The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Bishop or Shredder (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=25098)

godzod 09-10-2008 11:58 PM

Bishop or Shredder
 
In the next film who would you rather have as the next antagonist.

The Stryker 09-11-2008 03:17 AM

Well I would want a villain that wouldn't bore me to tears.

I vote Shredder.

funatic 09-11-2008 04:51 AM

We already saw bishop in the last 3 Matrix films, cleverly 'disguised' as Agent Smith... so my vote is for the Shred Head :shredder:

godzod 09-11-2008 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stryker (Post 633255)
Well I would want a villain that wouldn't bore me to tears.

I vote Shredder.

So i guess you prefer one dimensional villain like the Shredder.:roll:

Jester 09-11-2008 01:48 PM

So is this a thread where we're given a choice, but there is oviously a "right" one? :roll:



I like the idea of Bishop, the plot of the movie being a goverment official tracking down the TMNT to study them, all based on rumors flying around New York. I mean if they tweaked Bishop it could work. Heck, I'd like both. I could see Saki using a Bishop-like character to "DESTROY THE TURTLES!"

FearlessLeader 09-11-2008 02:00 PM

I would be happy with either honestly.

(which is not a choice so I did not vote *laughs*)

I like Shredder for his "ultimate nemesis" vibe he has with the Turtles, plus I could be interested to see how they would present him in a modern (hopefully hybrid) film. And I don't see the Shredder as one dimensional either. As proven in the 4Kids cartoon many interesting and different things can be done with his character and still keep the Shredder spirit.

Bishop I actually ending up liking more then I thought I would when he was first introduced. I think I like his character because unlike Shredder Bishop sees himself as the "good guy". He is saving humanity from threats most people can't even dream of, hence he finds all of his actions justified. He reminds me a bit of Magneto from X-Men fandom in that way.

One thing I don't think I would like is Bishop and Shredder working together. Unless it really is just one using the other, but somehow they don't seem like that would make good allies.

Tinuvielsdreams 09-11-2008 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 633317)
So is this a thread where we're given a choice, but there is oviously a "right" one? :roll:



I like the idea of Bishop, the plot of the movie being a goverment official tracking down the TMNT to study them, all based on rumors flying around New York. I mean if they tweaked Bishop it could work. Heck, I'd like both. I could see Saki using a Bishop-like character to "DESTROY THE TURTLES!"

I just don't imagine a stand alone Bishop as villian movie I always imagine him as a secondary antagonist.
If Shredder used a Bishop-like character then I am betting it would get interesting. I don't see Bishop being so easily controlled by Shredder as some others are. He would go all rogue and the turtles would have to fight him and Shredder. It could be a cool what if scenerio

cup-mikey-gertha 09-11-2008 02:57 PM

Shredder. But it has to be a human Shredder and not an utrom or a paranormal version.

:)

DTBlack 09-20-2008 02:19 AM

I'm kind of tired of the fact that ever since The Incredible Hulk came out people won't shut up about reboots. TMNT was a breath of fresh air after the atrocity that was Turtles III, why would they reboot? They seem to have a good thing going, I want to see them run with it, not start from scratch.

syk_skillz 09-20-2008 08:03 AM

People talk about rebooting the franchise so it can go back to it's roots and be more like the first movie from 1990 and not be directly made as a kids movie.

thebrownranger 09-20-2008 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DTBlack (Post 635119)
I'm kind of tired of the fact that ever since The Incredible Hulk came out people won't shut up about reboots. TMNT was a breath of fresh air after the atrocity that was Turtles III, why would they reboot? They seem to have a good thing going, I want to see them run with it, not start from scratch.

That's what I've been kind of saying. What I mean is that they should start from after the first movie b/c that's the only storyline where a continuing story w/ secondary villains could happen. And yeah, Bishop would be a horrible idea for a turtles movie.

shuriken 09-20-2008 09:03 PM

I'd like Bishop. But I doubt many people( the non dromers and non hardcore fans) would know who he is so they'll be like WTF where's the Shredder?

KROW 09-21-2008 10:11 AM

Neither. Shredder's been done to death and Bishop is just filler.

blue_angel99 09-21-2008 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KROW (Post 635356)
Neither. Shredder's been done to death and Bishop is just filler.

I agree.

But if I had to choose between the two, Bishop.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-22-2008 09:23 AM

Shredder
 
Shredder. How many non-TMNT fans know who Bishop is?

SassyGal 09-22-2008 11:42 AM

Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinuvielsdreams (Post 633320)
I just don't imagine a stand alone Bishop as villian movie I always imagine him as a secondary antagonist.
If Shredder used a Bishop-like character then I am betting it would get interesting. I don't see Bishop being so easily controlled by Shredder as some others are. He would go all rogue and the turtles would have to fight him and Shredder. It could be a cool what if scenerio

I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-22-2008 01:14 PM

Next Mutation
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SassyGal (Post 635602)
Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.



I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

But he's alive in "Next Mutation", and Next Mutation is considered by some to follow the movies.

Wolf Ninja 09-22-2008 01:14 PM

I say Shredder, but not as an alien or robotic or something like that.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-22-2008 01:21 PM

Shredder
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolf Ninja (Post 635614)
I say Shredder, but not as an alien or robotic or something like that.

I hope so. I hope the TMNT creators leared something about the Utrom Shredder in the 2003 cartoon, and how many disliked him (even if they liked the show).

SassyGal 09-22-2008 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 635613)
But he's alive in "Next Mutation", and Next Mutation is considered by some to follow the movies.

Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-22-2008 04:16 PM

Next Mutation
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SassyGal (Post 635638)
Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

But the TMNT live in an abandoned subway station and that stuff.

Jester 09-22-2008 05:26 PM

Next Mutation is kinda loosly based on the movies, as some one said in another thread, much like Archie comics are loosly based on the OT.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 08:49 AM

2007
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SassyGal (Post 635638)
Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

There's some debate if even the 2007 movie follow the three original movies, or is an own TMNT version.

SassyGal 09-23-2008 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 635807)
There's some debate if even the 2007 movie follow the three original movies, or is an own TMNT version.

Either way, I always thought Shredder's "death" in Secret of the Ooze was lame and would like to see him come back for another movie.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 11:08 AM

Krang
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SassyGal (Post 635824)
Either way, I always thought Shredder's "death" in Secret of the Ooze was lame and would like to see him come back for another movie.

I recall that, and thought: "Bad guys in films always come back, in the next film he will probably team up with Krang". I was disappointed when it didn't happen.

Andrew NDB 09-23-2008 02:23 PM

Bishop or Shredder? I guess it's better than asking "Bebop or Krang?" but unless we're talking about a reboot (in which case Shredder is logically going to be involved), it's like asking me which side of the jaw I'd like to get punched.

Shredder if I had to choose, and though I agree enough time has passed to see Saki on the screen again, I don't have enough confidence in TPTB in bringing about not only his return/resurrection but his portrayal on screen properly. In a sequel.

And about NT:TNM, it's absolutely a continuation of the first three films. You can figure that out not only by the TMNT having the same lair as in TMNT II and III and Splinter's ear (the only universe he has a severed ear is the theatrical), but by plenty of press releases and Eastman's own interviews that confirm it. Though some of those interviews are a little head-scratching... I seem to remember Eastman talking about how the Turtles were older and grittier and meaner than in the movies, and the whole show would be so edgy and dark. I'm not sure what he was smoking at the time, but the chances are it was pretty potent stuff.

About TMNT 2007 we have Kevin Munroe's own press release about it, flat-out telling us TMNT 1 and 2 were in-canon and serving as "a loose history" (meaning, and he brought up the Superman Returns example, that the films happened, they just needn't be referenced the hell out of in the movie). Then we saw the movie and they actually snuck in artifacts from TMNT 3 in there, so it's a logical leap to then assume the "loose history" was actually extended to encompass all 3 movies, not just the first 2. And why not, really? Though shoddy production values, TMNT 3 doesn't exactly damage anything from TMNT 1 and 2.

So basically... you have the first three movies, and then you have two different continuations, neither of which agree with the other. So you can follow two different paths and end up at either TMNT 4 or NT:TNM as the final destination.

Continuity 1) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => NT:TNM

Continuity 2) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => TMNT 4

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 02:40 PM

Jester
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635891)
Bishop or Shredder? I guess it's better than asking "Bebop or Krang?" but unless we're talking about a reboot (in which case Shredder is logically going to be involved), it's like asking me which side of the jaw I'd like to get punched in.

Shredder if I had to choose, and though I agree enough time has passed to see Saki on the screen again, I don't have enough confidence in TPTB in bringing about not only his return/resurrection but his portrayal on screen properly. In a sequel.

And about NT:TNM, it's absolutely a continuation of the first three films. You can figure that out not only by the TMNT having the same lair as in TMNT II and III and Splinter's ear (the only universe he has a severed ear is the theatrical), but by plenty of press releases and Eastman's own interviews that confirm it. Though some of those interviews are a little head-scratching... I seem to remember Eastman talking about how the Turtles were older and grittier and meaner than in the movies, and the whole show would be so edgy and dark. I'm not sure what he was smoking at the time, but the chances are it was pretty potent stuff.

About TMNT 2007 we have Kevin Munroe's own press release about it, flat-out telling us TMNT 1 and 2 were in-canon and serving as "a loose history" (meaning, and he brought up the Superman Returns example, that the films happened, they just needn't be referenced the hell out of in the movie). Then we saw the movie and they actually snuck in artifacts from TMNT 3 in there, so it's a logical leap to then assume the "loose history" was actually extended to encompass all 3 movies, not just the first 2. And why not, really? Though shoddy production values, TMNT 3 doesn't exactly damage anything from TMNT 1 and 2.

So basically... you have the first three movies, and then you have two different continuations, neither of which agree with the other. So you can follow two different paths and end up at either TMNT 4 or NT:TNM as the final destination.

Continuity 1) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => NT:TNM

Continuity 2) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => TMNT 4

As Jester said, it's the same like the 1987 cartoon and the Archie comics have the same background before becoming two separate TMNT universes.

Andrew NDB 09-23-2008 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 635895)
As Jester said, it's the same like the 1987 cartoon and the Archie comics have the same background before becoming two separate TMNT universes.

That's not really comparing apples to apples at all.

While Archie began grounded in the Fred Wolf cartoon universe, after #5, introduced/reintroduced characters that ended up flying in the face/directly contradicting those same characters over in the Fred Wolf universe... it was made very, very clear that Archie was in its own universe and TPTB even made mention of it.

With NT:TNM, it was loudly voiced by TPTB as a continuation of the first three films. And like it or hate it, nothing in NT:TNM flew in the face of or contradicted events in TMNT 1-3. Rather the opposite.

Same story with TMNT 4. We were told flat out by the showrunner in the beginning that it was keeping at least the first two movies in-continuity. We get the movie and yes, nothing in it is really contradicted by the first three movies.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 02:54 PM

1987 cartoon
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635898)
That's not really comparing apples to apples at all.

While Archie began grounded in the Fred Wolf cartoon universe, after #5, introduced/reintroduced characters that ended up flying in the face/directly contradicting those same characters over in the Fred Wolf universe... it was made very, very clear that Archie was in its own universe and TPTB even made mention of it.

With NT:TNM, it was loudly voiced by TPTB as a continuation of the first three films. And like it or hate it, nothing in NT:TNM flew in the face of or contradicted events in TMNT 1-3. Rather the opposite.

Same story with TMNT 4. We were told flat out by the showrunner in the beginning that it was keeping at least the first two movies in-continuity. We get the movie and yes, nothing in it is really contradicted by the first three movies.

It looks correct, but why is Next Mutation sometimes said to follow the 1987 cartoon. Maybe this: http://www.ninjaturtles.com/cartoon/synopses.htm (it has been there for many years).

Andrew NDB 09-23-2008 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 635902)
It looks correct, but why is Next Mutation sometimes said to follow the 1987 cartoon.

Because tonally it's closest to it? Fans not thinking things through? Take your pick.

Quote:

Maybe this: http://www.ninjaturtles.com/cartoon/synopses.htm (it has been there for many years).
If I remember back to 1997, 1998, I think Dan was just listing up "TMNT on TV" when he was putting that onto the site. The 4Kids show wasn't even out when he did that. If it was, it'd probably be on that same listing, too.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 04:04 PM

1997, 1998
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635910)
Because tonally it's closest to it? Fans not thinking things through? Take your pick.



If I remember back to 1997, 1998, I think Dan was just listing up "TMNT on TV" when he was putting that onto the site. The 4Kids show wasn't even out when he did that. If it was, it'd probably be on that same listing, too.

I don't know how the site was back in those days.

Andrew NDB 09-23-2008 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 635918)
I don't know how the site was back in those days.

With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/199712101...jaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-23-2008 04:48 PM

Thank you
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635931)
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/199712101...jaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Thank you very match :), I think it's interesting to study how the Internet looked in the past and comapre it to our own time.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 09-23-2008 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by godzod (Post 633303)
So i guess you prefer one dimensional villain like the Shredder.:roll:

There is NOTHING one-dimensional about Oroku Saki/Ch'rell!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-24-2008 12:47 PM

Up to you
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SassyGal (Post 635602)
Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.



I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

To this day, it's still up to you if Shredder died or survived and swam over to UK and tried to replace John Major and Elizabeth II... :)

Shark_Blade 09-27-2008 12:32 PM

Shredder of course (and I want human Shred head).

Bishop = snore-fest.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-27-2008 01:17 PM

Krang
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shark_Blade (Post 636628)
Shredder of course (and I want human Shred head).

Bishop = snore-fest.

Do you want Krang too?

thebrownranger 09-27-2008 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635931)
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/199712101...jaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Holy crap! I must have forgot, but is that how the site originally looked back then in '97?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 09-27-2008 07:50 PM

Care
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 635931)
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/199712101...jaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

I don't think they thought much about it, back in 1997 surfing the Internet was still a sensation.

Shark_Blade 09-28-2008 07:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by J 1982 (Post 636639)
Do you want Krang too?

Nope. He can stay in the OT universe.

To me Shredder is an important character in TMNT. He's such an icon that whenever people mentioned the turtles they always relate to their arch enemy = The Shredder. Imagine telling them 'Bishop' their reaction probably be like 'Who is that?', 'Does he works for the church?' etc..


To not see the Shredder for two movies now (though we get gists of references to him) is truly upsetting for me :cry: and I keep on hoping that one day he will return in his true glory, being one of the badass villain of all time.:)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.