A clown, yeah, but a clutz? And I agree with these views. And I'm not talking about what happens off screen, but on screen. That's the whole point of movies, to see stuff happen, not to imagine what did happen off screen!

Mikey could have been portrayed better. They managed to get a great Mikey on screen in the first movie, I think they should have kept up that formula with this one.

Swany 04-14-2007 05:26 AM

I don't think we was protrayed as an idiot. There was subtle wee things that showed his maturity. I mean for one he held down a job (that he hates no less). As for the fall ing down stuff. I can only remeber two examples, but the first time he was hanging upside down. He wasn't the only one that got spooked, you can tell by Don's face that he got a fright as well. As for the second time, is a lapse in concentration not enough to send you falling off a skate board. Tony Hawks is a pro and he's fallen plenty of times. Mikey is a teen, he falls once and is labelled as an idiot. I'd like to see people pull hold themselves like that on a half piple lip anyway.

As for the fighting, I don't think it was a case of less skill,. like everyone said. He just didnt get much screen time during fights. Damn censors.

Seiza 04-14-2007 05:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 499381)
Raph and April take down more foot than Mikey and Donny combines. Leo wasn't in the fight to compare. Maybe it's because we don't see enough of Mikey fighting, but compared to how Mikey fought in the first movie, he seemed to fall flat in that area.

This is the core problem with ninja!Mikey. There are allusions to his athleticism and skill (his tricks on the skateboard, being able to hold his body upside-down with ONE hand), but in an actual fight scene, Mikey (and Don even moreso in this movie) gets pushed back. Even in the final battle with the Generals, a bit more attention goes to Raph and Leo.

So it's like the movie's saying, "We know you know Mikey's good... but let's not acknowledge that on-screen!" :ohwell:

I think because of time limits, the writers chose to focus on the role that Mikey holds in the family (as the baby brother) rather than his ninja skills, because that supplements the "family" theme. I can't compare it to the 2k3 toon because that has, what? Up to six or seven seasons now? Way more time to work on Mikey. And because this movie is more focused on Raph and Leo (compared to the first movie, which was all Raph), even more time has been given to those two, further limiting the possible portrayals for Mikey and Don.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bry
He was a bit more childish, but at the same time not completely immature. He had more of an enthusiastic, wide-eyed innocence about him in this one, instead of just constantly making non-stop corny jokes. He was the lovable little brother.

(Much less irritating than in the 2K3 series, anyway!)

I definitely find this Mikey and 2k3!Mikey rather different. This Mikey seems a lot more... tame? I'm remembering all the jabs 2k3!Mikey takes at Raph, and just can't see movie!Mikey pulling off those same lines. Could just be the lack of interaction between them, though; the closest we got was Mikey's "oh, hey Raph -_-" line. XD

I wouldn't even call this Mikey "childish", but "childlike". To me, being "childish" means being selfish, thinking the world revolves around you, irresponsibility etc. Mikey is holding down a job he hates in the movie, which says a lot about his maturity. He clowns around, his baby blues almost reek of innocence; but that doesn't automatically mean he's "childish".

aabxx 04-14-2007 06:06 AM

Quote:

What did you think of Mikey in the new movie? I thought he was a bit too immature.
So they did a perfect portrayal then?

Compared to regular turtles, they're all extremely hyper anyway :D

Anyway many guys Mikey's age (and older too for that matter) are pretty immature. And what's strange about a dude deriving his social skills from playing too many videogames and watching too much television being too immature?

Actually when you think about it Raphael is pretty immature too... like, seriously... what's up with that anger? Only someone extremely immature shows that sort of anger... and Leo... well, he doesn't look the most mature himself saying stuff like "I'm better than you". And Don? Well... he's too smart to be immature :)

jenna 04-14-2007 08:53 AM

I didn't find Mikey immature strictly speaking. What was interesting as they seemed to start the core of his character as very much the young one, making his essence as the baby, and the innocence / fun loving element and immaturity that can go with this (which we have seen in 2k3) and then built on it, adding years of ninja training, the months of work he has done, the responsibility he has had with being the main bread winner of the family etc.

So essentially what we have is an immature character who is maturing. He is the one to call out to Splinter during the final battle to ask if he is OK, which is a thoughtful, mature action which none of the others takes. This shows maturity. He is learning to be a more responsible Mikey. The fact that he is still a bit behind the others is neither here nor there - he is still a teenager after all.

Warhorse 04-14-2007 09:19 AM

Heh. I still like old movie Mikey the best.

"Hey, a fellow Chucker, ey!" "Keep practicing!" Best scene in that movie!

But I did like Mikey's skateboarding skit, that was cool. Well, maybe in future movies, there could be a moment where one of his brother's gets knocked out and he has to defend them using their weapon, since his is so controversial.:roll: Be a good way to show what Mikey is made of.

Rooish 04-14-2007 10:35 AM

Firstly, my favourite Turtle has always been Michelangelo. And though the new movie made me like Leo, Don and Raph more than I ever had, my love for Mikey did not increase nearly as much. He had his good scenes and his bad scenes, but most of his development was left to the imagination, and to be inferred. Most examples of his maturity were subtly hinted at, while his cuteness and goofiness were played up (but then, they always are; he's the comic relief).

I did notice he was less boastful than his 2k3 version (thank God), which subsequently led to Raph being less angry with him (indeed, Raph barely interacted with Mikey at all, but he didn't seem too annoyed with Mikey compared to with Leo and Don. It even seemed that Raph was palling around with Mikey a little before the fight against the Bigfoot monster--they were more enthusiastic about investigating than Leo and Don were, and it seemed that Raph was talking to Mikey when he said "It smells like a monkey cage up here." As has been mentioned, Mikey also didn't seem to give Raph as hard a time as usual, except in the "Oh, hey Raph" part, when Raph was unconscious). As has also been mentioned, Mikey may be somewhat immature, but compared to a few of Leo's lines, and compared to Raph's constant jealousy and anger, and his bullying of Don and unexplained physical aggression towards Leo, Mikey's not any worse. I'm ... well, I'm of the mindset that envy and jealousy are among the most "immature" and dangerous and unhealthy of emotions. Mikey doesn't seem to show any of that in the new movie. Raph does. Don't get me wrong; I really sympathise with Raph and his portrayal made me love him a lot more. But there are some things that are not right about that boy.

Anyway, back to Michelangelo. I liked Mikey's energy and bubbliness. At times he was completely adorable, and I really liked how the movie made him out to be the youngest child (I've always thought of him like that), although it was a regression compared to his previous movie version in some ways--just in that he was more hyper and ADHD. It also made him seem kind of dumb at times, although that was pretty obviously part of his "youngest child" act. (I do that too, sometimes; I'm a youngest child and often act dumb for attention. I should probably stop that.) But he did show genuine compassion, and I think there were attempts on Munroe's part to allow us to see things through Mikey's eyes, as well as Leo's and Raph's (Don didn't get nothing). I loved that Mikey was holding his own job and functionally driving a vehicle. I loved his skateboarding scene, because it (and its aftermath) gave us a Mikey's-eye-view of events. He was bored and lonely, and his family was falling apart. Then Raph came on the scene ("Spoken like a true has-been") and it became Raph's movie. But at least we had that Mikey moment. In the final battle, Mikey and Don were almost completely overlooked--we got to see Raph beating up legions of Foot Ninja, Raph being tempted to join the dark side by Aguila, Raph holding up the rear and then somehow outrunning Don, Mikey, Splinter, April, and Casey to be in the lead to get into Winter's Tower, Raph standing in front of his brothers when the stone generals emerged from the portal they had been knocked into ... enough Raph, already! I was fine with Raph getting the final monologue, and the most development, but I really think Mikey and Don needed to show their competence in the final battle more than they did.

Some Mikey moments were genuinely sweet and heartwarming. He gave Leo a huge hug (notice how he hugged Leo around his middle, almost as if Mikey was accustomed to hugging someone taller and older than he is). He inquired about whether Splinter was all right in the final battle. He was bouncing around in April's apartment, and he was just warm and friendly in general ("Nice pad, guys!")--although not as warm as old toon Mike or 2nd movie Mike. One of the key moments--almost a switch back to Mikey's eye view--was when Raph was admitting to Splinter what he had done after the Leo-Raph fight. Right there we saw Mikey's concern for Raph and Leo and Splinter all in one. It was immensely moving for me.

On the minus side, I didn't like his clumsiness (him falling down at least 3 times?). I didn't like his creepy facial expressions at times (like when he was watching TV). More than anything, I hated the crappy, too-long "joke" at the end about inhaling Max Winters. Ew. The dude just died; show some tact, Mikey. That was just lazy writing. Movies should end with a bang, not a whimper.

Although Mikey was less annoying than the 2k3 Mikey (in my opinion), he was harder to identify with. There was none of 2k3 Mikey's inferiority complex, and nothing to really draw in the viewer to empathise with him (I find that Mikey in the cartoons has always been really easy to identify with, which might explain why he is so popular, especially with kids). For the most part, I liked his portrayal, except that it needed to be balanced with a bit more evidence that he isn't just a clumsy idiot. That was only inferred, and didn't do justice to him. Still, if he's done right, I'm all for youngest-child Mikey.

Bry 04-14-2007 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 499436)
I wouldn't even call this Mikey "childish", but "childlike". To me, being "childish" means being selfish, thinking the world revolves around you, irresponsibility etc. Mikey is holding down a job he hates in the movie, which says a lot about his maturity. He clowns around, his baby blues almost reek of innocence; but that doesn't automatically mean he's "childish".

You're absolutely right, that's exactly what I meant to say. "Childish" was the wrong word. You'll have to excuse me - I'm coming off an epic week of wording things extremely poorly. I think my brain melted on me somewhere. ;)

jenna 04-14-2007 01:58 PM

Wow. Rooish! Profound stuff, girl. Really enjoyed reading that. I really like your point about him being harder to relate to as a character. Perhaps some of those infamous 'novelisation scenes' like him talking to Don about the 'never left the glass bowl' thing would have fleshed that out. Despite the fact that I have always favoured Raph as a turtle, I also agree that he is often acting a little childishly by having temper tantrums. I'm a fiery red head so I know what it's like to feel like flipping out over the tiniest of little things, but there comes an age where you learn to take ownership of your temper and responsibility for yourself - there are consequences to such actions. So I agree that there's something not right about him - best thing he can do is get himself a good therapist.

But back to Mike, (no matter what my intentions, I always digress and start waffling on about Raph - grr!:roll: ) your points are all really valid and I hope that his character can be expanded on in the dvd. Maybe his character has lost the sympathy (ie with winters vapourising / Raph unconscious) due to his own loneliness that you referred to. Poor old Mikey is become weighed down by the weight of the world... bless

aabxx 04-14-2007 03:03 PM

Seriously, the turtles kill a lot of people. When you live that sort of life, joking about people dying can be... well... natural... that's how we humans deal with though situations... now of course none of us would make fun when someone dies, but these guys see it regularly, and they're the ones making other die... so... they see it in a completely different manner.

I interact with surgeons and you would be amazed by some of the things they say... when amongst themselves they talk and joke in a way most people would find very disturbing. I know I did in the beginning. But when working at a hospital, you realize every group has their own sort of morbid humor, that outsiders would deem discusting but which in reality is human nature when you're put under morbid situations regularly. Mikey showed no tact but he's a mass murderer (sounds brutal but it's true), and on top of that, he has little social training compared to just about every human being... imagine 4 brothers growing up under wicked circumstances with no contact with the outside world and I would imagine they would develop a sense of humor which they really don't want to show on screen... but sometimes it slips through!

Warhorse 04-14-2007 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 499502)
Firstly, my favourite Turtle has always been Michelangelo. And though the new movie made me like Leo, Don and Raph more than I ever had, my love for Mikey did not increase nearly as much. He had his good scenes and his bad scenes, but most of his development was left to the imagination, and to be inferred. Most examples of his maturity were subtly hinted at, while his cuteness and goofiness were played up (but then, they always are; he's the comic relief).

I did notice he was less boastful than his 2k3 version (thank God), which subsequently led to Raph being less angry with him (indeed, Raph barely interacted with Mikey at all, but he didn't seem too annoyed with Mikey compared to with Leo and Don. It even seemed that Raph was palling around with Mikey a little before the fight against the Bigfoot monster--they were more enthusiastic about investigating than Leo and Don were, and it seemed that Raph was talking to Mikey when he said "It smells like a monkey cage up here." As has been mentioned, Mikey also didn't seem to give Raph as hard a time as usual, except in the "Oh, hey Raph" part, when Raph was unconscious). As has also been mentioned, Mikey may be somewhat immature, but compared to a few of Leo's lines, and compared to Raph's constant jealousy and anger, and his bullying of Don and unexplained physical aggression towards Leo, Mikey's not any worse. I'm ... well, I'm of the mindset that envy and jealousy are among the most "immature" and dangerous and unhealthy of emotions. Mikey doesn't seem to show any of that in the new movie. Raph does. Don't get me wrong; I really sympathise with Raph and his portrayal made me love him a lot more. But there are some things that are not right about that boy.

Anyway, back to Michelangelo. I liked Mikey's energy and bubbliness. At times he was completely adorable, and I really liked how the movie made him out to be the youngest child (I've always thought of him like that), although it was a regression compared to his previous movie version in some ways--just in that he was more hyper and ADHD. It also made him seem kind of dumb at times, although that was pretty obviously part of his "youngest child" act. (I do that too, sometimes; I'm a youngest child and often act dumb for attention. I should probably stop that.) But he did show genuine compassion, and I think there were attempts on Munroe's part to allow us to see things through Mikey's eyes, as well as Leo's and Raph's (Don didn't get nothing). I loved that Mikey was holding his own job and functionally driving a vehicle. I loved his skateboarding scene, because it (and its aftermath) gave us a Mikey's-eye-view of events. He was bored and lonely, and his family was falling apart. Then Raph came on the scene ("Spoken like a true has-been") and it became Raph's movie. But at least we had that Mikey moment. In the final battle, Mikey and Don were almost completely overlooked--we got to see Raph beating up lesions of Foot Ninja, Raph being tempted to join the dark side by Aguila, Raph holding up the rear and then somehow outrunning Don, Mikey, Splinter, April, and Casey to be in the lead to get into Winter's Tower, Raph standing in front of his brothers when the stone generals emerged from the portal they had been knocked into ... enough Raph, already! I was fine with Raph getting the final monologue, and the most development, but I really think Mikey and Don needed to show their competence in the final battle more than they did.

Some Mikey moments were genuinely sweet and heartwarming. He gave Leo a huge hug (notice how he hugged Leo around his middle, almost as if Mikey was accustomed to hugging someone taller and older than he is). He inquired about whether Splinter was all right in the final battle. He was bouncing around in April's apartment, and he was just warm and friendly in general ("Nice pad, guys!")--although not as warm as old toon Mike or 2nd movie Mike. One of the key moments--almost a switch back to Mikey's eye view--was when Raph was admitting to Splinter what he had done after the Leo-Raph fight. Right there we saw Mikey's concern for Raph and Leo and Splinter all in one. It was immensely moving for me.

On the minus side, I didn't like his clumsiness (him falling down at least 3 times?). I didn't like his creepy facial expressions at times (like when he was watching TV). More than anything, I hated the crappy, too-long "joke" at the end about inhaling Max Winters. Ew. The dude just died; show some tact, Mikey. That was just lazy writing. Movies should end with a bang, not a whimper.

Although Mikey was less annoying than the 2k3 Mikey (in my opinion), he was harder to identify with. There was none of 2k3 Mikey's inferiority complex, and nothing to really draw in the viewer to empathise with him (I find that Mikey in the cartoons has always been really easy to identify with, which might explain why he is so popular, especially with kids). For the most part, I liked his portrayal, except that it needed to be balanced with a bit more evidence that he isn't just a clumsy idiot. That was only inferred, and didn't do justice to him. Still, if he's done right, I'm all for youngest-child Mikey.


You summed up exactly how I felt about Michelangelo in this movie. It's not that I disliked him, but that I know he could be better.

But I won't complain about Raph. He's my favorite, and I was spoiled rotten in this movie!:D

Shark_Blade 04-14-2007 10:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 499436)
So it's like the movie's saying, "We know you know Mikey's good... but let's not acknowledge that on-screen!" :ohwell:

Agreed. I hope we will see a lot of Mikey on the dvd soon.

Rooish 04-14-2007 11:00 PM

Thanks, jenna! Haha, yeah, I guess I just needed to vent.

I hope I wasn't too hard on Raph there. It's not that I mind the specific focus on him in the movie, it's more that I mind too much of a focus on any of the Turtles, at the real expense of the others. I do feel that Don was portrayed very well, but didn't get enough of a role. And as for Mikey--since this is the thread's topic--I feel that his portrayal had ... its downsides, although it was still charming and fun to watch.

(Leo's and Raph's portrayals were probably my favourite ever.)

Edit: aabxx, I agree that the Turtles must be desensitized to death, so I guess I was misplacing my annoyance there. It wasn't with Mikey, it was with the writing in that part. That being said, I think that Mikey has probably killed the fewest enemies ever (out of the Turtles)--even fewer than our resident "pacifist," Don.

Courk 04-14-2007 11:52 PM

Wow, I never thought about how many people they've killed. My overall experience is fairly limited (I know, what a great basis on which to start a thread about Michelangelo's portrayal). I grew up with the '87 series and the movies, and I barely remember the '87 series (I doubt there was any killing in that). I've only occasionally seen movies II and III, and that was ages ago, too, so I'm left with the original movie in terms of experience. Did anyone beyond Shredder die in that?

I'm going to have to watch this movie again and consider the weight that would add to all their shoulders.

Sage Ninja 04-15-2007 03:37 AM

I thought Michaelangelo's portayal was decent in this movie, not as bad as I thought he was going to be but certainly still a lot of room for improvement. I notice alot of people are commenting that Mikey was hyper and dumbed down. I can only particially agree to this because I thought (compared to his 2k3 cartoon version) he wasn't nearly as clownish and prone to embarrassing displays of immaturity, or teeth gnashing annoyingness and out of context remarks and running comentary. Actually i found his portrayal to be much more tamed than his 2k3 version, because Mikey in the movie, although still flamboyant, at least knew when to shut the hell up and be serious when the situation called for it (like during battle and in tension filled moments). In fact I found his more off the wall behavior (although still annoying) to be at least in proper context of a relaxed domestic situations (like his burp at the dinner table, or his talking about NightWatcher on the roof). In stead of in highly tense serious moments when it was inappropiate (except for that last scene in the movie with Winter's death). I also liked that his fan boy side was kept in a suble way, with him merely admireing Night watcher instead of embarassingly obsessing over him and acting childish about it, I felt he acting maturly about it. He came off as playful and fun loveing instead of obnoxious and annoying, and any annoying scenes he had where mostly due to him being overly excited instead of cocky and boastful.

That all said in comaprison to his 2k3 counter-part I thought movie Mike was an improvement. But being judged in its own context and what he could have been like, Movie Mikey falls a bit short. Just like in all media the movie seemed to play up his clownish and off the wall (I guess immature) side instead of his more ccomplex characteristics and put him as usual in the role of comic relief. I had a problem with him always falling down on his head the moment he got caught off guard or distracted. I didn't care for the fact that he had a job that you would normally think he would do well with (working with children), that just felt like a piece of Michelangelo that made him unique (his great love and rapport with children) was taken away from him. I even got a bit irked by his unwitty remarks that where designed to make him the subject of laughter, would it kill the writters to give Michaelangelo witty dialogue and give him more of a clever and sharp persoanlity instead of making him this dolt that sets him slef up to be put in his place all the time. I also didn't care to much for the show of fear he had in the tower fight. I think that about covered it with what I disliked about his portrayal.

I guess i would to see a more clever and warrior-like Mike. One that is well rounded enough that is relaxed and easy going and jokey in domestic situations but serious and deadly in battle. I would dearly like to see Mikey's warrior side explored more.

triplexxx 04-15-2007 03:50 AM

Still, you gotta admit, he displayed a load of talent in the final battle, running on top of enemies heads, holding his own against the generals just as well as his brothers did. Not to mention, he showed a good deal of sensitivity towards family issues, like when he listened in about Leonardo's kidnapping. And after skateboarding home through the sewers (which was pretty damn awesome), after noticing the Nightwatcher on the news, he mentioned his eagerness for his old warrior/crime-fighting days and once again being one of the "saviors of NYC".

odupianist 04-15-2007 09:46 AM

Too, much, to, read... lol anyways, my two cents... Mikey has always been known for being more of a natural at things. I've always thought he was the more athletic of all the brothers, maybe I'm assuming wrong. The nunchucks getting censored had a lot to do with his air time I think.

Warhorse 04-15-2007 10:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 500054)
I thought Michaelangelo's portayal was decent in this movie, not as bad as I thought he was going to be but certainly still a lot of room for improvement. I notice alot of people are commenting that Mikey was hyper and dumbed down. I can only particially agree to this because I thought (compared to his 2k3 cartoon version) he wasn't nearly as clownish and prone to embarrassing displays of immaturity, or teeth gnashing annoyingness and out of context remarks and running comentary. Actually i found his portrayal to be much more tamed than his 2k3 version, because Mikey in the movie, although still flamboyant, at least knew when to shut the hell up and be serious when the situation called for it (like during battle and in tension filled moments). In fact I found his more off the wall behavior (although still annoying) to be at least in proper context of a relaxed domestic situations (like his burp at the dinner table, or his talking about NightWatcher on the roof). In stead of in highly tense serious moments when it was inappropiate (except for that last scene in the movie with Winter's death). I also liked that his fan boy side was kept in a suble way, with him merely admireing Night watcher instead of embarassingly obsessing over him and acting childish about it, I felt he acting maturly about it. He came off as playful and fun loveing instead of obnoxious and annoying, and any annoying scenes he had where mostly due to him being overly excited instead of cocky and boastful.

That all said in comaprison to his 2k3 counter-part I thought movie Mike was an improvement. But being judged in its own context and what he could have been like, Movie Mikey falls a bit short. Just like in all media the movie seemed to play up his clownish and off the wall (I guess immature) side instead of his more ccomplex characteristics and put him as usual in the role of comic relief. I had a problem with him always falling down on his head the moment he got caught off guard or distracted. I didn't care for the fact that he had a job that you would normally think he would do well with (working with children), that just felt like a piece of Michelangelo that made him unique (his great love and rapport with children) was taken away from him. I even got a bit irked by his unwitty remarks that where designed to make him the subject of laughter, would it kill the writters to give Michaelangelo witty dialogue and give him more of a clever and sharp persoanlity instead of making him this dolt that sets him slef up to be put in his place all the time. I also didn't care to much for the show of fear he had in the tower fight. I think that about covered it with what I disliked about his portrayal.

I guess i would to see a more clever and warrior-like Mike. One that is well rounded enough that is relaxed and easy going and jokey in domestic situations but serious and deadly in battle. I would dearly like to see Mikey's warrior side explored more.

Yep, agree with your views here. New movie was far better for me to digest compared to 2k3 version (if I come across a 2k3 episode where Mikey is the the focal point, I'll skip it) but he seems to be missing something, a charm he had, from the first movie. His athletism is far more evidence in this new film, simply because CGI doesn't have the restraint that a man in a heavy suit was. But you're right, even with the controversial nunchuckus, they still could have used some imagination in thinking up other ways to have Mikey in one on one battle like Raph and Leo had (Donny too was severely short changed in the battle department, but this thread is about Mikey, so I elaborate on him more)

Courk 04-15-2007 11:38 AM

The 2k3 Mikey you guys are talking about -- is that the original 2003 version or the new FF version? I've only just started watching the older version, and in those 2 episodes he didn't seem too bad, but you're getting me nervous about future episodes.

jenna 04-15-2007 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Courk (Post 500162)
The 2k3 Mikey you guys are talking about -- is that the original 2003 version or the new FF version? I've only just started watching the older version, and in those 2 episodes he didn't seem too bad, but you're getting me nervous about future episodes.

In my opinion he is much more annoying in Fast Forward - to the point of being silly. In the older 2003 cartoon he has some childish moments but it never calls into question his skill or deadliness as a ninja.

Warhorse 04-15-2007 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenna (Post 500164)
In my opinion he is much more annoying in Fast Forward - to the point of being silly. In the older 2003 cartoon he has some childish moments but it never calls into question his skill or deadliness as a ninja.

Mikey's fine, as long as Turtle Titan isn't involved. And his constant Battle Nexus Championship boasting is a bit annoying at times.

He's ok in the 2k3, but easily is my least favorite Turtle in the 2k3 toon, maybe because I just can't relate to him at all. He has his moments, the Jurassic Park episode comes to mind, but I dunno. It could simply because I cant relate to him at all.

bullet 04-15-2007 01:15 PM

aw but i thought turtle titan was hilarious :(

Revan 04-15-2007 01:19 PM

I think it's silly he needs to dress up to be the turtle titan. The worst part... the dreaded grappling hook. da da da.

But if he's a ninja, that should be his 'power.' Stay in the shadows and thwart evil the way he is trained to do so. He is already a hero he just can't see it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.