The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Art Change (V . 4) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=21844)

turkishproverb 09-22-2007 02:04 AM

Art Change (V . 4)
 
I was looking through volume 4, and I realised the greatest change of the art's shading (from the old style to the new, and "Retcon" style,) occours around issue 9 (DOS) before that issue, the shading was noticable and intact. After that one, its stark black and white with elss detail and shading.

Anyone else notice this?

Andrew NDB 09-22-2007 03:28 AM

Around that point is when Laird became enamored with some rather elementary Photoshop (or at least, Photoshop-esque) toning, so he decided to forego the detailed duotones of the past.

Additionally, all of the Vol. 1 he will determine is canon will eventually be re-collected into TPB in similar tone-less fashion.

cormano 09-24-2007 06:13 PM

Yeah, it was talked about in the back of the books, if I remember correctly. I don't mind it with the new issues, I'm really against going back and redoing the old books, though.

Rooish 09-24-2007 06:52 PM

I think one time Roseangelo posted pictures of Laird's updated toning for all the original comics. Does anyone know where I can find those pictures? It looks so lame without the old dark toning.

DrSpengler 09-24-2007 07:09 PM

TMNT: Changing History

Yeah, Laird's "new and improved" inking looks like absolute garbage. I'm never letting go of my original issues if that's Laird's vision for the TMNT.

Mecha Cow 09-24-2007 07:45 PM

And so Peter Laird's transformation into George Lucas continues.

VaughnMichael 09-24-2007 07:51 PM

dun dun dun!
*waits for Tristan to come in and say something in lairds defense*:lol:

Roseangelo 09-24-2007 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecha Cow (Post 559625)
And so Peter Laird's transformation into George Lucas continues.

Nah, Lucas is better. As much as people whine about the Special Editions, he did eventually release the original versions on DVD. He listens and responds to fan opinion and actually employs a person for the sole purpose of fan relations. Hasbro gets to make whatever action figures they want to make without him putting down an iron fist - This even includes at least one fan requested figure a year. The Expanded Universe (everything that exists outside of the movies) has been allowed to grow into a HUGE thing including comic books and novels and you can bet that he's not reading and approving every single detail there. But he has built a team of people who understand what it is he wants and who know what the fans want and so they're able to deliver products that fit into the Star Wars brand without being micro-managed by Mr. Lucas.

turkishproverb 09-24-2007 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 559637)
Nah, Lucas is better. As much as people whine about the Special Editions, he did eventually release the original versions on DVD. He listens and responds to fan opinion and actually employs a person for the sole purpose of fan relations. Hasbro gets to make whatever action figures they want to make without him putting down an iron fist - This even includes at least one fan requested figure a year. The Expanded Universe (everything that exists outside of the movies) has been allowed to grow into a HUGE thing including comic books and novels and you can bet that he's not reading and approving every single detail there. But he has built a team of people who understand what it is he wants and who know what the fans want and so they're able to deliver products that fit into the Star Wars brand without being micro-managed by Mr. Lucas.


Finally, somone willing to point out that Lucas doesn't deserve half the crap he gets.

The guy is pretty hands off, aside from working on the films (repeatedly) and denying republication publicaiton of 1 item that was genrally hated by everyone (The star wars christmas special) And he's acnowledged that THAT is easily available online and in boot's.

His rehashes were annoying, yes, but ultimatelly he even released the unedited versions alongside, so now its like having the Regular+ Directors Cuts of the movies.

Although the regulars are better, which is weird...anyway...

But yea, I was just asking if anyone agreed this was the obvious turning point in the art.

Roseangelo 09-24-2007 08:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turkishproverb (Post 559641)
The guy is pretty hands off, aside from working on the films (repeatedly) and denying republication publicaiton of 1 item that was genrally hated by everyone (The star wars christmas special) And he's acnowledged that THAT is easily available online and in boot's.

I think the situation with the Holiday Special is pretty funny. Because, yeah, he's very clear that he's never ever releasing it for purchase. But he obviously doesn't care about the distribution of pirated copies, so it's kinda like a nudgenudge, winkwink kinda thing.

Quote:

Although the regulars are better, which is weird...anyway...
I actually like things about both versions, so I go back and forth with which versions I watch.

Quote:

But yea, I was just asking if anyone agreed this was the obvious turning point in the art.
Hehe. Well, I do agree with you that the loss of toning was not a good thing for the books. While it's most obvious with Jim's art, it's not exclusive to just him. With just a few exceptions, it seems that toneless is now the preferred style at Mirage and IMO that takes out half of the appeal of B&W art.

Oh, and somewhat related (I think), I wish they would go back to printing the books on newsprint. B&W art (again, IMO) looks better with the off-white rather than the stark, bright white paper they are currently using. And I'm sure it's cheaper to print on newsprint, too.

Andrew NDB 09-24-2007 10:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 559645)
Oh, and somewhat related (I think), I wish they would go back to printing the books on newsprint. B&W art (again, IMO) looks better with the off-white rather than the stark, bright white paper they are currently using. And I'm sure it's cheaper to print on newsprint, too.

You know, I hadn't ever even thought about the paper stock but you're absolutely right. TMNT always felt "right" in newsprint.

VaughnMichael 09-24-2007 10:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 559667)
You know, I hadn't ever even thought about the paper stock but you're absolutely right. TMNT always felt "right" in newsprint.

I agree with the both of you and I miss the smell the old news print comics had also.

Raph'N'Roll 09-24-2007 10:43 PM

I really liked that duo toning, black and white art needs that extra detail to make up for it's lack of colour, without it, it just looks empty and bland.
The detail in Vol 1 is fantastic, I wish Laird would bring back that style.

Rooish 09-24-2007 11:23 PM

When Laird does an updated "Return to New York," I'm going to kill myself.

Slash 09-25-2007 06:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 559681)
When Laird does an updated "Return to New York," I'm going to kill myself.

Careful what you say online... Someone might have just requested Laird to redo it. :P

EDIT: Just wondering, why does the official website have the original comics as they were and not Laird's idea?

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/one/pg10.htm

Roseangelo 09-25-2007 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slash (Post 559726)
EDIT: Just wondering, why does the official website have the original comics as they were and not Laird's idea?

Shhh... don't give him ideas. ;)

Rooish 09-25-2007 10:01 AM

Maybe he doesn't completely want to change history yet.

Or Berger doesn't have the time to update the new versions.

Roseangelo 09-25-2007 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 559764)
Maybe he doesn't completely want to change history yet.

Or Berger doesn't have the time to update the new versions.

And who knows if any of the issues are even complete beyond #1.

Slash 09-25-2007 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 559757)
Shhh... don't give him ideas. ;)

It just struck me as an oddity.

Janus Prospero 09-25-2007 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 559637)
Nah, Lucas is better. As much as people whine about the Special Editions, he did eventually release the original versions on DVD.

I do love how responsive Lucas is to the fans. I don't think I've ever seen a franchise embrace its followers the way Star Wars has.

Additionally I don't mind the Special Edition versions of the movies save for a few things. (Han totally shoots first! And adding Hayden Christensen at the end of Episode VI seemed a bit excessive.) But I actually like the added scene with Jabba the Hutt in A New Hope.

Anyway, my big beef with all this is when they did re-release the original unaltered versions on DVD, it was in a non-anamorphic widescreen format with 2.0 stereo sound as opposed to 5.1 surround. I guess it's not a big deal if you're watching it on a standard definition TV, but if you're a video/audio-phile like me and have ever watched a non-anamorphic DVD on a widescreen HDTV, it's annoying. I'm not even mad, just confused about this. Would it have been that difficult to encode the DVD in anamorphic format?

Anyway, I'm rambling, so I guess my point is, "WTF Lucas? WTF?"

Roseangelo 09-25-2007 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janus Prospero (Post 559846)
Additionally I don't mind the Special Edition versions of the movies save for a few things. (Han totally shoots first! And adding Hayden Christensen at the end of Episode VI seemed a bit excessive.) But I actually like the added scene with Jabba the Hutt in A New Hope.

Adding Hayden to the end of ROTJ is probably the only thing about the Special Editions that I absolutely loathe and would be happy to fight it out with George Lucas about it. But that's really not a rant for this thread. 8)

I had heard all the whining about the non-SE DVDs being non-anamorphic, but didn't really pay attention since I'm stuck in the world of standard definition TV. One day I will upgrade and perhaps another fist-to-fist showdown with Lucas will be in order. It wouldn't have required much effort to make the DVDs anamorphic, but I think it probably is Lucas's way of stickin' it to us while at the same time giving us what we ask for.

turkishproverb 09-25-2007 06:52 PM

MY problems with the SE's were differnt than my problems with the DVD SE's. THe two are wildly different if you watch.

FOr example, in the nonDVD SE they added a digital scream to Luke falling in cloud city, which was totally out of character as he had JUMPED.

That's not there in the DVD edition, but they did redub Bobba Fett :(

Roseangelo 09-25-2007 07:00 PM

You have to be careful about how you refer to them, because both versions of the SEs are on DVD. :lol:

I know what you mean, though. With the second release they fixed a lot of the stuff people complained about most.. but then he went and added Hayden in there. :dead:

turkishproverb 09-25-2007 07:37 PM

I know, uts just easier that way.

Yea, that was annoying. It actually would've mad emore sense to put the Kid from episode 1 in than Hayden, but that would've been wrong too.

Honestly, I've just been reediting all three versions together myself :).

Back to topic, does anyone disagree that this is the point the art changes style in TMNT V4?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.