![]() |
Tales of the TMNT Scrap Heap...
If anyone's into it, I just got word from Dan "The Man" Berger that my (so far) final bought story for Tales has been, um... flushed.
If anyone would like to read what would have happened, I just put the 6-page script to "The Path of the Laugh" up on my in-progress archive blog at: http://willtupper.wordpress.com/2008...nt-scrap-heap/ Sorry to all the folks who think Mikey's gotten the "story shaft" over the years (I'm a longtime reader, first time poster, here on the 'drome). Murph and I tried. We really did (darn space constraints!). Take Good Care, Will Tupper PS - Hello to friends Ross, Tristan, Andrew, Rose, Tokka, Michele... and anyone else I might have forgot :). |
I love it!! So sorry to hear we won't be seeing it in the comic shops any time soon. :tsad:
|
Welcome to the new era of Tales of the TMNT...
|
bummer that looked like a great little short too. what's this about a new era?
|
Quote:
|
ah, i see what you mean now!
|
@Evenstar227:
Thanks! I'm bummed of what's become of it (nada), but I'm glad you got a kick out of it, all the same. @JakeBlack: Thanks for the welcome. "So it goes," you know? It is what it is... Still looking forward to your and Murph's work on the TMNT source book, though. @trustno1: I've heard that the "new era" Jake mentioned involves a game of Scrabble. And a pinata. Wish I could tell you more, but that's unfortunately all I know... :D @Awesome Forum Moderator (whomever you are): Thank you for making me "Official TMNT Staff / Cast." Highlight of my night :). |
Quote:
But like you said, it is what it is. I hope the Sourcebook turns out well! It will be my final farewell to the TMNT. Incidentally, for those who have asked, I won't be posting my rejected pitches. It was a fun ride with an unfortunate end--for many of us if Mirage ends up not publishing in 2010, which, as I understand it at this point, is a may or may not situation. So, enjoy the plots that Will, Ross, and the others post. They will, very possibly, be the last TMNT content these guys generate, too... |
Yeah, I appreciate the work of all the guest writers/artists that did Tales. At least you guys were lucky enough to get a few issues published, its something others could have only dreamed about.
All in all it is sad, but what can you do. |
Quote:
|
Hey Will!
Bummed this isn't seeing print... I think it's a great spotlight on Mike and sums him up perfectly. I'm with you, I don't think Mike's ever really been given a chance to shine as a character the way Leo and Raph have. We get a lot of little insights into Don's perspectives on things which kind of brings him on par with Raph and Leo in terms of development, but Mike seems to be the reverse of his televisual self (in terms of spotlighting and developing anyway). Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
The possibility of Tales coming to an end has been looming for a while now Goongasnootch. I don't think 2009 was even totally definite until just after NYCC this year. The big thing is that Tales, when compared to a number of other books out there, it's not a huge seller. It does okay, but it's already well known amongst the fanbase that these comics are being put out at a loss every now and then. I think the average print run for tales is 3500 to 4000, so it's not huge. I check the sales estimates each month to see what's doing business and it's rare that TMNT show up, and if they do manage to crack the 300 top sellers it rarely manages to stray too far from the mid 200's.
The way things seem to go now is that Dan concentrates on what he knows is happening. As soon as 2009 was good to go, everything started rolling, and I'm pretty sure that as of the start of this week, everything for next year (regarding Publishing at least) is locked in and ready to go. I'm guessing that we'll know more about 2010 around this time next year. |
They could just print less copies to save money.
|
Or get more of these newer artists to keep drawing the series.
They should seriously take a look at the sales number for each issue. |
Quote:
|
That blows, Will. Would've been fun to read all of your backups together as kind of a "Challenges," Volume 2.
Yes, everything seems locked for 2010. Dan was nice enough to allow me to officially pitch an issue but now I've received word that it didn't make the cut. |
Quote:
I just wanna read comics... |
Quote:
|
The one thing I've been recommending to Ninja Turtles fans is to send mail to Mirage (and addressing it to Peter Laird might help) and let them know if you enjoy Tales. If you want it to keep going, they've got to know readers care about it.
And adding onto that point, give them specifics on what you would like to see. What content? What artists? You might not get what you want, but it's fans only chance of getting it. Heck, if you want more TMNT Adventures then tell them that. (Great story Will, as I've said on your blog.) |
Quote:
|
I think the best way to keep Tales of the TMNT coming (at least in the form it's been) is to go into your local comic book stores and request they carry it. Bug them about it. Ask them about it again and again, until they at least put a couple copies on the stand every month. Introduce the comic to your friends. Get the word out there any way you can.
Telling Peter over and over again you really, really like the book might make him feel a little bit better about continuously eating the publication losses... but if the book just keeps landing in the red zone month after month, that good will and hand-holding is probably really only going to go so far. And that's some good news about Tristan. |
Quote:
While it's great having such a passionate group of fans loyal to the books, the simple truth is that that will only carry the book so far. If you're a part of other comic forums, post about Turtles over in their free range boards, get people's awareness levels up! Quote:
Quote:
|
Too bad Mirage doesn't have some sort of yearly subscritpion service. It would make it a lot easier for me to get the book regularly.
|
Quote:
|
Well that's good, now you've blown it for everyone. Nice job. First you blew the Scrabble mystery, and now this. :P
|
Quote:
Don't get me wrong: I love the book. I've e-mailed Dan and let him know and offered as much support in dollars as I can afford. But Laird's brick-wall attitude is only ensuring that Tales will never see a profit. Until he gets over his Lawson fixation, speeds up trades of classic TMNT comics or finally concedes to offering TMNT graphic novels through book stores...the money is just going to keep going down the drain. Unfortunately, these are all things Laird has vowed never to budge on. So there ya go. |
Quote:
And no I'm not bashing lawson his art is ok for what it is but if they seriously want to get the series moving and selling they need to do a bit better.:ohwell: |
Quote:
There are SO many issues with Mirage and comics in general that there's no easy fix. Just today Newsarama had this article up. The US economy, the comics industry in general, plus the previously mentioned politics at Mirage have all combined to make Tales a tough call for anyone to predict. |
Quote:
I just think that if more people knew about new Turtles comics that there'd be more people buying them. I think rebuilding a fanbase is a possibility, it's just a matter of spreading the word, and making the older books more accessible to new readers. |
Dr. Spengler: I agree to a point about Peter and criticisms (and while "you don't have to buy the comic" sounds harsh, he has a point), but not entirely when it comes to suggestions. His ideas and preferences come first, but so long as suggestions don't conflict with his direction he seriously considers them. If you remember way back when, one of the reasons he started vol. 4 was because of a couple of fans expressing to him how much the turtles meant to them. He does connect with fans sometimes.
Regarding Tales and sales and distribution, Andrew and Trist are absolutely right - on the business end. But since the start of vol 4 and the new Tales Mirage Publishing hasn't been about business. The comics are Mirage's least profitable enterprise, kept alive by Pete so he and the guys can have fun. High sales might be incentive for him to stop and say, "people must enjoy Tales, I guess we should keep it going," but maybe not. I think Pete really does want artistic appreciation for his work and the turtles in general to make this seem worthwhile, otherwise why would he be doing vol. 4 and Tales in the first place? It sure ain't for the money. Depending on how much you care, you can certainly get friends into Tales or get it onto more shelves. That's great too. But you know what? At the end of the day, Pete is going to be publishing X Ninja Turtles comic book based on whether readers are making him feel positive about it. The new model for vol. 4 goes to show that he'll even do something outside Diamond distributing if he thinks it's worthwhile. High sales would of course let him know people are into the work, but human contact is what makes an artist feel good. |
I think I've ranted on this topic more than a few times, but it's kind of fun so why not again...
Oh Mirage, how I love you and yet how I get so annoyed by you. Here is how I see Tales at the moment... I really don't see much effort being made to make it into a worthy comic book. I'm not saying I don't think everyone's putting in their best effort, I mostly do - and completely believe that with our present writer pals here - but the overall series is wandering lost and confused with no real sense of direction. I don't know if I can say this well without someone being offended, so please understand that's not the intention, but with so many issues it feels more like the comic was produced for the sole purpose of getting paid rather than it feels like some actual attempt was made to produce a worthwhile comic book. (My biggest frustration in this regard is for an upcoming book that I don't think any present parties have a hand in, so fear not.) Back when Mirage and the TMNT were in their heyday, the people writing and drawing it were doing it out of passion for the characters, friendship, and the awesome bonus was that they got paid for doing that. That atmosphere in Mirage gave us not just a lot of stories that we all still hold dear (for example, the whole of Tales volume 1), but it also worked to shape the whole of the Mirage universe into what it is today. Unfortunately, that atmosphere at Mirage is now completely gone. The company has gone from being the greatest collaboration in independent comics to being nothing more than a dictatorship run by Peter Laird. (Hi Pete - Yes, you are a dictator and it's not cool.) No one is inspired to even try their best and some will outright tell you that they're not really trying. As frustrated as I am that this is affecting Tales, I really can't blame them. Hell, I'd do the exact same thing if I were them. I really think Tales needs to be reinvented. It needs to be something fresh and new. It needs to reintroduce itself to the comics market. I'd like to see writer/artist collaborations that last for more than one issue (in a row). Honestly, I would love to take a stab at being in charge of the book. I don't want to write it, I don't want to draw it, but I would love to be able to shape it into something that actually gets noticed on comic shelves. All of the potential is there for it to be successful; someone just needs to be allowed to be able to make it into that. As of right now Mirage itself isn't allowing the book to be successful. So long as that is the case, I have no pity for them and however much money they may be losing on the book. |
I'm pretty sure Tales 36 had to have sold better than at least half of the rest of the series. That sucker was promoted by just about every comic site and even some that were not solely devoted to comics, such as IGN. If my guess is false, then there is no justice.
Plus the fact that Jake Black do two issues in a row means they must think he's doing SOMETHING right. The whole "in-house only in 2009!" thing is mind-boggling. My brain hurts. |
Quote:
Sorry if I left any out, but as much as I know Lawson says he's going to take every job he can I'd really like to see these other guys for a bit. In house and they aren't even taking advantage of the fact that they have some really amazing artists whos works should be hanging in friggin' art galleries they're so good. I just don't get it, hell I'd kill for Peter to come back and draw a bit also. |
I love Dan, but I think the person in charge of the book needs to work in that position as their full-time job. We all know that Dan keeps busy enough doing the Web site stuff. And before him Murphy's time working on the book was minimal compared to all of his other responsibilities. If one person worked on it full-time, each book could get the proper promotion it needs.
The in-house rule isn't particularly mind-boggling to me - it actually makes perfect sense because Mirage is ensuring that all of the people who work in the physical Mirage building receive as much pay as possible over the course of the year. Is it best for the book in the long run? No, it's not. But that's how Mirage is going to continue to operate for the foreseeable future. As it stands, Peter's too cheap hire new employees/properly invest in anything. But hey, why should he care about making money on a comic book when he can continue to rake in the money for selling boys' pajamas while he rides around on his motorcycles every day? And so long as that's the case, I don't want to hear any whining about the comic not making money. |
Quote:
And just to clarify, it's not "in-house only in 2009." If it were, Tristan wouldn't have gotten any issues because he's a freelancer, not in-house. Mirage just changed the way freelancers could pitch, and how they scheduled the books' creative teams this year (as opposed to years past) in the editorial switch from Murphy to Dan. Consequently Ross, Will, Andrew, and I all had our stuff rejected. (I'm not saying it would have been accepted in the old regime, but the possibilities/opportunities would have been drastically different...) In 2008, there was an injunction for in-house only, but those freelancers like me who were published this year found ways around the system (like Peter asking for a pitch for a villain named The Decider...see jakeblack.com for the whole story...) I do appreciate the thought that I might have been doing something right. I wish I were doing the right thing right enough to get more work on the title this coming year. But, sadly, it's not meant to be--and like I said before, I don't think I will be doing any more TMNT projects after I finish the source book with Murph. |
The primary concern with Tales and numbers ultimately comes down to Diamond. A book has to be able to perform at a certain level and maintain those sales figures for Diamond to give it the distribution. As we've seen with TMNT, Mirage have other means of getting the Turtles out there, and Ross is spot on with his assessment of things. Pete keeps the comics going because they're fun to do and to read, not because they make money. I think everyone knows that, like Star Wars, the big money for the TMNT is in the licensing.
Jake is right about the sales figures too. I'm glad it sold as well as it did (another couple of hundred sales and it would've been a sell-out), as it beat out Wolverine and a few other surprises for that month of sales. Somewhat surprisingly, the movie adaptation comics and prequels were some of the best selling TMNT books in a long time too! I don't consider myself any better than any of the other writers to have gone through Mirage. I've loved everything Jake, Ross and Will have all brought to the table. My stories were chosen for 2009 for reasons I'm not totally aware of either. I've experienced a substantial amount of rejection from Mirage in the past, and Tales #50 would not have happened had a pitch of mine not shared a number of similarities to a story Ryan pitched. If I recall, both our initial pitches were rejected, but together we came up with something different. I'm 100% sure that I wouldn't have had anything published by Mirage this year had it not been for Ryan, and I'll never be able to thank him enough, and we've both had a LOT of fun on this story. I really do owe a lot to Eric Talbot too, who had suggested I script the short story that appeared in #48 after I got a chance to meet them all at NYCC. After that story was done I was told a little while after that there were a couple of spaces open for freelance positions in the Tales schedule, and I pitched for them, like anyone would. It may have come down to the timing of it all really, and straight forward luck. Previously, nothing I'd pitched involving the Foot or anything remotely similar to #36 had made it through, and to be honest I didn't expect any of my pitches to make it through, given the subject matter (the Foot, gang violence, organised crime). I didn't change my approach to pitching or anything like that, I just pitched what I thought were stories people would want to read and what I would want to write. Same as I always had. I was just fortunate that my stories were chosen. |
22
Quote:
|
666
Quote:
.. ♦ ♦ .. like Rose sez.. there is an 'atmosphere' that is gone, i guess i agree with that. I see it more too as a schizophrenia in the company. There is this seeming need to hold onto Mirage's indy comic roots while at the same time managing one of the biggest franchises on the planet. While not THE BIGGEST .. it's pretty damm huge. Dunno .. maybe there are many good, respectable, understandable things to be said about decisions being made. Can't say 100 % for certain. I just hope more bad ones aren't made, especially with 2009 looming. Mirage doesn't want to shoot itself in the foot with the biggest anniversary they've ever had coming up here. I really hope they are careful and that they don't f7ck it up. And it appears from what i am hearing from different sources that some screwy decisions & confusing have already been made. Coming from someone who's mind is always seeking logic, for this existence in general doesn't always make sense .. within' SCHIZOPHRENIA ..there is a duplicity, triplicity, and so on. An order of madness that doesn't always lead to the most appropriate and in fact sometimes downright absurd decision making ( sure i'm fine to talk ). God i just hope some this madness can be gotten ahold of and quashed relatively & soon. I'd hate to see things totally crash and burn to disaster. While many of these things are so much bigger than me .. i can see frightening things happening with perhaps not the franchise as a whole, but at least in the smaller factions.. like the comics. Which is honestly..while maybe not the biggest part of TMNT .. most assuredly it is at heart of it. But what does a 'schizophrenic' know ?? Hope i'm making sense. >v< |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:24 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.