The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Acting Without Actors: Kevin Munroe Envisions R-Rated CGI (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19789)

Fledermaus 04-19-2007 01:22 PM

Acting Without Actors: Kevin Munroe Envisions R-Rated CGI
 
Check it out! HollywoodChicago.com has this great article with Kevin! I'm really intrigued about a few things. For example, "language barrier" is mentioned... as are technical misfortunes. The more I hear about what challenges existed the more amazed I am at what everyone still managed to produce despite the odds. :o

Quote:

Originally Posted by HollywoodChicago.com
“Just as we were getting into the crunch of the movie, there was an earthquake in Taiwan right after Christmas,” Munroe said. “We had hundreds of thousands if not millions of images coming over, and when the earthquake happened, our T-3 got cut out. We actually had people flying in from Hong Kong with hard drives on their laps. They were delivering the film by hand.”

The computer-modeled magic for the film, which came alive through researchers developing musculature and details such as skin translucency, doesn’t necessitate the enterprise-level equipment you might expect. Munroe added: “At the core of it, we just had a bunch of regular PCs.”

Read the article by clicking the above link! (Courtesy of www.ninjaturtles.com. Thanks Dan! :D )

The Shelf 04-19-2007 01:27 PM

Dang it, you had my hopes up for an R-rated turtles movie. Or at least that they were considering making this first CGI film R-rated in the beginning.

bullet 04-19-2007 02:18 PM

yeah i read that article. the language barrier thing i thought was incredible.

Revan 04-19-2007 07:08 PM

I found it interesting about what was said about CG being veiwed as a kiddie medium. I wish this was not the case but since most CG movies have had G and PG ratings that's how people see CG movies now. It's unfortunate though, because I would be interested to see a CG horror flick sometime soon.

I would not, however, EVER want an R tmnt movie. I personally would like to see it, but I don't think it would be good for the franchise as a whole.

Fledermaus 04-19-2007 07:45 PM

I wouldn't want an R-rated TMNT movie, either... however I am hopeful that Imagi's mission at hand seems to be to push CG at least as far as the PG-13 rating with their next few movies. Perhaps they can test the waters with something like Gatchaman before starting a PG-13 turtles movie. I'm glad that Kevin is so open about breaking chains that confine feature-length animation to the family demographic. I for one am saddened that animation is marketed exclusively as such in this country (by animation, I mean feature-film animation that is actually WELL-ANIMATED that isn't a complete joke like South Park). It would be the same to me as if animation had gotten its start in the porn movie business and the general public saw it as ONLY allowed for that particular genre or demographic.

Yeah yeah... I know that's "how it is" in our culture and it "shouldn't" be any different. :roll: Females and non-whites should never have gotten the vote either.

iris 04-19-2007 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 502550)
Yeah yeah... I know that's "how it is" in our culture and it "shouldn't" be any different. :roll: Females and non-whites should never have gotten the vote either.

I'm not sure my ability to vote is a blessing on the country. :lol:

I like intensity, but I don't demand it out of TMNT. Doesn't quite work for me.

I'm currently talking to one of my friends who took her little boys to see TMNT, and I'm glad they could. They loved it.

TheAnimatedSeries 04-19-2007 08:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 502550)
Yeah yeah... I know that's "how it is" in our culture and it "shouldn't" be any different. :roll: Females and non-whites should never have gotten the vote either.

Cartoons not being for adults in this country is not a political issue. Most audiences just dont go for it. Like soiled panties/beetles out of a vending machine, something that suits one culture wont work in every other.

I'm sure everyone here would enjoy and pay to see serious animation, but we dont make up enough of the population to turn a profit. So we have to wait a little longer for tolerable animated movies that dont feature pop songs and sitcom star voices, which in the days of cgi are rare.

We dont even make good American animated musicals anymore. Just sexual innuendo loving animal ensembles who rock out to top 40 hits.

Fledermaus 04-19-2007 09:53 PM

I used the example on the principle that when a lot of people feared change, even fought against it because they couldn't imagine how it could possibly work. What about having an a trilogy of super-long fantasy movies? Gasp! An all-CG character in a live-action movie? LOTR helped break a lot of assumptions by showing audiences how fantasy could be done right. Even pirate swashbuckling movies, superhero movies... these were all ideas that just hadn't succeeded, or had died out decades ago.

Audiences won't go for controversial material until someone presents it the right way. I know it won't happen all at once, but it won't happen period if no one tries pushing for it.

By the way, you're dead wrong saying there's no politics in what goes and doesn't go in movies. Take a look at the changes in America cinema before and after the 60's.

I've said before that I'm okay with PG for another TMNT movie -- but I find it odd that movies like The Iron Giant and Titan A.E. (also PG) get to have blood and very minor swearing... and Michelangelo can't even hit someone with a blunt stick of wood. That's the kind of "intensity" that should have been in TMNT but wasn't allowed for political/cultural reasons. (the line between cultural acceptance and politics is often blurred, since the first is often used to support the second). And I think it hurt the potential of the movie (on top of a weak plot, dialog and not-so-clever humor). It's like we're in that stage of the cultural cycle where people are freaking out about our media/entertainment death drive smothering the innocent children. It happens now and then before the other side pulls back. (Kind of like how television animation was pretty mature for a while - think Batman: the Animated Series - and throughout the early-mid 90's before cartoons started getting dumber again. TMNT 2k3 is probably another casualty of this trend among censors.)

Buslady 04-19-2007 10:02 PM

I wouldnt mind a PG13 or whatever it takes to get away withallowing us to see Mike USE his chucks!! Make it a freaking DTV with a big fat warning that it's not a kiddie flick or something.

Fledermaus 04-19-2007 10:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 502636)
I wouldnt mind a PG13 or whatever it takes to get away withallowing us to see Mike USE his chucks!! Make it a freaking DTV with a big fat warning that it's not a kiddie flick or something.

:ohwell: As long as the DTV doesn't suck ass... and they usually do. I really hope the next TMNT movie could meet or even surpass what we just saw in theaters -- and that the next movie will also be released in theaters.

A PG13 turtles movie will certainly make people curious though. *shrugs* Just speculating.

Anyways, I actually sort of intended animation buffs to see the great things in the article. Here's another quote that had me thinking, "What do you know? No wonder it looked so awesome!"

Quote:

Originally Posted by HollywoodChicago.com
“We designed full-on muscle systems for the Turtles because they’re essentially wearing nothing but a sash and a half-shell,” Munroe said in the film’s production notes. “We also gave them unique characteristics. For example, on Raphael, he actually has veins that pop out whenever he flexes and Michelangelo has freckles.”

For help with all the minutiae, Munroe enlisted veteran art director and concept illustrator Simon Murton whose work ranges from “I, Robot” to “The Matrix Revolutions”.

I can see the design similarities between TMNT and the two mentioned movies. "I, Robot" especially.

Tinuvielsdreams 04-19-2007 11:14 PM

I couldn't believe the tech difficulties...I cant imagine how much info had to be carried by hand back and forth...People flying around with hard drives...WOW

I also know from experience muscle are not easy to do in certain 3D programs and all the extra detail, freckles and veins...also how freakin' long it takes to render 3D animation AGH!

It was a very good article to appreciate the movie even further

tinlunlau 04-20-2007 01:08 AM

i had to laugh at one thing concerning this article.

Hong Kong people aren't completely oblivious to Americanized slang as Kevin Munroe had described. HKer's know terms like "cool". they even use the word in their everyday speech.

Fledermaus 04-20-2007 01:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinlunlau (Post 502694)
i had to laugh at one thing concerning this article.

Hong Kong people are completely oblivious to Americanized slang. HKer's know terms like "cool". they even use the word in their everyday speech.

Yeah, I actually wondered about that. Terms like "palate" I can understand -- That's sort of an awkward word to begin with. I think even I might be confused. WTF does he mean by "palate?" Why not planks or splinters or shards or busted 2x4's?

I think that it is possible that the people in HK assumed that Kevin was using "cool" as a visually descriptive term, which is actually not an illogical interpretation -- cool color scheme, cool-mannered disposition. But if you're professional and trying to communicate (especially across languages and cultures) your ideas for the visual design, you shouldn't get all jab-in-the-ribs buddy buddy with the slang "hey guys, you gotta make this look badass or else" and assume they know what you mean. Badass and cool are subjective terms anyway. It's best -- in all cases -- to be specific when you're describing your vision.

I don't know. The definitions of "cool" can be a simple "good" or it can be, as Kevin probably meant it "mind-boggling, jaw-dropping awesome." Impressive, in other words. And have you heard Kevin Munroe talk? Even I have trouble following him at times. :lol:

So... in the end it's not that unbelievable. It's probably the context that caused the brief misunderstanding. :ohwell:

iris 04-20-2007 01:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinlunlau (Post 502694)
i had to laugh at one thing concerning this article.

Hong Kong people aren't completely oblivious to Americanized slang as Kevin Munroe had described. HKer's know terms like "cool". they even use the word in their everyday speech.

True, but just because most people in Hong Kong understand these terms doesn't mean the specific people Kevin was working with all did. And they may not have all been from Hong Kong.

Plus, Mr. Munroe speaks really quickly and writes almost the same way, so I can imagine it being difficult to follow. Dude's ideas just come tumbling down like a waterfall.

HollywoodChicago 04-20-2007 03:44 AM

Full audio interview with Kevin Munroe
 
By the way, the full audio interview (about 15 minutes) with Kevin Munroe can be listened to here.

bullet 04-20-2007 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinlunlau (Post 502694)
i had to laugh at one thing concerning this article.

Hong Kong people aren't completely oblivious to Americanized slang as Kevin Munroe had described. HKer's know terms like "cool". they even use the word in their everyday speech.

yeah there's actually a character for the word in chinese, too :P

tinlunlau 04-20-2007 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bullet (Post 502768)
yeah there's actually a character for the word in chinese, too :P

actually, the word "酷" is primarily used in Taiwan and other mandarin speaking areas. we don't use it in hong kong but we do know of its use down there.

bullet 04-20-2007 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinlunlau (Post 502790)
actually, the word "酷" is primarily used in Taiwan and other mandarin speaking areas. we don't use it in hong kong but we do know of its use down there.

apparently you're right, cuz my mom's from HK and she knows. i'm not sure where its used really, other than that i've seen it on TV multiple times when my mom watches entertainment shows, etc. i asked her what it was and she told me it is the mandarin equivalent of "cool." i thought that was pretty funny. does it mean anything else other than imitating the sound "cool" in mandarin?

tinlunlau 04-20-2007 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bullet (Post 502794)
apparently you're right, cuz my mom's from HK and she knows. i'm not sure where its used really, other than that i've seen it on TV multiple times when my mom watches entertainment shows, etc. i asked her what it was and she told me it is the mandarin equivalent of "cool." i thought that was pretty funny. does it mean anything else other than imitating the sound "cool" in mandarin?

when used with another word, it could mean "cruel".

Warhorse 04-20-2007 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 502636)
I wouldnt mind a PG13 or whatever it takes to get away withallowing us to see Mike USE his chucks!! Make it a freaking DTV with a big fat warning that it's not a kiddie flick or something.

WHat I don't understand, how come Mikey is allowed to use his chucks in the 2k3 toon, but not so much in the movie universe? This doesn't make much sense to me. I always thought that the M-7 tv system was equivalent to the PG movie system. Am I missing something?

bullet 04-20-2007 08:58 PM

i have a feeling the 2k3 toon is geared more towards the american audience. i mean, there's a lotta jokes and references in there to the pop culture here...whereas the movie was meant to be something more globally accessible?

shot in the dark here.

Roseangelo 04-20-2007 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 503078)
WHat I don't understand, how come Mikey is allowed to use his chucks in the 2k3 toon, but not so much in the movie universe? This doesn't make much sense to me. I always thought that the M-7 tv system was equivalent to the PG movie system. Am I missing something?

I think it has more to do with the movie having international distribution with the toon only going to the countries/territories that want it. The 'chucks aren't a problem in the US, not matter what the movie rating, it's the other countries that pose a problem.

What I don't get is why "Nunchucks are illegal in the Netherlands" is enough of a reason to virtually cut them completely out of the movie. Surely you're not making THAT much money in the Netherlands to care if they decide not to release it there?

Shark_Blade 04-20-2007 09:09 PM

We had discussed about Mikey's weapon before:

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19454

Warhorse 04-20-2007 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 503093)
I think it has more to do with the movie having international distribution with the toon only going to the countries/territories that want it. The 'chucks aren't a problem in the US, not matter what the movie rating, it's the other countries that pose a problem.

What I don't get is why "Nunchucks are illegal in the Netherlands" is enough of a reason to virtually cut them completely out of the movie. Surely you're not making THAT much money in the Netherlands to care if they decide not to release it there?

How come TMNT is so concerned with making the finished movie globally viewable, when say, they could have made a US version, and then cut down some controversial scenes for the international releases?

Or would this compromise make too much sense?;)

Next movie, PG-13, Raph needs to say damn, Splinter needs to say "I made a funny!" More Donny and Mike, and release two versions, unedited for U.S and other countries who don't have sticks up their arse, and an edited version for the more stricter countries!

And maybe some blood, not much, but maybe a drip on Leo's swords. Maybe the sound of a broken bone from a punch to an enemy from Raph.

iris 04-21-2007 08:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 503127)
How come TMNT is so concerned with making the finished movie globally viewable, when say, they could have made a US version, and then cut down some controversial scenes for the international releases?

From what I gather--
1. They decided to be slick about it and edit their violence into being... which worked pretty well, I thought.
2. There was no time to make two versions.

Personally, I could live without Splinter saying "I made a funny."

jenna 04-21-2007 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iris (Post 503452)

Personally, I could live without Splinter saying "I made a funny."

Me too. Way overdone.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.