The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   5th Movie Idea... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24062)

Kenneth 05-17-2008 10:35 PM

5th Movie Idea...
 
I hate to sound like a broken record, but in order for TMNT to have a box office hit they will have to go back to the 80-90's roots. Yes I'm talking about the old tune. 2k3 is nice I admit, but the older tmnt was much better, and had awesome ratings until the 6th season. I didn't know one person girl or boy that didn't like TMNT.

Being a hardcore tmnt fan I made myself find stuff I liked about the movie, but in reality I was very disappointed in the overall story line....

The old tune was a little on the goofy side, but it attracted more of an audience then any TMNT show that replaced it...


TMNT had/has (debatable) a huge fanbase.. It could do just as good as Spiderman, Batman, Iron Man, etc IF we get some new writers. I think the current team of writers isn't taking the whole TMNT seriously .... I mean come on who created the new villains in the last movie..


The right marketing/ writing/ movie magic TMNT can be just as popular as it was in the 90's.

I'm off my soap box!

I meant to say toon and not tune.. lol-- I didn't change my post though..

Kendamu 05-17-2008 10:55 PM

Peter Laird and Kevin Munroe are totally not taking the TMNT seriously enough. Riiiiiiight.

Look. If the OT is what's necessary for TMNT to make Iron Man type money, then why did the first movie do so well in 1990?

Jo Dawn 05-17-2008 11:09 PM

Going back to the OT is not the answer. No matter how 'big' it was in it's time, you have to realize that it also screwed TMNT for the future.

Because of it, people dealing with TMNT (production-wise) feel it must be a children's product. When, the TMNT truly aren't 'kiddy' in their beginnings. Making it a kid's only type thing has killed the franchise. Kids went to see Spider-Man and X-Men, and those did well. It didn't have horribly infantile moments that were 'KIDS ONLY', like the TMNT people like to try and do.

Spider-Man didn't have to wonder about their sequels. TMNT fans do. What we need to do is go more along the lines other companies are doing. Go BACK to the roots and tell the story like it should be told.

Ra 05-17-2008 11:44 PM

Right there with you Jo. Trying to get the next sequel it more like the OT will just doom the franchise into being seen as "kids" material. It really isn't the way to go. Spiderman, Batman, Superman...they are all seen as things for a general audience at the movies, but TMNT isn't. That's why I'm sad whenever TMNT doesn't get an M rating. And that's also why I'm hoping for everyone to put up their standards for the next movie ("everyone" being the people who are giving out the ratings for the next movie...if there is one at all).

We just need a wider audience. PG won't get us anywhere, I'm afraid, which will what an OT based movie will result in. The next movie really needs to get back to the roots of TMNT and try to include more adults as well as kids.

Kendamu 05-17-2008 11:57 PM

I don't think we necessarily need PG-13 for TMNT, Ra. Speed Racer was a really fun movie (with fighting!) and it was only PG as well. Studios just need to stop holding it back.

gobo 05-18-2008 12:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610351)
I hate to sound like a broken record

Be proud of your ability. I actually thought for a second that I left my 'broken record' player running in the other room. That's quite some talent... ^_^

Revan 05-18-2008 12:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610351)
I hate to sound like a broken record, but in order for TMNT to have a box office hit they will have to go back to the 80-90's roots.

The old tune was a little on the goofy side, but it attracted more of an audience then any TMNT show that replaced it...


TMNT had/has (debatable) a huge fanbase.. It could do just as good as Spiderman, Batman, Iron Man, etc IF we get some new writers.

...contradiction? You say tmnt needs to go back to it's Old Toon comedic roots and then you say you want it to do as well as spider-man, batman, and Iron man but those movies are all action oriented not comedic.

Think! Iron man made $100,000+ in one weekend and it was non-stop action. Favreau didn't kiddify the movie and it smashed in the theatres. Now you say tmnt should return to it's kiddy 1987 verison. :lol:...No. Just no, that is not the answer. The turtles just don't have the same popularity they once did. It would take a really really good movie to get the tmnt franchise humming again... perhaps one like the 1990 movie :P duh

Dragon Turtle 05-18-2008 12:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610351)
The old tune was a little on the goofy side, but it attracted more of an audience then any TMNT show that replaced it...


Different time and different generation my friend.


Quote:

TMNT had/has (debatable) a huge fanbase.. It could do just as good as Spiderman, Batman, Iron Man, etc IF we get some new writers. I think the current team of writers isn't taking the whole TMNT seriously .... I mean come on who created the new villains in the last movie..

I'm not sure I understand you, you want the writers to take TMNT more seriously, but at the same time you want it to be more like the less serious old cartoon? Also, movies like Spider-Man, Batman, Iron-Man,etc are summer tent pole movies, different marketing, different expectations.

Kevin Monroe and Peter Laird created the new villains, and were designed by Jeff Matsuda and Jose Lopez.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 610383)
I don't think we necessarily need PG-13 for TMNT, Ra. Speed Racer was a really fun movie (with fighting!) and it was only PG as well. Studios just need to stop holding it back.

Given the MPAA's unknown standards, it can't really be said what is PG for one movie is the same for another movie, even TMNT was deemed by some to be too violent/scary for children and was one edit away from PG-13, yet movies like Narnia and Star Wars can have people getting cut down left and right, yet still retain a PG rating. Walking the tightrope between PG and PG-13 is too difficult and unnessary.

Kendamu 05-18-2008 12:56 AM

True, but if TMNT were given it's respect as a comic book movie franchise it wouldn't have to walk any type of tightrope.

Dragon Turtle 05-18-2008 01:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 610391)
True, but if TMNT were given it's respect as a comic book movie franchise it wouldn't have to walk any type of tightrope.

Let's hope Warners has learned their lesson from TMNT's opening weekend, and can resist the allure of McDonald's Happy Meal money.

Kendamu 05-18-2008 01:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 610396)
Let's hope Warners has learned their lesson from TMNT's opening weekend, and can resist the allure of McDonald's Happy Meal money.

Doubtful. I'm guessing that we'll just have to wait until the 2k3 kids grow up and want their piece of big screen nostalgia before Mirage and whatever director they hire is allowed to do at least as much as the American version of Naruto (like throwing shuriken on screen!).

Guitar_Raph 05-18-2008 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610351)
I hate to sound like a broken record,

In this day & age, it would be a broken CD.

I would love to see another TMNT sequel. Maybe Nightwatcher can battle Turtle Titan or maybe have a band. Now I sound like a broken CD!

Drtooth 05-18-2008 08:53 AM

Wasn't one of the rejected TMNT ideas TMNT comedy movie? I don't know about you, but (sounding like a broken record myself) I'd rather see a DTV 2-D animated 80's style turtles movie than to see it creep up on the big screen.

Think about it this way, the first TMNT film was always different from the cartoon series. No Krang, No Bebop, No Rocksteady. Who was going to think a floating sequal would be any different? Other than changing it so April was a reporter, colored bandanas, and giving them the cartoon logo, there was nothing remotely like the cartoon. And the movies back then did as good as can be expected. 'cept of course the third one which came out thai tail end of their popularity.

And guess what, the kids who are currently watching 2k3 (unless they have older brothers or parents or something) haven't been exposed to that. In fact, I'd say that the 2k3 viewing public went into the film relatively unscathed. They were both similar interpretations of the TMNT. How many people here who watched the 80's cartoon were confused the first time they saw the first film, seeing Raph as a brooding angry character, instead of the Sarcastic jerk he was?

As I said, the only thing holding TMNT 2 back is Imagi. They're going through absolute hell due to change in management (check out the Gatchaman movie thread for that). Unless they settle this crap, they won't make a single movie they projected, let alone TMNT.

Kenneth 05-18-2008 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 610383)
I don't think we necessarily need PG-13 for TMNT, Ra. Speed Racer was a really fun movie (with fighting!) and it was only PG as well. Studios just need to stop holding it back.



Speed Racer had a horrible beginning.. I literally wanted to leave... It did get better at the end though.

Kenneth 05-18-2008 05:22 PM

When I get some more time I'll try to explain what I mean by creating TMNT more along the lines of X-man, iron man, spider man , and batman, and still stay true to the old toon's roots..

thebrownranger 05-18-2008 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn (Post 610372)
Because of it, people dealing with TMNT (production-wise) feel it must be a children's product. When, the TMNT truly aren't 'kiddy' in their beginnings. Making it a kid's only type thing has killed the franchise. Kids went to see Spider-Man and X-Men, and those did well. It didn't have horribly infantile moments that were 'KIDS ONLY', like the TMNT people like to try and do.

Spider-Man didn't have to wonder about their sequels. TMNT fans do. What we need to do is go more along the lines other companies are doing. Go BACK to the roots and tell the story like it should be told.

Totally, totally, totally %100 agree with you. It pisses the $h*t out of me because everybody depicts it as a franchise only for little toddlers. I guess thats why I hated FF and the new cgi movie so much. Lets hope the new upcoming season isn't as crappy as it visually looks. TMNT started out as an underground comic book for young teenagers and young adults (15-21). I seriously am not hoping for a sequel if they're thinking of making more random and useless storylines thats a waste of time and money. TMNT I was the best movie ever in every way hands down.

GK Punk 05-18-2008 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610351)
I hate to sound like a broken record, but in order for TMNT to have a box office hit they will have to go back to the 80-90's roots. Yes I'm talking about the old tune.

Going back to the original song won't do any good! Good day sir!

Canadian Turtle 05-18-2008 06:16 PM

If they were to go back to anything they should do an original comic throw back much like the first movie, but do the F-ing thing live action. I can't say how much I hate it when they ruin otherwise good stories with CG (not to say TMNT had a good story) But there is NO reason that with todays technology we can't do a darker, faster, tighter, grittier, dirtier, old school hard core TMNT movie using so called "guy in suite" technology, that would look BAD ASS!!

PS - Stan Winston is the only man on earth that could pull this off by the way.

Revan 05-18-2008 06:23 PM

^ It's easy to say what "would" work when you don't really have to worry about if you're right. guy it suits has been done 3 times already and yeiled one good movie, one mediocre, and one crap! CG could have worked if the script would have been different. It was a good idea to change things up and roll with the times, but unfortunate the movie was kiddified.
(Haven't we had this same conversation several times already? :lol:)

gobo 05-18-2008 07:52 PM

You know Andrew has... :P

Kendamu 05-18-2008 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenneth (Post 610480)
Speed Racer had a horrible beginning.. I literally wanted to leave... It did get better at the end though.

I thought the first five minutes or so was kinda lame because the particular cinematic technique they used was OVERUSED but I liked the rest.

Dragon Turtle 05-18-2008 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebrownranger (Post 610483)
Totally, totally, totally %100 agree with you. It pisses the $h*t out of me because everybody depicts it as a franchise only for little toddlers. I guess thats why I hated FF and the new cgi movie so much. Lets hope the new upcoming season isn't as crappy as it visually looks. TMNT started out as an underground comic book for young teenagers and young adults (15-21). I seriously am not hoping for a sequel if they're thinking of making more random and useless storylines thats a waste of time and money. TMNT I was the best movie ever in every way hands down.


In terms of Kiddy content, not much seperates the first and fourth movie, the first movie was designed to be a PG kids movie, with content that Eastman and Laird thought would be appropriate for kids.

ToTheNines 05-18-2008 08:17 PM

Well, TMNT was just following the trend (that's still going on) of making a continuation movie of a trilogy that was popular in the 80's/early 90's. Only problem is it had a pretty differnt tone, with all new actors, new characters, even a new medium. I'm not neccesarily calling for a live action film bringin back the old cast, but I think if they did that it would have done better. As a fan, I would have liked to see the story retold in the CGI medium, but it still was a good movie.

Kendamu 05-18-2008 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 610507)
In terms of Kiddy content, not much seperates the first and fourth movie, the first movie was designed to be a PG kids movie, with content that Eastman and Laird thought would be appropriate for kids.

Seems in 1990 you could get away with more at PG.

Dragon Turtle 05-18-2008 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 610519)
Seems in 1990 you could get away with more at PG.


Yeah, PG-13 was still fairly new, it's amazing what PG got away with prior to the creation of the PG-13 rating, which I believe was 1984.

Canadian Turtle 05-18-2008 10:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 610521)
Yeah, PG-13 was still fairly new, it's amazing what PG got away with prior to the creation of the PG-13 rating, which I believe was 1984.

Hahaha you should see what we get away with in PG movies up here in Canada. What would be rated R in the US can be as low as PG here (where it is called "G" not PG). For instance (I think it is still the same) With the use of the "F" word in the US, if it is used 2 times you get an R rating. I am not saying kids should be subjected to bad content it is just things like nudity and "adult" content are not as worried about in Canada.

Drtooth 05-19-2008 08:50 AM

Here's the question. I just saw Speed Racer yesterday (loved it. it looked like an anime), and it was PG, and here's what I found...

Spridel flipping Royalton off.

Multiple uses of the word "ass,"

and quite a bit of violence to name a few.

looking back at TMNT, that could have easily passed for a G film. It's like a souped up G film slapped with a PG rating for marketting purposes. Not that I didn't love TMNT, but they really could have gotten away with quite a bit more. I think they were just harder on it because it was animated.

Dragon Turtle 05-19-2008 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drtooth (Post 610573)
Here's the question. I just saw Speed Racer yesterday (loved it. it looked like an anime), and it was PG, and here's what I found...

Spridel flipping Royalton off.

Multiple uses of the word "ass,"

and quite a bit of violence to name a few.

looking back at TMNT, that could have easily passed for a G film. It's like a souped up G film slapped with a PG rating for marketting purposes. Not that I didn't love TMNT, but they really could have gotten away with quite a bit more. I think they were just harder on it because it was animated.


It's definately harder to get away with certain things in an animated movie then it is a live-action movie, however, these things get a bit strange once you hit PG-13 territory, such as last years Beowulf where people were getting impaled and ripped apart, yet Beowulf still maintained its PG-13 rating, where else a live-action version probably would have gotten an R. The reasoning being that the characters were cartoons instead of real people.


It should also be pointed out that the studio was also taking other countries outside the U.S. into account when it came to the amount of violence shown in TMNT, I believe they could have pushed the action/fighting level a little higher and still possibly hung onto a PG rating, even showing shurikens and more nunchuck action, but TMNT probably would have lost its PG equilvalent rating in other countries, particularly countries in Europe.

Buslady 05-19-2008 11:03 AM

TMNT is not taken seriously, and now' it's being killed slowly with all these series changes.
From a kid's POV-Kids can't keep up with the latest version of the cartoon, why would they want to go see the movies? The toys aren't that great. I rarely see kids oogling TMNT figs when they're checkin out other figs. Playmates needs to take it more serious with their products, give the fans something to the lines of the 2K3 figs but make them LOOK LIKE the cartoon, not some dorky squatting pose'd figure.

For a movie, kids would expect live action...what was the first 3? They seen those, I get kids going " i got all three movies!" or "I didn't like the new one cos they werent real"
I know it wont happen again, but I believe if they put out an ALL live action, animatronic TMNT by Henson, try to get the formula back that made TMNT1 and not cut out so much material, make it two hrs, make it for US...the fans. I think it'd be good. The tech today is ten times better, them being "real" kids could relate with them, imagine them as being real, they can make it dramatic and with lots of heart and still kick but. I think they could do it, but they dont take it seriously enough...it's who cares, just a kid flick. Why spend millions on it when a few kids'll see it?

Kendamu 05-19-2008 12:26 PM

I can agree with a lot of what's being said, but really TMNT was a pretty big success overall. They spent around $30 Million making the movie and, before DVD sales, they went home with $90 Million. As some of us might know, a movie in theaters is nothing but a big commercial for the DVD and the box office numbers are nothing but a prediction of how many people are going to buy the DVD.

So, if TMNT did about 3-times its budget before the real money came in with the DVD, I'm guessing it's safe to assume that it was a success. Sure, we may have wanted more Shuriken and more Nunchaku, but to the world-at-large it was a damn good movie. So, except for this "let's make the next one a comedy!" crap that Imagi's trying to pull right now, not much is going to change about the next one because the formula seems to be working.

Sad, but true.

Canadian Turtle 05-19-2008 12:56 PM

Well the bottom line is, I want a freakin special edition of the first 3 in a nice box set and some good behind the scenes. And even better an actual TMNT phenomenon documentary (which as a film maker I have been trying to pitch to mirage) that takes an actual look back at the entire franchise and shows everything from the comics to live tours.... anyways sorry a bit off topic.

Arcade Joe 05-19-2008 08:33 PM

New TMNT movie??
 
I've alway had this thing on the back of my mind to actually write a TMNT movie script for my own personal gratification. But it would never be made, because the direction would be too 'extreme' for younger viewers, however, if it was done right, it could attract a wide age group if you did it right.

I wanted to base it to where they are all adults and they kind of went on thier seperate ways,but after 9/11/01 they find each other. But I think using 9/11 in something like a turtles movie would be 'tramatic' for some people who lived in New York City at that time, so it may very well be a bad idea...

Andrew NDB 05-20-2008 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drtooth (Post 610573)
looking back at TMNT, that could have easily passed for a G film. It's like a souped up G film slapped with a PG rating for marketting purposes. Not that I didn't love TMNT, but they really could have gotten away with quite a bit more. I think they were just harder on it because it was animated.

They didn't even try pushing anything, not that you really can push PG that far before hitting PG-13 territory these days. I don't think the MPAA requested a single cut... all the kid-pandering/self-neutering/self-censorship was entirely voluntary of WB/Imagi.

Dragon Turtle 05-20-2008 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 610814)
They didn't even try pushing anything, not that you really can push PG that far before hitting PG-13 territory these days. I don't think the MPAA requested a single cut... all the kid-pandering/self-neutering/self-censorship was entirely voluntary of WB/Imagi.


The MPAA were pretty much looking over the shoulders of the Director/Producers ofTMNT early on, this is from an interview with producer
Thomas Grey:


"Sure. We can't get more than a PG. It's not designed to do that. We pre-tested it with the MPAA. We've actually pulled back quite a bit, like Sharika's throwing stars we've pulled out. Just a little too much violence. Yeah, we're really concerned about how parents will react. As long as there's a rating of PG, we should be OK. There's no profanity, but we do push a little bit."


I've always wondered who was Sharika?:???:

One scene in particular that got shot down by the MPAA was the ending of the Leo/Raph fight, were Raph brings the sai down an inch from Leo's eye.

The Rough House Fight Test from the dvd shows the original ending.

(courtesy of thebrownranger):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N3mZlokrKFo

I actually like the fight choregraphy in this test more then the actual fight from the movie.:)

ToTheNines 05-20-2008 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 610890)
One scene in particular that got shot down by the MPAA was the ending of the Leo/Raph fight, were Raph brings the sai down an inch from Leo's eye.

That scene was better off being shot down, in my mind. Say they kept it the way they had it, that means Raph intentionally stopped himself right? Now the way it ended up he stabs the floor right next to his throat, the way I see this is that he was so excited at the chance to kill that he accidentally missed, meaning he was so controlled by his anger that he almost killed his own brother, causing him to run away crying. While if he stopped himself he could have got up and gloated.

Andrew NDB 05-20-2008 08:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 610890)
"Sure. We can't get more than a PG. It's not designed to do that. We pre-tested it with the MPAA. We've actually pulled back quite a bit, like Sharika's throwing stars we've pulled out. Just a little too much violence. Yeah, we're really concerned about how parents will react. As long as there's a rating of PG, we should be OK. There's no profanity, but we do push a little bit."


I've always wondered who was Sharika?:???:

Ah, OK. I stand corrected.

And I'm pretty sure whoever took down the interview ****ed up and Thomas actually meant "Shuriken Throwing Stars."

Revan 05-20-2008 10:36 PM

If we are on the movie's rating and violence content... AGAIN I would just like to express my amazment that Prince Caspian had the same rating as TMNT but had hundreds of characters dying in battle where in TMNT the only person we witness "dying" is Winters. WTH?!

karailynn 05-21-2008 08:48 PM

just curious..but instead of being a "broken record" has anyone complained to anyone in the TMNT franchise? It's a no brainer that they listen to kids...b/c they buy their toys. They dont really have anything aimed at anyone over tha age of 9....so those voices maybe aren't heard. Has anyone been a broken record to the people that it matters?

Revan 05-21-2008 09:41 PM

I don't think there are enough of us for them to bother

Drtooth 05-22-2008 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neutrino (Post 610928)
If we are on the movie's rating and violence content... AGAIN I would just like to express my amazment that Prince Caspian had the same rating as TMNT but had hundreds of characters dying in battle where in TMNT the only person we witness "dying" is Winters. WTH?!


As I said, Speed Racer has Spridal flipping someone off, and it gets a PG. I think we got the prue faction of the MPAA hanging over TMNT's heads. The violence in it was no way a PG. maybe G. I find it an absolute joke that they had different standards for animation.

But whatever the reason, whatever the problem, that's not going to get Imagi to get its butt in gear, overthrow their new Ex-Dreamworks management, and bring back the original creative teams to make TMNT part 5 or part 2, or whatever. If they even finish Astroboy, that'll be a miracle.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:42 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.