The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   So we are not getting a TMNT 2. Your thoughts? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27070)

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle 04-24-2009 12:45 PM

So we are not getting a TMNT 2. Your thoughts?
 
While I am EXTREMELY excited that a new live-action film is on it's way, I'm a bit sad that Munroe's TMNT won't get a follow up movie. While TMNT wasn't perfect, I did enjoy the animation a lot. Especially the Leonardo vs. Raphael fight. Still quite stunning. The ending gave us a clue that the Shredder would return. And now we'll never really know what Karai meant or what she had in plan for the Turtles from her master. With the new movie being a reboot (meaning the continuity from the first 4 films is now out of the window.) that means the we have a new film universe of the Turtles. I would of liked to see how Munroe would of done in the sequel. Your thoughts?

Dragon Turtle 04-24-2009 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle (Post 687071)
While I am EXTREMELY excited that a new live-action film is on it's way, I'm a bit sad that Munroe's TMNT won't get a follow up movie. While TMNT wasn't perfect, I did enjoy the animation a lot. Especially the Leonardo vs. Raphael fight. Still quite stunning. The ending gave us a clue that the Shredder would return. And now we'll never really know what Karai meant or what she had in plan for the Turtles from her master. With the new movie being a reboot (meaning the continuity from the first 4 films is now out of the window.) that means the we have a new film universe of the Turtles. I would of liked to see how Munroe would of done in the sequel. Your thoughts?


If Mirage is smart, they would just go ahead and release TMNT 2 straight to DVD, it certainly wouldn't cost as much since most of the visual assets currently exists, and it would good way of increasing publicity for the feature film.

ToTheNines 04-24-2009 02:43 PM

I'm kind of sad that it was the only one of its kind, but it wasn't taking the TMNT where it needed to go in the publics eye. Now that comic book characters are being treated seriously on film, we need to go in that direction.

But I agree about the DTV thing.

Candy Kappa 04-24-2009 04:31 PM

the movie had great visual effects and stunning 3D models of the Turtles.
But I don't see it as a big loss not getting a tmnt2

MrPliggins 04-24-2009 04:38 PM

I think Imagi has moved on to other things..not sure they'd be interested. They could sell the models to another company, but it would probably be expensive and not worth it for a direct-to-DVD release.

CyberCubed 04-24-2009 04:46 PM

Yeah, I wouldn't mind seeing a direct-to-DVD CG TMNT movie using the same models from the 4th movie.

I doubt it'd happen, Imagi is in dire straights financially.

Candy Kappa 04-24-2009 04:49 PM

Imagi are working on Astro Boy.
And 3D models can be bought for a fair price, or remake then it aint hard

R-iZZy 04-24-2009 04:59 PM

TMNT just kept the franchise in that childish light that many of us fans have been saying needed to be cut off for a long time. I think Laird has realized treating comic characters seriously is the direction to go. The Dark Knight and Hellboy have done a good job at doing that, and it's being said even the new Superman reboot is going to be a little more serious. TMNT had its chance, but it didn't take it.

Munroe did a good job, not taking anything away from him. But it was, at the end of the day, a movie gearing toward children. In this day and age, the kids are down for grittiness and darkness. You make them happy while at the same time making the more mature audience happy, and you not only have a movie of better quality, but also of better marketability.

TheCanadiandrome 04-24-2009 06:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687146)
Yeah, I wouldn't mind seeing a direct-to-DVD CG TMNT movie using the same models from the 4th movie.

I doubt it'd happen, Imagi is in dire straights financially.

yeah, after how disappointing the first CG movie did in theatres, direct-to-dvd would make sense, but if it doesn't happen, meh, no loss

trustno1 04-24-2009 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle (Post 687071)
While I am EXTREMELY excited that a new live-action film is on it's way, I'm a bit sad that Munroe's TMNT won't get a follow up movie. While TMNT wasn't perfect, I did enjoy the animation a lot. Especially the Leonardo vs. Raphael fight. Still quite stunning. The ending gave us a clue that the Shredder would return. And now we'll never really know what Karai meant or what she had in plan for the Turtles from her master. With the new movie being a reboot (meaning the continuity from the first 4 films is now out of the window.) that means the we have a new film universe of the Turtles. I would of liked to see how Munroe would of done in the sequel. Your thoughts?

personally i did not like TMNT 4 at all. the characterizations of the turtles were good but that was it for me.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-24-2009 06:57 PM

Stone guys
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by trustno1 (Post 687164)
personally i did not like TMNT 4 at all. the characterizations of the turtles were good but that was it for me.

At least, those stone guys will probably be gone.

sdp 04-25-2009 01:36 AM

TMNT did a lot of things wrong but it also did a lot of things right.


I LOVED the character designs and thought the CGI was beautiful and love the movies Universe. I am very sad that we won't get to see this version of the turtles ever again. So here were my thoughts since the movie came out:

Didn't Monroe mention they originally planned for a DTV of an adaptation of comic #1 as a prequel when the movie came out? I would have LOVED that and its a shame it was scrapped.

I was sad when Monroe wasn't going to be in the sequel shortly after had come out since I wanted to see more of the MonroeTMNT-verse, and a sequel wouldn't be that.

We got word that there wouldn't be a new Imagi TMNT movie at least it didn't look like it but they were hoping that a new movie would come out and it'd be a live action/cgi hybrid. during this time its when we were revealed that they had rejected a Imagi TMNT sequel that would have been more lighthearted and comedy based. People were happy that it was rejected. However after it seemed there wouldn't be a new TMNT movie at all not cgi and not live action, I really regretted that we didn't get the more comedy based sequel since I would have rather seen another movie with those characters and another TMNT movie than nothing.

Also around this time is when we thought of a DTV and while it would have looked worse and a step-down, I would have wanted it anyway. By this time we also knew all the bad things happening at Imagi and not just them loosing trouble but getting rid of a bunch of people that were working on their movies and replaced them with people who instead of trying to make the best movie would cut costs to their liking more. Things with Imagi definitely didn't look good even if a sequel were to happen.


Then we saw the Imagi TMNT 2 poster with SHredder in the background and mikey kneeling with his unmutated turtles. I was Pissed that we would never see this or a sequel.




So yeah, I would LOVE to see a sequel/more of the CGI turtles. However As much as I like it I do prefer the live-action movie sequel. So while its sad I don't mind it as much since it was replaced by something better instead of something worse or nothing.

Aztec General 04-25-2009 08:45 AM

What I liked about the CGI film:

1) CGI was mostly excellent
2) Inclusion of Karai and post-Shredder Foot
3) Tensions between the family
4) Action was decent


What I didn't like:

1) The main story of the film was TERRIBLE! I mean seriously, 13 monsters to help an ancient Conquistador and his stone friends? As if that wasn't enough the monsters went on to play ZERO significance in the rest of the film. Just awful. How high was Peter when he approved this script?
2) The humans (Casey, April, Karai in particular) were way to skinny and bizarre looking.

I'm all about story and characters when I watch a movie. The characters were treated with respect but the story was so god awful that I just didn't care. I'm glad that Munroe isn't getting a chance to touch these characters again.

Mr._Mutant_Man 04-25-2009 09:06 AM

I'm okay with there not being a second CGI movie. The 2007 movie was okay, but it didn't amaze me. There were some good scenes, but I agree with the Nostalgia Critic that there are times when I forget that I'm watching a movie about the Ninja Turtles.

I didn't like some of the design all that much. April was way too skinny. Looked like she needed to hang out with the turtles more to fatten up on pizza or something.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-25-2009 10:32 AM

Cgi
 
I have no problems with CGI. Just the story of the 2007 "TMNT" film.

NiNi 04-25-2009 04:22 PM

I would've liked to have seen a CGI TMNT movie done at least ONE more time. Granted that the storyline wasn't the greatest in the 2007 film, it had potential; especially with the character models and overall scenery.

junkboy 04-25-2009 05:47 PM

Visually 4th movie was good.
But i did not like the plot. The main story was something like a side story in my opinion. Or in the quality of just a side story. While i enjoy it everytime i watch, it's just that.
I would be happy to see a direct to DVD sequal tho.
The first CGI just left off at a dirty point, i want to know more.

NinjaVanish 04-25-2009 07:28 PM

I enjoyed the TMNT movie, but much like the majority, I did not really like the "plot". A Shredder-less TMNT movie proves to be unexciting.

I did feel though that the main point of the movie was to reunite the turtles once again from their strained relationship and I actually thought the story of capturing monsters for an immortal human being was more of a "filler" and somehow the way to get April and Casey involved. The clash between Raph and Leo was essentially the best thing about the movie.

A straight to DVD of TMNT2 would be nice though, just to fullfill the theory of Shredder's return.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-26-2009 08:25 AM

Plot
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NinjaVanish (Post 687423)
I enjoyed the TMNT movie, but much like the majority, I did not really like the "plot". A Shredder-less TMNT movie proves to be unexciting.

I did feel though that the main point of the movie was to reunite the turtles once again from their strained relationship and I actually thought the story of capturing monsters for an immortal human being was more of a "filler" and somehow the way to get April and Casey involved. The clash between Raph and Leo was essentially the best thing about the movie.

A straight to DVD of TMNT2 would be nice though, just to fullfill the theory of Shredder's return.

The 2007 movie was the second TMNT movie in a row that very many of us disliked. Time to break this chain.

Donny 04-26-2009 09:24 AM

I was actually looking forward to a TMNT 2, hoping for an awesome return of the Shredder. It could have been interesting to see how Munroe would have handled that. So I would not be sad if we got a dtv TMNT 2 :)
But then again, I am also excited about the new movie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 687258)
Then we saw the Imagi TMNT 2 poster with SHredder in the background and mikey kneeling with his unmutated turtles. I was Pissed that we would never see this or a sequel.

Do you have a link? I have never seen that.

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle 04-26-2009 09:46 AM

http://img27.imageshack.us/img27/2839/tmnt2.jpg

Trying to locate what Peter said in his blog about this. I can't find it. I just remember him saying that the concept didn't really fly with him.

Donny 04-26-2009 09:57 AM

That poster looks so great! Now I am really thrilled to see how that movie could turn out.
But then again...if Peter dismissed it, I am sure he has a good reason. A cool poster does not equal a good story of course. But still; it does looks interesting.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-26-2009 03:15 PM

The poster rocks
 
The poster rocks

Ginny 05-08-2009 04:23 PM

That would be great if they'd release TMNT 2 as a DTV release. I'm hoping that they might do it as we get closer to the new movie.

Andrew NDB 05-08-2009 05:01 PM

Good riddence to bad garbage.

OK, that's a little bit harsh. But I'm certainly happy this particular "vision" of TMNT on the big screen is getting the book shut on it.

Tuxedo Moroboshi 05-08-2009 06:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 687076)
If Mirage is smart, they would just go ahead and release TMNT 2 straight to DVD, it certainly wouldn't cost as much since most of the visual assets currently exists, and it would good way of increasing publicity for the feature film.

I agree with this for the most part... but if that poster was really going to be the story, then ugh. I like Mikey, but I'm not sure I could stand to see him as the star. Maybe if they made him a little more like in the comics (i.e. toned down his "party-dude" personality considerably), then maybe I could see it happening without being really annoying.

Andrew NDB 05-09-2009 12:42 AM

That poster about sums up my worst fears had TMNT Part 5 gone forward in that.

http://www.myinrich.com/images/uploads/92571_judge.jpg

Some kind of hyper-exaggerated comical Judge Doom Shredder pitted against Michelangelo going around on hijinks to restore all the other TMNT and Splinter just in time for a toothless final battle, I'm sure.

Monte Williams 05-10-2009 05:40 PM

I'd much prefer a sequel to TMNT, even a direct-to-DVD sequel, than a live action adaptation of the first comic, which is a clunky, awkward, boring story.

ToTheNines 05-10-2009 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monte Williams (Post 691274)
I'd much prefer a sequel to TMNT, even a direct-to-DVD sequel, than a live action adaptation of the first comic, which is a clunky, awkward, boring story.

You know they'll refine and add to it, they're not just gonna adapt issue one and be done with it.

Andrew NDB 05-10-2009 10:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monte Williams (Post 691274)
than a live action adaptation of the first comic, which is a clunky, awkward, boring story.

Turn in your TMNT fan card. Turn it in now.

And anyone automatically thinking that an adaption of the first comic must slavishly follow it to the letter in the same sort of narrative is incredibly short-sighted and without imagination. Within 5 minutes, I can draw up ideas for how to spin a rough adaption of the first comic in wildly different ways.

Monte Williams 05-10-2009 11:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 691341)
And anyone automatically thinking that an adaption of the first comic must slavishly follow it to the letter in the same sort of narrative is incredibly short-sighted and without imagination.


Perhaps. Or perhaps such a person is simply observant; it's histrionic fans like you that have led to the creation of such stilted, lifeless, literal-minded adaptations as Sin City and Watchmen.

And I find it ironic that someone who is so sickened at the childish direction of the franchise demands that someone "turn in your fan card" for disagreeing with you about a given issue of a comic book.

Andrew NDB 05-11-2009 12:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monte Williams (Post 691375)
And I find it ironic that someone who is so sickened at the childish direction of the franchise demands that someone "turn in your fan card" for disagreeing with you about a given issue of a comic book.

Except that said "given issue of a comic book" happens to be the very first, and the genesis of everything TMNT that followed.

Though you're certainly entitled to your opinion.

TristanHuwJones 05-11-2009 01:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monte Williams (Post 691274)
I'd much prefer a sequel to TMNT, even a direct-to-DVD sequel, than a live action adaptation of the first comic, which is a clunky, awkward, boring story.

You do realise that the first Ninja Turtles movie was an adaptation of the very first comic, don't you?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monte Williams (Post 691375)
Perhaps. Or perhaps such a person is simply observant; it's histrionic fans like you that have led to the creation of such stilted, lifeless, literal-minded adaptations as Sin City and Watchmen.

But if that person were truly observant they'd take note of the fact that there is enough in Watchmen and Sin City to make a complete, legible film and that each one of those "graphic novels" those films are based on are made up of a number of comics telling complete arcs -- not a single forty page book. And if it weren't for "histrionic fans" the recent Batman films would've been significantly different, as would the X-men movies, the Hulk reboot wouldn't've happened, Iron Man probably wouldn't be anywhere near as good as it was, we wouldn't be getting a Deadpool movie, or Green Lantern and Superman wouldn't be getting a much needed make-over.

Sorry, but to even assume that anyone would make a direct comic to film translation of TMNT #1 is incredibly naive, especially when, as I said, it's already been done and quite successfully at that.

willtupper 05-11-2009 02:14 AM

Wasn't it more like issue 1, issue 3 (the idea of Splinter being abducted), Raphael #1 (Casey & Raph), issue 4 (kind of - Splinter being rescued, at least), Leonardo #1, issue #10, and issue #11 (Turtle defeated, team beaten, flee to the farm, regroup and kick butt?)?

To say it was just an adaption of just the very first comic is a bit of a stretch.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 691384)
You do realise that the first Ninja Turtles movie was an adaptation of the very first comic, don't you?


Andrew NDB 05-11-2009 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by willtupper (Post 691390)
Wasn't it more like issue 1, issue 3 (the idea of Splinter being abducted), Raphael #1 (Casey & Raph), issue 4 (kind of - Splinter being rescued, at least), Leonardo #1, issue #10, and issue #11 (Turtle defeated, team beated, flee to the farm, regroup and kick butt?)?

To say it was just an adaption of just the very first comic is a bit of a stretch.

I wouldn't say the first movie was an adaption of anything. I'd say it was "inspired" by the issues Will mentions here.

willtupper 05-11-2009 02:19 AM

Also (sorry for double-post), wasn't there originally a plan to do a direct-to-DVD release in conjunction w / the 25th anniversary that was just going to be a "direct comic to film translation of TMNT #1," financed by Mirage Studios, w / script by Steve Murphy?

I remember reading something like that on his blog, way back in the day.

Jeez, Tristan. Do you not even follow the Turtles at all? :P

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 691384)
Sorry, but to even assume that anyone would make a direct comic to film translation of TMNT #1 is incredibly naive, especially when, as I said, it's already been done and quite successfully at that.


TristanHuwJones 05-11-2009 03:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by willtupper (Post 691392)
Also (sorry for double-post), wasn't there originally a plan to do a direct-to-DVD release in conjunction w / the 25th anniversary that was just going to be a "direct comic to film translation of TMNT #1," financed by Mirage Studios, w / script by Steve Murphy?

I remember reading something like that on his blog, way back in the day.

Jeez, Tristan. Do you not even follow the Turtles at all? :P

I remember Murph saying something along those lines, but I mean a verbatim remake, like Psycho to Psycho, but without the masturbation(... or maybe not?). But I see your point, so I'll rephrase -- to say assume that anyone would make a live-action direct translation of the comic is incredibly naive. You look at the movies out there, and their source material, not one of them has come from any one book, rather a multitude of stories. For today's audiences, you would have to tweak just about everything to varying capacities for it (#1) to fly in a general capacity.

Also...
Quote:

Wasn't it more like issue 1, issue 3 (the idea of Splinter being abducted), Raphael #1 (Casey & Raph), issue 4 (kind of - Splinter being rescued, at least), Leonardo #1, issue #10, and issue #11 (Turtle defeated, team beaten, flee to the farm, regroup and kick butt?)?

To say it was just an adaption of just the very first comic is a bit of a stretch.
You're right, but I just said it was an adaptation. #1 was still in there, and it worked... It just jammed those extra parts in before they actually faced down the Shredder properly.

willtupper 05-11-2009 07:05 AM

Okay. I buy that.

In the first movie, plot point A and plot point Z were definitely from that first issue. Kind of a skeletal frame that they put all those other issue's "meat" on.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 691398)
You're right, but I just said it was an adaptation. #1 was still in there, and it worked... It just jammed those extra parts in before they actually faced down the Shredder properly.


Dragon Turtle 05-11-2009 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle (Post 687545)
Trying to locate what Peter said in his blog about this. I can't find it. I just remember him saying that the concept didn't really fly with him.


Well, I now have some info about how this art came to be, courtesy of Galen Walker, producer on last year's TMNT movie, who recently gave me a very nice copy of this same piece of art, printed on canvas. According to Galen, this art was created by an artist named Sam Michlap, who painted it after hearing a pitch about a possible TMNT movie sequel by some creative folks at Imagi. The pitch apparently involved a plot idea which had three of the Turtles affected by an anti-mutation serum, and only Michelangelo was left unaffected... and the only one who could save his brothers.

Just to be clear -- while I really like the art and I very much appreciate the fact that there were people at Imagi who were still interested in the Turtles enough to be discussing this stuff, this is not the direction we will be heading in for the next movie. -- PL


Quote:

Originally Posted by willtupper (Post 691392)
Also (sorry for double-post), wasn't there originally a plan to do a direct-to-DVD release in conjunction w / the 25th anniversary that was just going to be a "direct comic to film translation of TMNT #1," financed by Mirage Studios, w / script by Steve Murphy?


Due to costs and the uncertainty of Imagi being unable to deliver the picture this year, the project was canceled. The idea was to produce an A and B version of the first comic, one version would be a straight forward adaption while the other was to have extra content (most likely involving Mikey and Don who get little face time in issue #1). Mirage decided to go with the less expensive 4Kids DTV as their major media promotion instead.

Dan 05-11-2009 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 691341)
Within 5 minutes, I can draw up ideas for how to spin a rough adaption of the first comic in wildly different ways.

Well it's been more than five minutes where are your ideas?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.