The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Am I the only one who... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=20184)

Scandia 05-16-2007 08:53 PM

Am I the only one who...
 
Is APPALLED at the fact that in the movie, April and Casey are cohabiting?

I could not believe it when I saw it. And now the comic book confirms it.

Please don't tell me that "everybody does it nowadays"- cause I sure don't and won't. This is still supposed to be a family-friendly movie- not necessarily a kiddie movie, but one that is friendly to all audiences.

Did they cohabit before being married in the original comic book? I'm not counting when they were living in the farm in Northampton, but after they became an official couple and Shadow had already been born?

ZariusTwo 05-16-2007 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515838)
Please don't tell me that "everybody does it nowadays"- cause I sure don't and won't. This is still supposed to be a family-friendly movie- not necessarily a kiddie movie, but one that is friendly to all audiences.

For christ's sake, this is pretentious bollocks. The first movie is more violent than TMNT, and plenty of familes went to see that. Let's also not forget the darker content of the new series and countless other series like Batman: TAS that have moments of murder and scenes of psychtoic disorder.

Katie 05-16-2007 09:35 PM

hmm. Pre-marital cohabitation is not against my personal morals..I gotta say that right off.

I think that it really is quite impossible to be completely inoffensive to everyone all the time. It IS a family friendly movie for a good chunk of the audience...but there will always be portions of the audience that are offended by certian aspects.

What about April's attire? certian sections of society would be offended by it...does that make it not family friendly because it offends those people?

Or the fact that Casey does not seem to have a job? Some people might find that offensive....does that make it not family friendly because the traditional bread winning roles are reversed?

You could nit-pick alot of little things about alot of movies and shows. What we would end up with is NOTHING being TOTALLY inoffensive everyone. Because everyone has different interpretations of what they consider to be moral and what they would like to teach their families, etc, and because you will NEVER live in a world that conforms just to your specific moral standards, you have to use situations where you find yourself confronted with something you don't belive is right to teach your kids why you think this is wrong.

Just remember...not EVERYONE finds things like that to be wrong or immoral.


and on Casey and April....it's been a long while since I got to look through my old comics, but I do believe they did live together before marriage. And Shadow is neither Casey or April's Biological child....but the product of a rape on her mother who Casey later married (after knowing she was pregnant) and Casey lived with the mother before they were married as well. so yes, that is an accepted part of the TMNT comics.

Spitfire 05-16-2007 10:58 PM

Go preach your crap else where. I've had my fill of people like you for a life time.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 05-16-2007 11:00 PM

I think it's just you.

Quote:

Did they cohabit before being married in the original comic book? I'm not counting when they were living in the farm in Northampton, but after they became an official couple and Shadow had already been born?
Actually yeah they did.

Roseangelo 05-16-2007 11:04 PM

Not bothered one bit.

Although I do recall reading in an interview that it was a tricky thing to pull off for a PG movie.

Spitfire 05-16-2007 11:15 PM

I don't see how it would be hard to pull off. It's two people living together. They showed them kissing you'd think that would be harder to pull off.

"OH MY GOD THEIR LIVING TOGETHER!!" I mean you act like they were screwing or something.

MrPliggins 05-16-2007 11:17 PM

I'm all for cohabitation before marriage. When living together you experience each other's personal habits and flaws firsthand, every day. I think this is needed to know if you can deal with these annoyances for eternity.

iris 05-16-2007 11:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515838)
Is APPALLED at the fact that in the movie, April and Casey are cohabiting?

I could not believe it when I saw it. And now the comic book confirms it.

Please don't tell me that "everybody does it nowadays"- cause I sure don't and won't. This is still supposed to be a family-friendly movie- not necessarily a kiddie movie, but one that is friendly to all audiences.

Did they cohabit before being married in the original comic book? I'm not counting when they were living in the farm in Northampton, but after they became an official couple and Shadow had already been born?

What's the problem with seeing someone do something you disagree with, in fiction? Does liking a series or movie mean you endorse everything in it?

It was Casey and April's living arrangement that made you question the family friendliness of this flick? Really? Not the violence? Not the fact that one of the turtles was acting as judge, jury, and executioner to the baddies?

"Family friendly" flicks don't have to be 100% of your personal moral gold standard. If there are things you don't agree with (and I'm sure that happens to everyone with kids) maybe that's a good opportunity for a discussion about it. It's good for kids to learn that they need not emulate everything they see on a screen.

Avatar Yuffie 05-16-2007 11:19 PM

They're living in SIN! AIIIIIIEEEEEE!!!

*coughs*

Sorry for not following the disclaimer but will say it anyway: Modern couples do that nowadays. Kids won't question that. And even if they do, that's an indication that you should prepare the answers.

Revan 05-17-2007 12:44 AM

Appalled? Really? I noticed it but I didn't mind. Maybe not everyone does it nowadays but people do do it. I was not offended by anything in the whole movie and I thought they handled most everything pretty well considering the PG rating.

I thought it was almost too family oriented. I love the turtles-as-a-family theme and all but I could definately gone for just a tad more violence. Still, I thought they catered to the audience quite well. I don't see why you disapproved of the cohabitation. Is it because it is sin? Because there is sin in pretty much every movie. TMNT had all kinds of sin besides cohabitation but that is the secular world. K, I'm off religion now.:ohwell:

Janus Prospero 05-17-2007 01:33 AM

I just have to reiterate what others have said.

This movie contains loads of violence, instances of vigilantism, and possibly attempted fratricide. If premarital cohabitation is what bothered you most about this movie, perhaps you need to get your priorities straight.

I had another point to make, but I think Katie said it better than I could have, so go re-read her post.

Sage Ninja 05-17-2007 02:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515838)
Is APPALLED at the fact that in the movie, April and Casey are cohabiting?

I could not believe it when I saw it. And now the comic book confirms it.

Please don't tell me that "everybody does it nowadays"- cause I sure don't and won't. This is still supposed to be a family-friendly movie- not necessarily a kiddie movie, but one that is friendly to all audiences.

Did they cohabit before being married in the original comic book? I'm not counting when they were living in the farm in Northampton, but after they became an official couple and Shadow had already been born?

actually...I was rather impressed with that. I thought it was really cool to show Casey and April in a relationship where they lived together in a animated film. I was like hot damn they went there? Good for them! I think showing a couple cohabitating in an animated film is a step in a mature direction for PG films personally.

And honestly the whole thing was handled beautifully well. Its not like they showed them in bed together or anything.

jenna 05-17-2007 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515838)
Is APPALLED at the fact that in the movie, April and Casey are cohabiting?

I could not believe it when I saw it. And now the comic book confirms it.

Please don't tell me that "everybody does it nowadays"- cause I sure don't and won't. This is still supposed to be a family-friendly movie- not necessarily a kiddie movie, but one that is friendly to all audiences.

Did they cohabit before being married in the original comic book? I'm not counting when they were living in the farm in Northampton, but after they became an official couple and Shadow had already been born?

I've got to ask, what is your issue with it? That they are 'living in sin' to quote a very wise member of the board below ;) ? If you have religious beliefs about it (I know, no religious debates, not starting one - promise) then that's fine and your choice, but probably one that would not be echoed excesively by others who are less offended by anything outside of their remit.

Or is it another issue that I've missed?

Personally I think cohabiting is brilliant. It's the best thing I ever did, and I don't think I would be married now if we hadn't lived together first. :evilgrin:

I would have thought April and Casey could handle it. And as for its effect on family film audiences, I can't see it being a problem the number of families that fall outside of the traditional nuclear family is growing, and I think the film condones tolerance and acceptance of other religions / beliefs by having them living together.

Wouldn't the world be a boring place if we all thought the same way?

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 05-17-2007 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 515950)
And honestly the whole thing was handled beautifully well. Its not like they showed them in bed together or anything.

That's in the Unrated version.

Janus Prospero 05-17-2007 02:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael (Post 515955)
That's in the Unrated version.

Boom-chika-wa-wa!

Scandia 05-17-2007 05:26 AM

Quote:

and on Casey and April....it's been a long while since I got to look through my old comics, but I do believe they did live together before marriage. And Shadow is neither Casey or April's Biological child....but the product of a rape on her mother who Casey later married (after knowing she was pregnant) and Casey lived with the mother before they were married as well. so yes, that is an accepted part of the TMNT comics.
I knew that Shadow was not Casey's biological daughter. And that he lived with Gabrielle before marrying her. But that is part of the darker grittier comics meant for an older audience. And I did not know that Gabrielle had been raped- where is that stated?

Quote:

You could nit-pick alot of little things about alot of movies and shows. What we would end up with is NOTHING being TOTALLY inoffensive everyone. Because everyone has different interpretations of what they consider to be moral and what they would like to teach their families, etc, and because you will NEVER live in a world that conforms just to your specific moral standards, you have to use situations where you find yourself confronted with something you don't belive is right to teach your kids why you think this is wrong.
I am the first one who will tell you that I despise complete sanitation, emasculation, and political correctness in fiction. However, I guess I identified with April too much before this.

I don't care for the fact that Casey has no job- but he can find one easily.

Quote:

Is it because it is sin? Because there is sin in pretty much every movie. TMNT had all kinds of sin besides cohabitation but that is the secular world.
More like personal discomfort. And the fact that there is a higher rate of divorce among couples who co-habited than among those who didn't. Whether correlation equals causation that would be another story.


I just wanted to bring this up, since I had not seen anyone discuss it. It is not going to make me stop supporting the franchise. I usually do not mind things like that in most other movies/books/TV series...but I would not have expected to see it in this one. It was tricky to pull off to say the least. And I LOVED it when they kissed. Not to mention it was cool to see their relationship issues- not everything is sunshine and butterflies. But the cohabiting part I honestly did not see it coming.

Do I have friends who cohabit? Yes. Am I judging them for that? No. Will I stop being their friend because of that? No. Do I approve of it? No. Would I do it? No.

odupianist 05-17-2007 07:56 AM

Quote:

I'm all for cohabitation before marriage. When living together you experience each other's personal habits and flaws firsthand, every day. I think this is needed to know if you can deal with these annoyances for eternity.
Agree 200% lol

Quote:

Do I have friends who cohabit? Yes. Am I judging them for that? No. Will I stop being their friend because of that? No. Do I approve of it? No. Would I do it? No.
Are you "appalled" by them? Probably

Quote:

actually...I was rather impressed with that. I thought it was really cool to show Casey and April in a relationship where they lived together in a animated film. I was like hot damn they went there? Good for them! I think showing a couple cohabitating in an animated film is a step in a mature direction for PG films personally.
I was impressed as well. It shows that things really have changed since we last saw the TMNT on the big screen. I mean hell, at least Casey has a home now lol. I know it was one of the deleted scenes in the first movie where he's sitting in this run down place, kind of like in the 2k3 series.

Tinuvielsdreams 05-17-2007 08:09 AM

I don't think there would have been room for a wedding anyway... I don't see that kinda of thing happening in the TMNT world.

"Put down the weapons for a minute so we can hitched"
It doesn't work so well.

Personally I like to know what I am getting into, this next comment maybe out of line or spark another huge debate, but the divorce rate is high and I would rather live with someone then get divorced later cause I was suprised... Not that living together would stop all split ups but it could help...
I dunno I just appreciate the school of thought where I do what I want and you do what you want, staying out of everyone else's business unless invited.

ZariusTwo 05-17-2007 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515970)
It was tricky to pull off to say the least.

How the hell was it tricky? They just DID it, noone approving the film raised an issue with it, noone in the audience were dropping their jaw, except the elitist moralists with their mentally ill nitpicking...and they've got enough problems pointing out all of the violence portrayed in all of the films anyway.

The Shelf 05-17-2007 09:00 AM

I like how when people hear someone's opinion on a touchy subject everyone immediately takes it personally as if the person is telling them how to live their lives. Everyone needs to mellow out a bit. Scandia disagrees with cohabitation and didn't like seeing it in TMNT. Personally, I don't like cohabitation either. We're just voicing opinions; there's no need to attack Scandia for "preaching" (I so hate it when people use that term that way).

In any case, cohabitation may work for a few folks, but it does really screw up a lot of marriages in the long run more than it helps, and I would recommend against it. That said, I really doubt many kids would even realize that Casey and April were living together without being married.

EDIT: Oh, and to answer your question, Scandia. No, you're not the only one. I wouldn't say I'm appalled by it because appalled seems like a pretty strong word, but I do disagree with it. Props to you for risking the ridicule that a few people seem to be giving you.

Janus Prospero 05-17-2007 10:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scandia (Post 515970)
And the fact that there is a higher rate of divorce among couples who co-habited than among those who didn't. Whether correlation equals causation that would be another story.

I wouldn't put too much faith in that statistic. It has the inherent bias that people that are against pre-marital cohabitation are more than likely the same people that don't believe in divorce.

So it doesn't take into account people that didn't live together before getting hitched, but are now stuck in an unhappy marriage. :-(


Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 515995)
In any case, cohabitation may work for a few folks, but it does really screw up a lot of marriages in the long run more than it helps, and I would recommend against it.

Really? Pre-marital cohabitation destroys marriages? How? I'm not saying I disagree with you, I just don't see how it would. Perhaps you could give us a few examples?

To me, any marriage that fails probablly had deeper issues than the fact that they lived together a little bit before getting married.

SassyGal 05-17-2007 12:16 PM

It kind of went over my head that they were living together until my friend pointed it out :P . I'm not offended by it, but I'm not surprised others are. Everybody's different & has their own opinions :)

The Shelf 05-17-2007 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 516026)
Really? Pre-marital cohabitation destroys marriages? How? I'm not saying I disagree with you, I just don't see how it would. Perhaps you could give us a few examples?

To me, any marriage that fails probablly had deeper issues than the fact that they lived together a little bit before getting married.

First of all, I never said it destroys marriages. I think there are a lot of things that are involved in actually destroying a marriage. What I do think is that it can stealthily undermine marriages if it goes on too long.

Here's an example as you requested. If you're living with someone for a year or two before you decide to get married, you'll wind up putting yourself in a lot of tempting situations to go a whole lot further than a simple kiss or hug here and there. If you don't fall into that temptation, then great, maybe things will turn out great for you after all; but if you do, then you're setting yourself up for failure. If you start doing all the things that married people do, then you may begin to wonder why you should bother getting married in the first place. After all, it's only a piece of paper, right? You could still do everything else, but why bother going to the trouble to make it legally official? So you go on living together doing married people things without yet getting married, though you still plan to eventually. Now those inevitable deeper issues arise to cause enmity between you two. What will you do? Will you stick it out, or quit? You have a lot less reason to stick it out because you're not even married, remember? If you were married you would feel a lot more conviction to stick it out, but as it stands, you may feel you should just move on to someone new. Now when you go off and get married to someone else a few years down the road, you've already increased your chances of getting a divorce with that person because you've set a precedent in your life of quitting when things get rough. This may sound absurd, but people have an uncanny bad habit of following their own precedents.

This is perhaps the most straight-forward way I can think of that cohabitation can ruin your marriage. It likely won't ruin your marriage to the person you're living with because you probably won't marry that person anyway.

I'm sorry that this post has been so long, but you asked for an example. Maybe that wasn't even a very good example, but the way I see it, most people who live together don't end up getting married. The things they do with that person while they're living with them can come back to bite them down the road when they find someone they truly can love and live with.

But hey, maybe you guys are different. Maybe your experiences are special. If you cohabit, and things turn out great for you years down the road, then congratulations. I personally wouldn't take the risk, though.

SassyGal 05-17-2007 12:37 PM

Can't speak for anyone else, but I cohabited with my hubby only after we got engaged so we always intended on getting married, but I can see where you're coming from. Your example is actually just like my friend's situation. :)

Swany 05-17-2007 12:56 PM

I have to admit I pondered for a while if they were. It doesnt bother me. I cant really voice opinions on this I guess, (never been in a relationship). But people explore their relationships in different ways, emotionally and physically.

Im not going to "attack" anyone in any way though, there are people who don't beleive in Pre-marital cohabitation. (My own mother, for one)

And people who do (Yup another family member, my older bro and most of his friends)

People are allowed to have their own opinions and belifs on things like this. Can we not just be mature and respect each other?

(I actually had to look "cohabit" up on dictionary.com)

gobo 05-17-2007 01:18 PM

Why has this discussion arisen so late?

iris 05-17-2007 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 516099)
Why has this discussion arisen so late?

It's late? I saw some comments scattered around the boards.

gobo 05-17-2007 01:35 PM

First I'm hearing of anyone being freaked out by this aspect, and the movie has to be playing at less than a hand-full of cinemas anywhere by now (go ahead and prove me wrong... I know you want to). So, I'm just wondering why I hadn't read any such complaints before.

odupianist 05-17-2007 01:54 PM

Quote:

"Put down the weapons for a minute so we can hitched"
It doesn't work so well.
Scott Summers and Jean Grey any one?

bullet 05-17-2007 02:05 PM

er, two's company too?

jenna 05-17-2007 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 515995)
In any case, cohabitation may work for a few folks, but it does really screw up a lot of marriages in the long run more than it helps, and I would recommend against it. That said, I really doubt many kids would even realize that Casey and April were living together without being married.


It's funny you should say that - actually it's not the first time I've heard that. When I got married we had to have 'lessons' with the priest who performed our ceromony and he said that a larger % of those whose marriages fell apart had cohabited than those who didn't - I think it's a really interesting statistic. His reasoning was that when people first move in together it's like "playing house" and when the going gets tough the couple are not equipped to deal with it. I'm not sure I agree with that, I lived with my hubby for 18 months before we got married and then we've been married for 2 years, so our marriage is still young, but I lived away from home since I was 11 years old, so I don't think I was "playing house" at all!

I'm certainly not taking Scandia's words to be preachy - far from it, but I am interested in his / her objection (sorry, Scandia - I forgot to check if you were a he or a she). I have never followed convention so I am interested to hear that point of view.

bullet 05-17-2007 02:20 PM

i personally think a lot of numbers and figures propagated by the church are fabricated. i went to a religious school for a period of my life and it seemed that instructors and religious authorities often produced statistics without citing references...and some of those stats i found later to be totally false.

not sayin this particular figure is false, just puttin in my .02.

iris 05-17-2007 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 516106)
First I'm hearing of anyone being freaked out by this aspect, and the movie has to be playing at less than a hand-full of cinemas anywhere by now (go ahead and prove me wrong... I know you want to). So, I'm just wondering why I hadn't read any such complaints before.

Maybe nobody's spoken up so loudly because the Drome is teeming with heathenistic pre-epithalamic troglodytes skulking around in wait of delicious n00b innocents to rip asunder in sacrifical frenzies on our altar to the demon beast. :flaming:

Or maybe most uberfans here already knew about April and Casey's living sitation. But I like the first reason better.

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 516106)
go ahead and prove me wrong... I know you want to

:lol:

Janus Prospero 05-17-2007 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 516072)
Here's an example as you requested. If you're living with someone for a year or two before you decide to get married, you'll wind up putting yourself in a lot of tempting situations to go a whole lot further than a simple kiss or hug here and there. If you don't fall into that temptation, then great, maybe things will turn out great for you after all; but if you do, then you're setting yourself up for failure. If you start doing all the things that married people do, then you may begin to wonder why you should bother getting married in the first place. After all, it's only a piece of paper, right? You could still do everything else, but why bother going to the trouble to make it legally official? So you go on living together doing married people things without yet getting married, though you still plan to eventually. Now those inevitable deeper issues arise to cause enmity between you two. What will you do? Will you stick it out, or quit? You have a lot less reason to stick it out because you're not even married, remember? If you were married you would feel a lot more conviction to stick it out, but as it stands, you may feel you should just move on to someone new. Now when you go off and get married to someone else a few years down the road, you've already increased your chances of getting a divorce with that person because you've set a precedent in your life of quitting when things get rough. This may sound absurd, but people have an uncanny bad habit of following their own precedents.

This is perhaps the most straight-forward way I can think of that cohabitation can ruin your marriage. It likely won't ruin your marriage to the person you're living with because you probably won't marry that person anyway.

I'm sorry that this post has been so long, but you asked for an example. Maybe that wasn't even a very good example, but the way I see it, most people who live together don't end up getting married. The things they do with that person while they're living with them can come back to bite them down the road when they find someone they truly can love and live with.

No, that's a good example. I think you make some good points, but it also raises some other related moral issues such as premarital sex and choosing not to get married altogether. We won't get into that, but if those two issues were ok with someone than the issues you mention can occur from cohabitation are kind of moot. I also think that the issues you describe arise from the individual's own lack of willpower as opposed to the situation itself.

In my mind I would only want to live with someone that I intended to marry anyway, and I have. I did not take moving in with someone lightly and therefore the person I live with is someone that I have a strong emotional and spiritual connection with. So, if times became tough and enmity grew between us, this isn't someone I would just consider running out on because it was easier.

I think it's a much wiser idea to make sure you can handle each other under the same roof before 100% committing. Things may not work out, but if you do get married to that person, aren't you that much more secure in the marriage because you know what living with the person will be like?

Besides, would you really want to stay with someone whose only reason for not leaving you is because you're married? That's terrible. I want someone to be with me because they love me, not because they feel they have some obligation to.

jenna 05-17-2007 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bullet (Post 516132)
i personally think a lot of numbers and figures propagated by the church are fabricated. i went to a religious school for a period of my life and it seemed that instructors and religious authorities often produced statistics without citing references...and some of those stats i found later to be totally false.

not sayin this particular figure is false, just puttin in my .02.

Totally agree with you, but that is a whole other debate :lol:

The priest in question gave no reference for his figure - I think he wanted to guage whether or not we had been.... doing more than just living together.... (got to put it delicately, right?).

I think the grin on my face made him back off. I'm pretty sure he thinks I'm an evil temptress (he was a friend of my hubby, who was an altar boy, then I came along and they kind of... fell out!)

SassyGal 05-17-2007 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenna (Post 516127)
It's funny you should say that - actually it's not the first time I've heard that. When I got married we had to have 'lessons' with the priest who performed our ceromony and he said that a larger % of those whose marriages fell apart had cohabited than those who didn't

We had to do classes like that & I think everyone in the group session was trying not to laugh:lol: We also got that whole "playing house" comment and we both laugh today about that...the priest was trying to tell us that all our marriages were doomed if we live together, but 9 married years later, we still like playing house:lol:

Back to topic...as I said before, it went over my head they were living together & I think most kids will miss it as well simply because it wasn't made a big deal of...if it was more porno, then I would object:P

The Shelf 05-17-2007 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 516136)
No, that's a good example. I think you make some good points, but it also raises some other related moral issues such as premarital sex and choosing not to get married altogether. We won't get into that, but if those two issues were ok with someone than the issues you mention can occur from cohabitation are kind of moot. I also think that the issues you describe arise from the individual's own lack of willpower as opposed to the situation itself.

Morals and religion aren't the only reason why it's bad. If you don't end up sticking with that person for the rest of your life, then you've just spoiled something that's supposed to be especially for the person you do stick with. And, yes, I agree that lack of willpower is the primary cause that can be attributed to these sorts of issues, but unfortunately, most people don't have that strength of willpower. So why put yourself under that kind of temptation, unless as you said, you're willing to take the risks.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 516136)
In my mind I would only want to live with someone that I intended to marry anyway, and I have. I did not take moving in with someone lightly and therefore the person I live with is someone that I have a strong emotional and spiritual connection with. So, if times became tough and enmity grew between us, this isn't someone I would just consider running out on because it was easier.

Unfortunately, not everyone shares that kind of commitment to someone that they're not legally bound to.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 516136)
I think it's a much wiser idea to make sure you can handle each other under the same roof before 100% committing. Things may not work out, but if you do get married to that person, aren't you that much more secure in the marriage because you know what living with the person will be like?

Besides, would you really want to stay with someone whose only reason for not leaving you is because you're married? That's terrible. I want someone to be with me because they love me, not because they feel they have some obligation to.

I agree, but I don't think it's necessary to live with each other in order to determine whether you can handle each other. Besides, if you marry someone after knowing them for years and later you want to leave them just because you can't bear their little bad habits (which is the only knowledge you stand to gain from living with them) then perhaps you were loving them for the wrong reasons to begin with? I guess that's ultimately my point: the only thing you gain out of living with someone that you can't gain without living with them is discovering what their living habits are. So I don't think your argument about knowing whether or not someone loves you before you get married has anything to do with living with them beforehand. And if you really do love someone, then you're not going to care what their living habits are like. So what do you stand to gain by living together before you get married? No matter which way I look at it, the costs outweigh the benefits, even excluding my own moral and religious beliefs.

Mandi-chan 05-17-2007 03:56 PM

Quote:

Is APPALLED at the fact that in the movie, April and Casey are cohabiting?
I never knew that a couple living together before getting married was an issue, that never crossed my mind.

What's wrong with it?

iris 05-17-2007 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 516167)
Morals and religion aren't the only reason why it's bad. If you don't end up sticking with that person for the rest of your life, then you've just spoiled something that's supposed to be especially for the person you do stick with. And, yes, I agree that lack of willpower is the primary cause that can be attributed to these sorts of issues, but unfortunately, most people don't have that strength of willpower. So why put yourself under that kind of temptation, unless as you said, you're willing to take the risks.

When you said "morals and religion aren't the only reason" and I almost thought were were in for some medical edumacation about the evil things that happen to those who indulge in this behavior. :P

"Willpower" is all well and good, except that society focuses so much on "willpower" that all practical stuff gets left out. Like, what do you do if the willpower fails? Is your life over? The first question isn't appropriate to answer on this board, but the second question is clearly "no, your life is not over." But instead of saying that, we act like it will be the end of the world. We are setting people up to crash and burn.

Really, we do more damage by overplaying the risks involved than we do by stating the risks flatly. Not only does that lead people to mistrust most information they get from authority, but the fact is that people are really, really bad at judging risks, and exaggerated info just increases the problem. For example, girls hear "OMG you'll get pregnant!" over and over, and then if they risk take the risk and that doesn't happen immediately (which, you know, it probably won't), many of them actually conclude that they can't have kids! Which leads to all sorts of risky behaviors. Scaring people into compliance almost always backfires.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.