The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Should the new Turtles (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=28029)

turtle83 08-03-2009 10:04 PM

Should the new Turtles
 
look like the originals from the 1990 movie? What I mean is that they should use their faces (Masks) as a base for the CG movie and somehow make them even more realistic instead of using brand new faces.

just my opinion.

Raph 08-04-2009 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turtle83 (Post 712735)
look like the originals from the 1990 movie? What I mean is that they should use their faces (Masks) as a base for the CG movie and somehow make them even more realistic instead of using brand new faces.

just my opinion.

Its not gonna be a CG movie, It'll be live action!
But I say yes and no, they should stick closely to the comics, but thats what the first movie did too. I just hope they dont get too BTTS stylish :P

Slap-Happy 08-04-2009 01:36 PM

I say, a mix of the first issue look and first movie look would be best.

The Shelf 08-04-2009 01:44 PM

I'm fond of this look, but it may not transfer well to film:

http://image.com.com/gamespot/images..._screen008.jpg

Buslady 08-04-2009 02:10 PM

achoo! dang...ugh...

Canadian Turtle 08-04-2009 08:35 PM

I say they go as realistic as possible. This is a live action movie that most of you want to see done dark and gritty. If the TMNT were going to be real they would look like big dirty mutated Turtles that live in a sewer. My favorite look would be something like the Michael Zulli style done live action with a little touch of old school turtle character style.

odupianist 08-05-2009 11:47 AM

I think Dooney's style would be more realistic looking personally.

TMNTD 08-05-2009 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canadian Turtle (Post 713025)
I say they go as realistic as possible. This is a live action movie that most of you want to see done dark and gritty. If the TMNT were going to be real they would look like big dirty mutated Turtles that live in a sewer. My favorite look would be something like the Michael Zulli style done live action with a little touch of old school turtle character style.

Oh MAN !! Zulli's turtles are probably the most realistic looking mutant turtles I've ever seen. But they would probably scare children.

turtle83 08-05-2009 07:19 PM

Zulli's Turtles look pretty messed up and would make the new movie unbearable to most fans including myself.


I'm wondering if they will be the same height as the original turtles from 1990-91. It seems that the comics had the turtles listed around 4 feet tall. Movie Leo was about 5'7''.

At least the bodies won't be CGI

R-iZZy 08-06-2009 04:20 AM

Honestly, I wouldn't mind them taking on this look.

The Shelf 08-06-2009 08:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by turtle83 (Post 713328)
Zulli's Turtles look pretty messed up and would make the new movie unbearable to most fans including myself.

Zulli's turtles kind of resemble Tokka without all the spikes. I think they could make it work if they wanted to.

Warhorse 08-06-2009 07:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 713463)
Zulli's turtles kind of resemble Tokka without all the spikes. I think they could make it work if they wanted to.

No it won't. I hate to say it, but they're going to have to keep the Turtles "cute" looking to some extent in order to be well received by the regular movie going audience. You make them revolting, the movie will seriously flop.

Keep in line with the look of the first live action movie is the best course to go.

turtle83 08-06-2009 08:35 PM

Donatello from the first movie had the most aggressive/dark/serious looking face. Anything uglier than that would just be a little too much for the average moviegoer.

Here he is and should not get any uglier than this.


http://img517.imageshack.us/img517/8619/don.jpg

Warhorse 08-06-2009 09:57 PM

They could always go for the look they had in TMNT 2. I'd prefer it if they used CGI turtles though, like LOTR did Gollum, and use a mixture of the 2007 movie and the first movie look.

Tuxedo Moroboshi 08-06-2009 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warhorse (Post 713590)
You make them revolting, the movie will seriously flop.

Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Billbeaux 08-06-2009 11:33 PM

What if, instead of being uniformly green all over, their bodies were actually colored like real sliders (i.e. yellow "lines," the trademark red stripe on the side of the head, etc). If nothing else, that would provide one more way to tell the Turtles apart; especially if this director actually decided to go with all red masks.

turtle83 08-07-2009 12:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Clown Prince of Crime (Post 713677)
Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Not much of a fan of the second Transformers film, but you are right about the robots being a bit ugly. All of them are look bad EXCEPT bumblebee and Prime. They actually looked decent.

turtle83 08-07-2009 12:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FelixtheIVth (Post 713688)
What if, instead of being uniformly green all over, their bodies were actually colored like real sliders (i.e. yellow "lines," the trademark red stripe on the side of the head, etc). If nothing else, that would provide one more way to tell the Turtles apart; especially if this director actually decided to go with all red masks.

Nah, UNLESS they looked a lot like the original ones from the first movie. That would be freakin awesome. I'm not so excited of the excessive use of SPOTS on the their bodies (movie 2 and 3).

TMNTD 08-07-2009 12:45 AM

Yeah, I wondering about the height thing too. I know the Mirage turtles were between 4'6-4'9, and Archie turtles were 5'8 .

TMNTD 08-07-2009 01:25 AM

2 Attachment(s)
How would u guys feel if the turtles looked like this in the new movie

johnnyblaze 08-07-2009 01:44 AM

I absolutely loved the fact that in TMNT all he turtles actually looked young. They were small, thin, big hands, big feet...it truly captured the teenager aspect of the turtles IMO and I hope they find a way to bring that over into the new film.

Billbeaux 08-07-2009 07:25 AM

While we're at it, here's one that's been bugging me since I was seven...turtles don't have teeth :D

johnnyblaze 08-07-2009 08:41 AM

but mutated ninja turtles do :p

Canadian Turtle 08-07-2009 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by R-iZZy (Post 713444)
Honestly, I wouldn't mind them taking on this look.

Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.

The Shelf 08-07-2009 11:47 AM

I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.

turtle83 08-07-2009 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 713750)
I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.


100% agreed

turtle83 08-07-2009 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canadian Turtle (Post 713744)
Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.


The 1990 turtles WOULD NOT look out of place with Hellboy whatsoever (Well except maybe three of them:P). Take Michelangelo for example, I thought the fellas at Jim Henson's creature shop really took their time on his the overall facial design. His expressions were far more superior than Leo, Don, and Raph COMBINED.

Now imagine using that same face and mixing it with the most advance CGI.

You have major success right their.

Warhorse 08-08-2009 12:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Clown Prince of Crime (Post 713677)
Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Well, I beg to differ, I'm actually a huge fan of both movies and think the Transformers look fantastic, so, your POV is mute IMHO.

But you also have to look at it that the Transformers are robots, not creatures of flesh and blood, and to boot, we have already seen the Turtles on the big screen in both live action and in CGI. It's not going to be something new and never done before.

Quote:

Originally Posted by turtle83 (Post 713695)
Not much of a fan of the second Transformers film, but you are right about the robots being a bit ugly. All of them are look bad EXCEPT bumblebee and Prime. They actually looked decent.

Funny, people are talking about the look of Sideswipe, and think he's the best looking Transformer of them all.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canadian Turtle (Post 713744)
Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.

There's a difference from bad ass looking to ugly ass looking, and trust me, about as much of the general audience will flock to see grotesque looking Turtles as the flocked to see the Toxic Avenger.

Also, I grew up on the cartoon, and while I'm all for realistic settings, but the heart of the Turtles for me was their humor, their fun personalities, their quirks. If they take all of that out and make this movie into some serious, dark, suicide gothic style crap, I don't think I'm going to watch it. If me, a TMNT fan of the cartoons and movies, a little of the comics, thinks this way, then I can assure you, I'm not the only one.

Like I said, keep their look between the CGI and the live action films. If I could pin point, I'd like to see characteristics of Leo like he is in the 2k3 toon, Donny like he is in the 2k3/2007 film, Mikey like he was in the 1990 film (best adaptation I've seen of him IMO) and Raph can be juggled up between his 1990 film, 2k3 and 2007 film counterparts.

TMNTD 08-10-2009 12:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Shelf (Post 713750)
I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.

Since when did the 2007 " TMNT " movie become too dark and serious ? You're joking right ?

The Shelf 08-10-2009 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TMNTD (Post 714359)
Since when did the 2007 " TMNT " movie become too dark and serious ? You're joking right ?

Absolutely not. As I said, there are two main groups of turtle fans out there. Those that only like campy, goofy, fun turtles; and those that prefer the "dark and gritty" turtles. One group complained that the movie was too dark and serious while the other complained that it was too silly. That's why the movie didn't do very well. It tried to appeal to both audiences by offering something that each could like, but instead, each group just complained about the parts that didn't fit with what they liked.

TMNTD 08-10-2009 12:50 PM

Ok, gotcha.

Cipher 08-10-2009 01:14 PM

I honestly don't put much stock into the Turtles' designs. I've been exposed to so many varying styles through the comics that I'm game for anything. I could see a cartoonier design being chosen for relatability, and I could see a more realistic/ugly style to sell a reboot. I'll take skinny, agile Turtles, or hyper-muscular Turtles. It's all good. The only issue I really give a damn about is bandana color, and we already know that red will (sadly) be unlikely.

I will say that I'm not too fond of that "realistic" fanart that seems to have caught on recently. I don't see why everyone's freaking out about it. There have been much better realistic Turtles.

Quote:

Absolutely not. As I said, there are two main groups of turtle fans out there. Those that only like campy, goofy, fun turtles; and those that prefer the "dark and gritty" turtles. One group complained that the movie was too dark and serious while the other complained that it was too silly. That's why the movie didn't do very well. It tried to appeal to both audiences by offering something that each could like, but instead, each group just complained about the parts that didn't fit with what they liked.
I think that's a pretty succinct summary of the movie's failings. Tried to please everyone and, in doing so, ended up pleasing no one.

The Shelf 08-10-2009 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 714380)
I will say that I'm not too fond of that "realistic" fanart that seems to have caught on recently. I don't see why everyone's freaking out about it. There have been much better realistic Turtles.

I agree, but I can't seem to find any of the others. Please, do share, if you have some links handy. :)

Candy Kappa 08-10-2009 03:15 PM

This is a cool looking style
but it's a bit too much tortoise than turtle thought.

And they can't be too much realistic due to showing human emotion and being able to relate to them.

I think many people who don't like the idea of realistic turtles think about that.

they still have to have a fleshy snout rather then a hard beak to have facial expressions

The Stryker 08-10-2009 03:42 PM

I think realistic looking turtles would be creepy as ****.

Turtles are not cute animals.

Candy Kappa 08-10-2009 03:54 PM

Ain't he a cute Turtle

The Stryker 08-10-2009 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kiwamu The Kappa (Post 714407)
Ain't he a cute Turtle

Ugh...

No.

ToTheNines 08-10-2009 04:14 PM

http://www.hillcity-comics.com/graph..._novel8227.jpg

No.

Warhorse 08-10-2009 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 714415)

:oOMG:o, they look like something from the V TV show! That show creeped me the f**ck out when I was kid!

The Shelf 08-10-2009 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stryker (Post 714409)
Ugh...

No.

You're just saying that.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:04 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.