The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Mikey listening in... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19691)

Seiza 04-14-2007 11:46 AM

Mikey listening in...
 
In the scene where Raph and Splinter are talking, I wondered why they had Mikey listening in. According to my friend, that was where he was supposed to learn that Raph was the Nightwatcher, as well as about the Raph/Leo fight (apparently he was also disappointed that his brothers fought each other <3).

Since Raph never even mentions the Nightwatcher in the movie version, I wonder if this is from the novelisation? Anybody heard of this?

Swany 04-14-2007 11:52 AM

I loved that bit, it was such a sweet Mikey moment.

I think it was to show how he is affected by the conflict in his family. And to show that he isnt just the idiot everybody thinks he is. He looks so upset and overwhelmed. Its not a nice feeling. Knowing that you could lose a sibling.

Roseangelo 04-14-2007 12:10 PM

Yeah, I agree with Swany. I only wish they would have extended the scene slightly so that Mike would have had some dialogue.

jenna 04-14-2007 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seiza (Post 499529)

Since Raph never even mentions the Nightwatcher in the movie version, I wonder if this is from the novelisation? Anybody heard of this?

Actually, this doesn't happen in the novelisation... the conversation between Raph and Splinter does, but Michelangelo isn't listening in.

AquaParade 04-14-2007 02:47 PM

I can vouch for that :)

Sage Ninja 04-14-2007 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 499549)
Yeah, I agree with Swany. I only wish they would have extended the scene slightly so that Mike would have had some dialogue.

nah, I think it was handled just right in the movie with Michaelangelo not saying a word and just absorbing every thing in. I'm a big fan of none verbal reaction because I think body language and expression can convey meaning alot more profoundly than dialogue ever could.

And the silent way he creeped into the hallway then stayed in the shadows of the room spoke volumes. At first when I saw Mikey creep into the room I thought it was Donatello and I was rather suprised that it was Michaelangelo. I think the animators did a very good job on his facial expressions as he listens in. It is very suble and and detailed, and it was not the least bit over done, which was diffrent to the flamboyant expressions the animators generally gave Michaelangelo in the movie. Also I noticed that Michelangelo just looked shocked and sad, and not least bit accusatory. Nice touch.

Although I do wonder what the writter was going for in that scene with Michaelangelo listening in to the conversation. Technically the whole scene could have played out just as well with just Raphael and Splinter having their private talk. But the writter choose to have a witness to the intimate confession of Raphael, and expand to beyond just Raphael and Splinter. Interesting. Why have Mikey wonder in and listen to (what is obviously) a private conversation? Was there a reason for it?

jenna 04-14-2007 04:10 PM

Maybe it was becuase in the book Mikey is a fan of the Nightwatcher and the scene was supposed to show him finding out that his brother was the Nightwatcher and is not quite the hero he hailed him as, thus leaving him feeling slightly let down by Raphael - obviously this only applies if they originally had scenes involving Mikey's Nightwatcher fandom. I think it works well without earlier scenes though, because it shows how much mikey loves Leo and how upset he would be if Leo died.

Roseangelo 04-14-2007 07:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 499651)
Although I do wonder what the writter was going for in that scene with Michaelangelo listening in to the conversation. Technically the whole scene could have played out just as well with just Raphael and Splinter having their private talk. But the writter choose to have a witness to the intimate confession of Raphael, and expand to beyond just Raphael and Splinter. Interesting. Why have Mikey wonder in and listen to (what is obviously) a private conversation? Was there a reason for it?

Actually, this is exactly why I would have liked the scene to be a little longer, giving Mike the chance to say something to someone. I think what we do see works perfectly, but.. why IS Mike in that scene? Raph doesn't actually reveal that he's the Nightwatcher (aside from Leo) to anyone.. give the scene another minute or two and you could have done that with Mike and Raph in the training room.

Avatar Yuffie 04-14-2007 07:41 PM

It is to be noted that Raph, Splinter and Mikey are together for another scene: when they placed the helmets on the shelf.

People said Mikey's there for the humor... but I wonder if there's something more to it than that.

Roseangelo 04-14-2007 08:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Avatar Yuffie (Post 499792)
It is to be noted that Raph, Splinter and Mikey are together for another scene: when they placed the helmets on the shelf.

People said Mikey's there for the humor... but I wonder if there's something more to it than that.

Care to elaborate on this thought at all?

Raphamel 04-14-2007 10:50 PM

They only have one scene showing Mikey's Nightwatcher fanboydom, but I heard there are scenes cut out that are of Mikey & Don talking and showing more of Mikey's fandom. I think listening in Mikey could put two and two together and know Raph's "something really stupid" was fighting Leo to the point of making him defenseless and then leaving him open to capture (although I kinda feel more sorry for Raph during that whole running-after-Leo-in-the-truck scene.) I wish they would have made it a definite that Mikey's looks of sadness were because of Leo *and* that Nightwatcher/Raph let him down... but Leo was right, "there's something missing!" :ohwell:

Anyhoo, I don't see how he could know Raph was Nightwatcher until the final scene with the helmet/big turtle head. Maybe deleted scenes on the DVD will help us out? (Any deleted scenes with Don/Mike should be edited back into the actual movie anyway! GRRR!)

Seiza 04-15-2007 05:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenna (Post 499677)
I think it works well without earlier scenes though, because it shows how much mikey loves Leo and how upset he would be if Leo died.

Damn, you bought me over with this line. XD *is SO not a sucker for anything Leo/Mike!*

Thanks for clearing it up, I wonder where my friend heard it then... I agree that the scene works on its own (especially as Mikey's Nightwatcher fanboyism is played down in the movie).

But just like Sage Ninja, I wonder if there had been other reasons for Mikey's presence that didn't make it to the movie. For that to be where he learned Raph = Nightwatcher would tie that particular subplot up, for instance. If you removed Mikey from that scene, it would've played out just fine. So it's odd that they had him there, with even a close-up.

Avatar Yuffie 04-15-2007 05:54 AM

Quote:

Care to elaborate on this thought at all?
Hard to explain, but it felt like a "part II" of the conversation. In the first one, it was Raph admitting why Leo became a leader to Splinter. To conclude that, he surrendered his helmet, so that Raph can be part of the team again.

Mikey being there is a little coincidental, for me. Leo should have been there.

Anyways, who knows? Maybe Mikey's just there to give laughs and I'm just thinking on it too much...

Leonardo's_Girl 04-16-2007 06:47 PM

I think Mikey was just curious, and was serious for once. He did seem to feel uncomfortable about the brotherly conflicts, and it was a sweet scene when he was listening to Raph and Splinter's conversation. I guess he was trying to include himself into the situation a little more.

Lycanth 04-16-2007 07:23 PM

I think it was just to help show that they are a "family", not just a group of people who happen to live with each other.

mk.2 04-16-2007 08:17 PM

First time I saw that scene, I thought Mikey might have known everything all along (like conflict between brothers). Probably that cause him having a nightmare about birthday party. It seem to me that he the one that care the most about family issue. He probably watch his brothers from afar without them knowing it. Like, in the last part, he handed his mask over after Raph did.

Courk 04-16-2007 11:32 PM

That's interesting. I noticed he does that at least sometimes in the 2003 cartoon, too (at least in ep. 1 -- bear with me as I build up a knowledge base of the show). While Mikey was lying in the corner, he heard Splinter tell Raph he made a poor choice during the candle extinguishing scene, and Mikey repeats those words when Raph makes another poor choice.

RaphistheBest 04-17-2007 10:51 AM

I'm not exactly sure what to think about that scene. When I was watching the movie and that scene came up I thought "Hey, some brotherly love is gonna happen." or something like that. I waited for Mikey to walk up to Raph and Splinter and then all of a sudden that scene was over. I was like "WTF?" It just didn't make sense to me. After watching that scene I wondered if something had been cut and then I found out that the movie would've had another 30 minutes worth if everything was left in. So I'm really hoping that deleted scenes are on the DVD when it comes out.

Swany 04-17-2007 10:57 AM

I liked it, Mikey is usually loud and centre of attention. But the silence and his uncertintly here just made this such a great scene. Showed there was more to him and that he was taking the conflict in the family quite hard.

Shark_Blade 04-17-2007 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RaphistheBest (Post 501335)
I'm not exactly sure what to think about that scene. When I was watching the movie and that scene came up I thought "Hey, some brotherly love is gonna happen." or something like that. I waited for Mikey to walk up to Raph and Splinter and then all of a sudden that scene was over. I was like "WTF?" It just didn't make sense to me. After watching that scene I wondered if something had been cut and then I found out that the movie would've had another 30 minutes worth if everything was left in. So I'm really hoping that deleted scenes are on the DVD when it comes out.

Agreed. Maybe a scene where Mikey walks in and join Splinter and Raph would be nice(they exchange looks), because after that scene Mikey said "So..what happens now?" with that big blue eyes of his.lol

Tinuvielsdreams 04-17-2007 08:01 PM

Mikey had to have heard all that ruckus Raph made knocking the weights over, and the look in his eyes said it all. He was listening in probably wouldn't have known want to say during such a heavy Raph/ Splinter moment....I think he didn't talk because of that reason. They kept it strictly Raphael pilling what he had done and how he feels inferior and he thinks it is true now after what he did to Leo. Then he says they took him and it goes to Mikey's face looking worried and a little shook. I dunno about Mikey but what do you say to that...Pretty much "What do we do now"

Maybe he could have walked in at least but the camera kinda did this angle of looking down on Raph, Splinter touches his shoulder, Raph says "By your wish father"...Splinter exits towards the door where Mikey is standing but scene cuts.
What I was hoping for was maybe Donny joins Mikey in the doorway??

Swany 04-18-2007 04:34 PM

I was thinking that Donnie heard/saw Raph enter and thought it better of him not to follow. Mikey being younger and not so sure followed him. Probably to see why Raph looked so upset (upset being an understatement).

Courk 04-18-2007 05:00 PM

I didn't think Donnie heard or saw Raph enter. Then again, I have it in my mind that their lair is huge (it's in a sewer, I doubt it's as big as I think it is).

Rooish 04-18-2007 05:08 PM

What the heck is going on with Wikipedia? There's ridiculous speculation on Raph's and Don's pages. Raph's page says that Mike is "expressively let down" by Raph's admission to Splinter. Um ... Raph didn't admit he was Nightwatcher there, although maybe he was supposed to. He seemed just worried, to me.

Don's page says that Don perhaps suspected that Raph was the Nightwatcher. This is very speculative.

Tinuvielsdreams 04-18-2007 06:56 PM

Yeah I guess in his mind it was part of how he screwed up even though my guess is Splinter being Splinter he probably knew...

As for wikipedia...change it, public edits right?

jenna 04-19-2007 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 501960)
What the heck is going on with Wikipedia? There's ridiculous speculation on Raph's and Don's pages. Raph's page says that Mike is "expressively let down" by Raph's admission to Splinter. Um ... Raph didn't admit he was Nightwatcher there, although maybe he was supposed to. He seemed just worried, to me.

Don's page says that Don perhaps suspected that Raph was the Nightwatcher. This is very speculative.

I know! Tell me about it. I wondered if they'd seen a different film to me!
Also, a couple of days ago the pictures of both Raph and Don had disappeared on the character profiles. Silly person who did that.

Sage Ninja 04-21-2007 01:19 AM

I notice that alot of you are making a conection between Mikey and the night watcher thing in this scene. Why does that really have to be the case? Personally I don't think the night watcher thing had anything to do with the involvement of the writter putting Michaelangelo at the door listening, since for one thing the Night watcher thing wasn;t even mentioned.

I think it might have more to do with bringing in a third party and having some one who is not involved in the situation wittness it so you can see it from an out siders POV. Maybe in that instance Mikey was suppose to represent the audiance and what his reaction was supposed to reinforce the severity of the situatuion.

I also I notice that even though Mikey was listening in, he didn't really make much of an effert to conceal himself. He was sort of in plain view in the door way and I'm sure that Splinter could see him from where he was. But even though the situation was just between Raphael and Splinter, I wonder why Splinter didn't shoo Mikey away (which is what you think he would have done if he wanted his talk with Raphael to remain between them) instead he let him listen. I starting to belive that maybe Splinter let mikey stay there and listen instead of shooing him away was because his words that he spoke to Raph doesn't just imply to Raph but all the turtles. Did any one notice that Mikey also to a lesser degree seemed put out that he couldn't go out fighting like he used to, just like Raphael did?

Rooish 04-21-2007 02:54 AM

Definitely, Sage. Mikey seemed very excited to be out battling again ("The Turtles are back, dudes!")

I think he was listening in because he was concerned. And I think Splinter let him because he knew that it would be worse for Mikey to be left in the dark.

Seiza 04-21-2007 03:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 503342)
I notice that alot of you are making a conection between Mikey and the night watcher thing in this scene. Why does that really have to be the case? Personally I don't think the night watcher thing had anything to do with the involvement of the writter putting Michaelangelo at the door listening, since for one thing the Night watcher thing wasn;t even mentioned.

Mostly because of the irony of Mikey's Nightwatcher fanboyism-- it just seems natural for him to eventually find out his own brother was the hero he admired (especially since Mikey apparently said the Nightwatcher was better than Raph :lol: ).

But Mikey in the movie didn't seem nearly as fixated, so there's less need for "closure". I do think that was originally where Mikey was supposed to find out the Nightwatcher's identity, though, but the script changed. Maybe the writers couldn't find a way to fit the Nightwatcher deal in without compromising Raph's current lines. If it was to show the gravity of the situation, you'd think that they'd have included Don.

Quote:

Did any one notice that Mikey also to a lesser degree seemed put out that he couldn't go out fighting like he used to, just like Raphael did?
Yep. Ditto on the Splinter thing too.

MoreCowbell5263 04-21-2007 02:51 PM

If Don were included in that scene, that could've been a good opportunity for both Mike and Don to show some serious emotion in the movie. What I think would've been great, since the movie depicts Raph and Leo always butting heads with one another, this scene would've been a great way to show how much of a contrast Mike and Don are compared to their brothers. Raph, in this situation, gets angry at himself and throws a tantrum knocking stuff over, almost as if he didn't want to tell them what he did, but Splinter kinda forces it out of him. I'd imagine Leo kinda reacting similar if he and Raph had switched places in this movie. But Don and Mike were always going to each other for emotional support and comfort. I think it would've been touching if both Mike and Don were in the doorway listening in, Mike got very shocked and upset and immediately had a close moment with Don, like a deep hug, or Don putting a hand on Mike's shoulder for reassurance of whether or not Mike is ok, or they slowly walk out together worried or something.

I remember in the first two movies, the scene in April's apartment from the first, and searching the sewers for a new place to live in the second, effectively showed how Mike and Don handle themselves whenever their brothers fight. The first one, they kinda just sneak off to the side and talk to each other until the conflict resolves itself, giving you the idea that it's probably a common occurence and this is how they always deal with it. And in the second movie, I don't remember Don intervening, and Mike made a joke about timeshares to try to put the emotional tension at ease little before Raph's inevitable exit.

A touching brother-to-brother comforting moment between Mike and Don during this sequence would have been really great in my opinion and I think would've gone over really well with film critics.

Sage Ninja 04-24-2007 02:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MoreCowbell5263 (Post 503599)
If Don were included in that scene, that could've been a good opportunity for both Mike and Don to show some serious emotion in the movie. What I think would've been great, since the movie depicts Raph and Leo always butting heads with one another, this scene would've been a great way to show how much of a contrast Mike and Don are compared to their brothers. Raph, in this situation, gets angry at himself and throws a tantrum knocking stuff over, almost as if he didn't want to tell them what he did, but Splinter kinda forces it out of him. I'd imagine Leo kinda reacting similar if he and Raph had switched places in this movie. But Don and Mike were always going to each other for emotional support and comfort. I think it would've been touching if both Mike and Don were in the doorway listening in, Mike got very shocked and upset and immediately had a close moment with Don, like a deep hug, or Don putting a hand on Mike's shoulder for reassurance of whether or not Mike is ok, or they slowly walk out together worried or something.

I remember in the first two movies, the scene in April's apartment from the first, and searching the sewers for a new place to live in the second, effectively showed how Mike and Don handle themselves whenever their brothers fight. The first one, they kinda just sneak off to the side and talk to each other until the conflict resolves itself, giving you the idea that it's probably a common occurence and this is how they always deal with it. And in the second movie, I don't remember Don intervening, and Mike made a joke about timeshares to try to put the emotional tension at ease little before Raph's inevitable exit.

A touching brother-to-brother comforting moment between Mike and Don during this sequence would have been really great in my opinion and I think would've gone over really well with film critics.

that could hsve been nice but I think they wanted all the emotional focus on Raphael and Leonardo in this movie. I think Donatello just knows when to stay the hell out of it, when Raphael and Leonardo are haveing some drama and it escalades to the point where Splinter needs to get involved. I think Donatello is just practical natured enough like that that he realizes that it can't be chamnged by him and it has to run its course. I'm reading a lot between the lines here but I think that is why Donatello didn't show up at the door way with Michelangelo. Since if Michelangelo heard it Donatello must have too, and probably choose to stay out of it.

It does beg the question, of what Michelangelo was doing prior to Raphael storming into the lair though.

a_big_apple 04-24-2007 05:54 PM

Swany mentioned a while back that Mikey's silence in this scene is unusual, since he's usually the loud one who always has something to say or ask. I think that idea really clicks for me with that scene. I mean, what is there to say when you're unexpectedly witnessing your tough-guy brother having a really emotional moment? My first impression of Mikey's listening in was just that he heard some noise, and was curious. When it became clear that something was wrong, it makes sense to me that he'd stick around to find out what--that's just what you do when your sib and your parent are having a really serious conversation that's happening pretty much out in the open (as opposed to behind closed doors in Splinter's room, or something).

I think it would have been interesting to see something with Mike and Raph after Splinter leaves the room, but the more I think about it, the more I suspect Raph sort of...needs a moment to compose himself. I like to think that Mikey knows better than to intrude on Raph when he's actually having emotions, lol. I can sort of picture Splinter guiding Mike away on his way out, to give Raph a second to get himself together.

There's so much interesting speculation about this scene! It makes me really eager to see if anything has been deleted from it or not.

MoreCowbell5263 04-24-2007 06:20 PM

I agree, the scene was very well thought out, very deep, and every motion, every movement, every little detail in that scene had it's reason, and it was great. But I also wouldn't be surprised if the DVD of the movie had a deleted scene where that scene is altered, or Don comes in, or Mikey talks to Raph, or something they felt wasn't necessary for the scene.

Magdolin 04-24-2007 11:07 PM

Oh yes i agree! I love Mikey. Very much.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.