The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Peter defends Vol. 4, says possibility of Vol. 5 (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27330)

CyberCubed 05-19-2009 12:23 AM

Peter defends Vol. 4, says possibility of Vol. 5
 
This was originally posted as a reply in Pete's "Star Trek" blog post, but I think its important enough to bring it here for people who won't see it. It's also good for the people ragging on Vol. 4 to see his point of view.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter Laird
You have some completely valid points. Let me see if I can give you a bit of perspective from my side of things.

When I began TMNT Volume 4, I had been with the Turtles as co-creator and co-owner for about fifteen years. By that time, the whole "ninja hiding in the darkness" thing had kind of lost its appeal, at least for me. It's not that it's a bad concept, I was simply tired of it. I wanted to set up a situation where the Turtles could begin to interact with the larger world in ways they had not been able to previously. Having aliens land on Earth and establish a public presence seemed to be a good way to accomplish this -- giving the Turtles the ability to "hide in plain sight", as it were.

I know this took away a lot of the "secret ninja" aspect of the Turtles. However, to my way of thinking, having the ability to walk around in public didn't remove the ability of the Turtles to do the whole ninja thing -- I mean, they can still hide in shadows, scale buildings at night with their climbing claws, and fight with their ninja skills -- they just don't HAVE to all the time. They have more options now.

I'm not going to say that one approach is better than the other -- I can only say that for ME, the approach I took was the one which made doing Volume 4 interesting enough to me that I was willing to take the time and effort and money required to produce it.

As for my writing/plotting style -- you are correct in saying that it meanders. The way I am writing Volume 4 is quite possibly -- maybe even quite likely -- not what people expect from most comics, or most popular entertainment, which has exactly the "conflict-building tension-climax-resolution" formula that you describe. It may have a lot to do with why Volume 4 doesn't sell all that well. But the fact of the matter is that this is the way I want to tell this ongoing story. I am not interested in writing comics the way Kevin and I used to write the Turtle series. Those were fun stories, and some of them even hold up, I think, as good comics. But I am simply not interested in that approach for Volume 4. I fully understand that this approach is not to everyone's taste, and that I have lost readers who want what the old books were like. I regret that I can't provide that for them. Basically, it comes down to this -- if people want me to write a TMNT comic, Volume 4 is what they are going to get. I'm not going to do a series like Kevin and I used to. I don't want to. I have no interest in doing that. This is the form which currently pleases me.

This is why I have said, a number of times, that if you haven't realized after reading, say, a dozen issues or so of Volume 4, that it is not and very likely never will be like a traditional comic or like the comics that Kevin and I used to do together, I don't know how to help you. It's why I have said several times in the letters column of Volume 4 that if you don't like the way Volume 4 is going, STOP READING IT!!! They say that madness can be defined as doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. I have tried to make clear that this is the way I want to do Volume 4. If you like this approach, I am happy to have you as a reader. If you don't, I regret to lose you as a reader, but that's life.

I have tried to satisfy the types of readers who aren't interested in my Volume 4 approach by reviving the "Tales of the Turtles" series. I think a lot of very good work has been done in that series, with most of the issues being stand-alone stories. It's possible in the future that Mirage might publish a new, Volume 5 if you will, Turtle series which might be more like the old Volume 1 -- an ongoing continuity, but told with stories that run in short arcs, ranging from one to four issues. There are no plans to do so, but it's a possibility. But I can pretty much guarantee that it will never happen with Volume 4, and I am prepared to accept the consequences.

I hope this has been helpful. -- PL

Thoughts?

Ninjinister 05-19-2009 12:39 AM

I actually think this is the most mellow he's ever been when defending his opinion. I've seen him get pretty terrifying in the past. This is put respectably.

Despite not being a fan of Star Trek, I was interested in reading what he had to say on the film back when the post was made. I quit reading early on because it turned from a film review to a witch hunt on a completely different subject.

Machias Banshee 05-19-2009 12:55 AM

Glad to see both sides can talk civilly in that post. I gave up on it as Ninjinister did... who wants to read a bunch of mudslinging?

Maybe this'll ease some people's questions about Vol 4's premise. *crosses fingers*

trustno1 05-19-2009 01:01 AM

maybe people should be posting their thoughts over on the actual blog instead of here. that way peter can see what people want especially when it comes to a Volume 5! :)

twopinacoladas 05-19-2009 01:12 AM

I like volume 4 I didn't so much like when the turtles came out and the aliens and such but I enjoyed the storys and can accept it. It would be nice if the issues were out a little more consitant but I understand why its taking longer and am pleased Pete's going to finish it. I would love to see a volume 5 with a take more like the original books as well at some point and he seems like he would be open to the possibility.

Hopefully they could somehow market the book and at least turn a small profit so it would at least make it worth doing for them. I can say I appreciate getting the books that we do get considering the low sales and what not.

trustno1 05-19-2009 01:15 AM

so post over on the blog and let him know!

Archon_Turtle 05-19-2009 01:24 AM

Maybe now the dogs will stop barking so much...but probably not.

Big Kudos to Peter for eating a big slice of humble pie on this one.

hawkangel 05-19-2009 06:57 AM

I was unaware that there were so many critics out there of Volume 4.
I really like the series as its a nice reunion of the characters old and new.
To me, some of the best turtles stories was when they distanced themselves from their origins, Shredder, took them out of the sewers and into a whole new environment.

bedbugjones 05-19-2009 07:38 AM

i always felt like volume 4 was slowley building up to a big finish(and maybe lead into volume 5)i guess more people would perfer a tired generic fastpaced superhero comic. i perfer a nice long epic so volume 4 is my favorite so far:D

R-iZZy 05-19-2009 07:44 AM

Now why couldn't he make responses like this in his Turtle Tracks for Volume 4? It was definitely a more mellow and respectable approach to the disgruntled fans. Granted it might not be what I wanted to hear, but at least he broke it down calmly and with the most sincerity. But one thing is for certain, I can pretty much count on this volume not appealing to me for the rest of the way through.

DrSpengler 05-19-2009 10:05 AM

Meh.

At least he's making Vol. 4 available for free.

Because that's about as much as it's worth.

Cipher 05-19-2009 10:16 AM

Volume 4 - Great concepts, mediocre execution. I really appreciate almost every idea Laird's come up with (maybe excluding April's origin), but he's not much of a writer. I kind of wish he'd pulled a "City at War" and handed script duties over to Lawson.

Still, think it's entirely fair for him to say, "Don't like it, don't buy it." He's essentially funding it out of pocket. I can see some people's frustration with having the flagship title be a highly controversial pet project, but he did address it by giving us Tales. Volume 4's just about run its course anyway, and then maybe we can get a new arc with fresh talent.

Leo656 05-19-2009 10:38 AM

Hasn't been my cup of tea, though Tales is pretty good. Eh, Im one of those idjits that's so happy there's any TMNT books at all I'll buy it regardless.

plastroncafe 05-19-2009 01:30 PM

I'll admit that I'm not a huge fan of Volume 4, but that this post by Peter is really making me want to go back and re-read it all with this perspective of his in mind.

Thanks for c/p'ing this here, I probably wouldn't have seen it otherwise.

plastroncafe 05-19-2009 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 693283)
Volume 4 - Great concepts, mediocre execution. I really appreciate almost every idea Laird's come up with (maybe excluding April's origin), but he's not much of a writer. I kind of wish he'd pulled a "City at War" and handed script duties over to Lawson.

Still, think it's entirely fair for him to say, "Don't like it, don't buy it." He's essentially funding it out of pocket. I can see some people's frustration with having the flagship title be a highly controversial pet project, but he did address it by giving us Tales. Volume 4's just about run its course anyway, and then maybe we can get a new arc with fresh talent.

Part of me wonders if maybe Vol 4 would work better as a trade, than as individual issues. That maybe it'd read better in one lump, instead of waiting for monthly installments.

But that aside, everything you've said here? Is what I tried to say...only you did it way better. Heh, thanks for that!

Archon_Turtle 05-19-2009 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 693280)
Meh.

At least he's making Vol. 4 available for free.

Because that's about as much as it's worth.

Statements like this remind me of overweight 50 year old men, sitting in a big arm chair, watching football, screaming at the Quarterback that he is worthless for missing a catch.

It's like really? You do better.

What is the point of critical statements that those being criticized can't learn from? Feeding your own ego I suppose...

VaughnMichael 05-19-2009 01:57 PM

For me it was that I know that Peter & Jim can do and have done better work.
I'm just to the point that I don't care anymore, they and the companies involved don't listen so there's really no point in any of it.
If you want something to be the way you see things go out and start your own comic or cartoon or whatever.

Spitfire 05-19-2009 02:31 PM

Yeah it's his, he can do what he wants, and if he's happy with it then good for him. Honestly I think pleasing the fan base is half of the work in making a comic, the other half is producing work your proud of.

Like Vaughn said, the issue is they've done better work and we know they can do better. The story isn't a problem for me it's mainly the art. He did cover himself by making Tales volume 2 like he said so I respect him.

PAAATE 05-19-2009 03:25 PM

The only thing I don't like about volume 4 is the release schedule.. :P

Ok, the art could've been better, but it's not horrible to me.. I've seen way worse, art where you barely could make anything out in the picture.. But I guess vol 4 has the opposite problem, not enough detail :P

Well, that's still better than not being able to see what it's supposed to be..

Aztec General 05-19-2009 07:23 PM

"It's possible in the future that Mirage might publish a new, Volume 5 if you will, Turtle series which might be more like the old Volume 1 -- an ongoing continuity, but told with stories that run in short arcs, ranging from one to four issues."

This is EXACTLY what I want. A series of short arcs that make up a continuity. I don't want Peter's slow, winding, never reaching any form of climax story telling; nor do I want the one and done style of Tales. I want a more traditional 6 or so issue story arc. I hope Peter considers this.

DK2 05-19-2009 07:41 PM

At least we get Peter's perspective on TMNT V4 series on his intentions and execution. He was honest. I don't hate Vol.4 but wished it be at a good pace and more action in some way. The other thing is I want to know whats going on with the TMNT characters these days. Thats why I want to read the comics. Remember we had that gap from 1999-2001 by the time Vol.4 came along of no turtles comics?
Now Peter and Jim can do better? Maybe. I think 'cause Eastman is missing thats why. Remember all the scrutiny of Vol.1 when Peter and Kevin did their own solo efforts in the TMNT V1 from issues #12,14,15,17,18? People wanted them back together. Their weren't horrible issues but the readers wanted them TOGETHER. So then they did #19-21, "Return to NY".
Jim Lawson better? That was so long ago. Did he suffer an injury to his hands? I don't mean to be rude but it almost seems something happened to his art. It was slowly deteriating by TMNT V1 #27, then #'s 48-62 the art showed more and more deteriation. Kind of like artist While Portacio. He suffered an injury or illness where he had to relearn to draw. But his work now is nowhere near as good as before. Hence Jim Lawson art.
But I must admit he's growing on me as a writer.

Mr._Mutant_Man 05-19-2009 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 693404)
"It's possible in the future that Mirage might publish a new, Volume 5 if you will, Turtle series which might be more like the old Volume 1 -- an ongoing continuity, but told with stories that run in short arcs, ranging from one to four issues."

This is EXACTLY what I want. A series of short arcs that make up a continuity. I don't want Peter's slow, winding, never reaching any form of climax story telling; nor do I want the one and done style of Tales. I want a more traditional 6 or so issue story arc. I hope Peter considers this.

I'd still like to see comics that are concluded in one issue. Or at least something that stands alone while being part of a larger story. That's one of the best aspects of Tales IMO. A lot of comic storylines these days seem unnecessarily dragged out sometimes. A writer shouldn't have to be restricted to get a story done in one or two issues, but at the same time they shouldn't have to drag it out to six issues either.

I think Laird made some good points. He should write what he wants. If people don't like it, then they don't have to read it anymore. There's a lot of other comics out there. Lots of other TMNT comics too. The fans also have Tales of the TMNT for their TMNT fix (for now, anyway). I think it's cool that Laird was able to tell the story he wanted to tell. Unfortunately, the story he wanted to tell wasn't very profitable. It probably doesn't help that the TMNT comics don't really have a "jumping on" point for new readers except for the first issues, which haven't been made widely available in some time. I guess you could find them on the official website though.


I think Volume 4 has been okay. The only thing that I really dislike is the "April was a drawing" part.

I still don't get why Laird wanted to redo parts of Volume One, though. It's not broken, so don't fix it.

Rooish 05-19-2009 09:53 PM

I really like(d) Vol. 4. People have no attention span these days ... I feel like Vol. 4 is a bit like a novel or a manga, slowly building and adding in new characters and plot twists. I don't really care about action (it's awesome but I care more about character development and the odd dramatic moment, which was what Vol. 4 was all about), plus Jim Lawson draws better with more static scenes.

Vol. 4 did great things with the Turtles, April, Casey and Shadow. I feel they all developed quite nicely. Especially Leo, Mike and Don ... Raph needed a bit more development I feel.

All the family scenes were done with a bit of awkwardness, so they don't come across as lame or forced like in some other versions of TMNT.

You know Laird would have tied up all the loose ends eventually, and it would be a huge payoff at the end, but then he lost interest. I wonder if it was partially because of all the complaining?

There were problems ... some lame writing at times, and weird random "TM" symbols and Apple advertisements thrown in. I agree that some plot threads seemed pointless, but many were very interesting. And of course, the art at times. I too have wondered if Lawson had an injury ... or is just sick of making crappy money working for a rich rich business, and has stopped putting as much effort into his work.

I didn't mind the Turtles being able to come out of hiding due to the alien invasion. I like my Turtles best in a realistic world, but if I were writing a TMNT comic, I too would run out of ideas if my comic were all about gang violence and vigilantism.

willtupper 05-19-2009 10:58 PM

The only part of Mr. Laird's well-reasoned and rational defense I find curious is this:

On the one hand, he says (paraphrasing), "I'm telling the story I want to tell, in the manner I want to tell it."

But on the other hand, he says (again paraphrasing), "Issues have been slow in coming because I've not felt very inspired to tell this story!"

It may be (probably is) just me, but don't these two ideas seem just a bit contradictory?

I may be remembering this wrong, but I seem to recall a long time ago that Mr. Laird said the way he and Mr. Lawson work together on the Volume 4 issues amounted to Mr. Laird giving Mr. Lawson a short (half-page to page-and-a-half, if I'm remembering right) written description of the key points, or "beats," that he (Mr. Laird) wanted in the issue.

Then Mr. Lawson would go off and draw it.

And then Mr. Laird would come up with dialogue and narrative for the issue. Kind of a personal version of what's often called "Marvel-style."

I wonder (more pure conjecture, here) if maybe Mr. Laird would feel more inspired to attack new issues of Volume 4 if he tried writing it in "full-script" form. That way (and again, I'm speculating) he'd have more control over the finished product, in terms of layout, look, angle of individual panels... as well as the actual words.

It would be a bit more work for him at the front end, but it would also give him more control. I really don't know. With even the small amount of script work I got to do on Tales, I know I'd freak right out if I had to work "Marvel-style." I'm too much of a control freak for one. And then, just handing in a summary of something (to be fleshed out later) would probably feel like I was "cheating." I can't rationally explain that, but that's just how I am.

gobo 05-20-2009 12:10 AM

The manner in which he wants to tell the story is 'as the mood strikes'. So, that means with so many supposed fans giving him **** on a regular basis, he will be spitting out new issues at a turtle's pace. I could see where you would find those ideas contradictory though...

Andrew NDB 05-20-2009 12:26 AM

Very interesting. I can respect what he's saying, all things considered.

Andrew NDB 05-20-2009 02:58 AM

Quote:

I have tried to satisfy the types of readers who aren't interested in my Volume 4 approach by reviving the "Tales of the Turtles" series. I think a lot of very good work has been done in that series, with most of the issues being stand-alone stories. It's possible in the future that Mirage might publish a new, Volume 5 if you will, Turtle series which might be more like the old Volume 1 -- an ongoing continuity, but told with stories that run in short arcs, ranging from one to four issues.
Is it just me, or could it be read that he's implying that a Mirage Volume 5 might preclude a continuance of Tales Volume 2?

GordonUniverse 05-20-2009 03:25 AM

I don't pick up on that at all. And right after this excerpt, he says there are no plans, so if that's the truth, he's probably not trying to imply anything at all.

It reads to me more like he's just thinking out loud.

CyberCubed 05-20-2009 11:22 AM

If Tales V. 2 ends, but they get a lot of the same people to do short mini-arcs in Vol. 5, wouldn't that be ideal?

PAAATE 05-20-2009 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 693509)
If Tales V. 2 ends, but they get a lot of the same people to do short mini-arcs in Vol. 5, wouldn't that be ideal?

Well, it would be my ideal anyway :P

Aztec General 05-20-2009 05:18 PM

I like many plot points of Vol. 4 and I certainly like on-going, long building storylines (City At War anyone?); but I've basically given up on Laird ever coherently tying up his plot lines. Building is awesome...but building to SOMETHING is crucial!

So I'll continue to read Vol. 4 because I have invested interest in many of the storylines, but I'm not expecting too much at this point.

Vegita-San 05-20-2009 06:44 PM

Maybe I'm missing something..

But did anyone see a reason for Peter to totally go on the offensive and pretty much bash Dawn for no apparent reason? Maybe I took it the wrong way, but that's how it came off to me....an un-warranted attack...

I'm just curious as to how other people saw it..... to me it's being seen as a paranoid reply...and totally unnecessary.

If I where Dawn, I would probably have done the same thing. Kept it for years fretting over it, wondering why was done was done, and happened the way it happened, and finally deciding to get over it, delete the letter in question...that's how I took the note...

Vegita-San 05-20-2009 08:00 PM

Add on -

I may have just shot myself in the foot with my latest reply, but what the hell.
That's how I saw the situation and I wrote what I Saw.............probably will get a nasty reply in return...

Machias Banshee 05-21-2009 01:07 AM

I think the whole dogpile of "Oh he treated me bad!" "Oh, he treated me bad too!" is sending him over the edge. What was originally just a thread about his thoughts on the new Star Trek movie has turned into a court case against Peter Laird as a creator/participator in the franchise. How would You feel if people were out trashing YOU for they way You treat Your property?

It'd be like if everyone suddenly started saying, "Oh, Krang does such a ****** job of taking care of the forums here. He makes them ugly, and slow and not with enough extra buttons and crap to waste my day with.", and then turning around and saying, "Man, if only Shredder were in charge of the entire forum by himself, life would be perfect."

Considering the two created it TOGETHER, I would think Krang would be beside himself...



I'm sorry, but the more I read that thread, the less sympathy I have for those involved. I think that entire thread is a mess and people on ALL sides need to back off and take a breather...

This is being taken WAY too seriously by everybody.

Vegita-San 05-21-2009 02:43 AM

Looking back on it, my reply not only said what I felt, but also showed my reaction as to how I felt about Peters reply to dawn. If he thought THAT was 100% out of left field, maybe he'd get the gist of what I thought of his reply. A tad over the top.

And still, Dawn is trying to respectfully bring this train of thought to an end, but he keeps on dragging it up. All the more reason why I don't regret that earlier post..and if he can't see that even now...well...so long visiting pal blog.

Is it an over reaction on both sides? Perhaps. But doubtfull...
At least it gave me a good reason to end all my turtle websites once and for all...

Archon_Turtle 05-21-2009 03:10 AM

Hey Tristan! Remember when I said earlier on Facebook that having people talk to him on his blog was a bad idea? And that he should come here where comments can be moderated effectively? I Win! Eat Vegemite ya hack!

*kisses*

TristanHuwJones 05-21-2009 05:17 AM

Yeah, but notice how there's no Armaggon over there? That's 100% Peter Laird right there...

I eat Vegemite all the time. YOU eat it gackface.

gobo 05-21-2009 06:18 AM

O_o Is the alphabet backwards Down Under? :tangel:

TristanHuwJones 05-21-2009 07:17 AM

Yes. Yes it is. You guys will eventually learn the benefits of this. I know this because Australia is in the future, but all Australian residents are sworn to never revealing the secrets of the backwards alphabet, lest the Blazing Head of Hugh Jackman appear and bring doom to all.

Vegita-San 05-21-2009 07:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 693725)
Yes. Yes it is. You guys will eventually learn the benefits of this. I know this because Australia is in the future, but all Australian residents are sworn to never revealing the secrets of the backwards alphabet, lest the Blazing Head of Hugh Jackman appear and bring doom to all.

Is that anything like the DeckaBet? Where XY and Z, the so called useless letters, are combined into one? Or maybe since Dan Aykroyd made the announcement, only Canada has it :).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:36 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.