![]() |
What would be your ideal TMNT movie? (style)
Not talking about story or what universe it should approximate, strictly curious whether you'd prefer a new movie to be...
1) 100% live-action: Actors in suits, animatronics, the whole 9 yards. 2) Live-action with CGI assists: Kind of like... Babe. Actors in suits with some animatronics, but CGI assists to do things like the eyes and mouth movements/lip-synching, or even all-CGI Turtles in quick-cut heavy action scenes. 3) Hybrid live-action CGI: 100% CGI Turtles within a live-action movie. 4) 100% CGI: 100% CGI Turtles within a CGI movie. 5) Animated: A movie picture cartoon. |
I'm gona have to go with "Live-action with CGI assists". Just like Hellboy, it worked amazing for those films turtles needs the same treatment.
Obviously in a dream world I'd also love the film to be PG-13, not R because it wouldn't appeal to enough audiences and I think turtles would do well to be in the average comic movie view for the public eye. Batman has a great dark and gritty story while managing to still be a PG-13 film I think turtles would do well with the same. |
I would prefer a traditional animated movie. I'm getting tired of all those 100% CGI movies. Too much is too much.
|
Traditionally animated. I don't generally like anime, but I could dig a TMNT anime based on the comics.
|
Quote:
Theatrical film-wise, though, ideally I'm all about a PG-13 live-action take with CGI-assists... but I'd certainly be willing to settle on a hybrid (CGI Turtles in a live-action setting) take as a second pick as long as the Turtles don't seem jarringly out of place in the live-action. |
Depending on the creative teams involved and the resources allocated, all the different types of styles could do an equally good job in telling a good story, as well as delivering impressive visuals.
But being an huge animation fan, I would choose 100% CGI (even though deep down I'm bigger fan of the look of traditional 2D). CGI is especially good for action movies. With CGI you don't have to worry about being restricted to a few movie sound stages. A director could get any shot he wanted, from any angle at any distance, shots that would be too difficult or impossible to do in live action. Every combatant could have the skills of the best martial artists, and could be pushed further and harder then any living actor, especially with weapon fighting, the action itself could be pushed further before hitting eye-rolling territory. No matter how good the effects are in a movie, I sometimes find myself getting pulled out of a movie by an obvious CGI effect or CGI double. Whether if it was due too the lack of time and funding, the PG rating, or the absence of a veteran fight/action choreographer, TMNT didn’t take full advantage of its medium, in my opinion. 2D movies have many of the same benefits as 3D movies, only with a bit less freedom, I would love to see a 3D move emulate the style and look of 2D art, not every CGI movie needs have the same art direction of a Pixar movie. |
Animation
I prefer the same animation like the 1987 cartoon (I like the 2003 cartoon too when it come to stories, but not animation), an animated movie. The first TMNT movies are better than the 2007 CGI movie when it come to stories, but live action is a little bit lame when it comes to a film about talking turtles (It works better in a film about just an ordinary day in Bulgaria in 1989 or something without any science fiction or fantasy involved).
|
I voted for animation. We all had the taste of the live-action three times in a row and a CGI version. Animation sounds good specially when it's the version that drew the most millions of Turtles enthusiasts worldwide.
:D |
The live action is my favorite part of TMNT (the movies, the series) but I think CGI turtles in a live action movie could be great. I hope that's what the next movie is like.
|
I'd like to see a TMNT film done in the style of Beowulf/Polar Express. Using live actors in MoCap suits and then being done over CGI-style. It would be like seeing a live action film, but with more truer-to-format imagery.
|
Tell you what, I'd like to see an animated movie done in black and white. Cartoon animation that is. Although now that you mention it, a Beowulf style might be pretty bad ass.
|
ill go with the live action with cgi assist the new hulk movie looked good and if the turtles can pull off something like that i would deff be happy
|
Quote:
|
Mixes
Quote:
|
We've seen three live action movies and one cgi movie. I think it's time for a fully 2d animated flick. There are a lot of talented artists out there who I 'm pretty sure are itching for a chance like this. I wouldn't want it to be done in Anime because although I don't hate all anime (I hate some just as well as some American animation) I want the characters to be semi stylized but in a different manner ya' know? Kind of like the new toon, everybody has easily distinguishable features. Plus animated flicks usually have more liberty than live action ones when it comes to violence without being considered R or pg-13. Hell it could be kinda like Superman Doomsday just in theatres not straight to dvd.
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
I voted for 100% CGI
|
Black and white
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I didn't say I wanted a pg nor did I say pg-13. Although I do think pg-13 is the way to go I do believe a decent movie can be made in pg. As for Superman:Doomsay I thought it was pg-13 but I wasn't sure. |
Black and white movies
Quote:
|
I say either Live action with CGI assists (provided they can get good animatronics/prosthetics- no repeat of TMNT 3) ot completely animated. Maybe completely CGI... but definitely a classic animation style (just.. well, with a better studio and animation style than the past cartoons).
Realistically, we'd either see a hybrid or a complete CGI... but I think it's time for something much different than that to grab people's attention. |
Would Krang and the Utroms work in 100 % live action?
Would Krang and the Utroms work in 100 % live action? (I know an Utrom was planned for the second film)
|
(Thanks for clarifying in the OP, as "animation" actually applies to both traditional and CG methods.)
I would really love to see a traditionally animated film, myself. PG or PG13 would be fine, so long as the violence wasn't too subdued. I'm not interested in seeing Turtles go all the way to R, but some mild language and some blood here and there would be a nice touch. After all, with good writing and respectful treatment it'd be entirely possible to get a more serious, darker take on the concept without having to push the rating. (I will also note here that I really do think that it's possible to have an engaging story that will play well for adults but still be OK for kids to watch... maybe not your skittish 5-year-old, but kids under 12, certainly. It's definitely a hard balance to hit, and the last movie failed at it, but a good director could do it.) Also, with a 2D film there is so much that could be done with style and design to enhance the story. The 2k3 series had some decent stuff going there, but with a film budget the design could be improved upon and the animation could be absolutely stellar. All-CGI would be my second choice. Being animation, the director would still have complete control over everything, and you could still have a great visual style going on (see: Kung Fu Panda). I think animation in general opens up more possibilities and helps with suspension of disbelief (which is the only thing that I think would hold another live-action rendition back... the suits would have to be REALLY good or I'd be too distracted by their lack of believability when put in a scene next to real people). But in any movie treatment, I think I'd have to see some stronger and more clever writing (especially when the characters are supposed to be cracking funny jokes) for it to be enjoyable as I'd like. |
Quote:
|
But they planned an Utrom for the second film?
Quote:
|
I've always enjoyed the TMNT in animated forms but then I'm a cartoon geek.
|
Me too. I love cartoons.
Quote:
|
It could work...
Quote:
And watching giant turtles run around NYC fighting masked ninjas, utroms, and triceratons is supposed to feel how real again? |
I know
Quote:
|
Yeah, I know. Just so long as it's gritty and "real." That's really all I ask.
Now that I think about it, I wouldn't mind seeing a DTV turtles movie like Animatrix or Gotham Knight. Multiple stories, multiple styles, different peoples takes on who they think the turtles are. I'd pay a dollar to see that. Or like, $30. Damn! Now I REALLY want one to be done! |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Basically like some kids sitting around telling different stories about their encounters or what they've heard of the TMNT. We see, like, 3 or 4 mini-stories, each one depicting a different take on TMNT. One could be very dark, very brutal and urban and early Mirage-esque, another very colorful and child-like akin to the original cartoon, another one done sort of in-between and in CGI or something. |
Quote:
But, going along with that whole idea, I'd like to see: 1) Mirage 2) Old Toon (with Red Sky) 3) Image 4) Next Mutation 5) Some sort of "actual encounter" that takes place in present time during the movie that sort of blends several of those qualities together into something resembling the Turtles from the first movie. |
Archie
Quote:
|
i'm reeeeallly dreaming ...I wouldnt mind seeing turtles designed by bess to be either full CGI and more realistic, no stretch & skew, realistic movement, expression and such. And definately her Oroku Saki, he is amazing looking.
I can dream..I know it'll never ever happen! more realistically, model the next freaking movie after TMNT1 cos that just had it right. CGI assist w/ animatronics can work if handled well too. I'd like to see them portrayed a little older, maybe where they are today in their late 30s, dump the "teenage" from the titel, just make it 'Ninja turtles'...they do grow up eventually. And in no way, get rid of BUffy as April...ugh.I didnt care for matchstick playing case either! blah! yeah i know my typing sucks today |
Splinter
Quote:
|
Quote:
Splinter IS dead tho, they're in their late 30s. It's all part of nature. Death is apart of life...blahblahblah.... |
Splinter's death
Quote:
|
Quote:
Good 'ole vengeance. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:08 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.