The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   TMNT on Blue-Ray (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=21216)

tilallr1 08-07-2007 12:25 PM

TMNT on Blue-Ray
 
Hi everyone,

This is for those looking to buy or have bought TMNT on Blue-Ray. I just went to Futureshop and saw them playing it in 1080p this morning and it was brilliant. The clarity was almost 3-D it was awesome. Way better quality then even in the theaters. I will probably never go to a movie theater again. Plus, with Warner Brothers lack of good quality DVD's (Superman Returns and 300 were garbage quality even for standard DVD quality), I finally decided to buy the newly priced PS3 for only $500 and TMNT to watch it. The system also came with a free stand and game which was awesome.

So first off, does anyone know if TMNT blue-ray is on the 50GB disc or the 25? It must be the 50 but I cannot be sure.

Also, anyone else buy a blue-ray player just for this movie?

Janus Prospero 08-07-2007 12:47 PM

I didn't get a Blu-Ray player just for this movie, but I am getting this movie on Blu-Ray. I can not wait. Tonight after work I'm going to sit back, relax, have a glass of port, and enjoy this movie in high definition. :D

Oh, and take my advice and upgrade your PS3's firmware immediately. The DVD scaling capabilities with the new version are awesome. It makes my DVDs look like the HD content I get from OTA or cable.

ToTheNines 08-07-2007 12:49 PM

Off topic but... you drink port? I love that stuff :tlove:

tilallr1 08-07-2007 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 545045)
Oh, and take my advice and upgrade your PS3's firmware immediately. The DVD scaling capabilities with the new version are awesome. It makes my DVDs look like the HD content I get from OTA or cable.

Yep already did that. 1.90 baby. Its awesome what it can do for some of your old DVD's and PS2 games.

X 08-07-2007 01:01 PM

I bought three copies of TMNT last night.

Two regular versions, one for me and my 400 disc DVD player, and one for my Son, and the Blu-Ray version.

I have a 57 inch Hitachi widescreen HDTV capable of 480p, 720p, and 1080i, sadly no 1080p. I will say this though, I flipped between my DVD version and my Blu-Ray version, and must say the difference is still noticable even when playing my BD movies in 720p. Makes me think how good 1080p will look once I get one of those TV's.

With me buying three copies alone, I hope this movie does well enough to show them smartasses at WB a sequel would be a good idea, and that next time they shouldn't mess up so bad by putting it in with a lot of competition.

-X-

tekninja 08-07-2007 01:12 PM

I'm going to pick a blu-ray copy, hopfully on my lunch hour. I can't wait to see it in 1080p. Watch it over and over again. I wish the extra feature that is part af the target special edition was included on blu-ray, but oh well.

Ecto Jedi 08-07-2007 01:47 PM

So, uhh...Who's still stuck with DVD? YEAH!

raphdude 08-07-2007 02:24 PM

Tmnt Blu-ray- A Brief Review!
 
The Blu-Ray disc is absolutely AMAZING!!! 8) I'm so glad I got a PS3 WITH THE 1.90 UPGRADE!:D

One big difference I noticed is when Leo first appears out of the tree to attack the main gang member in South America. When I saw the film in the theatres, the print was very dark and you could only see Leo's eyes, in the regular dvd, you see his face better, but in the blu-ray disc, you can see his face CLEARLY.

I was also impressed with the sound. When leo says to raph as nightwatcher
"You don't want to do this," I can hear the chains whipping clearly in my surround speakers.

I also really liked the Leo mask artwork on the disc. better than the standard dvd, which is a flipper disc (widescreeen one side. full screen the other, the extras replicated identically on both sides of the disc).

The extras appear to be identical to the regular dvd. My only disappointment was that Warner did not include the audio track to listen to the deleted scenes by themselves:( . Munroe talks thru everything and that is a real shame. Most dvd's offer an optional director commentary track with deleted scenes. I wanted to hear what raph and leo were saying on the rooftop.
But honestly, I am so pleased with the quality of the transfer the extras don't matter that much to me.

Lastly, the extras on the blu-ray and regular dvd appear identical to the upcoming Austrailia dvd, so I would only think the reason to get the R4 version is for the collector's tin and the stickers.

Go get a PS3! It's worth it for this disc which is an excellent reference quality BLU-RAY! And pick up Pirates 1 and 2 while you're at it!8)

Mr. Snackpants 08-07-2007 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ecto Jedi (Post 545084)
So, uhh...Who's still stuck with DVD? YEAH!

Me too.

I'm not willing to commit to Blu-ray or hd dvd yet...I don't wanna get burned. I'll just wait awhile and see how it all turns out. I am getting pretty impatient, however, with my 1080p capable tv sitting there not being used to its fullest potential(except for the 360).

Ashangelo 08-07-2007 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Snackpants (Post 545121)
Me too.

I'm not willing to commit to Blu-ray or hd dvd yet...I don't wanna get burned. I'll just wait awhile and see how it all turns out. I am getting pretty impatient, however, with my 1080p capable tv sitting there not being used to its fullest potential(except for the 360).

Me too as well. I don't have the money to get an HD or Blu-Ray player. Plus the DVD's alone are hella expensive.

Fiendishglow 08-07-2007 04:15 PM

meh, I'll wait til I can get a blu-ray player for about 100 bucks.

A better picture is nice, but not 500, 600 dollars nice.

Not to mention there's a chance that one of the formats or very possibly both won't make it. I'll stick with the DVD version, and get the Blu-Ray (or whatever) a few years down the line. It's not like it's limited edition.

Mr. Snackpants 08-07-2007 04:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TMNTluvr1 (Post 545139)
Me too as well. I don't have the money to get an HD or Blu-Ray player. Plus the DVD's alone are hella expensive.

True, $30-$35 is too much. For that price you can a super special edition regular dvd w/ tons of extras, but you just get the basics in better quality of course.

Ecto Jedi 08-07-2007 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fiendishglow (Post 545146)
A better picture is nice, but not 500, 600 dollars nice.

Especially when I'd have to buy a new, $1000 high-def TV screen to see any notable improvement. I'll stick with the DVD, thank-you-very-much.

Andrew NDB 08-07-2007 08:29 PM

I picked up the Blu-Ray version today. Haven't watched the movie again yet, but I do notice that, suspiciously missing from the list of special features is, "The Apology."

ToTheNines 08-07-2007 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545222)
I picked up the Blu-Ray version today. Haven't watched the movie again yet, but I do notice that, suspiciously missing from the list of special features is, "The Apology."

I don't get it :|

Splinter's Iroonna 08-07-2007 09:00 PM

Please.. he's being himself.. as usual.

Hey, Andrew! I seriously am looking forward to your hard-hitting interview with Kevin Munroe!

Buslady 08-07-2007 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545222)
I picked up the Blu-Ray version today. Haven't watched the movie again yet, but I do notice that, suspiciously missing from the list of special features is, "The Apology."

Dude...if you hated the movie so much, WHY DID YOU BOTHER?????????

X 08-07-2007 10:13 PM

Well even if Blu-Ray and HD-DVD don't make it (I have both formats,) then at least one could say they have some movies in seriously ridiculously, super duper, high resolution. Seriously, I don't even have a 1080p HDTV yet, and am watching the BD version in 720p, and man it still kicks the crap out of the DVD version.

Oh and the BD version was 24 at Wal-Mart, not 30-35... :P

I however, won't be supporting both formats in full, like I do DVD (I have a 400 disc DVD player which spoils me from having to change out discs over and over,) until they release a multidisc BD or HD-DVD player. I will however, buy the Spidermans, Transformers, Pirates, on BD since they show it off nice.

-X-

Andrew NDB 08-07-2007 11:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Splinter's Iroonna (Post 545233)
Hey, Andrew! I seriously am looking forward to your hard-hitting interview with Kevin Munroe!

Me too. He agreed to it, I sent him the questions, and weeks later he confirmed he would still do it, but even that was a good month ago. Last word to me he was literally in Japan, very much busy with Gatchaman.

GreenWillow 08-08-2007 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545222)
I picked up the Blu-Ray version today. Haven't watched the movie again yet, but I do notice that, suspiciously missing from the list of special features is, "The Apology."

Are you saying that your official apology to Warner Bros. Imagi, Kevin Munroe and the entire fandom was supposed to be in the Special Features?

Wow. That would be Special.

~GW

Spitfire 08-08-2007 01:21 AM

You hated the movie yet you bought the more expensive Blu-ray version? Hm works in mysterious was indeed...

Roseangelo 08-08-2007 01:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx (Post 545379)
You hated the movie yet you bought the more expensive Blu-ray version? Hm works in mysterious was indeed...

Not only that, but by buying the DVD he's supporting the effort for a sequel.

I'll take my apology in Klingon, BTW.

Andrew NDB 08-08-2007 09:12 AM

What sequel? :)

tilallr1 08-08-2007 11:11 AM

Well watched it last night and this is the best quality home movie I have ever seen. The clarity was awesome, the details were stunning. Saw so much more of the movie then I did in theaters.

P.S. Blu-ray will win out over HD-DVD, just look at the 50GB disc quality over the HD 15GB-30GB quality. 20GB is alot more more space for video quality and sound. Blu-ray can also potential store in the future much more than that up to 500GB from what I have read. HD is stuck with a max of 30GB. Its obvious from this point alone that HD technology is done before it starts.

But now lets look at the cost of the media. Blu-ray is $4-$5 cheaper. Why, because HD has decided to have a flip feature to support old DVD technology on one side and the new HD version on the other. They thought this would help them win the war, but it hasn't. Why, because people are cheap and if they are buying a HD version of the film they don't care about the old DVD format on there. Its a waste of money.

Finally, DUAL Hi-def players (Which play both blu-ray and HD have entered the market - LG already has a player out and more are coming). They are expensive but will come down over time.

Also, they have anounced that in Japan the creation of a double sided disc with the HD format on one side and blu-ray on the other. So studios can release a high-def version of the film for both formats on one disc. But you can bet those will be expensive.

Andrew NDB 08-08-2007 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 545381)
I'll take my apology in Klingon, BTW.

It's Klingonese, I'll have you know! :)

Andrew NDB 08-08-2007 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tilallr1 (Post 545519)
Well watched it last night and this is the best quality home movie I have ever seen. The clarity was awesome, the details were stunning. Saw so much more of the movie then I did in theaters.

P.S. Blu-ray will win out over HD-DVD, just look at the 50GB disc quality over the HD 15GB-30GB quality. 20GB is alot more more space for video quality and sound. Blu-ray can also potential store in the future much more than that up to 500GB from what I have read. HD is stuck with a max of 30GB. Its obvious from this point alone that HD technology is done before it starts.

But now lets look at the cost of the media. Blu-ray is $4-$5 cheaper. Why, because HD has decided to have a flip feature to support old DVD technology on one side and the new HD version on the other. They thought this would help them win the war, but it hasn't. Why, because people are cheap and if they are buying a HD version of the film they don't care about the old DVD format on there. Its a waste of money.

Finally, DUAL Hi-def players (Which play both blu-ray and HD have entered the market - LG already has a player out and more are coming). They are expensive but will come down over time.

Also, they have anounced that in Japan the creation of a double sided disc with the HD format on one side and blu-ray on the other. So studios can release a high-def version of the film for both formats on one disc. But you can bet those will be expensive.

All valid points. And as more and more of these dual players -- meaning, players that play both HD-DVD and Blu-Ray -- become prevalent, people will simply have to ask the question, "Do I want the HD-DVD, or Blu-Ray version of this movie?" The answer, of course, should be Blu-Ray, with its larger capacity.

Truth is, though, I'm not entirely certain there's a huge demand for either. At least not yet.

Splinter's Iroonna 08-08-2007 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545557)
It's Klingonese, I'll have you know! :)

Quote:

Klingonese - Memory Alpha, the Star Trek Wiki
Klingonese (also known more commonly as "Klingon") is the language used throughout the Klingon Empire. It was boasted that half the quadrant was learning ...
memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Klingonese

:D ;)

ToTheNines 08-08-2007 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545557)
It's Klingonese, I'll have you know! :)

??? I thought they spoke Mandarin...

tilallr1 08-08-2007 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545558)
All valid points. And as more and more of these dual players -- meaning, players that play both HD-DVD and Blu-Ray -- become prevalent, people will simply have to ask the question, "Do I want the HD-DVD, or Blu-Ray version of this movie?" The answer, of course, should be Blu-Ray, with its larger capacity.

Truth is, though, I'm not entirely certain there's a huge demand for either. At least not yet.

The demand is not huge yet, as you say, but will be increasingly more so in the coming few years as players pricing plummets. I expect by the year 2010 that everyone will have either a blu-ray or hd-dvd player in their homes. Like everyone has dvd players now. I think that by then DVD's will be like Video cassettes. Something of a past, obsolete technology.

Of course the one thing I like about HD tech is that there isn't anything better. It means once you have settled down with your 1080p TV and blu-ray player you are set for quite a few years yet to come. I haven't heard of anything new on the horizon. Does it really need to get any better? I guess the next big step would be 3D TV's. But that is probably a decade away.

I can't wait for the day when Season packs are in HD and on one disc. With blu-ray's 500GB discs one day this WILL become a reality. Its awesome.

This also made me feel pretty good about choosing blu-ray. Here is a list of the major studios which support which format. I think the choice is obvious. The studios have already voted.

Blu-ray support
Paramount
Warner Bros.
Disney (Buena Vista)
Fox
Lionsgate
MGM
Sony Pictures

HD-DVD support
Paramount
Warner Bros.
Universal Studios

raphdude 08-08-2007 03:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tilallr1 (Post 545636)
This also made me feel pretty good about choosing blu-ray. Here is a list of the major studios which support which format. I think the choice is obvious. The studios have already voted.

Blu-ray support
Paramount
Warner Bros.
Disney (Buena Vista)
Fox
Lionsgate
MGM
Sony Pictures

HD-DVD support
Paramount
Warner Bros.
Universal Studios

I wasn't even originally planning on getting a blu-ray player to begin with. My initial concern was to get the lower priced PS3, the 60 GB, with the backwards compatibility chip in so I could plug and play all of my PS2 and PS1 games. The newer PS3 model will not have this chip. You will have to download patches from the internet. I never expected the PS3 (with the 1.90 update) to automatically up convert standard dvd and PS2 game playback! It was amazing! All I had to do was unplug my PS2 and plug in the PS3 so I didn't have to get new video/audio cables. The blu-ray player with 1080
resolution was a welcome bonus. I believe blu-ray will win the format war with all the studio support. Now that Spielberg's first film for hi-def dvd (Close Encounters) is a blu-ray exclusive, maybe Universal will finally bend.
I hope so.

Till then, I would like to see Lionsgate put out the OT on blu-ray, and 4KIDS the new toons as well!:) And most of all, I want the ORIGINAL MOVIE 1990
ON BLU_RAY!!!8) NEW LINE, ARE YOU LISTENING ?!!

I must say again though, that TMNT on blu-ray is an awesome reference disc!8) For both picture and sound! Got it for $24.95 at wal-mart!

Andrew NDB 08-08-2007 04:16 PM

Some people are of the mind that since the porno industry has sided with HD-DVD, that's the end of the war, but that's rubbish.

Janus Prospero 08-08-2007 11:50 PM

So I got the DVD on both DVD and Blu-Ray (Something I've always wanted to do, but haven't had a movie I've been willing to try it with.) Comparing the Blu-Ray ouput at 720p vs the DVD upscaled to 720p is kinda like comparing the saving of a JPG vs saving a BMP in MS Paint. They both look good, but there are artifacts in the JPG due to the compression, were as the BMP saves each individual pixel as it is. Of course the difference would probably be much more noticeable on a larger 1080p screen.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 545046)
Off topic but... you drink port? I love that stuff :tlove:

Oh yes. I love all kinds of alcohol. I'm a bit of a beer connoisseur too, but when it comes to wine it's port all the way. I know it's meant as an aperitif or a desert wine, but I could drink the stuff any time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by raphdude (Post 545105)
One big difference I noticed is when Leo first appears out of the tree to attack the main gang member in South America. When I saw the film in the theatres, the print was very dark and you could only see Leo's eyes, in the regular dvd, you see his face better, but in the blu-ray disc, you can see his face CLEARLY.

Yeah, he kind of snarls at the guy. Something I hadn't noticed in theaters.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Snackpants (Post 545121)
I'm not willing to commit to Blu-ray or hd dvd yet...I don't wanna get burned. I'll just wait awhile and see how it all turns out. I am getting pretty impatient, however, with my 1080p capable tv sitting there not being used to its fullest potential(except for the 360).

I'm kinda sitting back and watching the carnage myself. I only use Blu-ray because I have a PS3, and I only have 2 BR movies (TMNT included.) But I felt that as far as movies go, this is one I wanted to enjoy the best way I possibly could. Which is the only reason I caved to the format war in this instance.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545222)
I picked up the Blu-Ray version today. Haven't watched the movie again yet, but I do notice that, suspiciously missing from the list of special features is, "The Apology."

I do find it funny the amount of rancor with which you discuss the movie when even Kevin "The Man" Eastman said himself that he loved the movie and thought that it stayed "true to the turtles" and "had a perfect balance of seriousness and humor." And I'm assuming that Peter Laird liked it as well, since he played such a large part in its development.

Andrew NDB 08-09-2007 12:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tilallr1 (Post 545618)
With blu-ray's 500GB discs one day this WILL become a reality.

You mean 50 GB.

500 GB would be godly, though.

tilallr1 08-09-2007 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 545903)
You mean 50 GB.

500 GB would be godly, though.

The rumour right now is 500GB. But its just a rumour in the coming years who knows. Maybe even a 1 TB disc might be possible. But in reality they have already shown that blu-ray is confirmed capable of 100GB & 200GB discs. They have already made those. Just haven't sold them on mass yet. They will be coming next year I believe.

SavantiRomero 08-09-2007 06:19 PM

I'll be getting a dual drive later this year. I bought the target 2 disc dvd, and I have to say I'm very dissapointed in the quality of it. ALOT of detail was lost, capturing frames is embarrassing, alot of the motion is way too blurred also. Watching the movie in normal play speed is ok, tolerable.

I'll be picking up both HD and BD formats as soon as they appear in my area, as I'm not in a hurry to buy formats I can't currently watch. Very much looking forward to seeing the HD/BD formats in action as well as hoping they really did the animators work justice, cuase there is none on the standard DVD.

Andrew NDB 08-09-2007 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SavantiRomero (Post 546134)
I'll be getting a dual drive later this year. I bought the target 2 disc dvd, and I have to say I'm very dissapointed in the quality of it. ALOT of detail was lost, capturing frames is embarrassing, alot of the motion is way too blurred also. Watching the movie in normal play speed is ok, tolerable.

I'll be picking up both HD and BD formats as soon as they appear in my area, as I'm not in a hurry to buy formats I can't currently watch. Very much looking forward to seeing the HD/BD formats in action as well as hoping they really did the animators work justice, cuase there is none on the standard DVD.

Are you the same SavantiRomero that used to be on the mailing lists and used to spell your name as "Savante"? Good god, it's been eons, if it's you.

Fiendishglow 08-09-2007 09:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tilallr1 (Post 545618)
I expect by the year 2010 that everyone will have either a blu-ray or hd-dvd player in their homes. Like everyone has dvd players now. I think that by then DVD's will be like Video cassettes. Something of a past, obsolete technology.

You're insane if you think everyone will have Blu-Ray by 2010. That's 2.5 years away. Considering less than 30% of households have HDTV that would mean in 2.5 years 70% of people would have to go out and buy a HDTV and an even higher amount of people would have to go out and buy a Blu-Ray player.

Even if those 70% of households were to go out and buy HDTVs in the next 2.5 years (yes I'm aware that in 2009 standard signal will be shut off, but people will still go out and buy the converter boxes) a good portion of those households will be buying lower end models which Blu-Ray doesn't make as nice as a difference on.

Throw in the fact that there's a ton of people out there content with their DVDs and HD-DVD isn't going away by 2010 there's no way that everyone will have Blu-Ray by 2010. In fact until you can get a blu-ray player for 50 bucks and under (which won't be for years to come) there's absolouty no chance of it.

The reason everyone has a DVD player is because of the huge gap in technology between VHS and DVD. There's not that huge gap between Blu-Ray/HD-DVD and a DVD. Sure the picture is a lot better, the discs can hold a lot more.. but it's still a DVD at heart...

What is really going to hurt the two new formats is the fact that people have such huge DVD collections already (I myself have 150 and my girlfriend has almost 200). Because of this movies that sold well on DVD aren't going to sell as well on Blu-Ray. Not everyone is going to run out and rebuy every movie that they had on DVD, unlike before. The jump from VHS to DVD was worth rebuying all of your movies. The jump from DVD to Blu-Ray/HD-DVD isn't big enough where everyone is going to run out and rebuy their whole DVD collection, espechally since most people have been buying DVDs for only 5ish years and probably aren't ready to go out and replace it all. Sure people will want to upgrade their favorites, but you're not going to see people having Blu-Ray collections of 150, 200 movies for a long time unless they're really dedicated to better picture, and there just aren't enough people out there that dedicated to better picture.

I'm not saying Blu-Ray or HD-DVD is going to fail, but sucess isn't going to happen anytime soon.

Ecto Jedi 08-09-2007 10:03 PM

I do like how they put a two-minute-long HD-DVD/Blue-Ray promo first thing on the DVD -- really made me feel technologically inferior. Thanks, WB.

Splinter's Iroonna 08-09-2007 10:58 PM

I swear to God-- and I'm not MEANING this to be bad-- but I feel like I'm stuck in a room full of Donatellos at this point.

Or even better:

Quote:

It's the Pasadena Star Trek convention all over again." -- Nichelle Nichols, playing Uhura in "Futurama"

SavantiRomero 08-10-2007 11:26 AM

Yep, but I don't recall spelling my name with an "e." I ownzers ninjaturtles.net and a few other sites that have been down for some years.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.