![]() |
Is anyone else worried that the new movie might be a remake of the first?
My hope for TMNT 5 is a City at War movie, with some of Return to New York mixed in, with Karai bringing Shredder back to life somehow. Essentially I really want to see the story progress from the previous movies, as well as adapt some of the best comic book stories, (The Shredder clones, and the City at War saga).
However it seems like they're working on the movie being like issues #1-11, but excluding all the TCRI and Triceraton stuff....which is exactly the same thing the first movie did, more or less. Would anyone else like to see a NEW story, rather than just a remake of the first movie? I can't say I'm terribly excited to see the Turtles meet April/Casey for the billionth time, meet Shredder for the first time, and essentially follow the same story with Leo (or Raph) getting beat up and them retreating to the farm house. Would anyone else rather the 5th movie cover City at War, and since it seems Shredder is in it, use the worm clone story to revive him? It would be the best of both worlds, an adult oriented TMNT movie and it wouldn't be a re-tread of old ground. |
oh yeah man i totally agree with you. I mean i would have rather seen a sequel to batman and robin and batman forever than have to see the origin of batman RE-HASHED again. I can't say seeing batman put on the cape for the first time again and fight joker again was at all entertaining since we had all seen it so many times... I mean who cares if it totally re-ignited interest in the franchise and restored public opinion of the character in film. I mean whats the point of that? Plus we already saw the origin of batman in the animated series and tim burton's 1989 film so the only logical thing to assume is that re-starting a franchise means we won't see anything new or entertaining to us die hard fans at all. I mean batman begins was just totally the same as the first batman movie:roll:
really? you people who are so concerned with the idea of a re-boot just don't get it do you? |
If you cut out the OT beginning and Raph meeting Casey Jones, and the excursion to the farm, you will hardly have a remake of the first film.
Just as long as they don't spend an hour on the turtles training (10 minute flashback is all you need) and get right into heart of the story, I wouldn't have any problems with an "origin" story. |
Quote:
Look at everything else he posts. This is exactly what TMNT needs. |
I understand why fans might want to see an all-new story building off the previous continuity.
But fans need to understand why the movie franchise needs a reboot. The origin story hasn't been on the big screen for twenty years, the original film was hardly as comic-faithful as people claim it to be, and audiences hate loose sequels. Give them something to wash TMNT 2007 out of their mouths. To say that a re-boot would be exactly the same as the 1990 film is, well, baffling. There is so much to be improved upon or changed. Then, if this movie is successful in sparking interest and changing public opinion of the Turtles, we can move on to better stories like City at War. But that's not a place I, nor any other movie-goer, should see the old movie continuity going. |
I would be happy if it was an exact copy of TMNT 90 with the only change being Donatello acting/sounding like him self.
But really, it has been long enough. And if you still don't want to put up with the origin again, just wait for sequels :) |
I'm not seeing it as a reboot if they do it right. But hell, it's been 20 years, isn't that the standard lately for remakes?
|
As long as it's different enough from the 1990 film, PG-13, and based upon the original source material then I'll be watching.
|
I don't want a remake of TMNT 1, I want an original story, continuing from the last movie.
I hate remakes, they break up the established continuity when there's a series of movies. |
I'm fine with a re-make. "TMNT BEGINS"
|
Origin
Quote:
|
where has it been officially stated that they're going to exclude the TCRI/Triceraton stuff?
|
I don't know
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
If it was a remake of the first film they'd have Danny in it, April as a reporter, April's boss nagging her, and Tatsu.
It's gonna be based off the comics which means Baxter, mousers, and hopefully a foot showdown with all four turtles on a rooftop where the turtles finish off Shredder not Splinter. We haven't seen that yet. The turtles never finished off Shredder themselves in any of the movies. He did himself in in the sequel and Casey and Splinter basically did it in the first film. We've also never seen mousers or Baxter. If they did it right they could do the whole first comic in the first 30 minutes of the film and spend the rest of it introducing April and doing the mouser thing. The sequel could be the set up for Return to New York or they could edit the story down and try to cram it all into a 2 hour movie. |
The (Er...uh...New) TMNT Trilogy!!
1. V1 1-3. 2. Leo's one shot and V1 10. and 3. Return to New York. It's almost like the Star Wars Trilogy....in that TMNT Part 2 is the somber middle chapter, before the Turtles final triumph over the Shredder. |
Quote:
I'd prefer a trilogy if it was based upon the recurring theme of "revenge" in the Mirage comics. If you remember the TMNT fight and kill Shredder in order to take revenge for the murder of Hamato Yoshi (who was actually murdered for revenge himself). Shredder (technically a worm clone) then takes revenge on the TMNT by destroying April's apartment and ruining their lives. The Turtles then have their revenge by assaulting the Foot headquarters and killing the worm cloned Shredder in Return to New York. Then the Elite guards seek revenge on the TMNT during City At War. So my ideal Trilogy would have City At War as the final installment. |
I very much doubt this movie will do well enough to get two sequels. The TMNT fad is long over, and unless this becomes a hit ala Batman: Begins, I just don't see it happening.
We're lucky enough to have this movie as it is. |
The original movie reeks of late 80s/early 90s and the OT mixed in with the comic. Counting the first two parts of the mix is gone its definitely going to feel very different.
Like most here Begins proved that a re-boot and re-telling can be awesome. Now we have very little information and people are taking too literally the first known info. Which is always far from the truth/final product and happens all the time on forums. I'm not too big on the idea of a re-telling but I don't mind it either. I also like continuity so I do wish it was in continuity with the other three live action movies and it could be. But I also understand if it wasn't, and truthfully it being in continuity with the other 3 movies wouldn't help the movie at all story/plot wise besides that the Shredder is defeated, and thats from the first one....Third movie added nothing and second movie is just defeat shredder again. And yeah this movie could definitely do well enough for three movies. Even with the fad gone Transformers got a sequel and will likely get a third. Its also likely GI-Joe is getting a sequel and the fad also died in the 80s. If we're getting a movie it means they think it'll be successful if they didn't they wouldn't be making it. Also TMNT failed to be a huge hit but I remember reading all parties involved were very happy with how it did. |
I'm not really worried that it will be a remake.
I think that there have been enough successful comic book movies in the past year that the studio will let them have a PG-13 rating. It worked for The Dark Knight and whilst I hate the exec logic that "Dark Knight = dark therefore dark = big box office" I think for TMNT it could actually help as long as the script is good. Transformers success will also help them push for PG-13 I can't see them doing a straight adaptation of the early issues. For the simple reason that it would be a cliffhanger ending. It would end with the TMNT defeated and in exile. I'd be all for this for a second movie (like Empire Strikes Back) but that's too big a risk when you're trying to reboot the franchise. I think they'll take a route similar to the new cartoon, start with Purple Dragons (opening of issue 1), then move into issues 2-3/Raph with the intro of April, Baxter, the Mousers and Casey. They could link Baxter and Shredder as they did in the 2k3 cartoon (which would also make the plot seem like 1 story rather than 2 stories just put together) which would lead to the origin and the rooftop battle like in issue 1. AND WE'LL FINALLY GET TMNT VS SHREDDER ON THE BIG SCREEN!!!! Not TMNT beaten and Splinter beating Shredder, not Shredder killing himself by collapsing a dock, the TMNT taking on Shredder and winning! If they get sequels (fingers crossed) they could do the Utrom/Triceraton arc as the second film and if they were feeling brave they could end that film with Shredder's return, the defeat of Leo and the TMNT retreating. The third could then by Return to New York or even a combination of Return to New York/City at War. |
i personally don't want some mouser story..im so sick & tired of mousers, we all know what happens. I'd rather see a continuation and not waste the previous 4 movie's events.
they need a good suspenseful story...hell CAW would be fine. The River events would be fine! |
Channel 6
Quote:
|
Personally, I wouldn't mind if it was a remake of the first one, but it'd be nice to have some changes done with it and to have it a bit more accurate. Basically following the storyline as is in the comics.
As long as it looks good, it will probably be fine unlike the third movie where I know I was pretty irritated with how the turtle suits looked and how the storyline played out (I actually do like the 3rd movie for a few reasons, but I do tend to b*tch about it XD). I dunno - if anything, I'm just happy we're getting another movie. |
Third movie
Quote:
|
If we're getting Mousers then Reboot the shell out of TMNT
|
It's been said that they're aiming to tell a part of the TMNT origin which hasn't been told on film before. I think that sounds very much like TCRI. If they get the right writer and director, this could turn out to be TMNT's answer to Batman Begins.
With some clever thematic structuring and weaving, they could combine the Stockman plot (to introduce April), the TCRI plot (minus Turtles in Space), and the Shredder plot (which would need some fleshing out and intertwining with the other plots in a grand conspiracy sort of way, though not to the extent of making Saki an Utrom as that has been proven to only make the character less interesting) into one movie, ending with the apparent death of the Shredder. An eventual sequel (if greenlit) could more or less adapt Return to New York, and a third installment could be City at War. I see no reason to want a continuation of the established movie continuity, as most of it is quite frankly rather dumb. A proper reboot is exactly what the franchise needs, and there couldn't be a better time for it. Secret of the Ooze was TMNT's Batman Forever, and III was TMNT's Batman & Robin. Only way to really save it is to shake the Etch-A-Sketch and start over and do it right. So let's just hope they do just that. It right. |
I'd structure a trilogy like this:
1) TMNT Origins, April/Baxter/Mouser storyline, Casey is introduced, Foot rule NYC, TMNT confront and kill Shredder 2) Shredder returns and ruins their lives and they flee to Northampton. They struggle with their defeat and there is lots of bickering. Then jump into the Return to New York storyline. Use Leatherhead instead of Zog, since the Triceratons would not fit in here. 3) City At War This follows the main theme of the Mirage continuity: Revenge. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
LOL. Exactly. Instead we will get a film about immortal conquistadors and their 13 monster friends. :lol: |
Quote:
the batman begins had the theme fear, I'd be intresint if they could do more with the revenge thingie in the new movie |
Quote:
Above all else of the hopes I have for this new movie, this is the one I want to see done. I know it's been already adapted in the new cartoon, but a movie could span so much more on it. Some of the most, I think, intense fighting took place there. |
It has been stated that it's going to me the origin movie ( reboot ). Why is everyone still wondering if it's a continuity or not?
Check this link, it stated it right there. http://www.joblo.com/index.php?id=26169 Ron |
Quote:
|
Tcri
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:11 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.