![]() |
Everyone please take the time to respond to this...
I want to know what they are and why. I'm not fishing for compliments on my own work here (I am grateful for any left though :D), I want to know which issues of Tales are your favorites and why (in detail too, if "it kicked ass" I want to know what made it kick ass). I'd also like to know what stories you really liked elements of, but maybe not the rest (and reasons why, too).
I know City at War, Return to New York, those big arcs are always favorites, but I want to know about the other stories. What worked, what didn't. All that jazz. *sorry, didn't realise I posted this here -- could this get moved over to the comics forum please, mods? [Mod edit: Done! ~Machi] |
I'm not big on the comics, so I haven't read many. ... At least it's a response.
|
Most recently my favorite would be the michelangelo the third kind #1 comic, I really liked how everybody got real paranoid when the aliens showed up (obviously that would happen in real life), and especially one person got really paranoid and I guess you'll have to read it, also I really didn't expect such a cutting edge ending, I guess it really kept me interested that whole third kind series, it would've made for a good 2k3 cartoon, and also Tristan I love your work on #56 I really love that dark kick a@@ style:D
|
Woah... I like a lot of the issues... this could take some time... I'll get back to ya on that one, Trist. By the way, everything I've read of yours is on the list :D
|
I like all the issues not written by that talentless hack, Tristan Jones...
TAKE THAT! I'll respond to this properly when I've caught up on my reading of tales. |
"Leatherhead Too" (TMNT Volume 1, issue 45). Mainly it's Dan Berger's art simultaneously capturing the gritty-ness of battling ninjas and a gigantic, insane Leatherhead coupled together with the border-line tooney expressiveness. The way he draws eyes and mouths are wonderful. Everything Dan has done, I love but I think this is his best. Also, the plot is genuinely exciting. Inter-city gang warfare with just the right mix of out-of-this-world sci-fi. The Turtles even retain a bit of a care-free attitude, which I always love to see.
"Sky Highway" (TMNT Volume 1, issue 30) Veitch's art is amazing and fits the story perfectly. Those undead highway addicts are crazy characters whose qualities are sufficiently explained in the first few pages. It's poetic in a twisted sort of way. It's a very fun issue. My favorite issues are probably those that were written and drawn by the same creative mind, with a notable exception being the issues drawn by Paul Harmon and written by Tristan Jones. EDIT: Oh, You said favorite Tales. Sorry, I'll try to put up my thoughts later. |
Aside from the usual #1-11, Return to NY, City at War, Volume 2, etc.
I'd say my favorite was #46-47, the one where they go to ancient Japan and see Shogun Shoate. I love how Raph starts the Foot Clan, very ironic and satisfying. Of the new Tales, I'd say the one with Don on that planet with the alien race that looks like the Triceratons, I forgot their names. The one with the dead one and a ghostly spirit...something like that. |
you guys know he said "Issues of Tales" right?
|
Quote:
#36 was very good though, in terms of storytelling, artwork, and general pacing. |
Quote:
|
Disclaimer: I have not read all of Tales Volume 2. I have read large chunks, but missed many as well. And woe of woes, sorry Tristan, I'm yet to read #36 and #56, which I know are fan favorites. But from what I've read...
Favorites: #5 "Blind Faith" - Everything about this issue is excellent. The art is unique and beautiful. The action is intense. The story is pulpy yet down to Earth and the ending is a great character moment. #6 "Scars" - Great for the same reasons as #5. The action is good. I love Chris Allan's art, but he really pulled out all the stops here (check those panel to panel transitions). Mostly I love Ocho's soliloquies. It puts Leonardo on a moral high horse, and at the very end Ocho makes the reader question how right Leo really is. It's nice to see a sympathetic villain. Wish they'd used him more. #13 - 14 "Loops" - Yet another great character piece for Leonardo. When these issues aren't presenting humorous interactions and good action, they delve into the great implied continuity of Mirage, and they have a poignant little endpiece reflecting upon mortality. The great mix of fantasy and down-to-Earth thinking that I love about the series. #33 "The Bait" - Really just rides on the fun of seeing Casey and Splinter interact, and using a villain that's actually cool. Pretty much your ideal "quirky action" story. #41 "Swan Song" - I love this issue. Leo and Radical is something I would inherently say "no" to, but it was handled tastefully and set up a great revenge story. More hints of the bitter future the Turtles face, a reflective Leonardo, and the fantastic but underused villain Complete Carnage make this one work. #55 "A Day in the Life" - Simply a joy to read. The characters were fun, the humor worked, and the future Raph segment at the end put a lovely bittersweet cap on the issue. Elements that worked: #46 "Temps" - This one isn't a favorite, but it had tons of potential. This should have been a poignant, reflective story, but it wasn't. It wasn't even a decent action issue. The concept was strong but the execution lacked. #54 "Mere Appendix" - What could've been an interesting (if cliche) musing on identity and reality ended up being a confusing sci-fi melodrama that didn't really go anywhere or develop its theme. Again, strong concept, poor execution. #53 "This Mortal Shell" - Apparently this story was done by art students and isn't considered canon? These people should be hired to write a full issue, because that little story was fantastic all around. Favorites from other volumes include "Sons of the Silent Age" and "Twilight of the Ring" for being well written and interesting, and "Juliet's Revenge", "Leatherhead Too", and "I, Monster" for being damn fun. The first half of Volume 2 also had great and realistic character moments. And Tristan, I'll put myself out there by saying that I don't think "Return to New York" or the first eleven issues are even in the same league as "City at War" (still the series' highpoint) and some of the other issues I've listed. I don't care how many ninjas the Turtles are fighting as long as the stories approach some level of depth and reflection. I'm not asking for great literature, but it's something that the comics have been great at pulling off while still managing to incorporate ridiculous sci-fi and other fun elements. Quote:
|
Everything drawn by Dario. :tthumbsu:
I don't think I can get more specific unless I know what this feedback is being used for. Assuming that it's being used to decide what to do with the book in the future, my favorite issues aren't necessarily reflective of what I would like to see. And I do think the comics need to take a break to regroup themselves and figure out what it is they exactly want to be, but there's no one currently at Mirage that I think can turn any TMNT book into a successful title. |
Well, I can tell you what I like fundamentally and what I'd like to see more of.
I'd like to see more itnerconnected storytelling. Conflicts that aren't resolved in the span of one issue and then forgotten about entirely. The best issues of Tales are the ones that compliment one another and build an actual story arc (the "Leatherhead Trilogy" and the Shredder-Shark/Loops stories being examples of this in Tales Vol. 2). My problem with Tales Vol. 2 on a fundamental level is that too many threads are established and then never resolved or even so much as referenced again. What about the "Lady Shredder"? Or the Foot Mystics? They were billed as major threats to the TMNT, big new villains with lots of stories to be told. They have since been forgotten and kicked to the wayside. I'm tired of that. Tales is an anthology title, so by its very nature it features stand-alone stories. But you can have stand alone stories which build upon one another toward a grander scheme. Stand alone stories which are completely isolated and meaningless are not satisfying to read. Sure, they're a fun diversion at first, but after 50 issues the novelty begins to wear thin. Tristan's stories show promise; interconnecting to create an actual story arc. Here's hoping he keeps this up. So I suppose that's what I enjoy and want to see more of. Actual story arcs with build up and resolution. Tales has provided very few of these and that has been its most frustrating failing, at least from my perspective. Idealy, for this to really work, we'd need a TMNT book that is ongoing and not hindered by the anthology formula. But whaddaya gonna do? |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
There's no need to look at this beyond what it really is: me asking you which your favourites are and why. These are just things I like to take on board and things I know others do too. It also provides good conversation on the board, especially when you get so many downer threads these days. Quote:
|
I just think Tales needs more gangster stories, with mob bosses.
One of my favorite arcs of Image is when a mob boss kidnapped Shadow because he was the biological father, it was pretty damn awesome and nicely done. I think its best if TMNT does more "down-to-earth" stories, because as others have pointed out, its gotten too sci-fi heavy recently. More stuff with gang wars, maybe a little Foot thrown in, mob bosses, stuff like that. |
I've only read each Tales issue once, and the ones that have left lasting impressions with just a single reading are the following:
#1 - Not Forgotten - I think I'm a sucker for the pre-v1 turtles. Just brings me back to the golden days, and I like any bits of backstory I can get on what shapes the turtles into their own by the time of vol 1 #1. It was a solid story with a fresh breath of art, and the bitter-sweet ending was an unexpected bonus. #5 - Blind Faith - Amazing. Simplistic yet powerful art. A great introspective tale for Leonardo. The Blind-Sight mini that followed was very good as well, my fave of the new solo titles so far. #8 - Virus - Pure Berger brilliance. No one does Leatherhead quite like Dan story & artwise. A good tie-in to "Leatherhead Too," one of my favorite vol 1 issues, & following that narrative thread, #23 was great as well. #9 - The Path - This issue surprised me. I was not expecting to enjoy a Klunk-centric story but it turned out to be a good look at Michelangelo, exploring his personal, emotional side that get's so glossed over in the media with pizza-cravings and general buffoonery. In my opinion, this was Mikey's "Blind-Faith." #13-14 - Loops - I always enjoy a glimpse at the turtles in childhood or elderhood, and this had both! Art was crazy but enthralling. #33 - The Bait - An exciting story where the turtles don't even appear! I liked seeing the uncommon pairing of Casey and Splinter, the two characters are polar opposites and it was an intriguing juxtaposition. #36 - To Serve & Protect - everything you've written Tristan has exuded bad-assss, and Paul Harmon is artistic perfection. I knew this one would be good just by looking at the cover. #37 - Casey In Point - I'm starting to realize that I really enjoy backstories... and character development in general. #38 - Triptyche - If I remember correctly this one had little/no dialogue, and that's always an awesome thing when you can tell a compelling story without words. #40 - wait, maybe this is the one with no dialogue?... or maybe both?... Anyway, future Raph is my hero. The future turtles intrigue me to no end and this was an awesome action-packed solo epic for Raph. Reminded me of a few Wolverine stories I've read, which is a good thing. #42 - Curious Case of Mr. Jones - Another one I wasn't expecting to enjoy. It was just a fun issue all around, and sometimes its nice to take a breath from the grimy and gritty. #45 - Rocks - Another great stand-on-its-own story. I love seeing the turtles just being turtles, and here we find them on a harmless camping trip, which goes horribly awry. (Though there might be some bias in this one because I've been camping at that very reservoir, and like imagining that I was a few leagues away from an ancient monster ;)) #50 - World's Deadliest - Monster Mayhem! Great art and writing and LEATHERHEAD! #53 - Alien Invaders - Another priceless one-shot. Funny. Clever. #55 - A Day in the Life - see #1 as all the same words apply. I haven't read 56 yet, but if it's anything like your other stuff Tristan I'm sure it will be tops! Hope some of this helps. |
I will not go into issue numbers. At current arc i am loving Tristan's take on the TMNT universe. New writers are cool cause they themselves collect lots of new comics and cause of the fact that they know the current nice story arcs on other comics, they can understand the needs of readers and what they want to see in comics. We can see that at Tristan and Paul's books. I mean, keeping up with the industry.
At Vol.1, other than 1-11, Return to NY and CaW, i was fan of The River story arc by Rick Veitch. I lked Zulli's take on TMNT too, but i guess i had liked The River more. Cause of the fact that i am a huge Swamp Thing fan. More stories like that would be cool. Also more horror elements would be great. Cheesy horror is nice, funny and i must confess fitting to the nature of TMNT. I like that too. But by horror i mean Lovecraftian style horror, a bit on the psychological side. And as for the main story styles, yeah, back to the root, street level and dirty stuff. I guess most fans will like it. Nice thread by the way. I really like your work on book Trist but also your efforts to make it better ( for your stories and for the general situation of Mirage ) is admirable. |
I like:
- anything featuring Toddler Turtles - anything where Leonardo is the protagonist. My favorite Archie arc was the Animus War. There were a lot of good Tales. |
I really liked "blind sight" mini series, it was deep, had a interesting "Frank Miller" esque art style.
|
I like the issues where the story has interesting twists and tie-ins to older elements of TMNT without being forced.
I also enjoy the LH Tales. I also enjoy Don and Mike tales because those guys don't get the focus as much as Leo and Raph. Tales #22 was a great story with great artwork that I wish you all would follow up with. The Yoshi twist in it was really good. Some of the future stories have been good too. |
One I liked that I don't think have been mentioned yet is The Value of Gold
Thought it was an interesting, modern take on the old idea of slaves Also, the fact that these "sweatshops" really exist.. Blech! |
Tristan,
I think (like Rose) I'm a bit suspicious of your motives. But I think that is mostly because you are enigmatic, and also because you are Australian. If someone were to call me and say, "Hey, I'd like to know what you think of this and this, and also about these things," and was unable to provide me with a straight answer as to why they wanted to know, I'd tell them to go take a hike. Honesty IS the best policy, is all I'm trying to say :D. However, because you are who you are (and I've a soft spot in my heart for the enigmatic, and also the Australian), I will take the time to answer your question. These are my favorite issues from Volume 2 of Tales, and why: Issue 6: "Scars" Issue 12: "Paris Nocturne" Issue 27: "White Horses" Issue 41: "Swan Song" Issue 55: "A Day In The Life" Excluding the last one (which gets a pass because it's just so much friggin' fun), when I look at what I love about the Turtles, all my favorite stories have always been the issues where there's been actual narration in the issue. Where I KNOW who's telling the story, what it's about, and why they're telling it. "Scars," for me, is the best issue of Tales we've gotten so far. Because it flipped the good guy / bad guy roles right on it's ear... and made me completely sympathize w / the "devil," (Foot Clan's Cha Ocho) so to speak. It's just solid storytelling, from beginning to end. "Paris Nocturne" has just for bit of narration from Shadow at the beginning. But that's all that's needed. I know who's telling it. It's HER story. "White Horses" is April at her darkest moment. She's telling it, and through her voice, I come to care. "Swan Song" is Leonardo's voice, moving through the world, looking to put his life back together after losing his girl. I get that. I dig it. (An honorable mention here should go to "True Stories," TMNT Vol 1. #11. That's my favorite comic book, ever. Told through April's narration, I've probably read it at least 500 times). Many issues seem to slap a gorgoeus frontispiece (many by Mike Dooney, in particular, are just breathtaking) in front of a story, with a little lead-in saying that character (who often has little to do with the coming tale) is the one who's going to tell the story. And that's fine. But then there's no proof in what follows that they're the one who's actually doing the telling. None whatsoever. So, yeah. Those are my favorite issues. And, like I think a few other people have said, I think the multi-issue stories are great. However, I have to wonder if they're good for the comic in the way they're currently presented. Like, if I pick up a Paul Dini penned issue of Detective Comics, and it says "Part 1 of 3," I know that I'll be getting the next installment... next month. And then it'll finish, the month after that. With "Tales," it's we get the first part one month... and then wait a year-and-a-half to get that next installment. If I were a casual reader (and of the Turtles I'm proud to say that I'm not), and I saw that the current issue was tied to something 14 months ago, and that I REALLY should read that in order to know what's going on, well... There's a lot of comics in the comic shop. And I'd be willing to wager there will be something else that'll give me the direct punch to the gut I want, right away. I hope the comic continues. I really, really do. However (and I say this with the caveat that I truly dislike "Monday Morning Quarterbacking" anything. It just makes me feel icky), I think one solid move that could be made would be to de-rebrand the property. (What, Will?) What I mean is, there should be something out there on the shelves with "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" in the title. Not "TMNT," which is just another acronym that I suspect would mean nothing to the uninitiated. ABC. CBS. MTV. CNN. TMNT. VH1. NBC. See what I mean? "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" as a name has "marquee power." I'd be willing to wager if that were the name the last movie went by, rather than "TMNT," it would have made maybe 10 million more. But, again. Talking about this kind of stuff makes me feel gross. |
[QUOTE=willtupper;682677]Tristan,
I think (like Rose) I'm a bit suspicious of your motives. But I think that is mostly because you are enigmatic, and also because you are Australian. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
I can't remember the issue number, but I liked the superhero Turtles comic that came out pretty recently. I'm interested in seeing alternate versions of the Ninja Turtles (like Soul's Winter, but not as weird this time). I wouldn't mind seeing the superhero Turtles again.
I thought "Temps" was a good addition to the "City at War" story. It was interesting to take a look at the lives of one of the Foot ninjas. As far as an issue I didn't like quite so much, issue 40. The art was fantastic, but I wasn't a fan of the "silent" thing. Maybe a comic needs both art and dialogue for me to feel like I've gotten my money's worth.:ohwell: |
i used the official site as a reference- i was surprised by how many i really liked. tales vol. 2 is great, one of the most consistently well-written and drawn tmnt titles. i wish mirage had made better use of its rogues and allies gallery, so the issues in whch savanti, karai, complete carnage, leatherhead, rat king, etc appear in are the outstanding ones to me.
as an ot fan, i like stories that are essentially stand alone but easily fit into the overall universe. it's hard getting into issues that take place in vol. 2-4 since i only have read vol. 1. anyway, here goes.. issue 6, cha ocho story- it felt so right to see chris allan drawing the turtles again. good easy to pick up story that flowed really well. issue 9, death of klunk- i love this story. it's so sad. i remember reading it when my cat was hit by a car, so it had a lot of resonance. issue 17, the giant bugs- a nice fun story with some cool art by jim lawson. i liked the campy feel of the story. issue 24, rock of ages- great, tight story. one of murphy's best. issue 28- cha ocho and raph- awesome, clean, expressive artwork. issue 32, cowboys of moo mesa and savanti- i'm a big savanti fan, and this was one of his best appearances. always a pleasure. he's kinda like an ot villan in some ways. love 'im. issue 33- splinter teams up with casey to fight the foot and shredder shark, how can you go wrong? issue 41- old leo vs. complete carnage. cool issue, i love how tales has the freedom to look into the distant future. issue 42- casey is interrogated by the utroms- very funny issue. issue 43- the proposal. i like the story, seeing cousin sid again, and the ending was cool. plus the foot mystic was in it. issue 45, rocks- lovecraft!!! issue 47- origin of the super turtles- hell yeah! this is making good use of cool concets. issue 50, leatherhead and the monsters- beautiful artwork and a great story. plus the return of an old villian. it'd be nice to see some of those monsters again. issue 51, gutwallow- hilarious issue. i love dan berger's sense of humor. and renet was in it! issue 52- cudley???!! top notch artwork by brizuela as usual. issue 53- i loved every story in this isssue. they were all great. so tales has been on a roll lately, though i still have yet to pick up issues 55 and onward. i'm looking forward to that hun issue. |
Issues drawn by Chris Allan! I don't care what the story is about, I get into it because of his artwork.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:37 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.