The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Fan Input: How Much Should They Listen? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27109)

Archon_Turtle 04-27-2009 06:39 PM

Fan Input: How Much Should They Listen?
 
Original Link: http://gogreenmachine.wordpress.com/...d-they-listen/

Quote:

Snakes on a Plane, Transformers, Star Trek…More and more we are seeing people making big budget movies, turning their ear to the fans.

Snakes On A Plane won a tremendous amount of popularity via the Internets when it launched a huge viral marketing campaign. New Line won major kudos when they even extended shooting a full 5 days to incorporate fan suggestions into the script. The film grossed $62 million worldwide, nearly double the budget.

While not as tremendous a risk, Transformers held a content via their website to incorporate a “one-liner” for Optimus Prime. The film grossed $708 million worldwide.

So is the trend. Hollywood using the best free resource they have, the fans, to the advantage of their film.

The question I pose is this:

With the recent greelight of “Turtles 5″, do you think Legendary should solicite fan input for the film? If so, how much? Who’s vision should the film be ultimately? How receptive should the creative forces like Peter Laird be to the input of the community? Look around online, the fans are already seething with suggestions. Do you think they could make a better movie with or without them? Could too much fan involvement topple a project? These are all interesting questions…You should answer some! COMMENT!

Kendamu 04-27-2009 06:47 PM

It's already been stated in variety that the exec producer thinks that the first dozen or so issues of the original comic are the best source material. Plus, in that recent interview with Peter Laird he mentions stories that are close to the hearts of fans (which include a lot of that stuff from the first dozen or so issues). I think they're already going in a decent direction without the fans direct input. I think they're fine without our direct input. However, having some sort of event like the one for Transformers would be pretty cool.

EDIT: Actually, I hope fan input does happen. I'd love to see Tristan's idea about red bandanas early on that become colored ones later so April and Casey can tell them apart would be freakin' awesome. Fan input is probably the only way it'll happen.

Machias Banshee 04-27-2009 09:42 PM

*quotes herself from GGM.org*

Hm… It’s a bit of a double-edged sword.

On one hand, you have a talented(probably school-educated) creative team that’s taking a very popular franchise and trying to show it in a fresh new light. New technologies, new ways to portray characters… All under the creator’s watchful eye. No un-canonly behaviors, no odd-ball storylines that don’t make sense.

But on the other, who better to get feedback from than the people who live and breathe this stuff? Fans can give a myriad of perspectives on everything from character portrayals to what a NYC sewer actually looks like (Seriously, there are some…).

Part of me says that the fans have to be treated with some discretion. Sure, they can give input - but it’s ultimately how the Creator wants his creations to be portrayed. And there’s questions to consider when it comes to input:

  1. Which fans do you speak to? Do you take a massive survey for ideas, or do you speak to a few more articulate members?

  2. Which universe would the fans prefer? Mirage, Old Toon, Image, Old movies, TMNT, Archies, New Toon…. There’s some versions of fan-made TMNT that would make your toes curl, and probably horrify the general masses.

  3. How much of the fan’s suggestions would be used? The creative team are being PAID to create. If they want to create something, should they have to pass it first through the fans? I don’t think so…


In taking so much from the fans, there’s the potential set up for an incredible amount of letdown. On one day, the fans could be parading the writers around in a jeweled throne - the next day, they could be hanging the guys in the village square with piano wire. It’s a tricky balance, plus… you lose that sense of “Oh what’s it gonna be like?!”. Who wants to see a movie when you know Every little tiny thing that happens? It kills the suspense…

While I would love to be able to give input on the movie (I DID take those screenwriting courses… :P ), I have faith in the writers’ and the creators’ ability to create a new ‘universe’ to enthrall fans both young and old.

CyberCubed 04-27-2009 09:57 PM

Just as long as fans don't influence it TOO much. Some fan input is ok, but they should do what they want to do and what Peter Laird wants to do.

gobo 04-27-2009 10:32 PM

I say no. Were we to get a single chance at fan-input, it would likely be from some casual fan of the classic cartoon to have it make a reference to strange pizza toppings or some other reference to the series, making a joke of itself. While that might actually make TMNT 'popular' again, it won't bring it the respect it deserves. But, then again, it sometimes seems like the TMNT will never acheive that respect... :ohwell:

Spitfire 04-27-2009 10:49 PM

Listening to fans could work to an extent but since most fans have zero concept of what makes money and there's less turtles fans out there then those other films listed I think it would back fire. We might get what we want but not what will turn a profit. I also hardly consider letting the fans pick one line for a character in a movie listening to them.

I'd prefer this film both gives us the turtles movie we should have had to begin with and make enough money to warrant it continuing as a series.

Vincent 04-27-2009 11:39 PM

How much fan input? Well, to give a silly answer, they should just let me write the damn thing; either a first draft or rewrite whatever they've got. I'd even consider doing it for free, uncredited, and they could choose to use it or not. (I am not a fan fic writer, by the way, I have a film education and a writing education and I've studied the screenwriting craft in my own time and written original stuff and have no weird sexual obsession with fictional characters.) Why would I do it? 'Cause I don't want the movie to suffer the same mistakes all the other movies did, and I've analysed their flaws pretty thoroughly, so I think I've got a pretty good grip on what needs to be done. Why me? 'Cause this is a silly answer.

Kidding aside, I do think they should listen to the fans, to a certain extent. But they should take the input with a huge grain of salt.

tOkKa 04-28-2009 12:26 AM

22
 
-->> It would be stellar to see more in depth focus on the Yoshi / Saki / Shen dynamics .. i mean even just a little more than was even shown and eluded to in the first film. . . but that may just be me i guess.


i just really Appreciate Yoshi's importance to much of the TMNT's development as well as Saki's bent history to make him go the path he went. More of his history would be nice.
. . .



Cipher 04-28-2009 12:27 AM

They shouldn't. Fans are retarded. Not that it would be any better to have an entirely corporate agenda churning out luke-warm cinema garbage.

Ideally they'd just have a director or writer who is highly dedicated to the source material and overall tone of the series.

TristanHuwJones 04-28-2009 01:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 688096)
They shouldn't. Fans are retarded. Not that it would be any better to have an entirely corporate agenda churning out luke-warm cinema garbage.

Ideally they'd just have a director or writer who is highly dedicated to the source material and overall tone of the series.

Truth-quote for the day.

gobo 04-28-2009 02:02 AM

Back off, Aussie. I call dibs. It's the benefit of being his fellow American. :evilgrin:

Aztec General 05-03-2009 02:42 PM

They should listen to me. I'm brilliant! :thyper:

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27055

Jester 05-03-2009 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 688096)
They shouldn't. Fans are retarded. Not that it would be any better to have an entirely corporate agenda churning out luke-warm cinema garbage.

Ideally they'd just have a director or writer who is highly dedicated to the source material and overall tone of the series.

But Cipher, doesn't that make you retarded?

HA!! Circular reasoning for the win!

Fans are retarded. > Cipher is a fan. > Cipher is retarded.

Wait a minute....

Fans are retarded. > Jester is a fan. > Jester is retarded.

GAH!!! You win again, Cipher!:(

Doc_ock_4mugen 05-03-2009 03:28 PM

But if a Director/writer is highly dedicated to the source material and tone of the series, wouldn't that make the director/writer a fan?

Cipher 05-03-2009 08:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 689437)
But Cipher, doesn't that make you retarded?

Individual fans may be intellegent, but as a collective, movie-writing force the stupidity takes over. Like all the Constructicons forming Devastator or something. Or like a room frull of Einsteins arguing about bandana colors.

Andrew NDB 05-03-2009 09:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 687993)
EDIT: Actually, I hope fan input does happen. I'd love to see Tristan's idea about red bandanas early on that become colored ones later so April and Casey can tell them apart would be freakin' awesome.

I could live with that, if they must do the multi-colored thing.

Jester 05-03-2009 09:11 PM

Quote:

I could live with that, if they must do the multi-colored thing.
What about the other way around. Before the boys pick distinctive weapons, have colors to differentiate, then with the weapons they all go to red.

Andrew NDB 05-03-2009 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 689532)
What about the other way around. Before the boys pick distinctive weapons, have colors to differentiate, then with the weapons they all go to red.

No, because they would be a ninja clan first and foremost, before they start intermingling with the Aprils and Caseys of the world. And ninja clans don't metrosexualize.

Tristan's idea works because it could be kind of a grudging, "Okay, FINE, we'll wear multi-colored bandannas if it'll help you guys out" to April and Casey.

Jester 05-03-2009 09:19 PM

I guess I was thinking as kids...but whatever.

gobo 05-03-2009 09:30 PM

Splinter: Donatello, go give your brother a hand.
Michelangelo: Sensei, this is a broom, not a bo. I'm Mikey.
Splinter: Oh... Well, go help Raphael with the dishes.
Donatello: I may be holding forks, but that's just because I'm the only one who willingly does the dishes. Can't you tell us apart by now?
Splinter: All you turtles look alike to me...

mumbo230 05-04-2009 01:36 AM

Listen to the fans' cries regarding overall age and tone and then drown out all the other garbage.

Candy Kappa 05-04-2009 01:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 689540)
Splinter: All you turtles look alike to me...

epic:P

they did a similar thing in the archie series

Tuxedo Moroboshi 05-04-2009 06:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 689540)
Splinter: Donatello, go give your brother a hand.
Michelangelo: Sensei, this is a broom, not a bo. I'm Mikey.
Splinter: Oh... Well, go help Raphael with the dishes.
Donatello: I may be holding forks, but that's just because I'm the only one who willingly does the dishes. Can't you tell us apart by now?
Splinter: All you turtles look alike to me...

Humorous as that is, I doubt that'd be the case. Splinter is their father, afterall. Even with twins, parents tend to be able to tell their children apart... and other people can, too, for that matter, after having known them for a long time.

But, anyway, as far as Tristan's idea goes... I really like it! Being realistic here, if the Turtles had red masks throughout the entire movie, it might tend to turn off a bulk of the general public. The original comics are so far the ONLY medium in which they don't wear multi-colored masks (like superheroes rather than ninja). I think Tristan's idea is an awesome compromise that could please everybody.

As for fan input... heh, no. With some franchises I might say yes, but not with TMNT. The last thing I want to see in a new live-action TMNT movie is Raphael literally pulling the rug from underneath the Shredder... while Leonardo throws a pizza at his face.

Ninjinister 05-04-2009 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gobo (Post 689540)
Splinter: Donatello, go give your brother a hand.
Michelangelo: Sensei, this is a broom, not a bo. I'm Mikey.
Splinter: Oh... Well, go help Raphael with the dishes.
Donatello: I may be holding forks, but that's just because I'm the only one who willingly does the dishes. Can't you tell us apart by now?
Splinter: All you turtles look alike to me...

Actually reminds me of the Teen Techno Trio Plus One....

gobo 05-04-2009 02:31 PM

Glad people dug my lil' scenario. It was meant to exemplify an idea that occurred to me, though I guess not obviously enough. If they're going for a Batman Begins-style reboot, I fully expect to see them in all red masks to begin with, then switching to different colors after it confuses enough people.

Andrew NDB 05-04-2009 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Clown Prince of Crime (Post 689609)
Humorous as that is, I doubt that'd be the case. Splinter is their father, afterall. Even with twins, parents tend to be able to tell their children apart... and other people can, too, for that matter, after having known them for a long time.

And we're talking about a live-action film. All of the heads/faces in the TMNT films are pretty distinctive, colored bandannas or not.

Quote:

The original comics are so far the ONLY medium in which they don't wear multi-colored masks
So what? It's the source material. I don't see anyone wanting a Ghostbusters remake that gives Peter, Egon, Ray, and Winston different colored jumpsuits because of the damned Real Ghostbusters cartoon.

Quote:

As for fan input... heh, no. With some franchises I might say yes, but not with TMNT. The last thing I want to see in a new live-action TMNT movie is Raphael literally pulling the rug from underneath the Shredder... while Leonardo throws a pizza at his face.
All good reasons why TMNT fans really shouldn't be factored into things at all. It's with all the love in the world that I say this... but all of the fans in the TMNT fandom that once burned a torch for TMNT one day being taken seriously (ala the original comics) have pretty much given up, packed up, and walked away from the fandom en masse -- not counting the fresh young fans of the 4Kids cartoon, 98% of what we have left are the crazies and people nostalgic for things from their formative childhood years (the cartoon, toys, etc.) that long to recreate that period of their lives on some level, warts and all.

Tuxedo Moroboshi 05-04-2009 10:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 689720)
So what? It's the source material. I don't see anyone wanting a Ghostbusters remake that gives Peter, Egon, Ray, and Winston different colored jumpsuits because of the damned Real Ghostbusters cartoon.

That's true, but one thing to consider is that even to this day, the original Ghostbusters movies are considerably more well known than "The Real Ghostbusters" animated series. It's quite unfortunate that with TMNT, it's the unfaithful adaptation (the 1987 cartoon series) that's more well known than the source material (the original 1984 comics). I'm not against the idea of all the Turtles wearing red masks (in fact, it might even help to take them more seriously), but from a standpoint regarding how successful the movie would be... I dunno, it just seems like that might alienate people.

On the other hand, I could be wrong (and I wouldn't mind being proven wrong, as I think having them wear the red masks would be pretty awesome). Afterall, in the X-Men movies, we don't see Cyclops running around in blue or Wolverine running around in yellow. Instead, all of them wear black. It's actually almost the exact opposite situation, but again, the changes were so that the characters would be taken more seriously (though in this instance, I think I actually prefer the multi-colored outfits). If in this movie they are, in fact, pushing for a more serious tone than previous films and want to be faithful to Mirage, then maybe the all-red masks thing might not be out of the question... my only worry is how the general public (the ignorant masses who think the '87 toon started it all) will react to such a thing.

jalexbrown 05-07-2009 10:29 AM

@Andrew_NDB:
I'm trying to figure something out. Do you have a problem with people having a nostalgic love for the Turtles? I grew up with the Turtles, and yes, Turtles do have a strong nostalgic factor to me. In fact, it was all that I liked as a kid aside from the early Power Rangers. So I'm a fan with a strong sense of nostalgia for the Turtles...does that mean my opinion shouldn't count? I'd love to be able to statistically break down the TMNT fans into what exactly they're a fan of. Personally, I like all of it to an extent although the old-school, nostalgic TMNT definitely has a strong spot in my heart because it reminds me of my childhood. No sin in that, I suppose. I'm not ripping the new-school stuff and trying to say everything should be just like in the late 80s and early 90s, but I still think that was the best period for the Turtles, nostalgic or not.

joe-eyeball 05-07-2009 06:48 PM

First of all there is zero chance they will do the all red bandana thing. Remember someone has got to sell toys and little kids are going to want a blue one or a red one... Also they should limit how much they take from the fans to only a few things. This is because no matter what, they will never be able to make a Turtles movie that satisfies all. So fan input really can only be taken with a grain of salt.

Andrew NDB 05-07-2009 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Clown Prince of Crime (Post 689822)
That's true, but one thing to consider is that even to this day, the original Ghostbusters movies are considerably more well known than "The Real Ghostbusters" animated series.

That insinuates that the TMNT should be more "familiar" to get a bigger box office... even when the existing fandom (to say nothing of the general public) barely even put a dent in the last movie's box office.

Quite the opposite needs to happen. In TMNT's case, what they need to sell on the marketing side of things to the general public is the idea that this is the TMNT like we've never seen them; the TMNT on a level that has never been seen, straight off the pages of the Eastman & Laird comics.

Doing the colored bandannas is just one more piece of evidence to Joe-Q moviegoer to say, "Oh, no, you guys aren't fooling me again... it still looks like the kid stuff with the cowabunga and pizza and bright colors."

Quote:

my only worry is how the general public (the ignorant masses who think the '87 toon started it all) will react to such a thing.
It would be an educating experience for them. Keep in mind the general public doesn't give a sh*t about the TMNT and to the ones that even are aware of it, it's a joke. Why reinforce the joke?

Quote:

Originally Posted by jalexbrown (Post 690559)
@Andrew_NDB:
I'm trying to figure something out. Do you have a problem with people having a nostalgic love for the Turtles? I grew up with the Turtles, and yes, Turtles do have a strong nostalgic factor to me.

I grew up with the Turtles and the Turtles have a strong nostalgic factor to me as well. What I have a problem with is when that childhood nostalgia for the old cartoon overrides an objective perspective on what the TMNT were/are at their beginning and core.

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe-eyeball (Post 690692)
First of all there is zero chance they will do the all red bandana thing. Remember someone has got to sell toys and little kids are going to want a blue one or a red one...

I'm sure they could just change the colors of their skin for the toys.

Jester 05-07-2009 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jalexbrown (Post 690559)
@Andrew_NDB:
I'm trying to figure something out. Do you have a problem with people having a nostalgic love for the Turtles? I grew up with the Turtles, and yes, Turtles do have a strong nostalgic factor to me. In fact, it was all that I liked as a kid aside from the early Power Rangers. So I'm a fan with a strong sense of nostalgia for the Turtles...does that mean my opinion shouldn't count? I'd love to be able to statistically break down the TMNT fans into what exactly they're a fan of. Personally, I like all of it to an extent although the old-school, nostalgic TMNT definitely has a strong spot in my heart because it reminds me of my childhood. No sin in that, I suppose. I'm not ripping the new-school stuff and trying to say everything should be just like in the late 80s and early 90s, but I still think that was the best period for the Turtles, nostalgic or not.

You know...*goes to make a thread*

joe-eyeball 05-09-2009 07:53 PM

Quote:

I'm sure they could just change the colors of their skin for the toys.]
They have done that all ready and still went with colored bandanas. The bottom line if they don't have colored bandanas the casual turtle fan from way back will be pissed and confused. Remember, the audience for this film is broad and Hollywood will probably try to suck in as many movie goers as possible.

steve 05-11-2009 08:22 AM

It does not matter if there is or isn't fan input.

How much fan input was there when they created the turtles?

How much fan input was there for much of the other great movies?

If there was fan input they should leave it to simple things.

Other then that you have to trust a director and his screen writer to do his job.

You tell Spielberg that you want to change some of his ideas =D Once you have a general Direction, Tone and underlying cool story it really is up to every one else = special effects, actors, and director to take control.

By too much fan input you really get in the way of the creative direction of the intended source material. However if the intended source material sucks. Ya they need help =P


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.