![]() |
Why do you think Complete Carnage was never in the cartoons?
Does anyone find it odd that Complete Carnage is really the only major Mirage villain that was never featured in either the original cartoon or the 2k3 series?
The funny thing is the guy would have fit into either cartoon universe very easily, yet for some reason he was excluded from both. It really is an oddball situation, because the character himself feels rather obscure as a TMNT villain even though it shouldn't be that way. |
Quote:
|
I think it's because\ the tv would explode for lack of ability to contain such awesomeness. That and he is based on Etrigan, but I think there are enough differences to call him original. Think of similar characters from other companies that get used all the time. Entire cartoon series have been made of parody characters. Justice Friends short cartoon from Dexter's Laboratory for instance.
|
I was thinking perhaps because Kevin Eastman created the character. *shruggs*
But who really knows. |
Quote:
|
The absense of Complete Carnage and Radical from the 4Kids cartoon always baffled me. For one thing, Complete Carnage rocks my socks. For another thing, why did they make and heavily feature a superhero team without using Radical? Their issues were also pretty kid-friendly (barring "Swan Song") and could easily have translated into an episode.
It's just wierd that every other major Mirage character (featured before Volume 4) made an appearence while those two did not. Quote:
|
Actually I think the fact that it's basically Etrigan is the only plausible reason.
Eastman sold his Mirage rights, there's no reason why Laird wouldn't use him unless he just doesn't like the character. Eastman has his fingerprints all over so many of the TMNTverse and they're used. The Green Mantle and other characters were parodies of sorts. Homages. DC probably doesn't have a problem with that. That falls under more grey territory. Having a character like Carnage however tends to be a bit more likely to fall into infringing rights and likeness and yadda yadda. Bit of a difference between an homage character and a marketable independant character that just happens to share too many qualities with another established character. |
Quote:
I doubt it was a copy right issue since Raptarr got in despite looking completely like Warren Worthington Angel. I dont think there is any kind of hidden consperiacy. I think it was just poor timing they probraly would have gotten to that one sooner or later but maybe even in the 5th season if it got the same amount of episodes seasons 1-4 got. Then the show changed its tone completely after that season and it was no longer doing mirage adaptations. As for not being in the 80's toon pretty sure they probraly didn't think Radical and Complete Carnage wouldn't be cool enough toys. |
I'm not sure what Etrigan and Carnage have in common aside from the ears.
Complete Carnage isn't a short, rhyming demon from Hell dressed like a jester. He's a brutish, hulk of a man who isn't even well-spoken who can pass through walls and concrete and sh*t. |
Quote:
Perhaps it's just a matter of the show being under Peter's creative control and Complete Carnage and Radical just not being characters that immediately appealed to him. Maybe they were always Kevin's thing, and Peter just wanted to see other stories adapted first. Maybe no other writers or story-editors pitched the idea because they weren't encouraged by him. And then, of course, the show's focus changed direction in season five and on. |
It does seem ridiculous though because as you said, they had the Justice Force in the cartoon which Radical should have been a part of...so it doesn't make sense to see her not included.
Didn't she come to Pete's mind at all? It's also jarring how its the only issue of the original Tales not adapted into an episode. So they KNOW they skipped it purposely. |
Quote:
The ears, the face, the body, the costume (sorta). The only real difference is the horns. I mean if you don't think he bares more than a passing resemblance to Etrigan then maybe you should check out my new character. Awesome Man! http://i41.tinypic.com/29mpvdi.jpg I'm sure DC comics won't mind, because he's nothing like Superman. This guy is taller. |
Weren't there several Batman rip-off's in comics over the years though? Even some that wear almost the same black and gray costume?
|
Nobody was essentially Batman....
Speaking of which, Choate wasn't in the toon either. |
Quote:
I would say this definitely becomes more the case when you look at how few people have ever read the Mirage comics, versus how many millions more watch the toons. DC would be more likely to step in over a cartoon version, than a comic one. Which I know sounds assbackwards, but is often how it works. |
Quote:
|
who the hell is complete carnage and what his MO?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Like I say, they tend to ignore it in actual comics because that generally isn't worth the time, but bringing something into the 4Kids networks, millions of homes, toys, t-shirts, etc, DC would step in a heartbeat. Assuming they thought it infringed on their property. |
I don't think it's a leap to assume that if TPTB really wanted Complete Carnage in the 4Kids children's stuff then they would've done it... and if that just meant changing his ears, then they would've done that, too.
Simple fact is, either they make a conscious choice not to include him or they just didn't feel like doing a Carnage story. |
I'm certain they made a conscious choice not to include him, because they would have had to completely redo the character to the point he was unrecognizable to squeeze him in because DC owns Etrigan.
I think with Laird's love of all things Kirby, he would have absolutely included him if possible because Carnage is so obviously a tribute character. Probably easier to skip him then have to go back later and omit him from episodes (or pull them) because of legal issues. Which is likely what would have happened. And although I'm sure some folks will disagree with that, without getting an answer from the powers that be, it's the most plausible reason. Certainly a little more water holding than conspiracy theories. |
I am just guessing here, but I wonder if the Complete Carnage story was too violent for either cartoon. Though the 2k3 one does have a bit more violence, it is nowhere near up to Mirage level.
|
I only know a little about CC, but from what I've seen he would have slipped easily into the 2K3 fold. But maybe I'm missing something here, what makes him such a great villain? Is there an essential issue that he stars in?
|
Quote:
Quote:
I just think it's cool that the Turtles have at least one super-powerful, damn near unkillable villain. Melding with and drawing power from artificial material makes him far and above the most powerful enemy they've ever had. |
Quote:
Of course, he got to veto anything he didn't like, too. |
I don't think he wrote any, but as I understood it he had a lot more creative control and had his thumb more on the pulse of the 4Kids cartoon. I generally felt like he helped lay out the first couple of seasons at least and some of the things he's said in the past while that toon was in it's infancy seemed to indicate that. But again, that's at least partially speculation.
|
I'm still saying it has to do with the fact that Kevin Eastman created him.
I've asked Peter questions about Complete Carnage in his blog when I was working on my custom figure of him and he told me to go ask Kevin about him as he has no idea about the character. |
If season five had 26 episodes like the first four seasons, I think they would had adapted that issue into an episode.The show changed directions in season six.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I'm sure it was considered. They did every other tales issue as an episode. It probably had something to do with the format chance happening before they had a chance to use him. They probably didn't want to just randomly toss him in there.
Or as Vaughn said maybe Peter didn't feel he knew the character well enough to bring him to life in animation. |
Quote:
|
Radical shoulda been shoe-horned in with the Justice Force... After all, they added Nobody, Nano and Green Mantle in there...
|
Quote:
Or perhaps he just doesn't have an interest in him. |
I still think they probably would had use him if the show did'nt change format after season five.
|
I find it odd that that was the only Tales comic not to be adapted. And how could Peter not understand the character seeing how he helped write the story?
|
Quote:
|
This is a great question, and it's the perfect time to ask Pete as he's doing a question/answer on his blog right now. I didn't want to step on any toes and ask for you guys, but hurry up and ask because you've got me intrigued!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:37 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.