The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   What was wrong with the 4th movie? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27078)

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 10:41 AM

What was wrong with the 4th movie?
 
I'm noticing a lot of recent disdain for it, and I want to know, why? Yes, it didn't break new ground and it was essentially a movie for kids and fans of the franchise, but I don't see what was wrong with it.

The movie was barely about the 13 monsters, it was mostly about the Turtles splitting away as a family and getting back together toward the end. This is why most of the monster stuff aside from two (Bigfoot, and Jersey Devil), all happened quickly and off-screen.

In the review threads for this movie, it was heavily praised. (You can check the poll on it at the top of this forum, just to see those old posts about peoples reaction to the movie).

Thoughts?

Cure 04-25-2009 10:46 AM

It was boring and uninteresting, simple as that.

Ron 04-25-2009 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCure (Post 687325)
It was boring and uninteresting, simple as that.

X2.

Ron

sdp 04-25-2009 11:26 AM

I was going to make this topic but you beat me to it....Its really divided into two things:

What went wrong with the movie for me?

Kevin Monroe: He hyped the movie way too much in the forums. I loved that he posted here but he made me get huge unrealistic expectations based on
his posts.

The teaser: The teaser was amazing, it confirmed everything Kevin Monroe was saying was true which the movie wasn't.

Too much plot: Why set up the whole 13 monsters thing when they were pretty much not used, such a waste of time on something that wasn't fully used and anything with them felt like it was thrown to make us not forget about it. The foot was awesome but it added to the cluster of things the movie was already doing.


I liked the movie and I think its a good but it failed to be an amazing movie and one of the greatest TMNT stories like I(we were) was led to believe. And it failed to get me all excited about the TMNT after I saw it.

Doc_ock_4mugen 04-25-2009 11:28 AM

Most of the monster hunt part was boring, the only pat that I think that was awesome was the Leo/Raph fight... also No Shredder... Most people hate the Shredder-less films... And the artistic look of the non-turtle characters is kinda bothersome to some people... at least to me... I hate when people look like the offspring of Stick figures and Tetris blocks.

sdp 04-25-2009 11:36 AM

What went wrong with the movie for the general audience?


-CG, people wanted live action as CGI movies are still viewed as something for kids.

-No Shredder, It doesn't matter what people on this forum think to most of the TMNT fans, TMNT is the turtles and shredder.

-Too different from the OT, this movie is more like the new show than the old and people didn't like that.

-The movie is far from a great movie, its a decent film and a good TMNT story but it wasn't what people wanted. In fact everything in the movie was what people didn't associate the turtles with.

-TV spots and trailers were definitely geared for kids.


The movie had a lot of hype among the general audience and it started to decline more and more.

Aztec General 04-25-2009 01:55 PM

The main storyline (immortal Conqusitadors, 13 monsters, rock soldeirs, etc.) was nonsensical, stupid, uninteresting, underused, and just plain awful. I have no idea why Peter Laird approved this trash. Perhaps an unknown like Kevin Munroe was all he could afford to hire?

Cipher 04-25-2009 02:12 PM

Wasted opportunity (any mainstream Turtles fiction that doesn't up the ante hurts the franchise). Inconsistant tone. Unnecessary self-cencorship. Nonsensical, incoherrent plot.

Pick your poison. It did look pretty, though.

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 687352)
The main storyline (immortal Conqusitadors, 13 monsters, rock soldeirs, etc.) was nonsensical, stupid, uninteresting, underused, and just plain awful. I have no idea why Peter Laird approved this trash. Perhaps an unknown like Kevin Munroe was all he could afford to hire?

That kind of plot is very similar to stuff we see in the Mirage comics all the time.

Maybe it wasn't best to use that plot for a theatrical movie, but that plot isn't any different than all the sci-fi or monster stuff in the Mirage comic universe.

Cipher 04-25-2009 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687360)
Maybe it wasn't best to use that plot for a theatrical movie, but that plot isn't any different than all the sci-fi or monster stuff in the Mirage comic universe.

It's not that it wasn't realistic, it's that it was sloppy. You can't plug thirteen monsters, an evil corporation, and ninja rivalries into an hour and twenty minutes. The fact that we didn't even see all the monsters shows how asinine that plotline was.

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 687365)
The fact that we didn't even see all the monsters shows how asinine that plotline was.

I thought that was the point, the monsters were not the main focus on the movie, the focus was on the four brothers drifting apart (although mostly Leo and Raph), and the monsters were just to move the story along.

Did you really want to see them track down all 13 monsters in the film? I thought the way they did it was perfect, because if you stop to think about it, the movie wasn't "let's catch all the monsters ala Pokemon" like some people make it out to be.

I have some problems with the movies pacing itself, but the actual plot was no more ridiculous than what goes on in the Mirage universe half the time.

sdp 04-25-2009 04:07 PM

The plot isn't necessarily out there for the TMNT however people were not expecting that. Even if the OT dealt a lot with sci-fi, magic etc. People don't expect that when they think of the turtles, they think of shredder and mutations.


Yeah the movie tried to do too much and its all clustered up in the movie.


It doesn't deserve the hate it gets definitely though. It was still a disappointment.

NiNi 04-25-2009 04:08 PM

I like the 4th movie, but it did have some issues in my opinion.

Mainly it was the storyline. I mean they had to collect 13 monsters and such - you'd think that'd be more like something for a cartoon season if anything else. It was just a plot-line that didn't seem to work as a full length feature film.

Plus there was also the fact that Mikey and Don hardly had any screentime - that was a factor.

And that there seemed to be a wee bit more talking than action. Don't get me wrong, I love the dialogue in the movie when it was something meaningful - like when Splinter talks to Raph about the concept of favorite son/student.

Visually the movie was gorgeous, the voices were great, but it just seemed...like a rush job with the plotline.

Rooish 04-25-2009 04:46 PM

I think the problem was that it was sort of an inexplicably inconsistent movie. It didn't work as a kids' movie (too dark at times), it didn't work as an adults' movie (too short, the jokes were too lame, the dramatic parts seemed rushed and corny), and it tried to cram in too much in too short a time. If they'd just stuck with Munroe's original script, which was better fleshed out and longer, it would have been much better. It seems that nearly every joke from Munroe's original script was shortened or tamed just slightly, making them fall flat, almost without exception. It wasn't funny! The theatre was full when I went, and no one laughed. It was silent! The only time I laughed was the Gilmore Girls gag, and Mike bringing his Cowabunga Carl head out at the end. I cringed a lot more than I laughed, or cried for that matter.

It was hyperactive; there were too many plot-lines to follow, so none of them got fully developed. Max Winters and the monsters had nothing, absolutely nothing, to do with the Turtles. Any sort of deep meaning that could be derived from it--such as Winters' attempts to achieve immortality--could not be tied in with the Turtles. I'm not saying that the movie needed a deep plot, but since it tried to be deep, it could have been consistent about it.

Both Winters and the Foot/Karai seemed like two completely unrelated extra plots. Didn't give enough time for the Turtles plot

The Turtles plot was okay, but I suspect that people who weren't really familiar with the conflicts between the Turtles (because all they knew were the old toon Turtles) must have been really confused by how unhappy the family seemed. Mike and Don were barely in the movie, and Leo and Raph acted like little bitches. Raph took over the movie for no clear reason, since he acted like a jerk the whole time and didn't improve (and Leo was no better).

I just watched it and felt that it wasn't a very good movie because it was too short and inconsistent. All it really worked as was an action/adventure, but in all other respects--drama, humour, character development, universal appeal, or consistency--it didn't work. I found it frustrating to watch because it could have been a lot more. Nice animation though!

Cipher 04-25-2009 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687367)
Did you really want to see them track down all 13 monsters in the film? I thought the way they did it was perfect, because if you stop to think about it, the movie wasn't "let's catch all the monsters ala Pokemon" like some people make it out to be.

That's all fine, but if you're not going to invest time into the thirteen monsters, don't put the thirteen monsters into the film. It's writing 101.

Aztec General 04-25-2009 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 687382)
That's all fine, but if you're not going to invest time into the thirteen monsters, don't put the thirteen monsters into the film. It's writing 101.

LOL. Exactly. What was the point if they weren't going to do anything with it? Can anyone tell me why those monsters needed to be in the film to begin with? Aside from possible cute looking toys?

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 687388)
LOL. Exactly. What was the point if they weren't going to do anything with it? Can anyone tell me why those monsters needed to be in the film to begin with? Aside from possible cute looking toys?

So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?

Candy Kappa 04-25-2009 05:36 PM

loved the visuals, the cgi was amazing, but its seems like everyone is trying to do the same style, pixar, dreamworks and imagi
but the story was weak and bad written, the movie was way too short (and they edited away scenes)

Aztec General 04-25-2009 05:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687390)
So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?

What does any of that have to do with the TMNT? Who cares? 13 Monsters breaks the curse of immortality? What an incredibly stupid plot device! Why even bother having the TMNT in a movie about this?

You are free to your own opinion of course...but my lord the storyline was GOD AWFUL! Peter Laird must have been smoking some funky stuff when he approved this garbage.

Candy Kappa 04-25-2009 05:44 PM

i find most of the stuff in his review true, I disagree on the splinter part thought

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/vid...itic/6246-tmnt

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 687393)
What does any of that have to do with the TMNT? Who cares? 13 Monsters breaks the curse of immortality? What an incredibly stupid plot device! Why even bother having the TMNT in a movie about this?

So wait, in other words in order for something "having to do with TMNT," it has to constantly be about Shredder and the Foot, or the big-name villains like Baxter, Rat King, etc...?

Again, how is this different than the random one-shot monsters or aliens they face in the Mirage universe? And whether you like it or not, those characters are now canon TMNT characters.

Quote:

Peter Laird must have been smoking some funky stuff when he approved this garbage.
If Peter Laird thought the movie script was bad, he wouldn't have bothered to spend all that time on it.

Cure 04-25-2009 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687411)
So wait, in other words in order for something "having to do with TMNT," it has to constantly be about Shredder and the Foot, or the big-name villains like Baxter, Rat King, etc...?

Again, how is this different than the random one-shot monsters or aliens they face in the Mirage universe? And whether you like it or not, those characters are now canon TMNT characters.



If Peter Laird thought the movie script was bad, he wouldn't have bothered to spend all that time on it.

OK, you asked and got your answer. What's the point of disputing it with everyone when you got what you wanted?

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCure (Post 687426)
OK, you asked and your got answer. What's the point of disputing it with everyone when you got what you wanted?

Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.

Despite the fact it had the Turtles, Splinter, Casey, April, Karai and the Foot.

I bet if this movie had come out directly to DVD, and wasn't a theatrical release, people would just accept it for what it was.

ToTheNines 04-25-2009 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687428)
Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.

Because a theatrical release is a big ****in deal. No one except fans read the comic, so when aliens show up in issue 32 of tales, no one gives a ****. But when it's a movie, everyone sees it... it's a hell of a lot longer... and it takes bunches a money to make. So you don't want to **** it up, you make it as good as possible.

CyberCubed 04-25-2009 09:27 PM

The movie has some problems, but its not a disaster. As said, if this wasn't a theatrical release, I bet half the people complaining about it just wouldn't care.

Dragon Turtle 04-26-2009 04:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687428)
Because now the bizarre notion that "this movie barely had anything to do with TMNT" came up. Apparently despite monsters/aliens/robots whatever appearing in Mirage canon comics all the time, (not even counting the cartoons), it's somehow "not TMNT" for a movie.

Just like CGI vs live-action, or whether or not the movie reflected any particular version of TMNT, some people will not like sci-sf and fantansy elements, but those elements are as much as part of TMNT then anything else. It's all subjective.

As to what I feel were the shortcomings of the 4th movie:

1) Lack of action: There just wasn't enough action in the movie to appeal to casual non-turtle fans, who are not going to a movie theater to watch a movie that wasn't going to wow them. Even the fight between Leo and Raph, while technically beautiful, was short and vanilla. With the CGI medium you could have crafted set pieces that live-action could never hope to achieve.


2) Underdeveloped plot: Immortals? 13 monsters? Honestly, the premise was no more stupid then most TMNT plots, including the first movie, the difference being is how much those plots are developed. Max Winters, the stone warriors, and the monsters are barely seen throughout the film. I would compare the way they were handled in the same way Ghostbusters handled the Gozer plot, but unlike TMNT, there is more to the story then just Gozer.
The other major plot point (Leo and Raph) also feels short and somewhat contrived.

TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Personally, I was not a huge fan of the human character designs, Matsuda's designs might work better for 2d animation, but his simple cartoonish designs didn't work for me here.


Still TMNT was a good movie, pretty much on par with the first one.

Kendamu 04-26-2009 05:12 AM

I didn't hate it by any means. In fact, I had fun! However, I read the novel before I watched the movie, so I had slightly different expectations based on what I imagined. Not a huge problem, though.

My only really big gripe is that the TMNT vs. Foot Ninja scene outside of Winters' tower was waaaaaay to short! If that scene had been even only twice as long (about two minutes) I would've been happy and it would've been my favorite part!

Overall, I think the fourth movie is probably my second-favorite of the four. I don't like the third movie and I can only take so much Vanilla Ice before I have to stay away from the second movie for awhile due to it's climax.

Really, if there's anything I can say that can improve future TMNT movies, is that there needs to be more Ninja battles and less magic warriors fighting monsters. Considering where the new movie is supposed to be going, I think I'll get my wish in a couple years.

Candy Kappa 04-26-2009 05:35 AM

I also didn't like the scene shooting, like in the foot fight, it did hardly contain any editing, it was like watching a game not a movie.
like in advent children, they had camera angles and views that can't be done in live movies and it look amazing.

while tmnt it looked like they just made the camera view follow around in the 3d program, render it and they just went "that was quick, lets keep that"

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-26-2009 08:00 AM

The plot
 
The plot. I hated those stone generals and Raphael being so violent. The best TMNT story with one leaving the other is the 1987 cartoon's "Take Me to Your Leader".

Cipher 04-26-2009 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 687390)
So the Generals had something to hunt down? So Winters could break his curse of immortality?

Without the monsters, what would Winters be trying to do?

I'm going to try to explain this very slowly. Again.

The monsters may have been integrated (somewhat) into the plot. But the fact is that all of those plot points could be tied together with something less cumbersome than thirteen (unseen) monsters. Hell, just put one or two monsters in the movie for the Generals to hunt down, if you really, really have to have them in there at all.

I don't have a problem with supernatural elements (although the Turtles do need to have a more serious tale on the big-screen). It was just sloppy, awful writing.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-26-2009 03:02 PM

Science fiction
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 687505)
Just like CGI vs live-action, or whether or not the movie reflected any particular version of TMNT, some people will not like sci-sf and fantansy elements, but those elements are as much as part of TMNT then anything else. It's all subjective.

As to what I feel were the shortcomings of the 4th movie:

1) Lack of action: There just wasn't enough action in the movie to appeal to casual non-turtle fans, who are not going to a movie theater to watch a movie that wasn't going to wow them. Even the fight between Leo and Raph, while technically beautiful, was short and vanilla. With the CGI medium you could have crafted set pieces that live-action could never hope to achieve.


2) Underdeveloped plot: Immortals? 13 monsters? Honestly, the premise was no more stupid then most TMNT plots, including the first movie, the difference being is how much those plots are developed. Max Winters, the stone warriors, and the monsters are barely seen throughout the film. I would compare the way they were handled in the same way Ghostbusters handled the Gozer plot, but unlike TMNT, there is more to the story then just Gozer.
The other major plot point (Leo and Raph) also feels short and somewhat contrived.

TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Personally, I was not a huge fan of the human character designs, Matsuda's designs might work better for 2d animation, but his simple cartoonish designs didn't work for me here.


Still TMNT was a good movie, pretty much on par with the first one.

I like some science fiction, the entire concept of four turtles mutating is already still science fiction, but not fantasy. Fantasy belongs to fantasy movies/stories (like the Lord of the Rings, Mio, My Mio, the Brothers Lionheart, Willow, and even He-Man has some fantasy in it).

Buslady 04-26-2009 05:31 PM

The good: CGI, family element, mako, raph was hot

the bad: story was bland.

basically that's it. the main story line was weak, it was so run of the mill bland...yay monsters. How zzzzzzzzz.........

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-27-2009 05:08 PM

Cgi
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Buslady (Post 687638)
The good: CGI, family element, mako, raph was hot

the bad: story was bland.

basically that's it. the main story line was weak, it was so run of the mill bland...yay monsters. How zzzzzzzzz.........

I agree on CGI. Maybe they should test it more. But classic animation is what I like best.

gobo 04-27-2009 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed
What was wrong with the 4th movie?

No resonance. It wasn't bad by any means, but it wasn't very memorable.

Ralphmacchio 04-27-2009 06:04 PM

I'd rather watch the third one then this film.

Yes, I'd rather watch a paper thin story about the Turtles time traveling back to feudal japan then watch this. The story had no pacing, no character development, very uninteresting plot points. The back story of the bad guy was really dumb. Just a really uneven and easily forgotten movie. The Ralp-Leo fight was good but that's about it. If we are going to be fans, then we should be able to criticize.

BoggleKng 04-27-2009 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 687513)
I didn't hate it by any means. In fact, I had fun! However, I read the novel before I watched the movie, so I had slightly different expectations based on what I imagined. Not a huge problem, though.

The movie comic was a bit better and more involved.. The movie didn't totally stick as much as the 3rd one.... I found myself chuckling art Raph's one liners but that was about it.. kinda hard for people to pick up TMNT from it if they haven't been previously introduced..

Spitfire 04-27-2009 10:53 PM

It fell apart in the second act and only a few scenes really grabbed me.

Andrew NDB 04-28-2009 02:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 687505)
TMNT felt like a movie missing it's third act, although it should be noted that about 40 minutes was cut from the final version.

Nonsense. Unless there is a ton of establishing shots that didn't make the final cut, 98% of the movie we got is the movie that was in Munroe's script.

And to ask what was wrong with the movie? I'm being very honest, but I think an easier question to pose would be what wasn't wrong with it... to answer that question, maybe... eh... I guess the Turtles' CGI was pretty decent? Except for Mikey? A couple of the family/unity moments worked well, too, even if they seemed like they belonged in a better Turtles movie.

Dragon Turtle 04-28-2009 02:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 688113)
Nonsense. Unless there is a ton of establishing shots that didn't make the final cut, 98% of the movie we got is the movie that was in Munroe's script.

Just going by what Monroe said on the dvd and other places, the movie was around two hours long before cutdowns, and only a third of what was deleted made it to the dvd.

Andrew NDB 04-28-2009 02:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 688116)
Just going by what Monroe said on the dvd and other places, the movie was around two hours long before cutdowns, and only a third of what was deleted made it to the dvd.

That simply isn't true. At best, grossly exaggerated.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.