![]() |
To me, TMNT 2k3 ended with 'Enter the Dragons' Part II.
Not just animation style, obviously. But the tone was lost. While I liked Fast Forward and I am enjoying Back to the Sewer, the first 5 seasons were clearly the best Turtles animation we have got so far. I wish the DTV would be in the same type of animation as 2k3 and the same tone. That is what missing since they all decided to change it over but keep the same continuity. So to me (and I bet to a lot of you) 2k3 ended with 'Enter the Dragons' Part II. It's almost as if Seasons 6 & 7 can be ignored.
|
OK. Not sure why we needed yet another thread on this.
I view the transition more like B:TAS to TNBA, but whatever floats your boat. |
Quote:
...And that's a SERIOUS insult to TNBA...yeesh. BTTS is nowhere near it's quality. |
Quote:
|
I thought Season 5 actually had a noticeably different tone from the first four seasons. I didn't like it that much, it was a bit gimmicky, melodramatic, and rushed. Too much into the realm of "saving the world." That's always the risk you take when you open the series to a grander scale in hopes of making it more epic though.
Of course FF and BTTS can be ignored though. I don't hate them and have gotten some enjoyment out of them for wha they are, but yeah they definitely feel like extensions for the sake of extensions. Probably because they are :/ An expected fate of such a long-running action cartoons though, unfortunately. |
I agree with Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle, I feel nearly the same way (I dislike FF and BTTS).
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
As much as I enjoyed FF and BTTS is ok I'd much rather think that the series ended before that anime influenced pile of trash called the lost season.
To me that was the start of the season gimmicks, but we can thank a certain toy company for that even if they don't take advantage of it. |
You have to admit one thing about the Lost (held hostage) season.. it had structure. There were only 3 filler episodes... 1 wasn't produced, 1 had some connection to the plot, and the other... well.. it was a good stand alone episode. It definitely did what good fillers did, cut through the tension while waiting for the gathering storm.
But I restate, I had troubles since the 4th season... all those random aliens getting into fights with each other and the Turtles playing second/third to them... the endless string of Y’Lyntian based episodes (I'm sorry, but that crap ended for me with the equal to the Notes from the Underground saga)... The whole "Mutants and Monsters" subtitle (except for the Bishop related stuff) wore thin... I think the second half of that season was much better.... |
The Ninja Tribunal arc was good for what it was. I never had a problem with their anime powers, I knew it was only going to last for that one arc.
|
I do find it funny how it's ok to bash other seasons of the show but don't dare say a bad thing about the ninja tribunal or old uncle ancient one may lay a fart bomb in your face.
Each season has it's good and bad things for me even the next mutation had some cool things about it. I do agree though that we could take each season since the Ninja Tribunal though and look at it as a different series or stand alone. I mean really they haven't made an episode based on a Mirage comic since what season 4? And it's something I do find really funny that even tooth complains about episodes being fillers when they are based on issues of the comics hence why they got made. do a bit of research guys that's what the official site is there for. |
Quote:
Considering how Sons of a Silent Era (that's the title, right?) got massacred, I'm glad they didn't do that anymore. Of course, I don't see how a comic book adaption could have worked for any of FF... they certainly could have added some elements like Savanti and Renet some how.... Anyway, Filler is supposed to take tension off something, or help to build tension of the gathering storm... FF built up too much for the gathering storm, while BTTS is building up for a storm that may not even come. |
Quote:
allot of things could have been done in FF like the Arhcie future shark stuff, etc. Mirage voume 4 also could have been used and would have helped (perhaps) sales of the comic. I'm happy they didn't do that for Ff at all to be honest and thats why it was such a breath of fresh air for a long time fan like me, I'm the type of person who enjoys brand new stories and doesn't like to see the same thing over and over again. Like say I don't know Shredder every season, in some way shape or form. Peter Laird has also stated a number of times that no episodes are filler episodes and everything is connected in some way shape or form and I happen to agree with him on this 100%, you'd have to be blind not to see how all the events and characters are all tied together in one big story. |
Season 6 and 7 are both better than Season 5.
There, I said it. |
We don't beleive you.
There. I smited an opinion. Because I could. With sauce. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Though I do agree... everything is connected somehow... A lot of the "fillers" have connected in some way to past plots... and some things that happened in certain ones lead to evens. And frankly, I did like a lot of the stand alone episodes in the previous seasons... I'm going to sort of disagree with what Zarius said some place (either this thread or another)... I don't think the problem is the Cyber Shredder stuff... just the Cyber Splinter stuff. |
I felt the streak of quality began to noticeably diminish after season 4 (or more specifically, "Good Genes part 2"). Starting with the Ninja Tribunal arc, the show began to get gimmicky for season-long stretches at a time, when before, gimmicks were employed for maybe an episode at a time. While I don't hate season 5 (I enjoyed much of it, in fact), I could feel a distinct change in atmosphere, direction and overall tone which would only continue to disintegrate.
Fast Forward was some distracting fun that went on for too long and felt unfocused. Ignoring the change in setting, it just didn't have the edge the first 4 seasons had (which I hold in regard as being genuinely GOOD animation, both in story and production). Back to the Sewers ost my interest after about 4 episodes, focusing far too much on Mikey's juvenile humor (the previous seasons were guilty of this, but never to the extent BttS took it) and some moronic story arcs (collecting Splinter's "bits"). I didn't stick around long enough to see if the payoff with the Shredder War was worth it. I'll just wait for the DVD set. Anyhow, that's my personal weigh-in on the matter. I think the first 4 seasons make for some of the best animation of the decade (saying this not as a TMNT fan, but from a critical perspective) and proof that America still has the chops to stay in the television animation game (contrary to what most Japanophiles may think). Seasons 5-7 are a sudden drop in quality, while not in the "terrible" department (at least, not immediately), they don't live up to the first 4. |
Quote:
The one thing I think they got better with BTTS is that Mikey has at least twice shown that he is competent to save the day... Too little too late, I think. And that Superquest episode was Mikey acting like he was in a play ground... In the context of FF I sort of let it slide. I mean, the only concern was they had to get back to their own time... and maybe down the line watch out for Darius and Shokkenabo... but other than that, no Shredder... no Foot... Bishop was hiding something clearly, but he was never established as a threat of any kind... it was like a Vacation to them. The one thing that would have made BTTS powerful is when Mikey was clowning around near the beginning of the second episode, he turned around to hide tears or something. Changing the subject when they were talking about Splinter was a pretty understated moment... too bad that they burried that under more abusing Serling jokes later... |
Quote:
So would it still be possible to go back to the same story flow and art style on Seasons 1-4? Don't get me wrong. I'm OK with Fast Forward. I also bought Fast Forward collectibles like most of us here. I'm staring at Playmates' Fast Forward Mike Asst#54860 right now while it's unopened mint condition box is hanging on my wall. But my vote is with this sentiment. "Same As it Never Was" from Season 3 alone is far one of the best if not the best episodes for me in the Turtle universe. And how may of us here and out there love "Adventures in Turtle-Sitting" from Season 4? And I know that I am not the only person here who've watched the pilot ep "Things Change" over and over again until the media is already scratched. By my last count, I've reran The Shredder Strikes Back (1 & 2) for over 80 times. I've practically have the count of how many Foot/Feet (hehehe) attacked Leo. Point is, that is how excellent the episodes back then. You watch it again and again and again and again. Will you do the same with the other seasons? Just a thought. :roll: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I really liked Season Five a lot, but it did have it's flaws.
I hated the gimmicky anime-ish stuff with them turning into dragons (with only two of them actually looking like dragons...). That was just lame. I liked the idea of them tapping into their spiritual power (there is a spiritual side to the comics after all), and I didn't feel it was overdone or anything...it reminded me of Xena a little. Although, I hated the new weapons they got to go with their chi abilities as well as the amulets... I really can't stand the Ancient One (never did to begin with, thought he was annoying and gross for no reason...I would have liked him a lot better if he was like he was in the flashbacks with Yoshi and Splinter taking the kids to Japan). They kind of resolved (kind of) the vendetta Karai had against the Hamato clan, I was left with the impression in the last episode that she was willing to let it go and move on with her life. Especially when you consider the fact that she saved Leonardo's life, when she didn't have to... They finished off the Shredder storyline nicely too (I missed a couple of eps, did they have an ep explaining how Utrom Shredder took over the Shredder name?), and all that was really left was the Bishop/Stockman stuff. I LOVE Bishop, he was easily a more interesting villain than Shredder was and I would have loved to see more with him. Stockman too...I was hoping to see him finally get some peace. (Hacking Stockman was actually a pretty good ep, the only one from BTTS that I can honestly say I loved). Aside from the unresolved Bishop/Stockman (mainly Bishop) stuff...I really felt the finale for Season Five was an acceptable finale for the series as a whole. |
I agree. TMNT 2k3 ended with the defeat of Tengu Shredder. Enter the Dragons II pretty much had a happy ending for all once Tengu Shredder was defeated.
Also if you really look at Fast Forward and BTTS. They don't really connect to the timeline of the first five seasons. I mean sure you could say they're part of the timeline somewhere, but they don't directly connect to the first five seasons. Making them more like spin offs or sequel seasons than an actual part of the continuity. As for the anime hate. I wish people would give that a rest. Especially since there are people who do love anime on this forum. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
So yeah I agree with what you say there. It's like many of the people who don't watch anime just magically think every anime is DragonBall Z. And honestly I didn't really even consider the special weapons and the dragon forms anime powers anyways. I don't even know why they're considered that. Just because they yell out their attacks doesn't mean it's anime based. That's just another stereotype. |
True that it's unjust stereotyping, but it's the way of the world to judge every subject by its extremes. Sad but true...
|
Quote:
Not that I have anything against the good sort...it's just the good sort tend to only be 26 episodes, tell a story, and get the hell off of my screen before it becomes an irritation. |
Quote:
Oh well though... It's your loss. hmmm and you're right Gobo. It is the way of the world to judge everything to the extreme. |
It's the Ninja Turtles cycle. Show starts great, show gets toned down, show turns kiddy, animation goes to hell, show gets canceled. That's why I bailed out a long time ago. The cycle always repeats itself.
|
Quote:
|
Actually to be honest. Season 4 rather bored me. I mean it was great that we got more Bishop, but Bishop alone just couldn't save the season from being so boring. The whole mutation arc thing just seemed to drag... Though I did like the idea that they had to find some way to cure Don.
But I'll at least admit that season 4 was more interesting than the stupid triceraton vs federation stuff. I honestly felt that was the most boring aspect of the first five seasons. I just didn't really care about it. |
Quote:
Before I begin this rant I'd like to formally state this is in no way an attack on or directed at you, more or so a rant in general referencing a comment you made. Anime does not have good storytelling. Anime is about barfing exposition into your face in long monologues or in inappropriate situations. Stop me if you've seen this one Good guy attacks bad guy, bad guy deflects the attack and then talks about it for two episodes. Bad guy attacks good guy, good guy asks bad guy why he's bad. Bad guy stops and explains their entire life story in the middle of a fight. The only episodes of "Naurto" I saw took place during a martial arts tournament where some kid in orange fought another kid who looked like an emo jock. All the orange one kept doing was making copies of himself and it never worked yet he kept doing it, probably because it didn't cost money to reanimate it. Then out of no where the emo jock starts babbling about his life story. I'm sorry but if I paid to watch two people beat the hell out of each other I'd be pretty pissed if they started sharing life experiences. I bring that series up because anytime I make a claim anime is garbage they bring it up. I've also seen Bleach and don't get me started on how horrid that was. Anime breaks the number one rule of story telling, graceful reveal of exposition. They're too busy trying to save money so they animate faces talking to explain everything. This is the difference between a ****** movie and a good movie. Telling the audience everything is basically you calling the audience morons and proclaiming that your story is too complex for them thus you need to tell them everything. This could be why most anime fans are snot nose pricks who think they're smarter then everyone else because they can see some sophistication in the mess that is almost every anime's storyline. I've seen tons of it, against my will in most cases. Out of the **** I shuffled through I found a few gems, and they're all movies. I also enjoyed Cowboy Bebop but the voice acting and some of the dialogue is just horrid and barely holds up. I'd watch it subtitled but listening to Japanese people babble is equivalent to nails on a chalk board for me. Their vocal range passes the threshold of pain somehow, that or they just mix their vocals way to loud. Either or some of those screams could break glass. I also have trouble telling the difference between the men and women and am baffled that sometimes the male heroes are acted by women, which I guess further proves my point. As far as animation goes maybe I'm behind but most anime looks terrible. It's not fluid at all. That or they blow their load on the action sequences and leave the rest of the stuff to look low budget. I guess that's all that matters to the fans who make thousands of Linkin Park music videos using them. And you ever been to an anime convention? Eat onions for a week straight and don't bath. That's what the one I went to smelled like. There's being a nerd, such as myself whose currently posting on a Ninja Turtles message board, and then there's living the nerd. These people spoke using internet lingo, such as brb. Most of them either looked like their Mommy dressed them or a Halloween store exploded near their bedroom. If that's not bad enough hearing them talk is the real frightening part. Some of them think they're Japanese which is just plain sad and the others just sound like every nerd stereotype you've ever heard in a movie of TV series. Anime fans are like a whole different race/gender/religion of people all together. They're a bunch of bizarre smelling ape creatures that like hair gel and metrosexuals. I just don't, and won't ever understand them. Don't even get me started on the ones who like the video games... Quote:
|
Quote:
Stuff like Hokuto no Ken, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, heck even stuff like One Piece, Yu Yu Hakusho, Rurouni Kenshin and even Full Metal Alchemist don't try to explain every single attack in explicit detail. Heck even Bleach doesn't do that, and Bleach sucks harder than Naruto does in all honesty. Not saying they never do it, but unlike Naruto they don't do it all the time is what I'm saying. Now granted in series like Zatch Bell it does come up, but it's done in a way where the strategical elements that are used ARE that amazing, and in all honesty sometimes it just helps you get why it actually worked. Cause at least in Zatch Bell something will make you go WTF until it's explained and then suddenly you're like "Oh man I never expected that; that's what happened!" Another example of a series where it's used wisely is Detective Conan. An extremely long mystery series, but a damn good one. And honestly I think Naruto is a horrible series anyways. I mean I liked it years ago back when my only anime experience was DBZ, but the series has turned to garbage, and I've found better series so I feel that Naruto is a bottom of the barrel series. About as overrated as FF7 even. It's fandom is just as bad too to be honest. But anyways we're talking about shounen action series. Which by itself is just one genre, and is mostly catered to teenage boys anyways. Also not all animes break that rule. Not all animes explain stuff. That's just one of the many stereotypes it seems to get just because it happens in pokemon, yugioh, and Naruto. Animation wise... well I won't lie to you. Anime has it's bad animation moments, and it's good animation moments. Some series like Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann are animated beautifully. Like every episode is 40% of the entire animation budget. It's just that damn awesome, but with the long series like Naruto. You will see the animation is a bit on the sketchy side at times because of the budget. Then again it's not like Western animation has the best budget either. I mean it's not like all cartoons can have disney movie quality even though we wish they could. Oh and to be honest I wasn't a big fan of cowboy bebop either... I just didn't like it. I honestly don't get why people think it's the greatest thing ever. I mean animation and choreography it's good. Plot wise though not so much in my opinion at least. I never did like any of the characters. And well as for voices... all I can say is the Japanese voices are really good and fitting. It's obvious to all anime fans that the english voices just never match up, and rarely EVER fit the characters. Honestly compare japanese One Piece to 4kids One Piece. You'll see the difference. I've personally never been to an anime convention, but I honestly don't think it's as bad as you say, and even if it is I can assure you it's probably just as bad at comic con and other American comic conventions. Not to mention the sci fi conventions too. After all you think the basement dwellers only come out for anime conventions? Not to mention they dress up the same way... especially in their little costumes. I mean honestly it's not like anime conventions are the only guilty party in this. And heck knows I don't act like those people do. Then again I consider myself a casual anime fan. Heck if I did go to an anime con. I'd be like one of those guys that DOESN'T cosplay and I'd wear regular street clothes. I like video games, but I'm not some hardcore gamer or anything either. I mean anime and video games are just hobbies to me. Not my way of life, but when I see all the anime bashing on this forum. It's like you're indirectly insulting me. Even if you're not trying too. I feel a lot of anime haters use too many stereotypes to classify anime and its fans, but not all anime fans are like the ones you described. Just as not all animes are like the ones you described too. I'm not going to say you're blinded by your hatred, but I'm pretty sure there are people who would say that. But ah well... I can't force you to like something. All I'm asking for is for people to respect that there are anime fans on this forum so please just tone down the hate a bit. After all not all anime fans are bad, and they deserve respect just as much as anyone. |
Oh guys, common!
Fact: Not all anime are about magical powers. Fact: Saying that anime are only about magical powers is stereotyping. Fact: Anime and cartoon are entirely different art. I love anime. I was an otaku for a long time. I may not be an otaku anymore, but I am definitely an enthusiast. IF SOMEONE INSULTS ANIME, I AM DEFINITELY OFFENDED. I love cartoons. My place is filled with their existence. Let's not start an unncessary debate about which is better or not. :) TMNT is a cartoon. It had the anime version in Japan, am I correct. Some of the latter TMNT seasons appeared like anime. you know my preference in my earlier post. I'll repeat it-- I prefer TMNT cartoon version and not TMNT anime-like version. Not that I don't like anime. It's jsut that if I want to watch an anime episode, I'll pop in a Slam Dunk (THIS HAS NO POWERS) by Takehiko Inoue DVD or a New Mobile Report Gundam Wing (THIS HAS NO POWERS) in the player. Though, Naruto and Bleach (they are more than 100 episodes AND DEFINITELY HAVE STORIES), have new episodes. I might watch them in the weekend. Hehehe. :lol: |
Quote:
I'm not trying to say there's not a lot of bad anime because trust me I sat through alot of crappy ones that I regret watching but you sound like you saw most of the bad and none of the good. There are a dozen anime that hold up to great american cartoons like Justice League, Batman,TMNT, Spectacular Spiderman, and etc you just have to know how to look for them. (As much as you stereotype, I actually agree with some of what you said) |
Quote:
:evil: But, hey, everyone's entitled to his/her opinion. You can go on believing on that yourself for all the time you want. So it just means to say that you dispise the anime version of TMNT-- Mutant Turtles: Superman Legend (ミュータント・タートルズ超人伝説偏, Myūtanto Tātoruzu: Chōjin Densetsu Hen. Well. :oops: |
Quote:
Quote:
When it comes to anime for me, outside of a few, I'm all about classics, and especially 1970's-1980's stuff. |
Frankly, with the stuff in here as well as in "officially ticked" thread, it's becoming clear Spitfire doesn't want to watch shows for fear he might actually find something he likes (after claiming all of such a thing as 'bad'). As he's made note of seeing ads or previews from DVDs for shows and basing his displeasure on those simple viewings. Along with the stereotyping/umbrellaing [maybe not a word, but using it for the sake of this post] in here.
|
So that this thread somewhat stays on topic:
I feel the quality went down beginning with season 5. The origin stuff was good and so was the Splinter and Karai subplots but everything else was meh to me. The acolytes were a waste of character space, the turtles themselves received less focus than other seasons, most of the fights were boring energy blast battles, and the animation was inconsistent. I sat through a majority of the episodes somewhat bored. It tried to be an epic final season but that hurt more than helped. I consider Fast Forward too be a lot better. It wasn't too focused like TLS, the fights were a good medium between special weapon attacks and martial arts, the villains and allies had much more personality than Tengu Shredder, his minions, and the acolytes, and the story didn't try to be bigger than it actually was. If I had to choose between having TLS, BttS, and FF quality episodes for future seasons (since were obviously never returning to seasons 1-4 quality) I would choose FF. BttS and TLS focused too much on their gimmicky aspects unlike FF in which the the future was secondary to the characters most of the time. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:11 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.