The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   the fighting (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27888)

Sage Ninja 07-22-2009 01:52 AM

the fighting
 
So what are every ones expectations for the fighting in this film? I love the fact that this is going to be live action with guys in suits rather than CG, but at the same time I'm a little concerned about how it's going to look.

Just how limiting is it for stunt people to fight in giant costumes? I mean nothing beats the the fight that was shown in the first live action movie but I was a little put off by the fighting in the second and third movies. Alot of it seemed so fake and there are a few scenes where foot ninjas are supposed to be getting hit or thrown, and you can clearly see the stunt people just throwing them selves or flipping, which really takes away the feel of the fight. I know the fighting in the CGI film was kiddy by many peoples standards, but I did appreciate the the fluidy and agility of the fights scenes of the characters.

Also this also brings me to another topic. Preference? What sort of fighting do you want to see in the film? Do you want it to be flashy, defying the laws of physics and gavity eye candy or do want fight scenes more grounded in reality? I think personly I want to see good (though nice cherographed) realistic looking fighting. I mean I want the turtles to be agile and athletic, but I don't want to see them jumping forty feet into the air or flipping sixity times before landing a drop kick.

Also while I'm on it, do you want each turtle to have a distinct fighting style from each other? I mean they where all taught in the same fighting form and by the same teacher, but do you think it would be interesting to see each turtle have their own distinctive way of fighting?

ToTheNines 07-22-2009 08:19 AM

Well, Fusco is a fan of martial arts so you know we'll have plenty of altercations. But it's too early to expect anything from the quality of it.

And I personally just want to see the turtles fight in a brutal manor. Make me saw wow by how that ninja screams when they break his *enter any bone here*, not by skill level of their moves.

Doc_ock_4mugen 07-22-2009 09:32 AM

Realistic... but with a little bit of over the top flashyness... (No jumping 40 feet in the air and pulling of a 11880 degree spin for a dropkick. In your face videogame tony hawk!) Just enought for you to say Holy #$%^!
Fighting styles... Hmmm... Mostly the same, but with mild differences fitting to the Turtle... (I don't want to see a Drunken Boxing Mike, a WuShu Leo, Aikido Don and Berserker Capoeira Raph) They need to look like they studied under the same master and they're adding a little personal touch to their style...

Candy Kappa 07-22-2009 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Doc_ock_4mugen (Post 708837)
Realistic... but with a little bit of over the top flashyness... (No jumping 40 feet in the air and pulling of a 11880 degree spin for a dropkick. In your face videogame tony hawk!) Just enought for you to say Holy #$%^!
Fighting styles... Hmmm... Mostly the same, but with mild differences fitting to the Turtle... (I don't want to see a Drunken Boxing Mike, a WuShu Leo, Aikido Don and Berserker Capoeira Raph) They need to look like they studied under the same master and they're adding a little personal touch to their style...

yup something like that

The Shelf 07-22-2009 11:34 AM

Whatever they do, they need to have decent camerawork. That was one of the best aspects of the '07 movie. It made some pretty awesome fight scenes look that much more awesome. It's like the icing on the cake that makes it all worth it. I want to be pulled into the fight, not casually observing it from the audience.

Candy Kappa 07-22-2009 11:55 AM

thought the camera work on the large fight in the 07 movie was rather sloppy, like a video game screen

odupianist 07-22-2009 02:04 PM

The choreography (not the filming) style of Watchmen would be pretty sweet in my opinion, especially the scene with Nite Owl II and Sil Spectre II in the alley. Something grounded in reality, but still showing that these guys are ninja bad asses. So I don't want out in the open fighting all the time, some stealth action would be sweet too. Strike hard and fade away...

Sage Ninja 07-23-2009 02:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 708891)
Whatever they do, they need to have decent camerawork. That was one of the best aspects of the '07 movie. It made some pretty awesome fight scenes look that much more awesome. It's like the icing on the cake that makes it all worth it. I want to be pulled into the fight, not casually observing it from the audience.

I agree whole heartedly. I love it when the camera does all sort of cool angles that make you feel like you are right there in the thick of it. Like litterly inbetween the fighters seeing everything blow for blow.

Though I do agree that the big end fight in the court yard of the 07 movie was hard to follow on the eye. I'm not sure how to describe it, but it seemed like the camera was moving to fast in a sweeping gesture over the combatants for you to really get a good view on what was going on...do you think that was done in part for censoreship purposes?

That's another thing I want to see in the fights in this up coming film. I want to see the actual fighting, not cut aways or have vague camera work to hide the actual impact of blows and weapon use. If they're going to pull that crap, don't bother teasing us with it at all.

Doc_ock_4mugen 07-23-2009 03:32 PM

Also for the filming on fight scenes. I WANT TO SEE WHAT IS GOING ON!!! No Michael Bay shaky cam style crap that doesn't let you see what's going on... It's good to have some in the fray shots, but weaving the camera through the fight might be a bit disorientating

Spitfire 07-23-2009 08:05 PM

As long as it looks nothing like Watchmen or 300 did. Slow motion fight sequences are fine once but when you use them every time it gets very annoying.

ToTheNines 07-23-2009 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 709383)
As long as it looks nothing like Watchmen or 300 did. Slow motion fight sequences are fine once but when you use them every time it gets very annoying.

I know!

I never saw Watchmen, but my friends all thought I was retarted for not liking 300. I knew it wasn't gonna be a good movie, but I figured I'd see some bad-ass fighting...

The thing that made it really terrible was the digital blood looked SOOOO fu**ing fake in slow motion, where it wouldn't have stood out normally.

Arcade Joe 07-23-2009 08:24 PM

action scenes
 
I think it will depend on who directs the film, but since they got their writer, I presume it will be fairly realistic...

The Shelf 07-23-2009 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 709391)
The thing that made it really terrible was the digital blood looked SOOOO fu**ing fake in slow motion, where it wouldn't have stood out normally.

That was the art style they chose. That's like complaining that Sin City looked fake because there was color in an otherwise black and white movie. Both movies were overrated, though... :)

Spitfire 07-23-2009 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 709423)
That was the art style they chose. That's like complaining that Sin City looked fake because there was color in an otherwise black and white movie. Both movies were overrated, though... :)

Except Sin City was good. Also bad looking CGI isn't a style. They could have just as easily used fake blood but they didn't want to bother because it would have actually required some thought and effort on their part. They were too busy figuring out how many filters they could apply to it.

Sage Ninja 07-23-2009 11:03 PM

which is easier to manage? Fake blood or CGI blood? I've watched alot of House M.D and most of the blood used in it is CGI, and it looks pretty realistic.

The Shelf 07-23-2009 11:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 709444)
Except Sin City was good. Also bad looking CGI isn't a style. They could have just as easily used fake blood but they didn't want to bother because it would have actually required some thought and effort on their part. They were too busy figuring out how many filters they could apply to it.

Except it was a lot more than just the blood. My point is that they weren't trying to make it look realistic. Whether you like the style they chose for the film or not is irrelevant. It's still a style, no more or less than that of Sin City.

ToTheNines 07-24-2009 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 709454)
which is easier to manage? Fake blood or CGI blood? I've watched alot of House M.D and most of the blood used in it is CGI, and it looks pretty realistic.

I'm not sure. But I don't have a problem with CGI blood, it just looks like **** in slow mo.

Spike Spiegel 07-24-2009 04:10 PM

I hope the fighting aspects will be similar to some early eps of the 2k3 series, where they move as a team, at least at first, then stategically and surgically disperse over a huge gang of thugs/ninjas, where each Turtle's talent is put to use. But, this would have to be done in a way that is balanced by the camera angles, etc.

Maybe the screen gets split into boxes that resemble comic book panels?

The Shelf 07-24-2009 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spike Spiegel (Post 709748)
Maybe the screen gets split into boxes that resemble comic book panels?

I wouldn't mind that, but I think the first Hulk movie proved that general audiences don't go for that sort of thing.

Evenstar227 07-26-2009 01:46 PM

I think it'll depend on the quality of the cast & crew as to how the fighting will come off. Personally I thought the dudes in suits did great in the first movie, and there were some good moments in the sequels. Ever watch Jet Li in action? How fast he is? I'd love to see the Turtles move like him. I like the "wire fu" movies like Hero but don't think it'd work for this.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 709207)
Though I do agree that the big end fight in the court yard of the 07 movie was hard to follow on the eye. I'm not sure how to describe it, but it seemed like the camera was moving to fast in a sweeping gesture over the combatants for you to really get a good view on what was going on...do you think that was done in part for censoreship purposes?

My guess would be it was because they didn't want to focus on that particular battle in too much detail. They were about to crash Winter's party, after all, and bring the story to a conclusion. I wouldn't have minded more of a fight scene there (esp since April got to show her stuff), but the longer the fight went on the lesser their chances of gaining the tower. True, their team was composed of five exceptionally skilled ninja and the kick-butt duo of April & Casey, but there were swarms of Foot. The terrain they were fighting on probably wouldn't have worked to their advantage the way it did in the first movie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spike Spiegel (Post 709748)
Maybe the screen gets split into boxes that resemble comic book panels?

I didn't see the Hulk movie, but I did watch 24, and personally I found it hard to follow what was happening in multiple panels. I definitely wouldn't like trying to follow more than one panel in a fight scene! Even if I could rewind and watch it over and over to see everything it would be a drag.

Dragon Turtle 07-26-2009 11:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 708780)

Just how limiting is it for stunt people to fight in giant costumes? I mean nothing beats the the fight that was shown in the first live action movie but I was a little put off by the fighting in the second and third movies. Alot of it seemed so fake and there are a few scenes where foot ninjas are supposed to be getting hit or thrown, and you can clearly see the stunt people just throwing them selves or flipping, which really takes away the feel of the fight. I know the fighting in the CGI film was kiddy by many peoples standards, but I did appreciate the the fluidy and agility of the fights scenes of the characters.

The costumes should focus on mobility and freedom of movement as opposed to just looking good for promo pics, any imperfections in the costumes can be cleaned up digitally in post production.


Quote:

Also this also brings me to another topic. Preference? What sort of fighting do you want to see in the film? Do you want it to be flashy, defying the laws of physics and gavity eye candy or do want fight scenes more grounded in reality? I think personly I want to see good (though nice cherographed) realistic looking fighting. I mean I want the turtles to be agile and athletic, but I don't want to see them jumping forty feet into the air or flipping sixity times before landing a drop kick.
To get people interested in a ninja turtle movie, you'll really have to do something special with the action, the action/fight scenes will need to be more innovative and inventive then your typical action movie, sort of along the lines of Jackie Chans older HK movies or some of the recent stuff from Tony Ja. If Laird has any pull with the movie, then it's safe to say the turtles will not be jumping forty feet in the air or anything too outlandish. It would be nice to see the turtles fighting in concert with each other to defeat a large number of enemies, that's something you just don't see in action movies these days.


Quote:

Also while I'm on it, do you want each turtle to have a distinct fighting style from each other? I mean they where all taught in the same fighting form and by the same teacher, but do you think it would be interesting to see each turtle have their own distinctive way of fighting?
Outside of their basic ninja training, the turtles can have their own individual fighting styles.

Coola Yagami 07-27-2009 01:13 AM

What fighting styles? Leo is the most dedicated. Raph is just wild reckless rage, and Mike and Don most likely never bothered much to go past their standard ninjitsu training to consider trying another style. Unless you count Doin being more technical and Mike fighting with slapstick...

Dragon Turtle 07-27-2009 08:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 710568)
What fighting styles? Leo is the most dedicated. Raph is just wild reckless rage, and Mike and Don most likely never bothered much to go past their standard ninjitsu training to consider trying another style. Unless you count Doin being more technical and Mike fighting with slapstick...

Other then having their individual personalities be reflected in their fighting styles, as you have mentioned, they can have different hand-to-hand martial art styles while training under ninjitsu.

odupianist 07-28-2009 07:34 AM

They're all going to be similar due to being trained by one sensei, but as they get older, I'm sure they've added their own personalities to their style or have their own personal faults within Splinter's training. I think of when Splinter was "back seat ninja-ing" Don in 2k3 season 1.

NameGoesHere1066 08-11-2009 04:15 PM

no...slap...stick!

I was happy when I saw no stupid slap stick in the 07 movie, but I'm concerned with stupid kid friendly funny crap in a LIVE ACTION movie just to cater to the misgiuded soccer moms taking their 5 year olds to see turtles movie.

Warhorse 08-12-2009 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NameGoesHere1066 (Post 714597)
no...slap...stick!

I was happy when I saw no stupid slap stick in the 07 movie, but I'm concerned with stupid kid friendly funny crap in a LIVE ACTION movie just to cater to the misgiuded soccer moms taking their 5 year olds to see turtles movie.

Oh, wouldn't it be nice, to watch all the soccer moms freak out to no end, if they were to make the new movie into a hard PG-13, and show Leo or Raph stab one of the foot, and then withdraw their weapons from their impaled object, blood dripping from cold hard steel. They had that crap in GI Joe, why not in our Turtles? (mind you, I really didn't care for the movie as a whole, but when Snake Eyes got into gear, it had my full attention. And I paid attention to the fight scenes a PG-13 film can generate between two opponents wielding deadly weapons.)

Sage Ninja 08-13-2009 09:58 PM

this is what is going to scare me if they give us good fighting scenes in ninja turtles film. Is soccer moms making a big hue and cry over to much violence in the movie.

Cure 08-14-2009 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 714985)
this is what is going to scare me if they give us good fighting scenes in ninja turtles film. Is soccer moms making a big hue and cry over to much violence in the movie.

...and what if that does happen? They cry over anything. It won't affect the movie.

The Stryker 08-14-2009 01:27 PM

I wish people would waste their time worrying about the movie being good instead of little things like ratings and blood.

Sage Ninja 08-17-2009 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCure (Post 715054)
...and what if that does happen? They cry over anything. It won't affect the movie.

Are you kidding? It can affect the franchise if there is a big enough back lash of angry moms if they thought the movie was inapropiate for their eight year olds.

But I really don't want this to spin out into more bickering over rating and content.
Quote:

I wish people would waste their time worrying about the movie being good instead of little things like ratings and blood.
I'm not talking about blood and entrails here, I'm just talking about good marticial arts and how well it can be renedered with stunt men in costumes; maybe a discussion on live action fighting and agility in suits vs. CGI.

Evenstar227 08-18-2009 05:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 715477)
Are you kidding? It can affect the franchise if there is a big enough back lash of angry moms if they thought the movie was inapropiate for their eight year olds.

I wonder if it'd really even matter. A lot of people take their kids to see movies rated older than they are (ie, take a 10 year old kid to see a PG-13 movie). My best friend took her 7 year old son to see Transformers 2, a PG-13 movie, and that has some sensuality or something in it (so I heard; I haven't seen it yet). My point is that I don't think people are really gonna care. And even if there are soccer moms who make a big stink, the box office sales will be as high or higher thanks to all the happy TMNT fans who got their wish for a darker, more @ss-kicking movie. That's my guess, anyway.

Sage Ninja 08-18-2009 06:18 PM

good point evenstar227. I'm just always concerned about the double standards that exist on this property.

The Stryker 08-18-2009 11:24 PM

There is no double standard on Ninja Turtles.

It's because nobody gives a crap about the franchise is why they aren't allowed to take huge risks like super realistic fighting and blood.

Cure 08-18-2009 11:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sage Ninja (Post 715477)
Are you kidding? It can affect the franchise if there is a big enough back lash of angry moms if they thought the movie was inapropiate for their eight year olds.

OK. Gimme some examples.

odupianist 08-19-2009 08:21 AM

Watch a "movie" called "Behind the Shells". It mentions how enough angry moms pissed and moaned enough for Mirage (I use that as a general term) to make the second movie more kiddyfied after the first movie. Side note: is "Behind the Shells" on DVD yet? I'd buy it. I have a VHS copy around here somewhere.

Dragon Turtle 08-19-2009 08:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCure (Post 715884)
OK. Gimme some examples.

Every TMNT movie released after the first one.

The Stryker 08-19-2009 11:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 716156)
Every TMNT movie released after the first one.

Any Proof?

odupianist 08-20-2009 07:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stryker (Post 716200)
Any Proof?

The "Behind the Shells" video that I mentioned. PL or a producer from the movie (can't remember the name), one of them said that there was enough backlash from the first movie from moms that they had to tone it down for the second one.

Dragon Turtle 08-20-2009 10:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stryker (Post 716200)
Any Proof?

None of the later TMNT movies would approach the darker scenes from the first movie, as everyone involved, whether they were Mirage, the studio, or MPAA, took heat from different groups about the violence in the first movie.

From Dan Berger:

"We thought the original TMNT film from 1990 was suitable for all ages, but we got plenty of flack from some groups saying that it wasn't, so it is a subjective subject."



As odupianist mentions, Thomas Grey (the producer of all the TMNT movies) also talks about how they had to tone down the violence for TMNT: TSOTO, due to the negative backlash from the first movie.



And if you believe that this is all ancient history and doesn't have any bearing on the TMNT today, then here's an excerpt from a recent interview with Thomas Grey on the last TMNT movie:

"But we are kind of victimized by the fact that we have three pictures out here, so the Motion Picture Association said to us, "Well, you're rather special because the parents will say, 'Oh, the Turtles are benign, they're not going to be bad.'" And some of the action that we have in it is pretty strong. So they said, "You guys are walking on a tightrope here; pull back a little bit."


The MPAA doesn't care about the TMNT franchise, but they don't want to deal with any watchdog groups complaining about the MPAA letting the TMNT slide on violence.

odupianist 08-21-2009 08:41 AM

There's your proof. Thanks for the help Dragon Turtle. I could see Thomas Grey but not think of his name.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.