The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   If this is "The One", what do you guys expect? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27816)

Slap-Happy 07-14-2009 12:56 AM

If this is "The One", what do you guys expect?
 
If this is to be the definitive Ninja Turtles movie, what do you guys expect or want from it?

1. I want them to stay as close to the mirage books as possible (though it's pretty much garunteed that there are colored masks) to get a PG-13 rating.

2. I want them to interest more people in the comics, rather than the cartoons.

3. I want this movie to be marketed the way other superhero movies are marketed.

4. I want the director of this movie to love the TMNT, to understand how all of us fell about it, for him to know what we will feel if he f**ks it up.

5. I want these people to listen to the fans.

But, my most wanted thing out of this movie is...

6. I want this movie to be GOOD.

What about you guys?

Cipher 07-14-2009 01:19 AM

What I'd love but do not expect: Red masks.

What I have every right to expect but probably won't get: High caliber writing.

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 02:06 AM

Everything except the "listen to the fans" part. At least, broadly. Because there's a lot of crazies out there that speak more from "Bring back my childhood, cartoons, toys, and all!" and less from "Do what you need to make the best possible TMNT movie that's most becoming of the source material!"

And I think all-red bandannas would send a clear message -- as long as the rest of the film follows suit -- to all that this is a new beginning, a true reboot, and that all bets are off as far as the toddler-pandering of yore.

Spike Spiegel 07-14-2009 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 706231)
And I think all-red bandannas would send a clear message -- as long as the rest of the film follows suit -- to all that this is a new beginning, a true reboot, and that all bets are off as far as the toddler-pandering of yore.

I'm all for truly badass, actual "ninja" turtles that actually do "ninja" things. I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."

Cipher 07-14-2009 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spike Spiegel (Post 706263)
I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."

The only way that could happen is with a "City at War" adaptation. But if it plays its cards right the movie could be the equivalent of Batman Begins.

Doc_ock_4mugen 07-14-2009 11:49 AM

My Dont's:
no fart jokes, your momma jokes, no Venus, no Hyperactive/borderline special kid Mikey, no Mega angry Raph vs Splinter's boy Leo (at least knock it down a few notches...) stealing the spotlight and trurning Mike and Don into props.

My Do's:
NINJA ACTION!!! (They're called Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles) Red Bandanas would be cool... (Chances are that we won't see them) A Real threatening Shredder (even if he's killed off in one Battle, he should be a REAL threat... not a pansy that can be beaten in three minutes.) PG-13 Rating... (We don't need a mega watered down bordreline G version of the TMNT.) An adaptation as close to the source material as possible and treated with respect... MOUSERS!!! Hundreds of them...

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 706278)
The only way that could happen is with a "City at War" adaptation. But if it plays its cards right the movie could be the equivalent of Batman Begins.

"City at War" would be a very strange place to begin for a reboot. The whole story revolves/hinges upon the resolution of fallout from... events that haven't happened yet in the rebooted universe.

Cipher 07-14-2009 01:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 706293)
"City at War" would be a very strange place to begin for a reboot. The whole story revolves/hinges upon the resolution of fallout from... events that haven't happened yet in the rebooted universe.

Oh, I know. I'm just saying we're not going to get a The Dark Knight in terms of story quality unless that's the source material. The original issues just aren't up there in the writing department.

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 706299)
Oh, I know. I'm just saying we're not going to get a The Dark Knight in terms of story quality unless that's the source material. The original issues just aren't up there in the writing department.

Only if you're expecting a panel-for-panel adaptation. Which is silly. Not even The Dark Knight is a panel-for-panel adaptation, or close to it.

Aztec General 07-14-2009 03:32 PM

I expect a PG-13 action movie that takes the characters seriously, and attempts to tell a coherent story that is respectful of the original source material (Mirage Comics).

PAAATE 07-14-2009 03:34 PM

I expect an evil alien goo that transforms Casey Jones to a dancing emo boy. And then he hits April. :)

Or.. PG-13 movie, that treats the characters with respect.

sdp 07-14-2009 03:56 PM

I expect Krang and Shredder.

Cowabungas and Pizzas!

Technodrome, Rocksteady and Beebop too.

Slash/Rat King and Baxter Stockman as a fly in a sequel.

ToTheNines 07-14-2009 04:40 PM

An intelligent story, decent characterization, solid acting and brutal fights.

Of course there's alot of other specific **** I'd like to see, but I won't get started on that.

Arcade Joe 07-14-2009 07:39 PM

the "ONE"
 
I too, would like a PG-13 rating for the movie, but I'm not holding my breath.

I think the movie will have a good balance of action, humor and drama. I also expect multi colored bandanas, not all red ones.

The movie will be successful if they choose the right people for the major roles for Shredder, April, etc....

X 07-14-2009 07:49 PM

I would try and avoid cliches, or keep it to a minimum.

I am a screenwriter, and if I were handling this, and had a say-so, I would do one thing.

The ending would be the Turtles losing to Shredder. You only get better with time, and if this is an origin story again, and it's back to square one, then have the Turtles lose the first round.

It could work as an ending wether they have a sequel or not. They are just learning and learned a lot throughout the movie. That you don't always win in fights, but you do learn a lot. So if there's a no-go on a sequel, at least they learned a lot from their experience. However, if there is a sequel, then they live to fight another day.

Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.

The Terror of Death 07-14-2009 08:47 PM

This film only needs one thing to be the definitive turtle flick...















The guys ghost-riding on the roof of the Turtle Van while PG rap plays in the background.

PAAATE 07-14-2009 08:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X (Post 706408)
I would try and avoid cliches, or keep it to a minimum.

I am a screenwriter, and if I were handling this, and had a say-so, I would do one thing.

The ending would be the Turtles losing to Shredder. You only get better with time, and if this is an origin story again, and it's back to square one, then have the Turtles lose the first round.

It could work as an ending wether they have a sequel or not. They are just learning and learned a lot throughout the movie. That you don't always win in fights, but you do learn a lot. So if there's a no-go on a sequel, at least they learned a lot from their experience. However, if there is a sequel, then they live to fight another day.

Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.

Let's just say that I disagree...

Avoid clichées, YES, but I don't wanna see Shredder in more than one movie this time around...

And that's because I wanna get to a City at War-movie as soon as possible ;)

ToTheNines 07-14-2009 08:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X (Post 706408)
Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.

I agree. So the sequel could be Return to New York and the 3rd could be City at War.

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 09:03 PM

The Turtles getting beaten at the end and not killing Shredder wouldn't be a very satisfying ending to audiences. And carrying Shredder over into multiple back-to-back movies pretty well misrepresents his role in the source material.

Ideally, I'd like to see the first movie be completely urban, just a personal story of the Orokus and the Yoshis over the ages juxtaposed against the TMNT growing up and training for the day that Splinter finally sends them to accomplish their goal: the assassination of Saki. And we see that day. Cue ending credits.

Second movie I'd be OK being a little more outlandish. We can see the Utroms, maybe even a little Triceraton Homeworld jaunt ala the comics.

Third movie could reel things back in for a City at War finish to the trilogy, bringing back in the Foot as the central nemesis, the Shredder Elite, Karai, etc..

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 706434)
The Turtles getting beaten at the end and not killing Shredder wouldn't be a very satisfying ending to audiences.

I should add that this would be doubly so... especially coming off of a movie where the big payoff, big climax of the film is just the Turtles pushing some statues into an energy gate.

Mr. Stay Puft 07-14-2009 09:26 PM

I have to agree with Andrew on this, except I'd prefer the second movie to focus more on the "Silent Partner"/"Return to New York" stories. Personally, if they went that route, I'd love to have Shredder state, before attempting to finish Leo off in the opening antique shop battle, "Now I shall take your family from you as Hamato Yoshi did to mine!"

Mainly, I'd want this just to set up some internal conflict between Splinter and the turtles, leaving the team to not only heal physically, but emotionally as well. The turtles would have to overcome the fact that Splinter held such a major part of their "family" history from them and, while they begin to doubt his teachings at first and are angry that their brother almost died because Splinter brought them into his blood feud with Saki, they eventually grow from it and become a stronger family before deciding it's time to return to NY and finish off Saki for good.

Of course, this would only work if they told the origin as simply having Oroku Saki kill Yoshi and Tang Shen in the first movie and expanding upon it to include Oroku Nagi in the origin in the second movie.

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 09:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mikeys_in_tha_hizouse (Post 706442)
I have to agree with Andrew on this, except I'd prefer the second movie to focus more on the "Silent Partner"/"Return to New York" stories. Personally, if they went that route, I'd love to have Shredder state, before attempting to finish Leo off in the opening antique shop battle, "Now I shall take your family from you as Hamato Yoshi did to mine!"

Mainly, I'd want this just to set up some internal conflict between Splinter and the turtles, leaving the team to not only heal physically, but emotionally as well. The turtles would have to overcome the fact that Splinter held such a major part of their "family" history from them and, while they begin to doubt his teachings at first and are angry that their brother almost died because Splinter brought them into his blood feud with Saki, they eventually grow from it and become a stronger family before deciding it's time to return to NY and finish off Saki for good.

Of course, this would only work if they told the origin as simply having Oroku Saki kill Yoshi and Tang Shen in the first movie and expanding upon it to include Oroku Nagi in the origin in the second movie.

I agree with you on pretty much every point. I would absolutely like to see it made clear just how personal it really was between these two Clans, these two families, and for that to be the crux of things. Not shifting the focus onto extraneous tangents like, "Oh no! Will Little Danny become one of the Evil Foot?? Can he be redeemed??"

I only differ in that I believe all of the above can be accomplished suitably in a single movie. The second movie should be a complete breather from Shredder... but the fallout from his death can be felt in movie #3.

Mr. Stay Puft 07-14-2009 10:02 PM

I only fear that jumping from turtles vs. Foot in the first movie to Utroms and Triceratons in the second might be too much of a leap for some viewers who aren't quite familiar with the source material and might kill a chance for a big screen adaptation of "City at War".

Lil G 07-14-2009 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spike Spiegel (Post 706263)
I'm all for truly badass, actual "ninja" turtles that actually do "ninja" things. I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."

.....................except shorter..................................

Dragon Turtle 07-14-2009 10:33 PM

1) Story: As an origin story there really isn't much to do, other then not filling it up with bad humor and long winded training scenes, a combination of the first three issues would be ideal, with Shredder and Baxter as your main antagonists.


2) Characters: The only thing that the different factions of TMNT fans may agree on is their love of the main characters, all FOUR ninja turtles must be developed, all FOUR characters most be relevant to the story , this cannot be a Leonardo movie, Leo/Raph movie, Mike/Don movie, ect, it needs to be a movie where all four characters can shine both individually and as a group. The villains also most be developed into characters that can engage the audience, and that means going beyond the Shredder/Baxter portrayals in the Mirage comics.


3) Action: Realistically, this is what is going to bring non TMNT fans into the theaters, given their nature (and most likely budget), the movie cannot rely on massive CGI eye candy or huge explosions, and moviegoers have become numb to CGI stunt doubles and over produced fight scenes. This movie needs to set itself apart from the glut of dreary cookie cutter Hollywood action movies, perhaps by going back to old school fight choreography, but with much higher production values. And of course the action has to be PG-13.


4) Good Looking Turtles: There may not be another bigger make or break factor then the look of the turtles, good looking CGI/suit turtles can go a long way in getting people excited about the movie, bad CGI/suit turtles can be a promotional nightmare, leading to months of a bad press and mockery.

Andrew NDB 07-14-2009 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mikeys_in_tha_hizouse (Post 706451)
I only fear that jumping from turtles vs. Foot in the first movie to Utroms and Triceratons in the second might be too much of a leap for some viewers who aren't quite familiar with the source material and might kill a chance for a big screen adaptation of "City at War".

I get what you're saying, but one of the paramount principles of the source material is it's ability -- and nature -- to shift gears. One story in the comics can be gritty and urban and completely down-to-earth (the weirdest thing in the story being the Turtles themselves), the next can be some sorcery-type fare in the woods, the next can involve time-travel, the next can be some kind of space epic... and then it can go back to gritty and urban. It's one of the things that has always given me an appreciation for the material and the characters: their versatility.

I mean, of course if someone held a gun to my head and said, "Andrew, pick the type of TMNT stories you like best!" of course it's going to be the urban, gritty, down-to-earth material where they're ****ing sh*t up with other ninjas... but I think that in only doing those type of stories you're selling the proven versatility of the characters short.

And it's not to say that outer space/Triceraton/Utrom stories can't be gritty and badass. They can. They have. And could on screen as well.

Powder 07-14-2009 11:58 PM

i agree with most fans thusfar in terms of what you'd really want to see.. some violence in the field of pg-13, red bandanas, less focus on the corny jokes etc.. Alot of these 80's franchises and comic movies made in the last.. 8 years roughly, all seem to have unnessecary love stories thrown in there. Id hate to see that happen.. Also the whole drama between leo/raph and don/mike complementing eachothers humor thing.. they can pass on that. It would be cool if they had a scene where each character is put in a situation that could be somewhat selfexplanatory in regards to how they deal with things.. whether it be fight scenes or whatever else. It'd also be neat if they not only put empahsis on the ninja aspect, but the teen one aswell.. being that there in the field of like 13-18 years old or whatever, there will always be a repressed desire to rebel, or curse or whatever else, and they should show that even though they get trained and stuff, at the end of the day they are teens that have difficulty with finding out who they are and ****. either way i have a feeling this film will blow up just like batman and transformers, which could be really good or really bad depending on whether that awsome appeal is for the mass, uneducated movie goers, or the hardcore fans.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2009 12:16 AM

As I've said, my biggest fear is that the filmmakers behind this will do the old, "Let's try and please everyone" approach (to such a degree I believe it's almost an inevitability... which keeps my expectations at a healthy level of "nil"). "Everyone" meaning hardcore fans of the cartoons and such.

Such a thing is doomed to failure. Or mediocrity. Or both.

Krutch 07-15-2009 03:05 AM

My ideal movie would be something in the same tone of Hellboy, personally. It had a really nice balance of comedy, action, seriousness... Very well paced with an interesting story to boot. And its also along the lines of the visual upgrade I'd like to see.

Barrons directing is good in the first TMNT, but it did have a music video feel to alot of it. Which, of course, comes from his background. But have any of you watched any other movie directed by him? I saw "Rat" and wasn't too impressed. That being said, if he's announced as the director I wont complain. Just wish we'd get a fresh set of eyes taking on the helm.

Red bandannas would be neat, but still not preferable. I know it would be a great shout out to all the hardcore fans, but c'mon guys... its just the color of their bandannas. I personally like the colored versions, myself. The colors speak alot about their personality. It's kinda symbolic. Plus, think of a dark fight scene in an ally with four turtles wearing red masks and take away their weapons. You'd be too busy trying to figure out whos who than enjoying the fight scene.

As for the story, I'd really prefer something original. The first few volumes of Eastman and Lairds are great stuff but its nothing that hasnt already been mined and retold before in some fashion or another. "TMNT" had an original story, which was nice because it was new. It was just too bad, y'know, the story sucked.

I'd like to see equal character development for each turtle. We all know Leo and Raph tend to take center stage in the flicks. Time to change that up. I dont want to see a "Mikey and Don" movie either, but there's gotta be an easy way to balance out the development without giving any turtle the shaft.

Ground it in reality before going nuts. The beauty of TMNT is that you can place them in ordinary and exteeeeemly extraordinary situations and it never seems out of place. If I'm willing to believe that there are walking, talking Ninja Turtles I'm pretty much ready to believe anything else you throw at me. But before you start throwing Utroms and Battle Nexus's at the rest of the audience, put them in New York facing real, exisiting danger. Save any Star Wars stuff for the sequels.

Not sure what else to say cept the obvious stuff: great fight scenes, witty dialogue, and a fun experience that I'll want to revisit again and again like the first movie. I think that about covers my ideal movie ;)

nimrod 07-15-2009 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doc_ock_4mugen (Post 706279)
My Do's:
NINJA ACTION!!! (They're called Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles) Red Bandanas would be cool... (Chances are that we won't see them) A Real threatening Shredder (even if he's killed off in one Battle, he should be a REAL threat... not a pansy that can be beaten in three minutes.) PG-13 Rating... (We don't need a mega watered down bordreline G version of the TMNT.) An adaptation as close to the source material as possible and treated with respect... MOUSERS!!! Hundreds of them...

I think the Shredder in the first movie was a pretty real threat. He pretty much took on all 4 turtles by himself. There were other things wrong with the first movie but Shredder's abilities were not one of them.

Sage Ninja 07-15-2009 01:14 PM

Decent characterization. I re-he-he-eally don't want to see the typical sterotypes for their characters.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2009 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juggalo (Post 706493)
Red bandannas would be neat, but still not preferable. I know it would be a great shout out to all the hardcore fans, but c'mon guys... its just the color of their bandannas.

Which is supposed to represent their Clan. The Hamato Clan. When you have them with different colored bandannas it just makes them metrosexual/trying to make fashion statements with them. Which is sh*t.

Though as I've also said before, if colored bandannas is the only necessary evil to finally getting a TMNT film that resembles badass... I won't make a big stink about it.

Quote:

I personally like the colored versions, myself. The colors speak alot about their personality.
I'm just curious. What does purple speak about Donatello?

Quote:

It's kinda symbolic. Plus, think of a dark fight scene in an ally with four turtles wearing red masks and take away their weapons. You'd be too busy trying to figure out whos who than enjoying the fight scene.
The suits/faces/heads in the films are very distinctive, the voices are very distinctive, and there would be precious few times when you wouldn't see them with their weapons. If you still can't recognize who's who, then you deserve it.

And anyway as ninja, you're not really supposed to tell them apart. Historically they dress alike to disguise their numbers. The TMNT are stealth-killers... not the gang from "The Hills."

Cipher 07-15-2009 03:47 PM

Red bandanas + Different skin colors, voices and weapons = No problem.

If you've managed to make it through one issue of the comics without saying "Who dis turdle? I confuzzed," you'll be alright.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2009 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 706598)
Red bandanas + Different skin colors, voices and weapons = No problem.

I could grudgingly agree to those terms... even if the different skin color would be a little asinine (red-earred sliders don't have different color skins), at least it wouldn't be their own doing (i.e., like the different colored bandannas would be something they'd consciously be decorating themselves with).

Quote:

If you've managed to make it through one issue of the comics without saying "Who dis turdle? I confuzzed," you'll be alright.
Agreed. And we're not even talking about comics... we're talking about feature films in which there can be a great deal of detail put forth in differentiating the bodies/faces/heads and such.

I have to wonder if the same people who honestly fear that they won't be able to tell the TMNT apart on-screen if they didn't have different colored bandannas are the same kind of people that say that black people and Asian people all look alike.

ToTheNines 07-15-2009 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 706607)
I could grudgingly agree to those terms... even if the different skin color would be a little asinine (red-earred sliders don't have different color skins), at least it wouldn't be their own doing (i.e., like the different colored bandannas would be something they'd consciously be decorating themselves with).

They don't have to be red-earred sliders though.

Quote:

I have to wonder if the same people who honestly fear that they won't be able to tell the TMNT apart on-screen if they didn't have different colored bandannas are the same kind of people that say that black people and Asian people all look alike.
From my experience, that's only old people.


And mega-hicks.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2009 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 706610)
They don't have to be red-earred sliders though.

True. But that's what they are in the source material.

Quote:

From my experience, that's only old people.And mega-hicks.
I've known several people my age that, when it's just you two, they'll kind of do the move where they lean over, smile, and whisper, "You know, I get those black/asian people so mixed up all the time, they all look alike!"

Jester 07-15-2009 04:30 PM

Height is also a way to differentiate. It or musculature, weight. There are ways to make the 4 turtles distinct and individually recognized and still give them all red bandannas.

turkishproverb 07-15-2009 04:38 PM

On sliders, I can tell you skin coloring on the actual animals does differ a bit, so on mutant turtles it could easily increase slightly, much as pigmentation within an average ethnic group varies somewhat.

Powder 07-15-2009 05:04 PM

It'd be cool if they could at least give a shout to the classic by starting them off with red bandanas, maybe as younger turtles.. then as they grow up maybe they would want to express theyre individuality by wearing different colors and since raph wouldnt give a damn anyway, hed still be in red. Cause odds are they will be colored for the sake of idiots.. but that would be an awsome way to do it, by giving it recognition.

Andrew NDB 07-15-2009 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 706629)
then as they grow up maybe they would want to express theyre individuality by wearing different colors

Ugh. I'd rather get no explanation for them saddling the Turtles with multi-colored bandannas than that explanation.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.