The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Possibly Live Action CGI Turtle mix :) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=24285)

twopinacoladas 06-10-2008 09:56 AM

Possibly Live Action CGI Turtle mix :)
 
http://www.newsarama.com/comics/0806...T25-Laird.html

I dont think anyone has posted this yet, but it could be really cool. Very nice interview ;)

<i>NRAMA: On the film development front, how's it going with Imagi and WB on the sequel?

PL: I'm not sure that we will be working with Imagi on the sequel -- I'd like to, but we're looking into other options. I can't really talk about it in detail, but there are several interested parties we're talking to. One of the things which seems to appeal to everyone is this idea of doing what people are calling a "hybrid" movie -- one where most of it will be live-action, but the Turtles would be very realistically rendered CGI characters. I think that could be, if done correctly, incredibly cool. One thing that I would love to see happen is to try to get Sarah Michelle Gellar and Chris Evans (who performed the voices of April O'Neil and Casey Jones in the 2007 computer-animated TMNT movie) to reprise those roles in a sequel... but as live-action versions of April and Casey. I think that would be wicked cool! As far as I know, at this point they have not been asked, and I have no idea if they would be interested in doing it. I can hope, though!</i>

Raph 06-10-2008 10:17 AM

OMG, thats great news!! Theres hope!:cry:(<-happy cry) There is a TMNT god!!

Read the whole interview guys, it's a cool read! Thanks, twopinacoladas

Cowabunga Carl 06-10-2008 10:27 AM

I really liked the CGI movie. Hell I even took my name from it. I would like too see a sequil to TMNT but if they go live action will they ignore TMNT?

Raph 06-10-2008 10:34 AM

I think not, it'll definitly be continued from it, since Laird would like to see Chris Evans and Sarah reprise their roles as Casey and April! Let's hope they want to!!

twopinacoladas 06-10-2008 10:35 AM

Yeah on one hand I think there is a lot of potential to a sequel all CG but as Peter points out if dont correctly it could be sooo awesome. One of the concerns I would have is that it being done where you can clearly see that the turtles are CG and you may disconnect with them. On the other hand if done well this could be really awesome. On a side note one of my next projects will be to create a "realistic" ninja turtle myself using texture from actual turtles :D (3d btw) maybe i'll scrap the Spider-Man I started for now and do that Im starting to feel inspired again!

I dont think they would ignore it, heck Peter would like to see Chris Evans and Sarah Michelle (sp) playing April and Casey. I think a live action with cg turtles could draw a bigger crowd possibly then the last one.. who knows tho.

Cowabunga Carl 06-10-2008 10:44 AM

See that is my concern, that the CG turtles will stand out from the rest of the movie. But maybe I'm being a little to sceptical. A live action would fit in better with the first three.

Where would they go story wise though? Would they build on Karai's line about faces from the past? Will we finally see utroms in a movie? My vote would be City at War.

Raph 06-10-2008 10:51 AM

If done right, the Turtles won't stand out from the human characters. Just look at Jurassic Park with the dino's or The Hulk.

twopinacoladas 06-10-2008 10:54 AM

It could actually be better than the live action ones possibly even better than the first. The voices would be in sync and could do things that no stunt man could possibly do. It would all depend on the movies budget and team of modllers and animators that create it. This maybe just a possiblity but its really exciting.

Drtooth 06-10-2008 10:59 AM

I'd really perfer ALL CGI. And I really think Sarah Michelle Gellar was better as April when you DIDN'T see her act. I'm no Buffy fan, and I REALLY had a problem with her Daphne in the Scooby Movies (Hated their version of Fred too, but Velma and Shaggy were dead on). I mean, if you can do it right, fine... a hybrid's okay. But for my money, if you want to make a partially CGI film, you might as well make it all CGI. It's cheaper to do, and it doesn't seem phoney. None of these hybrid films really had the same feel as Roger Rabbit (the most popular hybrid film of all time, just using 2-D cartoons instead), and you can tell they're just talking to tennis balls on strings, or cardboard cutouts.

I would LOVE to see something with actual martial arts stuntmen talking to the characters, and having a CGI rotoscope pasted onto their movements (not motion capture... I mean, they'd actually be standing there with the actors, interacting with them).

But hey, as long as Disney doesn't get it, and make the turtles real turtles with CGI superimposed mouths.... Seriously, that possibility had me waking up screaming since Underdog came out.

Extreme_Enigma 06-10-2008 11:15 AM

Now THIS is what I'm talking about! It should be a hybrid movie with most of it live action and the turtles are cgi. That would be Great!... No wait, AWESOME! The bad news is that they might not make a sequel. But this is very interesting!!! :cry: :):) YYYYEEEESSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ToTheNines 06-10-2008 11:30 AM

Sorry but a hybrid won't be good. I don't mind it for certain random creatures in a movie, but this movie is obviously gonna star the Turtles. Also, not all hybrid movies look that bad, but 1. this is gonna be a kid's movie, so they won't spend that much money/time on it and 2. Why? I mean the first 2 movies looked pretty damn good in the early 90's... animatronics have got to be atleast a little better by now.

Evilsherbear 06-10-2008 11:53 AM

Whenever I think of CGI/live action I think of the Garfield movie. I don't want the turtles to end up like that. You'd have to do the CGI almost perfect to make it believable. Most of us are used to seeing CG in movies, and can spot even good CG right away (I know I do anyway). The movie would have to really pull you in with a good story and great acting on the live action people's part to get away with it.

turtle142 06-10-2008 12:10 PM

I'm not even worried about the whole will the cgi look bad thing, I'm just excited about the idea of "realistic" looking turtles again, after TMNT, which don't get me wrong, looked fine, I'd much rather see more realistic less gimpy turtles, I absolutely hope IMAGI doesn't get the job so THIS project can go through instead. Great news.

Kendamu 06-10-2008 12:52 PM

I wouldn't mind a hybrid movie at all as long as "it's done right."

Evilsherbear 06-10-2008 02:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 614991)
I wouldn't mind a hybrid movie at all as long as "it's done right."

If its done right, it'd be awesome. It just seems that to do it right, you'd have to put a LOT of time and money into it. I just don't know if studios are really willing to risk it, when doing a straight up CGI movie again would be a sure thing.

CyberCubed 06-10-2008 02:08 PM

I'm just glad that TMNT 5 isn't so dead like "you-know-who" keeps saying.

Good news.

Raph's Girl 06-10-2008 02:14 PM

Im not so sure about SMG playing April live action. It was ok for the animated but I would just think it was Buffy or Daphne Blake *lol* I'd have to see footage to see tho.

Chris Evans on the other hand. People will wonder if it's a crossover with Fantastic Four. Well some might... I think he'd be a good Casey. He's got the right look for it. Also helps that he's hot. *G*

ToTheNines 06-10-2008 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raph's Girl (Post 615003)
Chris Evans on the other hand. People will wonder if it's a crossover with Fantastic Four. Well some might... I think he'd be a good Casey. He's got the right look for it. Also helps that he's hot. *G*

yeah I know, I thought that Resuce Dawn was the sequel to Batman Begins because Christian Bale was in it.

Dragon Turtle 06-10-2008 02:21 PM

Unless they throw a boatload of money into the production of a "hybrid" movie, I say nay to the idea, the biggest problem with cgi turtles/live action humans is that they need interact with real actors for fight/action scenes, which is going to be both difficult and expensive to pull off right, especially if you try something similar to the mocap/cgi characters from "Pirates of the Caribbean".

ToTheNines 06-10-2008 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 615006)
Unless they throw a boatload of money into the production of a "hybrid" movie, I say nay to the idea, the biggest problem with cgi turtles/live action humans is that they need interact with real actors for fight/action scenes, which is going to be both difficult and expensive to pull off right, especially if you try something similar to the mocap/cgi characters from "Pirates of the Caribbean".

That would work, I thought Davy Jones looked tight as hell.

gobo 06-10-2008 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evilsherbear (Post 614999)
If its done right, it'd be awesome. It just seems that to do it right, you'd have to put a LOT of time and money into it.

Exactly what I'm thinking. And, what happened the last time they "put a LOT of time and money into" making a TMNT movie? 'Niller Ice and a movie ending that was so rushed that it was lame (Shredder being ejected from the club by an amp and Super Shredder being killed after just a few seconds). But, admittedly, I do think it's cool that one of the two songs Mr. Van Winkle ever did was for the Turtles. ^_^

thebrownranger 06-10-2008 05:50 PM

Hehehe I remember Kevin Eastman telling me at NYCC '08 about cg turtles and live action for the sequel :P I hope Imagi doesn't do the sequel. Another director would be nice as well.

Spitfire 06-10-2008 11:00 PM

With the budget they will have it's going to look like crap. Whatever they want to do we will see how it turns out. CGI annoys me.

Jelly Bean 06-11-2008 12:28 AM

I think I would like this idea with live action and CGI. Let's be posetive for once.

Buslady 06-11-2008 07:44 AM

im leery about a hybrid movie. the biggest fear with that would be the fact that if it's not done right you disconnect from the turtles. I seriously doubt Pete would allow that to happen tho! It'd be either they look right or scrap it. The way tech is today it could probably be done. But for the live performers, how convincing can they be standing next to a guy in a green suit? (a walking green screen)

I'd like to see, know I wont get it, live action all around.

Drtooth 06-11-2008 09:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebrownranger (Post 615039)
I hope Imagi doesn't do the sequel. Another director would be nice as well.

I still wish Imagi had the same management it always had. Kevin Munroe (sp?) left Gatchaman in a huff (another story of the studio effin' up the script for an imaginary audience of slow witted children). Then I would be all in for Imagi. I think the animation for TMNT was pretty good. Not quite pixar, but at least the humans weren't overly realistic and awkward looking like they are in Shrek.

I still think the next one should be all CGI with the same (or similar) character designs. I mean, TMNT didn't take a huge budget to produce, and dispite not being #1 in theaters all month (no thanks to Disney's film) it made the budget back and then some.

So, we'd either have an expensive to produce hybrid that won't make back it's budget, or a low budget that has the turtles pasted in, looking like a local furnature commercial.

Evilsherbear 06-11-2008 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jelly Bean (Post 615119)
I think I would like this idea with live action and CGI. Let's be posetive for once.

It's kind of hard to be positive when the last live action/CG people remember is either Garfield or the re-release of the original Star Wars movies. "Who Framed Roger Rabbit?" was great live action/animation but only worked BECAUSE we knew that the characters were cartoons, not "real" like the live action actors.

thebrownranger 06-11-2008 04:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drtooth (Post 615172)
I think the animation for TMNT was pretty good. Not quite pixar, but at least the humans weren't overly realistic and awkward looking like they are in Shrek.

The cg humans in shrek looked awesome compared to the deformed humans in tmnt. CGI should be about realism.

Spike Spiegel 06-11-2008 05:13 PM

The only hybrid I would possibly want is an old school human/puppet one like the original movies. I would be able to stand a CGI hybrid only if the CGI actually looked right.

Drtooth 06-11-2008 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thebrownranger (Post 615251)
The cg humans in shrek looked awesome compared to the deformed humans in tmnt. CGI should be about realism.

No, it shouldn't. No form of animation should be soley about looking real. If you want real, you might as well do live action. I feel that stylization is the key when handelling humans. Otherwise, you get ugly things that look so realistic, they're unrealistic.

personally, I liked the Humans better in Bee Movie and Over the Hedge (when we're talking Dreamworks), and Incredibles.

Canadian Turtle 06-11-2008 07:04 PM

Well, I like the idea of a Hybrid. We should think of flicks like Lord of the Rings or Hellboy as examples.

My question is, why do we all seem to suggest that this movie is going to be a HUGE risk and they will never have any money??? Is TMNT not just as huge if not WAY huger than some of the comic book movies out there are? As long as they treat it like a comic book movie for a wider audience.

So in other words if Peter Jackson or Del Toro did the movie we would be OK!!

Dragon Turtle 06-11-2008 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canadian Turtle (Post 615277)
Well, I like the idea of a Hybrid. We should think of flicks like Lord of the Rings or Hellboy as examples.

If a hybrid TMNT movie can get a LotR budget, and Weta or ILM to do the CGI work, then make it happen.


Quote:

My question is, why do we all seem to suggest that this movie is going to be a HUGE risk and they will never have any money??? Is TMNT not just as huge if not WAY huger than some of the comic book movies out there are? As long as they treat it like a comic book movie for a wider audience.
I believe TMNT has already proven its worth, especially if they are considering a more expensive Hybrid movie. "Alvin and the Chipmunks" cost 60 million to produce, and animating four human sized turtles is probably more costly then three small rodents.

And all of sudden TMNT's performance looks even better in the wake of Speed Racer's colossal failure.

ToTheNines 06-11-2008 10:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canadian Turtle (Post 615277)
My question is, why do we all seem to suggest that this movie is going to be a HUGE risk and they will never have any money??? Is TMNT not just as huge if not WAY huger than some of the comic book movies out there are? As long as they treat it like a comic book movie for a wider audience.

As a Turtle fan, you should know the franchise dosen't get the respect it deserves.

Andrew NDB 06-11-2008 11:23 PM

Seems like very sound hopes by Laird to me.

They are, however, only hopes. They still have to find a studio willing to plunk down the cash to make such a thing.

tilallr1 06-12-2008 09:51 AM

I'm sorry, but without a serious budget (Which they are never going to get), this will never be done well. They should stick to CGI (which in my opinion was beautiful by the way) and be done with it. They could make 10 movies for the same cost of 1 hybrid version. Plus TMNT started as a comic (animated) story and should remain that way. I have always prefered animated when dealing with TMNT.

If they do plan to make a hybrid I want them to reboot the franchise, with a darker, Mirage comics accurate tone to the origins of the Turtles. Rated PG-14 (AA) at the very least.

TerranigmaFreak 06-12-2008 04:37 PM

Live action CGI combo was meant for TMNT.

sdp 06-13-2008 10:53 AM

I loved the style and designs of the imagi movie and i'm sad that its probably won't get a sequel but a live action/cgi movie more than makes up for it.

Vincent 06-13-2008 01:39 PM

Well, as long as Michael Bay doesn't direct it...

The best thing that could happen would be if Joss Whedon or Guillermo del Toro (who are both great at the sci-fi-fantasy-action-dramedy genre) would write and direct it, but it doesn't seem like the kind of thing that could happen.

ETA: The third best thing that could happen was if I wrote it. But, you know...not gonna happen, that either.

Sage Ninja 06-14-2008 02:49 PM

I think this is good news I would really love to see live action people. It could have the same feel of realism as the first live action movie if it had actual actors in it instead of it all cgi animation. And other movies that have been of the CGi'/live action hybrid vareity have been pulled off nicely so I don't see why this couldn't eighther. And despite the cgi turtles I think they could pull it off. the only part I would be worried about is the fight scens between actual actors and CGI turtles. But one thing that I think would be a pus is that if it's PG rated it could have pg rated standads of a live action film rather than an animated one.

Drtooth 06-14-2008 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vincent (Post 615605)
Well, as long as Michael Bay doesn't direct it...


Feh. Michael Bay NOTHING. As long as Davis Media (or is it Davis films) stays the shell away from it, we're sitting pretty.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.