The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Why the New Film Needs to be PG-13 (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27056)

Cipher 04-23-2009 06:04 PM

Why the New Film Needs to be PG-13
 
I'm sure there are people who want to talk about other things in the main film thread, so let's bring the argument here.

Quote:

The "PG-13 or don't bother crowd" (which I actually coined four pages back) aren't saying it just because we think a PG movie would be poor entertainment.

We're saying it because it would be poor entertainment and strike another nail into the franchise's coffin. The franchise will never maintain a presence unless the public can get it into their heads that it isn't just a renewable cartoon and toyline.

You know how Batman can have action figures and cartoons, and people are still aware that there's an adult-oriented comic book being printed? You know how Batman, as a franchise, can pretty much do whatever it wants? If you want that to happen to the TMNT, we need a PG-13 movie to redefine them. Because the greater public simply will not see a PG movie.
Quote:

There's no argument (that it could be good or bad, regardless of rating). Now try getting people in the seats with a PG rating. Try having people take notice of the comics or larger franchise with a PG rating. People liked their light-hearted Turtles in 1989. Now they either want only old toon, or you have to give them something completely different. TMNT (2007) was a mess of conflicted tones with no clear target audience outside of the toy-buying, kiddie crowd. A memorable movie that does not make.

It's not about what we personally want to see in a movie (although I do think it needs the liberty of a higher rating). It's about what's best for TMNT. We want people to see the real, Mirage TMNT, with the humor and the darkness. We want people to be able to accept all aspects of the Turtles so it can support itself without whatever gimmicky toyline is running that year. This is a chance for that to come true. Accept no substitutions.
Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 686827)
I get the feeling the first movie is probably the darkest a TMNT theatrical movie will ever get.

So you want to see a perpetual cycle of the TMNT cracking pizza jokes and fighting ninjas with cymbals and comedy props?

Talk about setting your standards low.

Quote:

I'm with the rest of you on this, NC-17 or no sale.
I don't know why I bother. This is not about making the movie as dark and violent as possible. It's about appealing to the widest audience. Kids and teens/adults will see a PG-13 movie. Only kids will see a PG movie.
Taken from other thread. Discuss. Argue. Try to be mature.

Aztec General 04-23-2009 06:06 PM

I'm with you Cipher. If they want to be true to the original comics, if they want to treat TMNT like any other comic book franchise, and if they want to attract both adults and children this film MUST BE PG-13!

PG-13 or don't bother!

Cipher 04-23-2009 06:11 PM

I'd like to make one more point. I do not think the new movie should be "OMG DARK AND VIOLENT." I simply think that a PG-13 rating will put more people in seats. It would allow the film to present the off beat humor, character depth, and occasionaly realistic violence of the Mirage comics.

But yeah, it's not really about violence. It's about altering public perception. People simply need to know that this is a franchise capable of appealing to all ages, and yet another PG movie does not send that message.

I'm said now.

Aztec General 04-23-2009 06:14 PM

The fun tone of Iron Man plus some of the inner-city grit of Batman Begins would be perfect for TMNT. That's what I have in mind. Both films if you note, are PG-13.

Dragon Turtle 04-23-2009 06:32 PM

I'm curious as to what people actually expect a PG-13 TMNT movie to contain, considering the PG-13 rating covers a lot of territory.

LeoNerdo 04-23-2009 06:53 PM

I agree with this mostly. They made money with the 2007 flick but I think they could have a smash hit on their hands if they played this less towards kids and more towards the 20 - 30's crowd who remember the original toon, the comics, and the first movie.

CyberCubed 04-23-2009 07:05 PM

To be honest I think more people will see this movie just because it's live-action. A lot of casual fans didn't bother to see the 4th movie because it was all CG, and they passed it off as a kids movie. (Which is what it was essentially, but you get my point).

Live-action alone makes it interesting to a broader audience. I'm glad they went this route.

mumbo230 04-23-2009 07:31 PM

PG-13 just frees the movie up to tell a story without blatantly toning anything down.

What a PG-13 movie is capable of doing that a PG movie is not is putting the TMNT franchise in line with all the other major superhero franchises - Batman, Spider-Man, Iron Man, X-Men, the Hulk, all of them.

Right now I'm not even sure how much of the public is even aware that TMNT is a comic book franchise. The general public sees it as a kids series. This movie can fix that. And yes, having it live-action takes it strides in that direction already.

But PG-13 is that perfect rating for any action movie, since you can still get the kids in and yet everyone else too, so it's the biggest potential moneymaker. There are companies that specifically push their movies to a PG-13 rating - from either above or below - for this exact reason.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle
I'm curious as to what people actually expect a PG-13 TMNT movie to contain, considering the PG-13 rating covers a lot of territory.

A Spider-Man kind of PG-13, if that makes any sense. That's what I'd expect. Serious enough for older viewers with an acceptable level of action and violence, but still fun for the kids.

Well, except for Spider-Man 3, wouldn't want it anything like that :P

trustno1 04-23-2009 07:49 PM

i think that pg13 is ideal. transformers, spiderman, batman, all the other big "kids" franchises were all pretty intense movies but the kids all went and some were scared of bits but they still appealed to adults as well.

Spitfire 04-23-2009 07:55 PM

PG-13 means absolutely nothing without a solid cast, good script, and good director. I want a good movie not a violent one. If we can have our cake and eat it too then awesome but if not I'll be happy as long as some good people are working on the project.

Ginny 04-23-2009 08:06 PM

I'd like to see the movie PG-13 mainly because of the freak out the MPAA ratings board has with martial arts. I mean Kung Fu Panda was rated PG because of martial arts violence, to have the new TMNT movie close to the level I'm sure we all want to see, it would almost have to be PG-13.

ToTheNines 04-23-2009 08:08 PM

I'm pretty confident that this'll be PG13. I mean, people have to realise that kids DO go see PG13 movies (Although I sometimes wish they didn't :P) and (generally speaking) adults don't see PG movies.

I think Warner Brothers is what held back TMNT 07, since they hadn't had alot of super succesful PG13 superhero movies (sans Batman, but I think this will change soon), even though Columbia, Universal, and Fox were doing well with Spider-Man, X-Men, Hulk and the like.

odupianist 04-24-2009 04:10 PM

So does PG-13 = nunchukus? I hope so lol

Candy Kappa 04-24-2009 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by odupianist (Post 687128)
So does PG-13 = nunchukus? I hope so lol

yes but in UK it'll be cg'ed to a wet towel:lol:

Raven 04-24-2009 06:18 PM

I think with the recent success of the Dark Knight more movie studois might try to emulate that sort of dark and gritty mood, so I dont see why they shouldnt go for a PG-13 rating for a new movie.

Then again Im not a coke endused movie producer?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-24-2009 07:09 PM

Usa, 2007
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 686859)
To be honest I think more people will see this movie just because it's live-action. A lot of casual fans didn't bother to see the 4th movie because it was all CG, and they passed it off as a kids movie. (Which is what it was essentially, but you get my point).

Live-action alone makes it interesting to a broader audience. I'm glad they went this route.

It was still the box office number one film in the USA on 25 March 2007 according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TMNT_(film).

Vincent 04-25-2009 06:19 PM

The comics would have to be mentioned in some way in the trailer to inform people that this is not based on a kids cartoon or a toyline, as many people seem to think. Just a simple "See the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as originally imagined in the comics by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird" would go a long way toward opening people's minds to the fact that Batman doesn't have to be Adam West, so to speak.
That is, provided the movie actually does follow the spirit of the comics as closely as possible.

Dan 04-26-2009 05:09 AM

I don't think it would matter if people think it's based off a cartoon or a toyline. I mean Transformers was and that was a huge hit.

Candy Kappa 04-26-2009 05:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan (Post 687511)
I don't think it would matter if people think it's based off a cartoon or a toyline. I mean Transformers was and that was a huge hit.

yeah but transformers have evolved from it, and had a bunch of reboots/alternative stories

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-26-2009 08:29 AM

Background story
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Vincent (Post 687406)
The comics would have to be mentioned in some way in the trailer to inform people that this is not based on a kids cartoon or a toyline, as many people seem to think. Just a simple "See the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as originally imagined in the comics by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird" would go a long way toward opening people's minds to the fact that Batman doesn't have to be Adam West, so to speak.
That is, provided the movie actually does follow the spirit of the comics as closely as possible.

Why not mention the background story short at cinema before the film begins.

jalexbrown 05-07-2009 10:40 AM

I think that there's bigger missing information than the rating. While I agree that the PG-13 rating is probably most beneficial for the series, I think it's a pretty moot point to debate at a time when the script isn't even written and the writer/director isn't announced yet. It's sad that the 4th movie messed up in such a way that when the 5th movie is announced, we're actually willing to sit here debating what rating it should get. That never happened with any earlier movies in the series.

thebrownranger 05-07-2009 12:15 PM

Yeah PG-13 or don't even bother. I'm pretty sure having a rating like this would attract a bigger audience because people will start to take it more serious just like The Dark Knight. If they stick with PG people will more likely consider this new flick to be a joke or something of the sort.

joe-eyeball 05-07-2009 06:42 PM

Quite simply PG or G films only attract big audiences if they are Disney or Dreamworks cartoons. Other than that, making the Turtles movie PG means they are trying to make it a family film. A set of parents with a daugther and a son will not be going to see this. For the most part, and I know there are exceptions, but the turtles are typically a boys property. So if they make it PG-13 they allow themselves the capabilities of creating a story that can be for both core fans and the casual movie goer and not something dumbed down for little boys to see.

Jelly Bean 05-12-2009 07:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe-eyeball (Post 690689)
Quite simply PG or G films only attract big audiences if they are Disney or Dreamworks cartoons. Other than that, making the Turtles movie PG means they are trying to make it a family film. A set of parents with a daugther and a son will not be going to see this. For the most part, and I know there are exceptions, but the turtles are typically a boys property. So if they make it PG-13 they allow themselves the capabilities of creating a story that can be for both core fans and the casual movie goer and not something dumbed down for little boys to see.

you took the words right of my mouth. Personly i would like to see rated R and just see where that would take the franchise. But I know it won't happen, if this is going to happen, I hope and pray that it'll be pg-13.

Ninja-Tortoise 06-23-2009 05:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vincent (Post 687406)
The comics would have to be mentioned in some way in the trailer to inform people that this is not based on a kids cartoon or a toyline, as many people seem to think. Just a simple "See the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as originally imagined in the comics by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird" would go a long way toward opening people's minds to the fact that Batman doesn't have to be Adam West, so to speak.
That is, provided the movie actually does follow the spirit of the comics as closely as possible.

I agree with you 100% but keep in mind that not everyone got into tmnt with the comics including me. I got into it when I was little with the original cartoon from the 80's. Then when I was a little older I found out it started as a comic. I had always thought it started as a toon untill I was like 12 or 13 then I started collecting them when a comic shop opened near my house. I am 26 now and still do. Bottom line, they should make this new movie dark and gritty just like the comics. I want a dark knight tone of violence and darkness. PG-13 is like a R rated movie today. PG-13 even shows nudity sometimes (EVA mendes in the spirit) I say give us a good hard PG-13 ninja turtles movie or give us nothing.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.