The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Review Of The Ninja Tribunal DVD (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24114)

Spitfire 05-22-2008 01:20 AM

Review Of The Ninja Tribunal DVD
 
Alright so I had a chance to watch most of this DVD. I got up to "Fathers And Sons" before I had to leave for class.

For one I'd like to note the episodes are better then I remember them being. Course I haven't watched them since they were leaked online back when the DVD came out in Australia. Now their not great by any means but entertaining. The only thing is they lack some replay value for me as I can't see myself watching this again in the foreseeable future. Which means maybe in a year I might pop it back in. The whole series has that feel to me actually so that seems to be a big problem with the show as a whole for me.

On to the episodes themselves. The continuity does flow quite well and the story is interesting if you ignore the obvious "Dragon Ball Z" factor. They tried to add a bit more of the Japanese element into it and I give them props for that. I just highly dislike the fact the turtles choose to fight with energy beams instead of their weapons or fists. They yell their weapon names to much and fire techno-color beams all over the place way too often. This argument has been run into the ground though so I'll leave that behind.

The animation has been vastly improved on this transfer. I haven't gotten to see the last few episodes yet but what of it I have seen it looks way better then the Australian release I had. The backgrounds looked horrible and pixelated on almost every episode. This was in the later episodes though, the last three of which I have yet to watch and that's where it got the worst. The last two episodes especially looked really bad. I'm hoping the DVD stays consistent.

Now that I have that out of the way I'd like to mention my major issue with this season. I don't feel like I'm watching turtles. I don't feel like I'm watching some weird anime knock off either though but it doesn't feel like turtles to me. What's missing I can't say but the subject matter is a full 360 away from everything I think about when I think of turtles. I guess it's the dragon transformations, weapon laser beams, and zombies popping up all over. I like the Demon Shredder personally. I know some people think he's lame but I think they handled him well. I liked his rebirth scene rather gruesome for a kids show I thought. All the death and destruction that goes on in the season is what really sets it apart I guess. Though it's all undone basically at the end so it makes zero difference.

I almost felt like this was more of a turtles movie, or mini-series of it's own. It has an ending of it's own, like here's the end of the 2K3 style. It could have been the end to the series. FF was the same way in it's last episode. They finished it off with and ending that could serve as an ending to an entire series if they wanted, though I'm glad they didn't.

I don't know if this really counts as a review but I wanted to toss my opinions out on it and recommend the disk to anyone who hasn't picked it up yet. The DVD is worlds better in quality which personally helps me enjoy it more when every frame of animation doesn't look like a zoomed in drawing in Photoshop. You can still tell the season was low budget with all the use of stock footage but they still did a good job at keeping it consistent with the rest of the series.

Anyone else have any reviews or opinions they'd like to share about the DVD?

Ra 05-22-2008 02:22 AM

I really do think we were left out in the extras part. For me, I love looking at design concepts, character sheets, interviews with the people behind the scenes and so forth (like we had with Larid in the first few 2k3 DVDs). Then again, we've been pretty deprived of extras for quite some time now, so I shouldn't really make that big of a fuss about it.

Otherwise, no complaints. I love my DVD Box set and like to watch the odd episode on occasion.

odupianist 05-22-2008 07:26 AM

I agree with Ra. I got kind of disappointed in the DVD's when they started giving us instructions on how to play their card game instead of cool interviews with PL. And going out of order, but that's a whole nother issue.

X 05-22-2008 12:01 PM

I saw this DVD at Target (mine are on the way,) and must say I am dissapointed about one thing.

I mentioned awhile back how I wish they'd add the black line and comic panel up top, to match the season 1 and 2 DVD's. I see that they did not.

Now when I have season 1-4 on DVD with the black spine and strip, with comic panel, and Ninja Tribunal sitting between seasons 1-4, and season 6 (which I assume will be re-released with the look of seasons 1-4,) it will look odd.

That is unless, for some reason, they are going to be re-releasing SEASON 5, after they get done with 4, then in that case, I will be double dipping, just for the sake of making my DVD collection, look nice while bookshelfed.

-X-

Jon 05-22-2008 12:38 PM

I rather doubt they'll re-release Fast Forward (since it's already done in the 2-Disc routine Funimation is using); and also doubt Ninja Tribunal would be either.

veemonjosh 05-22-2008 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon (Post 611232)
I rather doubt they'll re-release Fast Forward (since it's already done in the 2-Disc routine Funimation is using); and also doubt Ninja Tribunal would be either.

Like I've said before, by the time they get done with rereleasing season 4, the Ninja Tribunal and Fast Forward disks will be LONG out of print.

4Kids would most likely put seasons 5 and 6 back out into circulation using the new format.

Jon 05-22-2008 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by veemonjosh (Post 611258)
Like I've said before, by the time they get done with rereleasing season 4, the Ninja Tribunal and Fast Forward disks will be LONG out of print.

4Kids would most likely put seasons 5 and 6 back out into circulation using the new format.


They might be out-of-print, but who knows.

The "new format", as-in what they already did with them.....

Tinuvielsdreams 05-22-2008 02:26 PM

I think the only thing that annoyed me after awhile was the need to yell out their mystic abilities when used. The didn't yell out what kind of kicks or punches they did, or talk to their weapons on most occasions. That was the part for me that showed they were under the anime influence.
The dragon avatars felt that way too, but it's just where they were going with this whole Japanese legend plot.

The backgrounds are awesome in the way they have a lot of detail and you just know someone really took their time. I always thought the animation just got better and better so visually it's really great to watch.

It's such a collection of all these new things and no it doesn't always feel like you are watching TMNT but then we have some old comforts added like splinter, Casey, and April and they do eventually take the battle to New York City and Don's inventions like the turtle taxi are thrown in so as far removed as it becomes at times it still maintained the fact we are watching turtles.

I wasn't really expecting extras so I didn't really pop it in to look and it sounds like I was kinda right from what everyone is saying.

And yeah Spit I definitely thought when I ordered it from Australia and saw it for the first time...
"Why wasn't this just a made a direct to DVD movie?" It felt like it really could have been, especially before we knew when and if they were going to air it.

Jester 05-22-2008 02:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinuvielsdreams (Post 611264)
And yeah Spit I definitely thought when I ordered it from Australia and saw it for the first time...
"Why wasn't this just a made a direct to DVD movie?" It felt like it really could have been, especially before we knew when and if they were going to air it.

13 episodes x 20ish minute running time = 260 minutes (give or take...) or 4 1/3 hours....one really long movie.

EDIT: The back of the case says 286....which makes it 4.7666666 hours.

Edit x 2: Um...it's kinda similar to the season 1 and 2 releases, slightly different, I guess as a way of saying "LOST SEASON!"
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...o/101_0562.jpg

Spitfire 05-22-2008 03:04 PM

Tell that to Lord Of The Rings, seriously some of them are 4+ hours.

Your right made for TV movie is a bit much but more or so mini-series would work. It could be stand alone. I'm sure edited down though it could easily be made into a 2 hour film with all the intros, credits, and recaps removed. There's also some scenes as well as entire episodes that aren't needed to move the story along that could be easily removed. That'd be fun to try and re-edit it, I might try that.

odupianist 05-22-2008 03:07 PM

heh Jester, glad to see how someone else did their DVD's. I did the Season 1 and 2 at the end because once things got out of order, it would have been too hard to put the Seasons where they lay. Don would be split up, etc.

gobo 05-22-2008 03:56 PM

Question to anyone who has this new, Region 1 Ninja Tribunal DVD: are the menu audios the same two they've been using for 2K3 DVDs for the past year (1&2)? Mine won't be ready to ship for awhile... :ohwell:

Spoiler:
For anyone interested, here are the rest of the 2003 version DVD Menu audios:
3
4
5
6
7
(S4)1
FF1
FF2

ToTheNines 05-22-2008 04:38 PM

Spit: Nice review

Jester: Could you post pics of the the back and inside of this release please?

Gobo: Nice find!

Tinuvielsdreams 05-22-2008 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx (Post 611268)
Tell that to Lord Of The Rings, seriously some of them are 4+ hours.

Your right made for TV movie is a bit much but more or so mini-series would work. It could be stand alone. I'm sure edited down though it could easily be made into a 2 hour film with all the intros, credits, and recaps removed. There's also some scenes as well as entire episodes that aren't needed to move the story along that could be easily removed. That'd be fun to try and re-edit it, I might try that.

Yeah I meant more potentially it felt like it could have been a film, it would have definitely needed some tweaking to have done it that way. Pretty much every Spit said would have to be done.
It would be fun to attempt

Jester 05-22-2008 08:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 611294)
Jester: Could you post pics of the the back and inside of this release please?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...o/101_0565.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...o/101_0566.jpg

I don't have a scanner, so this is the best i can do.

AquaParade 05-22-2008 08:14 PM

Just picked my dvd up. I saw some of the episodes here and there, but saved a little to be surprised with. I'm glad to say the rack at target has only two copies left on a rack that looked like it was holding 10-15. Good news to me.

ToTheNines 05-22-2008 08:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 611342)
I don't have a scanner, so this is the best i can do.

Good enough for me, thanks bud.

Machias Banshee 05-22-2008 08:52 PM

*adds stuff to birthday wish list*

I have to say, I LOVE the artwork in the scans there.

*wish Splinter would be drawn/dressed like that more often*

I'm of the same thought that the season was a little two anime-ish for my taste. If the Ninja Tribunal was a little less spiky-haired and floaty, I may have been able to tolerate them a little more.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinuvielsdreams (Post 611264)
I think the only thing that annoyed me after awhile was the need to yell out their mystic abilities when used. The didn't yell out what kind of kicks or punches they did, or talk to their weapons on most occasions. That was the part for me that showed they were under the anime influence.

I totally agree...



:shifty:




Super Gembu Mango Power!!
:mango: :mango: :mango: :mango: :mango: :mango:
*vanishes*

veemonjosh 05-23-2008 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon (Post 611263)
They might be out-of-print, but who knows.

The "new format", as-in what they already did with them.....

No, I mean "new format" as in the way that the pre-FF half-season sets are currently going.

And yes, I expect them to be out-of-print by then, since most 4Kids DVDs don't stay in print for more than two years.

Jon 05-23-2008 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by veemonjosh (Post 611528)
No, I mean "new format" as in the way that the pre-FF half-season sets are currently going.


That is how the Fast Forward DVDs are (two 2-Disc, dozen-or-so episodes). So no real difference for FF vs. the re-releasing of 2k3. And Ninja Tribunal does the routine too (just with one 2-Disc release).

syd 05-23-2008 06:59 PM

I don't like the Dragon Ball factor either, but perhaps I'm wont to anime style lah, I think overall the story's consistant which makes up the drawback a little.

Jelly Bean 05-24-2008 01:45 AM

I liked season five for the most part but I think it was more hype than than anything else.

gobo 05-24-2008 11:52 AM

Whoops!
 
Fixed my link for Fast Forward Menu 2. And, while everyone's so eager to answer my question, I guess I should say it seems I'll be getting it sooner than expected as it shipped just yesterday. Thanks for the concern. :)

sdp 05-25-2008 01:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 611267)

Are those all the single volumes?

That indeed looks cool, it almost makes me want to go back and get the single volumes, well almost ;D

Too bad they did away with them, they could have done Casey, Shredder etc.

Scandia 05-25-2008 06:47 AM

I have all the single volumes. But there is an error in my Notes from the Underground volume. It shows the same Raphael segment as the subsequent The Shredder Strikes Back volume. And TSSB is illustrated correctly and in sequence. This may be just my individual copy.

gobo 05-25-2008 08:58 AM

No, it was a mass-produced mistake. I only bought my copy right before they announced Season 1 Part 1 (oh well, I was buying it mostly for the interstitials anyway), and it had the exact same mistake.

Jon 05-25-2008 09:55 AM

Have to check my Notes From the Underground DVD, but think I got the correct version.

I've also read there are apparently 2 cover variations for it as well.

DrSpengler 05-26-2008 02:15 PM

Finally finished the Ninja Tribunal DVD. I chose to wait for this thing when the episodes were on You Tube and even when they were being run on TV. That was a...pretty long wait, to say the least.

I can't say that it lived up to my every expectation, but I found it to be a primarily enjoyable season which really *did* feel like a series finale, even if it wasn't.

I couldn't quite see what made it more dark or mature than the previous seasons. From the way fans were ranting and raving, you'd almost think the packaging on the set would be dripping with blood. Still, it did built tension very well and I liked how it tied in themes and storyline from previous seasons. It certainly felt really, really epic.

Having now seen season 5, I think I appreciate the direction Fast Forward took much more, now. I didn't hate Fast Forward, either, mind you. But the futuristic gimmick makes a bit more sense to me. Season 5 was all about mysticism and magic and demons and ghosts and what-not. After 13 episodes crammed with that stuff, I can see the need to go the opposite direction and give us a season-long arc about aliens and sci-fi technology. Season 5 was as much off the deep-end with its gimmick as Fast Forward was.

There were several things that bugged me about this season, namely the "anime" technique of screaming then name of their special attack whenever they used it. That drove me crazy, particularly since they were so inconsistent about it (sometime they'd yell the Japanese name, sometimes the English translation). The Acolytes dying and then coming back at the last second was a bit WTF. On the whole, I really didn't even like them at all.

On the whole, it was a good season, but still a step down in quality from season 4, which (IMO) was the zenith of the show's story-telling.

Jester 05-26-2008 08:24 PM

I thought that Search for Splinter was the one that had the mass printing error, cause it was the only single volume I had to buy on-line.

gobo 05-26-2008 08:35 PM

What? You think me and Scandia are just imagining it?? WHERE DO YOU GET THE NERVE, HUH??? :x

Spoiler:
courtesy of your friendly neighborhood gobo ^_^

Jester 05-26-2008 08:43 PM

No, but I could swear that SfS was another one to have a packaging snafu.

Spitfire 05-27-2008 12:04 AM

Nope just the Raph one. I had to dig to find one that wasn't messed up back when they came out.

Tinuvielsdreams 05-27-2008 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire666xXxXx (Post 612365)
Nope just the Raph one. I had to dig to find one that wasn't messed up back when they came out.

yeah I remember that mistake, and you are the one who sent me the fix. It's amazing how much that printing mistake bugged me...:lol:

veemonjosh 05-27-2008 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon (Post 611529)
That is how the Fast Forward DVDs are (two 2-Disc, dozen-or-so episodes). So no real difference for FF vs. the re-releasing of 2k3. And Ninja Tribunal does the routine too (just with one 2-Disc release).

I meant in the NEW BOX STYLE because, by 2011/2012, the DVDS WILL BE OUT OF PRINT.

Jon 05-27-2008 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by veemonjosh (Post 612469)
I meant in the NEW BOX STYLE because, by 2011/2012, the DVDS WILL BE OUT OF PRINT.


*OKAY!*

Cripes, I didn't figure there was that much of a difference to the DVDs packages. As, along with the other stuff I've described, they're pretty much similar too.

ToTheNines 05-27-2008 04:13 PM

The lost season and FF are different enough from the first four season that I don't think the uniformity is essential.

My 2k3 DVD's stand next to my OT collection and the movies, and not all of them are the same, so does it really matter?

Jon 05-27-2008 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 612476)
The lost season and FF are different enough from the first four season that I don't think the uniformity is essential.

My 2k3 DVD's stand next to my OT collection and the movies, and not all of them are the same, so does it really matter?


Exactly. They're similar, but have some minor difference. Which (as have noted) is just fine for me.

Scandia 05-27-2008 06:29 PM

I bought the DVD today at Target. For 11 dollars, I could NOT pass it up. I think it is a bargain at that price. They charge you twice that for a 6-episode disc of an anime series.

Now I finally own ALL the 2k3 episodes on DVD.

FlawedCoil82 06-01-2008 09:21 PM

I bought this dvd off Buy.com for 10 bucks plus free shipping, so (even though this season disappointed me), I thought that was a pretty fair price.

My feelings on NINJA TRIBUNAL are pretty much the same as everyone else. It had the potential to be incredible, but then it just fell apart half way through the season. Shredder was a huge disappointment. He was more like Magneto from X-Men (a masterpiece cartoon FAR FAR too damn long and inexcusably overdue on getting a DVD release) in Shredder clothing than anything. He showed absolutely nothing that would make you think he was a martial arts expert. It was all ray beams and magic. I was so badly hoping for the final battle with him to be a great choreagraphied fight between him and the 4 turtles (with their original weapons instead of the new ones). I didn't mind them 'glowing' to power up but that should have just helped them increase their speed. There was no need for the new weapons or ray beams. I'll gladly take the Utrom Shredder over the 'original' Shredder. At least the Utrom showed a hint of martial arts talent.

I will, however, say that it was still FAR better than anything that I saw from Fast Forward. That season just did nothing for me. To this day I could only watch 4 episodes before I couldn't stand it any longer. I don't know what happens in that season and I couldn't care less to find out. The new weapons, the new looks, none of the former villians (I saw Agent Bishop once), the crappier animation. It was like an entire season of Turtle Titan/Justice Force episodes (the worst episodes in my opinion from the earlier seasons). If I could find both DVDs for sale for a couple bucks one day, then I may pick them up just to say I have them and to help connect the original series with the BACK TO THE SEWERS series (which still puzzles me how they figure that series will do better than the 2003 series but with crappier animation). I'm not a kid though (I'm 26 years old) and I simply cannot appreciate the animation that is so common today. Cartoon Network for example is full of modern cartoons drawn all distorted, disfigured and ugly with very little work done to detail. I hope BACK TO THE SEWERS will be better than I fear it will.

Anyways, this season was decent, but probably my least favorite of the first 5 seasons (the first episode with the cool fight between them and the wooden guys on the rooftop was my favorite). Everything else was just too Dragonball Z-ish (another cartoon which I enjoy) and when they turned into dragons at the end, I could only groan in disappointment.
Jack

veemonjosh 06-04-2008 04:20 PM

Yeah, I guess it doesn't really matter that much about box designs. At least we have them out. ^_^;


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:57 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.