The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Ideas for a sequel... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19981)

sdp 04-06-2007 11:12 PM

Splinter dead for a sequel.
 
I might be in the minority but I loved Mako as splinter and i can't see another person taking the role of Splinter.

I beleive Kevin mentioned they toyed with the idea of splinter being dead in this movie but decided against it and i'm glad but i'd be cool with him dying in the next movie, pay tribute to Mako some more too.

Anyone else would agree?
I feel i'd be in the minority of this but I could be wrong.

triplexxx 04-06-2007 11:17 PM

It'd be excellent for drama since this movie already kind of used up all the drama regarding the conflicts that go on between the turtles and those conflicts already reached their resolution at the end. But I cannot see them doing it.

sdp 04-06-2007 11:22 PM

The movie wouldnt need to be about the turtles fighting, they can just be sad about splinter and being on their own against a returned evil foe Shredder.

triplexxx 04-06-2007 11:30 PM

That's what I just said. The turtles have no more reason to fight each other because their conflicts with one another have been resolved.

CJStyles 04-06-2007 11:30 PM

Honestly I wouldn't want to see Splinter die in the movie incarnation. But it would be interesting to see if done right

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-07-2007 12:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 491972)
The movie wouldnt need to be about the turtles fighting, they can just be sad about splinter and being on their own against a returned evil foe Shredder.

I think that would work perfect for a 3rd movie. The plot could be Shredder returning, and at the same time Splinter falling ill.

His death could take place right before the final fight with Shredder, the emotion would just be more intense.

Buslady 04-07-2007 12:45 AM

Should be at the beginning, the turtles cope with the death that would hit them hard, Splinter is their whole life, they owe him everything...yadda yadda...
meanwhile this thing from the past Karai mentions...happens...the boys have to gather themselves up for the climactic fight.

Shark_Blade 04-07-2007 12:55 AM

:eek: Splinter dead for the sequal?? No way! I'll be terribly devastated. And the turtles won't have any guidance from a guru anymore which detracts from it's original idea.

They are "teenage mutant ninja turtles", they are teenagers and I want them under supervision of a master that can help them and guide them all the time. TMNT won't age eventhough the timeline flow with the movie. They are forever teenagers and that's how we love them. Can you imagine Adult Mutant Ninja Turtles.Sad I know.

johnnyblaze 04-07-2007 12:56 AM

I was just thinking about this recenltly actually and if it came to that point I think i'd like an ambiguous death at the end of the film. As in Splinter is ill for most of it and have it end with him giving the turtles sage words of advice about their future, and their family. Leave it on a "happy note" with the family together in peace as it fades out. That way anyone can fill in the blanks as to his fate in anyway they wish and the film won't neccessarily be such a downer because really, the idea of a dead Master Splinter is a bummer.

Seiza 04-07-2007 12:57 AM

If Splinter dies, I would want to see it happen.

Er, I'm not morbid, but it'd feel pretty cheap to start up the movie and a turtle narrates, "It's been three years since Master Splinter left us...", yanno? I'd want it to be a case of show, not tell. [EDIT: Or johnnyblaze's idea works too, fanfic authors would have a field day with the fade-to-black scene. XD]

Though I agree with triplexxx: somehow, I can't see it happening in a movie. Maybe Splinter gets extremely injured, but not death.

Buslady 04-07-2007 01:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shark_Blade (Post 492022)
:eek: Splinter dead for the sequal?? No way! I'll be terribly devastated. And the turtles won't have any guidance from a guru anymore which detracts from it's original idea.

They are "teenage mutant ninja turtles", they are teenagers and I want them under supervision of a master that can help them and guide them all the time. TMNT won't age eventhough the timeline flow with the movie. They are forever teenagers and that's how we love them. Can you imagine Adult Mutant Ninja Turtles.Sad I know.

Um...Splinter IS in fact passed on, and the turtles are like 35 now...so they're adult in the current timeline. I liked to see how they could cope with being on their own and not bowing down every two seconds to Splinter.

Cascadia 04-07-2007 01:20 AM

The death of Splinter in the sequel would certainly add drama to the movie.

AquaParade 04-07-2007 01:58 AM

The death of Spliner would be an awesome story if done right. I'd like to see the last days of a sick dying Splinter who could barely speak(for obvious reasons:lol: ) and then have him pass away about 3/4 into the movie, and Shredder being added to the mix would definitley make room for some powerful moments regarding his return as Splinter is dying. Since I couldnt see a straightforward way to top this, it would be cool to end the trilogy with them having grown up a lot, so we can see that side of them on the big screen.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-07-2007 02:10 AM

I think Splinter's death would also be a good way to show Leo's vulnerability. Obviously he'd take Splinter's passing harder than the others.

Roseangelo 04-07-2007 02:16 AM

All of the reasons why this could be a great story is why I was SO disappointed with Splinter's death in the comic book, because absolutely NO possibilities were realized or even hinted at.

But as great of a story as this could be, I honestly don't think it's one meant for the big screen as I don't know that it would sit well with the general audience. The world can feel free to prove me wrong, though.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 04-07-2007 02:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 492062)
All of the reasons why this could be a great story is why I was SO disappointed with Splinter's death in the comic book, because absolutely NO possibilities were realized or even hinted at.

But as great of a story as this could be, I honestly don't think it's one meant for the big screen as I don't know that it would sit well with the general audience. The world can feel free to prove me wrong, though.

I think it could. They kinda scrathced the surface of that in the first movie in the campfire scene.

If people aren't convinced the TMNT can be deep, Splinter's death would show them. It would prove to be a powerfull scene.

Fledermaus 04-07-2007 02:23 AM

In TMNT 2007, I think the turtles are all still below the age of 20. Assuming the next film doesn't jump 10-15 years into the future, I am hoping that Splinter will stay around. I'd hate to have to lose either one of my parents as early as my twenties. :( It would feel premature, and I think that Splinter leaving so soon would also be premature. Maybe he could die in the third CG film (IF there's a third...) By then, the turtles should all be mature adults so that the passing of their father isn't tragic or sudden.

johnnyblaze 04-07-2007 09:02 AM

yeah they are all still teenagers (why people in reviews keep reffering to them as 20 year olds confuses me actually)

Buslady 04-07-2007 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 492068)
In TMNT 2007, I think the turtles are all still below the age of 20. Assuming the next film doesn't jump 10-15 years into the future, I am hoping that Splinter will stay around. I'd hate to have to lose either one of my parents as early as my twenties. :( It would feel premature, and I think that Splinter leaving so soon would also be premature. Maybe he could die in the third CG film (IF there's a third...) By then, the turtles should all be mature adults so that the passing of their father isn't tragic or sudden.


They're about 19 in the 2k7 movie.

Splinter's outlived his natural life span, but I don't see him living 30+ years, not even for a mutant. 20 years is good for a rat, he's old in the first movie, he's old today but seemingly pretty active. He'd hafta contract something or develop a nasty illness. Even Pnuemonia would have adverse effects on him.

Warhorse 04-07-2007 10:55 AM

If they play their cards right, this could be something that could be tackled upon the third (new) installation of the movies.

Next movie should concentrate on the conflict of the Turtles and The Foot. We definitely need more Karai, she has a natural screen presence, and has the potential of being one of the most dynamic characters ever on screen.

But the third movie could deal with Splinter's death. Depending how far you want to get into the franchise from a movie standpoint!

Splinter's Iroonna 04-07-2007 11:48 AM

Hands Off Splinter!

No Killie! No No No Killie!!!

Roseangelo 04-07-2007 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael (Post 492067)
I think it could. They kinda scrathced the surface of that in the first movie in the campfire scene.

As a ten-year-old watching that movie on opening day, that scene convinced me that they were going to kill Splinter, which was slightly traumatizing for me. I dunno what I would have done/though if he had actually died. That's the point of view I'm trying to look at when I say I dunno if it could be pulled off in a movie. But again, I'm not against the idea.

Zog the Equalizer 04-07-2007 11:57 AM

While Slinter's death would make a great plot point, but i like Slinter and dont want to see him ill the hole movie. I think it would be more dramatic if while the turtles fought Shredder Splinter came to their aid and shredder killed him. Splinter would die a noble death protecting his sons and the turtles would have even more of a drive to beat shredder

Willis 04-07-2007 12:09 PM

Question: In any of the comics or any turtles medium does Splinter die?

I really would hate to see Splinter die. I know not everyone may think so but to me, getting rid of Splinter is like getting rid of one of the turtles. It's just not done!

Now yes, I really did enjoy Mako in this movie *may he rest in peace* and will be surprized if they can find a suitable replacement. But I'd rather see this then 'oh by the way, splinter is dead' or a non-speaking splinter on his deathbed.

HOWEVER, and I'll say this to round off my opinion, IF they took this route...

1) Let it happen in the movie, not part of the narration.
2) Let something happen to Splinter, don't just say old age or the common flu did him in. Let him be attacked, or be struck ill by a disease created by their enemies.
3) Don't just have him be alive one second and dead the next, draw it out where theres some good emotion and screen-time for Splinter.
4) Don't just let the TMNT get over it easy, let them get mad, go nuts, react in their own little way. It may be 'Master Splinter', but it's also 'Father'.

Roseangelo 04-07-2007 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willis (Post 492210)
Question: In any of the comics or any turtles medium does Splinter die?

Yes. He dies in volume 4 of the comic book.

Only, both of these happen:

Quote:

3) Don't just have him be alive one second and dead the next, draw it out where theres some good emotion and screen-time for Splinter.
4) Don't just let the TMNT get over it easy, let them get mad, go nuts, react in their own little way. It may be 'Master Splinter', but it's also 'Father'.
Which is but one reason why I have issues with volume 4.

The Shelf 04-07-2007 12:15 PM

As interesting as it would be if they killed off Splinter in the movie, you really can't beat the way they killed him off in the comic. So I'm gonna have to say, "No, don't kill him off." It just wouldn't be as dignified in the movie. Having Shredder kill him is pretty lame IMO. It's too cliche, and it would cheapen Splinter's death IMO. One of the best things about Splinter is that he's always there when the turtles need him. If he faced off with Shredder to save the turtles in a last stand kind of way but got killed in the process, it would ruin the image of Splinter being the untouchable family savior because it would be like saying, "Splinter's not good enough anymore." Splinter dying of a heart attack at a ripe old age was the only way for him to go, and I liked the way it was handled a lot. The movie would just cheapen his death no matter which way you look at it.

Seiza 04-07-2007 12:15 PM

@Willis: No. 4 is something I'd especially like to see considerable, even HUGE, attention given to if Splinter dies in the movie. Judging by how much detail is in the first movie, though (and assuming Mr. Munroe and his team continue the movie), I don't think we have to worry too much. ^_~

The thing, though, is that just like Shredder, Splinter sticks out as a "given" in the turtles' franchise. You can't have the turtles without their rat-sensei. So I figure the writers will really debate whether to kill him or not.

Buslady 04-07-2007 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 492217)
Yes. He dies in volume 4 of the comic book.

Only, both of these happen:



Which is but one reason why I have issues with volume 4.

Yeah they don't really react much do they?
I was dissatisfied with the whole funeral and stuff. It was IMO insensitve. My god this was FATHER who DIED...HELLO!?

Spike Spiegel 04-07-2007 12:18 PM

I think the death of Splinter could be a great dramatic thing in the movies, but, as others here have said, "only if done right."

Roseangelo 04-07-2007 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 492222)
Yeah they don't really react much do they?
I was dissatisfied with the whole funeral and stuff. It was IMO insensitve. My god this was FATHER who DIED...HELLO!?

The funeral itself I didn't have issues with, but after the funeral everyone pretty much went back to their lives as if nothing was different. And I also don't have issues with Splinter dying of a heart attack, but I did not like that the Turtles were all off in a different frickin' state at the time. Maybe Peter thinks it's more "real" like that, but I don't want real, I want a frickin' good story in a comic book.

I have a friend (who is in her thirties) who lost her father a year ago to heart problems and it has probably been the hardest year of her life for her. Her life has yet to get back to "normal."

The Shelf 04-07-2007 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 492231)
The funeral itself I didn't have issues with, but after the funeral everyone pretty much went back to their lives as if nothing was different.

I can see where you're coming from, but I sorta disagree. Yeah, they could have shown a little more of the turtles' struggle to move on, but I think it shows their maturity and respect for Splinter that they didn't dwell on it too much. They were all mopey and depressed during and after the funeral. And immediately afterward, what did they do? Ran away. Every single one of them except Raph forced themselves to get away from home and get their minds on something else because they were afraid to think about Splinter. And Raph goes out and gets drunk to get his mind off it. I don't know about you, but I think that's a pretty typical male response to that sort of thing. It's something I would probably do (run away, not get drunk...). If Laird ever picks up the series again, I'd like to see one or more of the turtles finally break down from grief once things calm down in their lives again. That's what would happen to someone who bottled it up and moved on like they did.

I think the way Splinter's death and the turtles' response to it panned out in the comics seems pretty realistic to me.

Spawn Guy 04-07-2007 12:58 PM

As you know, we of the Christian faith believe that Splinter is not really dead, but that he must let the world think that he is dead...until he can find a way to control the raging spirit that dwells within him.

Dun dun dun dun DUN!

Fledermaus 04-07-2007 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spawn Guy (Post 492259)
As you know, we of the Christian faith believe that Splinter is not really dead, but that he must let the world think that he is dead...until he can find a way to control the raging spirit that dwells within him.

Dun dun dun dun DUN!

Qué???? :-?

Spawn Guy 04-07-2007 01:18 PM

I'm ripping off Family Guy. Who was ripping off the 70's Incredible Hulk intro.

Sewer Bull 04-07-2007 02:18 PM

Seriously... what kind of a fan would like to see Splinter dead in the official movies/TV shows? There are so many other ways to develop and thicken the plot in the sequel or in the third movie rather than putting the old rat down. Especially since those flicks are apparently aimed at the younger audience as well, you know - and that could be traumatic for kids.

I say, leave that "TMNT dealing with Splinter's loss" motive to the fan-fictions only. This card should never be played in anything canon, depicting the turtles as still teenagers.

Thus spake Bull.

Drtooth 04-07-2007 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Splinter's Iroonna (Post 492198)
Hands Off Splinter!

No Killie! No No No Killie!!!

Well, looks like Emperor Kuzco got his 2 cents in!

Anyway, I was just thinking that. But how would they do it without it being like the first film, when he was kidnapped, and they thought he was dead?

I would like to see it happen, because a lot of great character suffering and development could come out of it. I can imagine what it could be like. Leonardo takes it very hard and doubts his abilities to be leader, Raph takes it hardest of all and acts even more thuggish than usual. Mikey gets upset, similar to a child. Don is deeply upset, but somehow doesn't cry at all... Then a large fight breaks out causing the turtles to split again, and everything gets resolved in the end.

Spitfire 04-07-2007 03:09 PM

People who think Splinter being dead is a out of whack idea never read the comics huh? Though his death in the comics sucked.

I think Splinter should die in the middle of film. That way they have enough of both. Splinter gets ill and after the turtles get their asses handed to them they come home to see Splinter dead, personally I think a Foot ninja should kill him because he is weak he can't defend himself. That way the TMNT blame themselves for being tailed and really want to kill Shredder.

The end would be all out, and if they let the TMNT be who they are the turtles would be slaughtering people. I'd also want one of them to kill Splinter's killer. I wouldn't want him over looked at all like the foot who found their lair in the first movie.

We all know how Shredder should die*Beheading* so I'd go with that.

No idea why I bothered with this it'll never happen.

Buslady 04-07-2007 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 492231)
The funeral itself I didn't have issues with, but after the funeral everyone pretty much went back to their lives as if nothing was different. And I also don't have issues with Splinter dying of a heart attack, but I did not like that the Turtles were all off in a different frickin' state at the time. Maybe Peter thinks it's more "real" like that, but I don't want real, I want a frickin' good story in a comic book.

I have a friend (who is in her thirties) who lost her father a year ago to heart problems and it has probably been the hardest year of her life for her. Her life has yet to get back to "normal."

IMO if this was real, they were real and sensei died and all that, they would have a hard time finding out how to live without him; that's real life. Adults or not, it's still hard. Splinter was all they had for hte longest time, and all he'd done for them....like you said they go back to their lives like nothing happened. Ugh.

Warhorse 04-07-2007 06:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 492508)
IMO if this was real, they were real and sensei died and all that, they would have a hard time finding out how to live without him; that's real life. Adults or not, it's still hard. Splinter was all they had for hte longest time, and all he'd done for them....like you said they go back to their lives like nothing happened. Ugh.

I don't think so. I think Casey and April will be there to help out every which way they can. The Turtles aren't alone no mores!

triplexxx 04-07-2007 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 492522)
I don't think so. I think Casey and April will be there to help out every which way they can. The Turtles aren't alone no mores!

You got a good point there. The turtles do have support after all.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.